SHARED ARRANGEMENT AGREEMENT BETWEEN NSW TREASURY AND PARTICIPATING ENTITIES Conformant with TPP 12-04: Guidance on Shared Arrangements and Subcommittees for Audit and Risk Committees 1. Timing of the Agreement This Shared Arrangement Agreement is to take effect from 1 July 2013. 2. Principal Department I, the Secretary of the Treasury, recognise NSW Treasury as the principal department in this shared arrangements Agreement. The principal department includes the Crown Finance Entity and Industrial Relations, neither of which is a separate legal entity. 3. Participating Entities – where the Secretary, Treasury is CEO I, the Secretary of the Treasury, am also Chief Executive Officer of the following entities. I have determined that they will participate in a principal department-led shared arrangement led by Treasury: State Rail Authority Residual Holding Corporation Liability Management Ministerial Corporation Lotteries Assets Ministerial Holding Corporation Electricity Assets Ministerial Holding Corporation Ports Assets Ministerial Holding Corporation These agencies employ no staff. Furthermore, these agencies can deem any Treasury officer an employee if it suits their purpose. In light of these characteristics I, the Secretary, have determined that they will be treated as Treasury for the purposes of this Agreement. The Chair may override this determination temporarily should an occasion arise where, in his view, there is a conflict of interests or other unforeseen impediment. 4. Participating Entities – where the CEO is other than the Secretary, Treasury The CEO of the Residual Business Management Corporation (RMBC) is a General Manager who reports to the Treasurer. The officer filling the role of General Manager is also a Treasury employee, which is allowable under RBMC’s establishing legislation. The General Manager, RBMC, has agreed to opt into this Agreement. From 2013-14, RBMC’s annual financial statements will be prepared by Treasury staff. The detail of the Agreement follows from S.7 below. The two Directors of the Port Botany and Port Kembla Lessor Companies also report to the Treasurer and are also Treasury employees. The two Companies are controlled entities under the Ports Assets Ministerial Holding Corporation, of which the Secretary is CEO, so they have agreed to opt into this Agreement. From 2013-14 their annual financial statements will be prepared by Treasury staff. The detail of the Agreement follows from S.7 below. Treasury Shared Arrangements Agreement_July 2013 1 5. Excluded entities As at 1 July 2013, those entities in the Treasury Cluster not covered under this Agreement are: Long Service Corporation (LSC) and Treasury Corporation (TCorp) Each of these has its own Audit & Risk Committee and associated arrangements. Also: Hunter Valley Training Company Pty Ltd Cobbora Holding Company Pty Ltd As incorporated companies, these are not required to comply with TPP 09-051. 6. Purpose of the Agreement The aim of a shared arrangement is to ensure that the compliance cost of implementing TPP 09-05 for agencies is commensurate with their risk profile and benefit. Agencies are eligible to enter into shared arrangements where: an agency does not have a role that requires independence from other agencies; and an agency has total annual expenditure of less than $100 million, and the agency’s risk profile does not warrant stand-alone arrangements. 7. Terms of the Agreement 7.1 Chief Audit Executive (CAE) Treasury’s Chief Audit Executive acts as CAE for all entities within this Agreement. Appointments to the CAE role are by the Secretary, in consultation with the Audit & Risk Committee. The CAE also provides secretariat support to the Committee. The CAE has the authority to request and receive information from all entities covered by this Agreement, as do Treasury’s internal auditors and the NSW Audit Office. 7.2 Chief Financial Officer (CFO) Treasury’s Chief Financial Officer is authorised to undertake the CFO role, with all the authorities that entails, in relation to all entities within this Agreement including RBMC and the Ports Lessor Companies. 7.3 Rationale for shared agreement This Agreement includes the Corporations listed in Section 3 (above) because, while most are separate legal entities, the Secretary is the CEO of each one and they are staffed by Treasury officers. The Secretary has determined that having the Treasury Audit & Risk Committee, including the Treasury internal member, oversee all of them improves his line of sight. This Agreement includes the RBMC because, in the view of the General Manager: the Treasurer was seeking an increased level of oversight when he asked Treasury to take over from the previous private sector management; and the entity is too small to warrant its own Committee; and following a transition phase during 2013, RBMC will be entirely staffed by Treasury officers. 1 A full list of the entities that do come under this agreement can be found in Attachment 1. Treasury Shared Arrangements Agreement_July 2013 2 The Secretary agrees, after consultation with the Committee and the General Manager RBMC, that under this agreement the Treasury Audit & Risk Committee will extend its oversight to RBMC. The Treasury internal member will not be a member of the Committee for the purpose of the separate RBMC meetings. The RBMC and Ports Audit & Risk Committees will comprise all of the independent members of the Treasury Committee, unless a conflict of interests prevents this. This Agreement includes the Ports Lessor Companies even though they are not required to comply with TPP09-05 because, in the view of their joint Directors, there is sufficient reason in that: they are wholly owned by the Ports Assets Ministerial Holding Corporation (PAMHC), and their accounts consolidate into those of PAMHC the Secretary, Treasury is the CEO of PAMHC; and the Audit Office of NSW audits the Lessor Companies’ annual financial statements as well as those of PAMHC. The Secretary agrees, after consultation with the Committee and the Directors of the Ports Lessor Companies, that under this agreement the Treasury Audit & Risk Committee will extend its oversight to the Ports Lessor Companies. It is agreed that, when there is a need to discuss the affairs of the Ports Lessor Companies, the Committee will convene without the Treasury internal member. 7.4 Costs The costs of the Committee, CAE and secretariat in the service of RBMC and the Ports Lessor Companies will be met by NSW Treasury from its Audit & Risk allocation. RBMC will pay for its own audits, investigations and other initiatives supporting this Agreement. Should such activities be required in relation to the Ports Lessor Companies, they too will cover the costs. Treasury will recover the costs associated with the preparation of the accounts, and related accounting services, for all participating entities which are active in the financial year. The General Manager RBMC and the Directors of the Ports Lessor Companies may not vary this Section, but the Secretary may at his discretion. 7.5 Meeting format and schedule The Committee meets at least four times per year. Separate, sequential, meetings with separate agendas will be held to discuss RBMC on the same day as each regular Treasury meeting. The regular meeting will be formally closed and a new one opened when there is RBMC business to be discussed. No RBMC business will be dealt with during the main meeting, except in the case where RBMC is relevant to the consolidated financial statements. In that case it will be treated like any other agency in the same circumstances. The General Manager RBMC will be notified at what time RBMC’s meeting is likely to commence. He will be asked, during drafting of the Agenda, whether he has anything to bring to the Committee’s attention. For its part, the Committee can request information or presentation from the General Manager in the same way it can from Treasury management. If there are no items on the RBMC Agenda, the Chair will make a final call for RBMC Other Business immediately after closing the main meeting, while a quorum still exists. Treasury Shared Arrangements Agreement_July 2013 3 The same rules will apply to the Ports Lessor Companies as to RBMC, with the exception that meetings will not necessarily be held each time there is a Treasury meeting. There will be a Ports Lessor Companies meeting at least once a year, and otherwise as considered necessary by the Directors, the Audit Office, the CFO and/or the Committee. A schedule of meetings is compiled annually for the following year by the Audit & Risk Branch. 7.6 Charters Treasury retains its Audit & Risk Committee Charter unchanged, except that Annexure 1 has been amended to reflect the new shared arrangement. A new Participating Entities Committee Charter has been developed and forms part of this Agreement. Its annual review is the responsibility of the Chair, supported by the Chief Audit Executive in consultation with representatives of the other entities (in practice, the Director Crown Asset & Liabilities Management, the Chief Financial Officer (if different), the General Manager RBMC and the Directors of the Ports Lessor Companies or their delegate). 7.7 Composition and Terms of the Audit & Risk Committee The Committee for each of the smaller entities comprises the same personnel as that of the principal department. Members are selected from the DFS-monitored Prequalification List and appointed by the Secretary in consultation with the CAE and Chair. The Committee’s composition is in all respects compliant with TPP 09-05. Any changes in membership will be approved and appointed by the Secretary. Members are remunerated at the “large” agency rate, which is applicable to multi-entity shared arrangements. The terms and conditions under which the Treasury Audit & Risk Committee functions and under which its members serve apply to its coverage of all entities in this Agreement. It is understood that Treasury and its shared arrangements partners together constitute one Committee for the purpose of calculating the total number of committees on which a member can participate. 7.8 Conduct of the internal audit program All shared arrangement entities, including RBMC and Ports Lessor Companies, will share Treasury’s Chief Audit Executive and the internal auditors contracted by Treasury (at present, EY). For the Ports Lessor Companies, Treasury will make reference to the requirements of the Corporations Act in determining audit requirements. Their audit programs will be governed by Treasury’s Audit Manual and by the Protocols signed with Ernst & Young (now EY) in 2012. However each entity will have its risks separately examined and if necessary recorded and managed. There will also be regard to each entity in the development of each year’s internal audit plan. This is not to say that each entity will appear in each year’s plan, however: the key criterion for determining those audits which go ahead is risk, and it is applied across the cluster (as defined in Annexure 1 of the Audit and Risk Committee Charter). An entity which was financially active during the year, and which the Secretary judges can afford to pay for its own audits, will do so on a cost recovery basis. The others will be subsidised by Crown. 7.9 Reporting and continuous improvement The Committee will report annually on its activities and findings to the Secretary, Treasury in that capacity and in his capacity as CEO of the smaller agencies; and to the General Treasury Shared Arrangements Agreement_July 2013 4 Manager RBMC and Directors of the Ports Lessor Companies regarding its work in relation to their respective entities. The Committee complies with TPP 09-05 in performing an annual self-assessment (followed by an improvement plan if needed) and assessments by the Chair of each member. The Secretary formally assesses the Chair’s performance at least once per year, having regard to all of the entities for which he is CEO. The General Manager, RBMC and the Directors of the Ports Lessor Companies (or their delegate) will be invited at least annually to meet with the Chair to discuss the performance of the Chair, all members and the audit function in general, plus any other matters of concern, in relation to their respective entities. 7.10 External audit The Audit Office is responsible for the external audit of all agencies in the cluster. Crown staff, the CAE and the Chair will liaise with the Audit Office on behalf of each of the shared arrangements agencies. From 1 July 2013 this includes RBMC and the Ports Lessor Companies, whose financial statements from that time are compiled and overseen by Crown staff and management, with the General Manager and Audit & Risk Committee as quality assurance. 7.11 Attestations Each agency entering into a shared agreement is required to make an attestation to Treasury in accordance with TPP 09-05 and to make a declaration in its annual report. 7.12 Dispute resolution Disputes should be reported to the Chief Audit Executive, who must work with the Chair to restore an effective working relationship and resolve the dispute by way of open negotiations. If they cannot be otherwise resolved, disputes may be escalated to the Secretary, or as a last resort to another central agency for mediation or other resolution. 8. Determination of Secretary regarding Corporations of the Treasury Cluster I, the Secretary of the Treasury, have determined on behalf of the following Corporations, of each of which I am the Chief Executive Officer, that they will opt into a principal departmentled shared arrangements agreement with Treasury on the terms set out in this agreement. o State Rail Authority Residual Holding Corporation o Liability Management Ministerial Corporation o Lotteries Assets Ministerial Holding Corporation o Electricity Assets Ministerial Holding Corporation o Ports Assets Ministerial Holding Corporation The Long Service Corporation and the Treasury Corporation have their own arrangements and are excluded from this Agreement. ………………………………………………….. Philip Gaetjens Secretary and Chief Executive Officer Date: Treasury Shared Arrangements Agreement_July 2013 5 9. Entry of Residual Business Management Corporation into this Agreement I, the General Manager of the Residual Business Management Corporation (RBMC) agree to opt into a principal department-led shared arrangements agreement with Treasury, on the terms set out in this agreement. ………………………………………………….. [Name] General Manager Date: 10. Entry of Port Botany and Port Kembla Lessor Companies into this Agreement We, the sole Directors of the Port Botany and Port Kembla Lessor Companies, agree to opt into a principal department-led shared arrangements agreement with Treasury, on the terms set out in this agreement. ………………………………………………….. [Name] Director Date: ………………………………………………….. [Name] Director Date: 11. Approval of Secretary to a Principal Department-led Shared Arrangements Agreement with the conditions described in this document I, the Secretary of the Treasury, approve this Agreement and the terms described herein. ………………………………………………….. Philip Gaetjens Secretary Date: Treasury Shared Arrangements Agreement_July 2013 6 Attachment 1 Complete list of Entities covered by this Agreement Where Secretary is CEO Treasury (principal department) State Rail Authority Residual Holding Corporation Liability Management Ministerial Corporation Lotteries Assets Ministerial Holding Corporation Electricity Assets Ministerial Holding Corporation Ports Assets Ministerial Holding Corporation Where CEO/Director has opted in to the Agreement Residual Business Management Corporation Port Botany Lessor Company Port Kembla Lessor Company The Treasury Audit & Risk Committee also monitors the Total State Sector Accounts. Organisations which are within the Treasury Cluster but out of scope of this Agreement: Treasury Corporation Long Service Corporation Cobbora Holding Company Pty Ltd Hunter Valley Training Company Pty Ltd Treasury Shared Arrangements Agreement_July 2013 7