WORLD WINNING CITIES | December, 2014 Global Foresight Series 2014 China’s City Winners Nanjing City Profile 2 China’s City Winners The Case for Nanjing No other city in China’s Yangtze River Delta has a claim to history quite like Nanjing, whose name means ‘Southern Capital’ and which ruled over both ancient dynasties as well as China’s first modern republic. The city maintains a prominent role to this day as capital of Jiangsu Province, one of the richest regions on China’s developed coast. We see in Nanjing an increasingly dynamic city, the leaders of which are developing its key strengths while addressing areas that still need improvement. China’s City Winners: Nanjing Key Features • Capital of one of China’s most dynamic provinces, and a key city in the Yangtze River Delta (YRD) • Colossal educational and research infrastructure, and a highly educated population • Large services sector distinguishes it from YRD manufacturing cities • Location on Yangtze River and high-speed rail routes makes it a transport and logistics hub • E conomic pull extends beyond Jiangsu Province and YRD to inland provinces, attracting talent and shoppers • One of China’s most significant cities in ancient and modern history; a budding cultural center and a major tourist draw The city’s exceptional university system is by far the most developed of any city within the Yangtze River Delta (YRD) region. Its cohort of enrolled higher-education students exceeds even that of Shanghai in size, and the share of the population with a college degree is second only to Beijing’s. Nanjing’s government is keen to leverage its educational resources to greater effect by encouraging more local graduates to settle in the city, and by creating more opportunities for talented individuals to turn marketable ideas into private enterprises. In turn, the strong educational infrastructure supports a robust base of R&D across a range of industries, and more broadly contributes to the tertiary sector accounting for a larger share of Nanjing’s economy and employment than that of any big YRD city save Shanghai. Nanjing is seeking to expand this share by promoting growth in a variety of service sectors, notably software and finance. At the same time, the city has an impressive base of traditional industries, which has attracted investment from multinationals such as Bosch and BASF. Planners are expanding beyond a traditional emphasis on steel and chemicals to prioritize automobiles and electronics, while also developing more advanced sectors such as biopharmaceuticals and new energy. Nanjing City Profile 2014 3 Nanjing is one of the YRD’s most significant transport and logistics hubs and, sitting on the Yangzte River, is an important inland port. The city also lies at the crossroads of key lines in China’ s emerging highspeed rail network, including the Beijing-Shanghai route and a recently operational line connecting Shanghai with inland metropolises such as Chengdu. The office market is benefiting as services firms and MNCs account for a growing share of demand alongside traditional manufacturing companies. Limited available space in the established downtown area currently guarantees stable rental growth, while government incentives are ensuring the take-up of a portion of the large supply being delivered to the new Hexi CBD. Lying at the Yangtze River Delta’s north-west corner at the confluence of many regional highways and conventional rail lines, Nanjing is also a natural gateway for many of inland China’s residents to reach one of the coast’s most dynamic regions. The city’s urban area is served by one of the YRD’s largest and most ambitious subway networks, and there are plans for suburban rail lines to integrate it with more cities in the region. Nanjing’s growing retail market is fuelled not just by local spending but a huge catchment that attracts people from inland provinces to the bustling, glitzy malls of Xinjiekou, one of the YRD’s largest and most important retail concentrations. Developers are also moving to create new retail clusters in growing markets like Hexi. Nanjing is sometimes criticised as being old-fashioned and dominated by the public sector, and lacking the freewheeling entrepreneurial spirit that has given fellow YRD cities like Suzhou, Hangzhou, Wuxi and Ningbo an edge in indicators such as GDP, industrial output and retail sales. We believe that such claims are exaggerated. While it houses many state-owned champions, Nanjing is also home to Suning Appliance Co., which a domestic trade group declared to be China’s largest private company by revenue in 2013. More importantly, the city’s recent efforts to build on its traditional advantages while reforming its more conservative culture are showing signs of bearing fruit – over the past five years Nanjing’s average GDP growth has been the strongest of any major YRD city. In terms of the property market, we are optimistic about Nanjing across most sectors. While like other major Chinese cities Nanjing is building a number of new urban sub-centres, industrial zones, and business parks, it has taken a relatively measured approach to the construction of prime-quality real estate assets, which has helped control the risk for oversupply in several sectors. Nanjing’s residential sector has been affected by a recent nationwide slowdown, but the city’s low current inventories, relatively limited future pipeline, and rising demand from owner-occupiers should permit prices to continue to rise at moderate rates. Nanjing is seeking to leverage its status as a transportation hub to build capacity as a logistics centre; however, its existing stock of modern warehouse facilities is still small compared to that of other YRD cities, and the presence of MNC developers is also relatively limited. With developers just beginning to expand to promising new submarkets, the logistics property sector has plenty of potential. Nanjing’s hotel market faces the greatest immediate risk of oversupply, as the city’s stock of high-end rooms is set to nearly double over the next three to five years. Its tourism industry still has room to grow compared to those of other big YRD draws like Suzhou and Hangzhou, and the city government hopes that recent international events will broaden Nanjing’s visitor base beyond the current core of business travellers. 4 China’s City Winners Economic Dashboard Economic Dashboard Openness Size Population (million, 2013) 8.2 Utilised FDI (US$ billion, 2013) Metropolitan Population (million, 2013) 6.3 Exports (US$ billion, 2013) GDP (US$ billion, 2013) 132.0 Tertiary GDP (US$ billion, 2013) 71.8 4.0 32.3 Wealth GDP/Capita (US$, 2013) 16,153 Disposable Income per Capita (US$, 2013) Growth Population (% pa, 2000-2013) 2.4 GDP Growth (% pa, 2000–2013, LCU) 17.3 6,573 Education and Labour Higher Education Institutions (2013) 54 Total Enrolments (2013) Infrastructure Airport Passengers Throughput (million, 2013) Port Cargo Throughput (million tons, 2013) 15.0 202.0 711,600 Unemployment (%, 2013) 2.7 Average Wage Rate* pa (US$, 2012) 9,683 *Average wages of staff and workers in ‘non-private units’ in the Urban Area. See Definition of Terms Source: EIU, CEIC, Local Statistics Bureau Harbin Changchun Urumqi Jilin Shenyang Beijing Tianjin Hohhot Taiyuan Tangshan Dalian Yantai Shijiazhuang Weifang Qingdao Jinan Lanzhou Luoyang Zhengzhou Chengdu Wuhan Chongqing Changsha Hangzhou Wenzhou Nanchang Fuzhou Guiyang Quanzhou Kunming Guangzhou Nanning Tier 3 Early Adopter Wuxi Nantong Suzhou Hefei Xiangyang Tier 1 Core Tier 1.5 Transitional Tier 2 Growth Tier 3 Emerging Changzhou Xuzhou Nanjing Xi’an Haikou Dongguan Xiamen Shantou Foshan Shenzhen Hong Kong Macau Zhuhai Zhongshan Taipei Shanghai Jiaxing Ningbo Shaoxing Jinhua Nanjing City Profile 2014 5 Yangtze River Delta (YRD) Cities GDP, 2013 Yangtze River Delta (YRD) Cities GDP Growth, 2008-2013 14% 12% 1,500 Y-o-Y Growth RMB Billions 2,000 1,000 500 0 10% 8% 6% 4% 2% Shanghai Suzhou Hangzhou Wuxi Nanjing 0% Ningbo GDP 2013 Source: CEIC, City Statistical Bulletins 38 30 68 21 20 10 0 RMB Trillions 54 40 9 Shanghai 8 Nanjing 1 Hangzhou 16 1 - Suzhou Ningbo 12 1 Wuxi Higher-Education Institutions “211” Schools Source: CEIC, Ministry of Education Note:In the ‘211’ plan, the ‘21’ refers to the twenty-first century, and the final ‘1’ is shorthand for ‘100’ top schools Nanjing Yangtze River Bridge 2011 2012 Nanjing Hangzhou Shanghai Ningbo Suzhou Wuxi 2013 Industrial Output, 2013 68 50 2010 4 16% 3 12% 2 8% 1 4% 0 Shanghai Suzhou Wuxi Industrial Output 2013 Source: CEIC, City Statistical Bulletins Hangzhou Nanjing 5-Year CAGR Ningbo 0% 5-year CAGR Number of Schools 60 2009 Source: EIU Higher Education Institutions, 2013 70 2008 6 China’s City Winners City Overview Western Anchor of the Yangtze River Delta Nanjing sits in the north-west of the Yangtze River Delta (YRD). The city forms a triangle with Hangzhou and Shanghai that corresponds to the YRD’s heartland, one of the richest and most developed regions in China. As the capital of Jiangsu Province, Nanjing stands on the border between the province’s less developed north and its urbanized, industrialized south, an area that includes major YRD cities like Suzhou and Wuxi. Services-driven Centre and Industrial Suburban Area The city’s administrative area straddles a bend in the Yangtze River and covers a total land area of 6,587 sq km, though only a fraction of it is urbanised. The historic centre of Nanjing is south-east of the Yangtze River and west of the Purple Mountain, and is still partially enclosed by Ming Dynasty city walls. Here, former imperial palaces and presidential compounds share space with the modern city’s bustling downtown, centred on the Xinjiekou shopping and business cluster. This historic centre and its immediate surroundings comprise four services-dominated districts that official records mark as the ‘urban’ city centre. Almost all of Nanjing’s investment-grade offices and retail are located in this city centre, divided between the traditional core around Xinjiekou and the master-planned new CBD of Hexi in the south-west. The city centre is ringed by a designated ‘suburban’ region. Despite the suburban label, many of the districts in this area are developing quickly, thanks to the presence of industrial clusters and development zones that underpin Nanjing’s secondary sector. The city’s main manufacturing and logistics parks are concentrated in the suburban region and, as Nanjing’s urban population grows and the urbanised area expands, it is also witnessing increased volumes of residential and commercial development. This includes the areas to the immediate east and south of the city centre, as well as the area north of the Yangtze River, which has recently been targeted by the municipal government for a ‘cross-river development’ strategy. In a sign of the suburban region’s growing attractiveness, national Yangtze River Delta Anhui Hefei Jiangsu Highway Railway Nanjing Wuxi Wuhu Suzhou Shanghai Hangzhou Zhejiang Ningbo Nanjing City Profile 2014 7 developers like Wanda and China Resources are building or buying land for mixed-use projects in formerly underdeveloped areas such as southern Jiangning and northern Pukou. Nanjing One-hour City Circle In the far south of Nanjing lie Lishui and Gaochun, two areas that were formally designated as ‘districts’ in early 2013, but which were previously considered ‘rural’ counties. They are still lightly developed and relatively isolated from Nanjing’s main city area. Trans-Border One-Hour City Circle Nanjing also anchors a ‘One-Hour City Circle’, a ‘hub and spoke’ model of regional development that envisions a transport infrastructure linking Nanjing and its seven surrounding cities to form a conveniently accessible greater urban region. The cities include Zhenjiang, Yangzhou and Huaian in Jiangsu Province, and Ma’anshan, Wuhu, Chuzhou, and Xuancheng in Anhui Province – the large presence of Anhui cities in the mix reflects the weight that Nanjing carries in parts of Central China. The One-Hour City Circle covers about 63,000 sq km. Its urban population of 19.8 million is comparable to that of New York, and its total 2013 GDP of RMB 2.2 trillion (USD 362.6 billion) ranks between those of San Francisco and Philadelphia. Huai’an Jiangsu Yangzhou Chuzhou Zhenjiang Nanjing Ma’anshan Anhui Shanghai Wuhu Xuancheng Zhejiang ANHUI City Center Liuhe District ANHUI Suburban Districts JIANGSU Lishui & Gaochun Nanjing City Center Versus Hinterland, 2012 ANHUI 100% Pukou District Qixia District Gulou District Jianye District 80% Xuanwu District Qinghuai District JIANGSU Yuhuatai District Jiangning District 60% ANHUI 40% 20% 0% Lishui District Land Area Residential Population GDP City Centre Districts Source: Nanjing Statistical Yearbook Primary GDP Secondary GDP Suburban Districts Tertiary GDP JIANGSU Shijiu Lake Lishui & Gaochun Gaochun District ANHUI Gaocun Lake 8 China’s City Winners Demographics and Labour Force Largest YRD Metropolitan Area After Shanghai Nanjing’s population in 2013 was officially recorded at 8.2 million, making it more populous than Tier 2 YRD cities like Wuxi and Ningbo, but smaller than fellow Tier 1.5 cities Hangzhou and Suzhou. Official statistics can be misleading, however, as they lump city populations together with towns and villages that fall within their administrative region. Estimates from the Economist Intelligence Unit (EIU) that focus on Chinese cities’ contiguous metropolitan area present a truer picture. Nanjing’s estimated metropolitan population of 6.3 million makes it the second largest city in the YRD after Shanghai. This is significant from a real estate perspective because Nanjing’s population of workers and consumers is concentrated in a relatively large urban centre. Key Commercial Areas in Nanjing City Center Yangtze River Gulou Xuanwu Lake Purple Mountain Xinjiekou Hexi Confucius Temple Metro Line 1 Metro Line 2 Metro Line 10 Railways Nanjing City Profile 2014 9 Population, 2013 Between 150,000 and 200,000 new residents have been added to Nanjing’s metropolitan population over each of the past five years. These new arrivals include people migrating from inland areas in search of better opportunities in coastal provinces, as well as students graduating from Nanjing’s universities who have chosen to remain in the city. 25 Million People 20 15 10 5 0 Shanghai Nanjing Hangzhou Metropolitan Population Source: Economist Intelligence Unit (EIU) Confucius Temple Area Suzhou Wuxi Non-Metro Population Ningbo Services-oriented Workforce About 54.0% of Nanjing’s workforce is employed in the services sector, compared to 36.8% in the manufacturing sector and 9.2% in agriculture. The proportion of people in Nanjing’s tertiary sector dwarfs those of industrial Suzhou and Wuxi, and is even greater than the share of Nanjing’s fellow provincial capital Hangzhou. In fact, Nanjing’s labour structure resembles that of Shanghai more than any other city in the region, though with one key difference: its average wages at RMB 60,404 a year are almost one-third lower than Shanghai’s RMB 89,601, meaning that Nanjing has one of the most affordable servicesoriented labour forces in the YRD. 10 China’s City Winners Education and Research Nanjing University Educational Attainment, 2013 800 30% Thousand Students 700 25% 600 20% 500 400 15% 300 10% 200 5% 100 0 Nanjing Shanghai Hangzhou Suzhou Ningbo* Wuxi Number of Enrolled Students Share of Population with University Degree Source: CEIC; Nanjing Population and Family Planning Committee * No available data for population with degrees from Ningbo 0% Share of Population with University Degree One of China’s Leading Educational Centres In the field of education, Nanjing stands alongside Shanghai in a league apart from the rest of the Yangtze River Delta. Nanjing is home to 54 higher education institutions, more than any of its neighbours and second only to Shanghai’s 67. Even more impressive is Nanjing’s concentration of schools in the national ‘211’ project, a ranking of the top 100 schools that China expects to compete globally in the twenty-first century. Jiangsu’s total of 11 such schools is the highest of any province in China, and 8 of them are in Nanjing alone. Other Tier 1.5 and Tier 2 YRD cities make do with one or none at all. Nanjing’s 711,600-strong population of enrolled higher-education students in 2013 exceeded Shanghai’s total of 504,800, and, as a proportion of the city’s total population, was by far the highest in the region. Nanjing produces over 300,000 graduates per year to supply its growing service industries. At 26.1%, the share of the population with a university degree exceeds that of Shanghai and is second only to Beijing, China’s capital and educational leader. Nanjing City Profile 2014 11 Nanjing’s educational infrastructure and talented workforce make the city’s wage differential with Shanghai all the more remarkable. While this is a boon for companies looking for competitive labour costs, the flip side is that Nanjing wrestles with a brain drain, as each year many talented graduates seek higher-paying opportunities in Shanghai and other Tier 1 cities. The Nanjing government is seeking to combat this trend with a number of new initiatives, including an announcement in early 2014 that the city would unconditionally award local residency (‘hukou’) to all graduates of local universities, regardless of place of origin. Research Powerhouse Nanjing’s prowess in academia goes hand in hand with its leading position in scientific research and advancement. The city is home to dozens of innovation parks and incubators, as well as hundreds of officially recognised research centres and laboratories, many of them affiliated with key universities and major local enterprises. Among them are 17 research centres and 25 laboratories that have received the highest possible national designation; they carry out research in fields including forestry, pharmaceuticals, pollution control, telecommunications, palaeontology, flat panel displays, food safety, and sustainable agriculture. By the end of 2013, Nanjing counted among its population 82 ‘academicians’ of the Chinese Academies of Science and Engineering, representing about 90% of all such scientists in Jiangsu Province. The title of ‘academician’ is among the highest scientific honours that China bestows, and Nanjing’s large number guarantees both its cutting-edge status in research as well as continued access to funds and other resources. Nanjing has also gained traction in attracting research and development investments from external firms, many of which complement existing manufacturing facilities. In the fields of computing and telecommunications, international corporations such as SAP, Oracle, IBM and Ericsson have established R&D facilities or innovation centres in the city, as have domestic companies like Huawei and ZTE. In addition, Intel has formed a R&D institute in co-operation with Nanjing’s Southeast University to study cloud computing and mobile services. In other sectors, Atlas Copco has set up a machinery R&D centre alongside its industrial and logistics facilities, while Ford has established a subsidiary to research the manufacture of automobile components. 12 China’s City Winners Economic Structure Strength in Services Nanjing’s economy stands out among its YRD neighbours for the large size of its tertiary sector. While Suzhou, Wuxi, Ningbo and other cities in Shanghai’s industrial backyard tend to be dominated by manufacturing, Nanjing’s output is more diverse, with services accounting for 54.4% of the economy in 2013. This may partly be explained by the city’s status as a provincial capital, which means it houses a range of provincial government and media institutions; it is also home to the provincial headquarters of a number of national financial and telecoms firms. Moreover, the city clearly benefits from being the main base of electronics retailer Suning, which was China’s largest private company by revenues in 2012. Broadly speaking, finance and retail each account for about one-fifth of Nanjing’s services GDP. The tertiary share of Nanjing’s economy is even greater than that of fellow capital Hangzhou, due in part to its sizeable higher education and related research sectors. Nanjing’s government plans to continue enhancing the role of services in the city’s economy, targeting a tertiary share of 56% by 2015. Much of this growth is expected to come from the finance and software sectors. Development of the former will be concentrated in the emerging Hexi CBD area, which has been planned as a regional cluster for insurance and finance headquarters, as well as services outsourcing. Nanjing’s software sector was already China’s third largest by revenue in 2010, trailing only Beijing and Shenzhen. The city plans for sales in the sector to quadruple their 2010 totals by 2015, and has put considerable support into developing and incentivising investment in eight-plus software parks, the most notable being the Nanjing Software Valley located in Yuhuatai District. Economic Structure, 2013 100% 80% 37% 43% 46% 52% 53% 53% 54% 51% 46% 46% 44% Nanjing Hangzhou Wuxi Suzhou Ningbo 60% 40% 62% 20% 0% Shanghai Tertiary Secondary Primary Source: CEIC, City Statistical Bulletins Downtown Nanjing Industrial Structure Shifting Towards Advanced Manufacturing Nanjing’s secondary sector is dominated by four designated pillar industries: chemicals, electronics, iron and steel, and automobiles. In 2012 they accounted for 65.2% of Nanjing’s total industrial output, up from 63.0% in 2010. Chemicals is by far the largest sector, and even has a dedicated state-level development zone in the city’s north. However, growth in industrial output for chemicals and steel was nearly flat in 2013, which contrasted with higher growth rates for electronics and especially cars. Nanjing City Profile 2014 13 Cultivating a Greater Role for Private Firms and Entrepreneurship Nanjing Pillar Industries, 2013 350 50% 40% 250 200 30% 150 20% 100 10% 50 0 Chemicals Electronics 2013 Industrial Output Automotive Iron and Steel 2010-2013 CAGR RMB Billions 300 0% 2010-2013 CAGR Source: Nanjing City Investment Promotion Bureau The city’s high-level plans show that these trends are expected to continue. Chemicals’ share of total industrial output is targeted to fall from 2010 levels of about 30.6% to about 20% by 2015. In line with national plans to consolidate and redistribute steel-making capacity, the city government plans for the iron and steel industry’s share of industrial output to decline from nearly 9% to about 7.5%, with an emphasis on high-end products for use in cars and ships. Meanwhile, the roles for electronics and automobiles in the city’s secondary sector will be boosted. Municipal planners also have outlined aggressive goals to elevate Nanjing’s industrial economy into higher-value sectors by increasing the prominence of eight ‘newly emerging industries’: smart-grid technology, communications, wind power and photovoltaics, rail transport, aerospace, new materials, bio-medicine, and energy saving technology. The city has already scored some notable investments in these industries. For example, the state-owned aircraft manufacturing giant AVIC is setting up an engine plant in the Jiangning Development Zone. The city government has established designated industrial parks to further the development of these advanced industries, including an industrial park focused on life-science innovation in Jiangning District. The city has set a target for the revenues of newly emerging industries to exceed RMB 700 billion by 2015, compared with a combined RMB 1.2 trillion expected for existing pillar industries. Nanjing stands out among YRD cities for the size of its state sector. The large role of government is most notable in industry, where stateowned enterprises (SOEs) – many of them under central government control – account for about one-third of output. Nanjing also is a government town in other aspects: its huge university system is mostly public, and as one of China’s seven key military regions, Nanjing is home to a thriving defence industry whose factories, research institutes, and administrative facilities contribute to the local economy. Although the strong state presence has guaranteed Nanjing a certain level of investment and development, so far the city has been less exposed to the entrepreneurial boom that has driven the success of other YRD cities like Suzhou, Wuxi and Hangzhou. City leaders in recent years have begun taking measures to close the perceived gap in entrepreneurship. They are aware that Nanjing possesses one of China’s most robust educational and research infrastructures, a combination which in environments like Boston and the San Francisco Bay Area has underpinned an efflorescence of innovation and entrepreneurial vigour. Officials at all levels talk of incentives for small and medium-size enterprises, incubation facilities, and of supporting the monetisation of successful innovations. Recent policies have given researchers at state-owned universities and laboratories greater freedom to start or participate in businesses based on their intellectual property. One of the more comprehensive entrepreneurship-promotion plans is the ‘Nanjing 321 Plan’, which aims to attract leading scientific talent from among both mainland and overseas Chinese communities to launch companies in Nanjing. The plan’s bevy of incentives includes seed funds, subsidised housing, support from Nanjing’s existing base of research institutions, and risk compensation. The city is orienting its existing development zones to meet the needs of technology startups, and is building designated technology clusters and incubators throughout the city to serve ‘321 Plan’ beneficiaries as well as other promising young companies. 14 China’s City Winners Main Development Areas Decades of population growth and economic development have caused Nanjing to spread beyond its traditional urban boundaries. The urban core has been expanding to the east (around Purple Mountain), south (towards Hexi, the new South Train Station, and beyond), as well as to the northwest bank of the Yangtze River. The government also has seeded development in designated locations farther afield. This section discusses the areas beyond Nanjing’s traditional centre that JLL considers most important for the city’s ongoing and longterm development, beginning with urban sub-centres in Hexi and north of the Yangtze, and then introducing the city’s primary industrial development zones. Hexi New Town Hexi New Town spans a 94 sq km area south-west of Nanjing’s traditional core. Planned and developed since 2002, Hexi has been conceived to relieve pressure on the traditional core and to become a comprehensive urban sub-centre. It has benefited from successive waves of infrastructure development and official support, much of which is associated with hosting major sporting events such as the 2014 Youth Olympics. Today, Hexi is considered an extension of the city centre, and is home to the majority of Nanjing’s high-end housing as well as much of its future office and retail projects. Hexi New Town’s focal point is the Hexi CBD, whose 2 sq km core area stands alongside Xinjiekou as one of Nanjing’s main business districts. An already complete first phase comprises 16 buildings with a GFA of 2.4 million sqm, and a 5 million sqm second phase is expected to be completed by the end of 2014. A third phase is being considered. The CBD has attracted major developers, such as Sun Hung Kai, to acquire land in the area, and the major local developer and operator Deji has also been active there. Nanjing’s government intends for the Hexi CBD to become a centre for finance in Jiangsu Province as well as nearby areas. Supportive policies have already prompted large domestic banks, like China Development Bank and China Guangfa Bank, to purchase entire office buildings within the CBD to serve as regional headquarters. Other existing office buildings in Hexi have attracted a range of international firms to set up branches, including Ernst & Young, Samsung Electronics, Korea’s Hanabank and Taiwan’s Shin Kong Life Insurance. Nanjing City Profile 2014 15 Development Zones Nanjing’s suburban area contains a number of ‘development zones’, government-designated industrial areas whose infrastructure, policies, land and other resources are tailored to attract investment from large domestic and foreign corporations. There are eight provincial-level zones serving a variety of industries, while there are four zones with sufficient scale and central government support to have warranted national-level designation. Details of the four national-level zones are shown in the table below. The largest (by GDP) and fastestgrowing zones in 2013 were the Nanjing Jiangning Economic and Technological Development Zone (Jiangning ETDZ) and the Nanjing Economic and Technological Development Zone (Nanjing ETDZ). The 2,450 sq km Jiangbei New Area accounts for 40% of Nanjing’s land area, though its commercial centre is likely to focus on the riverside Pukou New Town, where prominent national developer China Resources has already purchased land for a mixed-use complex. Nanjing State-Level Development Zones GDP, 2013 35% 70 30% 60 RMB Billions The Jiangbei New Area’s development horizon as a major subcentre for Nanjing remains at least 10-15 years away, with the city’s immediate focus still fixed on Hexi New Town. Efforts are already underway to link the Jiangbei New Area effectively with the city core, however: two metro lines and one tunnel are under construction and will add to the existing six river-crossings. A total of 21 crossings are planned by 2030. 80 25% 50 20% 40 15% 30 10% 20 2009-2013 CAGR Jiangbei New Area The districts of Pukou and Liuhe sit on the northern bank of the Yangtze River opposite Nanjing’s urban core, and at present are more commonly associated with industrial parks and inexpensive housing than with thriving commercial developments. That looks set to change, however, as the districts have recently been designated the ‘Jiangbei New Area’ which is expected to receive the title of ‘National-Level Development Area’, a status currently held by Shanghai’s Pudong New Area and a small number of rapidly-developing zones elsewhere in the country. Such support at both local and national levels will boost investment in the area and improve Nanjing’s economic links with other cities to the north of the Yangtze. 5% 10 0 0% Nanjing ETDZ Jiangning ETDZ GDP 2013 Chemical Industrial Park Technology Zone 2009-2013 CAGR Source: Nanjing City Investment Promotion Bureau Nanjing State-Level Development Zones Name Year Founded District Planned Area (sq km) Industries of Focus Nanjing New & High Technology Industry Development Zone 1991 Pukou 16.5 Software, biological medicine, new energy; Microsoft, Samsung new materials Nanjing Economic and Technological Develoment Zone 1992 Qixia 16.2 Electronics & Information, biological mediicne, light industrial machinery, new materials LG, Sharp, Bosch, Siemens, A.O. Smith Jiangning Economic and Technological 1992 Development Zone Jiangning 38.5 Automobiles, electronics & information, smart grid, new energy, aviation, software Ford, Mazda, Siemens, Motorola, Ericsson, Hitachi Nanjing Chemical Industrial Park Lishui 45 Oil and gas chemical engineering; basic organic chemicals, life science, energy conservation, new materials Sinopec, Petro China, BASF, BP, DSM, Celanese, Huntsman and Ashland 2001 Source: Nanjing Investment Promotion Bureau, Nanjing Investment Environment Report 2011 Notable Investors 16 China’s City Winners Infrastructure Highways As a Yangtze River Delta city, Nanjing is situated among one of China’s densest networks of national highways and expressways. Some of the country’s longest and best-known road routes extend through the city, including the Shanghai-Xinjiang national highway, the Beijing-Fuzhou national highway and the Shanghai-Chengdu expressway. A number of expressways also radiate west from Nanjing across much of Central China, allowing the city to serve as a gateway to the YRD for much of that region, notably Anhui Province. The city’s location at the crossroads of regional road networks also positions it as an overland transport hub and distribution centre for both manufactured goods and increasing volumes of e-commerce. Railways Nanjing occupies a key position in China’s emerging network of express and high-speed rail lines, whose development over the past five years has dramatically reduced travel times to some of the country’s most important cities. Along with Tianjin and Jinan, the city is a key stop on the Beijing-Shanghai high-speed rail (HSR) line, meaning that most trains stop there, even those that skip other YRD stops like Suzhou and Wuxi. At the same time, the express service from Nanjing has been extended west to Hefei and Wuhan, and express trains to Chengdu began running in mid-2014. Shorter, more direct lines are also reducing travel times to cities in eastern China; a line to Hangzhou was completed in July 2013, and one to Anhui’s industrial hubs of Wuhu and Anqing is scheduled to open in mid-2015. While some of Nanjing’s HSR traffic passes through the old Nanjing Railway Station in the city’s north, the majority of fast trains stop at Nanjing South Railway Station. One of China’s largest high-speed rail stations in terms of floor area, the South Railway Station was built in tandem with the high-speed network and opened in 2010. Express and High-Speed Rail (HSR) Network, 2014 Harbin Changchun Shenyang Beijing Taiyuan Xi’an Chengdu Chongqing Under Construction (Major Routes) Wuhan Nanjing Shanghai Hangzhou Hefei Changsha Nanchang Fuzhou Direct Service from Nanjing Other High-Speed Lines Qingdao Zhengzhou Lanzhou Dalian Tianjin Jinan Shijiazhuang Kunming Nanning Guangzhou Shenzhen/ Hong Kong Nanjing City Profile 2014 17 Express and High-Speed Rail (HSR) Links From Nanjing To: Distance (km) Journey Journey Time: Time: Fast Regular Train Train (hours) (hours) Date Completed (est.) Shanghai 301 1.25 4+ July 2010 Hangzhou 249 1.5 6+ July 2013 Beijing 1,017 3.75 11+ Dec 2009 Wuhan 517 3.5 7+ April 2009 1,731 15 30+ July 2014 Chengdu Nanjing is also a major freight hub, with traffic by rail of 17.0 million tons in 2013, fivefold the relevant figure for Hangzhou and more than double that of Shanghai. Metro and Regional Rail Network With its first line opening in 2005, Nanjing was among the earliest Tier 1.5 cities in China to enter the ‘subway age’. Passengers made roughly 400 million metro journeys in 2012, placing Nanjing alongside Chonqqing as the most heavily used system outside of the four Tier 1 cities. The subway supports the growth of the city’s modern service sector by facilitating labour movements from suburban areas to the central business districts. The city’s current network consists of five lines and is 180 km long, making it the longest subway network of any YRD city outside of Shanghai. Three lines were completed shortly before the city played host to the Youth Olympics in mid-2014, including one traditional metro line serving the city centre and two designated surburban lines that extend to outer districts such as Liuhe and Pukou in the north and the border of Lishui in the south. Four more lines are under construction and expected to reach completion by 2017. Some of the suburban lines are planned to be extended beyond Nanjing’s borders as part of an emerging regional rail system that will be integrated with the metro network. Looking further ahead, the metro network will expand to include 17 regular metro lines and six suburban lines by 2030. City planners have a stated goal of building a dense network such that most of the traditional core population will live within 600m of a station. River Port Freight throughput at Nanjing’s port rose 5.2% in 2013 to reach 202.0 million tons, while container traffic reached 2.7 million TEUs, up 16.1%. Freight related to foreign trade accounted for about a tenth of the total (22.0 million tons), but is growing fast, up 26.5% y-o-y. Nanjing’s most important port facility is Longtan Harbour, located on the southern bank of the Yangtze River to the north-west of the city’s downtown. There are also five other ‘functional zones’ along the city’s extensive riverbank in which the government is investing in improved port infrastructure. The port areas are administered by the Nanjing Port Group. The Group positions Nanjing’s port as a “multi-functional river-seaport” that can serve requirements for transhipment, transfers between waterborne and overland transport, cargo distribution, and international trade. An ongoing project to dredge the Yangtze River is expected to make Nanjing’s port accessible to ships of up to 80,000 deadweight tons (DWT), which will expand the range of vessels able to dock at the city and reinforce its status as one of China’s key river transport hubs. 18 China’s City Winners Airport Lukou International Airport bills itself as one of the busiest passenger and freight airports in East China, though these claims should not obscure the fact that convenient access to Shanghai and its two airports means that, compared to more inland centres like Wuhan and Chengdu, Nanjing has relatively limited potential as a regional air hub. Even so, the airport is becoming increasingly busy, handling over 130,000 flights in 2013. Since 2009, passenger throughput has risen at about 8.5% a year to a 2013 level of 15.0 million. Meanwhile, freight traffic has grown by about 6.3% annually over the same period to reach 255,800 tons in 2013. Rising traffic levels have encouraged the airport to embark on an expansion plan that includes a 3.6 km second runway as well as a large second terminal building. The expansion went into operation in July 2014. The expanded airport is expected to satisfy projected 2020 traffic of 30 million annual passengers and 800,000 tons of freight. The city government has also been investing heavily in boosting accessibility between the airport and downtown, about 36 km to the north-west. The airport expressway was widened to 12 lanes in 2012, and a recently completed metro line extends from the airport to the city’s South Railway Station. Map of Existing and Planned Metro Network iver R gtze Yan Purple Mountain Yan g tze Riv er Xinjiekou Hexi Existing Under Construction Planned (tentative) Nanjing City Profile 2014 19 Lifestyle A True Centre of History and Culture It is a cliché that every city in China declares itself a ‘famous historical and cultural city,’ but few have as much right to the claim as Nanjing. As a former seat of power of six dynasties and the capital of China’s first modern republic, Nanjing has an air of imperial regality that is unique among the Yangtze River Delta’s more freewheeling commercial and cultural centres. Each year droves of tourists visit the city’s eastern Purple Mountain, whose slopes hold the tombs of the ancient Hongwu Emperor and modern founding father Sun Yat-sen. The city’s legacy permeates day-to-day life as well; for example in the largely-intact Ming-era city walls through which commuters pass daily, and the Republican-era street grid infused with some of China’s earliest modern urban planning. Locals’ pride in their heritage manifests itself in the recent trend of restaurants that serve haute cuisine from the city’s days as the Republican capital. Nanjing enjoys, along with Hangzhou, a reputation as one of the YRD’s more relaxing corners - prosperous and dynamic but removed from the hectic bustle of Shanghai and its satellites. Locals and newcomers alike find the city more suitable for ‘living’ than Shanghai, thanks to its lower cost of living, good educational infrastructure, View from Xuanwu Lake and pleasant dwelling environment. The latter point is evidenced in touches such as streets shaded by rows of trees, among them historic plane trees that residents fought to protect amidst the city’s subway construction boom. The New York Times has praised Nanjing for its “youthful exuberance.” It is a city supported by a large student population which, in turn, sustains a rising bar and music industry. At the same time, a growing group of independent artists – including several Nanjing natives that have returned home from careers abroad and in Beijing and Shanghai - shows works in local restaurants, cafés and galleries. At grander levels, the local government and private investors are promoting big projects to put Nanjing on the global art and architecture map. Along with the city’s historical assets, this push has given Nanjing one of the most robust collections of museums and cultural institutions of any Tier 1.5 city in China. The most notable recent addition is the Sifang Art Museum, a privately-funded 20,000 sqm exhibition space in the city’s forested periphery that was designed by New York architect Steven Holl, and which displays the work of a range of international contemporary artists. 20 China’s City Winners Major Local Enterprises Suning Appliance Corporation Nanjing Iron & Steel Group Established in 1990, Suning has grown to become one of China’s largest enterprises; its network of 1,600 appliance stores spread over nearly 300 cities has made it a household name across the country. The firm employs 180,000 staff in China, and in recent years has been one of the few traditional retailers to build a significant e-commerce presence. Listed on the Shenzhen Stock Exchange in 2004, Suning earned sales revenues of RMB 232.7 billion in 2012, and in 2013 the All China Federation of Industry and Commerce (ACFIC) declared it China’s largest private company by revenue. Nanjing Iron & Steel Group was founded in 1958 and was the first iron and steel enterprise in Jiangsu Province. The group’s primary steel-making subsidiary (Nanjing Iron & Steel Co.) produced 7.2 million tonnes of steel and generated revenues of RMB 32 billion in 2012. Listed on the Shanghai Stock Exchange in 2000, the group owns over 10 other subsidiaries involved in mining, real estate, logistics and hospitality, among other fields. Yurun Group In 2013, Yurun Group ranked 8th on ACFIC’s list of China’s largest private firms. Founded in1993, the conglomerate has its roots in food processing and is currently China’s largest meat processor. Over the past two decades, Yurun has expanded to include over 300 subsidiary companies in industries such as finance, real estate, construction, logistics, retail and hospitality. In total the group employs over 130,000 people and in 2012 generated revenues of RMB 106.1 billion. Sanpower Group Sanpower Group is a large private firm whose enterprises cover five main industries: retail and trading, investment, media, IT services, and real estate. Its most iconic properties are the three large department stores owned by its subsidiary Nanjing Xinjiekou Department Store Co. in downtown Nanjing. Sanpower earned revenues of RMB 56 billion in 2012 and the group currently employs over 60,000 people worldwide. The firm made international headlines in 2014 when it purchased UK department store chain House of Fraser. Nanjing City Profile 2014 21 Golden Eagle Group Jinling Petrochemichal (SOE) Golden Eagle Group’s retail division is one of Nanjing’s most recognisable department store chains. Since its flagship Golden Eagle store opened in the Xinjiekou retail cluster, the company has established 26 self-owned stores in 15 cities around the country, with a total GFA of over 1 million sqm. While many stores are in cities around Nanjing, the firm has a large presence in the western provinces of Yunnan and Shaanxi as well. In addition to retail, Golden Eagle Group is also active in the residential and hotel property sectors. Golden Eagle’s retail division earned revenues of RMB 16.8 billion in 2013. Jinling Petrochemical is a local subsidiary of China’s state-owned oil titan, Sinopec. Located in Qixia district in north-east Nanjing, the company’s key activities include oil refining as well as the production and sale of various petrochemical products; it is the largest production base for detergent raw materials in China. In 2013 the company processed 17 million tons of crude oil, and its total revenue exceeded RMB 10 billion. 22 China’s City Winners Major Foreign Investments Bosch Kimberly-Clark In 2013, global automotive technology and services supplier Bosch invested RMB 1.1 billion (US$171 million) in Nanjing for the construction of a production hub and R&D base for its Asia Pacific automotive aftermarket division. Located in the Nanjing Economic and Technological Development Zone, the new plant is expected to employ 3,500 people by 2015 and have a production capacity of 125 million spark plugs, 80 million brake pads and 25,000 units of diagnostic equipment. In 2013, Kimberly-Clark completed an international-grade diaper products manufacturing plant in Nanjing that included affiliated product development, research and logistics facilities. Designed to serve China’s growing diaper market, the plant was built at a cost of US$100 million. It will utilise a fully-automated production line and other advanced techniques to boost efficiency and reduce costs and delivery times in serving the East China region. Yangzi Pec–BASF Sun Well Solar Yangzi Pec–BASF is a joint venture between Sinopec and BASF. Set up in 2000, total investment reached US$4.6 billion by 2012. A polymer plant with annual output of 60,000 tons is scheduled to go into operation in 2014. It is the largest Sino-German petrochemical joint venture in China. Renewable energy equipment-maker Sun Well Solar is one of Taiwan’s key manufacturers of silicon thin-film modules. In 2010 the firm started construction on Nanjing’s first thin-film solar-cell production base. Sun Well Solar is investing US$600 million in the project, which is expected to reach full capacity of 300 mW by 2015. Schaeffler In 2013, Schaeffler, a worldwide leading manufacturer of precision bearings, invested €200 million (US$260 million) to build its largest China plant in Nanjing. Located in Jiangning High-tech Industrial Park, the factory will produce precision bearings for automobiles, wind power and other industrial equipment. The facility’s annual output value is expected to reach RMB 8-12 billion. Nanjing City Profile 2014 23 Real Estate Overview Real Estate Dashboard, 3Q 2014 Market Size Occupiers Office Stock Grade A (sqm) Retail Stock (sqm) 640,300 1,455,100 Number of International-Brand Hotels, 4-Star and Above 17 Retail Office Vacancy Grade A (%) Prime Retail Space Under Construction (sqm) 477,600 22.0% 533,000 Prime Retail Vacancy (%) 5.7% Service Firms PwC, Deloitte, KPMG, JLL, DTZ Financial Institutions Citibank, HSBC, Standard Chartered Bank, The Bank of East Asia, Bank of Nanjing, Liberty Mutual Insurance, Allianz, Pacific-Aetna Life Insurance, CITIC Prudential, MetLife, Aviva-COFCO Life Insurance, Sun Life Everbright Life Insurance, AIA Business Parks/ Industrial SH Volks Wagen, Changan-Ford-Mazda, SAC&ABB, Brembo, Siemens, Ericsson Panda Communication, Bao Steel, BOSCH, Kimberly-Clark, Philips, Honeywell, Hitachi, Du Pont, Valeo, Faurecia, TATA, Caterpillar, Continental Benchmark Values Offices Grade A – Rents (RMB per sqm pa) Prime Retail – Rents (RMB per sqm pa) 1,485 10,678 Logistics – Rents (RMB per sqm pa) 294 Manufacturing – Rents 275 High-end Residential CVs (RMB per sqm) 22,354 Offices Grade A – Indicative Yields (%) 4.7% Source: JLL Research Key Players Key Transactions Investors Acquired Nanjing IFC, a landmark project (72,700 sqm Sanpower Group office and 27,500 sqm retail) in Xinjiekou from ARA for RMB 2.5 billion (US$406 million), in Q1 2014 Investors/Developers/Operators Residential Poly, China Overseas Land & Investment (COLI), China Resources Land, Vanke, Forte, Evergrande, China Merchants, Hutchison Whampoa, Landsea, Suning Group, Yanlord Land Group, Agile Property Office Greenland Group, Golden Eagle, Deji Group, Suning Group, Siya Group, China Merchants Property Development Industrial/ Logistics PGL, Global Logistic Properties, Longtan Development, Goodman, Vailog, Shunyuan Logistics, Vantage Logistics Wanda Group, Greenland Group, Deji Group, Golden Retail (Shopping Eagle, China Overseas Land & Investment, Suning Malls) Group, Da Fa Land, Nanjing International Group Retail (Department Stores) New World Department Store, Golden Eagle, Grand Ocean, Suning Group, Nanjing Central DS Group, Spring Land, Yu Run Group Hotels InterContinental, Sheraton, Hilton, Sofitel, Westin, Crowne Plaza Hypermarkets: Walmart, Metro, Carrefour, Jin Run Fa Food and Beverage: Starbucks, Costa, KFC, McDonald’s, Pizza Hut, Element Fresh Market Activity Office Space Under Construction Grade A (sqm) Apparel: Prada, Louis Vuitton, Gucci, Ermenegildo Zegna, Giorgio Armani, Burberry, ZARA, H&M, MUJI, Uniqlo, IT, GAP Franshion China Development Bank/China Guangfa Bank Acquired a 51% stake in the Nanjing International Center (NIC) project from Nanjing International Group in 2013. The transaction value was RMB 1.1 billion and the project consists of office, retail, hotel and residential section, with a GFA of over 400,000 sqm (including future phases). These two banks each acquired office towers in Walsin Centro Phase 1 (located in Hexi) from the Walsin Group, for self-use. •In 2010, China Development Bank bought one 30,000 sqm building for RMB 675 million. •In 2011, China Guangfa Bank purchased another building (27,000 sqm) in the project for RMB 661 million. 24 China’s City Winners JLL’s View Industrial & Logistics Residential Nanjing’s traditional industries - like chemicals, automobiles and electronics - will increasingly share the limelight with higher valueadd sectors such as aerospace and biopharmaceuticals, and an improving business environment for these industries is expected to attract related firms to establish or expand capacity in the city. In terms of logistics property, the city has major ambitions as a logistics, transport and distribution hub for both manufactured products and consumer goods, but the current stock of modern warehouses is small compared to other YRD cities. GLP was once the only major international developer in the market, but it has been joined in 2014 by others like Goodman and Vailog, and interest in the city continues to grow. Lishui District, in the city’s south, has considerable potential as a new logistics submarket, and has been attracting increasing attention from developers. Despite a recent nationwide residential market slowdown, the outlook for Nanjing’s high-end residential sector remains positive thanks to a combination of relatively limited supply pipeline, low inventories and rising demand from owner-occupiers (a buyer segment the government is keen to support). Housing prices are highest in the traditional downtown, while the overwhelming majority of existing and future supply is concentrated in Hexi New Town. An expanding transportation infrastructure (notably the subway network) will allow other submarkets to develop in the future. Offices Absorption in Nanjing’s office market has traditionally been driven by domestic firms in core industries such as chemicals and automobiles. However, in recent years office demand has evolved in line with the city’s changing economic structure, with tertiary industries accounting for a greater share. Rising demand from these sectors will ensure moderate rental growth in the overall market for the foreseeable future, with the strongest performance being in the supply-constrained Xinjiekou submarket. At the same time, high volumes of supply will lead rents to increase at a slower pace in the new Hexi CBD, though government support for companies locating in this area will prevent vacancy from reaching critical levels. Retail Though Nanjing’s locals are not as famously free-spending as those in some YRD cities, the city’s retail market continues to grow rapidly, thanks in part to a large catchment that extends deep into neighbouring provinces. The city’s retail landscape has a high degree of concentration around the traditional downtown Xinjiekou submarket, which is home to Nanjing’s main luxury mall. In recent years, however, developers have started to expand into other areas – notably Hexi – and have also begun experimenting with suburbanfriendly formats such as outlet malls. Hotels The number of star-rated hotels in Nanjing totalled 107 in 2013, and JLL currently tracks 17 international-branded hotels rated four stars and above. The hotels market is supported by the city’s large number of business travellers, though many of them work in budgetconscious traditional industries that effectively limit achievable room rates. Hotel operators are hopeful that upcoming international sporting events, as well as a renewed government push to boost local tourism, will help attract a larger and more diverse customer base in time to absorb a projected 90% increase in high-end stock over the next few years. Nanjing City Profile 2014 25 Office Market Increasingly diverse tenant base drives demand The Nanjing office market has grown quickly over the past 3-4 years, though at 643,000 sq m its Grade A stock in 3Q14 was still slightly less than Hangzhou’s and well below that of Suzhou. Historically, modern office demand has been driven by manufacturing industries, including automotive, electronics and chemicals manufacturing. In recent years, demand increasingly has been supported by a mix of traditional industries such as pharmaceuticals along with an increasing share of tertiary industries, including financial services (e.g. banks and insurance) as well as professional services and real estate. Currently, domestic companies occupy about three-quarters of Grade A space in the city. While MNC demand in Nanjing is relatively strong compared to other Tier 2 markets, domestic demand has been the primary driver of the market over the past two years. In addition, most of Nanjing’s Grade B office space is occupied by local companies. Xinjiekou is the most popular office submarket and Nanjing’s traditional business district, containing clusters of MNC offices as well as the highest density of financial services companies. The area is located around one of the intersections of the city’s two existing metro lines and is also known for its high-end retail market. Xinjiekou’s Grade A office stock accounted for 47% of the city’s 3Q14 total. The second mature submarket is Gulou which is located to the north of Xinjiekou bordering Xuanwu Lake to the east, and close to the Jiangsu Provincial Government and a high concentration of educational institutions. As of Q3 2014, the Grade A office vacancy rate was approximately 10.7% in Xinjiekou and 17.9% in Gulou. The Xinjiekou submarket enjoys a rental premium over Nanjing’s other submarkets due to its more mature business environment and superior retail amenities. Core Grade A Office Stock Comparison, Nanjing Submarkets Core Grade A Office Stock Comparison, YRD Cities 60% 6 50% 40% 4 30% 3 20% 2 1 10% 0 0% Shanghai Hangzhou Suzhou Nanjing Ningbo Wuxi 3Q2014 Stock 2016 Forecast 3Q2014 Vacancy 2016 Vacancy Forecast Source: JLL Real Estate Intelligence Service (REIS) 400 Vacancy Rate Millions sqm 5 500 Thousands sqm 7 300 200 100 0 Xinjiekou 3Q2014 Stock Gulou Hexi 2016 Forecast Source: JLL Real Estate Intelligence Service (REIS) Others 26 China’s City Winners The most significant new office submarket in Nanjing is Hexi, a government-supported ‘New CBD’ built close to the Yangtze River, several kilometres to the south-west of the traditional downtown. The area has developed quickly with the government’s backing, expanding since 2006 to contain approximately 32% of the city’s Grade A market and 35% of its Grade B market. Looking ahead, we expect large supply to keep Hexi’s vacancy elevated, but preferential policies for Hexi and subsidies for companies moving are stimulating its rapid development as an office location, helping keep vacancy below critical levels. Owner-occupiers take up a high percentage of the office stock in Hexi, with state-owned firms and large banks commonly developing or purchasing office buildings for their own use. Core Grade A Office Rent Comparison, YRD Cities, 3Q 2014 10 RMB per sqm per day 8 6 4 2 0 Shanghai Hangzhou Nanjing Suzhou Ningbo Wuxi Source: JLL Real Estate Intelligence Service (REIS) Looking forward, the Grade A office market is expected to see moderate rental growth of approximately 2-6% per annum, driven by steady upgrade demand from local financial and professional services firms, and gradual expansion demand from MNCs to support their growing businesses in the region. The traditional CBD (and Xinjiekou in particular) has limited long-term supply and is likely to propel the majority of this growth. Hexi, on the other hand, with a large pipeline of future projects, will have high vacancy levels for the foreseeable future, and is forecast to become a tenant-favourable market. Downtown Xinjiekou, Facing Gulou Nanjing City Profile 2014 27 Retail Market Strong retail position in the YRD region Nanjing’s retail market includes about 1.5 million sq m of organised retail space, of which shopping centres constitute 1 million sqm and freestanding department stores the remainder. Xinjiekou is the core retail submarket and the focal point of the city, where the intersection of multiple metro lines brings in thousands of customers per day. Xinjiekou also attracts visitors from surrounding cities and towns such as Zhenjiang, Yangzhou, and Huai’an. Xinjiekou is home to Deji Plaza, the city’s sole luxury shopping mall, which was built in two phases for a total of 150,000 sqm. The nearby Golden Eagle Department Store is the city’s top-selling department store. Secondary submarkets include Gulou and Zhujiang Road to the north, Confucius Temple to the south, and Hexi to the west. Prime Retail Stock Comparison, YRD Cities 14 16% 12 14% 12% 10% 8 8% 6 6% 4 4% 2 0 2% Shanghai Suzhou Hangzhou Ningbo Nanjing Wuxi 3Q2014 Stock 2016 Forecast 3Q2014 Vacancy 2016 Vacancy Forecast Source: JLL Real Estate Intelligence Service (REIS) 0% Vacancy Millions sqm 10 28 China’s City Winners Prime Retail Rent Comparison, YRD Cities, 3Q 2014 Over the past five years, the retail market has grown rapidly, with total retail sales doubling from RMB 165.2 billion in 2008 to RMB 350.4 billion in 2013. Compared to other Yangtze River Delta cities, Nanjing’s total retail sales are about even with Suzhou and Hangzhou, and its 60 RMB per sqm per day 50 market has grown at a five-year compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 16.2%. This rapid uplift in retail sales is in line with the steady rise in disposable income per capita, which reached RMB 39,881 in 2013 for a five-year CAGR of 12.3%, the highest rate of any major YRD city. While Nanjing is not noted for its spending power relative to cities like Wuxi and Hangzhou, it remains a large and important market. 40 30 20 10 0 Shanghai Nanjing Hangzhou Wuxi Ningbo Source: JLL Real Estate Intelligence Service (REIS) Suzhou Nanjing City Profile 2014 29 New districts and retail formats further strengthen the local retail market Thus far, no submarkets have been able to compete directly with Xinjiekou’s dominance of the city’s retail market. However, this is set to change. Hexi is undergoing steady development and will eventually become a major retail destination. The area has already grown from having no organised retail in 2008 to over 340,000 sq m of space by 3Q14, in the process becoming the city’s second largest submarket in floor area terms. Major developers with upcoming projects in Hexi include Sun Hung Kai Properties, Deji and Golden Eagle. Many of these projects are located around the Yuantong Subway station, at the intersection of two existing subway lines. Additional modern retail properties are appearing in still farther afield locations, including Wonder City in Yuhuatai and a number of projects have been built in Jiangning, most notably Jiangning Wanda Plaza. Prime Retail Stock Comparison, Nanjing Submarkets 700 Thousands sqm 600 500 400 300 200 100 0 Xinjiekou 3Q2014 Stock Hexi Others Gulou Confucius Temple 2016 Forecast Source: JLL Real Estate Intelligence Service (REIS) Although traditional shopping malls and department stores have dominated the retail market to date, outlet malls are a growing presence. Developers are planning for catchment radii that capture the whole city plus neighbouring cities, especially those in North Jiangsu and East Anhui. A leading example is Nanjing Bailian Outlets in Tangshan New City, which will have a total GFA of 140,000 sq m and is expected to repeat the operator’s success in Qingpu, Shanghai. This and two other under-construction outlet properties will include luxury brands and are scheduled to open by end-2015. These malls will further strengthen Nanjing’s role as one of the major retail cities in the YRD region. 30 China’s City Winners Residential Market Low inventories and stable demand give reason for optimism Nanjing’s high-end housing market has, in recent years, followed a policy-driven trajectory similar to many other large cities. After the disruptions from the financial crisis inspired the government to loosen credit conditions, both the high-end and mass markets staged a rapid recovery. As speculative demand from investors threatened to price ordinary homebuyers out of the city’s housing market, however, a fresh round of tightening policies were introduced in late 2010 which caused high-end sales to fall and led developers to cut prices in 2011. Sales and prices rose over late 2012 and 2013 as the government fine-tuned policies to support the aspirations of first-time homebuyers. High-end Residential Stock Comparison, YRD Cities 90,000 120 80,000 70,000 60,000 80 50,000 60 40,000 40 30,000 20,000 20 0 10,000 Wuxi Hangzhou Nanjing Shanghai Ningbo 3Q2014 Stock 2016 Forecast 3Q2014 Capital Value Source: JLL Real Estate Intelligence Service (REIS) Suzhou 0 RMB/sqm Number of Units ’000 100 The high-end housing market is supported by the provincial capital’s large population of professionals, civil servants, as well as employees in state-owned enterprises and top-performing private firms. Nanjing is also a magnet for wealthy homebuyers from nearby inland cities seeking a foothold in the YRD. The city contains five major high-end submarkets. Nanjing’s first high-end projects were built in response to the development of Hexi New Town, which has since established itself as the city’s largest and most active submarket. At RMB 22,900 per sq m, Hexi’s average high-end prices are second only to the downtown Chengzhong submarket’s RMB 28,400 per sq m. Despite Chengzhong’s good location and convenient transportation, future high-end supply there is limited due to a lack of land. Since Metro Line 1 went into operation in 2006, high-end residential developments have quickly expanded from the downtown and Hexi to areas like Chengdong (in the east) and Chengnan (in the south). Elsewhere, Chengbei (in the north) is a mature residential area in which urban redevelopment is just beginning to spur high-end development – prices there were low in late-2014, but potential is high, with many new projects scheduled to launch in the coming years. Nanjing City Profile 2014 31 60 30,000 50 25,000 40 20,000 30 15,000 20 10,000 10 5,000 0 Hexi Chengnan Chengzhong Chengbei Chengdong 3Q2014 Stock 2016 Forecast Source: JLL Real Estate Intelligence Service (REIS) RMB/sqm Number of Units ’000 High-end Residential Stock Comparison, Nanjing Submarkets 0 3Q2014 Average Price As of October 2014, high-end sales in Nanjing and other YRD cities were slowing, and softer market conditions had prompted local governments to lift the Housing Purchase Restrictions (HPRs). Despite the slowdown, we remain optimistic about Nanjing’s residential market. Future demand is expected to be strong: alongside traditional drivers, graduates of the city’s top-tier universities who are moving into local high-paying industries provide a steady stream of the government’s favoured market of first-time homebuyers. In addition, both Nanjing’s current inventories and future high-end supply are limited compared to other major YRD cities, indicating that price growth should remain positive even if sales are impacted by this year’s slowdown. 32 China’s City Winners Industrial and Logistics A maturing logistics hub Located at the centre of Nanjing Metropolitan Area and along a major bend in the Yangtze River, Nanjing is a major logistics hub serving cities in north Jiangsu and east Anhui. There are three primary logistics submarkets in Nanjing: Longtan Logistics Park (near the river port), Airport Logistics Park (in the Jiangning Development Zone) and Chemical Industry Park. In combination these submarkets currently provide over 500,000 sq m of high-quality warehouse space, with demand mostly coming from manufacturers and the petrochemical sector, as well as from rapidly growing e-commerce business. Millions sqm 4 20% 3 15% 2 10% 1 5% 0% Nanjing Ningbo 3Q2014 Stock 2016 Forecast 3Q2014 Vacancy 2016 Vacancy Forecast Source: JLL Real Estate Intelligence Service (REIS) 1.2 1.0 0.8 0.6 0.4 Shanghai Suzhou Ningbo Nanjing Source: JLL Real Estate Intelligence Service (REIS) Vacancy 25% Suzhou 1.4 0.0 5 Shanghai Prime Warehouse Rent Comparison, YRD Cities, 2Q2014 0.2 Non-bonded Warehouse Stock Comparison, YRD Cities 0 However, despite its huge growth potential, Nanjing’s high-quality logistics market remains small compared to YRD peers like Suzhou. The major constraint is the city’s relative lack of qualified logistics facilities, a result of restrictions on land for logistics use. As in other major Chinese cities, logistics land in Nanjing is not as favoured by local governments as land for manufacturing or commercial use, which generate more tax and create more jobs. Much of Nanjing’s logistics property stock consists of manufacturing-refurbished warehouses, whose physical conditions and safety levels usually do not meet the requirements of 3PLs and their end-users. Until recently GLP was the only major international developer in the market, but it has been joined in 2014 by others like Goodman and Vailog, and interest in the city continues to grow. RMB per sqm per day Climbing the manufacturing value chain Nanjing’s manufacturing sector traditionally has been oriented around the pillar industries of chemicals, electronics, steel, and automobiles, which the government supports with key development zones and related infrastructure and incentives, and which have received investments from a range of MNCs. The city is now placing greater priority on more advanced industries including biopharmaceuticals, aerospace, and smart grid technology. Nanjing’s industrial zones compete for investment with YRD industrial titans like Suzhou and Wuxi. The provincial capital’s advantages include a location and transport infrastructure favourable for inland regional distribution, as well as a skilled workforce that is attractive to firms seeking to pair manufacturing plants with R&D facilities. Nanjing’s vacancy rate rose from single digits to 16.5% in 3Q14 as new supply reached the market, but inquiry levels continue to indicate healthy demand. Both international and major local developers now are looking to buy land parcels, with several focusing on Lishui District, far to the south of Nanjing’s city centre where land is easier to acqure. Over the next two years, nearly 300,000 sq m of high-quality warehouses are projected to be finished, with much of the new supply in Lishui. Despite the risk of oversupply, Lishui is very likely to become another major logistic submarket in addition to the existing three, covering distribution needs for Nanjing and the southern part of Anhui Province. Nanjing City Profile 2014 33 Hotels High-end stock set for rapid increase Data from the Nanjing Tourism Committee indicate that as of year-end 2013, the city had 107 star-rated hotels. The high-end hotel market (including both international and domestic properties) contained 18 five-star hotels and 23 four-star ones. Nanjing’s high-end hotels are concentrated in the Gulou area (which enjoys views of Xuanwu Lake), Xinjiekou and Hexi New Town. As of the end of 2013, the five-star hotel market had an average occupancy of 66.4% and an average daily rate (ADR) of about RMB 627, while four-star hotels had occupancy of 68.2% and ADR of RMB 396. JLL currently tracks 17 international-branded hotels in the high-end hotel market, with a total of 5,447 rooms. Nanjing’s hotel demand is driven by business travel as well as the tourism and MICE (Meetings, Incentives, Conferences and Exhibitions) travel segments. Business travel is the dominant source of demand, underpinned by a steady stream of travellers involved with Nanjing’s core industries. However, its MICE and tourism sectors are less significant compared to YRD neighbours like Suzhou and Hangzhou, which have promoted themselves more aggressively as destinations for travel and conferences. Nanjing does not lack for well-known attractions, but most of its visitors tend to come from Jiangsu Province or other nearby areas, and are less likely to favour high-end hotels. The business travellers who fill most of Nanjing’s internationalbranded hotel rooms often come from firms in heavy industries like car manufacturing and steel, which have less generous travel budgets compared to finance and related industries. While this can be expected to change as Nanjing’s service sector continues to grow, for the time being such firms’ smaller corporate accounts are restraining Nanjing’s average ADR compared to other cities in the region, especially those with greater shares of tourists and walk-in customers. A downtown construction boom has impacted demand for many of Nanjing’s hotels, and the ongoing national corruption crackdown has affected some high-end hotels’ MICE and banqueting business. Neither of these trends is isolated to Nanjing, however. Nanjing’s high-end hotel stock is expected to add another 12 international hotels with 4,168 rooms over the next 3-5 years, with major foreign brands such as Shangri-La, Grand Hyatt and JW Marriott all set to enter the market. While business travel demand is projected to maintain its steady rise as Nanjing’s core industries continue to develop and the economy diversifies, there is some risk of oversupply as a sizeable number of new hotels are added to the market over a short period. Hotel operators are therefore hopeful that the 2014 Youth Olympics, and its related infrastructure boom and city beautification projects, will raise Nanjing’s profile and expand the potential pool of future hotel guests. 34 China’s City Winners Definition of Terms Economic Dashboard Real Estate Dashboard Population: Refers to the total population living in the city in 2013, based on estimates from the Economist Intelligence Unit (EIU). EIU estimates include the entire population living in the city’s administrative area, rather than the more limited registered population figure usually provided in official statistics. Office Stock Grade A: Refers to the total completed Grade A office space (occupied and vacant) as defined by JLL REIS China. Metropolitan Population: Refers to the total population living inside the city’s contiguous core urban area. Excludes the population living in satellite cities and rural areas. Estimates from EIU. GDP: Refers to the gross domestic (i.e. regional) product of a location. Tertiary GDP: Refers to the portion of gross domestic product derived from the tertiary sector (i.e. services). Population Growth: Refers to the compound annual growth rate over the stated period. GDP Growth: Refers to the annual GDP growth rate over the stated period. Airport Passengers Throughput: Refers to the number of passengers passing through the airport, measured in millions. Port Cargo Throughput: Refers to the volume of freight transported by various means, measured in millions of tons. Utilised FDI: Refers to investments made inside China by foreign enterprises and economic organisations or individuals (including overseas Chinese, compatriots in Hong Kong and Macau, and Chinese enterprises registered abroad). Exports: Refers to the value of exports by trading companies registered in Nanjing. GDP/Capita: Refers to total gross domestic product divided by the registered population. Disposable Income (China): Refers to income, after tax and national insurance payments have been paid. Higher Education Institutions: Refers to the number of higher education institutions providing higher education courses and training for senior professionals. They include full-time universities, colleges, higher professional schools, higher professional vocational schools and others. Higher education institutions are set up according to the central government evaluation and approval procedures. Total Enrolments: Refers to the total number of students enrolled at the city’s higher education institutions. Does not include graduate students. Unemployment Rate: Refers to the ratio of the number of registered unemployed to the sum of number of persons employed and registered unemployed in a location. Average Wage: Refers to salary that is pre-tax and comprises all kinds of income, including bonuses, allowances and payments-in-kind as reported by the local statistics bureau. Exchange rate of RMB 6.0675 = US$1 is used, unless stated otherwise. Retail Stock: Refers to prime retail stock and includes department stores and shopping malls. Does not include stock in suburban areas. Number of Hotels: Refers to the number of international-brand hotels rated at four or five stars, as defined by JLL Hotels. Office Space Under Construction Grade A: Refers to the total amount of Grade A office space in properties under construction as of time of writing. Office Vacancy Grade A: Refers to Grade A office floor space (as a % of total Grade A stock) in existing properties that are physically vacant and ready for occupation. Prime Retail Space Under Construction: Refers to the total amount of prime retail space in properties under construction as of time of writing. Does not include properties in suburban areas. Prime Retail Vacancy: Refers to prime retail floor space (as a % of total lettable space) in existing properties that are physically vacant and ready for occupation. Offices Grade A – Rents: Refers to open-market rents that would transact for a typical space in the middle floors of the property, quoted on a GFA basis. Does not include management fees. Prime Retail – Rents: Refers to open-market rents that would transact for ground floor space in a typical retail centre, quoted on an NLA basis. Does not include management fees. Logistics – Rents: Refers to open-market rents that would transact for a typical international-standard warehouse, quoted on a GFA basis. Does not include management fees. Manufacturing – Rents: Refers to open-market rents that would transact for a typical international-standard manufacturing space. Does not include management fees. High-end Residential CVs: Refers to typical prices (within a range) for highend residential projects in RMB per square metre. Grade A Offices – Indicative Yields: Refers to the best (i.e. lowest) gross (pre-tax) yield estimated to be achievable for a notional en bloc stabilised Grade A property. Indicative yields represent JLL’s ‘market view’, based on a combination of market evidence where available and a survey of expert opinion. Nanjing City Profile 2014 35 Authors Michael Klibaner Head of Research JLL, Greater China +852 2846 5276 michael.klibaner@ap.jll.com Joe Zhou Head of Research JLL, East China +86 21 6133 5451 joe.zhou@ap.jll.com Warner Brown Senior Manager of Research JLL, Shanghai +86 21 6133 5345 warner.brown@ap.jll.com Jenson Zhang Senior Analyst of Research JLL, Shanghai +86 21 6133 5724 jenson.zhang@ap.jll.com JLL is the number one real estate research provider in Asia Pacific. A team of 100+ researchers are committed to providing best-in-class market knowledge that enables clients to optimise real estate strategies and mitigate risks. Our award-winning research includes the flagship Asia Pacific Property Digest (APPD) and industry-leading Real Estate Intelligence Service (REIS). http://www.ap.joneslanglasalle.com/researchhub World Winning Cities JLL’s World Winning Cities programme is a multi-year research initiative designed to draw together the essence of contemporary city competitiveness and to predict the future city winners and losers across the globe. The programme examines trends that will impact on the business and economic landscape and how they are coalescing to create the rising urban stars of the next decade. It is unique in assessing the contribution of real estate to sustainable competitive advantage and the implications for investors, developers, corporate occupiers and city governments. World Winning Cities Research goes beyond description to uncover the ‘why’ of city real estate market dynamics. www.joneslanglasalle.com/Pages/WorldWinningCities.aspx www.joneslanglasalle.com/China50cities Rosemary Feenan Global Research Programmes JLL +44 20 3147 1198 rosemary.feenan@eu.jll.com Jeremy Kelly Global Research Programmes JLL +44 20 3147 1199 jeremy.kelly@eu.jll.com Jones Lang LaSalle Regional Headquarters: Chicago 200 East Randolph Drive Chicago IL 60601 USA tel +1 312 782 5800 London 22 Hanover Square London W1S 1JA United Kingdom tel +44 20 7493 6040 Singapore 9 Raffles Place #39-00 Republic Plaza Singapore 048619 tel +65 6220 3888 Jones Lang LaSalle Greater China Offices: Beijing 11/F China World Tower 1 Jianguomenwai Avenue Beijing 100004, China tel +86 10 5922 1300 fax +86 10 5922 1330 Chengdu 29/F, Tower 1 Chengdu International Finance Square 1 Hongxing Road Section 3 Chengdu 610021, Sichuan, China tel +86 28 6680 5000 fax +86 28 6680 5096 Chongqing 2501A-2506 Metropolitan Tower 68 Zourong Road, Central District Chongqing 400010, China tel +86 23 6370 8588 fax +86 23 6370 8598 Guangzhou Room 2401-03, 24/F Main Tower Guangzhou International Finance Center No.5, Zhujiang Xi Road Tianhe District Guangzhou 510623 Guangdong, China tel +86 20 2338 8088 fax +86 20 2338 8118 Nanjing 8/F Asia Pacific Tower 2 Hanzhong Road Gulou District, Nanjing 210005 Jiangsu, China tel +86 25 6610 2688 fax +86 25 6610 2257 Shenzhen Room 2801-02, 28/F Tower Three, Kerry Plaza 1 Zhongxinsi Road, Futian District Shenzhen 518048 Guangdong, China tel +86 755 2210 0888 fax +86 755 2388 7600 Hong Kong 6/F Three Pacific Place 1 Queen’s Road East Hong Kong tel +852 2846 5000 fax +852 2845 9117 www.joneslanglasalle.com.hk Qingdao Unit 2302 COSCO Plaza 61 Hong Kong Middle Road Shinan District, Qingdao 266071 Shandong, China tel +86 532 8579 5800 fax +86 532 8579 5801 Tianjin Unit 3509 The Exchange Tower 1 189 Nanjing Road Tianjin 300051, China tel +86 22 8319 2233 fax +86 22 8319 2230 Macau Unit H, 16/F Finance and IT Center of Macau Nam Van Lake Quarteirao 5 Lote A Macau tel +853 2871 8822 fax +853 2871 8800 www.joneslanglasalle.com.mo Shanghai 25/F Plaza 66, Tower 2 1366 Nanjing Road West Shanghai 200040, China tel +86 21 6393 3333 fax +86 21 6393 3080 Shenyang 1808 Office Tower, L’Avenue 10 Huigong Street, Shenhe District Shenyang 110013 Liaoning, China tel +86 24 3109 1300 fax +86 24 3109 1330 Wuhan Unit 3202-03 Corporate Centre 5 1628 Zhongshan Avenue Jiang’an District Wuhan 430014, Hubei, China tel +86 27 5959 2100 fax +86 27 5959 2144 Xi’an Unit 2202-03 CapitaMall Office No.64 West Section of South 2nd Ring Road Yanta District, Xi’an 710065 Shaanxi, China tel +86 29 8932 9800 fax +86 29 8932 9801 Taiwan 20/F-1 TAIPEI 101 TOWER No 7 Xinyi Road Section 5 Taipei 11049, Taiwan tel +886 2 8758 9898 fax +886 2 8758 9899 www.joneslanglasalle.com.tw www.joneslanglasalle.com.cn To find out how Jones Lang LaSalle can assist you in making real estate decisions in Nanjing, contact: Kin Keung Fung Managing Director, Greater China 6th Floor Three Pacific Place 1 Queen’s Road East Hong Kong tel +852 2846 5000 kinkeung.fung@ap.jll.com Kevin Chan Managing Director, Nanjing 8/F, Asia Pacific Tower 2 Hanzhong Road Gulou District, Nanjing 210005 Jiangsu, China tel +86 25 6610 2688 kevin.chan@ap.jll.com Jones Lang LaSalle COPYRIGHT © Jones Lang LaSalle IP, INC. 2014 This publication is the sole property of Jones Lang LaSalle IP, Inc. and must not be copied, reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, either in whole or in part, without the prior written consent of Jones Lang LaSalle IP, Inc. The information contained in this publication has been obtained from sources generally regarded to be reliable. However, no representation is made, or warranty given, in respect of the accuracy of this information. We would like to be informed of any inaccuracies so that we may correct them. Jones Lang LaSalle does not accept any liability in negligence or otherwise for any loss or damage suffered by any party resulting from reliance on this publication.