Virtue: Aristotle and Confucius

advertisement

Virtue: Aristotle and Confucius

Virtue

• Focus is on “How should I live? What kind of a person should I be?”

• Rather than on “What should be done in this situation?”

• In other words, the focus in on personal character, rather than action.

• A good person is virtuous

– has the right character traits in the right balance.

What is a Virtue?

• General virtue

– an abiding character trait that makes one a good friend and a good citizen

– A golden mean between extremes.

• All humans should have general virtues, regardless of their particular circumstances.

Special Virtues

• An abiding character trait that

– helps you to fulfill your function in society well.

– as long as a reasonably good society would include this role.

• Vice

– a character trait that undermines your ability to function as a good friend, good citizen and to fulfill your function well.

Becoming Virtuous

• We are taught.

• We behave according to the dictates of virtue.

• We begin to understand what is virtuous.

• We want to be virtuous, but sometimes fail.

• Our desires and the dictates of virtue coincide.

Why be virtuous?

• We want others to be virtuous because we value good friends, and a good and efficient society. Fairness demands we be virtuous too.

• True human happiness can only be achieved in a virtuous life.

Sample virtues

• From Aristotle: courage, generosity, magnificence, high mindedness, gentleness, friendliness, truthfulness, wittiness, wisdom

• From Christian tradition: faith, hope, charity, chastity, piety, humility, obedience

Confucianism

• The morally superior person

– Has moral equals as friends,

– Is more concerned with duty than with desire,

– Always acts in accord with moral principles, but is not insensitive to others,

– Seeks to improve own virtues, but not others though others will be influenced by his/her example,

– Becomes prominent by helping others to be prominent.

Central Confucian virtues

• Humanity (jen): love others. You can have jen if you practice 5 things:

– Earnestness, liberality, truthfulness, diligence and generosity

• Propriety (li): follow the established rules of society to preserve harmony

• Filial piety (hsiao): support parents with reverence

Other Confucian virtues

• loyalty

• justice

• broadmindedness

• benevolence

• dignity

• wisdom

• courage

• righteousness

Decision Procedure for Deciding

What to Do

• What would a good friend do? What would a good citizen do?

• What special virtues should I have, given my role? What would a person with these virtues do?

• What kind of a person do I want to be? What would this person do in this situation?

• How will my actions influence my character? Do

I want to move in that direction?

Decision Procedure For

Assessing Character

• What virtues/vices did we see in this case?

• What role did these virtues/vices play?

• What will be the effect on character of behaving this way?

• What virtues should have been displayed?

• How would things have turned out differently if these virtues were displayed?

Download