UNIVERSITY OF MAKENI (UNIMAK) MBA-FINANCE – 4 TH COHORT PUBLIC FINANCE GROUP 2 - MEMBERS No NAME ID No NAME ID 1 Dennis Bangura - Leader 620 13 Ibrahim P. Mansaray 6968 2 Brima Yirah Konteh 6257 14 Sulaiman Kamara 6438 3 Abdul Rahman Bangura 1052 15 Edward Phillip Kamara 2865 4 Huldah Rhoda Bangura 2201 16 Christiana F. Kamara 2829 5 Willie K. Caulker 859 17 Albert Konerr Kamara 6340 6 Ibrahim M. Kamara 289 18 Ibrahim Sheku Kanu 2839 7 Woma Berewa 6924 19 Chernor Kamara 2090 8 Alie Dabor 2843 20 Jamil M. Kamara 2721 9 Samuel Abu Conteh 1910 21 Isatu Isha Holland-Cole 6821 10 Aminata Fofanah 1947 22 Albert Kamara 2907 11 Kelfala J. Lahai 6910 23 Ibrahim Michael Conteh 3943 12 Yusifu Janneh 6886 24 Vandi MS Kanu 6911 • Table of Content i. Introduction – Monitoring Government Allocations ii. Introduction – Monitoring Government Expenditure iii. Why Government Do Allocations iv. Government of Sierra Leone 2021 Budgetary Allocations v. Government of Sierra Leone 2021 Recurrent and Capital Expenditure vi. The Executive Control vii. The Legislative Control viii.Ministry of Finance Control ix. The Treasury Control x. Control by Warrants xi. Departmental Control Over Budgeted Expenditure xii. Control by the Auditor General GOVERNMENT ALLOCATION & EXPENDITURE Introduction • Before the start of every fiscal year, MDAs and other government functionaries prepare annual budget for their planned activities for the coming year. • When these budgets are prepared, resources would be allocated to them based on their expenditure level or priority areas. MONITORING GOVERNMENT ALLOCATIONS Introduction Cont.. • Budget/Allocation Monitoring is centered on the idea of ensuring that government is setting the right priorities and doing it in a manner that is fiscally responsible and responsive to citizen needs. • Key players control (Executive, Legislative, MoF, Treasury, Departmental and control by the Auditor General) and monitor government budgets by observing budget hearings and obtaining budget documents during the budget formulation and approval stages. If the political space allows, monitoring from the executive, audit department and legislative hearings because budget are generally determined by all branches of government. MONITORING GOVERNMENT ALLOCATIONS CONT….. • The key documents that monitoring groups should request are the executive budget proposal, supporting budget reports, documentation of any budget laws and reports developed by legislative budget committee. • When planning government monitoring initiatives related to the government budget cycle, citizen groups should first do an analysis of the political context to determine whether there is enough space available to carry out monitoring activities. In order for citizen engagement in the budget cycle to be successful, central government must be willing to allow citizens access to budget meetings and publicly share budget documents. MONITORING GOVERNMENT EXPENDITURE • Introduction • Public Expenditure monitoring and control helps governments, citizens and CSOs ensure that allocated public resources effectively reach their intended beneficiaries. It can help identify and address problems and weaknesses in systems of public expenditure, transfer and service delivery. It is also effective in revealing corruption and detecting the exact location of leakages. • Public expenditure tracking usually involves some form of both quantitative research such as for e.g. verifying financial accounts to monitor the actual flow of funds and qualitative research such as for e.g. interviewing users of public services about their experiences and assessments of the quality, accessibility and cost of public services. Expenditure control and monitoring can be undertaken at the local, district or national level. MONITORING GOVERNMENT EXPENDITURE • Introduction • In some cases, the flow of resources is tracked from the highest level of government like for e.g. the National Treasury through its various layers to the final beneficiaries viz. the end users of public services or programmes like school, transportation, energy or health centre etc. Such an undertaking requires substantial expertise, resources and coordination between actors from the national to the grassroots levels. • For e.g., the Public Expenditure Tracking Surveys (PETS) supported and implemented by the World Bank, engage researchers at both the national and grassroots level and use both interviews and technical reviews of financial records to trace the flow of funds from source to final destination WHY GOVERNMENT DO ALLOCATIONS • The very reasons why government allocate resources to different MDAs or undertake capital expenditure projects or recurrent expenditure is to boost economic growth, stability and equal distribution of scare resources. Implicitly, government allocate resources to mitigate/avoid market failure. Market Failure occurs when the competitive market system 1) produces the “wrong” amounts of certain goods and services or 2) fails to allocate any resources whatsoever to the production of certain goods and services whose output is economically justified. WHY GOVERNMENT DO ALLOCATIONS CONT.. • The first type of failure results from what economists call externalities or spillovers and the second type involves public goods. Government can take actions to try to address both kinds of market failure. 1. Externalities - An externality is a cost or benefit from production or consumption, accruing without compensation to someone other than the buyers and sellers of the product. It have Positive and Negative Externalities. 2. Public Goods & Services - A good or service that is characterized by nonrivalry and non-excludability; a good or service with these characteristics provided by government. Everyone can simultaneously obtain the benefit from a public good such as a global positioning system, national defense, street lighting, and environmental protection. WHY GOVERNMENT DO ALLOCATIONS CONT.. 3. One person's benefit does not reduce the benefit available to others. More important, there is no effective way of excluding individuals from the benefit of the good once it comes into existence. The inability to exclude creates a free-rider problem The inability of potential providers of an economically desirable good or service to obtain payment from those who benefit, because of non-excludability. 4. In which people can receive benefits from a public good without having to pay for it. As a result, goods and services subject to free riding will typically be unprofitable for any private firm that decides to produce and sell them. GOSL 2021 BUDGETARY ALLOCATIONS NON SALARY, NON INTEREST RECURRENT (SUBSIDIES AND TRANSFERS) BUDGETARY ALLOCATIONS FOR FY 2021 No DETAILS FY 2021 Budget % of Goods & Services (Le’m) 1 General Services 399,479.4 36.6% 2 Security Services 299,907.4 27.5% 3 Social Services 278,813.4 25.6% 4 Economic Services 185.992.0 16.8% 5 Contingency Expenditure 19,930.5 1.8% GOSL 2021 RECURRENT & CAPITAL EXPENDITURE No A B DETAILS In Trillion Leones % Recurrent Expenditure: 7.2 Trillion Wages and Salaries 3.5 trillion 48% Goods and Services 1.2 trillion 16% Interest Payment 1.3 trillion 18% Subsidies and Transfer 1.3 trillion 18% Capital Expenditure 3 trillion THE EXECUTIVE CONTROL • The executive is the branch of government that is responsible for the day-to-day management of the state. Under the doctrine of the separation of powers, the executive is not supposed to make laws (role of the legislature), nor to interpret them (role of the judiciary). The executive is supposed to put the laws into action and it is headed by the President and assisted by a number of ministers, who usually have responsibilities for particular areas. The Executive controls the budgetary allocations and expenditure in diverse ways among which are: THE EXECUTIVE CONTROL CONT… 1. Establishment of National Monitoring and Evaluation Directorate (NaMED) – Sierra Leone Government places importance on the monitoring and evaluation of development results. To this end, a National Monitoring and Evaluation Directorate (NaMED) has been established in the Office of the President with direct oversight of the President. NaMED will monitor and evaluate all Government and donor funded projects, programmes and policies articulated in the National Development Plan. 2. Strategic exploration of the budget 3. Strategic control and monitoring of the budget 4. Budget outturn and accountability 5. Analysis and assessment of result THE LEGISLATIVE CONTROL The legislative branch of government is responsible for enacting the laws of the state and appropriating the money necessary to operate the government. In Sierra Leone, the Public Accounts Committee (PAC) considers the Auditor General’s report and makes recommendations to the plenary of the entire house, the outcomes of which are then communicated to the state president for follow-up actions and sanctions where necessary. The legislative control processes are: 1. Establishment of a Budget Office. Strong, independent legislatures may create a non-partisan budget office, where alternative budget analyses and scenarios may be proposed. THE LEGISLATIVE CONTROL CONT.. 2. Proper scrutiny of the budget 3. Provides oversight functions 4. Frequent consultations between the administration and the legislative committees on budget policies and their implementation 5. Passing into law sound financial, management and procurement laws. MINISTRY OF FINANCE CONTROL • Ministry of Finance of Sierra Leone is a government body tasked with designing and implementing sound economic policies and public financial management, ensure efficient allocation of public resources to promote stable economic growth and development in the context of a stable macroeconomic environment. The control mechanism put in place among other things are: 1. It sanctions expenditure, subject to powers delegated to spending ministries. 2. It gives acceptance of provision in budget estimates. 3. It prescribes a financial code for internal audit system of the ministries. 4. It approves policies and programmes in principle. 5. It offers financial advice through integrated financial advisor. 6. It permits re-appropriation of grants. THE TREASURY CONTROL • Treasury is responsible for the formulation of fiscal policy; budget preparation; budget execution; management of financial operations; accounting; and auditing and evaluation. Management of government bank accounts; part of its control mechanisms are: 1. Controls liquidity in public financial administration 2. Controls the day-to-day cash management of the consolidated fund and other funds 3. Co-ordinates the receipts, custody, disbursement and transfer of public and trust monies as required by law, 4. Controls the commitments and contingent liabilities of Government, 5. Controls public debt management; CONTROL BY WARRANTS • In legal term, a warrant control is a legal document that is given by the court if you have any debt and it is the type of document that allows the agents of warrant control to have a check at your place, and they are allowed to get control over the things you own. Whatever they seize will typically be sold at auction to collect the debt that is required from you. • In financial transactions, a warrant is a written order by one person that instructs or authorises another person to pay a specified recipient a specific amount of money or supply goods at a specific date. Awarrant may or may not be negotiable and may be a bearer instrument that authorises payment to the warrant holder on demand or after a specific date. • Governments may pay wages and other accounts by issuing warrants instead of cheques. CONTROL BY WARRANTS Control by warrants are conveyed through one of the following warrants: 1. Annual General Warrant – this authorises the accountantgeneral to issue funds for the payment of personal emoluments and other services provided for in the approved estimate/budget/allocation. 2. Provisional General Warrant – this is issued before the appropriation act comes into operation at the beginning of the financial year. It provide for continuation of government activities at a level not exceeding the level of those services prevailing in the previous financial year. 3. Supplementary General Warrant – this is issued for additional personal emoluments and other services provided for in the approved Supplementary Estimates. CONTROL BY WARRANTS CONT.. 4. Reserved Expenditure warrant – this authorised the release of funds included in the approved annual and supplementary estimates but excluded from the annual general or supplementary general warrants, i.e, the release of fund which the minister of finance initially withheld in order to exercise special control. 5. Virement Warrant – this is issued when, as a result of unforeseen circumstances during the time the annual estimates being approved, an additional provision is required under a particular sub-head, and an equivalent amount can be saved under another sub-head. 6. Development Fund General Warrant – this authorised the A.G to issue funds for expenditure on capital projects, as contained in the annual estimate and authorises the officer controlling expenditure to incur expenditure on these projects. 7. Departmental Warrant– this is issued where there is need for an accounting officer of one ministry or department to authorise an accounting officer to another ministry to incur expenditure. DEPARTMENTAL CONTROL OVER BUDGETED EXPENDITURE • Department is a sector of a state government that deals with a particular area of interest. For Sierra Leone, the various types of parastatals/departments are NASSI, National Tourism Board, Office of the Administrator and Registrar General, Office of Diaspora Affairs, NRA, Statistics Sierra Leone etc. • Therefore, their control functions over budgeted expenditure are: 1. Controls on liabilities or guarantees- This control is applied on the incurrence of a liability or guarantee and again at the payment stage when the liability is extinguished or guarantee is paid. It seeks to verify: (i) the existence of budget cover or space within the authorized limits; and (ii) that the payment is being made to extinguish the liability to a real supplier and for a claim that was not paid earlier DEPARTMENTAL CONTROL OVER BUDGETED EXPENDITURE CONT.. 1. Payroll controls -The objective of payroll controls is to control personnel expenditures and staffing numbers. 2. Pension controls - The liability and associated expense for pensions and other retirement benefits should be recognized at the time the civil servants’ services are rendered. Any part of that cost unpaid at the end of the period is a liability. 3. Verification of goods and services- That is, verification of the goods and/or services delivered by a supplier to ensure that these conform to the specified quality and quantity; and a calculation of the liability incurred by the government to the supplier. 4. Manual Processing Controls - Key manual processing controls for purchasing, payment, and confirmation of receipt of goods and services are performed outside the typical information systems 5. Control of Procurement CONTROL BY AUDITOR GENERAL • The Auditor General is mandated to carry out audits on the economy, efficiency and effectiveness with which the audited government entities use their resources in carrying out their responsibilities. The Auditor General is the independent auditor reporting to Parliament. • Section 119 of the 1991 Constitution of Sierra Leone empowers the Auditor General to audit the public accounts of Sierra Leone and of all public offices including the courts, the central and local government administrations, the Universities and public institutions, together with statutory corporations, companies, bodies or organisations set up partly or wholly out of public funds. CONTROL BY AUDITOR GENERAL CONT.. • Some its control systems are: 1. Being a ‘watch dog’ 2. Physical controls 3. Accounting controls 4. Process controls 5. Procurement controls 6. Making recommendations