INTERIM GUIDELINES FOR ASSESSMENT AND GRADING IN LIGHT OF THE BASIC EDUCATION LEARNING CONTINUITY PLAN (DO 31 S. 2020) DepEd Goal Ensure that teaching and learning continues during the COVID-19 Pandemic, while looking after the health, safety, and well-being of all its learners, teachers, and personnel Background of DO 31. s. 2020 Pros & Cons of Non-Numerical Grading System PROs • Reduces score pressure • Non-graded assessment scheme may foster the intrinsic motivations of students for learning as the pressure of scores is lifted and learning is done for the sake of learning alone CONs • Adjusting and studying to a new grading system could potentially mean more work for teachers in this time they are adjusting to new teaching modalities • Decreased performance- students may tend to perform less knowing that they can obtain the targeted mark (pass) even by committing mistakes or performing less in a given task. It can possibly lead to underachievement, lethargy and complacency • When pandemic is over, they do not have the numerical grades that they may be needed in enrolling to the next grade level, to other countries/school and/or for the college application of SHS DO 31 s. 2020 a supplement to DO 12 s. 2020: Adoption of the Basic Education Learning continuity Plan for SY 2020-2021 in light of COVID-19 Pandemic. shall be implemented in all public elementary and secondary schools nationwide for SY 2020-2021 but DO No. 8, s. 2015 (Policy Guidelines on Classroom Assessment for the K to 12 Basic Education Program) is still in effect although provisions inconsistent with these guidelines are suspended for this school year. DO 31 s. 2020 Private schools, technical and vocational institutions, and higher education institutions including state and local universities and colleges offering the K to 12 Basic Education Program are encouraged to implement this DO and permitted to modify it with the approval of the RO. Assessment Principles Assessment should be holistic and authentic in capturing the attainment of the most essential learning competencies. Assessment is integral for understanding student learning and development Assessment Principles A variety of assessment strategies is necessary, with formative assessment taking priority to inform teaching and promote growth and mastery Assessment and feedback should be a shared responsibility among teachers, learners, and their families Assessment and grading should have a positive impact on learning Characteristics of Assessment Align with the Most Essential Learning Competencies Reliable, valid and transparent Fair, inclusive and equitable Practical and manageable for both learners and teachers Give learners a range demonstrate their learning of ways to Provide timely and accurate information as basis for feedback Role of Teachers, Learners and Parents Teachers Design the assessment to allow for flexibility in multiple modalities; Communicate to learners and parents/guardians the design and standards for grading the assessment; Set-up mechanisms to monitor and record progress remotely; Give timely, constructive, and relevant feedback; and facilitating remediation for learners who need further guidance. Role of Teachers, Learners and Parents Learners Learners are expected to be proactive in updating their teacher of their situation, progress and challenges encountered. A nonmandatory self-monitoring tool (see Annex E) may be accomplished independently or with the assistance of their parent/guardian, if necessary. Role of Teachers, Learners and Parents Parents and Guardians Communicating with the teacher to give updates on their child’s situation, progress, and challenges encountered; and Guiding their children in accomplishing the assessment tasks and/or monitoring tools designed by their teacher Purpose of Assessment Assessment should be used to inform and improve classroom practices and promote learning outcomes (D.O. 8 s 2015) Formative Purposes When assessment evidence is used to inform teaching and learning decisions with the view to improvement. Summative Purposes When assessment evidence is used to make decisions about learners’ outcomes at the end of the teaching period. Definition of Terms Classroom Assessment is an ongoing process of identifying, gathering, organizing, and interpreting quantitative and qualitative information about what learners know and can do. Formative Assessment is a process that involves teachers using evidence about what learners know and can do to inform and improve their teaching. This process, through the teacher’s immediate feedback, enables students to take responsibility for their own learning and identify areas where they do well and where they need help. Definition of Terms Summative Assessment is an assessment that is usually administered toward the end of a learning period to measure the extent to which the learners have mastered the essential learning competencies, the results of which are recorded and are used to report the learner’s achievement. Grading is the way of reporting assessment data by assigning a value to the results as a record of students' ability, achievement, or progress (Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development, 2020). The difference between formative and summative assessment Formative Assessment’s Summative Assessment’s goal is to monitor student’s learning to provide ongoing feedback that can be used by instructors to improve their teaching and by students to improve their learning. goal is to evaluate student’s learning at the end of an instructional unit by comparing it against some standard or benchmark The difference between formative and summative assessment Formative (Class/individual) Summative (individual) • Identifying gap between current • Grading and desired learner’s competence • Adapting for learner needs • Providing feedback • Improving instruction • Engaging students in the assessment and learning process • Ranking • Reporting • Promoting • Certifying Assessment Purposes Planning Collecting Interpreting Using Evaluating Planning assessment requires decision about • Assessment design • What to assess • How to Assess ASSESSMENT DESIGN Must be aligned with the most essential learning competencies Consider curricula across grades and learning areas Consider typical steps in development of learners Consider timing of assessment (before, during, after) Select Assessment Styles/Methods are practical and manageable for both that will best elicit the knowledge/skills/attitudes to be assessed learners and teachers Choose Context to be inclusive of gender, ethnicity, rurality, socioeconomic status, etc How to assess? Design Task so that knowledge/skills/attitudes being assessed determine success in the item are fair, inclusive and equitable that are varied for learners to have a range of was to demonstrate their learning Write Instructions to give clear guidance about what to be done (tasks and administration guidance) Provide timely and effective feedback Feedback and Remediation Both formative and summative assessment must be accompanied with timely, constructive, and meaningful feedback based on the learner’s record of progress. In giving feedback, teachers need to maximize available communication options (e.g. writing feedback on the output, texting feedback via SMS, and using online channels, among others) Feedback and Remediation Consistent with DO No. 8, s. 2015, “teachers should ensure that learners receive remediation when they earn raw scores which are consistently below expectation” in summative assessments “by the fifth week of any quarter. This will prevent a student from failing in any learning area at the end of the year. In order to inform teaching and promote growth and mastery, formative assessment strategies should: a. Establish clear learning targets and success criteria; In order to inform teaching and promote growth and mastery, formative assessment strategies should : a. Establish clear learning targets and success criteria; b. Elicit evidence of learning • This is not mandatory but highly recommended to be accomplished to keep track of the academic progress of the learners • Weekly feedback to help formative assessment • There is also feedback for the parents/guardians and teachers • Formative assessment is not necessarily a test, it could be a question or emoji Teacher gives also notes to provide timely feedback In order to inform teaching and promote growth and mastery, formative assessment strategies should: a. Establish clear learning targets and success criteria; this can be b. Elicit evidence of learning modified c. Provide timely and effective feedback based on the economic status of the learners In order to inform teaching and promote growth and mastery, formative assessment strategies should be: a. Establish clear learning targets and success criteria; b. Elicit evidence of learning c. Provide timely and effective feedback d. Engage learners in assessing and improving each other’s work In order to inform teaching and promote growth and mastery, formative assessment strategies should be: Diary/journal of what the learners a. Establish clear learning targets and success criteria; do daily, quizzes, b. Elicit evidence of learning additional c. Provide timely and effective feedback activities given by the teacher, d. Engage learners in assessing and improving each other’s work e. Increase learner’s ownership of their learnings comments/notes by the teacher INFORMAL FORMATIVE ASSESSMENT DECISIONS Have the learners mastered this concept/skill? Which learners need extra support? Are they ready to move to the next lesson? Do I need to find another way to explain this idea? Have the learners understood the lesson so far? What method did the learner use to solve the problem? What is his/her misunderstanding? Instructions for learners need to be clear Methods need to take learner context/resources into consideration Link between evidence and decisions needs planning Shift assessment control to learners/caregivers where possible Explain purpose to minimize input by caregivers Sample Kindergarten formative assessment (Reference: DO 31 s.2020 p72-74 Sample Kindergarten formative assessment (Reference: DO 31 s.2020 p72-74 Sample Kindergarten formative assessment (Reference: DO 31 s.2020 p72-74 Annex B: Sample Summative Assessment Tools that Qualify as Performance Tasks in Various Learning Delivery Modalities Online Learning Learning Area Written Outputs 1. blog post on a book / article review 2. essays submitted through email 3. e-journals 4. electronic mail writing Languages 5. reaction / reflection papers submitted through email 6. PDF reports Summative Assessment Tool Products Performance Tasks 1. YouTube campaign videos 2. case studies published through Adobe Acrobat 3. e-collages 4. compositions submitted through email 5. blog on literary analyses 6. multimedia productions uploaded in Facebook/YouTube 7. e-portfolios 8. research projects published in an e-journal 9. story / poem writing narrated through PowerPoint presentations 1. online debates via Zoom or Google Meet 2. online interviews 3. multimedia presentation using PowerPoint or Canva 4. panel discussions via Zoom or Google Meet 5. online presentations 6. recorded project presentation 7. recorded monologues 8. speech delivery via Zoom/Google Meet 9. storytelling / reading via Zoom/Google Meet Annex B: Sample Summative Assessment Tools that Qualify as Performance Tasks in Various Learning Delivery Modalities Modular Distance Learning, TVBI, RBI Learning Area 1. 2. Edukasyon 3. sa Pagpapakat 4. ao (ESP) Math Written Outputs essays journal writing journal / article reviews reaction / reflection papers 1. data recording and analyses 2. geometric and statistical analyses 3. graphs, charts, or maps 4. problem sets 5. surveys 1. 2. 3. 4. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Summative Assessment Tools Products Performance Tasks argument analyses 1. issue-awareness campaigns expressing feelings 2. presentations and multimedia and ideas through art presentations activities 3. personal action plans (plano ng journal responses pagsasabuhay) letter/song/poem 4. situation analysis (pagsusuri ng writing sitwasyon) diagrams 1. constructing graphs from mathematical surveys conducted investigatory projects 2. outdoor math models / making 3. probability experiments models of geometric 4. problem-posing figures 5. reasoning and proof number 6. using manipulatives to show representations math concepts / solve problems portfolio Points to remember….. Performance Tasks Clear Directions Each task must be accompanied with clear directions and appropriate scoring tools (i.e. checklists, rubrics, rating scale, etc.) to help learners demonstrate their learning . Collaboration Teachers are advised to collaboratively design and implement performance tasks that integrate two or more competencies within or across subject areas. Complex tasks may be broken down into shorter tasks to be completed over longer periods of time. Performance Tasks Points to remember….. Flexibility Learners must be given flexibility in the accomplishment of the performance tasks to consider time and resources available to them. Nonetheless, all learners within a class should be assessed on the same competencies using the same scoring tool. Opportunities Teachers must exercise their professional judgement in carrying out summative assessments, providing enough opportunities for learners to practice and to redo their work whenever necessary, so that they can reach their learning targets with the least amount of pressure. Rubric a learning and assessment tool that is used to evaluate written outputs, products, or performance-based tasks. It is a scoring guide that articulates the expectations and describes the levels of quality expected from a learner. (Andrade, 2000; Arter & Chappuis, 2007; Stiggins, 2001). Four essential features of Rubric (Stevens & Levi, 2013) 1)task description or a descriptive title of the task students are expected to produce or perform 2)scale (and scoring) that describes the level of mastery (e.g., exceed expectation, meets expectation, doesn't meet expectation) 3)components/criteria students are to attend to in completing the assignment/tasks (e.g., types of skills, knowledge, etc.) 4)description of the performance quality (performance descriptor) of the components/dimensions at each level of mastery. ANALYTIC • articulates different dimensions of performance and provides ratings for each criterion or dimension HOLISTIC RUBRIC • describes the overall characteristics of a performance and provides a single score Portfolio Grading This rubric is designed to evaluate the portfolio submission based on content, presentation of work, and reflection. Scoring 100 – 95 94 – 90 Performance Descriptor All required items are included, with a significant number of additions. Items clearly demonstrate that the desired learning outcomes for the term have been achieved. The student has gained a significant understanding of the concepts and applications. Reflections illustrate the ability to effectively critique work, and to suggest constructive practical alternatives. Items are clearly introduced, well organized, and creatively displayed, showing connection between items. All required items are included, with a few additions. Items clearly demonstrate most of the desired learning outcomes for the term. The student has gained a general understanding of the concepts and applications. Reflections illustrate the ability to critique work, and to suggest constructive practical alternatives. Items are introduced and well organized, showing connection between items. 89 – 85 All required items are included. Items demonstrate some of the desired learning outcomes for the term. The student has gained some understanding of the concepts and attempts to apply them. Reflections illustrate an attempt to critique work, and to suggest alternatives. Items are introduced and somewhat organized, showing some connection between items. 85 - 80 A significant number of required items are missing. Items do not demonstrate basic learning outcomes for the term. The student has limited understanding of the concepts. Reflections illustrate a minimal ability to critique work. Items are not introduced and lack organization. Rubric for online Rubric for offline interactive presentations Rubric for Assessing Informative Write-up Reports (Modular) Goal: • • • • Your task is___________________________ The goal is to ________________________ The problem/challenge is _____________ The obstacle(s) to overcome is (are) ____ Role: • You are ______________________________ • You have been asked to _______________ • Your job is ___________________________ Audience: • Your client(s) is (are) __________________ • The target audience is ________________ • You need to convince _________________ Situation: • The context you find yourself in is ___________ • The challenge involves dealing with _________ Product/ Performance and Purpose: • • • • You will create a ___________________________ in order to _______________________________ You need to develop ______________________ so that ___________________________________ Standards & Criteria: • Your performance needs to ________________ • Your work will be judged by _______________ • Your product must meet learning standards __________________________________________ • A successful result will _____________________ Possible STUDENT ROLES and AUDIENCES • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • Actor Advertiser Artist Astronaut Author Biographer Board member Boss Boy/girl scout Business person Candidate Carpenter Cartoon character Caterer Celebrity Chairperson Chef Choreographer • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • CEO Coach Community member Composer Client/customer Construction worker Dancer Designer Detective Doctor Editor Elected official Embassy staff Engineer Stenographer Expert (in) Eye witness • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • Farmer Filmmaker Fire fighter Forest anger Friend Geographer Geologist Government official Historian Historical figure Elected official Embassy staff Engineer Stenographer Expert (in) Eye witness Farmer Filmmaker Possible STUDENT ROLES and AUDIENCES • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • Fire fighter Forest anger Friend Geographer Geologist Government official Historian Historical figure Illustrator Intern Interviewer Inventor Judge Jury Lawyer Literary critic Lobbyist Museum director/curator • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • Museum goer Neighbor Newscaster Novelist Nurse Nutritionist Panelist Photographer Pilot Playwright Poet Policeman Radio listener Reader Reporter Researcher Reviewer Soldier School official scientist • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • Ship captain Social scientist Social worker Statistician Storyteller Student Taxi driver Teacher TV viewer Tour guide Travel agent Traveler TV movie character Tutor Viewer Visitor Web designer Zoo keeper Possible PRODUCTS and PERFORMANCE WRITTEN • Advertisement * Biography • Blog * book report/review • Brochure * crossword puzzle • Editorial * essay • Historical fiction * journal • Journal * lab report • Letter * magazine article • Memo * newscast • Newspaper article * play • Poem * research report • Proposal * script • Screen play * test • Story • position paper/policy brief ORAL • Conversation • debate • discussion • dramatization • Dramatic reading • infomercial • interview • radio script • Oral presentation • oral report • Poetry reading • puppet show • rap • speech • song • teach a lesson Possible PRODUCTS and PERFORMANCE WRITTEN • Advertisement * book/cd cover • cartoon * collage • Computer graphic * data display • design * diagram • display * drawing • Facebook/My space page * flowchart • flyer * game • graph * map • model * power point show • photograph * questionnaire • painting * poster • scrapbook * sculpture • Storyboard *videotape • Web site Grade 3 Integrative Most Essential Learning Competencies GRADE LEVEL STANDARDS: The learner listens critically to get information from text heard, demonstrate independence in using the basic language structure in oral and written communication and reads with comprehension. Budget of Work Subjects Most Essential Learning Competencies (MELC) (BOW) ESP English Nakapagpapalita ng mga natatanging kakayahan nang may pagtitiwala sa sarili (EsP3PKP-Ia-14) Week 1 Use common and proper nouns in a sentence (EN3G-If-2.2) Use plural form of regular nouns by adding /s/ or /es/ (e.g. dog, dogs, wish, wishes) (EN2G-Ig-h-2.3) Read and write numbers up to 10,000 in symbols and in words Math Health Science (M3NS-Ia-9.3) Add 3-digit by 3-digit numbers with sums up to 1000 without and with regrouping(M2NS-Ih-27.5) Week 1 Describe a healthy person (M3N-Iab-11) Week1 Classify objects and materials as solid, liquid, and gas based on some observable characteristics Week 1 Grade 3 Integrative Performance Task for Week 1 Goal: 1. Interview 3 members of your family on their preferred meal of the day, one for breakfast, one for lunch and another for dinner. 2. Make a meal plan for the family members or people living with you based on the food pyramid reflecting the go, glow and grow foods from the meal plan. 3. Make a tabular presentation of classification as to solid and liquid. 4. After making the meal plan, ask the elders in the family the cost of each meal in a day per person and the total cost for the entire family in a day. 5. Write a one paragraph with 3 to 5 sentences using the given proper and common nouns in describing your meal plan. Observe the correct use of singular and plural forms of nouns. Role: Your job is a nutritionist Audience: any family member to be interviewed -one for breakfast, one for lunch, and one for dinner Situation: You are a nutritionist and you are to prepare a meal plan for one day for one person based on their preferred menu following the food pyramid. You are going to share this meal plan to your classmates Product: Meal plan, tabular presentations of classification of foods, one paragraph with 3 – 5 sentences Standard: The performance task is to be assessed with the following guides Rubric for Assessing the Output Reference: Do 31 s. 2020 Menu Breakfast 1 cup of rice 1 piece of boiled egg 1 glass of Milo 1 piece of mango 1 bottle of Wilkin’s water Lunch 1 cup of rice 1 bowl of soup 3 pieces of meatballs 1 piece of dried fish 1 piece of banana Dinner 1 platter of pinakbet 1 cup of rice 1 slice of melon 1 glass of water 1 cup of milk Sample Output Cost Php 45.00 Php50.00 Php42.00 TOTAL COST in one day Php137.00 Total amount for 5 members in one day Php685.00 Materials Solid Rice / water Mango / Meatball / Dried fish / banana / pinakbet / melon / milk Liquid / / One day, my family spent a total of Php685.00 for our meals. We had rice, boiled egg, glass of Milo, mango and Wilkins water for breakfast. For lunch, we also had rice, bowl of soup, pieces of meat balls, dried fish, banana. And for dinner, we had pinakbet, rice, melon, water and milk. Conducting Assessment Remotely A. Communicating the Assessment Task Objectives of the assessment task Roles of learners and parents/guardians Procedure and expected timeline Standards and rubrics B. Record of Progress Self-reflection Tool Check-ins of teacher with learner (during assessment period) Evidence of learning in the student's learning portfolio The teacher must consult the learners, and when necessary, parents/ guardians, to allow room for adjustments/ flexibilities needed, if any. Learner A 77 91 36.4 56 75 45 81.4 88 Learner A 77 91 36.4 56 75 37.5 83 89 Learner A 77 91 27.3 56 75 52.5 79.8 87 On the use of technology STUDENTS SHOULD BE ABLE TO TELL US WHAT THEY ARE LEARNING, NOT WHAT APP THEY ARE USING