L EQUALITY SCHEME SECTION 75 AND SCHEDULE 9 OF THE NORTHERN IRELAND ACT March 2003 D:\401289085.doc Contents Page 1. Background to the Scheme 3 2. The Open University’s Commitment to the Scheme 6 3. Consultation Process 8 4. Introduction to the Open University 10 5. Statutory Duty under Section 75 of the Northern Ireland Act 19 6. Arrangements for Assessing Compliance with Section 75 duties 23 7. Arrangements for Screening and Prioritising 27 8. Equality Impact Assessments 29 9. Timetabling 30 10. Consultation 31 11. Monitoring 33 12. Publication of Assessments and Monitoring 35 13. Training 37 14. Public Access to Information and Services 40 15. Publication of the Scheme 42 16. Complaints 43 17. Summary Timetable 44 18. Appendices 46 2 D:\401289085.doc 1. Background to the Scheme, its Scope and Purpose This introductory section to the Open University’s Equality Scheme explains why equal opportunities are important, and how the Open University can fulfil the objectives of its Charter in a way that will promote equal opportunities and good relations in Northern Ireland. 1.1 The Need for an Equality Scheme – The Northern Ireland Act The new duties for public authorities in Northern Ireland to promote equality of opportunity and good relations grew from the multi-party talks in Northern Ireland, (the ‘Peace Process’) which culminated in the Belfast Agreement of 1998. The ‘Rights, Safeguards and Equality of Opportunity’ section of the Belfast Agreement included a commitment to introducing new statutory duties on public authorities to ‘mainstream’ equality and good relations. These duties were subsequently promulgated in Section 75 of the Northern Ireland Act 1998. The new statutory duties make equality central to the whole range of public policy decision-making. This approach is referred to as ‘mainstreaming’ and aims to condition and influence policy-making in all spheres and at all levels of government activity and public policy decision making. Mainstreaming equality is important for several reasons. Experience in Northern Ireland and elsewhere shows that questions of equality may easily become sidelined in organisations. Effective attention to ‘mainstreaming’ addresses this problem, by requiring all public authorities to engage directly with equality issues at an early stage in policy development. This is complementary to making more effective those measures adopted specifically to tackle discrimination, such as anti-discrimination law. 3 D:\401289085.doc The Northern Ireland Act 1998 (hereafter, “the Act”) requires public bodies to conduct their business in a way which promotes equal opportunities and good relations. Although the Open University is not a public body in Northern Ireland, it has been designated as such, for the purposes of the Act, by the Minister for Employment and Learning. The date of this designation was 13 April 2001. 1.2 Section 75 of the Northern Ireland Act 1998 (the Act) requires public authorities in carrying out their functions relating to Northern Ireland, to have due regard to the need to promote equality of opportunity. (a) between persons of different religious belief, political opinion, racial group, age, marital status or sexual orientation; (b) between men and women generally; (c) between persons with a disability and persons without; and (d) between persons with dependants and persons without. Without prejudice to these obligations, a public authority is also required, in carrying out its functions, to have regard to the desirability of promoting good relations between persons of different religious belief, political opinion or racial group. Schedule 9 of the Act (the Schedule) sets out a detailed procedure for the enforcement of these duties. In brief, public authorities are each required to produce an Equality Scheme stating how they propose to fulfil these duties. This must be submitted to the Equality Commission (the Commission) for approval. The Act provides that Equality Schemes produced by public authorities must conform to any Guidelines as to form and content issued by the Commission with the approval of the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland. The public authority must conduct a review or the Scheme within five years of submission of the Scheme to the Commission and the Commission must be informed of the outcome of that review. 4 D:\401289085.doc 1.3 The Equality Commission The Equality Commission for Northern Ireland has replaced the Equal Opportunities Commission, the Fair Employment Commission, the Commission for Racial Equality of Northern Ireland and the Northern Ireland Disability Council. The Equality Commission is responsible for ensuring that organisations fulfil their legal duties relating to equality and promoting good relations. 1.4 Producing the Open University Scheme The Open University Scheme was prepared under the direction of the Regional Director working with the Assistant Director (Development) and with guidance from the Open University’s Equal Opportunities Unit. It is broadly similar to other schemes in the Northern Ireland Higher Education sector produced by Queen’s University, Belfast, and the University of Ulster apart from the major difference of the Open University in Northern Ireland being part of a larger all U.K. institution. This difference has implications for the OU in Northern Ireland with regard to practical matters such as central approval of policies and their implementation in Northern Ireland – these are referred to in this document. The Scheme attempts to meet the guidance laid down by the Equality Commission and has been prepared with the support and approval of the appropriate authorities and decision-making bodies within the Open University. __________________________________________ 5 D:\401289085.doc 2. The Open University’s Commitment to the Scheme This document comprises the Open University’s Equality Scheme, in keeping with the requirements of Section 75 and Schedule 9 of the Northern Ireland Act 1998. The Open University recognises its statutory obligations under this legislation, and is fully committed to the fulfilment of these obligations, specifically in relation to (i) the promotion of equality of opportunity between persons of different religious belief, political opinion, racial group, age, marital status or sexual orientation; between men and women generally; between persons with a disability and persons without; and between persons with dependants and persons without, and (ii) good relations between persons of different religious belief, political opinion or racial group. This Equality Scheme endeavours to describe how the Open University will propose to meet these obligations in Northern Ireland. Under the power and authority vetted by The Council and by the Senate of the University in my position as Vice-Chancellor, it is my responsibility, delegated through the Open University Regional Director for Northern Ireland, to ensure that the formulation and implementation of the Open University’s policies are in compliance with the Act. In order to achieve this goal, I have instructed my Regional Director to ensure that all members of OU staff in Northern Ireland are made familiar with this Scheme and its implementation through a planned programme of communication and training. In collaboration with central and regional colleagues, it will be the responsibility of the Regional Director to ensure that new policies will be formulated and implemented in compliance with the provisions of the Scheme. She shall also be responsible for instigating a review of existing policies, to ensure compliance throughout the Open University’s entire range of policies. 6 D:\401289085.doc I shall ensure that appropriate internal arrangements are put in place, including a commitment to the allocation of necessary resources to ensure that the Equality Scheme can be implemented effectively, that progress can be monitored and reviewed in due course and that details of the Scheme are available in accessible formats and in a timely fashion. ________________________ Professor Brenda Gourley Vice-Chancellor The Open University Regional Director’s Statement: As Regional Director of the Open University in Ireland I undertake to ensure that the formulation and implementation of the Open University’s policies in Northern Ireland are in compliance with requirements of Section 75 and Schedule 9 of the Northern Ireland Act 1998. I am directly responsible to the Vice-Chancellor of the University for ensuring the effective implementation of the Open University’s Equality Scheme in Northern Ireland. ____________________________ Dr Rosemary Hamilton Regional Director The Open University Region 12 Ireland 7 D:\401289085.doc 3. Consultation Process Consultation with those in the community who are affected by the University’s policies is central to the successful operation of the Equality Scheme. The Scheme is, therefore, being presented to the Equality Commission following consultation with community groups and representatives. The Open University has welcomed comments from the general public; community groups; interest groups; students and their representatives; staff and their representatives; and representatives of people of different religious beliefs, political opinion, racial groups, age, gender, disability, marital status, sexual orientation and those with and without dependants. The closing date for the receipt of comments was Friday 7 th December 2001. The Open University continues to welcome comments which will help with the implementation of its Equality Scheme. All comments should be sent to: Mr Gary Sloan Assistant Director (Development) The Open University Regional Centre 40 University Road Belfast BT7 1SU Tel: 028 9024 5025 Ext. 72162 Email: w.g.sloan@open.ac.uk Fax: 028 9023 0565 The Scheme can be made available on disc or in large print and in Braille, also in minority languages (for those who are not fluent in English), or on an audio-cassette, by contacting the Open University at the address above. _________________________________________ The Open University has received responses from the following:- 1. Committee on the Administration of Justice (CAJ) 2. British Deaf Association 3. Coalition for Sexual Orientation 4. Department of Culture, Arts and Leisure 5. Department for Employment and Learning 8 D:\401289085.doc 6. Disability Action 7. Eastern Health and Social Services Board 8. Education & Library Board – Belfast, Ulster and Irish Studies, Belfast Central Library 9. Lifestart Mid-Ards 10. The Mediation Network for Northern Ireland 11. Mencap in Northern Ireland 12. N.B.N.I. Centre House, Chichester Street, Belfast 13. N.I.C. Northern Ireland Committee, Irish Congress of Trade Unions 14. Rural Community Network 15. Training for Women Network Ltd 16. West Belfast Economic Forum _______________________________________ 9 D:\401289085.doc 4. Introduction to the Open University 4.1 Established by Royal Charter in 1969, the Open University is now Britain’s largest single teaching institution. It was responsible for pioneering the concept of university-level education at a distance through supported open learning available to all adults, regardless of their previous qualifications. Today, it is recognised as a world leader with a reputation founded on the high quality and broad range of its courses and on its learning support and services to students. Over a million people from all walks of life have now benefited from such courses, and in any one year more than 200,000 study throughout the UK, Ireland and beyond. It is rapidly expanding to become a genuinely European Open University, without walls or frontiers. The OU’s headquarters are situated at Walton Hall - an attractive campus location in the fast-developing city of Milton Keynes, with its central position between London and Birmingham and Oxford and Cambridge. Whilst the OU is a national university, it also retains a local identity. Thirteen regional centres ensure that its students receive services which are accessible from their homes and workplaces. In Northern Ireland, the Open University has had a regional presence in Belfast since 1970 when it registered over 1,000 students. Since 1996 it has had a complementary Enquiry and Advice Centre in Dublin. Over 8,000 students were registered in 2001 for the Open University in Ireland. The Open University in Region 12 remains committed to Michael Young’s vision for an “Open University” and to the University's original mission, articulated by Lord Crowther for the Open University in 1969, to be 'open as to people, open as to places, open as to methods and open as to ideas'. This is the mission which has 10 D:\401289085.doc inspired students, staff and the wider public for a generation. It emanates from a commitment to research and scholarship of the highest quality and a commitment and ability of staff to make each Open University course intellectually exciting and, in the words of the former Vice-Chancellor Sir John Daniel, "academically unassailable". 4.2 The Objectives of the Open University The objects of the Open University as embodied in the Article of the Charter are the advancement and dissemination of learning through teaching and research by a diversity of means such as broadcasting and technological devices appropriate to higher education, by correspondence tuition, residential courses and seminars, and in other relevant ways. The Open University is also required to provide education of university and professional standards for its students, and to promote the educational well-being of the community generally. Currently the specific objectives of the Open University are set out in its “Plans for Change 2000 - 2010”, the University’s Strategic and Development Plans as follows:- i. Improving the attractiveness of the OU for lifelong learning To achieve a shift in the in the OU student mix over the next few years, in particular by providing more courses to meet people’s needs for continuing professional development and up-dating, and for leisure learning. To present a range of financially viable short courses, at further and higher education levels, in areas of high demand, including continuing professional development and updating, and leisure learning; and to develop new processes and systems, where appropriate, for short courses. 11 D:\401289085.doc To explore further ways of increasing flexibility for students in their OU study, such as more course start dates each year, more flexibility in assessment arrangements, ‘stretching’ of study across presentations, and implementing options that are found to be feasible and financially viable. To improve the services we provide in order to provide timely and useful information to help students make decisions on their continuing study with the OU, to meet their individual learning needs. To take further action to improve retention rates of students within course, within award and between awards. ii New market segments To explore how to make OU courses more attractive so that new market segments in the EU can be successfully targeted: - younger students (up to 25 years) for undergraduate diplomas and first degrees. - older students (with no dependants, still in work or retired, and so with time for study, and with disposable income) for leisure learning and personal development. - graduates and diplomates (of the OU and other HEIs) for postgraduate courses and continuing professional development and updating. 12 D:\401289085.doc - corporate markets for (mainly longer) courses for undergraduate and postgraduate awards and for shorter courses for continuing professional development and updating. - membership organisations (such as trade unions, professional institutions, and those concerned with culture and heritage), where the nature of the courses provided - more employment related or leisure learning - will depend on the type of organisation. To support partners in developing new markets in particular United States Open University (USOU). iii Widening participation in higher education To develop and implement a strategy for widening participation in higher education, by identifying groups currently disadvantaged, and then seeking out study opportunities that will improve participation and success for these groups, having regard to any Government policies and initiatives. To work collaboratively with other organisations to provide study opportunities and support, and to prepare students for higher education study, particularly with the OU for example through provision of further education with local providers, using the OU’s supported opening learning method. iv Accessibility To find ways of improving accessibility to the OU, increasingly through the use of I&CT, both in teaching and associated services/administration, and through other appropriate means. 13 D:\401289085.doc v Partnerships To enter into strategic partnerships in order to achieve the objectives above: - with corporate universities and large employers - with membership organisations - with local further education providers Some partnerships with employer organisations and further education providers may involve Regional Development Agencies, and relate specifically to the regions’ priority areas for economic regeneration. vi Market research To devise and implement an ongoing corporate market research programme that will support the OU’s strategic development: - to understand our markets and market segments better, so that current and future lifelong learning needs can be better met - to gauge the demand for shorter courses - to gauge the level of demand in the new market segments put forward for targeting 4.3 The Open University’s Government Structure 4.3.1 The Open University is governed by a Council which includes amongst its membership representatives of the academic and non-academic staff, associate lecturers and students, and a number of external co-opted members. Its structure has recently been reviewed and changes to the Charter and Statutes approved by the Privy Council. It is chaired by the ProChancellor and is normally scheduled to meet five times a year. Subject to the academic powers of the Senate, the Council exercises general control over the Open University’s affairs but is particularly concerned with its 14 D:\401289085.doc finances and property and with staff matters. The Council will be responsible for the effective implementation of the Open University’s Equality Scheme for Northern Ireland. 4.3.2 The Senate is the academic authority of the Open University and comprises just over 1000 members including all academic staff, both central and regional, and research fellows, together with specific individuals and elected representatives of the associate lecturers, students, the BBC, and the nonacademic staff. It is chaired by the Vice-Chancellor and normally meets at least three times a year. The Senate controls the Open University’s academic programme, its teaching and research, regulates its examinations, and is concerned with the institution of degrees and courses of study. Arising from these powers it promulgates the Student Regulations of the Open University, subject to the confirmation of the Council. The Senate may subject to the confirmation of the Council, delegate any of its specific powers as conferred by Statute to a body or person constituted for the purpose, and it has done this in relation to a growing number of issues. 4.4. The Duties and Responsibilities of individuals in the Open University 4.4.1 The Vice-Chancellor The Vice-Chancellor is the Chief Administrative Officer of the Open University. Under the statutes of the Open University, the Vice- Chancellor has a general responsibility to the Council and the Senate for maintaining and promoting the efficiency and good order of the Open University. The Vice-Chancellor is formally designated as the Principal Officer (Accounting Officer) of the Open University under the terms of the Financial Memorandum issued by the Higher Education Funding Council (England). In terms of the management structure of the Open University, the Vice-Chancellor has an overall responsibility for each unit in the Open University and many of the heads of such units (e.g. the Deans and Directors of Studies, the Secretary and the 15 D:\401289085.doc Director, Student Services) report directly to the Vice-Chancellor. Within the government structure of the Open University, the ViceChancellor chairs the General Assembly, the Senate, the Academic Board, the Validation Board, the Strategic Planning and Resources Committee, the Operational Planning and Budget Committee and the Honorary Degrees Committee, is a member of the Council and the Senior Staff Salaries Committee and, by virtue of office, a member of all boards and committees of the Open University established under the Council and the Senate. The Vice-Chancellor also chairs the Professorial Appointment Committees and the Academic Staff Promotions Committee. Ex officio the Vice-Chancellor chairs the board of OU Worldwide Ltd and is President of the United States Open University. 4.4.2 The Pro-Vice-Chancellors The Pro-Vice-Chancellors are appointed by the Council, on the recommendation of the Senate, from among the staff of the Open University. Until 1998 the Charter stated that they should be appointed from among the academic staff of the Open University; with the approval of the Privy Council in May 1998 this restriction on eligibility was removed. They hold office for a period not exceeding five years and are eligible for re-appointment. The statutes give the Council the power to determine the number of Pro-Vice-Chancellors that shall be appointed and the Vice-Chancellor has sole authority to determine the function and duties of each, subject to their constitutional roles being a matter for the Senate and the Council. Pro-Vice-Chancellors are accountable to the Vice-Chancellor for the execution of their duties. There are currently five Pro-Vice- Chancellors, who have been given specific responsibilities in the following areas: 16 D:\401289085.doc (a) curriculum and awards; (b) learning technologies and teaching; (c) research and staff; (d) strategy, planning and partnerships; and (e) students, quality and standards. 4.4.3 The Secretary The Secretary is an Officer of the Open University and is responsible, subject to the direction of the Vice-Chancellor, for the administration of the Open University. The Secretary is also a member of the senior management team and contributes to the co-ordinated development of the Open University generally as a member of the Vice-Chancellor’s Office Meeting (VCOM). The key responsibility of the Secretary is to work with the ViceChancellor to ensure the effective governance, administration and management of the Open University, including the efficient deployment of resource and information. 4.4.4 The Deans The Deans are the chief academic officers of the Open University within their respective Faculties/Schools and, as Head of a Spending Unit, also the chief administrative officer of the Open University within their Faculty School. A Dean has two major responsibilities: (a) to the Faculty/School for providing acceptable leadership and for representing the views of the Faculty/School in the formulation and execution of Open University policy; 17 D:\401289085.doc (b) to the Open University as the chief academic and administrative officer of the Open University within the Faculty/School and simultaneously for representing to the Faculty/School the policy of the Open University so that Faculty/School policy is appropriately affected. There are 6 Faculties and 2 Schools with Deans in the Open University. These are: - 4.4.5 Arts Social Sciences Education & Language Studies Mathematics and Computing Science Technology Open University Business School School of Health and Social Welfare The Regional Director – Open University Region 12 Ireland The Regional Director is the University’s senior responsible officer within the Region and is responsible to the Director, Student Services based at Milton Keynes and the Vice-Chancellor. The Regional Director’s principal responsibilities within the Region are to direct in accordance with established policies and procedures, the University’s operations and to co-ordinate the University’s educational system. She is supported in carrying out these responsibilities by staff of the Faculties and Schools based in the Region (Staff Tutors/Regional Managers) and by staff of Student Services - Assistant Directors, Student Service Managers and non-UAP support staff. Each has defined responsibilities and accountabilities in their individual role descriptions. The Regional Director will be responsible for the effective implementation and management of the University’s Equality Scheme in Northern Ireland. __________________________________ 18 D:\401289085.doc 5. Statutory Duty under Section 75 of the Northern Ireland Act 998 5.1 Section 75 of the Northern Ireland Act 1998 ("the Act") requires the Open University, in carrying out all its functions, powers and duties relating to Northern Ireland, to have: Due regard to the need to promote equality of opportunity: between persons of different religious belief, political opinion, racial group, age, marital status or sexual orientation; 5.2 between men and women generally; between persons with a disability and persons without; and between persons with dependants and persons without. In addition, without prejudice to its obligation above, the Open University shall, in carrying out all its functions, powers and duties relating to Northern Ireland, have: Regard to the desirability of promoting good relations between persons of different religious belief, political opinion or racial group. Schedule 9 to the Act requires the Open University to set out how it proposes to fulfil the duties imposed by Section 75. This document is intended to fulfil that statutory requirement. In particular, the Act requires that the Scheme must include: A general introductory statement specifying the purpose of the Scheme, and the public authority’s commitment to the statutory duty and a description of the internal arrangements for ensuring that the duty is effectively implemented. 19 D:\401289085.doc Specifically: The authority’s arrangements for assessing its compliance with the Section 75 duties and for consulting on matters to which a duty under that section is likely to be relevant. The authority’s arrangements for assessing and consulting on the impact of policies adopted or proposed to be adopted on the promotion of equality of opportunity. The authority’s arrangements for monitoring adverse impact of policies adopted by the authority on the promotion of equality of opportunity. The authority’s arrangements for publishing the results of equality impact assessments and of monitoring of any adverse impact of policies adopted by the authority on the promotion of equality of opportunity. This must include a commitment to including in the published results of an equality impact assessment: A statement of the aims of the policy to which the assessment relates; Details of any consideration given by the authority to measures which might mitigate any adverse impact of that policy on the promotion of equality of opportunity; Details of any consideration given by the authority to alternative policies which might better achieve the promotion of equality of opportunity. A commitment that in making any decision with respect to a policy adopted or proposed to be adopted by it, that the public authority shall take into account any equality impact assessment and consultation carried out in relation to the policy. 20 D:\401289085.doc The authority’s arrangements for training staff on issues relevant to the duties. The authority’s arrangements for ensuring, and assessing, public access to information and to services provided by the authority The authority’s timetable for measures proposed in the scheme. Details of how the Scheme will be published. The authority’s arrangements for dealing with complaints arising from a failure to comply with the Scheme. A commitment to conducting a review of the Scheme within five years of its submission to the Equality Commission and to forwarding a report of this review to the Equality Commission. On the recommendation of the Equality Commission, the Open University has included a programme of work on good relations and specifies how progress on this will be assessed. For the purposes of this Scheme the term "policy" has been taken to signify the essential plans of action which inform the execution of the Open University’s duties and functions both statutory and non-statutory, written and unwritten, current and proposed in Northern Ireland. A list of existing policy areas is shown in Appendix 4. 5.3 The Open University acknowledges that there may be difficulties in defining policies and in particular where policies cut across different functions or involve other public authorities. Where the Open University has lead responsibility for a policy which requires close co-operation with, or is managed by, other public authorities, it will ensure that there is active participation by all relevant authorities in any equality 21 D:\401289085.doc impact assessment. Where the Open University is required to implement a policy that has been formulated by another public authority, the implications of that policy on equality of opportunity and good relations will be addressed in partnership with the source organisation for that policy. 5.4 Objectives and targets relating to the statutory obligations under the Act will be integrated into the Region’s strategic and operational plans. The officers of the Open University based in Northern Ireland will include implementation of the statutory obligations in performance plans, both individual and collective, and processes which are currently used to implement and monitor existing objectives and targets will be employed in relation to the targets and objectives set in relation to the duties. 5.5 The University will conduct an Annual Review of progress of the Scheme which it will submit to the N.I. Equality Commission. This will involve an annual assessment of the progress made and the limitations experienced covering the implementation of the arrangements specified in the Scheme and in complying with the statutory duties. It will also include progress on the good relations duty. A report of the salient points arising from progress made during the course of the year will be made public. 5.6 An Annual Report will also be submitted to the University's Equal Opportunities Unit. This will form part of the University's formal Annual Review and Monitoring of Equality Opportunities policies, procedures and processes and its aim to ensure best practice in these areas. 5.7 The Open University will ensure, that implementation of its obligations under the Act is supported insofar as is reasonable with the necessary resources, human and financial. These will include resources for communicating with staff and providing appropriate training to those responsible for policy review and implementation. __________________________________________ 22 D:\401289085.doc 6. Arrangements for Assessing Compliance with Section 75 Duties 6.1 The Open University is committed to the fulfilment of its Section 75 obligations in its Northern Ireland region. To this end, internal arrangements have been put in place to ensure that this commitment will be effectively and demonstrably carried out, and that progress will continue to be monitored and reviewed. The statutory responsibility for the effective implementation of the Scheme lies with the Council of the Open University. Through the powers and authority invested in the Vice-Chancellor and by means of delegation to its Regional Director in Northern Ireland, it will be accountable for the development, maintenance and review of the Scheme in accordance with legislation, good practice, and any guidance which may be issued by the Equality Commission. The Regional Director will also put in place such arrangements as are necessary to enable her to review, on a regular basis, progress in relation to the Scheme. In discharging these duties the Regional Director will establish a small working group of the Region’s Equal Opportunities Committee to co-ordinate and manage the implementation of the Scheme, thus ensuring that the necessary actions are progressed in accordance with the Scheme’s commitments and timetables. This group will comprise the Regional Director (Chair), and the Assistant Directors with responsibility for Development, Student Services and Planning, Resources and Teaching Services. The Region’s Equal Opportunities Committee will liaise and seek guidance as appropriate, from the Open University’s central Equal Opportunities Committee. The Regional Director will provide the central point of contact for the public, officials, the Equality Commission, and complainants. She, or her representative as nominated from the Working Group, will also advise and inform appropriate central departments of the Open University on the implementation of Section 75 obligations. The Regional Director can be contacted at Regional Centre, 40 University Road, Belfast BT7 1SU, Tel: 028 9024 5025, Fax: 028 9023 0565. 23 D:\401289085.doc 6.2 The Regional Director will delegate to appropriate Section heads the duty to facilitate equality impact assessments where necessary on existing and new policies in areas for which they are responsible. She will also ensure that managers are appropriately trained in the requirements of Section 75 and Schedule 9, and that assessment of compliance with such duties becomes a mainstream element of their work. 6.3 The Open University will assess the extent to which each of its current policies has had an impact on the promotion of equality of opportunity and the promotion of good relations within the terms of the Act. This will be achieved through an inclusive and interactive process of (i) screening policies in consultation with representatives of affected groups, and (ii) subsequent equality impact assessments. Where appropriate, an equality impact assessment will include an annex on the promotion of good relations. The organisations indicated at Appendix 6 in relation to each main policy area will be consulted on these equality impact assessments. The following organisations will also be consulted specifically in relation to any equality impact assessment which deals with the promotion of good relations: Community Relations Council (N.I.) Northern Ireland Council for Ethnic Minorities Equality Commission for Northern Ireland In relation to the duty to promote good relations, the Open University will conduct an annual audit to determine (i) the state of community relations within the Open University in Northern Ireland and (ii) how the Open University is perceived in the community it serves according to religious belief, political opinion and racial group. The Open University will ensure that progress in meeting the objectives and targets set, in relation to the statutory duties, will be included in an annual report to the Commission, this will include progress on its good relations duty. The salient points arising from its annual report will be made public. 24 D:\401289085.doc The Regional Equal Opportunities Committee will meet at least four times each year to review progress and to help prepare an annual statement for submission to the Equality Commission. It shall also submit quarterly reports to the University’s Equal Opportunities Unit and the Council of the University. 6.4 The Open University will address complaints that it has not fulfilled its statutory obligations and will seek to resolve such complaints bilaterally. It will aim to give a substantive response to any such complaints within one month. When a complainant claims to have been directly affected by a failure of the Open University to comply with the Scheme, that person shall be informed of the procedure for bringing such a complaint to the Equality Commission. 6.5 The Open University will liaise with the following public authorities which are also required to submit their own equality schemes but whose duties, functions and policies are likely to overlap with those of the Open University: 6.6 Queen’s University Belfast University of Ulster Department of Employment and Learning Department of Agriculture and Rural Development Department of Health, Social Services and Public Safety Department of Enterprise Trade and Industry The Open University will conduct a comprehensive review of the Scheme within five years of its submission to the Equality Commission. This review will include an assessment of how the Open University has complied with its Section 75 obligations and how equality of opportunity and good relations have been advanced in relation to the main functional areas. 6.7 The Open University will consult with those bodies listed at Appendix 6 before submission of the review to the Equality Commission, and will ensure that the 25 D:\401289085.doc consultation process is open and inclusive. _____________________________________________ 26 D:\401289085.doc 7. Arrangements for Screening and Prioritising 7.1 The Open University will undertake to complete the initial screening procedure within six months of the date of commencement of the Scheme. In identifying policies, to be subject to initial screening, the Open University will use the listing as shown at Appendix 4. 7.2 The purpose of screening is to identify those policies which are likely to have a significant impact on equality of opportunity, so that greatest resources can be devoted to these policies. The Open University will systematically review each policy in terms of the nine categories listed at Section 75 of the Act. For each policy the following criteria will be considered: Is there any evidence of higher or lower participation or uptake by different groups? Is there any evidence that different groups have different needs, experiences, issues and priorities in relation to the particular main functional areas? Is there an opportunity to better promote equality of opportunity or good relations by altering policy or practice, or working with others in Government or the community at large? Have consultations in the past with relevant representative organisations or individuals within the relevant groups indicated that particular policies, functions or duties create problems that are specific to them? If the answer to any of these questions is positive then consideration will be given as to whether the policy will be subject to an equality impact assessment procedure. Where it is found that there is insufficient data to reach an opinion then additional information will be sought to inform the decision-making process. The main groups within each of the nine categories are identified at Appendix 7. 27 D:\401289085.doc 7.3 Consultations will form an integral part of the screening process, and will include all those organisations listed in Appendix 6. The University will comply with the Commission’s guiding principles on consultation and ensure that consultation is timely, open and inclusive. Specifically the Open University will work with representative groups and individuals of the Section 75 categories in order to identify how best to obtain their views. This may involve face to face meetings, advisory groups, surveys, consultative panels, internet discussions, citizens juries and other innovative ways of consulting. This is in recognition that there will be different areas of consultation for different groups and it will be important to establish the basis for dialogue and engagement during the life of the Scheme. A detailed report of the screening exercise will be included in the annual report to the Equality Commission. Any new policies developed during the five-year period will be screened for fuller impact assessment using the criteria as specified above. _____________________________________________ 28 D:\401289085.doc 8. Equality Impact Assessments 8.1 Following the screening process, the Open University will determine which policies will be subjected to equality impact assessment and will determine a timetable for these assessments. In addition, when the Open University is considering a new policy it will determine whether the policy has the potential to have significant implications for equality of opportunity and, if so, it will conduct a full impact assessment. The Open University, in making any decision with respect to a policy adopted or proposed to be adopted, shall take into account any equality impact assessment and consultation carried out in relation to the policy. 8.2 The methodology which will be used for an equality impact assessment is set out in Appendix 8. Equality impact assessments will be conducted in compliance with the requirements of Annex of the Commission's Guidelines. Consultation will take place with the relevant interest groups as well as the Equality Commission, other public bodies, voluntary, community, trade union and other groups directly affected by the policy under assessment. The Open University will use such methods of consultation as are described in Section 9. ___________________________________________ 29 D:\401289085.doc 9. Timetabling 9.1 The screening process will lead to the establishment of a timetable for conducting equality impact assessments on the Open University's policies over the next five years. The Open University will prioritise its policy review programme on the basis of: relevance to social need effect on people's daily lives effect on economic, social and human rights The timetable will be reviewed on an annual basis to accommodate necessary changes as dictated by altered circumstances. 9.2 The Open University will report to the Equality Commission in its first annual progress statement on the results of consultation on the screening exercise and the timetable for carrying out assessments of existing policies, who was consulted, their comments, and any changes made consequent to consultation. This report will indicate progress made and any problems experienced concerning the implementation of the arrangements specified in the Equality Scheme and in complying with the duties, including the good relations duty. __________________________________________________ 30 D:\401289085.doc 10. Consultation 10.1 In line with the guiding principles set out by the Commission, the Open University will continue to consult during the life of the Scheme, as appropriate, with the Equality Commission, the Community Relations Council and the bodies listed at Appendix 6. It should be noted that this list is not exhaustive and may be amended in the light of experience. The Open University will respond constructively to proposals from these bodies relating to any aspect of its compliance with the Section 75 obligations. The Open University will take all reasonable steps to ensure that any barriers to effective consultation are removed and that systems are in place to further ensure that information is available in an accessible format and in a timely fashion. The Open University recognises the central role of the Department of Employment and Learning (DEL) in determining policy and guidelines for all bodies within higher education. In taking forward its Scheme, the Open University will work closely with the Department in relation to those policies which the Department has developed or for which it has responsibility under Section 75 of the Act, in order to avoid duplication of effort and the inefficient use of resources. The Open University will consult on each stage of the screening process and subsequently on equality impact assessments, with interested parties, the public, trade unions, relevant public sector and non-governmental organisations (NGOs). Consultations will pay due regard to sensitivities of particular groups. The Open University considers it particularly important that sufficient, timely and appropriate information is provided to enable all affected groups and individuals to consider the full implications of proposals, and it will take all necessary steps to ensure this. 10.2 The public and voluntary sector bodies and NGOs to be consulted will include those listed in Appendix 6. In addition to consultations of the screening process and equality impact assessments, the Open University will also, from time to time, have need to consult on legislation, strategies, reviews and other plans. The bodies listed at Appendix 6 will be included in relevant consultations of this kind. 31 D:\401289085.doc In consulting NGOs, the Open University will aim to provide a reasonable period for response of at least eight weeks and to begin consultation as early as possible. Where it has not been possible to comply with this requirement the Open University will monitor and keep under review such circumstances and justify its actions. In the Open University’s Annual Review adequate time will be allowed for groups to consult among themselves as part of the process of forming a view. 10.3 In consulting on any matter to which this scheme relates, the Open University will normally write to the relevant bodies in the first instance. The Open University will also consult through other means such as meetings, standing or ad hoc consultative forums, attitude surveys, consultative panels, questionnaires and Internet discussion groups, having determined through partnerships with individuals and umbrella groups which format is most effective in providing satisfactory consultation for the groups identified. 10.4 Barriers to proper consultation will be removed by ensuring accessibility of language and appropriate format. In relation to the policy on which consultation is to take place, information will be made available, on request, in accessible formats, and including Braille, large print, audio cassette, signed video cassette, and minority languages to meet the needs of those not fluent in English. Arrangements for these contingencies are in hand with the service providers concerned. Consideration will be given as to how information may best be communicated to young people and to those with learning difficulties. Where necessary, specific training will be provided for those engaged in consultation exercises to ensure that they have the necessary skills. In organising consultation meetings, the Open University will aim to ensure a full participation in setting the time, venue, accessibility, and the provision of childcare. __________________________________ 32 D:\401289085.doc 11. Monitoring 11.1 Information concerning the uptake of services provided by the Open University and the impact of its policies on the different groups within the Section 75 categories will be of assistance in assessing progress towards equality of opportunity. Within one year of approval of the Scheme, the Open University will complete an assessment of the extent of its baseline data and of existing monitoring arrangements within each of the Open University’s policy areas. In doing so the Open University will ensure that a system will be established to monitor the impact of policies in order to identify their effect on the relevant groups. This will be reviewed on an annual basis and the results will be widely and openly published as specified in Section 12.1 of this document. If monitoring and examination show that a policy results in greater adverse impact than predicted, or if opportunities arise which would allow for greater equality of opportunity to be promoted, the Open University will ensure that the policy is revised. Where monitoring and evaluation show that a policy results in greater adverse impact than predicted, or if opportunities arise which would allow for greater equality of opportunity to be promoted, the Open University undertakes to review the policy accordingly. 11.2 The Open University will assess, in the first instance, the extent to which data relevant to its policies and those groups affected by them are held internally. It will then explore other sources of data, including sources available to the affected groups. In some cases an equality impact assessment may identify an anticipated differential adverse impact on particular groups within the Section 75 categories. Assuming that no alternative policy is feasible, steps will be taken to mitigate such anticipated adverse impact. The Open University may, in such circumstances, 33 D:\401289085.doc commission special monitoring analysis to confirm the extent of the adverse impact and/or the success of any mitigating measures. Information collated in this special monitoring would be taken into account in any future review of the policy involved. 11.3 The Open University will have regard to other sources of information, where relevant and available, including those provided by affected groups. Feasibility of alternative policies will be assessed, in so far as is possible, in ways which are acceptable to all sector representative groups. In its review of existing arrangements and its consideration of special monitoring of anticipated adverse impacts, the Open University will seek to co-operate closely with bodies including the Equality Commission and the Northern Ireland Statistics and Research Agency (NISRA). ______________________________________ 34 D:\401289085.doc 12. Publication of Assessments and Monitoring 12.1 The Open University will make publicly available the outcome of any equality impact assessment and of any monitoring undertaken in relation to Section 75, as described above. This material will be made accessible on the Region’s Internet website at www.open.ac.uk/ireland. It will also be available, in printed form and in alternative formats, from the Regional Director. In line with best practice as recommended by the Equality Commission the University will as far as possible, endeavour to make available, on request, all information used to make or inform a decision in this area. The Open University will inform the general public about the availability of this material through a variety of processes, including press releases and any other such mechanisms as may be required to ensure compliance with Section 75. It will also directly inform the bodies listed at the appropriate sections of Appendix 6 when such material is available. 12.2 The published documentation on an equality impact assessment will include: the aims of the relevant policy; details of the outcome of the assessment, highlighting any adverse impact which has been identified; associated available monitoring data; details of consideration given to means of mitigating any adverse impact of the policy on the promotion of equality of opportunity; details of consideration given to alternative policies which might better achieve the promotion of equality of opportunity. Such information will be made available on request in accessible formats such as Braille, disc and audio-cassette and in minority languages to meet the needs of those who are not fluent in English. 35 D:\401289085.doc In line with best practice as recommended by the Equality Commission the University will take further advice on how best to communicate with young people and people with learning disabilities and will make clear how this commitment will be operationalised. __________________________________________________ 36 D:\401289085.doc 13. Training 13.1 Building on existing training (which has included equal opportunities training for all full-time and part-time staff), the Open University will ensure that all of its staff will receive a programme of relevant communication and training on the Section 75 obligations. All new staff will be informed of the requirements of Section 75 in their induction training. All staff will receive a copy of the Equality Scheme. 13.2 The Open University will ensure that all existing staff receive training on Section 75 obligations, the requirements of this Equality Scheme, and arrangements for equality impact assessment, appropriate to their grade and responsibilities. Those who are charged with policy development and review will have specific training to assist them in embedding these obligations in any decision-making process associated with policy development and review. Those involved in consultation and impact assessment of existing policies will receive training in these duties. Skills training for those engaged in consultation exercises will be put in place to ensure that they have the necessary skills and knowledge to do this work effectively. Training will also pay regard to the good relations duty. 13.3 Copies of this scheme will be sent to all core regional staff and made available to other staff and students via the Region’s website, and the relevant webpage will be publicised widely through appropriate channels. Annual reviews will be made available to all staff. 13.4 A planned programme of training, including content and delivery mechanisms will be developed to cover the initial 5-year period of the operation of the Scheme. 37 D:\401289085.doc The Open University’s training scheme will reflect the following training objectives:- (i) To prepare a detailed training plan for all relevant staff over the 5-year period to which the Equality Scheme refers, which will aim to achieve the objectives outlined below. (ii) To raise awareness of current anti-discrimination legislation in Northern Ireland, including the provisions of Section 75, Schedule 9 and Section 76 of the Northern Ireland Act 1998. This should include an explanation of the duties and their implications for all employees. (iii) To provide those employees involved in the screening of policies with the necessary skills and knowledge to do this work effectively. (iv) To provide those employees involved in the quality impact assessment of policies with the necessary skills and knowledge to do this work effectively. (v) To provide those employees who deal with complaints in relation to the implementation of the Open University’s Scheme, with the necessary skills and knowledge to investigate and monitor complaints effectively. (vi) To provide those employees involved in the consultation processes with the necessary skills and knowledge to do this work effectively. (vii) To provide those employees involved in the implementation and monitoring of the effective implementation of the Open University’s Equality Scheme to do this work effectively. (viii) To evaluate the extent to which all participants in this training programme have acquired the necessary skills and knowledge to achieve each of the above objectives. 38 D:\401289085.doc (ix) The University is committed to including any of the affected Section 75 groups in the development of training. ________________________________________ 39 D:\401289085.doc 14. Public Access to Information and Services 14.1 The Open University is committed to effective communication with the public. It recognises, however, that there is a risk that some sections of the public will not enjoy equality of opportunity in accessing information provided by the Open University. There are three particular areas of concern: people with sensory and learning disabilities may have particular difficulties with information in print; members of minority ethnic groups, who are not fluent in English, may have difficulties with information provided only in English; some local newspapers are read predominantly by members of only one community. In disseminating information through the local press, the Open University will ensure that press statements and public advertisements are accessible to both main communities. 14.2 The Open University will assess its arrangements for providing information in Braille, large print, audiocassette, signed videocassette, and minority ethnic language formats. As part of this process and, in line with best practice as recommended by the Equality Commission, the University will consult widely with any affected Section 75 groups as part of this review and will consult with the Commission prior to the implementation of new practices. The Open University intends that all of its services are fully accessible to all parts of the community. Equality impact assessments will highlight any factors which create differential impact by making a service linked to a particular policy relatively inaccessible to particular groups. 40 D:\401289085.doc 14.3 The Open University will release relevant quantitative and qualitative data and other documentation such as consultants’ reports to ensure meaningful consultation. ________________________________________ 41 D:\401289085.doc 15. Publication of the Scheme Following approval of the Scheme by the Equality Commission for Northern Ireland, copies will be available from the same location and website address. The Open University will issue a press release when the Scheme is approved by the Equality Commission, and will place a prominent advertisement in the local press. As part of its commitment to ensure that the Scheme will be available in accessible formats and in a timely fashion, the Open University will give specific consideration to how best to communicate the Scheme in a comprehensible way to young people and those with learning disabilities. In disseminating information about its Equality Scheme through the press the Open University will ensure that press statements and/or public advertisements are carried in all the Belfast daily newspapers, including the North West version of the Belfast Telegraph. _____________________________________________ 42 D:\401289085.doc 16. Complaints 16.1 When a person believes that he/she has been directly affected by a failure of the Open University to comply with this Scheme, he/she should, in the first instance, bring a complaint to the attention of the Regional Director. The Open University will carry out an internal initial investigation of the complaint and will undertake to respond to the complainant within one month. The contact address for the Regional Director is as follows: The Open University in Ireland 40 University Road Belfast BT7 1SU Tel: 028 9024 5025 Fax: 028 9023 0565 E-mail: R12@open.ac.uk In responding to the complainant, the Open University will inform him/her of the procedure for pursuing the complaint further with the Equality Commission, as set out in Paragraph 10 of Schedule 9 to the Northern Ireland Act 1998. The Open University will ensure access to the complaints procedures. 16.2 In any subsequent investigation by the Equality Commission, the Open University will co-operate fully, providing access to any relevant documentation that the Commission may require. Similarly, the Open University will co-operate fully with any investigation by the Equality Commission under sub-paragraph 11(1)(b) of Schedule 9 to the Northern Ireland Act 1998. Complaints relating to the failure of the Open University to comply with this scheme must be submitted to the Equality Commission within twelve months from the day on which the complainant first knew of the matters alleged. ___________________________________________ 43 D:\401289085.doc 17. Summary Timetable The following timetable summarises the measures which the Open University proposes to take during the five years following the approval of this scheme. Year One Establish policy screening process, including development of pro forma Prioritise policies for screening in Year One Screen policies across all of the nine categories listed in Section 75 Develop timetable of equality impact assessments for subsequent years Conduct information audit Initiate pilot impact assessments on selected policies Assess training needs Deliver awareness training to appropriate staff Deliver skills training to appropriate staff Prepare annual report Prepare annual action plan Review implementation of Scheme Years Two – Four Screen all new policies Conduct impact assessment on prioritised policies Further train relevant staff Prepare annual report Prepare annual action plan Review implementation of Scheme 44 D:\401289085.doc Year Five Screen all new policies Conduct impact assessment on prioritised policies Further train relevant staff Prepare annual report Prepare annual action plan Review Scheme and report to Equality Commission _______________________________________ 45 D:\401289085.doc