Final Research Paper Research Topic: Is Online Banking a Threat to Traditional Banking? Course: ENG105 Semester: Fall 2020 SUBMITTED TO Dr. Shakila Nur (Snu) Department of English and Modern Languages SUBMITTED BY Name: Zunaid Islam ID: 1911727030 Sec: 39 Submission Date: 12th January, 2 Is Online Banking a Threat to Traditional Banking? Acknowledgement First and foremost, acclaims and much obliged to Almighty Allah, for His showers of endowments all through my research work to complete the research effectively. I would like to express my special thanks of appreciation to my educator and our honorable faculty member Dr. Shakila Nur, Assistant Professor, Department of English and Modern Languages, North South University who gave me the brilliant opportunity to do this wonderful research on the topic "Is Online Banking a Threat to Traditional Banking?" and giving invaluable direction all through this research. Her dynamism, vision, earnestness and inspiration have profoundly propelled me. She has instructed me the methodology to carry out the research and to show the research works as clearly as conceivable. It was an incredible privilege and honor to work and ponder beneath her direction. Finally, my heartiest appreciation to all my research survey members and participants who were able to form up some of their valuable time and offer assistance to help me collect all the necessary responses and data to conclude my research. Their profitable reactions were exceptionally important for compiling my research paper. At last, my much-obliged go to all the individuals who have bolstered me to complete the research work directly or in a roundabout way. i Declaration of Originality This can be to certify that to the finest of my knowledge, the content of this research paper is completely my own work. I certify that the intellectual content and every other materials of this research paper is the item of my claim and self-work and that all the assistance received in inception and preparation process of this following research paper and all other credible sources have been duly acknowledged. Zunaid Islam Dated at: 12th January, 2021 ii Abstract The digital transformation has had a major effect on nearly every angle of our lives. From the way, we associated with others to how we observe tv or work at our workstations. This is no diverse from the way that managing a bank account has changed, the alter has been profound and affected on every angle of banking from the way that clients are overseen through to the ventures made. Clients of banks have felt the positive effect of innovative solutions executed by banks. Banks play a crucial part in creating the financial and social conditions of a nation. The major share of the benefit of banks, by and large, comes from the spread. But the benefit of banks is beneath colossal weight since of persistent shrinking of spread. It gets to be vital for banks to decrease the cost per exchange for expanding spread that in turn will increment the profitability of banks. The utilization of technology in banks decreases the cost. Banks have realized that the cost of transaction radically diminishes by implementing online conveyance channels like ATM, POS Terminal, Versatile Phone, Web, etc. Each of these channels has its specific focal points in terms of improved client benefit and reduced exchange cost. (Fintech BD, 2017) Although, the cost benefits of shifting to online banking is lucrative and every bank wants to get a piece of this sweet pie but the question is whether online banking is just an added service of the banks or rather it is becoming a threat to the traditional banking model itself. iii Table of Contents Acknowledgement ................................................................................................................................... i Declaration of Originality ........................................................................................................................ ii Abstract .................................................................................................................................................. iii Table of Contents ................................................................................................................................... iv 1. Introduction ........................................................................................................................................ 1 2. Literature Review ................................................................................................................................ 2 3. Methodology ....................................................................................................................................... 4 3.1 Research Aims & Questions .......................................................................................................... 4 3.2 Research Design ............................................................................................................................ 4 3.3 Participants ................................................................................................................................... 5 3.4 Data Collection Procedure ............................................................................................................ 6 3.5 Data Analysis ................................................................................................................................. 6 4. Findings ............................................................................................................................................... 6 4.1 Quantitative Results...................................................................................................................... 6 4.1 Qualitative Results .......................................................................................................................... 16 4.2 Interview Questions ........................................................................................................................ 17 4.2.1 What are your thoughts on the current online banking system in Bangladesh? .................... 17 4.2.2 Do you think online banking will play a great role in achieving the goal of "Digital Bangladesh?" .................................................................................................................................... 18 4.2.3 Being a user, what are the common problems and limitations you face in our traditional banking system? ............................................................................................................................... 18 4.2.4 The current pace at which the online banking usage is growing, do you think we will soon end up switching to online banking from traditional banking? ............................................................... 19 4.2.5 Have you ever been a victim of an online banking scam? If yes can you share your experience? ....................................................................................................................................... 19 5. Discussion ......................................................................................................................................... 20 6. Conclusion and Recommendation .................................................................................................... 21 References ............................................................................................................................................. 23 Appendices............................................................................................................................................ 24 Appendix A: Survey Questions......................................................................................................... 24 Appendix B: Interview Questions ..................................................................................................... 25 iv 1. Introduction It is of no doubt that today technology driven transactions and online banking is at the core of banking industry- the industry that stays at the heart of a nation's economy. The modernization of technology led to a massive improvement in the banking sector throughout the world. And Bangladesh is no exception. We are travelling through the path that leads to the ultimate dream of Bengalis to see the country as "Digital Bangladesh". We have experienced a major revolution on how we used to see and practice banking. Fund transfers are now done instantly just by tapping on the "send money" button in our bKash app. In this fast-moving era, we want faster solutions to all our problems. This is what has given birth to online banking. But is it a threat to traditional baking practices? The focus of my research will be on how online banking is playing a role in our dayto-day transactions. Is this the ultimate solution to our banking needs or is it just another unknown hole that leads to nowhere but a dark room of scams and crimes? The research will mostly cover the impacts online banking has over the customers and whether it will totally replace traditional banking and become a threat to physical banks. The essential contrast between online banking and conventional banking is that, in traditional banking, the client has got to visit the bank's respective branch. Online banking spares customers’ time. Banks too appreciate lower overheads, establishment, premises, and maintenance costs, which comes about in reduction of exchange cost. Low exchange cost is one of the main reasons why online banking is getting notoriety. Around the world transaction cost of banks is diminishing as the number of online (branchless) exchanges is expanding very quickly. 1 Average Transaction Cost (in USD) Source: Javelin Strategy and Research 2. Literature Review Since the inception of monetary transactions, banks have played a tremendous role in terms of nit only transactions but holding, lending and saving money as well. Banks have made the whole complex monetary structure a lot easier and accessible to the end users. With time, banking processes became more and more simpler. It came to a point that now we do not even have to visit banks to transfer money- it's all within the palm of our hands. Ameme B, & Wireko J. (2016) states that in today's world, technology plays an important role and holds a relationship between the bank and customer satisfaction in banking sector. Advancement in technology has given birth to FinTech (Financial Technology) that has changed the way we saw and imagined banking system. Online banking is widely used these days. bKash is the largest online mobile banking platform in Bangladesh. Within just a short span of time, bKash 2 has grown to become the ultimate solution to most of our banking transaction needs. Now we do not send money, we bKash money. We as consumers are restless and want an instant solution to all our problems and that is a status quo. Online banking is slowly replacing the need of traditional banking as it is quick, easier and has way less limitations. Imaging waiting to be 18 years old then visiting a bank, filling up a 16 pages long account opening form and all the other documentations just to send money to a friend. Now you can just take your phone and open a bKash, Rocket or Nagad account within seconds and instantly send money. My report will cover up all these topics in depth with both qualitative and quantitative data. I will also speak in details on how online banking has changed consumer behaviors and whether it is a threat to traditional banking or rather the whole banking simpler and accessible. The report will also portray the risks and limitations of online banking. Online banking and FinTech is so popular in not only Bangladesh but the entire world. There are numerous researches and articles on this topic. Two of them are: o Digital Only Banks: A threat to traditional Banks- An article posted at FinTec Buz on February 11, 2020. o The Digital Banking Revolution in Bangladesh- An article posted at FinTech BD on February 12, 2017 Currently, almost 46% of consumers prefer digital interactions with banks, almost double what reports claimed in the year 2012. The rise of FinTech startups and digital-only banking options have put pressure on traditional financial organizations to modernize and rethink the needs of their customers. (FinTec Buzz, 2020) 3 3. Methodology 3.1 Research Aims & Questions As the title of my research says "Is online banking a threat to traditional banking?" Thus, the main aim is to assess and analyze the usefulness and people's perspective on the use of online banking and whether this technological advancement has had any positive impact on human lives, if so, then to what extent has this improved our easiness to banking. The questions have been designed to get as much information possible in order to draw out a conclusion of my research topic. I have made the questionnaire mostly focusing on the following 4 questions: 1. Does online banking seem to be a threat to traditional banking? 2. Which form of banking are you most convenient using? 3. Do you think traditional offline banking is still the safest form of banking? 4. Do you think online banking is cheaper than traditional banking? The first portion of the survey questionnaire is straight up relevant and direct to the topic and the rest 16 questions will help me evaluate and analyze the topic in detail with proper data and information. 3.2 Research Design The design of the analysis was quantitative, with a qualitative blend. A pre-tested questionnaire was created to analyze community actions in relation to key research issues. Participants were requested to answer the structured questionnaire online due to the pandemic situation and responses were collected subsequently after completion. Then a semi structured 4 interview was conducted to closely analyze the user’s perspective on the online and traditional banking. 3.3 Participants The population of interest in this study was 82 participants. 1. Age Group Sl. No. Age Group Respondent (no.) Respondent (%) 1 18-28 56 68.3% 2 29-39 18 22% 3 40 and above 8 9.7% 82 100% Totals 2. Gender Sl. No. Gender Respondent (no.) Respondent (%) 1 Male 56 68.3% 2 Female 26 31.7% 3 Prefer not to say 0 0 Totals 82 100% 3. City Sl. No. City Respondent (no.) Respondent (%) 1 Dhaka 52 63.4% 2 Chittagong 20 24.4% 3 Faridpur 8 9.8% 4 Gazipur 2 2.4% 82 100% Totals 4. Profession Sl. No. Profession Respondent (no.) Respondent (%) 1 Student 52 63.4% 2 Teacher 12 14.6% 3 Service Holder 15 18.3% 5 4 Businessman Totals 3 3.7% 82 100% 5. Interview Participants Ref. Code Profession Age P1 Student 21 P2 Teacher 36 P3 Service Holder 28 P4 Businessman 41 3.4 Data Collection Procedure In the process of data collection, a structured quantitative survey questionnaire was developed based on 17 questions and 6 demographic information and after a preliminary semistructured interview, qualitative data was conducted. 3.5 Data Analysis After collecting data through questionnaire and interview, quantitative data was analyzed using statistical method and thematic analysis was performed to determine the findings of the qualitative data. 4. Findings 4.1 Quantitative Results On the 20th December, 2020, I took an online survey to collect responses of people between 18 to 40 and above y/o. The purpose of the survey was to collect information and data to conclude my research topic "Is Online Banking a Threat to Traditional Banking?". The survey was promoted through online sources using Google Form as during the current situation 6 it was not feasible to conduct a physical survey. A total of 82 respondents participated in my survey questionnaire. After a successful fieldwork, I have collected relevant information and data that will help me draw out the conclusion and detailed analysis for my final report. All the questions and their recorded responses are given below and have been segmented according to the 4 primary question categories and each question having a number of sub-questions. The recorded responses of these questions are as below: Primary Question 1: Does online banking seem to be a threat to traditional banking? Sub-Question 1: We can say that mobile banking will soon replace traditional banking methods. This gives us a clear answer that majority people agree that mobile banking has a great chance of replacing the traditional banking methods. Here 51.2% mildly agrees and 24.4% strongly agrees with the statement. Sub-Question 2: Online mobile banking has made our daily lives so much easier and also made banking much more accessible to everyone. 7 95.1% of my audience agrees with this statement and believe online banking has made the way they transact money easier and more accessible. Out of which, 78% strongly agrees and 17.1% mildly agrees. Sub-Question 3: The regular offers given by bKash are very lucrative The majority finds the offers given by bKash are very lucrative. Out of which, 51.2% mildly agrees, 19.5% strongly agrees. However, 73% mildly disagrees with the statement and whereas 22% finds it neutral. Thus, to conclude more than half of the audience enjoys and claims the offers regularly. Sub-Question 4: If there were no daily limits to transactions, you would make payments over BDT 100,000 through bKash, Rocket, Nagad 8 Although, the previous responses show how people are becoming more attracted towards mobile banking but we can still see a good number of audiences are concerned about the safety and commitment of the online platform. My motive for this question was to analyze if people are confident enough to transfer large amounts through online means. The answer is No. Here the majority (36.6%) disagrees to get large funds transferred through mobile. Sub-Question 5: During COVID 19 pandemic, the introduction of contactless payment using mobile banking apps is very helpful and safe (in terms of hygiene) This gives us the most straight-forward response of the audience towards the innovative introduction of contactless payment. A whopping 82.9% audience strongly agrees how mobile banking apps helped and delivered a safe transaction during the pandemic. 9 Primary Question 2: Which form of banking are you most convenient using? Sub-Question 1: The overall traditional banking system is more convenient for most of us This however shows a completely different scenario where the portion of people finding traditional banking more convenient than mobile banking. Here 24.4% strongly agrees with the statement and also 24.4% mildly agrees with the statement. However, a good number of audiences also disagrees that accounts to 26.8% Sub-Question 2: It is more convenient to pay using bKash, Rocket, Nagad than credit cards or debit cards. We can see majority people finds paying with mobile banking apps easier and more convenient than paying with a credit or debit cards. This is obvious as the process of getting banking cards are very complex and time consuming. 10 Sub-Question 3: Cashing out money from a mobile banking agent is easier than a bank's ATM Booth This comes down to the debate of self-service v/s someone doing the task for you. ATM booth offers self-service while mobile banking agents are doing the task for you. Here people choose ATM booth over agent maybe because ATM booths is a faster way to get the job done whereas the time taken to cashing out depends on the agent and not us. Sub-Question 4: Mobile banking apps are too complex to use and less user friendly 11 This shows that the mobile banking is going towards the right direction as the purpose of people switching towards it is convenience and user friendliness and these apps seem to be doing it right as majority disagrees with the statement of these apps being complex. Sub-Question 5: It would be more helpful if we received the monthly salaries in our mobile bank accounts than our regular bank accounts A majority of my audience seems to disagree to receive their monthly pay through the online banking methods. This is because a great number of services still require offline payments in our country. For example, a local vegetable seller would ask to pay in cash than through bKash. Same goes for transportation like rickshaw, CNG autos. 12 Sub-Question 6: We often pay our utility bills (Electricity, gas, internet, etc.) using bKash, Rocket, Nagad This shows the impact of online banking in our daily lives. Majority of my audience seem to be using online means to pay their utility bills which proves that we are being more dependent on the online means of payment for our day-to-day transactions. Sub-Question 7: We end up overspending due to the convenience of instantly making payments through online banking apps This seems like an interesting question at first. But if we think economically, it is a very powerful question. Why? Because this shows how the convenience of online banking changes consumer's spending patterns and behavior. Customers are rational and if the banking model makes them spend more than it already has made a huge impact on our transaction habits. 13 Sub-Question 8: We keep more money in our bKash, Rocket, Nagad account than our bank accounts. A majority of my audience disagrees to keep their most funds in online accounts maybe because these platforms do not offer interest on savings like the physical banks do. Here 39% mildly disagrees and 36.6% strongly disagrees. Primary Question 3: Do you think traditional offline banking is still the safest form of banking? Sub-Question 1: Traditional banking method (i.e., bank money transfers) is safer than sending money through mobile banking apps 14 Here, majority of my audience claims that traditional banking is safer than online banking. 59.5% strongly finds it safer and 23.8% mildly finds it safer. Sub-Question 2: There are high chances to fall in the traps of mobile banking scams This proves that people question about the safety of online banking in our country. In my previous question we saw people disagreeing to transfer large funds through online and here a great portion of my audience agree that the risks associated with online banking like scams is very high. Hence, 66.7% strongly agrees and 23.8% mildly agrees. Primary Question 4: Do you think online banking is cheaper than traditional banking? Sub-Question 1: Transaction fee charged by bKash, Rocket, Nagad is affordable 15 Although, the sole portion of people "mildly agreeing" that online banking transaction fees are is the most. But if we give a closer look, the combined result of mildly and strongly agreeing or disagreeing is different. - Combined 40.5% people find online banking affordable - Combined 42.9% people find online banking less affordable or in other words, more expensive. Sub-Question 2: Transaction fee charged by banks is affordable Here we can clearly see the winner as a huge portion of the audience finds traditional banking transaction fees affordable. Here, 40.5% strongly finds it affordable and 28.6% mildly. Only 9.5% of people have a different response saying they do not find it affordable. 4.1 Qualitative Results In order to get more precise and a detailed result I went and prepared a set of questions to interview 5 participants to collect their view and perspective and an in-depth real-life opinion on the banking model. The researcher conducted a one-on-one semi structured interview session where 5 participants were asked similar questions and one response led to another question. The interview session has allowed the researcher to: 16 1. Collect generate multiple sources data rather than relying on a single source of information. 2. Record the real time in-depth responses that is more realistic for drawing out conclusions. 3. Understand the topic better as the body language and verbal communication is more than just numbers and predetermined options. 4.2 Interview Questions The recorded responses of the participants to the following questions are discussed below: 4.2.1 What are your thoughts on the current online banking system in Bangladesh? When the following question was asked to each of the 5 participants, P3 and P5 had same responses stating that online banking has made their daily transactions very quick and easy. P1 answered saying he feels very astonished how technology has evolved within such a short period of time and made banking more accessible to everyone. P2 and P4 had similar responses saying they are happy to see the upgrades in the banking sector but however they were concerned regarding the security of online banking as many scams have been reported in the recent years out of which online banking accounts to a great percentage. The response of P1 is as follows: I have been using bKash for the past 2 years now and I can't recall a single day I haven't opened the app since then. It has made my daily transactions so much easier and I am astonished to see how far we have come in terms of technology as a nation. The best part is that my profession requires me to make payments to certain people even on weekends. Previously, it wasn't possible due to bank holidays but now it is happening as online banking doesn't require particular days to make transactions. 17 4.2.2 Do you think online banking will play a great role in achieving the goal of "Digital Bangladesh?" All 5 of the participants agreed to this and they all truly believe that online banking plays a vital role in the making of Digital Bangladesh as they find banking sector plays a very crucial role in shaping up a country's economy. One of the interviewee's responses were: With all my heart, I truly believe that online banking will by playing a major role in the formation of Digital Bangladesh because be it any profession, everyone is involved in monetary transaction process; either directly or indirectly. Digitization will soon be taking over all the conventional practices of the nation and we already seem to have a great leap in FinTech as we have been able to get a strong ground in terms of online banking. 4.2.3 Being a user, what are the common problems and limitations you face in our traditional banking system? Upon asking the following questions one common response from every respondent was they find it too much work for doing a simple task. The participants do not like visiting the bank branch for every little transaction and fill out a number of documentations. One of the responses are extracted as follows: There is a saying- Modern problems require modern solutions. Similarly, in this modern era, why go for critical solutions? The traditional banking system is too hassling for me and being busy in my daily work schedule, it's tough to bring out time to visit the bank and thus, the work remains undone. I am strictly against filling out papers for every task as it is time consuming and a lengthy process and most importantly I do not like standing in the queue for depositing or withdrawing money. 18 4.2.4 The current pace at which the online banking usage is growing, do you think we will soon end up switching to online banking from traditional banking? 4 out of the 5 respondents had a common response saying yes, they believe that we as consumers will very soon switch to online banking from traditional banking methods. However, the response of P3 was quite unique and I as a researcher find it very relevant considering the country and environment, we live in. Her reply is extracted below: Yes, I somewhat agree to this because online banking usage is booming and we are getting more and more used to it and shifting our usage from conventional to digital banking methods. But there is something I want to mention. While growing up I have seen that we Bengali people tend to find something valuable and of high worth by touching it. If it is not tangible, we seem to question the originality and authenticity of it. So, considering the fact online banking is fully intangible, some of us might still prefer on using traditional banking over digital. 4.2.5 Have you ever been a victim of an online banking scam? If yes can you share your experience? Although, there has been a great number of recorded incidents of online banking scam but surprisingly none of my participants seem to be a victim of it. They all refused to it. However, P2 added an additional statement with her response. It is extracted below: Financial scams are everywhere; be it offline or online. There has been recorded scams even before the inception of online banking. I understand the fact that people are concerned about getting scammed online. But the thing is that the risk of online scams is less as there is a limit to the number of transactions, we can make online but if we consider conventional banking, there are incidents where hundreds of crore taka have been looted from the bank. Thus, if we 19 are cautious enough, we can easily avoid scams and I personally feel that the fear of this shouldn't hinder the growth of online banking. 5. Discussion In this particular part of the research paper, the researcher hereby discusses the factors that have been extracted from all the information and data collected. Considering all the factors mentioned, it can be said that online banking might very soon replace traditional banking methods due to the vast amount of benefits it provides to the users. The online internet banking framework gives comfort to exchange cash 24 hours in 365 days. You don’t get to stick to perform any transaction inside working hours as you'll be able to do as per your comfort in 24 hours. The clients can get to their overhauled passbook anytime to screen their transactions to oversee their budgetary plans. In addition, you don’t get to stand in queue for paying bills because it includes an option to pay any kind of charge including electricity, water supply, phone, and other utilities. In recent years, we have seen that internet banking has moved forward the quality of services by giving them the comfort to perform their transactions anytime amid the day. Customers are able to apply for credits, protections, and any other services without going by the banks physically which appears that the quality of e-banking is quick and successful. All these add-on features have made us so much used to banking online and occasionally perform offline banking. However, we have also gathered data that shows online banking having so many advantages, comes with a number of disadvantages too, which cannot go unnoticed. To begin with and preeminent, the security of transactions may be a huge issue. Your account data might get hacked by unauthorized individuals over the web. Your banking data may be spread out on a few gadgets, making it more at the chance. In addition, if the bank's server is down, due to the loss of network connectivity or a moderate connection, at that point it can be difficult to 20 know if your exchange went through. Finally, is the constrain of transactions. because as of now, no online bank in Bangladesh permits you to transfer more than 25,000 taka per day which can be frustrating at times particularly if you have a large fund to transfer. But even after all these, customers seem to prefer online banking more as per the responses we have gathered from the survey and interview. 6. Conclusion and Recommendation Online banking has evolved tremendously in a very short span of time in Bangladesh. The modernization of ICT has set the stage for extraordinary improvement in banking procedures throughout the world. The development of worldwide networks has considerably decreased the cost and increased the volume of global and local funds transfer. (Fintech BD, 2017) After carrying out a survey and collecting responses of 82 participants and interviewing 5 respondents physically, the researcher has come to a point of concluding "Whether online banking is a threat to traditional banking". Throughout the whole research process we have come along numerous benefits online banking offers to its users which makes them more used to the services every day at a constant rate. But at the same time, traditional banking also has its unique advantages that cannot be found in banking online. For example, taking out home and car loans, transferring large funds, opening LC to import goods from abroad. These are some services that can only be availed at your physical bank rather than virtual bank. Thus, to conclude we can say that online banking is not a threat to traditional banking, at least not as of now, because online banking has a long way to go in order to provide all the facilities offline banking offers. Also, the most relevant reason for internet banking not being a threat is that this itself is an extended feature offered by the traditional banks. In this financial market, they are not competing but rather working hand-in-hand. The largest online banking 21 organization in Bangladesh- bKash is owned by BRAC Bank which is a conventional bank, Rocket is owned by Dutch-Bangla Bank Ltd, City Touch is run by City Bank. So, for now we can say that it is not a threat but an add-on benefit provided by conventional banks to its customers. After analyzing the responses of the surveyed population, the researcher recommends the following to be taken into account by the online banking institution for it to be more user friendly: 1. Increase the transaction limit for large funds transfer. 2. Decrease the transaction fees. 3. Option to cash-out from dedicated ATMs. 4. Increase security by enabling 2 factor authentication and biometrics. 22 References Ameme, B., & Wireko, J. (2016). Impact of technological innovations on customers in the banking industry in developing countries. The Business and Management Review, 7(3), 388–397. Hilal, M. (2015). Technological Transition of Banks for Development: New Information and Communication Technology and Its Impact on the Banking Sector in Lebanon. International Journal of Economics and Finance, 7(5). Aladwani, A. M. (2001). Online banking: a field study of drivers, development challenges, and expectations. International Journal of Information Management, 21(3), 213-225. Samanta, Chandrima (2020, February 11). Digital Only Banks: A threat to traditional Banks. Fintec Buzz. Retrieved from https://fintecbuzz.com/digital-only-banks-a-threat-totraditional-banks/ Alam, Mahbubur Rahman (2017, February 12). The Digital Banking Revolution in Bangladesh. FinTech BD. Retrieved from http://www.fintechbd.com/the-digitalbanking-revolution-in-bangladesh/ 23 Appendices Appendix A: Survey Questions 1. We can say that mobile banking will soon replace traditional banking methods. 2. Online mobile banking has made our daily lives so much easier and also made banking much more accessible to everyone. 3. The regular offers given by bKash are very lucrative 4. If there were no daily limits to transactions, you would make payments over BDT 100,000 through bKash, Rocket, Nagad 5. During COVID 19 pandemic, the introduction of contactless payment using mobile banking apps is very helpful and safe (in terms of hygiene) 6. The overall traditional banking system is more convenient for most of us 7. It is more convenient to pay using bKash, Rocket, Nagad than credit cards or debit cards. 8. Cashing out money from a mobile banking agent is easier than a bank's ATM Booth 9. Mobile banking apps are too complex to use and less user friendly 10. It would be more helpful if we received the monthly salaries in our mobile bank accounts than our regular bank accounts 11. We often pay our utility bills (Electricity, gas, internet, etc.) using bKash, Rocket, Nagad 12. We end up overspending due to the convenience of instantly making payments through online banking apps 13. We keep more money in our bKash, Rocket, Nagad account than our bank accounts. 24 14. Traditional banking method (i.e., bank money transfers) is safer than sending money through mobile banking apps 15. There are high chances to fall in the traps of mobile banking scams 16. Transaction fee charged by bKash, Rocket, Nagad is affordable 17. Transaction fee charged by banks is affordable Appendix B: Interview Questions 1. What are your thoughts on the current online banking system in Bangladesh? 2. Do you think online banking will play a great role in achieving the goal of "Digital Bangladesh?" 3. Being a user, what are the common problems and limitations you face in our traditional banking system? 4. The current pace at which the online banking usage is growing, do you think we will soon end up switching to online banking from traditional banking? 5. Have you ever been a victim of an online banking scam? If yes can you share your experience? 25