Financing Residential Real Estate Lesson 7: The Financing Process Loan Costs Primary consideration for most buyers in choosing lender is how much loan will cost. Loan Costs Primary consideration for most buyers in choosing lender is how much loan will cost. In addition to interest rate, cost of loan may include: loan origination fee, discount points, miscellaneous charges, and mortgage broker’s fee. Loan Costs Points Point = percentage point 1 point = 1% of loan amount Loan Costs Points Point = percentage point 1 point = 1% of loan amount Usage issue: Some lenders use “points” to refer to origination fee and discount points together. Others use “points” to refer only to discount points. Loan Costs Loan origination fee Origination fee pays for lender’s expenses, such as staff compensation, facilities costs, and other overhead. Charged in almost every mortgage transaction. Typically around 1% of loan amount. Paid at closing, usually by borrower. Loan Costs Discount points Discount points are a lump sum paid at closing to increase lender’s upfront yield (profit) on loan. In exchange for upfront payment, lender charges borrower lower interest rate. May save borrower money in long run, depending on how long she owns home. Loan Costs Discount points How many discount points lenders charge varies depending on market conditions and other factors. Might charge 4 to 6 points for 1% interest rate reduction. Loan Costs Discount points Example: Market rate for mortgage: 5.25% Lender charges 4 points for 1% rate reduction $300,000 Loan amount x 4% 4 points $12,000 Cost of discount If lender is paid $12,000 up front, will charge borrower only 4.25% interest on loan. Loan Costs Discount points Discount points may be paid by buyer or seller. Buydown = Paying lender discount points to “buy down” buyer’s interest rate. Loan Costs Discount points Discount points may be paid by buyer or seller. Buydown = Paying lender discount points to “buy down” buyer’s interest rate. When buyer pays points, pays lender in cash at closing. When seller pays points, amount is withheld from loan amount and deducted from seller’s proceeds at closing. Loan Costs Miscellaneous fees In addition to an origination fee and discount points, lenders often charge borrowers other fees, such as: application fee document preparation fee underwriting fee Loan Costs Miscellaneous fees In addition to an origination fee and discount points, lenders often charge borrowers other fees, such as: application fee document preparation fee underwriting fee These vary widely from one lender to another. Borrower should ask loan originator if any can be reduced or waived. Loan Costs Mortgage broker’s compensation Buyers working with mortgage broker are generally charged a mortgage broker’s fee. May be separate fee or included in points quote for loan. Loan Costs Mortgage broker’s compensation Buyers working with mortgage broker are generally charged a mortgage broker’s fee. May be separate fee or included in points quote for loan. Shouldn’t make loan more expensive than one obtained without a broker’s help. Broker gets loan at wholesale price, marks it up to retail price, keeps overage as fee. Loan Costs Mortgage broker’s compensation Controversy over another form of mortgage broker compensation: yield spread premium (YSP). Loan Costs Mortgage broker’s compensation Controversy over another form of mortgage broker compensation: yield spread premium (YSP). Broker persuades borrower to accept a loan at “above par” (higher-than-market) interest rate. Loan Costs Mortgage broker’s compensation Controversy over another form of mortgage broker compensation: yield spread premium (YSP). Broker persuades borrower to accept a loan at “above par” (higher-than-market) interest rate. Lender pays broker YSP based on difference between market rate and borrower’s rate. Loan Costs Mortgage broker’s compensation Controversy over another form of mortgage broker compensation: yield spread premium (YSP). Broker persuades borrower to accept a loan at “above par” (higher-than-market) interest rate. Lender pays broker YSP based on difference between market rate and borrower’s rate. Practice gives mortgage brokers incentive to steer borrowers to more expensive loans. Comparing the Cost of Loans Truth in Lending Act The various fees charged in addition to interest make it hard to compare loans offered by different lenders. Truth in Lending Act (TILA): federal consumer protection law that requires lenders to disclose the cost of a loan using certain figures and terminology, to make comparison easier. Truth in Lending Act Annual percentage rate Most important TILA disclosure: annual percentage rate (APR). APR expresses relationship between all of the financing charges and the amount borrowed as a percentage. To determine which of two loans is more expensive, compare APRs, not just interest rates. Truth in Lending Act Total finance charge Another key TILA disclosure: total finance charge. Total finance charge includes: interest, origination fee, discount points paid by borrower, mortgage broker’s fee, finder’s fee, service fee, and/or mortgage guaranty or insurance fees. Truth in Lending Act Total finance charge Total finance charge does NOT include: title insurance costs, credit report charges, appraisal fee, or discount points paid by seller. Loan Costs No-fee or low-fee loans Some lenders offer no-fee loans or low-fee loans. No major lender charges such as origination fee or discount points. Only (or almost only) financing charge is interest. Interest rate often much higher than rate for loan with standard fees. Helpful for buyers with little cash for closing. Summary Loan Costs and Financing Options Origination fee Discount points Buydown Mortgage broker’s fee Truth in Lending Act APR Total finance charge No-fee or low-fee loan Home buyer counseling Summary Lesson 14: Fair Lending and Consumer Protection Consumer Protection Laws Federal consumer protection laws that apply to mortgage loan transactions: Truth in Lending Act Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act Consumer Protection Laws Truth in Lending Act Truth in Lending Act (TILA) – 1968 Implemented by Federal Reserve Board’s Regulation Z. Requires disclosure of finance charges. Regulates advertising of consumer credit. Truth in Lending Act Loans covered by TILA TILA applies only to consumer loans. Consumer loan = a loan used for personal, family, or household purposes. Consumer loan is covered by TILA if it is to be repaid in more than four installments (or is subject to finance charges) and is either: for $25,000 or less, or secured by real property. Truth in Lending Act Loans covered by TILA Thus, TILA applies to any mortgage loan used for personal, family, or household purposes, such as: buying or remodeling a home, consolidating personal debt, or sending kids to college. Truth in Lending Act Loans exempt from TILA TILA only applies to loans made to natural persons. Truth in Lending Act Loans exempt from TILA TILA only applies to loans made to natural persons. Doesn’t apply to: 1) loans made to corporations or organizations; 2) loans made for business, commercial, or agricultural purposes; or 3) loans > $25,000 not secured by real property. Truth in Lending Act Loans exempt from TILA TILA only applies to loans made to natural persons. Doesn’t apply to: 1) loans made to corporations or organizations; 2) loans made for business, commercial, or agricultural purposes; or 3) loans > $25,000 not secured by real property. Most seller financing is also exempt. Truth in Lending Act Disclosure requirements Lender must give mortgage loan applicant disclosure statement with estimates of loan costs within 3 days of receiving written application. Truth in Lending Act Disclosure requirements Lender expected to use best info reasonably available in preparing TILA disclosure statement. If estimates later prove incorrect, revised disclosures required. Truth in Lending Act Disclosure requirements Two most important disclosures: Total finance charge “Dollar amount your credit will cost you” Annual percentage rate (APR) “Cost of your credit as a yearly rate” TILA Disclosure Requirements Total finance charge For mortgage loan, these expenses would be included in total finance charge, if applicable: Interest Origination fee Points paid by borrower Finder’s fee Service charge Mortgage insurance premiums Guaranty fee Mortgage broker’s fee TILA Disclosure Requirements Total finance charge Not part of total finance charge for mortgage loan: Application fee Pest inspection fee Appraisal fee Flood inspection fee Document prep fee Impounds Notary fee Points paid by seller Credit report fee Late payment fees Survey fee Fees charged on default Title report fee Title insurance premiums TILA Disclosure Requirements Other disclosures TILA disclosure statement must also show: Lender’s identity Amount financed Payment schedule Total payments Any prepayment penalty Late charges Assumption policy TILA Disclosure Requirements ARMs APR for ARM can’t be calculated in same way as APR for fixed-rate loan, because total amount of interest to be charged is unknown at outset. When calculating APR for ARM, lender may use loan’s initial interest rate. Must state that APR is subject to increase after closing. TILA Disclosure Requirements ARMs Numerous special disclosures required for ARM secured by principal dwelling. CHARM booklet: “Consumer Handbook on Adjustable-Rate Mortgages.” TILA Disclosure Requirements ARMs Numerous special disclosures required for ARM secured by principal dwelling. CHARM booklet: “Consumer Handbook on Adjustable-Rate Mortgages.” Specific disclosures about ARM program(s) the applicant is considering, such as: how interest rate and payment may change; index used to determine ARM’s interest rate. TILA Disclosure Requirements ARM adjustment notice For ARM secured by principal dwelling, lender must notify borrower each time interest rate is being adjusted. Notice explains effect of adjustment on payment, loan balance, other aspects of loan. If payment amount will change, adjustment notice must be sent at least 25 days, but no more than 120 days, before change. Truth in Lending Act Right of rescission If security property is borrower’s existing principal residence, borrower has right of rescission. Truth in Lending Act Right of rescission If security property is borrower’s existing principal residence, borrower has right of rescission. May rescind loan agreement any time within 3 days after: signing agreement, receiving disclosure statement, or receiving notice of right of rescission. Truth in Lending Act Right of rescission If borrower doesn’t receive statement or notice, right of rescission doesn’t expire for 3 years. Truth in Lending Act Right of rescission Right of rescission applies to: home equity loans refinancing with a new lender Doesn’t apply to purchase loans. Truth in Lending Act Advertising under TILA TILA advertising rules apply to anyone who advertises consumer credit, not just lenders. Truth in Lending Act Advertising under TILA TILA advertising rules apply to anyone who advertises consumer credit, not just lenders. Rules prohibit: Bait and switch tactics. Misleading ads that feature only most attractive terms and disguise true cost of loan. Truth in Lending Act Advertising under TILA It’s legal to state cash price or APR in ad. But if particular “trigger” terms (such as downpayment, interest rate, or monthly payment) are stated, the rest of the terms must also be stated. Summary Truth in Lending Act Regulation Z Consumer loan Annual percentage rate Total finance charge ARM disclosures CHARM booklet Adjustment notice Right of rescission Advertising rules Bait and switch Consumer Protection Laws RESPA Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act – 1974 Affects how closing is handled in most residential mortgage transactions. RESPA Purpose of law RESPA has two main goals: to provide borrowers with information about all financing fees and closing costs; and to eliminate kickbacks and referral fees that increase borrowers’ costs. RESPA Covered transactions RESPA applies to all federally related loan transactions. Category includes most residential mortgage loans. RESPA Covered transactions Loan is federally related if both 1 and 2 apply: 1. Loan is secured by residential property with up to four dwelling units. Or loan will be used to finance construction of dwelling with up to four units. 2. Lender is federally regulated, has federally insured accounts, sells loans to secondary market agency, or makes more than $1 million in real estate loans per year. RESPA Exemptions RESPA doesn’t apply to: loan to purchase 25 acres or more; loan primarily for business, commercial, or agricultural purpose; loan to purchase vacant land, unless it will have dwelling built on it or mobile home placed on it; temporary financing (construction loan); assumption where lender’s approval not required or obtained. RESPA Requirements and Restrictions Disclosures to loan applicant 1. Within 3 days of written application, lender must give loan applicant: booklet about settlement procedures good faith estimate of closing costs mortgage servicing disclosure statement RESPA Requirements and Restrictions Affiliated business arrangements 2. When referring a party to another provider, a settlement service provider must disclose any affiliated business arrangement. Settlement service provider = lender, mortgage broker, title company employee, real estate agent. Affiliated business arrangement = referring provider has more than a 1% ownership or beneficial interest in the business the party is being referred to. RESPA Requirements and Restrictions Uniform Settlement Statement 3. Closing agent must itemize loan settlement charges on Uniform Settlement Statement form. Completed form must be available for inspection by borrower, upon request, at least one day before closing. Form has special sections for buyer and seller information; copies given to both parties at closing. RESPA Requirements and Restrictions Impound account deposits 4. If borrower required to make deposits into an impound account, lender can’t require excessive deposits. Excessive = more than necessary to cover expenses when due. Cushion of more than two months’ worth of payments generally considered excessive. RESPA Requirements and Restrictions Kickbacks and unearned fees 5. Lender or settlement service provider may not: give or receive kickbacks or referral fees; accept unearned fees; or charge a document preparation fee for required disclosures (Uniform Settlement Statement, impound account statement, or TILA disclosures). RESPA Requirements and Restrictions Choice of title company 6. Property seller may not require buyer to use a particular title insurance company. RESPA Requirements and Restrictions RESPA rule changes in 2010 In 2010, lenders will be required to start using new standardized form for good faith estimate (GFE) and new version of Uniform Settlement Statement. RESPA Requirements and Restrictions RESPA rule changes in 2010 New rules will also: Encourage lenders to give applicants GFE earlier in process, to facilitate comparison shopping. Place strict limits on cost increases between time of GFE estimates and closing. Require disclosure of more information about trade-offs between interest rate and other loan costs (such as yield spread premiums for mortgage brokers). Summary Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act RESPA Federally related loan transaction Settlement service provider Affiliated business arrangement Kickback or referral fee Unearned fee Good faith estimate of closing costs (GFE) Uniform Settlement Statement