Arts Education RESA Training February and March 2015 Resources and Tools NC Arts Education Wiki http://ances.ncdpi.wikispaces.net/ NCDPI Arts Education Listserv join-artsed@lists.dpi.state.nc.us K-8 Standards Quick Reference Guides for the NC Standard Course of Study ArtsEdSearch • the nation’s first online research and policy clearinghouse focused entirely on student and educator outcomes associated with arts learning in and out of school. Preparing Students for the Next America: The Benefits of an Arts Education “Growing Success for All Students” Focusing Question • How can arts educators look at student growth as a part of their regular instructional practices? Understanding Objectives and Alignment Policy and Legislation •Basic Education Program (§ 115C-81) The NC Standard Course of Study NC Standard Course of Study – Arts Education – Career and Technical Education – English Language Arts (and Literacy in History/Social Studies, Science, and Technical Subjects) – English Language Development* – Guidance* – Healthful Living (Health & Physical Education) – Information and Technology* – Mathematics – Science – Social Studies – World Languages The First Verb Revised Bloom’s Taxonomy • Provides the framework used for all NC Essential Standards • Common language used for all Essential Standards • Two-Dimensional: Cognitive Process and Knowledge Dimension Image Citation 12 Name a character from television, movies, books, or video games who would embody the verbs…. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Remember Understand Apply Analyze Evaluate Create Revised Bloom’s Taxonomy 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Remember Understand Apply Analyze Evaluate Create Revised Bloom’s Taxonomy Let’s practice making paper cranes. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Remember Understand Apply Analyze Evaluate Create Apply Revised Bloom’s Taxonomy How can we put these individual paper cranes together to create a kind of unified sculpture about peace that no one has seen before? 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Remember Understand Apply Analyze Evaluate Create Create Revised Bloom’s Taxonomy Critique the performance Evaluate 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Remember Understand Apply Analyze Evaluate Create Revised Bloom’s Taxonomy Show how the major technical elements are used to enhance the production. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Remember Understand Apply Analyze Evaluate Create Understand Revised Bloom’s Taxonomy 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Remember Understand Apply Analyze Evaluate Create How were the elements of music used to make this piece interesting? Revised Bloom’s Taxonomy 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Remember Understand Apply Analyze Evaluate Create Identify whole, half, quarter, eighth, sixteenth notes.... • Definitions of Cognitive Processes – Sub-verbs • Assessment Examples Revised Bloom’s Taxonomy Remember- Retrieve relevant knowledge from longterm memory. ● ● ● ● Recognize Identify Retrieve Recall Revised Bloom’s Taxonomy “The Marilyn Diptych” was created in: A.1832 B.1922 C.1962 D.2012 Revised Bloom’s Taxonomy Understand- Construct meaning from instructional messages, including oral, written, and graphic communication. ● ● ● ● ● ● Interpret Exemplify Summarize Infer Compare Explain Revised Bloom’s Taxonomy What is the painting about? What does it remind you of? What do you wonder about? What is the story? What does it mean? Revised Bloom’s Taxonomy Classify this random group of prints based on the printing processes intaglio, woodblock, and screenprint. Revised Bloom’s Taxonomy How are these two images similar? How are they different? Revised Bloom’s Taxonomy Apply- Carry out or use a procedure in a given situation. ● ● ● ● Execute Implement Carry out Use Revised Bloom’s Taxonomy Use your pencil, pen or marker to create a value study in 7 boxes starting with white on the left and proceeding gradually and evenly to black on the right. You may use any kind of marking technique including, shading, cross hatching, random marks, or stippling. Revised Bloom’s Taxonomy 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Remember Understand Apply Analyze Evaluate Create Use steady tone while performing this piece. Revised Bloom’s Taxonomy Analyze- Break material into its constituent parts and determine how the parts relate to one another and to an overall structure or purpose. ● Differentiate ● Organize Revised Bloom’s Taxonomy How did Picasso use black and white in this painting to create a mood of sadness and to document a tragic event? Revised Bloom’s Taxonomy Evaluate- Make judgments based on criteria and standards. ● Critique ● Judge Revised Bloom’s Taxonomy Which of these works of art uses color best to create a sense of happiness? Revised Bloom’s Taxonomy Create- Put elements together to form a coherent or functional whole; reorganize elements into a new pattern or structure. ● ● ● ● ● ● Generate Hypothesize Plan Design Produce Construct Revised Bloom’s Taxonomy 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Remember Understand Apply Analyze Evaluate Create Compose an original piece that is 8 measures long using whole, half, quarter….. Which 5th grade Clarifying Objectives would you choose for a lesson in which students made Origami Paper Cranes? Visual Arts Revised Bloom’s Taxonomy Preparation Sheet Lesson: 5th Grade Paper Crane Strand + Clarifying Objective Verb Evidence First Point in Time Evidence Second Point in Time Visual Arts Revised Bloom’s Taxonomy Preparation Sheet Lesson: 5th Grade Paper Crane Strand + Clarifying Objective Visual Literacy 5.V.2.2 Use ideas and imagery from the global environment as sources for creating art Verb Evidence First Point in Time Evidence Second Point in Time Visual Arts Revised Bloom’s Taxonomy Preparation Sheet Lesson: 5th Grade Paper Crane Strand + Clarifying Objective Verb Visual Literacy Use 5.V.2.2 Use ideas and imagery from the global environment as sources for creating art Evidence First Point in Time Evidence Second Point in Time Visual Arts Revised Bloom’s Taxonomy Preparation Sheet Lesson: 5th Grade Paper Crane Strand + Clarifying Objective Verb Visual Literacy Use 5.V.2.2 Use ideas and imagery from the global environment as sources for creating art Evidence First Point in Time 1. Use paper folding and patterns to make an origami paper crane symbol of peace. Evidence Second Point in Time Visual Arts Revised Bloom’s Taxonomy Preparation Sheet Lesson: 5th Grade Paper Crane Strand + Clarifying Objective Verb Visual Literacy Use 5.V.2.2 Use ideas and imagery from the global environment as sources for creating art Evidence First Point in Time Evidence Second Point in Time 1. Use paper 1. Use paper folding and folding and patterns to make patterns to an origami paper make an crane symbol of origami paper peace. crane symbol of peace. Visual Arts Revised Bloom’s Taxonomy Preparation Sheet Lesson: 5th Grade Paper Crane Strand + Clarifying Objective Verb Evidence First Point in Time Evidence Second Point in Time Visual Arts Revised Bloom’s Taxonomy Preparation Sheet Lesson: 5th Grade Paper Crane Strand + Clarifying Objective Visual Literacy 5.V.3.1 Evaluate how to manipulate tools safely and appropriately to reach desired outcomes. Verb Evidence First Point in Time Evidence Second Point in Time Visual Arts Revised Bloom’s Taxonomy Preparation Sheet Lesson: 5th Grade Paper Crane Strand + Clarifying Objective Verb Evaluate Visual Literacy 5.V.3.1 Evaluate how to manipulate tools safely and appropriately to reach desired outcomes. Evaluate how to manipulate tools safely and appropriately to Evidence First Point in Time Evidence Second Point in Time Visual Arts Revised Bloom’s Taxonomy Preparation Sheet Lesson: 5th Grade Paper Crane Strand + Clarifying Objective Verb Evidence First Point in Time Evaluate 1. Make a paper Visual Literacy 5.V.3.1 Evaluate crane and selfhow to evaluate on how manipulate tools you used your safely and tools safely. appropriately to reach desired outcomes. Evaluate how to manipulate tools safely and appropriately to Evidence Second Point in Time Visual Arts Revised Bloom’s Taxonomy Preparation Sheet Lesson: 5th Grade Paper Crane Strand + Clarifying Objective Verb Evidence First Point in Time Evaluate 1. Make a paper Visual Literacy 5.V.3.1 Evaluate crane and selfhow to evaluate on how manipulate tools you used your safely an tools safely. appropriately to reach desired outcomes. Evaluate how to manipulate tools safely and appropriately to Evidence Second Point in Time 1. Make a paper crane and using a teacher created rubric, self– evaluate on how you used your tools safely. Visual Arts Revised Bloom’s Taxonomy Preparation Sheet Lesson: 5th Grade Paper Crane Strand + Clarifying Objective Verb Evidence First Point in Time Evaluate 1. Make a paper crane Visual Literacy and self-evaluate on 5.V.3.1 Evaluate how you used your how to tools safely. manipulate tools 2.Make a paper safely an crane and selfappropriately to evaluate on how reach desired you used your outcomes. tools safely. Evidence Second Point in Time 1. Make a paper crane and using a teacher created rubric self– evaluate on how you used your tools safely. Visual Arts Revised Bloom’s Taxonomy Preparation Sheet Lesson: 5th Grade Paper Crane Strand + Clarifying Objective Verb Evidence First Point in Time Evaluate 1. Make a paper crane Visual Literacy and self-evaluate on 5.V.3.1 Evaluate how you used your how to tools safely. manipulate tools 2.Make a paper safely an crane and selfappropriately to evaluate on how reach desired you used your outcomes. tools safely. Evaluate how to manipulate tools safely and appropriately to Evidence Second Point in Time 1. Make a paper crane and using a teacher created rubric self– evaluate on how you used your tools safely. 2.Make a paper crane and using your own rubric, self–evaluate on how you used your tools safely. Visual Arts Revised Bloom’s Taxonomy Preparation Sheet Lesson: 5th Grade Paper Crane Strand + Clarifying Objective Verb Evidence First Point in Time Evaluate 1. Make a paper crane and selfVisual Literacy evaluate on how you used your tools safely. 5.V.3.1 Evaluate 2. Make a paper crane and selfhow to evaluate on how you used manipulate tools your tools safely. safely an 3.Make a paper appropriately to crane and selfreach desired evaluate on how outcomes. you used your 3.1 Evaluate how to tools appropriately manipulate tools to reach desired safely and outcomes. Evidence Second Point in Time 1. Make a paper crane and using a teacher created rubric self– evaluate on how you used your tools safely. 2. Make a paper crane and using your own rubric, self–evaluate on how you used your tools safely. Visual Arts Revised Bloom’s Taxonomy Preparation Sheet Lesson: 5th Grade Paper Crane Strand + Clarifying Objective Verb Evidence First Point in Time Evidence Second Point in Time a paper crane and self1. Make a paper crane and using a Evaluate 1. Make Visual Literacy evaluate on how you used your tools teacher created rubric self–evaluate safely. on how you used your tools safely. 5.V.3.1 Evaluate 2. Make a paper crane and self2. Make a paper crane and using your evaluate on how you used your tools own rubric, self–evaluate on how how to safely. you used your tools safely. manipulate tools 3.Make a paper 3.Make a paper safely and crane and using a crane and selfappropriately to teacher created evaluate on how reach desired rubric, self– you used your outcomes. evaluate on how tools you used your tools appropriately to appropriately to reach desired reach desired outcomes. Visual Arts Revised Bloom’s Taxonomy Preparation Sheet Lesson: 5th Grade Paper Crane Strand + Clarifying Objective Visual Literacy 5.V.3.2 Use appropriate media for the creation of original art. Visual Literacy 5.V.3.3 Create art using the process of drawing, painting, weaving, printing, stitchery, collage, mixed media, sculpture, ceramics, and current technology. Verb Evidence First Point in Time Evidence Second Point in Time Elementary Music Class/Course/Grade: 2nd grade Music Class Unit/Lesson Name (or Topic): Strand: Contextual Relevancy Clarifying Objective: 2.CR.1.1: Exemplify music representing the heritage, customs, and traditions of various cultures. Initial Verb: Point One Artifact: Point 2 Artifact: EXEMPLIFY Finding a specific example or illustration of a concept or principle (e.g., Give examples of various artistic styles) Middle School Music Class/Course/Grade: 7th grade Music Class Unit/Lesson Name (or Topic): Strand: Musical Literacy Clarifying Objective: 7.ML.2.2: Interpret, through instrument and/or voice, standard notation symbols for pitch in appropriate clefs. Initial Verb: INTERPRET Changing from one form of representation (e.g., numerical) to another (e.g., verbal) Point One Artifact: Point 2 Artifact: High School Music Class/Course/Grade: Intermediate Music (Band, Chorus, Orchestra, etc.) Unit/Lesson Name (or Topic): Strand: Musical Response Clarifying Objective: I.MR.1.3: Generate specific criteria for evaluating the quality and effectiveness of music and apply criteria in personal participation in music. Initial Verb: Generate to bring into existence; cause to be; produce Point One Artifact: Point 2 Artifact: ASW Examples: 2 Points in Time Examples of student work illustrating two points in time located on the NCASW Wiki. • These examples can be used as a springboard for discussion Which Clarifying Objectives would you choose for activities used in your classroom to illustrate growth? Group Work • Use the template to identify activities, clarifying objectives, and growth measurements in your content area and grade span • Use chart paper to develop one example to share with the group LUNCH – ENJOY! Every Kid Needs a Champion • Rita Pierson: Every kid needs a champion (TED Talk) http://www.ted.com/talks/rita_pierson_every_kid_needs_a_champion • Discussion and personal connections Group Work (Sharing) • Use the template to identify activities, clarifying objectives, and growth measurements in your content area and grade span • Use chart paper to develop one example to share with the group Analysis of Student Work NC Professional Teaching Standards Standard I: Teachers demonstrate leadership. Standard II: Teachers establish a respectful environment for a diverse population of students. Standard III: Teachers know the content they teach. Standard IV: Teachers facilitate learning for their students. Standard V: Teachers reflect on their practice. Standard VI: Teachers contribute to the academic success of students. Effectiveness Status NC Educator Evaluation System 1 2 3 4 5 Demonstrate Leadership Establish Environment Know Content 5 Rating Categories Not Demonstrated Developing Proficient Accomplished Distinguished Facilitate Learning Reflect on Practice Contribute to Academic Success 6 3 Rating Categories Overview of Standard 6 Contribute to Academic Success 6 End of Grade (EOG) or End of Course (EOC) tests 6 Career Technical Education Assessment 6 NC Final Exams 6 K-3 Checkpoints 6 Analysis of Student Work Overview: Analysis of Student Work ASW Process Participation in ASW Process for High School Teachers (60% rule) 1. If 60% of an educator’s classes* are in ASW subject areas, then the educator must participate in both ASW and any other Standard 6 measure covering the remaining classes. 2. If 60% of an educator’s classes* can be covered by an existing measure of student learning, then the teacher is not required to participate in ASW. *Please note that locally developed electives that do not follow the standards set forth in the NC Standard Course of Study are not included in the ASW Process. Participation in ASW Process for K-8 Teachers (45 minute rule) 1. Educators who have 45 minutes per week scheduled with students in these content areas are required to participate in ASW. 2. Educators who do not have 45 minutes per week scheduled with students in these content areas are not required to participate in ASW. For educators who do not meet the requirements to participate in the ASW Process, the district may choose to opt in to the ASW Process for those educators. The decision to opt in for a group of educators must be a district-wide decision. Principal’s Input Confirm Teacher Participation Teaching Context: Teachers Access Schedules to Validate Classes AND Course Codes If you have the wrong course codes for your classes, you will have the wrong Clarifying Objectives! ASW Process: A Quick Guide Teachers are responsible for the items within the red boxes. Overview: Analysis of Student Work (ASW) Process ASW Resources http://ncasw.ncdpi.wikispaces.net Jennifer DeNeal Race to the Top Project Coordinator for Educator Effectiveness North Carolina Department of Public Instruction Email educatoreffectiveness@dpi.nc.gov Comprehensive Arts Education (CAE) Update Spring 2015 Comprehensive Arts Education • January 7th, North Carolina State Board of Education State Board of Education Issues Session Board member Wayne McDevitt described experiences with arts education in North Carolina saying: –"Greg and I and Trish and others stood in awe as we watched this performance following our December meeting of a school over in Durham (R.N. Harris)... just tremendous –All of us are supporters of the arts... –Arts are at the very core of what it is we are about…the state has a rich history in this area with the school of the arts and the museums and even at the local level. –The research is clear, if we are going to achieve…the skills that we are trying to insure every student gets… If we are going to achieve that vision, mission and goals…then arts have to be integrated within that larger picture." Special Guests • Representative Becky Carney • Representative Linda P. Johnson • Secretary Susan Kluttz Other guests NC Legislation 1985 Basic Education Program 2008 Joint Select Committee on Arts Education 2009 S66 and H149 2010 S66 Arts Education Task Force 2011-12 H758 Arts Education Commission 2012-2013 Legislation (G.S. 115-C-296) S66 Task Force • Representation: – teachers, principals, superintendents, arts organizations, the business sector, parents, legislators, and higher ed • Ownership of plan – requires many partners working on many fronts • Key foundational language and broad goals S66 Vision for Arts Education In today’s globally competitive world, innovative thinking and creativity are essential for all school children. High quality, standards-based instruction in the arts develops these skills and effectively engages, retains, and prepares future-ready students for graduation and success in an entrepreneurial economy. Dance, music, theatre arts, and visual arts, taught by licensed arts educators and integrated throughout the curriculum, are critical to North Carolina’s 21st century education. Comprehensive Arts Education • Arts Education – (arts as core, academic subjects) • Arts Integration – (arts as a catalyst for learning across the curriculum) • Arts Exposure – (exposure to arts experiences) Comprehensive Arts Education S66: Recommendations A. Basic Education Program (BEP) B. High School Graduation Requirement C. A+ Schools Program D. Arts Integration E. Arts Exposure Accomplishments: Comprehensive Arts Education Focusing Question • How can NCDPI, NCDCR, Arts Education Leaders, administrators, and organizations partner together to support Comprehensive Arts Education? G.S. 115C-296: Arts Integration • Requires that preservice elementary teachers are prepared to “integrate the arts across the curriculum”. • Outgrowth of H758 Arts Education Commission • Wide-scale education legislation – S724 (June 2012) – H23 (March 2013) – S168 (July 2013) NC Pre-service Arts Integration Initiative Committee • Diverse, state-level • Representation from: – IHEs (Education and Arts Education) – Arts Educators – Administrators (LEA Staff, Principals, Superintendents) – Community Partners NC PAII – Goals and Next Steps • Support the preparation of pre-service educators to deliver a balanced education. • Identify models and practices to prepare pre-service educators to integrate the arts. • Foster collaborations to create access to a comprehensive arts education in our state. • Next steps: Continue educator support and prepare and support administrators. A+ Schools Program of the NC Arts Council A+ Schools Program “The largest, longest running, most successful arts-based whole-school reform effort in the nation” George Noblit, PhD, author of Creating and Sustaining Arts-Based School Reform A+ Schools Program • RESA Training – Spring 2014 – present – For K-8 educators and administrators to implement standards using arts integration • Arts integration courses taught at NCCAT • Targeted support for IHEs A+ Schools Program Conference to celebrate the 20th Anniversary of A+ Schools August 3 – 5, 2015 in Durham A+ Schools Program Learn more: Voices of A+ Cross-Sector Collaboration with Arts Education Leaders Cross-sector Collaboration with LEAs and Organizations • Think Tank – 8 Regions – Central Office Staff, Educators, IHE Members • Arts Education Coordinators • Arts Education Leadership Coalition – Dance, Music, Theatre Arts, Visual Arts Professional Organizations and ARTS North Carolina Other Examples: Department of Cultural Resources Other Examples: DCR The Big Picture North Carolina Museum of Art Education Concerts North Carolina Symphony Traditional Arts Programs for Students North Carolina Arts Council National Recognition for North Carolina: Comprehensive Arts Education National Recognition • National Endowment for the Arts (NEA) • Arts Education Partnership (AEP) Good News 10 STATE TEAMS JOIN PILOT PROGRAM TO STRENGTHEN ARTS THROUGH STATE POLICY Americans for the Arts announced that ten state teams would join a three-year pilot program to strengthen arts education by advancing state policy. Announced at the National Conference of State Legislatures’ legislative summit in Minneapolis, the ten states entering the pilot program are: Arizona, Arkansas, California, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, New Jersey, North Carolina, Oklahoma, Wyoming Comprehensive Arts Education Thank you & Questions Next Steps Think-Pair-Share State and National Updates Dance, Media Arts, Music, Theatre And Visual Arts •http://www.nationalartsstandards.org/ – Creating – Performing, Producing, Presenting – Responding – Connecting Artistically Literate Citizens Communication Creative Personal Realization Culture, History, and Connections Means to Well Being Community Engagement (January 2013 – National Coalition for Core Arts Standards Framework) Creative Practices Imagine Investigate Construct Reflect To form a mental image of concept To observe or study through exploration or examination To make or form by combining or arranging parts or elements To think deeply or carefully about National Standards Visual Arts Theatre Arts Media Arts Dance Music State Updates ArtsFolio • Primary Purpose – Provide a student-driven formative assessment process that documents the progression through arts proficiency levels • Outcomes – Navigating between middle & high school to ensure appropriate level placement – Creating a portfolio for beyond high school (college & career) Educator Effectiveness (Standards 1-5) • Administrator Guides – Overview of Arts Education programs – Arts-specific examples of indicators for Standards 1-5 NC Standard Course of Study – Arts Education – Career and Technical Education – English Language Arts (and Literacy in History/Social Studies, Science, and Technical Subjects) – English Language Development* – Guidance* – Healthful Living (Health & Physical Education) – Information and Technology* – Mathematics – Science – Social Studies – World Languages Standard Course of Study • No changes for the current school year • Academic Standards Review • Superintendent Atkinson explains the timeline and changes (video) • http://www.ncpublicschools.org “highlights” – Transcript Professional Development Upcoming Webinar Dates • March 4, 2015 https://www1.gotomeeting.com/register/715192641 • May 6, 2015 https://www1.gotomeeting.com/register/729725592 Free Response • If you had a day or two away from your regular work or life responsibilities, what would rejuvenate you as an artist? June 18-19, 2015 – Onslow County Questions and Sharing Plus/Delta • Please complete Plus/Delta • What is one take away you have from this information? • THANK YOU!!!!!!! Additional Supplementary Materials ASW Process: Step 1 Teacher Responsibility ASW Process: Step 2 Platform Responsibility ASW Process: Step 3 Teacher Responsibility ASW Process: Step 4 Teacher Responsibility ASW Process: Step 5 Platform Responsibility ASW Process: Step 6 Teacher Responsibility ASW Process: Step 7 Platform Responsibility ASW Process: Step 8 Platform Responsibility