Comparison Chart
Graphic Organizer
Use the graphic organizer below to compare and contrast the arguments of Federalists and Anti-Federalists.
Criteria:
Federalists
Anti-Federalists
Supporters
James Madison, Alexander Hamilton, and John Jay
George Mason, Patrick Henry, John Hancock, and Samuel Adams
Views on the
Articles of
Confederation
They believed the Articles of Confederation was too weak to
effectively deal with the nation’s issues.
They supported a weak central government and states’ rights.
They preferred the Articles of Confederation.
Views on a Strong
National
Government
They believed a strong federal government is more effective than a
confederacy of local governments at controlling factions.
They believed no federal government could pass laws that would be
suitable for all states. They also believed that the proposed federal
government took too much power away from the states.
Arguments For and
Against Ratification
of the Constitution
They were concerned that adding a bill of rights would, in effect,
limit the rights of citizens. They supported ratification.
The Constitution needed to protect the natural rights of citizens
(freedom of speech and religion, right to a trial by jury). They
opposed ratification.
Discovery Education Techbook
 Discovery Communications, LLC
1