Central Washington University Assessment of Student Learning Safety and Health Management Program Report 2013 Please enter the appropriate information concerning your student learning assessment activities for this year. Academic Year of Report: 2012-2013 College: College of Education and Professional Studies Department: Engineering Technologies, Safety, and Construction Department Program: B.S. in Safety and Health Management Program 1. What student learning outcomes were assessed this year, and why? There was no individual course assessment activities performed in the last four years. This is primarily due to faculty turnover issues within the SHM program. The SHM program hired a new program coordinator who started fall 2011. Another faculty member was added in fall 2013. One of the major goals of the coordinator was to change the SHM curriculum to meet accreditation requirements, and also develop and implement a course assessment plan. The goal was met and the new coordinator has developed a detailed course assessment plan which has implemented starting academic year 2013-2014. Our new SHM curriculum has been offered beginning this academic year. It is the result of the joint efforts of the SHM faculty and our industry advisory council’s curriculum committee. The new curriculum aligns with accreditation requirements, while meeting contemporary employment practices. The curriculum adds courses covering important topics, such as substance abuse in the workplace, business law, ergonomics, safety and health laboratory, and project management. The new assessment plan includes an (1) program educational objectives and (2) program outcomes. The assessment plan was reviewed by the program’s industry advisory board and the faculty and approved. The assessment plan is presented in Appendix A & B. However, one program assessment was made in the academic year 2012-2013, senior exit survey, the results of which is presented in this document. The goal of the SHM program is to get accredited by the Applied Science Accreditation Commission (ASAC) of ABET by 2017. Hence, the program outcomes for the SHM program has been written to match the requirements of ASAC based on the 2012-2013 Accreditation cycle. The SHM program will use the program criteria that apply to safety, occupational safety, industrial safety, and similarly named applied science programs. 2. How were they assessed? A) What methods were used? B) Who was assessed? C) When was it assessed? The assessment methods, who to assess, and the timings are all presented in the assessment plan presented in Appendix A and B. 3. What was learned? The goal of the program is to obtain course assessment data starting academic year 2013-2014. However, the following sections presents lessons learned from the senior exit survey conducted in spring 2013. Senior exit survey On May 28, 2013, Dr. Bill Bender, Associate Dean for the CEPS conducted a senior exit interview of the seniors in the SHM program. There were approximately 30 students in attendance. This was an open-ended discussion type survey. The comments and response from the SHM program are below. Comment#1: “Students feel advising is well done by Dr. Rajendran, however, the counseling center did not understand the SHM curriculum. Now that the SHM curriculum is settled you may want to meet with the advisors in Hertz to explain your {SHM} program. Perhaps include Tom Spencer, the SHM student that works there to assist” The program has reached out to the advising office at CWU and will ensure it communicates the curriculum change to the advisers. Comment#2: “Students appreciate the efforts of the faculty to help them get internships and jobs, however feel more opportunities could be found in areas besides construction. More than 60% of SHM employers are from the construction industry. One of the major goals of the program is to diversify its employer base to include other industries. Currently, the program is collaborating with the WA Farm Bureau to establish relationship with agricultural employers. The program advisory board is helping the program to meet this goal. For example, ConAgra Foods (Agricultural/food processing industry) recruited its first intern from the program this year – progress. Comment#3: “Students would like to see more guest speakers from OSHA, L&I, MSHA, etc.” The program has requested the assistance of its industry advisory board to identify guest speakers for various courses including the areas identified by the students. By the end of the year, the program should have at least 2 or 3 speakers per course, who can share current industry trends with the students. 4. What will the department or program do as a result of that information? Based on data obtained during the 2012-2013 appropriate changes have been made to the program in to be effective fall 2013. 5. What did the department or program do in response to last year’s assessment information? Based on data obtained during the 2012-2013 appropriate changes have been made to the program in to be effective fall 2013. 6. Questions or suggestions concerning Assessment of Student Learning at Central Washington University: Unable to complete at this time. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Appendix A CWU Department/Program Assessment Plan Preparation Form Department: Engineering Technologies, Safety, and Construction Program: B.S. in Safety and Health Management Program Department/Program Goals Related Related Method(s) of Who/What When Criterion of Achievement College University Assessment Assessed Assessed (Expectation of how good Goals Goals (What is the (population, (term, things should be?) assessment?) item) dates) Our SHM graduates will be Goal 1 Goal 1 Alumni Survey Program Fall - 1 to 3 Above 90% of the graduates will employed in the safety and health Goal 2 Goal 2 Alumni yrs. after be employed in a safety related discipline or a career of their graduation field. choice upon graduation. Our SHM graduates will be Goal 1 Goal 1 Alumni and Program Fall - 1 to 3 Above 80% of the graduates and prepared to develop, implement, Goal 2 Goal 2 Employer Alumni and yrs. after their employers either “Agree” and manage occupational safety Survey their graduation or “Strongly Agree” (Avg 4.0) and health programs. employers that they were prepared for a successful career in safety and health management discipline. Our SHM graduates demonstrate Goal 1 Goal 1 Alumni Survey Program Fall - 1 to 3 -Above 80% of the graduates are continued life-long learning Goal 2 Goal 2 Alumni yrs. after members in Safety and Health through contribution to graduation professional organizations professional safety societies and -Above 80% of the graduates organizations, professional have obtained safety related activities and training, the pursuit certifications of higher educational degrees, -Above 80% of the graduates and individual professional participated in continuing development. education/professional development safety courses since graduation. Our SHM graduates will act in a Goal 1 Goal 1 Employer Program Fall - 1 to 3 Above 80% of our graduate’s professional and ethical manner. Goal 2 Goal 2 Survey Alumni’s yrs. after employer either “Agree” or employers graduation “strongly agree” (Avg 4.0) that the graduates act in a professional and ethical manner. Our SHM graduates will have Goal 1 Goal 1 Alumni and Program Fall - 1 to 3 Above 80% of the graduates and good communication skills and Goal 2 Goal 2 Employer Alumni and yrs. after their employers either “Agree” are able to effectively work in Survey their graduation or “Strongly Agree” (Avg 4.0) teams. employers about our graduate communication skills. Appendix B CWU Student Learning Outcome Assessment Plan Preparation Form Department: Engineering Technologies, Safety, and Construction Program: Safety and Health Management Program A-Z (26 Program Outcomes) Student Learning Related Related Related Method(s) of Who Assessed When Standard of Outcomes (performance, Program/ College University Assessment (What is (Students from Assessed Mastery/ knowledge, attitudes) Departmental Goals Goals the assessment?)* what courses – (term, Criterion of Goals population)** Achievement dates) (How good does *** performance have to be?) Program Goal 4 Goal 1 A. Students will Department Goal 2 demonstrate their Goal 5 understanding of professional and ethical responsibilities as safety and health professionals. B. Students will demonstrate their ability to apply their applied science knowledge and solve problems using algebra, statistics, human physiology and anatomy, physics, chemistry, as it pertains to the practice of safety and health discipline. Program Goal 1 Goal 1 Program Goal 2 Goal 2 Department Goal 1 Goal 1 Goal 2 Goal 1 Goal 2 SHM 301 Homework assignment on ethics and professionalism Juniors Fall 80% SHM 490 Supervisor Evaluation during internship Juniors Summer 85% SHM 485 Ethics Paper SHM 301 Performance Metrics Quiz Seniors Spring 90% Juniors Fall 80% Juniors Spring 90% Juniors Winter 90% Seniors Spring 90% Seniors Winter 90% SHM 351 Accident Data Analysis SHM 353 Risk Assessment Matrix Exercise SHM 472 NIOSH Lifting Equation Problem SHM 474 Perception Survey C. Students will demonstrate their ability to design and conduct experiments, and to analyze and interpret data pertinent to the safety and health discipline. Program Goal 1 Goal 1 Program Goal 2 Goal 2 Department Goal 1 D. Students will demonstrate their ability to identify and describe the fundamental aspects of safety and health management. Program Goal 1 Goal 1 Program Goal 2 Goal 2 Department Goal 1 E. Students will demonstrate their ability to identify and describe the fundamental aspects of industrial hygiene. F. Students will demonstrate their ability to identify and describe the fundamental aspects of environmental Goal 1 Goal 2 SHM 351 Accident Data Analysis Juniors Spring 90% SHM 472 NIOSH Lifting Equation Problem Seniors Spring 90% SHM 474 Perception Survey Seniors Winter 90% Goal 1 Goal 2 SHM 301 Final Exam Juniors Fall 80% Program Goal 1 Goal 1 Program Goal 2 Goal 2 Department Goal 1 Goal 1 Goal 2 SHM 471 Final Exam Seniors Fall 85% Program Goal 1 Goal 1 Program Goal 2 Goal 2 Department Goal 1 Goal 1 Goal 2 SHM 477 Final Exam Winter Seniors 85% management. G. Students will demonstrate their ability to identify and describe the fundamental aspects of fire safety. Program Goal 1 Goal 1 Program Goal 2 Goal 2 Department Goal 1 Goal 1 Goal 2 SHM 379 Fire Safety Plan assignment Winter Seniors 85% H. Students will demonstrate their ability to identify and describe the fundamental aspects of ergonomics. Program Goal 1 Goal 1 Program Goal 2 Goal 2 Department Goal 1 Goal 1 Goal 2 SHM 472 Final Exam Spring Seniors 85% I. Students will demonstrate their ability to identify and describe the fundamental aspects of hazardous materials. Program Goal 1 Goal 1 Program Goal 2 Goal 2 Department Goal 1 Goal 1 Goal 2 SHM 377 Hazardous Materials Management Plan Assignment Seniors Fall 85% J. Students will demonstrate their ability to identify and describe the fundamental aspects of and emergency management. Program Goal 1 Goal 1 Program Goal 2 Goal 2 Department Goal 1 Goal 1 Goal 2 SHM 371 Emergency Management Plan Project Juniors Spring 85% K. Students will demonstrate their ability to identify and describe the fundamental aspects of systems safety and Program Goal 1 Goal 1 Program Goal 2 Goal 2 Department Goal 1 Goal 1 Goal 2 SHM 352 System Safety Quiz Juniors Spring 80% SHM 375 Research Project/Exam Juniors Spring 85% fleet safety. L. Students will demonstrate their ability to identify and describe the fundamental aspects of construction (or) manufacturing safety. Program Goal 1 Goal 1 Program Goal 2 Goal 2 Department Goal 1 Goal 1 Goal 2 SHM 323 Construction fundamentals quiz Juniors Winter 80% M. Students will demonstrate their ability to anticipate, recognize, evaluate, and develop control strategies for hazardous conditions and work practices. Program Goal 1 Goal 1 Program Goal 2 Goal 2 Department Goal 1 Goal 1 Goal 2 SHM 323 Pre-task plan assignment Juniors Winter 80% SHM 325 Pre-task plan assignment Juniors Winter 80% SHM 379 Life Safety Inspection Seniors Winter 85% N. Students will demonstrate their ability to apply business and risk management concepts as part of a comprehensive safety and health management program. Program Goal 1 Goal 1 Program Goal 2 Goal 2 Department Goal 1 Goal 1 Goal 2 SHM 471 Final Exam SHM 353 Class Project Seniors Juniors Fall Winter 85% 80% O. Students will demonstrate their ability to identify and apply applicable standards, regulations, and codes in Program Goal 1 Goal 1 Program Goal 2 Goal 2 Department Goal 1 Goal 1 Goal 2 SHM 301 OSHA regulation HW Assignment Juniors Fall 80% SHM 323 Final Exam Juniors Winter 80% the safety and health discipline. SHM 325 Final Exam Juniors Winter 80% SHM 377 Final Exam Seniors Fall 85% Winter Winter 90% 90% P. Students will demonstrate their ability to design and evaluate a comprehensive safety and health program. Program Goal 1 Goal 1 Program Goal 2 Goal 2 Department Goal 1 Goal 1 Goal 2 SHM 477 Audit Seniors SHM 474 Design of Seniors SHM program Project Q. Students will demonstrate their ability to complete worker safety and health training by applying adult learning theories. Program Goal 1 Goal 1 Program Goal 2 Goal 2 Department Goal 1 Goal 1 Goal 2 SHM 480 Training Exercise Seniors Winter 90% SHM 474 Safety Training Seniors Winter 90% R. Students will demonstrate their ability to conduct an incident investigation and analysis. Program Goal 1 Goal 1 Program Goal 2 Goal 2 Department Goal 1 Goal 1 Goal 2 SHM 351 Accident Investigation Report/Presentation Juniors Spring 90% S. Students will demonstrate their ability to apply the principles of safety and health in a non-academic setting through an internship, cooperative, or supervised experience. Program Goal 1 Goal 1 Program Goal 2 Goal 2 Department Goal 1 Goal 1 Goal 2 SHM 490 Supervisory Evaluation on preparedness for SHM profession Juniors Summer 85% T. Students will demonstrate their ability to use the techniques, skills, and modern scientific and technical tools necessary for professional practice in the safety and health discipline. Program Goal 1 Goal 1 Program Goal 2 Goal 2 Department Goal 1 U. Students will demonstrate their ability to function effectively on multidisciplinary teams. Program Goal 5 Goal 1 Department Goal 2 Goal 1 Goal 1 Goal 2 Goal 1 Goal 2 SHM 480 Industrial Equipment Lab exercise Seniors Winter 90% SHM 379 Fire Extinguisher Trainer Exercise Seniors Winter 90% SHM 471 PPE Selection exercise Seniors Fall 90% SHM 485 Group Projects Peer Evaluation Seniors Spring 80% SHM 490 Supervisor Evaluation Juniors Summer 75% Program Goal 5 Goal 1 V. Students will Goal 2 demonstrate their ability Department Goal 1 to deliver their recommendations effectively in oral communications, with a wide range of audiences. Goal 1 Goal 2 SHM 351 Accident Investigation Report/Presentation Juniors Spring 90% Program Goal 5 Goal 1 W. Students will Goal 2 demonstrate their ability Department Goal 1 to deliver their recommendations effectively in written communications, with a wide range of audiences. Goal 1 Goal 2 SHM 351 Accident Investigation Report/Presentation Juniors Spring 90% SHM 485 Professional Development Plan Seniors Spring 90% Program Goal 3 Y. Students will demonstrate their ability Department to identify contemporary Goal 5 safety and health issues within a global and societal context. SHM 481 Contemporary Issues Assignment Seniors Spring 80% Program Goal 3 Department Goal 5 SHM 481 Contemporary Issues Assignment Seniors Spring 80% X. Students will demonstrate their ability to engage in life-long learning by preparing a professional development plan. Z. Students will have the broad education necessary to understand the impact of safety and health solutions in a global and societal context. Program Goal 3 Department Goal 5 *Method(s) of assessment should include those that are both direct (tests, essays, presentations, projects) and indirect (surveys, interviews) in nature **Data needs to be collected and differentiated by location (Ellensburg campus vs University Centers – see NWCCU standard 2.B.2) ***Timing of assessment should be identified at different transition points of program (i.e., admission, mid-point, end-of-program, post-program)