Krista Botton SED 610 Two-week Lesson Plan Subject: Biology Topic: Pathogens and the Immune System Teachers: Krista Botton and Marissa Mullen Lesson 1: Wednesday, March 19 Purpose: o Standard 10d: Students know there are important differences between bacteria and viruses with respect to their requirements for growth and replication, the body's primary defenses against bacterial and viral infections, and effective treatments of these infections Introduction: Class “silent” brainstorm on current knowledge of bacterial life (types of cells, characteristics, diseases they cause, uses, etc) Activities: Notes Section 19-1 Review: Workbook p. 213-216 Homework: Workbook p. 213-216, Cornell notes Teaching Methods: assessment of prior knowledge, direct instruction with interactive lecture/discussion of 19-1 concepts Lesson 2: Thursday, March 20 Purpose: o Standard 10d: Students know there are important differences between bacteria and viruses with respect to their requirements for growth and replication, the body's primary defenses against bacterial and viral infections, and effective treatments of these infections Introduction: Questions/problems with Workbook or from Cornell notes Activities: Video – Body Story: Germs (25 min), Read aloud antibiotic resistance article (as a class) Review: Video and article review and enhance knowledge regarding bacteria Homework: Ch. 19 Vocabulary Teaching Methods: Clarifying questions, formative assessment, review/recall of concepts, visual representation of material Krista Botton SED 610 Lesson 3: Friday, March 21 Purpose: o Standard 10d: Students know there are important differences between bacteria and viruses with respect to their requirements for growth and replication, the body's primary defenses against bacterial and viral infections, and effective treatments of these infections Introduction: Warm up / Review Activities: Bacteria Lab (part 1), continue reading article and answer review questions Review: Lab and article review and enhance knowledge regarding bacteria Homework: Study for quiz Monday Teaching Methods: Clarifying questions, formative assessment, review/recall of concepts, kinesthetic learning Lesson 4: Monday, March 24 Purpose: o Standard 10d: Students know there are important differences between bacteria and viruses with respect to their requirements for growth and replication, the body's primary defenses against bacterial and viral infections, and effective treatments of these infections Introduction: Questions on article, questions before quiz? Activities: Bacteria Quiz, Bacteria Lab (part 2), finish article questions Review: Lab reviews and enhances knowledge regarding bacteria Homework: Finish lab report Teaching Methods: summative assessment, review/recall of concepts, kinesthetic learning Lesson 5: Tuesday, March 25 Purpose: o Standard 10d: Students know there are important differences between bacteria and viruses with respect to their requirements for growth and replication, the body's primary defenses against bacterial and viral infections, and effective treatments of these infections Introduction: Class “silent” brainstorm on current knowledge of viruses (living v. nonliving, characteristics, diseases they cause, etc) Activities: Notes section 19-2 Review: Workbook p. 217-219 Homework: finish workbook p. 217-219, Cornell Notes Teaching Methods: assessment of prior knowledge, direct instruction with interactive lecture/discussion of 19-2 concepts Krista Botton SED 610 Lesson 6: Wednesday, March 26 and Thursday, March 27 (Blocked Minimum Days) Purpose: o Standard 10d: Students know there are important differences between bacteria and viruses with respect to their requirements for growth and replication, the body's primary defenses against bacterial and viral infections, and effective treatments of these infections Introduction: Warm up / Review Activities: Video – Body Story: The Flu (25 min), Notes Section 19-3 Review: Workbook p. 220-222 Homework: finish workbook p. 220-222, Ch. 19 packet/objectives, study for quiz Teaching Methods: formative assessment, review/recall of concepts, visual representation of material, self-directed study, metacognition Lesson 7: Friday, March 28 Purpose: o Standard 10: Organisms have a variety of mechanisms to combat disease Introduction: Questions / clarification before quiz? Activities: Ch. 19 Quiz, Disease Transmission Activity, Notes Ch. 40-1 Review: Workbook p. 475-476 Homework: finish workbook p. 475-476 Teaching Methods: summative assessment, kinesthetic learning activity, selfdirected study Lesson 8: Monday, March 31 Purpose: o Standard 10a: Students know the role of the skin in providing nonspecific defenses against infection o Standard 10b: Students know the role of antibodies in the body's response to infection o Standard 10f: Students know the roles of phagocytes, B-lymphocytes, and T-lymphocytes in the immune system Introduction: Warm up / Review Activities: Notes Ch. 40-2 Review: Workbook p. 477-479, Ch. 40 Vocabulary, Cornell notes Homework: finish workbook p. 477-479 Teaching Methods: formative assessment, direct instruction, review/recall of concepts Krista Botton SED 610 Lesson 9: Tuesday, April 1 Purpose: o Standard 10a: Students know the role of the skin in providing nonspecific defenses against infection o Standard 10b: Students know the role of antibodies in the body's response to infection o Standard 10f: Students know the roles of phagocytes, B-lymphocytes, and T-lymphocytes in the immune system Introduction: Warm Up / Review Activities: Immune System Comic Strip Project Review: Exam review worksheet Homework: Finish project if needed, Ch. 40 Vocabulary, work on exam review Teaching Methods: formative assessment, self-directed study, metacognition, review/recall of concepts Lesson 10: Wednesday, April 2 Purpose: o Standard 10c: Students know how vaccination protects an individual from infectious diseases o Standard 10e: Students know why an individual with a compromised immune system (for example, a person with AIDS) may be unable to fight off and survive infections by microorganisms that are usually benign Introduction: Share comic strips / peer grade Activities: Notes 40-3 Review: workbook p. 480-482 Homework: finish workbook p. 480-482, work on exam review Teaching Methods: review / recall, direct instruction, metacognition Krista Botton SED 610 Team Teaching Assignment Reflection Day 1 What went well? The silent brainstorm showed that students have a good current understanding of bacteria. They were able to identify bacteria as prokaryotic cells and remembered that these cells do not have a nucleus. They also identified many uses of bacteria and remembered that bacteria are frequently used in genetic engineering – remembering the plasmid/recombinant DNA lab that we did in December. What could have been done better? The day went really well, it might be nice to incorporate cooperative learning into the lesson since their understanding of material is fairly good to begin with. Create a jigsaw activity? What will you do tomorrow? We will discuss some of the concepts that were covered today before the video on bacteria is shown. Video will need some introduction and discussion of mature behavior as the video is about a man who gets food poisoning. Reflection Day 2 What went well? Students enjoyed the video on Germs. Many shared their own food poisoning experiences. Many questions were raised about how other foods become contaminated with pathogens that cause food poisoning which led to a nice discussion of the E. coli outbreak in spinach that occurred last year and how scientists had to solve the puzzle of what was causing the infections. Having students read the antibiotics article aloud was a great idea because we were able to stop and discuss concepts in the article. I think that students had a much better understanding of the article and the concepts therein than I have experienced in years past where students merely skim the article in order to find the answers to the questions. What could have been done better? This day went really well; I don’t know that there was much I would have done differently. Ms. Mullen and I actually presented the article differently. She had students read and answer questions on their own. We had a great conversation about the interest and discussion of the article concepts that my students shared. She may have the article read aloud next year. What will you do tomorrow? Tomorrow I will ask warm up question on the section of direct instruction that will include information that will be on the quiz. I will direct students through the lab and we will continue reading the article as a class. Krista Botton SED 610 Reflection Day 3 What went well? The students did really well on the warm up. Most concepts were accurately recalled indicating that re-teaching of concepts is not really necessary. Not much of a surprise but, students LOVED the lab! I gave specific direction on how to culture a sample on a Petri dish using a giant Petri dish diagram on the whiteboard and a quick visual of their dishes showed that the groups have a nice spread. For once, NONE of my groups broke the agar. We continued reading the article as a class and we continued a nice class discussion. What could have been done better? I did not allow students to have pre-arranged lab groups so I assigned groups by rows to the lab. This did not really lead to the best mixes of students academically since I tend to seat many of my lower performing students toward the front of the room and many of these lower performing students were grouped into the same lab group. I may want to have pre-arranged groups for next year. Ms. Mullen and I also discussed changing the lab for next year to include a culture area that is selected by the students so that they can test an area that they are interested in (money, their cell phone, their calculator, etc). Some students seemed anxious to finish the article near the end. The last section was a bit more difficult to work though as it covered conjugation and the graphics that provided a visual were not visible on the copies of the article. We may want to include some instruction in this next year so that students better understand how plasmids with antibiotic resistance pass from microbe to microbe. What will you do tomorrow? I will have my students complete the quiz on bacteria and then we will finish the bacteria lab by looking at our bacterial cultures to see how many colonies have grown and compare the different areas we have tested. We will also finish the questions that accompany the article. Reflection Day 4 What went well? Students took the quiz and on average, did very well. Most of the bacteria cultures came out well. Students are demonstrating both comprehension and interest in the article and the topic of bacteria. What could have been done better? One group spread their bacteria on the wrong side of the Petri dish – in the lid, rather than on the agar. I need to clarify the directions to make sure that all students understand the lab and get the results that are anticipated. Ms. Mullen and I also did not have the growth that we had hoped for because of the room temperature over the weekend. The heat/air in our rooms is turned off over the weekend to save energy and since it was not warm outside, the rooms were cool and growth did not occur as we had hoped. We may need to consider incubation of samples next year. What will you do tomorrow? Krista Botton SED 610 Tomorrow we are moving on to viruses. We will attempt to assess prior knowledge and make sure that, in accordance with the standards, we are having students compare and contrast the growth, replication and defenses the body has against both bacterial and viral pathogens. Reflection Day 5 What went well? Students don’t seem to know as much about viruses as they do bacteria but students seemed interested in the material because of the focus on pathology. What could have been done better? This may also be a section that we could have students jigsaw, especially with some additional support materials. This would have students more actively involved with instruction and increase the cooperative learning experience. What will you do tomorrow? We will check the workbooks tomorrow and assess the students’ understanding with a warm up activity on the direct instruction. Students will watch a video about a battle with Influenza B and answer some questions. Finally, students will look at the final section of the chapter using a worksheet on their own. Reflection Day 6 What went well? We were on a block schedule today so students were in class for 70 minutes. It is a much longer period of time than students are accustomed to so time changing activities is important. The pacing seemed to go very well; most students were surprised when the bell rang. This would indicate that students were engaged in the activities and didn’t even notice the extended time period. Having students look at the last section of material on their own was good. What could have been done better? Today went very well. Ms. Mullen and I could not find great fault with our plans or their implementation. What will you do tomorrow? Quiz on bacteria and viruses tomorrow, and then we will do an activity on disease transmission and some notes from the text by the students. Reflection Day 7 What went well? The students again, really liked the activity on disease transmission. This was a new activity for me and Ms. Mullen provided me with some much needed guidance as she has used it in the past with other classes. Ms. Mullen warned me ahead of time how students often automatically assign AIDS as the disease being transmitted. I was able to circumvent this problem by calling it “pseudo-ebola.” The notes the students completed seemed to go very well and the ideas of Koch’s postulates tied in nicely with the activity we completed in class. What could have been done better? Krista Botton SED 610 Again, this lesson went very well and I wouldn’t change much. The only thing that was difficult for students was trying to determine who the original source/carrier of the disease was. It would be good to write out some directions on how to trace back the source and have students work in groups to try to determine who it was. Groups could then compare their answers and reasoning to fish out which groups are correct. What will you do tomorrow? Warm up tomorrow will cover concepts from the notes the students took on section 1. We will then move on to the next section with direct instruction. Reflection Day 8 What went well? Students never really like lecture material, especially when it is difficult material but today’s lesson went well enough. As I ran though the powerpoint with them, I drew a comic on the board (like they would be doing tomorrow). I think this really helped to keep students interested in the material and provided an avenue for better understanding and more complex questions from the class. This is a difficult section of material that I don’t think students could master without direct instruction. What could have been done better? I really think that things went well. Not all students drew my pictures in their notes but since their next assignment is to draw their own comic, I really don’t want too many students to copy my example from the board; they would just give me back exactly what I gave them and learning would not occur. What will you do tomorrow? Students will create their own comic strip of the specific immune response using their notes and the text. Reflection Day 9 What went well? This is an assignment that we have used before. It was better this year by far than it has been in the past. Students worked diligently on their comics, many regretting that my example from the day before was not in their notes! The new textbook’s diagrams are also awful so most students were really creative in their approach to the comic because there wasn’t much that they could steal from their books. What could have been done better? This assignment still needs a little work. Ms. Mullen and I should create a rubric that is distributed before the assignment so that students can see how we will grade it and be able to meet the requirements. We also discussed how we should clarify the directions to state whether we would like them to include nonspecific defenses in their comics. What will you do tomorrow? I will provide students the opportunity to share comics tomorrow then we will discuss immune system disorders and vaccines. Students usually enjoy this section of material…they like discussing the consequences of body systems not acting appropriately. Krista Botton SED 610 Reflection Day 10 What went well? Students really enjoy this section. It almost takes the entire class period although it is not that long because it initiates a great deal of discussion and questions from the students. What could have been done better? Nothing…it went great. It might be fun to have students do further research for extra credit and create medical brochures for some of the immune system topics in this section (vaccination, AIDS, autoimmune disorders, etc). What will you do tomorrow? Tomorrow we will review the material from the exam review worksheet (covering chapter 19 and chapter 40) in order to prepare for the test on Friday. Depending on the level of preparation by the students we may play a review game. Krista Botton SED 610 Team Teaching Reflection Marissa Mullen and I have been team teach with other for over two years. I truly believe that two heads are far superior to one when it comes to lesson design. Each member of the team teaching team considers different aspects that will lead to more effective teaching and consequently, learning experience. By working as a team we also increase each other’s repertoire of lessons since each member of the team brings different ideas and resources to the table. Working together, we can pull together the best of these ideas and resources to create lessons that will have an indelible mark on the understanding of our students. Team teaching is really only effective when the teachers who are team teaching with one another are open to new ideas and are respectful and considerate of each other. If teachers do not have this kind of relationship then the process will not be successful; it takes the right teaming of teachers or the right personality mixes. Marissa Mullen and I had a friendship that was established before we began team teaching and I think this may have led the to successful team teaching experience we have shared. We have a mutual respect for each other and value the ideas that the other shares. I cannot say that this is the case with all teachers in my department or that I could team with other teachers as successfully as I have with Marissa.