Title Author(s) Citation Issued Date URL Rights Optimal design and implementation of a permanent magnet linear vernier machine for direct-drive wave energy extraction Li, W; Chau, KT; Lee, CHT IECON 2012 - 38th Annual Conference on IEEE Industrial Electronics Society, Montreal, QC, 25-28 October 2012, p. 6200 6205 2012 http://hdl.handle.net/10722/225405 Annual Conference on IEEE Industrial Electronics Society. Copyright © IEEE. Optimal Design and Implementation of a Permanent Magnet Linear Vernier Machine for Direct-drive Wave Energy Extraction Wenlong Li, K. T. Chau, and Christopher H.T. Lee Department of Electrical and Electronic Engineering, The University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong wlli@eee.hku.hk, ktchau@eee.hku.hk, htlee@eee.hku.hk Abstract- This paper presents a permanent magnet linear vernier (PMLV) machine which is dedicated for low-speed direct-drive applications. Firstly, the machine operation principle is discussed, and the preliminary design approach is formulated. Then, by applying the analytical calculation method for solving the magnetostatic field problem, the machine structure, especially the stator toothed-pole structure which acts on the field modulation function is optimized. Finally, a PMLV machine is prototyped and implemented for direct-drive wave power generation. Both analytical calculation and experimental interpolating each other. By integration of the magnetic gear with the conventional high-speed machine, the integrated machine can enable low-speed operation but with high power density. Thus, the magnetic-geared machine becomes a hot research topic in recent several years [20]-[21]. By extending its operation principle, the permanent magnet vernier machine is developed which uses a toothed-pole structure for magnetic field modulation and exhibits a low-speed and high-torque nature [22]-[24]. verification are given to verify its performances. 1. Air-gaps �f'r"=======:r�===i Field modulation rings INTRODUCTION Linear machines are a class of electromagnetic devices which operates at a linear oscillatory or progressive motion. As their rotational counterparts, they can also be used for mechanical energy and electrical energy inter-conversion. Tn recent years, development and application of linear machines are in an accelerated pace in various fields, such as industrial automation, robotics, power generation, and transportation [1]-[5]. Low-speed drives, such as wind power generation and electric vehicle motor drives, attract more and more attention in recent years [6]-[12]. For the conventional machine topologies, at the same power rating, low-speed direct drives usually mean a large physical volume and relatively low power density compared to the high-speed drives. Tn order to solve these problems, mechanical gearboxes for speed reduction and torque transmission are widely applied, thus the power density of the whole driving system is improved accordingly. However, the mechanical transmission units inevitably incur the system complexity, operation cost and further deteriorate its control performance and reliability. For solving the problems raised by mechanical gears but still attaining their merits, the coaxial magnetic gears were proposed and applied for direct-drive applications [13]-[18]. The coaxial magnetic gear consists of two rotors and one stationary ring. One rotor operates at a low speed and other at a high speed. Thus, the high-speed drives can be worked as the low-speed drives via the coaxial magnetic gear. Fig. 1 shows its linear tubular morphology of the coaxial magnetic gear [19]. The two movers have surface-mounted PMs, and the stationary parts consist of iron rings and airspaces 978-1-4673-2421-2/12/$31.00 ©2012 IEEE Low-speed mover -speed mover Fig. l.Linear tubular magnetic gear. Air-gap Fig. mover 2.Linear tubular vernier machine. The purpose of this paper is to present a permanent magnet linear vernier (PMLV) machine. By studying its operation principle, the design procedure will be introduced. Then, by 6200 analytically modeling the field modulation effect of the toothed-pole structure, the dimensions of the toothed-pole structure are optimized and the performance is improved accordingly. Finally, a PMLV machine will be designed and prototyped for direct-drive wave energy conversion. By using analytical and experimental evaluations, the proposed machine performances will be verified. PRELIMINARY DESIGN II. The concept of vernier machine lies in its toothed-pole stator configuration which resembles to the field modulation rings in the magnetic gear, as shown in Fig. 2. Due to the distinct difference in the permeability of ferromagnetic material and air space, the toothed-pole structure can enable different pole-pair numbers of magnetomotive forces (MMFs) of stator and mover to develop a steady force. In order to realize this function, the pole-pair numbers of MMFs of PMs and armature winding and the stator tooth number should satisfy the following relationship: (1) Z = I Z ]±p l 2 where ZI is the number of teeth of the stator, Z2 and P are the pole-pair numbers of PMs of the mover and armature winding respectively. When AC current with an angular frequency w is fed into the armature winding, the resultant magnetic field of armature excitation rotates at a speed of wlP, and the mover speed is w1Z2. By borrowing the concept of gear ratio in magnetic gears, the gear ratio of this machine is Z2IP. A. Mover Design The mover configuration with PMs can be classified into three categories depending on the location of PMs, namely surface-mounted PM (SPM), surface-inset PM (STPM), and interior PM (TPM). Tn this design, only the SPM topology is considered and mathematically modeled. Under the current frequency f in the armature winding, the mover speed v can be expressed as: Z v=v..1 =2frm _2 p (2) where VI is the synchronous speed, Tm is the pole-pitch of PMs on the mover. For a given operation speed and current frequency, the PM pole-pitch can be easily determined. By using the Ampere's circuital law and assuming that the magnetic drop occurs only in the air-gap, the fundamental component of air-gap flux density Bagl can be expressed as: Bagl = 4 lr B lh m sin(wmlr) + hm 2Tm fLlgo (3) Tt = Stator Design According to (1), the stator tooth pitch Tt can be written in terms of the PM pole-pitch: (4) The developed thrust force of the linear machine is determined by the electric loading which is limited by the cooling method. Most of the heat is caused by the copper loss expressed as: , = 2mNI2p P(u (5) l�f Ac where m is the phase number, N is the turns of coil of each phase, I is the phase current, p is the copper resistivity, lef is the conductor effective length, and Ac is the cross-sectional area of the conductor. The heat produced by armature winding dissipates to the air space via the stator yoke. The relationship of the total copper loss with the coil temperature rise T and the heat transfer coefficient h can be expressed as [25]: (6) Pc" = 2PThTl�f According to (5) and (6), the machine electric loading can be determined, depending on the cooling method and its temperature limit. C Thrust Estimation Based on the air-gap flux density and the electric loading in the windings, the pull-out thrust force can be estimated from the magnetic field interaction: . 4m 1m NI (7) BgJ hm SIll 2 (� Z )dz Fem 1 _ lr Tm 9tJ where RI is the amplitude of the fundamental component of magnetic reluctance of the toothed-pole structure. Therefore, given the basic design requirements, the initial specifications of the linear machine can be determined according to the above equations. OPTIMAL SIZING Ill. As shown in Fig. 3, the toothed-pole structure of the vernier machine takes the field modulation function which inherently governs the machine operation. Therefore, it is necessary to study the underlaid relationship between its structure dimensions and the field modulation effect. Tn order to take a physical insight of contributions of the toothed-pole structure for the field modulation, an analytical calculation is carried out. By taking the toothed-pole structure as an anisotropic material, the calculation can be easily handled. Tn the calculation, the tubular linear machine configuration is considered. The permeabilities of the toothed-pole structure along z and r direction are described as: where BI is the PM remanence, hm is the PM thickness, !-lr is the PM relative recoil permeability, go is the air-gap length, Will is the PM length, and Till is the PM pole-pitch. B. 2Z 2 Tm Z] fL,p _= = fLfeT, fL,p - I = flo + + b, (flo - fLfe ) ' bt (fLte - flo) Tt (8) (9) where !-lo is the air space permeability, !-lIe is the stator iron core permeability, Tt is the tooth pitch and bt is the tooth 6201 In the region TIT: 2 2 a rp111(r,z) fllpJ arp111(r,z) a rp111(r,z) - (14) 0 + + flip flip r 2 2 oOlr az ar r where Mr is the PM residual magnetization vector in the r direction which can be expressed as: width. ??????????? Mover , ??????????? z Air-gap _ CD pp Mr(r,z) = ( _0_1 +r) I Mn sin(mnz) r n�l (15) where 1 Po= --2ro +hm Fig. 3. Toothed-pole structure. r / hI g0 x o at e -poIe )< \, }!r;t<;,t�r; ;�g�oxnx Y' x y x h xl x Air-gap region PM Fig. X region 1 � =----,--2-­ ro +rohm (2n -1) OJn =---lr Tm 4B1 M = flolr(2n - 1) jll r3 11 r2 The unique solutions of the above partial differential equations are governed by the boundary conditions. There are four boundaries formed by three regions and its conditions are given by: (17) B/z(ro,z) = 0 rl ro z 4.Analytical model in cylindrical coordinates. By solving Maxwell's equations in each region, the magnetic field can be analytically obtained [26]-[28]. In order to ease the computation, some assumptions have been taken into consideration: the permeability of the back iron of the mover and the yoke of the stator is considered to be infinite; the relative recoil permeability of PMs is considered to be unity; the saturation effect of the ferromagnetic material is ignored. As shown in Fig. 4, the three regions are the region I (PM), region IT (air-gap) and region TIT (toothed-pole structure). The flux density B and field intensity H in the above three regions can be expressed as: In the region I: (10) BJ = flo(HJ + Mre,) In the other two regions where no PMs involved: BII ,III = flII ,III H11,111 (16) (11) where Moes is the PM residual magnetization vector. It should be noted that the permeability in region TIT is not the same in the r and z directions. For the optimization of toothed-pole structure dimensions, the magnetic field excited by PMs is evaluated. Thus, there is no current involved, and the magnetic scalar potential is applied for solving the Maxwell's equations. The governing Maxwell's equations in the aforementioned three regions are expressed as: In the region I: (12) In the region IT: (13) BIr(rpz) = BIIr(rl'z) HIz (rl'z)= HIIz(rpz) (18) HIIz(r2,z) = H111z(r2,z) BJ//z(r3,z) 0 (21) BJ/r(r2,z) = BJ//r(r2,z) = (19) (20) (22) Using separation of variables, the general solution of the Laplace's equations can be easily obtained. By ignoring the right term of (12), the Poisson's equation can be reduced to the Laplace's equation. Thus, the general solution can be simplified as: lj// (r,z) = +X· I [a�Io(kl1r) +h};Ko(knr)]x sin(kl1z) 11=1 (23) where 100 and KoO are the modified Bessel functions of the first kind and the second kind of order zero respectively. The special solution of this Poisson's equation is: � - 2POMn sm(mnz) P (24) lj/ (r,z ) = L..., 2 r 11=1 OJn • Therefore, the solution of (12) is the summation of (23) and (24). The general solution of the region IT has the same form as that of the region I: +co lj/ (r,z) = I [a:,r10 (kJ) + h:,rKo(kl1r)]x sin(knz) rr n=1 (25) By using the same approach, the general solution of region TIT is described as: +oc lj/JJJ(r, z) = I [a:,rr10 (mJ) +h:,rrKO(ml1r)]x sin(kl1z) (26) n=l where 6202 � _kn mn- � V fltp_r (27) After calculating the magnetic field in each region, the machine performance can be evaluated analytically. For assessing the field modulation of the toothed-pole structure, the Pth order harmonic component of flux density in the stator back-iron is investigated. The flux density of r and z components of region TIT can be expressed as: oqJ111(r,z) _ (28) BIIII' - flip -r u'"r oqJ111(r,z) (29) BIIIz - _flip - z '" renewable energy sources in the future. Its low-frequency and reciprocating motion nature makes it hard to harvest directly. Till now, people usually capture this kind of energy by intermediate devices or facilities and then use conventional electric generators for electricity production [29]. This approach has low conversion efficiency and high initial cost. Therefore, the direct-drive approach attracts more and more attention [30]. For direct-drive energy harvesting, a generator of high thrust density is highly expected. The PMLV machine which possesses the magnetic gear effect is a suitable candidate for this application [31]. uz The unknown coefficients can be determined from the boundary conditions (17)-(22) as given by: a111 = _Ko(mnrj) bIll (30) n n 10(mnrj) 1 b�II where = XCOI](mnr2)Ko(mnr3)-10(mnr2)Ko(mnrj) + [10 (aV2)-Xl](OJnr2)]w10(mnr3) . . . . . . . . . 0.4 0.3 �0.2 p::l (31) 0.1 XCOKj(mnr2)1 o(mnrj) + 10(mnrJ)Ko (mnr2) [10(OJnr2)-XI j(OJnr2)]WI0(mnrJ) S = T= V = . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . o _ �flIPJfllp_Z C0flo MJ2PoI](OJn'i) +OJJo(OJnro)] OJ�10(OJnro) (a) ...... hlr,=O.4 2PoM JI0(OJnrj)-OJ"Io(OJ"ro)] 0.3 OJ�lo(OJnro) _._.- h/,,=0.55 - h/"tt=O.7 /1 // . . " , " " . '. I](OJnr])Ko(OJnro) +10(OJnro)K](OJnr]) 10(OJnrj)Ko(OJnro)-10(OJnro)Ko(OJnrj) cO '0. 0.2 ill Kj(OJnrj) + VKo(OJnrj) I](OJn'i)-Ufo(OJn'i) S-TV = W Ij(OJnrj)-Vio(OJnrj) v= 0.1 ------- x= V/o(OJnr2)+Ko(OJnrJ VI](OJnrJ-K](OJnr2) 0.2 (32) where 110 and KIO are the modified Bessel functions of the first kind and the second kind of order one respectively. Fig. 5 shows the Pth harmonic component flux density versus the PM remanence according to the variation of the tooth width b, and slot depth h, over the tooth pitch i,. It can be observed that when the tooth width equals to one half of the tooth pitch and the slot depth equals about 0.55 of the tooth pitch, the field modulation efficiency of the toothed­ pole structure is optimum. TV. TMPLEMENTATlON FOR DIRECT-DRIVE WAVE POWER GENERATION Because of its clean, sustainable, and tremendous features, the oceanic wave energy is accepted as one of the promising 0.4 0.8 0.6 (b) Fig. 5. Pth harmonic component of flux density versus tooth width and slot depth. (a) 3-D view. (b) 2-D view. Based on the above design approach, a PMLV machine is dimensioned and prototyped. For easing the fabrication, the single-sided flat type is adopted. The toothed-pole structure dimensions are set, namely the tooth pitch it 12 mm, tooth width bt 6 mm, and slot depth ht 6 mm. The number of teeth of the stator ZI is 27, pole-pair number of PMs Z2 is 24 and pole-pair number of armature MMFs P is 3. Tn order to assess the performance of the proposed machine, the finite element analysis (FEA) is applied for the field computation and a set-up is built for testing the prototype machine. Fig. 6 shows the test-bed of the proposed machine which consists of a DC reducer motor, the prototype machine and some mechanical components for rotational- 6203 = = = linear motion inter-conversion. The DC reducer motor serves as the prime mover. By using the cam and connecting rod, the rotational motion can be converted into linear motion which imitates the incident wave force. When the DC reducer motor operates at a constant speed, the prototype machine operates in an oscillatory mode via the cam and the linkage. Fig. 7 shows the magnetic field distributions at no-load condition. It can be seen that there are multi-pole-pair MMFs at the mover side, but at the stator side, only several pole­ pairs are found which confirms the field modulation function of the toothed-pole structure. As indicated by the arrow in Fig. 7, even with a tiny movement of the mover, the flux linkage in the armature winding is changed dramatically which confirms the high force production. When the prototype machine operates in the oscillatory mode, the no-load induced voltage waveform is measured as shown in Fig. 8. It can be observed that the amplitude of the voltage depends on the mover instantaneous velocity. Also, the measured no-load induced voltage waveform at 0.5 mls is compared with the simulated no-load induced voltage waveform under the same mover velocity. As shown in Fig. 9, the agreement is very good. Fig. 10 depicts the static force waveforms when the 3phase winding is fed with the rated current and without current. It shows that the cogging force as a parasitic force component is low compared with the rated thrust. Fig. 11 shows the static force characteristic at different currents. 50.00rns f � J 0.00V ... . ........ .... .. ....... .. . --. ....... ... . . .. .... .............. .... .....: .... : .... .: .... : .....: .... -: .....: .....: .... .: ..5.V./ . di�..... : : : : : : : 50: ms/�iv Fig. t!Ial!!! 5.00V 8.Measured no-load induced voltage waveform. 5.eeerns r -B f � T e.eev : ---� ----:-- Simulated waveform: ... . : . . .. : . �. 'Measw-e'd wavefoI'Ili : .. . . : .... : ... . . . .. .. . .. .. .. .. .. .. . . : . . .. . . . .. . . . .... . . . .... . _ . . . .. . . . .. . . . .... . .� .Y!9!'!.. . : : .: .: .: S mslaiv .: .: .: Fig. t!Ial!!! 5.00V 9.Comparison of no-load induced voltage waveforms. 300 .-------� 200 � 100 b � o � 0 -100 -200 -300+-------,-�--_.--� 5 15 o 10 20 Position (mm) Fig. 10. Rated static force and cogging force waveforms. 300 .-------� • 250 � 200 en 150 f-; 100 ] • • 50 o Fig. 7.Magnetic field distributions. 2 4 6 Current (A) Fig. II. Static force characteristic at different currents. 6204 8 10 brushless machine," V. CONCLUSION This paper has presented the design, optimization and application of a PMLV machine. Firstly, the basic specifications of the machine are determined by the traditional design approach. Then, by using the analytical calculation method, the relationship of the machine performance and the toothed-pole structure dimension is unveiled. According to the analytical result, a PMLV machine is designed and prototyped. Finally, the prototype machine is implemented for the direct-drive wave power generation. Both the numerical analysis and experimental results have been used to verify the machine performances. ACKNOWLEDGMENT [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [15] [16] L. Lu, Z. Chen, B. Yao, and Q. Wang, "Desired compensation adaptive robust control of a Iinear-motor-driven precision industrial gantry with improved cogging force compensation," IEEEIASME Transactions on Mechatronics, vol. 13,no. 6,December 2008, pp. 617-624. Y.G. Guo, J.x. Jin, J.G. Zhu, and H.Y. Lu, "Design and analysis of a prototype linear motor driving system for HTS maglev transportation," IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity, vol. 17, no. 2, June 2007,pp. 2087-2090. H. S. Lim, R. Krishnan, and N.S. Lobo, "Design and control of a linear propulsion system for an elevator using linear switched reluctance motor drives," IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics, vol. 55, no. 2,February 2008, pp. 534-542. Z.Z. Liu, F.L. Luo, and M.A Rahman, "Robust and precision motion control system of linear-motor direct drive for high-speed X-Y table positioning mechanism," IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics, vol. 52,no. 2,October 2005,pp. 1357-1363. F. Lin, P. Huang, and W. Chou, "Recurrent-fuzzy-neural-network­ controlled linear induction motor servo drive using genetic algorithms," IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics, vol. 54, no. 3, June 2007, pp. 1449-1461. Y. Fan, K.T. Chau and M. Cheng, "A new three-phase doubly salient permanent magnet machine for wind power generation," IEEE Transactions on Industry Applications, vol. 42, no. I, January/February 2006,pp. 53-60. K.T. Chau, Y.B. Li, J.Z. Jiang and S. Niu, "Design and control of a PM brushless hybrid generator for wind power application," IEEE Transactions on Magnetics, vol. 42, no. 10, October 2006, pp. 3497- 3499. S. Niu, K.T. Chau, J.Z. Jiang and C. Liu, "Design and control of a new double-stator cup-rotor permanent-magnet machine for wind power generation," IEEE Transactions on Magnetics, vol. 43, no. 6, June 2007,pp. 2501-2503. C. Yu, K.T. Chau, X. Liu and J.Z. Jiang, "A flux-mnemonic permanent magnet brushless motor for electric vehicles," Journal of Applied Physics, vol. 103,no. 7,April 2008, paper no. 07Fl03,pp. 1-3. Y. Fan and K.T. Chau, "Design, modeling, and analysis of a brushless doubly fed doubly salient machine for electric vehicles," IEEE Transactions on Industry Applications, vol. 44, no. 3, May-June 2008, [18] [20] permanent magnet arrays," IEEE Transactions on Energy ConverSion, vol. 25,no. 2,June 2010,pp. 319-328. K.T. Chau, D. Zhang, J.Z. Jiang, C. Liu and Y.J. Zhang, "Design of a magnetic-geared outer-rotor permanent-magnet brushless motor for electric vehicles," IEEE Transactions on Magnetics, vol. 43,no. 6,June 2007,pp. 2504-2506. R.C. Holehouse, K. Atallah, and J. Wang, "Design and realization of a linear magnetic gear," IEEE Transactions on Magnetics, vol. 47, no. 10,October 201I,pp. 4171-4174. L. Jian, K.T. Chau and J.Z. Jiang, "A magnetic-geared outer-rotor permanent-magnet brushless machine for wind power generation," IEEE Transactions on Industry Applications, vol. 45, no. 3, May/June 2009,pp. 954-962. W. Li, K. T. Chau, and J. Z. Jiang, "Application of linear magnetic gears for pseudo-direct-drive oceanic wave energy harvesting," IEEE Transactions on Magnetics, vol. 47, no. 10, October 2011, pp. 2624- 2627. [22] A Toba and T. A Lipo, "Generic torque-maximizing design [23] [24] [25] methodology of surface permanent-magnet vernier machine," IEEE Transactions on Industry applications, vol. 36, no. 6, November/December 2000,pp. 1539-1546. E. Spooner and L. Haydock, "Vernier hybrid machines," lEE Proceeding of Electric Power Applications, vol. 150, no. 6, November 2003,pp. 655-662. J. Li, K.T. Chau, J.z. Jiang, C. Liu, and W. Li, "A new efficient permanent-magnet vernier machine for wind power generation," IEEE Transactions on Magnetics, vol. 45,no. 6,June 2010,pp. 1475-1478. N. Bianchi, S. Bolognani, D. D. Corte, and F. Tonel, "Tubular linear permanent magnet motors: an overall comparison," IEEE Transactions on Industry Applications, vol. 39, no. 2, March/April 2003, pp. 466- 475. [26] Gysen, B.L.1., E.A Lomonova, J.J.H. Paulides, and AJ.A Vandenput, "Analytical and numerical techniques for solving Laplace and Poisson equations in a tubular permanent-magnet actuator: Part 1. semi­ analytical framework," IEEE Transactions on Magnetics, vol. 44,no. 7, [27] [28] 1751-1760,2008. 1. ./ian and K.T. Chau, "Analytical calculation of magnetic field distribution in coaxial magnetic gears," Progress In Electromagnetics Research, vol. 92,2009,pp. 1-16. L. Jian, K.T. Chau, Y. Gong, C. Yu and W. Li, "Analytical calculation of magnetic field in surface-inset permanent magnet motors," IEEE Transactions on Magnetics, vol. 45, no. 10, October 2009, pp. 4688- 4691. [29] A Muetze and J. G. Vining, "Ocean wave energy conversion - a survey," Proceeding of IEEE Industry Applications Conference, 8-12 October, 2006,pp. 1410-1417,Tampa, FL. [30] H. Polinder, B.C. Mecrow, A.G. Jack, P. Dickinson, M.A. Mueller, [31] pp.727-734. [II] C. Yu, K.T. Chau and J. Z. Jiang, "A flux-mnemonic permanent [12] coaxial magnetic gears using finite element comodeling," Journal of vol. 103,no. 7,April 2008, paper no. 07FlOl,pp. 1-3. X. Liu, K.T. Chau, J.Z. Jiang and C. Yu, "Design and analysis of interior-magnet outer-rotor concentric magnetic gears," Journal of Applied Physics, vol. 105,no. 7,April 2009,paper no. 07FI01,pp. 1-3. L. Jian, K.T. Chau, Y. Gong, J.Z. Jiang, C. Yu and W. Li, "Comparison of coaxial magnetic gears with different topologies," IEEE Transactions on Magnetics, vol. 45, no. 10, October 2009, pp. 4526Applied Physics, 4529. [17] L. Jian and K.T. Chau, "A coaxial magnetic gear with Halbach [21] REFERENCES vol. [13] K. Atallah and D. Howe, "A novel high-performance magnetic gear," IEEE Transaction Magnetics, vol. 37,no. 4,2001,pp. 2844-2846. [14] K.T. Chau, D. Zhang, J.Z. Jiang and L. Jian, "Transient analysis of [19] This work was supported and funded by a research grant (Project No. HKU 71071 IE) of the Research Grants Council in Hong Kong Special Administrative Region, China. [1] IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics' 57,no. 3,March 2010,pp. 831-839. magnet brushless machine for wind power generation," Journal of vol. 105,no. 7,April 2009,paper no. 07FI14,pp. 1-3. C. Liu, K.T. Chau and X. Zhang, "An efficient wind-photovoltaic hybrid generation system using doubly-excited permanent-magnet Applied Physics, 6205 "Conventional and TFPM Linear generators for direct-drive wave energy conversion," IEEE Transaction Energy ConverSion, vol. 20,no. 2, 2005,pp. 260-267. K.T. Chau, W. Li, and C. H. T. Lee, "Challenges and opportunities of electric machines for renewable energy," Progress In Electromagnetics Research B, vol. 42,2012,pp. 45-74.