City of Kendallville Comprehensive Plan The City of Kendallville Comprehensive Plan was funded, in part, by a planning grant administered by the Indiana Office of Community and Rural Affairs through the Small Cities and Towns Development Block Grant (CDBG) program. Primary Planning Assistance provided by: Table of Contents Preface Overview ............................................................... ii History of Planning Initiatives in Kendallville ...... ii Planning Jurisdiction ........................................... ii The Vision, Goals, and Objectives ......................... iv Comprehensive Plan Mandate................................. v Kendallville’s Fulfillment of the Mandate ............... v Beneficiaries ......................................................... vi Limitations of a Comprehensive Plan..................... vi Chapter One: Community Profile Demographics ........................................................ 2 Public Input and Notice .......................................... 3 Interest Group Interviews..................................... 3 Community Leaders Roundtable .......................... 4 Public Workshops................................................ 4 Additional Opportunities ..................................... 4 Public Hearing ....................................................... 5 Conclusion ............................................................. 5 Chapter Two: Vision City of Kendallville’s Vision for the Future ............ 8 Chapter Three: Manage Land Use and Growth Introduction ......................................................... 10 Goal ..................................................................... 11 Additional Information ......................................... 13 Agriculture ........................................................ 13 Open Space and Recreation ............................... 13 Residential ........................................................ 14 Residential Growth Management ....................... 16 Commercial ....................................................... 20 Commercial Growth Management ..................... 21 Industrial ........................................................... 23 Industrial Growth Management .......................... 23 General Growth Management Strategies ............ 23 Airport .............................................................. 24 Annexation ........................................................ 24 Future Land Use Classification Descriptions ......... 26 Future Land Use Classification Map ..................... 41 Chapter Four: Foster Convenient Circulation Introduction ......................................................... 44 Goal ..................................................................... 44 Additional Information ......................................... 46 Vehicular Network ............................................ 46 Pedestrian Network Plan .................................... 47 Other Modes of Transportation .......................... 49 Thoroughfare Plan Map Descriptions .................... 50 Pedestrian Network Map Descriptions .................. 55 Thoroughfare Plan Map ........................................ 63 Pedestrian Network Map ...................................... 65 Chapter Five: Serve Community Needs Introduction.......................................................... 68 Goal ..................................................................... 68 Additional Information ......................................... 69 Utility Services .................................................. 69 Public Services .................................................. 70 Parks and Recreation ......................................... 72 Chapter Six: Stimulate Economic Growth Introduction.......................................................... 76 Goal ..................................................................... 76 Additional Information ......................................... 78 Available Sites................................................... 79 Expansion and Retention ................................... 79 New Economic Growth...................................... 79 The Role of Tourism.......................................... 81 Chapter Seven: Nurture Environmental Quality Introduction.......................................................... 84 Goal ..................................................................... 84 Additional Information ......................................... 86 Water Quality .................................................... 86 Conserving and Managing Other Environmental Amenities ......................................................... 86 “Green” Development........................................ 87 Chapter Eight: Strengthen Community Character and Identity Introduction.......................................................... 90 Goal ..................................................................... 90 Additional Information ......................................... 91 Gateways ........................................................... 91 Corridors ........................................................... 92 Zoning and Subdivision Standards ..................... 92 Downtown Kendallville ..................................... 93 Chapter Nine: Conclusion Conclusion ........................................................... 98 Appendix A: Demographics Appendix B: Public Participation Appendix C: Documentation of Approval Preface Overview HISTORY OF PLANNING INITIATIVES IN KENDALLVILLE This Comprehensive Plan will replace the City’s 1963 Comprehensive Plan which included three (3) basic components: research and a study of existing conditions; proposals for future land use, supporting community services, and thoroughfares; and consideration for implementation. The objectives of the original plan were to “recognize the physical, economic, and cultural characteristics of the community, and propose planning action which will reflect the continuation of the most desirable aspects of each in the further development of the community.” There have been other planning initiatives in Kendallville since the 1963 Comprehensive Plan. An intern City Planner created a Kendallville Comprehensive Development Plan in 1977 after the two-lane State Road 3 bi-pass was completed. This plan was not officially adopted by the City of Kendallville, but does contain interesting information about the impact of the bypass on the growth and development of Kendallville. In 1991 a “Strategic Plan” was completed, and its focus was “on the process of planning rather than on the plan that is produced.” It covered beautification, downtown, economic development, education, environmental issues, government, healthcare and social services, recreation, tourism, and transportation. PLANNING JURISDICTION This new Comprehensive Plan, like most of the previous planning initiatives, goes beyond planning for land within Kendallville’s corporate limits to include the City’s extraterritorial jurisdiction. This area includes approximately two (2) miles of unincorporated land around the perimeter of the City. Kendallville’s City Limits encompass 3,940 acres, and the extra-territorial jurisdiction adds another 13,449 acres to Kendallville’s planning jurisdiction. Even though the extra-territorial jurisdictional area is not within the corporate limits, the residents and businesses of this area are part of the Kendallville community. What happens in Kendallville, impacts them. These areas include Little Long Lake, Round Lake, Noble Hawk, Cobblestone, and the Kendallville Outdoor Recreation Complex along Allen Chapel Road/County Road 1000E, Meadow Lane, and agricultural areas. For the purpose of this Plan, general references to the City of Kendallville, Kendallville, or the planning jurisdiction are meant to include the corporate limits as well as the extra-territorial jurisdiction. When the intent is to call out one specific area, the terms “city limits, “corporate limits,” or “extraterritorial jurisdiction” will be used. In 1994, the City embarked on a Land Use Analysis that included a detailed demographic and economic data analysis, a community goals exercise, and proposed land use scenario. ii CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Preface SCHOOLHOUSE RD WAYNE CENTER RD (CR 900 E) CR 900 N (CR 825 N) A RPORT RD APPLEMAN RD (CR 800N) RD COUNTY LINE RD RD RIL EY G IN GL NORTH LIMA RD AN CR 600 E STRATER ROAD (CR 750 N) N SAWYER RD (CR 660 E) ALLEN CHAPEL RD RIMMEL RD (CR 800 N) KAMMERER RD FA R ST RILEY ST AVE DIAMOND ST DRAKE RD GARDEN ST WESTON (CR 600 N) PROGRESS DR EAST DOWLING ST ROGERS RD DOWLING ST LL ST M TCHE ARK AVE OR LIMA RD CH AR D PL MAIN ST US HIGHWAY 6 CR 600 E HENRY ST WAITS RD (CR 500 N) CR 1000 E BEACON RD (CR 700 E) SHERMAN ST MAIN ST MAPES ROAD (CR 550 N) LIS BO D NR (CR 415 Corporate Limits and Extra-Territorial Jurisdiction MAP LEGEND N) Corporate Limits CR 750 E Extra-Territorial Jurisdiction CR 350 N STATE RD 8 CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 CR 300 N iii Preface The Vision, Goals, and Objectives A vision for the City of Kendallville’s future emerged through various meetings and workshops and from an extensive study of the community. This vision is in Chapter Two and is the basis for the goals, objectives, and implementation measures that are included in this document. Chapter Two: Vision is followed by six (6) chapters, each dedicated to one (1) of Kendallville’s broad goals. The goals are associated with the following topics: Manage Land Use and Growth Foster Convenient Circulation Serve Community Needs Stimulate Economic Growth Nurture Environmental Quality Strengthen Community Character and Identity As the Comprehensive Plan was being prepared, drafts were reviewed by a Steering Committee made up of a diverse group of citizens and community leaders. It was also reviewed by interest groups, City boards and commissions, and the general public. The final outcome is a user-friendly Comprehensive Plan that is full of goals and objectives that were significantly influenced by the residents of the Kendallville community, and a Comprehensive Plan that contains attainable implementation measures. The vision, goals, objectives, and implementation measures in these chapters will effectively and specifically guide decisions for policies, programs, and projects. The buy-in to the vision, commitment to the goals, and pursuit of the objectives and implementation measures will result in a significant positive change for the City of Kendallville and its planning jurisdiction. The Plan is intended to be a working document, meaning it should periodically be reviewed, evaluated, and updated to reflect changing trends, outlooks, and thinking. In this way, it will remain a relevant guide to the future growth and development of the City of Kendallville. iv CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Preface Comprehensive Plan Mandate The State of Indiana, through Indiana Statutes, Title 36, Article 7, as amended, empowers communities to plan with the purpose of improving “the health, safety, convenience, and welfare of the citizens and to plan for the future development of their communities to the end: Kendallville’s Fulfillment of the Mandate All State of Indiana minimum requirements have been met or exceeded throughout the planning process and within the Comprehensive Plan. Some of the highlights include: 1. That highway systems (and road systems) be carefully planned; 2. That new communities grow only with adequate public way, utility, health, educational, and recreational facilities; 3. That the needs of agriculture, industry, and business be recognized in future growth; 4. That residential areas provide healthful surroundings for family life; and 5. That the growth of the community is commensurate with and promotive of the efficient and economical use of public funds [IC 36-7-4-201].” Indiana Statutes state that communities may establish planning and zoning entities to fulfill that purpose [IC 36-7-4-201]. The Plan Commission is the body responsible for maintaining a comprehensive plan, which is required by state law to be developed and maintained [IC 36-7-4-501] if the community wishes to exercise the power of zoning. Indiana Code 36-7-4-502 and 36-7-4-503 state the required and permissible contents of a comprehensive plan. The required plan elements are listed below. The City of Kendallville Comprehensive Plan exhibits analysis of the community, existing land uses, development trends, land use suitability, economic feasibility, and natural land features. Public involvement provided the foundation for this Comprehensive Plan. This public input exceeded the criteria required by the State by providing several opportunities for people to provide input at the beginning of the planning process. Community input is woven into the content of this document with specific results contained in Appendix B. The City of Kendallville Comprehensive Plan has an overall theme of improving the health, safety, and welfare of residents and contains the State required elements in the chapters that follow. The City of Kendallville Comprehensive Plan contains several extra components that exceed those required by the State. For instance, the Plan includes chapters on infrastructure systems, economic growth, environmental quality, community facilities, and community character. 1. A statement of objectives for the future development of the jurisdiction. 2. A statement of policy for the land use development of the jurisdiction. 3. A statement of policy for the development of public ways, public places, public lands, public structures, and public utilities. CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 v Preface Beneficiaries The City of Kendallville Comprehensive Plan is designed to benefit the community as a whole, as opposed to a single property owner or group of property owners. As a result, from time to time, implementing this Plan may adversely affect a single property owner or a small group of property owners. However difficult or controversial, the greater good of the community will be served through the implementation of this Plan. No community has ever regularly improved itself without some controversy, opposition, or adverse effects on small numbers of property owners. The City has committed to implement, to the extent possible, this Plan with the greater good of the community in mind. As an assurance, each project, program, or policy that results from this Plan will first be evaluated to confirm the end result will positively move the community forward in the spirit of the Comprehensive Plan. Unforeseen conditions and situations must be considered in respect to where the community is at a specific time. Limitations of a Comprehensive Plan It is important to keep in mind that this Plan is not enforceable in itself and should not be mistaken as a zoning ordinance or as a substitute for other regulatory ordinances. This Comprehensive Plan has been designed to serve as a guideline for the future of the City of Kendallville. The City will utilize its zoning and subdivision control ordinances as a primary means of implementation and will update those ordinances periodically to improve successful implementation. The City will also use department policies, along with its capital, intellectual, political, and human resources to help achieve the vision, goals, and objectives of this Plan. vi CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Chapter One Community Profile Community Profile Demographics The US Constitution requires the federal government to administer a census every ten (10) years to allocate the number of US Representatives to each state. The data gathered from the census is often used to evaluate demographic changes in communities, counties, states, and the country as a whole. The demographic data collected by the census may be used to help understand a community’s past and where that community is today. The same data can also be analyzed to create estimates and projections to help predict the future of the community. Preparations are being made for the 2010 Census meaning much of the “current” census data is ten (10) years old. A few, more current statistics are available for Kendallville and Noble County, and that information is noted. Nonetheless, the City of Kendallville should update the demographic data in this Plan with statistics from the 2010 Census when that information becomes available. The information and statistics that follow are from the US Census Bureau (www.census.gov) and the Indiana University Kelley School of Business Indiana Business Research Center website (www.stats.indiana.edu). In most cases, the data is rounded to the nearest hundred. According to the 2000 Census, Kendallville is the largest community in Noble County with a population of 9,616. The 2007 population estimate for the City of Kendallville is 10,327, an increase of seven percent (7%) since 2000. Between 1990 and 2000, Kendallville experienced a twenty-four percent (24%) population increase. This increase was greater than increases experienced in Noble County (22%) and the State of Indiana (10%). 2 Kendallville’s population has historically made up twenty-one percent (21%) of the Noble County population and that trend continues based on the 2007 population estimates. Approximately seventy-five percent (75%) of Kendallville residents age twenty-five (25) and over have attained a high school diploma or higher. This figure falls short of the same figure for Noble County (77%) and the State of Indiana (82%). Twelve percent (12%) of Kendallville residents have attained a bachelor’s degree or higher. These figures for Noble County and the State of Indiana are eleven percent (11%) and nineteen percent (19%), respectively. It is important to note that these figures, from the 2000 Census, account only for those living within the Kendallville City Limits. The median home value in 2000 for owneroccupied homes in Kendallville was $81,100. This is less than the median home value for owner-occupied homes in Noble County ($88,600) and the State of Indiana ($94,300). Based on the 2000 Census, nearly half of the housing units in Kendallville were built before 1960. Of all housing units, approximately sixty-one percent (61%) were owneroccupied, thirty-two percent (32%) were renter-occupied, and seven percent (7%) were vacant in 2000. The owner-occupied rates for Noble County and Indiana were higher at seventy-one percent (71%) and sixty-six percent (66%), respectively. CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Community Profile Kendallville’s median household income appears to be falling behind Noble County and the State of Indiana. In 1990, Kendallville’s median household income was eighty-seven percent (87%) of the median household income for Noble County. In 2000, Kendallville’s median household income was approximately $34,000 – which was about seventy-nine percent (79%) of the same figure for Noble County ($42,700). Noble County figures have stayed consistent with State figures. Again, it is important to reiterate that these statistics – particularly home value and household income – only include areas within the Kendallville City Limits. Clearly, adding newer and/or higher-valued residential areas like Noble Hawk, Cobblestone, Little Long Lake, and Round Lake would likely swing home value and household income statistics close or even above the same figures for the State of Indiana. The 2000 Census indicates that forty-six percent (46%) of those in the Kendallville workforce are employed in manufacturing. Thirteen percent (13%) are employed in the education, health, and social service industries, and ten percent (10%) are employed in retail trade. It should be noted that in 2008 and 2009 the national economy has been suffering from a recession characterized by job losses, high unemployment, mortgage defaults, and declining property values. Kendallville and Noble County have experienced this recession firsthand with one of the highest unemployment rates in Indiana for much of 2009. That rate has ranged from sixteen and one-half percent (16.5%) to seventeen and nine-tenths percent (17.9%). Additional demographic information, including data, charts, graphs, descriptions and sources of the data are located in Appendix A. CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Public Input and Notice Various input opportunities were offered to residents and employees of the City of Kendallville and its planning jurisdiction. Meetings geared to obtain input from community leadership, interest groups, and the general public were held during the initial phase of the planning process. Each input opportunity included a “Community Values Survey” that encouraged participants to think about issues that may influence a community’s values. Folks were asked to rate their opinions on topics such as farmland preservation, property rights, the location of new development, and the regulation of new development. Results of the survey are referenced throughout this document. Additionally, a copy of the survey questions and all of the responses are located in Appendix B. A summary of each input opportunity follows. INTEREST GROUP INTERVIEWS The first input opportunity was targeted for interest groups. Six (6) interest groups were identified: agricultural and rural interests; parks and recreation, soil, and environmental interests; real estate professionals, developers, and builders; transportation, utility, and emergency service interests; economic development, business, industry, and downtown interests; and neighborhood associations and lake associations. Invitation letters were sent to over 100 individuals seeking their participation. An allday series of interviews was held with representatives from each interest group. The interest groups met independently to ensure adequate attention was given to each specific area of interest. Each interest group was given a brief overview of the comprehensive planning process and invited to participate in the Community Values Survey. Interviewees were asked to share their attitudes and 3 Community Profile perceptions about growth and development in and around Kendallville, as well as identify the community’s assets, liabilities, and needs. Interest group participants were given the opportunity to identify or explain specific issues relating to their interests. Thirty-six (36) people participated in the initial interest group interview. COMMUNITY LEADERS ROUNDTABLE Invitations were sent to community leaders that have an interest in community planning. These groups included Kendallville’s elected officials, the Kendallville Board of Public Works, members of the Kendallville Advisory Plan Commission, and members of the Kendallville Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA). was published in the local newspaper, provided to a local radio station, and distributed to the Chamber of Commerce. In total, twenty-six (26) people participated in the public workshops. The public workshop participants were first asked to complete the Community Values Survey. The second part of the public workshop required participants to identify Kendallville’s liabilities, assets, and needs. Each participant was asked to dream about what they would accomplish in Kendallville if funding was not an issue. For a complete list of the needs identified during the public workshops, as well as a listing of the liabilities, assets, and dreams, refer to Appendix B. The leadership was given a brief overview of the comprehensive planning process and asked to participate in the Community Values Survey. The City’s leadership was asked to discuss the current state of affairs in Kendallville and to identify the community’s strengths and weaknesses. The City’s leadership was asked to dream and discuss what the best future for Kendallville would be. Finally, leaders were encouraged to share advice on the preparation of the Comprehensive Plan. ADDITIONAL OPPORTUNITIES The Community Values Survey was also made available at the Office of Building, Planning, and Zoning for those residents who were interested in participating, but unable to attend a public workshop. PUBLIC WORKSHOPS The third opportunity for input was a set of two (2) public workshops aimed to gather information from the general public. One (1) public workshop was scheduled for 4:00 PM to catch people at the tail end of the workday or on their way home from work, and a second workshop was set in the evening. Those community leaders, interest group participants, and members of the general public that participated in the initial input part of the process were personally invited to review a draft of the Kendallville Comprehensive Plan. Additionally, a press release was submitted to local media to generate awareness about the Kendallville Comprehensive Plan and to solicit feedback on the draft. Informal “open house” meetings were held to hear comments and answer questions about the draft of the plan. To promote the public workshops, postcard invitations were sent to 300 residents. Approximately twenty-five percent (25%) of the post cards were sent to residents of the extra-territorial jurisdictional area, while the other seventy-five percent (75%) went to residents inside the Kendallville City Limits. A press release about the public workshops 4 A follow up article was written and submitted to the local newspaper to educate the public and increase awareness about the drafting of the Kendallville Comprehensive Plan. The article also served to solicit additional public participation. CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Community Profile Public Hearing A legally advertised public hearing was held by the Kendallville Advisory Plan Commission on May 3, 2010. The Plan Commission unanimously certified the Comprehensive Plan, and sent it to the Kendallville City Council for final adoption. Conclusion Based on demographic research and input from City leaders, local interest groups, and residents of Kendallville’s planning jurisdiction, the primary community needs in Kendallville are: Establishing policies to address basic growth and development issues such as the extension of utility infrastructure and annexation. Revitalizing the community’s core including the downtown commercial area; surrounding older residential neighborhoods; and abandoned industrial properties. Committing to the Comprehensive Plan and planning, in general, to best utilize the community’s resources. Broadening the community’s economic base by encouraging diversity in the types of employers and employment opportunities. Encouraging full utilization of Kendallville’s rich amenities and enhancement of those amenities where necessary and practical. The remaining chapters address these important issues, as well as other issues, by outlining a vision, goals, objectives, and implementation measures. CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 5 Community Profile 6 CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Chapter Two Vision Vision City of Kendallville’s Vision for the Future In an effort to develop a vision for Kendallville, the Steering Committee spent hours assessing various components of the community for the Comprehensive Plan. The Committee seemed to always come back to the question “for whom is this Plan intended?” The City of Kendallville is already a familyfriendly and visitor-friendly place. This fact shined through during every community input session. Friendly, caring people; low crime; quality schools; great recreational facilities; and a high quality of life coupled with a moderate cost of living make Kendallville an ideal place to raise a family. Several of these characteristics also make Kendallville a great place to visit. The City of Kendallville desires to maintain and strengthen its identity as a “familyfriendly” community by attracting families and keeping them in Kendallville throughout their retirement years. This Plan focuses on maximizing the opportunities to live, work, and recreate for families – both families that currently call Kendallville home and those that will in the future. Once a generation has completed its education (e.g. secondary or post-secondary) and the necessary social and geographic exploration often associated with young adulthood, it will be attracted to or back to the amenities, character, and opportunities that Kendallville possesses. Those same features, along with quality medical care and specialty housing opportunities like condominiums, will also appeal to and be appreciated by those nearing or in retirement. The “opportunities to recreate” that families find so appealing combined with special events will make Kendallville a great place for visitors, thereby strengthening the City’s identity as a visitor-friendly place. 8 CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Chapter Three Manage Land Use and Growth Manage Land Use and Growth Introduction The land use portion of this section is a core component of the Comprehensive Plan and is mandated by State Statute. Land use is simply how a piece of land is used. Thus, future land use is how a piece of land is best suited to be used in the future. Future land use should not be confused with zoning. A piece of ground can be zoned one way, but the future use of that same piece of ground could be completely different. For example, an area may be zoned “agricultural,” but its future land use may be “industrial.” More differences between future land use and zoning are listed in the table below. Future Land Use Zoning Not legally binding Legally binding A “guide” for development and/or change “Laws” that regulate development and change General – land use classification is tied to an area Specific – zoning district is tied to each parcel The “Plan” A tool to implement the “Plan” Future Land Use Classification Map usually reviewed and amended every five years and initiated by a governmental body Zoning Map usually amended on an as-needed basis and initiated by a property owner It is the intent of this Plan to encourage the advancement of compact form within the corporate limits of the City of Kendallville. Compact form describes a land use pattern that emphasizes full utilization of land inside the City to promote effective, well-organized, and responsible development. It is, in essence, using land resources responsibly and recognizing that land is a limited resource. Communities that recognize, plan for, and implement the compact form concept are typically more pedestrian-friendly and have an improved quality of life. These communities are more economically stable and achieve a 10 higher quality of public services with lower tax rates. While outlining policies that advance compact land use forms, this Plan also acknowledges the existence of a suburban-style land use pattern in specific areas within the corporate limits as well as in the extra-territorial jurisdiction. Kendallville shall support this type of development where and when it is appropriate. This chapter addresses current land use issues, and attempts to minimize and mitigate conflicts in the future by appropriately distributing land uses, as illustrated on the Future Land Use Classification Map. The Kendallville planning jurisdiction has been divided into land use classifications based on the current use of the land, adjacent uses, accessibility, availability of infrastructure and services, and the suitability of the land. The Future Land Use Classification Map and the policies of advancing compact form, while acknowledging the existence of a suburbanstyle development in certain areas, are consistent with and support the land use policies contained within the Noble County Comprehensive Plan. A goal, objectives, and implementation measures that address land use and growth management issues are identified in the remainder of this chapter. Implementation measures are abbreviated as IM, and identified with a number that corresponds with the appropriate objective. CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Manage Land Use and Growth Goal: Manage Land Use and Growth Proactively manage and direct growth and development in the City of Kendallville to provide an orderly and responsible land development pattern, community sustainability, and the highest quality of life for current and future residents. Objective 1: Advance Compact Form. IM 1.1 Update the Kendallville Zoning Ordinance to accommodate and support infill, redevelopment, and compact form. IM 1.2 IM 1.3 IM 1.4 Objective 2: Manage Community Growth. IM 2.1 Utilize the Comprehensive Plan and Future Land Use Classification Map when considering development proposals and rezoning petitions. Recognize that small deviations from this Plan and the Future Land Use Classification Map will accumulate and have a negative impact on the City’s future. IM 2.2 Update, utilize, and enforce the Kendallville Zoning Ordinance, Kendallville Subdivision Control Ordinance, and other applicable ordinances. IM 2.3 Ensure an adequate quantity of suitable land exists for all desired land uses. Encourage the revitalization of commercial buildings in and around downtown Kendallville through programs such as the existing Façade Improvement Matching Grant Program. IM 2.4 Establish policies outlining when new development is required to connect to public utilities. IM 2.5 Develop policies to help evaluate the expansion of the Kendallville City Limits through annexation. Develop and offer incentives for the redevelopment of vacant industrial properties. IM 2.6 Modify the Kendallville Subdivision Control Ordinance to protect existing streets from damages caused by construction traffic associated with new development. Promote redevelopment by placing an equal priority on providing improved infrastructure and services to vacant lots in need of infill development and areas in need of redevelopment. CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 11 Manage Land Use and Growth Objective 3: Mitigate Conflicting Land Uses. IM 3.1 Explicitly permit existing agricultural operations to continue at current levels. IM 3.2 IM 3.3 Buffer residential and other sensitive land uses from commercial and industrial development or redevelopment. Modify the Kendallville Zoning Ordinance to include adult business regulations and anti-funneling regulations; and to insure any “useconversions” are consistent with the character of the neighborhood. IM 3.4 Protect the Kendallville Municipal Airport from the encroachment of noise-sensitive uses that may hinder future expansion of the facility and increases in operations. IM 3.5 Incorporate non-remonstrance provisions for annexation and “right to farm” language into the rezoning and subdivision approval process. IM 3.6 Incorporate non-remonstrance provisions for airport expansion into the zoning and subdivision approval process when projects are proposed within one (1) mile of the Kendallville Municipal Airport. 12 Objective 4: Improve Communication About the ExtraTerritorial Jurisdiction. IM 4.1 Document the procedure for development and enforcement within the extra-territorial jurisdiction and make it available to the development community. IM 4.2 Require City standards to be met for all infrastructure improvements within the extra-territorial jurisdiction. IM 4.3 Establish policies for connecting to public utilities and policies for the expansion of the corporate limits through annexation. CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Manage Land Use and Growth Additional Information Eighty-eight percent (88%) of respondents in the Community Values Survey want to regulate land use to prevent conflicts even if it means losing the development investment. This speaks strongly about the degree of regulation and quality of development that Kendallville residents expect. The following sections provide additional information necessary to promote redevelopment and allocate and distribute growth and development throughout Kendallville’s planning jurisdiction. AGRICULTURE Because Kendallville’s planning jurisdiction extends nearly two (2) miles beyond the Kendallville City Limits, it is essential that the community recognize agricultural operations within the planning jurisdiction. The agricultural land within the extra-territorial jurisdiction gives the community the land it needs to continue to grow and develop, and also contributes to Kendallville’s small town charm. Respondents to the Community Values Survey were indecisive about protecting all productive agricultural land from new development and permitting productive agricultural land to be developed. Twentynine percent (29%) were neutral between the two (2) extremes, and another forty-one percent (41%) of the respondents did not feel strongly either way. The conclusion is that undeveloped land near the City is expected to eventually develop regardless if it is productive agricultural land or not. The agricultural community generally does not want to stand in the way of community growth. However, local farmers want the right to continue agricultural operations until they choose to sell or develop the land. This means that residents of new developments located adjacent to agricultural land should have little right to complain about the impacts CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 and effects of existing agricultural operations. New development should not adversely impact drainage of agricultural land. Additionally, the agricultural community within the extra-territorial jurisdiction sometimes feels “left out” when it comes to enforcement of issues like trespassing. OPEN SPACE AND RECREATION Access to open space and recreational areas is essential to a high quality of life, good health, and community spirit. Specifically in Kendallville, these areas include Bixler Lake Park and Campground, Sunset Park, the Kendallville Outdoor Recreation Complex, Noble County Fairgrounds, Detering Nature Preserve, Lonidaw Nature Preserve, multiple golf courses, and the lakes in and around Kendallville. From a land use and growth management perspective, open space and recreational areas are valuable because they can serve as a way to protect environmentally sensitive areas by incorporating them into an amenity that can be appreciated and enjoyed by the public. Often, these areas also create a buffer between noncompatible land uses. Generally, Kendallville should strive to maintain its existing recreational and open space areas. The City should consider adding to the system of recreation and open space, by modifying the Kendallville Subdivision Control Ordinance to require subdivisions of a certain size (e.g. either number of lots or acres of property) to provide land, develop it, and maintain it as open space and/or recreational areas. The regulations can range from very simple – such as requiring an outdoor picnic area in an office complex – to something more substantial such as requiring the installation of a playground in a residential subdivision. Specific details about the Kendallville parks and recreation system are in Chapter Five: Serve Community Needs. 13 Manage Land Use and Growth RESIDENTIAL Residential uses include single-family homes, multiple-family buildings, condominiums, assisted living facilities, and the like. Kendallville desires to provide housing opportunities for people with different incomes, needs, and desires. The City also recognizes that housing needs change with the economy and as people age and their household size changes. A mix of housing is important so that residents are able to find housing that enables them to live in Kendallville throughout their lives. Residential in Rural Areas For the purposes of this Plan, residential in rural areas is meant to include residential lots within the City’s extra-territorial jurisdiction that are at least two (2) acres (or adequately sized to comply with Noble County Health Department regulations for septic); without water and/or sewer utilities; and generally developed with driveway access directly off of a county road. Rural residential development reduces the opportunity for the City to expand and grow. A strip of residential development along a county road makes it cost prohibitive to provide utilities to those homes, and more importantly, to land beyond those homes. The proliferation of rural residential development can be detrimental to community growth by inadvertently creating a growth boundary for the community. Unfortunately, big picture issues like this are not a typical consideration when such a proposal is presented. Kendallville should strictly limit new rural residential development in the City’s planning jurisdiction. 14 Residential in Lake Areas Kendallville should establish regulations to minimize or eliminate the potential for “funneling” along the lakes. While the lake shorelines appear to be completely developed, it is possible for one (1) lot to be purchased, and the structures to be demolished to allow for this type of development. Funneling occurs when a lakefront property is used to provide lake access for “second tier” development. Funneling typically adds a larger population of lake users each with their own watercraft. The additional number of watercraft results in an increase of noise and environmental degradation and decreases water safety and quality of life for lake residents. New lake residential developments should have architectural features that building off surrounding properties or are “cottage” style. These structures will also have front façade characteristics on the façade that face the street and the lake shore. Residential Areas on the Fringe For the purposes of this Plan, residential areas on the fringe are generally meant to include subdivisions with curvilinear streets, homes that are generally wider than they are deep, and lots that are larger than 11,000 square feet (¼ of an acre), but smaller than 43,560 square feet (1 acre). While the City should emphasize compact form as the primary style of development for all land use types, the desire for suburbanstyle subdivisions is the preference of some. The City must recognize that costs associated with providing service to this type of development are higher than the costs associated with compact development. However, good planning and management of suburban-style residential developments will allow these areas to be efficiently and effectively incorporated into the community. CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Manage Land Use and Growth Infill development in residential areas on the fringe should be consistent in character with the neighborhood context (e.g. similar widthto-depth ratios and 4:12 or greater pitch for roof lines). Residential in Urban Areas Kendallville officials recognize the importance of older compact residential neighborhoods. The City has applied for and will continue to apply for grants for neighborhood stabilization and improvement when such funds are available. The most recent proposed project (in 2009-2010) involves the purchase of homes in neighborhoods directly east of downtown Kendallville. These homes will be rehabilitated before they are sold to moderateincome families. Traditional, old town-style neighborhoods possess character and diversity of housing opportunities that can be marketed to various age groups, family sizes, and income levels. These neighborhoods are also a vital part of revitalizing the core of Kendallville. For this reason, it is critical that the City review and revise enforcement and penalty sections of the Kendallville Zoning Ordinance and other code provisions, while stepping up actual enforcement. roof pitch, open front porches, and structures that are deeper than they are wide. A traditional residential zoning district could also be used to better regulate conversions from single-family homes to duplexes or triplexes that seem to be the source of many land use conflicts. The zoning district would not necessarily prohibit these types of conversions; it would just require the conversions to be completed in a way that compliments the neighborhood and mitigates possible conflict. Additionally, a traditional residential zoning district provides the opportunity for expansion of the City’s existing gridiron street pattern and/or a new “traditional residential” neighborhood to develop elsewhere in the City, further advancing compact form. Another way to work towards improving older compact residential neighborhoods is to make sure the City’s zoning regulations are conducive to improving and protecting these properties. The Kendallville Zoning Ordinance should be modified to include a “traditional residential” zoning district that would make it easier to improve existing properties without adding extra processes. The regulations might allow for greater coverage ratios, smaller setbacks, and alley access. A traditional residential zoning district would also allow the development of vacant lots in a way that is consistent with the neighborhood, potentially requiring a certain CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 15 Manage Land Use and Growth RESIDENTIAL GROWTH MANAGEMENT It is important to note at the time of this Plan, national, regional, and local real estate markets have been greatly impacted by a prolonged economic recession. The current real estate market is weak with homes being worth notably less than they were just a couple of years ago. Executive Housing The supply of executive housing (i.e. $250,000 and greater) is adequate in Kendallville until the year 2025. Both existing homes and lots available for new custom home construction are plentiful. Particularly, new homes and available lots can be found in Noble Hawk and Cobblestone golf course communities. The fully developed lake communities of Round Lake and Little Long Lake, as well as various homes and properties scattered throughout Kendallville, also offer alternative executive housing opportunities. The supply of moderate cost condominiums, villaminiums, and high quality attached single-family homes and apartments that would attract young professionals, young families, and seniors is very limited in Kendallville. The City’s condominium complexes are full with minimal turnover. The City has two (2) villaminium developments which are similar to condominiums except that the owner actually owns the land as well as the home, and pays into an association for exterior maintenance. Additionally, these developments do not have extra amenities such as a club house or recreational facilities. To appeal to these target populations, Kendallville should plan for and encourage the development of high density, moderate cost housing alternatives, specifically condominiums, villaminiums, and high quality attached single-family homes in the form of duplexes and townhomes. Moderate Cost Housing Moderate cost housing (i.e. $100,000 to $250,000) includes single-family detached homes, single-family attached homes (i.e. duplexes and townhomes), condominiums, and high quality apartments. Low Cost Housing Low cost housing (i.e. less than $100,000) includes single-family detached homes, single-family attached homes (i.e. duplexes and townhomes), income-based apartments, and market rate apartments. The supply of moderate cost single-family detached homes seems to be adequate now – in a weak real estate market. There is tremendous diversity with single-family detached options being available in many subdivisions including Hollybrook Heights, Knolls of Fairview, and Buffalo Ridge. Moderate cost housing options are also available in Kendallville’s traditional residential neighborhoods and near the lakes. Quality, low cost housing in the form of income-based and market-rate apartments are in short supply in Kendallville. Deerfield Apartments and Drake Terrace, which offer income-based apartments, are consistently above ninety-five percent (95%) occupancy. Nelson Estates provides market-rate apartments and is regularly above ninety percent (90%) occupancy. The Kendallville Retirement Community is consistently full with a short waiting list. While there are lots available for new construction in Kendallville’s newer subdivisions, as Kendallville’s population continues to grow, those wishing to build might find it difficult to find an available lot. Kendallville should plan for and encourage the platting of moderate cost single-family detached subdivisions. 16 Low cost single-family detached homes are plentiful in the current market. There are homes in traditional neighborhoods as well as older subdivisions that fit into this price range. Kendallville should plan for the development of more low cost housing opportunities. CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Manage Land Use and Growth These should primarily include apartments and attached single-family dwellings in the form of duplexes or townhomes. Type of Future Residential Development Based on the supply and type of housing opportunities in Kendallville, projected increases in population, and Kendallville’s vision of being a family-friendly community, residential growth in Kendallville’s future should include: New moderate cost housing in the form of urban and suburban subdivisions comprised of single-family attached or detached homes; New moderate cost housing in the form of condominiums, villaminiums, and quality apartments with on-site amenities; New low cost housing in the form of single-family attached homes and apartments; and New low cost housing designed specifically for the aging population. Regardless of the type of residential development, the City of Kendallville will discourage developments with uniform appearance, and emphasize quality landscaping, canopy trees, architectural diversity, and character in new residential developments. CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Quantity of Future Residential Development Kendallville experienced a twenty-three percent (23%) growth in population from 1990 to 2000, and experienced an estimated seven percent (7%) growth in population from 2000 to 2008. Population increases will likely continue in Kendallville. The 2030 population projections released by the US Census Bureau predict a seven percent (7%) growth rate for Noble County and a twelve percent (12%) growth rate for the State of Indiana. For the purposes of this Plan, a ten percent (10%) growth rate will be used to project the 2030 population of the City of Kendallville. When the population projections are converted into dwelling units, Kendallville could add 400 to 500 new dwelling units between the years 2010 and 2020; and another 400 to 500 new dwelling units between 2020 and 2030. Using one-third (1/3) of an acre (i.e. lot size of 100 feet by 150 feet) as the average lot size, approximately 150 acres of land will be needed for new residential development between the years 2010 and 2020. Another 150 acres of land will be needed for new residential development between 2020 and 2030. At least twenty-five percent (25%) of the projected residential development will be high density. 17 Manage Land Use and Growth Established Residential Established Residential areas are already constructed or platted as residential, and need to be “fully absorbed.” These areas should be the first priority for new residential development. The Established Residential areas will primarily fulfill the need for residential development in Kendallville from 2010 to 2020. Location of Future Residential Development The aforementioned figures (i.e. population growth, new households, and acreage for new residential development) give an estimate of the residential growth that Kendallville can expect to experience over the next twenty (20) years. However, it is much more important to the future of Kendallville that the location of growth be managed, regardless of the actual quantity. The Residential Development Phasing Map extracts the residential areas from the Future Land Use Classification Map and assigns each a timeframe for development. SCHOOLHOUSE RD WAYNE CENTER RD (CR 900 E) CR 900 N (CR 825 N) A RPORT RD APPLEMAN RD (CR 800N) ALLEN CHAPEL RD L e Long Lake STRATER ROAD (CR 750 N) N RD COUNTY L NE RD RD RIL EY G IN GL NORTH LIMA RD AN CR 600 E SAWYER RD (CR 660 E) R MMEL RD (CR 800 N) Round Lake KAMMERER RD DIAMOND ST DRAKE RD B x e Lake GARDEN ST WESTON (CR 600 N) PROGRESS DR EAST DOWLING ST ST ROGERS RD DOWLING ST AVE LL MITCHE FAIR ST RILEY ST Hende son Lake PARK AVE OR LIMA RD CH AR D PL MA N ST US HIGHWAY 6 CR 600 E HENRY ST WAITS RD (CR 500 N) CR 1000 E BEACON RD (CR 700 E) SHERMAN ST MA N ST MAPES ROAD (CR 550 N) LIS BO D NR (CR 415 Residential Development Phasing Map MAP LEGEND N) Established Residential (2010 - 2020) CR 750 E Planned Residential (2015 - 2030) Future Residential (2025+ ) Extra-Territorial Jurisdiction CR 350 N STATE RD 8 18 CR 300 N CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Manage Land Use and Growth Planned Residential Planned Residential areas are for new residential growth once Established Residential areas are ninety percent (90%) utilized. Planned Residential areas may be used to accommodate a development cannot be accommodated in an Established Residential area only when the development adjacent to existing development AND is clearly a benefit to the community. Planned Residential areas include expansions of existing residential subdivisions as well as entirely new residential areas, and include the following areas (in no particular order): Between North Lima Road and Richard Road; The area south of Appleman Road (County Road 800N) and west of Allen Chapel Road (County Road 1000E) extending stub streets like Northfield Lane and Edgewood Drive; Between North Lima Road and Angling Road; South of Bixler Lake Park on both sides of Sherman Street; South of Waits Road (County Road 500N) on both sides of Sherman Street extended; and Along Drake Road, west of State Road 3 and extending south along Beacon Road (County Road 700E). Planned Residential areas will likely fill the need for residential development in Kendallville from the year 2015 to 2030. CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Future Residential Future Residential areas are reserved for residential development to serve Kendallville’s population from the year 2025 and beyond. Kendallville recognizes some of the proposed locations for new residential growth are along the railroad, and appropriate buffering and setbacks will be required before any development is approved for these areas. The Future Land Use Classification Map designates a significant quantity of land for future suburban residential and high-density residential, much more than the projected 300 acres needed over the next twenty (20) years. There are many reasons for this. First, property is not always available meaning there is not always a willing seller. Second, the population projections and extrapolation of those projections could be conservative. Most importantly, the areas designated for future residential development have certain characteristics that make them more suitable for residential development than for other types of development including proximity to utilities; proximity to schools and parks; vehicular accessibility and safety; and potential for pedestrian connectivity. In most cases, the City has already recognized certain land is most suited for residential development at a density to support utility systems. This is evident in how the water and sewer systems have expanded through these future growth areas. It is vital that Kendallville “reserve” this land for future suburban and high density residential development, even if that development occurs twenty (20) or more years into the future. The community will then be able to realize a return on the infrastructure investment that has already been made and make the best use of the community’s land resources. 19 Manage Land Use and Growth COMMERCIAL Commercial uses include retail, service, office, entertainment, restaurant, and similar establishments. In Kendallville, primary commercial areas include downtown Kendallville and the US Highway 6 Corridor. There are also dispersed low intensity commercial nodes in and around the City. It should be noted that public workshop participants listed “quality restaurants” as the City’s biggest need. Downtown Kendallville Downtown Kendallville can be roughly defined as the 100 block of North Main Street, and the 100 and 200 blocks of South Main Street. It is a remarkable stretch of historic commercial buildings that together comprise a Historic District on the National Register. It is critical that the community continue to take the steps necessary to protect, preserve, enhance, and continue the revitalization of Downtown Kendallville. Downtown serves as the nostalgic core of the community even though it is no longer the primary commercial hub. The Community Values Survey suggests residents do share a fondness for the historic character of these buildings, but not at the cost of losing investment and jobs. Downtown Kendallville has a good mix of uses including the entertainment opportunities, small scale restaurants, specialty retail stores, offices, service-oriented businesses, and businesses in finance, insurance, and real estate. Kendallville city government is also a key component of downtown. Downtown Kendallville is going to benefit most from the continuation of the current mixture of uses, and adding second floor occupancy in the form of offices or residential lofts. The downtown would also benefit from a pocket park or plaza area that can serve as a center for downtown activities. 20 A well-crafted “downtown commercial” zoning district would help permit and support the mixed use composition that is critical to downtown’s revitalization. Such a district might create more accommodating regulations such as relaxed parking regulations and promote front and rear customer entrances. A downtown commercial zoning district could help ensure that infill of vacant lots (that could occur in the future) is consistent in character with existing downtown buildings. US Highway 6 Corridor With approximately 20,000 vehicles passing through each day, commercial uses find the US Highway 6 Corridor very appealing. Those uses primarily include restaurants, gas stations, and retail stores. The market supports, and will sustain, this type of land use indefinitely along US Highway 6. The City of Kendallville has enacted architectural standards for new development along US Highway 6. These standards ensure quality development and redevelopment of property along US Highway 6 and improve the first impression people get when driving through Kendallville. There are several areas along the US Highway 6 Corridor expected to transition to commercial uses over the next twenty (20) years. Specific attention should be given to make new development and redevelopment projects provide pedestrian facilities; safe vehicular access; minimal curb cuts; high quality development; and appropriate buffering to sensitive adjacent uses. Low Intensity Commercial Nodes There are a handful of low intensity commercial nodes in Kendallville. Generally, these are small commercial establishments geared toward serving a very specific and geographically-close population. The South Side Market on South Main Street and the Fasten-All store on US Highway 6 are both examples of low intensity commercial nodes. CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Manage Land Use and Growth The City of Kendallville’s zoning ordinance should accommodate these types of commercial nodes when appropriate. It is critical that these nodes be small and context sensitive to mitigate conflict with the dominate use of the area. These areas have prime accessibility, proximity to utilities, visibility, and appropriate uses planned for adjacent parcels. As a result, these areas should be reserved for future commercial development. The Future Commercial Development Phasing Map extracts the commercial areas from the Future Land Use Classification Map and assigns each a timeframe for development. COMMERCIAL GROWTH MANAGEMENT There is currently enough land zoned and available for commercial development in Kendallville to fulfill the needs of the community for at least the next twenty (20) years. However, there are certain areas that possess characteristics that make them more suitable for commercial development than other types of development. SCHOOLHOUSE RD WAYNE CENTER RD (CR 900 E) CR 900 N (CR 825 N) AIRPORT RD APPLEMAN RD (CR 800N) ALLEN CHAPEL RD L e Long Lake STRATER ROAD (CR 750 N) N RD COUNTY LINE RD RD RIL EY G IN GL NORTH LIMA RD AN CR 600 E SAWYER RD (CR 660 E) RIMMEL RD (CR 800 N) Round Lake KAMMERER RD FA R ST RILEY ST Hende son Lake AVE DIAMOND ST DRAKE RD B x e Lake GARDEN ST WESTON (CR 600 N) PROGRESS DR EAST DOWLING ST ROGERS RD DOWLING ST LL ST M TCHE ARK AVE OR LIMA RD CH AR D PL MAIN ST US HIGHWAY 6 CR 600 E HENRY ST WAITS RD (CR 500 N) CR 1000 E BEACON RD (CR 700 E) SHERMAN ST MA N ST MAPES ROAD (CR 550 N) LIS BO D NR (CR 415 Commercial Development Phasing Map MAP LEGEND N) Established Commercial (2010 - 2020) CR 750 E Planned Commercial (2020 - 2030) Future Commerc ial (2028+ ) Extra-Territorial Jurisdiction CR 350 N STATE RD 8 CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 CR 300 N 21 Manage Land Use and Growth Established Commercial Established Commercial areas are the downtown, existing commercial buildings along US Highway 6, and existing buildings in the low intensity commercial nodes. These areas need to be “fully utilized.” These properties should be the first priority for reuse, redevelopment, infill, and increased intensity to absorb new or changing commercial establishments. The Established Commercial areas should fill the need for commercial development in Kendallville from the year 2010 to 2020. in Kendallville from the year 2028 and beyond. Planned Commercial Planned Commercial areas are for new growth once Established Commercial areas are ninety percent (90%) “utilized” or when a new development cannot be accommodated in an Established Commercial area; AND only when the development is clearly a benefit to the community. Planned Commercial areas include greenfield sites as well as redevelopment sites, and will likely fill the need for commercial development in Kendallville from the year 2020 to 2030. Kendallville will limit commercial development along State Road 3 to two (2) specific areas: the T-intersection of State Road 3 and US Highway 6; and along State Road 3 south of Drake Road, with the most intense development being on the west side of State Road 3. These commercial developments shall have cohesive design; safe vehicular access off of Commerce Drive extended south and Drake Road; pedestrian facilities; quality materials and architectural design; and landscaping. South State Road 3 Corridor State Road 3, south of US Highway 6, is a four-lane limited access highway, with moderate to high traffic counts, and a significant quantity of available frontage. These characteristics make it very attractive for commercial development. With careful planning and management of growth, the area can be selectively developed to provide safe and accessible consumer opportunities for residential development in those areas. Future Commercial Future Commercial areas are reserved for commercial development to serve Kendallville’s population eighteen (18) years or more from now. The areas possess ideal qualities for commercial development: visibility, accessibility, and proximity to utilities. It is important that these parcels be identified now, because the first wave of development pressure could suggest institutional or residential uses that in the long term would not maximize the benefit to the City. Utilizing these “ideally commercial” areas for non-commercial uses will push commercial developments to locations that are not as well suited, thus compromising accessibility, safety, efficiency, and land resources. These Future Commercial areas will fill the need for commercial development 22 CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Manage Land Use and Growth INDUSTRIAL Industrial uses in Kendallville include manufacturing, warehousing, distribution, assembly and similar operations. Kendallville’s industrial areas provide many jobs and a diversified tax base; they are also a source of pride for community residents. From “home grown” industries like Flint and Walling, to national names like Kraft, Kendallville has a notable industrial base. GENERAL GROWTH MANAGEMENT STRATEGIES US Highway 6 Growth Pressure The pressure to grow out – along US Highway 6 in general – is obvious. This expansion outward often results in a contraction inward for the rest of the community. Additionally, this growth pattern creates a strain on City services such as longer distances for Fire Department and Police Department responses, and the elongation of utility systems. Industry can generate heavy truck traffic, noise, undesirable aesthetic appearance, air pollution, and the like. Kendallville will mitigate the potential negative effects of industrial development by promoting industrial uses where quality access to highways and railways exist, where they are compatible with adjacent uses, and where adequate utilities and public services exist. This Plan supports the growth along US Highway 6 when City services and utilities can support it, and when established areas are unable to accommodate the development. For instance, continuing to grow to the east along US Highway 6, without funding a new fire station and fire personnel to serve that area, could increase the City’s Insurance Service Organization (ISO) rating, thereby increasing insurance premiums for ALL property owners, and potentially making Kendallville less attractive to those wishing to invest. This is why compact form and making the best use of urban areas is so critical to Kendallville’s future. INDUSTRIAL GROWTH MANAGEMENT Kendallville’s industrial uses are located primarily in the East Industrial Park. However, there are smaller industrial areas located southwest of downtown along Ohio Street; directly north and west of downtown along Krueger Street; and in the northwest part of Kendallville along Stonebraker Drive. The East Industrial Park currently has two (2) lots, totaling 100 acres, available as industrial greenfield sites. There are at least a dozen industrial buildings totaling over 620,000 square feet of space available for sale or lease. Kendallville will take an active role in the redevelopment of some of these properties, and encourage their reuse and redevelopment over greenfield site development. CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Commercial and residential growth should be consistent with the “Phasing Maps” (contained within this section) that limit expansion outward, particularly along US Highway 6. Industrial expansions along US Highway 6, beyond the Kendallville Industrial Park East, should be permitted only when the demonstrated benefits to the community significantly outweigh the costs. 23 Manage Land Use and Growth Protection of Existing Infrastructure Kendallville should also take steps to protect existing infrastructure from being damaged or torn up during development. Concerns specifically involve heavy construction traffic accessing a new development site on inadequate streets. Streets, not designed to handle heavy traffic, could be damaged or destroyed during construction. Although the community is left with a nice new development, the streets accessing it would be in poor condition. There are a variety of ways the City can mitigate this issue. The City may designate “heavy construction traffic routes” and require the developer to use those routes as part of the approval. If such routes do not exist, potentially the City and developer can work together to reinforce streets or portions of streets to create such a route. The City could ask for financial security (e.g. bonds or line of credit) from a developer as part of the approval process. AIRPORT The Kendallville Municipal Airport’s ability to grow and expand its operations is impacted by the uses of land surrounding it. An Airport Hazard Overlay District should be added to the Kendallville Zoning Ordinance to protect the airport from incompatible adjacent uses. Such a district would add a set of regulations – primarily restricting noise-sensitive uses, lighting, and height – to the base zoning district. The Airport Hazard Overlay District might also include some basic public education mechanisms. As existing homes or businesses within the Airport Hazard Overlay District are modified, maybe a one-sheet informational brochure is given to the owner during the permit process. The brochure could simply remind the owner of their proximity to the airport and how the airport might impact the property in the future. New development could received the same type of literature, but 24 also be required to sign a “non-remonstrance” waiver. While industrial land uses are typically compatible with airport operations, land around the Kendallville Municipal Airport is not a logical location for all types of new industry. Kendallville’s industrial parks with prime accessibility and utility infrastructure are a better location for most industry. As a result, the future land use strategy around the Kendallville Municipal Airport should include preserving agricultural land uses as long as possible. Airport acquisition of adjacent agricultural land before growth/development pressures arise would provide the best protection. If land acquisition by the airport is not possible, business centers or technology facilities that are not noisesensitive would be most compatible with the airport. ANNEXATION Since 2000, Kendallville has completed a handful of voluntary annexations including the Parkview Noble Hospital complex and areas within the East Industrial Park. While Kendallville prefers voluntary annexations, the City should consider involuntary annexations that enable growth of the community while maintaining or reducing property tax rates. The City of Kendallville commits to undertaking annexation only when it is beneficial to the fiscal interest of the current residents and taxpayers of the City. The State of Indiana’s current one percent (1%) cap on owner-occupied residences, two percent (2%) cap on farms and enter-occupied residences, and three percent (3%) cap on industrial and commercial property will impact the distribution of taxes to all local governments when it is fully implemented in 2010. CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Manage Land Use and Growth Revenues Annexation provides revenue to the City in the form of property taxes. Annexation does not result in a decrease in property tax revenue for other taxing agencies. For example, the county and library would not lose tax revenue if the City annexed an area. City and to the fiscal interest of the residents and taxpayers of the City. Annexation can result in the City receiving additional revenue for Motor Vehicle Highway Fund, Local Road and Street Funds, and economic development-related income taxes. These funds are based on population or miles of streets, and would result in a transfer of revenue to the City of Kendallville. Expenditures The expenses incurred by the City for annexation are for the provision of municipal services, both capital and non-capital. Generally, these services include utility infrastructure and service, parks, police, fire (to those not already in Township), and administrative services. There is often confusion that a municipality must provide sidewalks, curbs, lighting, and improved streets and width equivalent to the standard required by the City for new development. Aside from pressure to do so, this is not required. If annexation is not plausible for new developments in the extra territorial jurisdiction, it should be required to meet all of the infrastructure development standards of the City. Development that receives City utility service should also be required to include a non-remonstrance agreement that prohibits all current and future property owners from remonstrating. Annexation agreements that outline the conditions and proposed timeframe for annexation should also be included. The bottom line is annexation of adjacent developed areas should only be undertaken when it is beneficial to the future plans of the CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 25 Manage Land Use and Growth Future Land Use Classification Map The Future Land Use Classification Map applies land use classifications across Kendallville’s planning jurisdiction. The term “land use classification” is used instead of “land use” because each classification integrates both land use and development form. This hybrid approach for classifying future development of land will result in a better system for managing development, particularly in urban areas. The following land use classifications are used on the Land Use Classification Map found on page 41: Agricultural Rural Residential Open Space and Recreation Lake Residential Suburban Residential Urban Residential High Density Residential Office and Institutional Downtown Commercial Low Intensity Commercial High Intensity Commercial Industrial Airport Hazard Overlay Wellhead Protection Overlay LAND USE CLASSIFICATION AND DESCRIPTION Each of the land classifications listed above has a page dedicated to describing how it can be used to manage growth and development. Further, the following headings are used, as described below, to convey the essence of each classification. These descriptions are intended to be conceptual. widely applied, while others are very specific to geographic locations. Land Uses: This section describes the general land uses that would be permitted in the classification. The zoning ordinance would indicate specific land uses permitted. Examples: This section strives to convey one (1) or more developments in Kendallville to represent the classification. All examples may not be exact matches, but represent the most similar in intensity and density. Appropriate Adjacent Classifications: This section describes the land use classifications that are best used adjacent to the subject classification. Three (3) categories of compatibility exist. “Best Fit” are classifications that are most suited for adjacency. “Conditional Fit” indicates land classifications that are suitable for adjacency if the building orientation, transitions, and architecture are implemented with sensitivity. The third category is those land classifications not listed, which represent classifications that are not typically appropriate adjacent to the subject classification. Development and Structural Features: This section identifies structural features (height, mass, and form); the orientation of the structure(s) on the site; and features that would generally be applied to entire subdivisions. Regulation Implementation: This section describes how the City’s development regulations will implement the land use classification’s intent. Purpose: This section gives a brief description of why the land use classification has been established. Geographic Location: This section conveys where each classification is best utilized within Kendallville’s planning jurisdiction. Some descriptions are vague because they can be 26 CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Manage Land Use and Growth Agricultural Purpose To maintain undeveloped areas for productive agricultural uses; conservation of natural features; and as a resource for long-term future growth of the community Geographic Location Located primarily in Kendallville’s extraterritorial jurisdiction Land Uses Crops, pasturage, small confined feeding, farm buildings, and farm houses Hobby farms and orchards Forests and woodlots Examples Orchard Hill Farms TRS Farms, Barker Bros. Farms Appropriate Adjacent Classifications Best Fit: Agricultural, Open Space and Recreation, and Rural Residential Conditional Fit: Lake Residential, Suburban Residential, Office and Institutional, High Intensity Commercial, and Industrial Development and Structural Features Largely undeveloped farms and farmsteads Regulation Implementation Utilize traditional zoning to regulate this land use classification. Because Kendallville’s planning jurisdiction extends nearly two (2) miles beyond the Kendallville City Limits, it is essential that the community recognize agricultural land uses. CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 27 Manage Land Use and Growth Rural Residential Purpose To identify residential development that possesses rural characteristics including large lots, large front yard setbacks, driveway access directly off of a county road, and a density that does not support water and sanitary sewer infrastructure Geographic Location Located primarily within Kendallville’s extraterritorial jurisdiction Land Uses Single-family detached residential Hobby farms Examples Eagle’s Nest Addition Generally, property with metes and bounds legal descriptions Appropriate Adjacent Classifications Best Fit: Agricultural, Open Space and Recreation, Rural Residential, Lake Residential, and Suburban Residential Conditional Fit: Urban Residential, High Density Residential, and Office and Institutional Development and Structural Features These rural residential areas are along Drake Road. Centralized building envelope Lots two (2) acres or greater Maximum two (2) or three (3) stories with gable or hip roof, if the context reflects the same Regulation Implementation 28 Utilize traditional zoning to regulate this land use classification CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Manage Land Use and Growth Open Space and Recreation Purpose To protect established conservation areas; to establish open space; to serve as a transition between incompatible uses; and to preserve land for private and public parks and recreational facilities Geographic Location Distributed throughout Kendallville’s jurisdiction, generally within walking distance from residential areas, and in proximity to more dense residential areas Land Uses Parks, recreation, trails, golf courses, and nature preserves Examples Bixler Lake Park and Sunset Park Kendallville Country Club, Noble Hawk Golf Links, and Cobblestone Golf Course Kendallville Outdoor Recreation Complex Detering Nature Preserve Appropriate Adjacent Classifications Best Fit: All land use classification Development and Structural Features Internal and external pedestrian connectivity Promote active and/or passive recreation Protect and enhance environmental features Regulation Implementation Utilize traditional zoning to regulate this land use classification Recreational opportunities are diverse and plentiful in Kendallville. CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 29 Manage Land Use and Growth Lake Residential Purpose To recognize the uniqueness of residential areas on lakes and to take into consideration the concerns that accompany development on a waterfront Geographic Location Lots bordering lakes in Kendallville’s planning jurisdiction Land Uses Single-family detached residential One and two-family condominium units Examples Round Lake and Little Long Lake Appropriate Adjacent Classifications Best Fit: Open Space and Recreation, Rural Residential, Lake Residential, and Suburban Residential Conditional Fit: Agricultural, Urban Residential, High Density Residential, Office and Institutional, and Low Intensity Commercial Development and Structural Features Centralized building envelope Established street-side and water-side building setbacks should be utilized Internal and external pedestrian connectivity Maximum two (2) stories with gable and/or hip roofs Onsite garages facing perimeter road; front of home facing the lake Second tier lots may be used for accessory buildings Street layout follows shape of shoreline Structures and land alterations should be sensitive to the lake Little Long Lake and Round Lake help diversify housing opportunities in the Kendallville community. Regulation Implementation 30 Utilize traditional zoning to regulate this land use classification CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Manage Land Use and Growth Suburban Residential Purpose To establish housing opportunities that possess suburban-style characteristics including use of curvilinear street patterns and cul-de-sacs, curbed streets, lots between one-quarter (¼) acre and one (1) acre in size, attached garages, structures that are generally wider than they are deep, and generally, access to water and sanitary sewer utilities Geographic Location Located inside the outer edges of Kendallville City Limits, and to a limited degree, outside and contiguous to Kendallville City Limits Land Uses Single-family detached residential Neighborhood amenities Examples Country Club Hills, Cobblestone, and Noble Hawk Garden Park Village, Knolls of Fairview, and Orchard Place Hollybrook Heights Appropriate Adjacent Classifications Best Fit: Open Space and Recreation, Rural Residential, Lake Residential, Suburban Residential, and Urban Residential Conditional Fit: Agricultural, High Density Residential, Office and Institutional, and Low Intensity Commercial Development and Structural Features Attached garages Centralized building envelope Structures generally wider than they are deep Front façade facing a public right-of-way Internal and external pedestrian connectivity Maximum two (2) or three (3) stories with gable or hip roofs, if the context reflects the same Predominant use of curvilinear street layout with cul-de-sacs A variety of suburban residential developments are available in Kendallville. Regulation Implementation Utilize traditional zoning to regulate this land use classification CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 31 Manage Land Use and Growth Urban Residential Purpose To establish housing opportunities that possess traditional-neighborhood characteristics including lots less than quarter (¼) acre, small setbacks, high percentage of the lot covered with structures, gridiron pattern of streets and alleys, curbs, and older homes that are generally narrower than they are wide Geographic Location Utilized inside Kendallville City Limits, particularly contiguous to downtown Land Uses Small lot single-family detached residential Two-family residential units Townhouses Examples Residential portions of Mitchell’s Addition Idding’s Addition (intersection of South Oak Street and Vine Street) Clark’s Addition (intersection of Clark Street and Mott Street) Appropriate Adjacent Classifications Best Fit: Open Space and Recreation, Suburban Residential, Urban Residential, High Density Residential, and Low Intensity Commercial Conditional Fit: Lake Residential, Downtown Commercial, Office and Institutional, and High Intensity Commercial Development and Structural Features Centralized or zero lot line building envelope Front façade facing a public right-of-way Internal and external pedestrian connectivity Maximum two (2) or three (3) stories with gable or hip roof, if the context reflects the same scale Street pattern may vary between grid or modified grid Use of alleys Urban residential neighborhoods can be a vital part of revitalizing a community’s core. Regulation Implementation 32 Utilize hybrid (i.e. traditional and form-based) zoning to regulate this land use classification CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Manage Land Use and Growth High Density Residential Purpose To establish affordable and desirable housing opportunities for the young adult, temporary, and aging populations Geographic Location Utilized throughout Kendallville in medium-sized to small-sized nodes Land Uses Apartments Two-family residential units Townhouses Multiple-unit condominium structures Assisted living facilities Retirement communities Examples Apartment complexes such as Carriage House, Lamplighter, Nelson Estates, Deerfield, and Kendallville Retirement Community East Pointe and North Pointe Condominiums and Haley Estates Small multiple-family structures Appropriate Adjacent Classifications Best Fit: Open Space and Recreation, Urban Residential, High Density Residential, Downtown Commercial, Office and Institutional, and Low Intensity Commercial Conditional Fit: Lake Residential, Suburban Residential, High Intensity Commercial, and Industrial Development and Structural Features Centralized or zero lot line building envelope Centralized parking Internal and external pedestrian connectivity Maximum two (2) or three (3) stories with gable or hip roofs, if the context reflects the same Multiple primary structures on a single lot in some cases High density residential development includes many different forms in Kendallville. Regulation Implementation Utilize traditional zoning to regulate this land use classification CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 33 Manage Land Use and Growth Office and Institutional Purpose To establish areas for large scale institutions that may have unique development characteristics; and to establish areas for small scale offices characterized by traffic volumes significantly lower than commercial developments Geographic Location Utilized throughout Kendallville, but most appropriate along secondary arterials or collectors; low intensity institutions may be integrated into neighborhoods Land Uses Place of worship, school, library, hospital, and community center Federal, state, and local government Stand-alone medical, dental, and professional service offices Examples East Noble High School Professional East Village Four County Area Vocational Cooperative Kendallville Municipal Airport Appropriate Adjacent Classifications Best Fit: Open Space and Recreation, High Density Residential, Downtown Commercial, Office and Institutional, Low Intensity Commercial, and High Intensity Commercial Conditional Fit: Agricultural, Lake Residential, Suburban Residential, Urban Residential, and Industrial Development and Structural Features Internal and external pedestrian connectivity Protect pre-development environmental features Structures should be sensitive to the surrounding context Regulation Implementation 34 Utilize traditional zoning to regulate this land use classification Office and institutional land uses include developments of various sizes and scale including large complexes (e.g. Parkview Noble Hospital) to small offices parks (e.g. Professional East Village). CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Manage Land Use and Growth Downtown Commercial Purpose To recognize and accommodate the uniqueness of the commercial core by providing the opportunity to integrate a mixture of uses while remaining sensitive to the surrounding historical character Geographic Location Downtown Kendallville Land Uses Predominately retail, service, office, entertainment, restaurant, and institutional Residential uses on upper floors Public surface parking lots located primarily behind buildings Examples Downtown Kendallville Appropriate Adjacent Classifications Best Fit: Open Space and Recreation, High Density Residential, Downtown Commercial, Office and Institutional, and Low Intensity Commercial Conditional Fit: Urban Residential and High Intensity Commercial Development and Structural Features Context sensitive – existing setbacks, building form, traffic circulation, lighting, signs, and connectivity Internal and external pedestrian connectivity Off-street parking supplemented by on-street parking Transparent glass or permeable storefronts Use of alleys Regulation Implementation Utilize hybrid (i.e. traditional and form-based) zoning to regulate this land use classification CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Downtown Kendallville has a good mixture of uses including storefronts and upper floor residential units. 35 Manage Land Use and Growth Low Intensity Commercial Purpose To establish areas for low intensity commercial uses that serve the local neighborhood, a targeted population, or other dominant use, are generally smaller in scale, and experience low traffic volumes Geographic Location Utilized throughout Kendallville in small-sized nodes Land Uses Dry cleaning, barber shop, and other personal services Café, coffee shop, and ice cream shop Convenience retail Club or lodge Examples South Side Market on South Main Street Fastenal facility along US Highway 6 Appropriate Adjacent Classifications Best Fit: Open Space and Recreation, Urban Residential, High Density Residential, Downtown Commercial, Office and Institutional, and Low Intensity Commercial Conditional Fit: Lake Residential, Suburban Residential, High Intensity Commercial, and Industrial Low intensity commercial uses generally serve specific and geographically-close populations. Development and Structural Features Buffer adjacent residential uses Context-sensitive – building materials, traffic circulation, signs, lighting, connectivity, and hours of operation Discourage strip development Internal and external pedestrian connectivity Maximum of 100,000 square feet of land in one (1) Low Intensity Commercial node Maximum two (2) stories Regulation Implementation 36 Utilize traditional zoning to regulate this land use classification CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Manage Land Use and Growth High Intensity Commercial Purpose To establish areas for high intensity and general commercial uses that serves the community and larger region Geographic Location Utilized throughout Kendallville along primary arterials with excellent and safe access Land Uses Indoor and outdoor retail, service, hotel, office, entertainment, and restaurant Examples Shopping centers such as Fairview Center, Publix Village Square, The Shoppes at Orchard Park, and Kendallville Plaza Kendallville Events Center Stand-alone facilities such as the Holiday Inn Express, Max Platt Ford, Hayden Honda, and Papa John’s Pizza Appropriate Adjacent Classifications Best Fit: Open Space and Recreation, Office and Institutional, Low Intensity Commercial, and High Intensity Commercial Conditional Fit: Agricultural, Urban Residential, High Density Residential, Downtown Commercial, and Industrial Development and Structural Features Centralized building envelope Buffer adjacent residential uses Internal and external pedestrian connectivity Landscaped parking areas Regulation Implementation Utilize traditional zoning to regulate this land use classification The consumer opportunities provided in high intensity commercial areas are vital to a community’s wellbeing. CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 37 Manage Land Use and Growth Industrial Purpose To establish areas for industrial uses that provides employment opportunities for the community and larger region Geographic Location Focused on the east side of Kendallville, along US Highway 6, and in other medium-sized to largesized pockets around Kendallville that have access to arterials and railroads Land Uses Manufacturing and production Warehousing and distribution Examples Kendallville East Industrial Park Stand-alone facilities including Kraft, Taylor Made Systems, and Quick Tanks, Inc. Appropriate Adjacent Classifications Best Fit: Open Space and Recreation, and Industrial Conditional Fit: Agricultural, High Density Residential, Office and Institutional, Low Intensity Commercial, and High Intensity Commercial Development and Structural Features Buffer adjacent residential areas Centralized building envelope External pedestrian connectivity Screen outdoor storage areas Regulation Implementation Utilize traditional zoning to regulate this land use classification Industrial areas provide employment opportunities for a community. 38 CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Manage Land Use and Growth Airport Hazard Overlay Wellhead Protection Overlay Purpose Purpose To protect the current and future operation of the Kendallville Municipal Airport Geographic Location To protect public wellheads that provides water for the City of Kendallville or large residential developments Based on the Federal Aviation Administration’s (FAA) recommended buffer around general aviation airports Geographic Location Appropriate Underlying Land Uses Appropriate Underlying Land Uses Examples Agriculture Very low density residential (1 dwelling unit/10 acres) Business and industry that are not sensitive to noise Passive recreation One (1), three (3), and ten (10) year recharge areas around established and proposed wellheads All uses, excluding quarry, gas stations, and chemical storage Not applicable Appropriate Underlying Classifications Best Fit: Not applicable Conditional Fit: Not applicable Examples Appropriate Underlying Classifications Development and Structural Features Not applicable Best Fit: Agricultural, Open Space and Recreation, Rural Residential, and Industrial Conditional Fit: Low Intensity Commercial and High Intensity Commercial Not applicable Regulation Implementation Utilize zoning overlay to regulate this land use classification Development and Structural Features Low structure height Low intensity, full cutoff light fixtures No retention ponds or recreational ponds Regulation Implementation Utilize zoning overlay to regulate this land use classification CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 39 Manage Land Use and Growth SCHOOLHOUSE RD WAYNE CENTER RD (CR 900 E) CR 900 N (CR 825 N) AIRPORT RD APPLEMAN RD (CR 800N) COUNTY LINE RD RD LE Y RD R G IN GL NORTH LIMA RD AN CR 600 E STRATER ROAD (CR 750 N) N SAWYER RD (CR 660 E) ALLEN CHAPEL RD RIMMEL RD CR 800 N) KAMMERER RD D AMOND ST GARDEN ST WESTON DRAKE RD ROGERS RD PROGRESS DR EAST DOWLING ST LL ST AVE M TCHE (CR 600 N) FAIR ST RILEY ST DOWL NG ST PARK AVE OR LIMA RD CH AR D PL MAIN ST US H GH AY 6 CR 600 E HENRY ST WAITS RD (CR 500 N) CR 1000 E BEACON RD (CR 700 E) SHERMAN ST MAIN ST MAPES ROAD (CR 550 N) LIS BO D NR (CR 41 5 Wellhead Protection Area MAP LEGEND N) One Year Capture Area CR 750 E Five Year Capture Area Ten Year Capture Area Corporate Limits CR 350 N Extra-Territorial Jurisdiction STATE RD 8 40 CR 300 N CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 SCHOOLHOUSE RD CR 900 N WAYNE CENTER RD (CR 900 E) Future Land Use Classification Map Agricultural Rural Residential 3 APPLEMAN RD (CR 800N) Open Space and Recreation ALLEN CHAPEL RD SAWYER RD (CR 660 E) RIMMEL RD (CR 800 N) Little Long Lake Lake Residential Suburban Residential COUNTY LINE RD RD EY R IL RD NORTH LIMA RD G IN GL AN Round Lake KAMMERER RD FAIR ST RILEY ST Bixler Lake GARDEN ST DRAKE RD 6 Low Intensity Commercial Extra-Territorial Jurisdiction ROGERS RD PROGRESS DR EAST AVE WESTON (CR 600 N) DIAMOND ST Downtown Commercial Proposed New Road DOWLING ST LL ST Office and Institutional Industrial DOWLING ST MITCHE High Density Residential High Intensity Commercial PARK AVE OR CH LIMA R D AR D P L T MAIN S 6 Henderson Lake Urban Residential STRATER ROAD (CR 750 N) N CR 600 E MAP LEGEND (CR 825 N) AIRPORT RD US HIGHWAY 6 City of Kendallville, Indiana Airport Hazard Overlay HENRY ST CR 600 E OHIO ST SHERMAN ST WAITS RD (CR 500 N) CR 1000 E BEACON RD (CR 700 E) 3 MAIN ST MAPES ROAD (CR 550 N) BON RD (CR 415 N) CR 750 E LIS March 31, 2010 CR 350 N NOTE: This is not a Zoning Map. STATE RD 8 CR 300 N Chapter Four Foster Convenient Circulation Foster Convenient Circulation Introduction A transportation plan is one (1) component of a Comprehensive Plan that is required by the State of Indiana. This chapter, Foster Convenient Circulation, is a transportation plan that looks specifically at the components necessary to foster convenient circulation within the City of Kendallville and its planning jurisdiction. The plan elements include vehicular street network, pedestrian network, and alternative modes of transportation. A Thoroughfare Plan Map and Pedestrian Network Map are included as well. A goal, objectives, and implementation measures (IM) that promote efficient transportation systems and coordinated improvements to those systems are identified in the remainder of this chapter. Note, implementation measures are abbreviated as IM, and identified with a number that corresponds with the appropriate objective. 44 Goal: Foster Convenient Circulation Provide a safe, appropriate, cost effective, and convenient circulation system that accommodates multiple common modes of transportation. Objective 1: Develop and continue to maintain a street network that is efficient and safe. IM 1.1 Ensure that adequate right-of-way is preserved for proper drainage, sidewalks, on-street parking, planned extensions, and planned widenings. IM 1.2 As land develops, work with Noble County to begin establishing a one-half (0.5) mile grid system of collector streets in the extra-territorial jurisdiction to ensure connectivity and efficient circulation. IM 1.3 As development occurs, require critical new connections as shown on the Thoroughfare Plan Map. IM 1.4 Ensure accessibility and efficiency for emergency services. IM 1.5 Strongly encourage connectivity between street networks in neighboring subdivisions. IM 1.6 Prepare and maintain a five-year capital improvements plan that identifies realistic construction and maintenance projects prioritized by importance and funding availability. IM 1.7 Minimize driveway cuts along arterial and collector streets. CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Foster Convenient Circulation Objective 2: Develop a pedestrian network of sidewalks, side paths, and off-street trails that connect popular destinations and provide recreational opportunities. IM 2.1 Require sidewalks within all new residential subdivisions including pedestrian linkages to adjacent development and areas likely to develop. IM 2.2 Require pedestrian facilities as part of commercial, office, and institutional developments such that pedestrians can safely reach main entrances from perimeter roads. IM 2.3 Encourage pedestrian facilities, particularly along perimeter roads, as part of industrial developments and as part of the redevelopment of brownfield sites. IM 2.4 Coordinate with other agencies [e.g. Indiana Department of Natural Resources (IDNR)] to help connect Kendallville’s pedestrian network to pedestrian facilities (i.e. Rails to Trails) outside Kendallville’s planning jurisdiction. CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Objective 3: Encourage enhancement of the Municipal Airport. IM 3.1 Periodically publish reports about the economic benefits of the airport to help the public realize its value. IM 3.2 Protect the Kendallville Municipal Airport from the encroachment of noise-sensitive uses that may hinder future expansion of the facility and increases in operations. IM 3.3 Encourage corporations that utilize aircraft to base their aircraft at the Kendallville Municipal Airport. IM 3.4 Incorporate non-remonstrance provisions for airport expansion into the zoning and subdivision approval process when projects are proposed within one (1) mile of the Kendallville Municipal Airport, and build educational components into the permit process for expanding developments. Objective 4: Integrate transportation facilities into the fabric of the community. IM 4.1 Balance the need to widen streets with the need for pedestrian facilities and streetscape design. IM 4.2 Mitigate dangerous intersections by redesigning, reconstructing, re-signing, installing signals, or other means. IM 4.3 Work to provide safe pedestrian crosswalks, trail crossings, and railroad crossings. IM 4.4 Consider pedestrian safety, circulation, and accessibility as a component of a street improvement project or large development project. IM 4.5 Maintain and promote lighting of public ways – vehicular and pedestrian – to encourage safety. 45 Foster Convenient Circulation Additional Information VEHICULAR NETWORK Street classifications are important because appropriate land uses, setbacks, and accessibility can be based, in part, on the classification of the street a property fronts. Kendallville uses the Indiana Department of Transportation’s (INDOT) classification system which includes primary arterials, secondary arterials, collectors, and local streets. The vehicular network in Kendallville does not end at the City’s jurisdictional boundary. Any assessment of vehicular circulation must consider the larger vehicular network. For this reason, reference was made to the Noble County Comprehensive Plan throughout the development of the Kendallville Thoroughfare Plan Map to ensure consistency in the maps and policies. Modifications and Additions The 2008-2009 reconstruction of US Highway 6 west of Main Street included consistent lane sizes and configurations, curbs, sidewalks, and a completely new street base and surface. The project has been a significant improvement in circulation as well as, safety and aesthetics. The City believes similar improvements are needed along US Highway 6 east of Main Street. This stretch of US Highway 6 involves various lane configurations, inconsistent lane sizes, and intermittent curbs and sidewalks. Much of US Highway 6 east of Main Street is not physically urbanized, even though the development along it is. Several of the intersections along the stretch of US Highway 6 east of Main Street could be upgraded and safe pedestrian crossings could be addressed in such a project. City officials will actively lobby the Indiana Department of Transportation (INDOT) to identify the issues, complete necessary engineering studies, and get a proposed project on the schedule – even if it is ten (10) years or more in the future. 46 There are issues with left turns from Eunice Avenue, West Avenue, and East Avenue onto US Highway 6. These streets are currently local streets providing access to only a dozen or so mostly residential properties. As development occurs on the north side of Kendallville, particularly the area between Shalley Drive and Miller Road, West Avenue and East Avenue should be extended north to provide connectivity to the new development. Additionally, new development in this area should provide east-west connectivity between North Lima Road/State Road 3 and Riley Road. Kendallville’s current street project, set to begin construction in Spring 2010, is the urbanization of East Dowling Street from Park Avenue to US Highway 6, including the intersection of Allen Chapel Road/County Road 1000E. The project includes curb and gutter, as well as sidewalk on the north side of East Dowling Street. The City of Kendallville also applied for Federal Stimulus Funds to mill and resurface eighteen (18) city streets. The City should consider the extension Donaldson Drive north to intersect directly with North Angling Road. The intersection of North Lima Road/State Road 3 and US Highway 6 is one of the most congested in Kendallville, and the extension of Donaldson Drive may relieve some of that congestion. Several circulation issues outside the Kendallville City Limits were identified throughout the planning process. These issues are mentioned here not as a “laundry list” of things the City should accomplish over the next twenty (20) years, but to generate awareness, and to outline the basic framework of streets that will help the circulation system grow in a way that is efficient and safe. As development proposals are presented, these circulation issues may be able to be addressed. CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Foster Convenient Circulation The triangle created by the intersection of Appleman Road/County Road 800N and Riley Road is awkward and now has to manage increased traffic from the new Wayne Center Elementary School. Visibility at the intersection of Sherman Street and Waits Road/County Road 500N is limited because of topography. The one-mile county road network should be expanded to include one-half (0.5) mile grid streets. These streets should serve as collectors providing curb cuts to local streets accessing entire subdivisions. Capital Improvement Plan Street projects should be identified and prioritized in a five-year capital improvements plan. Based on available and potential funds, the City should select the top priority project or projects to be completed over the next five (5) years. The majority of improvement funds should be spent on planned projects. Spending resources on unplanned improvements should be limited to emergency repairs. When projects are undertaken, it is crucial that quality improvements are made and pedestrian facilities are successfully woven into the project. PEDESTRIAN NETWORK PLAN Eighty-one percent (81%) of the respondents to the Community Values Survey want Kendallville to be a walkable community with sidewalks and bikepaths installed throughout the community. Fifty-six percent (56%) of the respondents feel strongly about this issue. Pedestrian networks are a family-friendly amenity that can set Kendallville apart from larger communities or communities without such a network. In addition to increasing the quality of life by providing a recreational opportunity, a complete pedestrian network can mitigate traffic by providing an alternative to using a vehicle. Pedestrian networks are also known to improve the overall health of the community. Kendallville has a great start on providing a pedestrian network with sidewalks in the majority of residential areas inside the City. Existing trails through Bixler Lake Park and Campground, Detering and Lonidaw Nature Preserves, and Blackman Woods Preserve are another component of the existing pedestrian network in Kendallville. A path connecting Bixler Lake Park and Campground and the Kendallville Outdoor Recreation Complex exists, but it is not a formal trail. Plans to connect Bixler Lake Park, the Kendallville Outdoor Recreation Complex, and the Mid-American Windmill Museum with trails are under development, and would be a tremendous asset in providing pedestrian connectivity. Additionally, the Indiana Department of Natural Resources (IDNR) has acquired approximately forty percent (40%) of the right-of-way necessary for the construction of a trail from Kendallville to Rome City. If completed, this trail would add a new dimension to Kendallville’s pedestrian network. CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 47 Foster Convenient Circulation A functional network will take many years of concerted effort. First and foremost, new development should have the appropriate pedestrian facilities. New residential developments should have internal sidewalks, as well as sidewalks connecting the neighborhood to the community at large; New commercial developments should have internal sidewalks, as well as pedestrian facilities that connect it to adjacent developments and the community-wide pedestrian network; New institutional developments should have internal, as well as pedestrian connectivity to adjacent development and the community-wide network; and New industrial developments should be encouraged to provide internal pedestrian connectivity, and be required to provide pedestrian connectivity from the industrial development to the community-wide network. When the community-wide pedestrian network is not developed in an area of Kendallville that is experiencing growth, the internal pedestrian facilities of the new development should extend to the edge of the site along perimeter roads to provide future connectivity. Second, it is important to maintain and improve the community’s existing pedestrian facilities. Much of the older part of Kendallville has sidewalks and is identified as the “Urban Sidewalk Area” on the Pedestrian Network Map. Because this is an older part of town, attention should be focused on sidewalk maintenance, specifically retrofitting intersections to comply with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). The City could institute a sidewalk program to assist property owners wishing to improve their sidewalks. The program could be low interest loan or some form of a cost share. 48 Finally, Kendallville should focus its investment on priority pedestrian collectors. The priority pedestrian collectors are destination-oriented: schools linked to neighborhoods; parks linked to neighborhoods; and local attractions being linked together. Develop a more formalized pedestrian connection between Bixler Lake Park and Campground, the Kendallville Outdoor Recreation Complex, and the MidAmerican Windmill Museum; Complete the sidewalk portion of the East Dowling Street construction project; Work with the Indiana Department of Transportation (INDOT) to create formalized pedestrian crosswalks at the intersections of US Highway 6 and North Lima Road; US Highway 6 and Riley Street/Riley Road; US Highway 6 and Kammerer Road/Fairview Run; and US Highway 6 and Allen Chapel Road; Complete pedestrian facilities along at least one (1) side of Drake Road between downtown and Hillcrest Drive; Install sidewalk along Sherman Street in front of South Side Elementary School; Complete sidewalk along at least one (1) side of Riley Road inside city limits; Install a pedestrian facility along Kammerer Road, between US Highway 6 and Allen Chapel Road; Install sidewalk along Allen Chapel Road from Kammerer Road to the Kendallville Outdoor Recreation Complex; and Install missing sections of sidewalk along North Angling Road from North Lima Road to the Carriage House Apartments. Kendallville shall strive to implement the initial phase of priority pedestrian collectors over the next twenty (20) years, and leverage local funds with grants and donations from transportation, recreation, environmental, health, and local organizations. CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Foster Convenient Circulation Kendallville’s pedestrian network will make use of these existing, developed, and proposed pedestrian facilities and ultimately be comprised of residential sidewalks, urban residential sidewalks, urban commercial sidewalks, on-street bike lanes, side paths, and off-street trails. OTHER MODES OF TRANSPORTATION Rail Kendallville is served by an east-west railroad operated by Norfolk Southern that bisects the City. The City should work with the railroad owners to maintain safe crossings and market the rail line as an economic asset. Transit The existing Noble Transit System is an on demand system that provides transportation services to the elderly population. The system focuses on getting this segment of the population to and from appointments and shopping for a nominal fee. The current system is an asset to the community and continues to grow as the demand for its service grows. Air The Kendallville Municipal Airport is within the municipal boundaries of the City of Kendallville even though it is not contiguous to the city limits. It is, in effect, an “island of city limits” located north of the remainder of the city limits. The Airport’s Board of Aviation Commissioners recently adopted a five-year capital improvements plan that includes repairing taxiway pavement in 2009; design and construction of runway and taxiway improvements in 2010 and 2011; stormwater improvements in 2012; and design and installation of medium intensity runway lights (MIRL) in 2013 and 2014. The Kendallville Municipal Airport is an asset to the community. The airport is home to one (1) of three (3) glider clubs nationwide and also hosts community events. Additionally, the airport is an economic development resource. Some believe that general aviation airports, such as the Kendallville Municipal Airport, will drive the next wave of economic activity – the way interstates do today and railroads have in the past. With this in mind, it is increasingly important to support the airport, promote its enhancement, and restrict encroachment of incompatible land uses. CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 49 Foster Convenient Circulation Thoroughfare Plan Map The Thoroughfare Plan Map illustrates the future classification of streets in Kendallville’s planning jurisdiction. The future classification takes into consideration the current classification of each street, as well as existing and future land uses along each street. The following street classifications are used on the Thoroughfare Plan Map found on page 63: Primary Arterial Secondary Arterial Collector Local STREET CLASSIFICATION AND DESCRIPTION Each of the street classifications listed above has a page dedicated to describing it. The intent is to use the descriptions as a guide for street projects – either construction of new streets or improvement of existing streets. The street classification descriptions should not be used as benchmarks for Kendallville’s existing streets. General Description: This section gives a brief description of the street classification, why it has been established, and its potential to be developed in the future. timelines, funding cycles, physical constraints, and political constraints. This section communicates the primary and secondary priorities for each street classification. Primary priorities are those that should not be foregone in design decisions. Secondary priorities are those that may be considered for compromise, non-inclusion, or later phases of the project. Traffic Management Options: This section describes vehicular traffic management options to consider when improving a street. The options listed are intended to identify the most appropriate means to intersect streets, slow traffic when appropriate, increase traffic efficiency when appropriate, and improve safety. Image Examples: Images of each street classification are included. The images are intended to portray some of the best examples available in Kendallville or in another Indiana community. The images may not represent the purest intent of the street classification. When applied in the real world, variations in design may be necessary. Street Features: This section conveys the primary design standards of the street classification. The standards include right-of-way widths, number of lanes, lane width, curbing, sidewalks, on-street parking, and street trees and tree plots within the right-of-way. Typical Cross Section: This section refers to a typical cross section illustration of the street classification. The illustration is intended to portray the “ideal” version of the street with the understanding that when applied in the real world, variations in design are often necessary. Design Priorities: During the design phase of all street improvement projects, decisions have to be made to meet budgetary constraints, 50 CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Foster Convenient Circulation Primary Arterial General Description Primary arterials are designed to carry very heavy volumes of traffic to major destinations in, out, or through the City. In Kendallville, primary arterials are limited to state-controlled US Highway 6 and portions of State Road 3. Kendallville will probably not see additional primary arterials developed during this Plan’s timeframe. Street Features Minimum Right-of-Way: 100 feet Maximum Number of Lanes: Four (4) lanes with turn lanes at major intersections Minimum Lane Width: Twelve (12) feet Curbs: Required within corporate limits Sidewalks: Required in urban areas and per Pedestrian Network Plan On-Street Parking: Prohibited Tree Plot: Required Street Trees: Preferred Typical Cross Section See illustration below Primary Design Priorities Limiting access (i.e. curb cuts) Sensitivity to context Intersection design Pedestrian facilities Width of travel lanes US Highway 6, a small portion of State Road 3 North (North Lima Road), and State Road 3 South (not pictured) are primary arterials. Secondary Design Priorities Street trees Traffic Management Options Acceleration and deceleration lanes Defined turn lanes at intersections Stop lights, flashers, and signage Primary Arterial: Typical Cross Section in Urban Areas 100 feet of Right-of-Way Lane Width: 12 feet Min. Curb: 2 feet Tree Plot: 10 feet Sidewalk: 5 feet CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 51 Foster Convenient Circulation Secondary Arterial General Description Secondary arterials are designed to carry heavy volumes of traffic to major destinations inside and outside of the City. Secondary arterials primarily connect collectors with primary arterials. Kendallville controls some of the community’s secondary arterials; some are controlled by Noble County and one (1) is under state-control. Any “new” secondary arterials in Kendallville’s future will mostly like be existing streets that are required to handle additional volumes of traffic due to new development. Street Features Minimum Right-of-Way: Sixty (60) feet Maximum Number of Lanes: Two (2) lanes with turn lanes at major intersections Minimum Lane Width: Twelve (12) feet Curbs: Required within corporate limits Sidewalks: Required in urban areas and per Pedestrian Network Plan On-Street Parking: Not permitted, except in downtown Tree Plot: Preferred Street Trees: Preferred Typical Cross Section See illustration below Main Street and Riley Street are examples of secondary arterials. Primary Design Priorities Intersection design Pedestrian facilities Width of travel lanes Traffic Management Options Secondary Design Priorities Limiting access (i.e. curb cuts) Sensitivity to context Street trees Width of tree plot Acceleration and deceleration lanes Defined turn lanes at intersections Stop lights, flashers, and signage Secondary Arterial: Typical Cross Section in Urban Areas 60 feet of Right-of-Way Curb: 2 feet Lane Width: 12 feet Min. 52 Tree Plot: 8 feet Sidewalk: 5 feet CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Foster Convenient Circulation Collector General Description A collector is designed primarily to provide access to platted subdivisions and to allow on-street parking when deemed safe. Driveway cuts should be limited with preference given to local streets accessing entire subdivisions. Collector streets primarily connect to other collectors; connect local streets with secondary arterials and primary arterials; and secondary arterials with other secondary arterials. The City will likely experience the development of new collector streets (both through new construction and by local streets being required to accommodate additional volumes of traffic due to new development) during the timeframe of this Plan. Street Features Minimum Right-of-Way: Sixty (60) feet Maximum Number of Lanes: Two (2) lanes with turn lanes at major intersections Minimum Lane Width: Eleven (11) feet Curbs: Required within corporate limits and within new developments Sidewalks: Required in urban areas and per Pedestrian Network Plan On-Street Parking: Variable, mostly in urban areas and based on context and safety Tree Plot: Preferred Street Trees: Required Sherman Street is an example of a collector. Secondary Design Priorities Intersection design Width of travel lanes Width of tree plot Traffic Management Options Narrower lane widths On-street parking Roundabouts Signage Typical Cross Section See illustration below Primary Design Priorities Sensitivity to context Pedestrian facilities Street trees Collector: Typical Cross Section in Urban Areas 60 feet of Right-of-Way Parking Lane: 8 feet Lane Width: 11 feet Min. CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Curb: 2 feet Tree Plot: 8 feet Sidewalk: 5 feet 53 Foster Convenient Circulation Local Street General Description A local street is designed primarily to provide access to platted residential lots and other individual properties. These streets generally connect with collector streets and other local streets. Local streets may include non-through streets. The City of Kendallville will experience the development of new local streets during the timeframe of this Plan. Street Features Minimum Right-of-Way: Fifty (50) feet Maximum Number of Lanes: Two (2) lanes Minimum Lane Width: Eleven (11) feet Curbs: Required within corporate limits and in new developments Sidewalks: Required in urban areas and per Pedestrian Network Plan On-Street Parking: Permitted on one (1) side of the street, not permitted on cul-de-sacs Tree Plot: Required Street Trees: Required Typical Cross Section See illustration below Primary Design Priorities South Oak Street and West William Street are examples of local streets. Access to properties Sensitivity to context Pedestrian facilities Street trees Traffic Management Options Secondary Design Priorities On-street parking Width of travel lanes Width of tree plot Narrower lane widths On-street parking Roundabouts Signage Local Street: Typical Cross Section in Urban Areas 50 feet of Right-of-Way Parking Lane: 7 feet Lane Width: 11 feet Min. 54 Curb: 18 inches Tree Plot: 5 feet Sidewalk: 4 feet CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Foster Convenient Circulation Pedestrian Network Map The Pedestrian Network Map focuses on facilities for non-motorized transportation, primarily walking and bicycling within Kendallville’s planning jurisdiction. Many of the pedestrian facilities exist, but the map goes further to plan for expansion of the Kendallville pedestrian network. The following pedestrian network classifications are used on the Pedestrian Network Map on page 65: Residential sidewalk Urban residential sidewalk Urban commercial sidewalk On-street bicycle lane Side path Off-street trail PEDESTRIAN FACILITY CLASSIFICATION AND DESCRIPTION Each of the pedestrian facility classifications listed above has a page dedicated to describing it. The intent is to use the descriptions as a guide for pedestrian facility projects – either the new construction of new facilities or improvements to existing facilities. The pedestrian facility descriptions should not be used as benchmarks for Kendallville’s existing pedestrian facilities. The following headings are used, as described below, to convey the essence of each pedestrian facility classification. communicates the primary and secondary priorities for each pedestrian facility classification. Primary priorities are those that should not be foregone in design decisions. Secondary priorities are those that maybe considered for compromise, non-inclusion, or later phases of the project. Safety Enhancements: This section describes safety options to consider when installing or improving a pedestrian facility. The enhancements listed are intended to be the most appropriate for the subject facility. Image Examples: This section includes images of each pedestrian facility classification. The images are intended to portray some of the best examples available in Kendallville or in another Indiana community if the facility is currently not present in Kendallville. The images may not represent the purest intent of the facility. When applied in the real world, variations in design may be necessary. General Description: This section gives a brief description of the pedestrian facility classification and why it has been established. Pedestrian Facility Features: This section conveys the primary design standards of the pedestrian facility. The standards include right-of-way, minimum width, construction materials, obstructions, and street separation. Design Priorities: During the design phase of all pedestrian facilities, decisions have to be made to best meet budgetary constraints, timelines, funding cycles, physical constraints, and public opinions. This section CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 55 Foster Convenient Circulation Residential Sidewalk General Description A residential sidewalk provides connectivity from home to home and linkages to pedestrian facilities along streets outside the neighborhood. A residential sidewalk is designed to accommodate walking, strollers, and children’s recreation in suburban neighborhoods. Facility Features Right-of-way: Within public right-of-way Minimum Width: Five (5) feet Surface: Concrete Obstructions: None allowed Street Separation: Five-foot (5’) tree plot Primary Design Priorities Reinforce neighborhood character Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) compliance at intersections Minimize obstructions Secondary Design Priorities Avoid steep slopes Avoid unnecessary curvature of alignment Safety Enhancements 56 Striped crosswalks Change in pavement material at intersections Lighting Tree canopy trimmed to give seven (7) feet or more of clearance Residential sidewalks exist in the majority of Kendallville’s suburban-style neighborhoods. CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Foster Convenient Circulation Urban Residential Sidewalk General Description An urban residential sidewalk provides connectivity from home to home and linkages to pedestrian facilities along streets outside the neighborhood or to urban commercial sidewalks. An urban residential sidewalk is designed to accommodate walking, strollers, and children’s recreation in urban neighborhoods. Facility Features Right-of-way: Within public right-of-way Minimum Width: Five (5) feet Surface: Concrete Obstructions: Not preferred Street Separation: Not required Primary Design Priorities Reinforce neighborhood character ADA compliance at intersections Avoid unnecessary curvature of alignment Street trees Secondary Design Priorities Avoid steep slopes Safety Enhancements Striped crosswalks Change in pavement material at intersections Lighting Tree canopy trimmed to give seven (7) feet or more of clearance Many of Kendallville’s older urban residential sidewalk intersections have been retrofitted and are compliant with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 57 Foster Convenient Circulation Urban Commercial Sidewalk General Description An urban commercial sidewalk provides connectivity from business to business and linkages to other pedestrian facilities along streets outside the commercial district. An urban commercial sidewalk is designed to accommodate walking, strollers, street furniture, and outdoor dining. Facility Features Right-of-way: Within public right-of-way Minimum Width: Eight (8) feet; twelve (12) feet when also used for outdoor dining Surface: Concrete; may include brick or paver accents Obstructions: Street lights, street signs, planters, trees, public art, and seating may be located on the sidewalk as long as six (6) feet of clear-way is consistently maintained Street Separation: Not required Primary Design Priorities Reinforce commercial character ADA compliance at intersections Street trees Secondary Design Priorities Avoid steep slopes Consistent placement of obstructions Minimize obstructions Urban commercial sidewalks can vary significantly depending on the commercial area they serve. Safety Enhancements 58 Striped crosswalks Change in pavement material at intersections Bollards Lighting Tree canopy trimmed to give seven (7) feet or more of clearance CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Foster Convenient Circulation On-street Bicycle Lane General Description An on-street bicycle lane is intended to provide a safer facility for fast-moving bicycle traffic, as well as linkages between side paths and off-street trails and other popular destinations. An on-street bicycle lane is designed to accommodate bicycle commuting, fitness cycling, and recreational cycling along existing roadways. Facility Features Right-of-way: Within public right-of-way Minimum Width: Five (5) feet Surface: Asphalt, debris free Obstructions: None allowed Street Separation: By painted stripe Primary Design Priorities On-street bicycle lanes help ensure cyclists’ safety by defining limits for motorists. Avoid unnecessary curvature of alignment Unobstructed Information and traffic signs Lane definition Drainage away from on-street bicycle lane Secondary Design Priorities Avoid steep slopes Lighting Placement on both sides of the street Safety Enhancements Striped lanes at street intersections Minimal vertical offset in pavement transitions Lighting Regular street sweeping of debris from bicycle lanes Storm water inlet orientation and product selection CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 59 Foster Convenient Circulation Side Path General Description A side path is designed to accommodate walking, jogging, strollers, children’s recreation, skating/blading, slow to moderate-speed cycling along collector and secondary arterial streets. Generally, a side path provides connectivity from neighborhood to neighborhood and linkages to community amenities. Facility Features Right-of-way: Within public right-of-way Minimum Width: Eight (8) feet Surface: Asphalt Obstructions: None allowed Street Separation: Six-foot (6’) This side path runs along Sherman Street providing access to the Bixler Lake trail system. Primary Design Priorities Reinforce neighborhood character Minimize obstructions Secondary Design Priorities ADA compliance at intersections Avoid steep slopes Safety Enhancements 60 Striped crosswalks Change in pavement material at intersections Bollards Lighting Tree canopy trimmed to give seven (7) feet or more of clearance CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Foster Convenient Circulation Off-street Trail General Description An off-street trail provides recreational and fitness opportunities within a natural setting. Off-street trails may provide connectivity between other pedestrian facilities and community destinations. Off-street trails are designed to accommodate walking, jogging, community, strollers, children’s recreation, skating/blading, and slow to moderate speed cycling. Facility Features Right-of-way: Not in a public right-of-way, but within an easement, or public park Minimum Width: Six (6) feet of surface with at least one-foot (1’) of shoulder on each side Surface: Asphalt, crushed limestone, or other suitable surface Obstructions: None allowed Street Separation: Not applicable Primary Design Priorities Reinforce natural character Minimize disturbance to sensitive natural features Use curves to avoid natural features Unobstructed Drainage away from off-street trail Secondary Design Priorities ADA compliance at intersections Avoid steep slopes The off-street trails within the Bixler Lake Park and Campground are comprised of a variety of different surfaces. Safety Enhancements Striped crossings or grade separated crossings at street intersections Signs for bicycles, pedestrians, and automobiles at intersections Bollards at approaches to major streets or midblock crossings Lighting at intersections CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 61 Foster Convenient Circulation 62 CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 SCHOOLHOUSE RD CR 900 N WAYNE CENTER RD (CR 900 E) Thoroughfare Plan Map Primary Arterial Secondary Arterial 3 APPLEMAN RD (CR 800N) Proposed Secondary Arterial ALLEN CHAPEL RD SAWYER RD (CR 660 E) RIMMEL RD (CR 800 N) Little Long Lake Collector Proposed Collector COUNTY LINE RD RD EY R IL RD NORTH LIMA RD G IN GL AN Round Lake KAMMERER RD Bixler Lake GARDEN ST WESTON DIAMOND ST Airport Extra-Territorial Jursiction 6 ROGERS RD PROGRESS DR EAST AVE M DRAKE RD Rail Road FAIR ST RILEY ST DOWLING ST ST ITCHELL (CR 600 N) Proposed Local Street DOWLING ST PARK AVE OR CH LIMA R D AR D P L T MAIN S 6 Henderson Lake Local Street STRATER ROAD (CR 750 N) N CR 600 E MAP LEGEND (CR 825 N) AIRPORT RD US HIGHWAY 6 City of Kendallville, Indiana HENRY ST CR 600 E OHIO ST SHERMAN ST WAITS RD (CR 500 N) CR 1000 E BEACON RD (CR 700 E) 3 MAIN ST MAPES ROAD (CR 550 N) BON RD (CR 415 N) CR 750 E LIS March 31, 2010 CR 350 N STATE RD 8 CR 300 N SCHOOLHOUSE RD CR 900 N WAYNE CENTER RD (CR 900 E) Pedestrian Network Plan Map ALLEN CHAPEL RD SAWYER RD (CR 660 E) APPLEMAN RD (CR 800N) Little Long Lake RD COUNTY LINE RD EY FAIR ST Proposed New Road Extra-Territorial Jurisdiction AVE S GARDEN ST DIAMOND ST P HENRY ST A Bixler Lake P P 6 A S CR 600 E OHIO ST PROGRESS DR EAST DOWLING ST ROGERS RD A M WESTON DRAKE RD Proposed Pedestrian Connection A PARK AVE LIMA R D RILEY ST T MAIN S D P L AR CH OR A KAMMERER RD Pedestrian Collectors (Priority) DOWLING ST ST ITCHELL A Attraction Pedestrian Collectors (Existing) STRATER ROAD (CR 750 N) A Henderson Lake Park Urban Sidewalk Area Round Lake S School Safe Pedestrian Crossing A R IL RD NORTH LIMA RD G IN GL AN CR 600 E S 3 6 (CR 600 N) S P A N US HIGHWAY 6 MAP LEGEND (CR 825 N) AIRPORT RD RIMMEL RD (CR 800 N) City of Kendallville, Indiana SHERMAN ST S WAITS RD (CR 500 N) CR 1000 E BEACON RD (CR 700 E) 3 MAIN ST MAPES ROAD (CR 550 N) BON CR 750 E LIS RD (CR 415 N) A A March 31, 2010 CR 350 N STATE RD 8 CR 300 N Chapter Five Serve Community Needs Serve Community Needs Introduction Kendallville’s elected officials and City staff strive to anticipate and meet the needs of the community by maintaining public lands and facilities and by providing services. The following types of services and facilities are addressed in this chapter: Utility services; Public services; and Parks and recreation. The types of utilities discussed in this section include water, sanitary sewer, and storm sewers. Public services include police, fire, and City administration. The third category includes passive and active parks, natural areas, pavilions, and recreational facilities. Primarily, the local government provides the services listed above, but private entities may also provide certain services. For instance, a golf course is a recreation facility, but it is neither owned nor operated by the City. Likewise, certain public services may be privately-owned and operated. Although, primary emphasis is on City-operated facilities and services, the existence of private facilities and services has been taken into consideration. The remainder of this chapter contains the goal, objectives, implementation measures (IM), and elaboration on specific steps related to serving the community’s needs. Note, implementation measures are abbreviated as IM, and identified with a number that corresponds with the appropriate objective. 68 Goal: Serve Community Needs Maintain and enhance viable infrastructure systems; adequate public services; and diverse recreational facilities to meet the current and future needs of the City of Kendallville. Objective 1: Position the City utilities to accommodate community growth while maintaining or enhancing the existing level of service to current users. IM 1.1 Develop and maintain a five-year capital improvements plan that coordinates utility expansions with proposed growth and redevelopment areas. IM 1.2 Require specific quality construction standards to be met or exceeded whenever new utility lines are installed. IM 1.3 Require new development to connect to City utilities. Objective 2: Maximize the use of the community’s resources when providing public services. IM 2.1 Maintain the existing Insurance Service Organization (ISO) rating across the City by managing where growth occurs. Specifically, control growth further to the east, while favoring redevelopment. IM 2.2 Coordinate with organizations to proactively provide or supplement community service programs. IM 2.3 Be prepared to capitalize on opportunities that may help improve and/or fund improvements to City Hall. CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Serve Community Needs Objective 3: Promote full utilization of existing recreational facilities, and enhance these facilities when practical. IM 3.1 Update and adopt an Indiana Department of Natural Resources (IDNR) approved Five-Year Park and Recreation Master Plan. IM 3.2 Make maintaining existing park amenities the highest priority, and work to develop an efficient cyclical maintenance program. IM 3.3 Periodically review the recreational facilities and programs offered by local organizations to minimize duplication, thus freeing up City resources. IM 3.4 Modify the existing Kendallville Subdivision Control Ordinance to require new developments to establish and maintain useable open space areas. IM 3.5 Work to connect Kendallville’s parks, neighborhoods, schools, and other amenities with sidewalks, side paths, or off-street trails. IM 3.6 Consider the development of a small park or plaza area in downtown Kendallville. IM 3.7 Evaluate the feasibility of relocating the Park Department Office to Bixler Lake Park and Campground. IM 3.8 Assess support for and the feasibility of an outdoor amphitheater on existing park property. Additional Information The following sections provide the background and essential information relating to the provision of utility services, public services, and parks and recreation to serve the community’s needs. The information in these sections also denotes actions in process and potential strategies that contribute to serving the public’s needs or the overall vision for Kendallville. UTILITY SERVICES Water The Kendallville Water Department consists of three (3) half-million (500,000) gallon water towers, treatment and iron removal facilities, and forty-six (46) miles of water mains. The Kendallville Water Department provides water service to over 3,200 customers, and to all major industries in Kendallville. Additionally, the Kendallville Water Department provides service to areas outside the Kendallville City Limits including the Meadow Lane area, Noble Hawk Golf Links and subdivision, Cobblestone Golf Course and subdivision, and the Kendallville Outdoor Recreation Complex. Recent improvements to the Kendallville water system provide constant, uninterrupted service to Parkview Noble Hospital and other west end developments. The Kendallville Water Department has recently completed a west end loop of the distribution system that included construction of the City’s third water tower. A relatively CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 69 Serve Community Needs new well also serves the Kendallville Industrial Park East. Water Pollution Control The Kendallville Water Pollution Control Facility, located on West Wayne Street has a total capacity of 2.68 million gallons per day (mgd). The facility is at seventy-five percent (75%) capacity. While there is available capacity to treat waste from growth and redevelopment, the type of discharge can make a difference in the City’s ability to treat it. Sanitary sewers owned and operated by the City of Kendallville extend outside the City’s corporate limits to Noble Hawk, Cobblestone, the Meadow Lane area, and the Kendallville Outdoor Recreation Complex. These users currently pay a forty percent (40%) surcharge for wastewater disposal. Extending sanitary sewer and water infrastructure from Kendallville north to the residential areas around Round Lake and Little Long Lake has been studied multiple times since 1991. There is significant cost to this project, and each time a study is completed, the cost estimates increase. It has been the City’s policy to wait for the lake associations to petition the City for sanitary sewer service, as the lake associations would bear the responsibility for much of the cost of the project. As the City develops north, towards the lakes, special consideration should be given to sizing utility mains appropriately to eventually serve the residential areas around Round Lake and Little Long Lake, the Kendallville Municipal Airport, and Wayne Center Elementary School. Additionally, as development occurs between the corporate limits and the lakes, the City should research and publish costs for the extension of infrastructure. Growth of Utility Systems The provision of water treatment and distribution and sanitary sewer collection and treatment are basic and vital to the community’s ability to grow. Both systems currently expand to the east and north edges of the Kendallville City Limits and even beyond the corporate limits to the west and south. The existence of municipal water and sewer utilities in these areas are, in part, dictating the location of growth. Both utility systems should expand by adding lines to service new development on land that is contiguous to the corporate limits or existing utility mains. Generally, those areas include land South of Bixler Lake Park and Campground; South of Waits Road/County Road 500N; East of Sherman Street; Along Drake Road/County Road 600 N west of South State Road 3; and North of the city limits and south of the development around Little Long Lake. PUBLIC SERVICES It is not uncommon for cities in Indiana to have less resources than necessary to provide the services their citizens and businesses need. When the State of Indiana froze property tax levies for all communities at their current rates in 2003, Kendallville was below its maximum levy and hit especially hard at a time when the community was striving to be efficient and prudent with its resources. It is estimated that the property tax freeze has cost the City of Kendallville a million dollars each year since 2003. This coupled with recent decreases in assessed value has resulted in less money in the City’s overall budget. The City of Kendallville has an approved Combined Sewer Overflow Long Term Strategy Plan that is complete. 70 CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Serve Community Needs City Administration Despite the scarcity of resources, the community members that participated in workshops and interviews are pleased with services provided by City government, and how Kendallville has grown over the past several decades. However, the condition of City Hall is a source of concern for citizens. Kendallville needs to be prepared to capitalize on opportunities that may become available to significantly renovate and/or develop a new City Hall in downtown Kendallville. Although a facility needs assessment has not been completed, consideration should be given to creating an accessible, larger, ground floor meeting room; meeting the physical and technological needs of each department; and creating a focal point for downtown that sets a standard for development in the City’s core. Public Safety Despite having less money in the City-wide budget than in previous years, the City has not reduced the amount of money allocated to public safety. Nonetheless, there is agreement that the Police Department and Fire Department are understaffed and already “doing more with less.” As difficult as it is, these departments must continue to find ways to improve efficiencies. Some ideas include: Partnering with other agencies (e.g. hospital, YMCA, and library) to implement preventative and proactive programs such as self-defense classes, smoke detector awareness, or CPR classes; Continue seeking Federal and State funding for programs or staff that would combat drug problems; and Continue utilizing and expanding the reserve officer and volunteer firefighter programs. services. For example, Fire Station #2 solved the community’s emergency response issues when it was developed on US Highway 6, north of the railroad tracks. This, in fact, gave the community one (1) station on the north side and one (1) station on the south side of the railroad. Both were strategically located to best serve the “north half” and “south half” of the community. However, Kendallville’s growth pattern since the establishment of Fire Station #2 has primarily been east and west along US Highway 6. The closest fire station to Kendallville’s newest industrial area is three (3) miles away. Longer response times can impact the community’s Insurance Service Organization (ISO) rating and, in turn, result in higher insurance premiums. This is just one (1) example that illustrates how important it is to properly manage growth. This example provides insight into how, physically, the community must grow. Unless Kendallville is willing and able to significantly invest in additional public services and facilities (e.g. fire stations and equipment), growth on the fringes, especially further out along US Highway 6, should be limited. New residential, commercial, and institutional development shall be limited to areas within or immediately contiguous to the city limits. While preferred inside or immediately contiguous to city limits, industrial development should be strictly controlled and permitted further from the corporate limits only under exceptional circumstances. Even with the maximization of resources, one thing is clear, Kendallville must grow in ways that consider the impact on these public CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 71 Serve Community Needs PARKS AND RECREATION Residents of Kendallville are proud of the community’s recreational amenities. Those amenities include Bixler Lake Park and Campground – a 117 acre lake with two (2) beaches surrounded by over 400 acres of park land including three plus (3+) mile walking trail, and playgrounds; Sunset Park; the Kendallville Outdoor Recreation Complex; and Blackman Woods Preserve. The Park Department Office is housed in the Youth Center off Iddings Street which is also used for park programs. ACRES, Inc. owns two (2) nature preserves in Kendallville’s planning jurisdiction including the twenty-five (25) acre Detering Nature Preserve and thirty (30) acre Lonidaw Nature Preserve. Detering Nature Preserve is located east of Friendly Village with a trailhead off of Kammerer Road. Lonidaw Nature Preserve is located along Allen Chapel Road (County Road 1000 East), just north of Kammerer Road (County Road 700 North). There are multiple private organizations that offer a variety of fitness and wellness opportunities, including the Cole Family Center YMCA. Kendallville’s planning jurisdiction contains three (3) golf courses: Kendallville Country Club, Noble Hawk Golf Links, and Cobblestone Golf Course. Clearly, Kendallville’s park land and recreational opportunities are above average from a quality and quantity perspective. This Comprehensive Plan recognizes that fact and commends past and present City officials for their commitment to providing these services to the community. The following components should be viewed as ways to improve upon and better utilize these already fantastic community resources. A Five-Year Park and Recreation Master Plan should be completed and approved by the Indiana Department of Natural Resources (IDNR) so that Kendallville can be eligible for State and Federal grants. These grants are 72 generally for land acquisition and park development and improvement. Like the other City departments, the Park Department budget is tight, and leveraging its resources with grants and donations from outside agencies is critical to successful implementation of new projects and programs. The most recent Five-Year Park and Recreation Master Plan expired in 2005. Many of the projects in that Plan have been completed; those that have not been completed should be reconsidered to see if the projects still have merit given the needs and demands of the community and the resources available to the Park Department. Because Kendallville park resources are so great – from a quantity and quality perspective, the City has faced some challenges with funding maintenance. The community must get creative on generating income and reducing expenses. Bixler Lake Park and Campground and the new Recreation Complex have so much to offer. They are fantastic resources, and the community should strive to use the facilities for more events and activities. Maximizing the use of these facilities could be a way to generate funds to offset some of the maintenance costs. The Kendallville Outdoor Recreation Complex is an eighty-nine (89) acre facility for outdoor sports and special events. The facility boasts four (4) diamonds, three (3) soccer fields, basketball, and shuffleboard courts. CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Serve Community Needs A cost-benefit analysis should be conducted on the current services provided by the Park Department to determine the least effective programs. The result could be to eliminate the least effective programs or to retool them to be more efficient. Another analysis might look outside the Park Department’s programs to see if programs offered by other organizations duplicate the Park Department’s offerings. The Park Department could consider partnering with these organizations or dropping duplicate park programs all together. The State of Indiana is working towards acquisition of strategic parcels of abandoned railroad right-of-way on the northwest edge of Kendallville. The abandoned railroad rightof-way is for the development of a trail between Rome City and Kendallville. The State, through the Department of Natural Resources, intends to continue the land acquisition process and hold title to the land until a local organization is willing to accept the land and spearhead construction of the trail. Relocation of the Park Department Office to Bixler Lake Park; Development of an outdoor amphitheater; Development of a downtown plaza or park; and Small parks or recreational facilities integrated near neighborhoods that do not currently have a park within walking distance. Pedestrian Network: Destinations within Bixler Lake Park and Campground are connected by existing trails. The trails make up three (3) formal walking trails that are published and made available to park patrons along with a tree and shrub identification guide. There is also a mountain bike trail within the Bixler Lake Park. The Kendallville community supports this effort to the extent possible because it would add a new recreational opportunity for those desiring fitness running or fitness cycling and elevates the pedestrian network to a new level by providing connectivity to an adjacent community. Later phases of the project could branch off towards the Kendallville Municipal Airport, extend through Kendallville accessing Noble Hawk Golf Links and Blackman Woods Preserve on the south side of the City; and continue south toward Avilla. New Projects New capital projects for the Kendallville Parks and Recreation system should be focused on the following (in no particular order): Development and expansion of a pedestrian network; CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Trails within Bixler Lake Park and Campground are comprised of a variety of different surfaces and provide pedestrian access around the entire perimeter of the lake. 73 Serve Community Needs Bixler Lake Park and Campground’s internal trail system is connected to neighborhoods west of the park by sidewalks along Diamond Street and Sherman Street. Consideration should be given to extending sidewalk along Lake Park Drive (from Cedar Street) where it enters the park and connecting to the existing pedestrian walkways along Lake Park Drive that leads north around the lake. Bixler Lake Park and Campground, the Kendallville Outdoor Recreation Complex, and the Mid-American Windmill Museum are physically very close to one another, and should have a more formalized pedestrian connection between them. Funding for trails and other pedestrian facilities, particularly those that provide connectivity to destinations or other pedestrian facilities, can be available from a variety of sources including natural resources, recreation, health, and transportation agencies. Relocation Park Office: The relocation of the Park Department Office to Bixler Lake Park and Campground makes sense from an operational perspective. Bixler Lake Park is the hub for recreational activity in Kendallville, and department’s maintenance facility is located there. Having the Park Department Office physically located in Bixler Lake Park makes the office more accessible to park patrons and allows for easier supervision of park-related activities. A new location may result in internal communication efficiencies, resource efficiencies, and additional opportunities to provide programming in cooperation with the Kendallville Public Library. carefully, it could be a source of revenue to facilitate additional community events. Furthermore, an organization other than the Park Department may be able to facilitate programming and promotion. Downtown Park: A new pocket park or outdoor plaza area in downtown could serve as the center for public events and activities that contribute to the vitality of the community core. It could also serve as outdoor seating for a restaurant. New Parks: The Kendallville Subdivision Control Ordinance should require new residential developments to set aside land for open space or to establish a recreational facility or park. The maintenance of these facilities would be the responsibility, collectively, of the property owners. This concept is widely adopted by other communities in the Midwest and serves to assure park amenities exist within walking distance of each household. Similarly, regulations may be adopted requiring or encouraging large non-residential developments to establish simple green spaces or recreational facilities for their employees. Outdoor Amphitheater: An outdoor amphitheater could be used to enhance a variety of existing community events and add more family-friendly events to Kendallville. Existing parks possess areas that could be appropriate for such a facility. While the construction and maintenance costs of an outdoor amphitheater should be studied 74 CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Chapter Six Stimulate Economic Growth Stimulate Economic Growth Introduction This chapter looks at ways to expand the local economy, while also looking at how to collaborate effectively with economic development organizations and other Northeast Indiana communities for economic growth. It should be noted that the nation has been experiencing a recession characterized by job losses, high unemployment, mortgage defaults, and declining property values. Kendallville has experienced, firsthand, the national recession, including plant closures and high unemployment. Successful economic development must leverage local and business resources including shovel ready sites, redevelopment buildings and sites, utility infrastructure, human capital, entrepreneurs, and business leaders. It must also recognize that community quality of life is a factor. The remainder of this chapter contains a goal, objectives, and implementation measures that elaborate on strengthening the local economy. Note, implementation measures are abbreviated as IM, and identified with a number that corresponds with the appropriate objective. 76 Goal: Stimulate Economic Growth Expand and diversify the local economy to enhance the standard of living for current and future residents of the City of Kendallville. Objective 1: Strengthen the comprehensive expansion and retention program. IM 1.1 Together with the Noble County Economic Development Corporation, work to establish and maintain an inventory of existing business and industry, and determine which has the greatest potential for expansion. IM 1.2 Identify the City’s best entrepreneurs and understand, through their experiences, how improvement can be made to the local economy. IM 1.3 Establish local incentive programs targeted to help existing businesses. IM 1.4 Publicize State incentive programs. Objective 2: Foster entrepreneurship and small business development. IM 2.1 Develop a local entrepreneurship or business apprenticeship program led by successful businesses. IM 2.2 Work with existing business and industry to determine goods and services that are needed locally, but not available. IM 2.3 Update the Kendallville Zoning Ordinance to expand provisions for home-based businesses that have minimal impacts on adjacent properties. IM 2.4 Work to transition successful and growing home-based businesses to commercial or industrial areas. IM 2.5 Establish an entrepreneurship center or small business incubator that would provide space and assistance for new start-up business and industry or business and industry in transition. CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Stimulate Economic Growth Objective 3: Promote orderly and sustainable economic growth. IM 3.1 Strongly encourage new business and industry to locate in areas where adequate public facilities exist, within service areas of existing emergency services, and in areas zoned for such uses. IM 3.2 IM 3.3 Promote the redevelopment of vacant buildings and properties and discourage premature development of greenfield sites. Ensure proposed business and industrial sites are compatible with surrounding uses and ensure redeveloped sites are sensitive to adjacent uses. Objective 4: Continually assess and strive to improve the quality of life for residents. IM 4.1 Recognize the relationship between quality of life and business and industry recruitment. IM 4.2 IM 4.3 Work with the local high schools, Four County Area Vocational Cooperative, the Freedom Academy, the Kendallville Public Library, and Literacy Empowerment Advocacy Program (LEAP) to equip students and displaced workers with the skills needed to fill local employment needs. Objective 5: Position Kendallville to grow and attract the industry it needs to strengthen and diversify. IM 5.1 Evaluate the local organizations involved in economic development and determine a single primary contact. IM 5.2 Determine what types of business and industry are best suited to diversify and complement the existing economic base. IM 5.3 Recognize the need for, and encourage the development of, information infrastructure and business class internet access in Kendallville. IM 5.4 Develop an incentive program that rates and qualifies projects based on pre-determined criteria. IM 5.5 Commit to investing in, and setting aside money for, economic development projects with emphasis on “packaging” sites and buildings for redevelopment. IM 5.6 Continue participating in regional economic development efforts that support the Northeast Indiana region on a national and global scale. IM 5.7 Utilize the value of the Kendallville Municipal Airport to attract and grow business and industry. Strive to establish a culture of planning and communication that will lead to new efficiencies and the best means to utilize the community’s resources. CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 77 Stimulate Economic Growth Objective 6: Recognize the role that tourism can play in the Kendallville economy. IM 6.1 Maintain and support the Kendallville Chamber of Commerce, the Noble County Convention and Visitors Bureau, and other agencies that play a role in local tourism. IM 6.2 Strive to attract first class serviceoriented businesses that provide dining, shopping, accommodations, and experiences to meet the needs of tourists. IM 6.3 Organize and promote events throughout the year that help generate funds for local resources and that raise awareness of Kendallville’s assets. IM 6.4 In conjunction with the Noble County Convention and Visitors Bureau, develop a strategy to promote tourism within Kendallville, specifically. Additional Information The City of Kendallville is committed to investing in economic development. While other communities are using their County Economic Development Income Tax (CEDIT) revenues to fund budget shortfalls, Kendallville has allocated all their County Economic Development Income Tax (CEDIT) revenue through 2018 to develop the Kendallville Industrial Park East and provide incentives to local business and industry. There are several agencies that promote economic development in Kendallville. The following organizations are listed as “economic development contacts” on the City’s website. Kendallville Economic Development Commission; Kendallville Economic Improvement District; Kendallville Economic Development Advisory Committee; Kendallville Redevelopment Commission; Kendallville Local Development Corporation; and Kendallville Chamber of Commerce. In addition to the aforementioned organizations, the City partners with the following regional organizations to promote Kendallville on a larger scale. Indiana Economic Development Corporation; Region 3A; Noble County Economic Development Corporation; Northeast Indiana Regional Partnership; and THR!VE Noble County, an initiative sponsored in part by the Indiana Home Town Competitiveness model. Each organization has its own mission, purpose, list of member contacts, as well as a role in economic development in Kendallville. 78 CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Stimulate Economic Growth To create a clear and organized first impression, Kendallville should determine and publicize a single point person or organization as the primary contact. AVAILABLE SITES The Noble County Economic Development Corporation website lists eight (8) available industrial buildings with over 430,000 square feet of space on thirty-nine (39) acres within Kendallville’s planning jurisdiction. By comparison, there are two (2) undeveloped industrial lots totaling 100 acres listed on the same website. Clearly, this information is subject to change regularly, but these figures express the substantial number of vacant industrial facilities in Kendallville. Although, the City still receives property tax revenue from these vacant facilities, they can negatively impact community character and may decrease adjacent property values. One (1) of the economic development organizations in Kendallville should focus heavily on these properties. A cost-benefit analysis should be conducted determining options (e.g. redevelopment, reuse, and/or demolition). To complement the creation of “shovel ready sites,” perhaps Kendallville should work with owners of these properties to create “turn-key” facilities. Redevelopment of vacant industrial facilities must be a key component of economic development in Kendallville. CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 EXPANSION AND RETENTION The expansion and retention of existing business and industry should receive as much attention and effort, if not more, than attracting new business and industry. It is critical that Kendallville’s economic development efforts are based on expanding and strengthening existing business and industry. City and economic development officials should foster and maintain relationships with existing industries, and through them, strive to better understand the local business climate. Where are decisions made for the plant; What issues do local companies face; Who are their suppliers; Who are their buyers; and Are there concerns with local labor or labor organizations? Understanding and building relationships with local business and industry increases the City’s awareness of the pressures faced by local business and industry and allows the City to deal directly with issues before they become “deal-breakers.” Often, a good understanding of perspectives and strong relationship enables both parties to capitalize on opportunities which they might not otherwise be aware. NEW ECONOMIC GROWTH Entrepreneurship While Kendallville wants to provide support for business and industry, the City recognizes that homegrown businesses generally have stronger ties to the local community and a commitment to stay and invest locally as the business prospers. Successful homegrown businesses are a source of pride for the community. Additionally, small businesses and small industries are a critical component of a healthy economy. For these reasons, Kendallville will focus on assisting entrepreneurs and small business startups. 79 Stimulate Economic Growth An entrepreneurship center or business incubator in or near Kendallville could offer many services and benefits to the emerging business community. The facility could offer educational programs and assistance to inexperienced entrepreneurs that might have a great concept, but not know what to do next. It could provide accounting, legal, human resource, and tax advisor services to new businesses to make sure these administrative details are not overlooked. Training may also include enhancing the creative potential of the entrepreneur, allowing the person to reinvent an existing business to become more productive, or allowing a startup venture to get off the ground with greater chance of longterm success. Kendallville has organizations that could facilitate or assist with the development of an entrepreneurship center or business incubator. The Four County Area Vocational Cooperative, the Kendallville branch of the Service Corps of Retired Executives (SCORE), and the entrepreneurial pillar of the Noble THR!VE program currently provide similar services, but not under the auspices of a formal entrepreneurship center or incubator. Recruitment Regional economic development agencies typically focus on recruitment, and get the local government involved when interest is expressed. Kendallville should prepare for new recruits by knowing the types of business and industry that will diversify and complement the existing economic base. The community should be prepared to showcase its quality of life and local amenities, and offer incentives. Noble County Economic Development Corporation work hand-in-hand with local officials. Both groups offer a variety of incentive packages to complement local incentives. Kendallville will continue the use of local economic incentives, but only when a project provides a notable benefit to the community. The key is to make sure incentives are offered only to the very best projects that will provide the most benefit. Kendallville should develop a set of “incentive criteria” to rate and qualify economic development projects. These criteria determine an economic development project’s eligibility for incentives. For instance, projects that involve the location of a locally-owned corporate headquarters might rank higher than a project involving construction of a new manufacturing plant. A project that doubles its workforce might rank higher than one (1) that adds only ten percent (10%) to its workforce. Projects that are not sensitive to the environment or public health may not qualify for incentives. Projects creating high-wage jobs rank higher than those that create low-wage jobs, and so on. It is important that the criteria be determined and made available before ranking projects. This means the industry knows, in advance, what the community seeks and can determine where its project ranks even before requesting incentives. Kendallville is familiar with and has employed a variety of state and local incentives. Tax increment financing (TIF), tax abatement, and bond financing are local incentives that can be used for economic development projects. The State of Indiana Economic Development Corporation and the 80 CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Stimulate Economic Growth THE ROLE OF TOURISM The tourism industry in Kendallville contributes to the economy, but more importantly, it adds value to the quality of life for its residents. Notable facilities include Bixler Lake Park and Campground, the MidAmerican Windmill Museum, the Kendallville Outdoor Recreation Complex, and downtown Kendallville. Notable events include Bluegrass Festivals, Kid City, Apple Festival, and the Noble County Fair. Kendallville will strive to become a “minivacation” destination for the average family. These “mini-vacations” might include visitors in town for a tournament; visitors in town staying with family or friends; visitors in town for an event; or folks just passing through. Networking with local and regional bus companies to become the destination of a “mystery trip” would be one way to boost local tourism. Having family-friendly amenities and events provides opportunities for visitors to experience the City’s amenities and interact with Kendallville’s biggest asset – friendly and caring residents. A handful of the projects contained within this Comprehensive Plan would enhance the existing tourist and visitor amenities: a pedestrian network linking local attractions; the continued revitalization of downtown; the development of a downtown plaza or park; and an outdoor amphitheater. CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 81 Stimulate Economic Growth 82 CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Chapter Seven Nurture Environmental Quality Nurture Environmental Quality Introduction Clean water, clean air, clean soil, and an aesthetically pleasing environment are some of the reasons for nurturing environmental quality. Maintaining natural areas and restoring natural features will enhance the quality of life in the City of Kendallville. Bixler Lake, Round Lake, Little Long Lake, Henderson Lake, and Bixler Lake Ditch (i.e. Deible Creek) are prominent water resources in the City of Kendallville. Because the flood zones in Kendallville are generally undeveloped, the City is impacted very little by flooding. It is important to preserve natural drainage patterns so that flooding continues to be a non-issue for the community. The remainder of this chapter contains a goal, objectives, and implementation measures that elaborate on nurturing environmental quality. Note, implementation measures are abbreviated as IM, and identified with a number that corresponds with the appropriate objective. 84 Goal: Nurture Environmental Quality Enrich environmental systems and features within Kendallville’s planning jurisdiction. Objective 1: Minimize conflicts between development and the natural environment. IM 1.1 Allow flexibility for new developments to preserve (i.e. avoid developing) existing high quality natural features and habitats. IM 1.2 Require buffers to filter surface water before it reaches a lake, creek, or ditch. IM 1.3 Integrate open space in future developments to provide recreational amenities and natural habitats. IM 1.4 Require suitable soils as a prerequisite for development. IM 1.5 Work through the Noble County Surveyor and appropriate state agencies to strengthen and enforce regulations that minimize soil erosion and prevent pollution at construction sites. CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Nurture Environmental Quality Objective 2: Protect the quality and quantity of ground water and minimize surface water contaminants. IM 2.1 Monitor changes in State and Federal laws dealing with groundwater supplies, and comply with applicable requirements. IM 2.2 Manage stormwater runoff to maintain and enhance water quality of lakes and streams. IM 2.3 Denote wellhead protection areas around the community’s wells and protect them from uses that can contaminate drinking water. IM 2.4 Reduce discharges of non-point source pollutants through education, storm water management, and reduction of impervious surfaces. IM 2.5 IM 2.6 Require buildings and impervious surfaces to be set back from the top of the bank of a stream or ditch. Utilize native or prairie grasses and other absorption plant materials along regulated ditches. Objective 3: Conserve and restore natural areas, including woodlots, wetlands, and water features. IM 3.1 Participate in State and Federal programs [e.g. Natural Resource Conservation Service (NRCS); Farm Services Administration (FSA); US Department of Agriculture (USDA); and Indiana Department of Natural Resources (IDNR)] to conserve, sustain, and restore natural areas. IM 3.2 Support the newly created Tree Commission in its efforts to achieve “Tree City USA” status. IM 3.3 Require appropriate landscaping be installed, especially canopy trees, when new development occurs. IM 3.4 Encourage new development to preserve existing natural areas through the use of development incentives. CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Objective 4: Improve Air Quality. IM 4.1 Support efforts to make trails accessible, reliable, safe, convenient, and an attractive alternative to vehicular transportation. IM 4.2 Give priority to “clean” business and industry when economic development incentives are requested. Objective 5: Develop and promote a solid waste management plan that emphasizes waste reduction and recycling. IM 5.1 Advocate the expansion of recycling to minimize waste disposal of plastic bottles, cardboard, metal, and other recyclable items. IM 5.2 Modify the Kendallville Zoning Ordinance to allow alternative energy sources (e.g. solar panels and wind turbines). IM 5.3 Educate the development community about the benefits of “green” buildings, and encourage the development of “green” buildings in Kendallville. 85 Nurture Environmental Quality Additional Information The Kendallville community wants to conserve, preserve, and protect its environmental amenities, but not to the point where the amenities cannot be enjoyed by residents. There must be a balance between providing access, enjoyment, education, and recreation in these natural areas while protecting and preserving them for future generations. WATER QUALITY Water bodies generally have a designated use associated with them. These uses can include drinking water, fishing, swimming, recreation, aesthetics, or irrigation. Each designated use has specific water quality standards established by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). The Federal Clean Water Act requires states to identify waters that do not meet those water quality standards and are therefore classified as “impaired.” Indiana’s Department of Environmental Management (IDEM) is responsible for testing and classifying waters in Indiana. According to Indiana’s 2008 list of impaired water bodies [known as the 303(d) list] prepared by the Indiana Department of Environmental Management (IDEM), Henderson Lake is the only impaired water feature in Kendallville. The quality standard not being met is polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) in fish tissue. Kendallville is sensitive to land uses and practices that may contaminate ground water resources and/or surface water resources. Kendallville’s lakes are an amenity and asset that need to be protected against degradation. Development that poses a risk to ground water and surface water will be prohibited unless proven measures are used to protect the water resource. Drainage and storm water management for developments within Kendallville’s planning jurisdiction is governed by the Noble County 86 Storm and Erosion Control Ordinance and approved by the Noble County Surveyor’s Office. This allows impacts of development to be considered on a county-wide scale. Kendallville should participate in the process of reviewing drainage plans for new developments, and should not hesitate to provide comments, positive or negative, about drainage. While flooding causes more damage to communities than any other type of natural disasters, Kendallville does not have large floodplain issues. The Federal Emergency Management Agency’s (FEMA) Flood Insurance Rate Map (FIRM) shows that the 100-year floodplain is limited to areas around the lakes and along the ditches between the lakes. Regardless of the limited floodplain, Kendallville will protect these small areas from development, and discourage development in areas known for localized flooding [those not shown on the Flood Insurance Rate Map (FIRM)]. CONSERVING AND MANAGING OTHER ENVIRONMENTAL AMENITIES Kendallville has areas that are or could be considered wetlands and wet soils. The City will strive to ensure State and Federal laws for wetland mitigation are met, and will consider ways to limit development in these areas. Some mitigation techniques include encouraging the use of conservation easements, promoting planned developments that are designed to preserve these areas, and requiring high quality soils that are suitable for development. Woodlots should be managed and preserved to the greatest extent possible. ACRES Land Trust has already acquired two (2) large woodlots and established nature preserves in each. A tree stand can reduce air temperatures in the summer by as much as ten degrees Fahrenheit (10ºF); clean pollutants from the air, absorbing an estimated ten (10) tons of carbon dioxide per year per acre of wooded CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Nurture Environmental Quality lot; and reduce the soil erosion on adjacent construction sites. For the property owner, saving a few trees on-site reduces energy bills and may make the property more valuable and easier to sell. New development should be designed to minimize the impact on existing woodlots and tree stands. The City of Kendallville is working towards becoming part of the Tree City USA program. A Tree Commission has been formed for this purpose. To be designated a Tree City, Kendallville needs to adopt and implement a tree care ordinance; pass a proclamation for the observance of Arbor Day; and fund a community forestry program with an annual budget of two dollars ($2) per capita. These elements establish a framework for the community to actively preserve and promote trees. Besides the benefits of the trees themselves, benefits of becoming a Tree City include improved image of the community and increased pride. Riparian corridors are various zones of vegetation located along rivers and creeks. These corridors have significant ecological and aesthetic value. Healthy riparian corridors are typically composed of large trees, woody understory and small flowers, grasses, and groundcovers. This vegetation stabilizes the banks of the waterway; reduces the amount or sediments and pollutants entering waterways; reduces water temperatures necessary to support aquatic life; and lessens flooding and drainage problems. “GREEN” DEVELOPMENT More than half of the participants in the Community Values Survey responded favorably to committing to becoming a “green” community. While becoming more environmentally conscious means different things to different people, for the purposes of this Comprehensive Plan, moving towards “green” means reducing wastes, increasing recycling, using alternative energy sources, and promoting “green” development.” The City of Kendallville has a yard waste composting site that allows residents to drop off grass clippings, branches, and other unwanted plant materials. It is then composted and converted into mulch that is available to residents. This site is well-used and reduces the quantity of wastes that go into a landfill. The City should take the necessary steps to ensure its longevity. While there are only a few streams and ditches in the “developed” part of Kendallville’s planning jurisdiction, as the community grows it will encompass more and more of these types of corridors. The City’s ordinances should strive to minimize the effect development has on these natural areas. Kendallville’s only recycling drop-off site is along Weston Avenue. The site is managed by the Northeast Indiana Solid Waste Management District. There have been issues with the recycling facility being full or overflowing, so the City should insist on better management of that site and encourage additional drop-off sites. Also, the costs and participation rates of curbside recycling should be evaluated. Alternative energy sources, primarily solar energy panels and wind turbines, are becoming more mainstream as Americans try CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 87 Nurture Environmental Quality to lessen dependence on fossil fuels. There are two (2) basic types of alternative energy facilities: the first is an on-site device where energy is generated and used on that site; and the second is a commercial-scale facility where large amounts of energy are generated and connected to the energy grid for mass distribution. It is very possible to see interest in on-site alternative energy devices in Kendallville’s planning jurisdiction. The City should be prepared to allow the use of these alternative energy devices in a way that mitigates negative effects to neighboring properties. These regulations should be woven into the Kendallville Zoning Ordinance. A large scale energy generation facility requires vast amounts of land, and while it is unlikely such a facility would seek to locate in close proximity to a municipality, the basic framework for regulating this type of facility should be included in the Kendallville Zoning Ordinance. Finally, Kendallville should become familiar with and begin to educate the development community on the concept of high performance green buildings. Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design (LEED) is a nationally recognized rating system for green buildings. This rating system promotes a “whole-building approach” by evaluating the building’s design, construction, and operation and recognizing performance in five (5) areas: sustainable site development, water savings, energy efficiency, materials selection, and indoor environmental quality. 88 CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Chapter Eight Strengthen Community Character and Identity Strengthen Community Character and Identity Introduction A community’s identity relies on physical features, vitality, cleanliness, land use patterns, cultural amenities, and reputation. Kendallville wants a family-friendly community with a balanced mix of job centers, consumer opportunities, recreational amenities, entertainment, and housing options. Kendallville also wants a vibrant downtown to strengthen the heart of the City. Building on the positive aspects of Kendallville is instrumental in retaining and attracting residents and businesses. To advance Kendallville’s character, the following strategies are recommended. Enhancing gateways and beautifying main corridors; Improving development standards for new development through zoning and subdivision standards; and Revitalizing the downtown. The remainder of this chapter contains a goal, objectives, and implementation measures that elaborate on strengthening community character and identity. Note, implementation measures are abbreviated as IM, and identified with a number that corresponds with the appropriate objective. 90 Goal: Strengthen Community Character and Identity Develop and maintain a community identity that promotes a positive and appealing image of the City. Objective 1: Enhance gateways into the community and beautify main corridors. IM 1.1 Identify main “entrances” into the community and construct a physical feature that exudes the character and identity Kendallville desires to portray. IM 1.2 Expand the scope and applicability of the current architectural design and landscaping standards required along major thoroughfares to include noncommercial uses. IM 1.3 Consider developing an “adopt a rightof-way” program to fund and maintain improvements at gateways and along major transportation corridors. Objective 2: Preserve historic and cultural amenities. IM 2.1 Encourage maintenance and enhancement of historic structures and cultural amenities through programs such as the downtown façade grant program. IM 2.2 Develop guidelines for maintenance and enhancement of historic structures. IM 2.3 Educate and inform the community about the role a Historic Preservation Commission could play in preserving the character of historic areas, and work towards formation of such a commission. IM 2.4 Ensure that infill and redevelopment projects in historic and cultural areas are sensitive to the context and appropriate for the area. CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Strengthen Community Character and Identity Objective 3: Promote the use of quality materials and aesthetic standards. IM 3.1 Modify the Kendallville Zoning Ordinance to require the use of high quality materials and design features that are consistent with the image Kendallville wishes to portray. IM 3.2 Increase the minimum landscape standards for all new development. IM 3.3 Offer incentives to developers to minimize monotonous and repetitive design in residential subdivisions. Additional Information GATEWAYS A community gateway can be a single element in the landscape, such as a signature building at a highly visible location. It can also be as simple as a sign. Gateways are important because they reflect the unique features and values of that community and shape a visitor’s first impression. Objective 4: Improve the vitality of downtown Kendallville. IM 4.1 Develop an inventory of existing downtown businesses and establish an open and working relationship with business owners. IM 4.2 IM 4.3 Recognize the importance of the Main Street Business Association, and encourage participation in that organization. Modify the Kendallville Zoning Ordinance to include a downtown commercial zoning district to ensure infill and redevelopment in downtown is sensitive to the context and appropriate for the area. IM 4.4 Address perceptions about the lack of parking in downtown. IM 4.5 Create a downtown park or plaza area that can be used for existing and new special events. Objective 5: Improve the visual appeal of older neighborhoods. IM 5.1 Modify the Kendallville Zoning Ordinance to include a traditional residential district to accommodate the issues specific to older neighborhoods. IM 5.2 There are multiple signs welcoming passers-by along US 6, traveling west. This sign, advertising downtown Kendallville, is located more than a mile inside the Kendallville City Limits. Kendallville’s current gateways have been blurred by the growth along US Highway 6 and State Road 3. It is hard to keep up with where Kendallville begins and ends along these main thoroughfares. Whatever the gateway feature becomes, it must, at minimum, be highly visible, made of high quality materials, and well-maintained. The gateway feature should be consistent at all locations, but scaled appropriately. As the community gateways project continues to develop, the City should consider searching for outside funding sources for implementation. Enforce the zoning regulations and maintenance requirements for vacant buildings and lots. CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 91 Strengthen Community Character and Identity CORRIDORS Kendallville has already recognized the role main corridors play in shaping a community’s character and identity. The City has implemented architectural standards for commercial developments along arterial and collector streets. These standards require the use of quality materials on building façades, breaks in expansive wall planes, screened trash receptacles, and landscaping. The application of these standards should extend beyond commercial uses, and potentially beyond major thoroughfares to include some degree of quality standard for every type of development in the community. The Kendallville Zoning Ordinance requires the use of high quality materials, such as brick or stone, on façade facing major thoroughfares. Overgrown and untidy right-of-way along US Highway 6, primarily east of Main Street, impacts the impressions of passers-by. These areas are generally non-urbanized roadways (i.e. no curb and no sidewalk) even though the development is urbanized. The responsibility of maintenance of these areas is an issue. These issues should be brought up as the City begins communicating with the Indiana Department of Transportation (INDOT) about the urbanization of this portion of US Highway 6. In the meantime, for untidy rightof-way areas maintained by property owners, the City should attempt addressing problem areas casually. Possibly a letter from the 92 Chamber or City or newspaper campaign could bring about the desired effect. ZONING AND SUBDIVISION STANDARDS Kendallville will update its zoning and subdivision control ordinances to establish higher standards for development. In recent years, courts have more frequently upheld aesthetic regulations, and communities have utilized such standards to improve the quality of life and character of the community. Kendallville is already requiring the use of quality building materials and landscaping for commercial developments along main thoroughfares. These standards are a great start, and after a few years of implementation, the standards should be reevaluated to make sure they are producing the desired effect on the character of the community. Once a community gets accustomed to higher quality development, it is not uncommon for the standards to be increased or made applicable to non-commercial development. Another key component of a community’s character is signs. The City should take a careful look at the current sign regulations and how the use of signs adds to or detracts from the community’s character. An abundance of outdoor advertizing mechanisms can detract from a community’s desired character. This Comprehensive Plan emphasizes redevelopment. Clearly, this is critical to improving Kendallville’s character. While changes to the Kendallville Zoning Ordinance CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Strengthen Community Character and Identity will not “create” redevelopment, they can help make redevelopment “more feasible.” Buffering standards are critical to successful redevelopment because older developments were generally built on smaller lots with smaller setbacks. Also, form and performance-based regulations that look at the physical characteristics of structures and performance standards of uses may make it easier to redevelop some properties. A “traditional residential” zoning district could be used to better regulate the conversion of older single-family homes to multiplefamily units. This district would not necessarily prohibit these types of conversions; it would just require the conversions be completed in a way that compliments the neighborhood. Modifying the Kendallville Zoning Ordinance to include a “downtown commercial” zoning district could allow uses by right that might be appropriate in downtown, but not in other commercial districts. Regulations of the district might be more accommodating of the physical restraints of downtown – for example relaxed parking requirements. Also, the proposed district would ensure redevelopment of parcels and improvements to buildings are sensitive to the context. DOWNTOWN KENDALLVILLE Downtown Kendallville has an outstanding stretch of historic structures that is on the National Register of Historic Places. Because downtown is such a large contributor to Kendallville’s character and identity, it is critical that the downtown commercial district be preserved and protected. Allowing a mixture of uses in a downtown commercial district (as previously discussed) and discouraging the development of public parking lots along the Main Street corridor will help maintain downtown remain vital and vibrant. CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Downtown Kendallville has consistent and very appealing streetscape features including handicap accessible sidewalks, brick pavers, historic light fixtures, flags, banners, trees, and seasonal plants. There are some vacant buildings in downtown, but there are also vacancies in nearly every other commercial development in Kendallville. The vacancies seem to be conglomerated in the 200 block of South Main Street on the west side of the street, and on the 100 block of South Main Street on the east side of the block. The Kendallville Publishing Company, the Kendallville City Hall, the Strand Theater, the Northeastern Center, and Weible’s Paint and Wallpaper have the largest “sidewalk” presence on Main Street. It is important to retain downtown occupants, these in particular, because they occupy so many storefronts and draw people downtown either for business or employment. 93 Strengthen Community Character and Identity Kendallville has recently adopted a Façade Improvement Matching Grant Program that provides a dollar for dollar match for projects that improve the exterior façades of downtown buildings. There is a $15,000 limit on the amount of the grant, and the program ensures proposed improvements are sensitive to the character of the structure and surrounding structures. There has already been a great deal of interest in the program, and such a program will assist property owners in maintaining and preserving the physical resources of downtown. Another way to help preserve the historic character of downtown is to establish a Historic Preservation Commission – something that has been discussed, but not implemented. The Façade Improvement Matching Grant Program should be considered an “educational step” towards the establishment of a Historic Preservation Commission, because the façade grant program requires proposed improvements to meet certain standards similar to what a Historic Preservation Commission might require. Once property owners and the public become familiar with these types of regulations and begin to see results, the City should reconsider establishing a Historic Preservation Commission. Sometimes dealing with perception is more difficult than dealing with reality. There is a perceived parking problem in downtown Kendallville. It is likely that a parking shortage does exist at specific times – for instance when a blockbuster movie is playing at the Strand Theater. It is more likely because a parking space or parking lot is not available in front of the store’s front entrance; folks assume that parking is not available, which is not the case. The Façade Improvement Matching Grant Program is enhancing the character of downtown. The top photo is a “before shot” of an approved grant project. The bottom photo is “after.” Signs along Main Street identify the location of public parking lots located behind stores. 94 CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Strengthen Community Character and Identity The more people that visit downtown Kendallville, the more vibrant the downtown becomes. Downtown merchants express that the best months for them are when events are held in downtown – July’s car show; October’s Apple Festival; and December’s Christmas. These events draw people downtown. The development of a downtown plaza or pocket park should be considered for downtown Kendallville. Such a facility could become the “event center” for downtown – hosting an array of events and activities throughout the year: an additional stage for the Bluegrass Festival; a blueberry brunch; live radio broadcasts; art in the park; and community ice cream socials. CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 95 Strengthen Community Character and Identity 96 CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010 Chapter Nine Conclusion Conclusion Leaders in most communities are faced daily with problems and situations that need immediate resolution. This forces decisions to be made on a reactive basis rather than a proactive basis. future is in the hands of its citizens... as residents, businesses, and community leaders. Kendallville’s leaders, interest groups, and the general public can look to the Comprehensive Plan as a positive vision for the future and begin working towards its realization. By instilling the vision of this document, leaders can make decisions, set priorities, and negotiate changes that are consistent with and complementary to the goals, and objectives. Growth and development can be directed in a way that will provide the most benefit to the community, strengthening its economic health and the quality of life of its residents. Orderly growth provides more opportunities for quality development, resulting in protection of Kendallville’s natural environment, amenities, neighborhoods, and business districts. By carrying out the implementation measures contained in this document, the community is more likely to achieve its long-range vision. Effective implementation will require efforts from the whole community, whether it is teams of volunteers focusing on the beautification of gateways or the combined efforts of the City and businesses to spearhead economic development. Successful implementation will occur through a series of small, manageable steps that, over time, build upon the success of the previous efforts. A comprehensive plan is not a static “set in stone” series of unalterable ideas or projects. To be effective, the Plan must be periodically reviewed, evaluated, and updated to reflect changing trends, outlooks, and thinking in the community. In doing so, Kendallville can collectively plan for the future in a positive and proactive way. Whether it is a vibrant downtown, a good mix of residential communities, or a competitive office and light industrial base, Kendallville’s 98 CITY OF KENDALLVILLE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN – 03/31/2010