UNC Charlotte Department of Geography and Earth Sciences Building Stone Walking Tour of Uptown Charlotte John Diemer (jadiemer@uncc.edu), Martha Cary Eppes (meppes@uncc.edu), John Bender (jfbender@uncc.edu, Emily Henke, Jennifer Aldred, Seth Brazell, Brian Biggers, and Suzanne Jones; University of North Carolina at Charlotte Charlotte, North Carolina is the largest city in the Carolinas (population ~750,000, 1.7 million in the metropolitan area) and is one of the major banking and investment centers of the world. The city dates to the late 18th century and has gone through multiple episodes of urban renewal throughout its history. Charlotte was the location of a gold-rush in the early 19th century and was subsequently the location of the first United States Mint located outside of Philadelphia. Today the “uptown” area of Charlotte is dominated by 20th and 21st century glass and steel skyscrapers; the 60 story Bank of America building is the tallest building between Philadelphia and Atlanta. In the process of more than two centuries of urban development, building stones have taken on an important role in construction of everything from pavers, curb stones, and street level planters, to building cladding, and floors and walls of building lobbies. Historic buildings, principally churches, have survived the redevelopment of uptown, and they also contain significant building stones as foundations, stairways, lintels and other architectural elements. Here we present a sampling of the wide variety of building stones readily visible in uptown Charlotte construction. The guide is the product of the collective effort of graduate students, undergraduate students, alumni and faculty from the Department of Geography and Earth Sciences at the University of North Carolina at Charlotte. In this guide, we attempt to describe each building, including its history, the building stones used in its construction, their specific geologic information, and whenever possible, the provenance of the origins of the visible building stones. We attempted to include information at each stop that would appeal to the expert, but also inform the novice. The tour begins at the College Street entrance of the Charlotte Convention Center and winds its way north along Tryon Street to 7th Avenue. There the tour heads east to the light rail line and makes its way back south toward the Convention Center. Although definitions of terms are generally given in that order, the guide is designed to be accessible at any of the locations. Enjoy your tour of Uptown Charlotte and its various types of Building Stones! An electronic version of this guide is available as a PDF on the GSA website (www.geosociety.org) or as a Google Map at http://goo.gl/maps/xb96 UPTOWN ROCKS: a walking tour of Charlotte City Center Annual Meeting of the Geological Society of America Building Stone Walking Tour of Uptown Charlotte Charlotte, North Carolina; November 2012 7th street Q P LEVINE 7TH STREET STATION DISCOVERY PLACE 6th street O HEARST N 5th street ARENA MAIN BOA R M S trade street ARENA STATION L INTERSTATE CTC LEGEND Visually Stunning Rocks K EPICENTER SUNTRUST Sedimentary Rock 4th street Metamorphic Rock J Igneous Rock BB&T More than one type 3rd street Building G F 2nd street/MLK H E 1 WELLS FARGO A CONVENTION NASCAR O RT H CENTER N ENERGY college street DUKE D B Lynx Light Rail I 3WF 1st C Overstreet Mall STATION THE GREEN tryon street church street BOA#2 HILTON brevard street LATTA T 3RD STREET caldwell street 2WF STONEWALL STREET STATION 500 ft 200 m page 2 Stop A: The Green College Street and 2nd Street The 1.5 acre urban pocket park known as the Green is located between the 400 block of South Tryon and South College Streets, immediately west of the Charlotte Convention Center. Designed by Wagner Murray Architects of Charlotte, it was completed in 2002 and sits directly on top of a 7-level underground parking structure. fig3 This fine-grained quartz sandstone was quarried near Crossville, Tennessee. Red iron staining highlights cross-bedding on some specimens. The high quartz content in this sandstone, deposited along the coast of an inland sea that covered most of North America in the Mississippian, about 340 million years ago, has made it a desirable and durable building stone. It is called a fieldstone because it has been left in its natural state. A2: Sandstone capping retaining walls This fine-grained, plane-bedded sandstone, used throughout the Green as retaining wall caps, was also quarried near Crossville, TN. One of the capstones on the southern side of the plaza has ripple marks (Figure 3), others have parting lineation (the small ridges evident on bedding planes where the stone has split). This stone was likely formed in a deltaic setting associated with the inland sea mentioned for A1 above, as evidenced by its plant fossils (Figure 4). Can you find a plant fossil in one of these stones? Figure 2. Stop A1: Tennessee Fieldstone Figure 3. Stop A2: Tennessee Bluestone ripple marks fig4 fig2 Ratcliffe on the Green A1: Sandstone blocks in the retaining wall Figure 1. Stop A: The Green Figure 4. Stop A2: Tennessee Bluestone plant fossils page 3 A3: Upper sections of the pillars on the ‘Ratcliffe on the Green’ building This limestone is a packstone (according to the Dunham classification scheme) meaning it is grain supported and the pores between the grains are filled with calcareous mud. It has a fine to medium grained texture (you can see individual grains without magnification), and contains a type of fossilized shell fragments known as bivalved molluscs, such as those visible in Figure 5. Figure 5. Stop A3: Fossiliferous limestone Many limestones form in warm, shallow seas where organisms with shells composed of calcite (CaCO3) accumulate layer by layer and eventually become lithified into a limestone. This example contains fossilized shell fragments and ooids (small spherical grains). Pull out your hand lens, because ooids are particles < 2mm in diameter that form when individual aragonite grains accumulate concentric layers of carbonate as they roll around on the shallow sea floor. Can you find the ooids? How many different other fossils can you observe in this building stone? A4: Pillar bases on the ‘Ratcliffe on the Green’ building This light colored packstone is composed of medium to coarsegrained skeletal fragments of shells, peloids and possibly ooids. The skeletal fragments are best seen on the cut edges of the blocks. Figure 6. Stop A4: Packstone/limestone Stop B: St. Peter’s Catholic Church 507 S. Tryon Street, Charlotte, NC 28202 The cornerstone of the original St. Peter’s Catholic Church was laid in 1851 at the corner of Tryon and First Street. St. Peter’s remained the only Roman Catholic church in Charlotte for the next 90 years. A munitions explosion at the end of the Civil War damaged the foundation of the original building. The cornerstone for the current building was laid in 1893. At the time, the church was on the southern limits of Charlotte, surrounded by empty lots. According to Charles A. Hastings, the architect for the recent renovation of the church, the structure is of Victorian gothic style, simplified to a Germanic starkness prevalent in the post-war South. Victorian details such as the basket weave brick panel in the bell tower, fish scale slate roof, and just a hint of gingerbread on the steeple dormers suggest the era’s love for repeated design motifs. B1: Church façade Can you determine how many different igneous rocks were used in the façade and adjacent pavement? We found at least four. These rocks are Silurian and Devonian aged granites locally derived from the Charlotte Belt, commonly interpreted as an exotic terrane accreted to North America during early to middle Paleozoic time. Can you spot the one piece of marble on the church property? Figure 7. Stop B1: Various granites and one marble page 4 Stop C: Mint Museum Plaza 500 South Tryon Street, Charlotte, NC 28202 Opened on October 1, 2010, the Mint Museum Uptown is a five-story building designed by Machado and Silvetti Associates of Boston. It houses the Mint Museum of Craft + Design as well as American, contemporary, and European art collections. The plaza in front of the Mint Museum Uptown is covered with a checkerboard of pavers composed of intrusive igneous rocks including gabbros and diorites (Figure 8). Figure 8. Stop C: Mint Museum gabbro and diorite pavers C1: Gabbro pavers The dark-colored gabbro pavers have interstitial pyroxenes and plagioclase feldspar with bladed laths (Figure 9). The upper platform also has smaller pavers composed of this rock. C2: Lighter pavers The diorite pavers contain xenoliths (pieces of ‘foreign’ rock that get incorporated into the magma without completely melting) of at least two different rock types, mostly fine grained basalts and diabases (Figure 10-11). Who in your group can stand on the biggest xenolith? We found one that is 8 cm in length! Figure 9. Stop C1: Gabbro pavers Figure 10-11. Stop C2: Diorite pavers with xenoliths page 5 Stop D: Duke Energy Center and the Harvey Gantt Center 400 South Tryon Street and 551 S. Tryon Street Completed in 2010 this 48 floor (764 feet) LEED Gold certified office building was designed by Thompson, Ventulett, Stainback & Associates, Jenkins-Peer Architects, and the Frelon Group. Despite its LEED status, the building stones were quarried from all over the world. Completed in 2009, the four level, 46,500-square-foot Gantt Center was designed by the Frelon Group Architects. It is located in the area once occupied by the historic Brooklyn neighborhood, a black community razed in the 1960s. Inspired by the former Myers Street School, with its prominent exterior staircases, the building’s exterior utilizes patterns reminiscent of quilt designs from the Underground Railroad era and woven textile patterns from West Africa. D1: Duke Energy Building exterior cladding The meta-granite exterior cladding of this building (Figure 12) was quarried in Brazil, then cut and polished in San Sebastián, Spain, before being shipped to North America where it is used commonly as building stone. Its minerals include: quartz (smokey gray), orthoclase feldspar (milky white), sodic plagioclase (also white in color) biotite (black), and muscovite (pale green to golden brown). The obvious flow fabrics, suggest the rock was subjected to metamorphism at some time during the long history of deformation of the South American craton. A granite with two micas such as this one is relatively rare and speaks to an unusual magmatic history. D2: “Staturetto White” marble The light stone in the wall is a white marble (metamorphosed limestone) with gray veins. This stone was quarried in Carrara, Italy, as was the marble for Michelangelo’s sculpture of the Pieta in St. Peters Cathedral in Rome and the David in Florence. The limestone protolith for the Carrara Marble is Jurassic in age. This parent rock was metamorphosed to marble during a poorly understood Tertiary uplift event of the Alpi Apuani mountains, where Carrara is located. Figure 12. Stop D1: Margherita White Granite (Brazil) D3 D2 D5 D4 D6 Figure 13. Stop D2-D6: Marbles, limestones and igneous rocks in the Duke Energy Building interior; quarried from Europe, Africa and Asia. D3: “Grigio Carnico” The dark stone in the wall is known as “Grigio Carnico”. It is a common building stone composed of black limestone with white veins of calcite. Also present are dark stylolites, which form along bedding planes in limestones and marbles. Styolites form as material on either side of the bedding plane undergoes compaction and differential solution, which results in the interpenetration of points and cones forming a rough contact surface. In cross-section, the stylolites appear as jagged, zigzag lines with considerable relief. The black color is likely due to high organic content. This stone was quarried in Vicenza, Italy, on the southern flanks of the Alps. D4: “Black Angola”: The dark black gabbro floor paver was quarried in Malala, Angola. D5: “China Impala”: The medium gray diorite floor paver along the lobby edges was quarried in Fujian, China. page 6 D6: “White Pearl” granite The light paver which covers most of the lobby floor and the exterior entryway is a more typical one-mica (biotite) granite that was quarried from Madrid, Spain. D7: Gantt Center courtyard syenite sculpture Walk across the street from the Duke Energy Center to the Harvey Gantt Center courtyard. There you will find a nice example of the contrast in appearance of stone that is “polished” vs. unpolished. Much like natural weathering, polishing a rock can change its appearance remarkably. It is hard to believe that the two contrasting portions of the sculpture are the same rock. Figure 14. Stop E: Bank of America at 400 South Tryon D8: Gantt Center courtyard pavers The lighter colored pavers in the Harvey Gantt Center Courtyard are a nice example of an almandine garnet-bearing meta-granite. The garnets are clearly visible as the dark-reddish minerals in the pavers. Rub your finger over them to feel how they stand in relief above the more easily weathered matrix of the stone. The darker gray pavers are the same diorite as stop C2 and the pinkish tiles and pavers are the same accent stone found throughout the City and described in stop L4. Figure 15. Stop E1: Rapakivi granite Stop E: Bank of America at 400 South Tryon (formerly Wachovia Center) South Tryon at 2nd Street Completed in 1974, this 32 floor (420 feet) office building was designed by Little and Associates in the architectural style known as modernism (Figure 14). E1: Exterior pavers Examine the pavers (trade name often “Baltic Brown”) in front of the Bank of America Building at the corner of South Tryon and 2nd Street and you will see a distinctive granite that features round Figure 16. Stop E2: Travertine mineral grains known as rapakivi whose formation have puzzled igneous petrologists for decades (Figure 15). Typical rapakivi texture is a mixture of variously mantled (that is to say rimmed), non-mantled or partly mantled, concentrically zoned, plastically distorted, fragmented, re-aggregated, large and small distinctly round minerals (ovoids). Commonly the ovoids themselves are orthoclase feldspar which may be mantled by plagioclase. Some ovoids display remarkable sphericity and are often mis-labeled as orbicular. The compositional and textural zoning of each ovoid is thought to reflect its history of crystallization related to temperature and pressure changes within the melt that produced the overall rock. The mantling is thought to occur during the reduction of pressure accompanying the emplacement of the magma into the country rock. Who in your group can find the largest ovoid? E2: Exterior travertine planters, pavers and walls Travertine is a form of limestone deposited rapidly by spring water with a high mineral content (Figure 16). It often has a fibrous or layered appearance such as those visible here, and it occurs in white, tan and cream (here) colored varieties. In caves it can form stalactites and stalagmites. It is frequently used as a decorative building material. Take a close look at all of the voids and small layers visible in the cut stone and imagine the centuries and millennia of mineral-rich water flowing and bubbling across the surface making this laminated rock. page 7 Stop F: Charlotte Information Center 330 South Tryon F1: Exterior planter cobbles The river cobbles visible at the entryway to the 330 South Tryon building (Figures 17 & 18) are similar in size and roundness to typical Piedmont river cobbles. These cobbles are rounded suggesting that they have traveled a sufficient distance to have their corners smoothed. The composition of the cobbles suggests that they were eroded from a mafic source rock. Figure 17. Stop F1: Mafic river cobbles Figure 18. Stop F1: Mafic river cobbles The mafic river cobbles at the 330 South Tryon building are similar in size and roundness to Pleistoceneaged quartz cobbles commonly found in terrace deposits of the nearby Catawba and Pee Dee Rivers. The cobble deposit visible in Figures 19-20 is located at a quarry adjacent to the Pee Dee River in Lilesville, NC, fifty miles southeast of uptown Charlotte. These major Piedmont rivers are typically characterized by adjacent terraces that range from a few meters to over a hundred meters in height above the modern channel and are thought to range in age from about 5000 to 1.5 million years. Gravels such as these speak to much different flow regimes in the past than those of the sanddominated modern channels of today. Figure 19. Pee Dee River gravels, Lilesville, NC Figure 20. Pee Dee River gravels, Lilesville, NC page 8 Stop G: Two Wells Fargo Plaza 301 South Tryon The Two Wells Fargo building (Figure 21, formerly known as Wachovia 2) features a large plaza with outdoor seating and multiple water features. The plaza is often used for outdoor events and is a great place for a picnic lunch. Look inside the interior lobby for more examples of marble and travertine. G1: Exterior cladding; bench walls and capstones surrounding plaza Figure 21. Stop G: Two Wells Fargo Plaza This visually stunning rock tells a story of several major metamorphic events (Figure 22 & 23). The parent rock was likely a granite that was subjected to sufficiently intense heat and pressure (amphibolitegrade metamorphism) to cause minerals of different compositions to segregate into corresponding light and dark bands clearly visible throughout the rock. This newly formed “gneiss” was then subjected to even higher temperatures (upper granulite facies) which caused a high level of partial melting and recrystallization of many minerals as evidenced by the highly deformed thin bands of fine-grained mafic minerals and regions of light-colored, mega-crystic plagioclase and orthoclase grains (light peach and milky white in color). The final product is a migmatite. As the rock began to cool, a third event injected molten magma into the migmatite which crystalized into the light-colored, quartz-rich veins that cross-cut the foliation. G2: Fountain capstones The dark stone benches and cladding material at the base of the Interstate Tower, Two Wells Fargo Plaza, and in other structures throughout the city, is often referred to as “black granite”. It actually is a gabbro containing a plagioclase feldspar known as labradorite which has a “labradoresence” or schiller effect, consisting of a stunning play of color and blue-green iridescence visible from certain angles (Figure 24-25). This optical phenomenon is the result of light refracting within lamellar intergrowths of Na-rich and Ca-rich lamellae within the crystal structure. The lamellae result from phase exsolution during cooling. The medium- to coarsegrained minerals visible throughout this rock are plagioclase (grey) pyroxenes (black) and possibly some olivine (green). Figure 22-23. Stop G1: Migmatitic gneiss G3: Plaza pavers Light colored pavers in the plaza are a locally quarried stone, the Mount Airy Granite (described in full in stop H1). The medium dark pavers are a granite similar to those described at stop L4, and the dark pavers are a gabbro, both intrusive igneous rocks formed from crystallization of magma deep within the earth’s crust. Figure 24. Stop G2: Gabbro Figure 25. Stop G2: Gabbro page 9 Stop H: Exterior of Three Wells Fargo Center (formerly Three Wachovia Center, Three First Union Center) 401 South Tryon Street This 32 floor post modern office building (450 feet) was completed in 2000. The architects were Thompson, Ventulett, Stainback & Associates. H4 H3 H1 H1 H1: Exterior column cladding near building, upper The light gray, “salt-and-pepper” meta-granite (Figures 26 & 27) is from Mt. Airy, Surry County, North Carolina, (home of Andy Griffith and the town after which “Mayberry” was modeled in the well known TV series). Mississippian in age having been dated at 334 +/- 3 Ma, this light-colored, biotite granitoid or monzogranite is dominated by tabular, sodic plagioclase feldspars, many of which have their long axes parallel to a weak foliation. The Mt. Airy quarry is the largest open-faced granite quarry in the world, and is one of the few quarries in the United States that exports granite to China. Mt. Airy Granite is the official “rock” of North Carolina. H2 H2 Figure 26. Stop H: Exterior column cladding H2: Exterior column cladding near building, lower The pink-colored, coarse grained syenite (Figures 26 & 28) has rare quartz crystals and is dominated by pink orthoclase feldspar with some black hornblende amphibole and light colored plagioclase. The long axes of the orthoclase minerals are roughly oriented in the same direction indicating the flow of magma during crystallization. Xenoliths present in the rock appear to follow the same flow pattern. Syenites are generally formed by alkaline igneous activity, likely within thick continental crust. To produce a syenite of this type, it is necessary to partially melt a gabbroic source rock to a relatively small degree (~5-10%). H3 and H4: Exterior column cladding granite Figure 27. Stop H1: Salt and pepper metagranite Figure 28. Stop H2: Pink syenite The columns near the street (Figure 26) have two additional, more “typical” garden variety granites. There is still another one in the building cladding above the level of the street. Can you describe the differences? page 10 Stop I: Interior of Three Wells Fargo Center (formerly Three Wachovia Center, Three First Union Center) 401 South Tryon Street I1: Walls (I1 in Figure 29) contain “Calacatta Gold Marble” building stone from Italy. This is a fine-grained, white to beige marble, formed from carbonates deposited as part of the Lias group of the early Jurassic Period (~180 - 200 million years ago). I2: Flooring (I2 in Figure 29) is composed of “Botachino Fiorito Marble” building stone. This light beige, magnesian limestone is also of the Lias group of the Jurassic Period. While this stone is called a ‘marble’ in the US and Chinese markets, in Europe it must be called a magnesian limestone, according to the “European Standard” of building stones. I3: Flooring (I3 in Figure 29) is composed of “Ruoms Limestone”. This dark, fossiliferous limestone is from Ruoms, a city in southern France. I1 I4 I3 I2 I5 Figure 29. Stop I1-I5: Marbles and granite I4: Flooring (I4 in Figure 29) is composed of a light-gray, coarsegrained granite building stone known as “Luna Pearl” from either Italy or Brazil. I5: Flooring (I5 in Figure 29) is composed of dark-colored gabbroic anorthosite. This stone is known as “Black Galaxy Granite”. Black Galaxy is quarried near Ongole, Andhra Pradesh, southern India. The gold specks are due to the presence of magnesiumrich orthopyroxene (“bronzite”). Black Galaxy is one of the more common stones used throughout the US for countertops in kitchens and bathrooms. I6: Flooring on second level. It is worth the trip up the escalator to view the nice examples of bisectional coiled ammonoid fossils in carbonate rocks (Figure 30). It is located in the floor tile just to the right of the top of the up escalator. Figure 30. Stop I6: Bisectioned coiled ammonoid fossil page 11 Stop J: BB&T Center (formerly Southern National Center) 200 South College Street A 22 floor office building (300 feet) finished in 1975 by Little & Associates architects, this building, with its Overstreet Mall, was inspired by a Minneapolis design with the intention of fostering retail shopping. For this reason, the building does not face a major street, but was intended to be part of an interior network of bridges between office buildings. J1: BB&T Overstreet Mall interior floor tiles Head inside and upstairs into the Overstreet Mall hallway to view floor tiles that are alternating dark and light colored carbonates (Figures 31-33). Both are algal laminated (fine layering caused by the growth of agal mats) and bioturbated (mixing caused by burrowing organisms). Algal mats grow where sunlight initiates the growth of blue-green algae in shallow water, for example on the floor of a tidal flat pond. During storm events thin layers of carbonate mud can coat the algal mats. After the storm the algal mat can re-colonize the surface. Where this process is repeated, multiple layers of algal mats can build up. The bioturbation can be recognized by the disruption of what would have been relatively flat, thinly laminated bedding. J2: BB&T exterior cladding The black rock that comprises much of the exterior cladding of the BB&T building along Tryon Street is an anorthositic gabbro containing calcic plagioclase feldspar, orthopyroxene, clinopyroxene, and a small amount of amphibole. Can you recognize the weak alignment of some feldspar crystals that indicate flowing magma? Figure 31. Stop J: BB&T Center Figure 32-33. Stop J1: BB&T Center Stop K: SunTrust Bank K3 (formerly First National Bank of Charlotte) 112 South Tryon Street This 21 floor neoclassical office building (250 feet) was finished in 1926 by architect Louis Asbury Sr. K1: SunTrust Bank façade for floors 4-22 (look up!) The cladding for much of the SunTrust Building is an oolitic limestone quarried by the Bedford Cut Stone Company in Bedford, Indiana. The limestone is the Salem limestone, which a member of the Sander Group. The Salem limestone is a part of a limestone belt extending from Stinesville, in Monroe County, to Bedford, in Lawrence County, Indiana. The Salem limestone was deposited during the Middle to Late Mississippian (~335 to 340 Ma) when a shallow, inland sea covered much of the North American craton. The Salem limestone is chemically pure (~ 97% calcite) and is classified as a grainstone. It contains a variety of fossils including foraminifers, bryozoa, gastropods, crinoids, bivalves and brachiopods. The Salem limestone is a freestone, meaning it has no preferential direction of splitting. This allows it to be cut and carved into a variety of shapes K2 Figure 34. Stop K3: Entrance to the SunTrust Bank with travertine (K2) and cross-bedded sandstone (K3) Figure 35. Stop K2: Travertine page 12 and sizes, which has made it a desirable building stone across the US since it was first quarried in 1827. L1 K2: Façade adjacent to the SunTrust Bank entrance Adjacent to the SunTrust entrance is travertine (Figures 34 & 35) similar to that at stops E and O. K3: SunTrust Bank Lower façade in the entryway This stone is a cross-bedded sandstone whose layering is accentuated by reddish oxidation (Figure 34). In some of the blocks, there is evidence of wavy soft-sediment deformation. Softsediment deformation structures such as those visible here occur during the very first stages of sediment compaction as it begins its slow journey to becoming a sedimentary rock. The very wet and loosely packed sediments deform as they are dewatered, resulting in unusual patterns in what would have originally been relatively simple and uniform bedding. L3 L2 Figure 36. Stop L: Interstate Tower building stones If you walk south along Tryon Street from the Sun Trust you might notice some nice slates and greenish fossiliferous marbles at the entrance to the 200 S. Tryon building. Stop L: Interstate Tower Figure 37. Stop L1: Serpentinite 121 West Trade Street This 32 floor post-modern office building (462 feet) was finished in 1990 and designed by architects Kohn Pedersen Fox Associates PC and Odell & Associates. L1: Serpentinite Serpentinite is a low-grade metamorphic rock of ultramafic composition that consists mostly of serpentine, chlorite and talc (Figure 37). It can vary in color from bright green to nearly black and is commonly referred to as “green marble” or “serpentine marble”. Serpentinites are commonly veined with calcite, dolomite, magnesite or magnesium carbonate which gives the rock its characteristic “marbled” fabric. The range in color may result from the variable amounts of forsterite and fayalite (species of olivine) that were present in the ultramafic parent rock (e.g. peridotite). L2: Black Granite The so-called “black granite” at the base of the building (Figure 36) is another example of the gabbro already described for the Two Wells Fargo Plaza and the Three Wells Fargo building (Stops G and H). This gabbro, however, contains less labradorite than others you may have already seen. Figure 38. Stop L3: Light gray granite L3 L1 L4 Figure 39. Stop L4: Red granite L3: Interstate Tower light gray granite The light gray granite (Figures 36 & 38) is felsic in nature, a term that is applied to rocks with high feldspar and silica content. This particular granite is composed of ~40% orthoclase feldspar (pink), ~35% plagioclase feldspar (white/gray), ~20% quartz (clear) and ~5% biotite and amphibole (black). A granite with co-crystallizing page 13 feldspars (as evidenced by their euhedral crystal shapes) is relatively unusual and is likely a result of the melt’s initial composition. Rapakivi texture (stop I), zoning, and xenoliths of a finer grained granite are also evident in this rock. L4: Seating walls in Thomas Polk Park (Figure 39) and the columns of the four sculptures at the corner of Trade and Tryon Streets (Figure 40) The intersection of Trade and Tryon Streets is considered the official center of the City of Charlotte and hosts four statues by artist Raymond Kasky titled “Transportation”, “Future”, “Commerce” and “Industry”. The base of the statues as well as the sculpture and walls of Thomas Polk Park which is located just in front of the Interstate Tower, are composed of a red granite with quartz veins and entrained xenoliths. A high iron content explains the deep red color. The granite used in this park is similar to that of many of the sidewalk paving stones and other features you may have noticed and have been noted throughout the tour. It is the chosen primary accent stone for the city of Charlotte. This park marks the site of the first courthouse built by Thomas Polk, the founder of Charlotte. The Mecklenburg Declaration of Independence was likely read here on May 20, 1775. Figure 40. Stop L4: Red granite pillars at corner of Trade and Tryon Streets Stop M: Bank of America Corporate Center 100 North Tryon Street This 60 floor post modern office building (871 feet) finished in 1992 was designed by Cesar Pelli & Associates Architects (Figure 41). No photos are allowed inside the building for security reasons. Figure 41. Stop M: Bank of America Tower M1-M3: Exterior cladding stones Three Precambrian granites comprise the cladding stones of this building. The first is from Ortonville, Minnesota (M1 in Figure 42) and has the trade name of “agate”. The second is derived from Marble Falls, Texas, (M2 in Figure 42) and goes by the trade name of “sunset beige”. The final granite (M3 in Figure 42) is from Milbank, South Dakota and sometimes goes by the name of “carnelian” or “Dakota Mahogany” (see stop T4 for more information). M4: Courtyard pavers The white pavers in the BOA Corporate Center courtyard are a classic white marble similar to the Carrara marble described in Stop D. Metamorphic black schist and a gray granite are the other two pavers. M5: Exterior columns The dark columns at the entryway are serpentinite, a metamorphosed peridotite (see Stop L for a full description). M1 M2 M3 Figure 42. Stop M1-M3: Bank of America Tower exterior cladding, three granites M6: Fountain The dark rock that forms the fountain is a typical medium- grained diorite that contains fine-grained xenoliths along with pyroxene, amphibole and small amounts of quartz. page 14 M7: Founder’s Hall flooring and walls It is definitely worth the effort to view to the main lobby of the BOA Corporate Center as well as Founder’s Hall, an interior shopping and dining area. The upper level of Founder’s Hall is part of the overstreet mall. Can you identify the ~dozen different marbles utilized in the lobby of the main tower as well as in Founders Hall? These marbles came from quarries in Spain, Italy, France, Turkey and the United States. One of the pink colored Italian marbles is Devonian in age and it is known as “fior de pesco” (peach flower). It is a favorite construction material of Cesar Pelli, the building’s architect, and is especially abundant in the main hall. Also of note, the lobby of the Bank of America Corporate Center contains one of the largest secular frescoes in the world. The fresco is the work of artist Ben Long and it took a year to complete. Figure 43. Stop M7: Founder’s Hall, various marbles N3 Stop N: Hearst Tower Interior Lobby 214 North Tryon Street This 47 story post modern office building (659 feet) was finished in 2002 and designed by architect: Smallwood, Reynolds, Stewart, Stewart & Associates, Inc. No photos are allowed inside the building for security reasons. Located within the College Street lobby of the Hearst Tower, there are brass railings from the Au Bon Marche department store in Paris. These railings accentuate the tower’s art deco influences. The building lacks a 13th floor for superstitious reasons. N1-N3: Floors and walls of the interior lobby The lighter colored floor stone is an augen gneiss (N1 in Figure 44) with the trade name “spray white” granite. Generally, augen gneiss is a high-grade metamorphic rock whose parent rock was likely granite. Augen comes from the German word for “eye”, as the sample’s main features are lenticular porphyroblasts of white plagioclase feldspars (1 in Figure 45). Black biotite compresses around these more resistant white feldspars in a preferred orientation. The augen gneiss was quarried at Xiamen, China, near Beijing. The second type of stone in the flooring is “dynasty black” granite. (N2 in Figure 44) also from Xiamen, China. This granite is a very common countertop stone, which is actually classified as a gabbro, an igneous rock with dark minerals. N2 N1 Figure 44. Stop N1-N3: Hearst Tower 1 1 Figure 45. Stop N1: Augen gneiss The walls in the lobby are dominated by “Beijing white” marble (N3 in Figure 44) from Yi Sin, China. This marble has distinctive stylolites (see stop D for a definition of stylolites) which are accentuated by a coating of insoluble residue. The marble was cut as facing pieces from the same block. When one of the pieces is rotated and they are placed side-by-side, they create a “book-end” marble effect. page 15 Stop O: Hearst Tower courtyard 214 North Tryon Street O1: Hearst Tower: Exterior cladding and plaza seating wall lower stone The black walls flanking the entrance to the Hearst Tower (as well as accent seating and unpolished pavers throughout the courtyard) are composed of anorthosite (a plagioclase feldspar-dominated igneous intrusive rock) with variable plagioclase crystal sizes belonging to the Cambrian Lac-Saint-Jean anorthosite suite from Quebec, Canada. This stone (Figure 48) has the trade name of “Peirbonka granite”. In certain light, the phenocrysts (large crystals) in this rock have a lovely blue iridescence. O1 O1 O2: Entry way pavers The lighter colored pavers in the Hearst Tower courtyard is a quartz granodiorite (Figure 49) containing quartz and dominated by plagioclase feldspar (often rectangular, creamy light gray) with mafic phenocrysts (large, dark crystals in a fine-grained ground mass) of the mineral amphibole (small black crystals). Large xenoliths are present in this rock, too. Note the well-formed plagioclase crystal laths which show evidence of compositional zoning (growth rings) which indicate the slow cooling rates of the magma which formed this rock. O2 Figure 46. Stop O: Hearst Tower exterior O4 O3: Seating wall upper and unpolished paver intersections This granodiorite (Figure 50) is weakly metamorphosed as evidenced by the subtle alignment of elongated crystals. O3 O1 O3 Figure 47. Stop O: Hearst Tower Courtyard Who can find the largest plagioclase xenocryst? We found one that is 10cm long! Can you differentiate the xenocrysts from the xenoliths of other igneous rocks that were likely included as ‘hitch hikers’ as the magma from this rock intruded into the country rock? Both the xenocrysts and xenoliths show reaction rims, halos around the crystals and rock fragments that represent partial assimilation with the magma after they were picked up. Figure 48. Stop O1: Anorthosite Figure 50. Stop O3: Granite Figure 51. Stop O4: Travertine Figure 49. Stop O2: Meta-diorite page 16 O4: Montaldo’s Department Store (220 North Tryon) exterior cladding The former five story Montaldo’s Department Store on the northwest corner of the Hearst Tower plaza was designed 1920 by Louis Asbury Sr. in Italian Renaissance Revival style. The building housed the Mint Museum of Craft + Design from 1999-2010. It is clad in white travertine (Figure 51) similar to that seen at stops E and K. Stop P: St. Peters Episcopal Church 115 West Seventh Street, Charlotte, NC 28202 St. Peter’s (Figure 52) was the first Episcopal Church in Charlotte and the parish can trace its origins to 1834. The current building at the corner of Seventh and Tryon Streets was completed in 1895. P1: Accent stone While much of the Church’s construction is brick, sandstone blocks (Figure 53) were used in the foundation, doorways, stairways and windows. These sandstones are medium-grained, planar stratified, brownish red sublitharenites (mostly quartz with rock fragments). The dark red/black color visible on many of the sandstone blocks is the result of weathered iron bearing minerals and of pollution. Restoration efforts have included plastering portions of the faces of many of the stones with stucco. Figure 52. Stop P: St. Peters Episcopal Church Find a stone where the stucco has chipped away in order to observe the actual color and grain characteristics of this rock. These sandstones are likely derived from fluvial deposits found in Triassic basins (~ 220 million years old) in eastern North Carolina, including the Deep River Basin which underlies the Durham/Chapel Hill area. Similar sandstones were used in 19th and 20th century brownstone construction in major cities up and down the East Coast. Figure 53. Stop P1: Sandstone P2: Roof tiles A common roofing material for this period of architecture, these slate roofing tiles (Figure 54) are possibly derived from the Ordovician Martinsburg Formation in Pennsylvania. Can you spot the banding in some of the tiles? This is the product of the deposition of sediment layers prior to the metamorphism that changed the stone from shale to slate. Figure 54. Stop P2: Slate page 17 Stop Q: Levine Museum of the New South 200 East Seventh Street, Charlotte, NC 28202 The recently renovated museum re-opened on October 13, 2001. The museum provides a comprehensive examination of post-Civil War Southern society, history and sociological evolution for the city and region, through interactive exhibits, events, lectures and workshops. Figure 55. Stop Q: Levine Museum Q1: Orange-colored exterior cladding The cladding stone used at street level of the Levine Museum is from a limestone quarry in Lueders, Texas. The Lueders Limestone ranges from brown to gray in color and is categorized as a fine to coarse grained, bioclastic packstone (grain to grain contact with mud cement) to wackestone (grains ‘floating’ in mud matrix). The Lueders Limestone contains both fragmented body fossils (ex: shells in Figure 56) and abundant trace fossils (Figure 57). These trace fossils record the behavior (e.g. burrowing) of organisms rather than their morphology. Trace fossils visible in this rock include planolites, a straight to gently curved horizontal burrow, as well as arthrophycus. Figure 56. Stop Q1. Shelly body fossils in Lueders Limestone The Lueders Formation is the uppermost member of the Albany Group which occurs on the eastern shelf of the Midland Basin. This limestone was deposited during the Early Permian (~275.6 ± 0.7 to 270.6 ± 0.7 million years ago) when a shallow sea covered this part of West Texas. Q2: White-colored exterior cladding This oolitic limestone (Figure 58) was also quarried near Lueders, Texas. This limestone is a fine grained, grayish white carbonate grainstone composed of ooids (see Stop A for more information on ooids) and shell fragments, including gastropods (obvious from their elongated spiral morphology). Put your nose or a hand lens on the rock to see the small ooids. The visible swirling pattern in some tiles is cross bedding. This bedding is due to the deposition of the carbonate particles in ripples and dunes migrating on the shallow sea floor. Figure 57. Stop Q1. Trace fossils in Lueders Limestone Figure 58. Stop Q2: Oolitic limestone page 18 Stop R: Arena Plaza 333 East Trade Street, Charlotte, NC 28202 On the plaza between the Bobcats Arena and the light rail line, there are several bench sculptures designed by Charlotte artist Paul Sires. These functional works of art feature a variety of stones from the Carolinas, Virginia, and Canada. Have a seat on rock that predates the dinosaurs! R1c R1b R1a R1: Tulip bench sculpture R1.a: Pink Kershaw Granite Figure 59. Stop R1: Tulip bench sculpture The “Pink Kershaw Granite” (Figure 60), quarried in Kershaw, SC, is a classic granite, but it is technically classified as a porphyritic quartz monzonite. It is part of the Liberty Hill Pluton and is Carboniferous to Permian in age (350 to 250 million years old). Large pink crystals of perthitic orthoclase (pink colored grains) dominate this stone but albite plagioclase (white colored grains), quartz (clear to translucent minerals), hornblende and biotite (dark minerals) are also visible. Some rapakivi texture (see stop E1 for information on this texture) is visible encasing some of the orthoclase grains. R1.b: Carolina Pink granite Figure 60. Stop R1.a: Pink Kershaw Granite The “Carolina Pink Granite” (Figure 61) is Devonian in age (415 to 355 million years) and is derived from the Salisbury Plutonic Suite in Salisbury, North Carolina. Its minerals include approximately 45% perthitic (characterized by linear blebs) orthoclase (pink), 25% plagioclase, 20% quartz(clear), and 10% biotite (black). R1.c: Texas Pearl grey granite The “Texas Pearl” grey granite (Figure 62) is a Proterozoic (2.5 billion to 550 million years old) granite from the Town Mountain Granite Suite near Marble Falls, Texas. See stop T for more examples of granites from the Town Mountain Granite Suite and the Llano Uplift. Perthitic feldspars (pink) are present, but this rock contains more quartz than the other two rocks in the sculpture. Sodic rich plagioclase (white), amphibole and biotite (black) and quartz (gray) are also present. Figure 61. Stop R1.b: Carolina Pink granite Figure 62. Stop R1.c: Texas Pearl grey granite page 19 R2: Half Gear bench sculpture This bench, in the shape of half a gear (Figures 63-65), is known in the building stone trade as “Virginia Mist Granite”. This unusual rock appears to be an intermediate igneous rock that has been metamorphosed as shown by the flow structure (banding of light and dark minerals). It also includes unusual looking swirls of light colored plagioclase feldspar and quartz rich veins. Note the latestage cross-cutting diabase veins (dark in color). Overall the rock may be a Jurassic diabase quarried near Culpepper, Virginia. The diabase is a fine- to coarsely-crystalline, sub-aphanitic to porphyritic, dark-gray mosaic of plagioclase laths (long narrow crystal habit) and clinopyroxene, with some olivine and bronzite (orthopyroxene) masses. The diabase occurs as dikes and sills associated with the Culpepper Mesozoic basin. Figure 63. Stop R2: Virginia Mist granite R3: Double Leaf bench sculpture R3a: Crystal Gold White granite The lighter rock in this sculpture is the “Crystal Gold White Granite” (Figure 67) and is from Vermillion Bay, in northwestern Ontario. The Nelson Granite company actively quarries syn-tectonic to pretectonic granites and granodiorites of the Archean Vermilion Granitic Complex. Minerals include sodium rich plagioclase feldspar (white), potassium feldspar (cream) and biotite and amphibole (black). Figure 64. Stop R2: Virginia Mist granite R3b: Forest Green granite “Forest Green Granite” (Figure 68) is actually a gabbro from a quarry operation in Saint Sebastien de Frontenac, Quebec, Canada. The gabbro is Cambrian to Devonian in age and includes calcicrich plagioclase (dark), pyroxene (black in the unpolished surface) and amphibole. The mineral composition and shape of the grains in this rock provide evidence that it is ‘cumulate’, meaning that most of the liquid was squeezed away during its crystallization in a magma chamber, leaving behind this assemblage of the early (high temperature) crystallizers on Bowen’s reaction series. R3a Figure 65. Stop R2: Virginia Mist granite close up R3b Figure 66. Stop R3. Double leaf bench sculpture Figure 67. Stop R3a. Crystal Gold White Granite Figure 68. Stop R3b. Forest Green Granite page 20 Stop S: Ritz Carlton Hotel 201 East Trade Street, Charlotte, NC 28202 This 17 story (200 feet) post modern building completed in 2009 was designed by Smallwood, Reynolds, Stewart, Stewart and Associates and is LEED Gold certified. S1: Exterior upper cladding and lobby flooring The pink and grey “marble” used in the main entrance walls and flooring in the lobby of the Ritz Carlton hotel is a fossiliferous limestone quarried in Friendsville, Tennessee, about 35 km southwest of Knoxville. How many different fossils can you find? We note at least three in this packstone to grainstone limestone: hemispherical bryozoan fragments as well as brachiopod (visible as small black arcs in Figure 70) and crinoid fragments. This pink, coarsely crystalline limestone is from the Holston Formation, a ~70200 meter thick stratigraphic unit within the Chickamauga Group of the Valley and Ridge geologic province of eastern Tennessee. The limestones of the Holston Formation formed during the Middle Ordovician (~460 million years ago) in shallow water on the southern continental shelf of Laurentia. In this environment, bryozoandominated reefs flourished but the high energy of the waves often broke pieces of limestone from the reef. Such fragments of bryozoans rolled across the seafloor, together with fragments of other animals, and gradually built up porous shoals of coarse-grained limestone fragments. These fossils are as coarse as ~1-2 cm in diameter and can be seen in the cut and polished surfaces of the limestone. In the Late Ordovician, a volcanic island arc collided with the southern margin of Laurentia causing the Taconic orogeny. Sedimentary rock strata on the continental margin, including the Holston Formation, were pushed landward, folded, broken, stacked and buried as the Taconic Mountains rose. The pressure associated with the collision and burial compacted the limestone, and cemented the grains more firmly together. (description from http://academic.brooklyn. cuny.edu/geology/powell/613webpage/NYCbuilding/TennesseeMarble/ TennesseeMarble.htm) S1 S2 Figure 69. Stop S. Ritz Carlton Hotel entrance Figure 70. Stop S1: Fossiliferous limestone Figure 71. Stop S1: Fossiliferous limestone The natural bedding in the cut limestone blocks has been used to form geometric patterns in the floor (Figure 71). This limestone can also be found in the J.P. Morgan building and Grand Central Station in New York City. S2: Ground level exterior cladding of the Ritz Carlton hotel and unpolished pavers in the main entryway This migmatitic (meaning the gneiss is undergoing the initial stages of melting) gneiss (provenance unknown) likely had a granitic parent body which was subjected to intense heat and pressure causing partial melting and the development of the beautiful gneissic banding that is visible. The rock appears to have been subjected to multiple subsequent metamorphic events resulting in folding of the gneissic banding. Figure 72. Stop S2: Migmatitic granite page 21 S3: A large infilled geode in the Ritz-Carlton lobby This large geode (Figure 73, provenance unknown) has been cut in half and polished. The stages of filling of the geode by chalcedony can be seen as layers in the polished surface. Geodes can form in any cavity (vug) within which dissolved silicates or carbonates precipitate out and form the multiple layers visible in the interior of the geode. Can you spot the “Virginia Mist Granite” from stop R in the lobby? Can you find the stylolites (already described in Stops D and N) in the lobby floor? Continue to the elevator to find a stunning example of an ammonite fossil. Stop T: Hilton Charlotte Center City / One Wells Fargo Building 222 East 3rd Street T1: Texas Pearl granite Figure 73. Stop S3: Geode sculpture One of the paving stones as well as the building and fountain facing stone comprises a light pink granite known as “Texas Pearl” from Llano, Texas (Figure 74 & 75). This Proterozoic granite is from the Town Mountain Granite suite and is comprised of albite (white plagioclase feldspar), orthoclase (pink feldspar), quartz biotite and amphibole (dark minerals). Here is yet another example of a rock with some Rapakivi texture. T2: Texas Pink granite Another one of the paving stones is a dark pink porphyritic granite known as “Texas Pink” from Granite Shoals, Texas (Figure 76). This Proterozoic granite is also from the Town Mountain Granite suite and is comprised of potassium feldspar (pink colored grains), sodic plagioclase (white colored grains), quartz and biotite. The Town Mountain Granite suite (TMG) of the Proterozoic Llano Uplift of central Texas is generally a pink, very coarse grained, porphyritic granite with accompanying pink coarse-grained nonporphyritic granite. Mineralogically, the TMG consists primarily of plagioclase feldspar, potassium feldspar (microcline), and quartz with biotite and/or hornblende. Accessory minerals commonly include titanite (sphene), zircon, magnetite and/or ilmenite, and apatite with fluorite, allanite, and/or pyrite being present in some rocks. Texturally the granites are dominated by the large pink microcline feldspar crystals. Differences in the color, shape, or amount of these microcline feldspar crystals are responsible for much of the differing appearance of building stone varieties. Faint to well-developed alignment of these large crystals (magmatic foliation) occurs somewhere in most intrusions. Regionally, the granites intrude multiply-deformed schists, gneisses, and other metamorphic rocks of the Llano Uplift. (from http://uts.cc.utexas.edu/~rmr/tmg.html) T1 T2 T4 T3 Figure 74. Stop T: Hilton Charlotte Center City and One Wells Fargo Center Figure 75. Stop T1: Texas Pearl granite Figure 76. Stop T2: Texas Pink granite page 22 Commercial quarry operations have been underway since 1882 when TMG was first quarried to construct the Texas Capitol building. T3: Rockville White granodiorite A third paving stone is a light-colored phaneritic granodiorite (Figure 77) known as “Rockville White” from Rockville, Minnesota. This Proterozoic granodiorite is a late intrusion associated with the Penokean Orogeny (see below) and is comprised of oligoclase (large white plagioclase feldspar), possible quartz, amphibole and biotite. The Penokean orogeny was a major event in the formation of the North American craton. The orogeny lasted about 10 million years and occurred in two phases. During the first phase, the PembineWausau island arc terrane collided with the ancient North American craton, along with volcanoes formed in its back-arc basin. The second phase involved a micro-continent called the Marshfield terrane, which today forms parts of Wisconsin and Illinois. Figure 77. Stop granodiorite T3: Rockville White T4: Dakota Mahogany granite A fourth variety of paving stone at this site is a dark gray to black granite (Figure 78) known as “Dakota Mahogany” from Milbank, South Dakota. This Archean granite is part of the Milbank Granite Suite. It contains orthoclase feldspar, sodic plagioclase, quartz and biotite. Figure 78. Stop T4: Dakota Mahogany granite The authors would like to thank the additional students of John Bender’s Economic Geology class for their research on the project. We especially thank Dr. Scott Hippensteel for his thorough and helpful review of the tour. page 23 Uptown Charlotte Building Stones World Provenance