Document 15453970

advertisement

Introduction

I would like to investigate the extent to which both young people and adults feel that young people also can and should have a say in the world. I am a young person and have strong views about the involvement of young people in decisions that affect their lives. I think that young people should be given the rights that are given to adults. It is my belief that young people can be treated as equal citizens in society and I wish to explore through this research project the perceptions and views of some young people and some adults about this subject. The participation of young people in decision-making is becoming more usual in different areas of life such as schools and the development of services. It will be interesting to test what the views of some groups are and from this, make recommendations for change in organizations or in society at national level. The comparison of views of young people and adults in England as described will also be informative.

Research Plan

Aim

• To investigate the views of young people

(11-14) & adults in England, regarding the extent to which they should influence decisions that affect their lives.

• To find out the views of adults in England.

The topic areas include voting, public decision making (for e.g. services) and school.

Ethical Consideration

The research ensured that all participants gave informed consent. Confidentiality & anonymity was guaranteed to guard against any sensitivity in young people about adults knowing their individual views. Adult participants were also guaranteed confidentiality and anonymity. The research was sensitive to cultural differences and took account of this when sharing the data.

Method

I designed a questionnaire about rights and gave this to a mixed group of adults and a group of students from my school aged between 11 and

18. The questionnaire explored attitudes of the two groups about young people’s rights.

These were then analyzed and the results used to determine whether young people should be provided the same rights as adults and if yes on what aspects.

Places From Where

I Gathered The Data

This research was conducted in one of the schools in Milton Keynes where many young people answered the questionnaire, some questionnaires were also filled up by some of the teachers. Some of the other data provided by adults was from my father’s and my neighbour’s office colleagues.

The extent to which children's ideas and opinions are considered at school

100

50

11 to 14

18+

0 a lot

11 to 14 26.82

18+ 26.66

a little

48.78

46.66

hardly at

24.39

26.66

never

0

0

In this question majority of people think that children’s ideas and opinions are considered only a little at school, but it is not like they are never considered, rarely they are considered.

The extent to which children's ideas and opinions are considered by society

100

50

11 to 14

18+

0

11 to 14

18+ a lot

5.12

6.66

a little

41.02

60 hardly at

33.33

26.66

never

20.51

6.66

In this question majority of people think that children’s ideas and opinions are considered only a little by the society, but it is not like they are never considered, rarely they are considered.

Freedom At School

11 to 14

18+

11 to 14

18+

100

80

60

40

20

0 too much about right not enough no way

2.56

13.33

38.46

73.33

56.41

13.33

2.56

0

In this question most of the young people think that they are not provided enough rights at school whereas majority of adults think that they are provided enough rights at school.

Schools Being Just Like Universities From The Point

Of View Of Freedom

100

11 to 14

18+

50

0

Strongly

Agree

11 to 14 10.52

18+ 0

Agree

13.15

0

Slightly

Agree

Slightly

Disagree

Disagree

Strongly

Disagree

57.89

0

15.78

28.57

2.63

71.42

0

0

In this question majority of young people slightly agree to the concept of schools being just like universities from the point of view of freedom, and majority of adults disagree to this concept.

Deciding The School Uniform

11 to 14

18+

100

50

11 to 14

18+

0

We shouldn't get to We should get to

14.63

21.42

46.34

7.14

Dress code of formal and decent

39.02

78.57

In this question majority of young people think that they should get to decide their school uniform whereas majority of adults think that there should be a dress code of formal and decent wear.

Do Children Feel Bad If They Are Called As A Child

100

20

0

11 to 14

18+

80

60

40 yes

10

23.07

slightly

12.5

0 sometimes not really

42.5

38.46

25

38.46

no

10

0

11 to 14

18+

In this question majority of young people feel bad sometimes if they are called as a child whereas majority of adults feel that young children sometimes or not really feel bad if they are called as a child.

Do Children Feel Offended If They Are Denied The Rights

Provided To Adults

100

80

60

40

20

0

11 to 14

18+ yes

12.5

31.25

slightly sometimes not really

12.5

12.5

30

18.5

32.5

25 no

12.5

12.5

11 to 14

18+

In this question most of the young people not really feel offended if they are called as a child whereas most of the adults think that children do feel offended if they are called as a child.

Are Children As Matured As An Adult?

100

80

60

40

20

0 yes

11 to 14 12.19

18+ 7.69

slightly sometimes not really

29.26

0

34.14

7.69

14.63

23.07

no

9.75

61.53

11 to 14

18+

In this question majority of young people feel that they are sometimes as matured as adults whereas adults feel that young people are not as matured as an adult.

Right Age For Voting

100

80

60

40

20

0

13

11 to 14 10

18+ 0

14

7.5

0

15

32.5

0

16

25

26.66

17

5

0

18 or above

20

73.33

11 to 14

18+

In this question majority of young people feel that 15yrs is the right age for voting whereas majority of adults feel that 18yrs or above is the right age for voting.

Age For Driving

100

80

60

40

20

0

11 to 14

18+

13

5

0

14

0

0

15

12.5

0

16

30

6.66

17

37.5

6.66

18 or above

15

86.66

11 to 14

18+

In this question most of young people feel that 17yrs is the right age for driving whereas most of the adults feel that 18yrs or above is the right age for voting.

Age For Marriage

100

80

60

40

20

0

13

11 to 14 2.43

18+ 0

14

2.43

0

15

9.75

0

16 17

18 or above

4.87

26.82

53.65

0 0 100

11 to 14

18+

In this question majority of young people feel that the right age for marriage should be 18yrs or above whereas all of the adults also feel that the right age for marriage should be 18yrs or above.

Rights In England Are

11 to 14

18+

100

80

60

40

20

0

Too many About Right Not Enough

7.31

10

73.17

80

19.57

10

11 to 14

18+

Majority of the young people as well as majority of adults feel that the rights in England are about right.

Conclusion

The conclusion I can draw from this research is that young people’s ideas and opinions should be considered in the society and schools, but that these should not be equal to adults because young people are not should not yet as mature as an adult. Here are some suggestions that I have drawn from my findings

• there should be a dress code of formal and decent wear in schools rather than either one particular uniform or complete freedom to wear what they want, this will let them express their identities well and also be decently dressed.

• Children should not be looked down on or be underestimated as even they can have good ideas and can know a lot.

• The age for voting should be set at 16yrs as, even though they are not completely as mature as an adult, they know about politics and social issues going on in society.

• The age for driving should be 18yrs old because driving is a risky thing and young people may race ridiculously and end up in an accident.

• Age for marriage should also be 18 yrs as children.

Download