Summary EIT – exam 1. International trade Classical theories - Unequal resource distribution - Absolute and comparative cost advantages New trade theories - Increased returns of specialization due to economies of scale (lower unit cost of production) - First mover advantage – economies of scales causing a barrier to entry for other companies - Government intervention If a country has absolute cost advantage in production, division of labor will lead to total output increasing. The country specializes itself of the production of product A/B. If a country is relatively better at producing a product, a comparative cost advantage arises. The country’s commodities (product) of A and B are divided: the higher outcome means that country should specialize in producing that significant commodity/product. Why trade barriers? (slide 9) Protecting domestic infant industries from international competition Protecting domestic strategic goods Protecting domestic jobs Limit foreign influence in domestic economy Provide extra income for government Protecting customers Types of barriers (slide 10) Tariffs Quota’s Licenses Embargo Export subsidies Voluntary export/important restraints Local content requirement Technical standards Capital controls Import products limiting amount import only for allowed licensed parties no import allowed lower costs for domestic exporters informal quota’s components of imported goods/origin excessive specifications import goods restrictions on cross border transactions 1 Effects of trade barriers (slide 11) Increased prices of foreign goods Increased domestic prices due to lower competition Smaller variety of goods available for consumers Increased number of jobs Loss of welfare Risk of trade wars Graphics - Welfare effects without international trade - A market with imports 2 - Gains and losses in a market with imports - Impact on tariffs By tariffs, world price will shift upwards, consumers will consume less, domestic producers produce more until their price reaches world price (Sw+t). / Less efficiency, higher prices. 3 - A market with exports 1.0 A market with exports 2.0 (employment will go up) - - Gains and losses in a market with exports 4 - Impact of quota’s Import tariffs promote domestic production, therefore introducing tariffs can increase import of a country (eg raw materials) because import increases, the supply of a currency will increase. Because of the tariffs, import prices rise, therefore production prices rise, therefore export products will become more expensive, decreasing the demand for the currency, leading to a devaluation of the currency. International trade agreements GATT - General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade - Goal: freer trade by lower tariffs on goods WTO - World Trade Organisation, replaced GATT in 1997 Goal: freer trade (by lowering on goods and services via the negotiation of new trade agreements, and setting disputes between WTO-members). WTO – principles underlying all WTO-rules Most favored nations principle Equal treatment for all country trading partners exemptions for: (1)free trade areas, (2)favorable conditions for developing countries and (3)barriers against dumping practices. National treatment Treating foreigners (import) and locals (domestic production) equal as a good has entered the market Trade facilitation Prohibition of applying bureaucratic delays and red tape in order to pose a burden for moving goods across borders for traders. Free trade agreement 1.0 5 Free trade agreement 2.0 Free trade agreement 3.0 Present issue number 1 6 China threatening to retaliate against US metals tariffs - An act of revenge - Trump imposed steep tariffs on aluminum and steel imports on national security grounds - China said this was reckless. - Anti-dumping investigation into US sorghum product If a product is exported at a price lower than the normal value of the product Consequences: Impact on American employers and consumers 25% Mercedes tariff NAFTA relation Present issue number 2 EU and BREXIT deals Britain leaves the EU’s single market and the Customer Union and follows in a deeper and special partnership with the EU, having a comprehensive free-trade deal. Possibilities Full membership Membership of the European Economic Area only The Swiss Solution The Turkish Solution A comprehensive free trade deal: CETA No deal (only WTO rules) 7 2. The foreign exchange market FE= bank deposits denominated in different currencies Trading FE= global OTC market operated by (mainly) banks Exchange rates= price of a nation’s currency in terms of another currency Real exchange rate= the rate at which the domestic goods can be exchanges for foreign goods (PPP concept) Theory of Purchasing Power Parity (PPP) - Two currencies are in equilibrium, when a market basket of goods, considering exchanges rate is priced the same in both countries - Currency 1 to 2 (ER1) = P1/P2 - P1= average price baskets of goods in country 1 in currency 1 - P2= average price of baskets of goods in country 2 in currency 2 - Does not provide a clear explanation of actual exchange rates because of restrictions in free trade. - Transport costs between countries and different production costs and goods are never identical. Interest parity condition - Domestic interest rate foreign interest rate + expected appreciation of foreign currency or Foreign interest rate – expected depreciation of domestic currency If a domestic interest rate is 2% and an appreciation is expected of 1%, investors will only accept a foreign interest rate of 1% (difference 2% - 1%) so that return on assets in both countries are identical. xbblCurrency board= arrangement in which the domestic currency is backed 100% by a foreign currency and a fixed exchange rate with that currency exist. Country has NO monetary policy: CB issues money into the economy in exchange of the foreign currency. Dollarization= arrangement in which the domestic currency is replaced by the US dollar. 8 Exchange rate determination Factors effecting the exchange rate 9 Semi fixed exchange rates Advantages and disadvantages of fixed systems 10 Policy trilemma= limited options and resources available for countries to implement a monetary policy. No free flow of capital is achieved, no fixed exchange rate and an independent monetary policy. 11 2. International Financial system Monetary consequences FE intervention - Sale of FE by the CB to banks leads to a decline of the monetary base (bank reserves + cash + money in the hands of households and corporates) and thereby reducing bank liquidity and as a consequence reducing the money supply and increasing interest rates. - Sale FE – monetary base decreases – money supply increases – interest rates increase – capital inflow increases – demand domestic currency increases – appreciation domestic currency - Sterilized intervention= the monetary effects of a FE intervention are counteracted by an offsetting open market operation (sale of a FE= offsetting operation is purchasing the same amount in bonds). Balance of Payments All transactions between a nation and other nations during one year 3 categories 1. Current account income generating transaction Net export of goods Net receipts from abroad (service, investment, unilateral) 2. Capital account capital transactions Net receipts from capital transactions (purchase securities, direct investments, loans) 3. Financial account official reserve transactions Net change in government CB international reserves FE 12 BoP – diagram Increase in FE > compare with import of goods Exchange rate regimes Rules of Golden Standard 1. Fixed gold price 2. Currency convertible in gold 3. Fixed ratio of the value of gold reserves (monetary) and the value of money (banknotes and coins) circulating (ratio of 1) 13 Bretton Woods System Rules 1. Gold price fixed in the US dollar 2. US dollar convertible in gold 3. Currencies of other participating countries pegged to the US dollar 4. Countries facing a structural balance of payment deficit (ER fall) may borrow the required FE (to finance net import) from the IFM in order to keep the exchange rate of their currency stable. 5. IMF-loans must be repaid in the medium term – debtor countries can reform their economies in the meantime in order to reduce the country’s dependency on imports and increase its competitiveness (rising exports). 6. IMF advises participating countries regarding their economic policy Worldbank – International bank providing cheap loans for capital development to developing countries GATT = General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (fixed exchange rate system has been abandoned in 1973 due to structural BoP deficits of the US. The European Monetary Union and beyond The European Monetary Union was intended as a step towards further deepening of the EU. The EMU introduced one common monetary policy, one currency and further economic coordination via de Stability and Growth Pact: to pursue sound public finances and coordination of fiscal policy rules (government deficits below 3% of GDP, government debt below 60% of GDP, and low and stable inflation). 14 Interdependency between the fiscal position of governments and the crisis situation in the banking sector: the potential vicious circle between banks and the debt of their sovereign. (slide 41) Banking Union helps with: Being stronger and more immune to shocks due to a system of supervision and prudential requirements. (sufficient capital reserves and liquidity) Falling banks will be resolved without taxpayer’s money, limiting negative effects on governments and so government fiscal positions via a common resolution framework including a resolution fund: so no bail out by governments and so government fiscal position will not be weakened further. 15 4. Banking 1 Bank (credit institution) = grant credits for its own account and repayable funds from the public. Functions Hold deposits and savings Make loans to households and corporates services Responsible for maintaining the payment system Financing banks Hold model until maturity Originate to distribute model 16 Financial institutes Insurance companies Investment funds (hedge, private equity, money market funds) Pension funds bank: technical provisions for future pensions Hedge fund: a leveraged investment fund Private equity fund: an investment fund specialized in investing in venture capital (equity in the companies the investment fund invests in) Money market fund: investment fund specialized in investing in money market instruments Money Officially-issued legal tender of notes and coins. Circulate medium of exchange. Functions Medium of exchange Store of value Unit of account Flat money = officially issues paper currency (banknotes and coins) Electronic money = debit cards (prepaid cards preloaded by banks) and credit cards Monetary aggregates M2 = M1 + close substitutes of M M3 = M2 + close substitutes of M2 17 Additional deposits = amount of cash + reserves Short in reserves but solvent > borrow additional funds from the CB Bank can make loans if it receives additional deposits 10 extra overnight deposits > required ratio 10 > create an amount of money up to 100 Liquidity management Bank holds excess reserves, positive difference between actual and required reserves if > the costs of additional borrowing of the CB, the repo rate (CB to commercial banks if funds fall) or lending rate exceeds costs of holding the excess reserves. Asset management 1. Select borrowers with low risk of default who pay interest rates 2. Select securities with high returns and low risk 3. Minimize risk by diversifying assets 4. Manage liquidity to meet deposit outflows, estimate the sum of L-assets and cash inflow, and sum the overnight deposits + cash outflow > exceed latter. Liability management The bank must ensure stable financing of the assets – long term assets should be financed by long term liabilities (Northern Rock!) 18 19 Banking structure Crisis management Eurozone 20 Bank Liquid assets short-term liabilities Non-liquid assets Long term liabilities Own funds (share capital and free reserves) Liquidity = can a bank deal with its short-term commitments? Enough cash flow available. Solvency = can a bank pay back all of its commitments (liabilities), buffers to deal with losses. (SLIDE 51) What can you do when you are running the risk of going bankrupt of all the losses you are making? 1. Loan from the ECB (or the FED if you are in the US) will improve the banks liquidity. This will help when you are not liquid. It will have no consequences for the bank solvency as it won’t increase own funds. 2. To increase own funds, you have to increase share capital by issuing shares (stock) own fund buffers will increase. On the left side of the T-Account, liquid assets will increase. Issuing shares (in the bank: being co-owner of the bank) increases own funds + bank reserves. However, if you are not solvent, no one wants to buy stock. 3. Sell non-liquid (risky) assets for cash 4. Liquidity improving: by substitute liquid of short-term liabilities by long term liabilities. You can only change short term loans to long term loans when they are maturing. (Wanneer ze ouder worden en je nog een keer opnieuw moet lenen en dat je dan 5 jaar leent ipv 30 dagen, want je kan niet de lening die je hebt veranderen naar een long-term lening). Resolutions: 1. Removal of managers 2. Sale of business 3. Bridge institution temporary vehicle which you use in order to sell a bank. Bridge institution can take over the bank to sell it afterwards. 4. Good bank – bad bank: you can sell the unhealthy assets to another separate bank (you make that bank) and let that one go bankrupt. (let bad bank go bankrupt and sell the good bank) 5. Bail-in: the holders of capital will pay for it. (The creditors and shareholders will pay for the bank’s rescue) (most important one). Forget about page 50. Why bailout should be avoided (using Ireland as an example): 21 Lower bank lending (lower risk profile) Italian banks holding government bonds Less spending lower economic growth lower taxes government debt goes up Italian government promises retirement age at 62 years and minimum wage for everybody (also the unemployed) government debt increasing Bank losses due to lower bond prices Re-financing cost-interest rate goes up Bail out government debt is going up even more and interest rates are going up even more. With a bail-out a bank is saved by the government by using tax payers’ money. Therefore, we arrange the possibility of bail-in. In Italy politicians will choose for a bail out. Bail in in Italy is practically suicide. Own government bonds government bonds go up Lower ban k lending - lower risk profile lower eco growth = lower taxes = government debt will go up. What goes wrong in emerging markets, it is almost one of the two and it is sometimes even two of the two: 1. Mismanagement of financial liberalization / globalization 2. Severe fiscal imbalances (not able to find new ways of getting new money, expenses of the government are to0 high). 22 Richest country in the world looking at roil reserves but miss-management of the country let to total break-down of the oil industry. That country has especially the second one. Interest rate loans go up Local assets prices go down Import prices go up Emerging markets: Government debt goes up. Banks miss management $ US: I goes up Capital flight Buy $ sell local currency exchange rate goes down SLIDE 62 1. Setting the official interest rate: EU is repo rate (amount of money available for banks at the repo rate is limited), US is federal fund target rate, UK = bank rate a. Lending facilities ECB: repo-facility amount you can borrow is limited; marginal lending (rate) facility; ad hoc facilities (in 2011 the situation in Europe was close to a financial meltdown and then the ECB made ad hoc loans, it is created when necessary). The steps are in the order for when you need more, so first repo-facility then marginal lending then ad hoc. i. Ad hoc facilities 2011/2012 3 year loan at 1% max 11,00 bn ii. Lending facilities ECB US: Fed fund target rate, discount facility: unlimited. ECB decides how much banks can lend from the CB. Lending facility when a bank wants to lend more than the ECB “allows”. ECB: 1. Repo facility: limited 2. Marginal lending rate facility 3. Ad hoc facilities US Federal fund target rate Discount facility: limited US bank reserves should be 1% of deposit when banks have more they can lend to other banks with deficits. IMPORTANT Federal Fund target rate beginning December changes Thursday. 23 Federal fund target rate will increase bank lending will become more expensive less lending less spending to slow down the economy. As US now coping with inflation overheated economy EXAM question: How can you lower the bank reserves related to the deposits outstanding. slide 63 (Over foto eronder) - Increase minimum reserve requirement excess reserves decrease - They (interest rates) will go up as soon as Sell cheap bonds to Banks - FED how can the interest rate increase to 1.5? o Setting federal fund rate higher o You can use tools in slide 62. - Why would you do it? Less banking reserves available, supply will go to the left 24 In this picture I am arguing if you lower bank reserves if you will lower supply. Balance sheet comm US ban Bank reserves Loans Securities 2 78 30 Deposits Brrowings from FED Own funds 110 100 5 5 110 FED wants to lower bank reserves: - Increase minimum reserve requirements/ratio excess reserve decrease - Open market operations sell cheap bonds to banks. However, interst rates will go up. Securities will go up bank reserves go down outstanding loans go down deposit goes down. ECB deposit rate is now -0.40% to stimulate commercial banks to do something else with their reserves, e.g. buying bonds. When increasing this rate banks will keep it on a loan at the CB, so they will not use it for other spending alternative alternative. Deposit rate goes up Bank reserves go up because they earn more money or loans or securities will be affected Securities go down higher interest rates are going down lower consumer borrowing lower bank lending = higher interest rate result in less lending from bank to public WATCH WHAT THE FED IS DOWING IN THE FIRST WEEK OF DECEMBER. IF THE FED IS DOING SOMETHING HE WILL ASK SOMETHING ABOUT IT. Over-night: you cannot borrow for a couple of years (only days weeks or months) SLIDE 64: (links onder) need to be able to understand when a bank is borrowing money. SLIDE 65 - If the deposit rate increases it is less expensive to hold money on the CB, it will stimulate bank to hold more money with the central bank and don’t use it for lending purposes. If banks are selling securities it will increase interest rates. 25 5. Banking 2 Capital adequacy management A bank should maintain adequate capital buffers to absorb losses under stress circumstances Hold capital up to 8% of the sum of risk weighted assets and off-balance sheet exposures Low capital buffers > capital crunch can cause a credit crunch and an economic crisis. Global financial risk Financial crisis in advanced economies Foreclosures increase supply of homes and lowers therefore house prices, creating negative equity. Foreclosures reduce cash flowing into banks and the value of mortgage-backed securities held by banks. When losses are incurred additional funds are required. If banks are not capitalized sufficiently to lend, economic activity slows down and unemployment increases, this increases foreclosures (balancing a loan from a borrower). 26 27 Government intervention Financial bailouts of failing banks Improve banking supervision (EU banking Union in addition to the EMU) and increasing bank’s capital buffers Fiscal stimulus spending in the US (in Europe opposite due to the Sovereign debt crisis Loose monetary policy resulting in cheap money for banks Economic reform measures in order to make economies more competitive 28 6. Financial crisis in emerging markets Developing an EM crisis 1. Mismanagement of financial liberalization or globalization Elimination of restrictions on cross border activities of domestic banks in combination with a weak financial infrastructure and weal prudential supervision can cause to much borrowing in FC, and allocating money insufficient. Asset bubbles and low ROI in domestic economy. 2. Severe fiscal imbalance Cause EM government to borrow much FC and allocate money inefficient in the domestic economy, debt running out of control. Currency crisis Economic crisis Foreign investors sell their investments, asset bubbles burst and private wealth falls, money is pulled out of the country into other countries, domestic currency depreciates and increase of interest rate and inflation. Economy contracts. Prevention Tighten prudential regulation and supervision of banks Fiscal consolidation and sustainable debt to GDP ratio’s Fiscal policy focused on supporting reforms aimed at expanding and diversifying the economy’s supply potential Limit currency mismatches: prevent carry trade (buying high yielding currency and funding it with a low yielding currency, buy low – sell high) Managing financial liberalization Central bank’s monetary policy instruments Setting official interest rate Discount lending Interest rate on reserves Reserve requirements Open market operations Ad hoc lending operations 29 Borrowings from CB increases the bank’s liquidity – bank reserves 1 Allowing to lend more to households and corporates 2 Results in an increase in the amount of deposits of households and corporates 2 Spending of consumers and corporates will increase!!! 30 OMO An activity by the CB to give or take liquidity in its currency to or from a bank or a group banks by buying or selling private sector securities or public sector securities in the open market or via repo or secured lending transaction with a Commercial B > CB gives money as a deposit for a defined period and as an eligible asset as collateral. Used for implementing monetary policy by means of supplying commercial banks with liquidity or taking surplus liquidity from commercial banks to manipulate interest rates. The supply of money and aggregate demand and thereby inflation, especially to control recessions. 31 ‘’Monetary policy instruments and the transmission mechanisms.’’ TRANSMISSION MECHANISM 1 1. INTEREST RATE CHANNEL ECB repo rate increase – bank borrows decrease (because more expensive) – affects bank lending decreases (bank lending costs decrease because bank liquidity is expensive) – total demand goods and services decrease (spending less) – affects GDP – affects inflation (people spend less so causes inflation to fall) 2. EXCHANGE RATE CHANNEL ECB repo rate increases – foreign capital moves to euro zone (higher interest rates cause attraction) – demand euro goes up – exchange rate increases – euro zone export and import affected (net export) – export falls (more expensive and higher export prices in FE, people spend less) – import increase (import prices in euro cheaper) – net export decreases – total demand affected and falls – GDP and inflation decrease 3. PRIVATE WEALTH CHANNEL ECB repo rate increases – bond and shares prices decrease – net present value company goes down as financing costs of company go up – profit goes down – share price goes down (=net present value) 32 TRANSMISSION MECHANISM 2 1. INTEREST RATE CHANNEL Open market selling of bonds to banks – less money available – lower bank lending or/and higher interest rates – total demand falls – GDP falls – inflation falls 2. EXCHANGE RATE CHANNEL Open market selling of bonds to banks – short of cash - higher interest rates make exchange rates go up as attracts foreign capital – more demand currency so appreciation – export falls – import goes up – net export falls – GDP and inflation decreases 3. PRIVATE WEALTH CHANNEL Open market selling of bonds to banks – bond and shares prices decrease – net present value company goes down as financing costs of company go up – profit goes down – share price goes down (=net present value) TRANSMISSION MECHANISM 3 Min reserve ratio= bank reserves / deposits x 100% > 1% required ratio 33 1. INTEREST RATE CHANNEL Min reserve requirements higher – banks have less money available as reserves are higher and short of cash – higher than 2% - lower bank lending as more expensive, interest rates higher – demand lower – GDP and inflation decrease 2. EXCHANGE RATE CHANNEL Min reserve requirements higher – SAME 3. PRIVATE WEALTH CHANNEL Min reserve requirements higher – bond and shares prices decrease – net present value company goes down as financing costs of company go up – profit goes down – share price goes down (=net present value) TRANSMISSION MECHANISM 4 Deposit rate -40, banks forced to keep as low as possible to use money for other purposes 1. INTEREST RATE CHANNEL Deposit rate increase – SAME Deposit rate decrease – banks are forced to move money from bank reserves 2. EXCHANGE RATE CHANNEL Deposit rate increase – SAME 3. PRIVATE WEALTH CHANNEL Deposit rate increase – SAME ___________________________________________________________________________ When does it not work? 2008 financial crisis: banks making losses Credit crunch in banking sector = lower risk exposure 34 Bank borrowing and bank lending to corporates IS NOT POSSIBLE/BENEFICIAL 1. INTEREST RATE CHANNEL ECB repo rate decrease 0% - bank borrowing – lending to governments – government conduct cheap borrowing – spending of people dried up as they not borrowed but the government borrowed – no effect on total demand – no effect on GDP and inflation EXAMPLE Government debt ratio out of control Italy: borrow cheap spend cheap, should have improved the economy 2. EXCHANGE RATE CHANNEL Decrease repo rate – exchange rate falls – goods are less expensive – export increases – import decreases 3. PRIVATE WEALTH CHANNEL Decrease repo rate – market interest rates fall – private wealth increases – uncertain about jobs pp ___________________________________________________________________________ ECB repo rate increased but banks don’t need money than it is useless to increase repo rate as this does not affect the banks > no monetary policy. Banks not shore of cash or don’t need cash? Use instruments number 2 or 3 Increase deposit rate if you want to lower GDP or inflation. 35 7. The conduct of monetary policy: strategy and tactics Price stability (ECB) = because inflation or deflation create economic uncertainty and lowers economic growth High employment and economic growth = stable eco growth – high and stable employment Dual mandate (FED) = high employment and economic growth – stable inflation Interest rate stability = fluctuating interest rate create economic uncertainty (inflation), are the result of fluctuating inflation. Stable prices strategy the same. Exchange rate stability = stable exchange rates (via monetary policies where higher IR are implemented during currency weaknesses). Stables trade relations with partners. ECB halves its purchasing pricing of securities, and the rate at which it prints new CB money to inject in the economy. Why? - Compromises, leaving the ECB room for manoeuvre rather than signaling a firm to end purchases in the future. - 2% ceiling ECB not reached, no inflationary pressure. - Normalize - Long-term interests need to be targeted (pin down the whole structure of interest rates) - Quantitative easing = targeting a quantity long-term security to purchase in order to ease long-term borrowing conditions by driving down yields on the purchased assets, and driving investors into other securities. - Direct rate targeting = specifies desired yields on the relevant assets and buys or sells securities to achieve it. ECB influencing the rate Signaling or market operations 1. Standing steady to buy and sell as required means they didn’t have to in the first place 2. Direct long-term investment interest rate targeting is useful when policy has to be tightened as well as loosened. Rate-targeting would involve a targeting rise in the common interest rate: ECB would package the bonds it holds and sell bundles that exactly correspond to the constructed rate. That would achieve the desired monetary policy and common safe asset without taxes and exposes etc. 36 Turkey current account surplus Article - Sharp rise in exports and fall in imports rebalancing crisis-hit economy - Largest monthly current account surpluses - Currency crisis have led to a rapid rebalancing of the economy - Foreign investors have been scared off by the rise of interest rates (deemed to be necessary during an overheating economy) - Lira plummeted - Swift correction Turkey’s current account balance - Consumers and businesses are cutting back on imports due to rising prices - Trade deficit improving in the months where there is a lot of tourism - Exchange rate depreciation makes country’s exports cheaper on world markets - Exchange rates increase profits of exporters - Export countries Germany US should support a recovery - Fewer working days in august so September export surged https://studiedelen.mijnhva.nl/studiedelen/fbe-4000EIT_17/18191/Documents/Turkey%20heads%20for%20record%20current%20account%20surplus.pdf US – China Article - Trade confrontation - Refusal to buy its debt by Beijing. - Tit-for-tat trade sanctions - One makes aggressive move, so the other responds and does the same. - Trump says China has been cheating on trade - Reaction to tariffs of US - Trump imposes 10% extra tariffs on extra Chinese exports. - To 25% as a consequence of tit-for-tat. - Risk a trade war - US thinks China is vulnerable for US pressure and tariff war - China soon runs out on products to impose tariffs on Obstacles for operating American businesses in China Eased enforcement of trade sanction on North Korea (scrap nuclear weapons) Manipulate the currency to drift down in value, which offsets the price effect of 10% tariffs. China big role of American government debt buyer. They make it harder to fund the US federal deficit. https://studiedelen.mijnhva.nl/studiedelen/fbe-4000EIT_17/18191/Documents/The%20US,%20China%20and%20the%20logic%20of%20trade%20confrontation.pdf 37 Turkey’s currency crisis Article - Slash public spending rapidly when inflation surged - Rebuild market confidence by cutting public spending in a sweeping austerity program. - Sharply raise interest rates in the face of a mounting currency crisis. - Spending and growth targets were a welcome sign to take measures to tame the inflation and depreciate the Lira. - Banks face mounting bad loans, as the borrowers in dollars struggle to meet the debt payments rising. - New economic program based on more realistic GDP and inflation. - Lower but more sustainable growth. https://studiedelen.mijnhva.nl/studiedelen/fbe-4000EIT_17/18191/Documents/Turkey%20unveils%20plan%20to%20fight%20currency%20crisis.pdf Exam practice 1. What can be done in order to stabilize a weak currency (€), by: a. Fiscal measures (fiscal policy means that you use your budget policy in order to influence the economy) i. Higher taxes people will have less money to spend (spending goes down) if you spend less, you spend less on goods (some are produced in the country itself, some are produced in another country) import goes down supply € goes down € appreciates. ii. Or: higher taxes lower spending lower inflation relative price decline exports more export more demand for € € appreciates. iii. Or: Lower government spending lower spending (total) …. (steps 1 or 2) € appreciates. b. Monetary measure (ECB) i. Increase official rate (repo rate) higher bank lending rates lower spending etc. € appreciates. ii. Or: to attract foreign capital increased demand for € € appreciates. iii. Or: ECB sells bonds to banks lower bank liquidity bank lending rates go up etc. c. Trade policy-related measures i. Tariffs: Impose a tariff people will import less (import goes down) supply of € goes down € appreciates (exchange rate goes up). ii. Or (bonus point): if import is price-inelastic an increase in import prices (by imposing a tariff) will increase the value of imports and the supply for € goes up € depreciates. If export will be lower this will lower the exchange rate. (If this happens, we could argue that an import tariff is not effective) THE FOLLOWING QUESTIONS ARE RELATED TO EACHOTHER 2. If government debt increases fast and unexpected, what will be the consequences for government borrowing rates? a. The government borrowing cost is going up (if borrow more, pay more). 38 3. What are the consequences for government prices? a. If interest rates go up Bond prices go down (if interest rates go down bond prices go up) example: if I buy a bond, interest rate goes up no one is interested in my bond if I lower my celling price then it becomes interesting because the rate of return increase. 4. What are the consequences for the financial position of banks holding such government bonds? a. Banks will have a weaker financial position, because they make a loss on their bond holdings. Assets BANK Liabilities ________________________________________________________ Bank holdings (goes down) Liabilities Own fund (goes down) 5. What will be the effect on bank lending? a. Bank lending goes down, because they have fewer capital buffers so less money available. Bank lending rate goes up bank lending goes down. 6. What will be the effect of this on the government debt? a. If bank lending is falling people spend less (because of lower bank lending) tax income will be less the economy will grow slower government debt will increase. b. If the government is increasing its debt by higher interest rate this will have consequences for the banking system. It will lower bank lending this means lower spending lower tax income the effect will be that government debt will increase. Solve it by lower the government deficit. Lower deficit and lower spending can trigger an economic recession. 7. So, what should the government do if situation nr. 2 is reality. a. The government should stabilize the government deficit (by increasing taxes or lower government spending). Otherwise the circle will go on where the government will increase influence the banker sector. THEORY If the repo rate of the ECB is lowered bank lending rates will go down more consumer spending more economic growth + inflation. We want more inflation to happen when there is a risk of deflation. 39 REALITY If the repo rate of the ECB is lowered when there is a bank crisis, lending will not fall (cheap government borrowing, risk free). The only thing you can do is an incentive for higher debt. more consumer spending more economic growth (but it is not a healthy economic growth because the government is spending, not the people. If there is a bank crisis going on should try to not make the red (picture) happen. More consumer spending also means more import. SAUDI ARABIA - Policy fixed exchange rate relative to US $. 1. Consequences for fiscal policy and monetary policy> I a. If US interest rates go up capita will flee to Saudi Arabia towards the US if capital is fleeing Saudi Arabia it has to be converted in dollars (sell the Saudi Arabian currency, then I can put it on a bank account in the US) exchange rate is depreciating (Saudi currency depreciates, because you are selling it). i. If you sell your Saudi currency, where will it go? It means that in the market supply and demand will meet each other. I have to find somebody that wants to buy euros. They maybe will want it if they think that the Euro will become strong. ii. If the Saudi currency is moving to the US, the price of that currency is going to drop. b. If you are a Saudi investor and you put your money on an account in Saudi Arabia and you can choose to invest 2. If you want a stable exchange rate Saudi Arabia should be forced to increase taxes (fiscal policy), or you use your monetary policy: increase interest rates. If you are fixing your currency to another currency, you will lose monetary independence. You will lose your autonomy. 40 EXAM TOPICS 1. International trade – cost advantages, types and effects of imposing trade barriers, WTO and International trade agreement Comparative cost advantage= when a country can produce a service or good at a lower operation cost. Absolute cost advantage= even though a country has an absolute cost advantage over all products, every country has a comparative one on a product or service. Trade barriers Tariffs Quota’s Licenses Embargo Export subsidies Voluntary export/important restraints Local content requirement Technical standards Capital controls Effects WTO Import products limiting amount import only for allowed licensed parties no import allowed lower costs for domestic exporters informal quota’s components of imported goods/origin excessive specifications import goods restrictions on cross border transactions Increased prices of foreign goods Increased domestic prices due to lower competition Smaller variety of goods available for consumers Increased number of jobs Loss of welfare Risk of trade wars Domestic production increases Deficit current account = net import of capital Restriction on import > lower capital import, country is worse off World Trade Organisation, replaced GATT in 1997 Goal: freer trade (by lowering on goods and services via the negotiation of new trade agreements, and setting disputes between WTO-members). WTO – principles underlying all WTO-rules Most favored nations principle Equal treatment for all country trading partners exemptions for: (1) free trade areas, (2) favorable conditions for developing countries and (3) barriers against dumping practices. 41 GATT - National treatment Treating foreigners (import) and locals (domestic production) equal as a good has entered the market Trade facilitation Prohibition of applying bureaucratic delays and red tape in order to pose a burden for moving goods across borders for traders. General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade Goal: freer trade by lower tariffs on goods 2. Foreign exchange market: determinants exchange rate; different regimes; pros and cons. Understanding of policy trilemma. Exchange rate Supply curve - import Eurozone, capital export Euro - Demand for exchange - Sell euro = shift supply curve to the right Demand curve - Export Eurozone, capital import Euro - Selling FE currency Demand export from Eurozone > demand euro INCREASE (import capital INCREASE) > euro appreciates > demand shifts to the right > demand + supply INCREASE Fixed Exchange rate is set by government or CB PRO Provides currency stability for investors Country business attractive Avoids inflation CON Expensive to maintain (foreign reserves needed) CB must convert FE to grow value, if not enough reserves, interest rates go up and recession Floating Determined by the market and supply & demand, self-correcting PRO Much more jobs created when the market reflects on the ER automatically. Demand for currency low, leads to low prices so higher demand and supply products World movement and actions do not have an impact on the currency CON High volatility 42 Makes current existing problems worse, conditions may get worse Managed floating Influenced exchange rates by CB or monetary policies PRO Adjustments needed to achieve equilibrium and good impact on economy Monetary policy is stronger CON Different governments set their exchange rates at inconsistent levels Fiscal policy weaker PPP Policy Trilemma Limited options and resources available for countries to implement a monetary policy. No free flow of capital is achieved, no fixed exchange rate and an independent monetary policy. 43 3. The European Union Preferential trading area - Country or group of countries receiving preferential treatment from another country or trading block - Tariffs and other import restrictions are abolished completely. - FREE TRADE AREA Economic and Monetary Union (EMU) - Implement effective monetary policy for euro with objective of price stability - Coordinating economic and fiscal policies in EU countries - Ensuring single market runs smoothly - Supervising and monitoring financial institutions 4. The functioning of banks and other financial institutions: how banks can create money; management of bank’s liquidity, assets, liability & solvency? Bank is a credit institution Hold people’s deposits and savings Make loans to households and corporate services Responsible for maintaining payment system ‘’Insurance companies, investment funds and pension funds banks’’ Money used as: Medium of exchange Store of value Unit of account Flat money (coins and paper) Electronic money (debit cards, credit cards, prepaid cards, smart cards) M2= M1 + substitutes M M3= M2 + close substitutes M2 Required reserve ratio = Cash + bank reserves / overnight deposits x 100% 44 LCR = High quality liquid assets / net outgoing cashflow in 30 days > 100% NSFR = Available amount of stable financing / required amount of stable funding > 100% Leverage ratio = Ratio of total share capital + reserves to total assets > 3% Liquidity management - Hold excess reserves if costs of additional borrowing exceed the costs of holding excess reserves. Asset management - Select borrowers with low risk of default - Select securities with high returns and low risks - Minimize risk by diversifying assets - Estimate the sum of liquid assets and overnight deposits. Liability management - Ensure stable financing of its assets (long – term assets, long – term liabilities) Capital adequacy management - A bank should obtain capital buffers to absorb losses 5. Causes and consequences of the 2008/2009 financial crisis for banks and other financial institutions in advanced economies and in emerging economies. 1. ADVANCED ECONOMIES Causes and consequences Irresponsible mortgage lending: risky loans past to investors as collateral Loose monetary policy: results in low interest rates and high bank lending Weak financial regulation: risk management was low Bursting of the housing bubble: value of property decreased, MBS (mortgage backed securities) prices decreased, creditworthiness questioned, withhold short-term credits so higher interest rate CREDIT CRUNCH investment capital not securable, prices of debt Solutions Improving supervision Loose monetary policy (cheap money for banks) Reform measures 45 2. EMERGING ECONOMIES Causes and consequences Mismanagement financial liberalization/globalization (borrow to much because of free trade and activities), money is allocated inefficient. Severe fiscal imbalances (borrow too much, money allocated inefficient domestically) Currency crisis occurs > FE SELL INVESTMENTS, ASSET BUBBLE & PRIVATE WEALTH BURSTS Economic crisis arises > DEPRECIATION OF CURRENCY BECAUSE OF SELLING DOMESTIC CURRENCY AND INVEST IN OTHER COUNTRIES, INCREASE INTEREST RATES SO INFLATION Solutions Tighten supervision of banks Limit currency mismatches (prevent excessive carry trade, buy low sell high) Managing financial liberalization 6. Tools and functioning of monetary policy – be able to explain the working of the different policy instruments: setting the official rate, conducting open market operations, changing the minimum reserve requirement, changing the deposit rate. ‘’A monetary policy is the implementation of actions taken by the CB or currency board or other regulatory authority to impact the economic activity in a country and keep the currency stable. It is for controlling inflation, consumption, growth and liquidity.’’ Monetary policy instruments - Setting official interest rate Refinancing the repo-rate. Maximum amount is set by the ECB. This is implemented when the inflation is getting higher than the target. When setting an official interest rate, borrowing and lending may be more expensive, so less people buy and inflation is pushed down. - Discount lending Marginal lending rate. This offers unlimited overnight credit to banks. A higher discount rate makes borrowing and lending more expensive, this means taking money out of the economy, and prices start to decrease. Inflation is decreasing, but employment as well. When prices are lower, export on the other hand is more interesting, so more demand for the currency so an appreciation of the currency arises. - Interest rate on reserves Deposit rate (interest on reserves). A negative deposit rate (currently) leads to banks paying for the balance with the ECB. Interest rates on savings account decreased, so consumption increases, prices rise, employment rises. Domestic production is increased, and export is not so interesting anymore. Less demand for the currency, so a depreciation. - Reserve requirements Minimum reserve ratio. If the required reserve ratio is increased, banks are forces to lower loans outstanding, so amount overnight deposits will fall and increase the amount of reserves by selling 46 securities. Interest rates increase again, and total spending falls. Consumer buying falls, prices fall, employment falls. Inflation decreases. Export more interesting because of the lower prices. Demand for currency increases, appreciation. A decrease of the ratio causes opposite effect. Banks have more liquidity, and are not forces to lower loans. The amount overnight deposits may increase, and decrease the amount by selling securities. Interest rates decrease, total spending rises. Consumers buy more, prices go up. Employment increases. Inflation happens. Export less interesting because of high prices. Domestic production increases. Less demand for the currency, depreciation. Ad hoc lending operations Actions taken for a reason or in a special situation. An urgent matter. - Open Market Operations OMO is an activity by the bank to give or take liquidity in its currency to or from a bank or group of banks. They do this by buying or selling securities in the open market, OR via repo or secured lending transaction with commercial banks. The CB gives the money as a deposit for a defined period and takes an eligible asset as collateral. The CB uses this as a monetary policy tool, by supplying commercial banks to manipulate interest rates, supply of money and aggregate demand and thereby inflation to control recessions. Buying and selling of government securities > affect money supply in the economy. 7. Understanding working of the monetary transmission mechanism, and why it doesn’t sometime work. 47