CITY UTILITIES DESIGN STANDARDS MANUAL STORM WATER (SW) CHAPTER 8 CULVERTS October 2013 City Utilities Design Standards Manual Stormwater Design Chapter 8 Culverts SW8.01 – Introduction A culvert is defined as a conduit for the conveyance of water under a roadway, railroad or other embankment. In addition to serving hydraulic functions, culverts must also carry overhead loads from traffic and other activities, thereby serving a structural function. Proper culvert design is essential because culverts often significantly influence upstream and downstream flood risks, floodplain management and public safety. The criteria presented in this chapter shall be used in the design of culverts. A culvert as distinguished from a bridge is usually covered with embankment and is composed of structural material around the entire perimeter although it can be supported on spread footings with the streambed serving as the bottom. A bridge is a structure having an opening measured along the centerline of a roadway of more than 20 feet between faces of abutments or spring lines of arches. Multiple barrel box culverts or multiple pipe culverts having an opening of more than 20 feet between the limits of the extreme openings are sometimes classed as bridges. (Bridge Inspection Manual Definitions) SW8.02 – General Design 1. Federal Highway Administration The design of culverts shall conform to the methodology described in the Hydraulic Design of Highway Culverts published by the U.S. Department of Transportation’s Federal Highway Administration Publication No. FHWA-NHI-01-020, September 2001 (Revised May 2005 or current edition) Available online at http://isddc.dot.gov/OLPFILES/FHWA/012545.pdf 2. Indiana Department of Transportation The Indiana Department of Transportation Design Manual 2011 or current edition provides valuable culvert design information. The Design Manual is available online at http://www.in.gov/dot/div/contracts/standards/dm SW8.03 – Hydraulic Design 1. Design Program The HY-8 program is the computerized implementation of FHWA culvert hydraulic approaches and protocols and shall be used for culvert design. Available online at http://www.fhwa.dot.gov/engineering/hydraulics/software/hy8/ 2. Backwater Culverts shall not increase backwater elevations on upstream properties. Backwater shall be contained within existing banks of the upstream open channel. December 16, 2013(last draft date) 2 City Utilities Design Standards Manual Stormwater Design 3. Chapter 8 Culverts Overland Flow Routes Emergency overland flow routes shall be checked to assure that backwater resulting from a potentially blocked culvert or intense storm does not flood or damage property. If an emergency overland flow route is not available, culvert flow capacity shall be increased. Sound engineering judgment shall be applied in determining the potential extent of backwater damage and the necessary increase in culvert flow capacity. 4. Minimum Diameter The minimum diameter for culverts crossing a public roadway shall be 15 inches (15”). The minimum diameter for private driveway culverts within right-of-way shall be 12 inches (12”). 5. Flow Velocity Both minimum and maximum flow velocities should be considered when designing a culvert. A minimum velocity of 3.0 feet/second when the culvert is flowing partially full is recommended to ensure a selfcleaning condition during partial depth flow. The maximum velocity should not exceed culvert manufacturer recommendations. The maximum velocity should be consistent with channel stability requirements at the culvert outlet. The maximum allowable outlet velocity of culverts, which discharge to an earthen channel, shall be 6 feet/second. As outlet velocities increase, the need for channel stabilization at the culvert outlet increases. If velocities exceed permissible velocities for the various types of nonstructural outlet lining material available, the installation of structural energy dissipators is appropriate. SW8.04 - Design Storm (see Section 2, Hydrology) 1. Public Culverts Publicly owned culverts crossing a roadway shall be designed to convey the peak flow resulting from a 100-year event. Driveway culverts within right-of-way shall convey the peak flow resulting from a 50-year event. 2. Private Culverts Privately owned culverts located outside right-of-way and serving areas which do not require detention shall be designed to convey the peak flow resulting from a 50-year event and provisions shall be made to contain the runoff from a 100-year event. Lesser capacities may be considered provided that proper accommodations are provided for onsite storage of the 100-year overflow. SW8.05 – Sumped Culverts Circular and elliptical pipes shall be installed with pipe inverts lower than adjacent channel flowline. Sound engineering judgment shall be applied to December 16, 2013(last draft date) 3 City Utilities Design Standards Manual Stormwater Design Chapter 8 Culverts determine the depth of sumping. Sumping increases the base flow capacity of circular and elliptical pipes, accommodates the future lowering of the channel, may increase the depth of pipe cover, and in environmentally sensitive areas allows for a natural stream bottom in the pipes. SW8.06 – Structural Design 1. Loading All culverts crossing a roadway shall be designed to withstand a minimum HS-20-44 loading as defined by the American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials (AASHTO). Culverts crossing a railroad shall be designed to withstand an E-80 loading. 2. Installation Depth Installation depths shall conform to Installation Depth Tables, Exhibits V-4-1 through V-4-4. Culvert types not listed in Installation Depth Tables shall conform to manufacturer specifications or recommendations. 3. Bedding and Backfill Backfill classifications, materials, and methods of compaction shall be in accordance with City Utilities standards for projects inside of the City limits and in accordance with County Highway standards outside the City limits unless special circumstances warrant otherwise. (Refer to pipe type chart. Such as concrete class for loading or cover requirements.) (Refer to bedding and backfill details) 4. Floatation and Anchoring Pipe floatation can occur when the uplift (buoyancy) forces outside the pipe are greater than the downward weight forces on the pipe. This uplift force can be great enough to cause the pipe to bend and dislodge from the embankment. Large diameter, flexible material culverts are more vulnerable to floatation. In most cases concrete headwalls and wingwalls provide enough weight to sufficiently anchor the ends of the culvert. (FHWA Culvert Manual) (concrete headwalls permitted??) MJG to rewrite! SW8.07 – Culvert Length Determination Culvert length design shall consider embankment width, installation depth and embankment slopes. Culvert length shall be designed to comply with (Section 5.7.4.3 Crossings) SW8.08 – Inlet and Outlet Configuration All Culverts, public and private, shall have end treatments such as prefabricated end sections, wingwalls and aprons, or headwalls at the inlet December 16, 2013(last draft date) 4 City Utilities Design Standards Manual Stormwater Design Chapter 8 Culverts and the outlet. The design of end treatments shall consider public safety and erosion control. 1. Roadside Safety Roadside ditch culverts for commercial and residential drives shall have sloped prefabricated end sections. Headwalls and wingwalls are not permitted. 2. Trash Racks Trash racks should be considered for inlet culvert end treatment where inlet clogging or downstream trash pollution is anticipated due to upstream land use activities. Trash racks shall not be used on culvert outlets, however trash racks may be warranted on outlets in areas where public safety is a concern. 3. Erosion Control Channel Stabilization and erosion control measures shall be utilized at the inlet and outlet of a culvert according to (Section 5.11.??) SW8.09 Environmental Considerations In channels with a base flow or normal pool, migration of aquatic species should be considered. Culverts should be sumped to maintain a base flow depth through the culvert equal to or greater than the adjacent channel base flow depth. Bottomless culverts may be considered to maintain a natural stream bottom. Where fish migration is a concern, contact the Indiana Department of Natural Resources (IDNR), Division of Fish and Wildlife for culvert design assistance. SW8. 10 Permitting Culvert installation may require approval and/or permitting from federal, state, or local agencies. Early coordination regarding permitting and approval is recommended. Each public agency may have design criteria which must be complied with for permitting. 1. Public Agencies City of Fort Wayne Street Engineering Department for work within City street or road right-of-way. Indiana Department of Transportation, Fort Wayne District for work within State, Federal, or Interstate Highway rights-of-way. Allen County Highway Department for work within County road right-ofway. Fort Wayne Parks and Recreation Department for work affecting the River Greenway or trail and bicycle system. Allen County Surveyor’s Office for work affecting Allen County regulated drains or mutual drains. December 16, 2013(last draft date) 5 City Utilities Design Standards Manual Stormwater Design Chapter 8 Culverts Allen County Department of Planning Services (DPS) for work within a flood zone. Indiana Department of Natural resources (IDNR) for: • • • • Early coordination for projects affecting stream channels or wetlands. Stream crossings. Work within a floodway or flood plain. All culverts and bridges, public or private, with a drainage area equal to or greater than 1 square mile. Indiana Department of Environmental Management (IDEM) for Early Coordination for projects affecting stream channels, including regulated drains. United States Army Corps of Engineers (USACE) for Early Coordination for projects affecting wetlands or stream channels including regulated drains. After Early Coordination is submitted to IDNR, IDEM and USACE (It is advisable to copy affected local public agencies) a field check is scheduled. On the field check IDNR, IDEM and USACE will determine which agency/agencies have jurisdiction and what permitting will be required. SW8.11 Culvert Materials The following sections define materials acceptable for open culvert drainage structures including driveway culverts within public right-of-way. 1. Ductile Iron Utility Piping This section covers ductile iron pipe for buried applications. Figure SW8.1 lists ductile iron pipe requirements. Standard ductile iron pipe is cement mortar lined with a bituminous seal-coat. Seal coat is generally intended for soft water applications that may react with the cement mortar lining. Consider alternative linings for services involving abrasives, pH levels below 4 and above 12 (6 and 12 without seal coat), acids, industrial wastes, chemicals and scum and grease lines. The exterior of ductile iron pipe is typically coated with an asphaltic coating 1 mil thick. Figure SW8.1 –Ductile Iron Utility Piping (33 05 33) Material Designation Pressure Class Class Designation Joints Gaskets Lining Coating Vulcaniz ed SBR Cement MortarAWWA C140 Asphalt icAWWA C151 350 Ductile Iron AWWA C151 250350 December 16, 2013(last draft date) AWWA C150 Pushon Sizes (in) Min Max 3 12 14 64 6 City Utilities Design Standards Manual Stormwater Design 2. Chapter 8 Culverts Concrete Non-Pressure Utility Piping This section covers reinforced concrete utility piping for use in nonpressure stormwater applications. Figure SW8.2 list various nonpressure concrete utility piping. A. Reinforced concrete pipe based on ASTM C76 is manufactured in Classes I, II, III, IV and V; based on when a D-Load produces a 0.001inch crack. Pipe class is to be selected based on the loading on the pipe and the depth of the pipe. Class I pipe is not acceptable. Reinforced concrete pipe with bell and spigot joints uses either of the following gaskets: 1. Rubber gaskets conforming to ASTM C443 intended to be watertight. 2. Flexible Joint Sealants conforming to ASTM C990 intended to prevent the flow of solids through the joint. B. Horizontal and vertical elliptical pipe manufactured based on ASTM C507, is manufactured in the following classes: 1. Horizontal elliptical pipe in five classes HE-A, HE-I, HEII, HE-III and HE-IV, for respectively, D-Loads of 600, 800, 1,00, 1,350 and 2,00 pounds. 2. Vertical elliptical pipe in five classes VE-II, VE-III, VE-IV, VE-V and VE-VI for respectively D-Loads of 1,000, 1,350, 2,000, 3,000 and 4,000. Figure SW8.2 lists the equivalent designated equivalent round size. Elliptical pipe size is specified by the rise in inches by span in inches. Elliptical pipe is typically tongue and groove joints, bell and spigot is available but from mixed manufactures and is not typical. C. Concrete Arch pipe is not typically available in the area; there are manufactures in Minnesota, Iowa and the Southern states. Arch pipe manufactured in accordance with ASTM C506 is classified in three classes; A-II, A-III and A-IV. The listed size for concrete arch pipe is its designated equivalent round size. Arch pipe size is specified by the minimum rise in inches and the minimum span in inches. D. Precast reinforced concrete box sections are manufactured according to ASTM C1577. Table 1 in ASTM C1577 list the design requirements for precast concrete box sections under earth dead and HL-93 live load conditions. Box sections are sizes are specified by (interior horizontal span in feet) by (interior vertical rise in feet) by (wall and slab thickness in inches). December 16, 2013(last draft date) 7 City Utilities Design Standards Manual Stormwater Design Material Reinforced Concrete Pipe Horizontal Elliptical Pipe Vertical Elliptical Pipe Arch Pipe Chapter 8 Culverts Figure SW8.2 –Concrete Non-Pressure Utility Piping (33 05 34.13) Sizes (in) Class Designation Joints Gaskets Min Max II III ASTM C76 Bell and Rubber 12 144 Spigot Gasket IV V HE-A HE-I HE-II HE-III HE-IV VE-II VE-III VE-IV VE-V VE-VI A-II Rubber Gasket 18 144 Flexible Sealant 36 144 ASTM C506 Rubber Gasket 15 132 ASTM C1577 Flexible sealant with External joint sealer system or membrane system 3’ W x 2’ H x 4” Wall Thickness 12’W x 12’H x 12” Wall Thickness ASTM C507 Tongue and Groove A-III A-IV Concrete Box Sections Table 1 Tongue and Groove Note- For RCP, Horizontal Elliptical pipe and Arch Pipe with diameters larger than 24”, flexible sealants may be used in lieu of rubber gaskets. 3. Non-Pressure High Density Polyethylene (HDPE) Utility Piping This section covers non-pressurized High Density Polyethylene (HDPE) pipe, Figure SW8.3 list typical HDPE pipe used for buried applications. HDPE pipe for storm drainage is available in corrugated dual walled, single walled, perforated or non-perforated and with soil or water tight joints. A. Corrugated dual walled HDPE pipe has a smooth interior liner in the waterway and includes and exterior corrugation that helps brace the pipe against deformations. There are two ASTM standards for dual walled HDPE pipe: Pipe manufactured per ASTM 2306 is made of virgin Polyethylene (PE) plastic compound and covers diameters from 12-inch to 60-inch. December 16, 2013(last draft date) 8 City Utilities Design Standards Manual Stormwater Design Chapter 8 Culverts Pipe manufactured per ASTM F2648 permits the use of recycled materials and covers diameters 2-inch to 60-inch. Corrugated dual walled pipe is also available with water tight joints; performance is based on ASTM D3212. Figure SW8.3 – Non-Pressure High Density Polyethylene (HDPE) Utility Piping (33 05 38.13) Sizes (in) Designation Joints Gaskets Fittings Material Min Max ASTM ASTM F2648 ASTM F2306 (or HDPE Dual-Walled (or ASTM ASTM F477 6 18 F2648 ASTM Pipe 2306) 2306) 4. Corrugated Metal (CMP) Utility Piping This section contains information on corrugated metal utility piping. Figure SW8.4 list typical metal pipe used for buried applications. A. Corrugated Metal Utility Piping is available in different metal thickness and corrugation patterns. The following list the Types of corrugations based on ASTM A760, ASTM A762 and ASTM B745: Type I- Round pipe with annular (circumferential) and helical corrugations. Type IA- Round pipe with outer shell of corrugated sheet and an inner liner of un-corrugated sheet, fabricated with helical corrugations and lock seams. Type IR- Round pipe with a single thickness of smooth sheet, with helical ribs projecting outwardly. Type IS- Round pipe with a single thickness of smooth sheet, with helical ribs projecting outwardly. With metallic coated steel inserts placed in the ribs creating a smooth inside surface. Type II- Type I pipe reformed into a Pipe-Arch. Type IIA- Type IA pipe reformed into a Pipe-Arch. Type IIR- Type IR pipe reformed into a Pipe-Arch. Type IIS- Type IS pipe reformed into a Pipe-Arch. Type III- Type I pipe with perforations. Type III- Type I pipe with perforations. Type IIIA- Semicircular pipe intended for underdrains having a smooth bottom and corrugated top. B. Corrugated Metal Utility Piping has various jointing systems classified as soil tight, silt tight, leak resistant or special design. Leak resistant joints are acceptable. Additional CMP joints are listed in the American Iron and Steel Institute Modern Sewer Design. C. Corrugated pipe is manufactured with various coatings, linings and metal types. They vary based on the required service life and durability. Coatings include; galvanized (zinc coated), aluminized, polymer coated, asphaltic coating and concrete coating. Metal types December 16, 2013(last draft date) 9 City Utilities Design Standards Manual Stormwater Design Chapter 8 Culverts include; aluminized steel pipe, polymer coated steel pipe and aluminum alloy pipe. D. Corrugated structural plate pipe is field jointed; bolt and nut requirements are listed within the structural plate’s respective ASTM standard. Structural Plate fittings are custom ordered. Figure SW8.4 – Corrugated Metal (CMP) Utility Piping (33 05 40) Type 14 Gauge Steel Pipe Pipe Designation Material Material Designation ASTM A760 Aluminized Steel ASTM A929 ASTM A762 PolymerCoated Steel ASTM A742 Joints External SemiCorrugated (Hugger) Coupling Band External SemiCorrugated (Hugger) Coupling Band Gaskets Fittings Rubber O-Ring Sizes (in) Min Max 4 144 4 144 4 120 Match Pipe Material 14 Gauge Aluminum Alloy Pipe ASTM B745 Aluminum Alloy ASTM B744 Corrugated Steel Structural Plate ASTM A761 Galvanized ASTM A761 Field Bolted - - - Corrugated Aluminum Alloy Structural Plate ASTM B746 Aluminum Alloy ASTM B209 Field Bolted - - - December 16, 2013(last draft date) Rubber O-Ring 10