Electric and Magnetic Fields (EMF) Answers to frequently asked questions for Xcel Energy customers EMF in nature Electric and magnetic fields Long before humans figured out how to capture electricity for everyday use, electric and magnetic fields (EMF) were natural phenomena. We can see that a compass needle is affected by the earth’s natural magnetic field – and it is a stronger field than those found around most household appliances and electric power lines. Electric and magnetic fields are created by the electricity we need to run the appliances and lights in our homes. EMF is present around electric power lines as well. The difference between natural EMF and human-made EMF is natural fields are static – they don’t alternate back and forth – while the electricity we use is alternating current. It operates at a frequency of 60-Hertz, meaning electric charges move back and forth 60 times every second and therefore is referred to as alternating current. Electrical substations serve many functions in controlling and transferring power on an electrical system. Several different types of equipment might be present, depending on the functions of the particular substation. For example, transformers change the high voltages used by transmission lines to the lower voltages used by distribution lines. Circuit breakers are used to turn power lines on and off. There are two basic types of power lines: transmission lines and distribution lines. Transmission lines are high-voltage power lines. The high voltage allows electric power to be carried efficiently over long distances from electrical generation facilities to substations. In the United states, most transmission lines use alternating current (ac) and operate at voltages between 50 and 765 kV (1 kV or kilovolt = 1000 volts (V)). Utilities use lower-voltage distribution lines to bring power from substations to businesses and homes. Distribution lines operate at voltages at or below 35 kV. For residential customers, these levels are further reduced to 120/240 V once the power reaches your home. Transmission lines (50–765 kV) Transmission station Steam electric generating plant Distribution station Distribution lines (4–44 kV) EMF | Xcel Energy | 2 Wherever there’s electricity… …There are electric and magnetic fields (EMF). Electric and magnetic fields are invisible–just like radio or TV signals. They surround any wire that is conducting electricity. The distribution power line serving your neighborhood produces EMF. So do household appliances such as your toaster, hair dryer, lamps and washing machine. Business equipment, such as computers, copiers and fluorescent lights, produce EMF, too. Typical 60 Hz magnetic field levels from some common home appliances Magnetic field 6 inches from appliance (mG) Magnetic field 2 feet away (mG) Electric shaver 100 — Vacuum cleaner 300 10 Electric oven 9 — Dishwasher 20 4 Microwave oven 200 10 Hair dryer 300 — Computers 14 2 Fluorescent lights 40 2 Faxogram machines 6 — Copy machines 90 7 Garbage disposals 80 2 Source: National Institute of Environmental Health Services / National Institutes of Health: EMF Associated with the Use of Electric Power For more information, call the EMF answer-line, (612) 330-6548 or Customer Service at 1(800) 895-4999. EMF | Xcel Energy | 3 Wherever there’s elecricity… (continued) Electric fields An electric field is created by voltage. The higher the voltage, the greater the electric field. For example, a high-voltage transmission line that brings electricity to a city will create a much stronger electric field than a television set or electric range. Electric field strength is measured in volts per meter (V/m) or kilovolts per meter (kV/m). An electric field is different from a magnetic field. An electric field is created whenever an electrical appliance is plugged in–even when it’s turned off. Magnetic fields When you turn on an electric appliance, the electric current creates a magnetic field. The higher the current, the greater the magnetic field. If you use a hair dryer on the low setting, for example, the magnetic field will be less than when you use the high setting. Magnetic field measurement is expressed in units called Gauss (G) or milliGauss (mG). A milliGauss is one-thousandth of a Gauss. In a home, the background magnetic field might be 0.5 to 4.0 mG, while a measurement directly under a transmission line or near an operating appliance might be 20 to 200 mG. Turn on an electrical appliance and you make a magnetic field around the appliance. EMF | Xcel Energy | 4 Properties of electric and magnetic fields Ability to pass through objects Most objects, such as a wall or even a tree, block electric fields. Unlike electric fields, magnetic fields cannot easily be shielded, and therefore will penetrate structures. Intensity over distance Both electric and magnetic fields are strongest close to their source. For example, if you move a few feet away from an operating toaster, the magnetic field reaching your body will be substantially less. Exposure to magnetic fields decreases with distance Suppose you’re standing in your kitchen, waiting for a cup of coffee to heat in the microwave. Out of your window, you can see two Xcel Energy employees working on a large distribution power line. What’s your exposure to the magnetic field around the distribution line and to the magnetic field around your microwave? Read on. • The worker up near the line is in a magnetic field of about 50 milliGauss (mG), the worker below the line is in a magnetic field of about 4 mG; while you–80 feet away–are in a magnetic field of approximately 1 mG from the power line. • If you were standing 1 foot in front of your microwave, your exposure from your microwave alone would be about 60 mG. Move another couple feet away and the magnetic field from your microwave would be approximately 4 mG. Changes with time Since Xcel Energy carefully regulates the voltage at which we generate power, electric fields around power lines and household appliances will be quite constant throughout the day or year, whether power is being conducted or not. Unlike the constant electric fields, magnetic fields vary with the amount of current being drawn. For example, when you come home from work or school and turn on the electric range or other electrical appliances, the current flowing in your home increases, as do the magnetic fields. The strength of these fields is determined by current flow and how close you are to the source. EMF | Xcel Energy | 5 Useful terms about electricity and EMF Current: The movement or flow of electricity. Current is measured in amperes or amps. Distribution lines: Power lines carrying power to neighborhoods (primary distribution) and to one or several buildings (secondary distribution). These typically operate at 35 kV (35,000 volts) or less. Electric fields: An electric field is created by voltage. An electric field is created whenever an electrical appliance is plugged in–even when it’s turned off. The higher the voltage the greater the electric field. Epidemiology: The science of occurrence of diseases in human populations, with the purpose of identifying cause and effect. Much of EMF research is epidemiological research. Magnetic fields: When you turn on an electric appliance, the electric current creates a magnetic field. The higher the current, the greater the magnetic field. Neutrals: A grounded conductor that completes the electrical loop allowing current to flow back to the source. Because the neutral conductor is grounded, the earth will provide a parallel path for this neutral return current. Power frequency fields: These are low-frequency fields (50–60 Hz) with low energy levels, generated by power lines and wiring in buildings and appliances. Right-of-way (ROW): An area of land around a power line that a utility has acquired for the construction and operation of the line. Service: Point of connection between the electric utility and the customer’s electrical system. Service drop: The overhead or underground cable that brings power to a residence or business from the distribution line; it usually attaches to the eave of the building if overhead. Transmission line: A power line carrying high-voltage electricity between regions. Transmission lines are built on steel towers, steel poles and wood poles, and operate at voltages between 50 and 765 kilovolts. Underground (UG): Refers to electrical conductors and equipment located below ground surface. Voltage: The measurement of the electric force required to move an electric charge. Voltage is measured in volts. 1,000 volts = 1 kilovolt (kV) Volts-per-meter: Measurement for electric fields. 1,000 volts-per-meter = 1 kV/m Wire codes: Classifications of electrical wiring configurations of power lines near residences. Introduced as a surrogate measure to estimate long-term magnetic field exposure. EMF | Xcel Energy | 6 Can EMF be harmful? Past and present research Several studies and statements from expert agencies and work groups have indicated that exposure to EMF is not linked to particular health outcomes. After 30 years of research there is no conclusive evidence of harmful effects. In order to analyze the possibility that any exposure to EMF could present a health risk for humans, scientists have conducted numerous national research programs and many more are in progress. This research takes several forms. • Laboratory studies in which single cells or cell groups are exposed to EMF under a variety of controlled conditions. • Laboratory studies in which animals (such as rats and mice) are exposed to EMF in controlled conditions and any possible effects are analyzed. • Studies of human populations in various communities, attempting either to prove or disprove that EMF and various diseases have any linkage. • Studies in occupational settings, attempting to investigate workplace exposure to EMF and any effects these fields might have on the development of various diseases. When examining the issue of EMF exposure and health risks, it is necessary to consider all relevant evidence, including studies reporting no effect of the exposure, with due attention to the relevance and quality of the study. All four study types (epidemiology, animal testing, cellular, occupational) are subject to many different sources of error, and independent replication is needed in different laboratories (or human populations) before results can be considered established. Early research in the 1960s concentrated on possible health effects from electric fields. Electric fields have received less attention, partly because they are readily shielded by building materials, so that fields from overhead power lines are very much weaker inside a building than outside. By the early 1970s, most scientists had concluded electric fields do not pose a threat to human health, so study shifted away from electric fields. Since the late 1970s, the possible health effects of magnetic fields have been the subject of public interest and significant study. The most recent scientific research and comprehensive review by federal agencies and scientific organizations concluded the evidence for a risk of cancer and other human disease from exposure to magnetic fields is “weak.” EMF | Xcel Energy | 7 Research on the possible health effects of EMF continues While no one can state that exposure to any substance or agent is absolutely safe, research can establish that a substance is unsafe. The interaction of humans with EMF is complicated and continues to be an area of public concern. Research continues in areas that scientists believe warrant fundamental study, including leukemia, breast cancer, neurodegenerative and cardiovascular diseases, and methodological modeling of biophysical processes. Other research programs are investigating the implementation of new technologies that lower EMF exposure. Our commitment to you You can count on Xcel Energy to be a reliable, well-informed EMF resource. If you have questions about EMF: • Call the EMF answer-line, 612-330-6548, or customer service at 1-800-895-4999; • Or visit our website: xcelenergy.com Go to Safety & Education> At Home & Work> Electric Safety Living with EMF A few simple steps you can take to help reduce your exposure to EMF Experts are telling consumers that EMF exposure is probably not a health hazard. However, if you are interested in reducing your exposure, follow these simple tips: • Move bedside motor-driven electric clocks or other electrical devices away from your bed. • Stand away from an operating microwave oven or other appliances that use a lot of electricity. • Remind family members to sit a few feet away from the TV and at least arm’s length away from the computer screen. • Tell your children not to play around electric equipment. (This is important for safety reasons, too!) Remember: to conserve energy, turn off lights and other appliances when you’re not using them. When you turn them off, you’re lowering your family’s magnetic field exposure as well. It is also important to properly maintain your appliances. Prudent avoidance: The philosophy advocated by some until further EMF research results are known. Under this philosophy, those EMF exposures that can be avoided– without major investments–are avoided. Appliance Magnetic Fields Magnetic field measurements can vary by electrical device and the number of devices and in use. For more information, call the EMF answer-line, 612-330-6548 or customer service at 1-800-895-4999. EMF | Xcel Energy | 8 EMF vs. Stray Voltage Two different issues Stray voltage shouldn’t be confused with electric and magnetic fields (EMF). These are two different concepts. Stray voltage is low-level voltage– usually less than 5 volts–on a metal object. In a dairy barn, for example, where the metal objects are tied to the barn’s electrical grounding system. Humans generally do not notice the stray voltage, but some farm animals–especially dairy cows–are more sensitive. Stray voltage is not a mystery. It has been studied for years and much is known about this phenomenon. Research on the problem has resulted in a number of techniques to reduce stray voltage to acceptable levels. Electric and magnetic fields are a separate issue. They exist around anything that is conducting electricity, including the appliances and wiring in your home and office and the power lines that run down the street. Scientists generally agree that the electric fields we encounter daily do not cause any adverse health effects. EMF | Xcel Energy | 9 The most recent scientific research and comprehensive review by federal agencies and scientific organizations concluded that the evidence for a risk of cancer and other human disease from the magnetic fields is “weak.” Answers to some frequently-asked questions about EMF Q Why can’t someone figure out a way to get rid of EMF? Q Are there state or federal standards for EMF exposure? Q What do EMF measurements tell me? AThere is no known way to get rid of EMF. Electric and magnetic fields occur wherever there is electric power. The same electricity that powers the lights and appliances in your home, office or school creates these electric and magnetic fields. A There are no federal standards limiting residential EMF exposure from transmission lines, but there are federal occupational standards that apply in the work place. The EMF levels of appliances vary by manufacturer and model. The designs of many newer model appliances, in general, often produce lower fields than older models. There is no federal certification program on EMF levels so beware of advertisements on appliances making claims of federal government certification of low or no EMF levels. A Magnetic field measurements are directly related to the amount of current flowing through transmission or distribution lines or appliances. Current is linked to the amount of electricity you are using and the specific way your house or business is wired. The amount of current on Xcel Energy’s power lines is determined by the amount of electricity being used by our customers. It is the nature of electricity to create EMF: If we use electricity, EMF will result. Q What level of EMF exposure is safe? AThere is no number we can point to that is a safe or dangerous level of EMF exposure. We don’t know if certain levels of EMFs are safer or less safe than other exposures. We also do not know if continuous exposure to a given field intensity causes a biological effect, or if rapid changes in exposures cause effects. Xcel Energy relies on state and federal health agencies to identify hazardous substances or physical agents with adverse health effects. These experts evaluate health research to determine if exposure limits are necessary. The accumulated evidence of health research on EMF falls short of establishing whether magnetic fields cause adverse health effects. Q Will underground lines reduce EMF? A Placing power lines underground does not shield magnetic fields. Magnetic fields are difficult to block and will continue to pass through the ground. At the center of an underground transmission line, fields from a buried line can actually be higher than those from an overhead line. These EMF levels will drop off quickly as distance increases. Underground lines also present challenges during outages. Faults occurring in underground installations are typically more difficult to locate and repair. Repair difficulty and duration are significantly greater than required to repair overhead power lines. EMF | Xc el En ergy | 10 Fairly simple measurements can be taken of main sources of elevated magnetic fields inside or outside a home. The measurements taken at your home or business are a “snapshot” of what magnetic field levels are. EMF levels will vary based on the time of day, time of year, number and type of appliances or office equipment in use. Your measurements are also directly related to how close our inspectors are to the source of the field. Questions & Answers (continued) Q What is the metal electrical box on the corner of my lot? And is it a source of EMF? QShould I be concerned if I live near a power line or substation? AIf the electric distribution lines in a neighborhood are underground, the box is probably a surface (pad-mounted) transformer. Transformers are electrical devices used to increase or decrease the voltage in the electrical power system for best efficiency during transmission, distribution, and use. Each transformer provides electrical service to several different residences (typically four to eight) in a neighborhood. AAfter more than 30 years of intensive research on power lines and EMF by our country’s most prestigious government research organizations, there is no evidence of health effects from power lines or exposure to EMF – even at high levels. These fields decrease as distance from the source increases. For high voltage transmission lines, EMF fields generated by these power lines are negligible and at “background” levels at distances greater than 300 feet. Very little magnetic field comes from a transformer and its connecting lines, and it will decrease rapidly with distance. Q Does EMF come from a transformer? AThe only connection between the high voltage and low voltage side of a transformer is through a magnetic field in the iron core within the transformer. The iron is very good at confining the magnetic field, so very little magnetic field gets out of a transformer. EMF will be present near the transformer and its connecting lines. Transformer fields are localized and will decrease rapidly with distance. QHas Xcel Energy developed any recommendations regarding the distance that schools should be located from power lines? A Xcel Energy transmission lines are constructed in compliance with the National Electric Safety Code. We have no additional recommendations beyond these requirements. Q Will EMF exposure interfere with the operation of pacemakers? A Under certain circumstances, EMF can interfere with cardiac pacemakers. For this reason, the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) has issued EMF exposure guidelines for workers with pacemakers. Depending on the pacemaker manufacturer and design, the E M F | X c e l E n e r g y | 11 magnetic field threshold for interference is in the range of 2 to 12 Gauss. Check with your pacemaker manufacturer if you have a concern. QI have heard of instances where there are an unusual number of health cases around electrical facilities. Are the facilities and EMF causing these health events? A Most clusters of health events are reported to public health agencies by concerned citizens. And according to the Centers for Disease Control, most investigations of suspected clusters fail to demonstrate that an excess of disease cases actually exists. Investigations of clustered health cases like this have indicated that most disease patterns occur merely by chance. If you are concerned about an unusual aggregation of health events, contact your local health department. For more information about EMF • Call Xcel Energy’s EMF answer-line, 612-330-6548, or customer service, 1-800-895-4999: • Or visit our website: xcelenergy.com Go to Safety & Education> At Home & Work> Electric Safety xcelenergy.com | © 2012 Xcel Energy Inc. | Xcel Energy is a registered trademark of Xcel Energy Inc. | Northern States Power Company-Minnesota, Northern States Power Company-Wisconsin, Public Service Company of Colorado and Southwestern Public Service Company, Xcel Energy Companies. | 12-07-037 Xc e l e n e rg y s uppo r t s s u stain able practices. Please recycle this d o c ume n t .