FOR
ANIMAL
CLONING
 Mr Qiang Sun
 Director of Non-human
Primate Research Facility
 Academy of Sciences
Institute of Neurosciences
 Shanghai, China
FOR
ANIMAL
CLONING
 Dr Ian Wilmut
 Scientist
 Roslin Institute
 Scotland
 Dolly’s creator
FOR
ANIMAL
CLONING
 Dr Alan Trounson
 Stem biologist
 Monash University
 Melbourne, Australia
 Wilmut’s associate / Dolly
FOR
ANIMAL
CLONING
 Mr Xu Xiaochun
 CEO
 Boyalife Group
(biotechnology company)
 China
FOR
ANIMAL
CLONING
AGAINST
ANIMAL
CLONING
AGAINST
ANIMAL
CLONING
AGAINST
ANIMAL
CLONING
 Mrs Nicola Davis
 Journalist
 The Guardian
 USA
 Followed monkey cloning
in Shanghai
 Dr Robert Lowell
 Scientist
 Francis Crick Institute
 London
 Mrs Patricia Henwick
 European Group on Ethics
in Science and Technology
 Ireland
 Mrs Emma Portland
 Member of Parliament
 European Parliament
 Brussels, Belgium
AGAINST
ANIMAL
CLONING
AGAINST
ANIMAL
CLONING
FOR
HUMAN
CLONING
FOR
HUMAN
CLONING
 Mrs Alexandra Thomas
 European Food Safety
Authority
 France
 Mr Wesley Cole
 Advisory Committee on
Genetics, Health and
Society
 London
 Dr Woo S. Hwang
 (claimed to have made human clones
but lied)
 National University
 Seoul, South Korea
 Dr Brigitte Boisselier
 Head of Cloneaid
 Cloneaid = human cloning
company
 France
FOR
HUMAN
CLONING
FOR
HUMAN
CLONING
FOR
HUMAN
CLONING
AGAINST
HUMAN
CLONING
 Dr Severino Antinori
 Fertility doctor
 Italy
 Dr Panayotis Michael
Zavos
 Head of an organization
called the Andrology
Institute
 Italy
 Randolfe Wicker
 Founder of Clone Rights
United Front
 World’s first Pro-human
cloning activist organization
 New York City
 Mrs Emma Portland
 Member of Parliament
 European Parliament
 Brussels, Belgium
AGAINST
HUMAN
CLONING
AGAINST
HUMAN
CLONING
AGAINST
HUMAN
CLONING
AGAINST
HUMAN
CLONING
 Mrs Patricia Henwick
 European Group on Ethics
in Science and Technology
 Ireland
 Dr Richard Garner
 Research professor
 The Royal Society,
University of Oxford
 England
 Mr Aidan Carson
 European Group of
Advisers on the Ethical
Implications of
Biotechnology
 Scotland
 Mr Henry Dale
 Research professor
 The Royal Society,
University of Oxford
 England
AGAINST
HUMAN
CLONING
 Robert Miller
 Member of the House of
Representative
 Vote : ban human cloning
 Washington DC
Mr XU
Dr SUN
Mrs DAVIS
Mr WILMUT
Dr TROUNSON
Dr LOWELL
Mrs HENWICK
Mrs HENWICK
Mr MILLER
Dr GARNER
Dr DALE
MRS BOISSELIER
Dr HWANG
Dr ANTINORI
Dr ZAVOS
Mr CARSON
Mrs PORTLAND
Mrs PORTLAND
Mr WICKER
Mr COLE
Mrs THOMAS