July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
802.11 July 2009 Closing Plenary Reports
Date: 2009-07-17
Authors:
Name
Company
Adrian Stephens
Intel
Corporation
Submission
Address
Phone
email
+44 792 008
4900 (mobile)
adrian.p.stephens@intel.com
Slide 1
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Abstract
• This document is a digest of the closing reports of all
802.11 sub-groups for presentation at the July 2009
closing plenary meeting.
Submission
Slide 2
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
802.11 WG Editor’s Meeting (July 09)
Date: 2009-07-12
Authors:
Name
Affiliation
Peter Ecclesine
Cisco Systems
Submission
Address
Phone
email
petere@cisco.com
Slide 3
Adrian
PeterStephens,
EcclesineIntel
(Cisco
Corporation
Systems)
from slide 1 of 11-09/0753r2 by Peter Ecclesine (Cisco Systems)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Abstract
This document contains a agenda/minutes/actions/status as
recorded at the IEEE 802.11 Editors’ Meeting
Submission
Slide 4
Adrian
PeterStephens,
EcclesineIntel
(Cisco
Corporation
Systems)
from slide 2 of 11-09/0753r2 by Peter Ecclesine (Cisco Systems)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Agenda for 2009-07-14
•
•
•
•
•
•
Roll Call / Contacts / Reflector
Go round table and get brief status report
Review action items from previous meeting
Numbering Alignment process
Amendment Ordering / ANA Status / Draft Snapshots
MB (87% approval) discussion
– 15 mins
• Conference Calls
Submission
Slide 5
Adrian
PeterStephens,
EcclesineIntel
(Cisco
Corporation
Systems)
from slide 3 of 11-09/0753r2 by Peter Ecclesine (Cisco Systems)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Roll Call – 2009-07-14
•
Editor’s Present
– P802.11mb Amendment (REVmb) – Adrian Stephens
– P802.11n Amendment (HT) – Adrian Stephens
– P802.11p Amendment (WAVE) – Wayne Fisher
– P802.11u Amendment (IW) -- Necati Canpolat
– P802.11v Amendment (WNM) – Emily Qi
– P802.11w Amendment (SEC) – Nancy Cam-Winget
– P802.11y Amendment (CBP) – Peter Ecclesine
– P802.11z Amendment (TDLS) – Menzo Wentink
– P802.11aa Amendment (VTS) – Hang Liu
•
Also present:
•
IEEE Staff present:
–
Michelle Turner – staff editor for 802, m.turner@ieee.org
•
802.11 Editor’s Not Present
–
•
Bill Marshall
P802.11s Amendment (MESH) –Kazuyuki Sakoda (until end ‘09)
•
IEEE Staff not present and always welcome!
–
Kim Breitfelder – manager publishing, k.breitfelder@ieee.org?
–
Michael Kipness – our staff liaison, m.kipness@ieee.org?
•
Note: editors request that an IEEE staff member should be present at least during Plenary meetings
–
Submission
Michelle Turner is present at this plenary meeting
Slide 6
Adrian
PeterStephens,
EcclesineIntel
(Cisco
Corporation
Systems)
from slide 4 of 11-09/0753r2 by Peter Ecclesine (Cisco Systems)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Volunteer Editor Contacts
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
TGn – Adrian Stephens – adrian.p.stephens@intel.com
TGp – Wayne Fisher – wfisher@arinc.com
TGs – Temporary: Kazuyuki Sakoda - KazuyukiA.Sakoda@jp.sony.com
TGu – Necati Canpolat – necati.canpolat@intel.com
TGv – Emily Qi – emily.h.qi@intel.com
TGw – Nancy Cam-Winget – ncamwing@cisco.com
TGz – Menzo Wentink– mwentink@qualcomm.com
TGmb – Adrian Stephens – adrian.p.stephens@intel.com (TBC)
TGaa – Hang Liu – hang.liu@thomson.net
Editor Emeritus:
– TGk – Joe Kwak– joekwak@sbcglobal.net
– TGr – Bill Marshall – wtm@research.att.com
– TGy – Peter Ecclesine – pecclesi@cisco.com
Submission
Slide 7
Adrian
PeterStephens,
EcclesineIntel
(Cisco
Corporation
Systems)
from slide 5 of 11-09/0753r2 by Peter Ecclesine (Cisco Systems)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Round table status report
•
•
•
•
•
TGp – Current D7.01. Hope to go to recirc this week.
Tgaa – Current D0.01. Internal review
TGv – Current D6.01. Hope to go to recirc this week
TGn – Sources of D11 have gone to Michelle!
TGmb – D1.0 has 730 comments. Bill M and Lee A will
edit as well.
• TGu – Current D7.0 and hope to receive Conditional
Approval
• Michelle has completed the 802.11 MECs in a very
timely manner, and Terry C will do the publication
coordination
Submission
Slide 8
Adrian
PeterStephens,
EcclesineIntel
(Cisco
Corporation
Systems)
from slide 6 of 11-09/0753r2 by Peter Ecclesine (Cisco Systems)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Round Table Status Report (2)
• Michelle says to get the files to her as soon as possible
after the final SB recirculation
• TGz – Current D5.0, hope to recirc this week and
receive Conditional Approval
• TGw – Current D11.0, files have been sent to Michelle!
Submission
Slide 9
Adrian
PeterStephens,
EcclesineIntel
(Cisco
Corporation
Systems)
from slide 7 of 11-09/0753r2 by Peter Ecclesine (Cisco Systems)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Summary of actions – 2009-07-14
• Necati email to Michelle list of issues with templates
Submission
Slide 10
Adrian
PeterStephens,
EcclesineIntel
(Cisco
Corporation
Systems)
from slide 8 of 11-09/0753r2 by Peter Ecclesine (Cisco Systems)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Reflector Updates
• Each editor is expected to be on the reflector and
current.
• If you didn’t receive the meeting notice from the
reflector, please send email to
adrian.p.stephens@intel.com
• To be updated:
– None
Submission
Slide 11
Adrian
PeterStephens,
EcclesineIntel
(Cisco
Corporation
Systems)
from slide 9 of 11-09/0753r2 by Peter Ecclesine (Cisco Systems)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
IEEE Publication Status
• IEEE 802.11-2007 published and for free download
with Get802
– Published in June 2007
– Combines all existing amendments and includes maintenance work
by TGma
• Publications completed for 802.11k, 802.11r and
802.11y,
– 11k now available with Get802
– 11r now available with Get802
– 11y now available with Get802
Submission
Slide 12
Adrian
PeterStephens,
EcclesineIntel
(Cisco
Corporation
Systems)
from slide 10 of 11-09/0753r2 by Peter Ecclesine (Cisco Systems)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
MEC Status
• P802.11p D7.0 has gone through Mandatory Editorial
Coordination in June 2009
•
See 11-09-0659-00-000p-P802-11p D7 Mandatory Editorial Coordination MEC.doc
• P802.11u D6.0 has gone through Mandatory Editorial
Coordination in July 2009
See 11-09-0788-00-000u-P802-11u D7 Mandatory Editorial Coordination MEC.doc
• P802.11v D6.0 has gone through Mandatory Editorial
Coordination in July 2009
See 11-09-0801-00-000u-P802-11v D6 Mandatory Editorial Coordination MEC.doc
• P802.11z D5.0 has gone through Mandatory Editorial
Coordination in July 2009
See 11-09-0810-00-000u-P802-11z D5 Mandatory Editorial Coordination MEC.doc
Submission
Slide 13
Adrian
PeterStephens,
EcclesineIntel
(Cisco
Corporation
Systems)
from slide 11 of 11-09/0753r2 by Peter Ecclesine (Cisco Systems)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Alignment Process for 802.11/p/v
• The 08/0644r8 Numbering Spreadsheet has all changes
from publication of 11k and 11r and 11y (and 11n
D7.03, 11p D7.0, 11vD6.01 and 11w D7.0)
• 11w and 11n have to be updated, Adrian and Nancy to
check.
• Next will be 11u
Submission
Slide 14
Adrian
PeterStephens,
EcclesineIntel
(Cisco
Corporation
Systems)
from slide 12 of 11-09/0753r2 by Peter Ecclesine (Cisco Systems)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Amendment & other ordering notes
• Editors define publication order independent of
working group public timelines:
– Since official timeline is volatile and moves around
– Publication order helps provide stability in amendment numbering,
figures, clauses and other numbering assignments
– Editors are committed to maintain a rational publication order
• Numbering spreadsheet 08/0644:
– Succeeding amendments to do their respective updates
– Must match the official timeline after plenaries
Submission
Slide 15
Adrian
PeterStephens,
EcclesineIntel
(Cisco
Corporation
Systems)
from slide 13 of 11-09/0753r2 by Peter Ecclesine (Cisco Systems)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
ANA Announcements
• Current ANA announced to group is 802.11-09-0031r5. (6/6/2009)
– See https://mentor.ieee.org/802.11/file/08/11-09-0031-05-0000-ana-database-assigned-numbers.xls
– All new requests received by end of meeting will be uploaded and announced
via 802.11 WG reflector
• Procedure for ANA is contained in 07/0827r0.
– See http://mentor.ieee.org/802.11/public/07/11-07-0827-00-0000-assigned-number-authority-ana-mechanisms.ppt
• Editorial Guidance
– ANA assignments should be done before the time of moving from WG LB to
Sponsor ballot.
– If a resource number is not in the ANA Database, please use <ANA> in drafts!
– Editors to replace any ANA controlled resources numbers with <ANA> upon
incorporation of material into drafts.
Submission
Slide 16
Adrian
PeterStephens,
EcclesineIntel
(Cisco
Corporation
Systems)
from slide 14 of 11-09/0753r2 by Peter Ecclesine (Cisco Systems)
July 2009
•
•
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Amendment Ordering
Data as of July 2009
See http://grouper.ieee.org/groups/802/11/Reports/802.11_Timelines.htm
Amendment numbering is
editorial! No need to make
ballot comments on these
dynamic numbers!
Amendment Number
Task Group
REVCOM Date
802.11 Amendment 4
TGw
Sept 2009
802.11 Amendment 5
TGn
Jan 2010
802.11 Amendment 6
TGz
Jan 2010
802.11 Amendment 7
TGp
June 2010
802.11 Amendment 8
TGv
June 2010
802.11 Amendment 9
TGu
Sept 2010 – was May 2010
802.11 Amendment 10
TGs
Sept 2010
802.11 Revision
802.11mb
June 2011
802.11-2011 Amendment 1
TGaa
June 2011
802.11-2011 Amendment 2
TGac
Dec 2012
802.11-2011 Amendment 3
TGad
Dec 2012
Submission
Slide 17
Adrian
PeterStephens,
EcclesineIntel
(Cisco
Corporation
Systems)
from slide 15 of 11-09/0753r2 by Peter Ecclesine (Cisco Systems)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Email Your Draft Status Updates
• Each editor, please send update for next page via the
editor’s reflector no later than Thursday am2 to update
table on next page!
Submission
Slide 18
Adrian
PeterStephens,
EcclesineIntel
(Cisco
Corporation
Systems)
from slide 16 of 11-09/0753r2 by Peter Ecclesine (Cisco Systems)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Changes from last
report shown in red.
T
G
Draft Development Snapshot
Published or Draft Baseline Documents
802.11
k
r
y
w
n
z
p
v
u
s
mb
aa
Sourc
e
MEC
Style
Guide
Most current doc
shaded green.
Editor
Snapsho
t Date
w
2007
2008 2008 2008 9.0
Frame
7.2
Yes
2007
Nancy CamWinget
10-Mar
n
2007
2008 2008 2008 9.0 11.0
Frame
7.2
Yes
2009
Adrian
Stephens
16-July
z
2007
2008 2008 2008 10. 11.0 5.0
0
Word
Yes
2007
Menzo
Wentink
17-July
p
2007
2008 2008 2008 10. 11.0 5.0 7.02
0
Frame
7.2
Yes
2009
Wayne
Fisher
16-July
v
2007
2008 2008 2008 6.0
Frame
7.2
No
2007
Emily Qi
Nov
u
2007
2008 2008
s
2007
2008 2008 2008 9.0 10.0 4.0 6.01
m
b
2007
Inc
2008 2008 2008
Inc
Inc
Inc
a
a
11.0
7.0
6.0 6.04
-
-
2.0
4.0
4.01
2.0
-
-
4.0
4.02
Frame
7.2
No
2007
Necati
Canpolat
Nov
5.01
6.01 3.02
Frame
8.0
No
2007
Kazuyuki
Sakoda ,
pro-tem
16-July
Frame
7.2
No
2009
Adrian
Stephens
12-May
-
-
-
-
2.0
-
0.05
0.01
Submission
No
Hang Lui
Slide 19
Adrian
PeterStephens,
EcclesineIntel
(Cisco
Corporation
Systems)
from slide 17 of 11-09/0753r2 by Peter Ecclesine (Cisco Systems)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
MB discussion
• Document 11-09-0706-00-000m-revmb-wg-ballotcomments.xls – the comments themselves
• MIB comments
• Annex removal comments
• PHY removal comments
• Late renumbering allows voters to track folding in
recent amendments
• Renumbering before Sponsor means SB voters only see
one numbering throughout time
• Wednesday PM2 of REVmb comment resolution Editors discussion
Submission
Slide 20
Adrian
PeterStephens,
EcclesineIntel
(Cisco
Corporation
Systems)
from slide 18 of 11-09/0753r2 by Peter Ecclesine (Cisco Systems)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Conference Calls
•
•
•
•
Are they of any value?
Next Meeting: September 20-25, Waikoloa
Cancel a week in advance if no agenda items.
7 September noon EDT (t-2 weeks), three editors of
eight will go to Waikoloa
Submission
Slide 21
Adrian
PeterStephens,
EcclesineIntel
(Cisco
Corporation
Systems)
from slide 19 of 11-09/0753r2 by Peter Ecclesine (Cisco Systems)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Reference Material
Submission
Slide 22
Adrian
PeterStephens,
EcclesineIntel
(Cisco
Corporation
Systems)
from slide 20 of 11-09/0753r2 by Peter Ecclesine (Cisco Systems)
July 2009
•
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Editorial
Streamlining
Focus is on consistency across all TGs:
– Completed
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Streamlined ANA processes – 07/0827r0
Consistent format for REDLINE contributions across TGs – 07/0788r0
Consistent process for editorial comment resolution across TGs (WG & Sponsor) –
07/2050r0
– Guideline for technical vs. editorial, sample editorial comment responses
Format for comment reporting across TGs (WG & Sponsor) – 07/1990r0
(tool in 07/2116r0)
Stable numbering method (See 07/2810r0)
Consistent naming of redlines (See 07/2810r0)
Draft templates for FRAME (no Word) to help train new editors more rapidly
– Under Construction (in priority order)
Revise the editor’s guideline
Mentoring program – Name a mentor for each new editor
Request in future Plenary sessions Mondays 7:30pm Frame surgery
MIB element numbering and compiling – publish a rolled-up MIB of k/r/y
Guideline on non-technical front matter
Guideline describing expected editorial development and maturity of draft through
stages in 802.11 for consistency across TGs
7. Guidelines for primitives – ARC to consider
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
Submission
Slide 23
Adrian
PeterStephens,
EcclesineIntel
(Cisco
Corporation
Systems)
from slide 21 of 11-09/0753r2 by Peter Ecclesine (Cisco Systems)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Numbering of Annexes and Clauses
• Proposal: TGMb will fix the ordering of annexes
– Ample bad precedent set by 11k
– Bibliography should be the final annex per IEEE Standards Style
Guide
• Clause numbering has similar issue during rollup
– TGn clause 3a, 11r clause 11a, 11y clause 11.9a
• REVmb numbering will stay using “Amendment style”
numbering until the very last possible moment.
Submission
Slide 24
Adrian
PeterStephens,
EcclesineIntel
(Cisco
Corporation
Systems)
from slide 22 of 11-09/0753r2 by Peter Ecclesine (Cisco Systems)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Draft naming convention
• Drafts and redlines are .pdf files
• Syntax:
Draft <project>_<draft> [Redline [Compared to <project>_<draft>]].pdf
• Examples:
• Draft P802.11n_D8.0.pdf
• Draft P802.11n_D8.0 Redline.pdf
• Draft P802.11n_D7.04 Redline Compared to P802.11n_D7.03.pdf
Please use this convention for all drafts posted on the 802.11 website.
Submission
Slide 25
Adrian
PeterStephens,
EcclesineIntel
(Cisco
Corporation
Systems)
from slide 23 of 11-09/0753r2 by Peter Ecclesine (Cisco Systems)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Publication Work Plan
Note: to be included in the editor’s operations manual
Here is the workflow we have used for a number of years with IEEE staff on publication of 802.11
publications:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
Editors provide FRAME source and any freestanding graphics (Powerpoint, Visio. TIF) to staff at time of REVCOM
submission.
Editors provide a list of requests editorial corrections no later than REVCOM approval date.
Staff prepares a publication draft and highlights changes they have made and questions they need addressed or
confirmed. This draft is sent to Task Group Editor and the Working Group Technical Editor (me). This typically
occurs about 2-3 weeks after approval for publication, since the preparation work is usually (but not always) begun
ahead of approval. This is also typically the draft peer reviewed by IEEE staff.
The Task Group Editor responds to all questions on domain specific questions, with copy to Working Group editor
(me). This typically takes about 3-5 days.
The Working Group Technical Editor reviews responses from the Task Group editor, completes any responses, and
provides a list of WG officers and voting members valid for the document as of the opening day of the Sponsor ballot.
This typically only takes one additional day from the prior step as most of the work is done in parallel by the two
editors.
Final draft is submitted by the IEEE staff to Working Group Technical Editor and Task Group Editor for sign-off. Any
changes from the responses or IEEE peer review are highlighted and explained. This typically takes only one or two
days more after the responses are received from the editors.
Task Group Editor gives final approval. No changes are expected. This usually occurs within 24 hours.
Working Group Technical Editor signs off and provides draft to Working Group Chair. No changes are expected. This
usually occurs within 24 hours and in parallel with the previous step.
Working Group Chair sends email to sponsor and IEEE staff letting them know the Working Group has signed off on
the publication process.
Submission
Slide 26
Adrian
PeterStephens,
EcclesineIntel
(Cisco
Corporation
Systems)
from slide 24 of 11-09/0753r2 by Peter Ecclesine (Cisco Systems)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Terry Cole on Changes to MIB elements
• You can incrementally add to a MIB element without deprecation
at any level. That is, add new values and meaning pairs.
•
• You can change the description of a MIB element without
deprecation at any level. That is add new text clarifying or even
changing the meaning of the element to keep up with the standard.
•
• I would advise deprecation when changing the definition of some
value of a MIB from one thing to another. However, I don't know
of any rules requiring this.
Submission
Slide 27
Adrian
PeterStephens,
EcclesineIntel
(Cisco
Corporation
Systems)
from slide 25 of 11-09/0753r2 by Peter Ecclesine (Cisco Systems)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Publications: lessons learned
• When quoting baseline text inaccurately, the baseline text is
changed whether or not the changes were marked. The IEEE staff
will actually do the appropriate changes as if the task group had
actually intended to change the baseline.
– Drafts can minimally quote baseline text to minimize such changes
– Should revisit the decision to include full context during insertion
• Full Annex titles have to be shown in the amendment; more
importantly included “normative” vs. “informative”
– TGk inadvertently changed Annex A to be fully informative
– TGr battled to fix Annex A but caused ripples
– TGy 08-1215r1 has brief review of significant things changed for
publication
– In editor’s operations manual and during balloting, should comment that
Annexes should be fully titled with good reason to vote “No” in balloting
Submission
Slide 28
Adrian
PeterStephens,
EcclesineIntel
(Cisco
Corporation
Systems)
from slide 26 of 11-09/0753r2 by Peter Ecclesine (Cisco Systems)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Publications: lessons learned (cont’d)
• Acronym rules are inconsistent
– Styleguide doesn’t include definitions
– Every document is treated as standalone, thus first acronym reference
must be spelled out. Even though, other amendments or baseline may
have defined and used the acronym earlier.
– Goal should be to have as few changes between the final balloted
amendment and final published amendment.
• How do we deal with subjective decisions made by the IEEE copy
editors as their styles vary?
• Booleans should be capitalized: TRUE and FALSE
– when “set to”
• Booleans should be lower case: is true and is false (raise the issue
with Style Guide update)
Submission
Slide 29
Adrian
PeterStephens,
EcclesineIntel
(Cisco
Corporation
Systems)
from slide 27 of 11-09/0753r2 by Peter Ecclesine (Cisco Systems)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
WNG SC Agenda
Date: 2009-07-17
Authors:
Name
Address
Company
Phone
Email
Tk Tan
2121 Ringwood
Ave, San Jose, CA
95131
GCT
Semicondu
ctor
+1-408-434-8028
tktan@ieee.org
Submission
Slide 30
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 1 of 11-09/0897r0 by Tk Tan, GCT Semi
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Abstract
Closing report for Wireless Next
Generation (WNG) Standing Committee
(SC) for July 2009, San Francisco,
California
Submission
Slide 31
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 2 of 11-09/0897r0 by Tk Tan, GCT Semi
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Presentations
Session 1 (Tuesday AM1)
– 1 - 802.11 Energy Consumption and Policy - Nordman
– 2 - QoS for Management Frames – Montemurro
•
11-09/0817r0
– 3 - 802.11 in TVWS – Kennedy
•
11-09-0749-01-0wng-802-11-in-the-tvws.ppt
Session 2 (Wednesday PM1)
– 4 - Enhancement Technology for vehicular communications – Cho
•
11-09-0832-02-0wng-enhancement-technology-for-vehicular-communications.ppt
– 5 - WLAN Public Easements – Paine
•
11-09-0830-01-0wng-public-easements-for-802-11.ppt
– 6 - Enhanced Security for 802.11i – Harkins
•
11-09-0315-04-0wng-enhanced-security.ppt
– 7 - Broadband V2I Access for High Speed Transportation – Morioka
•
11-09-0111-03-0wng-broadband-v2i-access-for-high-speed-transportation.ppt
Submission
Slide 32
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 3 of 11-09/0897r0 by Tk Tan, GCT Semi
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Motion
• Request approval by IEEE 802 LMSC to form an
802.11 Study Group to Address QoS for Management
Frames [as described in doc 11-09/0817r1] with the
intent of creating a PAR and five criteria.
• By: Michael Montemurro
• Second: Cam-Winget
[WNG Result: 34 – For; 3 – Against; 14 – Abstain.]
Submission
Slide 33
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 4 of 11-09/0897r0 by Tk Tan, GCT Semi
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Motion
• Moved: Because of its suitability as a primary candidate for a
TVWS technology, and in the expectation that the FCC and Ofcom
will clarify their requirements for the database in the interim, the
802.11WG should begin a Study Group to develop PAR and 5
Criteria documents for approval by the EC at the Atlanta Plenary
in November 2009
• By: Rich Kennedy
• Second: Harry Worstell
• YES: 39
• NO: 0
• ABSTAIN: 15
Submission
Slide 34
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 5 of 11-09/0897r0 by Tk Tan, GCT Semi
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
IEEE P802.11
Architecture Committee
802.11 Plenary Report for July 2009 sessions
Submission
Slide 35
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 1 of <no doc number> by David Bagby, Calypso Ventures, Inc.
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Project Status - General
• Economic conditions are limiting project progress
– Key volunteers/contributors have been unable to attend for
multiple sessions
– Participant’s job demands are preventing significant effort between
F2F sessions
• The original SC intention was to work on tasks between sessions
– as the projects are not geared to “apply effort for 2 hours every 2 months”
• … however, this is where manpower has been most seriously
impacted.
• Available manpower best matches participation needed
for smaller, specific tasks
• Ex: MIB recommendation
Submission
Slide 36
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 2 of <no doc number> by David Bagby, Calypso Ventures, Inc.
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
ARC Future Activities & Sessions
• SC Chair & WG Chair have decided to “hibernate” the
ARC SC…
– until industry conditions improve, or
– a specific focused task is requested of the SC for which the is
sufficient volunteer interest
Therefore, ARC SC will not be scheduling formal
sessions in Sept
• If you have a topic that you would like ARC SC
assistance with, contact the SC chair and we’ll see
what we can do.
Submission
Slide 37
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 3 of <no doc number> by David Bagby, Calypso Ventures, Inc.
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Planning for Sept 2009
• No Sept F2F sessions planned
• ARC SC will schedule teleconferences
• Conf Calls
– Tues Aug 4th, Tues Sept 1st
– 12:00 ET
Submission
Slide 38
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 4 of <no doc number> by David Bagby, Calypso Ventures, Inc.
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
July 2009 TGmb Closing Report
Date: 2009-07-17
Authors:
Name
Matthew Gast
Submission
Affiliations
Address
Phone
email
Trapeze Networks
5753 W. Las Positas Blvd,
Pleasanton, CA 94588 USA
+1 (925) 474-2273
msg@trapezenetworks.com
Slide 39
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 1 of 11-09/0870r1 by Matthew Gast, Trapeze Networks
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Abstract
Closing report for TGmb for July 2009 interim meeting in
San Francisco, California, USA.
Submission
Slide 40
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 2 of 11-09/0870r1 by Matthew Gast, Trapeze Networks
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
TGmb Status
(now with a double-digit number of comments resolved…)
Photo credit: Luc Bollen (fatboyke on Flickr); used with permission
http://www.flickr.com/photos/fatboyke/2668411239/
Submission
Slide 41
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 3 of 11-09/0870r1 by Matthew Gast, Trapeze Networks
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Accomplishments
• No interpretation requests received
• Defined process for handling commments
• Discussed major issues
– Process for deprecating features
– Criteria for removing text
– Major editorial issues requiring WG-level coordination
• Approved resolutions for 13 comments
Submission
Slide 42
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 4 of 11-09/0870r1 by Matthew Gast, Trapeze Networks
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Onward to September
• No change to plan of record
• Requesting weekly teleconferences every Friday for 90
minutes at 11 am ET
• Goal: Recirculation letter ballot in September
Submission
Slide 43
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 5 of 11-09/0870r1 by Matthew Gast, Trapeze Networks
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Current TGmb Plan of Record
 May 2008 – Issue Call for Comment/Input
 July 2008 – begin process input and old Interpretation requests
Acknowledge previous Task Group referrals





Sept 2008 – PAR revision process started
Nov 2008 – close receipt of new input
Nov 2008 – WG/EC approval of PAR Revision
Dec 2008 – NesCom/SASB approval PAR Revision
May 2009 – First WG Letter ballot
– (includes All published Amendments as of May 2009)
• Sep/Nov 2009 – Recirc start
• January 2010 – Form Sponsor Pool (45 days)
• March 2010 – Sponsor Ballot Start
– (Include all published amendments as of March 2010)
• July 2010 – Sponsor Recirc
• March 2011 – WG/EC Final Approval
• June 2011 – RevCom/SASB Approval
Submission
Slide 44
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 6 of 11-09/0870r1 by Matthew Gast, Trapeze Networks
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
References
• Agenda: 11-09/0732r7
• Minutes: 11-09/0777r0
• Motions: 11-09/0861r0
Submission
Slide 45
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 7 of 11-09/0870r1 by Matthew Gast, Trapeze Networks
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
TGn Closing Report - July 16 ‘09
Date: 2009-July-09
Authors:
Name
Company
Address
Bruce Kraemer
Marvell
5488 Marvell Lane,
+1-321 -427Santa Clara, CA, 95054 4098
Submission
Slide 46
Phone
email
bkraemer@ marvell .com
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 1 of 11-09/0775r0 by Bruce Kraemer, Marvell
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Status Summary
• Comment Resolution Complete
• Balloting Complete
• EC presentation package complete
• Preparing for July 31st submissions in
preparation for Sept 9,10,11 PatCom,RevCom,
Standards Board meetings
Submission
Slide 47
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 2 of 11-09/0775r0 by Bruce Kraemer, Marvell
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
TGn - Sponsor Ballot Recirc #5
• IEEE P802.11n 10 day Recirculation Sponsor Ballot #5 asked the
question “Should P802.11n Draft 11.0 be forwarded to RevCom?”
• Ballot Opening Date: Tuesday
Ballot Closing Date: Friday
June 23 , 2009 - 23:59 ET
July 03, 2009 - 23:59 ET
• RESPONSES:
277 eligible people are in this ballot group.
199 affirmative votes
19 negative votes
17 abstention votes
=======
238 votes received = 86 % valid returns
= 7 % valid abstentions
APPROVAL RATE:
199 affirmative votes
=
19 total negative votes =
Submission
91.3 % affirmative
8.7 % negative
Slide 48
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 3 of 11-09/0775r0 by Bruce Kraemer, Marvell
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Primary San Francisco Meeting Documents
• SB #0-5 Comment Composite
• July Meeting Report
• Closing Report
11-09- 0024 r16
11-09- 0659 r1
11-09- 0775 r0
•
•
•
•
11-09- 0565 r0
11-09- 0681 r0
11-09- 0693 r0
11-09- 0738 r0
May Meeting Minutes
SB#3 Telecon minutes
SB#4 Telecon minutes
SB#5 Telecon minutes
• TGn Draft
• EC presentation
Submission
11.0
11-09-0674 r2
Slide 49
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 4 of 11-09/0775r0 by Bruce Kraemer, Marvell
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
2009 Timeline – July EC Unconditional
July
Jun
Jul
Prelim
EC package
Wed Jun 17
Aug
Sep
Jul
Aug
31
40 days
09
RevCom Meeting Thu Sep 10
StdsBd Meeting Fri Sep 11
Oct
Sep
09 10 11
Oct
Submission
Nov
EC review
Fri Jul 17
RevCom
Package
Fri Jul 31
13-17
Oct
16-20
50 days
Slide 50
Nov
Dec
789
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 5 of 11-09/0775r0 by Bruce Kraemer, Marvell
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
TGn Timeline – Proposal
Event Name
Accepted Dates
Previously
Published
Proposal
Final WG Approval
Jul ‘09
Jul ‘09
Final EC Approval
Jul ‘09
Jul ‘09
RevCom/ Stds Board Approval
Nov ‘09
Sep ‘09
Publication
Jan ‘10
Nov ‘09
Actual
PAR Approved
Sep ‘03
Initial WG Letter Ballot
Mar ‘06
Recirculation WG Letter Ballot
Oct ‘07
Form Sponsor Ballot Pool
Jul ‘08
Initial Sponsor Ballot
Dec ‘08
Recirculation Sponsor Ballot
Jan ‘09
Submission
Slide 51
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 6 of 11-09/0775r0 by Bruce Kraemer, Marvell
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
July ’09 to Sep ‘09 TGn Teleconference Plan
Call time: 11:00 – 13:00 ET
Wednesday
Blocking
events
July 15
Plenary
Call number: 916-356-2663
Topic
Meeting chair
Bridge #
Passcode
July 22
EC result
Bruce Kraemer
2
4057730
July 29
RevCom Pack
Bruce Kraemer
2
8731443
Aug 19
Cont Process
Bruce Kraemer
2
9809703
Aug 26
Cont Process
Bruce Kraemer
2
7149717
Sep 02
Cont Process
Bruce Kraemer
2
1598931
Stds Bd result
Bruce Kraemer
2
4433203
Aug 05
Aug 12
Sep 09
Stds Bd
Sep 16
Sep 23
Submission
Interim
Slide 52
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 7 of 11-09/0775r0 by Bruce Kraemer, Marvell
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
TGp Closing Report
Date: 2009-07-16
Author:
Name
Lee Armstrong
Submission
Affiliations
Employer:
Armstrong
Consulting,
Inc.
Affiliation:
USDoT
Address
Phone
email
132 Fomer Road
Southampton, MA
01073
USA
+1 617 620
1701
LRA@tiac.net
Slide 53
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 1 of 11-09/0893r0 by Lee Armstrong (Armstrong Consulting, Inc.)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Abstract
TGp closing report for July meetings
Submission
Slide 54
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 2 of 11-09/0893r0 by Lee Armstrong (Armstrong Consulting, Inc.)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
July Meetings Summary
•
•
•
•
LB151 completed since March meeting, passed
180 comments, 95 editorial
5 time slots during the week, plus one ad-hoc
All comments resolved
Submission
Slide 55
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 3 of 11-09/0893r0 by Lee Armstrong (Armstrong Consulting, Inc.)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Key Motions
• Authorize a procedural ballot in preparation for
recirculation ballot
Submission
Slide 56
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 4 of 11-09/0893r0 by Lee Armstrong (Armstrong Consulting, Inc.)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Status
•
•
•
•
Current draft D7.02 is on server
All comments resolved
Plan recirculation ballot after July meeting
Weekly teleconferences planned for every Thursday @
1500 Piscataway time (temporarily on hold until ballot
completion)
Submission
Slide 57
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 5 of 11-09/0893r0 by Lee Armstrong (Armstrong Consulting, Inc.)
July 2009
Submission
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Slide 58
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 6 of 11-09/0893r0 by Lee Armstrong (Armstrong Consulting, Inc.)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Motion to authorize a recirculation ballot
• Having approved comment resolutions for all of the
comments received from LB151 on TGp P802.11p D 7.0
as contained in document 11-09-0688-03-000p,
• Instruct the editor to prepare Draft P802.11p D 8.0
incorporating these resolutions and,
• Approve a 15 day Working Group Recirculation Ballot
asking the question “Should TGp P802.11p D 8.0 be
forwarded to Sponsor Ballot?”
• Moved: Clint Chaplin
Seconded: Justin McNew
Result:
13,0,1
Submission
Slide 59
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 7 of 11-09/0893r0 by Lee Armstrong (Armstrong Consulting, Inc.)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
TGs San Francisco Closing Report
Date: 2009-07-16
Author:
Submission
Slide 60
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 1 of 11-09/0901r0 by Donald Eastlake 3rd (Stellar Switches)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Abstract
TGs closing report for July 2009 meeting
Submission
Slide 61
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 2 of 11-09/0901r0 by Donald Eastlake 3rd (Stellar Switches)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Status
• Current TGs Draft is D3.02
• The current TGs comment resolution spread sheet is 1109/471r11 and shows the resolution of all comments
through Wednesday of this week.
• An annotated agenda for TGs at this meeting is available in
11-09/661r13
• The TGs draft minutes will be posted shortly as 1109/902r0
Submission
Slide 62
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 3 of 11-09/0901r0 by Donald Eastlake 3rd (Stellar Switches)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Next Steps
• TGs is holding teleconferences on Wednesdays through the
September Interim at 10:00 for up to 1 ½ hours. On the
Following Dates: July 29, August 19, September 16
• Goal for the September 2009 TGs meeting in Waikoloa,
Hawai‘i:
– Continue resolving Letter Ballot #147 comments
towards a TGs 1st WG Re-circulation Letter Ballot
Submission
Slide 63
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 4 of 11-09/0901r0 by Donald Eastlake 3rd (Stellar Switches)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Closing Report
Date: 2009-07-17
Authors:
Name
Stephen McCann
Submission
Company
Research in Motion
(RIM) UK Ltd
Address
200 Bath Road, Slough,
Berkshire, SL1 3XE, UK
Slide 64
Phone
email
+44 1753 667099
smccann@rim.com
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 1 of 11-09/0904r0 by Stephen McCann, RIM
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Abstract
Closing report for TGu Interworking with
External Networks for July 2009, San
Francisco, California, USA
Submission
Slide 65
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 2 of 11-09/0904r0 by Stephen McCann, RIM
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
• Re-circulation Letter Ballot 152 progress
–
–
–
–
Resolved all comments this week
6 submissions
Ask WG for a 15 day re-circulation letter ballot
Ask EC for conditional sponsor ballot
• Teleconferences
– Wednesdays at 11 ET and Fridays at 12 ET from 19th August 2009
through 16th September 2009 for 1 hour.
• Plans for September 2009
– Re-circ LB comment resolutions
Submission
Slide 66
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 3 of 11-09/0904r0 by Stephen McCann, RIM
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
July 2009 Closing Report
Date: 2009-07-17
Authors:
Name
Dorothy Stanley
Submission
Affiliations
Address
Phone
Aruba Networks 1322 Crossman Ave +1 630-363Sunnyvale, CA
1389
94089
email
dstanley@arubanetworks.
com
Slide 67
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 1 of 11-09/0900r0 by Dorothy Stanley (Aruba Networks)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Abstract
This document contains the TGv closing report for July
2009.
Submission
Slide 68
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 2 of 11-09/0900r0 by Dorothy Stanley (Aruba Networks)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Goals and Accomplishments
• Comment resolution from LB 150
– Completed resolution of LB 150 comments
• Recirculation Letter Ballot
– Approved motion for recirculation
• Conditional Approval for Sponsor Ballot
– Approved motion requesting conditional approval for sponsor
ballot from ExCom
• Teleconferences
– Friday, August 14 Noon Eastern, 2 hours
– Tuesday, Sept 1, 15 Noon Eastern, 2 hours
Submission
Slide 69
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 3 of 11-09/0900r0 by Dorothy Stanley (Aruba Networks)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Comment Processing Summary
Total
140
Technical
93
Editorial
47
Editor Done/To Do
42/98
Comment resolutions adopted to date
Comments remaining
Submission
140
0
Slide 70
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 4 of 11-09/0900r0 by Dorothy Stanley (Aruba Networks)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Documents for 09/0676 comment resolution
Category
Volunteers
Document
Resolutions
# CID
# remaining
Annex
Joe Kwak
n/a
n/a
0
0
Collocated Interference
Jari Jokela, Jing Zhu
n/a
n/a
0
0
Diagnostics
D. Stanley
09-689
6/16, 6/19
6
0
Event
Joe Kwak
09-689
6/16, 6/19
8
0
FMS
A. Thomson
09-685
6/19
1
0
General
D. Stanley
09-689
6/16, 6/19
3
0
Multicast Diagnostics
Alex Ashley
09-694
6/23
2
0
Location/Timing
A. Thomson/Ganesh
09-684/09-710
6/19,23,26,30,7/10
25/11
0/0
Proxy ARP
D. Stanley
n/a
n/a
0
0
Roaming Management
Emily Qi
n/a
n/a
0
0
TFS/SleepMode
Emily Qi
6/23, 7/10
1/1
0/0
STA Statistics
G. Venkatsan
09-712
6/30, 7/10
7
0
Time Advertisement
A. Thomson
09-686
6/26, 7/10
13
0
TIM Broadcast
M. Wentink
09-689
6/16, 6/19
1
0
Traffic Generation
Moo-Ryong Jeong
n/a
n/a
0
0
Virtual AP
Qi Wang
09-696
6/23
5
0
TCLAS
G. Venkatsan
09-689
6/16, 6/19
4
0
Channel Usage
E. Qi
6/23
1
0
Directed Multicast
E. Qi
6/23, 6/30, 7/10
7
0
Submission
Slide 71
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 5 of 11-09/0900r0 by Dorothy Stanley (Aruba Networks)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Output Documents
• 11-09-0900-00-000v-TGv-July-2009-closing-report.ppt
• 11-09-0675-06-000v-July-2009-agenda.ppt
• 11-09-0842-00-000v-July-2009-meeting notes
Submission
Slide 72
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 6 of 11-09/0900r0 by Dorothy Stanley (Aruba Networks)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Motion - Recirculation WG Letter Ballot
• Having approved comment resolutions for all of the
comments received from LB150 on TGv Draft 6.0,
instruct the editor to prepare Draft 7.0 incorporating
these resolutions and
• Approve a 15 day Working Group Recirculation Ballot
asking the question “Should P802.11v Draft 7.0 be
forwarded to Sponsor Ballot?”
• Mover: Ganesh Venkatesan
• Seconder: Emily Qi
• Result: 9-0-2
Submission
Slide 73
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 7 of 11-09/0900r0 by Dorothy Stanley (Aruba Networks)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Motion - Conditional Approval for Sponsor Ballot
•
•
Approve document 11-09-720-01 as the report to the IEEE 802 Executive
Committee on the requirements for conditional approval to forward TGV to
Sponsor Ballot, and
Request the IEEE 802 Executive Committee to conditionally approve
forwarding the TGV Draft meeting conditional approval requirements to
sponsor ballot. Note: Approval for the addition of a myballot version of the
comments to a revision of 09-720 is given.
•
•
TGv vote:
Moved: Joe Kwak Seconded: Ganesh Venkatesan Result: 8-0-3
Submission
Slide 74
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 8 of 11-09/0900r0 by Dorothy Stanley (Aruba Networks)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
TGv Timeline – Updated July, 2009
• Initial Working Group Letter Ballot: July 07 – completed
– Jan 08 – D2.0, May 08 – D3.0, Nov 08 – D4.0
• Re-circulation Working Group Letter Ballot: November 08 (D4.0)
– Mar 09 – D5.0, May 09 – D 6.0, July 09 – D7.0, D7.0(unchanged)
• Form Sponsor Ballot Pool: August 09 (was June 09)
• Initial Sponsor Ballot: Oct 09 (was Sept)
– Octt 09 – D7.0
• Approved Sponsor Ballot: Nov 09
– Feb 09 – D8.0, March 09 - D9.0, April D10.0, May D11.0
– May 12th ( or so) for Revcom June Approval
• Final WG/EC Approval: July 2010
• RevCom/Standards Board Approval: June 4th/June 5th(or so)
• Note: TGv PAR is authorized through Dec 2010
Submission
Slide 75
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 9 of 11-09/0900r0 by Dorothy Stanley (Aruba Networks)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Goals for September 2009
• Comment resolution
• Recirculation Letter Ballot
Submission
Slide 76
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 10 of 11-09/0900r0 by Dorothy Stanley (Aruba Networks)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
References
Submission
Slide 77
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 11 of 11-09/0900r0 by Dorothy Stanley (Aruba Networks)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
IEEE 802.11 TGw July Closing Report
Date: 2009-07-17
Authors:
Name
Jesse Walker
Submission
Company
Address
Phone
email
Intel Corporation
2111 N.E. 25th Ave,
Hillsboro, OR USA
+1-503-7121849
jesse.walker@intel.com
Slide 78
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 1 of 11-09/0888r0 by Jesse Walker, Intel Corporation
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Abstract
This presentation contains the closing report for the
July 2009 meeting of IEEE 802.11 TGw
Submission
Slide 79
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 2 of 11-09/0888r0 by Jesse Walker, Intel Corporation
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
July Meeting Objectives
• July Meeting Objectives
– Consider motion to ask ExCom for approval to public P802.11w
P11.0
Submission
Slide 80
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 3 of 11-09/0888r0 by Jesse Walker, Intel Corporation
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Accomplishments
• Motion: Request the IEEE 802.11 Working Group adopt the
following motion:
Approve document 11-09/795r1 as the report to the IEEE 802 Executive
Committee on the requirements for approval to forward P802.11w
D11.0 to RevCom, and
Request the IEEE 802 Executive Committee to forward P802.11w D11.0
to RevCom.
P802.11w had a 94% approval on the last Recirculation Sponsor Ballot.
There are 6 disapprove voters representing 44 unsatisfied comments.
• Mover: Jouni Malinen
• Seconder: Kapil Sood
• Result: 7-0-0 (motion passes)
Submission
Slide 81
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 4 of 11-09/0888r0 by Jesse Walker, Intel Corporation
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Meeting Documents
• 11-09/0798r1 – meeting agenda
• 11-09/0877r0 – meeting minutes
Submission
Slide 82
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 5 of 11-09/0888r0 by Jesse Walker, Intel Corporation
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
TGz San Francsico Closing Report
Date: 2009-07-16
Authors:
Name
Menzo Wentink
Submission
Company
Address
Phone
email
Qualcomm
Straatweg 66,
Breukelen, the
Netherlands
+31-65-1836231
mwentink@qualcomm
.com
Slide 83
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 1 of 11-09/0896r0 by Menzo Wentink (Qualcomm)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
TGz Accomplishments in San Francisco
• TGz resolved all of the comments received on LB153
– The approved comment resolutions are in 09/739r4
– Approved a 15-day recirculation ballot on TGz draft 6.0
– The current approval rate is at 96%, after post-ballot vote changes
• Prepared a report to the EC to request for conditional
approval for 802.11z to go to Sponsor Ballot
– 8 unsatisfied comments remain, which will be carried forward
– The report to the EC is in 09/879r2
Submission
Slide 84
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 2 of 11-09/0896r0 by Menzo Wentink (Qualcomm)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
TGz Goals for Hawaii
• The goal for Hawaii is to work on the comments
received on the third recirculation ballot
Submission
Slide 85
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 3 of 11-09/0896r0 by Menzo Wentink (Qualcomm)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
802.11aa – Robust Audio Video Transport Streaming
San Francisco Closing Report
Date: 2009-07-17
Authors:
Name
Affiliation
Address
Phone
email
Ganesh
Venkatesan
Alex Ashley
Intel
Corporation
NDS Ltd
JF3-336 2111NE
25th Ave
+1 503 334
6720
Ganesh.Venkatesan@intel
.com
Submission
One London Road, Staines, +44 1784 848770
Middlesex, TW18 4EX,
England
aashley@nds.com
Slide 86
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 1 of 11-09/0891r0 by Ganesh Venkatesan, Intel Corporation
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Abstract
TGaa Closing Report for the IEEE 802.11 San
Francisco Session (July 2009)
Submission
Slide 87
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 2 of 11-09/0891r0 by Ganesh Venkatesan, Intel Corporation
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Goals for the session
•
•
Discuss [, adopt] proposals corresponding to graceful degradation
and intra-AC [, intra-stream] prioritization
OBSS
o
o
•
Joint meeting with 802.1AVB:
o
o
o
•
•
Submission
Converge on the TGaa solution to OBSS
Discuss TGaa goals for OBSS with TGac
TSpec mapping
Triggered 802.11k traffic stream/category statistics
Other requirements on 802.11 that may be useful to AVB
Resolve comments from Internal review of Draft D0.01
Review timeline
Slide 88
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 3 of 11-09/0891r0 by Ganesh Venkatesan, Intel Corporation
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Technical Presentations
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
Stream Classification Service (09/725r0)
Implementation for Intra-AC Differentiated Services (09/0022r1)
Applicability of .11s MCCA to HCCA OBSS (09/660r3)
OBSS Sharing with Access Fraction (09/662r2)
40MHz Channel Selection (09/740r0)
HCCAOP Scheme – Efficiency and Sharing 09/666r3)
Proposal for OBSS (09/757r0)
Agenda for the joint meeting with 802.1AVB (09/787r0)
20MHz versus 40MHz for Video (09/805r0)
OSQAP OBSS Requirements Compliancy (09/882r0)
Neighborhood Capture and OBSS (09/844r0)
Submission
Slide 89
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 4 of 11-09/0891r0 by Ganesh Venkatesan, Intel Corporation
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Accomplishments
1. Listened to 11 technical presentations
2. Adopted the Drop Precedence submission into
TGaa draft (726r1)
3. Listened to the complete OBSS solution (757r1)
and started evaluating the proposal against the
requirements document.
4. Met jointly with 802.1AVB (see next slide)
5. Decided not to meet in the September Interim
6. Teleconference schedule
7. Timeline review and noted a 4 month slip
Submission
Slide 90
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 5 of 11-09/0891r0 by Ganesh Venkatesan, Intel Corporation
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Topics at the Joint meeting with 802.1AVB
1. What is the worst case delay when streaming under different
conditions over a 802.11 link?
2. Is there a mechanism specified in 802.11 to propagate the worst
case delay under current conditions, to upper layers?
3. 802.11 TSPEC mapping to 802.1Qav TSPEC
4. How are QoS errors fed back from the 802.11 MAC?
5. SRP over 802.11 – need for relaying stream information (09/403r0)
– list choices, pros/cons of each for discussion jointly
6. Status Update on 802.11aa
7. Status Update on 802.11v
8. Goals for the November 2009 joint meeting
Submission
Slide 91
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 6 of 11-09/0891r0 by Ganesh Venkatesan, Intel Corporation
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
802.11 Interim – September 2009
TGaa will not be meeting in Waikoloa
Submission
Slide 92
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 7 of 11-09/0891r0 by Ganesh Venkatesan, Intel Corporation
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
802.1Qat Sponsor Ballot Pool
• 802.1Qat will be forming a sponsor
ballot pool soon
• Encourage all SA members interested
in 802.1Qat (and how it should work
with 802.11) to join the pool
Submission
Slide 93
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 8 of 11-09/0891r0 by Ganesh Venkatesan, Intel Corporation
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Goals for the November Plenary
Complete internal review, compile comments and resolve
them
Start November Plenary with Draft 0.02
Complete tasks that came out of the joint meeting with AVB
Listen to technical proposals
Make progress toward addressing all PAR scope items
Meet jointly with 802.1AVB
Submission
Slide 94
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 9 of 11-09/0891r0 by Ganesh Venkatesan, Intel Corporation
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Teleconferences
Mondays 11:00-12:30 Hrs ET on the
following days:
July 27, Aug 10, Aug 24, Sep 07, Oct 19,
Nov 02 and Nov 30.
Submission
Slide 95
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 10 of 11-09/0891r0 by Ganesh Venkatesan, Intel Corporation
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
TGac July 2009 Closing Report
Date: 2009-07-16
Authors:
Name
Affiliations
Address
Osama Aboul-Magd
Submission
Slide 96
Phone
email
613-599-5078
Osama53@rogers.com
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 1 of 11-09/0887r0 by Osama Aboul-Magd
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Abstract
This document is the closing report for the TGac for the
July 2009 session.
Submission
Slide 97
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 2 of 11-09/0887r0 by Osama Aboul-Magd
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Work Completed
•
A new revision of the TG Channel Models Addendum document was
approved by the TG (09/0308r6).
–
–
•
A new revision of the Functional Requirements and Evaluation
Methodology document was presented. A motion passed to accept
document 09/0451r7 as the baseline document.
–
•
•
Future enhancements to Enterprise simulation scenarios are expected.
TGaa presentation on progress related to OBSS issues
–
•
Consensus on the AoD and AoA ranges and distributions.
Need more work on Doppler model.
OBSS related presentations highlight the TG need to address OBSS issues for all types of
traffic.
Proposals to introduce changes to the TG selection procedure. The
discussion will continue during September meeting.
Number of technical presentations on UL traffic models and MU-MIM),
preamble issues, technology assessment against use cases, and SDMA.
Submission
Slide 98
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 3 of 11-09/0887r0 by Osama Aboul-Magd
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
September 2009 Goals
• Continue the work on Channel models. Measurement results are
expected to help close issues related to Doppler time.
• Continue the work on functional requirements and evaluation
methodology to enhance enterprise simulation scenario.
• Continue to discuss changes to the selection procedure with the
aim to reach a conclusion by the end of the meeting.
• Continue the work related to Specification Frames and the related
functional blocks
• Submissions
Submission
Slide 99
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 4 of 11-09/0887r0 by Osama Aboul-Magd
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Conference Call Times
• August 13, 2009
– 11:00 ET
• August 27, 2009
– 20:00 ET
• September 10, 2009
– 11:00 ET
Submission
Slide 100
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 5 of 11-09/0887r0 by Osama Aboul-Magd
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
TGad July 2009 Closing Report
Date: 2009-07-17
Authors:
Name
Eldad Perahia
Submission
Company
Address
Phone
email
Intel
Corporation
2111 NE 25th Ave
Hillsboro, OR 97124
503-712-8081
eldad.perahia@intel.com
Slide 101
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 1 of 11-09/0746r0 by Eldad Perahia, Intel Corporation
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Abstract
This document is the closing report for the TGad for the
July 2009 session.
Submission
Slide 102
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 2 of 11-09/0746r0 by Eldad Perahia, Intel Corporation
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Work Completed (1/2)
•
•
Task group documents
– 09/0228r5, TGad Functional Requirements, Eldad Perahia
– 09/0786r0, Selection Procedure, Eldad Perahia
– 09/0709r2, Lightly Compressed Video Traffic Modeling, Carlos Cordeiro
– 09/0296r8, TGad Evaluation Methodology, Eldad Perahia
– 09/0769r0, Service Coverage Extension in IEEE 802.11 TGad, Kapseok Chang
– 09/0768r3, Proposed Texts for Functional Requirement Document Draft, Sunggeun
Jin
– 09/0797r0, Topology Considerations on Simulation, Sungrae Cho
– 09/0835r0, Use cases, John Benko
Channel Modeling (802.15.3c joint meeting)
– 09/0874r0, Propagation measurements and considerations in conference room,
living room and cubicle environments, Hirokazu Sawada
– 09/0860r0, Updated conference room channel model, Alexander Maltsev
– 09/0334r0, Channel Models for 60 GHz WLAN Systems, Alexander Maltsev
– 09/0743r0, Measurement campaign at 60 GHz in the living room environment at
TUBS, Thomas Kürner
– 09/0744r0, Influence of moving people on the 60 GHz channel –a literature study,
Thomas Kürner
– 09/0854r0, Implementation of 60 GHz WLAN Channel Model, Roman
Maslennikov
Submission
Slide 103
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 3 of 11-09/0746r0 by Eldad Perahia, Intel Corporation
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Work Completed (2/2)
• Other Technical submissions
– 09/0782r0, Spatial Reuse, Carlos Cordeiro
– 09/0802r0, The Lund High Speed Wireless Center: 60 GHz Research,
John Anderson
– 09/0796r0, Contention-based Directional MAC Schemes, Sungrae Cho
– 09/0803r0, Multi-Channel Multi-Directional Contention Access, John
Stine
– 09/0804r0, Contention Mechanisms for Quality of Service and Energy
Conservation, John Stine
• Motion to adopt 09/0228r5 as the first draft of the TGad functional
requirements passed by a vote of 33/6/13
Submission
Slide 104
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 4 of 11-09/0746r0 by Eldad Perahia, Intel Corporation
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Goals for September
• Continue working on task group documents
• Technical contributions
• Joint meeting w/ 802.15.3c
Submission
Slide 105
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 5 of 11-09/0746r0 by Eldad Perahia, Intel Corporation
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Conference call times
• August 20 – 10:00-12:00 ET
• September 3 –
– 10:00-12:00 ET
– Channel modeling
• Possible topics
– TG documents
•
•
•
•
Functional Requirements
Evaluation Methodology
Selection Procedure
Channel modeling
– Summary of 15.3c documents for reference (system design, channel
model)
– Coexistence
Submission
Slide 106
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 6 of 11-09/0746r0 by Eldad Perahia, Intel Corporation
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
JTC1 Ad Hoc July 2009 Closing Report
Date: 2009-07-17
Authors:
Name
Jesse Walker
Submission
Company
Address
Phone
email
Intel Corporation
2111 N.E. 25th Ave,
Hillsboro, OR USA
+1-503-7121849
jesse.walker@intel.com
Slide 107
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 1 of 11-09/0889r0 by Jesse Walker, Intel Corporation
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Abstract
This presentation summarizes the July 2009 meeting of
the IEEE 802.11 JTC1 Ad Hoc.
Submission
Slide 108
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 2 of 11-09/0889r0 by Jesse Walker, Intel Corporation
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
JTC1 July Meeting Goals
• Meeting Objectives for San Francisco
– Review outcome of Tokyo SC6 meeting June 1-5
– Identify next steps
Submission
Slide 109
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 3 of 11-09/0889r0 by Jesse Walker, Intel Corporation
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Accomplishments
• Reviewed outcome of of the Tokyo SC6 meeting
– Likely that China will ask for a DIS fast track for WAPI as an IS
– SC6 to collect input from NBs on changes desired to PSDO
• Ad Hoc to generate suggestions for improvements to
PSDO by end of Waikoloa meeting
– IEEE 802.11 needs to receive comments from ballots, and a
process to respond
• Andrew Myles will assume the JTC1 Ad Hoc chair
after the San Francisco meeting concludes
Submission
Slide 110
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 4 of 11-09/0889r0 by Jesse Walker, Intel Corporation
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
September Meeting Planning
• Objectives
– Finish identifying potential improvements to PSDO
– Identify any actions required to support the liaison between IEEE
802 and ISO/IEC JTC1/SC6 related to 802.11
Submission
Slide 111
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 5 of 11-09/0889r0 by Jesse Walker, Intel Corporation
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
IEEE 802.11 Regulatory Ad Hoc
July 2009 Closing Report
Date: 2009-07-14
Authors:
Name
Rich Kennedy
Submission
Affiliations
Address
Phone
email
Research In
Motion
7305 Napier Trail
Austin, TX 78729
+1-972-207-3554
rikennedy@rim.com
Slide 112
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 1 of 11-09/0899r0 by Rich Kennedy, Research In Motion
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Abstract
This is the closing report of the first meeting of the IEEE
802.11 Regulatory Ad Hoc Group, at the July IEEE 802
Plenary in San Francisco.
Submission
Slide 113
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 2 of 11-09/0899r0 by Rich Kennedy, Research In Motion
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Proceedings
• Discussion of the revision of EN 300 328 (v1.8.1)
– Why it is being revised
– The participants
– The approach – find a Medium Utilization formula for fair sharing
by non-contention based access technologies
• The Formula: MU = PSD x Time; MU<[10]%
• What 802.11 must do
– Evaluate the formula and suggest changes as required
– Assist development of technology-neutral text for coexistence
measurement portion of the specification
– Attend and vote at the next ERM TG11 meeting (Oct 10 – 12)
• Plan for teleconferences with 802.15 and TG11 Chair
Submission
Slide 114
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 3 of 11-09/0899r0 by Rich Kennedy, Research In Motion
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Teleconference Schedule
• Thursdays at 9:00am PDT
–
–
–
–
Submission
August 6th
August 27th
September 17th
October 8th
Slide 115
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 4 of 11-09/0899r0 by Rich Kennedy, Research In Motion
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
References
• ERM_TG11(21)22 - Notes of the 21st meeting of TG11
(ETSI membership required)
– ETSI Collaborative Portal > ERM TG11 > Meeting Documents >
ERMTG11#21 > ERM_TG11(21)22r1
Submission
Slide 116
Rich
Adrian
Kennedy,
Stephens,
Research
Intel Corporation
In Motion
from slide 5 of 11-09/0899r0 by Rich Kennedy, Research In Motion
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Feedback on New WG PARs from WG11
for July Plenary
Date: 2009-07-13
Authors:
Name
Affiliations Address
Bruce Kraemer
Marvell
Jon Rosdahl
CSR
Submission
Phone
Marvell Lane,
+1-321-751-3988
Santa Clara, CA 95054
Highland, Utah, USA
+1-801-492-4023
email
bkraemer@ieee.org
jrosdahl@ieee.org
Slide 117
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 1 of 11-09/0894r0 by Bruce Kraemer (Marvell), Jon Rosdahl (CSR)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Pars under consideration by 802 EC July
2009
• Submitted Comments
• 802.21.1 New standard for Support for Emergency Services, PAR and 5C
• Submitted Nothing
• 802.1Qbc, Provider Bridging -- Remote Customer Service Interface, PAR
and 5C
• 802.1Qbe, MIRP, PAR and 5C
• 802.1Qbf, PBB-TE Infrastructure Protection, PAR and 5C
• PAR extension request for P802.1AR, PAR
• PAR extension request for P802.11n, PAR
Submission
Slide 118
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 2 of 11-09/0894r0 by Bruce Kraemer (Marvell), Jon Rosdahl (CSR)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Documents
•
•
•
•
11-09-0778 r2
21-09-0122 r1
21-09-0027 r8
21-09-0125 r0
Submission
WG11 PAR comments
Emergency Services PAR Supporting Info
Emergency Services PAR and 5C
Emergency Services ad hoc Report
Slide 119
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 3 of 11-09/0894r0 by Bruce Kraemer (Marvell), Jon Rosdahl (CSR)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Response from WG21 to comments
• Based on all the comments received on the Emergency
Services PAR , 802.21 WG has decided to withdraw this
PAR from further consideration at this time.
• WG21 will bring a request for an ECSG on this topic to
the EC for consideration in the Friday closing meeting.
Submission
Slide 120
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 4 of 11-09/0894r0 by Bruce Kraemer (Marvell), Jon Rosdahl (CSR)
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0868r0
Ethertype
•
Based on a a received letter ballot comment, TGz is requesting a change to the
Ethertype 890d registration information. The current information is:
890d
IEEE 802.11
4960 Almaden Expy
Suite 310
San Jose CA 95118-2007
UNITED STATES
•
IEEE P802.11r AP-AP Communication
The IEEE P802.11r amendment is currently
in Sponsor Ballot. The protocol is defined
in the IEEE P802.11r draft.
But since TGz and TGv are now also proposing to use the 890d Ethertype,
something like the following would probably be more appropriate:
890d
IEEE 802.11
IEEE 802.11 Management Protocol
4960 Almaden Expy
Suite 310
San Jose CA 95118-2007
UNITED STATES
Submission
Slide 121
Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation
from slide 1 of <no doc number> by Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation