St. Mary’s College of Marinduque Boac, Marinduque Integrated Basic Education Department SY 2020 – 2021 I. Title Subject Level Topic: English for Academic and Quarter Professional Purposes Grade 12 ABM Duration Writing a Position Paper Fourth Module # 3 2 weeks Day Code 1-14 CS_EN11/12A-EAPP-IIa-d-1 CS_EN11/12A-EAPP-IIat-d-2 CS_EN11/12A-EAPP-IIa-d-3 CS_EN11/12A-EAPP-IIa-d-4 CS_EN11/12A-EAPP-IIa-d-5 II. Objectives Define what is a position paper Identify situations in which a position paper may be effectively used in the present society Gather manifestos and analyze the arguments used by the writer/s Defend a stand on an issue by presenting reasonable arguments supported by properly cited evidences Write various kinds of position paper II. Discussion/ Broadening of Concept Position paper- is an essay that expresses a position about an issue. It gives arguments that support the opinion of the writer based on the facts collected. Its goal is to convince an audience that the opinion raised underwent thorough investigation and data collection and that it is therefore valid. Elements of a Position Paper A. Introduction – this part of the paper identifies an issue that is being discussed by the author emphasizing his position about the issue. Here, the topic is introduced background and history of the issue shall also be discussed. B. Body of the paper– this part illustrates the central argument which can be presented through a brief description of the argument. Details, point of view, evidences are used to support the claim. It can be divided into these sections namely: background information, evidence supporting the author’s position, and a discussion which addresses and refutes arguments that present both sides of the issue. C. Conclusion – this part restates the main points, then summarizes the arguments made in the paper and then provides a call of action. Position papers are utilized to present an issue and to generate a support on the issue. Therefore, gathering factual information to support your argument would be very essential. MRS. JELLIE O. ANAYA EAPPABM12-Q4-M3 Page 1 of 6 What about Manifesto as a form of writing? Manifesto is a document publicly declaring the position or program of its issuer. A manifesto advances a set of ideas, opinions, or views, but it can also lay out a plan of action. While it can address any topic, it most often concerns art, literature, or politics. Manifestos are generally written in the name of a group sharing a common perspective, ideology, or purpose rather than in the name of a single individual. It combines a sometimes violent societal critique with an inaugural and inspirational declaration of change. Although manifestos can claim to speak for the majority, they are often authored by social activists and usually linked to new ideas. WRITING A POSITION PAPER There are two basic of writing which specialized at convincing. 1. Persuasion appeals to readers’ emotions to make them believe something or take specific action. Persuasion can also use logic and evidence. Steps in Persuasive Writing 1. State your opinion and introduce your argument. 2. Give your reasons for your opinion. 3. Illustrate with examples to support your opinion. 4. Restate your opinion and your suggested solution. Example: 1 Parents’ love which is illustrated with their sacrifices is worth recognition. 2 They send their children to school even if they have not gone to school themselves, 3 even if their own wants are sacrificed just to fund students’ needs. 4 You, dear students must recognize this immeasurable love of your parents by being good in your studies. 2. Argumentation relies on logic and evidence to build a case for a specific claim. Argumentation de-emphasizes appeals to emotion. Steps in Argumentative Writing 1. Make a claim 2. Support your claim with reasons/evidence 3. Acknowledge the counterclaim 4. Refute the counterclaim 5. Conclude with strong statement Example: 1 Many students ignore the significance of doing well in their studies. 2 They often neglect their parents’ sacrifices by getting low grades or worst yet getting a failing marks. 3 On the other hand, psychologists say performance in school is influenced by many factors which include peers.4 However, to fair well in school is not only about influence but also about being exposed to social realities such as difficulties of getting decent job. 5 Thus, funding students to school becomes a big sacrifice among parents. MRS. JELLIE O. ANAYA EAPPABM12-Q4-M3 Page 2 of 6 Persuasive versus Argumentative This table below will help you differentiate Persuasive writing from Argumentative writing. CHARACTERISTICS CLAIM PURPOSE BASIS PERSUASIVE Claim is based on opinion Asks audience to do something. ARGUMENTATIVE Claim is based on factual evidence Proves a point to the audience. Based on character and emotion. Based on stabilized position and logic. References Saqueton G, Uychoco M .2016. English for Academic and Professional Purposes.1977 CM Recto Avenue, Manila: Rex Bookstore. Wyson, John Daryl B. 2016. English for Academic and Professional Purposes,Quezon City:Vibal Group Inc. 33English for Academic Purposes Learner’s Material and Teacher’s Guide. Department of Education, First Edition, 2016. https://www.britannica.com/topic/manifesto --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- MRS. JELLIE O. ANAYA EAPPABM12-Q4-M3 Page 3 of 6 ACTIVITY SHEETS Name: ___________________________ Grade/Level: ______________________ Subject: _______________________ Teacher: _______________________ I. Directions: List at least 5 issues that you can identify that the society, your community is facing right now. Identify particular information that you would like to deal with in your paper. Follow the table below. ISSUES Example: Cyberbullying WHAT I WANT TO FOCUS ON Effects among young people What should the government do to address cybercrimes? II. Directions: Read this sample position paper and identify the stand/ reasons of the writer. Use the reading guide provided for to facilitate better understanding of the paper.Use the template below to make your own position paper. Use separate paper for your answer. READING GUIDE Please identify the following: Position Paper’s Topic/Issue: _________________________________________________________ Evidences/Reasons: Sample Position Paper Should Homework be Mandatory? I can almost see many students nodding along with me as I ask this question. Younger generations overloaded with home tasks and numerous assignments have already raised this issue many times. Yet, homework remains mandatory. Is it fair or should it be cancelled? I believe that homework should not be viewed as a mandatory part of education for several reasons. First, children spend seven hours every single work day at school. That is a huge chunk of life, and with homework added on top of these hours, a child is left with no time to live his life to the fullest, socialize, or grow in other areas. MRS. JELLIE O. ANAYA EAPPABM12-Q4-M3 Page 4 of 6 Second, sitting at your desk solving problems does no good to your health. Kids need time to get outside and have some fun, join a football league, or ride their bikes with friends around the block. Otherwise, children will be very smart but surprisingly weak physically. Another argument against this position is that homework is not always the best way to obtain knowledge quality-wise. Students tend to ask their parents or siblings for help whenever facing difficulties. Busy parents not always willing to spend extra time explaining school material to their little one solve the problems themselves aiming to have more time for family, not lessons. As a result, the child will have the homework done. But that’s really not his work. So, the whole idea of dedicating time to self-education is lost here. Finally, knowing that after classes you would still have to work at home makes a kid less concentrated at school. This results in short attention spans and difficulty to concentrate on something for too long. All in all, homework should rather be an option. Students understanding that they are left behind at some subjects will take their time to go over the material at home. However, in other cases, they should have time after school for other activities. Accessed from: (https://chiefessays.net/position-essay-examples-to-help-you-grasp-the-idea/) PROJECT OUTPUT Directions: From the issues listed below, choose one (1) to work on to develop into a position paper. Second, do some researching/reading to gather information. Third, defend your stand by writing a position paper with the intention of convincing your reader to support your stand.Write your position paper on a sheet of paper. List of Issues: Online Classes Among Public Schools Students Curfew Among Minors Community Lockdown Government Funds Distribution Cyber Bullying ________________________________ (topic of your choice) MRS. JELLIE O. ANAYA EAPPABM12-Q4-M3 Page 5 of 6 Rubric for Writing a Position Paper Criteria Excellent 10-9 Content and Takes a strong, Development well-defined position; uses at least nine appropriate reasons with at least two supporting details for each reason. Counter arguments effectively addressed, without undercutting position. Organization Structure of paper and is clear and easy to Structure follow. Paragraph transitions are logical and maintained the flow of thought throughout the paper. Conclusion is logical and flows from the body of the paper. Format Paper follows guidelines. Paper has appropriate length as described for the assignment. Format enhances readability of the paper. Grammar, Rules of grammar, Punctuation usage, punctuation & Spelling are followed; spelling is correct. Language is clear and precise; sentences display consistently strong, varied structure. MRS. JELLIE O. ANAYA Good 8-7 Clear position taken and defined; Some reasons and some details present, but not fully developed. Counter arguments addressed. Fair 6-4 Position not clearly stated; development is brief, unrelated, unsupported general statements, reasons, and details, minimal facts used. Counter arguments not acknowledged. Structure of the paper is not easy to follow. Paragraph transitions need improvement. Conclusion is not logical. Poor 3-1 No clear position taken; reasons underdeveloped; no supporting facts used. Paper follows guidelines. Paper has Appropriate length for the assignment. Format is good. Paper follows most of the guidelines. Paper is over/under word length. Paper lacks more elements of correct formatting. Paper is inadequate/ excessive in length. Rules of grammar, usage, punctuation are followed with minor errors. Few/ no spelling errors. Paper contains Few grammatical, punctuation and spelling errors. Language lacks clarity or includes the use of some jargon or conversational tone. Paper contains grammatical, punctuation and spelling errors. Language uses jargon or conversational tone. Structure is mostly clear and easy to follow. Paragraph transitions are present. Conclusion is logical. EAPPABM12-Q4-M3 Organization and structure detract the message of the writer. Paragraphs are disjointed and lack transition of thoughts. Page 6 of 6