Presenter(s): __________________________________________________________________
Topic: __________________________________________________________________________________
4
(excellent)
Purpose
The project is well done and
it is clearly about their
assigned topic.
Content
Their claims are accurate.
They also included accurate
evidence about the topic.
Audience
They interacted with their
audience and they presented
in a way that was interesting
to their audience. They
spoke in loud and clear
voices.
Teamwork
They consistently worked as
a team. They had clear,
equal and different job
responsibilities and
supported each other during
the presentation.
Peer Reviewer (your name ) __________________________________
3 (good)
2 (average)
1 (needs
improvement)
The project is mostly about
their assigned topic.
Their project is always
about the topic, and often
their project is off topic.
Their project appears
to be about unrelated
topics
______/4
Their claims are unclear.
Some of their evidence
don't support their claims.
Their claims are
inaccurate. They did
not include relevant
evidence.
______/4
Their claims are clear. They
included relevant evidence
about the topic.
They used their own words
to summarize instead of
reading the words from the
slides. But they didn’t ask
or answer questions
They often read from the
slides instead of using their
own words to explain.
They sometimes spoke in
loud and clear voices.
They did not pay
attention to their
audience or had eye
contact with their
audience. They did
not speak in loud and
clear voices.
Each team member had
different and equal job
responsibilities. But the
presentation was not smooth
as they were not
collaborating together.
They tried to work as a
team. However, some
students spoke for the most
part of the presentation
whereas some didn’t speak
at all.
They did not work as
a team. They didn’t
know their job
responsibilities at all.
They accused and
blamed each other.
Points
______/4
______/4
Addi
tiona
l comments or questions:_______________________________________________________________________________________ _________
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Presenter(s): __________________________________________________________________
Topic: __________________________________________________________________________________
Peer Reviewer (your name ) __________________________________
4
(excellent)
Purpose
The project is well done and
it is clearly about their
assigned topic.
Content
Their claims are accurate.
They also included accurate
evidence about the topic.
Audience 观众
They interacted with their
audience and they presented
in a way that was interesting
to their audience. They
spoke in loud and clear
voices.
Teamwork
They consistently worked as
a team. They had clear,
equal and different job
responsibilities and
supported each other during
the presentation.
3 (good)
2 (average)
1 (needs
improvement)
The project is mostly about
their assigned topic.
Their project is always
about the topic, and often
their project is off topic.
Their project appears
to be about unrelated
topics
______/4
Their claims are unclear.
Some of their evidence
don't support their claims.
Their claims are
inaccurate. They did
not include relevant
evidence.
______/4
Their claims are clear. They
included relevant evidence
about the topic.
They used their own words
to summarize instead of
reading the words from the
slides. But they didn’t ask
or answer questions
They often read from the
slides instead of using their
own words to explain.
They sometimes spoke in
loud and clear voices.
They did not pay
attention to their
audience or had eye
contact with their
audience. They did
not speak in loud and
clear voices.
Each team member had
different and equal job
responsibilities. But the
presentation was not smooth
as they were not
collaborating together.
They tried to work as a
team. However, some
students spoke for the most
part of the presentation
whereas some didn’t speak
at all.
They did not work as
a team. They didn’t
know their job
responsibilities at all.
They accused and
blamed each other.
Points
______/4
______/4
Addi
tiona
l
com
ments or questions:_______________________________________________________________________________________ _________
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________