1 Detection of generator bearing inner race creep by means of vibration and temperature analysis Georgios A. Skrimpas, Ivaylo G. Dragiev, Reynir Hilmisson, Christian W. Sweeney, Bogi B. Jensen, Nenad Mijatovic, Joachim Holbøll Abstract—Vibration and temperature analysis are the two dominating condition monitoring techniques applied to fault detection of bearing failures in wind turbine generators. Relative movement between the bearing inner ring and generator axle is one of the most severe failure modes in terms of secondary damages and development. Detection of bearing creep can be achieved reliably based on continuous trending of the amplitude of vibration running speed harmonic and temperature absolute values. In order to decrease the number of condition indicators which need to be assessed, it is proposed to exploit a weighted average descriptor calculated based on the 3rd up to 6th harmonic orders. Two cases of different bearing creep severity are presented, showing the consistency of the combined vibration and temperature data utilization. In general, vibration monitoring reveals early signs of abnormality several months prior to any permanent temperature increase, depending on the fault development. Index Terms—Condition monitoring, vibration analysis, angular resampling, rotational looseness, bearing creep I. I NTRODUCTION Wind energy has seen continuous development over the past two decades reaching 320GW of installed cumulative global capacity in 2013 [1]. The vast majority of the newly designed wind turbines operate under varying speed conditions. A typical variable speed wind turbine drive train consists of one or two main bearings, a multistage gearbox and a fast rotating generator. In order to overcome the faults related to gearboxes, the concept of direct drive turbines has been adopted by numerous manufacturers [2]. Direct drive wind turbines are usually equipped with permanent magnet (PM) or synchronous generators, whereas single or double fed induction and PM generators, are installed in geared systems. The availability and reliability of wind power systems are essential parameters for their competitiveness compared to conventional energy sources. Reports presenting reliability data from various wind turbine types provide an insight in the component failure occurrence rate and severity [3], [4]. Based on this statistical data, generator faults correspond to approximately 5% of the total number of failures. However, G. A. Skrimpas is with the Remote Monitoring Group, Brüel and Kjær Vibro A/S, 2850 Nærum, Denmark and the Centre of Electric Power and Energy, Department of Electrical Engineering, Technical University of Denmark, 2800 Lyngby, Denmark I. G. Dragiev, R. Hilmisson and C. W. Sweeney are with the Remote Monitoring Group, Brüel and Kjær Vibro A/S, 2850 Nærum, Denmark B. B. Jensen is with the Department of Science and Technology, University of the Faroe Islands, 100 Tórshavn, Faroe Islands N. Mijatovic and J. Holbøll are with the Centre of Electric Power and Energy, Department of Electrical Engineering, Technical University of Denmark, 2800 Lyngby, Denmark there is not any differentiation between bearing defects or electric failures, although it is expected that bearing related issues are more frequent especially in fast rotating machines. Bearing faults can be generally divided into two categories: a) rotor dynamic failures and b) bearing subcomponent defects. Rotational and structural looseness, tilted inner race on the shaft or outer race on the bearing housing are typical failure modes of the first category [5], whereas all bearing subcomponents, namely inner race, outer race, ball and cage are subjected to faults of varying severity [6]. Monitoring of bearing vibrations reveal additional failure mechanisms, such as misalignment between gearbox and generator, rotor imbalance and electric erosion, as well as excessive vibrations generated by electric causes, such as open rotor phases in double fed induction generators [7]. Bearing inner race creep is assessed to be one of the most severe failure modes from an escalation and consequential damages standpoint. It is defined as the relative movement of the inner race relative to the shaft provoked due to insufficient fit or deformation of bearing and shaft [8]. A characteristic secondary damage is excessive shaft wear above tolerance, resulting in generator replacement or machining of the shaft and placing a sleeve. Both solutions generate substantial downtime when a new generator is not in stock or the proper equipment and personnel are not available respectively. There is very limited literature in regards to detection of bearing creep and its severity assessment. In [9], tapered roller bearing cone creep is analysed employing temperature readings and vibration measurements. The development rate is divided into three stages based on the relative speed between the axle and inner race. The speed is less than 0.25rpm in stage I and reaches gradually 8rpm in stage II, where the axle outer diameter is decreased by approximately 0.4mm. A slight temperature increase is observed in stage II, whereas both stages show stable vibration levels. The axle wear and creep speed are 1.5mm and 23rpm at the end of stage III. Both temperature and vibration levels present erratic behaviour reaching 150◦ C above ambient and 25Gs respectively. However, the spectral bandwidth is not specified and the exact vibration pattern is not presented. The present paper deals with the detection of generator bearing inner race creep by means of vibration and temperature analysis. A condition indicator based on the weighted average of the 3rd to 6th running speed harmonics is proposed towards efficient monitoring of rotational looseness. Exponential moving average is employed for temperature level assessment. Two study cases are presented illustrating different severity 2 levels along with the corresponding frequency spectra and temperature trends. The structure of the paper is as follows. Section II introduces a general concept in condition monitoring of generator bearings. The mechanism of bearing creep and its development are described in section III. The tools utilized towards the detection of inner race bearing creep are presented in section IV. Fault detection of two different bearing creep severity cases is shown in section V. Finally, section VI presents the conclusions of this work. II. G ENERATOR B EARING C ONDITION M ONITORING Vibration analysis has been the most wide-spread condition monitoring technique applied on wind turbines generators employing accelerometers installed radially at the load zone, as shown in Fig. 1 [10]. Tracking of speed related spectral components describing the shaft dynamics, such as the first and higher orders running speeds, is usually implemented in condition monitoring systems along with broadband measurements in various frequency ranges for overall vibration evaluation and early stage bearing defects [7]. Alternatively, an envelope can be set over the considered healthy vibration signature, where an alarm is triggered when a frequency component exceeds the above mentioned predefined limit. deformation of the two components under radial load [8], [16]. Furthermore, if the bearing is manufactured with normal level of hardening, permanent growth can occur in the rings if they are subjected to high temperature levels for certain period of time. The second mechanism is encountered in cases of interference fit. Creep is generated when the shearing stress on the fitting surfaces exceeds the tangential frictional force due to contact pressure [8]. In the two above mechanisms, the inner ring lags with respect to the shaft. In [16], a third bearing creep mechanism is proposed due to travelling waves generated by the forces acting on the ring surface when rolling elements cross over it. It is noted that in this mechanism the creep direction coincides with the ring rotational direction. Fig. 2 depicts a ball bearing where c is the clearance between shaft and inner ring. In addition, the shaft, inner ring and cage speeds are denoted as nshaf t , nir and nc respectively. Fig. 2 Fig. 1: Positioning of accelerometers on generator bearings. The accelerometers are installed at the load zone for more efficient and consistent fault detection. In addition to vibration based monitoring, temperature sensors are placed on the bearings’ housings in order to assess the condition of the bearings from a thermal standpoint. Due to the location of the temperature sensors, the measured values reflect approximately the outer ring temperature, when in fact a temperature difference in the range of 10◦ C up to 40◦ C is expected between the outer and inner rings. Other techniques applicable on generator condition monitoring, such as current signature analysis [11] - [14] or utilization of thermal imaging cameras [15], have been proposed, but with limited field applications. III. B EARING C REEP A. Bearing Creep Mechanisms There are three mechanisms mentioned in literature causing bearing creep. The first mechanism is induced due to increased clearance between the axle and the inner ring as result of The theoretical calculated inner ring linear displacement per one full shaft revolution is equal to πc [16]. Assuming inner ring inner diameter equal to Di = 170mm, clearance c = 1.5mm and speed nshaf t = 1620rpm, the angle of displacement of the inner ring relative to the shaft per shaft revolution is calculated as: φ Di = πc ⇒ φ ≈ 0.055 rad 2 (1) The creep speed, which is equal to the difference between the shaft and inner ring speeds, is then computed as follows. ncreep = φ Tshaf t ≈ 14.3 rpm (2) where φ is the creep angle over one full shaft revolution and Tshaf t is the period corresponding to shaft speed equal to nshaf t = 1620rpm. The above calculated speed value is based on theoretical considerations of the creep mechanism; nonetheless it is assessed as conservative from a practical position. In [9], creep speed reached 23rpm in case of tapered roller bearing under 1.4mm clearance for a shaft spinning at 1852rpm and wheel diameter of 860mm. Although a direct comparison between ball and cylindrical bearings should be avoided, it is expected that the actual creep speed is relatively higher compared to 3 the theoretical one, at least at the stage where the shaft outer diameter wear encounters for the clearance. B. Bearing Creep Development and Fault Diagnosis Techniques Bearings in wind turbine generators are installed applying interference fit between the shaft and the inner ring, implying low clearance, whereas the fit between the outer ring and the housing is referred as loose. Furthermore, internal radial bearing clearances are also present as shown in Fig. 3. The aforementioned clearances are considered to be unequal, i.e. ai 6= bj 6= ci for i = 1, 2 and j = 1, . . . , 4. It should be emphasized that any of the depicted clearances might also vary depending on the angle of measurement. For example, clearances c1 and c2 could have different values if measured horizontally and vertically. temperature spikes. The motion is expected to be intermittent depending on the operating condition and it can last for a few weeks up to few months. The detection of this stage is of essential importance in terms of minimizing any secondary damages. If the bearing remains in operation, the condition is irreversible and both shaft and inner ring suffer from excessive wear, reaching up to few millimetres. The effects of this stage include increased heat generation, potentially extreme vibrations, lubrication deficiency, misalignment and finally generation of smoke due to rubbing surfaces. IV. A NALYSIS BASED ON AVERAGED V IBRATION AND T EMPERATURE VALUES Bearing creep is manifested in vibration spectra as increasing high order running speed harmonics [17]. Tracking these spectral components along with continuous temperature monitoring offers a sound representation of the bearing status. The presence of harmonics is unavoidable in the vast majority of applications due to inherent mass imbalance, misalignment, poor installation and hardware imperfections. Furthermore, both temperature and vibration trends may show erratic behaviour depending on the operational condition and speed fluctuations of a wind turbine. A. Averaging of Vibration Data Fig. 3: Fitting and internal bearing clearances The shaft, bearings and bearing housings are usually manufactured from different materials, such as steel and cast iron, thus their thermal expansion rates are not equal. Due to varying operational and thermal conditions, speed fluctuations, installation issues, lubrication efficiency and bearing type, the clearances between the above components vary over time. Focusing on the geometrical differences of the inner ring and shaft, it can be concluded that the inner ring expands relatively faster. If the inner ring is subjected to numerous temperature peaks and depending on the manufacturing process, the expansion can become permanent. Although the dynamics and development of bearing creep under normal operation have not been studied in depth, it has been proposed that the mechanism follows various severity stages which are detectable via vibration analysis and temperature readings [9]. During the initial stage of the phenomenon, microscopic movement of the ring relative to the shaft takes place resulting in fretting of the shaft and inner ring fitting surface. From a vibration point of view, this condition is usually characterized by slowly increasing or erratic vibration levels. On the contrary, temperature peaks may be present at this stage, however there is not any permanent rise. The degree of clearance due to shaft wear and inner ring expansion determines the stage where the relative displacement transforms form microscopic to macroscopic. At this stage the ring spins slowly on the shaft generating higher vibrations and frequent A typical vibration spectrum of a bearing subjected to rotational looseness is characterized by increased 3rd order and higher running speed harmonics. In order to minimize the number of condition indicators established towards monitoring of looseness patterns, it is proposed to compute a weighted averaged value of the 3rd up to 6th order speed harmonics. The weighted arithmetic mean of a data set D = x1 , x2 , . . . , xN with corresponding non-negative weights w1 , w2 , . . . , wN is PN x̄ = Pi=1 N w i xi i=1 By normalizing the weights so as simplified to x̄ = N X (3) wi PN i=1 wi0 xi wi0 = 1, Eq. 3 is (4) i=1 PN where wi0 = wi / i=1 wi for i = 1, . . . , n. The efficiency of the above method is highly dependant on the proper weight selection. In this work, the assignment of weights relies on the argument that high weights should be assigned to lower orders, as the harmonic order is assessed to be inversely proportional to the condition severity. Based on the above, the proposed weights for the 3rd , 4th , th 5 and 6th order speed harmonics are: wi = 1 , i = 3, . . . , 6 i (5) Therefore, the averaged condition indicator is calculated as: 4 PN CIavg = i=3 xi /i PN i=3 1/i (6) where N is equal to six and xi stands for the ith running speed harmonic. At this point, it should be noted that one of the above running speed harmonics may coincide with a spectral component of electromechanical origin. In this case, it is essential to disregard it in order to obtain consistent and reliable description of the bearing condition. B. Averaging of Temperature Data Wind turbine generator bearings’ temperatures data are employed as safety triggers and fault diagnosis tools. Due to continuously varying load and running speed conditions, temperature periodic and transient fluctuations are repeated leading in thermal stress of the bearing and its lubrication. In order to accomplish integrated temperature monitoring, it is crucial to take into account absolute values as well as averaged trends, both under various conditions. The proposed method is exponential moving average which assigns exponential weights on latest and past data, as shown in Eq. 7. The coefficient α represents the degree of weighting decrease, where high value discounts older observations faster and low α corresponds to slow decay. Si = Ei , i=1 Si = α · Ei−1 + (1 − α) · Si−1 , i = 2, ..., N progressing bearing looseness. The trends do not increase monotonically, but they rather follow an erratic pattern with numerous peaks and valleys. The latter could be due to the expected intermittent microscopic and macroscopic movement and the operation of the generator. The same behaviour is encountered in higher power production, which is not depicted here. However, the amplitude of the 6th running speed harmonic is substantially higher due to the fact that it coincides with an electromechanical component generated in this machine type. As a result, this spectral component is not taken into account into the computation of the weighted average condition indicator shown in Fig. 6. Based on evaluation of the trends shown in Fig. 4, 5 and 6, the averaged condition indicator serves as reliable representation of its subcomponents and thus the fault diagnosis can be performed relying solely on it. (7) V. C ASE S TUDIES ON D ETECTION OF B EARING I NNER R ACE C REEP As discussed in section III-B, the development of rotational looseness due to relative movement between the axle and the inner ring follows various stages which can be detected by the combined employment of vibration analysis and temperature data trending. Although the time interval between the starting point of microscopic inner ring movement and actual bearing spinning depends on numerous factors and cannot be prognosticated consistently, any changes in either vibration or temperature levels can be utilized towards early fault detection. The following subsections present two study cases of bearing inner race creep of different severity, where vibration and temperature trends are illustrated along with frequency spectra from accelerometers installed on the generator bearing houses. A. Late Stage Bearing Creep In this section, a late stage fault on one of the generator bearings is presented from a vibration and thermal monitoring point of view. The shaft was subjected to extensive wear exceeding 2.0mm leading to the replacement of the generator. Fig. 4 and 5 illustrate five months vibration trends of 3rd , th 4 , 5th and 6th order magnitudes in power bin 1, i.e. power production below 25% of nominal output. The transfer rate of these scalar values from the wind turbine to a centralized server is approximately one hour. The first three harmonics under consideration present increasing trends indicating Fig. 4: Vibration trends of 3rd and 4th running speed harmonics over five months in power bin 1. The trends present erratic behaviour with multiple peaks for approximately three months. Fig 7 shows the power spectrum of the recorded vibration signal, where the first six running speed harmonics are pointed by arrows. The 3rd order harmonic dominates the spectrum accompanied by increased 5th order in this file, suggesting severe looseness pattern. Increased temperature trends usually indicate that the bearing condition has deteriorated to late stage, where in the case of bearing creep, it corresponds to continuous macroscopic inner ring movement and shaft wear. Fig. 8 displays the raw and averaged temperature values in low power production, where both trends show a clear change of the thermal state of the bearing. Although the averaged temperature levels are lower, the overall trend is more stable and can be utilized in combination with raw values to evaluate the severity of the fault. By comparing vibration and temperature data in Fig. 6 and 8 respectively, it can be seen that the weighted averaged condition indicator shows signs of progression approximately one month earlier. The early identification of the above men- 5 Fig. 5: Vibration trends of 5th and 6th running speed harmonics over five months in power bin 1. 5th order harmonic present exponential increase followed by high decline. 6th harmonic coincides with another spectral component and thus it is substantially higher. Fig. 6: Trending behaviour of weighted average condition indicator excluding the 6th order magnitude in power bin 1. The indicator offers clear representation of the bearing condition. tioned development is assessed to be essential in regards to minimization of potential secondary damages. B. Early Stage Bearing Creep Depending on the bearing type, operating conditions, lubrication and installation, bearing creep could follow alternative motifs in regards to vibration response and development. Fig. 9 and 10 display the vibration trends of the 3rd , 4th , 5th and 6th running speed harmonics at low to medium power production over six months period. Weak signs of progression can be observed on 3rd , 4th and 6th harmonics, whereas the 5th order show a clear step change. The bearing Fig. 7: Vibration spectrum of late stage bearing inner race creep. The amplitude of higher order running speed harmonics is comparable to 1st and 2nd orders. The frequency resolution is 0.1Hz. Fig. 8: Raw (blue) and averaged (red) temperature trends in power bin 1. The y axis scales are different in order to explicitly display any changes. operated for approximately three months under early rotational looseness, which resulted in scratches and minor fretting on the generator shaft. However, due to the challenging task of predicting the remaining useful lifetime of this bearing and fault development, proactive replacement is the commonest and recommended practise. Fig 11 depicts the power spectrum of bearing vibration data after the trend increase, highlighting the higher order speed harmonics. Although this vibration pattern reveals a potential early stage fault, tracking of the speed related spectral components over time establishes a reliable fault assessment technique. The prevailing issue arising from the above trends is the confidence level based on whom a wind turbine has to be 6 Fig. 9: Vibration trends of 3rd and 4th running speed harmonics over six months in power bin 2. Fig. 11: Vibration spectrum of early stage bearing inner race creep. Only the 5th harmonic amplitude is increased. Fig. 10: Vibration trends of 5th and 6th running speed harmonics over five months in power bin 2. Fig. 12: Zoom in the trending behaviour of weighted average condition indicator in power bin 2. stopped for inspection and troubleshooting. Making use of a generic looseness indicator, as shown in Eq. 6, the fault evaluation is rendered less complicated. Fig. 12 shows the trending behaviour of the averaged weighted condition indicator, where increase due to early creeping and decrease after the bearing replacement are noticeable. On the contrary, the information deduced by both raw and averaged temperature data do not offer any useful diagnostic information. The latter is most probably due to the low severity of the fault which did not reach the state of increased heat generation. vibration measurements respond earlier compared to temperature data up to several months depending on the progression of the fault. Consecutive temperature peaks and permanent temperature increase are clear signs that the bearing has entered into late stage, resulting in the necessity of bearing or generator replacement. Due to the fact that there is not any clear pattern regarding which running speed harmonics exhibit increasing trends under rotational looseness, it has been proposed to utilize an weighted average condition indicator based on the 3rd , 4th , 5th and 6th orders. The employment of this indicator has reliable revealed the overall change of the bearing condition, decreasing the number of total descriptors and hence rendering the diagnosis procedure less complicated. VI. C ONCLUSIONS Consistent diagnosis of rotational looseness in wind turbine generator bearings is crucial in terms of downtime minimization. Two cases of bearings subjected to severe and early bearing creep respectively have been presented based on vibration and temperature data. It has been shown that R EFERENCES [1] R. L. Arántegui, 2013 JRC wind status report - Technology, market and economic aspects of wind energy in Europe. European Commission, Joint Research Centre, Institute for Energy and Transport, 2014. 7 [17] Mobius Institute, Vibration Training Course Book Category II. Mobius Institute. VII. B IOGRAPHIES Georgios Alexandros Skrimpas received the Diploma in electrical and computer engineering from the Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Greece, in 2009 and the M. Sc. in wind energy from the Technical University of Denmark (DTU) in 2012. He is currently pursuing the Industrial Ph.D. degree at the Centre of Electric Power and Energy at DTU in cooperation with Brüel and Kjær Vibro. His research interests are diagnosis and prognosis of electrical and mechanical faults in wind turbines. Fig. 13: Raw (blue) and averaged (red) temperature trends in power bin 1. The y axis scales are different in order to explicitly display any changes. [2] S. Struggl, V. Berbyuk, and H. Johansson, “Review on wind turbines with focus on drive train system dynamics,” Wind Energy, 2014. [3] J. Ribrant and L. Bertling, “Survey of failures in wind power systems with focus on swedish wind power plants during 1997-2005,” IEEE Transactions on Energy Conversion, vol. 22, pp. 167–173, 2007. [4] F. Spinato, P. Tavner, G. van Bussel, and E. Koutoulakos, “Reliability of wind turbine subassemplies,” IET Renewable Power Generation, vol. 3, pp. 387–401, 2008. [5] H. Ma, X. Zhao, Y. Teng, and B. Wen, “Analysis of dynamic characteristics for a rotor system with pedestal looseness,” Shock and vibration, vol. 18, pp. 13–27, 2011. [6] K. Marhadi and R. Hilmisson, “Simple and effective technique for early detection of rolling element bearing fault: A case study in wind turbine application,” in International Congress of Condition Monitoring and Diagnostic Engineering Management, pp. 94–97, June 2013. [7] G. A. Skrimpas, C. W. Sweeney, B. J. Bogi, N. Mijatovic, and J. Holboell, “Analysis of generator bearings vibration data for diagnosing rotor circuit malfunction in dfigs,” in International Conference on Electrical Machines, 2014. [8] J. Murata and T. Onizuka, “Generation mechanism of inner race creep,” tech. rep., Koyo, 2005. [9] T. Nagatomo and D. G. Toth, “Investigation of the bearing damage progression starting from cone creep of a railroad axle journal bearing,” Quarterly Report of RTRI, vol. 47, pp. 119–124, 2006. [10] C. Andersson, S. Gutt, and M. Hastings, “Cost–effective monitoring solution using external surveillance centre,” in The 2nd World Congress on Engineering Asset Management (EAM) and The 4th International Conference on Condition Monitoring, 2007. [11] N. M. A. Freire, J. O. Estima, and A. J. Marques Cardoso, “Opencircuit fault diagnosis in pmsg drives for wind turbine applications,” IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics, vol. 60, pp. 3957–3967, 2013. [12] B. Corne, C. Debruyne, P. De Baets, and J. Desment, “Stator current measurements as a condition monitoring technology - the state-of-theart,” in International Conference on Electrical Machines, 2014. [13] B. Ebrahimi, J. Faiz, M. Javan Roshtkhari, and S. Khatami, “Advanced eccentricity fault recognition in permanent magnet synchronous motors using stator current signature analysis,” IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics, vol. 61, pp. 2041–2052, 2014. [14] S. Djurovic, C. Crabtree, P. Tavner, and A. Smith, “Condition monitoring of wind turbine induction generators with rotor electrical asymmetry,” IET Renewable Power Generation, vol. 6, pp. 207–216, 2012. [15] M. Picazo-Rodenas, J. Antonino-Daviu, V. Climente-Alarcon, R. RoyoPastor, and A. Mota-Villar, “Combination of non-invasive approaches for general assessment of induction motors,” in International Conference on Electrical Machines, 2014. [16] T. Niwa, “A creep mechanism of rolling bearings,” tech. rep., NTN, 2013. Ivaylo Gregoriev Dragiev received Bachelor and Master degrees in Marine Engineering from the Technical University of Varna (Bulgaria) from 1997 to 2002. Since 2002 he has been working as marine engineer for various international companies before switching to the wind industry with Vestas where he worked for the service department from 2008 until 2014. Currently he works as Diagnostic Engineer for Brüel and Kjær Vibro in Nærum, Denmark. His research interests are in condition monitoring systems and machine fault diagnosis for wind turbines. Reynir Hilmisson received the B.Sc. and M.Sc. degrees in Electrical Engineering and Acoustics from the Technical University of Denmark in 2007 and 2009. Since 2009 he has been with Brüel and Kjær Vibro as Diagnostic Engineer. Prior to joining Brüel and Kjær Vibro, he was an Acoustic Engineer for Tymphany Company and Electrical Engineer Intern for APC. He holds an ISO Level 3 certification in vibration diagnostics. His research interests are in development and implementation of condition monitoring solutions specific to wind power generation. Christian Walsted Sweeney received the B.Sc. from the University of Southern Denmark in 2006 and the M.Sc from the Technical University of Denmark in 2008 both in mechanical engineering. From 2008 to 2010 he was employed as a diagnostic engineer at Brüel and Kjær Vibro and since 2010 he is the team leader of the diagnostic services group. His research focus is on the development of condition monitoring systems and handling of large data quantities. Bogi Bech Jensen received the Ph.D. degree from Newcastle University, Newcastle Upon Tyne, U.K., for his work on induction machine design. He was in various engineering and academic positions in the marine sector from 1994 to 2004. He was at Newcastle University from 2004 to 2010 first as a Postgraduate, then Research Associate and finally as a Lecturer. From 2010 to 2014 he was Associate Professor and later Head of Research Group at the Technical University of Denmark (DTU), Lyngby, Denmark. He is currently Professor of Energy Engineering at the University of the Faroe Islands (UFI), where he is responsible for education and research in energy. Nenad Mijatovic received his Ph.D. degree from the Technical University of Denmark for his work in superconducting machine. After obtaining his Dipl.Ing. education at University of Belgrade, Serbia, he enrolled as a doctoral candidate in 2012. Upon completion of the PhD, he has continued to work in the same field of machine research - superconducting machines, as an Industrial PostDoc. The 3 year industrial PostDoc grant has been provided by Hojteknologifonden and supported by Envision Energy Aps., Denmark. Dr. N. Mijatovic is a member of IEEE from 2008 and his field of interest and research includes novel electrical machine design, operations and diagnostic. Joachim Holbøll is associate professor and deputy head of center at DTU, Department of Electrical Engineering, Center for Electric Power and Energy. His main field of research is high voltage components, their properties, condition and broad band performance, including insulation systems performance under AC, DC and transients. Focus is also on wind turbine technology and future power grid applications of components. J. Holbøll is Senior Member of IEEE.