THE THEORY OF ECONOMIC GROWTH 1 2 Questions • How important is faster labor-growth as a drag on economic growth? • How important is a high saving rate as a cause of economic growth? • How important is technological and organizational progress for economic growth? • How does economic growth change over time? • Are there economic forces that will allow poorer countries to catch up to richer countries? 3 American Real GDP per Capita, 1800-2004 (in 2004 Dollars) 4 Long-Run Economic Growth • We classify the factors that generate differences in productive potentials into two broad groups • differences in the efficiency of labor • how technology is deployed and organization is used • differences in capital intensity • how much current production has been set aside to produce useful machines, buildings, and infrastructure 5 The Efficiency of Labor • The efficiency of labor has risen for two reasons • advances in technology • advances in organization • Economists are good at analyzing the consequences of advances in technology but they have less to say about their sources “1974” • There was a slowdown in productivity growth from approximately 1974 to around 1990. • This is associated with the ITC (information and communications technology) ‘revolution’. • Slowdown causes: • Measurement – inadequate accounting for quality improvements • The legal and human environment – regulations for pollution control and worker safety, crime, and declines in educational quality. • Oil prices – huge increases in oil prices reduced productivity of capital and labor, especially in basic industries • Kondratiev cycles • 1873-1890 steam power, trains, telegraph • 1917-1927 electrification in factories • 1948-1973 transistor 7 Capital Intensity • There is a direct relationship between capital-intensity and productivity • a more capital-intensive economy will be a richer and more productive economy 8 Standard Growth Model • Also called the Solow growth model • Consists of • variables • behavioral relationships (aka laws of motion) • equilibrium conditions • The key variable is labor productivity • output per worker (Y/L) 9 Solow Growth Model • Balanced-growth equilibrium • the capital intensity of the economy (K/Y) is stable • This necessitates that the economy’s capital stock and level of real GDP are growing at the same rate • the economy’s capital-labor ratio is constant 10 Solow Growth Model • After finding the balanced-growth equilibrium, we calculate the balanced-growth path • if the economy is on its balanced-growth path, the present value and future values of output per worker will continue to follow the balanced-growth path • if the economy is not yet on its balanced-growth path, it will head towards it 11 The Production Function • The production function tells us how the average worker’s productivity (Y/L) is related to the efficiency of labor (h) and the amount of capital at the average worker’s disposal (K/L) (Y/L) F[(K/L), h] Cobb-Douglas production function (Y/L) (K/L) (h)1- 12 The Production Function (Y/L) (K/L) (h)1- • measures how fast diminishing marginal returns to investment set in • the smaller the value of , the faster diminishing returns are occurring 13 The Cobb-Douglas Production Function for Different Values of 14 The Production Function (Y/L) (K/L) (h)1- • The value of the efficiency of labor (h) tells us how high the production function rises • a higher level of h means that more output per worker is produced for each possible value of the capital stock per worker 15 The Cobb-Douglas Production Function for Different Values of h {or E in this particular plot} 16 The Production Function: Example • h = $10,000 • = 0.3 • K/L = $125,000 Y K 1 0.3 0.7 h (125,000) (10,000) $21,334 L L 17 The Production Function: Example • If K/L rises to $250,000 Y K 1 0.3 0.7 h (250,000) (10,000) $26,265 L L the first $125,000 of K/L increased Y/L from $0 to $21,334 the second $125,000 of K/L increased Y/L from $21,334 to $26,265 18 Saving, Investment, and Capital Accumulation • The net flow of saving is equal to the amount of investment • Real GDP (Y) can be divided into four parts • consumption (C) • investment (I) • government purchases (G) • net exports (NX = X - M) 19 Saving, Investment, and Capital Accumulation I (Y T C ) (G T ) ( M X ) The right-hand side shows the three pieces of total saving household saving (SH) government saving (SG) foreign saving (SF) I SH SG SF 20 Saving, Investment, and Capital Accumulation • Let’s assume that total saving is a constant fraction (s) of real GDP S S S s Y H G Therefore, it must be true that I sY F 21 Saving, Investment, and Capital Accumulation • We will refer to s as the economy’s saving rate • we will assume that it will remain at its current value as we look far into the future • s measures the flow of saving and the share of total production that is invested and used to increase the capital stock 22 Saving, Investment, and Capital Accumulation • The capital stock is not constant • We will let • K0 will mean the capital stock at some initial year • K2015 will mean the capital stock in 2015 • Kt will mean the capital stock in the current year • Kt+1 will mean the capital stock next year • Kt-1 will mean the capital stock last year 23 Saving, Investment, and Capital Accumulation • Investment will make the capital stock tend to grow • Depreciation makes the capital stock tend to shrink • the depreciation rate is assumed to be constant and equal to 24 Saving, Investment, and Capital Accumulation • Next year’s capital will be K t 1 K t investment depreciation K t 1 K t sYt K t The capital stock is constant when sYt K t Kt s Yt 25 Saving, Investment, and Capital Accumulation • Suppose that the economy has no labor force growth and no growth in the efficiency of labor • if K/Y < s/, depreciation is less than investment so K and K/Y will grow until K/Y = s/ • if K/Y > s/, depreciation is greater than investment so K and K/Y will fall until K/Y = s/ 26 Saving, Investment, and Capital Accumulation • Thus, if the economy has no labor force growth and no growth in the efficiency of labor, the equilibrium condition of this growth model is Kt s Yt 27 Equilibrium with Just Investment and Depreciation Output per Worker Equilibrium (the reciprocal of the capital-output ratio) /s K/L (assumes that and E are constant) The capital stock is growing because K/L > /s Capital Stock per Worker The capital stock is shrinking because K/L < /s 28 Saving, Investment, and Capital Accumulation • Remember that, in this particular case, we are assuming that • the economy’s labor force is constant • the economy’s equilibrium capital stock is constant • there are no changes in the efficiency of labor • Thus, equilibrium output per worker is constant • Now we will complicate the model Steady States • Steady state: yt, ct, and kt are constant over time • Gross investment must 1. 2. • • • Replace worn out capital Expand so the capital stock grows as the economy grows, nKt It = (n + d)Kt Ct = Yt – It = Yt – (n + d)Kt c = f(k) – (n+d)k