Topic 1 Nature of Change LEARNING OUTCOMES By the end of this topic, you should be able to: 1. Identify different types of change using a change spectrum; 2. Give examples of internally and externally generated change; 3. Describe the areas of organisational change; 4. Determine the impact of change on businesses; and 5. Justify the importance of change for organisations. INTRODUCTION This topic provides a basic understanding of organisational change, which refers to the modification of the existing organisation to enhance its effectiveness and efficiency. It introduces the basic concepts of organisational change and describes the various forms of change, the sources of change (internal and external) and the focus of change (people, structure and technology). In todayÊs complex business environment, the magnitude, speed and impact of change on organisations are increasing. Organisations are confronted almost daily with the need for change. Over the last few decades, many new products and services have been introduced into the market; local markets have become global markets; protected industries have been opened up to competition; and public institutions have either been privatised or found themselves adopting more market-oriented practices. In other words, change has become both pervasive and prevalent. Copyright © Open University Malaysia (OUM) 2 TOPIC 1 NATURE OF CHANGE Hence, change is inevitable in organisations. As the environment changes, organisations must adapt if they are to survive in the market. An organisationÊs ability to change will have a significant impact on its performance and success. Thus, managing change effectively is a major challenge facing organisations. 1.1 MAGNITUDE OF CHANGE The nature and pace of change can vary substantially from one organisation to another. Change experienced by organisations can be distinguished by their scale and importance. Generally, the change continuum ranges from incremental changes which involve fine-tuning the organisation to quantum changes which require the transformation of the organisation (Burnes, 2004). The incremental perspective views change as being a process whereby individual organisational subunits deal with changes incrementally and separately with one problem and one goal at a time. On the other hand, the quantum or transformation perspective sees change as radical and unpredictable due to the complex environment in which the organisation is operating. Figure 1.1 presents the change spectrum where change ranges from small-scale and incremental to large-scale and transformational. Figure 1.1: The continuum of change Source: Burnes (2004) Copyright © Open University Malaysia (OUM) TOPIC 1 NATURE OF CHANGE 3 Table 1.1 presents the differences between incremental change and quantum change. Table 1.1: Incremental vs Quantum Change Incremental Change Quantum Change Small scale. Large scale. Moderate form of change. Radical form of change. Involves limited dimensions and levels of the organisation. Involves multiple levels of the organisation, from top management through departments and work groups to individual jobs. Involves several organisational dimensions, including structure, culture, reward systems, information processes and work design. Operational changes. Strategic changes. Aims at improving the status quo. Aims at altering how the organisation operates. Occurs within the context of the organisationÊs existing business strategy, structure and culture. Examples: Examples: Improving the decision-making of work groups. Downsizing. Changing the activities, performance, behaviour or attitudes of individuals and groups. Business process reengineering. Total quality management. Change of organisational culture. Solving the problem of employee absenteeism. ACTIVITY 1.1 Describe the changes made in your work organisation. Then, identify whether they are incremental changes or quantum/transformational changes. Copyright © Open University Malaysia (OUM) 4 TOPIC 1 1.2 NATURE OF CHANGE FORCES OF CHANGE Changes can be triggered either by internal or external events. Internal forces of change are those factors originating from the organisation that give rise to changes (Paton & McCalman, 2008). There are a large number of such factors. Some examples are: (a) Product innovations as a result of research and development; (b) New marketing plans; (c) Organisational restructuring to fit a new product line; (d) Job redesign to fit new organisational structures; (e) Improving work processes to increase productivity; (f) Computerised human resource systems to better manage human resources; (g) Development of databases to facilitate the decision-making process; (h) Attitudinal and behavioural changes to improve employee performance; (i) Change in composition of workforce; (j) Changing employee attitudes, expectations and needs; (k) Organisational growth; (l) Leadership and management team succession; (m) Expansion through acquisition or merger; and (n) New company policies. External forces of change are generated from the outside environment. External changes that organisations are currently facing include (Paton & McCalman, 2008) the following: (a) Government Legislation These are governmental interventions in terms of changes and implementation of government laws and regulations for example, strengthening health-related legislation, new systems of handling foreign workers, emission control legislation, carbon free policy, new tax laws and tightening international trade. Copyright © Open University Malaysia (OUM) TOPIC 1 NATURE OF CHANGE 5 (b) Advances in Information and Communication Technology (ICT) The rapid advancement of ICT has both revolutionised existing markets and created new ones. The Internet, for example, has revolutionised how business transactions are done. In addition, mobile and wireless technologies not only speed up new product development, but also change the business portals. (c) Globalisation The integrated internationalisation of markets has changed the way modern corporations do business nowadays. Jobs, knowledge and capital can now be channeled across borders with far greater speed. The worldwide availability of the Internet and supply-chain logistics enable companies to locate and work with multiple partners to serve any market anywhere, thus venturing into a global market instead of national markets. Business organisations must change to keep up with global developments to position themselves for sustainable competitive advantage. (d) Changing Consumer Needs, Requirements and Expectations ConsumersÊ attitudes and demands for products and services are forever changing. The attitude towards green environment in the 1990s led to consumer demands for environmentally friendly products and packaging. In the 2000s, health-consciousness among consumers gave rise to the popularity of organic foods. More sophisticated and educated consumers are now demanding for more integrated financial services and packages. Developing innovative products to suit the changing preference of consumers has become a fact of life for business organisations. (e) Competitor and Supply Chain Activities The competition landscape has changed how firms do business nowadays. The methods of competition change in response to the strategic moves of competitors. Organisations are increasingly forming strategic alliances with providers of related services and products. This is done in an effort to gain competitive advantage and cost efficiency. Competition is essentially challenging the past and creating new and exciting ways of doing business. (f) General Economic or Social Pressure In the global economy and market place, societies are becoming less isolated and more independent. Economic downturns in the United States, for instance, will not only affect their immediate locality, but also create a ripple effect throughout the global society. Organisations worldwide have to learn to survive in bad times. Similarly, the contamination of foods in China has also created pressure for multinational companies to produce food and beverages of higher quality. Copyright © Open University Malaysia (OUM) 6 TOPIC 1 (g) Unpredictable Environmental Catastrophes Unpredictable catastrophes have been and will always be, a source of disruption and despair. Examples are the tsunami disaster in Indonesia, the fallout of Hurricane Katrina in the United States, and the meltdown of nuclear power in Japan in recent years. Since these catastrophes are unavoidable, they must be effectively managed when they occur. In short, organisations must change and adjust to regain their footing when these disastrous events take place. NATURE OF CHANGE The manner in which a trigger or driver of change impacts upon a situation, to a certain extent, depends on its source, nature and magnitude. Internally generated change is likely to be managed far more proactively and effectively due to prior knowledge and understanding. Table 1.2 highlights the differences between internally and externally generated changes. Table 1.2: Differences between Internal and External Sources of Change Internally Generated Change Externally Generated Change Proactive stance; Reactive response; Positive feelings; Negative feelings; Greater driving force; Greater restraining force; Viewed from an opportunistic position; Viewed from a problem-solving position; Greater certainty; Greater uncertainty; Greater control; Reduced control; Less disruption; and Closed boundaries and fixed time scales. Greater disruption; and Vague boundaries and variable time scales. Source: Paton & McCalman (2008) SELF-CHECK 1.1 Give and explain two examples of internal sources of change and two examples of external sources of change in your work organisation. Copyright © Open University Malaysia (OUM) TOPIC 1 NATURE OF CHANGE 7 ACTIVITY 1.2 We experience change throughout our lives. List three significant triggers of change, identify their sources and rank your feelings of „control‰ in coping with each change. Trigger Source (Internal/External) Ranking (5 – High Level of Control; 1 – Low Level of Control) 1. 2. 3. 1.3 FOCUS OF CHANGE – DETERMINING WHAT SHOULD BE CHANGED Changing an organisation is the process of modifying an existing organisation in order to increase organisational effectiveness. Most managers, at one point or another, will have to make some changes in their workplace. These changes are termed organisational change. The focus of organisational change can be people, structure and technology (Certo & Certo, 2009; Robbins & Coulter, 2009). In other words, managers may make three types of organisational change – changes in people, structure and technology. (a) People Change Emphasises the improvement of job performance by changing certain aspects of organisation members, such as their work attitudes and work behaviour. Managers may attempt to make this kind of change when human resources are shown to be the major cause of organisational ineffectiveness. (b) Structural Change Helps increase organisational effectiveness by changing organisational controls which influence organisation members in performing their jobs. Managers may choose to make structural changes within an organisation if they believe that the present structure impedes organisational effectiveness and efficiency. Copyright © Open University Malaysia (OUM) 8 TOPIC 1 (c) Technological Change Focuses on modifying the level of technology in both the management and production systems. Managers can change the technology used to convert input into output to increase production efficiency. Today, technological changes usually involve the introduction of new machinery, equipment, tools or methods. For instance, the evolution in ICT has given birth to online businesses. NATURE OF CHANGE Table 1.3 depicts the features of these three areas of change. Table 1.3: Categories of Organisational Change Focus of Change People What It Involves People factors are the competencies and all other characteristics of human resources within the organisation. Changes in employee attitudes, expectations, perceptions, skills or behaviour. Examples: Training given to employees to learn new computer skills. Stress management programmes to enhance employeesÊ welfare. Structure Structural factors are organisational controls, such as policies and procedures. Any modification in authority relationships, chain of command, coordination mechanisms, degree of centralisation or decentralisation, job design, span of control, work specialisation, departmentalisation, formalisation, standardisation, or team building. It may involve major changes in the actual structural design. Changing conditions or changing organisational strategies often lead to changes in the organisational structure. Examples: Revision of job specification and job description. Modifying organisational structure to fit the communication needs of the organisation. Decentralising the organisation to reduce the cost of coordination, increase the controllability of work units, increase employee motivation and gain greater flexibility. Copyright © Open University Malaysia (OUM) TOPIC 1 Technology NATURE OF CHANGE 9 Technological factors are any types of equipment or task processes which assist organisation members in performing their jobs. Changes in work processes, work methods, or tools and equipment used. Examples: Automation of production facilities. Computerisation of human resource systems. It has been generally accepted that organisational effectiveness depends primarily on activities centered around these three classes of factors. Figure 1.2 shows the interrelationship among these areas of changes in relation to achieving organisational effectiveness. Figure 1.2: Determining organisational effectiveness based on the interrelationships among people, structural and technological changes Source: Certo & Certo (2009) Note that these three types of organisational changes are interrelated in improving organisational effectiveness. For example, structural changes must take people and technological factors into account. Similarly, changing people necessarily involves some consideration in terms of structure and technology. Hence, a change that affects any one factor will, to a greater or lesser extent, interact with the other factors and create a chain effect. Copyright © Open University Malaysia (OUM) 10 TOPIC 1 NATURE OF CHANGE ACTIVITY 1.3 Identify what areas need to be changed at your workplace. Then, classify whether the change is people, structural or technological change. Explain your answer. 1.4 IMPACT OF CHANGE As mentioned in the beginning of this topic, change is inevitable in organisations. There are various factors which contribute to the need for an organisation to move from its status quo. The most obvious are those significant factors in the external environment. To understand the impact of change, just think about how the organisation will be affected by the following changes in the external environment: (a) Changes in communication technologies; (b) Changes in consumer attitudes; (c) Changes in societal values; (d) Changes in population demographics; (e) Changes in government laws; (f) Changes in the competition landscape; and (g) Changes in the supply chain. For example, changes in consumer value towards green environment and environmental protection laws are some of the forces driving manufacturers to use green technology in the production process so as to produce goods without causing further damage to the environment. The depletion of natural resources also prompts manufacturers to look for more efficient energy sources or stop harvesting animals and sea lives which are in danger of extinction. In short, changes in consumer attitudes and values, business conditions, economic events, technology, society, and the political and legal environment will have an impact on the production methods, work processes, and products and services provided by the organisation. Copyright © Open University Malaysia (OUM) TOPIC 1 NATURE OF CHANGE 11 SELF-CHECK 1.2 Describe how each of the following factors has an impact on your organisation: (a) The Internet; (b) Consumers becoming more health conscious; and (c) Changes in customer needs. 1.5 IMPORTANCE OF CHANGE Managers of organisations, be they in the public or private sector, or manufacturing or service line, will continue to be judged by their ability to effectively manage change. If an organisation is to thrive, it must change continually in response to the changing world. Change is crucial to the success of the organisation and so employees should be encouraged to generate ideas to achieve beneficial changes. Certo and Certo (2009) cited General Motors (GM) as a classic example. GM provides its employees with a „think list‰ to encourage them to develop ideas for organisational change. The employees of GM are reminded that change is vital to the continued success of GM. The think list includes questions such as: (a) Can a machine be used to do a better and faster job? (b) Can the handling of materials for the machine be improved? (c) Can the quality of a part be improved by changing the sequence of the operations? (d) Can the materials be cut or trimmed differently for cost efficiency? (e) Can the operation be made safer? (f) Can paperwork be reduced or eliminated? (g) Can the established procedures be simplified? Copyright © Open University Malaysia (OUM) 12 TOPIC 1 NATURE OF CHANGE In conclusion, change is important to organisations because it is a contributing factor to the following: (a) Flexibility to adapt to the changing environment; (b) Innovation and creativity for new product development; (c) Organisational learning; (d) Effectiveness and efficiency in both management and work systems; (e) Competitiveness; (f) High-performing organisations; (g) Sustainable growth; and (h) Ultimate survival. SELF-CHECK 1.3 Why is change important for your organisation? Give an example to support your answer. Organisations come in all shapes and sizes and offer a wide variety of products and services, but also face a host of challenges. Perhaps the only factor common to all organisations is change. Organisations experience different types of change, and the speed and magnitude of change vary from one organisation to another over time. Changes range from small-scale and incremental to large-scale and transformational. It is widely recognised that the ability of an organisation to manage change effectively is crucial for its success. Changing an organisation is the process of modifying an existing organisation to increase organisational effectiveness. Forces in the external environment are the major causes of change in organisations. Copyright © Open University Malaysia (OUM) TOPIC 1 NATURE OF CHANGE 13 The focus of organisational change can be people, structure and technology. Managers must be able to determine the appropriate changes and then implement such changes successfully to enable their organisations to be more flexible, innovative and effective. External forces of change People change Incremental change Quantum/Transformational change Internal forces of change Structural change Organisational change Technological change Burnes, B. (2004). Managing change (4th ed.). Harlow, England: Financial Times Prentice Hall. Certo, S. C., & Certo, S. T. (2009). Modern management: Concepts and skills (11th ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Merrill Prentice Hall. Paton, R. A., & McCalman, J. (2008). Change management: A guide to effective implementation (3rd ed.). London, England: Sage Publications. Robbins, S. P., & Coulter, M. (2009). Management (10th ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Merrill Prentice Hall. Copyright © Open University Malaysia (OUM)