COMPANY RECONSTRUCTION 1 OBJECTIVES After you have studied this chapter, you will be able to: 1. Differentiate between internal and external reconstruction. 2. Explain two way of capital reduction under internal reconstruction. 3. Explain accounting treatment for internal and external reconstruction. 2 INTRODUCTION Reconstruction occurs when a company makes material and formal changes to its capital structure. A company may have to reduce its paid-up share capital when: a) it has more than its optimum level of capital or b) its paid-up capital has been eroded by heavy losses. There are two types of reconstruction: 1) Internal reconstruction 2) External reconstruction 3 INTERNAL RECONSTRUCTION OR CAPITAL REDUCTION Internal reconstruction may be undertaken by a company that has surplus capital or its capital has been eroded by trading losses. A company may reduce its share capital in one of two ways: 1) By a special resolution and confirmation by the court 2) By a special resolution supported by a solvency statement 4 Reduction of Share Capital with Court Approval and Special Resolution Section 116 of the Company Act 2016 allows a company to reduce its capital in the following three situations: a) Write off or reduce the liability on its unpaid share capital. For example, a company with 50 million shares with an issue of RM2.50 per share paid to RM1.80 each, reduces the ordinary shares to RM1.80 each, fully paid. b) Cancel any paid-up capital which is lost or unrepresented by assets. The paid-up share capital is reduced to reflect the net assets of the company. c) Return to the shareholders any paid-up share capital which in excess of the needs of the company. 5 Reduction of Share Capital by Solvency Statement All the directors of the company are to make a solvency statement in relation to the reduction of share capital. The statement has to be made within 14 days for a private company and 21 days for a public company of the date of the resolution. In the case of the reduction of capital, a company satisfies the solvency test if: 1. Immediately after the reduction of capital there is no ground on which the company could be 6 found to be unable to pay its debts. Reduction of Share Capital by Solvency Statement 2. Either if it is intended to commence the winding up of the company within 12 months after the reduction of capital, the company will be able to pay its debts within 12 months after the commencement of the winding up; or in any other case, the company will be able to pay its debts as they become due during the period of 12 months immediately following the date of the reduction of capital. 3. The assets of the company exceed the liability of the company at the end of the reduction of capital. 7 Sections 64, Company Act 1965 allows company to reduce its capital in 3 situations: 1. To reduce or write off the uncalled capital on its shares. 2. To refund any surplus capital. 3. To cancel paid-up capital not represented by assets. 8 Reduce or Write Off the Uncalled Capital On Company’s Shares A company may have capital in excess of its needs, and at the same time its shares may only be partly called up. In this case, it may be in the interest of the company to reduce or write off uncalled capital as the company has more than sufficient capital and does not wish to make the calls at all. No accounting transaction. 9 Refund of Surplus Capital It happens when the company has excess financial resources and is not utilizing it. Consequence ⇒ low return on capital. Having excess capital may be detrimental to the company as it may not be able to meet shareholders’ expectation of higher return, dividend or earnings per share. As a result, the company’s share price may fall. One way to reduce its excess cash balances is for the company to reduce the paid-up value of the shares and refund the surplus capital to the shareholders. 10 Refund of Surplus Capital The accounting entries are: Debit Ordinay share capital Credit Bank 11 Capital Reduction Where Capital is Not Represented by Available Assets (Lost Capital) A company’s capital is eroded when the company has incurred heavy losses and has unable to pay dividends to its shareholders for number of years. The company can either be wound up (liquidated) or reconstructed. Liquidation of a company involves the disposal of the assets, settlement of the liabilities and distribution of the remaining assets to the shareholders. Known as “turnaround situation”. 12 Capital Reduction Where Capital is Not Represented by Available Assets (Lost Capital) Given below is the statement of financial position of a company whose capital is not represented by available assets. ABC Sdn Bhd Statement of Financial Position as at 31 December x4 Non-current tangible assets Intangible assets Current assets 600,000 ordinary shares Accumulated losses Current liabilities RM 200,000 20,000 30,000 250,000 600,000 (400,000) 200,000 50,000 250,000 13 Capital Reduction Where Capital is Not Represented by Available Assets (Lost Capital) In this company, the accumulated losses of RM400,000 have eroded the paid-up capital. There is also a cash flow problem as there is negative working capital (30,000-50,000 = -20,000). In this situation the company can: 1) Continue to be in business and face further erosion of capital. 2) Wind up its business 3) Reorganise 14 Journal Entries To Record A Scheme Of Capital Reduction a) b) c) d) Amount written off share capital Debit Share capital account Credit Capital reduction account xxx Reserves utilized for the scheme Debit Reserve account Credit Capital reduction account xxx To write off accumulated losses Debit Capital reduction account Credit Accumulated loss xxx Amount written off assets Debit Capital reduction account Credit Relevant assets xxx xxx xxx xxx xxx 15 Journal Entries To Record A Scheme Of Capital Reduction e) f) g) Surplus on revaluation of assets Debit Relevant assets Credit Capital reduction account xxx Shares issued in settlement of liabilities Debit Relevant liability Credit Share capital account xxx xxx xxx Issue of new shares in lieu of preference dividends in arrears Debit Capital reduction account xxx Credit Share capital account xxx 16 Journal Entries To Record A Scheme Of Capital Reduction h) Expenses of capital reduction Debit Capital reduction account Credit Cash/bank account i) Surplus on capital reduction account Debit Capital reduction account Credit Capital reserve account xxx xxx xxx xxx 17 Example 1: Internal Reconstruction (Refer to Attached file) 18 EXTERNAL RECONSTRUCTION The existing company is wound up and the new company is formed. A new company is form by the existing shareholders to take over the assets and liabilities of an ailing company. The consideration paid is usually in shares of the new company. The cost of undertaking an external reconstruction will be higher as one company has to be wound up and another formed. 19 BOOKS OF THE OLD COMPANY The realization and reconstruction account (RR account) is created. The RR account is debited with all the assets disposed of and credited with the purchase consideration. The balances in the various reserve accounts are transferred to the RR account instead of to the sundry members’ account. This is to determine the full loss sustained by the company. The loss borne by the shareholders is credited to the RR account and debited to the sundry members’ account. 20 EXAMPLE 2 Given below is the statement of financial position of Construction Bhd as at 31 December x9. Non-current assets Current assets 300,000 ordinary shares 100,000 6% preference shares Accumulated losses 8% debentures Trade payables RM 200,000 100,000 300,000 300,000 100,000 400,000 (200,000) 200,000 50,000 50,000 21 EXAMPLE 2 A scheme of reconstruction was agreed to by all parties and the required approvals received. A new company named Reconstruction was formed and its constitution states that the company’s capital is made up of 8 percent preference shares and ordinary shares. Reconstruction acquired all the assets of Construction for the following considerations: a) A 9 % loan stock in Reconstruction worth RM50,000 was issued to satisfy the claims of the debenture holders of Construction Bhd. 22 EXAMPLE 2 The trade payables of RM20,000 were paid in cash and the balance in 9% loan stock. Four 8% preference shares were issued at RM1 each for every five preference shares in Construction. The ordinary shareholders received one ordinary shares in Reconstruction for every three ordinary shares in Construction. The ordinary shares have a fair value of RM1 each. The non-current assets were valued at RM210,000 and the current assets at RM70,000. You are required to close the books of Construction Bhd. 23 EXAMPLE 2 ANSWER Determine the purchase consideration. RM To the ordinary shareholders One ordinary shares for every three shares held (1/3 x 300,000 x RM1) To the preference shareholders Four preference shares for every five shares held (4/5 x 100,000 x RM1) To the debenture holders 9% loan stock To the trade payables Cash 9% loan stock 100,000 80,000 50,000 20,000 30,000 24 280,000 EXAMPLE 2 Realisation and Reconstruction Account RM Non-current assets 200,000 Reconstruction Current assets 100,000 Loss on Realisation c/d 300,000 Balance b/d Accumulated losses 20,000 300,000 20,000 Sundry member’s account: 200,000 Preference Ordinary 220,000 RM 280,000 20,000 200,000 220,000 25 EXAMPLE 2 Realization and reconstruction Ordinary shares in Reconstruction Sundry Members-Ordinary RM 200,000 Balance b/d RM 300,000 100,000 300,000 300,000 26 EXAMPLE 2 Realization and reconstruction Reconstruction Account RM 280,000 Trade payable: Cash 9% loan stock Debenture holders: 9% loan stock Sundry members Preference Ordinary 280,000 RM 20,000 30,000 50,000 80,000 100,000 280,000 27 THE END 28