Insert company logo Common Hazards in the Food Manufacturing Sector Photo credit: Thong Siek Food Industry This set of slides may be used to complement your company’s in-house Workplace Safety & Health (WSH) training for workers. Common hazards highlighted can be contextualised to meet your workplace needs. Case studies with recommendations serve as good learning points. Safe work practices can help to prevent workplace accidents and injuries. All rights reserved, May 2019. The information provided in this training slides is accurate at time of publication. All examples shared in this training slides are meant for learning purposes only. The learning points for each example are not exhaustive and should not be taken to encapsulate all the responsibilities and obligations of the user of this training slides under the law. The Workplace Safety and Health Council does not accept any liability or responsibility for any modifications made to this set of training slides. Insert company logo 2 Contents 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Workplace Safety and Health (WSH) Policy WSH Rules and Regulations Risk Assessment Communication of WSH Hazards Common Hazards Other Hazards Insert company logo 3 1. Workplace Safety & Health (WSH) Policy The objective of the WSH Policy is to show the management’s commitment in ensuring a safe and healthy environment for everyone, and this includes all employees, visitors, interns, vendors, contractors, etc at the workplace. Example of a WSH Policy Statement (Source: www.wshc.sg) The WSH Council is committed to ensuring the safety and health of its members and employees. We believe that all WSH incidents are preventable. We will continually work towards building a strong WSH culture and achieving zero work injuries. We also recognise that every staff has a part to play in making the WSH Council a safe and healthy workplace for everyone. Insert company logo 4 Workplace Safety & Health (WSH) Policy Insert your company’s WSH Policy here. Insert company logo 5 2. WSH Rules and Regulations 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Follow all safe work procedures (SWP) and instructions. Report all unsafe work conditions and unsafe work practices to your supervisor or WSH Officer. … Please insert your organisation specific WSH rules and regulations.here. This can include work flow processes, equipment operation and … maintenance, emergency response etc. Emphasise on the Risk Management programme to prevent injury and ill health to employees. … Includes Workplace Health programmes/initiatives for staff well-being, where applicable too. Insert company logo 6 3. Risk Assessment • We can do our part to ensure a safe workplace for everyone. • Simple risk assessment using Look. Think. Do. • Look out for danger or potential risk(s). • Think of how to protect yourself and fellow co-workers. • Do your work safely. Insert company logo 7 Risk Assessment Insert company logo 8 3.1 Addressing Risks Step 1 Identify the Hazards. - Types (e.g., machinery hazards) and the associated risks. Step 2 Evaluate the Risks. - Is risk level acceptable? Low, medium and high. Step 3 Implement Risk Control Measures. - Take action to eliminate or reduce risks. Insert company logo 9 3.2 Risk Control Measures • Reduce the need for direct interaction with machine through the use of technology or automation. • Replace with a safer machine or manufacturing process. • Use of machine guards and interlock system. • Use of safe work procedures and lock-out tag-out. • Use of hardhat, safety goggles, safety gloves, hearing protectors and safety footwear etc. Insert company logo 10 4. Communication of WSH Hazards • Supervisor to highlight site-specific/equipment-specific WSH hazards (e.g., during toolbox meetings). • Workers are encouraged to inform Supervisor of any unsafe situation encountered at their worksite. • Near-miss incidents should be reported so that actions can be taken to prevent accidents. Ref: WSH Guide to Effective Toolbox meeting. Click guide. Insert company logo 11 5. Common Hazards 5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4 5.5 5.6 Slips, trips and falls Caught in machine Struck by falling object Contact with hot objects/surfaces Musculoskeletal Disorder Fires and explosions Insert company logo 12 5.1 Slips, Trips and Falls Slips, Trips and Falls are the most common causes of workplace injuries and can result in sprains, fractures, severe head injuries and even fatalities in some cases. Insert picture of obstructed walkway or spills Do: • Practise good housekeeping. • Wear anti-slip shoes. • Report uneven/damaged flooring. • Put up warning signs: slippery floors uneven floor damaged floors 13 Slips, Trips and Falls Some control measures include: • Cable trench to cover cables • Increase floor resistance e.g., placing anti-slip tape/mat/tiles Insert company logo Cable trench covering cables Anti-slip mat Warning strips on steps Anti-slip tile 14 Slips, Trips and Falls Case Study • A worker slipped, fell and hit her head on the floor at a bread factory around 1.30 am. • The slippery floor was caused by condensation outside the freezer. Worker was wearing her own footwear and walking towards the freezer when the accident happened. • The worker became unconscious and subsequently passed away. Recommendations • Practise good housekeeping by keeping the floor dry. • Install signages to warn others of wet floor. • Wear safety footwear at all times and ensure that it is in good condition by checking it regularly. Ref: Case Studies for Food Manufacturing (link). 15 5.2 Caught in machine • Machines with moving parts, if not handled properly, can cause severe injuries. • Injuries may also occur when working with unguarded machinery. • Many machines pose mechanical hazards which may lead to cuts entanglement, crushing, etc. • Use of machine guard is an effective engineering risk control measure. Mixer without guard Interlock installed such that mixer will shut off once the cover is lifted 16 Caught in machine Do: • Allow only trained, competent and authorised personnel to operate the machine. • Install warning sign(s) to alert machine operator the presence of hazard. • Ensure machine guarding is in place before operating the machine. • Turn off the main power switch before carrying out repair, maintenance and inspection. • Apply Lockout Tagout (LOTO ) procedure. 17 Caught in machine LOTO procedure • Announce the shutdown • Notify all affected workers that the machine is to be shut down. • Shutdown the machine • Proceed to shut down machine after ensuring that all moving parts have come to complete stop. • Ensure that there is no hazard caused to the workers during the shutting down of the machine. • Disconnect the energy source • Ensure the hazardous energy to the machine is properly isolated using circuit breakers, valves or isolating switches. • Confirm stored energy (e.g., present in springs, electrical, hydraulic and pneumatic systems) is dissipated before starting work. Insert company logo 18 Caught in machine LOTO procedure • Apply lockout tagout • Use a padlock to ensure hazardous energy cannot be restored unexpectedly or accidentally. • Affix a durable tag to provide identity of the person placing the lockout, and to warn that a work activity on the machine is in progress. • Verify the isolation and lockout • Check isolation and lockout is in use and effective. • Test the machine to confirm that it is unable to start by switching the controls to ‘on’ position. • Switch back to ‘off’ after the test. Insert company logo 19 Caught in machine Do not: • • • Work if you are unwell or on medication that can affect your alertness at work. Wear loose clothing or jewellery when operating the machine. Place your hands inside the machine while it is in operation. Insert company logo 20 Caught in machine Case Study Worker was collecting a sample of blended food product from a mixing tank. • Mixing tank was still in operation when the worker opened its cover to collect the sample. • Co-worker found the injured worker inside the mixing tank and he was pronounced dead at the scene. Recommendations • Install a safety interlock to power off the mixing tank once its cover is opened. • Collect the sample from the missing tank only if the mixer rotating mechanism has been de-energized. • Collect the sample from a safe location (e.g., from the storage container of blended product) instead of directly from the mixing tank. • 21 Cases in the news Past cases where machine guarding could be used to prevent accidents: 1. Worker caught by mixer rotating arm while preparing bean paste. URL: https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/bakery-owner-died-when-he-was-caught-by-rotating-mixer-arm-and-pulled-inside 2. Worker’s arm caught in meat grinder in supermarket. URL: https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/giant-supermarket-worker-hurt-after-arm-caught-in-meat-grinder Insert company logo 22 Caught in machine All hand injuries are preventable! Insert company logo 23 5.3 Struck by falling object Struck by falling object (SBFO) can lead to head or body injuries and even death. SBFO may occur in warehouses and store rooms with rack systems. 24 5.3 Struck by falling object Do: • Store loose, small or irregularly shaped items in boxes/crates. • Secure items from falling off with bars or straps across the shelf. • Store heavy items on lower shelves. • Use a step stool or ladder for access to foods above head level in a store room. • Adhere to the safe working load of the storage rack. • Inform Supervisor of unstable racks or loose/corroded joints encountered daily during periodic inspection. • Put a safety helmet in work areas where there is a risk of falling object. 25 Struck by falling object Case Study • A worker was found dead after he was pinned beneath the fruit crates in a warehouse. • He was standing next to a stacked column of metal racks which collapsed on him. • The racks were used to store crates of fruits. Recommendations • Use engineered racks to store heavy items. • Store heavier items on lower racks • Ensure no over-loading of items on the rack. • Conduct periodic inspection to look for defects in the racks (e.g., corrosion, dents and loose bolts and nuts). Heavier items placed on lower racks 26 Struck by falling objects Insert company logo 27 5.4 Contact with hot objects/surfaces Contact with hot objects/surfaces may involve contact with hot machines or processing equipment (e.g., steamer, oven), hot medium (e.g., deep frying oil) and hot food intermediate/product. Serious injuries such as burns or scalds can take place, and even resulting in death. Do: •Ensure all hot surfaces are insulated.. •Check for presence for warning signage(s) on hot surfaces including gauges and sampling points where insulation is not present.. •Wear appropriate PPEs ( e.g. gloves) when there is a need to work with hot equipment. Hot surface where insulation not present Photo credit: Thong Siek Food Industry 28 Contact with hot objects/surfaces Case Study A worker closed the door of an oven after placing meat into the oven for roasting. After 30 mins, he opened the oven door and turned the gas knob to release gas to the stove. He then lighted up the gas stove. Fire suddenly gushed out from the oven and injured the worker. Fig 1: Gas stove inside oven Fig 2: Releasing knob for gas Fig 3: Gas lighter Insert company logo 29 Contact with hot objects/surfaces Recommendations • Train the worker on the safe use of the stove and oven. • Provide a physical barrier or better position the gas knob so as to avoid the possibility of accidental contact with the gas knob. • Carry out periodic inspection of the oven, gas knob and piping as part of preventive maintenance regime. • Ensure there is adequate ventilation provided at the workplace. Insert company logo 30 5.5 Musculoskeletal Disorder (MSD) MSD refers to body disorders involving muscles, tendons and nerves. Symptoms of MSD include pain, cramp, swelling, numbness and tingling sensation. Examples of MSD include trigger finger, carpal tunnel syndrome, pain (neck, shoulder, lower back). Do: •Bend your knees and keep your back straight when lifting an item. •Seek help or use a trolley when moving heavy items. •Use hand tools which are ergonomically designed (e.g., soft grip handle) to minimize excessive exertion. •Inform your Supervisor if you experience bodily discomfort (e.g., aches, cramps) which could be symptoms of ergonomic problems. 31 Musculoskeletal Disorder (MSD) Do not: • • • • • Engage in prolonged repetitive activities without taking breaks. Adopt awkward posture. Adhere to static posture throughout work. Bend down when carrying a heavy item. Subject yourself to prolonged vibrations. Awkward posture of overstretching Incorrect lifting of heavy objects 32 Musculoskeletal Disorder Case Study • • Worker is required to manually transfer 4 bags of dairy product every day. Each bag weighs 25kg. Worker experiences severe strain on back, arms and legs, resulting in high absenteeism from work. Recommendations • Eliminate the need for manual lifting where possible. • Use a mechanical aid to reduce the strain posed on the worker. • Seek help from co-worker or transfer smaller quantities (e.g., 10kg) per trip. Worker lifting bags of dairy product Worker using mechanical aid for the lifting 33 5.6 Fires and explosions Fires can occur in the presence of flammable materials, oxygen and an ignition source. Explosion can happen when the equipment or piping are over-pressurised. Fires and explosions can also occur when dealing with finely divided materials (e.g., flour, icing sugar). Insert pictures of flammable materials 34 Fires and explosions Do: • Keep area work free of ignition source or flammable materials wherever possible. • Ensure the workplace is well-ventilated when handling finely divided materials. • Periodically maintain the local exhaust ventilation system (e.g., canopy hood with associated ducting used for deep frying to ensure no accumulation of flammable materials (See recent fire at local hotel here). • Ensure proper electrical bonding/grounding when transferring materials from one tank/ container to another. • Ensure fire fighting equipment (e.g., extinguishers,hose reels), alarms and detectors are checked and tested periodically. 35 Fires and explosions Case study: Dust Explosion involving Flour • A worker was cutting the support of an old conveyor pipe system with a cutting torch when flour poured out from the bottom opening of the silo. • Flash fire and dust explosion occurred when the flour came into contact with air. • Worker suffered burns on arms, face and other parts of body. Recommendations •Establish a permit-to-work system for hot work activity so that the work area can be assessed to be safe. In this case, the silo must be checked to be fully drained before work commencement. •Ensure work area is well-ventilated when handling flammable dust. Insert company logo 36 6. Other hazards 6.1 6.2 6.3 6.4 6.5 6.6 Cut by object Fall from height Exposure to electrical current Noise-induced deafness Fatigue Exposure to chemicals Insert company logo 37 6.1 Cut by object When preparing raw food for processing, hand injuries may occur if working with sharp tools (e.g., knives) or machines (e.g., band saw). Do: •Use designated tool and ensure that it is sharp before use. •Work on flat surfaces to ensure stability when cutting. •Wear cut-resistant gloves when working with a sharp tool. •Segregate sharp tools from other tools. •Return tools to designated place after use. Use of sharp tools 38 Cut by object Do: • Wrap all waste containing sharp objects before disposing. • Use push plate when cutting meat with a band saw. Use of push plate 39 6.2 Fall from heights Fall from height accidents in the food manufacturing sector often involve the improper use of ladders. Do: •Use a ladder of the correct height for the job. •Maintain 3 points of contact with the ladder at all times while ascending or descending. •Use anti-slip footwear. 40 Fall from heights Do not: • • • Carry loose items in your hands when using a ladder. Use the ladder on uneven ground. Use the ladder if there is visible defect (e.g., missing step, leg broken or bent). 41 6.3 Exposed to electric current There is a risk of electrocution when working with electrical equipment. Some pointers to note include: Do: •Switch off electrical equipment when not in use. •Isolate and replace damaged equipment. •Report any damaged wiring found. •Keep electrical equipment away from moisture or steam. Unsafe act to use re-joined wires 42 Exposed to electrical current Do not: • • • Overload an electrical point. Use damaged electrical equipment. Repair damaged equipment if not qualified to do so. Overloaded electrical point 43 6.4 Noise-induced deafness Frequent and long term exposure to loud sounds during work can cause noise induced deafness (hearing loss). Do: •Wear ear plugs/muffs properly. •Practise job rotation for work in noisy areas. •Maintain your hearing protectors. •Take rest breaks in quiet place. Do not: •Work in a noisy environment without hearing protection. •Use hearing protectors that are damaged or in poor condition. 44 Noise-induced deafness Insert company logo 45 6.5 Fatigue Fatigue is a state of tiredness leading to reduced mental and/or physical performance that can endanger workplace safety. It can decrease a person’s alertness and compromise a worker’s motor skills, reflex ability, judgement and decision-making while at work. Do: •Ensure sufficient sleep before reporting for work. •Take rest breaks after working for long hours or carrying our strenuous work. •Ensure workplace is brightly lit and well-ventilated. •Report to your supervisor if you are severely fatigued. Do not: •Consume excessive alcohol or over-eat before work. •Continuously skip meals due to work commitments. Insert company logo 46 6.6 Exposure to chemicals Workers who are in regular contact with chemicals may experience skin sensitisation and/or respiratory problems. Do: •Read the label on the chemical container to understand the nature of its contents and how it can be handled safely. •Check that the chemical container is in good condition. •Close containers tightly and return to designated place after use. •Ensure there is proper ventilation in the work area when using chemicals. •Use the appropriate PPE (e,g, face shield, gloves apron) to protect against chemical contact. Insert company logo 47 Exposure to chemicals Do not: •Use chemicals without knowing its nature. •Store incompatible chemicals together. •Try to contain a chemical spill unless equipped with a proper spill kit. Insert company logo 48 END Insert company logo 49