ACT Parliamentary Counsel’s Office Words and Phrases A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 The ACT Parliamentary Counsel’s Office has endeavoured to ensure that the material in this guide is as accurate as possible. If you believe that this guide contains copyrighted work in a way that constitutes a copyright infringement, or if you are a copyright owner who is not appropriately acknowledged in this guide, please tell us so that we can make the necessary corrections. Contents Page Some thoughts v How to use this Guide vii Classification of entries xv References Alphabetical list of words and phrases Use of figures xxv A–Z Other–1 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 iii Some thoughts ‘Make everything as simple as possible—but no more simple than that.’ Albert Einstein ‘(L)aws are not abstract propositions. They are expressions of policy arising out of specific situations and addressed to the attainment of particular ends.’ Justice Felix Frankfurter ‘The main aim of communication is clarity and simplicity. Usually they go together— but not always. ‘Communication is always understood in the context and experience of the receiver—not matter what was intended. ‘If unnecessary things add to clarity or simplicity they should be retained.’ Edward De Bono ‘Legislation should be written so that it is feasible for the ordinary person of ordinary intelligence and ordinary education to have a reasonable expectation of understanding and comprehending legislation and of getting the answers to the questions he or she has. ‘We need to balance two important principles. The first is that clarity of language should be an aim in itself, so that the ordinary person can have a reasonable expectation of being able to comprehend legislation. The second is that the clarity of the language should enhance and not detract from the legal policy and the substance of the legislation. In the end result, clarity of language should assist with the development and formulation of legislative policy.’ Dennis Murphy QC Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 v How to use this guide The entries Words and phrases are listed in alphabetical order and cross-referenced to other entries if appropriate. How entries are arranged Entries are listed in alphabetical order arranged on a letter-by-letter basis. In a letter-by-letter arrangement, spaces are ignored in entries consisting of 2 or more words. For example: all all and every all and singular allay allege ... all ... not allocate all of allowed (ie allande...) (ie allands...) (ie allay) (ie alle...) (ie alln...) (ie alloc...) (ie allof) (ie allow...). If a phrase contains 2 or more alternative words, only the first alternative is taken into account in working out the order of entries. For example, in the following phrases the second alternative ‘are’ is disregarded: is/are not to is/or is/are required to (ie isn...) (ie iso...) (ie isr...). What each entry consists of Each main entry contains a usage recommendation and suggested alternatives. Suggested alternative words and phrases appear in italic type. Some suggested alternatives have an arrow before them (eg ►remove as a suggested alternative for abate). This means there is an entry for the suggested alternative and a hyperlink to that word. Check this entry before using the alternative. Additional information, examples of change and no change and references to relevant texts are also included in many entries. In an entry containing an example of change, the changed words are struck through (eg abated) and the alternative words are underlined (eg reduced). Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 vii How to use this guide Usage recommendations There are 3 recommendations for usage: never use avoid using consider alternatives before using never use Practice The word or phrase must never be used. Example aforementioned usage—never use try—recasting / omitting extra information archaism further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 36 Cutts p 27 Fowler’s English Usage p 32 (afore-) Garner’s Dictionary pp 37 (aforesaid; aforementioned) , 366 (forbidden words and phrases—A generally useless words and phrases) Garner’s Legal Style p 101 Garner’s Redbook pp 161, 162 Gowers’ Plain Words p 202 Howard’s Guide p 12 Howard’s Handbook p 12 (aforementioned/aforesaid) Longman English Usage p 630 (said) Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 19 (afore-) avoid using Practice If possible, avoid using the word or phrase. Example emolument usage—never use try—bonus / pay / wages / salary / remuneration / earnings / money / income / salary and allowances extra information formal word Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 viii How to use this guide example of change The emolument she received for The income from her part-time work were was not large. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 413 Fowler’s English Usage p 309 (formal words) Garner’s Dictionary p 370 (formal words) Gowers’ Plain Words p 223 (emoluments) Howard’s Guide pp 306-7 (pay, salary, wages, remuneration, stipend or emoluments) consider alternatives before using Practice Before using the word or phrase, consider the alternatives. The alternatives are generally preferred, but always consider whether they are appropriate. Some entries include the option of omitting the word in question. Prefer brevity and omit the word or phrase if the meaning remains the same. ‘No change’ may be given as an option, but do this only if the alternative words are inappropriate. Examples abate usage—consider alternatives before using try—end / stop / diminish / reduce / remove / recasting (eg become less intense/widespread) / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. example of no change The storm suddenly abated. examples of change 1 If the fund out of which general legacies are payable is insufficient, the legacies are abated reduced proportionately. 2 The company took prompt action to abate remove the nuisance caused by the smoke emissions. 3 The proceeding abated ended on the plaintiff’s death. further reading Black’s Law Dictionary p 3 (abatement) Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 2 (abatement; abatement of criminal proceedings; abatement of legacies; abatement of nuisance; abatement of purchase money) Garner’s Dictionary p 4 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 2 (abate, abatement of an action, abatement of legacies; abatement of nuisance, abatement of taxes) New Oxford Dictionary p 2 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 ix How to use this guide acting [in an office] usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / no change extra information 1 It is usually unnecessary to refer to the person acting in an office—see LA s 185 and s 220. 2 Omit if appropriate. examples of no change 1 a broker or other person acting for a licensed insurer 2 I, Minister for ABC, acting under the XYZ Act, section 10 … examples of change 1 assessor includes a person acting as assessor 2 agent acting for … Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 x Classification of Entries Many entries are classified in the ‘Additional Information’ section of the entry into broad groups, eg formal words and archaisms. This part of the guide gives an explanation of the classifications and examples. Archaisms Rule Avoid using archaisms. Prefer a modern alternative. Explanation Archaisms are old-fashioned words and expressions that are no longer used in ordinary speech and writing. Archaisms are often used to achieve a legalistic and formal style. However, they are not necessary and can always be readily replaced. Examples aforementioned aforesaid albeit beforementioned belowmentioned chattels foregoing forth henceforth henceforward hereafter hereby herein hereinafter hereinbefore hereof hereto heretofore hereunder hereunto herewith hitherto howsoever in lieu of relict therewith Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 xi Classification of Entries Further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 57 Cutts pp 22, 77-8 Fowler’s English Usage pp 65-6 Garner’s Dictionary p 74 Garner’s Legal Style pp 182–4 Longman English Usage pp 54-5 Partridge pp 31-6 Commercialese Rule Avoid using commercialese. Prefer plain language. Explanation Commercialese is the complex style of writing often found in older business documents, particularly correspondence. It sounds stilted and old-fashioned because it often uses many words and Latin abbreviations. Replace it with polite, but plain language. Examples advise at your earliest convenience enclosed please find inst. please find enclosed prox. same ult. undersigned Further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 149 Fowler’s English Usage p 163 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 16–17 Partridge pp 216-18 (officialese, journalese and commercialese) Working Words p 122 Compound prepositions Rule Use the simplest, appropriate preposition. Explanation A compound preposition is a preposition consisting of 1 or more elements, eg because of and in the event of. A simple preposition consists of only 1 element, eg about, above, after, as, at, between, by, for, from, in, into, of, off, on, over, since, than, to, under, up, with and without. Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 xii Classification of Entries Some compound prepositions have simpler alternatives (either a simple preposition or a shorter compound preposition) and can be readily replaced. Use of these compounds is rarely justified. Other compound prepositions are entirely satisfactory (eg because of) or have useful roles in some contexts. Because of their lack of precision, compound prepositions can be especially useful in drafting to describe a relationship between concepts in the widest terms. However, frequently compound prepositions are unnecessary and are only clumsy devices applied mechanically without thought. Before using a compound preposition, always consider whether a simpler preposition would do. Examples of compound prepositions with ready alternatives as a consequence of in connection with as regards in excess of as to in favour of by means of in order that/to by virtue of in regard to for the purpose/purposes of in respect of for the reason that in terms of for which (there is) in the absence of in accordance with in the affirmative in addition to in the case of in as much as in the context of in association with in the course of in case of in the event that/of in conjunction with in the nature of Example of compound preposition to be used with care in relation to Further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 167 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 54–7 Dogmatic words Rule Avoid the unjustified use of dogmatic words. Explanation Legal writing suffers from two contradictory vices. On the one hand, lawyers overqualify, and sound timid and doubtful or even evasive (see Timid phrases). On the other hand, lawyers overuse dogmatic words such as clearly, obviously and undoubtedly. Used properly, dogmatic words are intensifiers. They reinforce the impact of other words by emphasising the writer’s conviction about them. They are, however, often used unnecessarily or inappropriately. Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 xiii Classification of Entries Dogmatic words should be reserved for cases where their use is necessary and beyond contention. For example, clearly should be reserved for what is truly clear. If a dogmatic word is used to prop up an argument (especially a weak one), the word becomes a weasel word (see Weasel words). Rather than supporting the argument, the would-be intensifier destroys its force by obvious exaggeration. Examples actually certainly clearly definitely incontestably inevitably necessarily obviously quite really surely undeniably undoubtedly Further reading Garner’s Legal Style pp 32, 36–7, 188–90 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 53–4 Doublets, triplets and synonym-strings Rule Avoid using doublets, triplets and longer synonym strings. Prefer the most specific suitable word. Explanation A doublet or triplet is a collection of 2 or 3 synonyms that express what can be said by 1 word. Doublets and triplets reflect the diverse sources of the English language and the resulting availability of synonyms (and near synonyms), drawn from different sources, for many ideas. According to Garner, there are several reasons why doublets and triplets have become part of legal language: • the language of the law originated in the more leisurely prose of past times • English oral tradition led to the use of repetition to allow listeners time to understand the speaker’s point • unfamiliar words could be given meaning by using them with 1 or more synonyms • lawyers seem to have a natural distrust of their ability to fully convey the intended meaning using just a single word, and so often use a number of synonyms in the hope of avoiding unintended meanings and potential misinterpretation. (A verbal scattergun instead of a rifle shot.) Doublets and triplets detract from precise, concise and specific meaning. In most cases, a single word from a doublet or triplet will be enough to express the meaning given by each word of the group. Occasionally, it may be necessary to use a doublet or triplet as a term of art, eg aid and abet. However, these occasions are rare. Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 xiv Classification of Entries Examples all and singular any and all cease and determine grant, bargain, sell and convey give, devise and bequeath hear and decide if and when pay, satisfy and discharge possession, custody and control way, shape or form Further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 292–5 Garner’s Legal Style pp 187–8 Euphemisms Rule Avoid the unnecessary use of euphemisms. Use the most direct word if appropriate. Explanation The word euphemism comes from 2 Greek words meaning speaking nicely. A euphemism is a vague, indirect word or phrase used to say something unpleasant in a less direct or confronting way. Euphemisms are used in 3 ways: • to disguise harsh or disagreeable facts (eg correctional facility for prison) • to dress things up or add status to something (hair consultant for hairdresser) • as genteel substitutes for words considered to be indelicate (lavatory for toilet) Euphemisms are generally not appropriate for legislation because of their tendency to become dated. Examples ablution facilities decease/deceased demise (for death) imbibe inebriated intoxicated less than truthful pass away permanent layoff predecease revenue enhancement Further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 256-7 Fowler’s English Usage pp 267-8 Garner’s Dictionary pp 330–1 Garner’s Legal Style pp 34–5 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 42–4 Howard’s Guide p 154 Longman English Usage p 254 Partridge pp 108-10 Right Words pp 143-4 Working Words p 212 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 xv Classification of Entries Foreign words and phrases Rule Avoid using foreign words. Write in English, not in Latin, Norman French or any other foreign language. Explanation Foreign words that have not been fully absorbed into English are obscure and irritating to readers who do not know the word or its meaning. They can be a sign of the writer’s disregard for readers. Technical legal expressions in Latin or Norman French are especially objectionable (see Technical words). Their obscurity can prevent non-lawyers from arriving at even a minimal understanding of the law. Foreign words are sometimes used as a substitute for proper reasoning and to cloak an unjustified assumption with figleaf respectability. Their misuse can lead to the embarrassment of the pretentious blunder. Foreign words usually have an English equivalent that can be readily substituted. If possible, use the English equivalent. Examples ab initio ad hoc ad idem bona fide ceteris paribus de novo ex officio force majeure in camera in loco parentis in personam in rem in situ Further reading Cutts pp 37-9 Garner’s Legal Style pp 3–4, 185–7 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 16, 74–5 Howard’s Guide pp 173, 239 (Latinisms) Longman English Usage pp 288-9, 405 (Latinisms) Right words pp 160-1 Legalese Rule Avoid using legalese. Prefer plain language. Explanation Legalese is the complicated, technical language and complex style of writing used in older legal documents. The reason for using legalese seems to be that it is believed to Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 xvi Classification of Entries result in certainty. However, this is not always the case. Using legalese often makes documents incomprehensible—not only to non-lawyers, but often to lawyers as well. Examples as appropriate as the case requires body corporate call in question derogate except as otherwise provided in pursuance of said same semble several subject of time is of the essence unless the contrary intention appears wherever occurring without limiting the generality of Further reading Cutts pp 140-7 (lucid legal language) Fowler’s English Usage pp 448–9 Garner’s Dictionary p 516 Garner’s Legal Style pp 182–90 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 6–7, 71–4 Howard’s Guide p 242 (legal English) Padding Rule Do not use throat-clearing phrases, flotsam phrases or other padding. Write simply and directly. Explanation Padding is using woolly words, phrases and even sentences that contribute nothing to the reader’s understanding of the writer’s meaning. Much padding is the oral equivalent of throat-clearing—an opening flourish before the writer gets down to saying what he or she wants to say. Other padding consists of the standard flotsam phrases (eg the fact that) that float idly in a sentence without carrying any meaning. Often using padding comes partly from an exaggerated feeling that wordiness is an ingredient of politeness, and that a blunt statement is crude, if not rude. Padding can usually be left out or replaced by simpler words. Eliminating padding helps develop a simpler, more direct writing style. Examples I can say that … I note that … I observe that … I should point out that … In addition, it is perhaps relevant to point out that … In my (considered) opinion, … In terms of … In the circumstances, … In the first instance, … In this connection/regard, … It is also important to bear in mind … Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 xvii Classification of Entries It is appreciated that … It is important to note that … It is interesting that … It is of significance that … It is/should be noted that … It may be recalled that … It may be stated with some confidence … It seems … It should be appreciated that … It should be pointed out that … It should not be forgotten that … My sense is that … of course on a … basis the fact that Further reading Garner’s Legal Style pp 55–7 Gowers’ Plain words pp 65–9 Technical words Rule Avoid using technical words. Explain any technical words that are necessary. Explanation Legal and other technical words are obscure and irritating to readers who do not know the words or their meaning. They can be a sign of the writer’s disregard for the reader. Technical legal expressions in Latin or Norman French are especially objectionable (see Foreign words and phrases). Some legal expressions have no special legal meaning. They are either pomposities that have a non-technical, English equivalent, or expressions of imprecise meaning whose use merely provides a delusion of certainty. Before using a legal expression, decide whether it is either of these kinds. Substitution of a non-technical equivalent for a legal or other expression may not, of itself, provide an appropriate solution. Your readers may be misled into believing that they understand the non-technical equivalent. If a technical expression is necessary, consider providing a brief, plain English explanation of its meaning using a textual note, footnote or explanatory provision. Examples chose in action in personam in rem Further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 741 (technologese) Cutts p 21 Garner’s Legal Style p 185–7 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 6–7, 71–2, 178–81 Law Words 1995 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 xviii Classification of Entries Timid phrases Rule Avoid timid phrases. Prefer direct, confident words. Explanation Timid phrases are phrases like it seems or on the one hand [ … but on the other]. Timid phrases are an example of weasel words. They suggest timidity or doubt or, if used excessively, evasion. Strike out timid phrases and, if necessary, substitute direct, confident words. If you need to express an opinion, say clearly that it is your opinion, eg it seems to me. If a statement needs to be qualified, state the qualification clearly. Examples at least as far as … is/are concerned it is (respectfully) suggested it is apprehended that it seems it appears that it would appear that it might be said that on the one hand … but on the other Further reading Garner’s Legal Style pp 32, 35–6 Weasel words Rule Avoid weasel words. Explanation Webster’s Third New International Dictionary (Vol. III, p 2590) defines ‘weasel word’ in the following way: weasel word n [ weasel = word; fr. the weasel’s reputed habit of sucking the contents out of an egg [while] leaving the shell superficially intact]: a word that destroys the force of a statement by equivocal qualification ... : a word used in order to evade or retreat from a direct or forthright statement or position weasel words are the adman’s way of crossing his fingers behind his back when he makes a somewhat elastic statement - Robert Littell. The Reader’s Digest Reverse Dictionary (pp 764–765) defines ‘weasel words’ as ... unreliable words or expressions, as in We will use our best endeavours, suggesting yet evading a promise or commitment [referring to eggs that when sucked dry by weasels keep their shape but are drained of their content]. Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 xix Classification of Entries Lawyers are notorious for qualifying every statement they make with weasel words. Weasel words are also dealt with under Dogmatic words and Timid phrases. Examples compelling if practicable meaningful rather reasonable relatively seems Further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 926 Garner’s Legal Style pp 36, 123, 129, 144, 192 Howard’s Guide p 407 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 xx significant somewhat sort of substantial unduly very virtually References Asprey Asprey, Michèle M (2003) Plain Language for Lawyers, 3rd ed, Federation Press, Sydney Black’s Law Dictionary Garner, Bryan (ed.) (2004) Black’s Law Dictionary, 8th ed, West Publishing Co, St Paul Minnesota Blamires’ Common Errors Blamires, Harry (1997) The Cassell Guide to Common Errors in English, Cassell, London Blamires’ Plain English Blamires, Harry (2000) The Penguin Guide to Plain English, Penguin Books, London Blamires’ Queen’s English Blamires, Harry (1994) The Queen’s English Bloomsbury Publishing, London Bryson’s Mother Tongue Bryson, Bill (1990) Mother Tongue: The English Language, Penguin Books, London Bryson’s Troublesome Words Bryson, Bill (2002) Troublesome Words, 3rd ed, Penguin Books, London Butterworths Legal Dictionary Nygh, Peter and Butt, Peter (gen eds) (1997) Butterworths Australian Legal Dictionary, Butterworths, Sydney Cambridge Style Guide Peters, Pam (1995) The Cambridge Australian English Style Guide, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge Crystal Crystal, David (2000) Who Cares about English Usage? 2nd ed, Penguin Books, London Cutts, Martin (1995) The Plain English Guide, Oxford University Press, Oxford Cutts Cwlth OPC Plain English Office of Parliamentary Counsel, Plain English Manual, Canberra Cwlth Style Manual Style Manual for authors, editors and printers (2002) 6th ed, John Wiley & Sons Australia, Canberra Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 xxi References Dick Dick, Robert C (1995) Legal Drafting in Plain Language, 3rd ed, Carswell, Scarborough Ontario Dickerson Dickerson, Reed (1965) The Fundamentals of Legal Drafting, Little, Brown & Co, Boston Drafting Practice Guide Parliamentary Counsel’s Office, Drafting Practice Guide, Canberra Evans Evans, Richard (1998) Lawful Expressions, Law Press, Melbourne Fowler’s English Usage Burchfield, RW (ed) (2000) The New Fowler’s Modern English Usage, 3rd rev ed, Oxford University Press, New York Funk Funk, Wilfred (1950), Word Origins: An Exploration and History of Words and Language, Wing Books, New York Garner’s Dictionary Garner, Bryan A (1995) A Dictionary of Modern Legal Usage, 2nd ed, Oxford University Press, New York Garner’s Legal Style Garner, Bryan A (1991) The Elements of Legal Style, Oxford University Press, New York Garner’s Redbook Garner, Bryan A. (2003) The Redbook; a Manual on Legal Style, Westgroup Gowers’ Plain Words Gowers, Ernest (1987) The Complete Plain Words, 3rd ed, revised by Sidney Greenbaum and Janet Whitcut, Penguin Books, London Howard’s Guide Howard, Godfrey (1993) The Good English Guide, Macmillan Reference Books, London Howard’s Handbook Howard, Godfrey (1997) The Macmillan Good English Handbook, Macmillan Publishers Ltd, London Hudson Hudson, Nicholas (1997) Modern Australian Usage, 2nd ed, Oxford University Press Melbourne Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 xxii References Jowitt’s Dictionary Burke, J (ed) (1977) Jowitt’s Dictionary of English Law, 2nd ed, Sweet and Maxwell, London LA Legislation Act 2001 Law Words 1995 Centre for Plain Legal Language (1995) Law Words: 30 Essays on Legal Words & Phrases Longman English Grammar Alexander, LG (2000) 3rd ed, Longman English Grammar, Longman, London Longman English Usage Greenbaum, Sidney and Whitcut, Janet (1988) Longman Guide to English Usage, Penguin Books, England Macquarie Dictionary The Macquarie Dictionary (1997) 3rd ed, The Macquarie Library, Macquarie University New South Wales Mellinkoff’s Dictionary Mellinkoff, David (1992) Mellinkoff’s Dictionary of American Legal Usage, West Publishing Co, St Paul Minnesota New Oxford Dictionary Pearsall, Judy (ed) (1998) The New Oxford Dictionary of English, Clarendon Press, Oxford NZ Legislation Manual Law Commission (1996) Legislation Manual: Structure and Style, Wellington New Zealand Oxford English Usage Weiner, ESC and Delahunty, Andrew (eds) (1993) The Oxford Guide to English Usage, Oxford University Press, Oxford Partridge Partridge, Eric (1999) Usage and Abusage, 3rd ed, Janet Whitcut (ed), Penguin Books, England Pearce and Geddes Pearce, DC and Geddes, RS (2006) Statutory Interpretation in Australia, 6th ed, Butterworths, Sydney Piesse Aitken JK (1995) Piesse: The Elements of Drafting, 9th ed, Law Book Co, Sydney Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 xxiii References Random House Dictionary The Random House Dictionary of the English Language (1987) 2nd ed unabridged, Random House, New York Right Words Murray-Smith, Stephen (1990) Right Words: A Guide to English Usage in Australia, Penguin Books Aust Ltd, Ringwood Vic Spelling Guide Parliamentary Counsel’s Office, Spelling, Abbreviations and Symbols Guide, Canberra Strunk and White Strunk, William & White, EB (2000) The Elements of Style, 4th ed, Allyn & Bacon, Boston Use the Right Word Reader’s Digest Use the Right Word: Modern Guide to Synonyms and Related Words (1969) Reader’s Digest Assoc. Pty Ltd, Sydney Working Words Hughes, Barrie (ed) (1993) The Penguin Working Words: An Australian Guide to Modern English Usage, Penguin Books Aust Ltd, Ringwood Vic Wydick Wydick, Richard C (1998) Plain Language for Lawyers, 4th ed, Carolina Academic Press, Durham North Carolina Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 xxiv A abate usage—consider alternatives before using try—end / stop / diminish / reduce / remove / recasting (eg become less intense/widespread) / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. example of no change The storm suddenly abated. examples of change 1 If the fund out of which general legacies are payable is insufficient, the legacies are abated reduced proportionately. 2 The company took prompt action to abate remove the nuisance caused by the smoke emissions. 3 The proceeding abated ended on the plaintiff’s death. further reading Black’s Law Dictionary p 3 (abatement) Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 2 (abatement; abatement of criminal proceedings; abatement of legacies; abatement of nuisance; abatement of purchase money) Garner’s Dictionary p 4 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 2 (abate, abatement of an action, abatement of legacies; abatement of nuisance, abatement of taxes) New Oxford Dictionary p 2 abide usage—avoid using if possible try—live / stay / obey / accept / await / execute / perform / tolerate extra information archaism in most senses example of change 1 Did you abide live there? 2 You must abide by obey the club’s rules. further reading Black’s Law Dictionary p 4 (abide; abide by) Blamires’ Plain English p 117 Fowler’s English Usage p 4 Garner’s Dictionary p 5 Longman English Usage p 2 Partridge p 31 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–1 A ab initio usage—never use try—from the start / from the beginning / omitting extra information 1 foreign phrase 2 For the use of start and begin, see commence. 3 It is not necessary to say that something is void ab initio. The words ab initio are redundant if the thing is void. 4 Use an alternative. example of change The contract was void ab initio. further reading Asprey pp 162, 220 Black’s Law Dictionary p 5 (ab initio) Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 1 Evans p 116 Garner’s Dictionary pp 5–6 (ab initio; in initio), 919–20 (void ab initio) Garner’s Legal Style p 186 Garner’s Redbook p 161 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 2 (ab initio; void ab initio; trespass ab initio) able see—is/are able to ablution facilities usage—never use try—washbasin / bathroom / recasting extra information 1 formal phrase 2 also euphemism with humorous overtones 3 Use an alternative. example of change A commercial kitchen must have ablution facilities a washbasin. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 7 (ablution) Longman English Usage p 4 (ablution(s)) New Oxford Dictionary p 4 (ablution) Partridge pp 1-2, 103 (ablution; ablutions) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–2 A abode usage—avoid using if possible try—home / house / residence / dwelling house / address / recasting (using, eg place where the person lives / usually lives / resides) extra information 1 formal word 2 If possible, use an alternative. 3 Some alternatives (eg home, house, residence and dwelling house) are not appropriate for homeless people. examples of change 1 Both defendants had no fixed abode address. 2 What is your usual place of abode? Where do you usually live? [or What is your address?] further reading Black’s Law Dictionary p 5 (abode) Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 3 Garner’s Dictionary pp 7 (abode, place of), 301 (dwelling house; dwelling; usual place of abode) Longman English Usage p 5 New Oxford Dictionary p 4 Partridge p 103 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–3 A above usage—consider alternatives before using try—over / ►exceed / ►greater than / heavier than / larger than / longer than / more than / ►older than / taller than / omitting / recasting (using at least) / the item previously mentioned / mentioned on the previous page / mentioned on page ‘x’ / no change extra information 1 informal word for more than, longer than etc 2 For describing quantities, weight, age etc, prefer an alternative. Generally, prefer over, at least, or a more specific alternative, eg older than, to other alternatives. 3 Above also means on a higher level or in a higher position (than). Over means directly above or across. In some contexts the meaning of the words is identical. 4 If referring to text mentioned earlier in a document, if possible specify the location of the text in the document (so ‘see division 2.1.3’ rather than ‘see above’). examples of no change 1 above the ground 2 see the comments mentioned above [if not possible to specify their location more precisely] 3 They lived above the shop. examples of change 1 the above vehicle 2 above 6 at least 7 people 3 above for longer than the agreed term of 6 months 4 Our plane flew above over Sydney. further reading Asprey pp 124, 165, 220 Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 149 (over) Fowler’s English Usage p 9 Garner’s Dictionary p 8 Howard’s Guide p 362 (see above and below) Howard’s Handbook p 330 (see above and below) Longman English Usage p 5 Partridge pp 2 (above and below), 2–4 (above and over; below and beneath and under) Working Words p 7 (above/over) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–4 A abovementioned / abovelisted / abovequoted usage—never use try—recasting extra information 1 archaism 2 If referring to text mentioned earlier in a document, if possible specify the location of the text in the document (so ‘see division 2.1.3’ rather than ‘see above’). example of change the abovementioned officer mentioned above [or mentioned in section 4] (see above) further reading Asprey pp 124, 220 (abovementioned) Garner’s Dictionary pp 8–9 (above B; above-mentioned; above-quoted; above-styled; abovecaptioned) Garner’s Legal Style p 100 (above-mentioned; above-listed) Longman English Usage p 5 (above) absence see—in the absence of abuts usage—avoid using if possible try—adjoins / is adjacent to / is next to / recasting extra information 1 formal word 2 If possible, use an alternative. see also—adjacent; adjoining example of change If the lots have a boundary abutting adjoining the same part of a road, … further reading Black’s Law Dictionary p 11 (abut) Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 10 Evans p 116 (abutting) Garner’s Dictionary p 12 (abutment; abuttals) Garner’s Legal Style p 183 (abutting) Garner’s Redbook p 157 (abutting) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–5 A accede usage—consider alternatives before using try—grant / allow / agree / consent / permit / take up office / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. example of no change Australia acceded to the convention last year. example of change I accede agree to your request. further reading Blamires’ Common Errors p 12 (accede/exceed) Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 11 Cutts p 26 Garner’s Dictionary p 12 (accede; exceed) Garner’s Redbook p 157 (accede to) Gowers’ Plain Words p 198 Longman English Usage p 7 (accede, exceed, succeed) Partridge p 5 (access; accession) Working Words p 8 accommodation usage—consider alternatives before using try—housing / houses / home / settlement / compromise / convenient arrangement / recasting using eg adapt / no change extra information Prefer a less formal alternative if appropriate. example of no change a high standard of accommodation example of change the mine workers’ accommodation houses further reading Blamires’ Plain English p 46 (accede/exceed) Cambridge Style Guide p 13 (accommodate) Fowler’s English Usage p 15 (accommodate, accommodation) Garner’s Legal Style p 100 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 198–9 Howard’s Guide p 5 (accommodate and accommodation) Howard’s Handbook p 6 (accommodate/accommodation) Longman English Usage p 10 (accommodation(s)) New Oxford Dictionary p 11 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–6 A accompany usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using with or attached) / no change extra information Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. examples of no change 1 The fee must accompany the application. 2 The illness is usually accompanied by a fever. 3 The soprano was accompanied by a cellist. example of change He sent a letter to accompany with the parcel. further reading Blamires’ Common Errors p 13 Blamires’ Queen’s English p 239 Gowers’ Plain Words p 199 Longman English Usage p 10 New Oxford Dictionary p 11 accord usage—consider alternatives before using try—give / grant / agree / recognise / recasting (using more direct language) / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. examples of no change 1 the accord between Australia and Indonesia 2 He went of his own accord. example of change Our views accord agree. further reading Blamire’s Queen’s English p 132 Fowler’s English Usage p 15 Garner’s Dictionary pp 14 (accord; accordance), 14–5 (accord; afford), 15 (accord; concord) Garner’s Redbook p 182 (accord; accordance) Longman English Usage p 10 (accord, account) Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 582 (accord and satisfaction) Right Words p 9 accordance see—in accordance therewith; in accordance with Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–7 A accordingly usage—consider alternatives before using try—so / therefore / consequently / recasting (using neutral words) / no change extra information 1 Can be a sentence adverb. For example, ‘He did not breach the rules; accordingly, there will be no inquiry.’ For more information, see hopefully, regretfully and thankfully. 2 Prefer a simpler or more neutral alternative if appropriate. example of no change We need to find out what their plans are and respond accordingly. further reading Asprey pp 182, 220 Cutts pp 26, 31 Evans p 116 Fowler’s English Usage pp 15, 702–3 (sentence adverbs) Garner’s Dictionary p 791 (sentence adverbs) Garner’s Redbook p 157 Gowers’ Plain Words p 199 New Oxford Dictionary p 11 according to usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using eg show) / in line with / based on / in accordance with / under / no change extra information 1 compound preposition 2 According to can be a weak form of attribution that carries a hint of doubt or even suspicion. 3 Prefer a simpler or more neutral alternative if appropriate. examples of no change 1 According to Einstein, ... 2 You need to operate the equipment according to the instructions. 3 The child may be placed with a member of the child’s community who has responsibility for the child according to local custom and practice. [Under could probably be substituted for according to in this example.] examples of change 1 according to the records show that 2 Salary will be fixed according to based on experience. further reading Fowler’s English Usage pp 15 (according), 167 (compound prepositions) Garner’s Dictionary pp 15 (according), 81 (as regards; as respects; as concerns) Gowers’ Plain Words p 199 Howard’s Guide p 5 Longman English Usage p 10 (according) New Oxford Dictionary p 11 (according) Partridge p 80 (conjunctions, disguised) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–8 A account see—on account of accountable [also accountability] usage—consider alternatives before using try—responsible / liable / explicable / answerable / no change extra information 1 formal word implying a high sense of personal responsibility 2 Accountable means to be personally responsible for, and is not appropriate to use for things, eg the weather. 3 vogue word 4 Use accountable only in appropriate contexts. example of no change Under the Westminster system of government Ministers are accountable to Parliament for their departments. examples of change 1 Who is accountable responsible for this mess? 2 The fog was accountable for the meeting’s late start. The meeting started late because [people were held up because] of the fog. 3 A chief executive is accountable responsible for the efficient and effective operation of the chief executive’s department. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 15 Fowler’s English Usage p 16 Garner’s Dictionary pp 15–6 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 199–200 Howard’s Guide p 6 (accountable or responsible) Howard’s Handbook pp 6–7 (accountable/responsible) Longman English Usage p 11 New Oxford Dictionary p 12 Partridge p 5 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–9 A accrue usage—consider alternatives before using try—add / gain / arise / appear for the first time / recasting / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Accrue does not mean simply to increase in size but rather to be added to bit by bit. Interest can accrue, but a balloon cannot. 3 It may be appropriate to use accrue rather than arise in relation to a cause of action (see Garner). 4 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. examples of no change 1 Interest accrues from day to day. 2 accrued entitlement to long service leave example of change He gradually accrued gained weight after the operation. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 16 Garner’s Dictionary p 16 New Oxford Dictionary p 12 accustomed to usage—consider alternatives before using try—used to / recasting (using usually) / no change extra information 1 formal phrase 2 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. example of no change We are accustomed to thinking of law and equity as sharply divided. example of change They were accustomed to taking usually took a walk in the evening. further reading Cutts p 26 Garner’s Dictionary p 17 (accustomed) Longman English Usage p 11 (accustom) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–10 A achieve usage—consider alternatives before using try—get / reach / recasting (using, eg becoming) / no change extra information 1 Achieve implies successful effort in reaching a definite, desirable goal. It should not be treated as only the equivalent of getting or reaching. 2 A challenge can be taken up, answered or rejected, but it cannot be achieved. example of no change She achieved her longstanding ambition when she graduated with first-class honours. examples of change 1 An officer achieving redundancy becoming redundant ... 2 She achieved reached 18 (years old). further reading Blamires’ Common Errors pp 14–5 Gowers’ Plain Words p 200 Howard’s Guide p 6 Hudson p 9 Longman English Usage p 12 (achieve, achievement) New Oxford Dictionary p 14 acknowledge usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using, eg Thank you for your letter) / no change extra information 1 formal, impersonal word used in letter writing, eg I acknowledge … 2 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. examples of no change 1 He acknowledged that the claims were true. 2 They refused to acknowledge her presence. 3 He is generally acknowledged as the world authority in the field. 4 She received an award acknowledging her bravery. further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 100 (acknowledgment) Gowers’ Plain Words p 200 Howard’s Guide p 6 (acknowledge/acknowledgement) Howard’s Handbook p 7 (acknowledge/acknowledgement) Mellinkoff p 8 (acknowledge and confer, acknowledge, acknowledgement) New Oxford Dictionary p 15 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–11 A acquaint usage—consider alternatives before using try—tell / inform / state / mention / say / find out / know / recasting / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. example of no change You two should become acquainted. examples of change 1 She acquainted him with told him the facts. 2 Are you acquainted with Do you know...? 3 He was acquainted with knew the former Prime Minister. 4 You should acquaint yourself with find out the facts. 5 You should acquaint yourself with read the document. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 18 Cutts p 26 (acquaint yourself) Garner’s Redbook p 157 (acquainted with) Gowers’ Plain Words pp 18, 200 Hudson p 305 (ploddery) Longman English Usage p 12 New Oxford Dictionary p 15 Partridge p 5 (acquaint with) Right Words p 10 Working Words p 11 acquire usage—consider alternatives before using try—get / buy / win / obtain / no change extra information Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. example of no change 1 the cost of acquiring and operating vehicles 2 She acquired a good command of Spanish. 3 An interest in land may be acquired under this Act by agreement or compulsion. example of change He acquired bought the car for a good price. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 18 Garner’s Redbook p 157, p 159 (acquire knowledge) Gowers’ Plain Words p 200 Howard’s Guide p 7 Howard’s Handbook p 7 Longman English Usage p 13 Partridge p 5 (acquirement/acquisition) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–12 A act see—any act, matter or thing ACT see—Territory acting [in an office] usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / no change extra information 1 It is usually unnecessary to refer to the person acting in an office (see LA, s 185 and s 220). 2 Omit if appropriate. examples of no change 1 a broker or other person acting for a licensed insurer 2 I, Minister for ABC, acting under the XYZ Act, section 10 … examples of change 1 assessor includes a person acting as assessor 2 agent acting for … action see—chose in action Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–13 A activate usage—consider alternatives before using try—operate / motivate / inspire / actuate extra information 1 formal word 2 Activate means to ‘make active’. Its usage is best confined to scientific contexts and is inappropriate to use in relation to people. 3 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. example of no change activated carbon examples of change 1 the controls that activate operate the vehicle’s brake 2 The coach activated inspired the team. further reading Blamires’ Plain English p 46 (activate/actuate) Fowler’s English Usage pp 18–9 (activate/actuate) Garner’s Dictionary p 21 (actuate; activate) Howard’s Handbook p 8 (activate/motivate) Howard’s Guide p 7 (activate or motivate) Longman English Usage p 14 (activate/actuate) New Oxford Dictionary p 18 Partridge p 6 (activate/actuate) Right Words p 11 (activate/activation) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–14 A actually / actual usage—consider alternatives before using try—in fact / omitting / recasting / no change extra information 1 Actually can be a sentence adverb. For example, ‘He actually expected me to be pleased about it!’ For further information, see hopefully, regretfully and thankfully. 2 Actually and actual are frequently used unnecessarily in writing, particularly for emphasis. However, actual is used in a number of legal concepts to distinguish things that arise from the facts rather than by operation of law. 3 Prefer a more neutral alternative if appropriate. 4 In actual fact is a tautology. see also—definitely/definite; real/really examples of no change 1 actual possession 2 The estimate was much less than the actual cost. 3 Those were her actual words. example of change This is the section that actually deals with … further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary pp 23–4 (actual; actual authority; actual bodily harm; actual causation; actual combat against the enemy; actual, constant and visible occupation; actual fraud; actual freehold; actual intention; actual knowledge; actual malice; actual money price; actual notice; actual possession; actual seisin; actual tenant in tail; actual total loss; actual undue influence; actually in possession) Fowler’s English Usage pp 19 (actually), 702–3 (sentence adverbs) Garner’s Dictionary pp 20–1 (actual; constructive), 21 (actual fact, in), 791–2 (sentence adverbs) Gowers’ Plain Words p 54 Howard’s Guide p 8 Longman English Usage p 14 (actual/actually) Mellinkoff’s Dictionary pp 11–2 (actual; actual/constructive; actual adverse possession; actual agent; actual authority; actual bias; actual controversy; actual damages; actual eviction; actual knowledge; actual malice; actual notice; actual reduction to practice) New Oxford Dictionary p 18 Partridge pp 6 (actual and actually), 280 (really, actually and definitely) Working Words p 13 (actual/actually) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–15 A actuate usage—consider alternatives before using try— motivate / operate/ activate extra information 1 formal word 2 Actuate means to ‘move something to action’. 3 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. example of no change actuating a grey-water diverter example of change He was actuated motivated by greed. further reading Blamires’ Plain English p 46 (activate/actuate) Fowler’s English Usage pp 18–9 (activate/actuate) Garner’s Dictionary p 22 (actuate; activate) Longman English Usage p 14 (activate, actuate) Partridge p 6 (activate/actuate) adapt [also adaptation / adaption] usage—consider alternatives before using try—change / adjust / no change extra information 1 Adapt means to make suitable to requirements or conditions, or to adjust or change appropriately. This meaning is not picked up by using change. 2 Prefer change if appropriate. 3 For the differences between adapt and adjust, see adjust. 4 Prefer adaptation to adaption. examples of no change 1 The person adapted quickly to the changed circumstances. 2 The novel was adapted for film. example of change The provision applies with the adaptations changes necessary … further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 17 (adaptation or adaption) Fowler’s English Usage p 20 (adaption) Garner’s Dictionary p 22 (adapt and adopt; adaptation) Garner’s Legal Usage p 100 (adapt; adopt) Garner’s Redbook p 184 (adopt; adapt) Longman English Usage p 15 (adapt, adopt, adept) Partridge p 6 (adapt and adopt) Right Words p 11 (adaptation/adaption) Use the Right Word p 6 (adapt and adjust) Working Words p 14 (adaptation/adaption) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–16 A addition [also additional and additionally] usage—consider alternatives before using try—more / extra / another / besides / as well as / additive / omitting / no change extra information 1 can lead to verbosity 2 Do not use with add. see also—in addition to examples of no change 1 The university has extended the range of its courses with the addition of the new campus. 2 The drill was a useful addition to the tool kit. 3 Addition is one part of arithmetic. 4 The authority may, by written notice, ask the applicant for more information necessary to consider the application properly. example of change Add an additional extra dash. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 18 (addition or additive) Cutts p 26 (additional) Evans p 119 (additionally) Garner’s Redbook p 157 (additional) Howard’s Guide p 8 (in addition to) Longman English Usage p 16 (additionally) New Oxford Dictionary p 20 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–17 A adduce usage—consider alternatives before using try—present / introduce / give / offer / deduce / lead / no change extra information 1 formal word, but used in Cwlth Evidence Act 2 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. 3 Adduce should not be confused with educe or deduce. Adduce is to put forward for consideration evidence or arguments. Educe is to draw out, evoke or elicit. Deduce is to infer. examples of change 1 The defendant may adduce present evidence. 2 … unless evidence sufficient to raise doubt about the presumption is adduced given. further reading Blamires’ Plain English p 46 (adduce/deduce) Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 26 (adducing evidence) Garner’s Dictionary p 22 (adduce; educe; deduce) Garner’s Legal Style p 134 (proof/evidence/testimony) Longman English Usage p 16 (adduce, deduce) Partridge pp 6 (adduce), 113 (evidence and testimony) Working Words p 16 (adduce/deduce) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–18 A adequate usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using enough) / suitable / appropriate / satisfactory / sufficient / no change extra information 1 Prefer enough if appropriate. For the use of enough, sufficient and adequate, see sufficient. 2 Do not use adequate enough. see also—an adequate number of example of no change adequate funding and resources examples of change 1 an adequate supply of enough firewood for the winter 2 The computer program is perfectly adequate for meets my needs perfectly. further reading Evans p 118 (adequate number of) Fowler’s English Usage p 21 Garner’s Dictionary p 23 (adequate; sufficient) Garner’s Legal Style p 183 (adequate number of, an) Garner’s Redbook pp 159 (adequate number of), 183 (adequate; sufficient) Gowers’ Plain Words p 200 Howard’s Guide p 9 (adequate, enough or sufficient) Howard’s Handbook p 153 (enough/sufficient/adequate) Longman English Usage p 17 New Oxford Dictionary p 21 Partridge pp 6 (adequate enough—adequate standard of living), 351 (tautology—adequate enough) adequate number of (an) usage—never use try—sufficient / recasting (using enough) extra information 1 verbosity 2 Use an alternative. further reading Evans p 118 Garner’s Legal Style p 183 Gower’s Plain Words p 200 Howard’s Guide p 9 (adequate, enough or sufficient) Howard’s Handbook p 153 (enough/sufficient/adequate) Partridge p 6 (adequate enough) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–19 A ad hoc usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using for the purpose / haphazardly) / no change extra information 1 Foreign phrase. However, ad hoc has become assimilated into English. For example, an ad hoc committee is a committee set up for a particular and limited purpose, usually alongside a regular committee. An ad hoc decision is a decision that applies only to the present case and need not be a precedent for similar cases. 2 Ad hoc is never qualified by very or fairly. 3 Ad hoc basis (or way) is a verbose way of saying ad hoc. 4 may imply hasty improvisation 5 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. examples of no change 1 an ad hoc committee 2 an ad hoc decision example of change The operation was carried out on an ad hoc basis haphazardly. further reading Blamires’ Queen’s English p 213 Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 24 Cambridge Style Guide pp 16–7 Cutts pp 3-9 Fowler’s English Usage p 21 Garner’s Dictionary pp 24, 813 (slipshod extension) Hudson p 12 Right Words p 12 ad idem usage—never use try—to the same effect / to that effect / in agreement / of the same mind extra information 1 foreign phrase 2 Use an alternative. example of change They were ad idem in agreement. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 25 Fowler’s English Usage p 21 Garner’s Dictionary pp 24, 366 (forbidden words and phrases—A generally useless words and phrases) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–20 A adjacent usage—consider alternatives before using try—near / close to / next to / adjoining / no change extra information 1 Adjacent is less specific than adjoining and may be used to mean close to, but not actually touching, as well as right up against. See also adjoining. However, its meaning may not be completely clear in some contexts. 2 Prefer near or next to if appropriate. see also—contiguous example of no change adjacent houses example of change The houses are adjacent next to each other. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 27 Cambridge Style Guide p 19 (adjacent or adjoining) Evans p 118 (adjacent to) Fowler’s English Usage pp 21–2 Garner’s Dictionary p 24 (adjacent; contiguous) Garner’s Redbook p 157 (adjacent to) Gowers’ Plain Words p 201 Howard’s Guide p 9 (adjacent or adjoining) Howard’s Handbook p 265 (next to/adjacent/adjoining) Longman English Usage p 17 Partridge p 6 (adjacent; contiguous) Right Words p 12 (adjacent/adjoining/contiguous) Working Words p 16 adjoining usage—consider alternatives before using try—near / next to / adjacent / no change extra information If things are adjoining, they are actually touching each other, eg adjoining walls share a common wall. see also—contiguous example of no change the adjoining terrace houses further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 27 Cambridge Style Guide p 19 (adjacent or adjoining) Garner’s Dictionary p 26 (adjoin) Howard’s Guide p 9 (adjacent or adjoining) Howard’s Handbook p 265 (next to/adjacent/adjoining) Longman English Usage p 19 (adjoin, adjourn) Right Words p 12 (adjacent/adjoining/contiguous) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–21 A adjust usage—consider alternatives before using try—change / no change extra information 1 Prefer change if appropriate. 2 Adjust, like adapt, can mean to make suitable to requirements or conditions. It can also mean to adapt to changed conditions. These meanings are not picked up by using change. 3 Adapt involves considerable change to meet new requirements, while adjust implies a minor change. Adapt also emphasises the purpose for which the change is made. examples of no change 1 The equipment was adjusted to comply with the standard. 2 The prices are adjusted for inflation. 3 Submariners must adjust to living in cramped conditions. examples of change 1 Adjusting Changing for the sake of change. 2 The insurer must adjust work out the amount to pay the insured person for the loss. further reading Evans p 118 (adjustment) Gowers’ Plain Words p 201 Fowler’s English Usage p 24 New Oxford Dictionary p 22 Partridge p 103 (Elegancies—adjust one’s dress) Use the Right Word p 6 (adapt and adjust) administrate usage never use try—administer extra information Administrate is a backformation from administration. Use administer. further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 4 Macquarie Dictionary p 26 administrator see—heirs, executors, administrators, successors and assigns Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–22 A admittedly usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using neutral words) / omitting / no change extra information 1 Sentence adverb. For example, ‘Admittedly, the salary was not wonderful but the duties were light’. For further information, see hopefully, regretfully and thankfully. 2 Prefer a more neutral alternative if appropriate. further reading Fowler’s English Usage pp 702–3 (sentence adverbs) Garner’s Dictionary pp 791–2 (sentence adverbs) New Oxford Dictionary p 23 adumbrate usage—avoid using if possible try—outline / foreshadow / overshadow / indicate faintly / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. examples of change 1 Counsel adumbrated outlined the plaintiff’s case. 2 The garden features were only adumbrated barely visible in the failing light. further reading Fowler’s English Usage pp 26, 350–1 (hard words) Garner’s Dictionary p 31 Gowers’ Plain Words p 201 New Oxford Dictionary p 25 Partridge p 178 (Literarisms—adumbrate) advantageous usage—consider alternatives before using try—useful / helpful / no change extra information Prefer a simpler, more precise alternative if possible. example of no change an advantageous position example of change It would be advantageous helpful if you could give me your answer next week. further reading Garner’s Redbook p 157 Gowers’ Plain Words p 201 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–23 A adverse usage—consider alternatives before using try—unfavourable / harmful / against extra information 1 formal words with archaic overtones 2 may have technical legal meaning example of no change the person in adverse possession obtained good title against the owner examples of change 1 the judge made an adverse finding a finding against 2 No adverse unfavourable inference may be drawn from the defendant’s silence. 3 The drug had adverse harmful side effects. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary pp 32 (adverse effect discrimination, adverse inference, adverse possession), 33 (adverse security assessment, adverse witness) Fowler’s English Usage p 28 (adverse, averse) Garner’s Redbook p 184 (adverse, averse) advert to usage—avoid using if possible try—mention / refer to / avert / turn to / call attention to extra information 1 formal phrase 2 Advert is sometimes confused with avert. Advert to is to refer to or mention something. Avert is to ward off, turn away or avoid something. examples of change 1 He adverted to mentioned the letter in passing. 2 Before adverting turning to my last point, .... further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 28 Garner’s Dictionary pp 33 (advert; avert), 93 (avert) Garner’s Redbook pp 157, 185 (allude; advert; elude) Gowers’ Plain Words pp 18, 201 Longman English Usage p 21 (advert, avert) Partridge p 7 (advert; avert) Working Words p 20 (advert/avert) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–24 A advise usage—consider alternatives before using try—tell / inform / state / say / mention / notify / let me know / announce / recasting / no change extra information 1 commercialese or pomposity for tell, say or mention 2 Advise has the connotation of counselling; of giving advice. It does not mean the same as tell. 3 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. see also—will/would you be good enough to advise me; as at present advised examples of no change 1 The lawyer advised her client about how to plead to the charge. 2 The drafter advised the policy officer about the human rights implications of the policy. examples of change 1 the student must advise tell the agency 2 Please be advised that your Your cheque has been posted separately to you. further reading Blamires’ Common Errors p 16 (advice) Cutts pp 26, 32 Fowler’s English Usage pp 29 (advise, advice), 163 (commercialese) Garner’s Dictionary p 33 Garner’s Redbook pp 157, 184 (advise; advice) Gowers’ Plain Words p 18 Howard’s Guide p 11 Longman English Usage p 22 (advice, advise) Partridge pp 7, 225 (commercialese or business English) Right Words p 16 (advice/advise) Use the Right Word p 301 Working Words pp 20–1 (advice/advise/counsel) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–25 A affect usage—consider alternatives before using try—change / hinder / delay / stop / effect / no change extra information 1 vague word 2 Prefer a more precise alternative if possible. 3 Affect and effect are frequently confused. Affect is normally used only as a verb, meaning to influence, have consequences, make a change in, impress or assume a pose. Effect is used both as a verb and a noun, but most commonly as a noun. As a verb, it means to bring about, cause, accomplish, produce or result in. As a noun, it means a result, consequence or impression. 4 For the use of stop, see cease. examples of no change for affect and effect 1 The strike affected our travel plans. (verb) 2 We felt the effect of the strike on our travel plans. (noun) examples of change 1 The race was affected delayed by the bad weather. 2 He was much affected changed by age. 3 The affects effects of the interest rate cut are hard to predict. further reading Blamires’ Common Errors p 16 Blamires’ Plain English pp 46-7 (affect/effect) Blamires’ Queen’s English p 230 (affect/effect) Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 5 (affect, effect) Cambridge Style Guide p 26 (affect or effect) Fowler’s English Usage p 31 (affect, effect) Garner’s Dictionary p 34 (affect; effect) Garner’s Legal Style p 101 (affect; effect) Garner’s Redbook p 184 (affect; effect) Gowers’ Plain Words p 201 Howard’s Guide p 12 (affect or effect) Howard’s Handbook p 12 (affect/effect) Hudson pp 15–6 (affect(ive/ed), effect(ive/ed)) Longman English Usage p 23 (affect, effect) New Oxford Dictionary p 28 Oxford English Usage p 115 Partridge p 8 (affect and effect) Right Words p 17 (affect/effect) Strunk and White p 45 (effect) Working Words p 21 (affect/effect) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–26 A affirm [as to truth] usage—consider alternatives before using try—swear / state (as a fact) / assert (strongly and publicly) / declare (support for) / defend / omitting / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Consider if it is necessary to deal expressly with both swearing and affirming. Usually it is sufficient to deal only with swearing an oath (see LA, dict, pt 1, defs oath, swear an oath and take an oath). 3 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. example of no change A person must swear an oath or make an affirmation before giving evidence. example of change an affidavit that has been properly sworn or affirmed further reading Garner’s Redbook p 165 (affirmation in terms of art) New Oxford Dictionary p 29 affirm [confirm] usage—consider alternatives before using try—confirm / uphold / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer confirm or uphold. examples of change 1 The court may affirm confirm the decision appealed against. 2 The magistrate’s order was affirmed upheld on appeal. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 35 New Oxford Dictionary p 29 Partridge p 39 (assert) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–27 A affirmative usage—avoid using if possible try—recasting (using words to the effect of yes or in favour) / positive / supportive / helpful / encouraging extra information 1 formal word 2 If possible, prefer an alternative. examples of no change 1 affirmative action 2 affirmative defence examples of change 1 He gave an affirmative answer said ‘yes’. 2 He voted in the affirmative for the resolution. 3 The family is often a source of affirmative positive influence. see also—in the affirmative further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 32 Garner’s Dictionary p 36 (affirmative, in the; negative, in the) Garner’s Redbook p 184 (affirmative (or negative), in the) Gowers’ Plain Words p 201 Longman English Usage p 24 New Oxford Dictionary p 29 Partridge p 28 (answer was...) affix usage—consider alternatives before using try—attach / stick / fasten / put / add to / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer attach, stick or fasten if appropriate. examples of change 1 the affixing attaching of the seal 2 The notice may be served by securely affixing attaching the notice to the vehicle. 3 whether or not affixed attached to land 4 He licked the stamp and affixed put it on the envelope. further reading New Oxford Dictionary p 29 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–28 A affluent usage—consider alternatives before using try—rich / well-off / wealthy / recasting / no change extra information 1 Affluent can imply too much of a good thing; a never-had-it-so good smugness. 2 Prefer a simpler, more neutral alternative if appropriate. examples of change 1 He came from an affluent well-off background. 2 Only the affluent wealthy can afford to bring legal proceedings. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 201 Howard’s Guide p 12 Longman English Usage p 24 New Oxford Dictionary p 29 Partridge p 8 afford usage—consider alternatives before using try—give / provide / supply / allow / let / recasting (using, eg can pay for) / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer give, provide, supply or another simpler alternative if appropriate. examples of no change 1 Only the rich can afford to stay in the hotel. 2 It took more time than he could afford to spare. example of change The hair afforded provided vital evidence. further reading Evans p 118 (afforded) Garner’s Dictionary pp 14–5 (accord; afford) Garner’s Redbook p 157 Gowers’ Plain Words p 202 New Oxford Dictionary p 29 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–29 A aforementioned usage—never use try—recasting / omitting extra information archaism further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 36 Cutts p 27 Fowler’s English Usage p 32 (afore-) Garner’s Dictionary pp 37 (aforesaid; aforementioned) , 366 (forbidden words and phrases—A generally useless words and phrases) Garner’s Legal Style p 101 Garner’s Redbook pp 161, 162 Gowers’ Plain Words p 202 Howard’s Guide p 12 Howard’s Handbook p 12 (aforementioned/aforesaid) Longman English Usage p 630 (said) Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 19 (afore-) aforesaid usage—never use try—recasting / omitting extra information archaism further reading Asprey pp 124, 220 Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 36 Cutts p 27 Dick pp 149–50 Evans p 118 Fowler’s English Usage p 32 (afore-) Garner’s Dictionary p 37 (aforesaid; aforementioned) Garner’s Legal Style p 101 Garner’s Redbook pp 161-2 Gowers’ Plain Words p 202 Howard’s Guide p 12 Howard’s Handbook p 12 (aforementioned/aforesaid) Law Words 1995 p 80 (said) Longman English Usage p 630 (said) Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 19 (afore-) after see—from and after; on and after Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–30 A afternoon [for time] usage—avoid using if possible try—pm extra information 1 Use pm/am, without full stops and with a space between the number and pm/am. 2 Afternoon is not usually precise enough for formal writing. see also—12 am example of change five o’clock in the afternoon 5 pm further reading Commonwealth Style Manual p 172 Evans p 143 (times) Partridge p 17 (a.m., pm.) afterward / afterwards [as an adverb] usage—consider alternatives before using try—afterwards / no change extra information 1 Prefer afterwards. 2 However, for the increasing trend not to use an ‘s’ in words ending in -ward(s), see forward/forwards. 3 In Australia and Britain, the common practice is to use –ward for the adjective and –wards for the adverb. example of no change Not long afterwards there was a knock at the door. further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 799–800 (-ward or -wards) Fowler’s English Usage pp 32–3 Garner’s Dictionary p 924 (-ward(s)) Howard’s Guide p 12 (after or afterwards) Howard’s Handbook p 13 (after/afterwards/in the wake of) Longman English Usage p 24 Macquarie Dictionary p 36 Working Words p 23 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–31 A against a background of usage—avoid using if possible try—because of / no change extra information 1 vogue phrase 2 Prefer because of if appropriate. example of change Lower interest rates may be inevitable against a background of because of high rates of unemployment. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 209 age usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting / omitting / no change see also—in this day and age extra information In describing a particular age, generally prefer an alternative. example of no change He died of a heart attack at the age of 39. examples of change 1 Adult means an individual who has attained the age of 18 years is 18 years old or older. 2 Child means an individual who is under 18 years of age old. 3 A person who is under 16 years of age old must wear a seatbelt. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 33 Longman English Usage pp 24–5 New Oxford Dictionary p 32 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–32 A aggregate usage—consider alternatives before using try—total / sum / adding up to / amount / quantity / recasting (using, eg all) / no change extra information 1 The primary meaning of aggregate is ‘to bring together a mass of discrete things or individuals into a whole’. (Garner) 2 Aggregate should not be used as a pretentious word for total. 3 Aggregated together is a redundancy. 4 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. examples of change 1 fines aggregating totalling almost $100 000 2 the aggregate all of our experience further reading Cutts p 27 Garner’s Dictionary pp 39 (aggregate; aggregation), 39 (aggregate) Longman English Usage p 25 Partridge p 9 aggrieved usage—consider alternatives before using try—dissatisfied / adversely affected / recasting / no change extra information 1 Aggrieved implies a feeling of resentment at having been unfairly treated. 2 Prefer a more neutral alternative if appropriate. example of no change He was aggrieved by the arbitrary way in which his request was dealt with. example of change A person aggrieved dissatisfied with a decision of the tribunal may appeal against the decision. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 40 (aggrieved; aggrieved person) Garner’s Dictionary p 39 (aggrieve) New Oxford Dictionary p 33 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–33 A agree on / to usage—consider alternatives before using try—permit / approve / no change extra information Agreeing on something implies mutual consent between people. Agree on is, therefore, not appropriate for a permission or approval given unilaterally. see also—mutually agree; understood and agreed; undertake and agree examples of no change 1 I agree with your approach. 2 an agreed statement 3 We must agree on the arrangements. example of change The authority agreed to approved the application for planning permission. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 41 (agreement) Fowler’s English Usage p 34 Garner’s Dictionary pp 39–40, 40 (agree with; agree to; agree on) Garner’s Legal Style p 187 (agree and covenant) Gowers’ Plain Words p 202 Hudson pp 17–8 Longman English Usage p 26 New Oxford Dictionary p 34 Partridge p 9 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–34 A aid usage—consider alternatives before using try—help / assist / encourage / recasting / no change extra information 1 Prefer help or assist if appropriate. 2 Aid, abet, counsel and procure are still to be used in relation to the commission of offences (see the Criminal Code, s 45 (Complicity and common purpose)). examples of no change 1 foreign aid 2 He walked with the aid of a walking stick. examples of change 1 Will you aid help me to change the tyre? 2 She saw the old man fall and went to aid help him. 3 Research was conducted to aid assist in making decisions about the best form of treatment. further reading Blamires’ Common Errors p 17 Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 6 (aid and abet) Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 42 (aid and abet) Cambridge Style Guide p 31 (aid or aide) Fowler’s English Usage pp 36–7 Garner’s Dictionary p 40 (aid and abet) Garner’s Legal Style p 188 (aid and abet) Garner’s Redbook p 163 (aid and abet in doublets) Gowers’ Plain Words p 202 Howard’s Guide p 14 (aid or help) Law Words 1995 pp 10–2 (aid and abet) Longman English Usage p 26 (aid, aide) Melinkoff’s Dictionary pp 21–2 (aid and abet, aid and comfort) New Oxford Dictionary p 35 Partridge p 39 (assist to) aim for usage—never use try—aim at extra information 1 non-standard English 2 Use aim at. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 37 (aim) Garner’s Dictionary p 40 (aim to; aim at) Gowers’ Plain Words p 190 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–35 A alia see—inter alia alibi usage—consider alternatives before using try—excuse / defence / no change extra information 1 To plead an alibi originally meant to rebut a charge by providing evidence that the person charged was somewhere else at the time of the offence. However, alibi is now frequently used to mean any excuse or defence. 2 Alibi is best reserved for contexts consistent with its original meaning. example of change She had a good alibi excuse for not finishing the work on time. further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 8 (alias, alibi) Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 45 Fowler’s English Usage p 40 Garner’s Dictionary pp 41–2, 813 (slipshod extension) Garner’s Legal Style pp 101, 185 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 202–3 Howard’s Guide p 16 Howard’s Handbook p 15 Longman English Usage pp 27–8 Melinkoff’s Dictionary p 24 New Oxford Dictionary p 4 Partridge p 12 Right Words p 21 Working Words p 25 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–36 A all usage—consider alternatives before using try—a / an / the / omitting / no change extra information All should be used only when necessary. All may be appropriate if the collective application of a provision needs to be emphasised. However, all is generally unnecessary for plural subjects. see also—all and every; all and singular; all ...not; all of; any and all; at all times; each and all; reasonable (all reasonable means) examples of no change 1 The committee must report all findings to the chief executive. 2 He slept all day. example of change All members hold A member holds office for 3 years. further reading Blamires’ Common Errors p 18 Dickerson p 131 Fowler’s English Usage p 41 New Oxford Dictionary p 44 NZ Legislation Manual pp 40–1 Partridge p 13 Right Words p 21 all and every usage—never use try—all / a / each / the / omitting extra information 1 doublet 2 Use an alternative. further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 188 (any and all) Garner’s Redbook p 163 (any and all in doublets) Partridge p 113 (every) all and singular usage—never use try—all / the / each / omitting extra information 1 doublet 2 Use an alternative. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 43 Garner’s Legal Style p 187 Garner’s Redbook p 163 (doublets) Partridge p 389 (whole) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–37 A allay usage—avoid using if possible try—remove / avoid / relieve / alleviate / diminish extra information 1 formal word 2 If possible, use an alternative. examples of change 1 To allay remove any doubt, it is declared that … 2 He took an aspirin to allay relieve the pain. further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 8 (allay, alleviate, assuage, relieve) Working Words p 25 (allay/alleviate/assuage/relieve) allege [also allegation] usage—consider alternatives before using try—claim / state / mention / contend / declare / assert / maintain / recasting (using eg charge) / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 To allege is formally to state a matter of fact as being true or provable, without yet having proved it (Garner). 3 Allege has accusatory connotations and may suggest guilt of a crime or misconduct. It is inappropriate for more neutral contexts. 4 Allege should not, therefore, be used as a synonym of assert, claim, contend, declare, maintain, mention or state. 5 Prefer a simpler or more neutral alternative if appropriate. examples of no change 1 His alleged involvement in the offence has been widely discussed. 2 He made serious allegations of corruption. example of change 1 If it is alleged claimed in a proceeding, … 2 His friends allege maintain that he is innocent. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 47 (allegation) Fowler’s English Usage p 41 (alleged) Garner’s Dictionary pp 43 (allege; contend), 43–4 (allegedly) Garner’s Legal Style p 106 (claim) Garner’s Redbook p 185 (allege; accuse; contend) Howard’s Guide p 16 (allegation or allege) Howard’s Handbook p 16 (allege/allegation) Longman English Usage p 28 Melinkoff’s Dictionary p 25 (allege/alleged/allegation) New Oxford Dictionary p 44 Partridge p 13 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–38 A allergic [also allergy] usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using eg dislike / strong dislike / intense dislike) / no change extra information 1 vogue word 2 Allergic originally meant a physiological sensitivity to something, eg a drug. 3 Allergic should not be used as a synonym for dislike. 4 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. example of no change He had a severe allergic reaction to the antibiotic. example of change She is allergic to dislikes loud music. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 42 (allergy) Gowers’ Plain Words pp 40, 203 Longman English Usage p 29 (allergic, allergy) New Oxford Dictionary p 45 Partridge pp 13, 377 (vogue words) Right Words p 21 all … not usage—consider alternatives before using try—not all / no change extra information For negative constructions, prefer not all to avoid ambiguity. see also—not example of change All drafters did not use the precedent. Not all drafters used the precedent. or No drafters used the precedent. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 43 (all B) Garner’s Legal Style p 101 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–39 A allocate usage—consider alternatives before using try—give / divide / set apart / designate / assign / distribute / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. example of no change the authority must allocate quotas to … examples of change 1 The shares must be allocated divided among the survivors. 2 An agency head must allocate give an approved classification level to each job in the agency. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 47 New Oxford Dictionary p 46 all of usage—consider alternatives before using try—all / no change extra information All of is needed before personal pronouns (eg them) and whom, whose and which. In other cases, all of is unnecessary and should be replaced by all. examples of no change 1 all of them 2 all of whom example of change All of the claims were dismissed. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 41 (all 1) Garner’s Dictionary p 43 (all A) Garner’s Legal Style p 101 Howard’s Guide p 16 Howard’s Handbook p 16 Longman English Usage p 28 (all 1) Partridge p 13 (all) Right Words p 21 (all) Working Words p 25 (all/all of) allowed see—is/are allowed to Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–40 A allows see—where/if the context permits/allows allude to usage—consider alternatives before using try—refer (to) / (indirectly or briefly) mention / suggest / hint (at) / recall / elude / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 For the difference between illusion, delusion and allusion—see illusion. 3 To allude is to indirectly mention, to refer is to directly or specifically mention. 4 Allude and elude are sometimes confused. To elude is to avoid, escape or evade. Allude usually relates to things said (or not said), and elude usually relates to things (or people) that disappear or escape (Cambridge Style Guide). 5 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. example of no change She often alludes to her early life. example of change The judgment alludes to briefly mentions the earlier decision on page 15. further reading Blamires’ Plain English p 47 (allusive/elusive) Cambridge Style Guide pp 195 (delusion or illusion), 236–7 (elusive or allusive) Fowler’s English Usage p 44 (allusion, allude) Garner’s Dictionary pp 45–6 Garner’s Legal Style pp 101–2 (allude; elude) Garner’s Redbook p 185 (allude; advert; elude) Howard’s Guide p 17 (allude or refer) Howard’s Handbook p 17 (allude/refer) Longman English Usage p 29 (allude, elude) New Oxford Dictionary p 47 Partridge p 15 (allude) and (allusion; reference) Right Words p 22 Strunk and White p 40 (allude) Working Words p 27 (allude/elude/evade; allusion/illusion/delusion; allusive/elusive/illusive) allusion see—allude and illusion Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–41 A alter usage—consider alternatives before using try—change / amend / modify / no change extra information 1 Alter and change overlap in their meanings. However, alter may suggest a relatively slight change. 2 Use amend for changes to legislation. 3 Prefer change or amend if appropriate. 4 Do not use alter in the sense of an amendment, change or modification altering something. example of no change The dressmaker altered the length of the slacks. examples of change 1 The discovery of gold altered changed the course of history. 2 If an entry in the register is altered changed, ... 3 If a proposed modification of a motor vehicle would alter change its class, … 4 A player may not alter change a wager once all bets have been taken. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 49 (alteration) Garner’s Redbook p 157 Gowers’ Plain Words p 203 Howard’s Guide p 17 (alter or change) Howard’s Handbook pp 18–9 (alter/change) Longman English Usage p 31 (altar/alter) New Oxford Dictionary p 49 Working Words p 29 (altar/alter) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–42 A alternate [also alternately] [as an adjective] usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using take it in turns or every other one in a series)/ alternative / no change extra information Alternate strictly means by turns, or every other one or second in a series—compare alternative. examples of no change 1 Cars may be driven only on alternate days. 2 The table was built of alternate layers of wood and glue. 3 alternate directors example of change An alternate alternative spelling of judgment is judgement. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 37 (alternate or alternative) Evans p 118 (alternate/alternative) Fowler’s English Usage p 45 Garner’s Dictionary p 47 (alternate; alternative) Garner’s Legal Style p 102 (alternative; alternate) Garner’s Redbook p 185 (alternative; alternate) Gowers’ Plain Words pp 203–4 (alternate(ly), alternative(ly)) Howard’s Guide pp 17–8 (alternate or alternative) Howard’s Handbook p 19 (alternate/alternative) Hudson p 21 (alternative; alternate) Longman English Usage p 31 (alternate, alternative) New Oxford Dictionary pp 49, 50 (alternative) Partridge p 16 (alternate and alternative), 377 (vogue words) Right Words pp 23–4 (alternate/alternative) Strunk and White p 40 (alternate; alternative) Working Words p 29 (alternate/alternative) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–43 A alternative [also alternatively] usage—consider alternatives before using try—different / other / new / revised / fresh / or / substitute / alternate / option / no change extra information 1 can be a vague word (eg alternative energy, alternative medicine) 2 Alternative means available as another possibility or choice—compare alternate. 3 Alternative originally meant 1 of 2 choices. However, the word is now used to mean 1 of any number of choices. 4 Prefer a more precise alternative if appropriate. 5 Use no alternative rather than no other alternative. examples of no change 1 The alternatives were dishonour or death. 2 I prefer the third of your alternatives. 3 alternative dispute resolution 4 alternative verdict 5 pleading in the alternative examples of change 1 alternative solar energy [What can be substituted depends on the context.] 2 I want to create an alternative new model. further reading Blamires’ Common Errors p 20 Blamires’ Plain English pp 32–3 Blamires’ Queen’s English pp 239–40 Cambridge Style Guide p 37 (alternate or alternative) Evans p 118 (alternate/alternative) Fowler’s English Usage pp 45–6 Garner’s Dictionary p 47 (alternate; alternative) Garner’s Legal Style p 102 (alternative; alternate) Garner’s Redbook p 185 (alternative; alternate) Gowers’ Plain Words pp 17, 203–4 (alternate(ly), alternative(ly)) Howard’s Guide pp 17–8 (alternate or alternative), 18 (alternative) Howard’s Handbook p 19 (alternate/alternative; alternative) Hudson p 21 (alternative, alternate) Longman English Usage pp 31 (alternate, alternative), 31–2 (alternative) New Oxford Dictionary p 50 Partridge pp 16 (alternate and alternative), 17 (alternative and choice), 377 (vogue words) Right Words pp 23–4 (alternate/alternative) Strunk and White p 40 (alternate. alternative) Working Words p 29 (alternate/alternative) ambiguous see—ambivalent Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–44 A ambivalent usage—consider alternatives before using try—ambiguous / recasting (using more neutral language, eg mixed feelings or contradictory ideas) / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Ambivalent means wavering or uncertain in direction or tendency. Originally it meant a psychological state in which a person suffers from irreconcilable desires. By extension, it may be used to describe a situation involving strong contradictory or conflicting views. However, it is frequently misused beyond this. 3 Ambiguous means have more than 1 possible meaning. Ambivalent and ambiguous are often confused. There is a tendency to consider ambiguous as derogatory. 4 Ambiguous is sometimes used as a synonym for vague, but this should be avoided. 5 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. example of no change Some loved her, some hated her; few were ambivalent about her. examples of change 1 The provision was ambivalent ambiguous. 2 She was ambivalent had mixed feelings about the past. 3 The section is so ambivalent ambiguous vague as to be meaningless. further reading Blamires’ Plain English p 47 (ambiguous/ambivalent) Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 10 (ambiguous, equivocal) Cambridge Style Guide p 39 (ambiguity) Fowler’s English Usage p 47 Garner’s Redbook p 185 (ambiguous; ambivalent) Gowers’ Plain Words pp 40, 204 Howard’s Guide p 19 (ambiguity and ambiguous; ambivalence and ambivalent) Howard’s Handbook p 20 (ambiguous) Hudson p 23 (ambiguous, ambivalent) Longman English Usage pp 34–5 (ambiguous, ambivalent) Melinkoff’s Dictionary p 26 (ambiguity) New Oxford Dictionary p 52 Partridge p 377 (vogue words) Right Words p 24 (ambivalent/ambivalence) Working Words pp 30–1 (ambiguous/ambiguity), 31 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–45 A ameliorate usage—consider alternatives before using try—improve / make better / become better / lessen / mitigate / reduce / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Ameliorate means to make or become better. It is not a synonym for lessen or reduce. 3 Ameliorate is also sometimes confused with counteract or mitigate. You can ameliorate conditions, but not difficult circumstances. 4 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. example of no change ameliorating waste [a technical legal term] examples of change 1 The court made the order to ameliorate reduce the likelihood of irreparable injury. 2 The monthly visits ameliorated the isolation she felt made her feel less isolated. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 50 (ameliorate; meliorate) Garner’s Redbook p 157 Gowers’ Plain Words p 204 Longman English Usage p 35 Partridge p 25 Working Words p 31 amend see—alter amend and alter see—alter Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–46 A amenity usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using agreeable / useful / convenient / comfortable)/ facility / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 vogue word to describe facilities (generally of an attractive or desirable kind) 3 Amenity is a concept in planning law. 4 Prefer a more precise, simpler alternative if appropriate. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 52 Fowler’s English Usage p 48 Garner’s Dictionary p 50 (amenability; amenity) Garner’s Redbook p 185 (amenable; amenity) Gowers’ Plain Words p 204 Howard’s Guide p 19 Longman English Usage p 35 New Oxford Dictionary p 53 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–47 A among usage—consider alternatives before using try—between / no change extra information 1 Between should be used to express the relation of a thing to many surrounding things together and individually. Among should be used to express a relationship between them collectively and vaguely. 2 Between suggests the idea of separating, and among suggests right in the middle of. 3 It is not correct that between must be used of 2 things and that among must be used if there are more. However, among is generally still reserved for situations where at least 3 things are involved. examples of no change 1 That view is widely held among electors. 2 She put the cat among the pigeons. examples of change 1 a treaty among between 4 powers 2 choose among between the 5 candidates 3 among between 2 spouses further reading Blamires’ Common Errors pp 22–3 Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 10 (amid, among), 24 (between, among) Cambridge Style Guide pp 41–2 (amid(st) or among(st)), 84–5 (between or among) Fowler’s English Usage pp 49 (among, amongst), 106 (between 2) Garner’s Dictionary pp 53, 105–6 (between A), 857 (superstitions—H. Never use between with more than two objects) Garner’s Legal Style p 102 (among; between) Garner’s Redbook p 189 (between; among) Gowers’ Plain Words pp 107–8 Howard’s Guide p 46 (between or among) Howard’s Handbook p 49 (between; between/among) Longman English Usage p 37 (among(st)) Oxford English Usage p 121 (between) Partridge p 48 (between and among) Strunk and White p 40 (among. between) Working Words p 32 (among/between) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–48 A amongst usage—avoid using if possible try—among / between extra information 1 becoming an archaism (although opinions are divided about this) 2 If possible, use an alternative. further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 41–2 (amid(st) or among(st)) Fowler’s English Usage p 49 (among, amongst) Garner’s Dictionary p 53 (among A) Howard’s Guide p 20 (among or amongst) Howard’s Handbook pp 21–2 (among/amongst/amid/amidst) Partridge p 26 (among and amongst; among(st); amid, amidst; while, whilst) Right Words p 25 (among/amongst) Working Words p 32 (among/amongst) amount equal to (the) usage—avoid using if possible try—omitting extra information verbosity example of change the amount equal to the difference between analogous usage—consider alternatives before using try—like / similar / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer like or similar if appropriate. examples of change 1 Analogous Like situations should be treated in a like way. 2 His handwriting is analogous similar to mine. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 51 Garner’s Dictionary p 54 (analogous; analogical) Gowers’ Plain Words p 205 Longman English Usage pp 38–9 Partridge p 27 (analogous and similar) Right Words p 26 (analogy/analogous) Working Words p 33 (analogy/analogous) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–49 A analysis see—in the final/last/ultimate analysis and usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting / both … and / no change / omitting and starting a new sentence extra information 1 And should be used only in a conjunctive sense, ie to join matters. 2 However, and has been judicially interpreted in a disjunctive sense. If necessary, the conjunctive sense of and can be made more certain by recasting or using both … and (see both). 3 In appropriate cases, and can be used to begin a provision equivalent to a subsection to indicate that what the provision says is in addition to what the previous provision says. Also can be used in the same way and is often preferred. See also in addition to. 4 It is incorrect to write and which (and similar expressions such as and who, and where, but which and or which) except by way of introducing a second relative clause with the same antecedent as the one that has just preceded it. If possible, avoid the use of and which and similar expressions. 5 And should be used to join units of the same kind and not, for example, unequal phrases (see example 2, examples of change). 6 Nouns joined by and require a plural verb form unless they are considered a unit, eg Hide and seek was fun. 7 If and joins 2 different concepts, consider making 2 sentences out of them. 8 Do not substitute while for and just to vary the connective. examples of change 1 buyers who are both wholesaler and retailer 2 Please get me a hammer, and some nails, and be quick. 3 The presentation, which was the best so far this year and which high officials attended, lasted more than 2 hours. [It would be preferable to recast using 2 sentences] further reading Asprey pp 187–192 (And and or) Blamires’ Common Errors pp 24–5 Blamires’ Plain English pp 199–200 Blamires’ Queen’s English pp 158–62, 170, 171, 173 Bryson’s Troublesome Words pp 10 (and), 10–1 (and which) Cambridge Style Guide p 46 Cwlth Style Manual, pp 71 (Compound subjects), 72 (And or but to start a sentence) Fowler’s English Usage pp 52–3 Garner’s Dictionary pp 55–6 Garner’s Legal Style pp 19, 51–2, 65, 70 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 98 (sentences beginning with and), 98–100 (And which), 188 (and which) Howard’s Guide pp 22–3 Howard’s Handbook p 24 Hudson pp 27–8 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–50 A and [continued] Longman English Grammar pp 83-4 (Sentence/turn-initial coordinators) Longman English Usage pp 39–41 Melinkoff’s Dictionary p 27 New Oxford Dictionary p 61 NZ Legislation Manual p 41 Partridge pp 27-8 (and to and yet which) Strunk and White pp 10, 25–6, 63 Working Words pp 34–5, 35–6 (and which) and authority see—power and/or authority and complete see—full and complete and completely see—entirely and completely and discharge see—pay, satisfy and discharge; perform and discharge; relieve and discharge Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–51 A and / or usage—avoid using if possible try—or / and / recasting (using A or B or both) extra information 1 And/or is a way of giving 3 alternatives by only mentioning 2, ie A and/or B means A alone, B alone or both A and B. If it involves more than 2 items, the reader may have to think too much about the alternatives. 2 Use an alternative. further reading Asprey pp 192–3 Cambridge Style Guide p 47 Cutts p 32 Cwlth OPC Plain English p 17 (in support) Dick pp 107–11 Evans p 119 Fowler’s English Usage p 53 Garner’s Dictionary pp 56–7 Garner’s Legal Style pp 31, 102–3 Garner’s Redbook p 43 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 16, 188 Howard’s Guide p 23 Howard’s Handbook p 24 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 28 Longman English Usage p 41 Partridge p 27 Strunk and White p 40 Working Words p 35 angle usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting / approach / no change extra information 1 Angle, like point of view, standpoint and viewpoint, can be useful if appropriately used. However, it is sometimes a lazy and clumsy way of saying something that could be said more precisely. 2 Do not use angle in the sense of approach or technique. example of no change The buildings met at right angles. examples of change 1 Uninsulated windows are unsatisfactory from every angle in every respect. [It would be better if reasons were given.] 2 She found a new angle approach to deal with the problem. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 54 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 61–2 Howard’s Guide p 23 Longman English Usage p 42 Partridge pp 28, 330 (standpoint; point of view; viewpoint; angle and slant) Right Words p 27 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–52 A annex / annexe usage—consider alternatives before using try—attach / join / add / take (without permission) / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. 3 The verb is always spelt annex. The noun is spelt annexe. example of no change the building annexe example of change A copy of the convention is annexed attached. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 55 Garner’s Dictionary pp 59, 369 (formal words) Howard’s Guide p 24 Howard’s Handbook p 25 New Oxford Dictionary p 67 Partridge p 28 Working Words p 36 (annex/annexe) annum see—per annum another person usage—consider alternatives before using try—anyone else / someone else / no change extra information 1 formal phrase 2 Prefer anyone else or someone else if appropriate. examples of change 1 the actual offender may have been another person someone else 2 A proceeding may be brought against the person who did the act or another person anyone else knowingly concerned in the doing of the act. further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 12 (another) antagonist see—protagonist Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–53 A anticipate [also anticipation] usage—consider alternatives before using try—expect / foresee / predict / no change extra information 1 It has been suggested (eg by Gowers and Garner) that anticipate should not be used as a synonym for expect and that anticipate should be used to convey the idea of forestalling an event or foreseeing an event and doing something about it before it happens. On this approach, anticipate is used only with a noun or pronoun, never with an infinitive or that-clause. 2 Although anticipate is now frequently used as synonym for expect, the better approach is to use anticipate only in the narrower sense suggested above. examples of no change 1 They anticipated every threat. 2 He spent in anticipation of next fortnight’s salary. 3 They anticipated their competitors by releasing their new product first. 4 anticipatory breach example of change It is anticipated expected that an instruction will be issued tomorrow. further reading Blamires’ Plain English p 20 Bryson’s Troublesome Words pp 12–3 Cutts p 32 Fowler’s English Usage pp 56–7 Garner’s Dictionary p 63 Garner’s Redbook p 186 (anticipate; expect) Gowers’ Plain Words pp 33, 51, 205 Howard’s Guide p 25 (anticipate or expect) Howard’s Handbook p 26 (anticipate/expect) Hudson p 31 Longman English Usage p 46 New Oxford Dictionary p 71 Partridge pp 28–9 (anticipate and expect) Right Words pp 28–9 Strunk and White pp 40–1 Working Words p 37 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–54 A antithetical usage—avoid using if possible try—against / opposite / opposed / mutually incompatible / directly opposed extra information 1 formal word 2 can be a formal word for against or opposed 3 If possible, use a simpler alternative. examples of change 1 His behaviour was antithetical to against [or breached] the firm’s code of ethics. 2 Your beliefs are antithetical directly opposed to mine. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 57 (antithesis) Garner’s Dictionary p 65 Garner’s Legal Style pp 158–9 (antithesis) Gowers’ Plain Words p 205 Longman English Usage p 44 New Oxford Dictionary p 73 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–55 A any usage—consider alternatives before using try—a / an / each / the / 1 or more / 2 or more / omitting / recasting / no change extra information 1 Any is frequently overused in drafting. 2 Use any (or if any) to indicate the possibility that there will not be any. Any may also be used (sparely) for emphasis. 3 Any may be ambiguous. In some contexts it can mean every. 4 Any should not be followed by a negative verb. 5 Any may be either singular or plural, but the singular usage is rarer. see also—any act, matter or thing; any and all; any other; at any time; if any examples of no change If, for any reason, it is not practicable to comply with subsection (1), … examples of change 1 without any a resolution of the merging council 2 in giving any information or advice to the Minister, … 3 a person who exercises any of the powers a power of the owner 4 The authority may remove any a buoy that is obstructing navigation. 5 The committee may be given any 1 or more of the following functions in a reference: … 6 A licence may authorise the licensee to do any 1 or more of the following things: further reading Asprey pp 165–6, 220 (any, each, every and all) Blamires’ Common Errors p 26 Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 13 Dick p 143 Fowler’s English Usage pp 57–9 Garner’s Dictionary pp 26 (adjectives G), 65 Garner’s Legal Style p 188 (any and all) Garner’s Redbook p 163 (any and all in doublets) Hudson p 31 Longman English Grammar p 184 Longman English Usage p 45 NZ Legislation Manual p 41 Partridge p 29 any act, matter or thing usage—never use try—anything extra information 1 Any act, matter or thing is a triplet. 2 Use an alternative. see also—thing Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–56 A any and all / any or all usage—never use try—all / any / each / 1 or more of / (2 or more of) / recasting extra information 1 unclear 2 Use an alternative. examples of change 1 The Minister may appoint the same person to any and all 2 or more of the following offices: … [if the power to appoint exists elsewhere] 2 The Minister may appoint a person to any and all 1 or more of the following offices: … [if the provision contains the power to appoint] further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 65 Garner’s Legal Style p 188 Garner’s Redbook p 163 (doublets) any other usage—consider alternatives before using try—another / recasting (using eg anyone else / someone else / any) / no change example of no change any other interest [if another interest may or may not exist] examples of change 1 the actual offender may have been any other person someone else 2 A proceeding may be brought against the person who did the act or any other person anyone else knowingly concerned in the doing of the act. 3 address for service, for a plaintiff, defendant or any other person anyone else, means... further reading Dickerson p 131 Howard’s Guide p 26 (any or any other) Howard’s Handbook p 27 (any/any other) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–57 A apparent usage—consider alternatives before using try—clear / plain / obvious / recasting / no change extra information Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. examples of no change 1 His apparent lack of concern masked his real feelings. 2 apparent authority example of change She laughed for no apparent obvious reason. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 62 Garner’s Dictionary p 66 Garner’s Redbook p 157 Gowers’ Plain Words p 205 Mellinkoff p 20 (agency; apparent authority) New Oxford Dictionary p 78 appear see—it appears that / it would appear that append usage—never use try—attach / give with / recasting (using eg at the end / add to the end) extra information 1 formal word 2 If possible, use a simpler alternative. example of change The results of the survey are appended to at the end of the chapter. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 369 (formal words) New Oxford Dictionary p 79 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–58 A applicable usage—avoid using if possible try—that applies / applying / suitable / relevant / appropriate / recasting extra information 1 formal word 2 If possible, use a simpler alternative. examples of change 1 prudential standards applicable applying to the insurance industry 2 The Act is not applicable to does not apply to the transaction. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 63 Garner’s Dictionary p 68 application see—make application applies see—to which this [provision] applies appoint [for date / time] usage—consider alternatives before using try—fix / set / decide / recasting / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. example of change the date appointed set for the directions hearing [or the date of the directions hearing] Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–59 A appraise usage—consider alternatives before using try—apprise / value / assess (the value, quantity or performance of) / estimate (the value or quantity of) / set a price (for) / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 For the use of appraise and apprise, see apprise. 3 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. examples of change 1 The valuer appraised assessed the land’s unimproved value at $90 000. 2 The dealer appraised estimated that the vase would be worth at least $1 000. further reading Blamires’ Plain English p 48 (appraise/apprise) Blamires’ Queen’s English p 230 (appraise; apprise) Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 14 (appraise, apprise) Fowler’s English Usage p 63 (appraise, apprise) Garner’s Dictionary pp 69–70 (appraise; apprise) Garner’s Legal Style p 103 (appraise; apprize; apprise) Garner’s Redbook p 187 (appraise; apprise; apprize) Gowers’ Plain Words pp 205–6 (appraise, apprise) Howard’s Guide p 28 (appraise, assess or estimate) Longman English Usage p 52 (appraise, apprise) New Oxford Dictionary pp 80 (appraise), 81 Partridge p 30 (appraise; apprise; apprize) Right Words p 34 (appraise/apprise) Working Words p 43 (appraise/apprise) appreciable usage—consider alternatives before using try—considerable / substantial / significant / recasting (using more precise words) / omitting / no change extra information 1 vague word 2 Prefer a simpler, more precise alternative if appropriate. example of change Its cost was appreciable It was expensive. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 52 Howard’s Guide p 28 Howard’s Handbook p 30 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–60 A appreciate usage—consider alternatives before using try—understand / realise / recognise / (be) grateful (for) / (be) pleased / increase (in value) / value (highly) / omitting / no change extra information 1 vogue word 2 often used as part of padding, eg ‘I would appreciate an early reply.’ 3 can be mild pomposity, eg ‘I appreciate how difficult it is for you to meet the target.’ 4 Avoid using if sympathy or value is not to be implied. 5 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. example of no change The staff don’t feel appreciated. [just joking!] examples of change 1 I appreciate understand how difficult this is for you. 2 I would appreciate be grateful for any information you can give me. 3 They expected the house to appreciate increase in value. 4 They failed to appreciate recognise the pressure she was under. further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 14 Fowler’s English Usage pp 63–4 Garner’s Dictionary p 70 Gowers’ Plain Words p 206 Howard’s Guide p 28 Longman English Usage pp 52–3 New Oxford Dictionary pp 80–1 Partridge p 30 Right Words pp 34–5 Working Words p 43 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–61 A apprehend usage—consider alternatives before using try—arrest / detain / seize / become aware / understand / comprehend / perceive / grasp / believe / anticipate / suppose / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. 3 It is apprehended that is officialese. see also—it is apprehended that example of no change apprehended violence order examples of change 1 A warrant has been issued for his arrest but he has not yet been apprehended arrested. 2 He could barely apprehend understand the exam question. further reading Blamires’ Common Errors p 30 (apprehend/comprehend) Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 66 (apprehension) Fowler’s English Usage p 64 (apprehend, comprehend) Garner’s Dictionary p 70 (apprehend; comprehend) Howard’s Guide p 28 (apprehend or comprehend) Howard’s Handbook pp 30–1 (apprehend/comprehend) Longman English Usage p 53 (apprehend, comprehend) New Oxford Dictionary p 81 Partridge pp 30 (apprehended that, it is), 285 (reprehend) Working Words p 43 (apprehend/comprehend) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–62 A apprise usage—avoid using if possible try—tell / inform / appraise extra information 1 formal word 2 Appraise and apprise are sometimes confused. To appraise is to fix the value of something or to assess the value of someone or something. By contrast, to apprise is to tell someone about something. example of change I thought it right to apprise you of tell you what happened. further reading Blamires’ Plain English p 48 (appraise/apprise) Blamires’ Queen’s English p 230 (appraise; apprise) Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 14 (appraise, apprise) Cutts p 27 Fowler’s English Usage p 63 (appraise, apprise) Garner’s Dictionary pp 69–70 (appraise; apprise) Garner’s Legal Style p 103 (appraise; apprize; apprise) Garner’s Redbook pp 161, 187 (appraise; apprise; apprize) Gowers’ Plain Words pp 205–6 (appraise, apprise) Longman English Usage p 52 (appraise, apprise) New Oxford Dictionary pp 80 (appraise), 81 Partridge p 30 (appraise; apprise; apprize) Right Words p 34 (appraise/apprise) Working Words p 43 (appraise/apprise) appropriate [as an adjective] usage—consider alternatives before using try—right / suitable / proper / recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information 1 vague word 2 Prefer a more precise alternative if appropriate. see also—as appropriate further reading Gowers’ Plain Words pp 206–7 Longman English Usage p 53 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–63 A approximately [also approximate] usage—avoid using if possible try—about / roughly / nearly / almost extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer about for approximations. 3 Approximately about is a tautology. 4 Approximate means very close. An approximate estimate is one that need not be exact, but should be as near to exact as you can conveniently make it. 5 Never use very approximate. example of change It cost approximately about $20. further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words pp 14–5 (approximate) Evans p 119 Garner’s Dictionary pp 8 (about; approximately), 71 (approximate; approximal; proximate; approximately), 369 (formal words) Garner’s Redbook p 157 Gowers’ Plain Words p 207 Partridge p 30 are see—is/are not to; is/are to area usage—consider alternatives before using try—activity / topic / recasting (using more precise words, eg matter/issue) / no change extra information Avoid using area as an omnibus word. For more information, see kind. examples of no change 1 the area health board 2 the area of a square example of change 1 There are a number of areas in which the draft might be improved. The draft might be improved in several ways. 2 Lack of water is another area of issue for concern. further reading Blamires’ Common Errors p 31 Blamires’ Plain English p 34 Blamires’ Queen’s English p 220 Garner’s Legal Style p 205 New Oxford Dictionary p 87 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–64 A arguably usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using neutral words, eg regarded as) / possibly / no change extra information 1 Sentence adverb. For example ‘She is arguably the greatest woman golfer of all time.’ See also hopefully, regretfully and thankfully. 2 Prefer a more neutral alternative if appropriate. 3 ambiguous further reading Blamires’ Common Errors pp 31–2 (arguable) Fowler’s English Usage pp 66, 702–3 (sentence adverbs) Garner’s Dictionary pp 791–2 (sentence adverbs) Longman English Usage p 55 New Oxford Dictionary p 88 Right Words p 36 (arguable) argue see—would argue arising usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using eg because of / resulting from) / omitting / no change extra information 1 vague word 2 Prefer a more precise alternative if appropriate. examples of no change 1 arising out of or in the course of employment 2 arising under the Constitution examples of change 1 each question arising for decision to be decided 2 any shortfall arising because the levy is not enough further reading Blamires’ Common Errors p 32 (arising out of) Gowers’ Plain Words p 4 (arise) Partridge p 36 (conjunctions disguised) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–65 A around usage—consider alternatives before using try—about / roughly / nearly / almost / no change extra information Prefer about for approximations. see also—approximately examples of no change 1 He looked around the room. 2 The mountains towered all around. example of change Around About 50 people attended the meeting. further reading Blamires’ Common Errors p 32 Fowler’s English Usage pp 67–8 (around, round) Garner’s Dictionary p 75 Gowers’ Plain Words p 207 Howard’s Guide p 2 (about, around, round) Howard’s Handbook p 3 (about/around/round) Longman English Usage pp 56–7 New Oxford Dictionary p 91 Partridge p 36 Working Words pp 7 (about/around), 46 (around/round) as usage—consider alternatives before using try—when / while / since / because / for / like / omitting / no change extra information As should generally not be used in the temporal sense of while or when, or in the sense of since or because. Its use in these senses may be ambiguous (see examples of change, example 2). see also—as a consequence of; as and from; as and when; as appropriate; as a/the result of; as at present advised; as concerns / as regards / as respects; as/so far as … is/are concerned; as from; as is often the case; as/so long as; as of; as of now / as of today; as on and from; as per; as provided by; as regards; as soon as is possible/practicable; as soon as possible; as soon as is practicable; as soon as reasonably possible/practicable; as such; as the case may be/requires; as the case may require; as to/for; as to whether/who/what/how etc; as well as … both; as yet/as of yet; at least as/so far as … is/are concerned; during such time as; except as/where otherwise provided/indicated; in as much as; in so much as; regarded as being; until such time as examples of change 1 As While they were working, they saw the truck arrive. 2 They stopped fighting as when [or because] the police arrived. Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–66 A as [continued] 3 As Because no-one else wanted to do it, I had to. (better as: I had to do it because no-one else wanted to.) further reading Blamires’ Common Errors pp 32–4 Blamires’ Plain English pp 175–6 (Mismatches After as), 217–8 Bryson’s Troublesome Words pp 16 (as … as), 118 (like, as) Cambridge Style Guide p 61 Fowler’s English Usage pp 68–72 Garner’s Dictionary pp 77–8, 78 (as … as A. And so … as) Garner’s Legal Style pp 103–4 Garner’s Redbook pp 219 (like; as), 235 (since; because; as) Gowers’ Plain Words pp 100–1 Howard’s Guide p 32 Howard’s Handbook p 34 Hudson pp 36–7 Longman English Usage pp 58–61 New Oxford Dictionary pp 95–6 Partridge pp 36–7 Style Manual p 103 Working Words pp 47–8, 48 (as/since/because/for) as a consequence of usage—avoid using if possible try—because of / recasting (using so or therefore) extra information 1 compound preposition 2 If possible, use an alternative. examples of change 1 if, as a consequence of the operation because of section 4, … 2 as a consequence because of the rain further reading Cutts p 27 Garner’s Redbook p 159 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 55, 216 New Oxford Dictionary p 391 (consequence) as and from usage—never use try—from / after / on and after / recasting (using eg 6 months beginning on) extra information 1 doublet 2 compound preposition 3 Use an alternative. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 60 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–67 A as and when usage—avoid using if possible try—when / whenever / if / as / recasting extra information 1 doublet 2 compound preposition 3 Use as and when only in cases where it is necessary to emphasise that something happens in stages. see also—if and when; unless and until further reading Cutts p 32 Fowler’s English Usage p 70 (as 6) Garner’s Dictionary pp 78–9 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 60–1 Howard’ Guide p 32 (as and when and if and when) Howard’s Handbook pp 34–5 (as and when/if and when) New Oxford Dictionary p 95 (as) Partridge p 37 as appropriate usage—never use try—omitting / as the case requires / as the case may be extra information 1 legalese 2 Use an alternative. 3 Omit. Use as the case requires or as the case may be only if absolutely necessary—see as the case may be/requires. example of change outside the time allowed under section 15 (1), (2) or (3), as appropriate [or under section 15]. Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–68 A as a / the result of usage—consider alternatives before using try—because of / recasting / no change extra information 1 compound preposition 2 Prefer because of if appropriate. examples of change 1 If a dispute arises as a result because of the application of the rules, … 2 If information indicating that an offence may have been committed is obtained as a result because of a random sample, ... 3 Some of the difficulties are as a result of because of the wet winter. further reading Blamires’ Common Errors p 34 Evans p 120 Gowers’ Plain Words p 260 Howard’s Guide p 32 Howard’s Handbook p 35 as at present advised usage—never use try—recasting / omitting extra information 1 officialese 2 Use an alternative. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 79 (as at) Gowers’ Plain Words p 42 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–69 A ascertain usage—avoid using if possible try—find out / decide / determine / work out / calculate / learn extra information 1 formal word 2 Ascertain means to find out in order to know for certain and is not a synonym for find out. 3 If possible, use a simpler alternative. examples of change 1 The amount of the grant is to be ascertained worked out using the formula. 2 The person could not ascertain find out who was in the vehicle. 3 a contingent interest, whether or not the limitation of the interest is ascertained known further reading Cutts p 27 Garner’s Redbook p 157 Gowers’ Plain Words p 208 Hudson p 305 (ploddery) Longman English Usage p 62 Working Words p 49 as concerns / as regards / as respects usage—never use try—for / about / regarding / concerning / respecting / in relation to / omitting / recasting extra information 1 compound preposition 2 often indicates verbosity 3 If possible, use an alternative. example of change As regards to content, the program The program will cover important current issues. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 663 (regard) Garner’s Legal Dictionary p 81 (as regards; as respects; as concerns) Garner’s Redbook p 159 (as regards) Gowers’ Plain Words pp 55–6 (as regards) Howard’s Guide p 33 (as regards) Howard’s Handbook p 36 (as regards) New Oxford Dictionary p 1561 (regards) Strunk and White p 49 (in regard to) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–70 A as / so far as … is / are concerned usage—never use try—on / for / to / recasting extra information 1 verbose, vague 2 If possible, use a simpler alternative. see also—at least as far … is/are concerned; in so far as/insofar as examples of change 1 The available punishments may not be a serious deterrent as far as convicted persons are concerned for convicted people. 2 The measures are not relevant as far as inflation is concerned to inflation. 3 So far as I am concerned To me [or For me] 4 The regulation has had no effect so far as the industry is concerned on the industry. further reading Fowler’s English Usage pp 169 (concerned), 284 (far 4) Garner’s Dictionary p 79 (as far as) Garner’s Legal Style pp 103–4 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 58–9 Hudson p 36 (as) Longman English Usage pp 158–9 (concerned) New Oxford Dictionary p 380 (concerned) Right Words p 38 (as far as) as for see—as to/for as from usage—avoid using if possible try—from / after / on and after / recasting (using eg 6 months beginning on) extra information 1 compound preposition 2 As from may be ambiguous and should be used, if at all, with care. 3 Except when dealing with a retrospective date, the as in as from is a redundancy (but see LA, s 151 (3) (Working out periods of time generally)). 4 If possible, use an alternative. see also—as of further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 70 (as 7) Garner’s Dictionary p 79 Gowers’ Plain Words p 60 Howard’s Guide p 32 (as from and as of) Howard’s Handbook p 35 (as from/as of) Longman English Usage p 60 (as 11) New Oxford Dictionary p 95 (as) Working Words p 47 (as) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–71 A as is often the case usage—never use try—often / recasting / omitting extra information 1 verbosity 2 Use an alternative. further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 106 Partridge p 38 as of usage—consider alternatives before using try—on / by the time / recasting (using eg when) extra information 1 As of can indicate the effective legal date of a document, eg when the document is backdated or the parties sign at different times (Garner) 2 In other cases on or a more direct alternative, eg when, should be used. see also—as from; as of now examples of change 1 She was admitted to practice as of on 5 April 1980. 2 His injury had not stabilised as of when by the time he was discharged from hospital. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 70 (as 7) Garner’s Dictionary p 80 (as of A) Howard’s Guide p 32 (as from and as of) Howard’s Handbook p 35 (as from/as of) Longman English Usage p 60 (as 11) as / so long as usage—consider alternatives before using try—while / only if extra information 1 compound preposition that often implies a condition 2 Prefer a simper alternative if appropriate. example of no change They have lived here as long as anyone can remember. example of change The board may keep a document for as long as while it is necessary for the inquiry. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 468 (long) Garner’s Dictionary p 80 New Oxford Dictionary p 1087 (long) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–72 A as of now / as of today usage—never use try—now / up to the present time / from now / up to now / for the present extra information 1 compound preposition that has been criticised 2 Use an alternative. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 70 (as 7) Garner’s Dictionary p 80 (as of C) Garner’s Legal Style p 104 (as of yet) Gowers’ Plain Words p 184 Howard’s Guide p 32 (as from and as of) as on and from usage—never use try—from / after / on and after / recasting (using eg 6 months beginning on) extra information 1 compound preposition and doublet 2 Use an alternative. 3 See LA, s 151 (2) (Working out periods of time generally)). aspect usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information 1 Aspect has the same traps for writers as angle, point of view, standpoint and viewpoint. Its use can lead to vagueness. 2 Avoid using aspect as an omnibus word. See also kind. 3 Prefer a more precise alternative if appropriate. see also—angle; point of view; standpoint; viewpoint examples of no change 1 The financial aspect of the proposal needs to be examined carefully. 2 The house had a northern aspect. example of change She was not a success from a business aspect business success. further reading Blamires’ Common Errors p 38 Blamires’ Plain English pp 34–5 Blamires’ Queen’s English pp 220–1 Cutts p 43 Garner’s Legal Style pp 32 (vague word), 205 (omnibus word) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–73 A aspect [continued] Gowers’ Plain Words p 62 Longman English Usage p 62 New Oxford Dictionary pp 98–9 Partridge pp 4 (abstract nouns), 39 as per usage—never use try—according to / in accordance with / through / by / as / recasting extra information 1 commercialese 2 Use an alternative. examples of change 1 The executor distributed the estate as per in accordance with the will. 2 as per usual 3 I enclose the forms as per our conversation discussed. further reading Blacks p 122 (as per) Cutts pp 32–3 Fowler’s English Usage p 71 (as 10) Garner’s Dictionary pp 80–1 Garner’s Legal Style p 104 New Oxford Dictionary p 1376 (per) Partridge p 38 as provided by usage—avoid using if possible try—under extra information 1 compound preposition 2 If possible, use an alternative. example of change bankrupt as provided by under the Bankruptcy Act 1966 as quickly as possible see—as soon as possible as quickly as practicable see—as soon as practicable Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–74 A assign [as a verb] usage—consider alternatives before using try—transfer / give / allocate / appoint / designate / set aside / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 technical legal term for transfer of rights in personal property and leases (transfer is the proper term for real property (see Mellinkoff’s Dictionary)) 3 However, the term is also used in a legal context as a synonym for transfer in a general sense; in these cases transfer should be used instead. 4 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. see also—transfer and assign example of no change The rights in the contract are assigned on the date the instrument of acceptance is signed. examples of change 1 He was assigned given the task of returning the company to profitability. 2 The company assigned set aside a large amount to cover claims made against it. 3 She assigned transferred her rights under the option to her mother. further reading Blacks p 127 (assign) Butterworths Legal Dictionary pp 79–80 (assignment) Garner’s Dictionary pp 83, 369 (formal words) Garner’s Redbook p 165 (assignment in terms of art) Howard’s Guide p 33 (assign or transfer) Howard’s Handbook p 36 (assign/transfer) Mellinkoff’s Dictionary pp 36-7 New Oxford Dictionary p 101 assign [as a noun] usage—never use try—assignee / omitting / recasting extra information 1 Assignee is the more commonly understood word. 2 Assign is usually only used in the plural in the doublet heirs and assigns. 3 Use an alternative. 4 It is usually unnecessary to define a person to include the person’s assignees. see also—heirs, executors, administrators, successors and assigns further reading Blacks p 127 (assignee) Dick p 131 Garner’s Dictionary p 83 (assign; assignee) Law Words 1995 pp 38–40 (heirs, executors, administrators, successors and assigns) LA, s 168 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 37 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–75 A assist [also assistance] usage—consider alternatives before using try—help / encourage / recasting / no change extra information 1 Assist is often a formal way of saying help and may sound pretentious. Assist usually suggests less physical involvement in performing a task than help. You normally assist someone in doing something, but you help them to do something. 2 Prefer help or encourage if appropriate. see also—be of assistance; provide assistance examples of no change 1 The registrar need not assist a person who wishes to copy the document. 2 a device to assist in fixing a ship’s position 3 fund, or assist in other ways, the provision of rehabilitation services 4 The chief executive must provide the staff necessary to assist the tribunal. 5 The chief executive has the function of assisting the community to set up programs for the prevention of child abuse. 6 The chief executive also has the function of providing information to people who are required to report cases of child abuse to assist them in performing their legal duty. examples of change 1 A lifesaver must go as quickly as possible to the assistance of help a person in distress. 2 An insurer must provide all reasonable help to assist for the inspection. 3 The approved provider must assist help the care recipient to understand the terms of the agreement. further reading Cutts p 27 Fowler’s English Usage pp 73–4 Garner’s Dictionary p 83 (assist; assistance) Garner’s Redbook p 157 (assist; assistance) Longman English Usage p 63 (assist, assistance) New Oxford Dictionary p 101 Partridge p 39 (assist to) association see—in association with Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–76 A as soon as is possible / practicable usage—never use try—as soon as possible / as soon as practicable / recasting (mentioning a period, eg within 14 days) extra information 1 verbosity 2 Use an alternative. as soon as possible usage—consider alternatives before using try—as soon as practicable / recasting (mentioning a period, eg within 14 days) / no change extra information 1 Vines v Djordjevitch (1995) 91 CLR 512 at 522 (High Ct): What does ‘as soon as possible’ mean? Presumably, ‘as soon as possible’ requires a higher degree of expedition [than a requirement for notice within a reasonable time]. Perhaps the most satisfactory paraphrase is to say with all reasonable expedition of which the circumstances allow. 2 Amann Aviation Pty Ltd v Commonwealth (1997) 92 ALR 600 at 632 (Full Fed Ct), applying Verelst’s Administrative v Motor Union Insurance Co Ltd [1925] 2 KB 137 at 142, per Roche J: The words ‘as soon as possible’ express a relative concept; possibility must be measured by reference to limiting factors. 3 Wills v Whiteside; Ex parte Wills [1987] 2 Qd R 284 at 288, per Andrews CJ; see also Martin v R (1975) 7 ACTR 1 at 3, per Joske J ‘As soon as possible’ does not mean ‘as soon as practicable’. It is a more stringent requirement. examples of no change 1 If a declaration commences before it is notified under the Legislation Act, the Minister must give notice of the declaration to the required media as soon as possible after the declaration is made. 2 Before making a declaration, the utility must tell the Minister as soon as possible of its intention to make the declaration. 3 The person in charge of a school must, as soon as possible, tell the chief health officer if the person in charge knows or suspects that a member of staff of the school has a vaccine preventable disease. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 77 (as soon as reasonably possible) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–77 A as soon as practicable usage—consider alternatives before using try—as soon as possible / recasting (mentioning a period, eg within 14 days) / no change extra information 1 Wills v Whiteside; Ex parte Wills [1987] 2 Qd R 284 at 288, per Andrews CJ: It is my clear view that ‘as soon as practicable’ does not mean ‘as soon as possible’. There is a plain distinction in meaning between these phrases according to the ordinary usage of the terminology involved. Although the terms in each phrase are not terms of precise meaning, it is plain enough that ‘as soon as possible’ in the ordinary course of events means something different from ‘as soon as practicable’. In my view, the former phrase applies a more stringent requirement to a person making the appropriate request:. 2 Wills v Whiteside, above, at 288, per Andrews CJ: ‘As soon as practicable’ means ‘as soon as reasonably practicable’. see also—Williams v R (1986) 161 CLR 278 at 313, per Wilson and Dawson JJ 3 Creely v Ingles [1969] VR 732 at 734, per Little J; Wills v Whiteside, above, at 295, per Demack J The phrase ‘as soon as practicable’ is one that defies definition, but it involves an element of flexibility and is a matter of fact that must be determined in light of all the circumstances see also—Tampion v Chiller [1970] VR 361 at 364, per Anderson J as soon as reasonably possible / practicable usage—never use try—as soon as possible / as soon as practicable / recasting (mentioning a period, eg within 14 days) extra information 1 verbosity 2 Use an alternative. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 77 (as soon as reasonably possible) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–78 A as such usage—avoid using if possible try—omitting / in principle / in itself / thus / so / recasting extra information 1 usually a redundancy 2 The meaning of as such can be ambiguous. 3 If possible, use an alternative. 4 not a synonym for thus or so far examples of change 1 The statistics, as such, add little … 2 There is no objection as such in principle to you taking leave. 3 It is possible to stay there overnight although there are no camping facilities as such. further reading Blamires’ Common Errors p 35 Fowler’s English Usage p 71 (as 11) Garner’s Redbook p 162 Gowers’ Plain Words p 60 Longman English Usage p 59 (as 5) New Oxford Dictionary p 1854 (such) Right Words p 38 assume see—presume Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–79 A as the case may be / requires usage—avoid using if possible try—omitting / recasting / according to the circumstances extra information 1 formal phrase 2 legalese 3 Use as the case requires or as the case may be only if absolutely necessary. examples of no change The reasonable expenses of the authority in taking action under subsection (4) are a debt owed by the lessee or occupier, as the case may be, to the authority. examples of change 1 … of a spear gun, longbow or crossbow—means a replica of a spear gun, longbow or crossbow, as the case may be, even if it is not capable of discharging a projectile 2 A proceeding is taken to have been started by, or may be continued against, X if it is started or continued by or against, as the case may be, Y. 3 If an equity holder is in liquidation or receivership, the liquidator, receiver or receiver and manager, as the case requires, may apply to the court. 4 complete includes— (a) sign; orand (b) seal, as the case requires. [Paragraphing would no longer be required.] further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 133 (case) Garner’s Legal Style p 106 (case of, in the) New Oxford Dictionary p 282 (case) as the case may require usage—never use try—omitting / as the case requires extra information 1 verbosity 2 Use an alternative. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 133 (case) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–80 A as to / for usage—avoid using if possible try—by / in / into / for / of / on / to / into / with / about / in relation to / omitting / recasting extra information 1 compound preposition 2 vague phrase 3 can be a redundancy 4 If possible, use an alternative. see also—as to whether/who/what/how etc examples of change 1 restrictions as to on imports 2 The person must give a clear indication as to of the person’s intention. 3 The authorised person asked as to his name. 4 If the child can form and express views as to about the child’s wellbeing, the views must be sought and considered. further reading Evans p 120 (as to) Fowler’s English Usage p 71 (as 12) Garner’s Dictionary pp 85–6 (as to) Garner’s Legal Style p 104 Garner’s Redbook p 162 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 55–7 Hudson p 37 (as 2 (c)) Longman English Usage p 61 (as 12) Partridge pp 38, 362 (to) Right Words p 39 (as to) Strunk and White p 23 Working Words p 50 (as for/as to) as to whether / who / what / how etc usage—avoid using if possible try—omitting as to / about extra information 1 compound preposition 2 As to is a redundancy before whether. 3 If possible, use an alternative. see also—issue as to whether/of whether; whether examples of change 1 a decision as to whether about 2 doubt has been expressed as to whether 3 an inquiry as to whether 4 an explanation as to why Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–81 A as to whether / who / what / how etc [continued] 5 the person must decide as to what further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 17 (as to whether) Fowler’s English Usage p 71 (as 12) Garner’s Dictionary pp 86 (as to 9); 727 (question (as to) whether; question (of) whether), 930 (whether) Garner’s Legal Style pp 104 (as to), 104 (as to whether), 135 (question as to whether; question of whether) Garner’s Redbook p 162 (as to) Gowers’ Plain Words pp 55–7 (as to), 57 (as to whether) Hudson p 37 (as 2 (c)) Longman English Usage p 61 (as 12) Partridge p 38 (as to whether) Right Words p 39 (as to) Strunk and White p 41 (as to whether) Working Words p 50 (as for / as to) as well as … both see—both as yet / as of yet usage—consider alternatives before using try—yet / so far / until now / recasting / no change extra information 1 verbosity 2 Yet is nearly always as good as, if not better than, as yet (or as of yet). 3 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. examples of change 1 No agreement has been reached as yet been reached. 2 The damage is as yet undetermined has not yet been assessed. 3 As yet hHe has not succeeded yet. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 87 Garner’s Legal Style p 104 New Oxford Dictionary p 95 (as) Partridge p 38 (as yet) Strunk and White p 41 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–82 A at all times usage—consider alternatives before using try—always / omitting / no change extra information 1 can be a redundancy 2 Omit if appropriate. example of no change Hens are kept— (a) with continuous daytime access to outdoor runs; and (b) with access at all times to indoor litter, perches and nests; and (c) with adequate protection at all times from predators and the elements; and (d) in accordance with the stocking level and other requirements for range systems under the code. example of change at all times when driving a vehicle, … at any time usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / no change extra information 1 can be a redundancy 2 Omit if appropriate. see also—from time to time examples of no change 1 The authority may end a proposed issue at any time before … 2 The chairperson may call a meeting at any time. 3 The machine must be available at any time. example of change The person who is, at any time, the parliamentary counsel may .... Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–83 A at least as / so far as … is / are concerned usage—avoid using if possible try—omitting / recasting extra information 1 timid phrase 2 verbosity 3 If possible, use a simpler, more direct alternative. see also—as/so far as … is/are concerned further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 36 Howard’s Guide p 94 (concerned) Howard’s Handbook p 95 (concerned) at present usage—avoid using if possible try—now / today / omitting extra information 1 verbosity 2 If possible, use an alternative. example of change The club has 5 000 members at present. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 90 (at the present time; at this time; at present) Garner’s Legal Style p 183 Garner’s Redbook p 159 (at the present time; at this juncture; at this point in time) New Oxford Dictionary p 1465 (present) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–84 A attain usage—consider alternatives before using try—reach / achieve / become / turn / obtain / recasting / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Except in the sense of reaching a particular age, attain implies successful effort in reaching a goal. It should not be treated as only the equivalent of reaching. 3 Attain (which means achieve or reach) is sometimes confused with obtain (which means get). 4 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. examples of change 1 The company attained reached its profit target. 2 The company attained insolvency became insolvent. 3 Adult means an individual who has attained the age of 18 years is at least 18 years old. 4 not attained the age of under 65 years old further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 17 Cutts pp 27, 31 Garner’s Dictionary pp 88–9 (attain; obtain) Garner’s Redbook pp 157, 188 (attain; obtain) Working Words p 53 attempt usage—consider alternatives before using try—try / no change extra information 1 Attempt is a more formal word than try. 2 The use of attempt as a verb instead of try may sound pretentious and excessively formal. Prefer try as a verb unless the context needs a more formal word like attempt, for example, in a context implying a considerable effort to achieve a difficult task. 3 On the other hand, attempt should be used as a noun instead of try except in very informal contexts. In legislation the use of try as a noun is inappropriate. 4 Attempt is also the offence under the Criminal Code (and the common law) of attempting to commit an offence. This means it is not necessary to expressly mention an attempt to do something in a provision that makes it an offence to do that thing. examples of no change 1 She made another attempt at the record. 2 An attempt to commit an offence is punishable as if the offence had been committed. Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–85 A attempt [continued] example of change He attempted tried to open the door. further reading Blamires’ Common Errors p 39 Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 84 Evans p 120 Garner’s Dictionary p 89 Garner’s Redbook p 157 Howard’s Guide p 393 (try or attempt) LA s 189 Longman English Usage pp 65–6 New Oxford Dictionary pp 107–8 attendance see—in attendance attest usage—consider alternatives before using try—witness / certify (to the genuineness of) / give evidence (about) / declare / say / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. examples of no change 1 His many achievements attest to his great talent. 2 Her many drawings of birds attest to her fascination with them. 3 I can attest to his tremendous energy. examples of change 1 The attaching of the seal must be attested witnessed. 2 The witness attested gave evidence that the defendant fired the shot. further reading Black’s Law Dictionary p 138 (attest) Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 84 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 40 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–86 A at the present day usage—never use try—today / omitting extra information 1 verbosity 2 If possible, use an alternative. example of change At the present day Today murder is not punishable by death. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 90 at the present time usage—avoid using if possible try—now / today / omitting extra information 1 verbosity 2 If possible, use an alternative. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 90 (at the present time; at this time; at present) Garner’s Legal Style p 183 Garner’s Redbook p 159 (at the present time; at this juncture; at this point in time) at the time that / when / of usage—consider alternatives before using try—when / recasting (using, eg when) / no change extra information 1 verbosity 2 At the time may be necessary if reference needs to be made back to the time. 3 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. example of no change If the victim is under 18 years old at the time of the offence, ... example of change She was 90 years old at the time of her death when she died. further reading Evans p 120 (at the time when) Garner’s Dictionary pp 90 (at the time that; at the time when), 912 (at the time of in verbosity) Garner’s Legal Style p 183 (at the time when) Garner’s Redbook p 159 (at the time that; at the time when) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–87 A at this time / point of time / moment in time usage—consider alternatives before using try—now / today / finally / omitting extra information 1 vague phrase 2 can be verbose 3 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. further reading Asprey pp 173, 220 (at this particular point in time; at this point in time) Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 200 (time, at this moment in) Garner’s Dictionary p 90 (at the present time; at this time; at present) Garner’s Legal Style p 34 (point in time) Garner’s Redbook p 159 (at the present time; at this juncture; at this point in time) Gowers’ Plain Words p 184 Howard’s Guide p 35 (at this moment in time and at the end of the day) Howard’s Handbook p 39 (at this moment in time/at the end of the day) Working Words p 53 (at this moment in time; at this point in time) attribute [as a noun] usage—consider alternatives before using try—quality / feature / characteristic / property / trait / talent / character / no change extra information 1 An attribute of someone or something is a feature or quality that is attributed to the person or thing. 2 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. examples of change 1 An attribute feature of steel is its strength. 2 She was a complex mix of good and bad attributes qualities. 3 His most appealing attribute trait was his openness. 4 Her success was due to her remarkable attributes talents. further reading Blamires’ Common Errors p 39 Blamires’ Queen’s English p 231 (attributable (applicable)) Garner’s Dictionary p 91 (attribute; attribution) Partridge pp 38 (ascribe and attribute), 40 (attribute, attributed) Right Words p 40 (attribute/character; property/quality/trait) Working Words p 53 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–88 A attribute [as a verb] usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using, eg give credit for / belonging to / is an outcome (or result / effect / consequence) of / coming from / applicable to / earmark / ascribe / no change extra information Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. examples of no change 1 Ancient peoples attributed magic properties to certain stones. 2 the part of the rate attributable to land occupied only by a pensioner 3 a financial benefit reasonably attributable to the breach examples of change 1 I attribute credit her success to her remarkable talents. [or Her success is due to her remarkable talents.] 2 His bad health is attributable to caused by smoking. 3 She attributed the word with gave the word a meaning it did not properly have. 4 This music may be attributed belongs to [or comes from] the 16th century. further reading Blamires’ Common Errors pp 39–40 Blamires’ Queen’s English pp 172, 231 (attributable (applicable)) Cutts p 27 Garner’s Redbook p 157 (attributable to) New Oxford Dictionary p 109 Partridge pp 38 (ascribe and attribute), 40 (attribute; attributed) Working Words p 53 at your earliest convenience / at your convenience usage—never use try—soon / as soon as you can / as soon as possible / as soon as you like / whenever it’s possible extra information 1 commercialese 2 At your convenience has humorous overtones. 3 Use an alternative. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 149 (commercialese) Gowers’ Plain Words p 217 (at your convenience) Howard’s Guide p 35 (at your convenience) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–89 A Australia usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / no change extra information 1 can be a redundancy 2 Connection with Australia is often implied and need not be stated. 3 See LA, dict, pt 1, defs Australia and Commonwealth. example of change the Commonwealth of Australia Australian Capital Territory see—Territory authorise usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using may) / permit / allow / approve / no change extra information 1 Authorise is an active word. It means to give official or legal approval to someone or permission to do something. (Often the approval will confer permission to do something.) By contrast, permit and allow can be passive words. They can mean to let something be done or happen. 2 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. see also—authorise and empower; is/are authorised examples of no change 1 an authorised act 2 authorised dealer 3 authorised officer 4 A security guard may allow someone to enter the building only if the person is authorised to enter. examples of change 1 The meat safety officer is authorised may … 2 This section applies if an Act requires or authorises allows a document to be served by post. further reading Black’s Law Dictionary p 143 (authorize) Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 97 Evans p 121 (be authorised to) New Oxford Dictionary p 113 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–90 A authorise and empower usage—never use try—permit / recasting (using may) / allow / authorise extra information 1 doublet 2 Use an alternative. 3 Prefer authorise to empower (or alternatives above). further reading Garner’s Redbook p 163 (doublets) Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 41 (authorize/empower) authority usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using may) / power / right / omitting / no change extra information Prefer alternative of saying that someone has a right (or is permitted / has power) to do something. see also—power and/or authority; is authorised examples of no change 1 the administering authority may … 2 a territory authority 3 The commissioner’s seal may be used only with the commissioner’s authority [or permission/approval]. 4 authority to take affidavits 5 authority to complete 6 The money was spent without parliamentary authority. 7 She spoke with authority on the subject. 8 He had absolute authority over his subordinates. examples of change 1 powers and authorities 2 The port captain may give a person a written authority permission. 3 have the authority to are allowed to further reading Black’s Law Dictionary p 142 (authority) Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 98 Gowers’ Plain Words p 208 Howard’s Guide p 36 Hudson p 41 LA, dict, pt 1, def power Longman English Usage p 69 New Oxford Dictionary p 113 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–91 A availability usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information 1 Using availability can contribute to abstract, loose writing. 2 Prefer more precise words if appropriate. examples of change 1 The availability of this particular material is extremely limited. This material is extremely scarce. 2 The actual date of completion of the purchase should coincide with the availability of the new facilities. The purchase should not be completed until the new facilities are available. [or ready] 3 A real concern of householders is the availability lack [or shortage] of gas. further reading Blamires’ Plain English p 28 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 80–1 aver [also averment] usage—avoid using if possible try—state (positively) / say / assert (as a fact) / swear / affirm / claim (as a fact) / declare / allege / recasting extra information 1 formal word 2 technical legal term, but allege is usually preferable even in this context 3 Use aver in solemn, formal context only. 4 Say is more neutral than aver and may not be a suitable alternative. 5 If possible, use an alternative. examples of change 1 a particular averred stated in a complaint 2 He averred declared that he was innocent. further reading Black’s Law Dictionary p 145 (aver) Butterworths Legal Dictionary pp 100 (aver), 101 (averment) Fowler’s English Usage pp 80–1 Garner’s Dictionary p 93 (aver; asseverate; averment; averral) Garner’s Redbook p 161 (aver) Longman English Usage p 70 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 25 (allege/alleged/allegation) New Oxford Dictionary p 116 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–92 A avert usage—consider alternatives before using try—avoid / prevent / turn away (one’s eyes or thoughts) / deflect / ward off / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 To avoid something is to keep away from it; to prevent something is to stop it happening; to avert something is to ward it off, to turn it away or deflect it. 3 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. 4 Avert is sometimes confused with advert. For the use of avert and advert, see advert. examples of change 1 The driver of a vehicle approaching an intersection must take the action necessary to avert avoid the collision at the intersection. 2 The talks failed to avert prevent the transport strike. further reading Blamires’ Plain English pp 19–20 Garner’s Dictionary pp 33 (advert; avert), 93 Longman English Usage pp 21 (advert, avert), 70–1 (avoid, prevent, avert) New Oxford Dictionary p 116 Partridge p 7 (advert; avert) Oxford English Usage p 120 Working Words p 20 (advert/avert) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–93 A aware usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using, eg know) / no change extra information 1 Aware is a vogue word that has become a blanket term of approval, eg a politically aware person or even an aware person. 2 Prefer a more precise alternative if appropriate. 3 A person can be made aware of something. But a person cannot be made to know something. examples of no change 1 I am aware of your difficulty. 2 Suddenly he became aware of the acute pain. example of change 1 Most people are aware of know about the danger of too much exposure to the sun. 2 She was aware knew that a problem existed. 3 As far as I am aware know, no-one has complained. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 82 Gowers’ Plain Words p 208 Howard’s Guide p 37 Longman English Usage p 71 New Oxford Dictionary pp 117–8 Oxford English Usage pp 120–1 Partridge p 377 (vogue words) Working Words p 59 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 A–94 B background usage—consider alternatives before using try—explanation / cause / recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information 1 vague word 2 Prefer a more precise alternative if appropriate. 3 Do not use as a verb. see also—against a background of examples of change 1 Your background experience indicates that you would be more suitable for other positions. 2 The high rate of unemployment provides the background explanation for low inflationary expectations. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words pp 208–9 Longman English Usage p 73 Right Words p 45 (background) backward / backwards usage—consider alternatives before using try—backwards / backward / recasting / no change extra information 1 Use backward as an adjective. 2 As an adverb, prefer backwards if appropriate. However, for the increasing trend not to use an ‘s’ in words ending in ward(s), see forward/forwards. examples of no change 1 a backward glance 2 backward medical techniques 3 She knows it backwards. 4 The child spelt the word backwards. 5 He walked backwards. [that is, in the opposite direction to the direction in which he was facing] 6 They swung backwards and forwards on the swing. further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 799–800 (-ward or -wards) Fowler’s English Usage p 86 Garner’s Dictionary p 924 (-ward(s)) Howard’s Guide p 38 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 B–1 B backward / backwards [continued] Howard’s Handbook p 42 Hudson pp 43–4 Longman English Usage p 73 Macquarie Dictionary p 150 Right Words p 45 (backward/backwards) Working Words p 62 basis usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using more precise words) / reason / no change extra information 1 vague word 2 often associated with padding 3 Prefer a more precise alternative if appropriate. 4 Do not use on a … basis. It is invariably only padding. see also—on a … basis; on the basis of example of no change on the basis of past trading examples of change 1 on a weekly basis weekly [or by the week] 2 The project is subsidised on a continuing basis continuously [or year after year] 3 X will be available on a consulting basis as a consultant. [or for consultation] 4 The services are to be available on a strictly limited basis. Only limited services are available. or Services will be provided for a strictly limited time. 5 The machines must be available both day and night on a 24 hour basis at any time of the day or night. 6 on a temporary basis temporarily further reading Black’s Law Dictionary p 161 (basis) Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 21 Evans p 120 Fowler’s English Usage pp 93–4 (base) Garner’s Dictionary pp 100, 362 (flotsam phrases) Garner’s Legal Style pp 57, 104 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 4, 85–6 Howard’s Guide p 43 Partridge p 45 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 B–2 B bear [as a verb] usage—consider alternatives before using try—have / carry extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. example of no change That tree bears sweet fruit. example of change The lighter must bear have a label. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 309 (formal words) Longman English Usage pp 79 (bear (verb)), 92 (born/borne) because see—the reason … is because; not because before see—before the end of; on or before beforementioned usage—never use try—the [item previously mentioned] / omitting / recasting extra information archaism further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 9 (above-mentioned; above-quoted; above-styled; above-captioned), 37 (aforesaid; aforementioned) Garner’s Legal Style pp 100, 183 before the end of usage—avoid using if possible try—recasting (using within / by / no later than / not later than / before) examples of change 1 unless the person pays the fee before the end of within the payment period 2 If a postponed law has not commenced before the end of the period of within 6 months beginning on its notification day, it automatically commences on the first day after that period. Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 B–3 B begin see—commence beg the question usage—never use try—recasting (using, eg Your conclusion is justified only if ... / evade the question (or issue) / ignore the question (or issue) / postpone consideration of the question (or issue) / raise the question (or issue)) extra information 1 The traditional meaning of beg the question is to take as a proven fact an issue that is debatable. The issue is woven into another assertion that effectively conceals the issue from debate. For example: ‘We must control immigration to prevent harm to Australia’s fragile environment’. The statement begs the question as to whether immigration really harms Australia’s environment. It makes it sound as if we can take that for granted, and pre-empts discussion of it by focusing on the need to control immigration. 2 A single word can be used in a question-begging way; eg aggressor, guilty, imperialism, offender, reactionary, victim. 3 The traditional meaning of beg the question belongs in the field of logic and appears not to be well understood. To beg the question is now used to mean ‘to evade the question’, ‘to ignore the question’, ‘postpone consideration of the question’ or, even more loosely, ‘to raise the question (for consideration)’. Difficulties of understanding are made worse by the use of beg in the phrase in an archaic sense. 4 Because beg the question is so often misunderstood and has archaic overtones, it is best not used at all. 5 If possible, prefer an alternative. further reading Blamires’ Common Errors pp 46–7 Blamires’ Queen’s English pp 211–2 Cambridge Style Guide pp 82–3 Fowler’s English Usage p 101 Garner’s Dictionary p 101 (begging the question) Gowers’ Plain Words p 209 Howard’s Guide p 44 Howard’s Handbook p 46 Longman English Usage p 81 New Oxford Dictionary p 156 Oxford English Usage p 121 Partridge p 46 Right Words p 49 (begging the question) Working Words pp 66–7 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 B–4 B behalf see—for and/or on behalf of; on behalf of being usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting / omitting / no change extra information 1 Do not use being and not being to join relative (or adjectival) clauses. A relative clause serves either to define, or to describe and evaluate, the noun to which it is attached. 2 Consider if a parenthetical further explanation is needed, eg that is, … see also—not being; regarded as being examples of no change 1 an issue being considered 2 a misrepresentation resulting in a vehicle being incorrectly classified 3 the cover does not extend to an unregistered vehicle while it is being driven to … examples of change 1 a person who is 70 years old or older being a person who has a driving licence and has a driving licence 2 The land is to be taken as being taken to be land granted in fee simple. 3 the authority must have regard to a decision being a decision if … 4 If the person: (a) being for a person who has received household support—has a child … 5 the document known as …, being the document as in force … 6 She is regarded as being the best dentist. further reading NZ Legislation Manual p 41 Strunk and White p 41 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 B–5 B below usage—consider alternatives before using try—under / less than / lighter than / shorter than / smaller than / younger than / omitting / recasting (using at most, not over, not exceeding or not more than) / the [item mentioned later / on the next page / on page ‘x’] / no change extra information 1 informal word for less than, shorter than etc. 2 For describing quantities, weight, age etc, prefer an alternative. Generally, prefer under, less than, or a more specific alternative, eg younger than, to other alternatives. 3 Below, beneath, under and underneath are all prepositions that mean lower than. Below is the opposite of above and is often used in relation to levels. Under is generally the opposite of over, and can mean covered by. Under also means subject to. Beneath can often be substituted for the other 3 and can also mean unworthy. Underneath can be used for under to mean covered by. The choice between the 4 prepositions often depends on what is most natural for the context. However, beneath has become somewhat restricted in its use and is becoming slightly archaic. Under has the broadest range of meanings. examples of no change 1 below ground level 2 See the comments mentioned below. [or See the comments on the next page / on page ‘x’ / or See the later comments.] 3 They lived below the shop. examples of change 1 below less than 7 people 2 below for less than 6 months 3 Cleaning his room was below beneath his dignity. 4 Our plane flew below under Sydney Harbour Bridge. 5 The pencil was found below underneath the chair. further reading Asprey pp 165, 220 (above, below) Black’s Law Dictionary p 164 (below) Fowler’s English Usage p 103 (below, under; beneath) Garner’s Dictionary p 103 Howard’s Guide p 362 (see above and below) Longman English Usage pp 82–3 Partridge pp 2–4 (above and over; below and beneath and under) Working Words p 67 (below/beneath/under/underneath) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 B–6 B belowmentioned / belowlisted / belowquoted usage—never use try—the [item mentioned later / on the next page / on page ‘x’] / omitting / recasting extra information archaism further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 103 (below-mentioned; under-mentioned) beneficial usage—consider alternatives before using try—useful / helpful / favourable / no change extra information 1 Beneficial has several technical legal meanings. 2 In other contexts, beneficial can be a vague word. 3 Prefer a more precise alternative if appropriate. examples of no change 1 a trust in which the trustee has a beneficial interest in the trust property 2 A beneficial provision is a provision that gives a benefit to a person and by doing so remedies an injustice. 3 She is the beneficial owner of the property under the trust. further reading Black’s Law Dictionary p 165 (beneficial) Butterworths Legal Dictionary pp 120 (beneficial interest; beneficial legislation), 120–1 (beneficial owner), 121 (beneficial ownership; beneficial ownership; beneficial use) Garner’s Dictionary pp 103–4 (benefic(ent); beneficial; benevolent) Gowers’ Plain Words pp 209 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary pp 51–2 (beneficiary; beneficial owner) Working Words p 68 (benevolent; beneficient; beneficial; benign) be of assistance usage—avoid using if possible try—help / assist extra information verbosity see also—assist further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 83 (assistance), 106–7 (be-verbs B) Gowers’ Plain Words pp 41-2 (may be of assistance) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 B–7 B beneath see—below bequeath usage—never use try—give / present / give by will / leave extra information 1 Bequeath is a technical legal term meaning to give personal property by will. The equivalent term for real property is devise. However, bequeath will be taken to include real property if that is clearly the intention of the testator. 2 Similarly, if the alternative give by will is used in legislation, consideration should be given to including a note explaining that it means the same as the technical legal term. 3 Sometimes bequeath is used as a pretentious way of saying give or present. see also—devise; give, devise and bequeath examples of change 1 I bequeath give my library to my son, Joseph. [in a will] 2 He bequeathed gave his papers to the library by will. 3 She bequeathed left her father’s Victoria Cross to the War Memorial. further reading Black’s Law Dictionary p 168 (bequeath) Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 123 Garner’s Dictionary pp 104–5, 273 (devise; bequeath) Garner’s Redbook p 201 (devise; bequest; legacy) Law Words 1995 pp 31–3 (give, devise and bequeath) Mellinkoff’s Dictionary pp 267–9 (gift; give), 269 (give, devise and bequeath) New Oxford Dictionary p 163 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 B–8 B between usage—consider alternatives before using try—among / no change extra information 1 For the use of between and among, see among. 2 Avoid using between with each or every. 3 Do not use between … or … or between … to …(eg between 10 to 20%). Instead, use between … and …. 4 Between … and …, like both … and …, needs proper balancing of the sentence—see both. 5 Be careful using between in relation to time, age, measurement, etc. Using between normally excludes the mentioned limits, eg the period between 1 October and 1 November does not include either of the mentioned dates (see LA, s 151 (6) (Working out periods of time generally)). example of no change You have a choice between doing what is right and doing what is wrong. further reading Asprey p 179 Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 24 (between, among) Cambridge Style Guide pp 84–5 (between or among) Fowler’s English Usage pp 105–7 Garner’s Dictionary pp 105–6 Garner’s Legal Style pp 102, 105 (among; between) Garner’s Redbook p 189 (between; among) Gowers’ Plain Words pp 102, 107–9 Oxford English Usage p 121 Partridge p 48 Right Words p 50 (between, between each, between every, between you and I) Strunk and White p 40 (among, between) blueprint usage—consider alternatives before using try—scheme / plan / no change extra information 1 vogue word 2 metaphorical word often used inappropriately 3 In engineering, the blueprint or masterplan marks the final stage of paper design. further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 25 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 40, 88, 209 Howard’s Guide p 51 Longman English Usage p 91 Partridge p 377 (vogue words) Right Words p 53 (blueprint) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 B–9 B body see—body corporate; person or body body corporate usage—consider alternatives before using try—corporation / no change extra information 1 formal phrase 2 legal term 3 use corporation instead of body corporate when referring to an entity, except in a context where body corporate is necessary (eg referring to the application of Corporations Act provisions to a body corporate). example of no change (real property context) The body corporate holds the common property and all necessary insurances for the building. example of change The commission is a body corporate corporation. a body corporate corporation carrying on general insurance business see also—Drafting Practice Guide; LA, dict, pt 1, def corporation, Corporations Act, s 9 (def body corporate) and s 57A (def corporation). further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 112 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 B–10 B bona fide usage—never use try—in good faith / genuine / honestly / sincerely extra information 1 foreign phrase 2 However, bona fide has become assimilated into English. 3 legal term equivalent to in good faith 4 However, its use can invariably be avoided because there are better alternatives. examples of change 1 a person who is living with the pensioner as the pensioner’s spouse on a bona fide genuine domestic basis although not married to the pensioner 2 The charge does not have effect against a bona fide an honest purchaser of the parcel of land for value. further reading Asprey pp 162, 220 Cambridge Style Guide p 93 (bona fides and bona fide) Evans p 121 (bona fides) Fowler’s English Usage p 112 (bona fide(s)) Garner’s Dictionary p 113 (bona fide and bona fides/good faith/bonne foi) Garner’s Legal Style p 185 Garner’s Redbook pp 161, 166 (terms of art), 190 (bona fide; real and bona fides; good faith) Gowers’ Plain Words p 209 (bona fides) Howard’s Guide pp 52–3 Howard’s Handbook p 54 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary pp 54 (bad faith), 56 (bona fide) Partridge p 50 Working Words p 76 (bona fide/bona fides) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 B–11 B both usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / each / no change extra information 1 Both is often superfluous. 2 Both should be used with and only if particular emphasis is needed or it is otherwise necessary to clarify the meaning of a sentence. 3 When using both … and, make sure the words are in their right positions and carry equal weight. Nothing that comes between both and and can be regarded as applying to anything after and, it must come before both; if it does not come before both, it must be repeated after and. 4 Both should not be used to refer to more than 2 people or things. 5 Never use both with as well as. see also—or both examples of change 1 Both form A and form B Forms A and B must be given to the registrar. 2 The judge decided all questions both of law and fact of law and of fact [or of both law and fact or omit both]. further reading Blamires’ Plain English pp 258–9 (both … and) Bryson’s Troublesome Words pp 26–7 (both … and) Fowler’s English Usage pp 113–4 Garner’s Dictionary p 115 Garner’s Legal Style p 66 (both … and) Gowers’ Plain Words pp 101–2 Howard’s Guide p 54 Howard’s Handbook pp 55–6 Longman English Usage pp 93–4 Partridge pp 38 (as well as), 50 Strunk and White pp 27–8 Working Words p 77 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 B–12 B break down / breakdown usage—consider alternatives before using try—analyse / divide / classify / change / alter / convert / recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information 1 Break down is a verb. Breakdown is a noun. 2 can be used as vague phrase in the sense of classifying 3 officialese 4 Avoid contexts where there is a possibility of confusion with the literal meaning, eg a complete breakdown of the processes. 5 Prefer a more precise alternative if appropriate. examples of no change 1 The reaction broke down the substance into its components. 2 The car broke down on the highway. examples of change 1 The applicants should be broken down into types classified according to type. 2 the population of Australia, broken down analysed [or classified] by age and sex 3 A breakdown An analysis of the errors has shown that lack of training is the main cause. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 116 (breakdown) Garner’s Dictionary p 117 (breakdown) Gowers’ Plain Words p 210 Howard’s Guide p 57 (breakdown / break down) Howard’s Handbook p 58 (breakdown/break down) Longman English Usage p 97 (breakdown, break down) Partridge p 52 but see—and (but which); but for; no option but to but for usage—avoid using if possible try—apart from / other than for / were it not for / except that for / recasting (using if … not) extra information 1 legalese 2 In legislative drafting use an alternative. examples of change 1 but for apart from this subsection 2 The provision would have expired but for its extension if it had not been extended. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 124 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 B–13 B by usage—consider alternatives before using try—under / recasting (using another preposition) / no change extra information 1 By has many meanings and care needs to be taken to avoid ambiguity in its use. 2 Be careful not to draw artificial distinctions in legislation by using different words to say essentially the same thing. In particular, take particular care in legislation not to draw unnecessary distinctions between by and under. As under is the word with the widest meaning, prefer under to by if appropriate. examples of no change 1 A guideline may incorporate a standard by reference. 2 This Act commences on a day to be fixed by proclamation. 3 the object is to be achieved mainly by … 4 The remaining provisions commence by force of this subsection. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 123 Longman English Usage p 103 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 64 (by and with; by operation of law) Partridge p 57 (by for beside) Working Words p 561 (with/by/of) by and / or under usage—avoid using if possible try—under / recasting extra information 1 doublet 2 redundancy examples of change 1 A form is prescribed by or under an Act. 2 The tests required by or under section 10. 3 by or under a law of the Tterritory law further reading Garner’s Redbook p 163 (by and under in doublets) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 B–14 B by and with usage—avoid using if possible try—recasting extra information 1 doublet 2 in general, a redundancy further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 125 Garner’s Redbook p 163 (doublets) Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 64 Partridge p 57 (by) by means of usage—avoid using if possible try—omitting / by way of / by / with / using extra information 1 compound preposition 2 usually verbose for by further reading Evans p 121 Garner’s Dictionary p 125 Garner’s Legal Style p 183 Garner’s Redbook p 160 Gowers’ Plain Words p 55 Wydick p 13 by reason of usage—avoid using if possible try—because of extra information 1 compound preposition 2 verbose for because of example of change The plaintiff died by reason because of the injuries. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 125 Garner’s Redbook p 160 Wydick p 13 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 B–15 B by reason only usage—avoid using if possible try—only because / recasting extra information compound preposition see also—by reason of by the name of usage—never use try—omitting / called / named extra information 1 compound preposition 2 can be a redundancy further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 247 Partridge p 57 by virtue of usage—never use try—because of / under / by extra information compound preposition further reading Asprey pp 172 (pursuant to), 220 Evans p 121 Garner’s Dictionary p 917 (virtue of, in and by) Gowers’ Plain Words p 55 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary pp 252–3 (formalisms); 677 (virtue) Wydick p 13 by way of usage—consider alternatives before using try—by / with / using / no change extra information 1 compound preposition 2 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 125 (by means of) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 B–16 C calculate usage—consider alternatives before using try—work out / find out / decide / suppose / assume / recasting (using, eg a formula) / no change extra information 1 Prefer a less formal alternative if appropriate. 2 Do not use calculate for suppose or assume. example of change The daily rate is calculated in accordance with the following formula worked out as follows: yearly rate 365 further reading Cutts p 27 Fowler’s English Usage p 125 (calculate for suppose/reckon) Howard’s Guide p 65 Howard’s Handbook p 64 Longman English Usage p 105 (calculate for suppose/assume) Partridge p 58 calendar month usage—avoid using if possible try—month extra information see LA, dict, pt 1, defs month and calendar month Month is defined as calendar month. Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 C–1 C call in question usage—avoid using if possible try—recasting extra information 1 formal phrase 2 legalese see also—in question; question example of change The proceeding must not be called in question is not invalid …[or A proceeding for an injunction, declaration or prerogative order must not be brought in relation to…] further reading Cwlth OPC Plain English p 17 called see—in this [provision] called can [also could] usage—consider alternatives before using try—may / might / is (or are) able to / no change extra information 1 Can generally emphasises the objective (or physical) ability to do something. May (or might) generally emphasises permission or possibility. However, in practice the meaning of can and the meaning of may are hard to distinguish. 2 If in doubt prefer may. example of no change The tribunal can deal with a complaint. example of change The committee can may be given any of the following functions in a reference: … further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 30 (can/may) Cambridge Style Guide pp 107–8 (can or may), 168–9 (could or might), 336 (hedge words) Cutts p 33 Fowler’s English Usage pp 126, 186 (could) Garner’s Dictionary p 128 (can/may) Garner’s Legal Style p 105 Garner’s Redbook p 191 (can; may) Howard’s Guide pp 65–6 (can or may) Howard’s Handbook pp 64–5 (can/may) Longman English Usage p 106 (can/may) Partridge p 58 (can and may) Right Words p 65 (can/could) Strunk and White pp 20, 42 Working Words p 90 (can/may) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 C–2 C cancel usage—consider alternatives before using try—revoke / no change extra information For the use of cancel and revoke, see revoke. further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 188 capability usage—avoid using if possible try—capacity / ability / no change extra information vogue word examples of change 1 capability capacity to contract 2 She had a well-developed capability ability to solve difficult problems quickly. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 129 (capacity/capability) Gowers’ Plain Words p 211 capable of usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using eg can or may) extra information Prefer an alternative if appropriate. examples of change 1 a bag capable of being that can be filled with beanbag filling 2 He is capable of doing can do it. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 129 Gowers’ Plain Words p 137 (capable of doing) Partridge p 61 capita see—per capita Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 C–3 C capitalise usage—consider alternatives before using try—draw on / profit / no change extra information vogue word further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 211 carry on / out usage—consider alternatives before using try—make / conduct / perform / recasting (using more specific words) / no change extra information Prefer the most specific, appropriate alternative (if any). see also—perform examples of no change 1 requirements to carry out work 2 a body that is not carried on for the financial profit of its members 3 If a cooperative begins to carry on an activity that is not a primary activity of the cooperative, … 4 The administrator must give the registrar a report on how the administration was carried out. 5 A foreign cooperative must not carry on business in the ACT unless it is registered as a foreign cooperative. examples of change 1 The inquiries were carried out made by the inspector. 2 carry out conduct an inquiry Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 C–4 C case usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using more precise words) / omitting / argument extra information 1 Using case can contribute to loose writing. 2 Avoid using case as an omnibus word. See kind for extra information. see also—as the case may be/requires; as the case may require; if this is not the case; if this is the case; in a case in which/to which/where; in any case; in case; in every case; in the case of examples of no change 1 a case of measles 2 You have no case. examples of change 1 as was formerly the case it used to be 2 in many cases often quite out of touch further reading Asprey pp 163–5 (where) Garner’s Dictionary p 133 Garner’s Legal Style pp 105–6, 183, 205 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 57–8 Longman English Usage pp 112–3 Partridge pp 4 (abstract nouns), 61 (case (of)) Strunk and White p 42 category usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / kind / no change extra information 1 Most legal drafting is expressed in the singular and it is usually unnecessary to distinguish between a class (using, eg category) and its members (see LA, s 145 (b)). Avoid mentioning category unless it is necessary. See class for extra information. 2 If it is necessary to mention class, prefer kind if appropriate. 3 Category originally had a narrower meaning than class. Although the extension of its meaning to a synonym for class has been criticised, it is now well established. further reading Cutts pp 27, 31 Fowler’s English Usage p 135 Partridge p 62 Right Words p 71 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 C–5 C cause usage—consider alternatives before using try—proceeding / ensure / omitting / no change extra information 1 Actions need not usually be taken personally, but can be taken by employees, agents, delegates or, for Ministers and senior officers, by officers of their departments. It is, therefore, usually unnecessary to talk of someone causing something to be done. 2 However, in drafting offences it may be necessary to use cause as a verb to ensure that the thing caused is a result of conduct, eg use ‘cause harm’ rather than use harm as a verb. 3 A cause is someone or something that makes an event happen. Since the word cause itself covers the idea of an explanation of an event, it should not be combined with because of, due to, as a result of or a similarly linking phrase. 4 legal term for lawsuit or proceeding see also—show cause examples of no change 1 the costs of an adjournment caused by the failure 2 cause of action 3 He devoted his life to the cause. 4 A unit owner must not use the unit in a way that causes a nuisance. 5 The unusual cold front caused the severe frosts. examples of change 1 The Minister must cause give a copy of the reference to be given to the authority. 2 The Minister must cause present a copy of the report to be tabled. 3 Remove a buoy that is causing, or may cause, an obstruction to obstructing, or may obstruct, navigation. 4 The registrar must cause enter the notice to be registered in the register. 5 The directors of a company must cause accurate accounts to be kept keep accurate accounts. 6 If the authority refuses the application, it must cause the applicant to be informed of tell the applicant about its decision. 7 A person involved in a ship’s operation (including a crew member) must cause it to be ensure it is operated safely. further reading Blamires’ Plain English pp 208–9 Blamires’ Common Errors pp 57 (cause), 57–8 (caused by) Blamires’ Queen’s English pp 72–4 (cause and result) Butterworths Legal Dictionary pp 38 (agent), 341–2 (delegate) Garner’s Dictionary pp 138–9 (causation), 139–40 (cause), 140 (cause of action; right of action; ground of action) and (cause to be) Garner’s Legal Style p 183 (cause to be done) Howard’s Guide p 70 (cause or causation) Howard’s Handbook p 71 (cause/causation) Longman English Usage p 118 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 C–6 C cause [continued] Mellinkoff’s Dictionary pp 67–8 (cause), 68 (cause of action) New Oxford Dictionary p 291 Partridge pp 62-3 (cause and reason) and (cause to be informed), 317 (source and cause) cease usage—consider alternatives before using try—stop / end / finish / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative. However, do not use stop or end if use seems artificial or unusual—see examples of no change. example of no change If the aged care service ceases to be liable to pay payroll tax, … examples of change 1 the appointment of a person ceases ends 2 The court may issue an injunction even though the conduct has ceased stopped. further reading Cutts pp 27, 31 Evans p 123 Fowler’s English Usage p 137 Garner’s Dictionary pp 141, 369 (formal words) Garner’s Legal Style p 188 (cease and determine) Howard’s Guide p 379 (stop) Howard’s Handbook p 344 (stop/cease/discontinue/terminate) Longman English Usage p 119 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 68 (cease and desist) ceiling usage—consider alternatives before using try—maximum / upper limit / no change extra information 1 vogue word 2 Prefer maximum or limit. 3 Avoid using words like extending, increasing or waiving with ceiling. further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 32 (ceiling, floor) Fowler’s English Usage pp 137–8 Garner’s Dictionary p 141 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 40, 75, 88, 211–2 Howard’s Guide p 71 Howard’s Handbook p 72 Longman English Usage p 119 Partridge p 63 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 C–7 C certainly / certain usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / no change extra information 1 Certainly is a sentence adverb. 2 Certainly and certain can be dogmatic words. 3 Prefer a more neutral alternative if appropriate. 4 Certain is often redundant, eg A certain car ran him over. example of no change Eligibility for registration, Act s 49 (2)—certain unqualified real estate salespeople [in heading] [only if unable to describe better] further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 142–3 (certain), 161 (clearly), 632 (overstatement), 791–2 (sentence adverbs), 926 (weasel words) Garner’s Legal Style p 129 Howard’s Guide p 73 Howard’s Handbook p 73 Longman English Grammar p 976 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary pp 51–2 (beneficiary) Partridge pp 64 (certain), 72 (comparatives, false) Strunk and White p 42 cestui que trust usage—never use try—beneficiary extra information 1 foreign phrase 2 legalese 3 archaism further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 144 Garner’s Legal Style p 186 Garner’s Redbook p 161 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary pp 51–2 (beneficiary) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 C–8 C ceteris paribus usage—never use try—other things being equal extra information foreign phrase further reading Blamires’ Plain English p 114 Cambridge Style Guide p 126 Cutts p 39 Fowler’s English Usage p 140 Garner’s Dictionary p 144 Longman English Usage p 122 chairman / chairwoman usage—never use try— chair / chairperson / convenor / coordinator / moderator / president / presiding member extra information 1 gender-specific word 2 LA, s 187 (1) provides that, if a law establishes a position of chair or chairperson of an entity, the chair or chairperson may be referred to as the chairman, chairwoman, chairperson or chair. LA, s 187 (2) makes similar provision for deputy chairperson. further reading Asprey pp 159–60 Cambridge Style Guide pp 126 (chairman), 576 (-person) Crystal’s English Usage pp 99–112 Cutts p 72 Fowler’s English Usage p 140 (chair, chairperson) Garner’s Dictionary pp 144–5 (chairman; chairwoman; chairperson; chair), 799–803 (sexism) Garner’s Legal Style p 203 Garner’s Redbook p 277 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 177–8 (chairman, chairperson) Howard’s Guide p 73 (chairman, chairperson or the chair) Howard’s Handbook p 74 (chairman/chairperson/the chair) Longman English Usage p 122 (chairperson) New Oxford Dictionary p 301 (chairman/chairperson/chairwoman) Partridge p 64 (chairman) Right Words pp 73–4 (chairman/chairperson), 152–5 ((the) female critique) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 C–9 C chairperson [for chair] usage—avoid using if possible try—chair / convenor / coordinator / moderator / president / presiding member extra information 1 gender-neutral alternative to chairman 2 criticised as an ugly creation 3 Prefer chair, which can be used for either sex with ease. see also—LA, s 187 (Chair and deputy chair etc) example of change The chairperson chair adjourned the meeting. further reading Asprey pp 159–60 (chair) Black’s Law Dictionary p 244 (chair) Cambridge Style Guide p 126 (chairman) Crystal’s English Usage pp 99–112 Fowler’s English Usage p 140 (chair, chairperson) Garner’s Legal Style p 203 (chair) Garner’s Dictionary pp 144–5 (chairman; chairwoman; chairperson; chair), 799–803 (sexism) Garner’s Redbook p 277 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 177–8 (chairman, chairperson) Howard’s Guide p 73 (chairman, chairperson or the chair) Howard’s Handbook p 74 (chairman/chairperson/the chair) Longman English Usage p 122 New Oxford Dictionary p 301 (chair) Partridge p 64 (chairman) Right Words pp 73–4 (chairman/chairperson), 152–5 ((the) female critique) Working Words p 103 (chair) change and alter see—alter Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 C–10 C character usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / recasting / reputation / no change extra information 1 Words like character are vague and abstract, but can be useful on occasion. However, they are often overused and are occasionally redundant. 2 Prefer available words that are more direct and specific. example of no change The applicant must provide 2 character references. example of change conduct of an exemplary character exemplary conduct further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 141 Garner’s Dictionary p 148 (character/reputation) Garner’s Legal Style p 106 (character; reputation) Garner’s Redbook p 192 (character; reputation) Gowers’ Plain Words p 189 Howard’s Handbook p 74 (character/personality/persona) Partridge pp 5 (abstract nouns), 65 (character) Right Words p 40 (attribute/character/property/quality/trait) Strunk and White p 42 chattels usage—avoid using if possible try—goods (if necessary, listing or defining the items to be covered) / personal property extra information 1 legal archaism 2 If possible, use an alternative. 3 If it is necessary to use chattels, a note should be included explaining what it means. See chose in action for an example of a similar note. 4 If personal property is used as an alternative, consider including a note explaining what it means. For example, a note along the following lines could be included. Note Personal property can include intangible personal property, eg a right. further reading Black’s Law Dictionary p 251 (chattel) Butterworths Legal Dictionary pp 185–6 Evans p 123 Garner’s Dictionary p 149 Howard’s Guide p 76 Law Words 1995 pp 34–7 (goods and chattels) Mellinkoff’s Dictionary pp 72–3 (chattel, chattel mortgage, chattel paper, chattel veil) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 C–11 C chose in action usage—avoid using if possible try—recasting (eg by defining what is intended) / thing in action extra information 1 Technical legal term. Sometimes partially anglicised to thing in action. However, the anglicised term is not widely used or understood (even among lawyers). 2 If it is necessary to use the term (in either form), a note should be included explaining what it means. For example, a note along the following lines could be included: Note A thing in action is an intangible personal property right recognised and protected by the law. Examples include debts, money held at a bank, shares, rights under a trust, copyright, and the right to sue for breach of contract. further reading Black’s Law Dictionary p 258 (chose; chose in action) Butterworths Legal Dictionary pp 192–3 Garner’s Dictionary p 153 Garner’s Redbook p 166 (chose in terms of art) Mellinkoff’s Dictionary pp 77–8 (chose in action; thing in action) Christian name usage—never use try—personal name / given name [by contrast with surname / family name] extra information inappropriate term for non-Christians further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 281 (first name or forename) Cwlth Style Manual p 58 (Personal names) Evans p 123 Garner’s Dictionary pp 153, 859–60 (surname; Christian name) Gowers’ Plain Words p 229 (forenames) Howard’s Guide p 169 (first/Christian name) Howard’s Handbook p 170 (first name/Christian name/forename) Partridge p 66 (Christian name) Right Words p 76 (Christian name/first name/given name) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 C–12 C claim [as a verb] usage—consider alternatives before using try—assert / allege / charge / contend / declare / maintain / mention / say / state / no change extra information 1 The strict meaning of to claim is to demand recognition of a right. 2 Claim may imply a degree of suspicion about the truth of what is claimed. Consider a more neutral alternative. 3 The use of claim as a substitute for charge, contend, declare, maintain, mention, say or state is still considered incorrect by some. examples of no change 1 a claim for compensation 2 a claim against the estate example of change The authority claims says that restructuring is necessary. further reading Black’s Law Dictionary p 264 (claim) Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 35 Fowler’s English Usage pp 148–9 Garner’s Dictionary p 159 Garner’s Legal Style p 106 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 33, 213 Howard’s Guide pp 79–80 Howard’s Handbook p 79 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 81 Partridge pp 66-7 Right Words p 77 (claim) Strunk and White pp 42–3 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 C–13 C class usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / kind / type / category / group / no change extra information 1 Most legal drafting is expressed in the singular and it is usually unnecessary to distinguish between a class (using, eg category, class, group, kind or type) and its members (see LA, s 48 and s 145 (b)). Avoid using class unless it is necessary. 2 If it is necessary to use class, use it as infrequently as possible consistently throughout the draft. Avoid making unnecessary, artificial distinctions in using classes (eg the use of kind and type, or class and kind). examples of no change 1 a class 2 dangerous substance 2 a class action examples of change 1 a stated person or a person included in a stated class of persons 2 the Minister may authorise a person or persons included in a class of persons further reading Cwlth OPC Plain English p 22 Garner’s Dictionary p 159 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 82 (class action) clearly / clear usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / no change extra information 1 Clearly may be a sentence adverb. 2 Clearly and clear are dogmatic. 3 Prefer a more neutral alternative if appropriate example of no change She spoke clearly. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 150 (clear, clearly) Garner’s Dictionary pp 161, 632 (overstatement), 792–3 (sentence adverbs), 926 (weasel words) Garner’s Legal Style pp 36, 129, 192–3 Garner’s Redbook p 192 (clearly; obviously) Howard’s Guide p 81 (clear/clearly; clear/plain) Howard’s Handbook p 80 (clear/clearly; clear/plain) Longman English Usage pp 137–8 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary pp 83–4 (clear/clearly/clear days/clear title) close proximity see—in close proximity Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 C–14 C cohabit usage—never use try—live together (in a domestic relationship) extra information formal word see also—LA s 169 (References to domestic partner and domestic partnership) further reading Garner’s Redbook p 193 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary pp 89–90 Right Words p 82 commence usage—consider alternatives before using try— start /begin / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer start or begin if appropriate. 3 However, commence should be used to describe legislation starting (see LA, s 11 (Meaning of commencement notice) and s 80 (References to commencement of law)). 4 Definite nuances exist with start as opposed to begin or commence. Usually used for physical movement, in some contexts start may suggest an abruptness. 5 Use begin for periods of time (use begin with end, not finish). examples of no change on the commencement of this section, … examples of change 1 to commence start an appeal 2 the period commencing beginning on the day the appointment takes effect 3 Before commencing starting to operate the factory, … 4 to commence start a proceeding further reading Blamires’ Plain English p 104 Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 39 Cutts pp 27, 31 Evans p 125 Fowler’s English Usage pp 163, 309 (formal words) Garner’s Dictionary pp 102 (begin), 174–5 (commence, begin, start), 369 (formal words) Garner’s Legal Style p 106 Garner’s Redbook p 158 Gowers’ Plain Words p 213 Howard’s Guide p 87 (commence/start) Howard’s Handbook p 90 (commence/start) Hudson pp 83, 305 (ploddery) Longman English Usage p 151 Partridge pp 71, 331 (start) Right Words p 87 Working Words p 122 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 C–15 C common usage—consider alternatives before using try—mutual / no change extra information Common means shared by 2 or more. Mutual involves reciprocity. Common contrasts with mutual in emphasising sharing rather than reciprocation in a relationship. examples of no change 1 common interest 2 mutual affection further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words pp 131–2 (mutual, common) Cambridge Style Guide pp 149–50 (common or mutual) Garner’s Legal Style p 107 (common; mutual) Garner’s Redbook pp 166, 222 (mutual; common) Howard’s Guide p 88 (common/mutual) Howard’s Handbook p 91 (common/mutual) Oxford English Usage pp 150–51 (mutual) Longman English Usage p 463 (mutual/reciprocal/common) Partridge pp 71-2 (common) Working Words p 122 (common/mutual/reciprocal) Commonwealth usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / Australia / federal / no change extra information 1 can be a redundancy 2 Connection with the Commonwealth is often implied and need not be stated. 3 For geographical references, prefer Australia. For other references, use Commonwealth or Australia as is most appropriate in the context. see also—LA, dict, pt 1, def Commonwealth further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 150 Cwlth Style Manual p 124 Evans p 125, 130 (federal/Commonwealth) Right Words pp 88–91 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 C–16 C comparatively usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / recasting / no change extra information Comparatively can only properly be used if something has been mentioned or implied giving a standard of comparison. If there is no standard of comparison (direct or implied), the use of comparatively is meaningless. example of change Output can be expanded in a comparatively short time. further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words pp 39, 174 (relatively) Fowler’s English Usage p 164 Gowers’ Plain Words p 50 Howard’s Guide p 90 (comparatively/relatively) Longman English Usage p 152 (comparative(ly)/relative(ly)) Right Words p 91 (comparatively/relatively) Working Words p 124 (comparatively/relatively) compare to / with usage—consider alternatives before using try—compare with / compare to / liken to / recasting / no change extra information 1 Something can be compared to or with something else. Historically, a distinction has existed between compare to and compare with, but is no longer consistently observed. Compare to was used to emphasise the way in which people or things are similar to others. In other words, compare to was used when liken to could be substituted. Compare with was used when both similarities and differences are being considered. 2 However, compared to and compared with are becoming indistinguishable in meaning. 3 If compare is used without an object, only with can be used. 4 In using compare, make sure that like is compared with like. examples of no change 1 Shall I compare thee to a summer’s day? 2 If we compare the speaker’s notes with the report of her speech, … examples of change 1 My present house is smaller compared to than my previous house. 2 Money cannot be compared to with happiness. further reading Blamires’ Plain English p 185 (compared with) Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 39 (compare to, compare with) Cambridge Style Guide p 151 (compare with or compare to) Fowler’s English Usage pp 164–5 Garner’s Dictionary p 183 Garner’s Legal Style p 107 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 C–17 C compare to / with [continued] Garner’s Redbook p 194 (compare with; compare to) Gowers’ Plain Words pp 213–4 Howard’s Guide p 91 (compare to/with) Howard’s Handbook p 93 (compare to/with) Longman English Usage pp 152–3 Partridge p 73 (compare to; compare with) Right Words pp 91–2 (compare/contrast) Strunk and White p 43 (compare) Working Words pp 124–5 compelling usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using more precise words) / persuasive / no change extra information 1 can be a weasel word 2 Prefer a more precise, neutral alternative if appropriate. 3 Compelling is not synonymous with impelling. If something is compelling, it forces you to do something; if something is impelling, it encourages or urges you to do something. further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words pp 39–40 (compel/impel) Garner’s Dictionary p 926 (weasel words) Garner’s Redbook p 194 (compel; impel) Howard’s Guide pp 93–4 (compelling/compulsive) Howard’s Handbook pp 93-4 (compelling/compulsive) Longman English Usage p 155 (compel/impel) Right Words p 93 (compelling/compulsive) compile usage—avoid using if possible try—prepare / compose extra information Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate example of change The board must compile prepare a list of approved service providers. further reading Longman English Usage p 157 (compose/compile) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 C–18 C complete [as verb] usage—consider alternatives before using try—finish / end / fill in / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. 3 For the use of end, see cease. 4 Do not unnecessarily qualify complete, ie avoid more complete, less complete, most complete and least complete. see also—entirely and completely; finish and complete; full and complete examples of no change 1 The warrant form was properly completed. 2 The study is the most complete study to date. examples of change 1 The person has satisfactorily completed finished a course of training. 2 Complete Fill in the form. 3 on the completion of when the repairs are finished 4 This book is more complete deals with a wider range of material [or goes into more detail] than the other. further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words pp 40–1 Garner’s Dictionary p 369 (formal words) Howard’s Guide p 90 (complete as an adjective) Howard’s Handbook p 94 (complete) Longman English Usage p 156 completely void usage—avoid using if possible try—void extra information redundancy further reading Black’s Law Dictionary p 1604 (void) Garner’s Dictionary p 919 (void; voidable) compliance see—in compliance with comply see—fail to / fail to comply Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 C–19 C component usage—consider alternatives before using try—part / no change example of no change an electrical component sold separately further reading Blamires’ Plain English pp 35–6 Cutts p 27 compose see—comprise compound [as a verb] usage—consider alternatives before using try— add to / aggravate / complicate / exacerbate / heighten / increase / intensify / multiply / settle / worsen / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Compound means, among other things, to mix together into a composite whole, to settle by mutual agreement. It does not mean (or, at least, did not originally mean) to multiply, make worse, aggravate or complicate. However, usage is shifting. 3 Prefer a more specific alternative if appropriate. examples of change 1 The delay only compounded aggravated the mistake. 2 The strike compounded added to the difficulties caused by the city’s inadequate carparks. further reading Black’s Law Dictionary p 304 (compound) Bryson’s Troublesome Words pp 41–2 Fowler’s English Usage p 167 Garner’s Dictionary pp 187–8, 813 (slipshod extension) Garner’s Redbook p 167 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 214–5 Howard’s Guide p 92 (compound a felony) Longman English Usage p 157 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 C–20 C comprise usage—avoid using if possible try—consist of / composed of / include / contain / made up of / have / formed of / constitute / is extra information 1 formal word 2 If possible, use an alternative. 3 Comprise needs to be used with care. 4 Comprise may be used in 2 ways: (1) to mean made up of, eg ‘Waltzing Mathilda’ comprises 4 verses; and (2) to mean combine to make up, eg the 4 verses comprise ‘Waltzing Mathilda’. However, the second of these uses has been criticised. 5 Comprise does not need of. Do not use comprised of. It is never correct. 6 The difference between comprise and include is that comprise is correct if all the components are listed and include if only some of them are. examples of no change 1 All the parts make up the whole, and the whole comprises all the parts. 2 The Minister may endorse the documents that comprise the scheme. examples of change 1 land comprising consisting of 1 parcel 2 if the property comprises includes the house 3 The register may comprise have divisions. 4 a motor vehicle that comprises is an excavator, bulldozer or forklift truck 5 a device comprising consisting of 2 sets of teeth further reading Blamires’ Plain English p 51 (comprise/consist) Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 42 Cambridge Style Guide p 155 (comprise or composed of) Fowler’s English Usage pp 167–8, 387 (include, comprise) Garner’s Dictionary p 187 (compose; comprise) Garner’s Legal Style p 107 (comprise; compose) Garner’s Redbook p 194 (comprise; compose) Gowers’ Plain Words p 215 Howard’s Guide p 92 (compose/comprise/consist/include) Longman English Usage pp 157–8 (comprise, consist, compose, constitute, include) NZ Legislation Manual p 42 Oxford English Usage p 125 Partridge p 76 (comprise and constitute) Right Words p 94 (compose/comprise) Strunk and White p 43 Working Words pp 126–7 (compose/comprise/constitute) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 C–21 C conceal usage—consider alternatives before using try—hide / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer hide if appropriate. example of no change concealed weapon further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 309 (formal words) Garner’s Dictionary pp 189–90, 369 (formal words) Garner’s Redbook p 158 Howard’s Guide p 93 (conceal/hide) Howard’s Handbook p 95 (conceal/hide) concept usage—consider alternatives before using try—idea / plan / design / invention / thought / program / no change extra information 1 vogue word 2 Prefer a more concrete alternative if appropriate. example of change a new concept idea in personal computing further reading Blamires’ Plain English pp 26–7 (concept/value) Cutts pp 27, 31 Fowler’s English Usage p 169 Garner’s Dictionary p 190 (concept; conception) Garner’s Redbook p 158 Gowers’ Plain Words p 215 Howard’s Guide p 94 Longman English Usage p 158 Working Words p 128 conceptual usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting / no change extra information Conceptual refers to the forming of concepts by generalising from particulars. It does not mean, for example, concept, idea or conception. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 190 Gowers’ Plain Words p 215 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 C–22 C concerned see—as far as … is/are concerned; at least as far as … is/are concerned concerning usage—consider alternatives before using try—about / affecting / in relation to / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Concerning can be used as a conjunction (introducing a clause) or a preposition (introducing a noun). Concerning is often used with jargon (eg ‘Concerning your problem...’). Concerning should, therefore, be used with care to avoid verbosity. 3 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. 4 For the use of affecting, see affect. examples of change 1 a false or misleading statement concerning about the price payable for the land 2 Any relevant indigenous organisation must be consulted about every issue concerning affecting the child or young person. further reading Cutts p 27 Garner’s Legal Style p 49 (as acceptable dangler) Garner’s Redbook p 158 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 18, 135 New Oxford Dictionary p 380 Partridge p 80 (conjunctions, disguised—concerning) concerns see—as concerns / as regards / as respects Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 C–23 C conclude usage—consider alternatives before using try—end / finish / decide extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. examples of no change The countries concluded a free trade agreement. examples of change 1 He concluded finished his speech with a question. 2 The judge concluded decided the case. further reading Black’s Law Dictionary p 308 (conclude) Garner’s Dictionary p 191 Garner’s Redbook p 167 Fowler’s English Usage p 170 Partridge p 77 conclusive see—final and conclusive concur usage—consider alternatives before using try—agree extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. example of no change The third judge concurred with the presiding judge. example of change I concur agree with your argument. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 170 Garner’s Dictionary p 194 conditions see—terms and conditions Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 C–24 C conform usage—consider alternatives before using try—comply / (recasting using eg in accordance with) extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. example of no change He conformed to what was expected of a model son. [or He did what was expected of a model son.] example of change She conformed to complied with the direction. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 157 (conform to / conform with) Garner’s Dictionary p 201 Howard’s Guide p 95 (conform to or with) Howard’s Handbook p 97 (conform to/with) conformity usage—avoid using if possible try—in accordance with / in agreement with / under extra information formal word examples of change 1 The registrar must register an instrument lodged in conformity accordance with this Act. 2 an act done in conformity with under a registered power of attorney confrontation usage—consider alternatives before using try—conflict / argument / disagreement / dispute / no change extra information can be a vogue word further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 216 Howard’s Guide p 95 Longman p 160 Working Words p 129 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 C–25 C conjunction see—in conjunction with connection see—for and/or in connection with; in connection with; in and/or in connection with; in this connection consensus usage—consider alternatives before using try—agreement / no change extra information 1 can be a vogue word 2 Prefer agreement if appropriate. 3 Consensus is inappropriate to use in relation to just 2 people because it means general agreement or collective opinion. 4 Do not use consensus of opinion or general consensus. example of change general consensus general view further reading Black’s Law Dictionary p 323 (consensus) Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 43 Cambridge Style Guide p 160 (consensus or concensus) Fowler’s English Usage p 172 Garner’s Dictionary p 205 Garner’s Legal Style p 108 Gowers’ Plain Words p 216 Howard’s Guide p 96 (consensus of opinion) Howard’s Handbook pp 98–9 (consensus of opinion) Longman English Usage p 162 (consensus/census) Partridge p 80 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 C–26 C consent usage—consider alternatives before using try—agree / approve / permit / acquiesce / no change extra information 1 In general terms, to consent means to give permission for something to happen or to agree to something. Consent has different elements in various areas of the law and needs to be used with care. 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. examples of no change 1 Consent is not a defence to some crimes. 2 consent judgment 3 consent to act 4 consent to marriage examples of change 1 If the authority consents agrees to the request... 2 The solicitor could not accept service without her client’s consent permission. further reading Black’s Law Dictionary p 323 (consent) Butterworths Legal Dictionary pp 249–50, 250 (consent award or decision; consent judgment; consent of the owner; consent order; consent to prosecution; consent to act; consent to marriage; consent to nomination) New Oxford Dictionary p 391 Use the Right Word p 115 (consent/acquiesce/agree/assent/concur/subscribe) Working Words p 48–9 (ascent/assent/consent) consequence usage—consider alternatives before using try—result / effect / outcome extra information formal word see also—as a consequence of; in consequence of example of no change Section 10 sets out the consequences of entering the agreement. examples of change 1 minimise the consequences effects of motor vehicle accidents 2 a financial hardship or other consequence result of the interest remaining subject to the order Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 C–27 C consequential usage—consider alternatives before using try—follows from / no change extra information Consequential has now only 2 meanings in common use. It can mean ‘important’ or ‘self-important’, eg ‘the consequential officials’. It also means ‘in the nature of a consequence or sequel’, eg ‘consequential amendments’ and ‘consequential changes’. In this sense, it is particularly applied to results that are indirect or secondary and incidental, eg ‘consequential loss’. For all other purposes, consequent is the adjective of consequence. However, use follows from rather than is consequent on—see consequent on. further reading Fowler’s English Usage pp 172–3 Garner’s Dictionary p 205 (consequent/consequential) Gowers’ Plain Words p 216 Howard’s Guide p 96 (consequent or consequential) Howard’s Handbook p 99 (consequent/consequential) Partridge p 80 Working Words p 131 (consequent/consequential/subsequent) consequently usage—avoid using if possible try—so / accordingly / recasting (using neutral words) / no change extra information 1 sentence adverb 2 Prefer a more neutral alternative if appropriate. further reading Cutts p 27 Evans p 126 Fowler’s English Usage pp 702–3 (sentence adverbs) Garner’s Dictionary pp 791–2 (sentence adverbs) Garner’s Redbook p 158 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 C–28 C consequent on usage—avoid using if possible try—because of / under / follows from / recasting extra information 1 compound preposition 2 formal phrase 3 usually means a direct result—compare with consequential, which means an indirect result. 4 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. example of change This amendment is consequent on follows from [or gives effect to] an undertaking made by the Minister. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 205 (consequent) Howard’s Guide p 96 (consequent or consequential) Howard’s Handbook p 99 (consequent/consequential) consider see—give consideration to considerable usage—consider alternatives before using try—significant / substantial / omitting / recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information 1 vague word 2 Considerable is not generally appropriate for concrete things, eg a ‘large’ house rather than a ‘considerable’ house. 3 Prefer a more precise alternative if appropriate. further reading Fowler’s English Usage pp 173–4 Gowers’ Plain Words p 52 Longman English Usage p 163 Partridge p 81 Working Words p 131 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 C–29 C consideration [in a non-legal sense] usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information 1 Avoid using consideration as an omnibus word. See kind for extra information. 2 Prefer more precise words if appropriate. see also—give consideration to example of change The consideration that has led to reason for the rejection of your claim …[or Your claim has been rejected because…] further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 174 (considerateness, consideration) Garner’s Legal Style p 205 Gowers’ Plain Words p 4 consist of / in usage—consider alternatives before using try—consist in / consist of / recasting / no change extra information 1 It is generally accepted that there is a difference between consist of and consist in. Consist of refers to the substance of which the subject is made or composed. It is usually used in relation to concrete nouns, especially materials. Consist in defines the subject by referring to its essential features or qualities. It is usually used in relation to abstract concepts. 2 Because consist in is not commonly used and may sound formal, prefer recasting if appropriate. examples of no change 1 The chair consists of wood and metal. 2 The work of the section consists in registering instruments. [or The section registers instruments.] further reading Blamires’ Plain English p 51 (comprise/consist) Cambridge Style Guide p 161 Fowler’s English Usage pp 174–5 (consist) Garner’s Dictionary p 207 Garner’s Redbook p 196 (consist of; consist in) Gowers’ Plain Words p 216 Longman English Usage p 163 Oxford English Usage p 126 Partridge p 81 (consist in and consist of) Working Words p 132 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 C–30 C constitute usage—consider alternatives before using try—form / establish / is / make up / set up / be / recasting (using, eg required for) / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer a less formal alternative if appropriate. examples of no change 1 a change to the club’s constitution 2 The tribunal is constituted by 1 member. [or One member makes up the tribunal.] 3 the person who constitutes the entity examples of change 1 The last of the members constitute form the majority. 2 Six members constitute form a quorum. [or Business may be carried on at the meeting only if at least 6 members are present.] 3 a body constituted established under this Act 4 does not constitute is not the entire interest 5 The making of the order does not constitute is not a conviction for the offence. 6 The giving of information to a territory body must be held to constitute is not a breach of confidence. 7 The chemicals are not close enough to the fuel system to constitute be a fire hazard. 8 a bag that, if filled with beanbag filling, would constitute be a beanbag 9 If the conduct constituting required for an offence consists of … 10 A person is not criminally responsible for an offence if the person’s conduct constituting making up the offence was a result of … 11 The person who carried out the conduct was under a mistaken belief about facts that, had they existed, would have meant that the conduct would not have constituted been an offence. 12 The conduct may constitute be professional misconduct. further reading Cutts p 27 Garner’s Redbook p 158 Partridge p 76 (comprise and constitute) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 C–31 C construct usage—consider alternatives before using try—build / form / frame / put together / make / no change extra information Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. examples of change 1 The factory was constructed built of bricks. 2 If a ship is being constructed built, … construe usage—avoid using if possible try—interpret / omitting / recasting extra information Prefer an alternative. example of change A reference to X is to be construed as a reference to Y. further reading Black’s Law Dictionary p 333 (construe) Collector of Customs v Agfa-Gevaert Ltd (1996) 71 ALJR 123 at 127 Cutts p 27 Fowler’s English Usage pp 175–6 (construct/construe) Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 112 (construction/interpretation) consult with usage—never use try—consult / confer (with) / seek (information or advice) / discuss (with) / ask / recasting extra information 1 phrasal verb 2 Use the simple verb or an alternative. see also—meet with/meet up with; miss out on; visit with examples of change 1 I consulted with my doctor about the rash. [or asked] 2 I intend to consult with my colleagues about your proposal. [or I intend to discuss your proposal with my colleagues. or I will ask my colleagues about your proposal.] 3 He consulted with checked his diary to check see if he was available for the meeting. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 583 (phrasal verbs) Fowler’s English Usage pp 594–5 (phrasal verbs) Gowers’ Plain Words p 184 Howard’s Guide p 98 (consult or consult with) Howard’s Handbook p 101 (consult/consult with) Longman English Usage p 164 (consult) New Oxford Dictionary p 394 (consult) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 C–32 C contained in usage—avoid using if possible try—in / under extra information verbosity example of change a classification contained in under an award contend see—would argue/contend/submit context see—in the context of; where/if the context permits/allows contiguous to usage—avoid using if possible try—next to / adjacent to / adjoining extra information 1 formal word 2 If possible, use an alternative. see also—adjacent; adjoining example of no change the contiguous zone examples of change 1 contiguous adjoining blocks of land 2 She parked her car contiguous next to mine. further reading Black’s Law Dictionary p 338 (contiguous; contiguous zone) Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 260 (contiguous; contiguous zone) Dick p 155 Garner’s Dictionary pp 24 (adjacent; contiguous), 26 (adjoin), 213 Garner’s Legal Style p 183 Garner’s Redbook p 158 Longman English Usage p 166 (contiguous, contagious) New Oxford Dictionary pp 396–7 Partridge p 6 (adjacent; contiguous) Right Words p 12 (adjacent/adjoining/contiguous) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 C–33 C contrary intention see—except where/if a contrary intention appears; unless the contrary intention appears controvert usage—never use try—dispute / deny / oppose extra information formal word further reading Garner’s Redbook p 197 (contravene; controvert) convene usage—avoid using if possible try—call / come together / assemble / arrange extra information formal word example of change The interim clerk must convene call the first meeting. convenience see—at your earliest convenience/at your convenience convey usage—avoid using if possible try—give / transmit / communicate / tell / inform / advise / make known / transfer / carry extra information 1 formal word 2 has a technical meaning in land law eg ‘In a conveyance it is not necessary to use the word ‘grant’ to convey land. Any words that indicate an intention to convey the land are sufficient.’ 3 convey means to transfer real property. further reading Garner’s Redbook p 168 (conveyance in terms of art) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 C–34 C convict usage—consider alternatives before using try—find guilty / recasting / no change extra information 1 Conviction needs to be used with care. For example, it may be possible for a defendant to be found guilty of an offence, but be discharged without conviction. 2 If possible, do not use convict in provisions creating offences. example of change A person who contravenes a notice is guilty of an offence punishable on conviction by... A person must not contravene a notice. Maximum penalty: ..... see also—LA, dict, pt 1, def found guilty convince usage—consider alternatives before using try—persuade / no change extra information 1 Do not use convince to mean persuade. You may convince someone of a fact, or convince someone that you are right, but it is debatable whether you can convince someone to do something. 2 Use convince with that or of, not to. further reading Blamires’ Plain English p 19 (convince, persuade, induce) Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 44 (convince, persuade) Fowler’s English Usage p 182 Garner’s Dictionary pp 222 (convince/persuade), 655–6 (persuade/convince) Garner’s Redbook p 197 (convince; persuade) Gowers’ Plain Words p 217 Longman English Usage p 169 Partridge p 83 Working Words p 138 (convince/persuade) corporate see—body corporate correct see—true and correct could see—can Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 C–35 C course see—during the course of; in the course of; of course covenant usage—consider alternatives before using try—contract under seal / contract / agreement / condition / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 vague word (with a number of meanings) 3 Covenant has a technical legal meaning. 4 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. examples of no change 1 a covenant to enter and view 2 the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights 1966 example of change He entered into a covenant contract [or contract under seal or deed] to sell the land. further reading Black’s Law Dictionary p 391 (covenant) Butterworths Legal Dictionary pp 297–8 Garner’s Dictionary p 234 Garner’s Redbook p 163 (covenant and agree in doublets) Mellinkoff’s Dictionary pp 135–6 (covenant), 116–8 (contract/agreement) crash [as an adjective] usage—avoid using if possible try—condensed / quick / short / intensive extra information vogue word examples of change 1 a crash short course [or condensed course] 2 launch a crash quick program further reading Fowler’s English Usage pp 188–9 Gowers’ Plain Words p 217 Howard’s Guide p 105 Longman English Usage p 175 Partridge p 377 (vogue words) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 C–36 C credence usage—consider alternatives before using try—credibility / plausibility / credulity / recasting (using credible, creditable or a simpler alternative) / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. 3 Credence, credibility, credible, creditable, credulity and credulous are sometimes confused. Credence means belief or trust and also plausibility; credibility, the quality of being believable or trustworthy; credible, believable, convincing or impressive; creditable, deserving of credit or respect; credulity, the quality of being ready to believe; and credulous, gullible or ready to believe. Credulity, like credulous, has negative connotations and implies being too ready to believe. 4 However, there are different views about whether credible can be used to mean convincing or impressive. see also—credibility; credulity/credulous example of change I don’t find her argument credible agree with her argument. further reading Blamires’ Common Errors p 82 (credible) Blamires’ Plain English pp 36–7 (credible/credibility) Cambridge Style Guide p 172 (credible or creditable; credulity or credibility) Crystal’s English Usage pp 57, 120 (at 14) Fowler’s English Usage p 189 (credence, credit, credibility; credible, creditable, credulous) Garner’s Dictionary p 235 (credible; credulous; creditable) Garner’s Legal Style p 109 (credible, creditable, credulous) Garner’s Redbook p 198 (credible; creditable; credulous; incredulous) Gowers’ Plain Words p 217 (credence, credibility, credulity) Howard’s Guide p 106 (credibility; credible or credulous; credit) Howard’s Handbook p 109 (credible/credulous) Hudson p 99 (credible, credulous, credit) Longman English Usage pp 175–6 (credence, credibility), 176 (credible, credulous, creditable) New Oxford Dictionary pp 430 (credence; credibility; credible), 431 (creditable; credulous) Oxford English Usage p 127 (credible) Partridge p 84 (credible; creditable; credulous) Right Words p 101 (credible/creditable) Working Words p 148 (credible/creditable/credulous) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 C–37 C credibility usage—consider alternatives before using try—plausibility / credence / credulity / recasting (using credible, creditable or a simpler alternative) / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer plausibility or another simpler alternative if appropriate. 3 For the use of credence, credibility, credible, creditable, credulity and credulous, see credence. example of no change The government has lost credibility on the issue. example of change The book’s anecdotes have scant regard for credibility plausibility [or are unbelievable]. credulity / credulous usage—consider alternatives before using try—credence / credibility / plausibility / recasting (using, eg gullible) / no change extra information 1 formal word that sometimes has negative connotations 2 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. 3 For the use of credence, credibility, credible, creditable, credulity and credulous, see credence. example of change His credulity gullibility was touching. criminate usage—never use try—incriminate extra information 1 now a needless variant of incriminate 2 becoming archaism further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 237 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 141 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 C–38 C Crown usage—never use try—Territory / Commonwealth / State / government / prosecution / recasting example of change The property is forfeited to the Crown Territory. further reading Fowler’s English Usage pp 191–2 curiously / curious usage—avoid using if possible try—recasting (using neutral words) / no change extra information 1 Curiously is a sentence adverb. 2 Curiously and curious are value-loaded words. 3 Prefer a neutral alternative if appropriate. example of no change Children are naturally curious. example of change I find your argument curious. I do not agree with your argument. further reading Fowler’s English Usage pp 702–3 (sentence adverbs) Garner’s Dictionary pp 791–2 (sentence adverbs) current / currently usage—consider alternatives before using try—now / at present / omitting / no change extra information Current and currently are frequently redundant because currency is implicit in the context. example of no change This section applies if the driver has been engaged in non-local area work at any time in the last 28 days but is not currently engaged in non-local area work. further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 46 (current, currently) Garner’s Redbook p 229 (presently; currently; momentarily) Gowers’ Plain Words p 218 (currently) Howard’s Guide p 109 Howard’s Handbook p 111 Strunk and White p 44 (currently) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 C–39 C curtilage usage—never use try—recasting extra information 1 formal word 2 What is included in a curtilage can be uncertain. further reading Black’s Law Dictionary pp 411–2 Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 313 Garner’s Dictionary p 241 Garner’s Redbook p 198 (curtilage; messuage) Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 145 customary usage—consider alternatives before using try—usual / no change extra information Prefer usual if appropriate. example of no change customary law example of change The work is to be carried out in the customary usual way. further reading Black’s Law Dictionary p 413 (customary) cutting edge see—on the cutting/leading edge Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 C–40 D date usage—consider alternatives before using try—day / recasting / no change extra information 1 Do not use date if day would be appropriate. 2 Use date of commencement of this Act / this regulation only if all provisions commence at the same time (but see LA, s 80). see also—to date examples of no change 1 The magistrate must tell the officer the date and time the warrant was signed. 2 the time and date stated in the notice. 3 the claimant’s date of birth. examples of change 1 beginning on the date day after its expiry 2 on or before the closing date day day see—at the present day day and age see—in this day and age dearth usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Dearth means scarcity and not lack of. 3 Dearth can contribute to abstract, loose writing. Prefer more precise words if appropriate. example of change 1 A dearth of information exists There is very little information on the subject. 2 There is a complete dearth of no authority on the point. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 199 Garner’s Dictionary p 249 Gowers’ Plain Words p 80 Longman English Usage p 186 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 D–1 D debtee usage—never use try—creditor extra information needless variant for creditor further reading Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 189 (-ee) decease / deceased usage—consider alternatives before using try—die / deceased person / dead / death / no change extra information 1 formal words 2 euphemisms 3 Prefer die, deceased person or death, unless the effect would be too abrupt or harsh. 4 Never use ‘the deceased’. example of change A worker is not entitled to weekly compensation if the worker is a deceased person dead. further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 249 (death; demise; decease etc), 251 (decease and deceased etc) Gowers’ Plain Words p 218 Longman English Usage p 188 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 152 (deceased, decedent) Partridge p 88 decide see—hear and decide decide to grant / decide to refuse to grant usage—never use try—give / refuse to give / grant / refuse to grant extra information verbosity Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 D–2 D decision see—make a decision; take a decision deduct usage—consider alternatives before using try—subtract from / take away / take from / take off / no change extra information 1 Prefer take off or subtract from if appropriate. 2 Subtract and deduct both express diminution in total or quantity. To subtract suggests taking a part from a whole or a smaller from a larger, eg to subtract a transfer fee from the amount of a transfer. To deduct suggests taking an amount or quantity from a total or aggregate so as to lessen or lower it, eg to deduct a discount. example of no change The authority may deduct the overpayment amount from the person’s salary. example of change The cost of processing the claim may be deducted from subtracted from the amount of the refund. further reading Cutts p 27 Garner’s Redbook p 199 (deduce; induce; deduct; deduction; induction) Macquarie Dictionary pp 565, 2113 (subtract) Partridge pp 88 (deduce; deduct), 338 (subtract) Random House Dictionary pp 520, 1898 (subtract) Working Words p 163 (deduce/deduct) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 D–3 D deem / deemed usage—never use try—taken / treated as / regarded as / considered / thought / recasting extra information 1 Deem is a formal word for consider, think, judge, treat as or esteem. 2 Deemed used to be frequently used in legislation to create fictions. The abandonment of deemed for this purpose in Australia is now too well established to revert to its previous use. Use taken to create legal fictions. 3 In creating a legal fiction, you should ask— • are you actually creating a legal fiction? • is the artificiality really necessary and appropriate? examples of change 1 I deemed it expedient thought it best not to worry you. 2 He deemed considered it his duty not to vote. 3 A person is deemed taken to consent if … [or, if consent is not ‘fictional’, a person consents if …] further reading Black’s Law Dictionary p 446 Butterworths Legal Dictionary pp 332 (deem) and (deemed credit sale contract), 333 (deemed dividend), (deemed employee), (deemed employer), (deemed income), (deemed manufacturer), (deemed supply) and (deeming clause) Cutts p 27 (deem) Fowler’s English Usage p 201 (deem) Garner’s Dictionary pp 254 (deem), 369 (formal words) Garner’s Legal Style p 109 (deem) Gowers’ Plain English p 218 (deem) Howard’s Guide p 115 (deem) Law Words 1995 pp 13–5 Longman English Usage p 190 (deem) Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 156 (deem and consider) New Oxford Dictionary p 481 NZ Legislation Manual p 42 Partridge pp 32 (archaisms), 89 (deem) Working Words p 163 (deem) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 D–4 D default usage—consider alternatives before using try—failure / recasting / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. example of no change the default setting example of change in default of appearance if the person does not appear further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 334 Working Words p 165 defer usage—consider alternatives before using try—delay / put off / postpone / no change extra information Do not use defer if delay is meant. examples of no change 1 I defer to your view. 2 The court may defer the operation of the order. 3 A person whose obligation to pay an amount is deferred because of the making of an application must pay interest. example of change She sought to defer delay the inevitable. further reading Black’s Law Dictionary p 454 Cutts p 27 Fowler’s English Usage p 201 (extended forms and derivatives) Longman English Usage p 191 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 D–5 D definite / definitely / definitive usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / definite / definitely / emphatic / no change extra information 1 vogue words 2 Definitely and definite are often used unnecessarily as emphasisers (see examples of change). 3 Definitive differs from definite by giving the idea of authority, conclusiveness, exhaustiveness or finality. A definite offer is an offer clear and precise in its terms. A definitive offer is an offer said to be the last word by the person making it. 4 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. see also—actually/actual; real/really examples of change 1 Lead is definitely harmful to a worker’s health. 2 The Minister approved the definite appointment of 2 arbitrators. 3 His answer was a definitive definite [or emphatic] no. further reading Blamires’ Common Errors p 86 (definite/ definitive) Blamires’ Plain English p 53 (definite/ definitive) Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 53 (definite, definitive) Cambridge Style Guide p 194 (definite or definitive) Crystal’s English Usage pp 57, 120 Fowler’s English Usage pp 19 (actually), 202 (definite, definitely) and (definite, definitive) Garner’s Dictionary pp 257 (definite; definitive), 919 (vogue word) Garner’s Legal Style p 33 (vogue word) Garner’s Redbook p 200 (definite; definitive) Gowers’ Plain Words pp 53, 219 (definitive) Howard’s Guide pp 115–6 (definite and definitely), 116 (definite and definitive) Howard’s Handbook p 120 (definite/definitive) Hudson p 305 (ploddery (definitive for definite)) Longman English Usage p 191 (definite, definitive) Partridge pp 89 (definite and definitive), 280 (really, actually and definitely) Right Words p 108 (definite/definitive) Working Words p 165 (definite/definitive) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 D–6 D degree usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / recasting / no change extra information 1 Degree is vague and abstract, but can sometimes be useful. Consider if it is necessary because it is often overused. 2 Prefer words that are more direct and specific. example of no change 1 She has an honours degree. 2 sexual assault in the first degree 3 …the degree of rotation allowed… 4 …to a significant degree… 5 …type or degree of disability… example of change 1 to a serious degree seriously 2 in a disastrous degree disastrously 3 may use a reasonable degree of force further reading Blamires’ Common Errors p 87 Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 339 (degree of force, degree of risk) Fowler’s English Usage pp 202–3 Gowers’ Plain Words p 189 Howard’s Guide p 116 Howard’s Handbook p 120 (to a degree) Longman English usage p 192 Partridge pp 4 (abstract nouns), 89 (degree, in a) delegate [as a noun] usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / no change extra information 1 can be a redundancy 2 It is usually unnecessary to refer to delegates exercising powers (see LA, s 239 and on delegations generally, see LA, pt 19.4.) further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 340 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 D–7 D deleterious usage—never use try—harmful extra information formal word example of change a substance that has a deleterious harmful effect on the user further reading Black’s Law Dictionary p 459 Gowers’ Plain Words p 219 Longman English Usage p 192 deliver usage—consider alternatives before using try—give / provide / supply / recasting / no change extra information 1 can be formal word for give, provide or supply 2 can be a vogue word, eg ‘Will the Government deliver on tax cuts?’ 3 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. example of no change When can you deliver the car? example of change 1 the cost of delivering providing dental services 2 The jury delivered gave its verdict. see also—signed, sealed and delivered further reading Blamires’ Common Errors p 87 Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 342 (delivery) Garner’s Dictionary pp 262–3 (delivery) Howard’s Guide p 116 Howard’s Handbook p 121 Longman English Usage p 193 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 161 Partridge p 377 (vogue words) delusion see—illusion Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 D–8 D demand usage—consider alternatives before using try—require / ask / no change extra information 1 can be formal word for require or ask 2 Prefer require or ask if appropriate. examples of no change 1 Her solicitor sent a letter of demand. 2 supply and demand 3 The wolf demanded to be let in. further reading Blamires’ Common Errors p 87 Fowler’s English Usage p 204 (for preposition usage with demand) Howard’s Guide p 117 Howard’s Handbook p 121 (demand from/of/on) Longman English Usage p 193 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 162 Partridge p 89 demise usage—never use try—lease / transfer / death / end / downfall / recasting extra information 1 formal word 2 euphemism for death 3 Ambiguous—can have various technical legal meanings 4 Do not use demise to mean end or downfall. examples of change 1 His demise death is remembered with sadness. 2 Acid rain caused the demise end of fishing in the lake [or ended fishing in the lake]. 3 The conflict of interest scandal led to the Minister’s demise resignation. further reading Black’s Law Dictionary p 464 Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 53 Butterworths Legal Dictionary pp 343–4 Blamires’ Common Errors p 87 Fowler’s English Usage p 204 Garner’s Dictionary pp 249 (death; demise; deceased etc), 264, 369 (formal words) Howard’s Guide p 117 Garner’s Redbook p 168 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 163 Partridge p 89 Right Words p 110 (demise) Working Words p 168 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 D–9 D demonstrate usage—consider alternatives before using try—show / no change extra information 1 can be formal word for show 2 Prefer show if appropriate. example of no change The detective demonstrated to the court how the gun had been fired. example of change They demonstrated showed their appreciation by giving flowers. de novo usage—never use try—recasting extra information 1 foreign phrase 2 A trial de novo is a completely new trial, as distinguished from a review of the first trial. example of change The appeal is a hearing de novo of the matter anew. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 322 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 113 depart usage—consider alternatives before using try—leave / go away / recasting / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer leave or go away if appropriate. example of change The port captain may require the ship to depart from leave the pilotage area. Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 D–10 D depend usage—consider alternatives before using try—depend on / no change extra information It is wrong in writing, though common in speech, to omit the on after depends. example of change It depends on whether it rains before harvesting. further reading Blamires’ Plain English pp 214–5 (depend/depending) Fowler’s English Usage p 205 Gowers’ Plain Words p 219 Howard’s Guide p 118 (depend, depend on or upon) Howard’s Handbook p 124 (depend on/upon) Longman English Usage p 195 dependant / dependent usage—consider alternatives before using try—dependent / dependant / no change extra information 1 Dependant is a noun meaning a person who depends on someone else for support. 2 Dependent is an adjective meaning relying on or subject to something else. further reading Blamires’ Plain English p 53 Cambridge Style Guide pp 196–7 (in support of a more flexible approach) Fowler’s English Usage p 205 Gowers’ Plain Words p 219 Howard’s Guide pp 94 (conditional or dependent), 118 (dependant or dependent) Howard’s Handbook pp 96 (conditional/dependent), 123 (dependant/dependent) Longman English Usage p 195 Partridge p 90 Right Words p 110 (dependant/dependent) Working Words p 169 depth see—in depth deputy chairperson see—chairperson Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 D–11 D derogate usage—never use try—recasting (using, eg does not limit / is in addition to / is an example of) extra information 1 formal word 2 legalese examples of change 1 This section does not derogate from limit section 10. 2 Without derogating from limiting section 10, … [Note It would be preferable to recast the clause as a separate provision in a positive form (see example 1).] described usage—consider alternatives before using try—mentioned / stated / specified / no change extra information 1 Prefer mentioned if appropriate. 2 Be careful not to draw artificial distinctions in provisions by using different words to say essentially the same thing, eg do not say in one provision ‘a person mentioned in section x’, and in another provision ‘a thing described in section y’, if the person or thing is only being identified by the reference. examples of change 1 the condition described mentioned in subsection (3) 2 a student described mentioned in section 6 designate usage—avoid using if possible try—name / choose / declare extra information formal word Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 D–12 D desires usage—consider alternatives before using try—wishes /wants / no change extra information Prefer wishes or wants. example of change A person who desires wants to carry out work on a road must give written notice to the authority. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 219 Howard’s Guide p 120 (desire, want or will) Howard’s Handbook p 125 (desire/want/wish) Longman English Usage p 198 desist usage—never use try—stop / end / cease / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative. 3 For the use of end and stop, see cease. further reading Cutts p 27 Evans p 128 Garner’s Dictionary pp 270, 369 (formal words) Gowers’ Plain Words p 219 Longman English Usage p 198 despatch see—dispatch Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 D–13 D despite usage—avoid using if possible try—omitting / although / recasting extra information 1 If possible, avoid using despite [provision/instrument] (see subject to). 2 For the use of the fact that with despite, see the fact that. further reading Blamires’ Plain English pp 215–6 Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 803 (notwithstanding) Cutts p 27 (despite the fact that) Garner’s Redbook p 160 (despite the fact that) Howard’s Guide p 120 (despite, despite of, in spite of) Howard’s Handbook p 126 (despite/despite of/in spite of) Law Words 1995 pp 53–5 (notwithstanding) Longman English Usage p 198 NZ Legislation Manual pp 43–4 (notwithstanding–subject to) detain usage—consider alternatives before using try—hold (in custody) / arrest / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 270 (detention), 369 (formal words) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 D–14 D determine usage—consider alternatives before using try—decide / settle / fix / conclude / end / recasting (using work out / find out) / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Never use as an alternative to end 3 Prefer decide or another alternative if appropriate. see also—hear and determine examples of no change 1 A determination under subsection (4) is a disallowable instrument. 2 The Minister may determine fees for this Act. examples of change 1 the amount determined in accordance with worked out as follows: 2 determining deciding the class of an area 3 to determine decide the level of the substance 4 a device to help determine fix a ship’s position 5 A trustee holds office on the terms determined decided by the Minister. 6 the tests for determining deciding 7 the most recent valuation determined decided under section 10 8 Either party may determine end the lease further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 354 Cutts p 27 Garner’s Dictionary pp 271, 369 (formal words) Gowers’ Plain Words p 219 Howard’s Guide p 121 (determine or find out) Howard’s Handbook p 126 (determine/find out) Longman English Usage p 200 detriment usage—consider alternatives before using try—harm / injury / damage / loss / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer a less formal alternative if appropriate. further reading Black’s Law Dictionary p 481 Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 354 Gowers’ Plain Words p 219 (detrimental) Mellinkoff’s Dictionary pp 167–8 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 D–15 D develop usage—consider alternatives before using try—arise / happen / take place / come / no change extra information 1 vague word 2 The primary use of develop is to give the idea of a gradual unfolding or building up. But increasingly used in the sense of any change in a situation (eg ‘a sudden development’). 3 Prefer a more precise alternative if appropriate. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words pp 17, 220 Howard’s Guide p 121 Howard’s Handbook p 127 Longman English Usage p 200 Partridge p 92 devise [by will] usage—avoid using if possible try—give / give by will extra information 1 Devise is a technical legal term meaning to give an interest in land by will. The equivalent term for personal property is bequeath. However, devise will be taken to include personal property if that is clearly the intention of the testator. 2 If it is necessary to use the term devise, a note should be included explaining what it means. 3 Similarly, if the alternative give by will is used in legislation, consideration should be given to including a note explaining that it means the same as the technical legal term. 4 If possible, use an alternative to devise. see also—bequeath; give, devise and bequeath examples of change 1 I devise give my house to my daughter, Bronwyn. 2 She devised gave her house to the foundation. [If necessary, making it clear that the gift was made by will.] further reading Black’s Law Dictionary p 483 Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 355 Garner’s Dictionary pp 104–5 (bequeath), 273 (devise; bequeath) Garner’s Redbook pp 169, 201 (devise; bequest; legacy) Law Words 1995 pp 31–3 (give, devise and bequeath) Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 269 (give, devise and bequeath) New Oxford Dictionary p 506 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 D–16 D devise [plan or invent] usage—consider alternatives before using try—plan / invent / arrange / work out / no change extra information 1 Devise means to plan or invent a complex procedure, system or mechanism by careful thought. It should not be used a synonym for any plan or arrangement. 2 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. example of no change She devised an ingenious system to separate the waste into various useful products. example of change He devised worked out the shortest route between work and home. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 273 (devise; bequeath) Garner’s Redbook p 169 Longman English Dictionary p 201 (device, devise) New Oxford Dictionary p 506 Partridge p 92 (device; devise) Right Words p 112 (device/devise) Working Words p 176 (device/devise) dichotomy usage—consider alternative before using try—difference / conflict / gap / division / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Dichotomy is properly used to differentiate between 2 mutually exclusive groups and should not be used to mean simply difference, conflict or gap. 3 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. example of no change the dichotomy between theory and practice example of change The dispute widened the dichotomy gap between the 2 groups. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 211 Gowers’ Plain Words p 220 Longman English Usage p 203 Partridge p 93 Working Words p 177 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 D–17 D diem see—per diem different to / than usage—consider alternatives before using try—different from / recasting / no change extra information 1 Different from (but indifferent to) is the normal usage, although different to and different than are sometimes used. Different from contrasts with similar to. 2 The use of different to and different than has been criticised. As there is usually little to be gained by using either phrase, different from or recasting should generally be preferred. 3 Prefer different from or recasting if appropriate. example of no change His writing style is similar to hers, but different to most peoples’. example of change The procedure in rule 8 is similar to the procedure in rule 9, but different to from the procedure in rule 2. further reading Blamires’ Plain English p 188 (different) Blamires’ Queen’s English pp 20–1 (different from / other than) Bryson’s Troublesome Words pp 55–6 (different from, to, than) Cambridge Style Guide pp 203–4 (different from, different to, and different than), 746 (than) Evans p 128 (different from/to/than) Fowler’s English Usage pp 212–3 (different) Garner’s Dictionary pp 275–6 (different (from) (than)) Garner’s Legal Style p 110 (different than) Garner’s Redbook p 201 (different from; different than) Gowers’ Plain Words p 220 (different) Howard’s Guide p 124 (different from, to or than) Howard’s Handbook p 131 (different from/to/than) Hudson pp 113-4 (differ(ent/ently) from/than/to) Longman English Usage p 206 (different) New Oxford Dictionary p 514 (different) Oxford English Usage pp 130–1 Partridge p 356 (than, different) Right Words p 113 (different from/different to) Strunk and White p 44 (different than) Working Words pp 178–9 (different from / different to) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 D–18 D differ with usage—consider alternatives before using try—differ from / recasting / no change extra information 1 In the sense of to be different, the idiom is to differ from. In the sense of to disagree, it is either differ from or differ with. However, differ from is the normal usage. 2 Prefer differ from or recasting if appropriate. 3 Differ from can be ambiguous in some contexts. For example, ‘She differs from her brother’ can mean that they are different in particular respects or hold different opinions. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 212 (differ) Garner’s Dictionary p 275 (differ (from) (with)) Gowers’ Plain Words p 220 (differ) Garner’s Redbook p 201 (differ from; differ with) Howard’s Guide p 124 (differ from or with) Howard’s Handbook pp 131–2 (differ from/with) Hudson pp 113–4 (differ (ent/ently) from/than/to) Longman English Usage p 206 (differ) New Oxford Dictionary p 514 (differ) Partridge p 94 (differ from; differ with) dilemma usage—consider alternatives before using try—difficulty / plight / predicament / problem / difficult choice / difficult situation / no change extra information 1 Traditionally to be in a dilemma meant to be faced with 2 (and only 2) alternative courses of action, each of which is unpleasant or difficult. Like alternative, dilemma is now appropriately used where there are more than 2 choices. However, the number of choices should be definite and each of them must be unpleasant or difficult. 2 Dilemma should not be used to mean any difficulty or predicament. For this, use an alternative. example of no change He was in a dilemma; should he resign or should he face the disciplinary proceeding? example of change We are in a dilemma have a difficult choice about where to take our holidays. further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 56 Fowler’s English Usage p 214 Garner’s Dictionary pp 277, 813 (slipshod extension) Gowers’ Plain Words p 221 Howard’s Guide p 125 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 D–19 D dilemma [continued] Howard’s Handbook p 132 Hudson p 115 Longman English Usage p 207 New Oxford Dictionary p 516 Partridge p 94 Right Words p 113 Working Words p 179 directly usage—consider alternatives before using try—direct / when / immediately / recasting / no change extra information Direct, although an adjective, is, like directly, an adverb. To avoid ambiguity, it is better to confine directly to its meaning of immediately in time and so avoid the possibility of confusion between, eg ‘the Minister is going to Sydney direct’ and ‘the Minister is going to Sydney directly’. examples of change 1 The tenant may arrange directly direct with the authority for a reading of the meter. 2 Please ring me directly when as soon as you receive this letter. further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 205–6 (direct or directly) Fowler’s English Usage p 215 Gowers’ Plain Words p 221 Howard’s Guide pp 125–6 (direct or directly) Howard’s Handbook p 133 (direct/directly) Longman English Usage p 208 Partridge p 94 disburse [also disbursement] usage—avoid using if possible try—pay / pay out extra information formal word example of no change Counsels’ fees are generally a disbursement. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 363 (disbursement) Cutts p 27 Gowers’ Plain Words p 221 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 D–20 D discharge see—pay, satisfy and discharge; perform and discharge; relieve and discharge disclaim usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using not responsible / not claimed / not accepted) / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. example of no change The trustee in bankruptcy may disclaim property vested in the trustee. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 365 (disclaim) and (disclaimer) Garner’s Dictionary p 252 (disclaim; declaim) Garner’s Redbook p 202 (disclaim; declaim) Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 171 disclose usage—consider alternatives before using try—inform / mention / point out / say / show / state / tell / reveal / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. example of no change A person must not disclose confidential information. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 221 Howard’s Guide p 127 (disclose or reveal) Howard’s Handbook p 135 (disclose/reveal) Longman English Usage p 210 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 D–21 D discontinue usage—consider alternatives before using try—end / stop / finish / cease / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Do not use discontinue as a pretentious synonym for end, stop, finish or cease. 3 For the use of end and stop, see cease. examples of no change 1 The plaintiff discontinued the proceeding. 2 That line of shoes has been discontinued. example of change He discontinued stopped reading the book. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary pp 366–7 (discontinuance of proceedings) Cutts p 27 Garner’s Redbook p 158 Longman English Usage p 210 Howard’s Guide p 371 (stop, cease, discontinue or terminate) Howard’s Handbook p 344 (stop/cease/discontinue/terminate) disinterested usage—avoid using if possible try—unbiased / impartial / objective / lacking interest / bored / uninterested / indifferent extra information 1 Disinterested means unbiased by personal interest. It is sometimes used to mean uninterested (ie not interested) or indifferent. Its use in the second sense is controversial. 2 The distinction between disinterested and uninterested does not appear to be well understood. Because there is little point in attempting to maintain a distinction that is not widely accepted and understood and there are appropriate alternatives, disinterested is best avoided. 3 If possible, use an alternative. further reading Blamires’ Plain English p 54 (disinterested/uninterested) Blamires’ Queen’s English p 233 (disinterested (uninterested)) Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 57 (disinterested, uninterested) Cambridge Style Guide p 210 (disinterested or uninterested) Fowler’s English Usage pp 218–9, 808 (uninterested) Garner’s Legal Style p 110 Garner’s Redbook pp 169, 202 (disinterested; uninterested) Gowers’ Plain Words p 222 Howard’s Guide p 397 (uninterested or disinterested) Howard’s Handbook p 137 (disinterested/uninterested) Longman English Usage p 212 New Oxford Dictionary p 530 Partridge p 95 Right Words p 410 (uninterested/disinterested) Strunk and White p 44 Working Words p 185 (disinterested/uninterested) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 D–22 D dispatch usage—avoid using if possible try—send / post extra information 1 formal word for send 2 Do not spell as despatch. further reading Cutts p 27 (despatch) Howard’s Guide p 129 (dispatch or despatch) Howard’s Handbook p 137 (dispatch/despatch) Partridge p 95 disseminate usage—avoid using if possible try—circulate / distribute / publish / issue / send extra information formal word diverge / divergent usage—consider alternatives before using try—differ / different / no change extra information If 2 paths diverge, they get further away from each other. Diverge and divergent do not mean the same thing as differ and different. Their meanings differ, but they do not diverge. see also—different to/than further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 55 (differ, diverge) Gowers’ Plain Words p 222 Howard’s Guide p 128 (discrepancy or divergence) Howard’s Handbook p 136 (discrepancy/divergence) Longman English Usage p 217 Working Words p 178 (differ/diverge) divided into usage—consider alternatives before using try—composed of / separated / broken into / split between / no change extra information An apple, halved, is divided into sections, but an apple is composed of seeds, flesh and skin. further reading Strunk and White p 44 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 D–23 D does not exceed usage—consider alternatives before using try—not exceeding / not greater than / not more than / at most / not over / up to / recasting (using under / less than / lighter than / shorter than / smaller than / younger than) / no change extra information Prefer an alternative. Generally, prefer recasting if appropriate. example of change the aggregate quantity does not exceed is not more than … doing see—capable of doing domicile usage—consider alternatives before using try—house / (place of) residence / recasting (using, eg place where the person lives / usually lives / resides) / no change extra information 1 technical legal concept 2 Also used as a formal, pretentious word for a person’s home. Do not use domicile to mean home or residence. example of no change His domicile of origin is Italy. example of change I have engaged a builder to renovate my domicile house. further reading Black’s Law Dictionary p 523 Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 383 Cutts p 28 (dwelling, domicile) Garner’s Dictionary p 291 Garner’s Redbook p 169 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary pp 179–80 New Oxford Dictionary p 547 Partridge p 96 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 D–24 D donate [also donation] usage—consider alternatives before using try—give / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer give if appropriate. example of no change she donated generously to the red cross further reading Fowler’s English Usage pp 225–6, 309 (formal words) Garner’s Dictionary pp 292, 369 (formal words) Gowers’ Plain Words p 222 Longman English Usage p 220 Right Words p 120 doubt whether / if / that usage—consider alternatives before using try—doubt whether / doubt if / doubt that / no change extra information 1 Idiom requires whether or if after a positive statement and that after a negative statement. 2 Consider the alternatives before using doubt whether (see whether). further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 60 (doubt if, that, whether) Gowers’ Plain Words pp 222–3 Howard’s Guide p 134 Howard’s Handbook p 142 (doubt if/that/whether) Longman English Usage p 223 Partridge p 97 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 D–25 D due usage—consider alternatives before using try—payable / owing / expected (at) / planned (for) / proper / adequate / recasting (using, eg merited) / omitting / no change extra information 1 Traditionally, due (when used in relation to a payment) contained an ambiguity, because it could mean either (1) ‘payable; owing; constituting a debt’ or (2) ‘immediately payable’. Sense (1) relates to the fact of indebtedness, sense (2) to the time of payment. Today, sense (2) is almost invariably the intended one. 2 Because a debt cannot be due without also being payable, the doublet due and payable is unnecessary in place of due. However, due and payable has been interpreted to mean required to be paid immediately. If that meaning is intended, it is preferable to say so rather than use the doublet due and payable. 3 The use of due to mean the proper quality or extent is often unnecessary. 4 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. 5 For the use of adequate, see sufficient. see also—due to examples of no change 1 the day when the licence is due for renewal 2 She was due for a promotion. 3 She turned left and drove due south down the road. 4 due diligence 5 due process of law 6 due skill and care 7 due date (for, eg payment) examples of change 1 due and payable [or payable immediately] 2 due for payment payable 3 payments due amounts payable 4 the commissioner must have due regard to consider [or take into account] 5 the amount of the levy is due and owing payable 6 debt due payable to the Territory 7 due proper notice [Note It would be better to explain what due/proper means, eg given in time and complying with certain requirements] 8 The new boundaries will take effect for the election that is due to be held before 2008. 9 He is due expected back soon. 10 He was only taking what was due owed to him. 11 He had paid his membership dues fees for years. 12 due proper administration of justice 13 due proper skill and care Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 D–26 D due [continued] further reading Blamires’ Common Errors p 101 Blamires’ Queen’s English p 242 Butterworths Legal Dictionary pp 393 (due administration of justice), (due and payable) and (due diligence), 1104-5 (standard of care) Garner’s Dictionary pp 298–9, 299 (due process of law) Mellinkoff’s Dictionary pp 181–3 New Oxford Dictionary p 570 (due, due date and due diligence) due to [as adjective / preposition] usage—consider alternatives before using try—because of / since / owing to / as /caused by / recasting / no change extra information 1 compound preposition 2 The traditional view is that due to (in the sense of because) is an adjective and must be attached to a noun. Despite the increasing use of due to as a preposition, the traditional view still has its strong supporters. Until the use of due to as a preposition becomes more firmly established, it is best not used as a preposition. 3 The simplest approach is to avoid due to altogether (except in the sense of required or owed as a legal or moral obligation) and to use because of (or a similar prepositional phrase). Another approach is to remember that due to should be regarded with suspicion unless it is used in the sense of caused by. (According to the traditional view, due to can rarely be used to begin a sentence. Due to at the beginning of a sentence should be treated with particular suspicion.) 4 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. 5 Due to the fact that can usually be replaced by because (see the fact that). example of no change I have 2 weeks leave due to me. examples of change 1 He was absent due to because of illness. 2 She lost the case due to because of her damaging admissions. further reading Blamires’ Common Errors pp 101–3 Blamires’ Plain English pp 206–8 Blamires’ Queen’s English pp 74, 129–33 Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 61 Cambridge Style Guide p 219 (due to or owing to) Cutts p 28 Fowler’s English Usage pp 232–3 Garner’s Legal Style p 111 Garner’s Dictionary pp 298–9 Garner’s Redbook p 204 (due to; because of) Gowers’ Plain Words p 109 Howard’s Guide p 137 (due to or owing to) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 D–27 D due to [as adjective / preposition] [continued] Howard’s Handbook p 144 (due to/owing to) Hudson pp 120, 319–20 (prepositional phrases) Longman English Usage p 227 New Oxford Dictionary p 570 Partridge p 98 Right Words p 125 (due to/owing to) Strunk and White pp 44–5 Working Words p 66 (because of/owing to/due to) duly usage—avoid using if possible try—properly / omitting extra information 1 formal word 2 Duly is usually unnecessary. examples of change 1 a duly properly completed form [Note It would usually not be necessary to substitute ‘properly’. If something needs to be substituted it would be better to explain what ‘properly completed’ means] 2 duly incorporated further reading Cutts pp 33–4 Garner’s Dictionary pp 299 (duly authorised), 926 (weasel words) Howard’s Guide p 137 Howard’s Handbook p 144 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary pp 181–3 duration see—for the duration of during usage—consider alternatives before using try—when / while / for / in / throughout / no change extra information Prefer an alternative if appropriate. see also—during such time as/during the time that; during the course of; during which; for and during example of no change The register may be inspected during normal working hours. examples of change 1 a report on the commissioner’s operations during for the year 2 the number of claims received during in the previous month 3 during the month of in March 2007 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 D–28 D during such time as / during the time that usage—never use try—while / as long as / during extra information verbosity further reading Evans p 129 (during such time as) Garner’s Dictionary p 300 Garner’s Legal Style p 183 Garner’s Redbook p 160 Gowers’ Plain Words p 60 Longman English Usage p 228 (during) Wydick p 16 during the course of usage—avoid using if possible try—while / during extra information verbosity further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 300 Garner’s Redbook p 160 Longman English Usage p 228 (during) during which usage—consider alternatives before using try—when extra information 1 compound preposition 2 Prefer when if appropriate. example of change the hours of the day during which when duty usage—consider alternatives before using try—function / recasting (using must) / role / obligation / no change extra information 1 Function is defined in the LA, dict., pt 1 to include authority, duty and power (see also def exercice). 2 Prefer function to duty, except to refer exclusively to an obligation. see also—it is the duty of example of change It is the duty of the insurer to The insurer must make payments to the claimant. Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 D–29 D dwell usage—consider alternatives before using try—live / reside / recasting / no change extra information 1 formal word for live (as a resident). 2 becoming an archaism for live 3 Prefer live or reside if appropriate. example of no change She let her eyes dwell on them for a moment. examples of change 1 He has dwelt lived in Canberra for almost 30 years. 2 Don’t dwell on live in the past. further reading Black’s Law Dictionary p 546 Fowler’s English Usage p 234 Garner’s Redbook p 158 Longman English Usage p 229 New Oxford Dictionary p 557 Partridge p 32 (archaism) dwelling / dwelling house usage—avoid using if possible try—house (if necessary after defining to include part of a house) / home / recasting (using, eg place where the person lives / usually lives / resides) extra information 1 formal word 2 Dwelling house has an established legal meaning. 3 If possible, use an alternative. example of change Service of an originating application in a proceeding to recover unoccupied land may be made by posting a copy of the application on a door of a dwelling house on the land. further reading Black’s Law Dictionary p 546 Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 399 (dwelling house) Cutts p 28 (dwelling, domicile) Garner’s Dictionary p 301 (dwelling house; dwelling; usual place of abode) New Oxford Dictionary p 577 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 D–30 E each usage—consider alternatives before using try—a / an / the / omitting / recasting (using, eg all) / no change extra information 1 Each should be used only when necessary. 2 If the subject of the sentence is plural, it is almost never necessary to use each. If the subject is singular, use each only if the meaning of the sentence would be unclear without it, eg use of a would allow the unintended interpretation that an obligation is discharged by applying it to a single member of a class rather than any or all of them. 3 If each is the subject of a sentence, the verb is singular and so is any pronoun, eg ‘Each student has a room to herself’. If a plural noun or pronoun is the subject, with each in opposition, the verb is plural, eg ‘They have a room each’. 4 If singular nouns linked by and are accompanied by each, the verb is singular, eg ‘Each student and graduate is entitled to attend the ceremony’. 5 Avoid using between with each. see also—on each occasion when example of no change Each account must be fully audited. example of change The receipts A receipt must each be made in triplicate. further reading Asprey pp 122 (each and every), 165–6 (Any, each, every and all) Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 62 Cambridge Style Guide pp 28–9 (1. verb–subject agreement) Dick p 144 Dickerson p 131 Fowler’s English Usage p 235 Garner’s Dictionary pp 302–3 Garner’s Redbook pp 139-40 (Idioms with ‘each’ and ‘every’) Gowers’ Plain Words pp 108 (between each), 129–30 Howard’s Guide p 139 (each; each and every; each other or one another) Howard’s Handbook p 146 (each; each and every; each other/one another) Longman English Usage p 230 NZ Legislation Manual pp 40–1 Partridge p 99 Right Words p 127 (each/every) Strunk and White p 10 Working Words p 196 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 E–1 E each and all usage—never use try—each / all / a / an / the / recasting extra information doublet further reading Garner’s Redbook p 163 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 186 each and every usage—never use try—each / every / a / an / the / all / recasting extra information doublet further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 302 Garner’s Legal Style p 111 Garner’s Redbook p 163 Howard’s Guide p 139 Howard’s Handbook p 146 Longman English Usage p 230 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 186 Partridge p 99 Strunk and White p 45 earliest see—at your earliest convenience / at your convenience earnt usage—never use try—earned extra information generally regarded as non-standard English example of change earnt earned income further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 236 (earn) Howard’s Guide p 139 (earned or earnt) Howard’s Handbook p 146 (earned/earnt) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 E–2 E easterly (direction) / eastwardly /eastward(s) usage—consider alternatives before using try—east / eastward / eastwards / eastern / no change extra information 1 Prefer east or eastwards to easterly if appropriate. 2 Easterly is appropriately applied to winds, airstreams, currents etc, and means ‘from the east’. It is also appropriately used to modify words implying motion or a position (notionally) arrived at by previous motion. 3 Do not use in an easterly direction. Substitute east or eastwards. 4 Use eastward as an adjective. 5 As an adverb, prefer eastwards. However, for the increasing trend not to use an ‘s’ in words ending in ward(s) (see forward/forwards). examples of no change 1 an easterly wind 2 They took an eastern course. 3 the eastern region of the State 4 an eastward flight examples of change 1 They set out in an easterly direction eastwards. 2 The easterly east side of New York. 3 She set out eastwards went east. further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 225–6 (east, eastern or easterly), 520 (north, northern or northerly), 705–6 (south, southern or southerly), 799–800 (-ward or -wards), 804 (west, western or westerly) Fowler’s English Usage pp 236 (easterly etc) and (eastward), 528 (northward(s)) Garner’s Dictionary pp 278 (directional words), 924 (-ward(s), 927 (westerly) Howard’s Guide p 286 (North, South, East, West or north, south, east, west; north or northern etc; northward, northwards or northerly etc) Howard’s Handbook pp 268-9 (North/north; Northern/northern; northward/northwards/northerly...) Longman English Usage pp 231 (eastward), 478 (north, northern) and (northward(s)), 664 (southward(s)), 762 (-ward(s)), 767 (westwards) Partridge pp 100 (easterly and eastern), 216 (northward; northwards), 317 (southward; southwards) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 E–3 E economic / economical usage—consider alternatives before using try—economical / economic / financial / no change extra information Economic is used for matters related to economics and the structure of the economy at large. Garner (Garner’s Redbook) suggests that financial should be used when writing about a company’s or household’s money. Economical is used for economy measures by which extravagance and waste are avoided. example of change The business was economically financially sound. further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 63 Cambridge Style Guide p 227 Garner’s Dictionary pp 303, 899 (uneconomic(al)) Garner’s Redbook p 208 (financial; economic; economical) Gowers’ Plain Words p 223 Howard’s Guide p 141 Howard’s Handbook p 148 Longman p 232 Partridge p 101 edge see—on the cutting/leading edge effect usage—consider alternatives before using try—do / produce / bring about / is / applies / force / make / operate / begin / start / outcome / affect / result / omitting / recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information 1 vague word 2 Prefer the most precise alternative if appropriate. 3 Do not use effect for make. 4 Use as a noun is more acceptable than as a verb. 5 For the use of effect and affect, see affect. 6 Prefer in force to in effect when referring to legislation. see also—affect / force and/or effect; full force and effect; null and of no effect/legal effect; to the effect that; void and of no effect examples of no change for affect and effect 1 The strike affected our travel plans. (verb) 2 We felt the effect of the strike on our travel plans. (noun) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 E–4 E effect [continued] examples of no change 1 The order ceases to have effect. 2 an effective, efficient and accountable system of local government 3 describing the general effect of the recommendation 4 the effectiveness and efficiency of the maritime industry 5 exercise effective control of a motor vehicle examples of change 1 This section has effect is subject to section 10. 2 section 11 has effect applies 3 until a further valuation takes effect for applies to the land 4 the withdrawal must be effected brought about 5 if an amendment has the effect of changing changes a rate 6 Service of a document by post may be effected made by properly addressing, prepaying and posting the document as a letter. 7 On service of the notice, the following provisions have effect operate...[or omit words after ‘notice’] further reading Blamires’ Common Errors p 106 Blamires’ Plain English pp 46-7 (affect/effect) Blamires’ Queen’s English p 230 (affect (effect)) Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 5 (affect, effect) Cambridge Style Guide p 26 (affect or effect) Crystal’s English Usage pp 34, 119 Fowler’s English Usage p 31 (affect, effect) Garner’s Dictionary p 34 (affect; effect) Garner’s Legal Style p 101 (affect; effect) Garner’s Redbook p 184 (affect; effect) Howard’s Guide p 12 (affect or effect) Howard’s Handbook p 12 (affect/effect) Hudson pp 15–6 (affect (ive/ed), effect (ive/ed)), 129 (effect(uate)), 305 (ploddery) Longman English Usage p 23 (affect, effect) Melinkoff’s dictionary p 250 (force and effect) New Oxford Dictionary p 28 (affect) Oxford English Usage p 115 (affect) Partridge p 8 (affect and effect) Right Words p 17 (affect/effect) Strunk and White p 45 Working Words p 21 (affect/effect) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 E–5 E effectual usage—never use try—effective / adequate / satisfactory / recasting extra information formal word example of change The dealing is effectual to confer confers a paramount title. effectuate usage—never use try—effect / give effect to / carry out / perform / bring about / cause to happen / bring into effect / recasting extra information formal word further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 305–6 (effect C. and effectuate), 369 (formal words) Garner’s Legal Style p 112 (effect; effectuate) Garner’s Redbook p 204 (effect; effectuate) Hudson p 129 (effect(uate)) Right Words p 130 (effectuate) effort see—in an effort to Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 E–6 E eg usage—consider alternatives before using try—for example / ie / such as / that is / no change extra information 1 For the use of eg and ie, see ie. 2 Abbreviations such as eg can be freely used in legislation in notes, tables and provision headings, where brevity is of particular importance. (It would, however, be unlikely that eg could appropriately be used in a provision heading.) 3 In general writing the use of eg is now generally acceptable in more contexts than in the past. For example, it can be used in general writing as part of the text inside brackets. In legislation eg can, therefore, be used in provisions (including examples) inside brackets. 4 A comma or another punctuation mark (eg an opening bracket or dash) should usually be used before eg. A comma should not be used after eg. 5 Use without full stops. example of no change There are many imaginary creatures, eg ghouls, in the cupboard. further reading Asprey p 162 Blamires’ Plain English pp 112-3 (Latin abbreviations) Cambridge Style Guide pp 231–2 Cutts pp 38–9 Cwlth Style Manual p 155 (Latin shortened forms) Evans p 129 Fowler’s English Usage p 240 Garner’s Dictionary p 307 Garner’s Legal Style p 112 (eg; ie) Garner’s Redbook p 204 (e.g.; i.e.) Howard’s Guide p 143 (eg or ie) Howard’s Handbook p 150 (eg/ie) Longman English Usage pp 234–5 (eg, ie) Oxford English Usage p 133 (eg; ie) Right Words p 130 Spelling Guide Strunk and White p 3 Working Words p 200 (eg/ie) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 E–7 E either … or usage—consider if use is appropriate try—recasting / no change extra information 1 Either … or requires proper balancing of the sentence (see both … and). 2 Avoid using either for more than 2 choices because either suggests a duality. further reading Blamires’ Plain English p 259 (Word order) Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 64 (either) Garner’s Legal Style pp 45 (either), 66, 67, 128–9 (either…or) Gowers’ Plain Words p 102 Howard’s Guide p 143 (either) Howard’s Handbook pp 150-1 (either) Right Words p 131 (either) Strunk and White p 27 Working Words p 201 elect [also election] usage—consider alternatives before using try—choose / recasting (using may) / omitting / no change extra information can be a formal word example of no change an election for members of the Legislative Assembly examples of change 1 A person may elect to make a claim. 2 If the chair is not present at a meeting, the members present may elect choose a member present to preside. further reading Cutts p 28 Garner’s Redbook p 158 (elect to) elucidate usage—never use try—clarify / explain / expand on / shed light on extra information formal word further reading Garner’s Redbook p 158 Gowers’ Plain Words p 223 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 E–8 E elude [or elusive] see—allude emolument usage—never use try—bonus / pay / wages / salary / remuneration / earnings / money / income / salary and allowances extra information formal word example of change The emolument she received for The income from her part-time work were was not large. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 413 Fowler’s English Usage p 309 (formal words) Garner’s Dictionary p 370 (formal words) Gowers’ Plain Words p 223 (emoluments) Howard’s Guide pp 306-7 (pay, salary, wages, remuneration, stipend or emoluments) employ [as use / apply] usage—avoid using try—use / apply / no change extra information 1 Formal word for use or apply. 2 Prefer use or apply. examples of change 1 They employed used a large crane to lift the beams. 2 He employed used a red biro to settle the draft. further reading Blamires’ Common Errors p 107 Fowler’s English Usage p 309 (formal words) Garner’s Dictionary p 370 (formal words) Gowers’ Plain Words p 223 Longman English Usage p 242 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 E–9 E empower usage—never use try—recasting (using may) / permit / allow / authorise / give power extra information formal word see also—authorise and empower examples of change 1 … is empowered may … 2 Control is also to be achieved by empowering authorising inspectors to give directions. enable usage—consider alternatives before using try—make possible / allow / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Enable means to make able, not to make possible. example of no change The bill will enable agreements made with foreign countries to apply to civil matters as well as criminal matters. examples of change 1 The bill will enable make possible [or allow] a saving of $1 million. 2 Random sampling will enable allow a comprehensive database to be built up. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 224 Longman p 242 enclose usage—consider alternatives before using try—attach / recasting (using, eg inside or with) / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. see also—enclosed please find / please find enclosed example of change An application form is enclosed provided with this letter. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 224 (enclosed) Howard’s Guide p 146 (enclose or inclose; enclosure or inclosure) Howard’s Handbook p 152 (enclose/inclose) Partridge p 107 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 E–10 E enclosed please find / please find enclosed usage—never use try—recasting (using, eg I enclose / enclosed is / I have enclosed / here is / attached is / see attached) extra information commercialese further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 314 Garner’s Legal Style p 112 Garner’s Redbook p 160 encounter usage—consider alternatives before using try—meet (with) / contend (against) / for / recasting / no change extra information formal word example of change The ship is in an appropriate condition to encounter for the ordinary dangers of the voyage. end see—before the end of; cease Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 E–11 E endeavour usage—consider alternatives before using try—attempt / try / recasting (using take all reasonable steps / take reasonable steps) / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Endeavour suggests struggle or toil, which try does not. 3 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. example of no change The health profession board must endeavour to make any decision jointly with the commissioner. examples of change 1 The Minister must endeavour try to reach … 2 The council must use its best endeavours take all reasonable steps to redeploy… 3 I have endeavoured to obtain the required information tried to find out what you wanted to know. further reading Cutts p 28 Dick p 155 Evans p 129 Fowler’s English Usage p 309 (formal words) Garner’s Dictionary pp 314–5, 370 (formal words) Garner’s Redbook p 158 (endeavour) Gowers’ Plain Words p 18 Howard’s Guide p 146 Right Words p 135 enhance [also enhancement] usage—consider alternatives before using try—increase / improve / intensify / raise (the value or price of) / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. 3 Enhance may be applied to things, values, reputations etc, but does not properly apply to people. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 250 Garner’s Redbook p 205 (enhance; improve) Longman English Usage p 244 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 195 (enhance, enhanced, enhancement) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 E–12 E enjoin usage—never use try—direct / require / recasting (using, eg must / prevented / stop) extra information 1 formal word 2 Technical legal word. example of change The defendant is enjoined prohibited by [the] injunction from continuing to develop the site. further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 113 Longman p 244 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 196 enormity usage—never use try—enormousness / recasting (using, eg wicked, evil, outrageous, huge, immense, vast extent, vastness, vast, very large) extra information 1 formal word 2 The traditional view is that enormity means great wickedness or a very evil act (eg Garner, Gowers, Strunk and White). However, enormity is sometimes used as a synonym for enormousness. Use an alternative to express a sense of outrage or indicate that something is large. further reading Blamires’ Plain English p 4 (What is plain English?) Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 66 Cambridge Style Guide p 243 (enormity or enormousness) Fowler’s English Usage pp 250-1 (enormity; enormousness) Garner’s Dictionary p 317 (enormity; enormousness) Garner’s Legal Style p 113 (enormity; enormousness) Garner’s Redbook p 205 (enormity; enormousness) Gowers’ Plain Words p 224 Howard’s Guide p 148 Longman English Usage p 244 (enormity; enormousness) New Oxford Dictionary p 613 Oxford English Usage p 135 Partridge pp 107–8 (enormity; enormousness) Right Words p 136 (enormacy/enormity) Strunk and White p 45 Working Words p 206(enormity/enormousness) enough see—sufficient Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 E–13 E enquire usage—never use try—inquire / ask / question / investigate / queried extra information 1 formal word 2 Like the use of enquiry and inquiry, there is not a completely settled practice in Australia for the use of enquire and inquire (see enquiry). 3 Use inquire rather than enquire in all contexts. further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 387–8 (inquiry or enquiry, inquire or enquire) Evans pp 129, 133 (inquire/enquire) Fowler’s English Usage pp 252, 309 (formal words) Garner’s Dictionary p 452 (inquire; enquire) Gowers’ Plain Words p 224 Howard’s Guide p 148 (enquire or inquire) Howard’s Handbook p 154 (enquire/inquire/enquiry/inquiry) Longman English Usage p 245 (enquire, inquire) Macquarie Dictionary pp 699 (en-), 708, 1101 (inquire) Partridge p 108 Right Words pp 136–7 enquiry usage—never use try—inquiry / investigation / recasting (using, eg asked / questioned / queried) extra information 1 There is not a completely settled practice in Australia for the use of enquiry and inquiry. However, inquiry is increasingly used for all applications. Enquiry appears to have formal overtones in Australia and appears to be limited in its use to single or ad hoc queries. 2 Use inquiry rather than enquiry in all contexts. example of change She made an enquiry asked about the fees.. further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 168 (query, inquiry, enquiry) Cambridge Style Guide pp 387–8 (inquiry or enquiry, inquire or enquire) Fowler’s English Usage p 252 Gowers’ Plain Words p 224 Howard’s Guide p 148 (enquire or inquire) Howard’s Handbook p 154 (enquire/inquire/enquiry/inquiry) Longman English Usage p 245 (enquire, inquire) Macquarie Dictionary pp 699 (en-), 708, 1101 (inquiry) Partridge p 108 Right Words pp 136–7 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 E–14 E entail usage—consider alternatives before using try—need / cause / impose / necessitate / involve / require / no change extra information 1 formal word with technical legal meaning 2 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. example of no change The estate was entailed to his male descendants. further reading Garner’s Redbook p 169 Gowers’ Plain Words p 225 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 241 enter / entry usage—consider alternatives before using try—add to / include / put / write / note / no change extra information can be a formal word example of no change An entry in the register must … example of change The registrar must enter include the applicant’s details in the register. further reading Asprey pp 217–8 Gowers’ Plain Words p 225 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary pp 197–8 (enter or entry) entered into usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / no change extra information can be a redundancy example of no change Alice entered into the spirit of the party by coming dressed as a skeleton. example of change The parties who entered into to the agreement... further reading Evans p 129 (enter into) Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 198 (enter into) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 E–15 E entirely and completely usage—never use try—completely extra information 1 ‘If entirely or completely is not enough, doubling won’t improve the chances of success. Better try something else. Maybe even, “Completely. And I really mean it!”’ (Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 199) 2 doublet further reading Evans p 129 (enter into) Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 199 entitled to see—is/are entitled to; is/are not entitled to entitlement usage—consider alternatives before using try—claim / right / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer claim or right if appropriate. example of change He had an existing entitlement right to superannuation payments. further reading Cutts pp 28, 31 Gowers’ Plain Words p 225 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary pp 199–200 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 E–16 E envisage usage—avoid using if possible try—consider / think / regard / recognise / realise / view / contemplate / imagine / intend / visualise / face / plan / expect / anticipate / foresee / recasting / no change extra information formal word meaning to visualise examples of change 1 The school committee envisaged expected that there would be no access to the school from the highway. 2 The repairs were envisaged expected to be finished by the end of the month. 3 The transfer is to take place in the way envisaged by mentioned in section 60. further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 66 (envisage, envision) Cutts p 28 Fowler’s English Usage p 254 (envisage, envision) Garner’s Dictionary pp 319–20 (envisage; envision) Gowers’ Plain Words p 225 Longman English Usage pp 246–7 (envisage, envision) Partridge p 108 Working Words p 207 (envisage/envision) envision usage—never use try—envisage / think / consider / regard / recognise / realise / view / contemplate / imagine / intend / visualise / face / plan / expect / anticipate / foresee extra information 1 formal word 2 more common in the United States than envisage further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 66 (envisage, envision) Fowler’s English Usage p 254 (envisage, envision) Garner’s Dictionary pp 319–20 (envisage; envision) Gowers’ Plain Words p 184 Longman English Usage pp 246–7 (envisage, envision) Working Words p 207 (envisage/envision) equal see—the amount equal to Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 E–17 E equally to…as to / as usage—never use try—equally / equally to … and / as extra information non-standard English examples of change 1 Section 10 applies equally to A as to and B [or Section 10 applies to A in the same way as it applies to B]. 2 The information would be equally as accurate as information complying with the chapter. 3 Both schools are equally as good. further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 67 (equally as) Garner’s Legal Style p 113 (equally as) Gowers’ Plain Words p 225 (Equally) Howard’s Guide p 32 (as 4) Howard’s Handbook p 34 (as) Partridge p 37 (as, equally) equitable usage—consider alternatives before using try—fair / just / reasonable / no change extra information 1 formal word with various legal meanings 2 Prefer fair if appropriate. example of change She sought an equitable fair share of the reward. see also—fair and equitable further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 67 (equable, equitable) Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 425 Cutts p 28 Longman p 248 (equable, equitable) Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 206 Partridge p 109 Right Words p 139 (equable/equitable) Working Words p 208 (equable/equitable) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 E–18 E equivalent usage—consider alternatives before using try—equal / the same as / corresponding / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Something is equivalent to something else, or is the equivalent of it, but not the equivalent to it. 3 Prefer equal or the same. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 226 Longman p 249 erroneous usage—avoid using if possible try—wrong / incorrect / mistaken / false / recasting / no change extra information formal word example of change Your view is erroneous mistaken. [or You are mistaken / wrong / incorrect.] further reading Garner’s Redbook p 158 Cutts p 28 escalate usage—consider alternatives before using try—rise / expand / develop / grow / intensify / increase / no change extra information 1 formal, vogue word 2 Escalate properly means increase step by step and is often overused. 3 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. examples of change 1 escalating rising prices 2 The issue has escalated developed into a major scandal. further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 325, 919 (vogue words) Garner’s Legal Style p 33 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 40, 88, 226 Howard’s Guide p 151 Longman p 251 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 E–19 E escrow usage—avoid using if possible try—recasting extra information 1 technical legal word 2 Recast in whichever of the following ways is appropriate: • for a conditional deed: This deed comes into operation only when X [the condition] is done. • for a third party holding a deed on trust: Z [the third party] holds this deed until Y [the condition] is fulfilled. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary pp 429–30 Garner’s Dictionary p 362 Law Words 1995 pp 16–7 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 208 establish usage—consider alternatives before using try—show / find out / set up / form / create / prove / recasting / no change extra information 1 Prefer show, find out or prove if appropriate. 2 For other senses of establish, consider alternatives before using. example of no change The Sports Drugs Testing Office is established. example of change The chief executive must assist the community to establish set up programs for the protection of children. further reading Cutts p 28 Gowers’ Plain Words p 226 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 E–20 E estate usage—consider alternatives before using try—interest / no change extra information 1 technical word, with archaic overtones 2 Prefer interest if appropriate. 3 However, estate is widely defined in LA, dict, pt 1 and the word may need to be used to pick up the definition. 4 Do not use estate or interest. example of no change the bankrupt estate further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 430 Fowler’s English Usage p 264 Garner’s Dictionary p 328 Law Words 1995 pp 19–20 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary pp 209–12 estop usage—avoid using if possible try—stop / prevent / hinder extra information 1 formal word 2 technical legal term 3 For the use of stop, see cease. example of no change (reference to nature of estopped) The plaintiff pleaded that the defendant was estopped from denying the validity of the contract. example of change (reference to effect of estopped) The defendant is prevented from denying the validity of the contract because of her previous conduct. further reading Asprey pp 117–8, 221 Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 431 (estop) and (estoppel) Garner’s Dictionary p 328 Melinkoff’s dictionary p 215 (estoppel) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 E–21 E etc usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / recasting / and so on / no change extra information 1 Use etc without commas before or after and without a full stop at the end. 2 Use etc only in provision headings and notes. Use etc sparingly and with care in provision headings to avoid overloading provisions. (If it is necessary to use etc in a provision heading, always consider whether the provision should instead be broken up.) 3 Do not use etc in chapter, part, division or subdivision headings. 4. Do not use etc at the end of a list preceded by including, for example, such as or a similar expression. 5 Do not use and before etc. example of no change Offences against Act—application of Criminal Code etc further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 68 Cambridge Style Guide pp 253–4 Cutts pp 34, 39 Cwlth Style Manual p 155 (Latin shortened forms) Evans p 129 Fowler’s English Usage p 265 Garner’s Dictionary p 329 Garner’s Legal Style pp 113–4 Howard’s Guide p 153 Howard’s Handbook pp 156–7 Longman English Usage p 253 Partridge pp 27 (and etc.), 109 Right Words p 142 Strunk and White pp 45–6 Working Words p 211 evacuate usage—consider alternatives before using try—remove / leave / escape / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer remove or a simpler alternative if appropriate. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words pp 226–7 Longman p 255 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 E–22 E even usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting / no change extra information As a general rule, even should be placed immediately before the word it qualifies: • Julie did not even see Ahmed last night • Julie did not see even Ahmed last night • Julie did not see Ahmed even last night. example of no change It must be disclosed even though it is otherwise protected. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 258 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 95, 97 Longman p 255 Partridge p 112 Working Words p 213 event see—in the event that/of eventuality usage—avoid using if possible try—possible result extra information formal word further reading Garner’s Redbook p 158 Gowers’ Plain Words p 227 Longman p 255 (eventuate/eventuality) eventuate usage—avoid using if possible try—happen / come about / take place / result / occur extra information 1 formal word 2 vogue word further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 68 Cutts p 28 Evans p 129 Garner’s Dictionary pp 332, 919 (vogue words) Garner’s Legal Style p 33 Gowers’ Plain Words p 244 (materialise) Longman p 255 (eventuate/eventuality) Partridge p 112 Right Words p 144 (eventuate, eventuality) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 E–23 E every usage—consider alternatives before using try—a / an / the / all / omitting / no change / recasting (using, eg each or any) extra information 1 Every should be used only when necessary. See each for further information. 2 Every takes a singular verb. This rule applies even where every is used with singular nouns linked by and, eg ‘Every school and university was closed that day’. 3 Avoid using between with every. 4 Blamire suggests using plural all instead of the singular every, to avoid using their as a singular pronoun eg instead of ‘Every student must make their own lunch’, better to say ‘All students must make their own lunch’. see also—each and every; in every case further reading Asprey pp 122 (each and every), 165–6 (any, each, every and all), 221 Blamires’ Plain English pp 313-4 (Gender) Cambridge Style Guide p 259 Dick p 144 Dickerson p 131 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 108 (use of between with every), 129, 150 Howard’s Guide p 155 Howard’s Handbook p 159 Longman p 256 NZ Legislation Manual pp 40–1 Strunk and White p 10 Working Words p 213 (every/everybody/everyone) evidence see—proof evident usage—avoid using if possible try—clear / plain / obvious extra information formal word example of change the meaning was evident obvious Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 E–24 E evince usage—avoid using if possible try—show / express / indicate / display / prove / reveal extra information formal word further reading Fowler’s English Usage pp 271–2, 309 (formal words) Garner’s Dictionary pp 333, (evidence, v.t.; evince), 370 (formal words) Gowers’ Plain Words p 227 Howard’s Guide p 156 (evince or evoke) Partridge p 113 Working Words p 214 evolve usage—consider alternatives before using try—change / develop / omitting / no change extra information Evolve means a process of natural change or development that is gradual and usually self-generated. example of no change Beliefs that have evolved or developed since European colonisation. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 227 examine usage—consider alternatives before using try—check / study / look at / no change extra information Prefer check if appropriate. exceed [also exceeding] usage—consider alternatives before using try—(be) over / (be) greater than / (be) heavier than / (be) larger than / (be) longer than / (be) more than / (be) older than / (be) taller than / higher than / recasting (using at least) / no change extra information Generally, prefer over, at least or a more specific alternative, eg older than, to other alternatives. see also—does not exceed; is or exceeds; not exceeding; in excess of Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 E–25 E except usage—consider alternatives before using try—other than / but / excluding / apart from / unless / recasting (using only or however) / no change extra information Use except or other than consistently. see also—except as otherwise provided; except as provided in/prescribed by; except where/if a contrary intention appears examples of change 1 Except that However, if the property … 2 A person must not may construct a road except only under section 10. further reading Blamires’ Plain English p 173 Longman p 257 Partridge p 114 except as / where otherwise provided / indicated usage—never use try—omitting / recasting (to identify the exceptions) extra information 1 legalese 2 General expressions like except as otherwise provided are very unhelpful to readers, lead to loose drafting, and may give rise to legal uncertainty. They must, therefore, never be used. The provisions that are the exceptions should always be identified as precisely as possible. see also—subject to example of change 1 (1) Except as otherwise provided in section 10, an An application must be in writing. (2) However, an application under section 10 may also be made orally. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 601 (notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained herein) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 E–26 E except as provided in / prescribed by usage—never use try—subject to / omitting / recasting extra information 1 legalese 2 Expressions like except as provided in/prescribed by are technical drafting devices used to indicate that there are exceptions to a provision and what the exceptions are but they have appropriate alternatives (see subject to). To avoid the problems of elegant variation, they should never be used. example of change (3) A ship does not include a seaplane. Except as provided in subsection (4), a ship does not include a seaplane (4) However,…. exception see—take exception to; with the exception of exceptionable usage—consider alternatives before using try—exceptional / open to exception (or objection) / objectionable / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. 3 Exceptionable and exceptional are sometimes confused. Exceptional means out of the ordinary, an exception to the general rule, very unusual, uncommon, well above average, rare, superior or extraordinary. 4 Exceptionable always has negative implications, because it describes something people find objectionable or take exception to. see also—unexceptional and unexceptionable further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 261 (exceptional or exceptionable) Crystal’s English Usage pp 83, 121 Fowler’s English Usage p 273 Garner’s Legal Style p 114 Howard’s Guide p 156 (exceptionable, exceptional, unexceptionable and unexceptional) Howard’s Handbook p 160 (exceptionable/exceptional/unexceptionable/unexceptional) Working Words p 214 exceptional see—exceptionable Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 E–27 E except where / if a contrary intention appears usage—never use try—unless the contrary intention appears / omitting extra information 1 legalese 2 General expressions like except where/if the contrary intention appears are technical drafting devices that are rarely necessary. If a general expression is necessary, there is an appropriate alternative (see unless the contrary intention appears). To avoid the problems of elegant variation, they should never be used. excess see—in excess of excessive number of (an) usage—never use try—too many extra information 1 verbosity 2 Use an alternative. further reading Evans p 129 Garner’s Legal Style p 183 exclude usage—consider alternatives before using try—leave out / omit / no change extra information Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. example of change exclude omit the details further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 227 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 E–28 E excluding usage—consider alternatives before using try—apart from / other than / except / no change extra information Prefer an alternative if appropriate. example of change excluding other than credit accounts further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 227 exclusive see—sole and exclusive exclusively usage—consider alternatives before using try—only / no change extra information Prefer only if appropriate. examples of change 1 The pool consists exclusively only of over-quota eggs. 2 a motor vehicle used exclusively only for primary production further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 227 execute usage—consider alternatives before using try—carry out / perform / sign / sign and deliver / make / enforce / complete / recasting (adding an explanation) / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Execute has technical legal meanings. 3 Prefer a plain, accurate alternative if appropriate. Alternatively, consider including a note explaining the intended meaning. example of change Please come in and execute sign the contract. further reading Asprey p 118 Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 444 Garner’s Dictionary p 337 Law Words 1995 pp 21–3 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary pp 220–1 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 E–29 E executor see—heirs, executors, administrators, successors and assigns exhibit usage—consider alternatives before using try—show / display / no change / recasting extra information 1 can be a formal word for show or display 2 Exhibit also has a technical legal meaning of an object received in evidence when tendered by a party to the proceeding. 3 Prefer show or display if appropriate. examples of change 1 An inspector who is not in uniform must exhibit display his or her identity card. 2 He exhibited odd behaviour behaved oddly. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary pp 446-7 ex officio usage—never use try—automatically / without further appointment / recasting extra information foreign phrase example of change A police officer is, ex officio Every police officer is an authorised officer. further reading Evans p 129 Garner’s Dictionary pp 334-5 (ex cathedra; ex officio) Melinkoff’s Dictionary p 222 expedient usage—consider alternatives before using try—appropriate / suitable / convenient / no change extra information 1 formal word with negative overtones 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. example of change the Minister considers expedient appropriate further reading Blamires’ Plain English p 56 (expedient/expeditious) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 E–30 E expedite usage—avoid using if possible try—hasten / hurry / speed up / recasting (using, eg quickly) extra information formal word further reading Cutts p 28 Garner’s Dictionary p 370 (formal words) Gowers’ Plain Words p 227 expeditiously usage—avoid using if possible try—quickly / promptly / immediately / as soon as possible / as soon as practicable / as quickly as possible / as quickly as practicable extra information 1 formal word 2 For the use of as quickly as possible and as quickly as practicable (see as soon as possible and as soon as practicable). example of change must act expeditiously quickly further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 228 expend [also expenditure] usage—consider alternatives before using try—spend / use up / pay / recasting (using costs as a noun) / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. example of no change income and expenditure examples of change 1 expenditure spending related to the conduct of gambling 2 an income and expenditure statement a statement of receipts and payments 3 the company’s expenditure costs in receiving eggs further reading Cutts p 28 Garner’s Dictionary pp 340, 370 (formal words) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 E–31 E expiration see—upon/on the expiration expire [also expiration] usage—consider alternatives before using try—end / ceases to have effect / die / stop / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Expire is used to describe legislation coming to an end (see LA, s 82, def repeal). 3 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 264 (expiry or expiration) Cutts p 28 (expiration) Evans p 130 (expiration) Garner’s Dictionary pp 341, 370 (formal words) exportation usage—never use try—export / no change extra information Exportation is usually a verbose way of saying export. expressed usage—consider alternatives before using try—stated / specified / recasting / omitting / no change extra information Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. example of no change the notional value per hen quota expressed in US dollars examples of change 1 the cash price expressed stated in the contract 2 If a licence is expressed to restrict restricts the minerals covered by the licence,… expression see—the expression Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 E–32 E expunge usage—never use try—strike out / delete / cancel / destroy / wipe out / remove extra information formal word example of change the record was expunged destroyed [or deleted] further reading Melinkoff’s Dictionary p 224 (expunge the record) extant usage—never use try—current / in force extra information formal word extend usage—consider alternatives before using try—give / no change extra information can be a formal word for give example of no change 1 The Minister may extend the time for making objections. 2 Extend time for objections. example of change extend give credit example of no change an extension of time further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 370 (formal words) Gowers’ Plain Words p 228 Longman p 263 extent see—to the extent that Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 E–33 E extinguish usage—consider alternatives before using try—end / put out / remove / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 For the use of end, see cease. example of change 1 The right to recover the amount is extinguished ends at midnight. 2 They extinguished put out the fire. Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 E–34 F facilitate usage—consider alternatives before using try—help / assist / ease / encourage / hasten / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Facilitate means to help to bring about. You facilitate what is being done, eg ‘We used the database to facilitate a search for consequential amendments’. You do not facilitate the people who are doing something, eg ‘We were assisted in our search for consequential amendments by the database’ [or we used the database to do a search for consequential amendments]. 3 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. 4 For the use of help and assist, see assist. example of no change The object of this code is to facilitate the provision of telecommunications services. example of change The authority must do everything necessary to facilitate assist … further reading Cutts p 28 Evans p 130 Garner’s Redbook p 158 Gowers’ Plain Words p 228 Longman English Usage p 266 Working Words p 220 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 F–1 F facility usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information 1 vague word 2 Prefer a more precise alternative if appropriate. see also—ablution facilities example of no change institutions and facilities that provide care and protection for children and young people [Note If there are a number of references to institutions and facilities, it would be preferable to use a defined term.] examples of change 1 educational facility school 2 correctional facility jail further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 267 (facility or faculty) Garner’s Redbook p 207 (facility; ease; building) Longman English Usage p 266 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 229 (facile) Partridge p 116 Strunk and White p 46 facsimile / facsimile transmission usage—consider alternatives before using try—fax / no change extra information 1 Fax is now standard English and is perfectly appropriate in formal contexts. 2 Fax is both a noun and a verb, and describes— a document sent by fax the method of transmission (including the scanning of the original document and the printing of the transmitted data to produce an exact copy of the original document) a machine that transmits faxes, and the sending of a document by fax. 3 Facsimile transmission is now an archaism and should never be used. 4 Use fax rather than facsimile. 5 However, facsimile is an appropriate word outside telecommunications for something that is an exact copy (in all respects) of a book or document. further reading Evans p 130 Fowler’s English Usage p 288 (fax) Garner’s Dictionary p 350 (fax) Howard’s Guide pp 163-4 (fax or facsimile) Macquarie Dictionary p 770 (fax) New Oxford Dictionary p 669 (fax) Right Words p 99 (copy / duplicate / facsimile / replica) Working Words p 222 (fax) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 F–2 F fact see—actually/actual (for in actual fact); the fact that factor usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information 1 The traditional meaning of factor is something contributing to a particular result. Factor has, however, come to be used as an omnibus word and as a substitute for words such as circumstance, component, consideration, constituent, element, event, fact, feature or happening. 2 Factor should be used in its traditional sense. For other meanings, prefer more precise words. 3 Factor also has a technical legal meaning (see examples of no change 2). examples of no change 1 Six and 3 are factors of 18. 2 A payment is a reportable payment if it is made by a factor to a smash repairer in relation to the transfer of a debt owing to the smash repairer. examples of change 1 Her superior training was the great factor in her winning the match. She won the match because she was better trained. 2 Air power is becoming an increasingly important factor playing an ever greater part in deciding conflicts. further reading Blamires’ Plain English p 38 Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 456 Fowler’s English Usage p 281 Garner’s Dictionary pp 346–7, 813 (slipshod extensions) Garner’s Legal Style pp 114, 205 Garner’s Redbook p 170 Gowers’ Plain Words p 4 Howard’s Guide p 161 Longman English Usage p 267 Partridge pp 116-7 Strunk and White p 46 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 F–3 F fail to / fail to comply usage—consider alternatives before using try—contravene / recasting (using must not) / does not / no change extra information LA, dict, pt 1 defines contravene as including fail to comply with. example of no change the corporation’s failure to collect the insurance premium in full examples of change 1 The Minister may remove all or any members of the corporation if it fails to does not comply with its obligations under the Act. 2 If an insurer fails to does not make a payment, … further reading Evans p 130 (fails to) Gowers’ Plain Words p 228 Longman English Usage p 268 fair and equitable usage—avoid using if possible try—fair / equitable extra information doublet far see—as/so far as … is/are concerned; in so far as; insofar as farther / farthest see—further favour see—in favour of Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 F–4 F feasible usage—consider alternatives before using try—practicable / possible / can be done / probable / plausible / no change extra information 1 Feasible means practicable or capable of being done. It should not be used to mean probable or plausible. 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. examples of no change 1 It is feasible to get the job done by tomorrow morning. 2 feasible solution to the problem example of change It is feasible possible it might rain this afternoon. further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 74 Garner’s Legal Style p 144 (viable) Gowers’ Plain Words p 228 Longman English Usage p 273 Right Words p 151 (feasible) Working Words pp 222–3 feature usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information 1 Hackneyed word. Prefer more precise words if appropriate. 2 Avoid using feature as a verb in the sense of to offer as a special attraction. example of no change He had prominent facial features. further reading Longman English Usage p 273 Right Words pp 151–2 (feature) Strunk and White p 47 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 F–5 F feedback usage—consider alternatives before using try—answer / response / no change extra information vogue word example of no change The client gave positive feedback about the job. example of change I didn’t get feedback an answer to my question. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words pp 228–9 Howard’s Guide pp 164–5 Longman English Usage p 274 fewer usage—consider alternatives before using try—less / no change extra information 1 Fewer relates to number. Less relates to degree, quantity or extent. 2 A good rule of thumb is to use fewer with plural nouns (eg fewer people, worries etc) and less with singular nouns (eg less land, boredom etc). The same rule of thumb applies to fewer than and less than. 3 Measurements (eg money, time, distance and weight), although expressed in the plural, are thought of as single units and require less than (eg to pay less than $100 and weigh less than 30g). 4 Alternatively, less applies to mass nouns (ie nouns almost always used in the singular because they refer to concepts, substances or quantities with no clearcut boundaries, eg salt, butter, honesty and education) and fewer applies to count nouns (ie nouns that refer to things that can be counted and so can be pluralised, eg cars, books, people and offices). 5 However, less is gradually replacing fewer in most contexts and the issue of using fewer rather than less is now more a matter of style than grammar. Using fewer is more formal than using less. 6 Note that it is necessary to write a smaller number or fewer rather than a fewer number. Garner (Garner’s Redbook) states that it is redundant to say a fewer number because the sense of a number is included in the meaning of fewer. see also—not fewer than further reading Blamires’ Plain English p 57 (fewer/less) Bryson’s Troublesome Words pp 74–5 (fewer, less) Cambridge Style Guide pp 276–7 Garner’s Redbook p 207 (fewer; less) Garner’s Legal Style pp 123–4 Garner’s Redbook p 207 (fewer; less) Gowers’ Plain Words p 241 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 F–6 F fewer [continued] Howard’s Guide p 166 (fewer or less) Howard’s Handbook p 167 (fewer/less) NZ Legislation Manual p 43 (less than/more than) Right Words pp 155–6 (fewer/less) Strunk and White p 51 (less) Working Words pp 223–4 field usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using more precise words) / no change / omitting extra information Avoid using field as an omnibus word. See kind for extra information. example of no change The job is being advertised to test the field of potential applicants. example of change He practised in the field of medicine. further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 205 Howard’s Guide p 167 (field, province or sphere) final see—in the final/last/ultimate analysis final and conclusive usage—avoid using if possible try—final / recasting extra information doublet example of change If there is a dispute about a bid, the auctioneer’s decision is final and conclusive. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 293 (doublets) Garner’s Redbook p 163 (doublets) Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 245 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 F–7 F finalise usage—consider alternatives before using try—end / complete / decide / finish / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. 3 For the use of end, see cease. examples of change 1 The drafter needs to finalise finish the draft. 2 The inspector must finalise complete the investigation within 1 month. further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 75 (finalize) Evans p 130 Garner’s Legal Style p 114 Longman English Usage p 279 Right Words p 156 (finalise) Strunk and White pp 47, 83 Working Words p 225 find see—enclosed please find / please find enclosed finish and complete usage—never use try—finish / complete / recasting extra information doublet further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 293 (doublets) first see—firstmentioned / first mentioned / first-mentioned; in the first instance Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 F–8 F firstly usage—never use try—first / recasting extra information 1 needless variant 2 much criticised further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words pp 75–6 (first, firstly) Cambridge Style Guide p 280 Evans p 131 (first) Fowler’s English Usage p 298 (first) Garner’s Dictionary pp 319 (enumerations), 359 Garner’s Legal Style p 83 Gowers’ Plain Words p 229 Howard’s Guide p 168 (first or firstly etc) Howard’s Handbook p 170 (first, second …/firstly, secondly…) Longman English Usage p 280 Partridge p 120 Strunk and White p 57 (secondly, thirdly, etc) Working Words p 225 further reading firstmentioned / first-mentioned / first mentioned usage—never use try—first / recasting extra information 1 formal word 2 Do not hesitate to repeat words rather than use firstmentioned to avoid repetition. Alternatively, use a tagged term. Readers may otherwise have difficulty in working out what is referred to. 3 For similar reasons, avoid substituting former (see former). 4 If you want to refer otherwise than specifically to the first of 2 or more things, try first. see also—lastmentioned/last mentioned/last-mentioned example of change 1 If a person (the buyer) buys stolen goods from a person who stole the goods, the firstmentioned person buyer... Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 F–9 F first name usage—never use try—personal name / given name / [by contrast with surname / family name] extra information Use of first name is inappropriate for people in whose culture the family name is given first, eg Chinese, Japanese, Koreans and Vietnamese. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 281 (firstname or forename) Cwlth Style Manual p 58 (Personal names) Howard’s Guide p 169 (first or Christian name) Howard’s Handbook p 170 (first name/Christian name/forename) see also—Christian name first to happen / occur usage—never use try—happens first / whichever happens first extra information needless variant fit usage—avoid using if possible try—appropriate / suitable / recasting (using more precise words) extra information 1 vague word 2 value-loaded word 3 Prefer a more precise alternative if appropriate. see also—fit and proper; fit and suitable/fitting and proper further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 115 (fitted) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 F–10 F fit and proper usage—never use try—appropriate / suitable / recasting (using more precise words) extra information 1 doublet 2 Fit and proper has no settled general legal meaning and only provides an illusion of certainty. It has been suggested that it delegates the job of deciding criteria to the courts. 3 Use an alternative and provide criteria, eg how to work out if a person is suitable (see Second-hand Dealers Act 1906, s 11 and Gaming Machine Act 2004, s 20). example of change The applicant is a fit and proper suitable person to be given a licence. further reading Asprey p 122 Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 481 (fit and proper) and (fit and proper person) Garner’s Dictionary pp 293 (doublets, triplets and synonym strings), 361 Garner’s Redbook p 163 (doublets) Howard’s Guide p 2 (abet) Law Words 1995 pp 24–6 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 247 fit and suitable / fitting and proper usage—never use try—appropriate / suitable / recasting extra information doublet further reading Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 247 see also—fit and proper flat rate usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information Flat rate may not have a clear meaning. Prefer more precise words if appropriate. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 484 (flat interest rate) Howard’s Guide pp 169–70 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 F–11 F following usage—consider alternatives before using try—after / next / because (of) / recasting / no change extra information 1 Prefer after, next or because of if appropriate. 2 The use of following before paragraphs should generally be limited to cases where the paragraphs are pure tabulation or it is desirable to clarify that the paragraphs are both cumulative and alternative (eg using 1 or more of the following:), ie a series of separate things in the form of a list. Applying current drafting practice, the use of following would result in the paragraphs (or penultimate paragraph) not ending in or or and. Dot points could also be used in appropriate cases without punctuation at the end of each paragraph other than the last. 3 Following should not generally be used before paragraphs that are not pure tabulation, but rather an ordinary sentence broken up into paragraphs. examples of no change 1 … stating any of the following matters: … 2 The owner of a vehicle must choose an insurer according to the following principles: … examples of change 1 the month following after the month in which the application is made 2 the following next month 3 if a rate is set between 1 September and the following 30 June in a financial year further reading Commonwealth Style Manual p 99 Fowler’s English Usage p 305 Garner’s Redbook p 158 Longman English Usage p 286 Partridge p 121 Right Words p 159 Working Words p 228 for see—but for for and during usage—never use try—while / during / for extra information doublet further reading Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 250 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 F–12 F for and / or in connection with usage—never use try—in / in connection with / in relation to / about / for / to / of extra information 1 doublet 2 If a connecting phrase is necessary, prefer in relation to (see in relation to). for and / or on behalf of usage—never use try—for / on behalf of extra information doublet further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 293 (for and in behalf of in doublets) Garner’s Redbook p 163 (for and in behalf of in doublets) forbear usage—avoid using if possible try—refrain (from) / tolerate / recasting extra information formal word further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 78 Garner’s Legal Style p 115 Garner’s Redbook p 208 (forbear; forebear) Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 250 Working Words p 230 force and / or effect usage—never use try—recasting (using has effect / force) extra information doublet see also—full force and effect example of change … is of no force or effect does not have effect until approved. further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 293 (doublets), 366 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary pp 250–1 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 F–13 F force majeure usage—avoid using if possible try—recasting extra information 1 foreign phrase 2 vague phrase 3 Force majeure does not have a fully settled meaning and needs to be used with care. 4 If it is necessary to use force majeure, its intended meaning should be explained (eg by a note or examples). 5 Synonym for the equally vague act of God. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 489 Garner’s Dictionary p 366 Law Words 1995 pp 27–30 Melinkoff’s Dictionary p 10 (act of God, force majeure, vis major) foregoing usage—never use try—following / omitting / recasting extra information 1 archaism 2 Foregoing is sometimes confused with following. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 367 Garner’s Legal Style p 115 Howard’s Guide p 172 (forego or forgo) Howard’s Handbook p 174 (forgo/forego) forename usage—never use try—given name / other name [by contrast with surname / family name] extra information Forename is open to the same objections as first name (see first name). further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 281 (firstname or forename) Garner’s Dictionary pp 859–60 (surname; Christian name) Gowers’ Plain Words p 229 Partridge p 66 (Christian name) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 F–14 F forenoon usage—never use try—am / morning extra information Use am/pm, without full stops, for times. see also—12 am example of change 10 o’clock in the forenoon 10 am forfeit usage—consider alternatives before using try—lose / give up / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. example of no change An object seized under this section is forfeited to the Territory. example of change If you do not comply with a condition, you forfeit lose your right to compensation. forma see—pro forma Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 F–15 F former [as opposite of latter] usage—avoid using if possible try—recasting / first extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer to repeat words rather than use former to avoid repetition. Alternatively, use a tagged term. Readers may otherwise have difficulty in working out what is referred to. 3 For similar reasons, avoid substituting firstmentioned and like terms (see firstmentioned). 4 Former can refer to only one of 2 things and if you use it of more than 2 you may puzzle your readers. 5 If you want to refer otherwise than specifically to the first of more than 2 things, try first. see also—latter further reading Blamires’ Plain English p 204 (former/latter) Bryson’s Troublesome Words pp 79–80 (former, latter) Cambridge Style Guide p 291 (former and latter) Fowler’s English Usage p 309 Garner’s Dictionary p 370 Garner’s Redbook p 209 (former; latter) Gowers’ Plain Words p 115 Howard’s Guide p 174 (former and latter) Longman English Usage pp 292–3 Partridge p 122 Right Words p 163 (former/latter) Working Words p 232 (former/latter) forth usage—never use try—out / recasting extra information archaism example of change set forth out Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 F–16 F for the duration of usage—never use try—while / during / as/so long as extra information compound preposition example of change The dog howled for the duration of as long as she sang. further reading Cutts p 28 Dick p 155 Garner’s Dictionary p 372 Garner’s Legal Style p 183 for the purpose / purposes of usage—consider alternatives before using try—in this [eg provision/Act] / for this [eg provision/Act] / because of / under / to / for / omitting / recasting/ no change extra information 1 compound preposition 2 Prefer the simplest alternative if appropriate. examples of change 1 created by a stratum plan for the purposes of under this Act 2 for the purposes of this part, the total cost of work is 3 For the purposes of In this Act, a reference to X does not include a reference to Y. 4 a motor vehicle prescribed by regulation for the purposes of this subsection 5 for the purposes of the Act, section 10 … 6 amounts not immediately required for the purposes of the fund may be invested 7 The authority may invite a person to attend a meeting for the purpose of advising to advise it about anything. 8 is used only for the purposes of theatre, film and television 9 for the purpose of providing to provide nursing and personal care further reading Cutts p 28 (for the purpose of) Cwlth OPC Plain English p 33 (For the purposes of this Act / section etc) Garner’s Redbook p 160 (for the purposes of —ing) Gowers’ Plain Words p 55 (for the purpose of) Longman English Usage p 580 (purpose) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 F–17 F for the reason that usage—never use try—because extra information compound preposition further reading Evans p 131 Garner’s Dictionary p 372 Garner’s Legal Style p 183 Garner’s Redbook p 160 Gowers’ Plain Words p 55 forthwith usage—never use try—immediately / promptly / quickly / as soon as practicable / as soon as possible / at once / now / as quickly as practicable / as quickly as possible / recasting (stating time) extra information 1 Formal word without a precise meaning. 2 For the use of as quickly as practicable and as quickly as possible (see as soon as practicable and as soon as possible). example of change Please reply forthwith immediately/within 7 days. further reading Asprey pp 176–7, 221 Garner’s Dictionary pp 370 (formal words), 372 Garner’s Redbook p 161 Gowers’ Plain Words p 230 Howard’s Guide p 212 (immediately, forthwith, straight away) Howard’s Handbook p 203 (immediately/forthwith/straightaway) Melinkoff’s Dictionary pp 3–4 (absolutes) fortuitous usage—consider alternatives before using try—fortunate / lucky / no change / recasting extra information Fortuitous means happening by chance or accidentally. It does not mean fortunate or lucky. further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 80 Crystal’s English Usage pp 83, 121–2 Garner’s Legal Style p 115 Garner’s Redbook p 209 (fortunate; fortuitous; gratuitous) Howard’s Guide p 174 (fortuitous or fortunate) Longman English Usage p 293 Partridge p 122 Right Words p 14 (adventitious) Strunk and White p 47 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 F–18 F fortunately / fortunate usage—consider if use is appropriate try—recasting (using ‘neutral’ words) / no change extra information 1 Fortunately is a sentence adverb (ie an adverb that qualifies a sentence as a whole). 2 Fortunately and fortunate are value-loaded words. 3 Prefer a more neutral alternative if appropriate. further reading Fowler’s English Usage pp 702–3 (sentence adverbs) Garner’s Dictionary pp 791–2 (sentence adverbs) Garner’s Redbook p 212 (hopefully; fortunately) forward / forwards [as adjective / adverb] usage—consider alternatives before using try—forwards / forward / recasting / no change extra information 1 Most directional words ending in ward(s) are used as adverbs, adjectives or nouns, eg backward(s), downward(s), forward(s) and upward(s). An exception is towards which is used as a preposition. 2 In Australian (and British) English the adverb form of these directional words has traditionally ended with an ‘s’, and the adjective and noun forms have not. In American English adjectives, nouns and adverbs are treated in the same way and do not usually end in an ‘s’. There is an increasing trend in Australian English not to end adverb forms with an ‘s’. The trend is more advanced with some directional words than others. 3 The trend is perhaps most advanced in relation to forward(s). There have been various attempts to rationalise the cases in which forwards should nevertheless continue to be used as an adverb, eg for moving straight ahead (Longman English Usage), for a physical movement, or for movement towards a place (Working Words). However, the rationalisations are not persuasive. 4 It is now too late to say that the adverb form of forward(s) always ends with an ‘s’. However, there is no generally accepted rule for when forwards should continue to be used as the adverb. 5 All that can be suggested is that the traditional rule should be kept in mind and a decision made on a case-by-case basis about what sounds most appropriate. Consider avoiding the problem by recasting. see also—afterward / afterwards; backward / backwards; easterly (direction) / eastwardly /eastward(s); onward / onwards; outward / outwards; toward / towards Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 F–19 F forward / forwards [as adjective / adverb] [continued] examples of no change 1 forward planning 2 forward selling 3 The saloon door swung backwards and forwards. 4 The company carried the losses forward to the next year. 5 I look forward to seeing you. 6 She arranged to bring the case forward. 7 The car can only move forward [or forwards]. 8 She looked forward [or forwards]. example of change from this time forward on further reading Fowler’s English Usage pp 311, 833 (-ward(s)) Garner’s Dictionary p 924 (-ward(s)) Howard’s Guide p 174 Howard’s Handbook p 175 Hudson p 421 (upward) Longman English Usage pp 294, 595 (rearward(s)), 762 (-ward(s)) Macquarie Dictionary pp 834 (forward), 835 (forwards) Partridge pp 122-3, 382 (-ward/ -ward(s)) Right Words p 163 (forward/forwards) Working Words pp 233, 553 (-ward words) forward [as a verb] usage—consider alternatives before using try—send / give / redirect / no change extra information Except to mean send on, prefer send or give. example of no change She arranged for her mail to be forwarded [or redirected] to her new address. example of change Please forward send the parcel by courier. further reading Cutts pp 28, 31 Garner’s Redbook p 158 Gowers’ Plain Words p 230 Howard’s Guide p 174 Howard’s Handbook p 175 Longman English Usage p 294 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 F–20 F for which (there is) usage—avoid using if possible try—with / recasting extra information compound preposition example of change ‘With a view to’ is a compound preposition for which there is with a simpler alternative. frame usage—avoid using if possible try—develop / make / prepare / cast extra information 1 vogue word 2 vague word 3 Prefer a more precise alternative if appropriate. example of change 1 frame develop a budget 2 frame prepare a question frequently usage—consider alternatives before using try—often / regularly / no change extra information Prefer often if appropriate. fresh usage—consider alternatives before using try—new / renewed / recasting (using again) / no change extra information overused word example of change A fresh new crop was sown. further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 81 Gowers’ Plain Words p 230 Howard’s Guide p 177 (fresh or new) Howard’s Handbook p 265 (new/fresh/renewed) Right Words p 164 (fresh) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 F–21 F from usage—consider alternatives before using try—on and after / after / recasting (using eg 6 months beginning on / inclusive) / no change extra information 1 Be careful using from. Use of the word will usually mean that time is reckoned exclusive of the mentioned day (see LA, s 151 (3)). 2 Prefer after to from, because it is less likely to be ambiguous. 3 In recasting, the words the period of are unnecessary if the period itself is mentioned (see period). see also—as and from; as from; as on and from; from and after; from and including; on and from further reading Asprey pp 179–80 from and after usage—never use try—from / after / on and after / recasting (using eg 6 months beginning on) extra information doublet further reading Asprey p 122 Garner’s Dictionary p 243 (doublets) Garner’s Redbook p 163 (doublets) Melinkoff’s Dictionary p 262 from and including usage—avoid using if possible try—on and after / after / from / recasting (using eg 6 months beginning on / inclusive) extra information 1 Pearce and Geddes suggest using from and including [a particular day] to and including [another day] to precisely fix the beginning and end of a period of time. However, this formulation is not grammatical and is not often used in ordinary speech. 2 Prefer after or on and after or recasting. 3 In recasting, the words the period of are unnecessary if the period itself is mentioned (see period). further reading LA, s 151 and s 151A Pearce and Geddes pp 229-33 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 F–22 F from time to time usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / no change extra information 1 can be a redundancy 2 References to from time to time are usually unnecessary. LA, s 197 provides that, if a law gives a function to an entity, the function may be exercised from time to time. See also the following provisions of the LA: • s 42 (3) (Power to make statutory instruments) • s 47 (2) (b) (Statutory instrument may make provision by applying law or instrument) • s 52 (2) (Instrument may authorise determination of matter etc) • s 102 (References to laws include references to laws as in force from time to time) • s 131 (Signpost definitions) • s 148 (Terms used in instruments have same meaning as in authorising laws) 3 However, from time to time is necessary if, for example, provision is to be made in relation to a matter by adopting etc the provisions of a law (other than an ACT law or instrument) as in force from time to time (see LA, s 47 (3)). See also the following provisions of the LA: • s 207 (1) (b) (Appointment may be by name or position) • s 217 (1) (b) (Acting appointment may be made by name or position) • s 233 (1) (b) (Delegation may be made by name or position) example of change as amended from time to time under section 10 further reading Asprey pp 173–5, 222 fulfil usage—consider alternatives before using try—comply with / satisfy / carry out / perform / do / complete / meets / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. examples of change 1 A person is eligible for a licence only if the person fulfils satisfies the conditions mentioned in section X. 2 The chief executive has the function of providing information to people who are required to report cases of child abuse to assist them to fulfil comply with their legal obligation. Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 F–23 F full and complete usage—never use try—complete / recasting extra information doublet further reading Garner’s Redbook p 163 (doublets) Gowers’ Plain Words p 61 full force and effect usage—never use try—effect extra information doublet further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 366 (force and effect) Garner’s Redbook p 163 (doublets) fulsome usage—never use try—detailed / full / generous / outgoing / lavish / abundant / recasting extra information 1 Fulsome has negative connotations. 2 Fulsome means lavish in an excessive and distasteful way. For example, fulsome praise is not flattering. 3 However, fulsome is frequently used to mean abundant, full, generous or lavish. 4 Fulsome has been described (by Bryson p 82) as one of the most frequently misused words in English. Because there are appropriate alternatives, fulsome should not be used. example of change Please provide me with a more fulsome detailed report. further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 82 Fowler’s English Usage p 318 Garner’s Dictionary p 377 Garner’s Legal Style p 115 Garner’s Redbook p 209 Howard’s Guide p 179 Longman English Usage p 299 New Oxford Dictionary p 742 Oxford English Usage p 165 Partridge p 124 Right Words p 165 (fulsome) Working Words p 235 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 F–24 F function [as a verb] usage—avoid using if possible try—work / operate / act / perform / no change extra information 1 Function should be used only of machinery or something that works like a machine (eg the heart). 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. 3 formal word example of no change The heart started to function as soon as the electrodes were applied. example of change She functions works well as team leader. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 230 Howard’s Guide p 179 Partridge p 124 Right Words p 166 (function) Working Words p 235 furnish usage—consider alternatives before using try—give / provide / supply / send / recasting (using inform, mention or tell) / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Furnish is the right word for provide with furniture. 3 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. example of no change She furnished her apartment in art deco style. example of change A producer must furnish give the required information to the company. further reading Cutts p 28 Garner’s Dictionary p 378 (as a useful vague word for contracts) Gowers’ Plain Words p 230 Longman English Usage p 300 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 F–25 F further / farther usage—consider alternatives before using try—additional / moreover / omitting / also / and / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer further to farther in all contexts. 3 Further to that is a verbose elaboration of further or furthermore and should not be used. example of change the further additional information further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 73 (farther, further) Cambridge Style Guide pp 298–9 (further or farther etc) Fowler’s English Usage pp 285–6 (farther, further) Garner’s Dictionary pp 349–50 (farther; further) Garner’s Legal Style p 114 (farther; further) Garner’s Redbook p 207 (farther; further) Howard’s Guide p 163 (farther or further) Howard’s Handbook pp 164-5 (farther/further) Hudson p 163 Longman English Usage p 300 (further, furthest, farther, farthest) Oxford English Usage p 137 (farther, farthest) Partridge p 117 (farther/farthest/further/furthest) Right Words pp 150–1 (farther/further) Strunk and White p 46 (farther, further) Working Words pp 221–2 (farther/farthest/further/furthest) furthermore usage—avoid using if possible try—omitting / also / moreover / in addition / too / again/ and / further / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. further reading Garner’s Redbook p 158 Gowers’ Plain Words p 18 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 F–26 G gainfully employed usage—never use try—recasting / employed / working extra information verbosity further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 230 geared to usage—avoid using if possible try—adapted to / adjusted to / suited to / satisfying extra information vogue phrase further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 231 gender or sex usage—consider alternatives before using try—sex / no change extra information 1 Gender is a grammatical term. The ordinary term for describing whether a person or animal is male or female is sex. 2 However, there is a trend to limit the use of sex to refer to the biological differences between men and women and to extend the use of gender to refer to psychological and social differences. example of no change noun of the same gender example of change The person must state his or her gender sex. further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 84 (gender) Cambridge Style Guide p 303 Fowler’s English Usage p 325 Garner’s Redbook p 235 (sex; gender) Howard’s Guide p 182 (gender or sex) Howard’s Handbook p 179 (gender/sex) Working Words pp 238–9 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 G–1 G generality see—without limiting the generality of; without prejudice to the generality of get usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using more specific words, eg become / buy / obtain / receive / take) / omitting / no change extra information 1 Prefer a more specific alternative if appropriate. 2 Get is generally more appropriate in informal spoken English. However, it may be appropriate for new legislative schemes. example of no change A student may get AUSTUDY if … example of change He has not got any no sense. further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 309–10 Cutts p 34 Strunk and White p 48 Working Words p 240 give consideration to usage—never use try—consider / have regard to / take into account / think about extra information verbosity example of change In deciding whether to grant or refuse an application, the Minister must give consideration to consider … further reading Asprey pp 148, 221 Evans p 131 Garner’s Dictionary p 912 (verbosity) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 G–2 G give, devise and bequeath usage—never use try—give / give by will extra information 1 Triplet much loved by will drafters. 2 Give is a sufficient replacement. see also—bequeath; devise example of change I give, devise and bequeath all my property to... further reading Asprey pp 122, 222 Butterworths Legal Dictionary pp 524-5 Garner’s Dictionary p 386 Garner’s Legal Style p 188 Garner’s Redbook p 164 (triplets) Law Words 1995 pp 31–3 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 269 give recognition to usage—never use try—recognise extra information verbosity example of change She gave recognition to recognised the original landowners. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 912 (verbosity) good and sufficient usage—never use try—adequate / enough / sufficient / suitable / appropriate / satisfactory extra information 1 doublet 2 For the use of adequate, enough and sufficient, see sufficient. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 61 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 G–3 G good enough see—will/would you be good enough to advise me got see—get grant usage—consider alternatives before using try—give / make / agree to / approve / transfer / accept / omitting / no change extra information 1 Grant is a word with formal overtones. 2 Give and grant are interchangeable in most contexts. Give is the more general and less formal word. Grant has certain technical meanings in real property law, eg a grant of freehold title. In other contexts, grant implies that one gives something out of generosity, mercy or a sense of justice. It points strongly to the giver’s discretion to do as the giver pleases, and the would-be receiver as depending on that discretion. Applied to the giving of licences and other forms of permission, it has overtones inconsistent with modern administrative law concepts. 3 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. examples of no change 1 Freehold title to land may be granted if.... 2 The prisoner was granted a pardon. 3 He granted 3 wishes. examples of change 1 A licence may be granted given on conditions. 2 The authority may grant agree to the request. 3 I grant agree with your point. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 341 (granted) Garner’s Dictionary p 391 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary pp 273–4 Partridge p 80 (conjunctions, disguised—granted/granting) Use the Right Word pp 243–4 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 G–4 G greater than usage—consider alternatives before using try—over / exceeds / heavier than / larger than / longer than / more than / older than / taller than / higher than / recasting (using at least) / no change extra information 1 Generally, prefer over, at least, or a more specific alternative, eg older than, to other alternatives. 2 Prefer more than when using measurements (eg amounts of money or weights) or numbers. see also—not greater than example of change if the wall is greater than higher than 4 feet greatest see—the greatest number of ground see—on the grounds of/that group usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / kind / no change extra information 1 Most legal drafting is expressed in the singular, and it is usually unnecessary to distinguish between a class (using, eg group) and its members (see LA, s 48 and s 145 (b)). Avoid mentioning group unless it is necessary. See class for extra information. 2 If it is necessary to mention class, prefer kind if appropriate. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 210 (brackets, groups) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 G–5 G guilty of usage—consider alternatives before using try—commits / engages in / no change extra information 1 A person should not be said to be guilty of an offence unless the context relates to a person who has been found guilty by a court. 2 A person commits an offence by engaging in conduct that constitutes the offence, regardless of whether it ever becomes known. However, the person is guilty of the offence only if guilt is decided by the trier of fact in a prosecution for the offence. Judge Learned Hand is said to have remarked that anyone can be a killer, but only a jury can make a murderer (quoted Garner). 3 See LA, dict, pt 1, def found guilty. example of no change A person may be found guilty of the offence only if the prosecution proves … example of change A person is guilty of commits an offence if… further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 116 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 G–6 H hand see—under the hand of happen see—first to happen; upon/on the occurrence/happening of happens first see—whichever happens first hardly … than usage—never use try—hardly … when / recasting extra information 1 Because hardly is not a true comparative, the use of hardly with than in comparative structures has been criticised. Because there is usually little to be gained by using than with hardly, hardly … when or recasting should be used. 2 Because hardly means almost not, it should not be used with another negative. further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 328 (hard or hardly), 746 (than) Fowler’s English Usage p 350 (hardly) Garner’s Legal Style p 116 (hardly) Gowers’ Plain Words p 231 (hard, hardly) Howard’s Guide p 42 (barely, hardly and scarcely) Howard’s Handbook p 44 (barely/hardly/scarcely) Longman English Usage p 332 (hardly, barely, scarcely) has / have a liability to usage—never use try—must / is liable to extra information verbosity example of change A person has a liability to must pay the fee. has / have a responsibility to usage—never use try—must / is responsible / for extra information verbosity Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 H–1 H has / have knowledge of usage—avoid using if possible try—know / aware extra information verbosity example of change 1 He has knowledge of knows what happened. 2 She had knowledge of was aware of the danger. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 912 (verbosity) has / have need of usage—avoid using if possible try—needs / requires / wants / desires / wishes extra information verbosity further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 912 (verbosity) has / have no power to usage—never use try—cannot / must not / may not extra information verbosity has / have power to usage—never use try—may / can extra information verbosity has / have the option of usage—never use try—may extra information verbosity Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 H–2 H he usage—avoid using if possible try—recasting (avoiding gender-specific personal pronouns) extra information 1 Avoid personal pronouns in the masculine or feminine form as far as possible. If it is necessary to use a personal pronoun, both masculine and feminine forms must be used, eg he or she. The neuter form need not be used (see LA, s 145 (a)). 2 The use of he or she occasionally in a document is appropriate, but it makes the text laboured and cumbersome if used repeatedly. It also gives rise to unnecessary argument, eg whether she should be used before he and, if so, how often. Usually it is convenient (and often clearer) to repeat the relevant noun, eg the applicant, the judge, the authorised person. He or she should, therefore, be used only where it is idiomatically required. 3 If a provision applies only to the neuter form (eg to a corporation), a personal pronoun in the neuter form only (eg it) may be used wherever appropriate. 4 They can be used to avoid personal pronouns in the masculine and feminine forms. It works well if the sentence is written in the plural. However, this type of sentence is usually not suitable for legal drafting. 5 The use of the pronoun they (or their) to refer to a singular subject is now increasing, eg ‘If a person wants to apply for a licence, they must complete a driving test’. However, this use of they (or their) is still contentious and it should only be used as a last resort. 6 In some situations, you can be substituted. It creates a style that addresses the reader more directly. However, it should be clear to the reader who you is. This approach is still a fairly novel one for legislation and needs to be used with caution. further reading Asprey pp 152–61 Cambridge Style Guide pp 331–3 (he and/or she) Cwlth OPC Plain English p 18 Cwlth Style Manual pp 58–9 (Sex-neutral references to individuals) Corporations Law Simplification Task Force paper on singular use of they Fowler’s English Usage p 358 (he or she) Garner’s Dictionary pp 799–803 (sexism) Garner’s Legal Style pp 45, 200–3 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 118–9 (they for he or she) Howard’s Guide pp 197 (he or she; he or they), 397 (unisex grammar) Howard’s Handbook pp 190–1 (he or she; he/they), 360 (unisex grammar) New Oxford Dictionary pp 844-5, 1711 (she) Right Words p 154 (the female critique) Working Words pp 184 (discriminatory language), 254 (he/she) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 H–3 H hear and decide usage—consider alternatives before using try—hear / decide / deal with / no change extra information 1 doublet 2 Use both hear and decide only if necessary. 3 Hear and decide may be necessary to refer to the entire court procedure giving rise to issue estoppel (see example of no change). example of no change The magistrate must not hear and decide the charge. example of change If the defendant chooses to have the offence heard and decided dealt with by a court,... hear and determine usage—never use try—hear and decide / hear / decide / deal with extra information doublet heirs, executors, administrators, successors and assigns usage—avoid using if possible try—omitting / recasting extra information 1 word-string with technical legal meanings 2 Contracts occasionally define a party to include the party’s heirs, executors, administrators, successors and assigns. Similar definitions are sometimes included in legislation. 3 Expanding the definition of party in this way has little or no legal effect on its own. It is mostly descriptive of the way in which the general law would operate anyway. However, it may give rise to legal difficulties and should usually be avoided. 4 See LA, s 168. see also—assign further reading Dick p 131 Garner’s Dictionary pp 29 (administrator; executor), 83 (assign; assignee), 338 (executor; executer), 400 (heir) Garner’s Legal Style p 184 (and the heirs of his body) Law Words 1995 pp 38–40 Piesse pp 43–5, 54 help see—assist Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 H–4 H hence usage—avoid using if possible try—therefore / from now on / as a result / from here / so / thus / recasting / omitting extra information 1 Hence, ie ‘from this point’, can be useful for introducing a conclusion instead of therefore, thus or so. However, the word is becoming an archaism. 2 Hence should not be used in relation to space (eg ‘from here’) or time (eg ‘from now on’). further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 338 Cutts p 34 Fowler’s English Usage pp 316 (from whence), 357 Garner’s Dictionary p 878 (thence; whence; hence) Right Words pp 188–9 Working Words p 255 henceforth usage—never use try—from now on / recasting (using eg on and after) / omitting extra information archaism further reading Cutts p 28 Garner’s Redbook p 161 Gowers’ Plain Words p 232 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 283 henceforward usage—never use try—from now on / recasting (using eg on and after) / omitting extra information archaism her usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (avoiding gender-specific personal pronouns) / no change extra information 1 see she 2 Prefer recasting if appropriate. further reading Garner’s Legal Style pp 31, 200 (him/her) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 H–5 H hereafter usage—never use try—after [X] / from now on / recasting / omitting extra information archaism further reading Asprey pp 123–4, 175, 222 Howard’s Guide p 200 (here-words) Howard’s Handbook p 192 (here-words) Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 283 hereby usage—never use try—then / by [X] / by way of [X] / because of [X] / by force of [X]/ recasting (supplying any necessary details) / omitting extra information archaism further reading Asprey pp 123–4, 222 Cutts pp 34–5 Evans p 132 Garner’s Redbook p 162 Howard’s Guide p 200 (here-words) Howard’s Handbook p 192 (here-words) Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 283 herein usage—never use try—in [X] / recasting / omitting extra information archaism further reading Asprey pp 123–4, 222 Cutts pp 34–5 Dick p 150 Garner’s Legal Style p 116 Garner’s Redbook p 161 Gowers’ Plain Words p 18 Howard’s Guide p 200 (here-words) Howard’s Handbook p 192 (here-words) Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 283 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 H–6 H hereinafter usage—never use try—after [X] / recasting / omitting extra information archaism further reading Asprey pp 123–4, 175, 222 Garner’s Legal Style pp 116-7 (herinafter called), 182 Howard’s Guide p 200 (here-words) Howard’s Handbook p 192 (here-words) Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 283 hereinbefore usage—never use try—before [X] / recasting / omitting extra information archaism further reading Asprey pp 123–4 Cutts pp 34–5 Dick p 150 (hereinbefore mentioned) Garner’s Legal Style p 116 Howard’s Guide p 200 (here-words) Howard’s Handbook p 192 (here-words) Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 283 hereof usage—never use try—of [X] / recasting / omitting extra information archaism further reading Asprey pp 123–4 Cutts pp 34–5 Gowers’ Plain Words p 18 Howard’s Guide p 200 (here-words) Howard’s Handbook p 192 (here-words) Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 283 Partridge p 33 (archaisms) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 H–7 H hereto usage—never use try—to [X] / recasting / omitting extra information archaism further reading Asprey pp 123–4 Cutts pp 34–5 Evans p 132 Gowers’ Plain Words p 18 Howard’s Guide p 200 (here-words) Howard’s Handbook p 192 (here-words) Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 283 heretofore usage—never use try—before [X] / up to now / until now / to this time / recasting / omitting extra information archaism further reading Asprey pp 123–4, 175, 222 Cutts pp 28, 34–5 Garner’s Dictionary pp 404 (hitherto; thitherto), 904–5 (up to now) Garner’s Redbook p 161 Howard’s Guide p 200 (here-words) Howard’s Handbook p 192 (here-words) Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 283 Partridge p 33 (archaisms) hereunder usage—never use try—under [X] / recasting (using, eg follows / below) / omitting extra information archaism further reading Asprey pp 123–4 Gowers’ Plain Words p 18 Howard’s Guide p 200 (here-words) Howard’s Handbook p 192 (here-words) Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 283 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 H–8 H hereunto usage—never use try—to [X] / recasting extra information archaism further reading Asprey pp 123–4, 222 Garner’s Legal Style pp 182-3 Howard’s Guide p 200 (here-words) Howard’s Handbook p 192 (here-words) Partridge p 33 (archaisms) herewith usage—never use try—attached /with [X] / with this [X] / by way of [X] / here is / recasting / omitting extra information archaism further reading Asprey pp 123–4, 222 Cutts pp 28, 34–5 Garner’s Legal Style p 116 Gowers’ Plain Words p 18 Howard’s Guide p 200 (here-words) Howard’s Handbook p 192 (here-words) Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 283 him usage—avoid using if possible try—recasting (avoiding gender-specific personal pronouns) extra information see he further reading Garner’s Legal Style pp 31, 200 (him/her) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 H–9 H his usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (avoiding gender-specific personal pronouns) / no change extra information 1 see he 2 Prefer recasting if appropriate. further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 201 hither usage—never use try—to this place / here / in this direction / recasting extra information archaism further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 338 (hence) Fowler’s English Usage p 362 Right Words pp 188–9 hitherto usage—never use try—before [X] / previously / up to now / until now / recasting extra information archaism further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words pp 93-4 Cutts p 28 Garner’s Dictionary pp 404 (hitherto; thitherto), 904–5 (up to now) Garner’s Redbook p 161 Howard’s Guide p 202 Howard’s Handbook p 193 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 286 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 H–10 H hopefully usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using I hope or let us hope or it is hoped that) / no change extra information 1 Hopefully traditionally meant with hope or in a hopeful way. However, it is now widely used as a sentence adverb (ie an adverb that qualifies a sentence as a whole) to express the hopes of the person using it, eg ‘I hope’. This extended use has been heavily criticised, but appears to be well established. 2 Because of its extended use, care needs to be taken to avoid ambiguity when using hopefully (see example 2, examples of change). see also—regretfully; thankfully example of no change He looked hopefully at the clock. examples of change 1 Hopefully, I will I hope to leave on the 10 am plane. 2 The meeting will resume hopefully straight after lunch. We hope that the meeting will resume straight after lunch. [or The meeting will resume straight after lunch and we hope that the outstanding issues can be resolved.] further reading Blamires’ Plain English p 311 (the parenthetical adverb) Bryson’s Troublesome Words p- 95-7 Cambridge Style Guide pp 345–6 Cwlth Style Manual p 74 (‘Hopefully’ as a sentence adverb) Fowler’s English Usage pp 366, 702–3 (sentence adverb) Garner’s Dictionary pp 407–8, 792 (sentence adverbs), 813 (slipshod extension) Garner’s Legal Style pp 33, 117 Garner’s Redbook p 212 (hopefully; fortunately) Gowers’ Plain Words pp 232–3 Howard’s Guide p 204 Howard’s Handbook p 195 Longman English Usage pp 343-4, 640–1 (sentence adverbs) Strunk and White p 48 Working Words p 259 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 H–11 H house usage—consider alternatives before using try—home extra information Prefer home if appropriate. examples of no change 1 a fashion house 2 a carafe of house red 3 There was a full house. examples of change She invited me to her house home. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 554 (home) Fowler’s English Usage p 363 (home, house) Howard’s Guide pp 203 (home or house), 205–6 Hudson p 183 (house) Longman English Usage p 341 (home) New Oxford Dictionary pp 876–7 (home), 888–9 Right Words p 191 (home/house) how see—as to how Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 H–12 H however usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / recasting / but / even so / yet / on the other hand / by whatever means / to whatever extent / no matter how / how / no change extra information 1 There is no rule preventing the use of however at the beginning of a sentence. The placement of however is governed by the nature of the sentence in which it appears. 2 However is useful for providing a contrast. 3 However should generally be used sparingly as an intensifier, and generally only when it is necessary to emphasise the universal application of a provision. see also—whatever; whenever; wherever; whichever; whoever example of no change (2) The chief police officer must keep the motor vehicle under this section until the earlier of the following happens: (a) the person is dealt with by a court for the offence; …… (3) However, subsection (2) does not apply if…….. further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 258–9 (-ever or ever), 347–8 Cutts p 35 Cwlth Style Manual pp 74–5 (‘However’ as a conjunction), 101 (Linked clauses) Fowler’s English Usage p 367 Garner’s Dictionary p 409 Gowers’ Plain Words p 163 Howard’s Guide p 206 Howard’s Handbook p 196 Longman English Usage p 346 Partridge p 147 Right Words pp 194–5 (how/however) Strunk and White pp 48–9 Working Words p 260 (how ever/however) howsoever usage—never use try—by whatever means / to whatever extent / no matter how / however / recasting extra information archaism example of change A ship is any kind of vessel used in navigation by water, howsoever however propelled or moved. further reading Asprey pp 123–4, 222 Cambridge Style Guide p 57 (archaisms) Garner’s Dictionary p 409 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 H–13 H husband usage—never use try—spouse / partner / domestic partner / no change extra information 1 Discrimination on the ground of marital status is unlawful under the Discrimination Act 1991. 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. 3 LA, s 169 provides a definition of domestic partner. Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 H–14 I idem see—ad idem identified in usage—consider alternatives before using try—mentioned in / no change extra information 1 Prefer mentioned in if appropriate. 2 Be careful not to draw artificial distinctions in provisions by using different words to say essentially the same thing, eg do not say in one provision ‘a person mentioned in section x’, and then in another provision ‘a thing identified in section y’, if the person or thing is only being identified by the reference. example of no change The defendant was identified in a line-up by the victim. identify usage—consider alternatives before using try—name / no change see also—identified in; identify with example of no change An inspector must identify himself or herself by showing an identity card. further reading Garner’s Legal Style pp 117-8 identify with usage—consider alternatives before using try—associate with / closely link with / understand / support / recasting / no change extra information 1 vogue phrase 2 Do not use identify with without a direct object. further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 361-2 Garner’s Dictionary pp 413, 919 (vogue words) Garner’s Legal Style p 118 Gowers’ Plain Words p 233 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–1 I ideology usage—consider alternatives before using try—faith / creed / beliefs / philosophy / no change further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 118 Gowers’ Plain Words p 234 Howard’s Guide p 210 (ideology or philosophy) ie usage—consider alternatives before using try—that is / that is to say / eg / for example / no change extra information 1 This is sometimes used (by confusion with eg) to introduce an example. It stands for id est (that is) and introduces a definition, eg ‘the outposted officers, ie Ms X and Mr Y’. Eg stands for exempli gratia (for the sake of example) and introduces an illustration, eg ‘a domestic animal eg a cat’. 2 Abbreviations such as ie can be freely used in notes, tables and provision headings where brevity is particularly importance. (It would, however, be unlikely that ie could appropriately be used in a provision heading.) 3 In general writing the use of ie is now generally acceptable in more contexts than in the past. For example, it can be used in general writing as part of the text inside brackets. In legislation ie can, therefore, be used in provisions (including examples) inside brackets. 4 A comma or another punctuation mark (eg an opening bracket or dash) should usually be used before ie. A comma should not be used after ie. 5 Use without full stops. further reading Asprey p 162 Blamires’ Plain English p 112 (Latin abbreviations) Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 64 (eg, ie) Cambridge Style Guide pp 362–3 Cutts pp 38, 39 Cwlth Style Manual p 155 (Latin shortened forms) Evans p 132 Fowler’s English Usage p 376 Garner’s Dictionary p 414 Garner’s Legal Style p 112 (eg/ie) Garner’s Redbook p 204 (e.g.; i.e.) Gowers’ Plain Words p 234 Howard’s Guide p 143 (eg or ie) Howard’s Handbook p 150 (eg/ie) Longman English Usage pp 234–5 (eg, ie), 758 (viz, ie) Oxford English Usage p 133 (eg/ie) Right Words p 130 (eg) Strunk and White p 3 Working Words p 200 (eg/ie) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–2 I if usage—consider alternatives before using try—though / but / and / however / whether / whether or not / although / no change extra information 1 The use of if for though, but, and or however may give rise to ambiguity or absurdity (see example 1, examples of change). 2 Care is also needed in the use of if in the sense of whether. This too can give rise to ambiguity. For the use of whether and if, see whether. 3 If can also be a source of ambiguity if combined with not. If not is best avoided (see example 2, examples of change). 4 It is usually unnecessary to use then after an if clause (see example 3, examples of change). 5 For the use of if, when and where, see where. 6 Blamires states that the word if should link directly with a verb eg ‘He will die if he continues smoking like that’ (if links directly with the verb will die). It is not correct to make if hang on a noun eg ‘Workers are threatening a strike if their demands are not met (if hangs on a strike). The threat is there without any condition. It is the strike that is conditional. Instead, ‘The workers are threatening to strike if their demands are not met’. see also—if and when; if any; if practicable; if this is not the case; if this is the case examples of change 1 This case, if though not proved, is arguable. 2 The instructor gave a short, if not considered although not considered, [or but not considered] reply to the query. 3 If the notice is given, then the plaintiff must … further reading Blamires’ Plain English pp 212-3 Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 99 Cambridge Style Guide pp 364–5 Fowler’s English Usage pp 376–7 Garner’s Dictionary pp 414, 414–5 (if not) Garner’s Legal Style p 65 Gowers’ Plain Words p 103 Howard’s Guide pp 32 (as and when and if and when), 408 (whether or if) Howard’s Handbook pp 34–5 (as and when/if and when), 200 (if/whether) Longman English Usage p 355 Oxford English Usage pp 141, 221 Partridge p 152 Right Words pp 201 (if/if not), 201–2 (if/whether) Working Words p 268 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–3 I if, and only if / if, but only if usage—avoid using if possible try—if / only if / recasting (using eg must not…unless or may…only if) extra information 1 In logic, the proposition ‘A if, and only if, B’ implies 2 propositions: • ‘if A, then B’ • ‘if B, then A’ (or ‘if not B, then not A’) 2 However, in legislation, if, and only if, is often used simply as a more emphatic form for if’ or only if conditional statements. 3 But in legislation if , and only if, is sometimes used to combine both a grant of power (if) with a restriction on the exercise of the power (only if). Care must be taken in recasting existing provisions using the term to ensure that the dual senses of grant and restriction are retained. examples of change 1 A person has a defined qualification if, and only if, if the person has a degree of the following kind: … 2 An act or practice breaches an information privacy principle if, and only if, only if it is contrary to, or inconsistent with, the principle. 3 For this chapter, property belongs to a person if, and only if, only if— … 4 An inspector may enter premises if, and only if, only if the entry is made— (a) in accordance with a search warrant; or (b) with the occupier’s consent of the occupier. further reading Garner’s Redbook p 212 (if an only if; only if) if and when usage—avoid using if possible try—if / when / whenever / recasting extra information 1 doublet 2 compound preposition 3 If and when should be reserved for cases where there is substantial doubt about whether an event will happen and it is necessary to reinforce the doubt. see also—as and when; unless and until further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 99 Fowler’s English Usage p 377 Garner’s Dictionary p 414 Garner’s Legal Style p 118 Gowers’ Plain Words p 61 Howard’s Guide p 32 (as and when and if and when) Howard’s Handbook pp 34-5 (as and when/if and when) Longman English Usage p 355 (if 4.) Partridge p 152 Working Words p 268 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–4 I if any usage—avoid using if possible try—recasting (using eg any) / omitting extra information 1 If any should be used sparingly. 2 If used, use brackets not commas, ie (if any), not, if any,. example of no change on the conditions (if any) stated in the certificate example of change if an agent made the sale for the owner—the agent’s name and address (if any) further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 414 if not see—if if possible usage—consider alternatives before using try—if practicable / recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information can be weasel words see also—possible if practicable usage—consider alternatives before using try—if possible / recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information can be weasel words see also—practicable further reading Evans p 145 (Weasel words) Garner’s Dictionary p 926 (weasel words) if the context permits / allows see—where/if the context permits/allows Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–5 I if this is not the case usage—avoid using if possible try—if not / recasting extra information verbosity further reading Cutts p 28 if this is the case usage—avoid using if possible try—if so / recasting extra information verbosity further reading Cutts p 28 illegible see—unreadable illusion usage—consider alternatives before using try—delusion / allusion / mirage / no change extra information 1 Illusion, delusion and allusion are sometimes confused. 2 The Cambridge Style Guide states that illusion and delusion both refer to false perceptions, although their implications are slightly different. Delusion suggests that the misapprehension is subjective and results from distorted thinking or a disordered mind. Illusion suggests that the misapprehension is produced by external circumstances, eg ‘an optical illusion’. 3 An allusion is, by contrast, a passing reference or an incidental mention of something, either directly or by implication. further reading Blamires’ Plain English p 53 (delusion/illusion) Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 9 (allusion) Cambridge Style Guide p 195 (delusion or illusion) Fowler’s English Usage pp 44 (allusion, allude) 203, (delusion, illusion) Garner’s Dictionary pp 46 (allusion; illusion), 418 (illusion; delusion) Garner’s Legal Style p 102 (allusion; illusion) Garner’s Redbook pp 185 (allusion; illusion), 212 (illusion; delusion; hallucination) Hudson pp 19–21 (allusion) Longman English Usage pp 29 (allusion, reference), 193 (delusion, illusion) Strunk and White p 40 (allusion) Working Words p 27 (allusion, illusion, delusion) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–6 I imbibe usage—never use try—drink / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 euphemism further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 309 (formal words) Garner’s Dictionary pp 370 (formal words), 418 Longman English Usage p 358 imbue usage—avoid using if possible try—inspire (with) / infuse (with) / instil (into) / no change extra information Prefer a less formal alternative if appropriate. further reading Fowler’s English Usage pp 395–6 (infuse) Gowers’ Plain Words p 235 (inculcate) Howard’s Guide p 212 (imbue or infuse) Howard’s Handbook p 203 (imbue/infuse) Longman English Usage pp 358, 368 (inculcate) Partridge p 153 Working Words p 270 (imbue/infuse/instil) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–7 I immediately usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / quickly / promptly / at once / now / as soon as practicable / as soon as possible / as quickly as practicable / as quickly as possible / when / straight away / recasting (mentioning a period, eg within 14 days) / no change extra information 1 It is generally unnecessary to use immediately with before or after. For example, it is unnecessary to say in a provision the day immediately after the day when payment is made. The day after the day when payment is made would be sufficient. The day after indicates that the provision cannot be referring to any day after the day of payment, rather it can be referring only to the very next day after that day. 2 For the use of as quickly as practicable and as quickly as possible, see as soon as practicable and as soon as possible. example of no change A person who was a member immediately before the commencement of the scheme may … examples of change 1 Please tell me immediately as soon as [or when] you receive it. 2 the immediately preceding last financial year 3 28 days immediately preceding before the day this Act commences further reading Asprey pp 176–7 Gowers’ Plain Words p 234 Howard’s Guide p 212 (immediately, forthwith or straight away) Howard’s Handbook p 203 (immediately/forthwith/straightaway) impact [as a noun] usage—consider alternatives before using try—effect / influence / no change / recasting extra information 1 vogue word 2 Prefer effect or influence if appropriate. example of change The development of the graphical interface has had a significant impact effect on the popularity of personal computers. further reading Blamires’ Plain English p 39 Evans p 132 Garner’s Dictionary pp 420, 919 (vogue words) Garner’s Legal Style p 118 Garner’s Redbook p 158 Gowers’ Plain Words p 234 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–8 I impart usage—avoid using if possible try—give / tell / pass on / inform / instruct / mention / point out / say / show / specify / state extra information formal word further reading Cutts p 28 implement [as a verb] usage—consider alternatives before using try—carry out / perform / conduct / do / keep / set up / put in place / fulfil / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. example of no change An agency head must implement fair employment practices. examples of change 1 to implement carry out the commissioner’s recommendations 2 The committee must ensure that an effective quality assurance system is implemented set up for complaints. further reading Cutts p 28 Garner’s Legal Style p 119 Garner’s Redbook p 158 Gowers’ Plain Words p 234 imply usage—consider alternatives before using try—infer / suggest/ hint / no change extra information For the use of imply and infer, see infer. further reading Blamires’ Plain English p 60 (imply/infer) Bryson’s Troublesome Words pp 99-100 (imply, infer) Garner’s Legal Style p 119 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 235–6 (infer) Mellinkoff’s Dictionary pp 301–2 Working Words p 272 (imply/infer) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–9 I import [as a noun in the sense of giving meaning] usage—never use try—meaning extra information formal word example of change ‘Try’ does not have the same import meaning as ‘endeavour’. import [as a verb in the sense of giving meaning] usage—never use try—express extra information formal word example of change ‘Try’ does not import express the full meaning of ‘endeavour’. important usage—consider alternatives before using try—significant / substantial / critical / key / recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information 1 Important is a vague, omnibus word. See kind for extra information. 2 Prefer a more precise alternative if appropriate. further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 100 (important, importantly) Fowler’s English Usage pp 382–4 Garner’s Legal Style pp 32, 205 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–10 I importantly usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using neutral or more precise words) / no change extra information 1 Importantly can operate as a sentence adverb (ie an adverb that qualifies a sentence as a whole), especially when preceded by more or most. 2 Importantly can be ambiguous in some contexts. It can mean ‘in an important way’ or ‘significantly’. see also—important further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 100 (important, importantly) Fowler’s English Usage pp 383, 702–3 (sentence adverbs) Garner’s Dictionary pp 791–2 (sentence adverbs) Working Words p 272 importation usage—avoid using if possible try—import / no change extra information 1 Importation can mean the act of importing. 2 Generally prefer import. impose usage—consider alternatives before using try—provide / prescribe / give / omitting / recasting / no change extra information Use impose only for obligations or punishments. examples of no change 1 A penalty is imposed on the person. 2 This Act imposes a general obligation for safety. examples of change 1 given or imposed 2 The captain is released from the obligation imposed on the captain by subsection (1) captain’s obligation under subsection (1). 3 the period of limitation imposed under this section Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–11 I in a case in which / to which / where usage—avoid using if possible try—if / recasting (using eg for) extra information verbosity example of change in a case to which if section 5 applies further reading Asprey p 163 (where) Cwlth OPC Plain English pp 17–8 in accordance therewith usage—never use try—in accordance with / under extra information archaism in accordance with usage—consider alternatives before using try—under / by / as required under / as required by / according to / as specified in / agrees with / in line with / recasting / no change extra information 1 compound preposition 2 Generally, prefer under to in accordance with. However, use in accordance with if it is necessary to emphasise, or make it clear, that something must be done in a particular way or in a way complying with certain requirements. 3 See LA, dict, pt 1, def under. examples of no change 1 The Minister may approve a recommendation only if satisfied that the recommendation has been made in accordance with the guidelines. 2 (1) The child should be placed in accordance with the first of the following options that is available.... (2) If the child cannot be placed in accordance with subsection (1).... examples of change 1 A person may construct a road only in accordance with under section 10. 2 the category given to the goods in accordance with under subsection (2) [if subsection (2) only provides for the allocation of goods to categories] further reading Cutts p 28 Evans p 116 (accordingly) Garner’s Dictionary p 14 (accord; accordance) Garner’s Redbook p 160 Gowers’ Plain Words p 55 Howard’s Guide p 5 (in accordance with) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–12 I in actual fact see—actually/actual in addition to usage—consider alternatives before using try—additional to / as well as / besides / recasting (using also or and) / no change extra information 1 compound preposition 2 can lead to verbosity 3 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. example of no change The payment is in addition to … examples of change 1 (3) In addition to any payment to which the officer is entitled under subsection (2), the The officer is also entitled to … 2 The powers of an inspector under this Act are in addition additional to, and do not limit, the powers of an inspector under other Acts. further reading Blamires’ Plain English p 200 Garner’s Redbook p 160 Gowers’ Plain Words p 55 Howard’s Guide p 8 (addition) Longman English Usage p 16 (additional(ly)) Working Words p 273 in all probability usage—avoid using if possible try—probably extra information verbosity example of change It will in all probability probably rain during training. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 85 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–13 I in a … manner / way usage—avoid using if possible try—recasting (using the appropriate adverb ending in ly) extra information verbosity see also—in a timely manner/way examples of change 1 in a careful way carefully 2 in a cautious manner cautiously further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 882–3 (timely) Garner’s Legal Style p 125 Garner’s Redbook p 160 Gowers’ Plain Words p 85 (in a cautious manner) in and / or in connection with usage—never use try—about / for / in / of / over / to / with / in relation to / in connection with / recasting extra information doublet in an effort to usage—never use try—to extra information verbosity example of change She ran in an effort to catch up. in any case usage—consider alternatives before using try—in any event / anyway / no change extra information Prefer an alternative if appropriate. further reading Evans p 132 (in case of) Garner’s Dictionary p 133 (case) Garner’s Legal Style p 106 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–14 I in a particular respect usage—never use try—omitting extra information redundancy in a position usage—avoid using if possible try—recasting (using more direct words, eg can) extra information 1 vague phrase 2 can lead to woolly writing examples of change 1 Are you in a position to Can you give me your weekly report? 2 I am not in a position to cannot agree to your request. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words pp 62 (not in a position), 254 in as much as usage—never use try—since / because of / so far as / in that extra information compound preposition further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 575 Cutts p 28 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 55, 103–4 Howard’s Guide p 214 (in as much as, insofar as or in so much as) Howard’s Handbook p 207 (in as much as/ insofar as/ in so much as) in association with usage—consider alternatives before using try—with / no change / in relation to extra information 1 compound preposition 2 In association with implies a looser connection with something than with. 3 Prefer with if appropriate. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 55 Longman English Usage p 63 (association) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–15 I in a timely manner / way usage—never use try—promptly / quickly / as soon as possible / as soon as practicable / immediately / at once / as quickly as possible / as quickly as practicable / recasting extra information 1 verbosity 2 For the use of as quickly as possible and as quickly as practicable, see as soon as possible and as soon as practicable. further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 882–3 (timely) in attendance usage—avoid using if possible try—present / recasting extra information 1 formal phrase 2 verbosity example of change The member chosen by the members in attendance present presides. inaugurate usage—consider alternatives before using try—start / begin / introduce / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer start or begin if appropriate. 3 For the use of start and begin, see commence. example of change The judge inaugurated started the proceeding. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 370 (formal words) Gowers’ Plain Words p 235 in behalf of see—on behalf of Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–16 I in camera usage—never use try—not in open court / not open to the public / in closed court / privately / in chambers / recasting extra information foreign phrase further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 575 Cambridge Style Guide p 372 Garner’s Dictionary pp 428–9 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 304 (in camera; in chambers) incapable usage—consider alternatives before using try—cannot / unable / may not / no change extra information For the use of can and may, see can and may. examples of change if the person is incapable of giving cannot give consent within a reasonable time is physically or legally incapable of consenting cannot consent incapacitated usage—consider alternatives before using try—unable to (eg work or earn income) / no change extra information 1 formal word with negative overtones 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 19 incapacity usage—consider alternatives before using try—illness / disability / no change extra information 1 formal word with negative overtones 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–17 I in case usage—avoid using if possible try—if extra information compound preposition further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 372 Evans p 132 (in case of) Garner’s Legal Style pp 106, 183 Gowers’ Plain Words p 55 Longman English Usage p 112 (case) inception usage—avoid using if possible try—start / beginning extra information 1 formal word 2 For the use of start and begin, see commence. example of change The project has changed dramatically since its inception it started. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 235 incidence usage—consider alternatives before using try—how often / rate of (occurrence) / extent / no change extra information If possible, avoid using rate of occurrence rather than rate of (see occur). example of change the incidence extent of the disease in the Territory further reading Cutts p 28 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–18 I incidentally usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / no change extra information can be a redundancy example of change The seminar will include 3 segments, each incidentally written specially for the seminar. further reading Garner’s Legal Style pp 119, 120 (incident(al) to) Gowers’ Plain Words p 54 inclined to think usage—avoid using if possible try—omitting / recasting extra information 1 timid phrase 2 Overuse of inclined to think may cause ridicule. see also—it seems further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 42 in close proximity usage—never use try—near / close / nearby / close by extra information 1 verbosity 2 Use an alternative. example of change The child may be placed with a carer who lives in close proximity near the child’s family or community. further reading Blamires’ Common Errors p 245 (proximity) Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 948 (proximity) Garner’s Dictionary p 711 (proximate; proximal) Gowers’ Plain Words p 85 Longman English Usage p 575 (proximity) New Oxford Dictionary p 1494 (proximity) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–19 I includes see—comprise; means and includes; the term includes/also includes inclusive usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / recasting / no change extra information 1 can be a redundancy 2 See LA, s 106 (References to provisions of laws are inclusive). example of no change from 9 to 12 December 1996 (inclusive) example of change sections 1 to 3 (inclusive) in compliance with usage—consider alternatives before using try—in accordance with / recasting (using, eg complying with) / under / as required by / as required under / no change extra information 1 formal phrase 2 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate example of change If a parentage test is carried out in compliance with in accordance with section 10, ...[or If a parentage test complies with section 10,...] in conjunction with usage—avoid using if possible try—with / and extra information compound preposition example of change The Act must be read in conjunction with the Taxation Administration Act. further reading Cutts p 29 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–20 I in connection with usage—avoid using if possible try—about / for / in / of / over / with / to / in relation to / recasting extra information 1 compound preposition 2 connecting phrase 3 Prefer a simpler preposition if appropriate. If it is necessary to use a connecting phrase, prefer in relation to wherever appropriate (see in relation to). see also—for and/or in connection with; in and/or in connection with examples of change 1 The corporation has the legal capacity and powers of an individual for or in connection with the performance of for carrying out its functions. [or omit all words after ‘individual’] 2 The committee may do anything necessary or convenient to be done for, or in connection with relation to, its functions. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 576 (in connection with or caused by) Gowers’ Plain Words pp 4, 18, 55–6 in consequence of usage—avoid using if possible try—because of / recasting (using so or therefore) extra information compound preposition further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 216 incontestably / incontestable usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / recasting (using more ‘neutral’ words) / no change extra information 1 Incontestably is a sentence adverb (ie an adverb that qualifies a sentence as a whole). 2 Incontestably and incontestable are dogmatic words. 3 Prefer a more ‘neutral’ alternative if appropriate. further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 36 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–21 I increasingly less usage—never use try—less and less extra information logically inconsistent phrase further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 235 incredible usage—consider alternatives before using try—incredulous / omitting / no change extra information Only a person can be incredulous (ie unable to believe something). By contrast facts and events are incredible (ie unable to be believed). further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 373–4 Garner’s Legal Style p 120 Right Words p 206 (incredible/incredulous) incredulous usage—consider alternatives before using try—incredible / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 For the use of incredulous and incredible, see incredible. further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 120 Right Words p 206 (incredible/incredulous) increment usage—consider alternatives before using try—step / increase / addition / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. further reading Cutts p 29 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–22 I inculcate usage—consider alternatives before using try—imbue / impress on / indoctrinate / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer a less formal alternative if appropriate. 3 One inculcates values into people and one indoctrinates people with values. 4 For the use of inculcate and imbue, see imbue. further reading Fowler’s English Usage pp 389–90 Garner’s Dictionary p 435 Gowers’ Plain Words p 235 Longman English Usage p 368 Right Words p 206 Working Words p 274 incumbent on usage—avoid using if possible try—recasting (using must) extra information 1 formal word 2 can lead to woolly writing incur usage—avoid using if possible try—recasting extra information formal word examples of change 1 reasonable administrative costs incurred by of the board 2 incurred expense spent money on further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 585 (incurred) and (incurring a debt) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–23 I indebtedness usage—consider alternatives before using try—debt / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer debt if appropriate. further reading Cutts p 29 in-depth [as an adjective] usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / comprehensive / thorough / detailed / no change extra information 1 vogue phrase 2 sometimes a redundancy examples of change 1 an in-depth a comprehensive review 2 an in-depth a thorough study further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 51 indicate usage—consider alternatives before using try—direct / imply / mention / name / nominate / point out / point to / say / show / specify / state / tell / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. see also—except as / where otherwise provided/indicated examples of change 1 The evidence clearly indicates shows the nature of the offence. 2 The applicant must indicate to tell the registrar … 3 the concentration of alcohol in the person’s blood indicated shown by the test further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 370 (formal words), 438 Garner’s Legal Style p 120 Gowers’ Plain Words p 235 Right Words pp 206-7 (indicate) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–24 I indisputably / indisputable usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / recasting (using more ‘neutral’ words) / no change extra information 1 Indisputably is a sentence adverb (ie an adverb that qualified a sentence as a whole). 2 Indisputably and indisputable are dogmatic words. 3 Prefer a more ‘neutral’ alternative if appropriate. further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 161 (clearly), 632 (overstatement), 791–2 (sentence adverbs), 926 (weasel words) individual usage—consider alternatives before using try—person / people / no change extra information 1 Use individual to distinguish a natural person from a corporation (see LA, dict, pt 1, defs individual and person). 2 Individual is also appropriate to contrast a person with an organisation or body of people (whether express or implied). 3 However, it is inappropriate as a synonym for person. examples of no change 1 An individual or corporation may apply for a licence. 2 The company had individual and corporate shareholders. 3 How can a single individual hope to rectify all the evils of society? 4 He is very much an individual. 5 The rights of the individual against the State. examples of change 1 Do you see that individual person standing over there? 2 He is a strange individual person. 3 There were a number of individuals people in the room. further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 102 Fowler’s English Usage pp 391-2 Garner’s Dictionary p 439 Garner’s Legal Style p 439 Howard’s Handbook p 209 Howard’s Guide p 209 Hudson p 199 Longman English Usage p 370 Partridge p 157 Right Words p 208 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–25 I inebriated usage—avoid using if possible try—intoxicated / under the influence of (eg alcohol or drugs) / recasting (using affected by …) extra information 1 formal word 2 euphemism further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 34 in every case usage—consider alternatives before using try—always / in every instance / no change extra information Prefer an alternative if appropriate. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 133 (case) Garner’s Legal Style p 106 (case of, in the) inevitably usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / no change extra information Inevitably is usually only needed if the element of inevitability needs to be stressed. see also—must inevitably/necessarily further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 54 in excess of usage—avoid using if possible try—over / exceeds / greater than / heavier than / larger than / longer than / more than / older than / taller than / recasting (using at least) extra information 1 compound preposition 2 Prefer an alternative. Generally, prefer over, at least, or a more specific alternative, eg heavier than, to other alternatives. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 55 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–26 I infant usage—consider alternatives before using try—child / not an adult / minor / baby / juvenile / recasting (using a defined term, eg young person) / no change extra information 1 imprecise, no legal meaning 2 Prefer child or recasting. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary pp 596-7 Gowers’ Plain Words p 235 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary pp 73–5 (child/infant/minor) in favour of usage—avoid using if possible try—for / supporting extra information compound preposition example of change I am in favour of support the motion. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 55 infer usage—consider alternatives before using try—imply / derive / conclude / no change extra information It is a common error to use infer for imply. A writer or speaker implies (ie says something indirectly) what the reader or hearer infers (ie deduces). For example, if you see someone staggering along the road you may infer that the person is drunk, but if you say ‘Had one too many?’, you do not infer but imply that the person is drunk (Gowers p 235 quoting A P Herbert). The distinction between infer and imply is, however, becoming blurred in practice and imply is replacing infer as the word used in all contexts. Nevertheless, the distinction should continue to be observed. example of change I inferred from the lack of response that no-one was home. example of no change The councillor inferred implied that he would not agree to the proposal by refusing to answer questions. further reading Blamires’ Plain English p 60 (imply/infer) Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 597 (inference) Cambridge Style Guide pp 370–1 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–27 I infer [continued] Garner’s Legal Style p 119 Garner’s Redbook p 214 (imply; infer) Gowers’ Plain Words pp 235–6 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary pp 301–2 Strunk and White p 49 Right Words pp 204-5 (imply/infer) inferior … than see—superior … than infirmity usage—consider alternatives before using try—permanent illness / permanent disability / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. further reading Gowers’ Plain words p 19 inflammable usage—consider alternatives before using try—flammable / no change extra information 1 Flammable and inflammable both mean easy to set on fire. However, for this meaning, flammable should be preferred to avoid confusion. 2 Inflammable is sometimes mistaken for a negative. The correct negative is nonflammable. 3 Inflammable is still available for figurative use or to mean easily aroused to passion or excitable. example of no change An inflammable mix of racism and poverty. example of change The curtains were highly inflammable flammable. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 282 (flammable or inflammable) Fowler’s English Usage p 302 (flammable) Garner’s Dictionary p 361 (flammable; inflammable) Gowers’ Plain Words p 32 Longman English Usage p 372 (inflammable, flammable, inflammatory) Oxford English Usage p 137 (flammable) Partridge pp 120 (flammable), 158 (inflammable and inflammatory) Right Words p 158 (flammable/inflammable) Strunk and White p 47 (flammable) Working Words p 226 (flammable/inflammable/nonflammable) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–28 I inform usage—consider alternatives before using try—instruct / mention / point out / say / specify / state / tell / advise / ask / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. 3 It is incorrect to use inform for tell or ask where someone is being asked to do something. examples of change 1 The decision-maker must inform tell the applicant, in writing, that … 2 Please inform ask the instructor to come at 4 pm. 3 The lawyer informed advised the defendant about his rights. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 395 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 18, 236 Longman English Usage p 373 Partridge p 158 Working Words p 281 in isolation usage—consider alternatives before using try—in itself / alone / on its own / no change extra information Prefer in itself or alone if appropriate. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 239 initial usage—consider alternatives before using try—first / no change see also—first name Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–29 I initiate usage—avoid using if possible try—begin / start / propose / open / introduce extra information 1 formal word 2 For the use of start and begin, see commence. example of change Initiate Start the shut-down sequence. further reading Cutts pp 29, 31 Garner’s Dictionary pp 370 (formal words), 448 Gowers’ Plain Words p 236 initio see—ab initio in lieu of usage—never use try—instead of / in place of / in substitution for extra information 1 archaism 2 compound preposition example of change The court awarded damages in lieu of instead of granting an injunction. further reading Butterworths Legal Dicitonary p 577 Cutts p 29 Gowers’ Plain Words p 241 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary pp 314–5 in like manner as usage—never use try—as / in the same way as Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–30 I in loco parentis usage—never use try—acting in place of a parent / recasting extra information foreign phrase example of change responsible adult, for someone else, means a person who is a parent, step-parent, guardian, person in loco parentis acting in place of a parent, or spouse, of the other person. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 577 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 315 in order that / to / for usage—consider alternatives before using try—so / that / so that / to / for / recasting / no change extra information 1 In order to and in order for are complex prepositions. In order that is used to begin a noun phrase expressing purpose. 2 All are formal phrases and are usually verbose. 3 In order to can usually be replaced by to, and in order for can usually be replaced by for. Sometimes recasting is necessary to preserve clarity (see example 4, examples of change). The use of in order to instead of to may be justified by considerations of rhythm, emphasis or the nearby presence of a to – infinitive (see examples of no change). 4 In order that can usually be replaced by so, that or so that. 5 The traditional view is that in order that (but not so that) has to be followed by may, might, shall or should, instead of can, could, will or would. Although usage is changing, this is an additional reason to avoid the phrase. 6 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. examples of no change 1 The Government wants to reform the banks in order to make them more accountable to their customers. 2 Ascertain means to find out in order to know for certain. [Note See the presence of the first ‘to’ in both examples.] examples of change 1 A smoking section was set up in order that so that guests might could smoke while they ate. 2 A block and tackle is necessary in order that so boats can be hauled far enough up on the beach. 3 Jack and Jill went up the hill in order to to fetch a pail of water. Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–31 I in order that / to / for [continued] 4 In order to be heard by everyone you must speak loudly. You must speak loudly to be heard by everyone. 5 in order to effect the installation of to install a speed-limiting device 6 In order for For a disciplinary charge to be proved [or To prove a disciplinary charge], criminal behaviour must be established beyond reasonable doubt. further reading Blamires’ Common Errors pp 150-1 (in order), 151 (in order to) Blamires’ Queen’s English p 126 (misconnected phrases) Cutts p 29 (in order to) Evans p 133 (in order to) Fowler’s English Usage pp 398-9 (in order that), 399 (in order to) Garner’s Dictionary pp 450-1 (in order (to) (for) (that)), 517 (in order to in legalisms and lawyerisms) Garner’s Legal Style pp 121, 183 (in order to) Gowers’ Plain Words pp 55 (in order to), 249 (order, in order that) Longman English Usage p 500 (order) Working Words p 284 (in order to/ in order that) in personam usage—avoid using if possible try—against the person / recasting extra information 1 foreign phrase and technical legal term 2 A right in personam is a right primarily available against a particular person. By comparison, a right in rem is a right available against the world at large (see in rem). 3 Civil proceedings are divided into proceedings in personam and proceedings in rem. A judgment in personam is directed at a particular person, eg compelling a person to do what the person is required to do. A judgment in rem is a judgment made by a court that directly affects particular property, eg the arrest of a ship. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 577 Garner’s Legal Style p 121 Jowitt’s Dictionary p 952 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 316 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–32 I in place usage—consider alternatives before using try—in force / in effect / omitting / no change extra information overused, imprecise and journalistic phrase example of no change A school teacher acts in place of a parent. example of change The arrangements in place are satisfactory. further reading Right Words p 209 (in place) in pursuance of usage—never use try—under / because of extra information 1 compound preposition 2 legalese further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 721 (pursuant to) in question usage—avoid using if possible try—concerned / relevant / being considered / in dispute / in issue / omitting / recasting extra information If the text is about issues in question between parties, consider if in issue is appropriate. see also—call in question; question example of change the contract in question Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–33 I inquire usage—consider alternatives before using try—ask / question / investigate / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. example of change The employer inquired asked about references. further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 370 (formal words), 452 Gowers’ Plain Words p 224 (enquiry) inquiry see—enquiry in re see—re in receipt of usage—avoid using if possible try—receiving / have / get / recasting extra information verbosity example of change If the applicant is not already in receipt of receiving an allowance... further reading Cutts p 29 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–34 I in regard to usage—never use try—about / concerning / on / for / in / of / over / to / with / in relation to / recasting extra information 1 compound preposition 2 connecting phrase 3 Prefer a simple preposition if appropriate. If it is necessary to use a connecting phrase, prefer in relation to if appropriate (see in relation to). example of change the authority’s responsibilities in regard to for the preservation of heritage buildings further reading Cutts p 29 Evans p 133 Fowler’s English Usage p 663 (regard) Gowers’ Plain Words pp 18, 55–6 in relation to usage—consider alternatives before using try—about / for / in / of / over / to / with / recasting / no change extra information 1 compound preposition 2 If possible, avoid using connecting phrases (eg in connection with, in regard to and in respect of) as compound prepositions by using simple prepositions (eg for or of). When defining something that has a relationship with something else, it is not usually necessary to use a connecting phrase. A simple preposition is usually sufficient. 3 If it is necessary to use connecting phrases, use the least number of different connecting phrases and use them consistently throughout the draft. Avoid making unnecessary, artificial distinctions between different connecting phrases. 4 If it is necessary to use a connecting phrase, prefer in relation to if appropriate. 5 See LA, dict, pt 1, def in relation to. see also—to and/or in relation to examples of no change 1 anything done by the corporation in relation to a transferred harbour 2 If an inspector exercises a power in relation to a person,... 3 A member of a committee is not subject to the direction of anyone else in relation to anything done in his or her capacity as a member. Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–35 I in relation to [continued] examples of change 1 This part applies in relation to wheat. 2 This part does not apply in relation to dangerous goods in bulk if … 3 (a) in relation to for premises—an occupier of the premises; 4 a consumer in relation to of particular goods 5 an appeal in relation to about the categorisation of land 6 previous year of tax, in relation to for a financial year, means … 7 an employer liable to pay tax in relation to for taxable wages 8 consult with the commission in relation to about the allocation of funds 9 court, in relation to for a claim, means a court with jurisdiction to hear the claim. 10 personal service, in relation to of a document on a person, means.... 11 The powers under this part may be exercised in relation to for all ships. 12 The rates vary in relation to with the child’s age. 13 ensuring that carriers are accountable in relation to for the exercise of their powers further reading Evans p 133 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 18, 55–6 in rem usage—avoid using if possible try—against the thing / against the world at large / in the matter of / recasting extra information 1 foreign phrase and technical legal term 2 see in personam further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 578 (in rem) and (in rem actions) Garner’s Legal Style p 184 Jowitt’s Dictionary p 952 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 317 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–36 I in respect of / to usage—avoid using if possible try—about / for / in / of / over / to / with / in relation to / recasting extra information 1 compound preposition 2 connecting phrase 3 Prefer a simple preposition if appropriate. If it is necessary to use a connecting phrase, prefer in relation to if appropriate (see in relation to). see also—to and/or in respect of examples of change 1 payments in respect of for the year 2 The insurer issues a certificate in respect of for the vehicle. 3 The warranty applies in respect of to every major component of the goods. 4 concerns in respect of about parking 5 A gaming machine pays only in respect of for the highest win. 6 The amount claimed in respect of for the video machine. 7 the fee payable in respect of for an application further reading Evans p 133 Fowler’s English Usage p 671 (respect) Garner’s Dictionary p 764 (respect) Garner’s Legal Style p 137 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 55–6 in short supply usage—consider alternatives before using try—scarce / no change extra information verbosity further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 261 Partridge p 279 (rare and scarce) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–37 I insightful usage—consider alternatives before using try—perceptive / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Insightful is often used as an overstatement for perceptive. If used at all, insightful should be reserved for instances of remarkably penetrating vision. example of change That was an insightful a perceptive remark. in situ usage—never use try—on site / on-the-spot / in [its] usual place / in [its] original place / undisturbed extra information foreign phrase further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 578 Cambridge Style Guide p 373 in so far as / insofar as usage—never use try—as far as / so far as / as / so that / to the extent that extra information compound preposition see also—as/so far as … is/are concerned further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 578 Cutts p 29 Gowers’ Plain Words p 104 in some instances usage—never use try—sometimes extra information verbosity example of change In some instances Sometimes, less is more. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 58 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–38 I in so much as usage—never use try—so far as extra information compound preposition further reading Gowers’ Plain Words pp 103–4 inspect usage—consider alternatives before using try—check / test / no change extra information Prefer the simplest, appropriate word. example of change The inspector may inspect check the vehicle’s roadworthiness. in spite of usage—never use try—despite / omitting / recasting extra information compound preposition example of change She succeeded in spite of despite her disadvantages. inst. usage—never use try—recasting (using this month or the name of the present month, eg January) / instant extra information 1 abbreviation of foreign word 2 commercialese 3 Inst. stands for instante mense (‘this month’) or instant. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 775 (ult.) Garner’s Dictionary pp 454, 895 (ult.) Gowers’ Plain Words p 16 Partridge p 367 (ult., prox., inst.) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–39 I instance usage—never use try—example / recasting extra information Instance beguiles writers in the same way as case into roundabout ways of saying simple things (Gowers p 58). see also—in some instances; in the first instance; in this instance examples of change 1 In the majority of instances, the Most officers will have a window. 2 in most instances usually further reading Gowers’ Plain Words pp 57–8 Partridge pp 4 (abstract nouns—instance), 159 (instance) institute [as a verb] usage—avoid using if possible try—begin / start / commence / bring into use / set up / establish extra information 1 formal word 2 For the use of begin and start, see commence. further reading Cutts p 29 Garner’s Dictionary pp 370 (formal words), 456 instrument usage—consider alternatives before using try—document / recasting (using in writing) / omitting / no change extra information 1 Instrument has both general and technical legal meanings. For non-lawyers, instrument used in its legal sense can be confusing (or give rise to derision). 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. 3 See LA, s 14 (Meaning of instrument). see also—instrument in writing; written instrument example of change A member is appointed for the term stated in the member’s instrument of appointment. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 606 Garner’s Dictionary p 456 Law Words 1995 pp 41–3 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 319 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–40 I instrument in writing usage—avoid using if possible try—written notice / notice / document / instrument / certificate / recasting extra information In general, a redundancy (but see LA, s 14 and dict, pt 1, defs document and writing). example of change instrument in writing notice published in the gazette further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary pp 606-7 Garner’s Dictionary p 456 (instrument) Law Words p 42 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 319 (instrument) in support of usage—consider alternatives before using try—for / supporting / no change extra information 1 compound preposition 2 Prefer an alternative. integrate usage—consider alternatives before using try—amalgamate / coordinate / combine / join / consolidate / no change extra information 1 vague word 2 Integrate can be useful to describe the process of combining different elements into a whole, especially to mean bringing racially or culturally different people into equal membership of society. 3 However, prefer a more precise alternative if appropriate. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 403 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 17, 236 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–41 I inter alia usage—never use try—among other things / recasting extra information foreign phrase further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 611 Cambridge Style Guide p 392 Cutts p 39 Evans p 133 Garner’s Legal Style p 121 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 323 Right Words p 210 (inter alia) interest see—in the interest of interesting usage—consider alternatives before using try—puzzling / dramatic / unusual / important / recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information 1 vague word 2 Prefer a more precise alternative if appropriate. further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 32 Partridge p 160 interestingly usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using ‘neutral’ or more precise words) / no change extra information 1 sentence adverb (ie an adverb that qualified a sentence as a whole) 2 vague word 3 Prefer a more ‘neutral’ or ‘precise’ alternative if appropriate. see also—interesting further reading Fowler’s English Usage pp 405, 702–3 (sentence adverbs) Garner’s Dictionary pp 791–2 (sentence adverbs) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–42 I interim usage—consider alternatives before using try—meantime / provisional / temporary / no change extra information Prefer the simplest, appropriate word. in terms of usage—avoid using if possible try—about / for / in / of / to / in relation to / recasting / omitting extra information 1 compound preposition 2 often only padding examples of change 1 He was realistic in terms of about the prospects for increased sales. 2 The extra spending made little difference in terms of to the creation of more employment. further reading Garner’s Legal Style pp 57, 121 Garner’s Dictionary p 872 (terms, in) Gowers’ Plain Words pp 4, 55–6 Longman English Usage p 702 (terms) Strunk and White p 50 inter pares see—primus inter pares interrogate usage—consider alternatives before using try—question / ask / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 370 (formal words) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–43 I interval usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / recasting / no change extra information Interval is sometimes misused to describe only a space or period of time, rather than a space or period between 2 things or events (Gowers). example of change 6-monthly intervals every 6 months [or twice a year] further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 237 inter vivos usage—never use try—between living people / recasting (using, eg during the life of) extra information foreign phrase example of change an agreement inter vivos between living people further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 612 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary pp 268 (gift inter vivos), 657 (trust inter vivos) in the absence of usage—avoid using if possible try—without / not having extra information 1 compound preposition 2 pomposity example of change In the absence of Without additional information your application cannot be dealt with. [or Your application cannot be dealt with without additional information] further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 55 Howard’s Guide p 2 (absence) Howard’s Handbook p 3 (absence) Longman English Usage p 5 (absence) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–44 I in the affirmative usage—avoid using if possible try—recasting (using words to the effect of yes or in favour) extra information formal phrase see also—affirmative example of change The court ruled in the affirmative in favour of the plaintiff. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 32 (affirmative) Garner’s Dictionary p 36 (affirmative, in the; negative, in the) Gowers’ Plain Words p 201 (affirmative) Longman English Usage p 24 (affirmative) Partridge p 28 (answer was...) in the case of usage—avoid using if possible try—for / in / recasting (using if … applies) / omitting extra information compound preposition examples of change 1 … in the case of for a fatal injury, includes … 2 in the case of for a licence mentioned in subsection (3) (a) further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 372 Garner’s Dictionary pp 133 (case), 877 (the case of) Garner’s Legal Style p 106 (case of, in the) Gowers’ Plain Words pp 18, 55–6 Longman English Usage p 112 (case) in the context of usage—avoid using if possible try—for / of / to / recasting extra information compound preposition examples of change 1 The emergency beacon is not needed in the context of for the ferry’s normal operations. 2 The operation of the account by a single person is impossible in the context of if there is a proper system of financial control. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words pp 56, 188 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–45 I in the course of usage—avoid using if possible try—during / while / when / throughout / omitting extra information compound preposition example of change in the course of during the journey further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 55 in the event that / of [also in the eventuality of] usage—never use try—if / when / recasting extra information compound preposition examples of change 1 In the event of If conflict arises between the public interest and the private interest of a person, … 2 In the event of If there is a short pay by a machine, …[or If a person is shortchanged by a machine…] 3 The member presiding at a meeting has a deliberative vote and, in the event of an equality of voting if the votes are equal, a deciding vote. further reading Cutts pp 29, 31 Garner’s Legal Style p 183 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 55, 184, 227 in the final / last / ultimate analysis usage—consider alternatives before using try—in the end / finally / no change extra information vogue phrase example of change in the final analysis end further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 205 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–46 I in the first instance usage—never use try—first extra information verbosity example of change In the first instance First, contact the landowner. further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 57 Gowers’ Plain Words p 58 in the interest of usage—never use try—for extra information compound preposition further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 183 in the nature of usage—avoid using if possible try—like / similar to extra information compound preposition further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 128 (nature, of a—) Gowers’ Plain Words pp 55, 247 in the negative usage—avoid using if possible try—recasting (using words to the effect of no or against) extra information formal phrase see also—in the affirmative example of change The answer was in the negative no. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 36 (affirmative, in the; negative, in the) Gowers’ Plain Words p 247 Partridge p 28 (answer was...) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–47 I in the neighbourhood of usage—never use try—about / near / close to / in / nearby / close by extra information compound preposition further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 55 in the vicinity of usage—never use try—about / near / close to / nearby / close by extra information compound preposition further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 55 in this connection usage—never use try—omitting / recasting extra information padding further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 67 in this day and age usage—avoid using if possible try—now extra information verbosity further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 184 in this instance usage—never use try—here / (in this) case / (for this) case / omitting / recasting extra information padding further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 58 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–48 I in this [provision] called usage—avoid using if possible try—omitting extra information 1 It is unnecessary to state the provisions for which a term is defined unless the term is to have a limited operation within the section in which the term is defined. If a term is defined for a particular provision only and it is used outside that section, a signpost definition should be included in the dictionary. 2 See LA, s 156 (Application of definitions in dictionaries and sections). examples of change 1 the appropriate Minister may prepare a report (in this section called (a summary report) for… 2 (in this Act called the existing line) [and include a signpost definition in the dictionary] in toto usage—never use try—completely / as a whole / entirely / fully / totally / wholly / without exception / total / in all / recasting extra information foreign phrase further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 578 Cambridge Style Guide p 373 intoxicated usage—consider alternatives before using try—under the influence of (eg alcohol or drugs) / recasting (using affected by …) / no change extra information euphemism further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 34 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–49 I in view of usage—avoid using if possible try—because of / as / since extra information 1 compound preposition 2 For the use of in view of with the fact that, see the fact that. further reading Cutts p 29 (in view of the fact that) Gowers’ Plain Words p 55 involve usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information 1 vague word 2 Prefer a more precise alternative if appropriate. example of change The additional cost involved is $50 for each computer. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words pp 4, 17, 33, 237–8 involvement usage—consider alternatives before using try—connection / recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information vague word further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 238–9 in which usage—consider alternatives before using try—where / when / no change extra information Prefer where or when if appropriate. examples of change 1 the State in which where the exemption was granted 2 the month in which when the corporation files its claim Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–50 I in writing usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / written / recasting / no change see also—instrument in writing; notice in writing example of no change only if the defendant agrees in writing examples of change 1 The registrar must note, in writing, make a written note of … 2 a statement in writing written statement 3 a report in writing written report ipso facto usage—never use try—by that very fact / recasting extra information foreign phrase further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 401 Evans p 133 ironically / ironic usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using more ‘neutral’ words) / no change extra information 1 Ironically can be a sentence adverb (ie an adverb that qualified a sentence as a whole). 2 Ironically and ironic are value-loaded words. 3 Prefer a ‘neutral’ alternative if appropriate. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 402 (irony) Fowler’s English Usage pp 415 (irony), 702–3 (sentence adverbs) Garner’s Dictionary pp 468–9 (irony), 791-2 (sentence adverbs) Garner’s Legal Style pp 153-4 (Irony) Right Words pp 214–6 (ironic/irony/sardonic/satiric) Working Words pp 290 (irony/ironic/ironical/ironically) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–51 I irrespective of usage—avoid using if possible try—recasting (using whether or not or even if) further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 121 Gowers’ Plain Words p 239 is / are able to usage—avoid using if possible try—can / may extra information verbosity examples of change 1 If the child is able to can form and express views about his or her wellbeing, those views must be sought and considered. 2 The chief executive must provide regular care, planning and review for a child that fully involves the child so far as the child is able to can take part. further reading Evans p 121 (be able to) Garner’s Legal Style p 183 is / are allowed to usage—avoid using if possible try—may / can extra information verbosity is / are authorised usage—avoid using if possible try—may / can extra information can be a verbosity example of change The local authority is authorised may … further reading Evans p 121 (be authorised to) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–52 I is / are entitled to usage—consider alternatives before using try—may / can / recasting (using must) / no change extra information 1 can be a verbosity 2 Is entitled to can be appropriate to make it clear that someone has a right to something. However, often may is sufficient. see also—is not entitled to example of no change A member is entitled to be paid the remuneration and allowances the Minister decides. [if a member can decline payment, but otherwise has a right to payment] example of change The carrier is entitled to may enter the property. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 942 (words of authority) Garner’s Legal Style p 183 is / are liable to usage—consider alternatives before using try—must /is given to / is apt to / is likely to / is expected to / probably / is responsible for / no change extra information 1 can be a verbosity 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. 3 Do not use liable to as a substitute for apt or likely. Use apt to mean to have a natural tendency or be inclined towards. Use likely to mean expected or probable. 4 Liable to is best reserved for negative events that are a possibility or habitually happen. Liable to also means responsible or subject to liability, eg to taxation or civil or criminal liability. example of no change She is liable to pay the levy. examples of change 1 Under pressure he is liable likely to give up. 2 The workload is liable likely to increase. 3 The computer system is liable given to breakdowns. 4 A beneficiary is liable to must tell the authority about any changed circumstances. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 444 Fowler’s English Usage pp 64 (apt, liable), 455 (liable, likely), 460 (likely) Garner’s Dictionary pp 72 (apt; apposite), 527 (liable), 530 (likely) Garner’s Legal Style p 124 (liable; apt; likely) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–53 I is / are liable to [continued] Gowers’ Plain Words p 241 Longman English Usage p 54 (apt, liable, likely) Oxford English Usage pp 119 (apt), 146 Partridge p 176 (liable) Right Words p 36 (apt/likely) Working Words p 44 (apt/liable/prone/likely) is / are not entitled to usage—avoid using if possible try—cannot / may not / must not extra information can be verbosity example of change A registered insurer is not entitled to must not decline CTP business. is / are not required to usage—avoid using if possible try—may / can / need not / does not have to / may, but need not, / can, but need not, extra information 1 can be a verbosity 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. is / are not to usage—avoid using if possible try—must not / does not extra information see also—is/are to examples of change 1 An additional penalty is not to must not be imposed on the person. 2 the owner is not to must not be taken 3 This agreement is not to does not have effect while the State is a party to another agreement about … Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–54 I is or exceeds usage—avoid using if possible try—is at least example of change the weight of the load is or exceeds at least is / are required to usage—avoid using if possible try—must extra information verbosity issue [as a noun] usage—consider alternatives before using try—subject / topic / concern / consideration / dispute / matter / blood relative / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative (other than matter) if appropriate. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words pp 4, 239 issue [as a verb] usage—consider alternatives before using try—make / give / transfer / send / omitting / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. examples of no change 1 The surveyor may issue licences. 2 A certificate of survey has not been issued for the ship. examples of change 1 The Minister may issue make standards about … 2 The chief executive must issue give an identity card to each inspector. Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–55 I issue as to whether / of whether usage—never use try—issue whether extra information verbosity further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 470, 930 (whether) Garner’s Legal Style pp 135 (whether, as to), 144 (whether (or not)) is the duty see—it is the duty of is / are to usage—consider alternatives before using try—must / will / omitting / recasting / no change extra information 1 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. 2 Use must if a duty is to be imposed. 3 There is no rule preventing must being used in relation to the Executive, Ministers or courts. see also—is to be read; is to be taken examples of no change 1 An election is to be held on … 2 The committee’s function is to … 3 The reference must state the functions the committee is to perform. examples of change 1 If the notice is to be served by post, the notice may be addressed to … 2 The election is to must be conducted as if … 3 All land is to keep keeps its previous designation. 4 an order that a claimant is to have has leave 5 The commissioner is to be appointed under the XYZ Act. 6 The chairperson is to preside presides at a meeting if the chairperson is present. further reading Cwlth OPC Plain English p 20 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–56 I is to be read usage—avoid using if possible try—recasting extra information verbosity example of change the provision is to be read applies with the changes … is to be taken usage—never use try—is / is taken extra information verbosity examples of change 1 The land is to be taken as being taken to be land granted in fee simple. 2 A claimant is to be taken to have remedied noncompliance if … further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 191 (be-verbs) is / are unable to usage—avoid using if possible try—cannot / may not / must not extra information verbosity examples of change 1 is unable to cannot give notice to the owner 2 If a person is unable to cannot comply with subsection (1) (a) before starting on a journey by railway, ... 3 It the officer is unable to cannot continue to perform the duties,... 4 If, for any reason, the chair is unable to cannot perform the duties of the position, … further reading Evans p 121 (be unable to) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–57 I it appears that / it would appear that usage—avoid using if possible try—omitting / recasting extra information timid phrase further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 36 (it would appear that) item usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information Prefer a more precise alternative if appropriate. example of no change item 10 example of change Please tick the items goods that you wish to buy. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 240 it is apprehended that usage—never use try—I/we suppose / omitting / recasting extra information timid phrase further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 18 it is lawful see—lawful it is (respectfully) suggested that usage—avoid using if possible try—omitting / recasting extra information timid phrase further reading Garner’s Legal Style pp 36, 82 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–58 I it is the duty of usage—avoid using if possible try—recasting (using must) extra information verbosity further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 184 it may necessitate usage—never use try—[you] may have to extra information formal phrase further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 247 (necessitate) it might be said that usage—avoid using if possible try—omitting / recasting extra information timid phrase further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 36 it seems usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / recasting / no change extra information timid phrase see also—seems further reading Garner’s Legal Style pp 36, 57 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–59 I it will be seen by a perusal of usage—never use try—you will see by reading / you will see from extra information pomposity further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 18 it would appear that see—it appears that/it would appear that … ize [usually at end of word] usage—consider alternatives before using try—… ise / no change extra information Follow the spellings used in the latest edition of the Macquarie Dictionary. If a word is given with ...ise and ...ize equally preferred, prefer ...ise. examples of change 1 organize organise 2 recognize recognise 3 civilization civilisation 4 fertilizer fertiliser further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 405–7 Garner’s Legal Style pp 21-2 Gowers’ Plain Words p 239 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 I–60 J jointly and severally [also joint and several] usage—avoid using if possible try—recasting (using together / collectively and separately / alone / individually / each of them) extra information 1 doublet 2 The words jointly and severally (and joint and several) are not legal terms of art. They can be replaced with plainer alternatives without loss of legal effect. It is also possible to use a modern phrase with the traditional legal phrase in brackets, eg ‘together and separately (also known as ‘jointly and severally’)’. 3 To clarify the application of a provision to combinations, the words ‘or in any combination’ could be added. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 643 (joint and several), (joint and several liability), (joint and several obligation) and (joint and several promise) Garner’s Dictionary pp 479 (joint and several), 799 (several) Law Words 1995 pp 44–6 (joint and several) Right Words p 367 (several) junior … than see—senior … than just and reasonable usage—avoid using if possible try—just / fair / reasonable / impartial extra information doublet further reading Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 345 justify usage—consider alternatives before using try—prove / defend / no change extra information Prefer the simplest appropriate word. Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 J–1 J juvenile usage—consider alternatives before using try—child / not an adult / infant / minor / recasting (using a defined term, eg young person) / no change extra information 1 Prefer child or recasting. 2 Juvenile has derogatory connotations in some contexts. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 431 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 347 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 J–2 K kind usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information 1 Most legal drafting is expressed in the singular and it is usually unnecessary to distinguish between a class (using, eg category, class, group, kind or type) and its members (see LA s 48 and s 145 (b)). Avoid using class unless it is necessary. 2 If it is necessary to use class, use it as infrequently as possible consistently throughout the draft. Avoid making unnecessary, artificial distinctions in using classes (eg the use of kind and type, or class and kind). 3 If it is necessary to mention class, prefer kind if appropriate. 4 Avoid using kind as an omnibus word. ‘Whatever is generic in writing is an enemy to good legal writing. Just as glib generalities weaken the arguments they would support, so omnibus words detract from the message they would convey. Expunge these words from your vocabulary and you will find your writing more vigorous, concrete and vivid.’ (Garner) 5 Never use kind of as a hedge word (diminisher), eg ‘He was kind of late’. 6 Never use kind of a as a contraction for a kind of a. see also—type and kind example of change a person of the kind mentioned in section 14 further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 427 (kind of) Fowler’s English Usage pp 433–4 Garner’s Legal Style pp 123, 205 (kind of) Gowers’ Plain English p 134 (those kinds of things) Strunk and White p 51 (kind of) knowledge see—has/have knowledge of Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 K–1 L lack usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting / no change extra information Lack can contribute to abstract, loose writing. examples of change 1 There is a complete lack of spare pens. There are no spare pens. 2 There exists a considerable lack of knowledge about Not much is known about … further reading Gowers’ Plain Words pp 80–1 laid before see—lay/laid before landlord usage—consider alternatives before using try—lessor / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Landlord has negative overtones. last see—in the final/last/ultimate analysis; lastmentioned/last-mentioned/ last mentioned last will and testament usage—never use try—will extra information It is not necessary to use last will and testament. The word last serves no legal purpose and the word will includes testament. further reading Law Words 1995 pp 47–9 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 L–1 L lastly usage—never use try—last further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 434 lastmentioned / last-mentioned / last mentioned usage—never use try—recasting / last extra information 1 formal word 2 Do not hesitate to repeat words rather than use lastmentioned to avoid repetition. Alternatively, use a tagged term. Readers may otherwise have difficulty in working out what is referred to. 3 For similar reasons, avoid substituting latter (see latter). 4 If you want to refer otherwise than specifically to the first of 2 or more things, try last. see also—firstmentioned/first-mentioned/first mentioned later see—no later than; not later than latter usage—avoid using if possible try—recasting / last extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer to repeat words rather than use latter to avoid repetition. Alternatively, use a tagged term. Readers may otherwise have difficulty in working out what is referred to. 3 For similar reasons, avoid substituting lastmentioned and like terms (see lastmentioned). 4 Latter can refer to only one of 2 things and if you use it of more than 2 you may puzzle your readers. 5 If you want to refer otherwise than specifically to the first of more than 2 things, try first. see also—former further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 291 (former and latter) Fowler’s English Usage pp 443–4 Garner’s Dictionary p 370 (former) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 L–2 L latter [continued] Gowers’ Plain Words p 115 Longman English Usage pp 292–3 (former, latter) Partridge p 175 Right Words p 163 (former/latter) Working Words p 232 (former/latter) lawful usage—consider alternatives before using try—valid / legitimate / legal / omitting / recasting (using may) / no change extra information 1 It is sometimes desirable to mention that some conditions depend on whether the action mentioned in the conditions is itself not an offence (see examples of no change). 2 Usually, lawful is an unnecessary gloss if what is intended is a reference to legal competency. In phrases such as it is lawful, may is then appropriate (see may). 3 Lawful is now rather formal and old-fashioned. Prefer an alternative if appropriate. example of no change without lawful justification or excuse further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 439 (legal, legalistic, legitimate or lawful) lay see—lay/laid before; overlay; underlay lay / laid before usage—consider alternatives before using try—present to (the Legislative Assembly) extra information Present to is the concept used in the Standing Orders of the Legislative Assembly and the LA. example of change The Minister must lay before present to the Legislative Assembly … layoff see—permanent layoff leading edge see—on the cutting/leading edge Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 L–3 L leading question usage—consider alternatives before using try—loaded question / searching question / no change extra information In law, a leading question is a question designed to help or trap a person by suggesting the answer. Generally, leading questions are allowed only in crossexamination. The term is sometimes applied in non-legal contexts to questions requiring a guarded answer. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 438 Fowler’s English Usage pp 445–6 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 74, 270 least see—at least as/so far as … is/are concerned legal practitioner usage—consider alternatives before using try—lawyer / no change extra information 1 formal phrase 2 See LA, dict, pt 1, defs lawyer and legal practitioner. legally usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using ‘neutral’ words) / no change extra information 1 Legally can be a sentence adverb (ie an adverb that qualified a sentence as a whole) 2 Prefer a more ‘neutral’ alternative if appropriate. further reading Fowler’s English Usage pp 702–3 (sentence adverbs) Garner’s Dictionary pp 791–2 (sentence adverbs) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 L–4 L less usage—consider alternatives before using try—fewer / lesser / no change extra information 1 For the use of less and fewer, see fewer. 2 For the use of less and lesser, see lesser. 3 Note that to provide for less than X and more than X has the effect of excluding X itself and leaving it unprovided for. see also—increasingly less; not less than; or less lesser usage—consider alternatives before using try—less / no change extra information 1 Lesser means smaller in importance, significance or status. It is used with count nouns (see fewer). 2 Less is used with mass nouns (see fewer) and means smaller in amount. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 441 let usage—consider alternatives before using try—leased / allow / permit / leave / no change extra information 1 It is unnecessary to refer to both let and leased. 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. example of change If the land were let leased at a nominal rent, … further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 448 (leave, let) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 L–5 L level usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / recasting (using more specific words) / no change extra information 1 Words like level are vague and abstract, and can be useful on occasion. However, they are often overused. Therefore, consider if use is necessary. 2 Prefer available words that are more specific if appropriate. examples of change 1 overall level of total expenditure 2 significantly higher level of expenditure further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 189 liable to see—is/are liable to liability to see—has/have a liability to liaise with usage—avoid using if possible try—talk to / coordinate / contact extra information vogue phrase lieu see—in lieu of Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 L–6 L like usage—consider alternatives before using try—as / as if / as though / just as / such as / similar / the same / no change extra information Like should not, as a rule, be used as a conjunction (see examples of change). see also—in like manner as examples of no change 1 The Minister, like her predecessor, is a lawyer. 2 Nothing succeeds like success. examples of change 1 Nothing succeeds like as success does. 2 It looks like as if he is going to succeed. 3 in like similar [or the same] circumstances 4 a like similar case further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 447–8 (in support of use of like as conjunction) Gowers’ Plain Words p 104 likewise usage—consider alternatives before using try—similarly / also / recasting (adding and to avoid using as conjunction) / no change extra information The use of likewise as a conjunction remains contentious. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 449 limited number of usage—avoid using if possible try—few extra information 1 verbosity 2 If possible, use an alternative. further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 119 (limited) Gowers’ Plain Words p 241 (limited) Howard’s Guide p 246 (limited) Partridge p 177 (limited) Working Words p 316 (limited) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 L–7 L limiting see—without limiting the generality of listed usage—consider alternatives before using try—mention / state / set out / recasting / no change extra information 1 Be careful not to draw artificial distinctions in legislation by using different words to say essentially the same thing, eg do not say in one provision ‘a (thing) listed in section x’ and then in another provision say ‘ a person mentioned in section y’. 2 Prefer mention or state if appropriate. For the use of mention, state and set out, see state. example of change Removal allowance is payable if the transfer is to a place listed mentioned in section 50. literally usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / no change extra information Literally is an overworked word that has lost much of its force and credibility. Strictly speaking, it means according to the letter, ie word for word or exactly as the utterance has it. The word literally can make a liar of you. Beware of using literally to unduly exaggerate. example of change literally dead with fatigue dead tired further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 452–3 Garner’s Dictionary pp 531, 813 (slipshod extension) Garner’s Legal Style p 125 Gowers’ Plain Words p 242 Strunk and White p 52 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 L–8 L livelihood usage—avoid using if possible try—living / occupation / business extra information formal word further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 242 locality usage—avoid using if possible try—place / area / district extra information formal word further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 242 lodge usage—consider alternatives before using try—file / made to / give / send / recasting / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. examples of change 1 A claim for compensation must be lodged with made to the chief executive. 2 A claimant may apply for compensation by lodging giving a completed form with to the Minister. 3 An application must be lodged made in writing with to the authority. Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 L–9 L logically / logical usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using ‘neutral’ words) / no change extra information 1 Logically can be a sentence adverb (ie an adverb that qualified a sentence as a whole). 2 Logically and logical can be value-loaded words. 3 Prefer a more ‘neutral’ alternative if appropriate. further reading Fowler’s English Usage pp 702–3 (sentence adverbs) Garner’s Dictionary pp 791–2 (sentence adverbs) long see—as/so long as Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 L–10 M maintain usage—consider alternatives before using try—keep / continue / have / state / assert / no change extra information Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. examples of no change 1 maintaining an aid to navigation 2 A standard may specify the objectives to be achieved and maintained. 3 The duties of a pilot’s employer are to develop and maintain the pilot’s skills. 4 A windscreen wiper must be provided with a pump to maintain the efficient operation of the wiper. example of change The tribunal must maintain keep a register of decisions. major usage—consider alternatives before using try—main / chief / principal / serious / recasting (using important / big / large / strong / great) / no change extra information vague, overused word examples of no change 1 major road (in contrast with minor road) 2 the two major political parties 3 the major part of this paper examples of change 1 a major serious illness 2 a major big loss further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 476 Garner’s Legal Style p 32 Gowers’ Plain Words p 243 Working Words p 324 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 M–1 M major part usage—avoid using if possible try—most extra information verbosity further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 243 (majority) Working Words p 324 (major) majority usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using, eg most / the greater part of) / no change extra information 1 It has been suggested that majority and minority should be used to refer only to people or things that can be counted, and not to a single thing or uncountable nouns, eg experience. 2 Prefer most if appropriate. 3 The phrase the majority of should be reserved for cases where the difference between a majority and a minority is significant, eg cases involving voting on an issue. However, when used for voting numbers, majority can be ambiguous. For example, ‘a majority of 10’ can mean either that the difference between the votes for and against was 10 or that there were 10 votes in the majority. 4 Majority may be treated as singular or plural according to whether the people or things mentioned are being considered as a group or individually (see examples of no change). examples of no change 1 The majority of members are likely to support the bill. 2 The Right had a greater majority of votes than 3 years ago. examples of change 1 The majority of Most members represent urban electorates. 2 The majority of Most of the building was damaged by fire. 3 the vast majority most further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 461 (majority), 486 (minority) Fowler’s English Usage pp 476–7 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 133, 243 Right Words p 243 Working Words p 324 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 M–2 M make a decision usage—avoid using if possible try—decide extra information verbosity example of change It is necessary to make a decision decide … make an order usage—avoid using if possible try—order extra information verbosity example of change The court may make an order that... make application usage—avoid using if possible try—recasting (using, eg apply) extra information verbosity example of change A person may make an application apply to the Minister for a licence. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 912 (verbosity) make a statement usage—avoid using if possible try—state / assert /mention extra information verbosity example of change A person must not make a statement state … further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 11 (abstractitis) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 M–3 M make payment usage—avoid using if possible try—pay extra information verbosity further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 912 (verbosity) make provision for usage—avoid using if possible try—provide for extra information verbosity further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 543, 912 (verbosity) make reference to usage—avoid using if possible try—refer to / mention extra information verbosity further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 125 make sure usage—never use try—ensure / verify / clarify Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 M–4 M man / men usage—consider alternatives before using try—person / human being / recasting / no change extra information gender-specific word examples of change 1 1 man person, 1 vote 2 Man is not a solitary animal. Human beings are not solitary animals. see also—man-made further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 463–4 Cwlth Style Manual p 58 (Sex-neutral references to individuals) Fowler’s English Usage pp 705–6 (sexist language), 182–5 (discriminatory language) Garner’s Dictionary pp 799–803 (sexism) Longman English Usage p 645 (sexism) Working Words p 325 ...man / men usage—avoid using if possible try—recasting (using gender-neutral words) extra information 1 gender-specific word 2 For a list of gender-neutral alternatives for gender-specific job titles, see Cwlth Style Manual pp 59-60 (Occupational titles). 3 If possible, use a gender-neutral alternative. see also—chairman/chairwoman; workman/working man further reading Cwlth Style Manual p 58 (Sex-neutral references to individuals) Garner’s Dictionary pp 801-2 (sexism) Garner’s Legal Style p 203 Longman English Usage p 645 (sexism) Right Words p 154 (the female critique) manhole usage—avoid using if possible try—accesshole / sewerhole / utility hole / trapdoor / recasting extra information 1 Arguably a gender-specific word. 2 If possible, use a gender-neutral alternative. further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 203 Right Words p 154 (the female critique) Working Words p 183 (discriminatory language) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 M–5 M manhood usage—avoid using if possible try—adulthood / recasting extra information 1 gender-specific word 2 If possible, use a gender-neutral alternative. manhour usage—never use try—working hour / work hours / labour hours / recasting extra information gender-specific word see also—man further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 464 manifestation usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using more ‘neutral’ words) / no change extra information 1 vague word 2 Prefer a more ‘neutral’ alternative if appropriate. further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 32 manifestly / manifest usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using ‘neutral’ words) / no change extra information 1 dogmatic words 2 Prefer a more ‘neutral’ alternative if appropriate. further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 161 (clearly), 926 (weasel words) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 M–6 M mankind usage—avoid using if possible try—humanity / human beings / humans / people / the human race / humankind / persons / recasting / no change extra information gender-specific word example of change the problems of mankind humanity further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 463–4 (man) Fowler’s English Usage pp 479, 705–6 (sexist language) Partridge p 185 Right Words p 245 Working Words pp 182–5 (discriminatory language), 325 man-made usage—never use try—artificial / manufactured / constructed / fabricated / handmade / handcrafted / recasting extra information gender-specific word see also—man further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 464 manner usage—consider alternatives before using try—way / method / omitting / recasting (using, eg how) / no change extra information 1 Manner is a fruitful source of verbosity. 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. see also—in a … manner/way; in a timely manner/way; in like manner as examples of change 1 in like manner the same way as 2 in a hasty manner hastily 3 the manner in which how 4 in a manner similar to like 5 The objects of this Act include promoting the protection of children in a manner way that ... further reading Cutts p 29 Garner’s Dictionary p 547 (manner in which) Longman English Usage p 433 Partridge p 4 (abstract nouns) Working Words p 326 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 M–7 M manpower usage—avoid using if possible try—workforce / staff / workers / human resources / labour / labour force / personnel / people / recasting extra information gender-specific word further reading Working Words p 183 (discriminatory language) marginal [or marginally] usage—consider alternatives before using try—small / slight / only just / bare / recasting / no change extra information Do not use marginal as a substitute for small or similar words. examples of change 1 There has been a marginal slight increase in the inflation rate. 2 The cost of rehabilitating the mine site was marginal small. 3 The business is marginally barely profitable. 4 The airconditioning system is marginally only just capable of handling hot days. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words pp 243–4 master [as a noun] usage—avoid using if possible try—employer / teacher / principal / captain (of ship/harbour) / registrar / judicial registrar / person in charge / person in control extra information 1 Master can be regarded as gender-specific (at least in some contexts) and, except when referring to the Master of the Supreme Court or the master of a ship, should be avoided if possible. 2 If what is intended is a reference to the master in a master–servant relationship, employer and employee are usually sufficient. Master in this context is dated and can have negative overtones. examples of no change 1 the master [of the Supreme Court] 2 the master of the ship [if captain is not appropriate for the context] examples of change 1 the apprentice’s master employer 2 a schoolmaster schoolteacher [or principal] further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 312 (employer and employee; master and servant), 550 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 M–8 M material [as an adjective] usage—consider alternatives before using try—essential /important / necessary / significant / relevant / appropriate / recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information 1 vague word that can mean, eg essential, important or relevant 2 Prefer a more precise alternative if appropriate. 3 False or misleading in a material particular [respect] has a well established meaning in criminal law (see, eg Minister for Immigration v Dela Cruz (1992) 110 ALR 367, 371, 372, and R v Marslen and Shaw (1995) 79 A Crim R 199, 202-3). 4 Material is also used in a number of other legal concepts (see Butterworths Legal Dictionary). In these concepts it also has a well-established meaning. example of no change false or misleading in a material respect examples of change 1 A return must be correct in all material essential details. 2 A claim for benefit must include all material information necessary to enable the claim to be decided. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary pp 731 (material) , (material alteration), (material fact) and (material form), 732 (material omission), (material particular), (material personal interest) and (material representation) Garner’s Dictionary pp 550–1, 813 (slipshod extension) Garner’s Legal Style p 125 (material; relevant) Working Words p 239 (germane/material/relevant) materialise usage—consider alternatives before using try—happen / come about / take place / occur / appear / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 244 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 M–9 M matrix usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information 1 vogue word 2 Avoid using matrix in the vague sense of situation or surrounding substance. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 919 (vogue words) Garner’s Legal Style p 33 Gowers’ Plain Words p 244 matter usage—consider alternatives before using try—issue / thing / substance / subject / topic / concern / consideration / dispute / recasting / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. see also—any act/matter/thing; any other examples of no change 1 A standard may include matters prescribed by regulation. 2 A certificate stating any of the following matters: 3 the matters of which details are required 4 the matters contained in a document 5 The client’s matter involved many issues. examples of change 1 If a member has an interest in a matter an issue being considered by the corporation, … 2 A change has happened in relation to a matter something that … maximum [also maximal / maximise] usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using eg most / biggest / greatest / heaviest / oldest / thickest) / no change extra information 1 Prefer a more specific alternative if appropriate. 2 If possible, avoid using maximal or maximise. example of no change a motorised wheelchair with a maximum speed of less than 10km/h further reading Gowers’ Plain Words pp 245, 246–7 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 M–10 M may usage—consider alternatives before using try—can / no change extra information 1 May should be used if a power, permission, benefit or privilege given to someone may, but need not, be exercised—the exercise is discretionary. 2 May should not be used in cases where the ability to do something is being emphasised (see can). see also—as the case may be/requires; as the case may require further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 107–8 Cutts p 33 (can) Garner’s Dictionary pp 128 (can; may), 552–3, 942 (words of authority) meaningful usage—consider alternatives before using try—reasonable / significant / important / useful / worthwhile / omitting / recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information 1 vogue, weasel word 2 overused omnibus word (see kind for extra information) example of change We are making many meaningful changes useful improvements to our file management. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 471 Garner’s Dictionary pp 553, 919 (vogue words), 926 (weasel words) Garner’s Legal Style pp 32, 33, 125–6, 205 Gowers’ Plain Words p 183 Strunk and White p 53 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 M–11 M means [as a noun] usage—consider alternatives before using try—way / form / type / financial resources / income / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. see also—by means of example of no change The machine must be built to transmit energy by mechanical means only. examples of change 1 another means kind of communication 2 by any means in any way means and includes usage—never use try—means extra information 1 doublet 2 Use means if that is what you mean. 3 The expression means and includes should not be used because complete and incomplete meanings cannot be stipulated at the same time. 4 However, the first clause of a definition may be introduced by means and a later clause may begin with includes. A construction of this kind is, for example, appropriate if the later clause is intended to remove a doubt arising from the meaning given by the first clause. The includes clause should not, however, contradict the substance of the means clause. further reading Dick p 152 Garner’s Dictionary p 258 (Definitions C.) Piesse pp 46–7 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 M–12 M measure [as a noun] usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / recasting / no change extra information 1 Words like measure are vague and abstract, and can be useful on occasion. However, they are often overused. Therefore, consider if use is necessary. 2 Prefer available words that are more direct and specific if appropriate. examples of change 1 a tight measure of control 2 an increasing measure of more independence further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 189 medical practitioner usage—consider alternatives before using try—doctor / no change extra information 1 formal phrase 2 See LA, dict, pt 1 def doctor and medical practitioner. further reading Cwlth OPC Plain English p 42 meets the requirements of usage—avoid using if possible. try—complies with / satisfies / fulfils / recasting extra information verbosity example of change If a vehicle meets all the requirements of complies with the vehicle standards, it is generally suitable for road use. Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 M–13 M meet with / meet up with usage—consider alternatives before using try—meet / no change extra information 1 phrasal verb 2 Meet with is appropriate where what is met is an abstraction, eg opposition or disaster. Meet with is also appropriate when meet is used in the sense of experiencing or being subject to something (usually an abstraction) or in the sense of having or receiving a particular reaction to something, eg approval or disapproval. 3 In other contexts, meet with is not regarded as appropriate in Australian (or British) English, although it is common in American English. 4 However, it has been suggested (by, eg Hudson) that there is a useful distinction between meet and meet with. Meet implies a brief (perhaps unplanned) meeting; with perhaps just an exchange of greetings. This kind of meeting could take place in the street. Meet with implies a longer, more formal meeting; with an exchange of news and views. This kind of meeting would normally take place in an office. This suggestion does not yet have widespread support in Australia. 5 Prefer meet if appropriate. 6 Never use meet up with. see also—consult with; miss out on; visit with examples of no change 1 Her views met with opposition. 2 The expedition met with disaster. 3 He met force with sweet reason. 4 The announcement was met with widespread protests. 5 She met disaster with courage. 6 We hope you meet with good fortune. 7 I am sorry if it doesn’t meet with your approval. examples of change 1 Tarzan meets with Jane. 2 I will meet with you at the train station. 3 I met with her after the concert. 4 I will meet up with you soon. [or I will see you soon.] further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 473–4 (meet (up) (with)), 583 (phrasal verbs) Fowler’s English Usage pp 594–5 (phrasal verbs) Gowers’ Plain Words p 184 (meet with) Howard’s Guide p 263 (meet with and meet up with) Howard’s Handbook p 249 (meet with/meet up with) Hudson pp 17-8 (agree), 250 (meet (with)) Longman English Usage pp 441-2 (meet) New Oxford Dictionary p1151 (meet) Working Words p 340 (meet with) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 M–14 M men see—man/men; ...man/men mens rea usage—avoid using if possible try—state of mind /mental element / recasting (using means to / intends to) extra information 1 foreign phrase 2 Technical term in criminal law to describe the state of mind required to constitute an offence: the mental element of the offence. 3 If it is necessary to use the term, include a note explaining what it means. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 740 Garner’s Dictionary p 556 mention usage—consider alternatives before using try—state / set out / no change extra information See state for a discussion of the use of mention, set out and state. see also—abovementioned/abovelisted/abovequoted; aforementioned; belowmentioned/belowlisted/ belowquoted; firstmentioned / first-mentioned / first mentioned; lastmentioned / last-mentioned / last mentioned; undermentioned mercifully / merciful usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using ‘neutral’ words) / no change extra information 1 Mercifully can be a sentence adverb (ie an adverb that qualifies a sentence as a whole). 2 Mercifully and merciful are value-loaded words. 3 Prefer a more ‘neutral’ alternative if appropriate. further reading Fowler’s English Usage pp 702–3 (sentence adverbs) Garner’s Dictionary pp 791–2 (sentence adverbs) Longman English Usage pp 443, 640-1 (sentence adverbs) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 M–15 M mere usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / recasting / no change extra information 1 Mere can be used as a depreciative, dogmatic word. 2 Prefer a more ‘neutral’ alternative if appropriate. further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 36 method by which usage—consider alternatives before using try—way in which / system for which / no change methodology usage—consider alternatives before using try—way / method / no change extra information 1 Methodology means a body of methods or an analysis of procedures. 2 Sometimes used as a formal word for way or method. 3 Prefer way or method if appropriate. further reading Cutts p 36 Gowers’ Plain Words p 246 might see—it might be said that Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 M–16 M minimum [also minimal / minimise] usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using, eg least / lightest / smallest / thinnest / youngest) / no change extra information 1 Prefer a more specific alternative if appropriate. 2 If possible, avoid using minimal or minimise. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words pp 245, 246–7 minor usage—consider alternatives before using try—child / recasting (using a defined term, eg young person) / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer child or recasting. further reading Mellinkoff’s Dictionary pp 73–5 (child/infant/minor) minority [in voting] usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting / no change extra information 1 It has been suggested that minority (and majority) should be used to refer only to people or things that can be counted, and not to a single thing or uncountable nouns, eg tolerance. 2 Minority when used for voting numbers can be ambiguous. It can mean either the shortfall between the votes for and against or the smaller set of votes. 3 Minority may be treated as singular or plural according to whether the people or things mentioned are being considered as a group or individually. example of change The motion was lost by a minority of 4 by a vote of 50 to 4 [or with only 4 voting for it]. further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 461 (majority), 496 (minority) Fowler’s English Usage pp 476–7 (majority), 496 (minority) Gowers’ Plain Words pp 133, 243 Right Words p 243 Working Words p 324 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 M–17 M minus usage—consider alternatives before using try—less / without / negative / recasting / no change extra information 1 can be a colloquialism as an alternative to without 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. example of change minus less any administrative costs further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 487 miss out on usage—never use try—miss extra information 1 phrasal verb 2 Use the simple verb. see also—consult with; meet with/meet up with; visit with further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 583 (phrasal verbs) Fowler’s English Usage pp 594–5 (phrasal verbs) modify usage—consider alternatives before using try—change / alter / adapt / amend / no change extra information Prefer a less formal alternative if appropriate. example of no change If a proposed modification of a motor vehicle would change its class, … examples of change 1 A business plan may be modified changed by the corporation. 2 The provision applies with the modifications changes necessary … modus operandi usage—never use try—way of operating / way of proceeding / way of working / method extra information foreign phrase further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 491 Cutts p 39 Working Words p 348 (modus operandi/modus vivendi) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 M–18 M moment of time see—at this time/point of time/moment of time money usage—consider alternatives before using try—amount / no change extra information Except in expressing the idea of an identifiable (but not necessarily quantifiable) quantity of money, prefer amount. example of no change any money in a video machine example of change Money Amounts received from the sale of liquor must be banked and paid to the council monthly. moneys / monies usage—avoid using if possible try—money / amounts extra information 1 In ordinary usage, money is a mass noun (see fewer) with a collective sense and should not be pluralised. 2 To express the idea of individual quantities of money, use amounts rather than moneys. 3 Monies is an illogical and misconceived plural. It should never be used. examples of change 1 All the moneys money received at the fete was used to offset the costs. 2 All moneys amounts must be accounted for. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 492 (supporting use of moneys as pluralised count noun) Cutts p 29 (monies) Garner’s Dictionary p 571 (monies) Longman English Usage p 454 Macquarie Dictionary p 1387 (supports either spelling) Oxford English Usage p 58 Partridge p 196 Working Words p 349 (supports either spelling) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 M–19 M monitor [as a verb] usage—consider alternatives before using try—check / supervise / oversee / no change extra information Prefer the simplest appropriate word. month see—calendar month moreover usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / and / also / in addition / too / again / further / besides / no change extra information formal word further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 247 Longman English Usage p 457 more than usage—consider alternatives before using try—exceeds / over / greater than / heavier than / larger than / longer than / older than / higher than / recasting (using at least) / no change extra information Generally, prefer over, at least, or a more specific alternative, eg older than, to other alternatives. see also—not more than; more than 1 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 M–20 M more than 1 usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using 2 or more) / no change extra information 1 legalese 2 Prefer recasting if appropriate. examples of change 1 if there is more than 1 transferee are 2 or more transferees, … 2 This Act does not prevent more than 1 2 or more infringement notices being served on a person for an offence. morning [for time] usage—never use try—am extra information Use am/pm, without full stops, for times. see also—12 am example of change 6 o’clock in the morning 6 am further reading Partridge p 17 (a.m.) motion see—of its own motion motivation usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information Motivation can be a vague word. further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 32 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 M–21 M much as see—in as much as; in so much as; not so much as must usage—consider alternatives before using try—should / will / necessary / is to / may / recasting (using eg may…only if) / no change extra information 1 Use must if a duty is to be imposed. 2 There is no rule preventing must being used in relation to the Executive, Ministers or the Courts. 3 Must is sometimes used unnecessarily in declarative expressions, in an attempt to capture a sense of authority and obligation. In such cases, the present tense is often more appropriate. examples of change 1 A person must be a resident to be eligible is eligible only if the person is a resident. 2 An applicant must may use only an approved form. [or …must use an approved form] 3 An applicant must not may bid unless only if … further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 577–8, 939–43 (words of authority) NZ Legislation Manual p 43 must inevitably / necessarily usage—never use try—must extra information redundancy further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 54 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 M–22 M mutatis mutandis usage—never use try—with the necessary changes / with the appropriate changes extra information foreign phrase further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 499 Cutts p 39 mutual usage—consider alternatives before using try—common / reciprocal / no change extra information For the use of common and mutual, see common. mutually agree usage—never use try—agree extra information tautology example of change If the parties mutually agree to extend the time, … myself usage—consider alternatives before using try—I / me / no change extra information Myself should be used only for emphasis (eg ‘I saw it myself’) or as the reflexive form of the personal pronoun (eg ‘I have hurt myself’). Do not use myself as a rather self-conscious replacement for I or me. example of change The drafting will be done by Ms X and myself me. further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 470–1 (me), 500 (myself), 679–80 (self) Garner’s Legal Style pp 44–5, 127–8 Gowers’ Plain Words p 116 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 M–23 M my sense is that usage—never use try—I consider / I think / omitting / recasting / no change extra information timid phrase see also—it seems further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 57 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 M–24 N name see—by the name of; Christian name; first name; forename; under that name namely usage—never use try—omitting / recasting extra information redundancy example of change The following information must be included in the application, namely: natural person usage—avoid using if possible try—individual / person / human being extra information 1 legalese 2 See LA, dict, pt 1, defs individual and person example of change A natural person An individual or corporation may apply for a licence. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 582 nature usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information 1 Words like nature are vague and abstract, and can be useful on occasion. However, they are often overused. Therefore, consider if use is necessary. 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. see also—in the nature of examples of change 1 improvements of a useful nature useful improvements 2 of a careful nature careful further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 128 Gowers’ Plain Words p 189 Strunk and White p 53 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 N–1 N necessarily usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / no change extra information 1 dogmatic word 2 Only use necessarily if there is an element of necessity. see also—must inevitably/necessarily further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 54 necessitate usage—avoid using if possible try—require / make necessary / oblige / need / force / cause / have to extra information formal word see also—it may necessitate further reading Cutts p 29 Garner’s Dictionary pp 370 (formal words), 583 need see—has/have need of negative see—in the negative neighbourhood see—in the neighbourhood of neither see—nor nevertheless usage—consider alternatives before using try—however / even so / yet / no change extra information Prefer the simplest appropriate word. further reading Cutts p 29 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 N–2 N next usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting / no change extra information The meaning of next is sometimes unclear when used to mention a future day, eg ‘next Saturday’. Usually it means the relevant day nearest in time. However, many people draw a distinction between this and next, using this to mean the day, eg Saturday, of the current week and next to mean the day, eg Saturday, of the following week. example of no change The standards do not apply to a vehicle designed to be controlled by a person walking next to it. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 513 night [for time] usage—never use try—pm / am extra information Use pm/am, without full stops, for time. example of change eleven o’clock at night 11 pm further reading Partridge p 17 (a.m.) no see—has/have no power to; no later than; no option but to; no question that/but that; null and of no effect/legal effect; void and of no effect no force or effect usage—never use try—no effect extra information doublet further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 366 (force and effect) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 N–3 N no later than usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using by / before / within) / no change extra information 1 Prefer before, within or by. 2 See LA, s 151 (Working out periods of time generally). see also—not later than example of change no later than 30 June before 1 July nonetheless usage—avoid using if possible try—however / even so / yet extra information Prefer the simplest appropriate alternative. further reading Cutts p 29 non-flammable see—inflammable no option but to usage—avoid using if possible try—must / recasting extra information verbosity example of change You have no option but to must refund my money. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 63 no question that / but that usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting / no question of / no change extra information No question that can be ambiguous. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 256 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 N–4 N nor usage—consider alternatives before using try—or / no change extra information 1 Nor is used with neither and or with either. 2 If the initial negative is not or no, either nor or or may be used if the meaning of the sentence is clear. However, nor is usually used if it is necessary to repeat the negative, and or is usually used if it is not necessary to repeat the negative. It is not usually necessary to repeat the negative because the original not or no remains in force throughout the rest of the sentence and does not need reinforcing with nor. 3 Neither … nor requires proper balancing of the sentence (see both … and). example of change She cannot read nor or write, or She cannot can neither read nor write, or She cannot read nor can she write. further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 509 (neither with nor), 519 (nor or or) Garner’s Legal Style pp 66, 128–9 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 102, 148–9 Right Words p 272 Strunk and White p 53 normalise usage—consider alternatives before using try—restore to normal / make normal / return to normal / no change further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 247 northerly (direction) / northwardly / northward(s) see—easterly (direction)/eastwardly/eastwards Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 N–5 N not usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting / no change extra information 1 Not can give rise to ambiguity. Its position in a sentence affects the meaning of the sentence and needs to be checked. For example, ‘All drafting is certainly not easy’ can mean ‘All drafting is not easy’ or ‘Not all drafting is easy’ (see all … not). 2 If possible, write in the positive and not in the negative. see also—is not entitled to; is/are not to; not … because; not being; not exceeding; not fewer than; not greater than; not later than; not less than; not more than; not only … but also; not prepared to; not so much as; not un-/infurther reading Cambridge Style Guide p 521 not … because usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting / no change extra information Not followed by because sometimes leads to ambiguity. For example, ‘I did not draft the instrument because of what you told me’ can mean ‘I refrained from drafting the instrument because of what you told me’ or ‘It was not because of what you told me that I drafted the instrument’. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 150 not being usage—avoid using if possible try—other than / except / recasting extra information Do not use not being or being to join relative clauses (see being). example of no change The vehicle was not being used … examples of change 1 A person, not being other than … 2 The licence is not being properly improperly used. further reading NZ Legislation Manual p 41 not entitled to see—is not entitled to Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 N–6 N not exceeding usage—consider alternatives before using try—not greater than / not more than / at most / not over / up to / recasting (using under / maximum / less than / lighter than / shorter than / smaller than / younger than) / no change extra information Generally, prefer recasting if appropriate. not fewer than usage—consider alternatives before using try—at least / recasting (using over / minimum / exceeds / greater than / heavier than / larger than / longer than / more than / older than / taller than / not less than) / no change extra information 1 Generally, prefer at least or recasting. 2 For the use of fewer and less, see fewer. not greater than usage—consider alternatives before using try—not exceeding / not more than / at most / not over / up to / recasting (using under / maximum / less than / lighter than / shorter than / smaller than / younger than) / no change extra information Generally, prefer recasting if appropriate. nothing in this … usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting / no change extra information indirect phrase example of change Nothing in this This section is taken to does not imply … notice in writing usage—never use try—written notice / notice / recasting Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 N–7 N notification usage—never use try—notice extra information formal phrase example of change 1 On giving notification notice, … 2 If the person receives notification in writing written notice before... notify usage—consider alternatives before using try—inform / instruct / mention / point out / say / specify / state / tell / no change extra information formal word example of no change The scheme commences 2 months after it is notified. example of change The board must notify tell each applicant of what the decision is. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 248 not insee—not un-/in- not later than usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using before / within / by) / no change extra information 1 Prefer before, within or by. 2 See on or before for further information. see also—no later than examples of change 1 The registrar must review each standard not later than within 7 years after its approval. 2 Not later than Within 7 business days after … Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 N–8 N not less than usage—consider alternatives before using try—at least / recasting (using over / minimum / exceeds / greater than / heavier than / larger than / longer than / more than / older than / taller than) / not fewer than / no change extra information 1 Prefer at least or recasting. 2 For the use of fewer and less, see fewer. example of change Not less than At least 5 days after the publication of the notice, … further reading Cutts p 29 not more than usage—consider alternatives before using try—not exceeding / not greater than / at most / not over / up to / recasting (using under / less than / maximum / lighter than / shorter than / smaller than / or less / or fewer / younger than) / no change extra information Generally, prefer recasting if appropriate. examples of change 1 The Minister may extend the period for not more than up to 2 months. 2 The standards do not apply to a vehicle with a motor of not more than 1kW power output that has a maximum power output of up to 1kW. further reading Cutts p 29 not only … but also usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting / no change extra information Not only … but also requires proper balancing of the sentence (see both … and). further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 521 Gowers’ Plain Words p 102 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 N–9 N not prepared to usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using more direct words, eg does not) / no change extra information 1 verbosity 2 Prefer a more direct alternative if appropriate. example of change I am not prepared to approve your claim. Your claim has not been approved. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 62 not required to see—is not required to not so much … as usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting / no change extra information Not so much … as requires proper balancing of the sentence (see both … and). further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 102 not to see—is not to Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 N–10 N not un- / in- usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting / no change extra information 1 Because they are double negatives, not in- and not un- constructions (eg ‘not incapable’ and ‘not unwelcome’) should always be used with care. Used appropriately, the constructions can be very useful in avoiding bald assertions and subtly underscoring the tentativeness of a statement. Instead of simply negating the other word, not operates to modulate its force. For example, not impossible means that something is possible, but difficult. 2 The construction is, however, overused. The construction can be ‘a timid, lilylivered, pussyfooting way of avoiding a simple and direct statement’ (Right Words). The not un- disease is well illustrated by George Orwell’s famous sentence: ‘A not unblack dog was chasing a not unsmall rabbit across a not ungreen field.’. further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 215–6 (double negatives), 521–2 Gowers’ Plain Words p 43 Right Words p 274 notwithstanding / notwithstanding the fact that / notwithstanding that usage—never use try—despite / although / even though / even if /subject to / however / but / still / yet / recasting extra information 1 archaism 2 If possible, avoid using despite [provision / instrument] or subject to [provision / instrument] (see subject to). further reading Cutts pp 29, 31 Garner’s Dictionary pp 600–1, 601 (notwithstanding the fact that; notwithstanding that) Garner’s Legal Style p 184 (notwithstanding the fact that) Law Words 1995 pp 53–5 NZ Legislation Manual pp 43–4 (notwithstanding—subject to) nought usage—consider alternatives before using try—0 / zero / no change extra information 1 Except at the beginning of a sentence, express the number 0 as a figure and not as a word. 2 If a word is necessary, prefer zero. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 504 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 N–11 N now see—as of now null and of no effect / legal effect see—null and void null and void usage—never use try—void / invalid / recasting (using of no (legal) effect) extra information doublet example of change This contract is null and void void. further reading Cutts p 36 Dick p 127 Garner’s Dictionary pp 293 (doublets, triplets and synonym-strings), 604, 919 (void; voidable) Garner’s Legal Style p 129 Howard’s Guide p 2 (abet) Law Words 1995 pp 56–8 number see—a limited number of; an adequate number of; an excessive number of; the greatest number of numerous usage—consider alternatives before using try—many / no change example of change too numerous many to be counted further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 535 Garner’s Legal Style p 129 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 N–12 O object see—with the object of objective usage—consider alternatives before using try—aim / goal / purpose / object / end / no change extra information Objective is often used instead of object in the sense of purpose, aim or end. However, used in this sense, there is no difference in meaning between the two words, and object or another alternative should be preferred. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 406 observe [also observance / observation] usage—consider alternatives before using try—comply with / obey / see / notice / keep / retain /preserve / remark / maintain / recasting / no change extra information 1 Observe is incorrect when used as a substitute for keep, retain or preserve. For these meanings, prefer an alternative. 2 Observance and observation are sometimes confused. Both nouns are formed from observe, but have distinct meanings. Observance is the ‘observing’ (that is, the attending to, carrying out or keeping) of a custom, duty, ritual or tradition. Observation is ‘observing’ in the sense of watching and noticing. It also means a comment, particularly a comment based on watching and noticing. 3 Observance is a formal word and should be used only for contexts implying a reverence for custom, ritual or tradition (and duties arising out of them). 4 Observation should be used only for contexts implying watching and noticing, including comments based on watching and noticing. 5 For other contexts, prefer a simpler alternative. Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 O–1 O observe [also observance / observation] [continued] examples of no change 1 Strict religious observance was required at the school. 2 A parent of a child may make decisions about the child’s observance of racial, ethnic, religious or cultural traditions. 3 Careful observation is vital, and observations must be recorded at once. 4 He was kept in hospital for overnight observation. 5 She made vital observation about the experiment. 6 the Sunday Observance Society 7 the observation balloon example of change 1 A driver must observe obey the speed limit. 2 The plaintiff insisted that the contract be strictly observed complied with. 3 She made a petulant observation remark. 4 He kept making indiscreet observations comments in a loud voice. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 534 (observance or observation) Garner’s Dictionary p 611 (observance/observation) Fowler’s English Usage pp 538-9 (observance, observation) Partridge p 221 (observance and observation) and (observe) Working Words p 373 (observance/observation) obtain usage—consider alternatives before using try—get / receive / acquire / find out / no change extra information Obtain is a formal word for get. example of change I have tried to obtain the information find out what you wanted to know. further reading Cutts p 29 Garner’s Dictionary pp 88-9 (attain; obtain), 611 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 O–2 O obviate usage—avoid using if possible try—avoid / prevent / forestall / remove (the need for) / eliminate (the need for) / make obvious / remedy / recasting extra information 1 formal word 2 To obviate something means to anticipate it and take effective action to dispose of it in advance. It does not mean only to reduce or remove the need for something. 3 Obviate is sometimes misunderstood as meaning to make obvious or remedy. examples of change 1 Outside blinds obviated the need for curtains made curtains unnecessary. 2 If the building owner was aware of black ice on the footpath, it should have taken reasonable steps to obviate eliminate the danger. 3 Airbags obviate reduce the risk of serious injury. further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 144 Garner’s Dictionary p 611 Longman English Usage p 490 Macquarie Dictionary p 1489 New Oxford Dictionary p 1280 Working Words p 373 obviously / obvious usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / recasting (using ‘neutral’ words) / no change extra information 1 Obviously can be a sentence adverb (ie an adverb that qualifies a sentence as a whole). 2 Obviously and obvious are dogmatic words. 3 Prefer a more ‘neutral’ alternative if appropriate. further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 161 (clearly), 926 (weasel words) Garner’s Legal Style pp 36, 129 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 O–3 O occasion [as a noun] see—on each occasion when occasion [as a verb] usage—avoid using if possible try—cause / leads to / results in extra information formal word further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 370 (formal words) Hudson p 305 (ploddery) occur usage—consider alternatives before using try—happen / omitting / no change extra information Prefer happen if appropriate. see also—upon/on the occurrence/happening of; wherever occurring; whichever first occurs/occurs first examples of change 1 a change occurs happens 2 After the occurrence of any of the following events happens, … further reading Longman English Usage p 490 Working Words p 373 occurrence see—upon/on the occurrence/happening of Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 O–4 O oddly / odd usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using ‘neutral’ words) / no change extra information 1 Oddly can be a sentence adverb (ie an adverb that qualifies a sentence as a whole). 2 Oddly and odd are value-loaded words. 3 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. further reading Fowler’s English Usage pp 702–3 (sentence adverbs) Garner’s Dictionary pp 791–2 (sentence adverbs) of course usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / recasting / no change extra information padding further reading Gowers’ Plain Words pp 67–8 off usage—consider alternatives before using try—from / no change extra information Do not use off if you mean from. example of no change He took off his hat. example of change The child took the book off from the teacher. Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 O–5 O off of usage—never use try—off extra information 1 compound preposition 2 non-standard English example of change The bird flew off of the tree. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 546 Garner’s Legal Style p 129 officio see—ex officio of its own motion usage—avoid using if possible try—on its own initiative extra information formal phrase example of change A court may, of its own motion on its own initiative, … of limited use usage—avoid using if possible try—not very useful extra information pomposity further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 241 (limited) of whether / who / what / etc see—question of whether/who/what/how/etc Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 O–6 O older than usage—consider alternatives before using try—over / higher than / recasting (using at least) / no change extra information Prefer over or at least if appropriate. example of change A person who is older than over 18 years old may … on see—on or about; upon the expiration; upon the occurrence/happening of on a … basis see—basis on account of usage—avoid using if possible try—because of / for extra information compound preposition example of change Sick leave means leave of absence on account of because of illness. further reading Fowler’s English Usage pp 15-6 (account) Longman English Usage pp 10-1 (account) on and after usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (eg after / inclusive / 6 months beginning on) / no change extra information 1 Prefer recasting. 2 See on or before for more information. 3 See LA, s 151 (Working out periods of time generally). example of change on and after 1 July after 30 June Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 O–7 O on and from usage—avoid using if possible try—on and after / recasting (eg after 6 months) see also—as on and from extra information 1 See on or before for more information. 2 See LA, s 151 (Working out periods of time generally). on behalf of usage—consider alternatives before using try—for / by / no change extra information 1 On behalf of has 2 current meanings in Australian (and British) English: 1 ‘in the place of’ (someone) or ‘as the agent or representative’ (of someone) and 2 ‘in the interest of or for the benefit of’ (someone else, a cause etc). In American English in behalf of is sometimes used for the second meaning. In behalf of is not an accepted Australian usage and should never be used. 2 For can often be substituted for on behalf of without loss of meaning. Prefer for if appropriate. 3 On behalf of is sometimes confused for on the part of (which means by). see also—for and/or on behalf of; on the part of examples of no change 1 a claim on behalf of the deceased person’s dependants or estate 2 On behalf of the corporation, I would like to thank... 3 The application must be signed by or on behalf of the applicant. 4 The defendant’s solicitor undertook to enter an appearance on behalf of the defendant. examples of change 1 She is dealing with the matter on behalf of for her spouse. 2 He fought on behalf of for a just man’s reputation. 3 They accepted the prize on behalf of for the team. 4 She was committed to working on behalf of for the poor. 5 conduct engaged in on behalf of for a corporation by its representative 6 It was an 11th hour decision on his behalf by him. 7 The objects of this Act include ensuring that services provided by or on behalf of for government foster... further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 22 (behalf) Fowler’s English Usage p 101 (behalf) Howard’s Guide p 293 (on behalf of or on the part of) Howard’s Handbook p 277 (on behalf of/on the part of) Hudson p 49 (behalf) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 O–8 O on behalf of [continued] Garner’s Dictionary p 102 (behalf) Longman English Usage p 81 (behalf) Macquarie Dictionary pp 190 (behalf), 825 (for) Partridge p 46 (behalf of, in and on) one usage—consider alternatives before using try—1 / same / recasting / no change extra information 1 Except at the beginning of a sentence, express the number 1 as a figure and not as a word. 2 The number 1 should not be confused with the word one used in a non-numeric way (see examples 1 and 3 to 5, examples of no change). 3 The use of one is sometimes unnecessary (see example 4, examples of change). examples of no change 1 The one that got away. 2 One year ago … 3 one another 4 anyone 5 no one examples of change 1 Within one 1 year after … 2 more than one 1 3 imprisonment for one 1 year 4 The problem is not an easy one easy. 5 molluscs (whether or not of the one same species) further reading Gowers’ Plain English p 116 (unnecessary use of one) on each occasion when usage—avoid using if possible try—whenever / when extra information 1 compound preposition 2 verbosity Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 O–9 O ongoing usage—consider alternatives before using try—continuing / in progress / no change extra information overused, vogue word further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 33 Gowers’ Plain Words p 248 on grounds that see—on the grounds of/that only usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting / no change extra information 1 Adverbs like only are sometimes awkwardly separated from the words they are intended to qualify. They should be placed where it will be perfectly clear which word or words they are intended to qualify and where natural usage requires them to be placed. There are no strict rules about where only should be placed in a sentence. However, it is usually best to place it directly before the words it qualifies. 2 Misplacement of only can lead to ambiguity or worse. see also—if, and only if/if, but only if; not only … but also examples of change 1 A person may only surrender a licence only if … 2 The Minister may only be satisfied only after considering the following … further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 541 Garner’s Legal Style p 130 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 95–7 Right Words p 285 on or about usage—consider alternatives before using try—on / about / no change extra information If possible, find out what alternative applies and use it. further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 184 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 O–10 O on or before usage—consider alternatives before using try—not later than / recasting (using before / not less than / at least / x months ending on or at the end of / inclusive) / no change extra information 1 Prefer an alternative. 2 See LA, s 151 (Working out periods of time generally). example of change on or before 30 June before 1 July further reading Cwlth OPC Plain English p 19 (period) Pearce and Geddes pp 305-9 on the basis of usage—avoid using if possible try—by / from / because of / using / recasting extra information compound preposition example of change The amount of the fee is to be decided on the basis of using the schedule of fees approved by the chief executive. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 56 on the cutting / leading edge usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information 1 vague, vogue phrase 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 33 on the expiration see—upon/on the expiration Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 O–11 O on the ground / grounds of / that usage—avoid using if possible try—because of extra information 1 compound preposition 2 verbosity further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 184 Gowers’ Plain Words p 55 on the occurrence / happening of see—upon/on the occurrence/happening of on the part of usage—never use try—by / recasting (using, eg by) / among / for / omitting extra information 1 compound preposition 2 leads to verbosity example of change 1 It was an 11th hour decision on the part of by the plaintiff. 2 The equipment was damaged because of carelessness on the part of by the technician [or because of the technician’s carelessness]. 3 The defendant’s case was harmed by a lack of candour on the part of the defendant the defendant’s lack of candour. [Note This sentence would be better further recast (see lack).] further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 101 (behalf) Garner’s Dictionary p 620 Garner’s Legal Style p 130 Gowers’ Plain Words p 55 Howard’s Guide p 293 (on behalf of or on the part of) Howard’s Handbook p 277 (on behalf of/on the part of) Hudson p 49 (behalf) Longman English Usage p 81 (behalf) Partridge p 46 (behalf of, in and on) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 O–12 O onward / onwards usage—consider alternatives before using try—onwards / onward / recasting / no change extra information 1 Use onward as an adjective. 2 As an adverb, prefer onwards. However, for the increasing trend not to use an ‘s’ in words ending in ward(s), see forward/forwards. examples of no change 1 The caravan resumed its onward journey. 2 Onward Christian soldiers. 3 We must move onwards [or on]. 4 From the end of her schooling onwards.... further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 554 Howard’s Guide p 296 Howard’s Handbook p 279 Longman English Usage p 497 Macquarie Dictionary p 279 on which usage—consider alternatives before using try—when / no change extra information Prefer when if appropriate examples of change 1 the day on which when the licence is due for renewal 2 the day on which when the application was received by the board Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 O–13 O operational [also operationally] usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information 1 vague word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 33 opinion usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using eg consider or think) / no change extra information Opinion is a word that can give rise to verbosity. examples of no change 1 an opinion given by the office 2 In my opinion, this is a clear case of trespass. examples of change 1 In my opinion I consider that … 2 I am of the opinion think that … further reading Gowers’ Plain Words pp 63, 248 optimistic [also optimism] usage—consider alternatives before using try—confident / hopeful / no change extra information Optimistic means the habit of mind of being disposed in all circumstances to hope for the best. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 248 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 O–14 O optimum [also optimal / optimise] usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using eg best / biggest / fastest) / no change extra information Optimum means strictly the product of conflicting forces. For example, the optimum speed of a car is not the fastest speed of which it is capable, but the speed that reconciles the conflicting desires of its owner for, for example, speed and economy. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words pp 245, 248–9 option see—has/have the option of; no option but to or usage—consider alternatives before using try—either … or … but not both / nor / recasting / no change extra information 1 Or should be used only in a disjunctive sense (ie to express alternatives). 2 However, or has been judicially interpreted in a conjunctive sense. This is in accordance with normal usage. If necessary, the disjunctive sense of or can be made more certain by recasting or using either … or … but not both. 3 Or should be used to join units (eg clauses) of the same type and not, for example, to join unequal phrases. 4 For the use of or which, see and. see also—and/or; either … or example of change Buyers who are either wholesaler or retailer, but not both. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words pp 98–100 NZ Legislation Manual p 41 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 O–15 O oral [also orally] usage—consider alternatives before using try—verbal / spoken / unwritten / no change extra information Oral and verbal are frequently confused. Oral has to do with the mouth; verbal has to do with words. What is spoken is oral. What is expressed in words, whether written or spoken is verbal. Although this distinction is not always observed in practice, maintaining the distinction helps to avoid ambiguity. examples of no change 1 oral agreement [an agreement expressed by word of mouth, not in writing] 2 verbal misunderstanding [a misunderstanding about words rather than substance] example of change verbal oral promise further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 789 (verbal) Fowler’s English Usage pp 820–1 (verbal) Garner’s Dictionary pp 813 (slipshod extension), 910–11 (verbal), 911 (verbal contract) Garner’s Legal Style p 144 Gowers’ Plain Words p 249 Working Words p 380 (oral/verbal) or authority see—power and/or authority or both usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / no change extra information Because or generally includes and, it is not usually necessary to use or both. examples of no change 1 The officer may exercise the power under either provision or both provisions. 2 The person may recover damages from the owner or driver of the vehicle (or both). Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 O–16 O order see—make an order; in order that/to or less usage—avoid using if possible try—not exceeding / not greater than / not more than / at most / not over / up to / recasting (using under / less than / maximum / lighter than / shorter than / smaller than / younger than) extra information Generally, prefer recasting if appropriate. example of no change a maximum capacity of 500L or less or otherwise usage—consider alternatives before using try—or / omitting / recasting (substituting the appropriate noun or verb) / no change extra information Although usage appears to be changing, otherwise has traditionally been regarded as an adverb, to be used only in parallel with other adverbs (see examples of no change). Because there is little to be gained by using otherwise in any other way, this view should be preferred. examples of no change 1 They will finish the task successfully or otherwise. 2 the motion has been withdrawn or otherwise disposed of examples of change 1 The case turned on the validity or otherwise of the instrument [or The case turned on whether the instrument was valid.] 2 They may have succeeded or otherwise failed. 3 The instrument needs to be drafted by tomorrow or otherwise we will miss the client’s deadline. 4 They need to know whether their instrument has been registered or otherwise. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 550 Fowler’s English Usage pp 559–60 (otherwise) Gowers’ Plain Words pp 249–50 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 O–17 O other see—any other otherwise see—except as/where otherwise provided/indicated; or otherwise; otherwise than otherwise than usage—avoid using if possible try—other than / apart from / however / but / except / excluding / recasting (using eg only) extra information 1 Prefer an alternative. 2 Other has traditionally been regarded as an adjective and its use as an adverb instead of otherwise has been strongly criticised. However, current usage seems to accept that other than can be used as an adverb. If practicable, the problem should be avoided by preferring an alternative. examples of change 1 A proceeding may not only be started in a court otherwise than under this part. 2 An If an application is not made otherwise than in person … 3 a boat used otherwise other than in accordance with … further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 550 (other than and otherwise) Fowler’s English Usage p 559 (other) Gowers’ Plain Words pp 249–50 (otherwise) outside of usage—consider alternatives before using try—outside / no change extra information 1 compound preposition 2 can be non-standard English example of no change The outside of the house needed painting. example of change The newspaper did not circulate outside of the State. [or The newspaper circulated only in the State.] further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 562 Garner’s Dictionary p 629 Garner’s Legal Style p 131 Oxford English Usage p 154 Right Words p 290 (outside of/inside of) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 O–18 O outward / outwards usage—consider alternatives before using try—outwards / outward / recasting / no change extra information 1 Use outward as an adjective and as an adverb to mean away from a port. 2 In other contexts, prefer outwards as an adverb. However, for the increasing trend not to use an ‘s’ in words ending in ward(s), see forward/forwards. examples of no change 1 He fell sick on the outward journey. 2 The liner took on its passengers and headed outward [or out to sea]. 3 Her outward composure hid her nervousness. 4 They journeyed outwards. further reading Howard’s Guide p 299 Howard’s Handbook p 284 Macquarie Dictionary p 1531 Working Words p 383 over see—above overall usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / altogether / average / in all / on balance / total / recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information vague word example of no change The overall area of the house, including the verandahs and carport, is 250m3 examples of change 1 The overall increase in homes with access to the internet is staggering. 2 The overall total output last month was 550 units. further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 33 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 17, 33, 56, 250–1 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 O–19 O overlay usage—consider alternatives before using try—overlie / no change extra information Overlay and overlie are sometimes confused. Overlay means to put over something else especially by coating or otherwise affixing a layer or surface to it. Overlie means lying or situated over. examples of no change 1 The earlier painting was overlaid with a more recent painting. 2 I could see the seam of gold overlaying the stratum of hard rock. see also—underlay further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 552–3 Fowler’s English Usage pp 563–4 Gowers’ Plain English p 240 (lay, lie) Longman English Usage p 508 Partridge p 235 overlook usage—consider alternatives before using try—neglect / disregard / ignore / supervise / monitor / oversee / no change extra information Overlook has 2 different meanings. It can mean ‘fail to notice’ or ‘fail to take into account’. It can also mean ‘look over’ or ‘oversee’. If its use is ambiguous in the particular context, prefer an alternative. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 553 Fowler’s English Usage p 564 Gowers’ Plain Words p 251 Longman English Usage 503 Partridge p 235 Right Words p 290 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 O–20 O oversee usage—consider alternatives before using try—supervise / monitor / direct / manage / check / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 553 Fowler’s English Usage p 564 Right Words p 290 oversight [as a verb] usage—consider alternatives before using try—supervise / monitor / direct / manage / check / no change extra information 1 Oversight has a long history as a noun whose meaning corresponds to the first meaning of overlook, that is, fail to notice or take into account. However, it has recently been used as a verb with a meaning like the second meaning of overlook, that is, oversee. This extended use is confusing and has been criticised. 2 formal word 3 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 290 (formal words), 553 Fowler’s English Usage p 564 (overlook, oversee) Longman English Usage p 508 Right Words p 290 owing...due see—due Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 O–21 O owing to the fact that usage—never use try—because of extra information verbosity see also—the fact that own motion see—of its own motion Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 O–22 P panacea usage—consider alternatives before using try—remedy / no change extra information A panacea is a cure-all, not just any remedy. further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 557–8 (panacea) Garners’ Legal Style p 131 Right Words p 292 paradigm usage—consider alternatives before using try—model / exemplar / example / no change extra information formal word further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 559–60 Right Words p 293 paradoxically / paradoxical usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using ‘neutral’ words) / no change extra information 1 Paradoxically is a sentence adverb (ie an adverb that qualifies a sentence as a whole). 2 Paradoxically and paradoxical are value-loaded words. 3 Prefer a more ‘neutral’ alternative if appropriate. further reading Fowler’s English Usage pp 702–3 (sentence adverbs) Garner’s Dictionary pp 791–2 (sentence adverbs) Working Words p 390 (paradox) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 P–1 P parameter usage—consider alternatives before using try—boundary / limit / border / framework / condition / criterion / ground / consideration / variable / edge / guideline / element / recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information 1 vague, vogue word 2 Use parameter with care. Avoid using parameter as an omnibus word. See kind for extra information. 3 Prefer a more precise alternative if appropriate. 4 Parameter is sometimes confused with perimeter or boundary. further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 637, 919 (vogue words) Garner’s Legal Style pp 33, 131, 205 Gowers’ Plain Words p 251 pares see—primus inter pares parol usage—consider alternatives before using try—oral / unwritten / word of mouth / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. 3 For the use of oral and verbal, see oral. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 639 part see—on the part of partial usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using eg biased / prejudiced / unfair / incomplete) / no change extra information Partial can mean exhibiting favouritism or bias. Avoid potential ambiguity by recasting using, for example, biased, prejudiced, unfair or incomplete, depending on what is meant. see also—partially Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 P–2 P partially usage—consider alternatives before using try—partly / recasting (using eg biased / prejudiced / unfair / incomplete) / no change extra information 1 Partially and partly are synonyms in most contexts. 2 It has been suggested that partly implies that only some parts of the whole are concerned, and partially implies that it is a question of degree over the whole. On this basis, a partly finished draft is a draft only parts of which have been finished, and a partially finished draft is a draft whose parts have all been finished in some degree but which needs further work. The distinction is a fine one and, in most contexts, is of little practical significance. 3 However, partially is stylistically more formal, and grammatically less flexible than partly. Therefore, prefer partly if appropriate. 4 Note also that partially can mean in a way exhibiting favouritism or bias. Avoid potential ambiguity by recasting using, for example, biased, prejudiced, unfair or incomplete, depending on what is meant. see also—partial example of change The apple was partially partly bruised. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 566 Fowler’s English Usage pp 573–4 Garner’s Dictionary p 640 Garner’s Legal Style pp 131–2 Longman English Usage p 516 (partial) Oxford English Usage p 155 Partridge p 239 Right Words p 296 Strunk and White p 55 Working Words p 392 participate [also participation] usage—consider alternatives before using try—take part / share / no change extra information 1 vague word 2 formal word 3 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. example of no change to provide for community participation in local government example of change A member who participates takes part in a meeting … further reading Gowers’ Plain Words pp 239, 252 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 P–3 P particular usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / respect / detail / fact / information / example / no change extra information Particular is occasionally used unnecessarily in writing, especially for emphasis. see also—in a particular respect; in a material particular (see material) examples of no change 1 (1) The operator must not change the nature of the service without the chief executive’s written approval. (2) In particular, the operator must not increase the number of the service’s child care places without the chief executive’s written approval. 2 Subsection (1) does not apply of the statement is not false or misleading in a material particular. examples of change 1 and, in particular for example 2 has become correct in an essential particular respect 3 This particular section deals with … further reading Cutts pp 29, 31 (particulars) Gowers’ Plain Words pp 54 (particular), 97 (in particular) Hudson p 305 (ploddery) partly see—partially pass away usage—avoid using if possible try—die / recasting (using death) extra information euphemism further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 34 payable …. due see—due payment see—make payment Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 P–4 P pay, satisfy and discharge usage—never use try—satisfy / discharge / comply with extra information triplet further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 188 peaceable see—peaceful peaceful usage—consider alternatives before using try—peaceable / no change extra information 1 Peaceable applies to a person or group of people who are disposed to keep good relations with others. It can also be applied to human character or intentions. 2 Peaceful applies to non-human subjects. It refers to situations, periods or general activities that are calm and free of disturbance and conflict. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 572 pecuniary usage—avoid using if possible try—financial / monetary extra information formal word example of change direct or indirect pecuniary financial interest pending usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using, eg until) / no change extra information starchy word example of change Completion of the project was delayed pending the recruiting of more staff until more staff were recruited. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 252 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 P–5 P people see—persons per usage—consider alternatives before using try—through / by / for each / a / for / no change extra information foreign phrase, but absorbed into English see also—as per; per annum; per capita; per cent/percent/per centum; per day/month/year; per diem; per procurationem/per proc./per pro./p.p.; per se; per stirpes examples of no change 1 $50 per 100 2 $20 a day per person 3 100km/h 4 100 kilometres per hour examples of change 1 1 bottle per for each person 2 $100 per for 10 tickets further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 572 Cutts pp 32-3 Cwlth Style Manual pp 202, 205 Fowler’s English Usage pp 583-4 Garner’s Dictionary p 649 Howard’s Guide p 308 Howard’s Handbook p 291 per annum usage—never use try—a year / by the year / for each year / per year / annually extra information foreign phrase example of change $500 per annum a year further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 572 Cutts p 39 Garner’s Dictionary p 649 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 16, 252 Howard’s Guide p 308 (per) Howard’s Handbook pp 41 (a year/per annum), 291 Right Words p 299 Working Words p 396 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 P–6 P per capita usage—avoid using if possible try—a head / for each person / per head / per person / each / recasting (adding an explanation of the phrase) extra information 1 foreign phrase 2 Also a technical legal term in succession law relating to the distribution of the estate (or a part of the estate) of a deceased person. A distribution per capita means that the class of distributees take an equal share in the estate in their own right. A distribution per stirpes is the opposite of a per capita distribution (see per stirpes). If it is necessary to use the term, include a note (or provision) explaining what it means. further reading Black’s Law Dictionary p 1171 Cambridge Style Guide p 572 Cutts p 39 Fowler’s English Usage p 584 Garner’s Dictionary p 649 Gowers’ Plain Words p 252 Howard’s Guide p 308 (per) Howard’s Handbook p 291 (per) Mellinkoff’s Dictionary pp 474–5 Right Words p 299 (per) per cent / percent / per centum usage—never use try—% example of change 9 per cent % further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 573 Cwlth Style Manual pp 186, 188 Fowler’s English Usage p 584 Garner’s Dictionary pp 649–50 Howard’s Guide pp 308-9 (per and per cent or percentage) Howard’s Handbook pp 291 (per), 292 (per cent/percentage) Right Words p 299 (per) Working Words pp 396-7 (per cent / percentage) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 P–7 P percentage usage—consider alternatives before using try—some / few / many / most / recasting (by, eg including a figure or adding an adjective such as high, low, large or small) / no change extra information 1 A percentage is the proportion of a number to 100. 2 Percentage should be used only to express the relationship between a number and another number, not to express an absolute number. 3 Do not use percentage when you mean some, few, many or most. Percentage should be used only if it is possible to express the size of a relationship either by a number, or by a useful description, eg ‘a high percentage’. 4 A percentage does not mean a small part. ‘A part is always less than the whole, but a percentage may be the whole or more than the whole.’ (Fowler) example of change A high percentage of Most drafters went to the training session. further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 573–4 Fowler’s English Usage pp 584-5 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 252–3 Howard’s Guide pp 308-9 (per cent or percentage) Howard’s Handbook p 292 (per cent/percentage) Right Words p 299 (per) Working Words pp 396-7 perceptible usage—consider alternatives before using try—perceptive / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Perceptive means showing fine perception. It implies the exercise of intelligence and critical judgment, not just powers of observation. 3 Perceptible means able to be perceived (or observed). 4 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 574 perceptive see—perceptible Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 P–8 P per day / month / year usage—consider alternatives before using try—a [day/month/year] / for each [day/month/year] / no change extra information 1 legalese 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. further reading Cutts p 39 (per annum) Fowler’s English Usage pp 583-4 (per) Garner’s Dictionary p 649 (per) Gowers’ Plain Words pp 16, 252 Howard’s Guide p 308 (per) Howard’s Handbook p 291 (per) per diem usage—never use try—a day / by the day / for each day / per day / daily extra information foreign phrase further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 572 Cutts p 39 Garner’s Dictionary p 650 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 16, 252 Working Words p 397 perform usage—consider alternatives before using try—carry out / make / conduct / do / recasting (using more specific words) / no change extra information Prefer the most specific, available word. However, prefer carry out to perform if appropriate. example of no change The report must include performance indicators. example of change In performing carrying out the functions … further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 253 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 P–9 P perform and discharge usage—never use try—perform / discharge / recasting extra information doublet further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 61 period [of time] usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / term / time / day / date / recasting / no change extra information 1 Use of period leads to verbosity. Period of is unnecessary when the period itself is mentioned, eg ‘a period of 20 years’ means no more than ‘20 years’. 2 Do not use period of time. 3 A period is a length of time, not an instant in time. If you want to describe when something happened or is to happen, use day or date rather than period. examples of no change 1 if the offence took place over a period 2 the period of registration 3 allowing the claimant a reasonable period examples of change 1 within the period of 1 year beginning on 1 July 2007 2 A member is to be appointed for a period term of not longer than 2 years. 3 For a period of Within 2 weeks before … 4 A person who has not been a grower for a period of at least 3 years … 5 in the period of within 28 days before the commencing day 6 a short period of time further reading Cwlth OPC Plain English p 19 Garner’s Legal Style p 184 Gowers’ Plain Words p 253 permanent layoff usage—avoid using if possible try—dismissal / termination (of employment) extra information euphemism further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 35 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 P–10 P permissible see—permissive permissive usage—consider alternatives before using try—permissible / no change extra information 1 Permissive means a hands-off approach, tending to permit anything. 2 Permissible implies limits on what is permitted. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 575 permit [as a verb] usage—consider alternatives before using try—let / allow / recasting (using may) / no change see also—where the context permits per month see—per day/month/year perpetrate see—perpetuate perpetuate usage—consider alternatives before using try—perpetrate / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Perpetuate and perpetrate are sometimes confused. Perpetuate means to prolong or make last. Perpetrate means to commit or carry out. 3 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. example of no change The rumours perpetuated the doubts about him. example of change He perpetuated perpetrated a fraud on his employer. [or committed] further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 132 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 P–11 P per procurationem / per proc. / per pro. / p.p. usage—never use try—for / on behalf of extra information foreign phrase (literal meaning ‘through the agency of’). example of change AB per pro for CD further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 572–3 Cutts p 39 Garner’s Dictionary p 653 Gowers’ Plain Words p 16 perquisite see—prerequisite per se usage—never use try—by itself / in itself / as such / essentially / for its own sake / standing alone / as a matter of law extra information 1 foreign phrase 2 can be legal term of art further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 572 Cutts p 39 Garner’s Dictionary pp 653–4 Gowers’ Plain Words p 16 person usage—consider alternatives before using try—individual / corporation / no change extra information Use individual to distinguish a natural person from a corporation (see LA, dict, pt 1, def individual). see also—another person; any other; body corporate; natural person Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 P–12 P person or body usage—consider alternatives before using try—entity (if necessary after defining entity) / person / no change extra information 1 can be a redundancy 2 See LA, dict, pt 1, defs body, corporation, entity, individual and person. example of change an instrument made by a person or body an entity persons usage—consider alternatives before using try—people / peoples / anyone / someone / omitting / no change extra information 1 It has been suggested that persons is used when speaking of a number of people who can be counted and people is used when speaking of a large or uncounted number of individuals (Harper quoted in Fowler’s English Usage). However, in current usage persons is tending to yield to people in all contexts. 2 prefer an alternative. example of change 1 Aboriginal persons peoples of Australia 2 Torres Strait Islander persons people 3 persons people with disabilities 4 persons people from non-English-speaking backgrounds 5 English-speaking persons people 6 children and young persons people 7 The persons people responsible for this crime must be punished. 8 Twelve persons people came to lunch. 9 This person has eaten, but the rest of the persons people are hungry. 10 The 3 people eligible to serve on the selection committee… further reading Cutts pp 29, 31 Cwlth Style Manual pp 121-44 (non-discriminatory language) Fowler’s English Usage p 583 (people, persons) Garner’s Dictionary pp 649-50 (people) Garner’s Legal Style p 132 (people; persons) Gowers’ Plain Words p 253 Howard’s Handbook p 291 (people/persons) Howard’s Guide p 291 (people/persons) Longman English Usage p 525 Partridge pp 241 (people), 244 (persons) Right Words p 298 (people) Working Words p 396 (people) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 P–13 P personally usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / no change extra information can be a redundancy examples of change 1 I personally think … 2 Personally, I like the idea. further reading Garners’ Legal Style p 132 Strunk and White p 56 personam see—in personam personnel usage—consider alternatives before using try—staff / people / employees / no change extra information Prefer the simplest appropriate word. per stirpes usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (adding an explanation of the phrase) / no change extra information 1 foreign phrase 2 Also a technical legal term in succession law relating to the distribution of the estate (or a part of the estate) of a deceased person. A distribution per stirpes can happen if a person (B) who would have been entitled to share in the estate of a deceased person (D) dies before D. B’s share will be taken in equal shares by B’s surviving next of kin (if any) as representatives of B. A distribution per capita is the opposite of a per stirpes distribution (see per capita). If it is necessary to use the term, include a note (or provision) explaining what it means. further reading Black’s Law Dictionary p 1181 Garner’s Dictionary pp 649 (per capita (B)), 834 (stirpital), 872 (terms of art) Law Words 1995 pp 59–2 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary pp 474-5 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 P–14 P pertaining to usage—never use try—about / of / in relation to / on extra information archaism peruse usage—avoid using if possible try—read / study / consider / examine extra information 1 formal word 2 One meaning of peruse is to read, study, consider or examine carefully or thoroughly. see also—it will be seen by a perusal of example of no change for perusal of any other document that it is necessary to peruse…$5.00 per 100 words example of change I enclose a document for your perusal you to consider. further reading Cutts p 29 Fowler’s English Usage pp 309 (formal words), 591 Garner’s Dictionary pp 370 (formal words), 656 Partridge p 244 Working Words p 400 per year see—per day/month/year phase usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information Avoid using phase as an omnibus word. See kind for extra information. example of no change a 3-phase electrical system further reading Garner’s Legal Style pp 32 (as vague word), 132 (as vague word), 205 (as omnibus word) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 P–15 P plan on … ing usage—avoid using if possible try—plan to … extra information verbosity example of change I plan on moving to move. further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 132 please see—enclosed please find/please find enclosed point of time see—at this time/point of time/moment of time point of view usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting / no change extra information 1 vogue phrase 2 Point of view (like angle, standpoint and viewpoint) can be useful if appropriately used. However, it is sometimes used as a refuge from the trouble of precise thought, and provides a clumsy way of saying something that could be said more simply and effectively. It is used, for instance, as circumlocution for a simple adverb, eg ‘from a temporary point of view’ instead of ‘temporarily’ (Gowers). example of change From an energy efficiency point of view, For energy efficiency, there are advantages in having double glazed windows. [or recast] further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 604 Garner’s Dictionary p 916 (viewpoint; point of view; standpoint) Gowers’ Plain Words pp 61–2 Partridge p 330 (standpoint; point of view; viewpoint; angle and slant) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 P–16 P portion usage—consider alternatives before using try—part / share / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer part or share if appropriate. 3 A portion is something cut or taken away from the whole (eg ‘a portion of cake’). By contrast, part is only a constituent part of the whole (eg ‘a part of the house’). examples of change 1 the portion part of the rate attributable to land occupied only by a pensioner 2 her portion share of the drink further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 370 (formal words), 672 Partridge p 250 (portion and part) position [as a noun] usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information 1 can be a vague word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. 3 never use position in regard to see also—in a position example of no change A retractable axle is taken to be an axle only when it is in the lowered position. [or ... only when it is lowered] example of change I am in a position to can… further reading Gowers’ Plain Words pp 4, 253–4 Partridge pp 4 (abstract nouns—position), 251 (position to do (something), not to be in a) position [as a verb] usage—avoid using if possible try—place / put extra information formal word Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 P–17 P possess usage—consider alternatives before using try—have / keep / own / no change extra information formal word further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 370 (formal words), 673 possession, custody and control usage—never use try—possession / ownership extra information 1 triplet 2 If necessary, define possession to include particular kinds of control. further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 186 possible see—as soon as is possible/practicable; as soon as possible; as soon as practicable; practicable; if practicable power see—has/have no power to; has/have power to power and / or authority usage—never use try—power / omitting extra information 1 doublet 2 See LA, dict, pt 1, defs power and function. p.p. see—per procurationem / per proc. / per pro. / p.p. Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 P–18 P practicable usage—consider alternatives before using try—practical / possible / feasible / recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information 1 Practical, with its implied antithesis of theoretical, means useful in practice or responding effectively to actual conditions. Practicable means capable of being done or used, possible, or feasible (Gowers). 2 Practicable (in the sense of feasible) is virtually a synonym of possible. see also—as soon as is possible/practicable; as soon as possible; as soon as practicable; if practicable; if possible further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 599 Fowler’s English Usage p 612 Garner’s Dictionary pp 676 (possible; practicable), 678 (practical; practicable) Garner’s Legal Style p 133 Gowers’ Plain Words p 254 Right Words p 323 Working Words pp 410–1 practical see—practicable practical considerations usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information vague phrase further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 32 practically usage—consider alternatives before using try—almost / nearly / virtually / no change extra information Since practically can also mean in a practical way, avoid using it in phrases where it might be ambiguous, eg ‘practically trained lawyers’. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 254 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 P–19 P practice usage—consider alternatives before using try—practise / no change extra information Practice is the spelling for the noun. Practise is the spelling for the verb. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 599 Garner’s Legal Style p 133 practise see—practice practitioner see—legal practitioner; medical practitioner preceding usage—avoid using if possible try—last / before / earlier / previous / recasting extra information formal word examples of change 1 28 days immediately preceding before the commencing day 2 the day immediately preceding before 3 the preceding previous year 4 During the 3 years immediately preceding before the accident, … further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 255 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 P–20 P precipitate usage—consider alternatives before using try—hasty / rushed / rash / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. 3 The traditional meaning of precipitate is the doing of something in a hasty, rushed and perhaps rash or uncontrolled way. It relates to time. The traditional meaning of precipitous is a steep decline. It relates to space. However, precipitous is increasingly used instead of precipitate to mean sudden. Nevertheless, precipitous should not be used in this way. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 601 Fowler’s English Usage pp 613–4 (precipitous) Garner’s Dictionary p 681 Garner’s Legal Style p 133 Longman English Usage p 552 Oxford English Usage p 157 (precipitous) Partridge pp 253-4 (precipitously) Working Words p 412 precipitous see—precipitate precis usage—avoid using if possible try—summary extra information foreign word further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 601 preclude usage—avoid using if possible try—prevent / exclude / leave out / omit extra information formal word example of change Subsection (2) does not preclude prevent … Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 P–21 P predecease usage—avoid using if possible try—die before extra information 1 formal word 2 euphemism further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 18 prefer … than usage—never use try—prefer … to / prefer … over / recasting / prefer … rather than extra information non-standard English example of change He prefers facts than to rumours. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 615 (prefer) Garner’s Plain Words p 133 prejudice see—without prejudice to the generality of preliminary to usage—avoid using if possible try—before extra information compound preposition further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 133 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 P–22 P preparatory usage—avoid using if possible try—introductory / recasting (using prepare for / make ready) extra information legalese example of no change a preparatory school further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 133 prepare usage—consider alternatives before using try—set up / make ready / no change extra information Prefer the simplest, appropriate alternative. see also—not prepared to prerequisite usage—consider alternatives before using try—condition / perquisite / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prerequisite means a prior condition. 3 Perquisite means a benefit or privilege attaching to a position. 4 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 607 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 P–23 P prescribe usage—consider alternatives before using try—set / fix / prescribed by regulation / recasting / omitting / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prescribed is defined in LA, dict, pt 1 to mean, in an Act, ‘prescribed by the Act or by regulation under the Act’. See also LA, dict, pt 1, def by regulation. 3 Prescribe should continue to be used, as appropriate, in provisions giving power to make statutory instruments. In other contexts, prefer set or fix. 4 As prescribe is not a well understood concept, in provisions giving power to make statutory instruments prefer an alternative phrase (eg declared by regulation) or recasting. If it is necessary to use prescribed, prefer prescribed by regulation (or another kind of legislative instrument) rather than just prescribed. 5 If possible, avoid using prescribe in the sense of prescribed by the Act (or provision of the Act). 6 If an authorising provision states that something may be prescribed in a statutory instrument, in prescribing the thing, it is usually unnecessary to use the word prescribe. In prescribing things in a statutory instrument, avoid using prescribe, especially in provision headings. 7 Prescribe and proscribe are sometimes confused. To prescribe is to lay down rules to be followed. To proscribe is to condemn or prohibit something (see proscribe). see also—except as provided in/prescribed by example of no change A person may apply for a benefit in the way prescribed by regulation. examples of change 1 The education board prescribed set the syllabus for subject. 2 Section X of an Act states: ‘The fee for a licence is as prescribed by regulation.’. The regulation made under that section states: Prescribed fee Fee for licences—Act, s X ‘Z. The prescribed fee for a licence is $100.’. 3 This section applies to a provision prescribing setting a penalty for an offence. further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 607–9 (prescribe or proscribe) Garner’s Legal Style p 133 (prescribe; proscribe) Gowers’ Plain Words p 255 prescribed form usage—avoid using if possible try—approved form / recasting extra information 1 Forms should not generally be prescribed in legislation, especially Acts. 2 If possible, use approved form or recast. Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 P–24 P present [as an adjective or adverb] see—as at present advised; at present; at the present day; at the present time; the present writer present [as a verb] usage—consider alternatives before using try—give / offer / introduce / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 370 (formal words) presently usage—consider alternatives before using try—now / soon / at present / currently / no change extra information 1 Presently has 3 meanings: now, soon and currently. 2 The use of presently to mean now has been criticised (see Gowers). 3 Because of its possible meanings, use of presently can be ambiguous. examples of change 1 The office is presently currently giving a number of seminars on its role. 2 I will join you at the Christmas party presently soon. further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 133 Gowers’ Plain Words p 255 Strunk and White p 57 preserve usage—consider alternatives before using try—keep / no change extra information 1 formal word for keep 2 Prefer keep if appropriate. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 370 (formal words) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 P–25 P presume usage—consider alternatives before using try—assume / no change extra information 1 Presume and assume have similar meanings. When used to mean ‘to suppose’, the words are interchangeable. Otherwise, the choice of word depends on usage and the degree of tentativeness behind the presumption or assumption. 2 In Australian English, assume is more common than presume. Presume is, however, invariably used in certain legal contexts, eg the presumption of innocence and evidentiary presumptions. 3 Outside these legal contexts, a presumption expresses what the writer really believes. By contrast, an assumption can be made for the sake of argument and without implying belief in its truth. 4 Because of it depersonalised nature, assume slips readily into a discussion and draws less attention to itself and more to the particular point the writer wants to highlight. Presume, by contrast, seems to draw attention to itself and to the presumptive act by the writer. It has the faint suggestion of presumptuousness. further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 62–3 (assume or presume) Fowler’s English Usage p 74 (assume, presume) Garner’s Dictionary pp 84 (assume; presume), 689 (presumption) Right Words p 39 Working Words p 50 presumptive usage—consider alternatives before using try—presumptuous / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Presumptive and presumptuous are sometimes confused. Presumptive means based on a presumption or inference. It also means giving reasonable grounds for presumption or belief. Presumptive is neutral in its connotations. Presumptuous, by contrast, has negative connotations. It means arrogant, presuming too much or taking unwarranted liberties. 3 Presumptive is used in some technical legal expressions, eg heir presumptive. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 609 Garner’s Dictionary pp 400 (heir), 689 Garner’s Legal Style p 133 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 P–26 P previous to usage—avoid using if possible try—before extra information compound preposition further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 133 Gowers’ Plain Words p 110 prima facie usage—consider alternatives before using try—at first sight / on the face of it / a strong case / an arguable case / recasting (using, eg from what can be seen) / no change extra information 1 foreign phrase 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate (or include a note explaining what it means). further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary pp 914 (prima facie), 914-5 (prima facie case), 915 (prima facie evidence) Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 15 (a priori, prima facie) Cambridge Style Guide p 611 Gowers’ Plain Words p 207 (a priori) Howard’s Guide p 28 (a priori or prima facie) Howard’s Handbook p 31 (a priori/prima facie) Right Words p 35 (a priori or prima facie) primus inter pares usage—never use try—first among equals / having precedence but no greater authority extra information foreign phrase further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 916 Cambridge Style Guide p 611 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 P–27 P principal [also principally] usage—consider alternatives before using try—main / chief / major / predominant / leading / first / recasting (using (most) important / big / large / great) / principle / no change extra information 1 vague word 2 Prefer a more precise alternative if appropriate. 3 Principal and principle are frequently confused. Principal, as an adjective, means chief or most important. As a noun, it means capital, as opposed to interest or other income, or the head of a body (eg ‘the principal of a school’). Principle means a rule, body of beliefs or the like. examples of no change 1 principal and interest 2 the agent’s principal 3 the school principal 4 the company’s principal Australian register 5 principal executive officer 6 principal home 7 principal in the first degree example of change The principal main objects of this Act are .... further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 916 Cambridge Style Guide p 611 Cutts p 29 principle see—principal Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 P–28 P prior usage—avoid using if possible try—earlier / before / previous / omitting / recasting extra information 1 formal word 2 Although prior can be used as an adjective (eg ‘prior engagement’), prefer earlier or previous if appropriate. 3 Prior to is a compound preposition that can readily be replaced by the simple preposition before. As Bryson (pp 29-30) puts it, there is no difference between before and prior to ‘except that prior to is longer, clumsier and awash with pretension. If, to paraphrase Bernstein, you would use ‘prosterior to’ instead of ‘after’, then by all means use prior to instead of before’. examples of change 1 A member who is absent without the local government’s prior leave … [or A member who is absent without having obtained the local government’s leave …] 2 The trustees must not may exercise a power under subsection (1) without the prior agreement of the Minister only with the Minister’s agreement. 3 An applicant must pay the fee prior to before the application is heard. further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 22 (before, prior to) Cutts pp 29, 31, 36 (prior to) Garner’s Legal Style pp 134, 184 Garner’s Dictionary pp 370 (formal words), 692 (prior; previous), 692 (prior to) Gowers’ Plain Words pp 55, 110 prioritise usage—consider alternatives before using try—rank / set priorities / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. further reading Cutts p 29 Garner’s Legal Style p 134 probability see—in all probability Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 P–29 P problematic [also problematical] usage—consider alternatives before using try—questionable / recasting / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Problematic can mean either having the nature or appearance of a problem, or questionable. 3 Use questionable if that is what is meant. 4 Prefer problematic to problematical. further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 360-1 (-ic / -ical) Working Words p 420 pro bono / pro bono publico usage—avoid using if possible. try—recasting (using more precise words, eg free or in the public interest) extra information 1 foreign phrase 2 Pro bono (or pro bono publico) does not have a settled meaning. further reading 71ALJ 735 (1997) (note about pro bono work) Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 927 Garner’s Dictionary pp 695–7 Law Words 1995 pp 63–5 proceed usage—consider alternatives before using try—act / go / go ahead / continue / recasting / no change extra information formal word examples of change 1 The commissioner must proceed act as quickly as possible. 2 The commissioner may proceed act in the absence of a person who has been given reasonable notice. 3 The captain of a requisitioned ship must proceed with all practicable speed go as quickly as possible to help a ship in distress. 4 Before proceeding to consider considering … further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 370 (formal words), 680 (precede. A. and proceed) Hudson p 305 (ploddery) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 P–30 P process usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information 1 vague, vogue word 2 Prefer a more precise alternative if appropriate. further reading Garner’s Legal Style pp 32 (vague word as a noun), 34 (vogue word as a verb) procure usage—consider alternatives before using try—obtain / get / cause / bring about / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 also technical legal term 3 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. example of no change A person is taken to have committed an offence if the person aids, abets, counsels or procures the commission of the offence by someone else. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 930 productive of usage—avoid using if possible try—recasting (using produces) extra information verbosity example of change Good research is productive of produces good outcomes. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 255 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 P–31 P pro forma usage—never use try—as a matter of form / for the sake of form / as a gesture / recasting extra information foreign phrase further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 927 Cambridge Style Guide p 613 Cutts p 39 Garner’s Dictionary p 700 promptly usage—consider alternatives before using try—as soon as practicable / recasting (mentioning a period, eg within 14 days after …) / quickly / no change extra information 1 The expression ‘prompt’ should not be given a meaning different from its ordinary English meaning.: Bowling v Weinert [1978] 2 NSWLR 282 at 290 per Lee J. 2 US judicial authority is consistent with prompt or promptly meaning without delay or with reasonable speed. Terms such as as soon as practicable, immediately, promptly, within a reasonable time, in relation to the time when notice of an accident must be given to an insurer all mean essentially the same thing, ie not instantaneous notice, but rather notice within a reasonable length of time, taking into account all the facts and circumstances: Certified Indem. Co. v Thun 439 P 2D 28 at 30; 165 Colo. 354 This view is consistent with Lee J’s view in Bowling v Weinert. 3 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. proof usage—consider alternatives before using try—evidence / no change extra information Proof is evidence found to be conclusive (or sufficiently persuasive) to establish the existence of a fact. Evidence is any way in which a fact in issue might be proved or disproved. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 938 Garner’s Legal Style p 134 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 P–32 P proper usage—consider alternatives before using try—appropriate / suitable / adequate / no change extra information 1 vague word 2 can be value-loaded word 3 For the use of adequate, see sufficient. see also—fit and proper; fit and suitable/fitting and proper proportion usage—consider alternatives before using try—some / few / many / most / recasting (using eg a formula including a figure or adding an adjective such as high, low, large or small) / no change extra information 1 If possible, use formulas instead of provisions that express concepts as proportions of each other. However, avoid the unnecessary use of formulas. x For example, there is no point in saying ‘ ’ instead of ‘half of x’. 2 2 Proportion should be used only to express the relationship between a number and another number, not to express an absolute number. 3 Do not use proportion when you mean some, few, many or most. Proportion should be used only if it is possible to express the size of a relationship either by a number, or by a useful description, eg ‘a large proportion’. see also—percentage example of no change The levy must cover a fair proportion of the estimated cost. example of change A large proportion Most [or Many] of the audience left at interval. further reading Cwlth OPC Plain English p 23 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 252–3 Working Words p 427 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 P–33 P proposition usage—consider alternatives before using try—plan / project / proposal / offer / no change extra information 1 formal, blunderbuss word. 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. example of no change My argument is based on the proposition that there is life on Mars. example of change a promising commercial proposition proposal further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 616 Gowers’ Plain Words p 85 pro rata usage—avoid using if possible try—proportionately / in proportion extra information foreign phrase further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 927 Garner’s Dictionary p 705 proscribe usage—avoid using if possible try—prohibit / forbid / condemn / recasting (using is not permitted / must not) extra information 1 formal word 2 Proscribe and prescribe are often confused. See prescribe for more information. example of change Smoking is proscribed not permitted in our building. further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 607–9 (prescribe or proscribe) Garner’s Legal Style p 133 (prescribe; proscribe) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 P–34 P prosecute usage—consider alternatives before using try—carry on / conduct / no change extra information can be formal word for carry on or conduct example of no change The authority may prosecute offences against the Act. example of change prosecute carry on its business protagonist usage—consider alternatives before using try—antagonist / party / supporter / advocate / spokesperson / recasting / no change extra information 1 The traditional meaning of protagonist was the chief champion of a cause. However, it is now frequently used to mean simply one who fights for something. 2 By contrast, antagonist is someone who fights against something. 3 formal word 4 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 617–8 Garner’s Legal Style pp 134–5 pro tanto usage—avoid using if possible try—in part / to that extent / as far as it goes / so much / recasting extra information foreign phrase further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 927 Garner’s Dictionary p 708 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 P–35 P pro tem(pore) usage—avoid using if possible try—for the time being / temporarily / recasting (using interim arrangement / informal arrangement) extra information foreign phrase further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 927 Cambridge Style Guide p 613 Garner’s Dictionary p 709 provide [also provision] usage—consider alternatives before using try—give / supply / arrange for / make / is / no change extra information Prefer the simplest, appropriate alternative if appropriate. see also—as provided by; except as provided in/prescribed by; except as/where otherwise provided/indicated examples of no change 1 An Act to provide for … 2 an amount provided for in the budget 3 the estimated cost of providing public hospital services 4 provide funds for research and education 5 the provision of aged care services 6 The council may charge for services and facilities provided by it. 7 The authority must arrange for someone else to provide meat processing services. examples of change 1 In providing giving information or advice to the Minister, … 2 A board must provide give the Minister with a written report of its findings. 3 The advisory committee may provide give advice to [or advise] the Minister. 4 The committee must provide make regular reports to the Minister. 5 Bridge provides is a game of skill. 6 The authority provided supplied electricity to the town. further reading Cwlth OPC Plain English p 41 Partridge p 266 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 P–36 P provided (that) usage—consider alternatives before using try—however / if / only if / unless / providing / recasting / no change extra information 1 Do not use provided that to introduce a proviso. 2 Provided (that) can be a heavyweight way of prefacing a condition. Generally, prefer an alternative (eg if, however or only if) for this purpose. examples of change 1 He said he would send the draft out provided that only if it was settled first. 2 I expect to finish the first draft by tomorrow provided that if I do not have any interruptions. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 619 Garner’s Dictionary p 710 Garner’s Legal Style pp 53–4, 135 Gowers’ Plain Words p 104 Law Words 1995 pp 66–8 Longman English Usage pp 574–5 Partridge p 266 Right Words p 336 Working Words pp 428–9 provision see—make provision for provisions see—terms and provisions Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 P–37 P provisions of usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / recasting / no change extra information The phrase the provisions of is usually unnecessary unless it is used as a convenient label to describe a list of different provisions, so that it can be used again later in referring back to the same list of provisions. However, it can frequently be omitted even in these cases. example of no change The ship must comply with the following provisions of the standard:... examples of change 1 The provisions of section 5 apply Section 5 applies to ... 2 On the commencement of this section, the provisions of the management agreement apply applies as if … 3 tell the person, in general terms, of the provisions of about section 20 4 The other provisions of this This section do does not apply to … 5 If the case is not covered by the provisions of these rules, … further reading Cutts p 30 Cwlth OPC Plain English p 19 prox. usage—never use try—recasting (using next month or the name of next month, eg February) extra information 1 abbreviation of foreign phrase 2 commercialese 3 Prox. stands for proximo mense (‘next month’). further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 775 (ult.) Garner’s Dictionary p 859 (ult.) Gowers’ Plain Words p 16 Partridge p 367 (ult., prox., inst.) proximity see—in close proximity Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 P–38 P punctually usage—avoid using if possible try—recasting (requiring the obligation to be carried out by a particular date) extra information 1 Punctually means by the required date specified in the instrument concerned: Sperry Rand Australia Ltd v Arrandale Properties Pty Ltd [1979] VR 409 at 411, 415 per Lush J. 2 Use of punctually is usually unnecessary. If a written notice must be given, a payment made or an obligation carried out by a particular date, the provision should state this. purchase usage—consider alternatives before using try—buy / acquire / get / obtain / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. further reading Cutts p 30 Fowler’s English Usage pp 309 (formal words), 639 Garner’s Dictionary pp 370 (formal words), 719 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary pp 63–4 (buy/purchase) Partridge p 275 purchaser usage—consider alternatives before using try—buyer / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer buyer. see also—purchase further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 719 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 P–39 P purport [as a noun] usage—consider alternatives before using try—gist / substance / purpose / object / no change extra information formal word example of change The purport substance of the claim for an extension of time was … further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 256 purpose see—for the purpose/purposes of purpose is to usage—avoid using if possible try—omitting extra information padding purposefully see—purposely Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 P–40 P purposely usage—consider alternatives before using try—intentionally / purposefully / purposively / no change extra information 1 Purposely means done on purpose or intentionally. It is used to emphasise that something happened intentionally, and not just by accident. Its opposite is accidentally. 2 Purposefully means done for a particular purpose. It looks beyond the immediate situation, and sees the action as a step toward a preconceived goal. Its opposite is aimlessly. 3 Purposively means done to serve useful function, although not because of planning. It represents the idea that behaviour is always directed towards an end, and is not random. Unlike purposely and purposefully, it can be used of nonhuman and inanimate subjects. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 623 Garner’s Legal Style p 135 purposively see—purposely pursuance see—in pursuance of Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 P–41 P pursuant to usage—never use try—under / in accordance with / according to / for extra information 1 compound preposition 2 legalese example of change an approval given pursuant to under section 10 further reading Cutts p 30 Garner’s Dictionary pp 721, 896 Garner’s Legal Style pp 135, 184 Gowers’ Plain Words p 256 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 P–42 Q qua usage—never use try—as / in the capacity of / recasting (using, eg as such) extra information 1 foreign word 2 Use of qua may be obscure and irritating to those who do not understand what it means, or pretentious to those who do. examples of change 1 He was interested in money qua money for its own sake. 2 She attended the course qua as occupational health and safety officer. further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 624–5 Gowers’ Plain Words p 256 quadrate [as a verb] usage—never use try—conform /agree / adapt / recasting (using eg in accordance with / meets the requirements of) extra information formal, obscure word example of change The draft quadrates with meets our instructions. quantum usage—never use try—amount / share / portion extra information foreign phrase Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 Q–1 Q question [as a noun] usage—avoid using if possible try—subject / topic / issue / problem / matter / dispute / challenge / proposal / omitting extra information vague word see also—beg the question; call in question; in question; leading question; no question that/but that; question of whether/who/what/how etc further reading Cwlth OPC Plain English p 17 Gowers’ Plain Words p 256 question as to whether / who / what / how etc see—as to whether/who/what/how etc question of whether / who / what / how etc usage—never use try—omitting of extra information 1 verbosity 2 non-standard English further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 135 quite usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information 1 dogmatic word meaning completely, entirely or totally, eg ‘His conduct was quite outrageous’ 2 hedge word (compromiser) meaning rather, to a moderate degree or fairly, eg ‘She worked quite fast’ 3 vague word, however, the meaning is often clarified by the context further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 336 (hedge words) Fowler’s English usage pp 645–6 Garner’s Dictionary p 926 (weasel words) Garner’s Legal Style pp 192–3 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 Q–2 R rata see—pro rata rate see—flat rate rather usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information 1 hedge word (compromiser)—weasel word, eg ‘It was rather dark.’ 2 intensifier, eg ‘The car drove past rather fast.’ 3 vague word, however, the degree of downtoning or intensification is often clarified by the context. 4 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 336 (hedge words) Fowler’s English Usage pp 652–3 Garner’s Dictionary pp 124–5 (but rather), 926 (weasel words) Garner’s Legal Style p 192 re usage—never use try—omitting / about / regarding / on / concerning / recasting extra information 1 foreign word 2 re is an abbreviation of in re, which means in the matter of or in the case of. examples of change 1 Dear Ms Smith Re: Will of XYZ 2 Dear Mr Smith Re About your letter of 10 November, … [or Thank you for your letter of 10 November.] further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 548 (in re) Cambridge Style Guide p 640 Cutts p 35 Gowers’ Plain Words p 16 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 R–3 R reaction usage—consider alternatives before using try—opinion / view / impression / response / no change extra information The traditional meaning of reaction is an automatic response to something. example of change She gave a considered reaction response to the letter. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words pp 256–7 read see—is to be read real [also really] usage—consider alternatives before using try—true / genuine / actual / omitting / recasting / no change extra information 1 Real is often used unnecessarily. 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. see also—actually/actual; definitely/definite; realistic example of no change real estate examples of change 1 real genuine fears 2 real true facts [or facts] 3 the real problem further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 641–2 Fowler’s English Usage p 19 (actually) Gowers’ Plain Words pp 51–2 Partridge p 280 (real; really, actually and definitely) Working Words p 463 (real/realistic/really) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 R–4 R realistic usage—consider alternatives before using try—frank / feasible / likely / practical / probable / reasonable / sensible / workable / omitting / no change extra information 1 vogue, question-begging vague word 2 Prefer a more precise alternative if appropriate. examples of change 1 realistic reasonable offer 2 realistic workable solution 3 He spoke in realistic frank terms. 4 An increase in the shopping centre’s turnover is not realistic likely. 5 a realistic likeness further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 34 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 17, 257 Working Words p 463 (real/realistic/really) reappoint usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / recasting / no change extra information 1 can be a redundancy 2 It is usually unnecessary to deal with reappointment to an office (see LA, s 208 (1) (c) and dict, pt 1, def appoint). reason see—by reason; by reason only; for the reason that; the reason being that; the reason … is because reasonable usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information can be a weasel word further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 926 (weasel words—reasonable and all reasonable means) receipt see—in receipt of Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 R–5 R recognisance usage—avoid using if possible try—undertaking / agreement / promise / bail undertaking extra information 1 Recognisance is often used in criminal law, mainly in setting bail and sentencing. 2 Recognisance is not usually a technical term and can often be given a plain language alternative (if necessary after defining the alternative). further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 989 Law Words 1995 pp 69–72 recognition to see—give recognition to reduce to writing usage—never use try—put in writing / write down / record in writing extra information formal phrase reduction usage—consider alternatives before using try—cut / no change extra information a reduction cut in interest rates further reading Cutts p 30 Working Words p 154 (cut in) redundant usage—consider alternatives before using try—inappropriate / too much / excessive / unnecessary / no change extra information Do not use redundant if you mean inappropriate. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words pp 258–9 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 R–6 R refer back to usage—never use try—refer to / mention extra information redundancy further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 136 referred to usage—consider alternatives before using try—mentioned / set out / stated / specified / recasting / no change extra information 1 Prefer mention if appropriate. 2 Be careful not to draw artificial distinctions in provisions to mean essentially the same thing, eg do not say in one provision ‘a person mentioned in section X’, and then in another provision say ‘a thing referred to in section Y’, if the person or thing is only being identified by the reference. 3 See state for a discussion of the use of mention, set out and state. example of no change It must be referred to the authority for certification. examples of change 1 a representation referred to mentioned in paragraph (x) 2 for a licensee to whom mentioned in paragraph (a) refers 3 an exemption to which mentioned in paragraph (a) refers 4 operators referred to mentioned in paragraph (a) 5 the number of units referred to stated in the schedule 6 the map referred to set out in the schedule Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 R–7 R reference usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting / no change extra information 1 Generally use a quotes form of definition rather than a referential form of definition. 2 If a referential definition is used, use the short form (see example 1, examples of change). see also—make reference to; with reference to examples of no change 1 A guideline may incorporate a standard by reference. 2 A marine incident may be the subject of a reference by the Minister. examples of change 1 A reference to X is to be read as not including a reference to Y. X does not include Y. 2 a report about the operation of this Act, with particular reference mentioning particularly further reading Cwlth OPC Plain English p 33 Drafting Practice Guide refrain (from) usage—avoid using if possible try—recasting (using, eg do not) extra information formal word example of change Please refrain from smoking do not smoke in this building. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 259 refurbish usage—consider alternatives before using try—refurnish / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Both refurbish and refurnish deal with renovating. 3 Refurnish means renovating by buying furnishings. 4 Refurbish means renovating by fixing up or otherwise making do with what you already have. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 648 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 R–8 R refurnish see—refurbish refuse [as a verb] usage—consider alternatives before using try—fail / decline / deny / omitting / recasting (using, eg does not or contravene) / no change extra information 1 It is usually unnecessary to deal with a person refusing to do something. 2 See LA, dict, pt 1, defs breach, contravene and fail. see also—decide to grant/refuse example of change If the Minister refuses or fails to does not grant a licence, … refute usage—consider alternatives before using try—contradict / deny / rebut / repudiate / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Refute has traditionally meant the use of proof to deny a charge or claim. Its use to mean simply deny has been criticised. 3 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. example of change The company refuted denied claims that the release of oil from the tanker was negligent. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 648 Fowler’s English Usage pp 662–3 Garner’s Legal Style p 136 Gowers’ Plain Words p 259 regard see—as regards; in regard to; regarded as; regarded as being; regarding; with regard to Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 R–9 R regarded as usage—consider alternatives before using try—taken to be / no change extra information Prefer taken to be if appropriate. example of no change She is regarded as the best drafter in the office. examples of change 1 The nominal defendant is to be regarded as taken to be a licensed insurer. 2 A restored vehicle is regarded as having taken to have been built when it was originally built and not when it was restored. regarded as being usage—avoid using if possible try—regarded as extra information verbosity example of change She is regarded as being the best drafter in the office. further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 136 Strunk and White p 41 (being) regarding [as a preposition] usage—consider alternatives before using try—about / in relation to / recasting / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative. further reading Cutts pp 30, 31 Fowler’s English Usage p 663 (regard) Garner’s Legal Style p 48 (as acceptable dangler) Gowers’ Plain Words p 18 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 R–10 R regardless whether usage—never use try—regardless of whether extra information non-standard English further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 747 regards see—as regards regretful see—regretfully regretfully usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using eg I regret to say / regrettably / no change extra information 1 Regretfully traditionally meant with regret or in a regretful way. Like hopefully, its meaning has been extended. Regretfully is now used to express the regret of the person using it. This extended use is subject to the same criticisms that have been made of hopefully and can give rise to ambiguity. 2 See hopefully for more information. 3 Regretful properly means feeling or showing regret, and regrettable means causing regret. Errors are regrettable; those who have committed them are regretful. 4 Regrettably and regretfully both involve regret. Both should be used only in senses corresponding to the correct uses of the adjectives regretful and regrettable that is, with regret or sadly, and unfortunately. However, both are now commonly used as sentence adverbs (ie an adverb that qualifies the sentence as a whole). In regretfully, the feeling of regret is more straightforwardly expressed by the writer or is attributed directly by the writer to someone else. Regrettably is more abstract and implies that regret is called for by a situation. The writer puts the writer’s evaluation of the situation as calling for regret and invites the reader to endorse the evaluation. However, the writer does not directly express a feeling of regret or attribute the feeling directly to someone else. Regrettably can, therefore, be used for a more impersonal style of writing. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 648 (regrettably and regretfully) Fowler’s English Usage pp 664 (regretful, regrettable), 702–3 (sentence adverbs) Garner’s Dictionary pp 748–9 (regretful; regrettable), 791-2 (sentence adverbs) Garner’s Legal Style pp 136–7 Working Words p 468 (regretfully/regrettably) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 R–11 R regrettable see—regretfully reimburse usage—consider alternatives before using try—repay / pay back / refund / pay / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. example of no change The employer must reimburse the employee for the employee’s expenses. examples of change 1 The beneficiary must reimburse repay the amount of the overpayment. 2 The authority must reimburse refund any overpayments. 3 A care provider must reimburse pay a care recipient the full amount of any unrefunded accommodation bond balance. further reading Cutts p 30 Gowers’ Plain Words p 259 relating to usage—consider alternatives before using try—about / for / in / of / over / to / with / in relation to / recasting / no change extra information 1 compound preposition 2 Prefer a simple preposition if appropriate. If it is necessary to use a connecting phrase, prefer in relation to if appropriate (see in relation to). examples of no change 1 threatening processes relating to wildlife 2 anything else relating to local government declared by regulation examples of change 1 an Act relating to about the functions of the Attorney-General 2 An award may require information about relating to the next crushing season. 3 An Act to consolidate and amend the law relating to for the management and development of racecourse x 4 the person holds a current licence relating to for the vehicle Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 R–12 R relation see—in relation to; to and/or in relation to relatively usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / fairly / rather / no change extra information 1 Relatively can only properly be used if something has been mentioned or implied giving a standard of comparison. If there is no standard of comparison, the use of relatively is meaningless. Its use is only a shrinking from the nakedness of an unqualified statement (Gowers). It is a weasel word. 2 Relatively should not be used to mean fairly or rather. example of no change The stock can be expanded in a relatively short time. example of change About 100 people were taken to hospital but relatively few were detained. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 50 Working Words p 124 relevant usage—consider alternatives before using try—concerned / appropriate / omitting / recasting / no change extra information Relevant is sometimes used as a tagged term, eg the relevant employee. However, more meaningful tagged terms should be preferred, eg the dismissed employee. examples of no change 1 the date and, if relevant, time of the sale 2 allowing a general safety obligation to be discharged by complying with relevant standards 3 as soon as practicable after the relevant facts come to the member’s knowledge examples of change 1 from the beginning of the relevant financial year concerned 2 the period for which the relevant rate notice is issued Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 R–13 R relict usage—never use try—surviving spouse / spouse / domestic partner extra information archaism example of change if a pensioner dies leaving a relict spouse further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 666 Garner’s Dictionary p 750 relieve and discharge usage—never use try—discharge / recasting extra information doublet remainder usage—consider alternatives before using try—rest / no change extra information formal word further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 370 (formal words) remittance usage—avoid using if possible try—payment / amount / money extra information formal word further reading Cutts p 30 Gowers’ Plain Words p 259 remove usage—consider alternatives before using try—take away / take off / put out / move / no change extra information formal word further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 370 (formal words), 755 (remove; removal) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 R–14 R remuneration usage—consider alternatives before using try—pay / wages / salary / salary and allowances / income / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. example of no change remuneration package example of change An overpayment may be recovered by deduction from a member’s remuneration salary. further reading Cutts p 30 Howard’s Guide pp 306-7 (pay, salary, wages, remuneration, stipend or emoluments) render usage—consider alternatives before using try—make / give / do / send / carry out / perform / show / omitting / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. example of no change The plasterers rendered the wall. examples of change 1 if road works on a State-controlled road are rendered necessary 2 requisition the ships that the captain considers best able to render assistance help 3 The so-called improvements rendered made the machine slower. further reading Cutts p 30 Gowers’ Plain Words p 259 repeat again usage—consider alternatives before using try—repeat / no change extra information Unless repeat for a second time (ie do a third time) is meant, again is redundant. further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 137 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 R–15 R repetitious usage—consider alternatives before using try—repetitive / no change extra information 1 Both repetitious and repetitive deal with repetition. 2 Repetitious implies that the effects of the repetition are negative. 3 Repetitive is a more neutral word that only acknowledges the physical fact of repetition. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 654 repetitive see—repetitious replace see—substitute represent usage—consider alternatives before using try—show / be / act for / stand for / is / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. example of no change A Senator for a State represents all the people of the State. example of change The light green areas on the map represent are forests. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 260 represents [in a formula] usage—never use try—means extra information Define terms used in a formula in the same way as other terms are defined. example of change A represents means the allocated amount. Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 R–16 R request usage—consider alternatives before using try—ask / require / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. 3 However, request can be treated as the noun form of ask. examples of no change 1 The corporation must comply with the request. 2 on the written request of the clerk example of change The Minister may request ask the corporation to reconsider the plan. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 370 (formal words) require usage—consider alternatives before using try—ask / impose / need / want / no change extra information 1 Require is useful to indicate a formal, obligatory demand. 2 Require should not be used in the sense of need or want (see example 3, examples of change). see also—as the case may be/requires; as the case may require; is/are not required to; is/are required to examples of no change 1 Control in pilotage areas is achieved by requiring certain ships to use a pilot. 2 A regulation may require additional information to be provided to the authority. examples of change 1 the duties of a pilot’s employer to develop and maintain the skills required needed by the pilot 2 The approval is not required to need not be applied for. 3 Do you require need a pen? 4 The authority may, by written notice, require ask the applicant for additional information necessary to consider the application properly. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 260 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 R–17 R requirements of usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / no change extra information can be a redundancy examples of change 1 maintained in accordance with the requirements of chapter 10 2 The committee must compare the provision of the care with the requirements of the standards. see also—meets the requirements of requisite see—prerequisite rescind [also rescission] usage—consider alternatives before using try—revoke / repeal / cancel / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer repeal for legislative instruments and revoke for non-legislative instruments. 3 Rescission has a technical meaning in contract law. 4 See LA, dict, pt 1, def repeal. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 1016 Garner’s Dictionary p 761 (rescission; recision; recission; rescision) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 R–18 R residence [also residential] usage—consider alternatives before using try—home / address / recasting (using, eg place where the person lives / usually lives / resides) / no change extra information 1 formal pretentious word for home or house 2 Also, term with legal connotations in some contexts. 3 If possible, avoid place of residence. 4 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. examples of no change 1 The taxpayer’s place of residence is relevant in deciding liability to taxation. 2 Please state your residential address. examples of change 1 He has a large residence house. 2 What is your place of residence? Where do you live? 3 An employee is entitled to the reasonable cost of travelling from and to the employee’s place of residence place where the employee lives. 4 The notice may be served on the vehicle’s owner by posting it to the owner at his or her place of residence or business residential or business address lastknown to the person serving the notice. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 1018 Cutts p 30 New Oxford Dicitonary p 1578 Partridge p 286 (reside and live; residence and house) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 R–19 R reside usage—consider alternatives before using try—live / recasting / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 To reside is to live permanently or for some time at a particular place. 3 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. see also—place of residence examples of change 1 Most of the people who work in Civic reside live elsewhere. 2 Please state the names of your children who are residing living with you. 3 An officer is entitled to an allowance for a child who ordinarily resides lives with the officer. 4 The power to issue a licence resides with the Minister. The Minister may issue a licence. further reading Cutts p 30 New Oxford Dictionary p 1578 Partridge p 286 (reside and live; residence and house) Working Words p 472 residue see—rest, residue and remainder respect see—in a particular respect; in respect of/to; respecting; to and/or in respect of; with respect to respectfully see—it is (respectfully) suggested that respecting [as a preposition] usage—avoid using if possible try—about / in relation to / recasting extra information formal word further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 671 (respect) Garner’s Legal Style p 49 (as acceptable dangler) Gowers’ Plain Words p 18 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 R–20 R respective(ly) usage—avoid using if possible try—omitting / recasting extra information 1 Respective has the role of alerting the reader to the need to match up items in 2 separate series, eg 2 or more subjects with 2 or more verbs. However, respective is often used unnecessarily, because it is usually clear from the context that the provision is to be read distributively between multiple items and the items appropriately matched (see example 1, examples of change). If necessary, clarify the relationship between the items by recasting (see example 2, examples of change). 2 Respective is also used in a general distributive sense. It can always be omitted in these contexts. If necessary, improve the provisions by recasting (see example 3, examples of change). examples of change 1 The rates of salary, general allowance and jurisprudential expenses payable to the Chief Judge, Senior Judge and other judges of the District Courts are those respectively the rates fixed by the tribunal. 2 W, X, Y and Z are respectively the Office’s fire wardens, sector warden and assistant fire wardens. W is the office’s fire warden, Y is the sector warden, and Y and Z are assistant fire wardens. 3 Local governments are responsible for weed control in their respective areas. A local government is responsible for weed control in its area. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 657 (respectfully or respectively) Fowler’s English Usage pp 671–2 Garner’s Legal Style pp 137–8 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 52–3 Strunk and White p 57 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 R–21 R responsibility usage—consider alternatives before using try—function / duty / recasting (using must) / no change extra information 1 It is unnecessary to use responsibility and duty. 2 Prefer function to duty unless an obligation is to be imposed. 3 See LA, dict, pt 1, def function. see also—has/have a responsibility to examples of no change 1 adequate to allow a local government to accept autonomous responsibility 2 The order transfers responsibility for the harbours from the harbours corporation to the ports corporation. 3 The captain of a ship is not relieved from responsibility for the ship’s operation … 4 the degree of the repairer’s responsibility for the accident examples of change 1 advise on the exercise of the commissioner’s statutory responsibilities functions 2 have a responsibility to must further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 260 rest, residue and remainder usage—never use try—all other property / all remaining property / all the rest of the property / the balance of the property / all property left over / rest / balance / residuary estate (in a will) extra information 1 triplet 2 The phrase rest, residue and remainder is sometimes used in wills to leave a person the part of the testator’s property left after paying debts and giving gifts. However, the phrase is tautological. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 765 Law Words 1995 pp 73–6 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 R–22 R result usage—consider alternatives before using try—outcome / consequence / effect / recasting (using because) / no change see also—as a/the result of; with the result that examples of no change 1 changes that will result in a more effective and efficient maritime industry 2 to encourage the speedy settlement of claims resulting from motor vehicle accidents 3 reduce the incidence of motor vehicle accidents and minimise the results examples of change 1 resulting from because of the decision 2 The inspector must report the results outcome of the investigation to the chief executive. retain usage—consider alternatives before using try—keep / engage / employ / recasting (using continue to) / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. examples of change 1 The board may retain keep a document produced at an inquiry. 2 The board may retain continue to use its rules. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 370 (formal words) revenue enhancement usage—avoid using if possible try—tax increase extra information euphemism further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 35 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 R–23 R revoke usage—consider alternatives before using try—repeal / cancel / no change extra information 1 Prefer repeal for Acts and subordinate laws and revoke for non-legislative instruments. 2 Revoke and cancel can both mean to put an end to something. Cancel originally pointed specifically to the crossing out of something, eg cancelling an entry by drawing a line through it. It is also particularly apt to deal with the physical marking or alteration of something to render it invalid for further use, eg cancelling a postage stamp by overmarking it, cancelling a cheque by writing cancelled across it or cancelling a bus ticket by perforating it. It is, therefore, the appropriate word to use for bringing instruments to an end in a way that involves (or usually involves) physical marking or alteration, eg cancelling a licence. For bringing instruments to an end in other ways or for bringing rights not necessarily embodied in an instrument to an end, prefer revoke if appropriate, eg revoke an appointment, approval, decision, decree, exemption, permission, promise or right of access. 3 See LA, dict, pt 1, def repeal. example of no change 1 An appointment continues until the new council revokes it 2 The authority may revoke an exemption given to a person if... further reading Funk p 125 Garner’s Dictionary p 771 (revoke; retract) Use the Right Word pp 190-1 (erase, cancel, etc) and (void, cancel, repeal, rescind, revoke etc) rewarding [as an adjective] usage—consider alternatives before using try—gratifying / satisfying / valuable / no change extra information 1 overused word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 261 right, title and interest usage—never use try—interest / recasting extra information triplet further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 188 Law Words 1995 pp 77–9 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 R–24 S sadly / sad usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using ‘neutral’ words) / no change extra information 1 Sadly is a sentence adverb (ie an adverb that qualifies the sentence as a whole). 2 Sadly and sad are value-loaded words. 3 Prefer a more ‘neutral’ alternative if appropriate. further reading Fowler’s English Usage pp 702–3 (sentence adverbs) Garner’s Dictionary pp 791–2 (sentence adverbs) said [as an adjective] usage—never use try—the / this / that / those / recasting (using another ‘pointing’ word or a defined term) / omitting extra information 1 archaism 2 legalese see also—aforesaid; it might be said that example of change the said car further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 672 Fowler’s English Usage p 685 Dick pp 141–2 Garner’s Dictionary pp 366 (forbidden words and phrases—A. generally useless words and phrases), 778-9 Garner’s Legal Style pp 138, 182 Gowers’ Plain Words p 261 Law Words 1995 pp 80–2 Longman English Usage p 630 Partridge pp 293 (said, the), 358 (the said) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 S–1 S same [as a pronoun] usage—avoid using if possible try—he / she / him / her / it / they / them / recasting (using, eg the noun itself) extra information 1 commercialese 2 legalese 3 Same should not be used as a word to refer to provisions, Acts, legislative instruments or other instruments. 4 If possible, avoid the substitution of gender-specific personal pronouns (see he; she). examples of change 1 Give same it to the buyer. 2 The registrar refused to file same it. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 672 Fowler’s English Usage pp 686–7 Dick pp 143–4 Garner’s Dictionary pp 366 (forbidden words and phrases—A. generally useless words and phrases), 780 Garner’s Legal Style pp 138–9 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 16, 117–8 Longman English Usage p 631 Partridge p 294 sanction [as a verb] usage—consider alternatives before using try—approve / permit / allow / authorise / recasting (using may) / impose a penalty / penalise / confirm / no change extra information 1 formal word that can be ambiguous 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. example of change The Minister must sanction approve the transfer. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 688 Garner’s Dictionary p 780 Garner’s Legal Style p 139 Right Words pp 361–2 Working Words p 482 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 S–2 S sans usage—avoid using if possible try—without extra information foreign word example of no change sans serif type example of change sans without advertisements further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 689 Garner’s Dictionary p 781 Longman English Usage p 631 Working Words p 482 satisfy usage—consider alternatives before using try—comply with / complete / fill in / carry out / perform / fulfil / answer / meet / convince / make certain / no change extra information 1 vague word 2 Prefer a more precise alternative if appropriate. see also—pay, satisfy and discharge example of no change if the chief executive is satisfied examples of change 1 The notice may specify how it must be satisfied complied with. 2 An applicant must satisfy meet the requirements of the section. [or comply with the section] further reading Longman English Usage p 632 (satisfied, happy) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 S–3 S save [as preposition or conjunction] usage—never use try—except (for) / but / other than / subject to / unless / recasting extra information archaism examples of change 1 save as prescribed by except for … 2 All the plaintiff’s claims, save except the claims based on contract, have been accepted. further reading Cutts p 30 Fowler’s English Usage p 692 Garner’s Dictionary p 781 Hudson p 35 (archaism) Longman English Usage p 632 Partridge p 294 save and except usage—never use try—except / other than / subject to / unless / recasting extra information 1 doublet 2 archaism further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 293 (doublets, triplets and synonym-strings), 782 Gowers’ Plain Words p 60 scarcely … than usage—never use try—scarcely … when / scarcely … before / recasting extra information 1 Because scarcely is not a true comparative, the use of scarcely with than in comparative structures has been criticised. Since there is usually little to be gained by using than with scarcely, an alternative should be used. 2 Because scarcely means ‘almost not’, it should not be used with another negative. example of change He had scarcely just opened the door than when the telephone rang. further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 329 (hard or hardly), 677 (scarcely), 746 (than) Fowler’s English Usage pp 693 (scarcely), 770 (than) Gowers’ Plain Words p 231 (hard, hardly) Longman English Usage p 332 (hardly, barely, scarcely) Partridge p 144 (hardly….than) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 S–4 S scenario usage—consider alternatives before using try—scheme / plan / program / outline / prediction / possible state of affairs / idea / development / no change extra information 1 vogue word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 919 (vogue words) Garner’s Legal Style p 34 (worst-case scenario) Gowers’ Plain Words p 261 Longman English Usage pp 633–4 Partridge p 379 (vogue words) sealed see—signed, sealed and delivered seasonable usage—consider alternatives before using try—seasonal / no change extra information Seasonable means in keeping with the season. It affirms that what is described is right for the time of the year and is to be expected then. By contrast, seasonal means changing with, depending on, or associated with, the season. It reflects the periodic character of the seasons and is a neutral word. examples of no change 1 Hot weather is seasonable in Canberra for January. 2 Grape picking is seasonal work. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 679 Fowler’s English Usage p 697 Garner’s Dictionary p 785 Garner’s Legal Style p 139 Gowers’ Plain Words p 261 Longman English Usage p 636 Partridge p 296 seasonal see—seasonable Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 S–5 S secondly usage—never use try—second further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 280 Longman English Usage p 280 (firstly) Working Words p 225 seems usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / recasting / no change extra information weasel word see also—it seems further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 787 semble usage—avoid using if possible try—it seems / omitting extra information legalese example of change …but, semble, the point may still be arguable. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 790 senior … than usage—never use try—senior … to / recasting extra information Because senior is not a true comparative, the use of senior with than in comparative structures has been criticised. (The same criticism applies to junior … than.) Since there is little to be gained by using than with senior, senior … to or recasting should be used. see also—hardly … than; scarcely … than; superior … than further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 746 (than) Fowler’s English Usage p 770 (than) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 S–6 S sense see—my sense is that sensual usage—consider alternatives before using try—sensuous / no change extra information Depending on the context, sensual can be a value loaded word, hinting at lust and gratification of physical senses and appetites (including sexual ones). further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 682 Fowler’s English Usage p 701 Garner’s Dictionary p 791 Garner’s Legal Style p 139 Longman English Usage p 640 Partridge p 299 (sensual, sensuous, sensory) separate and apart usage—avoid using if possible try—separate / apart extra information doublet further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 292–4 (doublets, triplets and synonym-strings), 794 separate and distinct usage—avoid using if possible try—separate / distinct extra information doublet further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 292–4 (doublets, triplets and synonym-strings), 794 sequential order usage—never use try—in order / in sequence / sequentially / recasting extra information redundancy example of change The books were arranged in sequential order by accession date. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 795 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 S–7 S seriatim usage—never use try—in a series / in turn / one after another / in sequence / successively / serially / one at a time / in the same order extra information foreign word example of change The claims were dealt with seriatim one after another. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 796 Partridge p 299 servant usage—consider alternatives before using try—employee / no change extra information 1 Dated word with negative overtones in some contexts. 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. example of no change public servant example of change servant employee or agent further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 312 (employer and employee; master and servant), 550 (master) Longman English Usage pp 674–5 (staff) service [as a verb] usage—consider alternatives before using try—serve / satisfy / no change extra information Prefer an alternative if appropriate. examples of no change 1 The mechanic serviced the car. 2 The rent serviced the loan. example of change A branch is to be established to service serve the needs of the town. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 704 Garner’s Dictionary p 796 Gowers’ Plain Words p 28 Longman English Usage p 643 Partridge p 299 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 S–8 S serviceable usage—consider alternatives before using try—useful / durable / wearing well / in working order / working (well) / no change extra information Prefer an alternative if appropriate. example of change The operator must ensure that the aircraft’s emergency systems are serviceable in working order. servitude usage—avoid using if possible try—recasting (using, eg easement / land subject to an easement / land benefited by an easement / imprisonment) extra information 1 formal word 2 Technical legal word with simpler alternatives. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 1071 Garner’s Dictionary p 797 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary pp 186–9 (easement/servitude) set out usage—consider alternatives before using try—state / include / mention / required by / specify / explain / arrange / omitting / recasting / no change extra information 1 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. 2 For the use of state, mention and set out, see state. examples of no change 1 The approved standard must be set out in the regulation. 2 the map set out in the schedule [or omit ‘set out’] examples of change 1 the corporation’s progress in achieving financial and other performance targets set out stated in its current operational plan 2 The application must set out state the grounds on which the warrant is sought. 3 The document does not set out include a statement of reasons for the decision. 4 the markings set out in required by chapter 6 5 the markings set out mentioned in chapter 4 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 S–9 S several usage—consider alternatives before using try—separate / different / respective / individual / various / some / omitting / no change extra information 1 legalese 2 becoming archaism in many contexts 3 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. 4 By contrast with a few, several (for a number) cannot be qualified with quite or only. see also—jointly and severally example of no change Several spectators left the game early in disgust. examples of change 1 They went their several different ways. 2 He called on 3 several separate occasions. [or He called 3 times.] 3 She outlined the several steps in the process. further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 275–6 (few or a few) Fowler’s English Usage p 705 Garner’s Dictionary p 799 Right Words p 367 shall usage—never use (in legislation) avoid using if possible (elsewhere) try—must / will / recasting extra information Traditionally, shall is used for the first person, simple future tense (eg ‘I/We shall go to town tomorrow’), and will is used for the second or third person simple future tense (eg ‘You/he/they will go to town tomorrow’). Avoid the use of shall or will in the first person simple future tense in legislation by recasting. Elsewhere, if possible, avoid the use of shall by using must or will or recasting. further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 687–8 (shall or will) Cutts pp 30, 36-7 Cwlth OPC Plain English p 20 Fowler’s English Usage pp 706–7 (shall and will) Garner’s Dictionary pp 830–1 (statute drafting), 939–42 (words of authority) Garner’s Legal Style p 139 (shall; will) Gowers’ Plain Words pp 141–2 (shall and will) Longman English Usage p 646 (shall, will) NZ Legislation Manual p 43 Partridge pp 300–2 (shall and will) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 S–10 S she usage—avoid using if possible try—recasting (avoiding gender-specific personal pronouns) extra information 1 Avoid personal pronouns in the masculine or feminine form as far as possible. If it is necessary to use a personal pronoun, both masculine and feminine forms should be used, eg he or she. The neuter form need not be used (see LA, s 145 (a)). 2 The use of he or she occasionally in a document is appropriate, but it makes the text laboured and cumbersome if used repeatedly. It also gives rise to unnecessary argument, eg whether she should be used before he and, if so, how often. Usually it is convenient (and often clearer) to repeat the relevant noun, eg the applicant, the judge, the authorised person. He or she should, therefore, be used only where it is idiomatically required. 3 If a provision applies only to the neuter form (eg to a corporation), a personal pronoun in the neuter form only (eg ‘it’) may be used wherever appropriate. 4 They can be used to avoid personal pronouns in the masculine and feminine forms. It works well if the sentence is written in the plural. However, this kind of sentence is usually not suitable for legal drafting. 5 The use of the pronoun they (or their) to refer to a singular subject is now increasing, eg ‘If a person wishes to apply for a licence, they must complete a driving test’. However, the use of they (or their) is still contentious and it should only be used as a last resort. 6 In some situations you can be substituted. It creates a style that addresses the reader much more directly. However, it should be clear to the reader who you is. This approach is still a fairly novel one for legislation and needs to be used with caution. further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 331–3 (he and/or she) Cwlth OPC Plain English p 18 Corporations Law Simplification Task Force paper on singular use of they Fowler’s English Usage p 358 (he or she) Garner’s Dictionary pp 799–803 (sexism) Garner’s Legal Style pp 45, 200–3 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 118–19 (they for he or she) New Oxford Dictionary pp 844-5 (he), 1711 Right Words p 154 (the female critique) Working Words pp 184 (discriminatory language), 245 (he/she) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 S–11 S short supply see—in short supply should usage—consider alternatives before using try—must / would / no change extra information 1 Use must if a duty is to be imposed (see LA, s 146 (Meaning of must and may). 2 Should may be used in legislation only in provisions that are not intended to have substantive legal effect, eg objects clauses. In a provision of this kind, should can be useful to make it clear that the provision is not intended to impose a legally enforceable duty, eg that the provision is intended to be directory. 3 Should can be used to express an assumption about what is likely, eg ‘The draft should be ready by tomorrow’. Should is also used in subordinate clauses to express a judgment, plan, reaction or wish, eg ‘The meeting agreed that the committee should start work immediately’. 4 By contrast, would is now the usual way to express the hypothetical future, eg ‘I said that I would have the draft ready tomorrow’. In particular, there is no longer any rule requiring the use of should in the first person. Would is also used to express a willingness or preference, eg ‘I would like to come’. example of no change The committee must make recommendations to the chief executive about the sanctions the chief executive should consider. further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 691–3 (should or would) Cutts p 37 Fowler’s English Usage p 711 (should and would) Garner’s Dictionary pp 805, 942 (words of authority) Gowers’ Plain Words p 143 Longman English Usage p 649 (should, would) Partridge pp 397–8 (would and should) Right Words p 370 (should/would) Working Words p 491 (should/would) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 S–12 S show cause usage—avoid using if possible try—recasting (using, eg give reasons / make representations) extra information 1 legalese 2 Show cause means to give a legally satisfactory reason why action should (or should not) be taken. 3 If possible, use an alternative. example of change 1 The defendant must show cause give a satisfactory reason why summary judgment should not be entered for the plaintiff. 2 The registrar may take disciplinary action against a person only if the person has been given a reasonable opportunity to show cause give reasons why the disciplinary action should not be taken. [Note The ‘reasonable opportunity’ should be fully spelt out in the legislation.] further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 1082 (show cause) and (show cause notice) Garner’s Dictionary pp 805-6 New Oxford Dictionary p 1724 (show) sibling usage—consider alternatives before using try—brother(s) / sister(s) / brother(s) and sister(s) / recasting (using a defined term) / child / kin / no change extra information Prefer a less formal word if appropriate. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 712 Garner’s Dictionary p 806 Gowers’ Plain Words p 261 Longman English Usage p 651 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 S–13 S [sic] usage—avoid using if possible try—recasting extra information 1 foreign word 2 Sic should be used only to indicate that a quote is reproduced as it appeared in the original document. It should be used selectively, and never as a snide form of criticism. 3 It is usually better to quote without editorial interpolation, even if the quoted material contains an obvious error. The use of sic can excessively highlight the error, and can trivialise the quote or impliedly criticise its author. 4 It is often more sensible to avoid erroneous words and phrases by paraphrasing or ellipsis. Errors can also be pointed out using less obtrusive techniques, eg an appropriately worded footnote. further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 694 Cutts p 39 Fowler’s English Usage p 712 Garner’s Dictionary pp 806–7 Longman English Usage p 651 Partridge p 302 Right Words p 370 Working Words p 492 signed, sealed and delivered usage—avoid using if possible try—recasting extra information 1 triplet 2 Signed, sealed and delivered does not have a completely clear legal meaning. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 808 Law Words 1995 pp 83–5 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 S–14 S significant usage—consider alternatives before using try—important / considerable / substantial / recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information 1 vague, weasel word 2 Prefer a more precise alternative if appropriate further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 572 (weasel words) Garner’s Legal Style p 32 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 261–2 simple / simply usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / recasting (using more ‘neutral’ words) / no change extra information 1 The use of simple or simply can be depreciative or dogmatic. 2 Prefer a more ‘neutral’ alternative if appropriate. examples of no change 1 fee simple 2 simple interest example of change The existence of native title is simply not relevant in this case. further reading Garner’s Legal Style pp 36–7 simpliciter usage—never use try—simply / taken alone / taken by itself / summarily / unconditionally / absolutely / on its own extra information foreign word further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 366 (forbidden words and phrases—A. generally useless words and phrases), 809 Garner’s Legal Style p 186 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 S–15 S simplistic usage—consider alternatives before using try—simple / no change extra information 1 Simplistic means excessively simple. 2 Since simplistic itself contains the idea of ‘too much’, do not use over simplistic. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 695 (simple or simplistic) Fowler’s English Usage p 714 Garner’s Dictionary pp 809–10 Hudson p 305 (ploddery (simplistic for simple)) Longman English Usage p 653 Partridge p 305 sine die usage—never use try—indefinitely / without fixing a day extra information foreign phrase example of change The court adjourned the hearing sine die indefinitely. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 1084 Cambridge Style Guide p 696 Cutts p 39 Fowler’s English Usage p 714 Garner’s Dictionary p 810 Longman English Usage p 654 Partridge p 306 Working Words p 493 sine qua non usage—never use try—recasting (using essential / indispensable / necessary / necessity) extra information foreign phrase example of change It was a sine qua non an essential part of our agreement that you would meet all out-of-pocket expenses. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 1084 Cambridge Style Guide p 696 Fowler’s English Usage p 714 Garner’s Dictionary p 810 Longman English Usage p 654 Partridge p 306 Working Words p 493 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 S–16 S singular see—all and singular situate usage—never use try—situated / it is / omitting / recasting extra information archaism example of change I give all my property, wherever situate it is, to … [or omit ‘, wherever situate,’] further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 716 Garner’s Dictionary p 811 Longman English Usage p 655 Partridge p 306 situation usage—consider alternatives before using try—location / position / condition / plight / state of affairs / omitting / recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information 1 vague, vogue word 2 can lead to woolly writing 3 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. examples of change 1 The situation location of the photocopier is unsuitable. 2 The parties are in a conflict situation. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 716 Garner’s Dictionary p 811 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 4, 190, 253–4 Longman English Usage pp 655–6 Partridge pp 4 (abstract nouns—situation), 369 (vogue words) Right Words p 372 Working Words pp 494–5 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 S–17 S so usage—consider alternatives before using try—as / very / much / therefore / recasting / no change extra information 1 So can be useful to refer back to lengthy or complex concepts (see example 2, examples of no change). However, it should be used sparingly for this purpose and care should be taken to avoid possible ambiguity or momentary uncertainty. 2 Because so has a number of meanings, care needs to be taken to avoid ambiguity in other contexts. see also—as/so far as … is/are concerned; as/so long as; at least as/so far as is/are concerned; in so much as examples of no change 1 If a traffic sign is installed at or near a place so that a person parking at the place is likely to see the sign, … 2 (1) An employer must not reduce an employee’s remuneration because an application has been made under this division. (2) If an employer purports to do so, the reduction is ineffective. examples of change 1 unless the person has a reasonable excuse for doing so 2 it is to be read so that it authorises taken to authorise 3 while the vehicle is being driven so as far as is necessary to obtain a permit 4 He cannot write so very well. further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 701–2 Fowler’s English Usage pp 720–2 Garner’s Dictionary pp 813–14 Longman English Usage pp 659–60 Partridge p 312 sole and exclusive usage—never use try—exclusive / only / recasting extra information doublet further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 294 (doublets, triplets and synonym-strings), 816 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 S–18 S some see—in some instances; somewhat somewhat usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information 1 hedge word (diminisher)—weasel word 2 vague word 3 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 336 (hedge words) Garner’s Dictionary pp 817, 926 (weasel words) Garner’s Legal Style p 192 soon see—as soon as is possible/practicable; as soon as possible; as soon as practicable; as soon as reasonably possible/practicable sort of usage—avoid using if possible try—omitting / recasting (using more precise words) / kind of / somewhat / rather extra information 1 Do not use sort of as a hedge word (diminisher)—weasel word or a fudge word, eg ‘It was sort of cold’. 2 Do not use sort of with the plural, eg ‘those or these sort of things’. 3 can be non-standard English further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 427 (kind of) Fowler’s English Usage p 728 (sort) Garner’s Dictionary p 818 Garner’s Legal Style p 123 (kind of; sort of) Gowers’ Plain Words p 134 (these kinds of things) Longman English Usage p 398 (kind, sort) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 S–19 S southerly (direction) / southwardly / southward(s) see—easterly (direction)/eastwardly/eastwards spearhead [as a verb] usage—avoid using if possible try—head / lead / direct extra information vogue word example of change She was appointed to spearhead head our quality program. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 262 Longman English Usage p 665 specific usage—consider alternatives before using try—particular / omitting / no change extra information Specific is occasionally used unnecessarily in writing, particularly for emphasis. example of change This specific section deals with … further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 54 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 S–20 S specify usage—consider alternatives before using try—mention / state / name / nominate / set out / omitting / recasting / no change extra information 1 Be careful not to draw artificial distinctions in legislation by using different words to say essentially the same thing, eg do not say in one provision ‘a person mentioned in section X’, and then in another provision say ‘a (thing) specified in section Y’, if the person or thing is only being identified by the reference. 2 Take particular care in legislation not to draw unnecessary distinctions in provisions between state and specify as this can create an artificially complex structure. 3 Prefer mention or state if appropriate. For the use of mention, state and set out, see state. examples of change 1 a standard specified mentioned in paragraph (a) 2 an offence provision specified mentioned in schedule 2, column 2 3 a test specified in required by chapter 4 4 someone else specified nominated by the authority 5 Do not exceed the maximum permitted filling ratio specified in under chapter 10. 6 If chapter 10 specifies the way in which the goods are to be transferred applies to the transfer of the goods, … 7 the day specified stated by the applicant 8 endangered species means a species specified mentioned in the schedule. 9 A map of the area is specified set out in the schedule. spectrum usage—consider alternatives before using try—range / no change extra information vogue word example of no change the radio-frequency spectrum example of change a spectrum range of views further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 262 Longman English Usage p 666 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 S–21 S standpoint usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting / no change extra information 1 vogue word 2 Standpoint (like angle, point of view and viewpoint) can be useful if appropriately used. However, it is sometimes used as a refuge from the trouble of precise thought, and provides a clumsy way of saying something that could be said more simply and effectively. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 604 (point of view) Garner’s Dictionary p 916 (viewpoint; point of view; standpoint) Gowers’ Plain Words pp 61–2 Longman English Usage p 546 (point of view, standpoint, viewpoint) Partridge p 330 start usage—consider alternatives before using try—begin / commence / no change extra information For the use of begin and start, see commence. state [as a verb] usage—consider alternatives before using try—mention / declare / say / specify / set out / fix / tell / inform / no change extra information 1 State is much stronger than say and similar words, and should be reserved for formal or impressive contexts. State should be used for the initial declaration of something. To avoid the problem of elegant variation, prefer state for this purpose to alternatives such as specify or stipulate if appropriate. In less formal contexts, however, prefer a simpler alternative, eg tell. 2 Mention should be used for cross-references, eg ‘a person mentioned in section X’. Be careful not to draw artificial distinctions in provisions by using different words to say essentially the same thing, eg do not say in one provision ‘a person mentioned in section X’, and then in another provision say ‘a (thing) stated in section Y’, if the person or thing is only being identified by the reference. Use mention consistently for cross-reference purposes to avoid the problem of elegant variation in cross-references. Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 S–22 S state [as a verb] [continued] 3 The use of mention for cross-referencing purposes is supported by the comments of Dixon CJ in Tooheys Limited v Commissioner for Stamp Duties (1960) 105 CLR 602 at 612. That case concerned the application of the NSW Stamp Duties Act to a trust made by Tooheys. A declaration of trust was defined as an instrument under which property was held in trust for the persons or purposes, ‘mentioned therein’. No particular persons were mentioned in the trust made by Tooheys. Dixon CJ held that ‘This argument appears to me to limit too narrowly the meaning of the phrase in which the word “mentioned” occurs. It may be conceded that the word “mentioned”, when applied to persons and objects, usually imports or implies some reference which identifies them by name or designation. … But it is apparent from the subject matter with which we are concerned … that there is no point manner of identifying, describing or defining the objects of the trust declared and that the word “mentioned” is used in as wide a sense as “referred to” or “described”.’ 4 Use set out if a document, map, diagram or other item is being incorporated into, and reproduced in, an instrument, eg ‘the map set out in the schedule’, or simply say ‘the map in the schedule’. see also—described; referred to; listed examples of no change 1 The application must state the grounds on which the warrant is sought. 2 the day stated by the applicant examples of change 1 the corporation’s progress in achieving financial and other performance targets stated in its current operational plan 2 a standard stated mentioned in paragraph (c) 3 an offence provision stated mentioned in schedule 2, column 2 4 endangered species means a species stated mentioned in the schedule 5 the map stated set out in the schedule [or in] further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 18 Longman English Usage p 677 Partridge p 331 (state and say) statement see—make a statement State of usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / no change example of change the State of New South Wales Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 S–23 S state-of-the-art usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting / no change extra information vogue word further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 828, 919 (vogue words) Garner’s Legal Style p 34 Partridge p 379 (vogue words) steps see—take steps to stipulate usage—avoid using if possible try—set / state / impose / require / insist on / ask / provide (for) extra information 1 formal word 2 Stipulate originated in the language of contracts and is not appropriate for statutory contexts. examples of change 1 A determination must stipulate set standards to be followed. 2 The application must stipulate state the following details: … further reading Cutts p 30 Garner’s Dictionary pp 833–4 stop see—cease Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 S–24 S strangely / strange usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using ‘neutral’ words) / no change extra information 1 Strangely is a sentence adverb (ie an adverb that qualifies a sentence as a whole). 2 Strangely and strange are value-loaded words. 3 Prefer a more ‘neutral’ alternative if appropriate. further reading Fowler’s English Usage pp 702–3 (sentence adverbs) Garner’s Dictionary pp 791–2 (sentence adverbs) structure [as a verb] usage—consider alternatives before using try—organise / set up / prepare / form / no change extra information formal word subject of usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting / no change extra information legalese examples of change 1 a block that is the subject of a declaration declared to be reserved under 2 The approval need not be the subject of an application applied for. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 839 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 S–25 S subject to usage—avoid using if possible try—with / under / on / omitting / recasting (using, eg However) extra information 1 legalese 2 General expressions like subject to this Act/this regulation are very unhelpful to readers, lead to loose drafting and may give rise to legal uncertainty. They must, therefore, never be used. The provisions to which the relevant provision is subject should always be identified (as precisely as possible) or the provisions recast to make it clear what provisions are the dominant ones. 3 It is not necessary to provide expressly that a provision is subject to another provision if this appears unambiguously from the provisions themselves. The relationship between provisions can often be clarified by rearrangement. 4 Consider if it is appropriate to break a section (or equivalent) into 2 or more subsections. For example, the section, ‘Subject to section X, Y and Z, a person may fish for gemfish in the fishery only if the person has a gemfish fishing right.’, may be rewritten as: ‘(1) A person may fish for gemfish in the fishery only if the person has a gemfish fishing right. ‘(2) This section applies subject to: • • • section X (section heading) section Y (section heading) section Z (section heading).’ 5 Alternatively, use However (if necessary after rearranging the order of provisions). see also—under and subject to example of no change Subsection (2) has effect subject to any relevant industrial award or agreement. examples of change 1 (1) Subject to subrule (2), a A document in accordance with a form in schedule 1 must have a cover sheet. (2) A However, a document in accordance with form 45 or form 45A must not have a cover sheet. [or recast to put the exceptions in subrule (1) and omit subrule (2)] 2 to be read subject to the modifications with the changes necessary to … 3 … subject to under any artificial confinement 4 The licence is renewed subject to on conditions. 5 whether the person is or has been subject to a domestic violence order has been made against the person further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 840 (subject to the provisions of this Act) NZ Legislation Manual pp 43–4 (notwithstanding—subject to) Piesse pp 89–91 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 S–26 S submit usage—consider alternatives before using try—refer / send / give / state / subject / say / put / make / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. see also—would argue/contend/submit example of no change The company submitted [or made] a bid for the land. examples of change 1 The committee must submit give a report to the Minister. 2 Counsel submitted said that he had not received the doctor’s report before the hearing. further reading Longman English Usage p 685 subscribe usage—consider alternatives before using try—sign / recasting (using agree (with) / think / consent (to) / approve (of)) / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. example of no change He subscribed to the magazine as soon as it became available. examples of change 1 The summons must be subscribed signed by the magistrate who issues it. 2 I subscribe to agree with the view set out in the dissenting judgment. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 846 subsequent to usage—avoid using if possible try—after extra information 1 compound preposition 2 officialese further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 846–7 Garner’s Legal Style pp 140, 184 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 55, 110 Partridge p 338 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 S–27 S subsequently usage—consider alternatives before using try—after / afterwards / later / then / following / consequently / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. example of change If the corporation subsequently later establishes a superannuation scheme, … further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 846 Gowers’ Plain Words p 262 Longman English Usage p 686 Working words p 131 (consequent/consequential/subsequent) subsist usage—consider alternatives before using try—exist / live / recasting / omitting / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. examples of change 1 The relationship subsisting between the parties when the contract was signed was one of mutual trust. 2 They were able to subsist live on wild berries. [or They lived on wild berries.] further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 847 substantial [also substantially] usage—consider alternatives before using try—considerable / big / large / omitting / recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information 1 vague word 2 can be a weasel word 3 Prefer a more precise alternative if appropriate. examples of no change 1 substantial performance 2 Strict compliance with an approved form is not necessary and substantial compliance is sufficient. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 926 (substantially in weasel words) Gowers’ Plain Words p 52 Longman English Usage p 686 (substantial, substantive) Partridge p 338 (substantial and substantive) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 S–28 S substitute usage—consider alternatives before using try—replace / no change extra information Substitute and replace are complementary words. Substitute means to put a person or thing in the place of another. Replace means, among other things, to take the place of another person or thing. example of change The object of the scheme was to substitute replace exports with domestically produced goods. further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 654–5 (replace or substitute) Fowler’s English Usage p 748 Garner’s Dictionary p 848 Gowers’ Plain Words p 263 Longman English Usage pp 686–7 Partridge p 284 (replace; substitute) subtenancy usage—consider alternatives before using try—sublease / no change extra information formal word further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 844 (sublease etc), 848 succeeding [as a preposition] usage—never use try—after / next / following / recasting extra information formal word example of change the day next / immediately succeeding after further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 848 Partridge p 338 (succeed and follow) successor see—heirs, executors, administrators, successors and assigns Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 S–29 S such usage—avoid using if possible try—the / that / this / these / those / as / a / an / any / omitting / recasting / like / similar extra information 1 Do not use such if an article (the, that, this, these or those) can be used (see example 1, examples of change). 2 Do not use the such … as form if it is not necessary(see examples 2–4, examples of change). 3 Such … that/which/who should not be used for such … as. see also—as such; during such time as; until such time as examples of change 1 A member is entitled to be paid such the remuneration and allowances as the Minister decides. 2 within 6 months or such a [or any] longer period as allowed by the chief executive allows 3 take such steps as are appropriate steps [or take appropriate steps] 4 subject to such conditions as are decided by the Minister [or subject to the conditions / the conditions (if any) decided by the Minister] 5 if no such an audit has not been carried out 6 before making or revoking a declaration under subsection (1) or revoking such a declaration 7 nuts such as like almonds and walnuts 8 The instrument was structured in such a way that made it difficult to read. [or The instrument’s structure made it difficult to read.] further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 725–6 (such and such as) Dick pp 137–41 Dickerson p 131 Fowler’s English Usage pp 749–50 Garner’s Dictionary p 849 Garner’s Legal Style pp 140, 187 Gowers’ Plain Words p 114 Longman English Usage pp 687–8 Partridge pp 338-9 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 S–30 S suffer usage—consider alternatives before using try—permit / allow / have / recasting (using, eg may) / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. example of no change The accident victim suffered patiently. examples of change 1 The owner of premises must not suffer allow the premises to be used for … 2 The organisation must agree to make good any loss suffered by of a care recipient. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 850 Longman English Usage p 688 suffice usage—never use try—do / recasting (using enough / adequate / sufficient / appropriate / satisfactory) extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer recasting using enough if appropriate. 3 For the use of enough, see sufficient. example of change Two copies of the document will suffice do. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 263 Longman English Usage p 688 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 S–31 S sufficient [also sufficiently] usage—consider alternatives before using try—enough / adequate / reasonable / omitting / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer enough if appropriate. 3 However, whenever considerations of quality or kind are essential, sufficient or adequate is the better word (see example 1, examples of no change). 4 Adequate means suitable to the occasion or circumstances. It can apply to quality as well as quantity, eg ‘an adequate performance’. 5 Sufficient means enough for a particular need or purpose. It implies a quantity adequate for a particular need or to fulfil a particular purpose. It does not imply measuring up to a standard. It emphasises instead the end being sought; the degree to which something contributes to the achievement of the end is what makes the thing sufficient or insufficient. see also—good and sufficient examples of no change 1 A peppercorn can be sufficient consideration for a contract even though it is not adequate consideration. 2 a jurisdiction of local government sufficient to allow … 3 If the child is in need of care and family members cannot provide sufficient care,... examples of change 1 this Act does not make provision or sufficient adequate provision 2 it is sufficient enough to show that a representative had the state of mind 3 a sufficient number enough further reading Cutts p 30 Fowler’s English Usage pp 251–2 (enough, sufficiently) Garner’s Dictionary pp 23 (adequate; sufficient), 850 (sufficient number of) Garner’s Legal Style p 184 (sufficient number of) Howard’s Guide p 9 (adequate, enough or sufficient) Howard’s Handbook p 153 (enough/sufficient/adequate) Longman English Usage p 245 (enough, sufficient) Partridge pp 330–1 (sufficient and enough) Use the Right Word p 9 suggested see—it is (respectfully) suggested that Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 S–32 S sui generis usage—never use try—unique / one of a kind extra information foreign phrase further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 727–8 Garner’s Dictionary pp 851–2 Garner’s Legal Style pp 140, 187 sui juris usage—never use try—of full legal capacity extra information foreign phrase further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 851–2 Garner’s Legal Style p 140 suitable see—fit and suitable/fitting and proper sum usage—consider alternatives before using try—quantity / amount / total / no change extra information Prefer an alternative if appropriate. example of no change the sum of human experience example of change the sum total of the amounts Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 S–33 S summon [as a verb] usage—consider alternatives before using try—send for / call (eg for / together / into action) / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 370 (formal words) Longman English Usage p 689 superior … than usage—never use try—superior … to / better than / greater than / recasting extra information Because superior is not a true comparative, the use of superior with than in comparative structures has been criticised. (The same criticism also applies to inferior … than.) Since there is little to be gained by using than with superior, an alternative should be used. see also—hardly … than; scarcely … than; senior … than further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 746 (than) Fowler’s English Usage pp 753 (superior), 770 Longman English Usage p 690 Partridge pp 71 (false comparatives), 154 (inferior (or superior) than) supersede usage—avoid using if possible try—replace / set aside extra information formal word example of change until it is superseded replaced further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 855 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 S–34 S supplementary usage—consider alternatives before using try—additional / extra / more / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. examples of change 1 supplementary additional benefit 2 The instructions are supplementary additional to … further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 263 supply see—in short supply support see—in support of sure see—make sure Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 S–35 S sustain usage—consider alternatives before using try—bear / undergo / experience / suffer / keep (eg up / going / from giving way) / supply / support / confirm / uphold / receive / get / have / recasting / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Sustain implies endurance without giving way or yielding, not only the fact of something adverse. 3 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. examples of change 1 damages for injury or loss sustained received 2 sustain a broken arm break an arm 3 The beam sustained bore [or carried] the weight of the pulley. 4 sustain keep up a conversation 5 The town was sustained supplied with food by air. 6 The applicant’s claim was sustained upheld. 7 The site can sustain support a viable multi-purpose sports centre. 8 If the trust sustains makes a loss on an investment, the trustees must set aside funds to cover the loss. further reading Fowler’s English Usage pp 756–7 Garner’s Dictionary p 862 Longman English Usage p 693 Partridge p 339 syndrome usage—consider alternatives before using try—disease / condition / attitude / recasting / no change extra information 1 vogue word 2 A syndrome is a set of symptoms that may suggest a disease or medical condition. It is not the disease or condition itself. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 759 Gowers’ Plain Words p 263 Longman English Usage p 695 Partridge p 369 (vogue words) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 S–36 T take a decision usage—never use try—decide extra information verbosity take exception to usage—consider alternatives before using try—object to / disagree with / no change extra information verbosity further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 866 taken see—is to be taken take steps to usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / recasting (using more direct words) / no change extra information 1 verbosity 2 Prefer a more direct alternative if appropriate. example of no change Steps have been taken to acquire land for the new school. example of change I will take steps to refund your application fee. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 63 tanto see—pro tanto Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 T–1 T target usage—consider alternatives before using try—goal / ambition / purpose / aim / object / no change extra information 1 vogue word 2 Avoid illogical metaphorical uses of target, eg ‘Target in danger’ to mean that the target is in danger of not being reached (see Gowers, p 264). further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 763 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 40, 75, 88, 263–4 Partridge p 369 (vogue words) telephonic usage—consider alternatives before using try—telephone / recasting/ no change extra information needless, more formal variant for telephone example of change telephonic telephone warrant further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 868 tenancy usage—consider alternatives before using try—lease / term / no change extra information formal word with a number of legal meanings in land law. examples of no change 1 The owner cannot terminate the occupier’s tenancy. 2 joint tenancy further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 1155 Garner’s Dictionary p 869 tenement usage—avoid using if possible try—interest (in land) / estate (in land) / house / building extra information formal word without a fixed legal meaning further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 1157 Garner’s Dictionary p 870 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 T–2 T term see—the term; the term includes/also includes terminate usage—consider alternatives before using try—end / finish / stop / cancel / dismiss / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. 3 For the use of end and stop, see cease. examples of change 1 terminate end an agreement 2 terminate end the chair’s appointment further reading Cutts pp 30, 31 Fowler’s English Usage p 768 Garner’s Dictionary p 370 (formal words) Gowers’ Plain Words p 264 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary pp 65–6 (cancel/terminate) terms and conditions usage—never use try—terms / conditions extra information doublet see also—in terms of; terms and conditions; terms and provisions; the terms of terms and conditions examples of change 1 on terms and conditions agreed between the parties 2 The terms and conditions [or conditions] on which the members hold office are to be decided by the Minister. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 872 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 T–3 T terms and provisions usage—never use try—terms / provisions extra information doublet further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 872 Territory usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting / omitting/ no change extra information 1 can be a redundancy 2 Connection with the ACT is often implied and need not be stated (see LA, dict, pt 1, def the Territory. 3 A reference to an office or body of the Territory need not include ‘the Australian Capital Territory’, ‘ACT’ or ‘the Territory’ only because it is included in its name or title. 4 Avoid the unnecessary use of ‘Territory of the’ (see example 2, examples of change). examples of change 1 the Parliamentary Counsel of the Territory 2 the Territory of Christmas Island testament usage—consider alternatives before using try—will / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer will. 3 Do not use the doublet will and testament. see also—last will and testament further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 1162 Garner’s Dictionary pp 873–4 Law Words 1995 pp 47–9 (last will and testament) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 T–4 T than usage—consider alternatives before using try—as / other than / recasting/ no change extra information Do not use than as a substitute for as or other than. see also—different to/than; greater than; hardly … than; inferior … than; junior …than; no later than; not later than; otherwise than; scarcely … than; senior … than; superior … than; than me/him/her/us/them; than what examples of change 1 More than twice as much work was done this week than as last week. 2 He disliked hearing any view than other than his own. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 770 Gowers’ Plain Words p 105 Partridge p 347 Working Words p 517 thankfully usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting using (eg I am pleased to say) / no change extra information 1 Thankfully traditionally meant with thanks or in a thankful (or grateful) way. Like hopefully its meaning has been extended. Thankfully is now used to express the thanks (or gratitude / relief) of the person using it. This extended use is subject to the same criticisms that have been made of hopefully and can cause ambiguity. 2 see hopefully for more information further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 648 Fowler’s English Usage pp 770–1, 702–3 (sentence adverb) Garner’s Dictionary pp 791–2 (sentence adverbs), 876 Garner’s Legal Style p 140 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 232–3 Longman English Usage pp 640-1 (sentence adverbs), 703 Working Words p 517 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 T–5 T than me / him / her / us / them usage—consider alternatives before using try—than I / than he / than she / than we / than they (with verb expressed) / recasting/ no change extra information 1 Than can be used as a conjunction, introducing a clause, eg ‘They found the task easier than we did’. 2 It can also be used as a preposition, before a noun or pronoun, eg ‘I would rather have the time than the money’. 3 However, sometimes its function is disguised because a verb has been left unstated, eg ‘They stayed longer than us [than we did]’. The strict grammatical view is that the correct pronoun in this example is we, not us, whether or not the verb is expressed. However, the use of me, him, her or us, rather than I, he, she or we, after than is in accordance with common usage and sounds less formal. Indeed, the use of than with the correct pronoun without the verb expressed may sound pedantic. 4 The use of than to introduce an elliptical clause can cause ambiguity. For example, ‘You give her more challenging work than me’ is ambiguous. Does it mean you give her more challenging work than you give me, or you give her more challenging work than I give her? To settle the ambiguity, the point needs to be spelt out more fully, for example, by introducing the relevant verb. further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 745–6 Fowler’s English Usage pp 769–70 Garner’s Dictionary p 876 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 104–5 Partridge pp 347–8 Working Words p 517 than what usage—never use try—than / recasting extra information non-standard English example of change She worked harder than what I did. further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 745–6 (than) Garner’s Dictionary p 875 (than) Partridge p 348 Right Words p 394 Working Words p 517 (than) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 T–6 T that usage—consider alternatives before using try—the / omitting / so / recasting / who / which/ no change extra information 1 Use that instead of the only if it is necessary to avoid ambiguity or for emphasis (see example 6, examples of change). 2 Avoid the false subjects there is and there are etc. This will also avoid use of the unnecessary that (see example 7, examples of change). See also—there is/are/was/were/will be. 3 That can frequently be omitted in defining clauses without loss of clarity or inelegance (see examples 4 and 8, examples of change). 4 That is frequently overused in drafting. This can make writing seem formal and even stilted. Used more sparingly, that helps to make writing more lively and more in line with everyday speech. Generally, use that only if it is grammatically or stylistically necessary, or necessary to avoid ambiguity (including momentary ambiguity). 5 It is difficult to lay down precise rules for when that is stylistically necessary. However, that is more likely to be necessary as a conjunction after the following verbs: answer, agree, announce, argue, assert, assume, assure, calculate, ensure, inform, learn, maintain, reckon, request, state, suggest. On the other hand, that is unusual with the following verbs: ask, believe, presume, suppose, think. The use of that is optional with the following verbs: be told, confess, consider, declare, grant, hear, know, perceive, propose, say, see, understand. Generally, do not use that if its use is stylistically optional (or unusual). If a less formal writing style is used, that is less likely to be stylistically necessary even with verbs usually accompanied by that in more formal writing. If in doubt, leave that out. 6 Sometimes the absence of that may cause readers to be put on the wrong track at least temporarily, eg ‘He felt (that) her many fine features suited her for the task’. In other cases, the meaning may be permanently elusive, eg ‘The instructor said on finishing we must turn off our computers’. Does this mean that the instructor said that we must turn off our computers when we finish, or that the instructor gave the instruction when she finished? 7 The use of that as a conjunction can lead to unduly long or complex sentences and structural mistakes. 8 Do not use that if since, if or so would be appropriate. 9 For the use of who and that, see who. 10 For the use of which and that, see which. see also—the fact that; who or that Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 T–7 T that [continued] examples of no change 1 The authorised officer must warn the person that it is an offence to fail to state the person’s name. 2 in a way that preserves its confidentiality 3 The court must assume that the exercise of power … 4 The application [to set aside a bankruptcy notice] must be accompanied by a copy of any application to set aside the judgment for which the bankruptcy notice was issued and any material in support of that application. examples of change 1 in detail that is sufficient in sufficient detail 2 at the times and places that the chairperson determines decided by the chairperson 3 … the date and time that when the magistrate signed … 4 … is satisfied that it is necessary … 5 a State that corresponds corresponding 6 proposed performance targets for that the year 7 If there are any conditions that do not comply with this section, … 8 Everybody knows that money does not grow on trees. 9 any salary that is paid 10 a voyage that begins or ends beginning or ending in Australian waters 11 on a day that is not other than a Saturday or Sunday 12 It was not that so important that the meeting had to be cancelled. further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 746–7 Cwlth OPC Plain English pp 13, 23 Cwlth Style Manual p 75 Fowler’s English Usage (2nd ed) pp 622–30 (tentative list of verbs that prefer that expressed/omitted/used or not according to context on p 624) Fowlers’ English Usage pp 771–5 Garner’s Dictionary pp 564 (miscues), 876–7 (discussion of usage: wrongly suppressed and unnecessarily repeated) Gowers’ Plain Words pp 121–4, 189–90 Longman English Grammar p 14 (useful discussion on the use of that) Partridge p 348 Right Words pp 394–5 Working Words pp 517–8 the course of see—during the course of; in the course of the effect that see—to the effect that Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 T–8 T the equivalent to see—equivalent the expression [in definitional sense] usage—avoid using if possible try—omitting extra information 1 redundancy 2 formal phrase example of change A reference to the expression relevant law is a reference to the law of the State where the person lives. the fact that usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / recasting (using eg because / although / that) / no change extra information The expression the fact that can be useful and appropriate, but it is sometimes a clumsy way of saying what might be said more simply. If it is preceded by because of, despite, in spite of, in view of, notwithstanding or owing to, it may be only an intricate way of saying because or although. see also—owing to the fact that examples of change 1 Owing to the fact that Because the public holiday fell on a Saturday, … 2 Despite the fact that he was late Although he was late,... further reading Cutts pp 27 (despite the fact that), 29 (in view of the fact that) Fowler’s English Usage p 233 (due to the fact that) Garner’s Dictionary pp 347 (fact that, the), 876 (that (D)) Garner’s Legal Style p 57 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 59–60 Longman English Usage pp 227 (due to the fact that), 264 (fact) Partridge p 388 Strunk and White pp 24, 46 (fact) Working Words p 66 (because of/owing to/due to) the generality of see—without limiting the generality of; without prejudice to the generality of Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 T–9 T the greatest number of usage—never use try—most / recasting extra information 1 verbosity 2 Use an alternative. example of change The candidate with the greatest number of most votes is elected. theme usage—consider alternatives before using try—subject / recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information 1 vague, vogue word 2 Prefer more precise words if appropriate. further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 32 thence usage—never use try—from that place / from there / from that source / recasting / from that direction / for that reason / therefore extra information archaism further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 338 (hence) Fowler’s English Usage pp 316 (from whence), 777 Garner’s Dictionary p 878 Partridge p 121 (from hence) Right Words p 399 Working Words p 519 thenceforth / thenceforward usage—never use try—from that time on(wards) / since then / from then / omitting / recasting extra information archaism further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 878 Partridge pp 35 (archaisms), 349 Working Words p 519 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 T–10 T the option of see—has/have the option of theoretically / theoretical usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using ‘neutral’ words) / no change extra information 1 Theoretically is a sentence adverb (ie an adverb that qualifies a sentence as a whole). 2 Theoretically and theoretical can be value-loaded words. 3 Prefer of more ‘neutral’ alternative if appropriate. further reading Fowler’s English Usage pp 702–3 (sentence adverbs) Garner’s Dictionary pp 791–2 (sentence adverbs), 878 (theoretic(al)(ly)) the present writer usage—avoid using if possible try—I / we / my client / our client / omitting / recasting extra information often circumlocution for the first person further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 360 (first person (A)), 688 (present) Garner’s Legal Style pp 81–2 Partridge p 388 thereabout(s) usage—avoid using if possible try—about then / about there / recasting extra information appears to be becoming an archaism further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 777 Garner’s Dictionary p 878 Partridge p 349 Working Words p 519 (there–) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 T–11 T thereafter usage—never use try—afterwards / after [X] / then / omitting extra information formal word, becoming an archaism example of change If an authorised person asks a person to state the person’s name and address, the authorised person must record the reasons for doing so as soon as possible thereafter afterwards. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 750 Cutts p 30 Fowler’s English Usage pp 777–8 Garner’s Dictionary p 401 (here– and there– words) Partridge pp 35 (archaisms), 349 Working Words p 519 (there–) the reason see—for the reason that; the reason being that; the reason … is because the reason being that usage—never use try—because extra information verbosity further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 184 the reason … is because usage—never use try—recasting (using eg because) extra information verbosity example of change The reason for the delay is The delay happened because the file was misplaced. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 737 (reason … is because) Garner’s Legal Style p 136 Gowers’ Plain Words p 258 Howard’s Guide p 344 (the reason is because and the reason why) Longman English Usage p 595 (reason) Partridge p 271 (reason... because, or why ... because) Right Words pp 348-9 (reason) Working Words pp 66 (because), 463 (reason) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 T–12 T thereat usage—never use try—recasting (using, eg at it / there) extra information archaism further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 401 (here– and there– words), 878 Working Words p 519 (there–) thereby usage—never use try—by [X] / by way of [X] / recasting extra information formal word, becoming an archaism further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 750 Fowler’s English Usage p 777 (thereabout(s)) Garner’s Dictionary pp 401 (here– and there– words), 878 Working Words p 519 (there–) therefor usage—never use try—for [X] / recasting / omitting extra information archaism example of change She bought the latest model of the computer, paying $5,000 therefor for it. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 750 Fowler’s English Usage p 778 Garner’s Dictionary pp 878–9 (therefore, therefor) Garner’s Legal Style pp 141–2 Partridge p 349 Working Words p 519 (there–) therefrom usage—never use try—from [X] / recasting extra information archaism further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 778 (thereat) Garner’s Dictionary pp 401 (here– and there– words), 879 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 T–13 T therein usage—never use try—in [X] / recasting extra information archaism further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 750 Garner’s Dictionary p 401 (here– and there– words) Garner’s Legal Style p 116 Gowers’ Plain Words p 18 Working Words p 519 (there–) thereinto usage—never use try—in [X] / recasting extra information archaism further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 778 (thereat) Garner’s Dictionary p 401 (here– and there– words) there is / are / was / were / will be usage—consider alternatives before using try—there are / there is / there were / there was / recasting / omitting/ no change extra information 1 These phrases are enemies of a lean writing style. 2 If it is important to assert the present, past or future existence of something, there is etc may be necessary (see example of no change). In other cases, the use of there as the introductory slot-filler in a sentence is padding. 3 There is (or was) should be used if what follows is singular or may be regarded as a single unit. There are (or were) should be used if what follows is plural. Two or more singular things add up to a plural. see also—that example of no change There is enough work to keep everyone fully occupied. examples of change 1 There are 3 reasons why I disagree with you. I disagree with you for 3 reasons. 2 If there are any conditions that do not comply with this section, … 3 This section applies to an intersection where there are no without traffic lights. further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 749–50 (there–) Fowler’s English Usage p 778 Garner’s Dictionary p 879 Garner’s Legal Style p 142 Gowers’ Plain Words p 131 Working Words p 520 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 T–14 T thereof usage—never use try—of [X] / from / out of / recasting extra information archaism further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 401 (here– and there– words), 880 Garner’s Legal Style p 116 Gowers’ Plain Words p 18 Partridge p 35 (archaisms) thereon usage—never use try—on / then / recasting extra information archaism further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 750 Fowler’s English Usage p 778 (thereat) Garner’s Dictionary p 401 (here– and there– words) Working Words p 519 (there–) thereout usage—never use try—out of [X] / from [X] / recasting extra information archaism further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 778 (thereat) Garner’s Dictionary pp 401 (here– and there– words), 880 Garner’s Legal Style p 116 thereto / theretofore usage—never use try—to [X] / recasting extra information archaism further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 401 (here– and there– words), 404 (hitherto; thitherto), 880 Gowers’ Plain Words p 18 (thereto) Partridge p 35 (archaisms) Working Words p 519 (there–) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 T–15 T thereunder usage—never use try—under [X] / recasting extra information archaism further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 750 Garner’s Dictionary p 401 (here– and there– words) Gowers’ Plain Words p 18 thereunto usage—never use try—recasting extra information archaism further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 778 (thereat) Garner’s Dictionary pp 401 (here– and there– words), 880 (thereunto appertaining) thereupon usage—never use try—at that instant / recasting extra information formal word, becoming an archaism. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 777 (thereabouts) Garner’s Dictionary pp 401 (here– and there– words), 880 therewith usage—never use try—with [X] / recasting extra information archaism further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 778 (thereat) Garner’s Dictionary p 401 (here– and there– words) Gowers’ Plain Words p 18 Working Words p 519 (there–) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 T–16 T these usage—consider alternatives before using try—the / no change extra information 1 Except in references to the instrument containing the word (eg ‘these rules’), use these instead of the only if it is necessary for stylistic reasons to avoid ambiguity, or for particular emphasis. 2 As a demonstrative adjective, these should modify a plural noun (eg kinds), not a singular one (eg kind). see also—kind; sort of (for these kinds/sorts of) example of no change In these rules: … further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 259–60 (deictic terms), 880 (these kind of; these type of; these sort of) the term [in definitional sense] usage—avoid using if possible try—omitting extra information 1 redundancy 2 formal phrase the term includes / also includes usage—never use try—and includes extra information 1 redundancy 2 formal phrase the terms of usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting/ no change extra information This phrase is the agreement equivalent to provisions of (see provisions of). example of change The person is required by the terms of the person’s appointment to live on the land. Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 T–17 T the time when see—time they usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting / no change extra information 1 The use of the plural is usually unsuitable for legal drafting. 2 For discussion of the use of they to refer to a singular subject (see he; she). thing usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting / something / no change extra information Thing can be very useful in contexts where a more specific term is not needed or available. However, it can be overused. see also—any act/matter/thing example of change a thing something complying with the ADR further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 880 think usage—consider alternatives before using try—consider / recasting / no change extra information 1 Think has been criticised as colloquial. However, it can be useful in achieving a less formal writing style. 2 Use consider if use of think could be taken to be inappropriate. For example, to say that a corporation thinks something could be regarded as inappropriate. Consider does not solve the problem, but makes it less obvious. The preferable solution would be to recast the provision. 3 Do not use thinks fit. see also—inclined to think example of change Do what you think fit consider appropriate. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 780 Partridge p 350 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 T–18 T this [as an adjective] see—in this instance this [as a pronoun] usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting / no change extra information This should always have a clear, single antecedent (eg a noun, phrase, clause or sentence). If it is not crystal clear what this refers to, the sentence should be recast. examples of no change 1 This section applies if … 2 This part provides for … further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 780 Garner’s Dictionary pp 62 (antecedents, false), 259–60 (deictic terms) Garner’s Legal Style p 142 this office / department etc usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using more personal language, eg I / me / we / us) / no change extra information starchy language further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 248 this writer usage—avoid using if possible try—I / we / my client / our client / omitting / recasting extra information often circumlocution for the first person further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 360 (first person) Garner’s Legal Style pp 81–2 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 T–19 T thither usage—never use try—there / to that place / to there / in that direction / recasting extra information archaism further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 338 (hence) Fowler’s English Usage p 362 (hither) Garner’s Dictionary p 881 Right Words p 400 those usage—consider alternatives before using try—the / no change extra information 1 Use those instead of the only if it is necessary for stylistic reasons to avoid ambiguity, or for particular emphasis. 2 As a demonstrative adjective, those should modify a plural noun (eg kinds), not a singular one (eg kind). see also—kind; sort of (for those kinds/sorts of) example of change The container is not suitable for those the dangerous goods. further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 259–60 (deictic terms), 880 (these kind of; these type of; these sort of) thrice usage—never use try—3 times extra information archaism further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 781 Garner’s Dictionary p 881 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 T–20 T thus usage—consider alternatives before using try—so / therefore / for example / in this way / as follows / no change extra information Prefer an alternative if appropriate. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 755 Garner’s Dictionary p 881 Gowers’ Plain Words p 264 thusly usage—never use try—thus / so / therefore / for example extra information Americanism further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 782 Garner’s Dictionary pp 881–2 (thus) Garner’s Legal Style p 143 Working Words p 521 (thus) till usage—avoid using if possible try—until extra information 1 Till and until are equally acceptable in formal English. In formal writing until is the more common word, particularly at the beginning of a sentence. Till is perhaps less formal, at least in some contexts. However, as till is less known, use until. 2 Till is a word in its own right and is not a mere contraction of until. Til, ’til and ’till are all incorrect forms of the word. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 756 Fowler’s English Usage pp 782–3 Garner’s Dictionary p 882 Garner’s Legal Style p 143 Partridge p 350 Right Words p 401 Working Words p 521 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 T–21 T time usage—avoid using if possible try—recasting (using eg when / now) extra information 1 The word time is often superfluous. Phrases mentioning time should generally be simplified unless it is necessary to refer back to an identified time. 2 Mention of time can imply the date as well as the actual time or date. 3 It is unnecessary to say at the time and when (see example 2, examples of change). see also—at all times; at any time; at the present time; at the time that/when/of/at this time/point of time/moment of time; from time to time; until such time as examples of no change 1 The vehicle was stolen at the time of the offence. 2 the time and date of the offence stated in the notice 3 any further time the authority allows 4 The chair may call a meeting at any time. examples of change 1 at this point in time now 2 open for business at the time when the person … 3 The policy comes into force as from the time when … 4 3 days time in 3 days further reading Working Words p 521 time is of the essence usage—avoid using if possible try—recasting (using more precise words) extra information 1 legalese 2 The phrase time is of the essence is not necessary in contracts and may not be sufficient to enable a party to rescind a contract if a relevant act is not done by the time mentioned in the contract. It should not be used in legislation. 3 Prefer recasting explaining the consequences of not complying with time limits. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 1170 (time stipulation) Garner’s Dictionary p 882 Law Words 1995 pp 86–8 timely see—in a timely manner/way times see—at all times Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 T–22 T times more than / greater than usage—never use try—recasting (using, eg times) extra information redundancy example of change The monthly output was 3,000 widgets—more than 3 times greater than in the previous month last month’s output. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words pp 264–5 title see—right, title and interest to see—as to; compare to/with; different to/than to and including usage—avoid using if possible try—not later than / recasting (using before / not less than / at least / x months ending on or ending at the end of) extra information 1 Pearce and Geddes suggest that from and including a particular day to and including another day should be used to precisely fix the start and end of a period. However, this formulation is ungrammatical and is not often used in normal speech. 2 See LA, s 151 (Working out periods of time generally). see also—from and including further reading Pearce and Geddes pp 305-9 to and / or in relation to usage—never use try—to / about / for / of / in relation to extra information 1 doublet 2 Prefer a simple preposition if appropriate. If a connecting phrase is necessary, use in relation to if appropriate (see in relation to). Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 T–23 T to and / or in respect of usage—never use try—about / for / to / of / in relation to extra information 1 doublet 2 Prefer a simple preposition if appropriate. If a connecting phrase is necessary, use in relation to if appropriate (see in relation to). to date usage—never use try—so far further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 218 together usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / no change extra information Together is redundant with words like assemble, connect, consolidate, cooperate, gather, join, link and merge. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 844 Working Words p 525 too usage—consider alternatives before using try—also / very / either / no change extra information Do not use too if also, very or either would be appropriate. examples of change 1 A notice may also be revoked too. 2 not too very popular [or not popular] further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 787 Garner’s Dictionary pp 884–5 Garner’s Legal Style p 143 Partridge p 353 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 T–24 T total [also totally] usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / no change extra information Total is often used for emphasis, but is usually redundant. examples of change 1 total devastation 2 total absence 3 totally void further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 919 (void; voidable) Working Words p 526 to the effect that usage—avoid using if possible try—so that extra information verbosity further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 886 to the extent that usage—consider alternatives before using try—if / when / as far as / so far as / so that / no change extra information 1 verbosity 2 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. examples of change 1 If the vehicle has been modified to the extent that so that the manufacturer’s specification is no longer appropriate... 2 The chief executive must provide regular care planning and review for a child that fully involves the child to the extent that so far as the child can take part. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 228 toto see—in toto Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 T–25 T touching [as a preposition] usage—never use try—for / about / in relation to extra information archaism further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 886 toward / towards [as a preposition] usage—consider alternatives before using try—if / when / so far as / no change extra information 1 Towards generally implies movement and is sometimes misused for to. Use to unless movement is implied (or stated) or the use of towards is otherwise appropriate. 2 In other contexts, prefer towards. However, for the increasing trend not to use an ‘s’ in words ending in wards(s), see forward/forwards. examples of no change 1 It was much hotter towards the end of the afternoon. 2 The car slid towards the edge of the road. 3 She gave $2 towards the gift. 4 His attitude towards the proposal was ambiguous. 5 untoward examples of change 1 He sat with his back towards to me. 2 Parents have responsibilities towards to their children. further reading Blamires’ Queen’s English p 150 Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 202 (towards, toward) Cambridge Style Guide p 763 Fowler’s English Usage p 788 Garner’s Dictionary pp 886, 924 (-ward(s)) Howard’s Guide p 391 Howard’s Handbook p 353 Longman English Usage p 724 Macquarie Dictionary p 2237 Right Words p 404 Working Words p 527 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 T–26 T to which this [provision] applies usage—avoid using if possible try—omitting extra information 1 redundancy 2 If a provision states that it applies to something, it is unnecessary in later references to the thing to state that it is a thing to which the provision applies. further reading Cwlth OPC Plain English p 22 to wit usage—never use try—omitting / recasting / for example / that is extra information archaism further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 549 Garner’s Legal Style p 183 Partridge p 35 (archaisms) transfer and assign usage—never use try—transfer / give / sell / recasting (using more precise words) extra information doublet further reading Law Words 1995 pp 89–91 transmit usage—consider alternatives before using try—send / give / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. example of change The registrar must transmit send a copy of the notice to each party. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 888 Partridge p 354 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 T–27 T transpire usage—consider alternatives before using try—become known / happen / take place / pass / elapse / recasting / no change extra information 1 Apart from its technical botanical or biological meanings, transpire originally meant to become known. Its extension to happen or take place is contentious. 2 formal word 3 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. examples of change 1 If it transpires that [X] … If [X] happens, … 2 Six months transpired passed before the plaintiff filed her claim. further reading Fowler’s English Usage pp 790–1 Garner’s Dictionary p 888 Garner’s Legal Style p 143 Gowers’ Plain Words p 265 Working Words p 528 transportation usage—consider alternatives before using try—transport / no change extra information 1 Transportation has a penal meaning. It also means a system, or the act, of transporting or the state of being transported. 2 In other contexts, prefer transport. further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 184 Right Words p 405 trauma / traumatic usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting / no change extra information 1 Trauma strictly means a serious injury or shock that has long-term effects. 2 Used as a vogue word to mean anything unpleasant. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 888 Gowers’ Plain Words p 88 Right Words p 406 Working Words pp 528–9 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 T–28 T true and correct usage—never use try—correct / accurate / true extra information doublet further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 294 (doublets, triplets and synonym-strings) try see—attempt try and usage—never use try—try to extra information Try and is non-standard English. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 771 Fowler’s English Usage pp 796–7 Garner’s Dictionary p 893 Garner’s Legal Style p 143 Gowers’ Plain Words p 265 Partridge p 356 Right Words p 407 Working Words p 530 turbid see—turgid turgid usage—consider alternatives before using try—turbid / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Turbid means (of water) muddy, soiled, cloudy or unclear, and (of writing) confused, unclear, perplexing or obscure. 3 Turgid means (of things), bloated, swollen or distended, and (of writing) inflated, pompous or bombastic. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 772 Fowler’s English Usage p 798 Garner’s Dictionary p 893 (turbid; turgid; torpid) Garner’s Legal Style p 143 Right Words p 407 Working Words p 531 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 T–29 T two usage—consider alternatives before using try—2 / no change extra information Except at the beginning of a sentence, express the number 2 as a figure and not as a word. further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 605–6 type usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / kind / recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information 1 Most legal drafting is expressed in the singular, and it is usually unnecessary to distinguish between a class (using, eg type) and its members (see LA, s 48 and s 145 (b)). Avoid mentioning type unless it is necessary. See class for extra information. 2 If it is necessary to mention class, prefer kind if appropriate. 3 Avoid using type as an omnibus word. See kind for extra information. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 894 (type of) Garner’s Legal Style p 205 Partridge p 357 type and kind usage—never use try—omitting / kind / type extra information 1 doublet 2 If it is necessary to mention class, prefer kind if appropriate. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 294 (doublets, triplets and synonym-strings) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 T–30 U uberrima fidei usage—avoid using if possible try—of the utmost good faith / recasting (adding an explanation of the phrase) extra information foreign phrase further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 894–5 ult. usage—never use try—recasting (using last month or the name of the last month, eg July). extra information 1 abbreviation of foreign word 2 commercialese 3 Ult. stands for ultimo mense (last month). further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 775 Fowler’s English Usage p 802 (ultimo) Garner’s Dictionary p 895 Gowers’ Plain Words p 16 Partridge p 357 ultimate usage—consider alternatives before using try—final / decisive / best / most advanced / successful / last / no change extra information vogue word see also—in the final / last / ultimate analysis further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 895 (ultimate destination) Partridge p 72 (comparatives, false) Working Words p 535 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 U–1 U ultimately usage—consider alternatives before using try—at last / in the end / finally / eventually / no change extra information Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. example of change He ultimately finished the task in the end. [or eventually] further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 895 ultra vires usage—consider alternatives before using try—beyond power / unauthorised / invalid / no change extra information foreign phrase further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 776 Garner’s Dictionary p 895 un see—not un–/in– unable to see—is/are unable to unbeknown / unbeknownst usage—never use try—unknown extra information 1 Unbeknownst is an archaism. Unbeknown is becoming an archaism. 2 colloquialisms further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 805 Garner’s Dictionary pp 895–6, 901 (unknown) Partridge p 358 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 U–2 U uncontroverted and uncontradicted usage—never use try—not disputed / not denied / not opposed extra information doublet further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 294 (doublets, triplets and synonym-strings) Garner’s Legal Style p 188 undeniably / undeniable usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / no change extra information 1 Undeniably is a sentence adverb (ie an adverb that qualifies a sentence as a whole). 2 Undeniably and undeniable are dogmatic words. 3 Prefer a more ‘neutral’ alternative if appropriate. further reading Garner’s Legal Style pp 129, 192–3 under see—below; by and/or under under and subject to usage—never use try—under / recasting extra information doublet under that name usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / no change extra information can be a redundancy example of change XYZ, a the corporation incorporated under that name in the Netherlands, … Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 U–3 U under the hand of usage—never use try—signed by extra information archaism underlay usage—consider alternatives before using try—underlie / no change extra information Underlay and underlie are sometimes confused. Underlay means to put underneath. Underlie means lying underneath. see also—overlay further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 778 Fowler’s English Usage pp 563–4 (overlay, overlie), 806 Gowers’ Plain Words p 240 (lay, lie) Partridge pp 359–60 Working Words p 537 underlie see—underlay undermentioned usage—never use try—the [item mentioned later / on the next page / on page ‘x’] / omitting / recasting extra information archaism further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 103 (below-mentioned; under-mentioned) underneath see—below Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 U–4 U undersigned usage—never use try—I / we extra information commercialese further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 360 (first person), 897 Gowers’ Plain Words p 265 Partridge p 360 understood and agreed usage—never use try—recasting (using agreed) / omitting extra information doublet further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 294 (doublets, triplets and synonym-strings), 897 undertake [also undertaking] usage—consider alternatives before using try—carry out / perform / do / take on / agree / promise / attempt / try / say you will / task / recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information 1 An undertaking can be a formal promise to give, to do or not to do something. 2 Prefer a simpler alternative if appropriate. example of no change 1 The defendant’s solicitor undertook to enter an appearance on behalf of the defendant. 2 A firm of builders from Sydney undertook the project. [or (less formally) took on] 3 The task was a mammoth undertaking that involved hundreds of volunteers. examples of change 1 a person undertaking carrying out building work 2 A ship is in an appropriate condition for the voyage that it is undertaking its voyage if … 3 undertake agree to make good 4 I undertake to will prepare copies of signature. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 1209 (undertaking) Garner’s Dictionary p 898 Gowers’ Plain Words p 265 New Oxford Dictionary p 2016 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 U–5 U undertake and agree usage—never use try—agree extra information doublet further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 61 undoubtedly / undoubted usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / recasting (using more ‘neutral’ words) / no change extra information 1 Undoubtedly is a sentence adverb (ie an adverb that qualifies a sentence as a whole). 2 Undoubtedly and undoubted are dogmatic words. 3 Prefer a more ‘neutral’ alternative if appropriate. further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 161 (clearly), 632 (overstatement), 791–2 (sentence adverbs), 926 (weasel words) Garner’s Legal Style pp 36, 192 Gowers’ Plain Words p 54 unduly [also undue] usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / too / unusually / no change extra information 1 weasel word 2 Unduly can only properly be used if something has been mentioned or implied giving a standard of comparison. If there is no standard of comparison, the use of unduly is meaningless. Its use is only a shrinking from the nakedness of an unqualified statement. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 926 (weasel words) Gowers’ Plain Words pp 50–2 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 U–6 U unequal for usage—never use try—unequal to extra information non-standard English example of change The photocopier was unequal for to the task. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 807 Gowers’ Plain Words p 265 unequivocal [also unequivocally] usage—consider alternatives before using try—clear / plain / unambiguous / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 899 (unequivocal; unequivocable) Working Words p 538 unexceptionable usage—consider alternatives before using try—entirely satisfactory / acceptable / not meriting criticism / inoffensive / unremarkable (because, eg it will not raise objection) / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Unexceptionable can have negative overtones. 3 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. 4 Unexceptionable and unexceptional can have similar meanings, but are frequently confused. see also—unexceptional further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 261 (exceptional or exceptionable) Fowler’s English Usage pp 273 (exceptionable, exceptional etc), 807 Garner’s Dictionary p 335 (exceptionable; exceptional) Right Words pp 409–10 Working Words p 214 (exceptionable/exceptional) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 U–7 U unexceptional [also unexceptionally] usage—consider alternatives before using try—not unusual / not extraordinary / not out of the ordinary / usual / normal / ordinary / unremarkable (because, eg of blandness) / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Unexceptional can have negative overtones. 3 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. 4 Unexceptional and unexceptionable can have similar meanings, but are frequently confused. see also—unexceptionable further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 261 (exceptional or exceptionable) Fowler’s English Usage pp 273 (exceptionable, exceptional etc), 807 Garner’s Dictionary p 335 (exceptionable; exceptional) Right Words pp 409–10 Working Words p 214 (exceptionable/exceptional) uninterested see—disinterested unique usage—consider alternatives before using try—unusual / uncommon / special / outstanding / remarkable / interesting / novel / rare / recasting (using eg sole) / no change extra information 1 The traditional meaning of unique is something that is one of a kind and has no like or equal. Although it is now often used more loosely, unique should be reserved for things that are one of a kind. However, because the meaning of unique is now disputed, it is preferable to use other words (eg sole) to express the absoluteness implicit in the traditional meaning of unique. 2 According to its traditional meaning, unique is an absolute and cannot be qualified by words like comparatively, more, less, most, somewhat or very. By implication, there are no degrees of uniqueness. However, modifiers like almost, nearly or absolutely are acceptable because they comment on whether uniqueness has been achieved rather than its quality. 3 To avoid these difficulties, prefer an alternative if appropriate. further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 779–80 Fowler’s English Usage pp 808–9 Garner’s Dictionary pp 24–5 (adjectives (B)), 900 Garner’s Legal Style p 143 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 150–1 Partridge pp 72 (comparatives, false), 361 Right Words pp 410–1 Working Words p 538 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 U–8 U unlawfully [also unlawful] usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information Avoid the use of unlawfully in contexts where the word begs the question of precisely when the relevant act is unlawful. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 902 unless [in must not … unless] usage—consider alternatives before using try—may … only if extra information Except in simple offences, avoid the use of double negatives wherever possible. example of change The registrar must not may renew a licence unless only if the determined fee has been paid. unless and until usage—avoid using if possible try—unless / when / if / until / recasting extra information doublet see also—as and when; if and when further reading Cutts p 37 Fowler’s English Usage pp 809–10 Garner’s Dictionary p 902 Gowers’ Plain Words p 61 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 U–9 U unless the contrary intention appears usage—avoid using if possible try—omitting / recasting (identifying particular provisions) extra information 1 legalese 2 General expressions like unless the contrary intention appears are often unhelpful to readers, lead to loose drafting, and may give rise to legal uncertainty. They should never, therefore, be used. The provisions that are in conflict (or possible conflict) should be identified as precisely as possible and the conflict dealt with in a way that makes it clear what provision is the dominant one. 3 See LA, s 155 (Definitions apply subject to contrary intention). further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 601 (notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained herein) NZ Legislation Manual p 26 unnatural usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting (using ‘neutral’ words) / no change extra information 1 value-loaded word 2 Prefer a more ‘neutral’ alternative if appropriate. further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 902–3 unquestionably / unquestionable usage—consider alternatives before using try—preferably / omitting / recasting (using ‘neutral’ words) / no change extra information 1 Unquestionably is a sentence adverb (ie an adverb that qualifies a sentence as a whole). 2 Unquestionably and unquestionable are dogmatic words. 3 Prefer a more ‘neutral’ alternative if appropriate. further reading Partridge p 361 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 U–10 U unreadable usage—consider alternatives before using try—illegible / not interesting to read / difficult to read / uninteresting / no change extra information Illegible means text not clear enough to be read. It is used to describe poor quality or defaced handwriting or printing. Unreadable means too dull or difficult to read. However, unreadable is sometimes used as a synonym for illegible and can, therefore, be ambiguous. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 378 (illegible, unreadable) Garner’s Dictionary p 416 (illegible; unreadable) Garner’s Legal Style p 118 Partridge p 361 Working Words p 269 unrealistic see—realistic unserviceable usage—consider alternatives before using try—defective / not useful / incapable of being used / unfit / unsuitable / not in working order / no change extra information vague word until see—till; unless and until until such time as usage—consider alternatives before using try—until / when / no change extra information 1 verbosity 2 However, the phrase can be used to stress the uncertainty about whether a contemplated event will ever happen. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 903 Garner’s Legal Style p 184 Gowers’ Plain Words p 60 Fowler’s English Usage p 812 Partridge p 362 Working Words p 521 (till/until) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 U–11 U unto usage—never use try—to / omitting / recasting extra information archaism further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 812 Garner’s Dictionary pp 903–4 up till / until usage—consider alternatives before using try—until / no change extra information To combine up with till or until is strictly redundant and should be avoided unless particular emphasis is required. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 756 (till or until) Working Words p 521 (till/until) upon usage—consider alternatives before using try—on / to / in / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Used as prepositions, on and upon usually mean exactly the same thing. However, on is less formal and less emphatic than upon. 3 Prefer on if appropriate. see also—upon / on the expiration; upon / on the occurrence / happening of examples of no change 1 once upon a time 2 row upon row examples of change 1 She climbed upon on the roof. 2 The frog jumped upon on the tank. 3 The bailiff served the writ upon on the defendant. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 814 Garner’s Dictionary p 904 Partridge p 362 Working Words p 376 (on/upon) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 U–12 U upon / on the expiration usage—never use try—at the end extra information formal phrase upon / on the occurrence / happening of usage—never use try—when [X] happens extra information starchy or formal phrase usage usage—consider alternatives before using try—use / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Usage can be used when referring to treatment or rules, especially rules formed by customary practice. In other contexts, prefer use. examples of no change 1 harsh usage 2 historical usage 3 modern English usage 4 common usage examples of change 1 public transport usage use of public transport 2 come into usage use further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 782 Garner’s Dictionary p 905 Gowers’ Plain Words p 266 Working Words p 540 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 U–13 U utilise usage—avoid using if possible try—use / make use of extra information 1 formal word 2 Utilise is generally a pompous synonym for use. 3 However, utilise can connote something more than use. It can imply that a resource has been used to its best advantage. If you need to emphasise an opportunistic element, make use of is a less pompous alternative. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 783 Cutts pp 30, 31 Fowler’s English Usage p 816 Garner’s Dictionary pp 370 (formal words), 905 (use; utilization), 906 Garner’s Legal Style p 143 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 59, 266 Partridge p 362 Right Words p 414 Working Words p 543 utterly [also utter] usage—consider alternatives before using try—completely / omitting / recasting / no change extra information Utterly can be used as depreciative, dogmatic word. further reading Garner’s Legal Style p 36 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 U–14 V valid [in non-legal sense] usage—consider alternatives before using try—sound / just / well-founded / authoritative / having merit / no change extra information A valid argument is one in which the conclusion follows from the premises, even if the premises are false. example of change valid sound argument further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 266 validate [in non-legal sense] usage—consider alternatives before using try—confirm / no change extra information vague word example of change validate confirm a hypothesis further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 266 various different usage—avoid using if possible try—various / several different extra information can be a redundancy further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 908 Working Words p 545 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 V–1 V vary usage—consider alternatives before using try—change / amend / differ / no change extra information 1 Avoid elegant variation. 2 Prefer amend or change if appropriate. 3 For the use of amend, see alter. examples of change 1 the agreement as varied from time to time the amended agreement [or the agreement as amended] 2 The premiums may vary differ according to the class of the vehicle. 3 varying changing the aid to navigation’s character 4 The Minister may vary amend the order. 5 The authority may vary amend an exemption. further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 907–8 (variance; at variance; variation; variant) venal usage—consider alternatives before using try—corrupt / dishonest / venial / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. 3 Venal and venial are sometimes confused. Venal means able to be bribed or influenced by bribery. Venial means excusable or pardonable. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 787 Fowler’s English Usage p 820 Garner’s Dictionary pp 908–9 Garner’s Legal Style p 145 Partridge p 363 Working Words p 546 vendee usage—avoid using if possible try—buyer / purchaser extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer buyer if appropriate. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 909 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 V–2 V vendor usage—consider alternatives before using try—seller / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer seller if appropriate. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 909 venial usage—consider alternatives before using try—excusable / pardonable / slight / trivial / venal / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. 3 For the use of venal and venial, see venal. veracity usage—consider alternatives before using try—truthfulness / accuracy / correctness / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 813 (slipshod extension), 910 Partridge p 363 verbal [also verbally] usage—consider alternatives before using try—oral / no change extra information For the use of oral and verbal, see oral. Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 V–3 V verbatim usage—consider alternatives before using try—exact / literal / word for word / accurate / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 912 (verbatim; ipissima verba; literatim) verbose usage—consider alternatives before using try—wordy / no change extra information formal word further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 789 (verbiage and verbosity) Partridge p 364 (verbiage and verbosity) verify usage—consider alternatives before using try—confirm / check / swear (or affirm) / prove / find out / state (to be true) / no change extra information formal word example of change Please verify check that I have given you the right change. further reading Cutts p 30 Garner’s Dictionary p 913 verily usage—never use try—omitting extra information archaism example of change I verily believe … further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 913 Partridge p 35 (archaisms) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 V–4 V veritable usage—avoid using if possible try—real / genuine / true / omitting extra information formal word example of change a veritable genuine belief very usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / recasting (using more precise words) / much / no change extra information 1 Do not use very unless it adds something. Used too frequently it ceases to have any meaning. 2 Worse still, very can operate as a weasel word and have the effect of weakening rather than strengthening a statement, eg ‘My toothache was very excruciating’. 3 Do not use very to intensify weak or commonplace words, eg very good, very bad, very nice. Recast using more precise words. 4 Very should be used to modify adjectives (eg happy, sad, sorry) and not, properly, past participles (eg enhanced or uninterested). However, the distinction can sometimes be difficult to apply in practice, particularly if the participle is operating as an adjective rather than as a verb (eg tired, drunk or depressed). example of no change very tired examples of change 1 very evident 2 very much liked 3 I am very reluctant … further reading Fowler’s English Usage pp 823–4 Garner’s Dictionary p 914 Garner’s Legal Style p 144 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 53–4, 267 Partridge p 365 Working Words p 548 very approximate see—approximately Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 V–5 V via usage—consider alternatives before using try—by way of / by / through / in / from / recasting / no change extra information 1 Via is useful in explaining the precise route taken on a journey, eg ‘London via Athens’. 2 In other contexts, prefer an alternative. examples of change 1 The message was sent via by fax. 2 She received the information via from her brother. 3 Please reply via in code. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 791 Fowler’s English Usage p 824 Garner’s Dictionary p 915 Partridge p 365 Working Words p 548 viable usage—consider alternatives before using try—durable / effective / feasible / lasting / practicable / profitable / promising / successful / useable / workable / recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information 1 vague, vogue word 2 Prefer a more precise alternative if appropriate. 3 Viable originally meant capable of independent existence or survival. It is best reserved for cases where its original meaning is appropriate. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 824 Garner’s Dictionary pp 813 (slipshod extension), 915, 919 (vogue words) Garner’s Legal Style pp 34, 144, 199 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 40, 217, 267 Right Words p 418 Working Words p 548 vicinity see—in the vicinity of view see—in view of; point of view; with a view to Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 V–6 V viewpoint usage—avoid using if possible try—recasting extra information 1 vogue word 2 Viewpoint (like angle, point of view and standpoint) can be useful if appropriately used. However, it is sometimes used as a refuge from the trouble of precise thought and provides a clumsy way of saying something that could be said more simply and effectively. example of change There is no reason to keep applications that have been processed, apart from a statistical information viewpoint except for statistical information. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 604 (point of view) Garner’s Dictionary p 916 (viewpoint; point of view; standpoint) Gowers’ Plain Words pp 61–2 Partridge p 321 (standpoint etc) vires usage—avoid using if possible try—power / authority extra information foreign word see also—ultra vires further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 917 virtually [also virtual] usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / recasting (using more precise words) / no change extra information 1 hedge word (diminisher)—weasel word 2 vague word 3 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 917, 926 (weasel words) Garner’s Legal Style pp 144, 192 Right Words p 419 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 V–7 V virtue see—by virtue of vis-à-vis usage—avoid using if possible try—face to face / opposite / in relation to / about / as regards / regarding / on / for / in / of / over / to / with / recasting (using more precise words) extra information foreign phrase further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 793 Fowler’s English Usage p 827 Garner’s Dictionary p 917 Right Words pp 419–20 Working Words p 549 visit with usage—never use try—visit / afflict (with) extra information 1 phrasal verb 2 Use the simple verb. see also—consult with; meet with / meet up with; miss out on examples of change 1 There was nothing to do but visit with each other. 2 They were visited with afflicted with epidemics of a strange disease. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 583 (phrasal verbs) Fowler’s English Usage pp 594–5 (phrasal verbs), 828 Gowers’ Plain Words p 184 Longman English Usage p 758 New Oxford Dictionary p 2066 (visit) vitiate usage—consider alternatives before using try—invalidate / weaken / impair / lessen / reduce / contaminate / corrupt / cure / correct / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 813 (slipshod extension), 918 Right Words p 420 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 V–8 V viva voce usage—never use try—orally / spoken / oral examination extra information foreign phrase further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 794 Fowler’s English Usage p 828 vivos see—inter vivos viz usage—never use try—namely / that is to say / recasting (using the following) / omitting extra information abbreviation of foreign word (videlicet) further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 792 Cutts p 39 Fowler’s English Usage p 828 Garner’s Dictionary pp 918–19 Garner’s Legal Style p 144 Working Words p 550 void usage—consider alternatives before using try—voidable / no change extra information 1 Void means of no legal effect at all. A void contract, therefore, gives no rights at all. 2 Voidable, on the other hand, means capable of being voided or confirmed. A voidable contract, therefore, is capable of being enforced until it is ended by one of the parties or declared to be void. see also—ab initio; void and of no effect further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 919 (void; voidable) void ab initio see—ab initio Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 V–9 V void and unenforceable see—void and of no effect void and of no effect usage—never use try—void / of no (legal) effect / has no (legal) effect / invalid extra information doublet further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 920 voidable see—void voluntary [also voluntarily] usage—consider alternatives before using try—by choice / unpaid / intentional / spontaneous / willing / no change extra information vague word further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 268 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 V–10 W want usage—consider alternatives before using try—lack / need / require / wish / would like to have / no change extra information 1 can be vague word 2 can be formal word 3 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. examples of change 1 Their wants needs were minimal. 2 want lack of resources further reading Fowler’s English Usage pp 832–3 Garner’s Dictionary p 924 Partridge p 372 Working Words pp 552–3 warrant [as a verb] usage—consider alternatives before using try—authorise / permit / allow / justify / guarantee / assure / no change extra information 1 formal word 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 924–5 Partridge pp 372–3 wastage see—waste Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 W–1 W waste usage—consider alternatives before using try—destroy / throw away / wastage / recasting / no change extra information 1 Wastage originally meant the quantity wasted or lost by use, decay or other natural processes. Used in this sense wastage is neutral in its connotations. 2 By contrast, waste can mean to use or expend carelessly, extravagantly or without purpose. Used in this sense waste has negative connotations. 3 Waste can also mean something eliminated or discarded as no longer useful or required after completion of a process. Used in this sense waste is generally neutral in its connotations. 4 Waste is also a legal term of art in property law. 5 Wastage is increasingly used as a formal word for waste. Wastage takes on the negative connotations of waste when used as its synonym. If a neutral word is wanted to refer to the natural attrition of a resource, prefer an alternative. 6 Do not use wastage as a long variant of waste. examples of no change 1 a waste of time 2 go to waste 3 waste disposal 4 wasteland 5 Plants produce oxygen as a waste product. 6 We can’t afford to waste our resources. 7 nuclear waste example of change Energy wastage waste was cut by 75%. further reading Butterworths Legal Dictionary p 1260 (waste), (wasteland) and (wasteland of the Crown) Cambridge Style Guide p 801 (waste or wastage) Fowler’s English Usage p 833 (wastage) Garner’s Dictionary p 925 (wastage) Gowers’ Plain Words p 268 (wastage) Howard’s Guide p 407 (wastage or waste) Howard’s Handbook p 367 (wastage/waste) Longman English Usage p 763 (wastage, waste) New Oxford Dictionary p 2085 (wastage) and (waste) Working Words p 553 (wastage/waste of) way see—by way of; in a … manner/way; in a timely manner/way Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 W–2 W westerly (direction) / westwardly / westward(s) see—easterly (direction) / eastwardly / eastwards what usage—consider alternatives before using try—which / that / who / whom / omitting / no change extra information 1 In a question, use what if the inquiry is general, because it implies open choice. Use which if the inquiry is more specific, because it implies alternatives. 2 What is often unnecessary if used with than or as. 3 Do not use what as a relative pronoun instead of who, whom, which or that. see also—as to whether / who / what / how etc examples of change 1 She worked harder than what I did. 2 He was the one what whom I most admired. further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 805 Fowler’s English Usage pp 839–41 Garner’s Dictionary pp 927–8 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 119–20 (singular or plural verb) Partridge p 374 Working Words p 558 whatever usage—consider alternatives before using try—however / omitting / no change extra information Whatever should be used sparingly as an intensifier, and generally only when it is necessary to emphasise the universal application of a provision. see also—however; whenever; whichever; whoever / whomever example of no change A ship is any kind of vessel, whatever its size, used in navigation by water. example of change … (by whatever name called) (however called) … further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 258–9 (–ever or ever) Dick p 149 Fowler’s English Usage p 841 Garner’s Dictionary p 928 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 W–3 W whatsoever usage—never use try—of any kind / whatever / recasting extra information archaism example of change A ship is any kind of vessel, whatsoever whatever its size, used in navigation by water. further reading Dick p 149 Garner’s Dictionary pp 366 (forbidden words and phrases—A. generally useless words and phrases), 928 when usage—consider alternatives before using try—where / if / and then / as / no change extra information 1 For the use of where, if and when, see where. 2 When is sometimes mistakenly used for and then, as or in. example of no change A retractable axle is taken to be an axle only when it is lowered. examples of change 1 Please send me your instructions when I will and I will then estimate how long it will take to prepare a draft. 2 She was working on the draft when the file server went down. As she was working on the draft, the file server went down. 3 When In deciding whether to give an approval... see also—as and when; at the time that/when; if and when; on each occasion when further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 928 (when (A)) Garner’s Legal Style pp 65, 81 Gowers’ Plain Words p 105 Partridge p 375 Working Words p 558 when and as usage—never use try—when / whenever / as and when / as / recasting extra information 1 doublet 2 compound preposition further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 70 (as and when) Garner’s Dictionary pp 78–9 (as and when) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 W–4 W whence usage—never use try—from where / from which place / from that direction extra information archaism further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 338 (hence), 805 Fowler’s English Usage pp 316 (from whence), 842 Garner’s Dictionary pp 376 (from hence; from thence), 878 (thence; whence; hence), 928 Partridge p 375 Right Words p 426 Working Words p 558 whenever usage—consider alternatives before using try—when / if / omitting / no change extra information 1 Whenever should be used sparingly as an intensifier, and generally only if it is necessary to emphasise a provision’s recurring application. 2 For the use of when and if, see where. see also—however; whatever; wherever; whichever; whoever/whomever further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 258–9 (–ever or ever) Fowler’s English Usage p 842 Garner’s Dictionary p 928 Working Words p 260 (how ever/however) whensoever usage—never use try—when / whenever / omitting extra information archaism further reading Cutts p 30 Gowers’ Plain Words p 268 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 W–5 W where usage—consider alternatives before using try—if / when / in which / that / recasting / no change extra information 1 Use where for place, but if to introduce a set of facts, conditions or cases. However, avoid the use of double ‘if clauses’ (especially ‘if clauses’ within ‘if clauses’)—preferably by recasting rather than using where for the second if clause (see example 7, examples of change). 2 Use if when it is possible that something will happen, but not certain. If an event is so certain that if is inappropriate, use when. 3 Use in which as a relative pronoun rather than where, except to refer to a place. However, in less formal writing, where may be appropriate. see also—and (and where); except as / where otherwise provided / indicated examples of no change 1 The officer must leave the notice where the seizure or damage happened. 2 the place where the car was found examples of change 1 Where If a person is granted a licence, … 2 Where When this Act expires, … 3 Where If there are 2 or more applicants, … 4 the appeal where in which the precedent was set 5 An emergency situation is where happens if … [or An emergency situation is a situation in which …] 6 I see where that … 7 An order is an order made in favour of a person if— (a) if the order is for a residence order—.... further reading Cwlth OPC Plain English pp 20–1 Garner’s Dictionary pp 928–9 Howard’s Handbook pp 34-5 (as and when/if and when) Partridge p 287 (see where) whereabout usage—never use try—about that / about which / whereabouts / recasting extra information archaism further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 843 (where– compounds) Garner’s Dictionary p 929 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 W–6 W whereas usage—avoid using if possible try—considering / because / while / although / since / on the contrary / but (by contrast) / by which / because of which / recasting extra information 1 formal word 2 archaism (except in contrasts) 3 Before using a preamble or recital, consider if it is necessary. 4 Avoid the use of whereas in preambles, eg by using an introduction like ‘The Legislative Assembly’s reasons for enacting this Act are—’, followed by short, numbered sentences. (The enacting words should remain the same whether or not there is a preamble.) 5 Avoid the use of whereas in recitals, eg by using a heading such as ‘Background’, followed by short declaratory sentences. further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 805–6 (where–) Cutts p 30 Fowler’s English Usage p 843 (where– compounds) Garner’s Dictionary pp 929, 931 (while) Garner’s Legal Style p 144 Law Words 1995 pp 92–4 Partridge p 35 (archaisms) whereat usage—never use try—at which / recasting extra information archaism further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 805–6 (where–) Fowler’s English Usage p 843 (where– compounds) Garner’s Dictionary p 929 Partridge p 35 (archaisms) whereby usage—avoid using if possible try—under which / by which / under what / from which / according to which / recasting extra information 1 formal word 2 possibly archaism further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 805–6 (where–) Fowler’s English Usage p 843 (where– compounds) Garner’s Dictionary p 929 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 W–7 W wherever usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / no change extra information Wherever should be used sparingly as an intensifier, and generally only if it is necessary to emphasise the exhaustive application of a provision. see also—however; whatever; whenever; whichever; whoever / whomever further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 258–9 (–ever or ever), 805–6 (where–) Fowler’s English Usage p 843 (where– compounds) wherever occurring usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / no change extra information 1 formal phrase 2 legalese wherefor(e) usage—never use try—for that / for which / why / for what purpose / therefore / recasting extra information archaism further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 805–6 (where–) Fowler’s English Usage p 843 (where– compounds) Garner’s Dictionary p 929 Garner’s Legal Style pp 96, 116 Partridge p 35 (archaisms) wherefrom usage—never use try—from that / from which / recasting extra information archaism further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 805–6 (where–) Fowler’s English Usage p 843 (where– compounds) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 W–8 W wherein usage—never use try—in which / where / recasting extra information archaism further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 805–6 (where–) Fowler’s English Usage p 843 (where– compounds) Garner’s Legal Style p 116 whereof usage—never use try—of which / recasting extra information archaism further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 805–6 (where–) Fowler’s English Usage p 843 (where– compounds) Garner’s Dictionary pp 929–30 Garner’s Legal Style p 116 Partridge p 35 (archaisms) whereon usage—never use try—on which / where / on what / recasting extra information archaism further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 805–6 (where–) Fowler’s English Usage p 843 (where– compounds) Partridge p 35 (archaisms) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 W–9 W wheresoever usage—never use try—wherever / recasting extra information archaism example of change This Act applies to all ships connected with Australia, wheresoever they may be wherever they are. further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 805–6 (where–) Dick p 149 Fowler’s English Usage p 843 (where– compounds) Garner’s Dictionary pp 366 (forbidden words and phrases—A. generally useless words and phrases), 930 where / if the context permits / allows usage—never use try—omitting / recasting (using eg unless the contrary intention appears) extra information legalese whereto usage—never use try—to which / recasting extra information archaism further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 805–6 (where–) Fowler’s English Usage p 843 (where– compounds) wheretofor usage—never use try—recasting extra information archaism Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 W–10 W whereunder usage—never use try—recasting extra information archaism further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 805–6 (where–) whereupon usage—never use try—at / after which / and then / recasting extra information archaism further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 805–6 (where–) Fowler’s English Usage p 843 (where– compounds) Garner’s Dictionary p 930 wherewith usage—never use try—with which / recasting extra information archaism further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 805–6 (where–) Fowler’s English Usage p 843 (where– compounds) wherewithal usage—never use try—the means (esp. financial) / the resources (esp. financial) / recasting extra information 1 formal word 2 possibly archaism further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 805–6 (where–) Fowler’s English Usage p 843 (where– compounds) Garner’s Dictionary p 930 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 W–11 W whether / whether or not usage—consider alternatives before using try—if / no change extra information 1 Prefer if if appropriate. However, whether is generally preferable to express an alternative or possibility rather than a conditional idea. Whether leaves the possibility of something happening evenly balanced, while if suggests greater uncertainty about whether the possibility will happen. In using if, take care to avoid ambiguity (see example 1, examples of no change). 2 In the phrase whether or not the words or not are usually superfluous, since whether implies or not. Whether or not should be reserved for cases where it means regardless of whether (see example 3, examples of no change). see also—as to whether/who/what/how/etc; issue as to whether/of whether; regardless whether examples of no change 1 Please tell me whether there is any change in your circumstances. [if the person is required to say now whether there is any change, rather than telling of a future change] 2 X’s appointment depends on whether there are sufficient funds. 3 Change is coming, whether or not you want it. 4 The committee must find whether the provision of the care complies with the standards. examples of change 1 The captain of the ship must decide whether or not to use the emergency beacon. 2 If the court is considering whether or not to make an order about a child... further reading Bryson’s Troublesome Words p 214 (whether or not) Cambridge Style Guide p 806 (whether) Garner’s Dictionary pp 414 (if (A)), 930 (whether) Garner’s Legal Style p 144 (whether (or not)) Gowers’ Plain Words p 103 Howard’s Guide p 408 (whether or if) Howard’s Handbook p 200 (if/whether) Hudson p 429 (whether or not) Longman English Usage pp 355 (if 1), 770 (whether) New Oxford Dictionary pp 904 (if), 2102 (whether) Partridge pp 148 (if), 376 (whether or no; whether or not) Right Words pp 201-2 (if / whether), 426 (whether) Working Words pp 268 (if), 558 (whether or not) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 W–12 W which usage—consider alternatives before using try—that / who / whose / and / omitting / recasting (using where, how or when) / no change extra information 1 Prefer that wherever grammatically and idiomatically appropriate. 2 That cannot be used in a commenting clause—the relative pronoun must be which. With a defining clause, either which or that is grammatically permissible. 3 Gowers’ Plain Words (p 158) explains defining and commenting clauses in this way: If you say, ‘The man who was here this morning told me that’, the relative clause is a defining one, it completes the subject ‘the man’, which conveys no definite meaning without it. But if you say, ‘Jones, who was here this morning, told me that’, the relative clause is commenting; the subject ‘Jones’ is already complete and the relative clause only adds a bit of information about him which may or may not be important but is not essential to the definition of the subject. 4 A useful test for distinguishing between commenting and defining clauses is given by Garner (Legal Style p 141). If putting the clause in brackets leaves the basic meaning of the sentence intact, the clause is a commenting clause (properly introduced by which). If the sentence is rendered nonsensical or its meaning is changed, the clause is a defining clause (properly introduced by that). 5 Commenting clauses should be used infrequently in legislative drafting. 6 Although that as a relative pronoun may not be preceded by a preposition, it is permissible for which to be preceded by a preposition. 7 Do not use which to refer to people, other than people in a body (see that). 8 Do not use which without a proper antecedent. Which should only be used to refer to a specific antecedent, and not to a general idea or whole statement (see example 13, examples of change). 9 For the use of whose instead of of which for inanimate objects, see whose. 10 If which is needed as the subject of a subclause, try restructuring as a new provision. see also—and (and which/or which); during which; for which (there is); in which; on which; to which this [provision] applies examples of no change 1 the journey for which the ticket was issued 2 the salary or wage to which the officer was entitled 3 a newspaper circulating generally in the locality to which the recommendation relates 4 a program by which stated objectives are to be achieved 5 The consequences of entering into the agreement are stated in section Y, which has effect despite anything in the agreement. [However, it would be preferable to recast this as 2 sentences (using separate provisions).] 6 a scheme under which participants … Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 W–13 W which [continued] 7 as long as the premises are used for the purposes for which they are presently used examples of change 1 premises at which where … 2 the times at which when the road may be used 3 land on which where … 4 state the place at which where … 5 stating the way in which how the accreditation 6 Section 10 explains the way in which how meat processing is to be recorded. 7 the day on which notice is given 8 a corporation the assets of which whose assets [or having assets or with assets] 9 the court by which that convicts an insurer is convicted 10 the parts of the land in which where a pensioner has rights to exclusive occupancy 11 state the place at which, the way in which and the person to whom where and how the penalty may be paid. 12 the month in which when the system is installed 13 You must finish your homework, after which and only then may you watch television. 14 property of which the defendant is the sole owner owned solely by the defendant 15 The application must state the grounds on which the warrant is sought for seeking the warrant. 16 The vehicle standards set the standards with which that vehicles must comply with to be registered. further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 806–7 Dick pp 132–3 Cwlth OPC Plain English p 19 (of which) Fowler’s English Usage pp 774–5 (which/that), 844–5 Garner’s Dictionary pp 765–7 (restrictive and non–restrictive clauses), 930-1 Garner’s Legal Style pp 140–1 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 120–1, 189–90 Partridge pp 376–7 Right Words pp 395–7 Working Words pp 558–9 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 W–14 W whichever usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / recasting / no change extra information Whichever should be used sparingly as an intensifier, and generally only when it is necessary to emphasise the universal application of a provision. see also—however; whatever; whenever; wherever; whoever/whomever further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 258–9 (–ever or ever) whichever first occurs / occurs first usage—never use try—omitting / recasting (using earlier) / whichever happens first extra information 1 formal phrase 2 legalese whichever happens first usage—avoid using if possible try—omitting / recasting (using earlier) extra information 1 legalese 2 Often it is clear from the context that one event in a list of events will happen first and cause a particular result. examples of change 1 The licence remains in force after its current term ends until— (a) the licence is renewed; or (b) a provisional renewal of the licence lapses; or (c) an application for renewal is withdrawn or refused; whichever happens first. 2 The notice must be filed and served within 1 week after the earlier of— (a) the day when the bill was served; and (b) the day when the notice of rights was served; whichever happens first. Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 W–15 W whichsoever usage—never use try—omitting / recasting / whichever extra information archaism while usage—consider alternatives before using try—although / and / but / when / no change extra information 1 While should be used only in its temporal sense, eg ‘Your letter came while I was on holidays’. 2 Its use as a conjunction equivalent to although can be ambiguous and inappropriate in formal writing. 3 While should not be used as a synonym for and. see also—while … at the same time examples of no change 1 I will draft the first instrument while you are preparing instructions for the next. 2 The guard may not leave the entry door while on duty. examples of change 1 While Although the language of the draft is plainer, its substance is unchanged. 2 The first edition of the book was published in English and in French, while and the second edition was published only in French. further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 807–8 Fowler’s English Usage p 845 Garner’s Dictionary p 931 Garner’s Legal Style pp 144–5 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 105–6 Partridge p 378 Working Words p 559 while … at the same time usage—avoid using if possible try—while extra information redundancy example of change While she was carrying on her practice, she was at the same time working on her thesis. further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 931 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 W–16 W whilst usage—never use try—while / although / and / but / when extra information 1 formal word 2 becoming an archaism example of change a person who, whilst although not qualifying as an operator, … further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 807–8 Cutts pp 30, 31, 37 Fowler’s English Usage 845 (while) Garner’s Dictionary p 932 Gowers’ Plain Words p 106 Partridge p 26 (among and amongst; amid, amidst; while, whilst) Right Words p 426 Working Words p 559 whither usage—never use try—to where / to which place / where / in which direction extra information archaism further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 338 (hence) Fowler’s English Usage pp 846–7 Garner’s Dictionary p 932 Right Words p 426 (whence) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 W–17 W who usage—consider alternatives before using try—that / whom / recasting / no change extra information 1 Normally, who is used as the relative pronoun to refer to human beings, and that (or which) is used to refer to inanimate things. However, that can also be used to refer to people or words that might be thought of as people-substitutes, eg anyone, everyone and someone (although who comes more naturally in most cases). 2 Either who or that may be used to refer to groups of people described using a collective noun (eg a committee), but that should be preferred. 3 Use that to refer to both humans and animals or humans and things. 4 The traditional distinction between who and whom is that who acts as the subject of a verb (eg ‘the person who is talking’) and whom as the object of a verb or preposition (eg ‘the person of whom we spoke’). However, whom is increasingly rarely used (except after prepositions) and often sounds unnatural and even excessively pedantic. If possible, avoid both infringing the traditional distinction and the use of whom by using that, omitting whom, or otherwise recasting. see also—and (and who); as to whether/who/what/ how/etc; who has; who or that; whom examples of change 1 The corporation who that made the decision no longer exists. 2 The draft was prepared by a team of drafters, none of who whom are here today. [or ..., and none of them are here today] further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 809–10 (whom) Cwlth OPC Plain English p 18 Fowler’s English Usage pp 773 (who or that), 847–9 (who and whom) Garner’s Dictionary pp 932–4 Garner’s Legal Style pp 145 (who; whom), 202 (to avoid sexist language) Gowers’ Plain English pp 122, 189–90 (who or that) 124–5 (who or whom) Partridge pp 378–9 Right Words pp 395 (who or that), 427–8 (who/whom) Working Words pp 559 (who/that), 559–60 (who/whom) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 W–18 W whoever / whomever usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / recasting / no change extra information 1 Whoever should be used sparingly as an intensifier, and generally only when it is necessary to emphasise the universal application of a provision. 2 Whomever sounds very stilted. If possible, avoid using whomever. see also—however; whatever; whenever; wherever; whichever further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 258–9 (–ever or ever) Fowler’s English Usage p 849 Garner’s Dictionary pp 934–5 Right Words p 427 (whoever/who ever) Working Words p 260 (how ever/however) who has usage—consider alternatives before using try—with / no change example of change The person who has with the strongest claim will succeed. whole of usage—consider alternatives before using try—entire / full / total / whole / all of / omitting / recasting / no change examples of change 1 the value of the whole of the entire property 2 If the whole of all of the insurer’s CTP business is transferred … 3 a road with street lighting along the whole of the road wholly usage—consider alternatives before using try—completely / entirely / fully / totally / recasting / no change extra information Do not use more or less wholly. examples of change 1 a structure wholly completely enclosed by walls 2 a business wholly totally or substantially owned by the family 3 wholly fully or mainly engaged in primary production further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 151 (more or less wholly) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 W–19 W whom usage—avoid using if possible try—that / who / omitting / recasting extra information see also—who examples of change 1 He needs someone in whom he can trust who can be trusted. 2 She needs someone in whom she can confide in. 3 He is the person whom we believe will be successful. who or that usage—never use try—who / that extra information see also—who whose usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting / of which / no change extra information 1 Although whose is increasingly being used to refer to animals and things as well as people, it should not generally be used in this way in formal writing. 2 Prefer recasting if practicable. If not, prefer whose to of which. examples of change 1 The pedestrian was hit by a car whose lights were not on without its lights on. [or that did not have its lights on] 2 We stayed at a farm whose owner is owned by a wine maker. 3 the dog whose leg was broken with a broken leg further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 808–9 (who and whose) Fowler’s English Usage pp 849–50 Garner’s Dictionary p 934 Garner’s Legal Style p 145 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 125–6 Partridge p 379 Right Words pp 396–7 (that/which/who/whose) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 W–20 W whosoever / whomsoever usage—never use try—whoever / whomever / omitting extra information archaism further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 849 (whoever) Garner’s Dictionary pp 366 (forbidden words and phrases—A. generally useless words and phrases), 934 Garner’s Legal Style p 145 Partridge pp 35 (archaisms), 379 wife usage—consider alternatives before using try—spouse / partner / domestic partner / no change extra information 1 Discrimination on the ground of marital status is unlawful under the Discrimination Act 1991. 2 Prefer an alternative if appropriate. 3 See LA, s 169 (References to domestic partner and domestic partnership). will [as a verb] usage—consider alternatives before using try—may / must / recasting / no change extra information 1 Traditionally, shall is used for the first person, simple future tense (eg ‘I/we shall go to town tomorrow’) and will is used for the second or third person, simple future tense (eg ‘You/he/they will go to town tomorrow’). Avoid the use of shall or will with the first person, simple future tense by recasting. 2 Will can usefully be used instead of must: in a standard form contract—to express the obligations of the party supplying the contract; or in a contract or arrangement involving delicate relations between the parties—to express both parties’ obligations; or in an instrument—to direct a person of the same standing as the maker of the instrument to do something (see example 3, examples of no change). However, must should be used to create obligations intended to have criminal or direct civil consequences. see also—last will and testament Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 W–21 W will [as a verb] [continued] examples of no change 1 The insurer must tell the commissioner that the issue will not be referred to the tribunal. 2 changes that will result in a more effective and efficient maritime industry [used in an objects clause] 3 An agency head will ensure that workplace conditions do not have an indirect effect of discriminating against employees because of race, sex, or physical disability. [from a direction given by an official of the same standing as the agency head. Note There are no criminal or direct civil consequences for not complying with the direction.] examples of change 1 Payment of the amount will be enforceable may be enforced under this part. 2 The authority will must grant a statutory fishing right to a person who is eligible for the grant of the right. 3 The commissioner will may exercise the following powers of the agency: … further reading Cambridge Style Guide pp 687–8 (shall or will) Fowler’s English Usage pp 706–7 (shall and will) Garner’s Dictionary pp 941–2 (words of authority) Garner’s Legal Style p 139 (shall; will) Gowers’ Plain English pp 141–2 (shall and will) will and testament see—last will and testament will / would you be good enough to advise me usage—never use try—please tell me / please let me know extra information officialese further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 18 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 W–22 W –wise usage—consider alternatives before using try—recasting / no change extra information New words formed by adding –wise as a suffix to a noun should be used with caution (eg population-wise, saleswise, taxwise). further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 812 Fowler’s English Usage pp 851–2 Garner’s Legal Dictionary p 936 Garner’s Legal Style pp 34, 135 Gowers’ Plain Words p 268 Right Words p 424 (the way of the wise) Working Words p 553 wit see—to wit with see—by and with; compare to/with; differ with withal usage—never use try—in addition / also / as well / nevertheless / with / omitting / recasting extra information archaism further reading Fowler’s English Usage pp 833 (Wardour Street), 852 Garner’s Dictionary p 937 Garner’s Legal Style p 146 Partridge pp 35 (archaisms), 380 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 W–23 W with a view to usage—avoid using if possible try—to / for / recasting extra information compound preposition officialese example of no change The appeal must be conducted with a view to its prompt disposal. [or The appeal must be heard and decided as quickly as possible.] examples of change 1 a proceeding with a view to for the summary conviction of a person 2 a division established with a view to for the election of a member 3 cause an investigation to be made with a view to ascertaining conduct an investigation to find out further reading Gowers’ Plain Words pp 55, 267, 63 (cause an investigation to be made with a view to ascertaining) Partridge p 380 within / within-named [as an adjective] usage—never use try—omitting / enclosed / recasting extra information archaism examples of change 1 the within property 2 the enclosed document within further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 937 Garner’s Legal Style p 146 without doubt usage—consider alternatives before using try—omitting / no change extra information 1 dogmatic phrase 2 Prefer omitting if appropriate. further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 161 (clearly), 632 (overstatement), 926 (weasel words) Garner’s Legal Style pp 36, 192 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 W–24 W without limiting the generality of usage—never use try—without limiting / including, for example / in particular / including / for example / without limiting the scope of extra information 1 formal phrase 2 legalese examples of change 1 Without limiting the generality of subsection (3), … 2 … board a ship and operate it, including, without limiting the generality of the foregoing, for example, by moving it … without prejudice to the generality of usage—never use try—without limiting / including, for example / in particular / including / for example / without limiting the scope of extra information 1 formal phrase 2 legalese further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 581 (without prejudice) Law Words 1995 pp 95–8 (without prejudice as used in negotiations) with reference to usage—avoid using if possible try—for / about / concerning / recasting (using, eg I refer to) extra information compound preposition further reading Cutts p 30 Gowers’ Plain Words pp 4, 56 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 W–25 W with regard to usage—avoid using if possible try—about / concerning / to / in / for / recasting extra information compound preposition examples of change 1 I am writing to ask with regard to about the availability of suitable staff. 2 Similar considerations apply with regard to the review of decisions. further reading Cutts p 30 Fowler’s English Usage p 663 (regard) Garner’s Dictionary p 747 (regard (A)) Gowers’ Plain Words p 56 with respect to usage—consider alternatives before using try—about / for which / for / concerning / in relation to / no change extra information 1 connecting phrase 2 compound preposition 3 Prefer a simple preposition if appropriate. 4 With respect to should be used as a connecting phrase in instrument-making powers if the broadest power is wanted (but see LA, dict, pt 1, def in relation to). examples of change 1 any matter with respect to which for which provision may be made by a standard 2 a standard with respect to about industry-funded support arrangements further reading Cutts p 30 Garner’s Dictionary p 764 (respect) Garner’s Legal Style p 137 (respect) Gowers’ Plain Words p 56 with the exception of usage—never use try—other than / except / excluding extra information verbosity further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 55 Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 W–26 W with the object of usage—avoid using if possible try—to extra information verbosity example of change with the object of preventing to prevent accidents in the workplace further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 938 with the result that usage—avoid using if possible try—so that extra information verbosity further reading Gowers’ Plain Words p 260 workman / working man usage—never use try—worker / employee / working person extra information gender-specific word further reading Cwlth Style Manual pp 58 (Sex-neutral references to individuals), 59 (Occupational titles) Fowler’s English Usage pp 705–6 (sexist language) Garner’s Dictionary pp 789–803 (sexism), 943 Garner’s Legal Style p 203 Longman English Usage p 645 (sexism) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 W–27 W workmanlike usage—never use try—skilful / well made / businesslike / recasting extra information gender-specific word see also—man worthwhile usage—consider alternatives before using try—useful / valuable / promising / worth / recasting / no change (using more precise words) / no change extra information 1 vague word 2 Prefer a more precise alternative if appropriate 3 When used adjectively, worth needs an object. The object can be either while (ie the spending of time) or something else (eg having). It is not appropriate to describe something as simply being worth 4 It is permissible to use worth, but not worthwhile before an –ing word examples of change 1 Our meeting was worthwhile useful in solving the outstanding issues. 2 The trip was worthwhile worth making. further reading Fowler’s English Usage p 857 Garner’s Dictionary p 943 Gowers’ Plain Words p 269 Right Words pp 430–1 Strunk and White p 64 Working Words p 565 would usage—consider alternatives before using try—should / omitting / no change extra information 1 For the use of would and should, see should. 2 Would is often used as a hedge-word, qualifying the absoluteness of the verb following. Prefer the unqualified verb if appropriate (see would argue/contend/submit). example of change I would agree … further reading Garner’s Dictionary pp 943–4, 944 (would seem) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 W–28 W would argue / contend / submit usage—avoid using if possible try—contend / claim extra information timid phrase further reading Garner’s Legal Style pp 36, 146 writer see—the present writer; this writer writing see—in writing; instrument in writing; notice in writing; reduce to writing writing signed usage—avoid using if possible try—signed notice / signed document / signed instrument / recasting extra information 1 formal phrase 2 legalese example of change A member may resign by writing signed by the member and signed notice of resignation given to the Minister. written instrument usage—never use try—in writing / written notice / notice / document / instrument / recasting extra information redundancy further reading Garner’s Dictionary p 456 (instrument) Law Words 1995 p 42 Mellinkoff’s Dictionary p 319 (instrument) Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 W–29 W written notice usage—consider if use is necessary try—notice / no change extra information can be a redundancy example of no change The chief executive may, by written notice to the chairperson of the committee, give the committee a reference. example of change A member may resign by signed written notice of resignation given to the Minister. Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 W–30 Figures 0 see—nought 1 see—more than 1; one 2 see—two 12 am usage—consider alternatives before using try—12 noon / midday / midnight / no change extra information 1 Prefer an alternative. 2 The correct designation for the time at noon is 12 noon or midday, not 12 am (which strictly speaking means before noon). further reading Cambridge Style Guide p 38 Fowler’s English Usage p 46 Right Words p 272 [X] days usage—consider alternatives before using try—[Y] weeks/months / no change extra information 1 Prefer periods expressed in weeks or months rather than days if appropriate. This is consistent with normal usage. 2 See LA, dict, pt 1, defs calendar month, calendar year, financial year and month. example of change 14 days 2 weeks Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 Other–1 Use of Figures [X] months usage—consider alternatives before using try—[Y] year(s) / no change extra information 1 Prefer periods expressed in years rather than days, weeks or months if appropriate. This is consistent with normal usage. 2 See LA, dict, pt 1, defs calendar month, calendar year, financial year and month. example of change 24 months 2 years Words and Phrases: A Guide to Plain Legal Language October 2006 Other–2