6 Spillways and Energy Disspators 6.1 Functions of Spillways To release the surplus water or flood water that can not be contained in the allotted storage space Bottom outlet 1 Dr.-Ing. Asie Kemal Jabir, AAiT, 2011 -2013 6.2 Necessity of Spillways Many failures of dams have been caused by hydraulic failure (40%), i.e overtopping Improperly designed spillways Spillways of insufficient capacity (Underestimation of the design flood) Malfunctions of spillways components Special precaution for embankment dams since any over topping may lead to the Dam’s failure In concrete dams, the impact of overtopping is less serious, It may increase the stress on the dam body Undermine the stability of the dam by eroding the foundation at the toe of the dam mainly by the overflowing impinging jet, Spillways are relatively expensive Spillways cost account for about 20% for earth and rock fill dams, Small portion for concrete dams 2 Dr.-Ing. Asie Kemal Jabir, AAiT, 2011 -2013 6.3 Component parts of A spillway A spillway generally has the following 5 component parts 1. Approach channel / Entrance channel 2. Control structure 3. Discharge channel / conveyance features / waterways 4. Terminal Structures / Energy Dissipators 5. Exit channels 7 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. River Dam Control Structure Approach Channel Discharge Channel Terminal Structure Exit channels Dr.-Ing. Asie Kemal Jabir, AAiT, 2011 -2013 3 6.3.1 Approach / Entrance Channel It draws water from the reservoir and carries it to control structure It is required in those types of spillways in which the control structure is away from the reservoir They are not required for spillways which draw water directly from the reservoir Control structure Reservoir Dam Fig 5 Approach channel Dr.-Ing. Asie Kemal Jabir, AAiT, 2011 -2013 4 Energy Dissipator Exit channel Dr.-Ing Asie Kemal Jabir, AAIT, 2011-2013 5 6.3.2 Control Structure It is a control device which regulates the outflow from the reservoir It limits or prevents outflows below fixed reservoir levels It regulates releases when the reservoir rises above the level Definite relationship between discharge and head A control structure usually consists of Weir (sharp crested, broad crested, and ogee) Orifice Fig 6 Control Structure Dr.-Ing. Asie Kemal Jabir, AAiT, 2011 -2013 6 6.3.3 Discharge Channel Conveys the water released through the control structure to the river downstream The conveyance structure may be The downstream face of a concrete dam Open channel excavated along the ground surface Closed conduits place through or under a dam Tunnels excavated through an embankment The channels may have Rectangular, trapezoidal or circular x-sections Flat or steep slopes Discharge Channel Dr.-Ing. Asie Kemal Jabir, AAiT, 2011 -2013 7 6.3.4 Terminal Structures When spillways flow drop from the reservoir pool level to downstream river level The static head is converted to kinetic energy The energy manifest itself in form of high velocity which may cause scour of the toe of the spillway and dam and other appurtenant structures scour the bed of the receiving river Terminal structures are provided at the downstream end to dissipate this excess energy Hydraulic jumps with stilling basins Bucket type 8 Dr.-Ing. Asie Kemal Jabir, AAiT, 2011 -2013 6.3.5 Exit Channels They are provided to convey the spillway discharge from the terminal structure to the river downstream An exit channel is not required for the spillway which discharges water directly into the river downstream Spillways placed through abutments, saddles, exit channels are usually required . Dr.-Ing. Asie Kemal Jabir, AAiT, 2011 -2013 9 6.4 Location of Spillways (link) Spillways should be located so that spillway discharge will not undermine the toe of the dam Spillways may be located either in the middle or at the edges Place the spillways in the main gorge so that the flood flows will be confined with in the banks of the river, Locate and align the spillways so that the main direction of the flow in the downstream is maintained unchanged If a suitable saddle can be found, they may be located away from the dam Although hydraulically more suitable, it would not be always possible to design heavy structures such as spillways, if a suitable foundation is not available in the main gorge. Then, a choice has to be made to locate the spillway structure on the flank. Saddle Dam Dr.-Ing. Asie Kemal Jabir, AAiT, 2011 -2013 10 6.5 Spillway Design Considerations In designing a spillway, the following factors have to be given due considerations a) It must have adequate capacity • It should be sized so that there will not be any overtopping b) It must be hydraulically and structurally safe. • It has to be safe against • Overturning, • Sliding, • Failure by crushing and tension cracks for various load combinations c) Its surface should be erosion resistant. d) It must be located so that its discharge will not erode or undermine the downstream toe of the dam e) Its capacity should not exceed that of the receiving river Dr.-Ing. Asie Kemal Jabir, AAiT, 2011 -2013 11 6.6. Types of Spillways 6.6.1 Classification scheme Based on various criteria, spillways can be classified A) Classification based on purpose A) Main / service spillways B) Auxiliary spillways C) Emergency spillways B) Based on control A) Controlled spillway B) Uncontrolled spillway C) Classification based on prominent features A) Free over-fall or straight drop B) Overflow Ogee spillways C) Chute spillway D) Side channel spillways E) Siphon spillways F) Shaft spillways G) Others Dr.-Ing. Asie Kemal Jabir, AAiT, 2011-2013 12 6.6.2 Classification Base on Purpose A. Main / Service spillways Designed to pass the Inflow Design Flood (IDF) Necessary for all dams B. Auxiliary Spillways Where site conditions permit, service spillways are supplemented by auxiliary spillways to gain an overall economy The main / service spillway are designed to handle the most frequent floods Floods exceeding the capacity of the service spillway are handled by Auxiliary spillways Auxiliary spillways are designed in such a way that their capacity is less than that required for the IDF Total spillway capacity = service spillway + auxiliary spillway capacity Auxiliary spillway crest is kept higher than the service spillway beyond the dam to avoid the possibility of damage to the dam or other structures. C. Emergency spillways It is used during emergencies and acts as an additional safety valve of the dam Emergencies: Floods exceeding design flood Malfunctioning of spillway gates It is usually provided in a saddle or a depression along the reservoir rim, 13 Its crest level is kept above the maximum water level Dr.-Ing. Asie Kemal Jabir, AAiT, 2011-2013 6.6.3 Classification based on Mode of Control A) Controlled (Gated) spillways Gates are provided over the crest to control the outflow from the reservoir. In such spillways, the full reservoir level is usually kept at the top level of the gates. The outflow from the reservoir can be varied by lifting the gates to different elevations. B) Uncontrolled (free) spillways Gates are not provided over the crest to control the outflow from the reservoir. Water flows over the crest uncontrollably The FRL is at the crest level of the spillway. The water escapes automatically when the water level rises above the crest level. Dr.-Ing. Asie Kemal Jabir, AAiT, 2011-2013 14 6.6.4. Classification based on Pertinent Hydraulic Features 6.6.4.1 Free Overfall Spillways The control structure is a narrow crested weir with vertical or near vertical downstream face and the water falls freely more or less vertical Arch dam Scour hole It is suited for thin arch or buttress overflow dams or to a crest which has a nearly vertical downstream face. Dr.-Ing. Asie Kemal Jabir, AAiT, 2011-2013 El Atazar Dam (Spain) Dr.-Ing. Asie Kemal Jabir, AAiT, Gebidem2011-2013 Dam (Switzerland). Fig 2.8 Some pictures of free overfall spillways Two challenges 1. The underside of the jet / nappe should be sufficiently ventilated to prevent a pulsating, fluctuating jet. 2. If the stream bed does not consist of sound rock, scouring of the stream bed may occur. d – max scour hole depth H – the height of the drop q - specific discharge of the free jet Where erosion can not be tolerated, artificial pool or stilling basins are provided. It is not suitable where the foundation is weak the apron is subjected to large impact forces which may cause vibration Dr.-Ing. Asie Kemal Jabir, AAiT, 2011-2013 6.6.4.2 Ogee (Overflow) Spillway Description It is an improvement up on the free overfall spillway. Main Feature The control structure isan ogee-shaped (inverted S) weir. The shape is made to conform the profile of the lower surface of napee of a ventilated jet issuing from a sharp crested weir when the head over the weir is the design head. The nappe shaped profile is ideal: Atmospheric pressure Dr.-Ing. Asie Kemal Jabir, AAiT, 2011/2012 Hydraulics of Overflow (Ogee) Spillway: It is divided in to 3 zones: The crest : control structure The face: discharge channel The toe: energy dissipator Dr.-Ing. Asie Kemal Jabir, AAiT, 2011/2012 A. The Spillway Crest The crest is shaped in the form of an ogee. It is made to conform closely to the profile of the lower surface of the nappe from a sharp crested weir A.1 Profile of the Crest The profile of the crest is described by first separating the crest it into two quadrants upstream and downstream from the high point (apex) of the lower nappe. The apex is normally defined as the crest axis (origin of coordinates). Appex, Origin x Downstream Upstream y Dr.-Ing. Asie Kemal Jabir, AAiT, 2011/2012 Extensive experiments by USBR resulted in the development by USACE (WES) of curves which can be described by simple equations Downstream Profile where o x and y are the coordinates of the point on the spillway surface, with the origin at the apex (see Fig). o He is the design head, excluding the head due to the velocity of approach, & o K and n are constants, which depend upon the inclination of the upstream face of the spillway. U/s Slope K n Vertical 2.000 1.850 1:3 (H:V) 1.936 1.836 2:3 (H:V) 1.936 1.810 3:3 (H:V) 1.873 1.776 Dr.-Ing. Asie Kemal Jabir, AAiT, 2011/2012 The curved profile of the crest section is continued till it meets tangentially the straight sloping surface of the downstream face of the overflow dam (Figure). The location of this point of tangency depends upon the slope of the downstream face of the overflow dam, which is determined from the stability requirements of the overflow section. Upstream profile The upstream profile is defined as a compound circular arc. It should be tangent to the upstream face and should have a zero slope at the crest U/s Slope a/Hd b/Hd R1/Hd R2/Hd Vertical 0.175 0.282 0.5 0.20 1:3 (H:V) 0.139 0.237 0.68 0.21 2:3 (H:V) 0.115 0.214 0.48 0.27 3:3 (H:V) 0 0.199 0.45 Dr.-Ing. Asie Kemal Jabir, AAiT, 2011/2012 Discharge over the crest The discharge over the spillway crest is given by the weir equation Where Co is coefficient of discharge (maximum value of 2.2) Le is effective crest length Hd is the total head on the crest Hd = H + Ha H is the water depth at crest Ha is the head due to the velocity of approach Dr.-Ing. Asie Kemal Jabir, AAiT, 2011/2012 Effective Length of Crest Le Piers and abutments cause side contractions of the overflow. Under such conditions, the effective length, Le, is less than the net length of the crest. The effect of the end contraction may be taken into account by reducing the net crest length as follows: where Le is the effective length of crest, L’ is the net (clear) length of crest, which is equal to the sum of the clear spans of the gate bays between piers, Hd is the actual total head of flow on crest, N is the number of piers, Kp is the pier contraction coefficient, and Ka is the abutment contraction coefficient. Dr.-Ing. Asie Kemal Jabir, AAiT, 2011/2012 Pier Contraction The pier contraction coefficient, Kp, is affected by the shape of the pier nose, the thickness of the pier, the design head, and the approach velocity. For conditions of design head, Ho, average pier contraction coefficients may be assumed as follows: Pier condition Square nosed pier Rounded nosed piers Pointed nose piers Kp 0.02 0.01 0 Abutment Contraction The abutment contraction coefficient, Ka, is affected by the shape of the abutment, the angle between the u/s approach wall, the axis of flow, and the head in relation to the design head, and the approach velocity. The average abutment coefficients may be assumed as follows: Abutment condition Square abutments at 90o Rounded abutments at 90o Rounded abutments at 45o Ka 0.2 0.1 0 Dr.-Ing. Asie Kemal Jabir, AAiT, 2011/2012 6.6.4.3 Side Channel Spillway Side Channel Trough Dr.-Ing. Asie Kemal Jabir, AAIT, 2011-2013 The control structure, i.e., the control weir, is placed approximately parallel to the upper portion of the discharge channel. Discharge Channel Control It has advantages that make it desirable for certain spillway layouts. where a long overflow crest is needed to limit the surcharge head and the abutments are steep and precipitous, where the control must be connected to a narrow discharge channel or tunnel, the side channel spillway is often the best choice, where a dam spillway is not feasible, such as in the case of an earth dam, The factor limiting its adoption is that this type of spillway is hydraulically less efficient. Side channels are definitely not considered for dams with a large design flood due to the limited overflow head of say 3 m. Dr.-Ing. Asie Kemal Jabir, AAIT, 2011-2013 6.4.4.4 Chute Spillway Dr.-Ing Asie Kemal Jabir, AAIT, 2011-2013 28 Energy Dissipator Exit channel Dr.-Ing Asie Kemal Jabir, AAIT, 2011-2013 29 Description A spillway whose discharge is conveyed from the reservoir to the downstream river level through a steep open channel, placed either along a dam abutment or through a saddle. It is used often in conjunction with embankment dams. some times, even for a gravity dam, a separate spillway is required when the valley is narrow and an overflow spillway cannot be provided at the dam site. It can be conveniently provided independently in a saddle at a low cost. Factors influencing the selection of chute spillways are the simplicity of their design and construction, their adaptability to almost any foundation condition, and the overall economy often obtained by the use of large amounts of spillway excavation in the dam embankment. 30 Dr.-Ing Asie Kemal Jabir, AAIT, 2011-2013 6.4.4.5. Shaft Spillway 31 Dr.-Ing Asie Kemal Jabir, AAiT, 2011-2013 A shaft spillway is an uncontrolled spillway in which the water enters over a weir and drops through a vertical or sloping shaft into a conduit which discharges into the downstream channel. The structure comprise of three elements: an overflow control weir, a vertical transition, and a closed discharge channel. Shaft spillways are typically used for dams with small to medium design discharges, with a maximum of approximately 1000m3/s. The overfall height of the structure may be almost 100m although 50m is more relevant. Dr.-Ing Asie Kemal Jabir, AAiT, 2011-2013 32