For POSOCO Executives Concept of Sub Critical and SuperCritical Boilers, Parameters, Design, efficiency and Boiler ( Combustion) Material compiled by: Mr. V.K.Gupta, EX DGM NPCIL, NPTI (Nagpur) and CBIP New Delhi. Mo-9555486426 & Email: vs4951@rediffmail.com Generation of Electricity from Fossil Fuel CATAGORY INSTALLED GENERATION CAPACITY(MW) % of SHARE IN Total Electricity generation from Fossil Fuel as on 31.01.2022 data Ministry of Power Coal 2,03,900 51.6% Lignite 1.7% 6,620 Gas Diesel 24,900 510 6.3% 0.1% Total Fossil Fuel 2,35,929 59.7% A Sub-critical or Supercritical Boiler Lay out Selective Catalytic converter A schematic layout of a typical coal fired supercritical TPP The slide shows layout of the Sub-Critical Boiler say below 500MW. It shows how the boiler accessories like Coal Mills, various Fans, AHP and ESP etc. are located and connected to boiler or the steam generator what ever you may call it. Now then, a steam generator has a nest (banks) of various tubes like Water walls, Economiser, Superheater and Re-heater tubes. If we look from outside, boiler is a enclosure of sealed tubes all around. In the first pass it has water walls, arch tubes, in the horizontal pass it has tubes nest forming roof or penthouse and in the second pass it has steam tubes covering it all around up to the economiser ash hopper. The bottom portion of the first pass has apertures made by forming water walls at the four corners to accommodate wind box assemblies or the burner assemblies. At the bottom it has ash panel and trough seal. It is through this opening 20% of the ash and clinkers from combustion process will be existing through clinker grinder and to the ash disposal arrangement. WW, economiser, superheater and reheaters tubes banks are inner assemblies and their connecting headers out side the furnace. Only tubes form the heat absorbing surfaces and headers not. Water walls are also called riser tubes or the evaporating tubes because it is here the boiler feed water is evaporated by absorbing sensible & latent heat from combustion zone. It is partial in case of sub-critical boilers and complete (100%) in case of supercritical boilers. Modern thermal power plants operate at very high pressures greater than the Critical pressure of steam. The description explains how Super Critical power plants are different from the normal power plants. Supercritical power plants boiler were in service from the late fifties. But the technology did not really take off due to problems of reliability especially from the metallurgical aspect. The single most important factor that determines the use of higher and higher pressure and temperatures are the availability of materials to withstand these conditions. Increases in operating pressure and temperatures have to go hand in hand with developments in metallurgy. With more than 600 boiler units in service the reliability issue seems to have resolved. Supercritical boiler units are the standard for future power plants in many countries including India. A Block diagram of the plant cycle Why Supercritical Technology: To Reduce emissions for each Kwh of electricity generated. Adhering to latest environment emission release norms. Efficiency of these units is higher than subcritical. 1% rise in efficiency reduces Co2 emission by 23%. Nox is also reduced. The most economical way to enhance efficiency. To achieve fuel cost saving : Economical Reduce boiler size / MW To Reduce Start Up Time Understanding sub-critical technology Water when heated to subcritical pressure, temperature increases until it start boiling. This temperature called saturation temperature at that pressure, remains constant until all water is converted to steam. When all liquid is converted to steam then again temperature starts rising (Superheat). Sub-Critical boilers typically have a mean ( Boiler drum) to separate steam and water. The mass of boiler the drum , which limits the rate at which the sub-critical boiler respond to the load changes. Too great a firing rate will result in high thermal stresses in the boiler drum. There are no operational limitations due to oncethrough boilers compared to drum type boilers. In fact, once-through boilers are better suited to frequent load variations than drum type boilers, since the drum is a component with a high wall thickness, requiring controlled heating. This limits the load change rate to 3% per minute, while oncethrough boilers can step-up the load by 5% per minute. This makes once-through boilers more suitable for fast start up as well as for transient conditions. SUB CRITICAL POWER PLANT Understanding Supercritical Technology When water is heated at constant pressure above critical pressure, its temperature never be constant. Because there is no latent heat requirement. Water straight flashes into steam and continuing gaining heat to superheat level. No Distinction between liquid and Gas , the mass density of the two phases remain the same. No stage where water exist as two phases and require separation. No Drum. The actual location of the transition from liquid to steam in a once through supercritical boiler is free to move with different conditions: Sliding pressure Operation. For changing boiler load and pressure, the process is able to optimize the amount of liquid and gas region for effective heat transfer. Spiral Tubes Water Walls Advantages / Disadvantages: Advantages: Benefits from averaging of heat absorption variation resulting in less tube failure. No individual tube orifice Reduced no of evaporator wall tubes and ensure minimum water flow Minimizes peak tube metal temperature Minimum Tube to Tube metal temperature difference Disadvantages: Complex wind box opening Complex water wall support system Tube leakage identification – a tough task More the water wall pressure drop : Increases boiler feed pump power input Adherence of ash on the shell of tube fin Comparison of Subcritical and Supercritical Description Supercritical Subcritical Coal and Ash handling Low High 02. Pollution Low High 03. Auxiliary Power Consumption Low (6%) More (7-8%) Low More Sr No. 01. 04. Specific Enthalpy 05. Sp. Coal Consumption Low ( approx. 4% less than subcritical) High 06. Air Flow & Dry Flu Gas Loss Low High 07. Coal and Ash handling Low High 08. Pollution Low High 09. Auxiliary Power Consumption Low (6%) More (7-8%) Comparison of Subcritical and Supercritical Sr No. Description Supercritical Subcritical 10. Overall Efficiency High (40-42%) Low (36-37%) 11. Total Heating Surface Required high (84439m2) low (71582m2) 12. Tube Diameter Low High 13. Material Requirement (Tonnes) Low 7502 MT High 9200 MT 14. Start Up Time Less More 15. Blow Down Loss Nil More 16. Water Consumption Less More 17. Cost Of Generation Less More Current designs of supercritical plants have installation costs that are only 2% higher than those of subcritical plants. Fuel costs are considerably lower due to the increased efficiency and operating costs are at the same level as subcritical plants. Specific installation cost i.e. the cost per megawatt (MW) decreases with increased plant size. Justification of Fast start Up & bearing higher load variation SALIENT FEATURES OF 500 MW Sub-Critical BOILER • • • • • • • • • • TYPE OF BOILER: Single Drum Top supported, Fusion welded WW Panel, Controlled circulation system, Tangential fired, Radiant Dry Bottom Pulverized coal fired outdoor Balanced Draught Cut corner 51mm OD WW Tubes at 63.5 mm pitch • Rap around Buck stay system • FIRST PASS: • Boiler Furnace Depth 15.7972mtr • Furnace Width 19.177mtr • Height of Furnace (upto Radiant roof)64.168mtr. • SECOND PASS: • Depth -13.716mtr • Width -19.177mtr • Total Height of Boiler90mtr. Boiler Description: The boilers of thermal power plants are known as utility boilers, because they are there for generation of high pressure and temperature steam which drives steam turbine and generator to generate electricity. Thus the utility boilers means which are used for generation of electricity. A 500 MW STG will continuously generate 500 MW of electricity. But this 500 MW is a load which is put on the generator and in turn it will generate 500MW every moment. If the load on TG is less it will generate less but if load imposed is more it can not generate more as the maximum generation limit is 500 MW. This is called rating of Turbine and generator. The boiler has to produce superheated steam at rated pressure and temperature around 1600 Tons / hour. All boilers are manufactured as per the rules of IBR (Indian Boiler Regulation). A boiler is defined as the closed vessel having a volume of more than 22.75 liters and is used for raising steam at pressure above 1 kg/cm2g. This is because safety is connected to it. Now-a-days older thermal power plants of capacity less than 210MW are being gradually phased out. Even at some places older 210 MW TPS are being discontinued being, 1.Uneconomical 2.They do not meet the environment safety norms. 3. Being replaced by 500 MW and above units and they are the future. 4. Boiler can be Sub Critical or Super critical. If the steam pressure and temperature are below 221 kg/cm2 and temperature below 3740C, they are called subcritical and the one above are supercritical. Vertical Tube Furnace: To provide sufficient flow per tube , constant pressure furnace employ vertically oriented tubes. Tubes are appropriately sized and arranged in multiple passes in the lower furnace where the burners are located and the heat input is high. By passing the flow twice through the lower furnace periphery (two passes). The mass flow per tube can be kept high enough to ensure sufficient cooling. In addition the fluid is mixed between passes to reduce the upset fluid temperature. Spiral Tube Furnace: The spiral design on the other hand, utilizes fewer tubes to obtain the desired flow per tube by wrapping them around the furnace to create the enclosure. This also has the benefit of passing all tubes through all heat zones to maintain a nearly even build temperature at the outlet of the lower portion of the furnace. Because the tubes are “wrapped” around the furnace to form the enclosure, fabrication and erection are considerably more complicated and costly. Spiral Tubes Water Walls Advantages / Disadvantages: Advantages: Benefits from averaging of heat absorption variation resulting in less tube failure. No individual tube orifice Reduced no of evaporator wall tubes and ensure minimum water flow Minimizes peak tube metal temperature Minimum Tube to Tube metal temperature difference Disadvantages: Complex wind box opening Complex water wall support system Tube leakage identification – a tough task More the water wall pressure drop : Increases boiler feed pump power input Adherence of ash on the shell of tube fin 660 MW Supercritical Thermal Power Plant Boiler Operating Parameters FD FAN 2 No’s (Axial) 11 KVA /1950 KW 228mmwc 1732 T/Hr PA FAN 2 No’s (Axial) 11 KVA /3920 KW 884 mmwc 947 T/Hr ID FAN 2 No’s (Axial) 11 KVA /5820 KW 3020 T/Hr Total Air 2535 T/ Hr SH OUTLET PRESSURE /TEMPERATURE / FLOW 256 Ksc / 5400C /2225 T /Hr SH OUTLET PRESSURE /TEMPERATURE / FLOW 46 Ksc / 5680C / 1742 T/Hr SEPARATOR OUTLET PRESSURE /TEMPERATURE 277 Ksc / 412 C ECONOMISER INLET 304 Ksc / 270 C MILL OPERATION 7 / 10 COAL REQUIREMENT 471 T/Hr SH / RH Spray 89 / 0.0 T/Hr Boiler Efficiency 87 % AIR AND FLUE GAS PASS SYSTEM Similar to 500 MW units No of ESP Passes: 6 No of field per passes = 18, 1 to 7 field 70 kv 8 & 9 field 80 Kv No of Hoppers per pass = 36 Flue Gas Flow per pass = 1058 T / Hr (Over Heat Degree Superheat) Over Heat Degree of Super Heat (OHDR) In Operation of Supercritical Boiler, many important Parameters are required to be monitored and controlled; Over Heat Degree of Super Heat (OHDR) is one of them. Just to simplify, if in a supercritical Boiler, if the evaporator water temperature is maintained at 405 Deg C at 25 MPA , then it will have a OHDR of 20 deg C, as the critical temperature as per T-S curve for a pressure of 25 MPA is 385 Deg C Generally Boiler Manufacturers specify OHDR around 25 Deg C, and Water to coal ratio of 6 to 7. Higher OHDR than 25 Deg C essentially means that the Heat absorbed in the evaporator section is more than designed as a result of which steam will be generated in in Straight Water walls , steam being a bad conductor of Heat will not be able to absorb heat from the Water wall Tubes, as a result of which the metal temperature of water walls will have a tendency to shoot up. This may lead to failure of water walls or supply tubes exposed to high heat radiant portions, but not able to cool down. Higher OHDR also means that as compared to Water flow, coal consumed will be more, displaying lower Water to Coal ratio than specified. Low water to coal ratio will also happen in cases where GCV of coal is much lower requiring much more coal for generating same quantity of steam. Lower OHDR than 25 DegC signifies that Water is not able to absorb required heat, thereby leading to evaporation of water post evaporator, Water to coal ratio will show higher value , establishing that water flow is higher than Coal, this will lead to drop in Water and eventually steam temperature. Low OHDR will lead to lowering of Steam generation and eventually MW generated. So monitoring and maintaining OHDR and Water to Coal ratio are significantly important aspects for stable and efficient Operation of a Supercritical Boiler Comparison of water chemistry Steam pressure vs. load: Constant pressure implies stable pressure of the steam generator and main steam line over the unit’s load range. Meanwhile, the basic nature of a simple, rotating turbine is to require less pressure as load and flow rate are reduced, and if the main steam pressure is limited to only that required for each load, this mode is referred to as pure sliding pressure. Sliding Pressure: Implies the variable pressure required at the turbine inlet based on load & steam flow rate . Again the sliding pressure can be classified as pure sliding pressure modified sliding pressure The basic nature of a simple, rotating turbine is to require less pressure as load and flow rate are reduced, and if the main steam pressure is limited to only that required for each load, this mode is referred to as pure sliding pressure. However, when we speak generally of “sliding pressure” we often mean “modified sliding pressure”. This mode has a limited amount of pressure throttling to provide a modest amount of fast-response load reserve. The modified sliding pressure operation combines the advantages of constant-pressure operation with those of the sliding pressure mode. The ability to activate the storage capacity of the boiler by opening the throttle valves is combined with the advantages of low lifetime consumption of the plant and high part load efficiency. Kcal /kWh HHV 2376 2232 Spiral Waterwall Tubes: Among the heat-absorbing surfaces, the furnace walls are exposed to the highest heat flux. This is because of the intense radiant heat from the fireball. Currently, two design variants are used for once-through units: the spiral furnace tube arrangement and the vertical tube arrangement. Design choice is governed by furnace size and customer preference – both variants have advantages, depending on project drivers. RIFLE TUBE & PLAIN TUBE Start up and low load re-circulation system One of the critical parameters of a once-through system is the proper selection of minimum acceptable once-through flow in the evaporator tubes. Below a particular load, the water wall flow is kept constant in order to ensure flow, high enough to cool the tubes. This load is typically 30 – 40% of BMCR and below this load; the boiler will operate under the low load re-circulation system At low loads where the water flow is to be kept constant, a water-steam separator and a drain water return system are required. The water separator consists of one or more vertical vessels with tangential inlets. The separator is in a wet condition when operating under the low load circulation range. In the once-through mode, the separator runs dry. Steam Separator: Generally a steam separator and a separator drain tank were installed to separate the steam and the water at the furnace outlet during a low-load recirculation operation. This design is different from that of a conventional NC boiler, for which a steam drum is installed to separate the water from the steam under all operating loads. The steam drum is designed to have sufficient water storage capacity, and usually contains complicated internal parts, such as steam cyclones, scrubbers, internal feed pipes, and baffles. Because of the complex internals, steam drums require a large amount of maintenance work during outage periods. However, the steam separator design is simple in configuration and has no internal, therefore significantly less maintenance work is required. Steam Drum Steam Separator Boiler Start –up systems: The start-up system in super critical boilers is used to protect super-heaters from water carry-over by separating water from steam and re-circulating it through the evaporator surfaces during start-up, low load operation and shutdown of the boiler. The required water flow rate through the evaporator tubes is therefore maintained greater than the evaporation rate to protect them against overheating. The start-up system equipment consists of two steam water separators, a water collection tank, a boiler circulating pump and the associated piping and control valves to return the fluid from the water collection tank to the economizer inlet. During start-up, the unit is operated much like a drum boiler where water is recirculated to maintain a minimum flow through the furnace equivalent to 30% of full load flow. The system is similar to a pumped circulation drum boiler with the steam water separators and the water collection tank functioning like the steam drum. The water flowing through the furnace is a combination of water from the water collection tank and boiler feedwater. The boiler feed pump controls the total flow through the furnace so the minimum required mass flow is maintained. Steam generated through the furnace circuits is separated from the water in the vertical separator, routed to the super heater and then to either the steam turbine or the turbines bypass system. The water from the vertical separator is returned to the water collection tank and then to the circulating pump. The 381 valve, located at the discharge of the circulating pump, controls the flow proportionally to tank level to maintain the water inventory in the collection tank. Water is also recirculated from the pump discharge to the collecting tank to assure that the minimum flow required through the pump is maintained. Above the minimum boiler load the unit switches to oncethrough operation. The circulating pump is taken out of service but is kept pressurized. A small flow of feedwater from the economizer outlet is routed to the circulating pump inlet and back to the separator to maintain the components in the ready state for use during shutdown. From the figure below we can understand the complete system of the start up of the supercritical boiler. If we can see the start up thoroughly we will find the starting procedure of a supercritical boiler is similar to the subcritical boiler. TYPE OF BOILER: Single Drum Top supported, Fusion welded WW Panel, Controlled circulation system, Tangential fired, Radiant Dry Bottom Pulverized coal fired outdoor Balanced Draught Cut corner 51mm OD WW Tubes at 63.5 mm pitch Rap around Buck stay system Controlled Circulation In Boiler: If the Operating pressure of boiler is between 180 kg/cm2 to 200 kg/cm2 then circulation in boiler is to be assisted with mechanical pumps, to maintain circulation through WW. To regulate the flow through various tubes, orifice plates are used WHAT IS A BOILER TURNDOWN RATIO? A boiler turndown ratio refers to the ratio between a boiler’s highest fire setting (maximum output) and lowest fire setting (minimum output). Turndown ratios vary depending on the boiler. For example, if your boiler has a 3:1 turndown ratio, that means that at its lowest fire setting you will be operating at 33% of the boiler’s full capacity. If you have a 10:1 turndown, that means that at its lowest setting, your boiler is operating at 10% of its full capacity. WHY IS A BOILER TURNDOWN RATIO IMPORTANT? Generally, a higher turndown ratio provides more flexibility and more efficient operations that translate into significant cost savings over time. Some facilities need to run their boilers at the highest settings only on infrequent occasions or during seasonal peak demands. Even though these occasions are rare, the facility needs to have enough steam system capacity to meet those demands when they arise. It doesn’t make sense to run a boiler at full capacity 24x7x365, which is why it’s crucial for facilities with fluctuating demands to have a flexible turndown ratio that allows them to “turn down” the capacity to better match their actual demand. If the boiler does not have a high turndown ratio, facilities don’t have many options for controlling how much fuel they’re using. Operating a boiler system with a high turndown ratio offers these facilities greater efficiency because it can operate at a lower capacity during low-demand times while also meeting those peak demands with ease. BOILER EXPANSION DETAILS FIRST PASS: • Vertically Downward Expansion at Ring Header (10.250mtr elev.) : 330mm • Horizontal Expansion at Ring Header (10.250mtr elev.) : 36mm SECOND PASS : • Vertically Downward Expansion at Ring Header (44.060mtr elev.) : 174mm • Horizontal Expansion at Ring Header (44.060mtr elev.) : 58mm BOILER EXPANSION DETAILS • BOILER DRUM EXPANSION : • Vertical Downward Expansion at 75.333mtr elev.=29mm • Horizontal Expansion at 75.333mtr elev.= 53mm BOILER PARAMETERS (BMCR) / 500 MW • STEAM FLOW AT SH OUTLET • PRESSURE OF SUPERHEATED STEAM • TEMP.OF SUPERHEATED STEAM - 1625 t/h 178 kg/sq.cm 540 0C • • • • • 1392.4 t/h 45.04 kg/sq.cm 337 0C 42.39kg/sq.cm 540 0C STEAM FLOW AT REHEATER OUTLET ENTRY PRESSURE OF REHEATED STEAM ENTRY TEMP. OF REHEATED STEAM EXIT PRESSURE OF REHEATED STEAM ENTRY TEMP. OF REHEATED STEAM - • FEED WATER INLET TEMP. FEED WATER TEMP BEFORE ECO. FEED WATER TEMP AFTER ECO. - 254.5 0C 283 0C 357 0C Boiler Parameters • TEMP.AT LTSH OUTLET • TEMP.AT S/H DIVISIONAL OUTLET • TEMP.AT FINAL S/H OUTLET - 436 0C 488 0C 540 0C DESIGN PARAMETERS OF BOILER • • • • • • BOILER DRUM PRESSURESH OUTLET PRESSURE FINAL SH TEMP. REHEATER OUTLET PRESSURE BOILER HYD. TEST PRESSURE REHEATER HYD. TEST PRESSURE - 209 kg/sq cm 191 kg/sq cm 540 0C 52.4 kg/sq cm 313.5 kg/sq cm 78.6 kg/sq cm HEATING SURFACE OF BOILER • • • • • • • • • ECONOMISER WATER WALL STEAM COOLED WALL LTSH SH DIVISIONAL PANELS PLATEN SH (FINAL SH) SH ROOF RH FRONT COILS RH REAR COILS - 20000 sq mtr 7000 sq mtr 2010 sq mtr 8500 sq mtr 2025 sq mtr 2200 sq mtr 830 sq mtr 4128 sq mtr 3500 sq mtr • TOTAL HEATING SURFACE AREA = 50193 sq mtr WATER HOLDING CAPACITY OF BOILER • • • • • BOILER DRUM (FULL) : CIRCULATION SYSTEM : ECONOMISER : SUPERHEATER(LTSH,SH Div. Panel, Final SH): REHEATER : • TOTAL VOLUME : 60 cubic mtr 170 cubic mtr 150 cubic mtr 130 cubic mtr 105 cubic mtr 615 cubic mtr • DM WATER REQUIRED FOR HYD. TEST (DRAINABLE) : 420 cubic mtr SOOT BLOWER DETAILS • WALL SOOT BLOWERS : 88 Nos. (FUTURE - 16 Nos.) (FRONT & REAR AT EACH ELEVATION - 6 Nos. EACH, RHS &LHS -5 Nos. EACH, TOTAL 4 ELEVATIONS) • LRSB • APH SOOT BLOWERS : 40 Nos. (FUTURE - 4 Nos.) :2 Nos. COMPARISON BETWEEN NATURAL & ASSISTED CIRCULATION BOILERS S/H S/H DRUM DRUM BOILER WALLS ECO ECO BOILER WALLS CC PUMP FEED LINE FEED LINE RING HEADER NATURAL CIRCULATION BOILER (SUB CRITICAL BOILER 30MW-250MW) DRUM CG. 26 MTR – 58 MTR FORCE CAUSING FLOW OF WATER THROUGH TUBES F = WCOLD X H1 - W HOT X H2 RING HEADER ASSISTED CIRCULATION BOILER (500MW) DRUM CG – 75.33 MTRS CRITICAL BOILERS OR ONCE TROUGH OR MONOTYPE BOILER STEAM SEPERATOR BOILER WALLS S/H WATER ECO DRAIN FEED PUMP IMPORTANT FEATURES OF 500 MW BOILER • • • • • • • • • • • • • • C.C. PUMPS ORIFICE PLATES IN BOTTOM RING HEADER RIFLED TUBES IN WATER WALLS DIVISIONAL SUPERHEATERS ECO LINK CONNECTIONS FROM BOTTOM OF BOILER DRUM DOWN COMMERS CONNECTION TO ONLY BOTTOM RING HEADER. ECO RECIRCULATION CONNECTION TO BOTTOM RING HEADER REAR. 2 NOS. TRISECTOR TYPE AIR PREHEATERS. 8 NOS. BOWL MILLS ( XRP 1043 TYPE) & GRAVEMETRIC 36” SIVE FEEDER ( FEEDER LOCATION 21 MeL ) 4 NOS OIL ELEVATION & 8 NOS. COAL ELEVATION. 2 NOS. I.D FANS, 2 NOS. F.D.FANS, 2 NOS. SEAL AIR FAN, 11 SILENCERS , No of SAFETY VALVES - 20 HEA IGNITERS. COAL CONSUMPTION – 8400 T/HR. NUMBER OF TUBES & DIAMETERS DESCRIPTION NO. OF TUBES / PANELS DIAMETER OF TUBE IN MM 68 NOS. 159 FRONT-269 NOS., REAR-269 NOS, LHS-212 NOS, RHS-212 NOS. 51 HANGER TUBES 44 NOS. 63.5 SCREEN TUBES 177 NOS. 63.5 REAR ARCH 177 NOS. 63.5 LHS-37 NOS.& RHS-37 NOS. 63.5 ECONOMISER 92 X 3 BANKS 38.1 LTSH 62 X 2 BANKS 47.63 6 ASSY. & 8 PANELS i.e. 48 NOS. 44.5 25 COILS 51 FRONT-74 NOS. & REAR 74 NOS. 54 RADIENT ROOF 1ST PASS 150 NOS. 63.5 SUPER HEATER CONNECTION TUBES(DRUM TO RADIENT ROOF ) 21 NOS. 159 B.P. SIDE WALL ( FRONT ) 60 NOS. 63.5 B.P. SIDE WALL ( REAR ) 31 NOS. 51 B.P. ROOF TUBES 126 NOS. 51 B.P.FRONT SCW TUBE 126 NOS. 51 B.P.REAR WALL TUBE 137 NOS. 51 RISER TUBES( W/W O/L HDR. TO DRUM) WATER WALL ( FUSION WELDED ) EXTENDED SIDE W/W PANEL DIVISIONAL PANELLETE FINAL SUPERHEATER REAHEATER SAFETY VALVES LOCATION M.S.LINE HRH LINE CRH LINE SAFETY VALVE 2 4 2 2 ERV (ELECTROMATIC RELIEF VALVE) 4 DRUM 6 What are the key differences between the subcritical boiler units and the Supercritical boiler units? 1. Boiler Efficiency The main advantage and the reason for a higher pressure operation is the increase in the thermodynamic efficiency of the Rankine cycle. Large Subcritical thermal power plants with 170 bar and 540 / 540 ° C (SH / RH) operate at an efficiency of 38 %. Supercritical boiler units operating at 250 bar and 600/615 ° C can have efficiencies in the range of 42 %. Ultra supercritical boiler units at 300 bar and 615 / 630 °C will still increase the efficiency up to 44 %. Increase in efficiency directly lead to reductions in unit cost of power and CO2 emissions. 2. Operational Flexibility: Most of the Supercritical boiler units use the once through technology. This is ideal for sliding pressure operation which has much more flexibility in load changes and controlling the power grid. However this also requires more sensitive and quick responding control systems. 3. Evaporation End Point: In subcritical boiler units the drum acts as a fixed evaporation end point. The furnace water walls act as the evaporator. Not so in the case of a supercritical unit. The evaporation end point can occur in various levels of the furnace depending on the boiler load. The percentage of Superheat in supercritical boiler units is higher than subcritical boiler units. Because of this the furnace tubes act more as superheaters than waterwalls. This necessitates the use of higher grade of materials like alloy steels in the furnace. 4. Heat transfer Area: Higher steam temperatures in supercritical boiler units results in a lesser differential temperature for heat transfer. Because of this heat transfer areas required are higher than subcritical boiler units. Higher Superheat steam temperatures entering the HP turbine also mean higher reheater inlet temperatures which again results in a higher heat transfer areas. 5. Water chemistry: In supercritical boiler units the water entering the boiler has to be of extremely high levels of purity. Supercritical boilers do not have a steam drum that separates the steam and the water. If the entering water quality is not good, carry over of impurities can result in turbine blade deposits. 6. Materials: Supercritical power plants use special high grade materials for the boiler tubes. The turbine blades are also of improved design and materials. In fact, the very increase in higher pressure and temperature designs are dependent on the development of newer and newer alloys and tube materials. The aim of the industry is to achieve power plant efficiencies in the range of 50 %. Thankyou