MSD : SAE Aero Aircraft Design & Build Preliminary Horizontal and Vertical Stabilizer Design, Longitudinal and Directional Static Stability Horizontal Stabilizer Parameters: 1. Ratio of horizontal tail-wing aerodynamic centers distance with respect to fuselage length πππ /ππ 2. Overall fuselage length ππ 3. Horizontal tail-wing aerodynamic centers distance πππ 4. Horizontal tail volume coefficient ππ» 5. Center of gravity location π₯ππ 6. Horizontal tail arm ππ‘ 7. Horizontal tail planform area ππ‘ 8. Horizontal tail airfoil 9. Horizontal tail aspect ratio π΄π π‘ 10. Horizontal tail taper ratio ππ‘ 11. Additional geometric parameters (Sweep Angle, Twist Angle, Dihedral) 12. Incidence Angle ππ‘ 13. Neutral Point π₯ππ 14. Static Margin 15. Overall Horizontal Stabilizer Geometry 16. Overall Aircraft Static Longitudinal Stability 17. Elevator (TBD in Control Surfaces Design) Vertical Stabilizer Parameters: 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. Vertical tail volume coefficient ππ£ Vertical tail arm ππ£ Vertical tail planform area ππ Vertical tail aspect ratio π΄π π£ Vertical tail span ππ£ Vertical tail sweep angle Λ π£ 24. 25. 26. 27. 28. Vertical tail minimum lift curve slope πΆπΏπΌ π£ Vertical tail airfoil Overall Vertical Stabilizer Geometry Overall Aircraft Static Direction Stability Rudder (TBD in Control Surfaces Design) 1. l/Lf Ratio: 0.6 The table below shows statistical ratios between the distance between the wing aerodynamic center and the horizontal tail aerodynamic center πππ with respect to the overall fuselage length (Lf). 2. Fuselage Length (Lf): 60.00 in Choosing this value is an iterative process to meet longitudinal and vertical static stability, internal storage, and center of gravity requirements, but preliminarily choose ππ = 60.00 ππ 3. Horizontal tail-wing aerodynamic centers distance πππ : 36.00 in πππ = 0.6 ππ πππ = 36.00 ππ 4. Horizontal Tail Volume Coefficient (VH): 1.0 The table below shows the horizontal and vertical tail coefficients for various types of aircraft. ππ» = ππ‘ ππ‘ ππ ππ» = 1 5. Center of Gravity Location (xcg):π. πππ Justification: a) Choose center of gravity aft of aerodynamic center to aid (give more room) with placing components to meet specified center of gravity location. b) If horizontal tail stabilizes aircraft pitching up, it generates a positive lift force, adding to the wing lift. c) 0.30π is the aft most recommended limit for center of gravity placement. 6. Horizontal Tail Arm ππ : 35.2537 in ππ‘ = πππ − π₯ππ − π₯ππ ππ‘ = 35.2537 ππ 7. Horizontal Tail Planform Area (St): 3.6352 ππ‘ 2 ππ» = ππ‘ ππ‘ =1 ππ ππ‘ = 3.6352 ππ‘ 2 8. Airfoil Selection: NACA-0021 Justification: a) Choose symmetric airfoil as the horizontal tail should behave in a similar manner when at a positive or negative angle-of-attack b) Horizontal tail should never stall, specifically it should at least stall later than the wing for recovery c) Maximize πΆπΏ πππ₯ π‘ d) Maximize πΆπΏ πΌ π‘ e) Minimize overall drag f) Minimize overall size NACA-0009: NACA-0010: NACA-0015: NACA-0018 NACA-0021: NACA-0024: NACA-0018, NACA-0021, NACA-0024 Airfoil Comparison: 9. Aspect Ratio π¨πΉπ : 4 Justification: a) It is recommended that the aspect ratio of the tail be such that the span is longer than the propeller diameter to ensure that a portion of the tail is out of the wake or downwash of the wing, increasing tail efficiency π . b) Horizontal tail aspect ratio should be lower than that of the wing to increase stall angle and allow for recovery if needed c) It is recommended that: 2 π΄π π‘ = π΄π π€ 3 π΄π π‘ = 4 10. Horizontal Tail Taper Ratio ππ : 0.7 a) For transport aircraft, the horizontal tail taper ratio is usually between 0.4 and 0.7 b) To ensure a higher stall angle than the wing through a lower Oswald efficiency factor and a lift distribution that is less elliptical, choose ππ‘ = 0.7 11. Additional geometric parameters (Sweep Angle, Twist Angle, Dihedral): N/A a) For the benefits of applying the any of the above parameters to the horizontal geometry, refer to the preliminary wing design parameter selection document b) In the preliminary design phase, it is recommended to make these parameters have the same values as those of the wing. 12. Horizontal Tail Incidence Angle ππ : 4.2300 deg - Determine horizontal tail incidence angle to trim (longitudinal) aircraft at cruise πΆπ ππ = πΆπ ππ π€ + πΆπ ππ + πΆπ ππ = 0 π‘ π πΆπ 0 π€ + πΆπ πΌ π€ πΌπ€ πππ’ππ π + πΆπ 0 π‘ + πΆπ πΌ π‘ πΌπ€ πππ’ππ π + πΆπ 0 π + πΆπ πΌ π πΌπ€ πππ’ππ π = 0 πΆπ ππ π€ + πΆπΏ0 π€ π 2 −π 1 36.5ππ π₯=π π π₯=0 π₯ ππ π − π₯ ππ π + πΆπΏπΌ π€ π₯ ππ π − π₯ ππ π π€π 2 πΌ0 π€ + ππ Δπ₯ + πΌπ€ πππ’ππ π + πππ» πΆπΏ πΌ π0 + ππ€ − ππ‘ − πππ» πΆπΏ πΌ π‘ 1 36.5ππ ππ‘ = 4.2300 πππ 13. Neutral Point ππ΅π· :0.7067π πΆπΏ πΌ π₯ππ π₯ππ πΆπ πΌ π ππ π‘ = − + πππ» 1− π π πΆπΏπΌ π€ πΆπΏπΌ π€ ππΌ π₯ππ = 0.7067π 14. Static Margin: 0.3548 ππ‘ππ‘ππ ππππππ = π₯ππ − π₯ππ ππ‘ππ‘ππ ππππππ = 0.3548 π₯=π π π₯=0 π€π 2 ππ π’ ππΌ Δπ₯ πΌπ€ πππ’ππ π = 0 π‘ 1− ππ ππΌ πΌπ€ πππ’ππ π + 15. Horizontal Stabilizer Geometry 16. Overall Aircraft Longitudinal Stability Criteria for Longitudinal Static Stability πΆπ πΌ = ππΆπ <0 ππΌ πΆπ 0 > 0 πΆπ 0 = πΆπ 0 π€ + πΆπ 0 π‘ +πΆπ 0 π πΆπ 0 = πΆπ ππ π€ + πΆπΏ0 π€ π₯ππ π₯ππ π2 − π1 − + πππ» πΆπΏ πΌ π0 + ππ€ − ππ‘ + π‘ π π 36.5ππ π₯=π π π€π 2 πΌ0 π€ + ππ Δπ₯ π₯=0 πΆπ πΌ = πΆπ πΌ π€ + πΆπ πΌ π‘ + πΆπ πΌ π πΆπ πΌ = πΆπΏπΌ π€ π₯ππ π₯ππ ππ 1 − − πππ» πΆπΏ πΌ 1 − + π‘ π π ππΌ 36.5ππ πͺπ πΆ π/πππ πͺπ π π₯=π π π€π 2 π₯=0 πππ’ Δπ₯ ππΌ -1.4679 0.1281 18. Vertical tail volume coefficient π½π : 0.06 The following table shows the vertical tail characteristics for various aircraft. Because our aircraft configuration and mission requirements are very similar to the C-130, many vertical tail parameters are chosen so that they match those of that aircraft. ππ£ = ππ£ ππ£ ππ ππ£ = 0.06 19. Vertical tail arm ππ : 36.1102 in During the preliminary design phase, the vertical tail arm is selected to be equal to the horizontal tail arm, then adjusted after further iterations if needed. ππ£ = 36.1102 ππ 20. Vertical tail planform area πΊπ½ : 1.1521 ππ‘ 2 ππ£ = ππ£ ππ£ = 0.08 ππ ππ£ = 1.1521 ππ‘ 2 21. Vertical tail aspect ratio π¨πΉπ : 1.84 Choose vertical tail aspect ratio such that it matches that of the C-130 (Table 6.6). π¨πΉπ = π. ππ 22. Vertical tail span ππ : 17.4716 in π΄π π£ = ππ£ 2 ππ£ ππ£ = 17.4716 ππ 23. Vertical tail sweep angle π²π : 18.8 deg Choose vertical tail sweep angle such that it matches that of the C-130 (Table 6.6). Λ π£ = 18.8 πππ 24. Vertical tail minimum lift curve slope πͺπ³πΆ π : 0.0011137 [1/deg] - Determine minimum vertical tail lift curve slope so to meet the static directional stability requirement πΆπ π½ > 0 πΆπ π½ = πΆπ π½ π€π + πΆπ π½ πΆπ π½ = −ππ ππ π πΆπΏ πΌ π£ πππ π£ πππ ππ ππ + ππ£ πΆπΏ πΌ ππ£ 1 − π£ ππ ππ½ = 0.0011137 1/πππ 25. Vertical Tail Airfoil: NACA-0009 a) Choose symmetric airfoil as the vertical tail should behave in a similar manner when at a positive or negative angle-of-attack b) To minimize structure and weight, choose airfoil with smallest thickness that meets πΆπΏ πΌ π£ πππ c) Refer to symmetric airfoil plots when choosing the horizontal tail airfoil πΆπ πΌ = ΔπΆπΏ π£ ΔπΌ NACA-0009 (As Stabilizer not Airfoil, from XFLR5) πΌ (deg) πΆπΏ π£ 0 0 5.00 0.314 πΆπΏ πΌ = 0.1214 [1/deg] π£ 26. Vertical Stabilizer Geometry 27. Overall Aircraft Directional Stability Criterion for Directional Static Stability πΆπ π½ = ππΆπ >0 ππ½ πΆπ π½ = πΆπ π½ π€π + πΆπ π½ πΆπ π½ = −ππ ππ π π£ πππ ππ ππ + ππ£ πΆπΏ πΌ ππ£ 1 − π£ ππ ππ½ πͺπ π· π/πππ 0.2847