A Comparison of Scale: Macro, Micro, Nano Comparison of Scale PK Activities (3) Participant Guide www.scme-nm.org Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) University of New Mexico MEMS Introduction Topic Scale Inquiry Activity: Cut to Size Shareable Content Object (SCO) This SCO is part of the Learning Module Scale Target audiences: High School, Community College, University Support for this work was provided by the National Science Foundation's Advanced Technological Education (ATE) Program through Grants #DUE 0830384 and 0902411. Any opinions, findings and conclusions or recommendations expressed in this material are those of the authors and creators, and do not necessarily reflect the views of the National Science Foundation. Copyright © by the Southwest Center for Microsystems Education and The Regents of the University of New Mexico Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) 800 Bradbury SE, Suite 235 Albuquerque, NM 87106-4346 Phone: 505-272-7150 Website: www.scme-nm.org Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) Int_Scale_AC12_PG_040413 Page 2 of 10 Cut to Size Activity Scale Inquiry Activity: Cut To Size Activity Participant Guide Introduction To understand microsystems, their applications and fabrication, you need to have a good understanding of size and scale. This leads to a better understanding of the function of micro-sized objects and the applications in which they are used. Microchip containing a nano-sized insulin pump [Printed with permission from Debiotech S.] For example, this picture shows a microchip of a nano-sized pump used to supply a continuous infusion of insulin to a diabetic. This device is small enough to be mounted on a disposable skin patch. The nanopump inside the micro-size chip is able to control delivery at the nanoliter level, the amount very close to the physiological delivery of insulin .(1) This pump is constructed using MEMS technology fabrication techniques. In this activity you will discover similar devices in the macro, micro, and nano-scales. You will identify objects that exist in each of these scales given a specific length. You will be asked to think of ways that these objects can be used to perform a necessary task. Description and Estimated Time to Complete This activity allows you to explore the macro, micro and nano- scales and to begin thinking about the types of objects found in these scales. In this activity you will cut a 20 cm paper ruler in half, then continue to cut each new piece in half until it becomes too small to cut. For each cut, you will identify an object that has the length of the remaining size. Even after the ruler becomes too small to cut, you will continue to identify objects for several lengths all the way down into the nano-scale. . Estimated Time to Complete Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) Int_Scale_AC12_PG_040413 Page 3 of 10 Cut to Size Activity Allow approximately 60 minutes to complete this activity. Activity Objectives and Outcomes Activity Objectives Demonstrate your knowledge of metric scales by identifying at least 15 objects that range in size from the nano-scale to the macro-scale. Identify at least 3 macro-size objects that perform the same tasks but in the micro-scale. Activity Outcomes For each cut of the ruler you will indicate on a chart the length of the new ruler and at least one object that measures that length. When you are no longer able to cut the ruler in half, you will continue to identify objects that measure specific micro and nano lengths as indicated on the activity chart. By the end of this activity you should be able to answer the following questions: How many cuts would it take to get to the size of a water molecule (approximately 1 nm)? How do you denote lengths using the metric system? What are some objects that overlap the micro and nano-scales? What is an object in the micro or nano-scale that performs the same function or task as a macrosized object? What are some tasks that micro or nano-sized objects perform that affect your life? Team It is recommended that you complete this activity with one or two other participants. Working with others will promote more discussion and ideas. Supplies One 20 cm long strip of ruled paper. (One is provided on the Cut to Size Activity Chart at the end of this activity). One piece of stock paper (or thick printer paper) – if available One pair of scissors One Cut to Size Activity chart (last 2 pages of this activity) One pencil Computer with Internet access Computer with PowerPoint or Adobe Reader Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) Int_Scale_AC12_PG_040413 Cut to Size Activity - PG Page 4 of 10 Documentation Record your observations during this activity. Complete the Cut to Size Activity Chart. Record the results for each step of the activity. Revise your hypothesis to reflect the results. Summarize your discussions with other participants. Answer the Post-activity questions. Think About the Outcome Answer the following based on what you think will be the outcome of this activity. Expectations: You will discover functional objects that range from the nano-scale to the macro-scale. You will identify micro and nano-sized objects that work as efficiently as macro-sized objects with equivalent functions. Observations: What is the difference between a micro-sized object and a nano-sized object? Describe any previous experience or observations that you have had relating to micro and nano-sized objects. What types of objects do you think of when you think "micro"? What types of objects do you think of when you think "nano"? Hypothesis: Write a statement on what you expect to discover in fulfilling the expectations. Predictions: What types of objects will you find in the micro and nano-scales that perform the same functions as objects macro-scales (> 100 microns)? What types of objects will you find in the micro-scale? What types of objects will you find in the nano-scale? Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) Int_Scale_AC12_PG_040413 Cut to Size Activity - PG Page 5 of 10 Inquiry Activity: Cut To Size Description This activity allows you to explore the macro, micro and nano- scales. You will cut a 20 cm long paper ruler as small as you can get it and identify an object that has the length of each cut size. This activity will help you begin to think about objects in the micro and nano-scales. 1. View the Presentation: "Macro, Micro, or Nano?" Description View either the PowerPoint or Flash version of the presentation "Macro, Micro, or Nano?" How did you do? How many did you get correct? 2. Print out the Cut to Size Activity Chart Description Print out the Cut to Size Activity Chart at the end of this handout. Print page 2 of the chart on stock paper, if available. Cut out the metric ruler along the red line. 3. Cut the ruler in half. Description Cut the ruler in half. Discard one half of the ruler. Answer the following questions: a. What is the new length of the ruler? Record the length on the activity chart. (Be sure to use metric notation). b. Give an example of an object of this size. (You are welcome to Google images for ideas) c. What is the function (task) of this object? (i.e. red blood cells (6 to 8 μm in diameter) carry oxygen from the lungs to the body) d. Is this object macro, micro, or nano in length? Refer back to the presentation if you need to. e. Record your answers to these questions on the chart. Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) Int_Scale_AC12_PG_040413 Cut to Size Activity - PG Page 6 of 10 4. Repeat Step 3 Description Repeat step 3 until the ruler gets too small to cut in half. Use the activity chart to keep track of the number of times you cut. 5. How many cuts did you get? Description How many cuts did you get before the ruler got too small to cut? On the activity chart, highlight the number of cuts you were able to do before the last piece was too small to cut. 6. Complete the Activity Chart Description For the remaining cuts indicated on the chart, answer the following. a. Give an example of an object of this size? b. What is the function of this object? c. Is it macro, micro, or nano? 7. How many cuts to 1 nm? Description a. Determine how many cuts it would take to get to 1 nanometer. b. How many cuts? ______________ c. What are two objects that are 1 nm in length or diameter? 8. Revisit your hypothesis and predictions Description a. Revise your hypothesis to reflect your results. b. How well did your results match your predictions? (Be specific) 9. Answer the Post-Activity Questions Description Answer the Post-Activity Questions at the end of this procedure. 10. Discuss results with other participants Description Discuss your activity results with other participants. 11. Write up your documentation Description See the Documentation section and complete your documentation for this activity. Submit your documentation as required. Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) Int_Scale_AC12_PG_040413 Cut to Size Activity - PG Page 7 of 10 Post-Activity Questions 1. How many cuts would it take to get to the size of a molecule approximately 1 nm in diameter? 2. What types of objects did you find in the micro-scale? Nano-scale? 3. Based on the types of objects that you found in the micro and nano-scales, what types of professions do you think directly utilize the functional capabilities of these objects? (Be specific) 4. What are some objects that overlap the micro and nano-scales? 5. What is an object in the micro-scale that performs the same function or task as a macrosized object? 6. What are some functions that micro and nano-sized object perform that affect your life? Summary This activity allowed you to explore objects in three different scales – macro, micro, and nano. Even though nano, and most micro-sized objects cannot be seen with the naked eye, you should have found that there still exists billions and billions of functional objects within these scales. It is important that you get a sense of relative size and develop a good understanding of scale and units. This understanding will assist in all aspects of your life. References 1 "Debiotech's Insulin Nanopump™". MedGadget. April 23, 2007. http://medgadget.com/archives/2007/04/debiotechs_insulin_nanopump.html Support for this work was provided by the National Science Foundation's Advanced Technological Education (ATE) Program. Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) Int_Scale_AC12_PG_040413 Cut to Size Activity - PG Page 8 of 10 Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) Int_Scale_AC12_PG_040413 Cut to Size Activity - PG Page 9 of 10 Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) Int_Scale_AC12_PG_040413 Cut to Size Activity - PG Page 10 of 10 Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) University of New Mexico MEMS Introduction Topic A Comparison of Scale: Macro, Micro, Nano Primary Knowledge (PK) Shareable Content Object (SCO) This SCO is part of the Learning Module Scale Target audiences: High School, Community College, University Support for this work was provided by the National Science Foundation's Advanced Technological Education (ATE) Program through Grants #DUE 0830384 and 0902411. Any opinions, findings and conclusions or recommendations expressed in this material are those of the authors and creators, and do not necessarily reflect the views of the National Science Foundation. Copyright © by the Southwest Center for Microsystems Education and The Regents of the University of New Mexico Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) 800 Bradbury Drive SE, Suite 235 Albuquerque, NM 87106-4346 Phone: 505-272-7150 Website: www.scme-nm.org Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) Int_Scale_PK12_PG_040813 Page 1 of 22 Comparison of Scale - PK A Comparison of Scale: Macro, Micro, Nano Primary Knowledge Participant Guide Description and Estimated Time to Complete In order to grasp many of the concepts associated with MEMS and MEMS devices and components, you need to understand scale and the size of objects associated with different scales. This unit introduces you to various concepts associated with scale, and a comparison of the macro, micro and nano-scales. Estimated Time to Complete Allow approximately 30 minutes to complete. Introduction The Milky Way [Image credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech2] Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) Int_Scale_PK12_PG_040813 Page 2 of 22 Comparison of Scale - PK At one time or another everyone has asked the question "How big is the universe?" Trying to develop the answer can be overwhelming because there is no answer. The size of the universe is unknown; however, the size of objects within the universe is known. These objects are constantly being studied, measured, and compared. These comparisons are a means of evoking some sense of scale as to how big the universe could be. For example, the Milky Way (pictured above) is one of billions of galaxies. Our sun is one of several 100 billion stars within The Milky Way. There are over 50,000 billion, billion stars. There are more stars in the universe than there are grains of sand on our planet.1 Our sun is considered a middle-sized star. Giant stars are as much as 10 times larger. However, when compared to Earth, the sun is approximately 109 times larger in diameter meaning that 1.3 million earths could fit inside the sun! Do the math! The sun is much larger than Earth. From the sun's center to its surface, it is about 109 times the radius of Earth. Some of the streams of gas rising from the solar surface are larger than Earth. [Image source: NASA - Image credit: World Book illustration by Roberta Polfus] For years astronomers have explored the universe looking for hints as to how big it really is. At the same time, other scientists have been exploring how small things are and how small something has to be before it goes beyond the reach of manipulation or measurement. In these explorations, another whole universe has been discovered, but on a much smaller scale. Instead of objects being measured in kilometers and light-years, objects are measured in micrometers and nanometers, and even the number of atoms (see image right). This unit will explore the concept of scale: what is big, what is small, and how do these objects compare in size? When working with micro and nanotechnologies it is important to have an understanding of size and of scale. This will lead to a better understanding of the processes and applications used in these technologies. Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) Int_Scale_PK12_PG_040813 This atomic force microscope image by German physicist Franz Giessibl shows dozens of silicon atoms. Scientists have debated whether the light and dark crescents - or wing-shaped features seen on the atoms represent orbitals - the paths of electrons orbiting the atoms. [Printed with permission. See F. J. Giessibl et al., Science 289, 422 (2000)] Page 3 of 22 Comparison of Scale - PK Objectives Explain the differences in the macro, micro and nano scales in terms of size, applications, and properties. Define microtechnology and nanotechnology. Identify objects and applications in the micro-scale and the nano-scale. Size is Relative Size is Relative "The sun is big" is a relative statement. Big relative to what? "An ant is small." Again, another relative statement. Relative to the size of a human being, yes, an ant is small (anywhere from 2mm long to 25 mm long); however, relative to a human hair (0.1 to 0.06 mm), an ant is huge. The comparative size of an object in relative terms (big, small, huge) can be illustrated in a scale. In the top scale of "Size is Relative", the ant is the smallest object. However, in the bottom scale the ant is the largest object. Additional comparison scales could be created at both ends of these two scales illustrating even smaller and largest objects. Question: In the top scale, the ant is the smallest object. What are three additional objects that could be added to this scale that are bigger than the ant, but smaller than the bumblebee? Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) Int_Scale_PK12_PG_040813 Page 4 of 22 Comparison of Scale - PK Scale is a Relationship Scale is the relationship between what is being compared and how that relationship is represented numerically or visually. Two scales can look very similar, but be completely different in the range represented. Two objects can look the same size, but when put in the correct scale, the difference becomes obvious. Take a look at the two objects in the figure. They look close to the same size, don't they? In reality, the ant is approximately 5 mm in length and red blood cells are approximately 5 μm in diameter or 1,000 times smaller! How Big is Small? One light-year is 9,460,730,472,580.8 km or about 9.5 x 1015 meters! One kilometer (km) is 1000 meters or 1x103 meters. One micrometer is 10-6 (a millionth) of a meter. One nanometer is 10-9 (a billionth) of a meter. One kilogram (kg) is 1000 grams or 1x103 grams. One milligram (mg) is 10 -3 (a thousandth) of a gram. An attogram is 10-18 of a gram. Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) Int_Scale_PK12_PG_040813 Page 5 of 22 Comparison of Scale - PK The Scale of Things [Graphic courtesy of the Office of Basic Energy Sciences, U.S. DOE] In the above chart "The Scale of Things – Nanometers and More", you can get a feeling of how things can look the same size, but when placed next to a scale, the real size becomes more apparent. Take a few minutes to study the objects on this chart. Which would you consider macro (large than micro)? Which objects would you place in the micro-scale and which objects in the nano-scale? Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) Int_Scale_PK12_PG_040813 Page 6 of 22 Comparison of Scale - PK Macro, Micro and Nano – What's the difference? Macro, Micro, Nano [Micro image of microgears courtesy of Sandia National Laboratories] [Nano image Printed with permission Craighead Group/Cornell University and © Cornell University] Macro – anything that can be seen with the naked eye or anything greater than ~100 micrometer. Micro – 100 micrometers to 100 nanometers Nano – 100 nanometers to 1 nanometer Electrical and mechanical devices, components and systems are being manufactured in a variety of sizes from macro to nano. The figure shows such components: Standard light bulb with a diameter of ~8 millimeters (mm) or 3.2 inches Microgears with individual gear teeth ~8 micrometers (µm) wide Microcantilever with a gold nano-dot 50 nanometers (nm) in diameter. In commercial and residential electrical applications, components such as switches, light bulbs and fans are macro-size objects (greater than 100 micrometers). Airbag actuation sensors, shock sensors for computers and implantable drug delivery systems are micro-sized objects. Biomolecular sensors for proteins and antigens, carbon nanotubes as connectors, and gene analysis devices are nano-sized objects. Can you add objects to the following table? Macro Switches Light bulbs Fans Pumps Micro Microswitches Inertial sensors Chemical sensors Micropumps Nano Carbon Nanotubes Biomolecular sensors Biomolecular motors Table 1: Macro, Micro and Nano Objects Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) Int_Scale_PK12_PG_040813 Page 7 of 22 Comparison of Scale - PK A Sense of Size A honey bee is approximately 12 mm long A human hair is 60 to 100 micrometers in diameter A red blood cell averages about 7 micrometers in diameter The DNA helix is 0.002 micrometers wide or 2 nm wide. Something for you to do: Estimate the size of other objects that you are familiar with. This is a good time to take and break and do one of the activities in this Scale Learning Module. A good activity to do is "Cut To Size." Scales As seen in previous graphics, a good way to compare the size of different objects is to place the objects on a scale. There are two basic scales that are used: the linear scale and the logarithmic scale. Following is a brief discussion and illustration of both types of scales. Linear Scales Linear Scale In a linear scale each increment and incremental increase is equal to the one before (in other words – equal divisions for equal values). For example, the linear scale above goes from 0 millimeters to 25 millimeters in 5 mm increments. This scale works fine when the total range in the size of objects is small, such as illustrating the sizes of five objects from the size of a bumble bee (~24 mm long) to the size of a pinhead (~1 mm in diameter). Can you estimate the size of each object in the scale? Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) Int_Scale_PK12_PG_040813 Page 8 of 22 Comparison of Scale - PK Logarithmic Scales Logarithmic Scale But what happens when the range becomes bigger (e.g. from 1.5 Gm to 5 μm)? In such a comparison, a linear scale is not practical, nor as effective; therefore, a logarithmic scale could be used (above). A logarithmic scale uses the logarithm of a physical quantity rather than the quantity itself. It is effective for comparing the relative size of objects when the actual range in size is huge. The above graph covers a range from the diameter of the sun (1.39 Gm) to the size of a pin head (1.5 mm). Imagine how long a linear graph would be that compared these objects. Linear vs. Logarithmic These two graphs above illustrate the exact same information, but look how different they look. They both show the increase in the number of transistors per die from 1970 to 1995. The graph on the top is a linear scale and the one on the bottom is a logarithmic scale. Notice in the linear scale, the growth is easily seen as being exponential. In the log scale, it almost looks linear; however, since it is logarithmic, you can easily see that the growth between 1970 and 1975 went from over 1000 to just under 10,000 transistors per die. Between 1990 and 1995, the growth was from 1,000,000 to almost 10,000,000 per die! That's a significantly larger increase. By 2008 transistors per die has increased to over 200 million! Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) Int_Scale_PK12_PG_040813 Page 9 of 22 Comparison of Scale - PK Macro vs. Microdevices When comparing macroscopic devices to their micro equivalents, the micro devices are much smaller, much lighter, more energy efficient, and constructed with fewer materials. In equivalent applications, such as sensors or transducers, microdevices exceed their macroscopic equivalents in reliability, efficiency, selectivity, response time, and energy consumption. Micro-sized objects allow us to go places where no objects have gone before. Microtechnology "Microtechnology is the art of creating, manufacturing or using miniature components, equipment and systems that have been mass produced. The first and foremost feature in this field is its multidisciplinary nature, as microtechnology systems use electronic, computerised, chemical, mechanical and optical elements as well as various other materials." [Federal School of Polytechnics]5 The products of Microtechnology are microsystems and microsystem components. Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) Int_Scale_PK12_PG_040813 Page 10 of 22 Comparison of Scale - PK What are Microsystems? Microsystems are miniaturized integrated systems in a small package or more specifically, micro-sized components working together as a system and assembled into a package that fits on a pinhead (see figure above). In the United States, these devices are referred to as microelectromechanical systems or MEMS. European countries referred to such devices as microsystems or MST. These two terms – MEMS and MST – are often used interchangeably. Microsystems are microscopic, integrated, self-aware, stand-alone products that can sense, think, communicate and act. Some systems can do all of these things, plus scavenge for power. Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) Int_Scale_PK12_PG_040813 Three MEMS blood pressure sensors on a pin head [Photo courtesy of Lucas NovaSensor, Fremont, CA] Page 11 of 22 Comparison of Scale - PK Microsystems Applications MicroFluidic pump used for inkjet printheads (The piezoelectric crystal expands and contracts to move fluid from the reservoir through the nozzle) Ink Jet Print Heads (see figure) Automobile applications (flowrates, tire and oil pressures, crash sensors, airbag deployment) Biomedical applications (drug delivery, diagnostics, therapeutics) Optical applications (digital light processing, microopticalelectromechanical systems, digital mirror devices) Homeland security (gas detections, motion detectors) Environmental applications (earthquake, volcano and tsunami sensors, atmospheric sensors) RF (Radio Frequency) MEMS (digital communications, switching) Mass Storage Devices Aerospace (leak detection, vibration sensors, positioning, navigation, monitoring space personnel health) Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) Int_Scale_PK12_PG_040813 Page 12 of 22 Comparison of Scale - PK Nano meets Micro The smaller microsystems become the smaller their components become. For example, IBM has been working on a read/write storage device that can fit 1 Terabit of data on a surface the size of a standard postage stamp. 6 In order to do this, the "bit-making" component needs to be nanosize, not micro-size. Hence the overlap occurs of micro and nano devices. In the IBM read/write storage devices, the cantilevers are approximately 2 microns wide while the read/write tip is approximately 10 nm wide at the apex (see figure right). MEMS Read/Write Storage Device (IBM Millipede – prototype) [Photo courtesy of IBM] Nanotechnology The term Nanotechnology is so new, that how it is defined, depends on who you ask. Below are some definitions of Nanotechnology: "Nanotechnology is the understanding and control of matter at dimensions of roughly 1 to 100 nanometers, where unique phenomena enable novel applications. Encompassing nanoscale science, engineering and technology, nanotechnology involves imaging, measuring, modeling, and manipulating matter at this length scale." National Nanotechnology Initiative (NNI) "Research and technology development at the atomic, molecular or macromolecular levels, in the length scale of approximately 1-100nm range. Creation and use of structures, devices and systems that have novel properties and functions because of their small and/or intermediate size. An ability to control or manipulate on the atomic scale." MANCEF Roadmap 2nd Edition, p.161 (based on NNI) "The name nanotechnology originates from [the] nanometer. In the processing of materials, the smallest bit size of stock removal, accretion or flow of materials is probably of one atom or one molecule namely 0.1-0.2nm in length. Therefore, the expected limit size of fineness would be of the order of 1nm. Accordingly, nanotechnology mainly consists of the processing of separation, consolidation and deformation of materials by one atom or one molecule." N. Taniguchi, "on the Basic Concept of Nanotechnology," Proc. Intl. Conf. Prod. Eng. Tokyo, Part II – Japan Society of Precision Engineering, 1974 Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) Int_Scale_PK12_PG_040813 Page 13 of 22 Comparison of Scale - PK Nanoscience Structure of a bacterial flagellar motor. The flagellum is used to move the bacterium through the system. The flagellum is powered by the rotary engine anchor to the cell wall and powered by proton motive force. The rotor can rotate at speeds as high as 17,000 revolutions per minute, moving the flagellar filament at speeds as high as 1000 rpms. Microtechnology is studying this biomolecular devices to see if it can be manufactured and use to move cargo such as medicine to specific parts of the body..7 [Image courtesy of LadyofHats] Nanotechnology, or more specifically, nanoscience has been around for quite a long time. Nanoscience is concerned with the study of novel phenomena and properties of materials that occur at extremely small length scales. Physicists and biologists have been studying nanodevices such as cells, molecules, and atoms for years, and in some cases, centuries. In the 18th century, John Dalton, a British chemist and physicist, made the earliest steps toward recognizing that matter was composed of atoms. In 1952, a series of experiments by Alfred Hershey and Martha Chase, known as the "Hershey-Chase Blender Experiments", supported the role of DNA as the carrier of genetic information. Nanotechnology is the application of nanoscale science, engineering and technology to produce novel materials and devices. Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) Int_Scale_PK12_PG_040813 Page 14 of 22 Comparison of Scale - PK So what is Nano? Nano is a lot of things: Anything less than 100 nm in any dimension regardless of how it was made. Anything made by specifically placing materials atom by atom or molecule by molecule. Anything made from the bottom up (one atom at a time). Anything with unique properties because of its small size (Some of the laws of physics that apply to macroscopic objects, do not apply to nano-size objects). Micro vs. Nanotechnology In addition to the actual size of the objects, fabrication is another primary difference between micro and nanotechnology. Nanotechnology normally uses what is referred to as the "bottom up" approach to fabrication. Microtechnology normally uses the "top down" approach. Bottom up Assembling a quantum corral [Images courtesy of IBM STM Image Gallery] The bottom up approach means a structure is made by building it atom by atom or molecule by molecule from the bottom up. Each individual atom or molecule is manipulated or controlled for correct placement. The figure on the left (above) shows four stages in the assembly of a quantum corral. The figure on the right (above) shows the final assembly of a corral that has been made by placing 48 iron atoms in a circle, one at a time, onto the surface of gold. So what does the bottom up approach sound like? Nature or the building of a living object. The cells of a seed multiply to become a full blown tree. The tree continues to grow by taking individual atoms and molecules and assembling its leaves. Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) Int_Scale_PK12_PG_040813 Page 15 of 22 Comparison of Scale - PK Top down Creating suspended cantilevers using the top down approach The top down approach selectively removes material until the desired structure is achieved. In semiconductor and some MEMS processes, one applies a pattern, selectively etches away exposed material and ends up with a circuit or component (as illustrated above). The above graphic shows how microcantilevers (red) are initially incorporated into a block of layered material. By removing the layer below (green), the microcantilevers are released and suspended over the substrate (blue). What does the top down approach sound like? Sculpturing A sculptor can start with a tree trunk and by removing select pieces of the tree, end up with a totem pole, bird, desk, or any desired object. What about Mount Rushmore? How was that made? Start with a cliff, and remove everything that doesn’t look like a president! Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) Int_Scale_PK12_PG_040813 Page 16 of 22 Comparison of Scale - PK Shrinking Technology The space of one transistor, now holds hundreds of transistors (graphic not to scale) Semiconductors have evolved over the years with technological advancements in the deposition of materials and the selective removal of materials through the photolithography and etch processes. Deposition layers have become thinner and etched widths have become smaller (see figure). A deposited gate oxide layer used to be 20 microns or larger. Now it can be as thin as 1 nm! Gate widths, patterned and subsequently etched have shrunk from more than 1 micron dimensions to less that 50 nm! Since today's semiconductor manufacturing processes are creating structures less than 100 nm, this technology can be considered Nanotechnology. Nano meets Micro As devices shrink, the necessity to use nanosized objects when constructing micro-sized devices increases. Take for instance the electronic electrodes shown in the figure to the right. The image on the left shows carbon nanotubes (green) linked to four electronic leads (gold). The leads were made using a standard semiconductor technology deposition of metal by evaporation, followed by lithography and etch for the electrode pattern. The carbon nanotubes were deposited onto the chip from solution and located using an Atomic Force Microscope (AFM). Attaching the nanotubes to the leads required the "find 'em and wire 'em" technique. [University of California – Berkeley]8 This technique does not lend itself to high volume production! [The right graphic is an illustration of a carbon nanotube from the Southwest Center for Microsystems Education.] Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) Int_Scale_PK12_PG_040813 Nanotube connectors for microelectronics [University of California – Berkeley, Image source: Office of Basic Energy Sciences, U.S. DOE] Page 17 of 22 Comparison of Scale - PK BioMEMS One of the greatest applications for micro / nano devices is in the biomedical field. The overlap between microbiology and microsystem feature sizes makes integration between the two possible. Devices fabricated for the medical field are referred to as bioMEMS. Examples of BioMEMS Drug delivery system using a micropump and nanosized needles Examples of BioMEMS are Drug delivery systems with nanosize needles and microsize pumps Diagnostics arrays that use microcantilevers and nano coatings (monolayers) to capture nanosize particles. Artificial Retina Prostheses that use an electrode microarray implanted on the retina. Micro-sized laboratories for analyzing liquid samples such as blood, urine and sputum. Numerous devices used for diagnostic and therapeutic applications Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) Int_Scale_PK12_PG_040813 Page 18 of 22 Comparison of Scale - PK A Biosensor A gold dot, about 50 nanometers in diameter, fused to the end of a cantilevered oscillator about 4 micrometers long. A one-molecule-thick layer of a sulfur-containing chemical deposited on the gold adds a mass of about 6 attograms, which is more than enough to measure.10 [Printed with permission Craighead Group/Cornell University and © Cornell University] A biosensor is a devices used to detect, capture and analyze analytes (i.e. antibodies, antigens, proteins) within a sample solution. The biosensor in the figure consists of a gold dot, about 50 nanometers in diameter, fused to the end of a cantilever oscillator about 4 micrometers long. A one-molecule-thick layer (monolayer) of a sulfur-containing chemical is deposited on the gold. An external excitation causes the cantilever to oscillate. This biosensor cantilever could be used to detect and collect e-coli cells in a sample. The cells would stick to the chemically treated layer on the gold dot adding a few attograms of mass to the cantilever. Even though a few attograms is very small, it is enough to affect a measurable change in the oscillations of the cantilever. This allows the concentration of e. coli cells in the sample to be measured. Matching Activity Match the following components with their scale Component 1 Strain of hair 2 A molecule 3 75 nm 4 233 mm 5 48 microns 6 Pollen A B C Scale Macro Micro Nano Table 2: Components and Their Scale Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) Int_Scale_PK12_PG_040813 Page 19 of 22 Comparison of Scale - PK Summary Milky Way (left) [Image courtesy of NASA/JPL-Caltech] Quantum Corral of 48 iron atoms [Courtesy of IBM STM Gallery] How big is big? How small is small? It depends on the scale. A macro-scale can be millions of times bigger than a microscale. The microscale is a thousand times bigger than the nanoscale. In the macro-scale, the earth is small when compared to the sun, but huge compared to a baseball. In the micro / nano-scales, an 8 micron wide red blood cell is huge compared to a 2 nm diameter carbon nanotube. The discovery of nano-sized particles has made an already big universe even bigger. Distances are now measured in lengths from light years to nanometers (see pictures above). Modern technologies are taking advantage of the wide range of sizes in order to improve existing processes and develop new ones. Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) Int_Scale_PK12_PG_040813 Page 20 of 22 Comparison of Scale - PK Food For Thought How have discoveries in the microscale affected the study of the universe? How have discoveries in the micro and nano-scales affected our daily lives? In today's world, what is small? References 1. To see the Universe in a Grain of Taranaki Sand, by glen Mackie. http://astronomy.swin.edu.au/~gmackie/billions.html 2. Milky Way Image. "Our Milky Way Gets a Makeover". NASA/JPL-Caltech. 06/03/08. http://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/spitzer/multimedia/20080603a.html 3. Image credits from NASA.gov: Sun and Earth(Image credit: World Book illustration by Roberta Polfus), Earth (Image credit: NASA/Goddard Space Flight Center), Sun (Image credit: NASA/Transition Region & Coronal Explorer), Greek Islands (NASA/GSFC/LaRC/JPL, MISR Team), MEMS Gyroscope (NASA Jet Propulsion Laboratory) 4. Image of Nanowire looped on human hair. NSF image. Credit: Limin Tong/Harvard University. http://www.nsf.gov/od/lpa/news/03/pr03147_images.htm 5. "Microtechnology". Micronora.com. http://www.micronora.com/ref/microtechnologies.htm 6. "IBM's Millipede Project Demonstrates Trillion-Bit Data Storage Density". IBM Research. Zurich. June 22, 2002. 7. "EU supports research towards the construction of nanomotors". Max Planck Institute for Biophysical Chemistry. Nanowerks News. March 16, 2006. 8. "Carbon Nanotube Electronics". Nanoelectronics Research Group. Department of Physics. University of Maryland. http://www.physics.umd.edu/condmat/mfuhrer/ntresearch.htm 9. Quantum Corral Images. IBM STM Image Gallery. http://www.almaden.ibm.com/vis/stm/stm.html and http://www.almaden.ibm.com/vis/stm/corral.html 10. Silicon Atoms Image. “Observing the Wings of Atoms”. Feng Lui. University of Utah News and Public Relations. June 2, 2003. http://web.utah.edu/news/releases/03/jun/orbitals.html 11. Image of micro-sized gears (Macro, micro, nano) – Courtesy of Sandia National Laboratories. www.mems.sandia.gov 12. Micro to Nano – An Introduction. Mathius Pleil, SCME, CNM 13. Microtechnology Education Resource Center (MERC) Related SCME Units (can be downloaded from scme-nm.org) Units of Weights and Measures PK Units of Weights and Measures Activity Conversion of Weights and Measures Activity Scale Activity: Cut to Size Scale Activity: The Scale of Biomolecules Scale Activity: Zoom In / Zoom Out Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) Int_Scale_PK12_PG_040813 Page 21 of 22 Comparison of Scale - PK Glossary Linear Scale: A scale each increment and incremental increase is equal to the one before. Logarithmic Scale: A scale that uses increments in powers of 10 Macroscopic: Objects greater than 100 microns or visible to the naked eye MEMS: Microelectromechanical Systems Micro: A scale between 0.1 μm and 100 μm Micrometer: One thousandths of a meter (10-6 meter) Micron: A unit of measurement equal to 1 milli Torr or 1 millionth of a meter. Nano: A scale between 0.1 nm and 100 nm Nanometer: One billionth of a meter (10-9 meter) Nanotechnology: Technology involved with design and fabrication of devices and thin films with dimensions in the nanometer range (1E-9 m). Support for this work was provided by the National Science Foundation's Advanced Technological Education (ATE) Program. Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) Int_Scale_PK12_PG_040813 Page 22 of 22 Comparison of Scale - PK Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) University of New Mexico MEMS BioMEMS Topic The Scale of Biomolecules Activity SCO This SCO is part of the Learning Modules Biomolecular Applications for bioMEMS and Scale Target audiences: High School, Community College, University Support for this work was provided by the National Science Foundation's Advanced Technological Education (ATE) Program through Grants #DUE 0830384 and 0902411. This Learning Module was developed in conjunction with Bio-Link, a National Science Foundation Advanced Technological Education (ATE) Center for Biotechnology @ www.bio-link.org. Any opinions, findings and conclusions or recommendations expressed in this material are those of the authors and creators, and do not necessarily reflect the views of the National Science Foundation. Copyright © by the Southwest Center for Microsystems Education and The Regents of the University of New Mexico Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) 800 Bradbury Drive SE, Suite 235 Albuquerque, NM 87106-4346 Phone: 505-272-7150 Website: www.scme-nm.org The Scale of Biomolecules Activity Participant Guide Description and Estimated Time to Complete This activity is an exploration of the scale of biomolecules (nucleic acids, carbohydrates, proteins, and lipids). You will identify the relationship between the sizes of different biomolecules and cells. An understanding of the size of cells and biomolecules allows you to better understand how these components can be used within MEMS devices and as bioMEMS devices. Estimated Time to Complete Allow approximately 45 minutes to complete Introduction Nanoscience is concerned with the study of novel phenomena and properties of materials that occur at extremely small scales. Nanotechnology is the application of nanoscale science, engineering and technology to produce novel materials and devices. "Nanotechnology is the understanding and control of matter at dimensions of roughly 1 to 100 nanometers, where unique phenomena enable novel applications. Encompassing nanoscale science, engineering and technology, nanotechnology involves imaging, measuring, modeling, and manipulating matter at this length scale. " National Nanotechnology Initiative (NNI) BioMEMS is one of the outcomes of the merging of Nanotechnology and Microelectromechanical Systems (MEMS). Biomolecules are enabling the design and fabrication of MEMS devices with components in both the micro and nanoscales. BioMEMS takes advantage of the properties of biomolecules to do the same work as fabricated components. To better understand Micro and Nanotechnologies, it is important to understand the components and the size of these components relative to each other. Activity Objectives and Outcomes Activity Objectives Demonstrate your understanding of the relative size of biomolecules by creating an illustration that consists of correctly proportioned molecules joined to other molecules and cells. Describe two applications of biomolecules in MEMS. Activity Outcomes You will be become familiar with the scale of cells and biomolecules and how they are used in bioMEMS devices. Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) Int_Scale_AC13_PG_040413 Page 2 of 4 The Scale of Biomolecules Activity Supplies This activity can be completed using a graphics software program such as PowerPoint. If no such program is available, then a paper graphic can be constructed with the following supplies. Per participant or team One large sheet of graph paper Ruler Colored markers Pictures of items in the following table - "Relative size of Biomolecules in Nanometers". Pictures can be drawn or downloaded from the internet. If downloaded, adjust the size of each object relative to the size given in the activity table before printing. Activity – The Scale of Biomolecules Complete one of the following two procedures using the table on the next page – Relative Size of Biomolecules in Nanometers. Procedure 1: Using a graphics program or a large sheet of graph paper and printed or drawn pictures, create a scaled graphic of the following: A red blood cell attached to a spore, which is attached to a bacterium, which is attached to a liposome vesicle, attached to a tobacco mosaic virus. Add a porin channel to the liposome vesicle. Place a 10,000 nm long flagellum on the bacterium. Even though your graphic will be in the macroscale, you must maintain the correct proportion to the actual sizes of the objects. The actual size of each object is listed in the table Relative Size of Biomolecules in Nanometers.. Procedure II: Using a graphics program or a large sheet of graph paper and printed or drawn pictures, create a scaled graphic of ALL of the objects in the table (Relative Size of Biomolecules in Nanometers) illustrating relative sizes and the correct size proportions. Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) Int_Scale_AC13_PG_040413 Page 3 of 4 The Scale of Biomolecules Activity Relative Size of Biomolecules in Nanometers Object Hydrogen atom Water molecule, H2O Amino acid DNA (width) Cell membrane Ferritin iron-storage protein Bacterial S-layer Porin channel Actin filament Intermediate filament Microtubule Bacterial flagellum Tobacco mosaic virus Magnetosome crystals Liposome vesicle Pores in synthetic membrane Bacterial cell Spores Red blood cell Human hair Diameter (nm) 0.1 0.3 1 2.5 5-9 12 5-35 4-10 5-9 10 25 12-25 18 35-150 100 (minimum) Inside diameter (nm) 8 2-8 2-3 12-15 2-3 4 85 (minimum) 200 (minimum) 250 (minimum) 1000 (maximum) 1,000-8,000 6,000-8,000 60,000 to 100,000 Post-Activity Question Briefly discuss two applications of biomolecules as a component in a MEMS or bioMEMS device. Your discussions should include the sources of your information as well as how the devices works and the function of the biomolecule within the device. Summary It is important to understand the actual size of an object to better understand its function and application in a bioMEMS device. The nanoscale of biomolecules enables functions to be performed that were not possible a few years ago. We now have the technology to incorporate nanosize particles such as short chains of DNA, antibodies, proteins, and other biomolecules into a fabricated MEMS. SCME Resources Biomolecular Applications for bioMEMS Learning Module (Can be downloaded from scmenm.org. Select Educational Materials/BioMEMS) Support for this work was provided by the National Science Foundation's Advanced Technological Education (ATE) Program. This Learning Module was developed in conjunction with Bio-Link, a National Science Foundation Advanced Technological Education (ATE) Center for Biotechnology @ www.bio-link.org. Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) Int_Scale_AC13_PG_040413 Page 4 of 4 The Scale of Biomolecules Activity Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) University of New Mexico MEMS Introduction Topic Scale Activity: Zoom In / Zoom Out Shareable Content Object (SCO) This SCO is part of the Learning Module Scale Target audiences: High School, Community College, University Support for this work was provided by the National Science Foundation's Advanced Technological Education (ATE) Program through Grants #DUE 0830384 and 0902411. Any opinions, findings and conclusions or recommendations expressed in this material are those of the authors and creators, and do not necessarily reflect the views of the National Science Foundation. Copyright © by the Southwest Center for Microsystems Education and The Regents of the University of New Mexico Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) 800 Bradbury Drive SE, Suite 235 Albuquerque, NM 87106-4346 Phone: 505-272-7150 Website: www.scme-nm.org Scale Activity: Zoom In / Zoom Out Activity Participant Guide Description and Estimated Time to Complete As you learned in the Scale unit and other activities, macro objects consist of micro and nano-sized objects. In this activity you will illustrate what you've learned about the various scales by creating an illustration of an object and the various sized objects that it contains. For example, you could start with a macro-sized object (such as a human) and slowly zoom in to its nano-sized components (like DNA). You may also choose to go the other way and zoom out from the nano-sized object to the macro-sized object. To get you started, we'll take you through the universe to our galaxy, to earth, to man, and end up somewhere inside of the human body to parts yet unknown. Estimated Time to Complete You should set aside approximately 2 – 3 hours to complete this activity. Introduction Exploring the universe involves the study of the objects within it as well as its composition. Measurements and comparisons are constantly being made in an effort to discover something new and to move closer to how big the universe could be. While astronomers have been trying to figure out how big the universe really is, scientists and engineers have been exploring how small things are and how small something has to be before it cannot be manipulated or measured. So what have these scientist found? In this activity, you will illustrate what these scientists have found. Activity Objectives and Outcomes Activity Objective Illustrate the relationship of scale by breaking an object into its various sized components: macro (> 100 microns), micro, nano. Calculate how much bigger (in powers of 10) one object is over another object in a different scale. Activity Outcomes The outcome of this activity should illustrate your understanding of how objects are constructed from smaller objects all the way down to the nano-scale and beyond. At the end of this activity you Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) Int_Scale_AC15_PG_040413 Page 2 of 6 Zoom In / Zoom Out Activity should be able to answer the following questions: When constructing micro-sized objects, would it be more logical to construct the object from the bottom up or from the top down? Be prepared to justify your answer. When constructing nano-sized objects, would it be more logical to construct the object from the bottom up or from the top down? Be prepared to justify your answer. Team You can do this activity by yourself or with one other participant. Supplies The supplies that you need for this activity is dependent upon how you choose to illustrate the assignment. Resources Exploring the World of Optics and Microscopy. Molecular Expressions. http://micro.magnet.fsu.edu/index.html Virtual Scanning Electron Microscopy. Molecular Expressions. Interactive Java Tutorial. http://micro.magnet.fsu.edu/primer/java/electronmicroscopy/magnify1/index.html Introduction to Optical Microscopy, Digital Imaging, and Photomicrography. Molecular Expressions. http://micro.magnet.fsu.edu/primer/index.html Secret Worlds: The Universe Within. Molecular Expressions. Interactive Tutorial. http://micro.magnet.fsu.edu/primer/java/scienceopticsu/powersof10/ Documentation Your documentation will include (but not limited to) the following items: A discussion of each on-line tutorial and answers to questions about the tutorials. A short description of your project – what you are going to illustrate. A visual presentation of your illustration. It could be animated PowerPoint, flash animation, physical model, manual flip animation, or expanded drawing. Answers to Post-Activity Questions Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) Int_Scale_AC15_PG_040413 Page 3 of 6 Zoom In / Zoom Out Activity Activity: Zoom In / Zoom Out Description In this activity you should demonstrate what you have learned about the various scales by creating an illustration of an object and the various sized objects that it contains. 1. Complete an on-line tutorial. Description a. Read the following instructions BEFORE going to the tutorial. b. Go to http://micro.magnet.fsu.edu/primer/java/scienceopticsu/powersof10/ and put the tutorial in the Manual Mode. (Click on the "manual" button) c. Familiarize yourself with the screen. Find where the name and the size of the objects are illustrated. d. Zoom In – Read what the object is and its size. e. Answer the following questions: What is the first object in the micro-scale? How big is this object? What is the first object in the nano-scale? How big is this object? How much bigger is the "oak tree leaf" to the "cells on the leaf's surface"? How big is an individual leaf cell? How big is the nucleus of a carbon atom? (Use a metric prefix.) How much bigger is the nucleus of a leaf cell than the nucleus of a carbon atom? Now Zoom Out. 2. Complete another on-line tutorial. Description a. Go to http://micro.magnet.fsu.edu/primer/java/electronmicroscopy/magnify1/in dex.html b. Zoom in and out on several objects in this tutorial. c. "Play" with the four slider controls and figure out what they do. What type of analytical tool was used to capture these images? When viewing these images, what effect did the amount of light (brightness) have on the object's details? Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) Int_Scale_AC15_PG_040413 Page 4 of 6 Zoom In / Zoom Out Activity 3. Layout your illustration. Description a. Pick an object that you would like to create your own zoom in or zoom out. b. Ideas: Pencil, piece of fruit, any animal (chicken, cat, etc.), MP3 player c. Outline how you will present this object from the macro to nano-scale or vice versa. 4. Create your illustration. Description Create an illustration with at least 15 steps covering three scales that carry the viewer from a nano-sized object to a macro-sized object (zoom out) or vice versa (zoom in). Here are some ideas on how to create your illustration. You are welcome to use other methods. a. Animated PowerPoint presentation b. Flash animation c. Physical model d. Manual flip animation e. Expanded drawing For each step in your illustration indicate what the object is and its size. 5. Present your illustration. Description Present your illustration to your instructor and other participants of this activity. Solicit feedback. What were the strengths and weaknesses? What could have made it better? What is accurate? If not, where were the inaccuracies? Was this a good illustration for what you were trying to represent? If not, why not? 6. Answer the Post-Activity Questions. Description Answer the Post-Activity Questions at the end of this procedure. 7. Complete your documentation. Complete your documentation as outlined in the previous Documentation Section. 8. Submit your illustration and documentation. Description Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) Int_Scale_AC15_PG_040413 Page 5 of 6 Zoom In / Zoom Out Activity Post-Activity Questions 1. When constructing micro-sized objects, would it be more logical to construct the object from the bottom up or from the top down? Explain the reasoning behind your answer. 2. When constructing nano-sized objects, would it be more logical to construct the object from the bottom up or from the top down? Explain the reasoning behind your answer. 3. What type of analytical tools enable scientist to see objects in the micro and the nanoscales? (List at least three. Briefly discuss each. In your discussion identify the distinct differences between the tools in relation to "what" they can see.) Summary In this activity you continued to explore what matter is made of and how small matter can be. References A Comparison of Scale: Macro, Micro, and Nano PK Scale Inquiry Activity: Cut to Size Support for this work was provided by the National Science Foundation's Advanced Technological Education (ATE) Program. Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) Int_Scale_AC15_PG_040413 Page 6 of 6 Zoom In / Zoom Out Activity Southwest Center for Microsystems Education (SCME) Learning Modules available for download @ scme-nm.org MEMS Introductory Topics MEMS Fabrication MEMS History MEMS: Making Micro Machines DVD and LM (Kit available) Units of Weights and Measures A Comparison of Scale: Macro, Micro, and Nano Introduction to Transducers, Sensors and Actuators Wheatstone Bridge (Pressure Sensor Model Kit available) MEMS Applications Overview Microcantilevers (Dynamic Cantilever Kit available) Micropumps Overview Crystallography for Microsystems (Breaking Wafers and Origami Crystal Kits available) Oxidation Overview for Microsystems (Rainbow Wafer Kit available) Deposition Overview Microsystems Photolithography Overview for Microsystems Etch Overview for Microsystems (Rainbow Wafer and Anisotropic Etch Kits available) MEMS Micromachining Overview LIGA Micromachining Simulation Activities (LIGA Simulation Kit available) Manufacturing Technology Training Center Pressure Sensor Process (Three Activity Kits available) MEMS Innovators Activity (Activity Kit available) BioMEMS Safety BioMEMS Overview BioMEMS Applications Overview DNA Overview DNA to Protein Overview Cells – The Building Blocks of Life Biomolecular Applications for bioMEMS BioMEMS Therapeutics Overview BioMEMS Diagnostics Overview Clinical Laboratory Techniques and MEMS MEMS for Environmental and Bioterrorism Applications Regulations of bioMEMS DNA Microarrays (GeneChip® Model Kit available) Hazardous Materials Material Safety Data Sheets Interpreting Chemical Labels / NFPA Chemical Lab Safety Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) MEMS Applications Revision: 5/20/11 Check our website regularly for the most recent versions of our Learning Modules. For more information about SCME and its Learning Modules and kits, visit our website scme-nm.org or contact Dr. Matthias Pleil at mpleil@unm.edu www.scme-nm.org