Idea of professionalism style of profession

advertisement
Presentation for the ISA Forum, RC52
August 2012 in Buenos Aires
Kurt Dauer Keller
Department of Learning and Philosophy, Aalborg University
The idea of professionalism
• The notion of professionalism as the ideal type of a ’third social logic’ next to
(state) bureaucracy and market (Freidson)
• The very idea of professionalism is theoretical (conceptual, discursive), and
of normative as well as of descriptive interest
• It must be conceived as a distinct political and sociocultural ’institution’: a
significant factor of the civil society, deeply rooted in our lifeworld and
civilization
• In its inherent association with ethics and trust: a notion of the entirety of
social order (alternative to ’the state’ and ’the market’)
• An open empirical question: in what ways and to what extent are concrete
professions marked by the habitus (and institution) of professionalism?
ISA Forum 2012
K.D. Keller, Aalborg University
2
The style (and other important notions) of a profession
• The style: the recognized identity (prevailing image) of a characteristic
form of professional practice; the social sense and significance that it
represents
• not a cognitive or discursive idea, but a corporeal experience of
practical meaning
• The habitus: the actual organization and accomplishment of
professional work (not enough elucidated in previous research, cf.
Abbott 1988, Freidson 2001)
• The institution: the socioculturally taken for granted coherence
between the social field and the habitus of a profession
ISA Forum 2012
K.D. Keller, Aalborg University
3
The phenomenological understanding of experience and behavior
as intentional (perspectival, oriented) meaning
 Figure on a background
 Theme in a context
 Event in a situation
Examples:
 A personal action that makes sense and is of significance within an interpersonal communication, an occupational community or an anonymous
socioculture
 The focus-foreground-background structure of work organization:
situated discretion - competent practice - social identity
ISA Forum 2012
K.D. Keller, Aalborg University
4
Ideal types of social order and their work organizational implications
IDEAL TYPICAL
SOCIAL ORDER
MOTIVATED
DISCRETION
INSTITUTED
PRACTICE
POSITIONING
(POWER GAME)
STATE
politics (law)
obedience
MARKET
economy (money)
self-interest
hierarchic
placement
competition
PROFESSION
ethics (trust)
impartiality
surveillance and
governance
turnover and
consumption
expert labour
ISA Forum 2012
K.D. Keller, Aalborg University
occupational
organization
5
Dimensions of professional style
discursive
descriptive
interpretive
corporeal
ISA Forum 2012
K.D. Keller, Aalborg University
6
Practical understanding of evidence and expert knowledge to be
attained through health educations (Voldbjerg et al.)
 Corporeal knowledge in the education of nurses:
 Handling lung and throat tissue
 Actualizing emotions of sorrow and loss
 Interpretive knowledge in the education of occupational therapists:
 Evocation of a mythology of the establishment of the professional discipline
 Interpretive knowledge in the education of radiographers:
 Realizing how criteria of picture quality may depend on the context of application
ISA Forum 2012
K.D. Keller, Aalborg University
7
Developmental and dynamic coherence of varieties of expert
knowledge
Critical, reflected
explanation
Holistic, integrating
interpretation
Immediate, corporeal
understanding
ISA Forum 2012
K.D. Keller, Aalborg University
8
The democracy of professionalism and professions
Predominant aspects of democracy in the ideal types of social logic:
Realted to ’politics’:
 The state: delegation and civil rights (formal, ’cognitive’ orientation)
 The market: liberty (appetitive, ’conative’ orientation)
Related to ’the political’:
 The professionalism: character attitude (humanistic , ’emotional’ orientation)
Important aspects of democracy without particular relation to one ideal type:
 Freedom of organization, press and speech
 Deliberation
The cross-cutting question of ’systemic colonizing’ of the lifeworld (and civil society)
ISA Forum 2012
K.D. Keller, Aalborg University
9
Download