Siuslaw River Basin SURFACE PROCESS SURVEY Josef Kuklinski, Jon Michael | Geology 202 | March 1, 2019 The Formation of the Triangle and Little Lakes Although there are 1400 named lakes within Oregon, there are exceedingly few in the Coast Range. In fact, the glacial and volcanic processes which are responsible for most of the lakes within the Cascade Range are not present in the Coast Range.1 So, what created these anomalous lakes? The answer lies somewhere between 2.6 million years ago and 11,000 years ago during the Pleistocene Epoch. The Pleistocene Epoch was categorized by global cooling and massive glaciation, including Earth’s most recent period of repeated glaciations.2 Though the area in question did not have any glaciers during this time, it did have a high level of precipitation due to local climate as well as the rain-shadow effect. By studying the fossilized pollen grains in core samples taken from Little Lake, we get a snapshot of the plants that were growing in the area during that time and thus an accurate idea of what the climate was. From about 42,000 years ago to 25,000 years ago, the local region was colder and wetter than present day conditions.3 For comparison, average annual precipitation for the Oregon Coast ranges from 60-90 inches near the coast and all the way up to 200 inches high in the coast range.4 The Coastal Range during the Pleistocene was cold and quite moist, but this cannot be the sole cause as we would expect to see a great number of lakes in the Coast Range which is clearly not the case. Something specific in this region must have stopped a large amount of water from draining out of the area for a time. Since glacial and lava dams are not possible causes in this case, perhaps a local geologic feature or event is to blame. The Coast Range is continuing its uplift due to stress from the Cascadia Subduction Zone. The strata are almost entirely made up of layered marine sandstone of the Tyee Formation, with volcanic formations poking through at the top, forming the ridges of the highest peaks in the Range.5 Sandstone is easily weathered and eroded away by water (and gravity) due to its permeable and porous nature. Thus, the mystery unravels. An actively uplifting mountain range composed of delicate marine sandstone interspersed with rivers and streams throughout tends to form narrow river valleys. If you then add heavy rains (of the Pleistocene) into the mix, landslides and other mass-movements become very real possibilities and this is the picture it paints: During a particularly fierce downpour at least 42,000 years ago, the bedrock failed on a northwest-aspect slope near the southern end of the lake causing a landslide to move down into the valley and dam Lake Creek, a major tributary of the Siuslaw River. The lake that formed would have filled in an area much greater than today, but lakes are temporary on geologic timescales and the majority of the basin has been filled in with sediment. This sediment deposition also raised the water level of Triangle Lake above the elevation of Little Lake, causing a small stream to burst through the southwest bank and form Little Lake PAGE 1 The Geomorphology of the Siuslaw River Channel The Siuslaw River is a 110-mile-long river that morphs from a narrow bedrock and alluvial channel in the mountains southwest of Eugene, to a wide, alluvial floodplain before emptying into the Pacific Ocean near Florence.6 In this study, we ventured to investigate and explain what could have caused this, with a running hypothesis of it being a combination of discharge and sediment transport. To understand why this evolution occurs, though, we must first discuss discharge and the mechanics of erosion. Water can weather and erode a rock both mechanically and chemically. One of the many ways in which water can mechanically erode bedrock is through sediment transport.7 The kinetic energy of the water combined with the abrasive qualities of the rocks can devastate unsuspecting bedrock. Sediment can be transported by being suspended in solution as the suspended load, ‘bouncing, sliding, or rolling’ along the channel bed as bed load, or dissolved in solution.8 The sediment can be thought of as an exfoliant, if you will. A stream’s ability to move a certain amount of sediment (capacity) and its ability to move heavier sediment (competency) are directly related to its velocity and discharge. Though only velocity is pictured (fig. 1)9, a graph of Figure 1 Stream Velocity vs. Sediment Diameter discharge vs. sediment diameter would look similar. A stream’s discharge is the volume of water that passes through a given crosssectional area. In other words, discharge is how much water is flowing downstream at any given point. This, along with many other properties, change over the course of a stream. For example, discharge increases the further downstream you go due to an increase in volume from tributaries. The Bradshaw Model10 illustrates how these different properties increase or decrease as the water continues its flow from upstream to midstream. Now, back to the question at hand: why does the Siuslaw River transition from a narrow bedrock and alluvial channel near its headwaters to a wide, alluvial floodplain near its mouth? The volume of water flowing through a stream is at its lowest near the headwaters as no tributaries have added to it yet. Since the volume of water is low, we can deduce that both discharge and velocity are lower as well. In practical terms, this translates to a stream that is not yet flowing strongly enough to remove much material and gouge out a wide channel, instead carving a narrow channel to fit the needs of the discharge level. As we continue down the river, the gradient, or slope, begins to decrease all the way down to nearly-flat at the ultimate base level. At this point, the water has gained in both velocity and volume. With a higher capacity and competency, the stream is now flowing with enough energy to erode the channel bed and walls, deepening and/or widening the stream until a dynamic equilibrium is achieved between discharge and channel shape. When the stream is wider, a smaller proportion of the river is experiencing friction with the channel bed and walls resulting in a net positive velocity. Eventually the gradient will decrease to such an extent that the river is forced to slow down.11 It’s important to note here that the shape of a river is defined during ‘Extreme High Water’ events when kinetic energy is at its maximum and that mass simply must be preserved. The discharge is still at its highest, or nearly highest point, and that water must go somewhere. If the discharge is high enough, the river will overflow its banks and flood the surrounding flatlands. Since the discharge is so high at this point, massive amount of sediment is eroded and transported downstream or out into the floodplains.12 As the sediment-laden water spreads out across the flatlands, it slows down, decreasing its capacity and competency forcing its suspended load and bed load to be deposited. This process eventually results in a wide, fanlike alluvial floodplain as the discharge shapes the river to fit its needs. PAGE 1 Building a Beach: Surface Process Survey at Heceta Head Aerial Photograph of Heceta Bay and lighthouse Standing on the extreme precipice of the Oregon Coast overlooking a scene of chaos: white, frothing waves come barreling towards the coast, breaking themselves with terrible vengeance upon the sea stacks. This is a situation one can encounter at numerous locations along the Oregon Coast, but it raises a troublesome question: how can the headland, sea stacks, and beach holdfast under such conditions? Shouldn’t they be disappearing? Well, the answer is a simple one: They are disappearing, quite violently in fact. In the picture above, you can see that the waves approach the shore in a straight line, yet perfectly conforms to the shape of the land as they collide with the land. This is achieved through a process known as wave refraction, and it either disperses the wave’s energy (the beach) or concentrates it (the cliffs).13 The wave energy is incredibly destructive to the cliff and creates numerous erosional features such as sea caves, sea stacks, and sea arches. The sea stacks shown here are remnants of a headland that is, well, no longer with us. The mere fact that these headlands have formed tells us a lot about the local geology and surface processes. A headland is “an elevated area of hard rock that projects out into an ocean or other large body of water.”14 These are formed in strata that are alternatively soft and hard so as to cause a differential erosion pattern.15 As the soft stone is eroded out from underneath a harder layer, they eventually form sea arches which erode and collapse leaving isolated sea stacks not unlike the ones pictured above. My observations on the beach confirm this (see pictures below). PAGE 2 it is estimated that streams and rivers move about 1.65 billion tons of sediment from land to the oceans each year.17 In conclusion, the answer is yes, many of the features along the coast including at Heceta Head are disappearing. There is no reason to fear, though! Due to the continuous uplift this region experiences, more cliffs and strata are being exposed to replace that which was lost!18 The figure above shows a large layer of soft sedimentary stone overlying the much harder layers of basalt. Here, it is easy to see the differential weathering. Another massively important factor that goes into shaping a beach: the sand! More specifically, the input and output of it. As waves wash up on the beach, they deposit their suspended load, however the backwash created as the wave retreats removes sediment. This effect is amplified during stormy conditions when the backwash is of much greater magnitude than the swash.16 There is also the longshore current which moves sand along our coast from north to south due to the Coriolis effect. However, like the waves, the input of the longshore current is lessened because it removes sand from offshore as well. The largest input of sediment onto the beach would have to be the Siuslaw dumping the rest of its suspended load along its banks and in the estuary. In fact, PAGE 3 Hale, Jamie, and Jamie Hale. “25 Beautiful 'Real' Lakes in Oregon.” OregonLive.com, OregonLive.com, 16 Aug. 2018, expo.oregonlive.com/life-and-culture/erry2018/08/b663d4d3391150/25-beautiful-real-lakes-inore.html. 2 Johnson, W. Hilton. “Pleistocene Epoch.” Encyclopædia Britannica, Encyclopædia Britannica, Inc., 30 July 2018, www.britannica.com/science/Pleistocene-Epoch. 3 Worona, Marc A., and Cathy Whitlock. “Late Quaternary Vegetation and Climate History near Little Lake, Central Coast Range, Oregon.” Geology, GeoScienceWorld, 1 July 1995, pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/gsabulletin/articleabstract/107/7/867/183066/late-quaternaryvegetation-and-climatehistory?redirectedFrom=fulltext. 4 “Siuslaw Watershed.” Oregon Explorer, oregonexplorer.info/content/siuslaw-watershed. 5 Armantrout, N.B. “Watershed Analysis and Restoration in the Siuslaw River, Oregon, USA.” The Canadian Journal of Chemical Engineering, Wiley-Blackwell, 16 Apr. 2008, onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1002/9780470696 026.ch20. 6 Sullivan, William L. Atlas of Oregon Wilderness. Navillus Press, 2014. 7 “Rivers and Streams - Water and Sediment in Motion.” Nature News, Nature Publishing Group, www.nature.com/scitable/knowledge/library/riversand-streams-water-and-26405398. 8 “Stream and River.” Science Clarified, www.scienceclarified.com/landforms/Ocean-Basinsto-Volcanoes/Stream-and-River.html. 1 Data, US Climate. “Temperature - Precipitation Sunshine - Snowfall.” Map of Eugene - Oregon - Longitude, Altitude - Sunset, www.usclimatedata.com/climate/oregon/unitedstates/3207. 10 Borneman, Elizabeth. “How Rivers Change the Landscape.” GeoLounge: All Things Geography, GeoLounge: All Things Geography, 24 Apr. 2014, www.geolounge.com/rivers-change-landscape/. 11 Board of County Commissioners - Lane County, www.lanecounty.org/government/county_departments /public_works/land_management_division/land_use_ planning_zoning/floodplain_information. 9 Britannica, The Editors of Encyclopaedia. “Diffraction.” Encyclopædia Britannica, Encyclopædia Britannica, Inc., 14 Apr. 2014, www.britannica.com/science/diffraction. 14.“Landforms of Erosion.” A Level Geography, www.alevelgeography.com/landforms-of-erosion/. 15 “Headland Landforms.” World Landforms, worldlandforms.com/landforms/headland/. 16 “Coast and Shore.” Science Clarified, www.scienceclarified.com/landforms/Basins-toDunes/Coast-and-Shore.html. 17 “Stream and River.” Science Clarified, www.scienceclarified.com/landforms/Ocean-Basinsto-Volcanoes/Stream-and-River.html. 13 18http://geog.uoregon.edu/amarcus/geog607w09/Rea dings/Roering,2008,OCRbackground2008.pdf PAGE 4