1 Potential of Photovoltaic Systems in Countries with High Solar Irradiation George Makrides1, Bastian Zinsser 2, George E. Georghiou 1, Markus Schubert 2 and Jürgen H. Werner 2 1 PV Technology, Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, University of Cyprus 75 Kallipoleos Avenue, P.O. Box 20537, Nicosia, 1678, Cyprus 2 Institut für Physikalische Elektronik (ipe) Universität Stuttgart, Pfaffenwaldring 47, 70569 Stuttgart, Germany Abstract-- Renewable energy sources derived principally from the enormous power of the sun’s irradiation have been gaining ground and are now the most popular and modern forms of energy. Solar power in the form of direct solar irradiation conversion has already been very popular in countries such as Germany and Japan, which successfully used solar energy for many years. The enormous potential of photovoltaic (PV) systems is more obvious and favourable in countries of high irradiation such as Cyprus. The objective of this paper is to describe the potential of PV systems in countries of high solar irradiation through the assessment of the energy yield and performance of thirteen (13) different types of PV systems which have been installed in Nicosia, Cyprus and through comparison with an identical test site located in Stuttgart, Germany. Index Terms — Monocrystalline silicon, multicrystalline silicon, concentrator, photovoltaic potential and thin film. I. INTRODUCTION T HE PV technology sector is a fast growing industry which has shown a worldwide increase with European installed capacity reaching 4689 MWp in 2007 and proving in this way its ability for future development [1]. Amongst the European countries, Germany has been and continues to be the European PV market leader with the most installations. The enormous prospects and job opportunities that have been created due to this technology in Germany has led the way for new upcoming markets such as Spain and Italy. In general the Mediterranean region is an area of strategic importance for PV markets and can potentially play an important part in the integration and uptake of this technology especially due to the favourable conditions for PV in the region. Solar irradiation in Cyprus is one of the highest in Europe, with more than 300 days of the year considered as having sunny weather and with every square metre receiving an annual irradiation of around 2000 kWh/m2 on a tilted surface of 27.5 º, which is much higher than the sunniest areas of the world’s largest market, Germany [2]. The high solar resource of such countries clearly indicates that photovoltaic technologies can have a major impact and potential as an alternative energy source. In order to gain ground over conventional electricity prices, PV technologies need to overcome the key commercial challenge of the initial high cost. The high cost is directly affected by the system cost, performance and operating life. Currently solar cells cost around € 2.3 per watt for crystalline cells and € 1.3 per watt for thin film which are less efficient but can be integrated into building material [3]. Important cost reductions are achieved mainly through the improvement of manufacturing techniques on crystalline technologies and also on the emergence of new technologies such as thin film and concentrator. This paper provides a review of all the current and upcoming PV technologies. Accordingly in order to fully realize the potential of this technology, 13 different PV technologies have been installed both in Cyprus and Stuttgart. Performance measurements and comparisons between the two test sites are also presented in this work. Finally the high solar resource and the high energy yield shown by all systems in Cyprus prove that PV is a suitable candidate to be used as a renewable energy source for this country. II. PHOTOVOLTAIC TECHNOLOGIES Eventhough commercial PV modules are available and a vast deployment is being undertaken, it is essential that more research is carried out to improve this technology and target well-known issues to increase its competitiveness. PV technologies have demonstrated important achievements and transformations over the past 50 years and are expected to undergo important developments in the following decades. The ambition for more PV installations is strengthened and also there are widespread opportunities of a whole business growth and a market with massive job and potential opportunities. Market and research analysts estimate that in the near future crystalline PV modules will continue to dominate this market segment due to the fact that in most installation cases there is a limited area which accordingly necessitates modules with high efficiency. However once the first thin film modules with efficiencies up to 10 % become available which is expected by 2008 then many monocrystalline modules with low efficiency will come under pressure in maintaining their market share. The expected development of PV technology over the coming decades is shown below (see Table I) [4]. 2 TABLE I EXPECTED DEVELOPMENT OF PV TECHNOLOGY OVER THE COMING DECADES. Description 2020 2030 Typical turn-key system price (2007 €/W excl VAT) Typical electricity generation costs southern Europe (2007 €/kWh) Typical commercial flat plate module efficiencies Typical commercial concentrator module efficiencies 2.5 / 2.0 1 Long term potential 0.5 0.15 / 0.12 0.06 0.03 up to 20% up to 25 % up to 40 % up to 30% up to 40 % up to 60 % A. Crystalline Technologies The most economic choice for grid connected applications at the moment is crystal based silicon PV which has been reported to reach efficiencies of 20 %. Such efficiencies are the highest amongst all other market technology based PV modules. Monocrystalline technologies are highly efficient but are also expensive because the manufacturing processes are slow, require highly skilled operators and are labour and energy intensive. Until recently the majority of solar cells were made from pure monocrystalline silicon having no impurities or defects in its lattice. This has been a time consuming and expensive manufacturing methodology and since then a number of approaches to reducing costs of crystalline PV cells and modules or increasing their efficiency have been under development during the past 20 years. These include cells using polycrystalline material which consists of small grains of monocrystalline silicon. Furthermore special manufacturing techniques have been adopted by PV companies such as the Sanyo heterojunction with intrinsic thin film (HIT) and the Sunpower back contact cells which lead the way for increased efficiencies due to special techniques. B. Thin Film Technologies Initial products of thin film technologies were made from very thin films of silicon in a form known as amorphous silicon (a-Si). Amorphous silicon cells are cheaper to produce than those made form crystalline silicon and are also better light absorbers facilitating in this way thinner and therefore cheaper films to be used. Accordingly the manufacturing processes for thin film modules production operates at a much lower temperature than that of crystalline silicon and this conserves energy which is continuously required. Another manufacturing advantage is the fact that PV substrates can be easily deposited on a wide variety of both rigid and flexible substrates including steel, glass and plastics. Amorphous silicon is by no means the only material suited to thin film technologies. Among the many other possible thin film technologies some of the most promising are those based on compound semiconductors in particular Copper Indium Diselenide (CuInSe2), Copper Indium Gallium Diselenide (CIGS), and Cadmium Telluride (CdTe). C. Concentrator Technologies A new emerging PV technology which can provide several economical advantages over the existing technologies is to use high efficiency III - V cells along with cheap concentrating optics in a concept which was known to humanity for a long time. Concentrator technologies make use of relatively inexpensive optics such as mirrors and optics to focus light from the sun onto a smaller area of semiconductor material. Latest concentrators use Fresnel lenses arranged as a number of identical strings over corresponding PV cells reaching concentration factors up to 500 times. Concentrators utilize the direct solar illumination component and therefore require an accurate tracking system to follow the sun’s trajectory. Such technologies are primarily used so as to economize on the solar cell material. This is achieved with the use of inexpensive mirrors and plastic lenses to concentrate the solar energy onto a smaller area PV cell. To sum up the most important advantages of concentrator systems over fixed plate technologies are the increase in power output and the simultaneous decrease of cell size and number of cells used. It is expected that very high efficiency concentrating systems will increase their competitiveness when cell efficiencies reach an overall module efficiency of 30 % by the year 2020. D. Building Integrated PV (BIPV) Technologies A further significant milestone in new PV technologies is achieved through BIPV technologies which comprise of photovoltaic systems that are readily integrated with the architectural building or with an object’s phase. The integration of such systems usually requires the advice of professional civil engineers, architects and PV system designers during the design of the system and the building. In this case a good evaluation of the place of integration is required so as to maximize solar coverage and electricity output. BIPV are usually installed on facades, building window systems and as flexible rolls on roofs. BIPV technologies achieve system cost reductions by considering and integrating their costs into building construction costs. Eventhough there are at the moment a number of innovative ideas and designs for such technologies, the field of BIPV has still room for improvement. E. Emerging and new PV Technologies Implementations of other PV technologies are conceptually the subject of numerous research activities worldwide. The target always in this direction is the limitation of costs and the increase of conversion efficiency. New technologies include sensitized oxide cells, organic solar cells, multijunction cells and other nanostructured materials. PV technologies in this category can be distinguished mainly through the approaches taken to tailor the properties of the active layer to better match the solar spectrum and approaches that modify the incoming solar spectrum and function at the periphery of the active device [4]. 3 III. PERFORMANCE MEASUREMENTS IN CYPRUS An important requirement for successful application and integration of photovoltaic technologies in any location is to have knowledge of its potential at the specific location of installation. To evaluate the PV potential in Cyprus, thirteen (13) grid-connected PV systems of nominal power 1 kWp each have been installed in Nicosia, Cyprus and Stuttgart, Germany (see Fig. 1 and 2) providing the opportunity for direct comparisons under the different climatic conditions of the two countries. More specifically, the installed PV technologies in Nicosia, Cyprus consist of twelve fixed plate mounted systems, a two-axis tracking system and a flatcon concentrator system. The systems are of installed power 1 kWp and include technologies of mono crystalline, multi crystalline silicon to amorphous silicon, cadmium telluride (CdTe), Cu(InGa)Se2, HIT-cell and other solar cell technologies from a range of manufacturers such as BP Solar, Atersa, Sanyo, Solon, SunPower etc. The PV modules are mounted on mounting racks at optimal inclination to provide maximum annual yield for each respective location. Table II gives a detailed description of the installed systems. TABLE II INSTALLED PHOTOVOLTAIC TECHNOLOGIES AT THE TWO TEST SITES. Manufacturer Module Type Atersa Atersa BP Solar A-170M 24V tracked A-170M 24V BP7185S Sanyo HIP-205NHE1 Suntechnics STM 200 FW Schott Solar ASE-165-GT-FT/MC 170Wp ASE-260-DG-FT 250Wp SW165 poly P220/6+ MA100T2 ASIOPAK-30-SG FS60 WS 11007/75 Schott Solar SolarWorld Solon Mitsubishi Schott Solar First Solar Würth Technology monocrystalline Silicon monocrystalline Silicon monocrystalline Silicon (saturn-cell) monocrystalline Silicon (HIT-cell) monocrystalline Silicon (back contact-cell) multicrystalline Silicon (MAIN-cell) multicrystalline EFG Silicon multicrystalline Silicon multicrystalline Silicon amorphous Silicon amorphous Silicon Cadmium Telluride Cupper-Indium-GalliumDiselenide (CIGS) A. Measurement System Description Both climatic data and PV system measurements are acquired and stored from the test facilities through the advanced measurement platform. The platform comprises of installed metereological and electrical sensors which are connected to a central database. The measurement system includes a number of sensors and a central datalogging system which stores data at a resolution of 1 second. The monitored metereological data include the global irradiation at the plane of array (POA), wind direction and speed as well as ambient and module temperature. The electrical parameters measured include current and voltage at MPP as obtained at each PV array output. All the installed acquisition devices are shown below (see Table III). Fig. 1. Photovoltaic systems installed at the University of Cyprus Nicosia, Cyprus. TABLE III INSTALLED DATA ACQUISITION EQUIPMENT AND SENSORS AT BOTH TEST SITES. Parameter Sensor Model Data Measurement Temperature Ambient Temperature Module Global Irradiance Direct Normal Irradiance (DNI) Sensor DC Voltage DC Current Datalogger Temperature Temperature Pyranometer Pyrheliometer TopMessage PT 100 PT 100 CM 21 CH 1 DC Voltage DC Current Potential Divider Shunt Resistor The PV systems at both sites have been monitored from the beginning of June 2006 and currently the second year of evaluation has been completed. IV. PHOTOVOLTAIC SYSTEMS IN CYPRUS Fig. 2. Photovoltaic systems installed at the ipe Stuttgart, Germany Most PV installations in Cyprus include grid connected systems on rooftops and stand alone systems in remote areas used for agricultural purposes but also to power 4 250 Stuttgart Nicosia 200 2 Solar Irradiation [kWh/m ] 150 100 50 Winter 1.0 Spring 1/ 9/ 2 1/ 006 10 /2 1/ 006 11 /2 00 6 1/ 6/ 20 1/ 06 7/ 20 1/ 06 8/ 20 06 Summer Autumn Fig. 4. Solar irradiation in the POA as measured by the pyranometers installed both in Nicosia and Stuttgart. Availability (MW) Generation (MW) PV AC Power (kW) 1000 1/ 3/ 20 1/ 07 4/ 20 1/ 07 5/ 20 07 0 1/ 12 /2 0 1/ 06 1/ 20 1/ 07 2/ 20 07 telecommunication and other remote cabinets. The most important advantage of PV usage in Cyprus is its ability to minimise the maximum electricity demand. This important advantage of PV systems over other renewable energy technologies has been demonstrated in accordance to its electricity production which is in phase with maximum electricity demand. In Cyprus most of the load is consumed during the hot summer period due to the increased operation of air conditioning systems. It is estimated that maximum demand and electricity consumption will be increasing in Cyprus mainly due to the increase of building construction and this may accordingly lead to electricity tariffs that are more favourable for PV generation (Fig. 3). 17 /0 9/ 20 06 V. RESULTS A. Solar Resource in Cyprus PV modules installed in Cyprus are subject to high irradiation which favours their performance but also to extreme high module temperatures up to 60 °C in the summer. The solar irradiation measured on site in Cyprus using the installed pyranometer was found to be 1997 kWh/m2 with maximum contribution during the summer period. Lower annual irradiation for the same time period (1/06/2006 – 1/6/2007) has been measured by the same type of pyranometer in Stuttgart with annual irradiation of 1460 kWh/m2 and highest irradiance shown in April (see Fig. 4). As it is essential to avoid uncertainty errors in measurements obtained from only one source (the central pyranometer) a number of silicon solar radiation sensors have been further spread over the field to detect inhomogeneous irradiation, which could be caused by obstacles afar. At both locations the measured deviation between silicon solar cell sensors was very small approximately 1 % ensuring the validity of the measured results. 25 20 15 10 5 0 12 /1 /2 0 1/ 06 1/ 20 2/ 07 1/ 20 07 Fig. 3. Weekly variation of total generation (MW), availability (MW) in phase with PV electricity generation of a 1 kWp installed system. The plot shows only time periods from 6:00 am to 17:00 pm every day. Stuttgart Nicosia 30 Ambient Temperature [ °C] 15 /0 9/ 20 06 13 /0 9/ 20 06 11 /0 9/ 20 06 35 Winter Spring 9/ 1/ 2 10 006 /1 /2 11 00 /1 6 /2 00 6 0.0 00 :0 0: 00 0 00 :0 0: 00 0.2 00 :0 0: 00 200 6/ 1/ 20 7/ 06 1/ 20 8/ 06 1/ 20 06 0.4 400 A comparison of average daily ambient temperatures has also shown that in Cyprus the maximum average ambient temperature of 29 °C in the summer and minimum of 9 °C during the winter is obtained. The climatic conditions were different in Stuttgart as the observed ambient temperatures reached maximum averages of 23 °C in July and respective minimum temperatures of 4 °C in December (see Fig. 5) [5]. 3/ 1/ 20 4/ 07 1/ 20 5/ 07 1/ 20 07 600 PV AC Power (kW) 0.6 00 :0 0: 00 Total Generation (MW) 0.8 800 Summer Autumn Fig. 5. Ambient monthly average temperature measured both in Nicosia and Stuttgart. B. Solar Energy production Most installed PV systems produced annual ac energy yield within the range of 1600-1700 kWh/kWp (see Fig. 6). For the same period of time the tracker has shown ac energy yields of 2039 kWh/kWp and dc energy yield of 2236 kWh/kWp showing 30 % higher ac energy yield of the tracker than the average fixed plate energy yield for the same period [6]. 5 2500 2500 DC Energy Yield AC ENergy Yield AC Energy Yield [kWh/kWprated] 2000 Energy Yield [kWh/kWprated] Stuttgart AC Energy Yield [kWh/kWp] Nicosia AC Energy Yield [kWh/kWp] 1500 1000 500 2000 1500 1000 500 0 At er sa m At e At rsa er sa Tra m cke BP ono r m -c-S o Su S no i nP an -cSI ow yo er HI m T-S on i ocSi Sc ho tt So Sc MA IN h la -S rW ott or EF i ld G So mu -Si lti lo -c n -S m i ul ticSi M its ub is h S c i aho Si W tt a Fi urt -Si rs h tS C ol IGS ar C dT e on oA t c-S er I sa tra m cke on r BP om c-S Su on I S nt o ec an -cSi hn yo ic H s I m T-S on i ocSi Sc ho tt So Sc M A ho IN la -S rW tt o r EF i ld G m So u l Si lo tin c m -S i ul ticSi M its Sc u b ho ish i tt So a-S i la W ra ? -S Fi i rs rt h t S CI G ol ar S Cd Te 0 Fig. 6. DC and AC Energy yield of the installed systems in Nicosia in the time period June 2006 – June 2007. The values are normalized to the nameplate power. Fig. 8. AC-Energy yield of the 12 fixed systems in Stuttgart and Nicosia in the time period 01.06.2006 – 01.06.2007. The values are normalized to [kWp] with the nameplate power. The highest annual energy yield was obtained from the SunPower mono c-Si, Sanyo HIT, Copper Indium Gallium Diselenide (CIGS) and Cadmium telluride (CdTe) systems (the latter two being thin film technologies). The highest average energy yield was shown during the summer months with June providing the highest ac yield of 168 kWh/kWp for the fixed plate systems and 215 kWh/kWp for the tracker. An important observation made was that technologies with the lowest temperature coefficients have shown the highest annual energy yields. In addition, the increased module temperature that is observed in Cyprus is an important loss mechanism especially near midday reaching an excess of 60 ˚C (see Fig. 9). AC Energy Yield [kWh/kWp] 600 50 600 40 400 30 200 Module temperature (°C) Summer Autumn Winter Spring 60 Power DC Power AC Module Temperature 800 DC - AC Power (W) 700 1000 20 0 500 10 23:00:00 07:00:00 15:00:00 23:00:00 400 300 200 Fig. 9. DC power, AC power and module backside temperature over the course of a sunny day in Cyprus (10th of August 2006) for PV system (Sanyo HIT). 100 A te At rsa er T sa ra ck m on er B oP cm on Si S oun Sa c -S Po ny w oH I er I m T-S on i ocS i S ch ot tM S A S c I ol ar hot N-S W t i or EF ld G m -S S i ul ol on ti-c -S m i ul ticS i M its ub is hi a S ch -Si ot ta W -S Fi urt i h rs t S CI G ol ar S C dT e 0 Fig. 7. AC Energy yields of the installed systems in Nicosia in the four seasons, normalized to the nameplate power. C. Comparison of Performance with Germany The high potential of PV in Cyprus is obvious when comparing data between the two test sites. In Stuttgart the average annual yield was 1194 kWh/kWprated and in Nicosia it was 1580 kWh/kWprated. The difference between the best and the worst performing PV-system is 15 % in both countries related to the average values (see Fig. 8) although it should be noted that the solar irradiation measured in Stuttgart during the period of June 2006 – June 2007 was approximately 19 % higher than the long term average irradiation of other years. VI. CONCLUSION The key to successful integration of photovoltaic systems is to have knowledge of their performance and potential under the climatological conditions of any particular location. The high energy yield and performance results of the different PV systems installed in Cyprus clearly indicate that such technologies can have a major impact and potential as an integral part of the future energy mix of Cyprus. Finally information extracted in this work will help to classify the performance of each technology for the particular climatological conditions in Cyprus. VII. ACKNOWLEDGMENT The authors gratefully acknowledge the contributions of the German Federal Ministry for the Environment, Nature Conservation and Nuclear Safety (BMU), which supported this work under contract No. 0327553. We also gratefully acknowledge the support by the companies Atersa, First Solar GmbH, Phönix Sonnenstrom AG, Schott Solar GmbH, 6 SMA Technologie AG, SolarWorld AG, Solon AG and Würth Solar GmbH & Co.KG. Finally the authors would like to acknowledge the financial support by the Cyprus Research Promotion Foundation (grant number TEXNO0506/16). VIII. REFERENCES [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] Systemes Solaires, "Le Journal des Energies Renouvelables," Photovoltaic Barometer, No. 184-2008, Apr. 2008. B. Zinsser, G. Makrides, G. E. Georghiou and J. H. Werner, " First Operation Year of 13 Photovoltaic Technologies in Germany and Cyprus," in Proc. 2007 EUPVSEC Conf., pp. 17-20. U. A. Rahoma, "Utilization of Solar Radiation in High Energy Intensive of the World by PV System," American Journal of Environmental Sciences, vol. 4, pp. 121-128, 2008. PhotoVoltaic technology Platform, "A Strategic Research Agenda for Photovoltaic Solar Energy Technology," vol. LB-77-07-276-EN-C, pp. 1-70. G. Makrides, B. Zinsser, G. E. Georghiou, M. Schubert and J. H. Werner, "Outdoor Efficiency of Different Photovoltaic Systems Installed in Cyprus and Germany," in Proc. 2008 PVSC33 Conf., pp. 17-20. G. Makrides, B. Zinsser, G. E. Georghiou and J. Werner, "Performance assessment of different Photovoltaic Systems under Identical field conditions of high irrdaiance," in Proc. 2008 PV-SAT4 Conf., pp. 199-202. IX. BIOGRAPHIES George Makrides received the BEng First Class Honours degree in Electrical and Electronic Engineering from Queen Mary University of London in 2003. He continued his studies obtaining the MPhil degree in Engineering from the University of Cambridge and graduated in 2004. He worked for two years as a radio network engineer in a private telecommunication operator of Cyprus and he is currently a PhD student at the University of Cyprus, Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering. His research interests include renewable sources of energy and specifically photovoltaic systems. Bastian Zinsser received his undergraduate and postgraduate degree from the Institute of Physical Electronics University of Stuttgart and is currently a PhD student at the same Institute in the field of Photovoltaic Systems. His research interests include the areas of grid connected photovoltaic systems, PV system modeling and analysis. George E. Georghiou is currently an Assistant Professor at the Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, University of Cyprus. Prior to this, he was the undergraduate course leader in Electrical Engineering at the University of Southampton, Department of Electronics and Computer Science and a Research Advisor for the Energy Utilisation, University of Cambridge. Having graduated from the University of Cambridge with a BA (1995 – First Class), MEng (1996 – Distinction) and PhD (1999), Dr Georghiou continued his work at the University of Cambridge in the capacity of a Fellow at Emmanuel College for a further three years (1999-2002). His research interests lie predominantly in the area of renewable sources of energy and in the utilization of electromagnetic fields and plasma processes for environmental, food processing and biomedical applications, BioMEMS, Nanotechnology and Power Systems. Markus B. Schubert holds a Dipl.-Ing. and a Dr.-Ing. degree, both obtained from the Faculty of Electrical Engineering at the University of Stuttgart. Since 1985, he worked as a research assistant at Stuttgart University, Institute of Physical Electronics (ipe). Since 1993 he serves as a group leader at ipe, managing various research projects on thin film sensors and solar cells. M. B. Schubert has authored and coauthored more than 100 publications. Since 1999, he assists Prof. J. H. Werner as the associate director of ipe. Jürgen H. Werner is currently the Director of the Institute of Physical Electronics (ipe) at the University of Stuttgart and widely accepted as a pioneer in the field of PV. He earned his diploma degree in 1979 from the University of Tübingen and received his Ph.D. from the University of Stuttgart in 1983. His PhD thesis work on grain boundaries in silicon at the Max-Planck-Institute for Solid State Research, received the Otto-HahnMedal of the Max-Planck-Society, in recognition for the quality of his work. Between 1985-1987 he spent two years in the United States as a guest scientist at the IBM T. J. Watson Research Center and AT&T Bell Laboratories, Murry Hill, working on Schottky diodes. In 1987 he was offered a position as a permanent scientist at the Max-Planck-Society and in 1991 he received the habilitation from the University of Munich. During these years, his research concentrated on semiconductor interfaces. In 1996 he became the director and full professor of the Institute for Physical Electronics. Prof. Werner is author and co-author of over 230 publications, the editor of nine books and has more than 30 invited papers at prestigious international conferences..