Ammeters, Voltmeters etc, for Class Use R151 2 0 4 6 8 10 Ammeters, Voltmeters etc, for Class Use R151 January 2008 January 2008 CONTENTS 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. Scope of this guide Survey of schools The National Curriculum requirements Useful definitions Factors influencing choice Meters currently available Types of ammeters and voltmeters 7.1 Single function, single range, analogue meters 7.1.1 Educational OTK / TickiT 7.1.2 GLOBE 7.1.3 Harris 7.2 Dual function, multiple range, analogue meters 7.2.1 Dual scale SDAR 7.2.2 Dual scale GLOBE 7.2.3 Ravencourt 205 range 7.2.4 Dual scale Harris meter 7.2.5 Unilab Basic student meter 7.2.6 GLOBE PA221 basic meter 90 7.2.7 GLOBE triple scale meters 7.3 Single function, single range, digital meters 7.3.1 GLOBE & TickiT 7.3.2 Timstar 7.3.3 SATZ 7.3.4 IPC 7.4 Dual function, multiple range, digital meters 7.4.1 Unilab Easy Read 7.5 Multimeters, analogue 7.5.1 Draper AMM1 7.5.2 Rapid 105DMM 7.6 Multimeters, digital 7.6.1 JPR UNI-T UT20B 7.6.2 Rapid 212 pocket 7.6.4 Ravencourt SATZ UT30B 7.6.5 Economatics Skytronic 7.6.6 Rapid 318 7.6.7 CALTEK CM2400T 7.6.8 jtw DT830D+ 7.6.9 Draper DMM1A 7.6.10 UNI-T 39A 7.6.11 SATZ 51 7.6.12 CALTEK CM3900A 7.6.13 UNI-T UT60A 8. Galvanometers 9. Repairs to meters 10. Disposal of meters Appendix 1 Manufacturers' and suppliers' addresses Page 1 1 2 3 3 4 4 5 6 7 8 9 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 21 22 24 25 26 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 40 41 43 CLEAPSS would like to acknowledge the help of all the technicians and teachers who completed the questionnaire and provided further more detailed information about their use and experiences with electrical meters. We would also like to thank the staff of a wide range of suppliers for their help in providing samples of meters for laboratory testing and for the additional information they gave. This guide replaces R151 Ammeters etc 1998. Strictly confidential Circulate to members and associates only As with all CLEAPSS materials, members and associates are free to copy all or part of this guide for use in their own establishments. ® © CLEAPSS , The Gardiner Building, Brunel Science Park, Uxbridge UB8 3PQ Tel: 01895 251496; Fax: 01895 814372; E-mail: science@cleapss.org.uk; Web site: www.cleapss.org.uk R151 AMMETERS AND VOLTMETERS FOR CLASS USE 1. Scope of this guide This guide brings up-to-date information on ammeters and voltmeters suitable for secondary school pupil use, up to and including Key Stage 4. It does not attempt to address post-16 needs directly but would be useful to those considering purchasing for students studying at this level. It replaces the last edition published in 1998. Relatively few meters are made in this country now and suppliers are constantly reviewing sources in Europe, the Far East and South Africa as well as updating existing models. For a further discussion about electrical measurement see the CLEAPSS Laboratory Handbook (on the Science Publications CD-ROM), sections 10.3 and 12.3. 2. Survey of schools To help in gathering information for this guide, a small-scale survey of schools was carried out. CLEAPSS would like to thank all those who replied and helped with further discussions. Of over thirty schools which responded, eight covered the age range 11 to 16, whilst the rest covered different ranges of pupil ages up to 18, mainly 11 to 18. While the sample is small, conversations with technicians suggest that the summary results shown below are reasonably typical of many other schools. Table 1 Use of analogue and digital meters • In Key Stage 3, almost twice as many of the sample schools now use digital ammeters and voltmeters as use analogue meters. The main reason given was that pupils find it easier to read the current or voltage from digital meters which was one of the main purposes of the scientific activity involved. • In Key Stage 4, classes more schools use digital meters than analogue but the difference was not quite as marked as in Key Stage 3. In part this is because teachers believe that interpretation of analogue scales is an additional useful skill to be encouraged. • About 1/6th of the schools responding use multimeters throughout. These are also more widely used in schools with post-16 pupils. • Post-16 pupils are encouraged to make greater use of analogue meters. Table 2 Replacement of meters • A very large majority of schools in all categories replace meters less frequently than annually. • The main reason given was that they bought meters that were of better quality, as far as their limited finances permitted. This sometimes meant that they could buy fewer meters. • Another significant reason given was that it had become increasingly difficult in the schools’ experience to get manufacturers to undertake repairs or to find a small independent repair company which would do it economically. • Those schools which had opted to use multimeters throughout regarded this as a good investment since one set of meters covered use as both ammeter and voltmeter. 1 Table 3 Problems with meters • The most frequently-reported problem is with pupils overloading circuits and blowing fuses where these are used for protection. • A second problem is that younger pupils sometimes use the wrong range on multimeters. This has led a number of schools to use multimeters mainly with older pupils. • In a few instances, schools reported problems with connections for 4 mm plugs which had been insufficiently soldered. 3. The National Curriculum The National Curriculum includes teaching which requires pupils to use ammeters and voltmeters themselves (as well as sometimes having their use demonstrated). Extracts from the National Curriculum are given below in Table 4. Table 4 Electricity and magnetism requirements in the National Curriculum at key stages 3 and 4 NATIONAL CURRICULUM The relevant parts of the programme of study for science at key stages 3 and 4 states that the following should be covered: Key Stage 3 3.1 Energy, electricity and forces. 3.1a Energy can be transferred usefully, stored, or dissipated, but cannot be created or destroyed. 3.1c Electric current in circuits can produce a variety of effects. Explanatory notes Energy: This includes the properties and behaviour of light and sound, renewable energy resources and emerging technologies such as fuel cells. Circuits: This includes current and voltage in series and parallel circuits. Variety of effects: Electrical devices are designed to make use of a variety of effects caused by electric currents, including heating, chemical changes and magnetic effects. Key Stage 4 7 Energy, electricity and radiations. 7.a Energy transfers can be measured and their efficiency calculated, which is important in considering the economic costs and environmental effects of energy use. 7.b Electrical power is readily transferred and controlled, and can be used in a range of different situations. Meters which can measure current and voltage are thus required in class sets. Galvanometers are also useful for classwork or demonstrations investigating the principles of electromagnetic induction and so on but the prime concern of schools will be to maintain class sets of ammeters and voltmeters for which a considerable sum of money would be required. As such sets are expensive it is important that care is taken to ensure that meters purchased are reasonably resistant to damage. 2 4. Useful definitions Table 5 Useful definitions SOME DEFINITIONS Meter Descriptions Analogue Digital Single-function Dual-function Value shown by a pointer on a scale or a bar of variable length on a display screen. Value shown by digits on a display screen. Either an ammeter or a voltmeter, not both. Both an ammeter and a voltmeter. Single-range Dual-range For example, covers only 0 - 1 A or 0 - 10 A, not both. For example, both 0 - 1 A and 0 - 10 A. Multi-range Multi-purpose For example, 0 - 1 V, 0 - 5 V, 0 - 10 V and 0 - 50 V. Is made both dual-function and multi-range by the attachment of shunts (devices to give various current ranges) and multipliers (devices to give various voltage ranges). Digital multimeter This is made both multi-function and multi-range by the (DMM) use of a switch, usually a rotating one. Shunt A shunt is a device which can be connected to a meter to adapt it to enable it to read a specified range of current, eg, 0 to 10 mA. Multiplier A multiplier is a device which can be connected to a meter to adapt it to enable it to read a specified range of voltages, eg, 0 to 100 mV. Galvanometer Historically this was the name given to a moving-coil, electric-current detector but is now mainly used to denote a device which can measure the magnitude and direction of very small electric currents. It may be used, for example, to detect a null or unbalanced condition in a bridge or potentiometer circuit. Whilst a centre-zero meter is ideal, some of the models in the analogue meters described below would meet some of the uses to which a galvanometer may be put. 5. Arrangement of terminals and switches Varies. At least three terminals (or a slider). Two. Three terminals (or two and a switch). Three or more. Two. Two, three or occasionally four. - Factors influencing choice The major factors are as follows. Analogue or digital display - Teachers may hold different views about the relative merits of analogue and digital meters, as indicated in the survey results. Digital displays are now widespread in everyday domestic and commercial life. Digital instruments are easier to read than analogue ones and the survey showed that many teachers favour the use of digital meters with younger pupils, especially when the experiment is essentially about checking the voltage or current. However, not all digital meters indicate current direction so clearly as do most analogue meters. Robustness - On the whole, digital meters are more robust than analogue ones. However they are significantly more expensive and this is especially important when schools need class sets. Understanding what is being measured - This is likely to be improved if the meter is simple and has only one function and one range; eg, it measures only current from 0 to 1 amp. Ease of reading - Digital displays are easier to read than analogue scales. However, some analogue scales are easier to read than others; eg, if intermediate graduations are in tenths rather than fifths, quarters or thirds. 3 Control - If several functions and ranges can be obtained by choice of terminals or with an accessible switch, then a teacher cannot be sure what pupils are reading. The following list indicates possibilities in decreasing order of teacher control. Singlefunction, single-range meters; multi-purpose meters with single-range shunts and multipliers; dual/triple range, single-function meters or multi-purpose meters fitted with dual/triple range shunts and multipliers; digital multimeters. Economy - A meter which can provide several functions and/or ranges, with or without the fitment of additional shunts or multipliers, is more economical but may have some of the disadvantages noted above. Schools also need to balance the merits of cheaper meters which may not be easily repairable and should perhaps be considered disposable, against more-expensive meters which might last longer and may be repairable. Price - Digital meters are significantly more expensive than analogue meters. Dualor multi-range meters are usually more expensive than single-range meters. Limited budgets in many science departments may lead to a conflict of choice given the factors above. However, as far as is financially possible, pupils should use both digital and analogue electrical meters at some stage during key stages 3 and 4. To improve the chances of accurate reading, most pupils at Key Stage 3 should use only single function meters because multimeters are confusing for many. 6. Student meters currently available In order to help schools reach decisions about the purchase of meters, this guide has been divided into the following sections or families of meters: • single-function, single-range analogue meters; • dual-function, dual- or triple-range analogue meters with, or without, separate shunts or multiplers; • single-range digital meters; • multi-range digital meters; • multi-range analogue multimeters; • multi-range digital multimeters. Schools choosing single-function, single-range analogue meters will find that most of these are inexpensive but quite adequate for junior forms. Many of these cost around £5 - 7 and it is hardly worth paying to have them repaired once out of the warranty period, even if a repairer can be found. Choosing digital meters poses more of a problem because the available single-function meters cost between about £22 and around £40 each. One solution is to buy digital multimeters at half this price and cover their fronts so that pupils are discouraged from altering the function (see section 7.6). The meters intended for pupil use were selected for review largely on the basis of cost within a given category. A few, which might otherwise have been tested, were not available from the suppliers or manufacturers so the list is not completely comprehensive. In a few cases, models shown in the most-recent printed catalogue had been deleted. On-line catalogues are usually more up-to-date but suppliers quite often delete, add or modify models, especially multimeters. Similarly, whilst prices were correct at the time of publication, costs fluctuate and schools are advised to check firm prices before purchasing goods. 7. Types of ammeters and voltmeters examined Meters are manufactured in families, or series, as noted above. Within a family, meters will have different functions, eg, ammeter, voltmeter, and different ranges, eg, 0 - 1 A, 0 - 10 V, 0 - 10 A but often similar cases and appearance. A small number of the suppliers and manufacturers contacted were not able to provide samples of their ammeters and voltmeters for testing but the vast majority did. 4 7.1 Single-function, single-range analogue meters: features examined and reported Suspension The moving-coil suspension is either pivoted, ie, the moving coil is supported between points turning in fixed cups, or taut band, ie, it is supported between two phosphor-bronze strips. Taut-band meters should stand up better to school use but are very much harder to find. The majority of those reviewed are probably pivoted. The uncertainty is because many of the suppliers do not know which method of suspension is used in their meters. Scale divisions Size of each scale division is identified. Scale length Following the British Standard 89 recommendation, this is measured as the length of the arc passing through the midpoints of the smallest divisions of the scale (the outer scale where there are two). Dimensions Indicated in the table. They include the terminals. Zero adjustment The percentage of the scale length it covers. The greater it is, the more likely that deviations caused by abuse can be corrected. Most have a plastic screw. Comment is made on whether the adjustment screw is too prominent and easy to turn, so making it easier for pupils to tamper with the equipment. Robustness Comment is made on the material of the case and its design, eg, the presence of sharp corners etc. Comment is made on the ability of the movement to withstand mechanical shock; all analogue meters were subjected to limited height-drop tests. Mechanical stability: all were found to be stable. Terminals All are captive with 4 mm sockets and usually tightly fixed with nuts and split washers. Some have locating pins and star washers which are better. Meters with two ranges, eg, 0 - 1 A and 0 - 10 A, will have three terminals. The arrangement can be seen in the photographs. Polarity indication Almost all have red and black terminals; some have + and - signs as well. Access Comment is made on how easy it is for pupils to reach and damage components and how easy it is for a repairer to reach components. Repairability To replace damaged coils and hairsprings costs about as much as the supply of a new meter and so is not usually worth while once the meter is out of warranty. However, some manufacturers will make a moderate charge for minor repairs and adjustments, replacing covers etc. It is always worth asking for a quotation. See the Laboratory Handbook section 10.3.4 for advice on repair including d-i-y repair. Section 9 of this guide also gives some guidance on repair options. Comments Other significant features, if any, are mentioned. Ranges and prices Ranges in the families; suppliers' catalogue numbers; references to pages in this guide. Models measuring milliamps and microamps are only mentioned if they are in the same series. 5 7.1.1 Analogue meters: TickiT and 'Educational' OTK Suppliers Suspension Scale divisions Scale length Dimensions Zero adjust Robustness Terminals Polarity indication Access Repairability Comments Beecroft, Commotion, Economatics, GLS, Granet, Griffin Education 'economy', Philip Harris, Optical Vision, Scientific & Chemical, Timstar 'value', YPO. Moving coil pivoted. 0.02 A for 0 to 1 A. 0.2 V for 0 to 6 V. 68 mm. h 53 mm d 120 mm w 80 mm. 8%. Easy adjustment with a screwdriver. Clear-plastic front cover. Tough, white-plastic base. Smooth corners. Movement stands up well to mechanical shock. 4 mm or crocodile clip. Clear: red and black; + and -. Difficult for pupils. Easy for repairer with a tubular spanner or a nut driver. It would probably not be worth sending meters away for repair once out of warranty. This meter is very good value at the low prices quoted. Ranges available and prices Ammeters Voltmeters Range 1A 2A 5A 6V 15 V Beecroft WELO-3801 £5.82 27013 £5.50 RA 3250 £5.25 G257133 £5.95 L408810 £6.50 EHA-380-010L £7 B8A 74444 £5.87 0-1A £5.99 EMA 010010 £6.20 EL06820 £5.99 - WELO-3802 £6.39 27015 £5.50 RB 3250 £5.25 G405034 £5.95 - WELO-3803 £6.39 27017 £5.50 RE 3250 £5.25 G405047 £5.95 L408840 £6.50 EHA-380-030H £7 - WELO-3804 £6.39 27019 £5.50 RD 3250 £5.25 G257146 £5.95 L408930 £6.50 EHB-450-010X £7 B8A 74469 £6.79 0-6V £5.99 EMV 010010 £6.20 EL06825 £5.99 467731 £4.50 WELO-3805 £6.39 27021 £5.50 RD 3250 £5.25 405060 £5.95 L408960 £6.50 EHB-450-020L £7 B8A 74470 £6.79 0-15V £5.99 EMV 010020 £6.20 EL06826 £5.99 46774x £4.50 Commotion Economatics GLS Granet Griffin Education Philip Harris Optical Vision Scientific & Chemical Timstar YPO EHA-380-020Y £7 B8A 74457 £6.79 0-2A £5.99 EMA 010020 £6.20 EL06821 £5.99 - 6 0-5A £5.99 EMA 010030 £6.20 EL06822 £5.99 467723 £4.50 7.1.2 Analogue meters: EDM-series GLOBE meter Suppliers Suspension Scale divisions Scale length Dimensions Zero adjust Robustness Terminals Polarity indication Access Repairability Comments ASCOL, Rapid. Moving coil. 0.2 A for 0 to 10 A. 0.2 V for 0 to 10 V. 75 mm. h 95 mm d 143 mm w 97 mm. 12%. Easy adjustment with a screwdriver. Clear-plastic face cover. Lightweight black-plastic base (though for some makes the casing may be red). Smooth corners. Movement stands up well to mechanical shock. 4 mm or crocodile clip. Clear: red and black; + and -. Three Philips head screws on the base making access difficult for pupils. Easy for repairer with a long screwdriver. It would probably not be worth sending meters away for repair once out of warranty. This meter seems to be good value. Ranges available and prices Ammeters Voltmeters Range 1A 3A 5A 10 A 3V 5V 10 V 15 V ASCOL P59-1050 P59-1060 P59-1070 P59-1080 P59-1110 P59-1120 P59-1130 - £8.53 £8.53 £8.53 £8.53 £8.53 £8.53 £8.53 85-2579 85-2580 85-2581 85-2582 85-2593 85-2594 85-2595 85-2597 £4.50 £4.50 £4.50 £4.50 £4.45 £4.45 £4.45 £4.45 Rapid Rapid also produces versions of the meter for the ranges 0 - 1 mA, 0 - 10 mA, 0 - 100 mA, 0 - 200 mA, 0 - 500 mA at prices ranging between £4.45 to £5.95. There are also microammeter ranges of -20 to 100 µA and 0 to 500 µA at similar prices. Similarly ASCOL produces versions of the meter for the ranges 0 - 1 mA, 0 - 100 mA, 0 - 500 mA at prices ranging between £8.53 to £10.08. It also markets microammeter ranges of -20 to 100 µA and 0 to 500 µA at similar prices. 7 7.1.3 Analogue meters: Harris Suppliers Suspension Scale divisions Scale length Dimensions Zero adjust Robustness Terminals Polarity indication Access Repairability Comments Philip Harris. Moving coil pivoted. 0.02 A for 0 to 1 A. 0.2 V for 0 to 10 V. 60 mm. h 65 mm d 95 mm w 83 mm. 10%. Easy adjustment with a screwdriver. Solid well-built blue-plastic base. Clear-plastic face cover. Smooth corners. Movement stands up well to mechanical shock. 4 mm or crocodile clip. Clear: red and black; + and -. Two Philips head screws on the base, making access difficult for pupils. Easy for repairer with a long screwdriver. It may be worth sending meters away for repair once out of warranty. This meter is much more expensive but very solidly made. Ranges available and prices Ammeters Voltmeters Range 1A 5A 10mA 100mA 10 V Philip Harris B8A-74627 B8A-74639 B8A-74603 B8A-74615 B8A-74664 £31.84 £31.84 £26.22 £31.84 £31.84 8 7.2 Dual-function and dual- or triple-range analogue meters: features examined and reported 7.2.1 Analogue dual-scale meter: SDAR SM1104/5 (ammeter/voltmeter) & TickiT Suppliers Suspension Scale divisions Scale length Dimensions Zero adjust Robustness Terminals Polarity indication Access Repairability Comments Commotion, The Consortium, Griffin Education, Rapid, Timstar. Moving coil pivoted. 0.02 A for –0.2 to 0.6 A. 0.1 A for –1 to 3 A. 0.1 V for -1 to 3 V. 0.5 V for -5 to 15 V. 80 mm. h 97 mm d 133 mm w 95 mm. About 12%. Very positive movement. Clear-plastic front cover. Lightweight, black-plastic base. Slightly sharp basal corners. Movement stands up to mechanical shock. 4 mm or crocodile clip. Clear: red and black; + and -. One small Philips head screw on the base, making it difficult for pupils. Easy for repairer with a small screwdriver. It would probably not be worth sending meters away for repair once out of warranty. Large clear screen for readings. This meter is good value at the prices quoted. Ranges available and prices Ammeters Voltmeters Range -0.2 to 0.6 A & -1 to 3 A -1 to 3 V & -5 to 15 V Commotion 27047 27049 £6.99 £6.99 011816 011817 £7.45 £7.45 EHA 380 011J EHA 380 013F £7.80 £7.80 85-2578 85-2590 £4.50 £4.45 EL-06770 EL-06771 £7.25 £7.25 The Consortium Griffin Education Rapid Timstar Timstar also offers a 0 to 100 mA & 0 to 500 mA model, though this is much more expensive at £26.70. 9 7.2.2 Analogue dual-scale meter: GLOBE EDM-series Suppliers Suspension Scale divisions Scale length Dimensions Zero adjust Robustness Terminals Polarity indication Access Repairability Comments ASCOL. Moving coil. 0.1 V for 0 to 5 V. 0.333 V for 0 to 15 V. 0.02 A for 0 to 1 A. 0.1 A for 0 to 5 A. 71 mm. h 97 mm d 133 mm w 95 mm. 9%. Very positive movement. Clear-plastic front cover. Solid black-plastic base. Smooth basal corners. Movement stands up to mechanical shock. 4 mm or crocodile clip. Clear: red and black; - terminal marked. Single Philips head screw on the base, making it difficult for pupils. Easy for repairer with a small screwdriver. It would probably not be worth sending meters away for repair once out of warranty. The casing is identical with the models in 7.2.1 but the scale for the voltmeters are different. Scale division magnitude on 0 to 15 volt range make accurate readings more difficult to take on this model. Ranges available and prices Ammeters Voltmeters Range 0 to 1 A & 0 to 5 A 0 to 5 V & 0 to 15 V ASCOL P59-1090 P59-1150 £8.53 £8.53 10 7.2.3 Analogue dual-scale meter: Ravencourt Premium A205 (ammeter), V205 (voltmeter) Suppliers Suspension Scale divisions Scale length Dimensions Zero adjust Robustness Terminals Polarity indication Access Repairability Comments Beecroft, Granet, Griffin Education, Ravencourt, Scientific & Chemical, Timstar. Moving coil pivoted. 0.01 A for -0.2 to 1 A. 0.1 A for -1 to 5 A. 0.1 V for -1.7 to 5 V. -0.5 V for -5 to 15 V. 90 mm. h 105 mm d 100 mm w 90 mm. 9%. Positive movement using a screwdriver. Clear-plastic front cover. Opaque black-plastic base with substantial rubber feet screwed in. Smooth basal corners. Movement stands up to mechanical shock. 4 mm or crocodile clip. Clear: red and black; - terminal marked. Two Philips head screws below the front face, making it difficult for pupils. Easy for repairer with a small screwdriver. It may be worth checking on repair options once out of warranty. Anti-parallax mirror improves chances of accurate readings. Ranges available and prices Ammeters Voltmeters Range -0.2 to 1 A & -1 to 5 A -1.7 to 5 V & -5 to 15 V Beecroft WELO-3904 WELO-4404 £26.50 £26.50 L409190 L409310 £20.50 £20.50 EHA 550 010Q EHA 560 010J £23.55 £23.55 A205 V205 £17.80 £17.80 EMA 050 010 - Granet Griffin Education Ravencourt Scientific & Chemical £19.07 Timstar ELO 6775 ELO 6815 £19.00 £19.00 11 7.2.4 Analogue dual-scale meter: Harris (separate ammeters & voltmeters) Suppliers Suspension Scale divisions Scale length Dimensions Zero adjust Robustness Terminals Polarity indication Access Repairability Comments Philip Harris. Moving coil pivoted. 0.02 A for 0 to 1 A. 0.1 A for 0 to 5 A. 60 mm. h 65 mm d 95 mm w 85 mm. About 12%. Needs a screwdriver to turn, has positive movement. Clear-plastic front cover. Very solid blue-plastic base. Smooth basal corners. Movement stands up to mechanical shock. 4 mm or crocodile clip at rear of meter. Clear: red and black; + and - terminal marked on meter face. Two Philips head screws below the front face making it difficult for pupils. Easy for repairer with a small screwdriver. It would be worth checking on repair options once out of warranty. More expensive but solidly made. Ranges available and prices Ammeters Voltmeters Range 0 to 1 A & 0 to 5 A 0 to 5 V & 0 to 15 V Philip Harris B8A 74597 B8A 74640 £36.92 £35.59 12 7.2.5 Analogue Unilab Basic Student meter using shunts & multipliers Suppliers Suspension Scale divisions Scale length Dimensions Zero adjust Robustness Terminals Polarity indication Access Repairability Comments Philip Harris Moving coil pivoted 0.02 A for -0.2 to 1 A. 0.1 A for -1 to 5 A. 60 mm h 80 mm d 100 mm w 150 mm. About 10%. Positive movement using a screwdriver. Clear-plastic front cover. Very solid grey base. Smooth basal corners. Movement stands up to mechanical shock. 4 mm or crocodile clip. Clear: red and black; terminal marked. Two Philips head screws below the front face making it difficult for pupils. Easy for repairer with a small screwdriver. It would be worth checking on repair options once out of warranty. This is a much more expensive meter but will serve as both an ammeter and a voltmeter over a range of current and voltage magnitudes using appropriate shunts or multipliers. Can also be used to measure ac currents. Ranges available and prices Ammeter / Voltmeter Range Meter only Shunts & multipliers Philip Harris B8H 30981 Shunts cover the ranges: 1 to 5 A, 50 mA to 100 mA, 1 mA to 10 mA. £46.35 Multipliers cover the ranges: 1 to 5 V, 5 to 10 V, 10 to 50 V. Prices vary but are in the region of about £10 to 12 each. (Ac shunts & multipliers are more expensive) 13 7.2.6 Analogue dual-purpose, multi-range GLOBE PA-221 Basic meter 90 Suppliers Suspension Scale divisions Scale length Dimensions ASCOL, Beecroft, Commotion, Griffin, Rapid, STE. Moving coil pivoted. 1 unit for -10 to 50 units. 2 units for -20 to 100 units. 84 mm. h 57 mm d 113 mm w 165 mm. Zero adjust About 8%. Positive movement using a screwdriver. Robustness Clear-plastic top cover. Solid red or blue metal base (depending on the supplier). Smooth top corners though basal corner inclines to be sharper. Four rubber feet. Movement stands up to mechanical shock. 4 mm or crocodile clip. Positive terminals are black for current ranges and red for voltage ranges; terminal marked. Four Philips head screws, slightly inset on the base, making it difficult for pupils. Easy for repairer with a small screwdriver. It may be worth checking on repair options once out of warranty. This meter is converted from ammeter to voltmeter using a sliding device. There is a choice of four ranges for each of current and voltage measurement with current maxima of 100 µA, 100 mA, 1 A and 5 A and voltage maxima of 100 mV, 1 V, 10 V and 50 V. The face indicates whether the meter is being used as an ammeter or voltmeter. For less-able pupils there is a danger of confusion about which sockets to use and which scale to read. Nevertheless, this is a very versatile meter at the price. Terminals Polarity indication Access Repairability Comments Ranges available and prices Ammeter / Voltmeter Range Various ASCOL P59-3996 £17.05 Beecroft WELO-4801 £31.36 Commotion 27051 £15.00 Griffin EHA-800-010R £21.65 Rapid 85-2576 £10.90 STE 10565 £13.91 14 7.2.7 Analogue triple-range GLOBE ammeter and voltmeter Suppliers Suspension Scale divisions Scale length Dimensions Zero adjust Robustness Terminals Polarity indication Access Repairability Comments ASCOL, Rapid. Moving coil. 0.1 A for 0 to 5 A. 1 mA for 0 to 50 mA. 10 mA for 0 to 500 mA. 0.1 V for 0 to 3 V. 0.5 V for 0 to 15 V. 10 V for 0 to 300 V. 80 mm. h 97 mm d 133 mm w 95 mm. About 10%. Positive movement using a screwdriver. Clear-plastic top cover. Solid black-plastic base. Reasonably smooth corners. Movement stands up to mechanical shock. 4 mm or crocodile clip. Black-coloured common terminal & three red ones for each different current or voltage connection; the - terminal is marked. Three Philips head screws, slightly inset on the base, making it difficult for pupils. Easy for repairer with a small screwdriver. It would probably not be worth sending meters away for repair once out of warranty. A very large screen makes reading easier. Ranges available and prices Ammeter Ranges Voltmeter 0 - 50 mA, 0 - 500 mA, 0 - 5 A 0 - 3 V, 0 - 15 V, 0 - 300 V ASCOL P59-1140 £8.53 Rapid 85-2577 85-2590 £4.50 £4.45 Rapid also sell triple scale voltmeters (0 to 3 V / 10 V / 15 V and 0 to 3 V / 15 V /30 V) both at similar prices to those above. 15 7.3 Single-function, single-range digital meters: features examined and reported Display 3 ½ digit liquid-crystal display is the most common with a nominal height of 0.5" (12 - 13 mm). 3 ½ means that the maximum reading (omitting the decimal point) is 1999, so 4 ½ means 19999 etc. Thus readings on a 20 V meter would be from 0.00 to 19.99 V. Battery & low The most common battery used is the PP3, (9 V). Most have battery indication a means of indicating when the battery strength is low, eg, by flashing ‘LOW BATT’ sign. Polarity indication A negative sign in front of the display indicates reversed connections. Overload When the load is greater than the maximum capable of being displayed, the display usually shows ‘1’. Since most ammeters are rated at 10 A, their shunts will be overloaded before this indication but will withstand minor overloads for some time. On/off switch Almost all have on/off switches. Dimensions Indicated in the table. They include the terminals. Resistance All 10 A ammeters have a resistance of 0.01 ohms. Not commented on further. Robustness Comment is made on the material of the case and its design, the presence of sharp corners etc. Terminals All are captive with 4 mm sockets and tightly fixed with nuts and split washers. Meters with two ranges, eg, 0 - 1 A and 0 - 10 A, will have three terminals. The arrangement can be seen in the photographs. Polarity indication Almost all have red and black terminals; some have + and - signs as well. Access Comment is made on how easy it is for pupils to reach and damage components and how easy it is for a repairer to reach components. Repairability As noted in Section 9 of this guide, repairs to digital meters are not usually within the scope of schools and may affect the warranty. Costs of digital meters are much higher than those for analogue so schools are advised to contact suppliers direct. Not commented on further. Uncertainty This is usually less than that for analogue bench meters and sufficient for pre-sixth form work and indeed much sixth form work as well. Not commented on further. Resolution Indicates level of accuracy. Typically this will be in steps of 0.01 A or 0.01 V. Comments Other significant features, if any, are mentioned. Ranges and prices Ranges in the families; suppliers' catalogue numbers; references to pages in this guide. 16 7.3.1 Digital single-purpose GLOBE & TickiT ammeters & voltmeters Suppliers Display Battery On/off Resolution Beecroft, Commotion, Granet, Rapid, YPO. 3 ½ digit liquid crystal. 9 V PP3 or 6F22 battery; ‘LOBAT’ sign indicates replacement need. On/off sliding switch 0.02 A for 0 to 10 A or 0.01 V for 0 to 20 V. Dimensions h 75 mm d 165 mm w 100 mm. Robustness Fawn-plastic case with four small rubber feet on base. Fairly robust. 4 mm sockets only on front of casing. Red and black; + and - terminal marked. Terminals Polarity indication Access Comments Battery reached via a sliding panel, giving easy access for all. Four Philips head screws, slightly inset on the base making it difficult for pupils to access circuits. Easy for repairer with a small screwdriver. More modestly priced than most digital meters. Good range of meters available from Rapid but both basic meters also available from Commotion. Ranges available and prices Ammeter & Voltmeter Ranges Ammeters 0 - 10 A, 0 - 2 A, 0 - 200 mA, 0 - 200 microA Voltmeters 0 - 20 V & 0 - 2 V Rapid 85-2572 to 85-2575 85-2570 to 85-2571 All priced at £19.50 Both priced at £19.50 Ammeter 0 - 10 A Voltmeter 0 - 20 V WELO-4001 WELO-4501 £22.50 £22.50 27065 27063 £22.50 £22.50 L409550 L409500 £20.00 £20.00 467553 467545 £14.75 £14.75 Beecroft Commotion Granet YPO 17 7.3.2 Digital single-purpose Timstar Premium ammeters & voltmeters Suppliers Display Battery On/off Resolution Rapid, Timstar. 3 ½ digit liquid crystal. 9 V PP3 battery; display fades for low battery. On/off sliding switch. 0.02 A for 0 to 10 A or 0.02 V for 0 to 20 V. Dimensions h 44 mm d 155 mm w 80 mm. Robustness Solid plastic case (white for ammeter, black for voltmeter). 4 mm sockets. Red and black; +/- shown on casing. Four inset screws on the base, making it difficult for pupils. Sliding cover hard to remove to replace battery. - Terminals Polarity indication Access Comments Ranges available and prices Ammeter & Voltmeter Ranges Ammeter 0 - 10 A Voltmeter 0 - 19.99 V Rapid 85-1640 85-1635 £27.50 £27.50 ELO 6829 ELO 6828 £23.00 £23.00 Timstar 18 7.3.3 Digital single-purpose SATZ ammeters & voltmeters Suppliers Display Battery On/off Resolution Beecroft, Economatics, GLS, Granet, Griffin Education, Ravencourt, Scientific & Chemical, Timstar. 3 ½ digit liquid crystal. - sign indicates reversed polarity. 9 V PP3 battery; 'BATT' signal on LHS of screen indicates need for replacement. On/off press switch. 0.01 A for 0 to 10 A or 0.01 V for 0 to 20 V. Dimensions h 70 mm d 90 mm w 95 mm. Robustness Solid grey plastic case; smooth corners. Reasonably robust. 4 mm inset Red and black; +/- shown on casing. Small, inset, Philips head screws on the base, making it fairly difficult for pupils. Sliding cover removed to replace battery. Terminals Polarity indication Access Comments Ranges available and prices Ammeters & Voltmeters Ranges Ammeter 0 - 10A Voltmeter 0 - 20V Beecroft ELO 4001 ELO 4501 £22.50 £22.50 ZA 010 ZV 020 £21.95 £21.95 G377578 G377565 £24.70 £24.70 L409470 L409450 £25.50 £25.50 EHA- 700P EHA-750 £24.00 £24.00 ZA 010 ZV 020 £23.50 £23.50 EMV-100010 EMV-100010 £23.30 £23.30 EL18560 EL18562 £23.00 £23.00 Economatics GLS Granet Griffin Educational Ravencourt Scientific & Chemical Timstar 19 7.3.4 Digital single-purpose IPC ammeters & voltmeters Suppliers Display Battery On/off Resolution Griffin Educational, Scientific & Chemical. 3 ½ digit liquid crystal. 9 V PP3 battery; ‘LOBAT’ signal indicates need for replacement. On/off sliding switch. 0.01 A for 0 to 10 A or 0.01 V for 0 to 20 V. Dimensions h 70 mm d 115 mm w 90 mm. Robustness Solid black-plastic case; smooth corners but slightly sharp edge at junction of base. 3 rubber feet on base. Reasonably robust. 4 mm inset at side of case Red and black; +/- shown on casing. Four inset Philips head screws on the base to access battery compartment, making it fairly difficult for pupils. - Terminals Polarity indication Access Comments Ranges available and prices Ammeters & Voltmeters Ranges Ammeter 0 - 10 A Voltmeter 0 - 19.99 V Griffin Educational EHA- 200-030A EHB- 250-020E £41.90 £41.90 EMA-020010 EMV-020010 £38.10 £38.10 Scientific & Chemical Ammeters also available for ranges 0 to 2 A, 0 to 200 mA, and 0 to 200 microamps; Voltmeters also available for 0 to 2 V range. 20 7.4 Dual function, multi-range digital meters: features examined and reported 7.4.1 Digital Unilab multi-purpose Easy Read meter for Harris Suppliers Display Battery On/off Resolution Philip Harris. 3 ½ digit liquid crystal. 9 V PP3 battery; ‘LOBAT’ signal indicates need for replacement. Battery only on when shunt or multiplier is in place. On/off by insertion of shunt. 0.01 A for 0 to 10 A or 0.01 V for 0 to 20 V. Dimensions h 73 mm d 65 mm w 96 mm without shunt. h 73 mm d 108 mm w 104 mm with shunt. Robustness Terminals Polarity indication Access Comments Solid orange-plastic case; sharply angled corners. Metal plate on back & base. Robust. 4 mm inset at side of case. Shown on shunt or multiplier. Two small, inset, Philips head screws on the base to access battery compartment, making it fairly difficult for pupils. Shunts and multipliers all fit snugly. Although the meter is quite expensive and there is an added cost for each shunt etc, the meter has multiple usage for a variety of situations. Ranges available and prices Ammeter / Voltmeter Ranges Easy Read meter Philip Harris B8H 79933 £46.97 Current shunts and voltage multipliers for standard dc ranges cost about £10 each. Shunts for milliamp and ac ranges are more expensive. 21 7.5 Multimeters, analogue: features examined and reported Multimeters are available for a range of purposes in the home, in industry and commerce and in schools. Analogue multimeters can normally be used to measure ranges of dc and ac currents, dc voltages, resistance and most offer other facilities as well. They typically have at least three sets of scales and are often designed as pocketsized units. Deciding which measurement setting to employ, which scale to use and to take accurate measurements proves very difficult for younger and for lower-ability pupils. If they are used as ammeters or voltmeters for Years 7 and 8, then it would be prudent to have the range switch set by a technician or teacher and probably covered, although this does not overcome the problem of which scale to read. Features reviewed are shown below. Suspension The suspension is either pivoted, ie, the moving coil is supported between points turning in fixed cups, or taut band, ie, it is supported between two phosphor-bronze strips. Taut-band meters should stand up better to school use but are lessfrequently available. Range of the meter Multimeters will usually cover a range of possible measurement options including: dc current (often including microamp ranges up to about 10 A) dc voltage (often from millivolt ranges up to 500 V or more) ac voltage (say 10 to 500 V) ac current on some models resistance (say ×1 ohm to ×1 kohm) AF output (dB) capacitance (µF) Battery & lowbattery indication Note is made of which battery is used and the means of indicating when the battery strength is low. Uncertainty Only commented on if the claimed maximum uncertainty is greater than 2%. Scale length As before, this is measured as the length of arc through the midpoints of the smallest divisions of the outer scale. Dimensions Indicated in the table. Zero adjustment The percentage of the scale length it covers. The greater it is, the more likely that deviations caused by abuse can be corrected. Most have a plastic screw. Comment is made on whether the adjustment screw is too prominent and easy to turn, so making it easier for pupils to fiddle. Robustness Comment is made on the material of the case and its design, the presence of sharp corners, etc, and on the ability of the movement to withstand mechanical shock; analogue meters were subjected to drop tests. Mechanical stability. All were found to be stable. Terminals Usually three 4 mm jack sockets including one black COM and two red (typically one for 10 A and one for V / ohm / mA) Polarity indication Almost all have red and black terminals; some have + and - signs as well. 22 Access Comment is made on how easy it is for pupils to reach and damage components, how easy it is for a repairer to reach components and to replace the battery and fuse. Repairability To replace damaged coils and hairsprings probably costs more than the price of a replacement meter and so is not usually worthwhile. However, some manufacturers will make a moderate charge for minor repairs and adjustments, replacing covers, etc. It may be worth asking for a quotation. See Section 9 of this guide and Laboratory Handbook section 10.3.4 for further advice on repair including d-i-y repair. Comments All come with a pair of leads often with retractable protective sleeves. Other significant features are mentioned including the ranges which the meter covers. Generally analogue multimeters are not recommended for lower-school use because there are multiple scales and they are often not easy to read. Prices What the supplier offers, catalogue numbers, prices. 23 7.5.1 Draper pocket multimeter AMM1 Suppliers Suspension Range of meter Battery Uncertainty Scale length Scientific & Chemical. Moving coil. See below. AA 1.5 V battery; Low battery signal indicates need for replacement. 5% for most scales. 37 mm. Dimensions h 33 mm d 100 mm w 63 mm. Zero adjustment 9 % positive movement of plastic screw. Light plastic case. Smooth corners. Sufficiently robust. Only two 4 mm jack sockets. Red & black coded and ‘+’ and ‘-‘ signs shown. Single small, inset screw rear access to battery compartment, making it fairly difficult for pupils. Parallax mirror. Fuse and diode protected. Leads have unprotected ends. Very small divisions make it difficult to read accurately. Very compact but limited current range, multiplicity of scales and difficulty in reading probably make it unsuitable for lower school use in particular. Ranges include: dc current 500 microamps, 10 mA, 250 mA, dc voltage 2.5 V, 10 V, 50 V, 250 V, 500 V, ac voltage 10 V, 50 V, 250 V, 500 V resistance ×10 ohm, ×1 kohm. Robustness Terminals Polarity indication Access Comments Prices Multimeter Ranges Draper analogue Pocket multimeter AMM1 Scientific & Chemical EMM 310010 £7.20 24 7.5.2 Rapid analogue multimeter 105 DMM Suppliers Suspension Range of meter Battery Uncertainty Scale length Granet, Rapid. Moving coil. See below. Two AA 1.5 batteries; battery check facility. 3% for most scales. 55 mm. Dimensions h 46 mm d 145 mm w 73 mm. Zero adjustment 9% positive, movement of plastic screw. Solidly built plastic case with yellow outer casing. Smooth corners. Robust. Three 4 mm jack sockets. Red & black coded but not signed. Two inset screws protect rear access to battery compartment, making it fairly difficult for pupils. Robustness Terminals Polarity indication Access Comments 500 mA / 250 V fuse and diode protected. Leads have protected ends. Well built and very cheap but multiplicity of scales and small scale divisions probably make it less suitable for lower school use in particular. Features include: audible continuity test. Ranges include: dc current 50 microamps, 5 mA, 500 mA, 10 A, dc voltage 2.5 V, 10 V, 50 V, 250 V, 500 V, ac voltage 10 V, 50 V, 250 V, 500 V, resistance ×1 ohm, ×10 ohm, ×100 ohm, ×1 kohm AF output -10 to +56 dB, capacitance 0 to 250 µF. Prices Multimeter Ranges Draper analogue Pocket multimeter AMM1 Granet L412000 £8.60 Rapid 85-0722 £4.55 25 7.6 Multimeters, digital (DMMs): features examined and reported There has been a rapid expansion in the range of digital multimeters available to school and other buyers in recent years. They cost considerably less than singlefunction digital meters. As with analogue multimeters, if they are used as ammeters or voltmeters with Years 7 and 8, then it would be helpful to have the range switch set by a technician or teacher and perhaps covered with a suitable piece of card, or even hardboard. Such a cover will not be pupil-proof but it would be time-consuming to make something more elaborate and it is necessary to be able to remove the cover easily to switch the meter on and off. If there is a choice, it may be better to use digital multimeters as voltmeters, since there is then less chance of the fuse in the meter being blown. General advice on digital multimeters is given in section 12.3 of the Laboratory Handbook. The market has become highly competitive. They often are alike but have different trade names or look alike but have slightly different features. If meters are being purchased to be used as ammeters or voltmeters for Key Stages 3 and 4, choices are not easy. However, some digital multimeters do not have the 10 A current range essential for work involving heating and magnetic effects. Apart from this, buyers should choose a low-price meter with a rotary switch. Opinions will vary on the suitability for pupils of autoranging, the facility of the meter to select the right range. CLEAPSS believes that, where pupils are sufficiently able, there is value in the pupil learning to select the correct range so that a non-autoranging model should be chosen. However, if DMMs are to be used in the sixth form, schools are advised to look closely at the ranges, particularly if electronics is taught and to look for suitable low-current ranges. The following observations may help schools to make judgements. dc volts Many digital multimeters have the following ranges: 200 mV, 2, 20, 200 and 1000 V. One or two lack the 200 mV range. The resolution on the 2 V range is 1 mV so that the omission of the 200 mV range may not matter. However, it would be difficult to measure the emf of a thermocouple without this range. dc current What is available varies much more. Several have the following ranges: 200 µA, 2, 20, 200 mA, 2, 10 A; however, some have only three or two current ranges. Both 2 mA and 10 A ranges are desirable, with at least one intermediate range. The high resolution of the multimeter enables reasonably-accurate readings to be made of quantities only a tenth of the range maximum so that many intermediate ranges may not be necessary. ac ranges Again, these vary from model to model. They often correspond to the dc ranges, with one or two omissions, but some DMMs have no ac current ranges. Some digital multimeters with several ac ranges are needed for work on transformers and it might be useful to be able to measure alternating current powering a heating coil: both 20 mA and 10 A ranges are useful. However, most school work is with dc so that limited ac ranges may not matter for most of the meters to be used by a class. Resistance The following ranges are standard: 200 Ω, 2, 20, 200 kΩ, 2 MΩ. Several have an additional 20 MΩ range, some a 20 Ω range. While the 20 MΩ range is valuable for electronics, a 20 Ω range is more useful for general work. Other facilities DMMs frequently have other facilities, for example, for testing continuity, diodes and transistors, for measuring capacitance etc. With the possible exceptions of continuity testing and ‘hold’, these facilities are an additional complication during general use and so are to be avoided if possible. They may be of use during electronics work. 26 What pupils see can be simplified if the front of the meter is covered. The cover should conceal any sockets which should not be used as well as the switch and associated information. If necessary, holes could be drilled over the sockets to be used. A selection of lower-priced digital multimeters is reviewed. Features included are shown below. Display 3 ½ digit liquid-crystal display is the most common with a nominal height of 0.5" (12 - 13 mm). 3 ½ means that the maximum reading (omitting the decimal point) is 1999, so ‘4 ½’ means 19999 etc. Thus readings on a 20 V scale would be from 0.00 to 19.99 V. Battery & low battery indication A variety of battery types is used. Most have some means of indicating when the battery strength is low, eg, by a flashing 'LOW BATT' sign. In some of the models the highest current circuit is not fused. On/off switch Almost all have on/off switches. Dimensions Indicated in the table. Resolution Indicates level of accuracy. Robustness Comment is made on the material of the case and its design, the presence of sharp corners etc. Terminals Usually three 4 mm jack sockets including one black COM and two red (typically one for 10 A and one for V / ohm / mA) Polarity indication Almost all have red and black terminals; some have + and - signs as well. A negative sign in front of the display indicates reversed connections. Access Comment is made on how easy it is for pupils to reach and damage components, how easy it is for a repairer to reach components and to replace the battery and fuse. Repairability See Section 9 of this guide and Laboratory Handbook section 10.3.4 for further advice on repair, including d-i-y repair. Comments All come with a pair of leads often with retractable protective sleeves. Other significant features are mentioned including the ranges which the meter covers. Digital multimeters do not suffer from the scale-reading problems as analogue multimeters but still suffer from the potential problem of a wide range of possible range settings (see suggestion above). Prices What the suppliers offer, catalogue numbers, prices. 27 7.6.1 JPR UNI-T UT20B digital pocket multimeter Suppliers Suspension Battery/fuse On/off Dimensions Robustness Terminals Polarity indication Access Comments JPR. 3 ½ digit liquid crystal. 12 V A23 battery; appearance of battery symbol indicates need for replacement. 0.2 A, 250 V fuse. Rotating switch for scale selection and on/off. h 26 mm d 90 mm w 52 mm. Compact red-plastic case; smooth corners. Test leads fixed to side of casing. Test leads colour coded. Guidance booklet indicated that there should be a screw access to the battery compartment on the base but none was apparent on the model tested. Features include: diode test. Ranges include: dc current 2000 microamps, 20 mA, 200 mA, dc voltage 200 mV, 2000 mV, 20 V, 200 V, 300 V, ac voltage 200 V, 300 V, resistance ×200 ohm to ×2000 kohm. This is an extremely-low price model but has limited dc current ranges in particular but if found to be useful by schools could be considered as disposable. Prices Range Multimeter UNI-T UT20B JPR 375-405 £3.95 28 7.6.2 Rapid 212 digital pocket multimeter Suppliers Suspension Battery/fuse On/off Dimensions Robustness Terminals Polarity indication Access Comments Granet, Philip Harris, Rapid. 3 ½ digit liquid crystal. 9 V PP3 battery; appearance of battery symbol indicates need for replacement. 250 mA, 250 V fuse. Rotating switch for scale selection and on/off. h 25 mm d 125 mm w 70 mm Neat black-plastic case; smooth corners. 3 jack sockets for 4 mm plugs: COM, 10 A (fused) and v / ohm / mA. No colour coding or use of +/signs. Two Philips head screws, deeply set in the base, making pupil access difficult. Easy for battery and fuse replacement. Connecting leads have protected ends. Features include: diode test, transistor test. Ranges include: dc current 200 microamps, 2000 microamps, 20 mA, 200 mA, 10 A, dc voltage 200 mV, 2 V, 20 V, 200 V, 600 V, ac voltage 200 V, 600 V, resistance ×200 ohm to ×2000 kohm. This is a competitively low price model and could be useful to schools opting for class sets of digital multimeters. Prices Range Pocket Multimeter 212 Granet L412030 £13.00 Philip Harris B8L26852 £11.16 Rapid 85-0622 £5.50 29 7.6.3 Ravencourt SATZ UT 30B digital multimeter Suppliers Suspension Battery/fuse On/off Dimensions Robustness Terminals Polarity indication Access Comments Ravencourt, Timstar. 3 ½ digit liquid crystal. 9 V PP3 battery; the appearance a of battery symbol indicates need for replacement. 05 x 20 - 315 mA, 250 V fuse. Rotating switch for scale selection and on/off. h 30 mm d 128 mm w 72 mm. Gold-coloured plastic case; smooth corners. 2 small rubber feet. 3 jack sockets for 4 mm plugs: COM, 10 A (fused) and v / ohm / mA. Sockets colour coded with a small orange/red and black mark which is not immediately obvious. There is no + or polarity indication. Removal of rubber feet gives access to two small Philips head screws inset on the base - pupil access is difficult. Screws are very small but battery and fuse replacement are not very difficult. Features include: data HOLD function via button in centre of dial, diode test, transistor test. Ranges include: dc current 200 microamps, 2 mA, 20 mA, 200 mA,10 A, dc voltage 200 mV, 2 V, 20 V, 200 V, 500 V, ac current 200 mA, 10 A, ac voltage similar range to dc voltage though with less accuracy, resistance ×200 ohm to ×20 Mohm. This is another competitively priced model and could be useful to schools opting for class sets of digital multimeters. Prices Range SATZ UT30B Ravencourt Palmsize UT30B £7.70 Timstar EL52410 £7.70 30 7.6.4 Economatics Skytronic digital multimeter Suppliers Suspension Battery/fuse On/off Dimensions Robustness Terminals Polarity indication Access Comments Economatics. 3 ½ digit liquid crystal. 9 V PP3 battery; Appearance of a battery symbol indicates need for replacement. 200 mA, 250 V fuse. Rotating switch for scale selection and on/off. h 28 mm d 125 mm w 70 mm. Plastic case; smooth corners. 3 jack sockets for 4 mm plugs: COM, 10 A (fused) and v / ohm / mA. Sockets colour coded. Two Philips head screws deeply set in the base, making pupil access difficult. Easy for battery and fuse replacement by adults. Lead ends are not protected. Features include: diode test, transistor test. Ranges include: dc current 200 microamps, 2000 microamps, 20 mA, 200 mA,10 A, dc voltage 200 mV, 2 V, 20 V, 200 V, 1000 V, ac voltage 200 V, 750 V, resistance ×200 ohm to ×2000 kohm. This is also a competitively low-price model. However, there was screen fade on the model tested although this problem was not commented on by schools nor has it been reported to the suppliers. If it is not a problem this model could be useful to schools opting for class sets of digital multimeters. Prices Range Economatics Skytronic Economatics 600.032 RB 5328 £8.95 31 7.6.5 Rapid 318 digital multimeter Suppliers Suspension Battery/fuse On/off Dimensions Robustness Terminals Polarity indication Access Comments Granet, Rapid. 3 ½ digit liquid crystal. 9 V PP3 battery; appearance of battery symbol indicates need for replacement. 300 mA, 250 V fuse. Rotating switch for scale selection and on/off. h 46 mm d 200 mm w 97 mm. Solid black plastic-case; smooth corners. Substantial rubber outer case. 4 jack sockets for 4 mm plugs: COM, 10 A, A and v / ohm. Sockets colour coded. Single inset Philips head screws on the base, making pupil access difficult. Easy for battery and fuse replacement. Features include: audible continuity test, diode test, transistor test. Ranges include: dc current 20 and 200 microamps, 2 mA, 20 mA, 200 mA, 2 A, 10 A, ac current 200 microamps, 2 mA, 20 mA, 200 mA, 2 A, 10 A, dc voltage 200 mV, 2 V, 20 V, 200 V, 1000 V, ac voltage 200 mV, 2 V, 20 V, 200 V, 700 V, resistance ×200 ohm to ×200 Mohm. This is a competitively low-price model with a wider range of functions than some other low priced models and could be useful to schools opting for class sets of digital multimeters. Prices Range Rapid 318 Multimeter Granet L412060 £20.53 Rapid 85-0719 £9.90 32 7.6.6 CALTEK CM2400-T digital multimeter Suppliers Suspension Battery/fuse On/off Dimensions Robustness Terminals Polarity indication Access Comments The Consortium, JPR. 3 ½ digit liquid crystal. 9 V PP3 battery; Low-battery signal indicates need for replacement. 200 mA, 250 V fast fuse. Rotating switch for scale selection and on/off. h 27 mm d 125 mm w 68 mm. Solid yellow-plastic case; smooth corners. 3 jack sockets for 4 mm plugs: COM, 10 A, and v / ohm / mA. No colour coding but printing on case. Two Philips head screws, deeply set in the base, making pupil access difficult. Easy for battery and fuse replacement. Leads have protected ends. Features include: audible continuity test, diode test, transistor test, temperature measurement. Ranges include: dc current 200 microamps, 2 mA, 20 mA, 200 mA, 10 A, dc voltage 200 mV, 2 V, 20 V, 200 V, 600 V, ac voltage 200 V, 600 V, resistance ×200 ohm to ×2000 kohm. Automatic zero adjustment. This is another low-price model with an adequate range of functions. Prices Range CALTEK CM2400-T The Consortium 055787 £12.55 JPR 375-482 £10.50 33 7.6.7 jtw DM-830D+ Suppliers Suspension Battery/fuse On/off Dimensions Robustness Terminals Polarity indication Access Comments Scientific & Chemical. 3 ½ digit liquid crystal. 9 V PP3 battery; ‘BAT’ symbol indicates need for battery replacement. 200 mA, 250 V fuse. Rotating switch for scale selection and on/off. h 27 mm d 135 mm w 78 mm. Solid black-plastic case, enclosed in orange-rubber protective case; smooth corners. 3 jack sockets for 4 mm plugs: COM, 10 A, and v / ohm / mA. Colour coding shows polarity but no + or - sign. Two Philips head screws, inset on the base, making pupil access difficult. Easy for battery and fuse replacement. Features include: audible continuity test, diode test, transistor test, temperature measurement. Ranges include: dc current 200 microamps, 2 mA, 20 mA, 200 mA, 10 A, dc voltage 200 mV, 2 V, 20 V, 200 V, 1000 V, ac voltage 200 V, 750 V, resistance ×200 ohm to ×2000 kohm. This is another low-price model with an adequate range of functions. Prices Range jtw DM-830 D+ Scientific & Chemical EMM 040010 £10.91 34 7.6.8 Draper DMM 1A Suppliers Suspension Battery/fuse On/off Dimensions Robustness Terminals Polarity indication Access Comments Scientific & Chemical. 3 ½ digit liquid crystal. 9 V PP3 battery; Appearance of battery symbol indicates need for replacement. 250 mA, 250 V fuse. Rotating switch for scale selection and on/off. h 50 mm d 140 mm w 64 mm. Solid blue-plastic case enclosed in blue-rubber jacket; smooth corners. 3 jack sockets for 4 mm plugs: COM, 10 A, and v / ohm / mA. No colour coding or + or – signs to indicate polarity. Single Philips head screw, inset on the base, making pupil access difficult. Easy for battery and fuse replacement. Integral support attached to back of instrument. Lead ends protected. Features include: audible continuity test, data HOLD function, diode test, transistor test. Ranges include: dc current 2000 microamps, 20 mA, 200 mA, 10 A, dc voltage 200 mV, 2 V, 20 V, 200 V, 600 V, ac voltage 200 V, 600 V, resistance ×200 ohm to ×2000 kohm, This is another fairly low-price model with an adequate range of functions. Prices Range Draper DMM 1A Scientific & Chemical EMM 010010 £14.77 35 7.6.9 UNI-T UT39A Suppliers Suspension Battery/fuse On/off Dimensions Robustness Terminals Polarity indication Access Comments Commotion. 3 ½ digit liquid crystal. 9 V PP3 battery; Appearance of battery symbol indicates need for replacement. 315 mA, 250 V fast fuse. Power on/off button. h 40 mm d 160 mm w 84 mm. Solid black-plastic case enclosed in red-rubber protective jacket; smooth corners. 4 jack sockets for 4 mm plugs: COM, 10 A, microamp / mA and v / ohm. No colour coding. Single Philips head screw, inset on the base, making pupil access difficult. Easy for battery and fuse replacement. Features include: audible continuity test, capacitance measurement, data HOLD facility via blue button, diode test, transistor test. Ranges include: dc current 20 microamps, 200 microamps, 2 mA, 20 mA, 200 mA, 10 A, dc voltage 200 mV, 2 V, 20 V, 200 V, 1000 V, ac current 200 microamps, 20 mA, 200 mA, 10 A, ac voltage 2 V, 20 V, 200 V, 750 V, resistance ×200 ohm to ×2000 Mohm. Leads do not have protected ends. Screen shows data hold operating and dangerous voltages. Auto-disconnect if not used for 15 minutes. Rear has bracket for upright standing. This model has a wider range of functions should they be needed, at what is still a reasonable price. Prices Range UNI-T 39A Commotion 27037 £17.50 36 7.6.10 SATZ UT51 Suppliers Suspension Battery/fuse On/off Dimensions Robustness Terminals Polarity indication Access Comments Ravencourt, Timstar. 3 ½ digit liquid crystal. 9 V PP3 battery; appearance of battery symbol indicates need for replacement. 2 A, 250 V and 10 A 250 V fuses. Power on/off switch. h 50 mm d 200 mm w 95 mm. Very solid black-plastic case enclosed in black-rubber protective jacket; smooth corners. 4 jack sockets for 4 mm plugs: COM, 10 A, A and v / ohm. Red and black colour coding. Single Philips head screw, inset on the base, making pupil access difficult. Easy for battery and fuse replacement. Features include: audible continuity test, capacitance measurement, diode test, transistor test. Ranges include: dc current 20 and 200 microamps, 2 mA, 20 mA, 200 mA, 2 A, 10 A, dc voltage 200 mV, 2 V, 20 V, 200 V, 1000 V, ac current 200 microamps, 2 mA, 20 mA, 200 mA, 2 A, 10 A, ac voltage 200 mV, 2 V, 20 V, 200 V, 750 V, resistance ×200 ohm to ×2000 Mohm. Bracket for upright standing and holster provided. This model again has a wider range of functions, should they be needed, at what is still a reasonable price. Price Range SATZ UT 51 Ravencourt SATZ UT51 £19.95 Timstar EL52415 £19.95 37 7.6.11 CALTEK CM3900A Suppliers Suspension Battery/fuse On/off Dimensions Robustness Terminals Polarity indication Access Comments Commotion. 3 ½ digit liquid crystal. 9 V PP3 battery; appearance of battery symbol indicates need for replacement. 2 A, 250 V fast fuse. Power on/off button. h 46 mm d 170 mm w 85 mm. Solid orange / yellow-plastic case; smooth corners. 4 jack sockets for 4 mm plugs: COM, 20 A, micro / mA and v / ohm. Red and black colour coding and named. Single Philips head screw, inset on the base, making pupil access difficult. Easy for battery and fuse replacement by adults. Two deep set larger Philips head screws protect access to the circuits. Leads ends protected. Features include: audible continuity test, diode test, transistor test. Ranges include: dc current 200 microamps, 2 mA, 20 mA, 200 mA, 2 A, 20 A, dc voltage 200 mV, 2 V, 20 V, 200 V, 600 V, ac current 200 microamps, 2 mA, 20 mA, 200 mA, 2 A, 20 A, ac voltage 200 mV, 2 V, 20 V, 200 V, 600 V, resistance ×200 ohm to ×20 Mohm. Screen indicates units as well as value. Bracket for upright standing provided. Automatic power off after 15 minutes. This model again has a slightly wider range of functions, should they be needed, though the price is a little higher. Price Range CALTEK CM3900A Commotion 27027 £25.00 JPR 375-475 £14.95 38 7.6.12 UNI-T UT60A digital multimeter Suppliers Suspension Battery/fuse On/off Dimensions Robustness Terminals Polarity indication Access Comments Philip Harris. 3 ½ digit liquid crystal. 9 V PP3 battery; appearance of battery symbol indicates need for replacement. 0.5 A, 250 V and 10 A, 250 V fast fuses. Orange on/off power switch. Blue switch enables rapid change between dc and ac. h 40 mm d 175 mm w 85 mm. Red rubberised case; smooth corners. Four 4 mm jack sockets COM, 10 A, micro / mA and Hz / v / ohm. Not colour coded or marked + or -. Single Philips screw protects access to the battery compartment on the base and two screws protect access to the circuits. Auto-ranger selects best range for greatest resolution. Instrument has a RS232c standard serial port, interface cable and software to enable connection to a computer for data capture. Lead ends unprotected. Integral support for upright usage included. Features include: audible continuity test, capacitance measurement, data HOLD facility, diode test, frequency test. Ranges include: dc current 400 microamps, 4000 microamps, 40 mA, 400 mA, 4 A, 10 A, ac current 400 microamps, 4000 microamps, 40 mA, 400 mA, 4 A, 10 A, dc voltage 400 mV, 4 V, 40 V, 400 V, 1000 V, ac voltage 4 V, 40 V, 400 V, 750 V, resistance ×400 ohm to ×40 Mohm. This is a more-expensive model but the extra facilities including computer linkage potential may make it of interest to some schools. Price Range UNI-T UT60A Maplin N80CB £29.99 Philip Harris B8L 16652 £36.50 39 8. Galvanometers Whilst this guide deals mainly with ammeters and voltmeters for pupil use, it is worth mentioning galvanometers which can also be used by pupils. As noted in Section 4, Table 5, galvanometers are moving-coil, electric-current detectors mainly used as devices which can measure the magnitude and direction of very small electric currents. They may be used, for example, to detect a null or unbalanced condition in a bridge or potentiometer circuit. Only a small proportion of schools’ suppliers include the traditional centre-zero galvanometers for pupil use in their catalogues but, for many purposes, some of the analogue ammeters described in section 7.1, in which the scale starts at a minus number, could be used for this purpose. More suppliers sell demonstration galvanometers but these are much more expensive and are outside the scope of this guide. Table 6 gives an outline of some of the pupil models currently on the market. No further tests were carried out on these models. Table 6 Pupil galvanometers available Moving coil - centre zero Suppliers Range Catalogue Number Price ASCOL -35 mV - 0 - 35 mV P59 1100ELO 4901 £8.53 Beecroft (STE) -35 mV - 0 - 35 mV ELO 4901 £28.66 Griffin Education (STE) -35 mV - 0 - 35 mV EHG-250-100c £24.40 Philip Harris -3.5 mA - 0 - 3.5 mA B8A 74731 £33.55 Philip Harris -50 microA - 0 - 50 microA B8A 74729 £36.12 9. Repairs to meters General guidance is given in Laboratory Handbook section 10.3.4. On the whole it is advisable for school staff only to undertake simple external repairs to analogue (and digital) meters such as tightening terminals. This is because any attempt to repair internal faults will invalidate any warranty. Little maintenance is possible on digital meters, other than replacement of the battery, in any case. Many schools tend to be restricted by finances to cheaper meters. When a meter is faulty and is within the warranty period, the supplier should be contacted and should provide a replacement free of charge. Nowadays, it is often as costly for a supplier to repair a meter as to replace it. So, if a cheaper meter is outside its warranty period, schools may well be advised to replace the meter, especially since it is easy to forget to include the cost of postage and packing in each direction in calculating costs. Each supplier has its own approach to repair of meters. Table 7 gives information received from suppliers and manufacturers. Some do not undertake repairs at all, others will including some who use a linked repair company. Schools are advised to seek advice about repair and replacement from the supplier before meters are purchased. It is usually worth asking for a quote if there is not a standard price for repairs. 40 Table 7 Repair information Supplier/manufacturer Repair service offered other than warranty replacement Beecroft None Commotion None Economatics None Granet None Griffin Education / Fisher None JPR None Philip Harris / Findel Charged service provided by Techlab Ravencourt Charged service provided Scientific & Chemical None though it might consider a large batch of repairs. Timstar Charged service provided P&B Weir Charged service provided 10. Disposal of electrical meters and other electrical equipment 10.1 The WEEE regulations The Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment (WEEE) Regulations 2006 are intended to reduce the amount of waste electrical and electronic equipment which is currently being disposed of in landfill sites. The intention is to encourage separate collection and, as far as possible, treatment and recycling. Most of the provisions came into force on 1st July 2007. They make producers of new equipment responsible for paying for the treatment or recycling of products at the end of their useful life. This will affect all businesses which manufacture, brand, import, sell, store or dismantle such equipment. Distributors and retailers will be responsible for taking back WEEE in a way convenient to customers (including schools and colleges) and free of charge. This may ultimately be reflected in purchase costs once the Regulations have been in operation for sufficient time to assess their impact. The Regulations apply to all electrical and electronic equipment whether used in domestic, educational or commercial situations. Thus, items such as refrigerators, radios, lighting equipment, computers and medical equipment will be covered. It follows that, in schools, all such equipment and not solely that used in science departments, will be covered by the Regulations. These kinds of equipment will, in future, carry the RECYCLE, DO NOT DISCARD symbol. It will take some time for suppliers and manufacturers to finalise and implement their systems for meeting the new requirements. These may involve different approaches according to the nature of the equipment and to the area of the country in which they are located. Schools, domestic and other users of electrical equipment are not obliged to take advantage of the collection approaches offered but will need to make alternative arrangements that also meet the requirements, if they choose not to. Schools will also need to be able to identify where electrical equipment was purchased when it ultimately comes to disposal, so would be advised to keep copies of invoices or delivery notes to help them. Different arrangements will apply for products put on the market before 13 August 2005. If the school is replacing such electrical equipment, the new “producer” will be responsible for financing the collection, recycling and disposal of old equipment (even if a different make is being purchased). If the equipment is not being replaced then responsibility falls on the school (or business) to dispose of the equipment in accordance with the Regulations. Further information is given in CLEAPSS position statement PS75. 41 10.2 Responses of manufacturers and distributors to the WEEE regulations At the time of updating this guide (July 2007), there was a wide range of different responses from suppliers of meters about how they would meet the WEEE requirements. Some had clearly given a good deal of thought to the matter and had linked with a compliance scheme for reporting on, collection and treatment of all WEEE produce for which the company had responsibility. Others were proposing to offer to schools disposal of WEEE which they returned but were clearly anticipating that many schools would undertake responsibility for disposal of broken waste electrical items themselves. A few had not, at that stage, really devised any facility at all and were only starting to give the matter some thought. A small number of companies had not fully appreciated the extent of their responsibilities and were at that time indicating that they believed that they would not carry any liability where they bought in products from other UK or EU companies and manufacturers for resale. Equally a few manufacturers believed that the liability lay with the suppliers. Clearly the situation will change as companies appreciate more fully the extent of their responsibilities and have had some experience of the scale of the problem. Nevertheless, schools are advised to check the approach of the relevant company at the time of any proposed purchase. 42 Appendix 1 Manufacturers’ and suppliers’ addresses ASCOL PO Box 6745 Beeston, Nottingham NG9 6QN Tel: 0115 9256049 Fax: 0115 9254511 Email: sales@ascol.co.uk Web site: www.ascol.co.uk GLS Fairway 1 Mollison Avenue Enfield EN3 7XQ Tel: 0845 1203213 Fax: 0800 9172246 Email: sales@glsed.co.uk Web site: www.glsed.co.uk Beecroft & Partners Ltd Northfield Road Rotherham, South Yorkshire S60 1RR Tel: 01709 377881 Fax: 01709 369264 Email: sales@beecroft-science.co.uk Web site: www.beecroft-science.co.uk Granet PO Box 404, Aylesbury, Buckinghamshire HP19 9WD Tel: 01296 398624 Fax: 01296 426507 Email: sales@granetscience.co.uk Web site: www.granetscience.co.uk IP Chambers Electronics Holker School Cark-in-Cartmel Grange-over-Sands, Cumbria LA11 7PQ Tel: 015395 58555 Fax: 015395 58558 Email: mail@ipcel.co.uk Web site: www.ipcel.co.uk Griffin Education Bishop Meadow Road Loughborough LE11 5RG Tel: 01509 233344 Fax: 01509 555200 Email: griffin@fisher.co.uk Web site: www.griffineducation.co.uk Commotion Group Commotion House Morley Road Tonbridge, Kent TN9 1RA Tel: 01732 773399 Fax: 01732 773390 Email: sales@commotiongroup.co.uk Web site: www.commotiongroup.co.uk Fisher Scientific Bishop Meadow Road Loughborough LE11 5RG Tel: 01509 231166 Fax: 01509 231893 Email: sales@fisher.co.uk Web site: www.fisher.co.uk (Order Fisher products via Griffin Education) The Consortium Hammond Way Trowbridge Wiltshire BA14 8RR Tel: 0845 3307780 Fax: 0845 3307785 Email: enquiries@theconsortium.co.uk Web site: www.theconsortium.co.uk Philip Harris Ltd Hyde Buildings Hyde Cheshire SK14 4SH Tel: 0845 1204520 Fax: 0800 1388881 Email: customerservice@philipharris.co.uk Web site: www.philipharris.co.uk Economatics 19b Orgreave Close Handsworth, Sheffield S13 9NP Tel: 0114 2813311 Fax: 01114 269740 Email: sales@economatics.co.uk Web site: www.economatics.co.uk JPR Electronics 4 Circle Business Centre Dunstable, Bedfordshire LU5 5DP Tel: 01582 470000 Fax: 01582 470001 Email: sales@jprelec.co.uk Web site: www.jprelec.co.uk 43 Maplin Electronics Ltd PO Box 777 Valley Road, Wombwell Barnsley, Yorkshire S73 0BS Tel: 0870 4296000 Fax: 0870 4296001 Email: customerservice@maplin.co.uk Web site: www.maplin.co.uk Timstar Laboratory Suppliers Ltd Timstar House Marshfield Bank, Herald Drive Crewe, Cheshire CW2 8UY Tel: 01270 250459 Fax: 01270 250601 Email: sales@timstar.co.uk Web site: www.timstar.co.uk Optical Vision Ltd Unit 2b, Woolpit Business Park Woolpit, Bury St Edmunds Suffolk IP30 9UP Tel: 01359 244200 Fax: 01359 244255 Email: info@opticalvision.co.uk Web site: www.opticalvision.co.uk Unilab (See Philip Harris for details) Hyde Buildings Hyde, Cheshire, SK14 4SH Tel: 0845 1204520 Fax: 0800 1388881 Email: enquiries@philipharris.co.uk Web site: www.unilab.co.uk Rapid Electronics Severalls Lane Colchester Essex CO4 5JS Tel: 01206 751166 Fax: 01206 751188 Email: sales@rapidelec.co.uk Web site: www.rapidonline.co.uk P & B Weir Electrical Unit 10 Leafield Trading Estate Corsham SN13 9SW Tel: 01225 811449 Fax: 01225 810909 Email: sales@pbweir.co.uk Web site: www.pbweir.co.uk Ravencourt Ltd Drift Road Stamford, Lincolnshire Woolpit Business Park PE9 1UT Tel: 01780 489100 Fax: 01780 489099 Email: sales@ravencourt.com Web site: www.ravencourt.com Yorkshire Purchasing Organisation (YPO) 41 Industrial Park Wakefield, Yorkshire WF2 0XE Tel: 01924 824477 Fax: 01924 834805 Email: sales@ypo.co.uk Web site: www.ypo.co.uk Scientific & Chemical Supplies Carlton House, Livingstone Road Bilston WV14 0QZ Tel: 01902 402402 Fax: 01902 402434 Email: info@scichem.com Web site: www.scichem.com STE UK Ltd Staplehurst Road Sittingbourne, Kent ME10 2NH Tel: 01795 474700 Fax: 01227 200112 Email: sales@steuk.co.uk Web site: www.steuk.co.uk 44