Performance of mechanical ventilators for noninvasive positive pressure ventilation in children Brigitte Fauroux, Karl Leroux Gilbert Desmarais, Daniel Isabey, Annick Clément, Frédéric Lofaso, Bruno Louis. Table 1: Patient 1 with spinal muscular amyotrophy Pmax Pressurisation PEEP T PS ven P Ventilators Setting slope (cmH2O) (s) (cmH2O)(cmH2O) tilator (cmH2O/s) (cmH2O) ELYSEE150 double circuit PSV 10 ZEEP * * * * * * ELYSEE150 simple circuit PSV 10 ZEEP * * * * * * 1 LEGENDAIR PSV 10 ZEEP 0.63 0.28 -0.30 9.8 10.0 14.0 NEFTIS22 PSV 10 ZEEP 0.80 0.27 -0.84 9.1 10.0 48.1 SMARTAIR simple circuit PSV 10 ZEEP * * * * * * VS INTEGRA simple circuit PSV 10 ZEEP * * * * * * VS ULTRA double circuit flow trigger3 PSV 10 ZEEP 1.43 0.31 -0.83 10.3 10.0 60.1 VS ULTRA simple circuit PSV 10 ZEEP * * * * * * VS UTRA double circuit press trigger PSV 10 ZEEP * * * * * * ELYSEE150 double circuit * * * * * * ACV 250 ZEEP ELYSEE150 simple circuit4 9.8 10.0 14.0 ACV 250 ZEEP 0.28 0.32 -0.75 EOLE3 pressure trigger ACV 250 ZEEP * * * * * * EOLE3 flow trigger5 12.2 12.0 37.0 ACV 250 ZEEP 0.05 1.60 2.00 LEGENDAIR ACV 250 ZEEP * * * * * * NEFTIS26 10.8 12.0 49.3 ACV 250 ZEEP 0.65 0.28 -0.92 VS ULTRA double circuit flow trigger7 ACV 250 ZEEP 1.41 0.31 -0.71 12.7 12.5 61.7 VS ULTRA simple circuit ACV 250 ZEEP * * * * * * VS UTRA double circuit pressure trigger ACV 250 ZEEP * * * * * * VTm (L) VTv (L) * * 0.20 0.20 * * 0.23 * * * 0.25 * 0.30 * 0.25 0.27 * * * * 0.18 0.17 * * 0.32 * * * 0.25 * 0.25 * 0.22 0.34 * * Abbreviations: PEEP: positive end-expiratory pressure, T: trigger time delay, P: trigger pressure, PS: pressure support, Pmax: maximal inspiratory pressure delivered by the ventilator, VTm: measured tidal volume, VTv: tidal volume measured by the ventilator, ZEEP: zero end-expiratory pressure, ACV: assist control ventilation. Values reported in this table were obtained when the leak valve (Figure1) was closed. Effects of a leak simulated with the leak valve are indicated in the footnotes * does not detect the inspiratory effort or auto-triggering. 1auto-triggering for a leak of 3L/min, the ventilator requires a back up rate slightly below the spontaneous breathing rate 2alarm for a leak of 6.8L/min, pressure support falls to 6.7 cm H2O for a leak of 16L/min 4does not detect the inspiratory effort for a leak of 3L/min 5alarm for a leak of 1.2L/min, VT 165 ml 6alarm for a leak of 4.5L/min, VT 140 ml 7alarm for a leak of 3.4 l/min, VT 175 ml 3alarm Ventilators which do not have a compatible mode: GK425T, HARMONY2, iSLEEP22, KNIGHTSTAR330, SMARTAIR + leak circuit, SYNCHRONY and SYNCHRONY2, VIVO40,VPAP3ST, VPAP3STA, VS INTEGRA + leak circuit, VS SERENA, VS ULTRA + leak circuit. Table 2: Patient 2 with Duchenne muscular dystrophy Pmax Pressurisation PEEP T PS VTm P ventilator slope VTv (L) (cmH2O) (s) (cmH2O)(cmH2O) (L) (cmH2O) (cmH2O/s) PSV16 ZEEP 0.36 0.20 -1.52 16.1 16.0 142.9 0.357 0.384 ELYSEE150 double circuit1 2 ELYSEE150 simple circuit PSV16 ZEEP 0.47 0.19 -1.33 16.0 16.0 137.2 0.354 0.373 LEGENDAIR3 PSV16 ZEEP 0.64 0.20 -0.59 17.3 16.0 12.6 0.351 0.323 4 PSV16 ZEEP 1.00 0.21 -2.04 14.4 17.0 36.0 0.370 0.300 NEFTIS2 SMARTAIR simple circuit PSV16 ZEEP * * * * * * * * VS INTEGRA simple circuit PSV16 ZEEP * * * * * * * * VS ULTRA double circuit flow trigger5 PSV16 ZEEP 1.35 0.17 -1.31 15.9 16.0 100.5 0.370 0.450 VS ULTRA simple circuit6 PSV16 ZEEP 0.89 0.17 -1.37 16.0 17.0 109.9 0.378 0.460 VS UTRA double circuit pressure trigger PSV16 ZEEP * * * * * * * * 7 ELYSEE150 double circuit ACV500 ZEEP 0.40 0.32 -2.08 25.3 26.5 10.4 0.482 0.498 25.1 26.0 7.2 0.476 0.499 ELYSEE150 simple circuit8 ACV500 ZEEP 0.54 0.29 -1.81 EOLE3 pressure trigger ACV500 ZEEP * * * * * * * * 27.7 29.0 10.5 0.504 0.585 EOLE3 flow trigger9 ACV500 ZEEP -0.04 0.15 -0.48 21.9 22.5 32.6 0.473 0.498 LEGENDAIR10 ACV500 ZEEP 0.66 0.12 -0.38 23.0 23.0 37.8 0.474 0.420 NEFTIS211 ACV500 ZEEP 1.01 0.21 -2.09 5 23.2 23.5 69.3 0.431 0.530 VS ULTRA double circuit flow trigger ACV500 ZEEP 1.38 0.17 -1.30 * * * * * * * * VS ULTRA simple circuit ACV500 ZEEP VS UTRA double circuit pressure trigger ACV500 ZEEP * * * * * * * * Ventilators Setting Abbreviations: PEEP: positive end-expiratory pressure, T: trigger time delay, P: trigger pressure, PS: pressure support, Pmax: maximal inspiratory pressure delivered by the ventilator, VTm: measured tidal volume, VTv: tidal volume measured by the ventilator, ZEEP: zero end-expiratory pressure, ACV: assist control ventilation. Values reported in this table were obtained when the leak valve (Figure1) was closed. Effects of a leak simulated with the leak valve are indicated in the footnotes * does not detect the inspiratory effort or autotriggering. 1no detection of inspiratory effort or autotriggering for a leak of 16L/min for a leak of 8.8L/min 3alarm for a leak of 78 L/min, pressure 14/0, the ventilator requires a back up rate slightly below the spontaneous breathing 4alarm for a leak of 7.5 L/min, pressure support falls to 12.5 cmH O 2 5-autotriggering for a leak of 15L/min 6no detection of inspiratory effort or autotriggering for a leak of 16L/min 7no detection of inspiratory effort or autotriggering for a leak of 5L/min 8alarm for a leak of 5L/min, VT 285 ml 9alarm for a leak of 7.0 L/min, VT 302 ml 10does not detect the inspiratory effort or auto-triggering for a leak of 12 L/min, the ventilator requires a back up rate slightly below the spontaneous breathing 11alarm for a leak of 8.6 L/min, VT 300 ml 2autotriggering Ventilators which do not have a compatible mode: GK425T, HARMONY2, iSLEEP22, KNIGHTSTAR 330, SMARTAIR + leak circuit, SYNCHRONY and SYNCHRONY2, VIVO40, VPAP3ST, VPAP3STA, VS SERENA, VS ULTRA + leak circuit. Table 3: Patient 3 with cystic fibrosis Ventilators Setting ELYSEE150 double circuit1 2 ELYSEE150 simple circuit LEGENDAIR3 NEFTIS24 SMARTAIR simple circuit5 VS INTEGRA simple circuit VS ULTRA double circuit flow trigger6 VS ULTRA simple circuit7 VS UTRA double circuit pressure trigger6 ELYSEE150 double circuit7 ELYSEE150 simple circuit EOLE3 pressure trigger EOLE3 flow trigger8 LEGENDAIR9 NEFTIS210 VS ULTRA double circuit flow trigger11 VS ULTRA simple circuit12 VS UTRA double circuit pressure trigger13 Pmax Pressurisation PEEP T PS ven VTm P slope (cmH2O) (s) (cmH2O)(cmH2O) tilator (L) (cmH2O/s) (cmH2O) VTv (L) PSV16 ZEEP 0.17 0.33 -1.24 18.5 18.5 170.2 0.263 0.236 PSV16 ZEEP PSV16 ZEEP PSV16 ZEEP PSV16 ZEEP PSV16 ZEEP PSV16 ZEEP PSV16 ZEEP PSV16 ZEEP ACV500 ZEEP ACV500 ZEEP ACV500 ZEEP ACV500 ZEEP ACV500 ZEEP ACV500 ZEEP ACV500 ZEEP ACV500 ZEEP 0.42 0.64 0.97 0.24 * 1.43 0.66 0.30 0.27 * * 0.0 0.7 1.16 1.40 0.80 0.19 0.06 0.16 0.10 * 0.16 0.13 0.07 0.34 * * 0.07 0.06 0.16 0.15 0.10 -1.34 -0.53 -1.75 -0.20 * -1.41 -1.15 -0.69 -1.67 * * -0.42 -0.50 -1.76 -1.20 -1.0 18.8 16.6 15.1 16.7 * 16.3 16.2 16.2 27.8 * * 32.9 27.3 28.4 32.3 32.1 17.5 16.0 16.0 17.0 * 16.0 16.0 16.0 29.0 * * 33.0 27.0 29.0 31.5 32.5 170.9 7.1 74.4 22.3 * 92.6 119.1 69.0 60.6 * * 29.8 33.3 106.6 173.4 108.7 0.258 0.240 0.298 0.318 * 0.272 0.286 0.293 0.447 * * 0.488 0.488 0.472 0.434 0.552 ACV500 ZEEP 0.44 0.14 -0.84 32.1 31.5 102.7 0.454 0.525 0.268 0.190 0.260 0.340 * 0.340 0.315 0.295 0.446 * * 0.415 0.500 0.420 0.530 0.500 Abbreviations: PEEP: positive end-expiratory pressure, T: trigger time delay, P: trigger pressure, PS: pressure support, Pmax: maximal inspiratory pressure delivered by the ventilator, VTm: measured tidal volume, VTv: tidal volume measured by the ventilator, ZEEP: zero end-expiratory pressure, ACV: assist control ventilation. Values reported in this table were obtained when the leak valve (Figure1) was closed. Effects of a leak simulated with the leak valve are indicated in the footnotes * does not detect the inspiratory effort or autotriggering. 1no detection of inspiratory effort or autotriggering for a leak of 10L/min for a leak of 6L/min 3alarm for a leak of 55L/min, pressure support falls to 16/0, the ventilator requires a back up rate slightly below the spontaneous breathing 4alarm for a leak of 9L/min, pressure support falls to 9.8 cmH O 2 5without leak, no detection of the inspiratory effort without humidification 6no detection of inspiratory effort or autotriggering for a leak of 9L/min 7no detection of inspiratory effort or autotriggering for a leak of 6L/min 8autotriggering for a leak of 9L/min 9no detection of inspiratory effort or autotriggering for a leak of 8.5L/min, the ventilator requires a back up rate slightly below the spontaneous breathing 10alarm for a leak of 7.5L/min, VT falls to 230 ml 11autotriggering for a leak of 15L/min 12no detection of inspiratory effort or autotriggering for a leak of 5L/min 13no detection of inspiratory effort or autotriggering for a leak of 5L/min 2autotriggering Ventilators which do not have a compatible mode: GK425T, HARMONY2, iSLEEP22, KNIGHTSTAR330, SMARTAIR + leak circuit, SYNCHRONY and SYNCHRONY2, VIVO40, VPAP3ST, VPAP3STA, VS SERENA, VS ULTRA + leak circuit. Table 4: Patient 4 with laryngomalacia Pmax Pressurisation PEEP T PS ven VTm VTv P Ventilators Setting slope (cmH2O) (s) (cmH2O)(cmH2O) tilator (L) (L) (cmH2O/s) (cmH2O) ELYSEE150 double circuit PSV14 PEEP8 * * * * * * * * ELYSEE150 simple circuit PSV14 PEEP8 * * * * * * * * GK425ST PSV14 PEEP8 * * * * * * * * HARMONY2 PSV14 PEEP8 * * * * * * * * iSLEEP22 PSV14 PEEP8 * * * * * * * * 1 KNIGTSTAR330 PSV14 PEEP8 8.19 0.21 -0.16 14.6 14.0 46.9 0.051 0.074 LEGENDAIR2 PSV14 PEEP8 8.23 0.21 -0.48 14.3 14.0 12.0 0.042 0.030 NEFTIS2 PSV14 PEEP8 * * * * * * * * SMARTAIR leak circuit PSV14 PEEP8 * * * * * * * * SMARTAIR simple circuit PSV14 PEEP8 * * * * * * * * SYNCHRONY PSV14 PEEP8 * * * * * * * * SYNCHRONY2 PSV14 PEEP8 * * * * * * * * VIVO40 PSV14 PEEP8 * * * * * * * * VPAP3ST PSV14 PEEP8 * * * * * * * * VPAP3STA PSV14 PEEP8 * * * * * * * * VS INTEGRA leak circuit PSV14 PEEP8 * * * * * * * * VS INTEGRA simple circuit PSV14 PEEP8 * * * * * * * * VS SERENA PSV14 PEEP8 * * * * * * * * VS ULTRA double circuit flow trigger PSV14 PEEP8 * * * * * * * * VS ULTRA leak circuit PSV14 PEEP8 * * * * * * * * VS ULTRA simple circuit PSV14 PEEP8 * * * * * * * * VS UTRA double circuit pressure trigger PSV14 PEEP8 * * * * * * * * Abbreviations: PEEP: positive end-expiratory pressure, T: trigger time delay, P: trigger pressure, PS: pressure support, Pmax: maximal inspiratory pressure delivered by the ventilator, VTm: measured tidal volume, VTv: tidal volume measured by the ventilator. Values reported in this table were obtained when the leak valve (Figure1) was closed. Effects of a leak simulated with the leak valve are indicated in the footnotes * does not detect the inspiratory effort or autotriggering. 1autotriggering 2autotriggering for a leak of 2.6L/min for a leak of 6L/min, the ventilator requires a back up rate slightly below the spontaneous breathing Ventilator which does not have a compatible mode: EOLE3XLS Table 5: Patient 5 with vocal cord paralysis Ventilators Setting PSV14 PEEP8 ELYSEE150 double circuit1 2 PSV14 PEEP8 ELYSEE150 simple circuit 3 PSV14 PEEP8 GK425ST 4 PSV14 PEEP8 HARMONY2 5 PSV14 PEEP8 iSLEEP22 6 PSV14 PEEP8 KNIGTSTAR330 LEGENDAIR7 PSV14 PEEP8 8 PSV14 PEEP8 NEFTIS2 PSV14 PEEP8 SMARTAIR leak circuit PSV14 PEEP8 SMARTAIR simple circuit PSV14 PEEP8 SYNCHRONY9 9 PSV14 PEEP8 SYNCHRONY2 PSV14 PEEP8 VIVO4010 11 PSV14 PEEP8 VPAP3ST 12 PSV14 PEEP8 VPAP3STA PSV14 PEEP8 VS INTEGRA leak circuit 13 PSV14 PEEP8 VS INTEGRA simple circuit 14 PSV14 PEEP8 VS SERENA PSV14 PEEP8 VS ULTRA double circuit flow trigger PSV14 PEEP8 VS ULTRA leak circuit PSV14 PEEP8 VS ULTRA simple circuit15 16 VS UTRA double circuit pressure trigger PSV14 PEEP8 Peep (cmH2O) 8.6 6.7 7.5 8.1 8.3 8.3 8.1 7.5 * * 8.2 8.0 8.0 7.8 7.8 * 7.2 7.7 * * 8.8 9.0 Pmax Pressurisation PS VTm T P ventilator slope (L) (s) (cmH2O)(cmH2O) (cmH2O) (cmH20/s) 0.289 -1.94 13.9 14.0 24.4 0.242 0.246 -1.61 14.1 14.0 34.5 0.260 0.127 -0.21 13.6 14.0 23.7 0.294 0.128 -0.25 14.0 14.0 34.7 0.323 0.073 -0.54 14.5 15.0 12.2 0.285 0.061 -0.44 14.9 14.0 25.1 0.349 0.095 -1.24 14.4 14.0 8.2 0.303 0.073 -1.17 13.4 14.5 17.1 0.294 * * * * * * * * * * * * 0.119 -0.58 14.2 14.0 36.6 0.305 0.138 -1.01 14.3 14.0 36.1 0.330 0.210 -0.60 13.6 14.0 19.5 0.250 0.170 -0.23 14.0 14.0 39.3 0.313 0.112 -0.21 14.2 14.0 44.4 0.313 * * * * * * 0.059 -0.69 13.9 14.0 37.4 0.340 0.1 -0.4 14.1 14.0 35.5 0.327 * * * * * * * * * * * * 0.1 -1.1 15.0 14.0 51.7 0.3 0.1 -1.2 14.8 14.0 50.4 0.3 VTv (L) 0.233 0.262 No ind. No ind. No ind. 0.373 0.278 0.245 * * 0.262 0.262 0.160 0.312 0.322 * 0.405 0.320 * * 0.3 0.3 Abbreviations: PEEP: positive end-expiratory pressure, T: trigger time delay, P: trigger pressure, PS: pressure support, Pmax: maximal inspiratory pressure delivered by the ventilator, VTm: measured tidal volume, VTv: tidal volume measured by the ventilator. Values reported in this table were obtained when the leak valve (Figure1) was closed. Effects of a leak simulated with the leak valve are indicated in the footnotes * does not detect the inspiratory effort or autotriggering. 1autotriggering for a leak of 52L/min for a leak of 6L/min 3pressure support falls to 12.7 cm H O when leak > 114L/min 2 4alarm for a leak of 79L/min and pressure support falls to 13.7 cm H O 2 5autotriggering for a leak of 26L/min 6autotriggering for a leak of 5L/min 7alarm for a leak of 6L/min, the ventilator requires a back up rate slightly below the spontaneous breathing 8autotriggering for a leak of 6L/min 9pressure support falls to 11 cm H O when leak > 120L/min 2 10autotriggering for a leak of 28L/min, and does not detect the inspiratory effort when used with a humidifier 11alarm for a leak of 50L/min and pressure support falls to 14.2 cm H O and PEEP to 6.8 cm H O 2 2 12alarm for a leak of 42L/min and pressure support falls to 14.2 cm H O and PEEP to 6.9 cm H O 2 2 13autotriggering for any leak 14autotriggering for a leak of 20L/min 15autotriggering for a leak of 15L/min 16autotriggering for a leak of 7.5L/min 2autotriggering Ventilator which does not have a compatible mode: EOLE3XLS Table 6: Patient 6 with central apnea Ventilators ELYSEE150 double circuit1 ELYSEE150 simple circuit LEGENDAIR2 NEFTIS23 SMARTAIR simple circuit4 VS INTEGRA simple circuit VS ULTRA double circuit flow trigger VS ULTRA simple circuit VS UTRA double circuit pressure trigger5 Pmax Pressurisation PEEP T PS P Setting ventilator slope VTm (L) (cmH2O) (s) (cmH2O)(cmH2O) (cmH2O) (cmH2O/s) PSV12 ZEEP 0.23 0.18 -1.03 12.3 12.0 83.7 0.26 PSV12 ZEEP * * * * * * * PSV12 ZEEP 0.55 0.15 -0.97 12.1 12.0 7.4 0.85 PSV12 ZEEP 0.97 0.15 -1.80 6.2 13.0 16.4 0.36 PSV12 ZEEP 0.23 0.08 -0.36 12.1 13.0 7.8 1.02 PSV12 ZEEP * * * * * * * PSV12 ZEEP * * * * * * * PSV12 ZEEP * * * * * * * PSV12 ZEEP 0.47 0.13 -1.50 13.0 12.0 96.0 1.12 VTv (L) 0.65 * 0.83 0.31 1.03 * * * 1.01 Abbreviations: PEEP: positive end-expiratory pressure, T: trigger time delay, P: trigger pressure, PS: pressure support, Pmax: maximal inspiratory pressure delivered by the ventilator, VTm: measured tidal volume, VTv: tidal volume measured by the ventilator, ZEEP: zero end-expiratory pressure, ACV: assist control ventilation. Values reported in this table were obtained when the leak valve (Figure1) was closed. Effects of a leak simulated with the leak valve are indicated in the footnotes * does not detect the inspiratory effort or autotriggering. 1does not detect the patient’s inspiratory effort or autotriggering for a leak of 8L/min for a leak of 2.3L/min, the ventilator requires a back up rate slightly below the spontaneous breathing 3alarm “disconnected circuit, patient compliance” + autotriggering for a leak of 10L/min, 4autotriggering for a leak of 1.5L/min 5autotriggering for a leak of 24L/min and does not detect the patient’s inspiratory effort with a humidificator 2autotriggering Ventilators which do not have a compatible mode: EOLE3XLS, GK425T, HARMONY2, iSLEEP22, KNIGHTSTAR330, SMARTAIR + leak circuit, SYNCHRONY and SYNCHRONY2, VIVO40, VPAP3ST, VPAP3STA, VS SERENA, VS ULTRA + leak circuit Table 7: Testing of the quality of the expiratory triggers by the difference between the patient’s inspiratory time during spontaneous breathing (Tinsp) and the inspiratory time during mechanical ventilation (T I). Tinsp-TI (s) Ventilators patient # 1 patient # 2 patient # 3 patient # 4 patient # 5 patient # 6 ELYSEE150 double circuit * 0.04 0.12 * 0.35 -0.32 ELYSEE150 simple circuit * 0.05 0.21 * 0.40 * GK425ST na na na * 0.21 na HARMONY2 na na na * 0.09 na iSLEEP22 na na na * 0.27 na KNIGTSTAR330 na na na 0.00 0.20 na LEGENDAIR 0.05 0.06 0.14 -0.09 0.18 -0.34 NEFTIS2 -0.23 -0.23 -0.12 * -0.08 -0.06 SMARTAIR leak circuit na na na * * na SMARTAIR simple circuit * * -0.05 * * * SYNCHRONY na na na * 0.25 na SYNCHRONY2 na na na * 0.05 na VIVO40 na na na * 0.39 na VPAP3ST na na na * 0.27 na VPAP3STA na na na * 0.07 na VS INTEGRA leak circuit na na na * * na VS INTEGRA simple circuit * * * * 0.40 * VS SERENA na na na * -0.23 na VS ULTRA double circuit flow trigger 0.02 -0.05 0.14 * * * VS ULTRA leak circuit na na na * * na VS ULTRA simple circuit * -0.11 0.08 * 0.48 * VS UTRA double circuit pressure trigger * * 0.00 * 0.48 -0.52 Abbreviations: na: not applicable. This parameter was only calculated for pressure-targeted ventilators.