Apparent Memories Normally, and at present I remember something because it happened to me This might change The reason I remember is because it happened to me. I saw Susan So I remember seeing Susan The memory is caused the right way. Suppose this changed . l. I remember 2 I remember what happened to me 3. But I don't remember it the right way The apparent memory. I have the memory, but I was never in Susan’s presence. Consider an actual case. Surgical intervention causing apparent memories I think I remember but I remember being someone where I, i.e. my body was not Is that my memory? No, because it is not caused in the right way With such technology, I could 'remember' events taking place long before I was born. Physical and Mental criteria for personal identity come into conflict.