SHORT AND MEDIUM TRANSMISSION LINES EE 455: Power/Machines Laboratory Contributors: Dr. A.A. El-Keib Dr. Tim A. Haskew Mr. Clifton Black Mr. Johnny Carlisle Mr. Neil Hutchins Objectives To examine the characteristics of a short transmission line by looking at a simple circuit model of a short line. To examine the characteristics of a medium length transmission line by looking at a simple circuit model of a medium line. References Electromechanical Energy Devices and Power Systems, Zia A. Yamayee and Juan L. Bala, Jr., John Wiley and Sons, Inc., New York, New York, 1989. - Section 9.5 Discussion A transmission line, which delivers electric power, dissipates heat because of the resistance of the conductors. It acts, therefore, as a resistance which, in some cases, is many miles long. The transmission line also behaves like an inductance because each conductor is surrounded by a magnetic field which also stretches the full length of the line. Finally, the transmission line behaves like a capacitor with the conductors acting more or less like widely-separated plates. We can picture a transmission line as being made up of thousands of elementary resistors, inductors and capacitors as shown in Figure 1. R L C Figure 1. Distributed Equivalent Circuit. In high-frequency work, this is precisely the circuit which has to be used to explain the behavior of a transmission line. Fortunately, at low frequencies of 50 Hz or 60 Hz, we can simplify most lines by lumping the impedances together. Two commonly used transmission line models are the Pi-model and the T-model. These models are shown in Figure 2. R XL R XC XL R Xc XL Xc (b) T Model (a) PI Model Figure 2. Pi- and T-Models. In the nominal pi-model, the inductance from which the inductive reactance is calculated is equal to the sum of the inductances in the distributed equivalent circuit, and the same is true for the resistance R. The capacitance from which the capacitive reactance is calculated is equal to one half the sum of the capacitors in the distributed equivalent circuit. In the T model, L and R are equal to one half of the total inductances and resistances of Figure 1. The capacitance C is equal to the sum of the capacitors shown in Figure 1. The inductance L and capacitance C are replaced by their equivalent reactances. The relative values of R, XL and XC depend upon the transmission line length. Lines under 50 miles in length have negligible resistance and capacitance compared with inductance and are classified as short lines. This model is shown in Figure 3(a). Lines which are between 50 and 150 miles in length have negligible resistance, but the capacitive reactance is appreciable and must be included. These lines are classified as medium lines and can be modeled using the pi-model of Figure 3(b) or the T-model of Figure 3(c). A good understanding of transmission line behavior can be obtained by using these models. The model of Figure 3(a) will be used in this laboratory exercise to study short lines, while the model of Figure 3(c) will be used to study medium lines. As a matter of interest, typical 60 Hz lines have a series reactance of about 0.8 ohms per mile per phase and a shunt capacitive reactance of about 200,000 ohms per mile*. * From “Regulation and Losses of Transmission Lines” Electrical Transmission and Distribution Reference Book, pp. 279-280, Westinghouse Electric Corporation, East Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. XL XL XL XC (a) XL Xc Xc (b) (c) Figure 3. Various Length Line Models. EE 455: Power/Machines Laboratory Short and Medium Transmission Lines 2 Pre-lab Questions 1) Using Figures 4 and 5, calculate expected values for Tables 1 and 2. 2) What length transmission lines are considered short and medium lines? Explain why. 3) Compute the nominal ABDC constants for the transmission line modeled in Figure 4. 4) Compute the nominal ABCD constants for the transmission line modeled in Figure 5. Equipment List Quantity 1 1 1 2 1 1 1 1 1 Description Power Supply Module Resistance Module Inductance Module Three-Phase Transmission Line Module Capacitance Module Three-Phase Ammeter Three-Phase Voltmeter Three-Phase Watt/VAR Meter Phase Angle Meter Number EMS 8821 EMS 8311 EMS 8321 EMS 8329 EMS 8331 EMS 8425 EMS 8426 EMS 8446 EMS 8451 Procedure Caution: High voltages are present in this Laboratory Experiment! Do not make any connections with the power on! 1) Construct the circuit in Figure 4. For the load, place a 300 ohm resistor in parallel with a 300 ohm inductor for each phase (wye-connected). Set the transmission line impedance to 60 ohms, and adjust the source such that Vs = 200 volts (line-to-line). VR 5 6 200V 3-phase phase 4 1 4 IS 60 ohms 2 5 3 6 IR LOAD EMS 8329 Figure 4. EE 455: Power/Machines Laboratory Short and Medium Transmission Lines 3 2) Measure Is, IR, and VR for the circuit, and record the measurements in Table 1. VS (V) IS (A) IR (A) VR (V) With Load Without Load Table 1. 3) Remove the load from the circuit and repeat all necessary measurements to complete Table 1. Using your measurements from Table 1, compute the transmission line voltage regulation. Compare your results with a calculation of voltage regulation based on analysis of the per-phase equivalent circuit. 4) Reconnect the load and insert the phase angle meter (EMS 8451) to measure the phase angle of the sending end voltage with respect to the receiving end voltage. Use the known load impedance and load voltage phasor measurments to compute the receiving end current phasor. Use the ABDC constants computed in pre-lab question 3 to compute the sending end voltage and current phasors. Compare these results to the measurements. 5) Construct the circuit in Figure 5. For the load, place a 300 ohm resistor in parallel with a 300 ohminductor for each phase (wye-connected). Set the impedance of each EMS 8329 transmission line module to 120 ohms Note: When using the EMS 8329 transmission line model, the capacitor is not part of the model, so add a shunt capacitance of 300 ohms per phase (wye-connected). Set Vs = 200 volts. VR 4 1 4 5 IS 2 3 6 200V 3-phase 120 ohms EMS 8329 4 1 5 2 6 3 120 ohms EMS 8329 5 LOAD IR 6 EMS 8331 Figure 5. 6) Measure Is, VR, and IR, and record in Table 2. VS (V) IS (A) IR (A) VR (A) With Load Without Load Table 2. EE 455: Power/Machines Laboratory Short and Medium Transmission Lines 4 7) Remove the load and make the necessary measurement to complete Table 2. 8) Reconnect the load and insert the phase angle meter (EMS 8451) to measure the phase angle of the sending end voltage with respect to the receiving end voltage. Use the known load impedance and load voltage phasor measurments to compute the receiving end current phasor. Use the ABDC constants computed in pre-lab question 4 to compute the sending end voltage and current phasors. Compare these results to the measurements. 9) Remove the phase angle meter and insert the three-phase watt/VAR meter (EMS 8446) to measure the load complex power. Record your measurements. Relocate the meter to measure the source complex power output. Record your measurements in Table 3. Use the data in Table 2 and the equivalent circuit to account for the differences in the load and source complex powers. Also, compare computed versus measured efficiency. Measurement Location Load Source P (W) Q (VAR) Table 3. Questions 1) A 35 mile long three-phase transmission line has a total series reactive impedance of 60 ohms. It delivers 40 MW at 200 kV with a power factor at the load of 0.9 lagging. Find the sending end voltage, current, and power factor. Calculate the voltage regulation of the line. 2) A 100 mile long 3-phase transmission line transmits 80 MW at 200 kV with a 0.9 lagging power factor at the load. The line has a series impedance of 35+j140 ohms and Y = j0.000650 S. Find the voltage, current, and power factor at the sending end of this transmission line using the pi-model. Also compute the efficiency and voltage regulation of the line. Use per unit analysis. 3) Discuss the difference between Vr with and without a load for the short transmission line (circuit of Figure 4). Is there any difference? Why or why not? 4) Discuss the difference between Ir with and without a load for the medium transmission line (circuit of Figure 5). Is there any difference? Why or why not? EE 455: Power/Machines Laboratory Short and Medium Transmission Lines 5