+1 Traits® Condensed 5-Point 3-12 Writer’s Rubric aka One Pager Modified for Short Answer Responses
Word Choice: The use of science vocabulary,
and precise language that is accurate and informs
the reader.
Organization: The internal structure, thread of
central meaning, logical and sometimes intriguing
pattern or sequence of the ideas.
 Words convey the intended message in a
precise, interesting, and natural way.
*Conventions: The mechanical correctness of
the piece; spelling, punctuation, capitalization,
grammar usage, and paragraphing.
The organizational structure of this responses
enhances and showcases the central idea or
theme of the lesson or topic
A. Words are specific and accurate.
The response clearly targets information or
B. Words and phrases create demonstrate mastery of
concepts.
concept referenced the question or prompt
C. Natural, effective and appropriate language.
A. Thoughtful transitions connect ideas.
D. verbs, specific nouns and modifiers.
B. Sequencing is logical and effective.
E. Language enhances and clarifies meaning.
C. Pacing is well controlled.
F.
Precision is obvious by choice of words and
phrases.
D. Organizational structure is appropriate for the
question/prompt
 The language is functional, even if it lacks much
 The organizational structure is strong enough
energy.
to move the reader through the text without too
Words are adequate and correct in a general sense.
much confusion.
A. Familiar words and phrases communicate.
A. The responses have a recognizable focus on
B. Attempts at accurate technical language.
C. Passive verbs, everyday nouns, mundane
information or concept referenced the
modifiers
question or prompt.
D. Language functions, with one or two fine moments.
B. Sequencing shows some logic, yet structure
E. Occasionally, the words and phrases show
refinement and precision
takes attention away from the content.
C. Pacing is fairly well controlled.
 The writer demonstrates a good grasp of
 The writer struggles with a limited vocabulary
 The writing lacks a clear sense of direction.
 Errors in spelling, punctuation, capitalization,
A. The responses have no recognizable focus on
information or concept referenced the
question or prompt.
B. Connections between ideas, if present, are
confusing.
C. Sequencing needs work.
D. D. Pacing feels awkward.
usage and grammar and/or paragraphing repeatedly
distract the reader and make text difficult to read.
Spelling errors are frequent.
A. Punctuation missing or incorrect.
B. Capitalization is random.
C. Errors in grammar or usage are very noticeable.
D. Paragraphing is missing.
E. Little, if any, editing; the reader must read once to
decode, then again for meaning.
Key Question: Does the organizational structure
enhance the ideas and make it easier to
understand?
Key Question: How much editing would have to be
done to be ready to share with an outside source?
A.
B.
C.
D.
E.
F.
Words are nonspecific or distracting.
Many of the words don’t work.
Language is used incorrectly.
Limited vocabulary, misuse of parts of speech.
Language is unimaginative and lifeless.
Jargon or clichés, persistent redundancy.
Key Question: Do the words and phrases Provide Clear
and Accurate Information
standard writing conventions (e.g., spelling,
punctuation, capitalization, grammar usage,
paragraphing)
A.
B.
C.
D.
E.
F.
Spelling is generally correct.
Punctuation is accurate.
Capitalization skills are present.
Grammar and usage are correct.
Paragraphing tends to be sound.
The writer may manipulate and/or edit for stylistic
effect; and it works!
 The writer shows reasonable control over a
limited range of standard writing conventions
Spelling is usually correct or reasonably phonetic on
common words.
A. End punctuation is usually correct.
B. Most capitalized words are correct.
C. Problems with grammar and usage are not serious.
D. Paragraphing is attempted.
E. Moderate, inconsistent editing (a little of this, a little
of that).
*Expectations for Conventions should be based on grade level and include only those skills that have actually been taught.
© 2010, Education Northwest
Page 2