Assessment Report Standard Format July 1, 2011- June 30, 2012 PROGRAM(S) ASSESSED _________Clinical Laboratory Science____ ASSESSMENT COORDINATOR ______Dr. Cheryl Conley____________ YEAR __1________ of a ____1______YEAR CYCLE 1. ASSESSMENT MEASURES EMPLOYED Briefly describe the assessment measures employed during the year. What was done? Graduate job performance evaluated by current employers; all employers were completely satisfied with our WSU graduates. All graduates were employed within 1-2 months of graduating. Graduate critique of Program’s ability to prepare students for employment in the clinical field; graduates indicate that the CLS Program more than prepares them for the Board of Registry exam and entry level work experience. Program’s continued accreditation by NAACLS; WSU has submitted a self study to NAACLS in preparation for site inspection in Fall of 2012; NAACLS accreditation currently extends to April 2013. Student preparation for clinical practicum evaluated Who participated in the process? Program officials Program faculty Clinical coordinators Employers NAACLS representatives What challenges (if any) were encountered? Hiring and retention of adjunct faculty who teach advanced clinical coursework; our program has only 1.5 FTEs to administrate the program, recruit, maintain and expand the number of clinical affiliates, teach, and evaluate student competence. The program is dependent on adjunct faculty to teach four upper level courses. These courses are taught in the Summer and Fall in order to accommodate adjunct schedules so we do not have flexibility in the calendar year to change the instruction time frame which will limit the number of students we can accept into the program. Semester conversion and adjunct promotions within our clinical affiliates have adversely impacted adjunct teaching schedules and we will be actively recruiting adjuncts in microbiology and hematology. Placement of students in limited clinical sites: WSU CLS Program currently has twelve clinical affiliates. Over the past year, WSU has successfully recruited four more affiliates including Raj Soin, Mercer Medical Center, Wright Patterson Medical Center, and Miami Valley South. Many hospital laboratories train both associate level clinical laboratory technician and our CLS students so our program must work closely with our community colleges to ensure that clinical rotations do not overlap; some of our larger hospital affiliates will take only 1 student at a time. We must be able to mutually resolve the clinical rotation capacity issue so that the program can expand to increase the number of graduates. We have 14 students in our current class and 14 students in the upcoming class and our clinical affiliates are accommodating them for their clinical rotations. In 2015, the new Clinical Laboratory Technician associate at Sinclair Community College will require more clinical sites as they anticipate a class of 15 students requiring clinical rotation. Very limited supply budget: The supply budget has not changed over the last 10 years. Many of the supplies needed for the laboratory courses are donated but the realistic budget should be at least twice the current budget. The current supply budget is $6,500 annually. With increased class size, this budget is not practical. There is no advertising budget: The CLS Program created a video that is on the Wright State web site for better exposure. Feedback from students indicate that this is a good tool for recruitment. We are continually looking for volunteers to help promote our program in the area high schools. We are working with the Development Office to gain greater visibility and identify potential donors for our program. We attend university-sponsored career fairs and events which highlight programs within the university. For the second year in a row we have roughly twice the number of applicants that our program can accept so there is no need at this point to actively recruit. There is no capital equipment budget: Many of the pieces of equipment are antiquated as they were donated by hospital based programs many years ago. We must start replacing centrifuges, microscopes, and other specialized pieces of equipment. With increased class size, we have identified and discarded equipment no longer functioning, but this necessitates sharing equipment. NAACLS (our accrediting organization) specifies that the students must be trained on “modern” equipment. Our hospital affiliates continue to donate retired equipment to our program, but this practice should not be the sole mechanism for equipment replacement. We are working with Development to identify other sources of funding for equipment. We are planning to increase lab fees to help off set equipment expenses and intend to solicit capital equipment funds from our clinical affiliates. 2. ASSESSMENT FINDINGS Pass a national certification examination Of the 15 eligible to take the Board of Certification (BOC) exam, 13 graduates have passed and two graduates have yet to take the BOC. Obtain employment as a laboratory scientist recognizing the dynamics of the profession and possessing the ability to adjust to various roles in the clinical laboratory 100% employed in the profession regionally Two students received CompuNet scholarships Two of our students received national recognition with ASCP scholarship awards. Graduate and employer responses to surveys: employers indicate that the WSU CLS graduates are well prepared. Our graduates also indicate that the program prepared them well for their careers in the clinical laboratory. 3. RESPONSE TO ASSESSMENT FINDINGS List planned or actual changes (if any) to curriculum, teaching methods, facilities, or services that are in response to the assessment findings. The CLS Program continues to work with the community in an effort to identify resources to increase numbers of CLS graduates annually. Nationally there is extreme concern over the numbers of qualified laboratory scientists who will be replacing those retiring. The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics projects that by 2014, an additional 81,000 technologists and technicians will be needed to replace retirees and 68,000 to fill new positions. The Bureau of Labor Statistics projects clinical laboratory employment growth of 14.7 percent between 2010 and 2020, adding 23,800 more professionals to the 161,200 jobs currently in the field. The average age of the laboratory workforce is 49.2 years with 40% of the workforce projected to retire within 10 years. There is concern whether the current educational infrastructure is sufficient to meet market demand for clinical laboratory scientists and technicians. Most of the hospital based training programs have closed and the number of NACCLS accredited CLS programs have decreased from 770 in 1975 to 219 in 2012. The number of CLS/MT program graduates has decreased from 6,519 in 1977 to 4,800 in 2012. The Bureau of Labor Statistics indicates there is a current U.S. vacancy rate of 9-20% and with current number of graduates at 4,800, they project a shortfall of 4,500 per year now and 9,000 per year by 2015. In the past 5 years, there have been 51 students who have completed the Wright State CLS Program and 14 students are on track for this year. Based on these statistics, there is a clear and absolute need to expand the CLS Program. The Kettering Network and Premier Healthcare project a need for at least 25 graduates per year for each network. The current WSU capacity which is approved through NAACLS ( National Accrediting Agency for Clinical Laboratory Sciences) is 12. This number was based on space, equipment requirements, and teaching staff. We are currently exploring ways of increasing the capacity of the program. Our renovated student laboratory can accommodate 25 students. We will continue to work with our clinical affiliates in an effort to identify resources within our community which could be used to recruit and retain Clinical Laboratory Scientists in the area. We have four additional clinical affiliates which will help us in the expansion efforts (Mercer Med. Cen., Raj Soin, Miami Valley South, Wright Patterson Med. Cen.). 4. ASSESSMENT ACTIVITIES FOR THE COMING YEAR We will continue to monitor student retention rates, student success on the ASCP Board of Certification exam, graduate placement rates, and the post graduation questionnaires to ensure that the Wright State CLS Program provides complete and appropriate training for the CLS graduates of the future. 5. UNIVERSITY LEARNING OUTCOME ASSESSMENT As part of the HLC Academy project, each program of study will eventually assess two University Learning Outcomes in required courses in the major. One outcome will be assessed in 2014-15, and the second will be added in 2015-16. Identify the two ULOs that will be assessed and, if possible, the likely course(s) to be used. University Learning Outcomes: Wright State graduates will be able to: 1. communicate effectively 2. demonstrate mathematical literacy 3. evaluate arguments and evidence critically 4. apply the methods of inquiry of the natural sciences, social sciences, and the arts and humanities 5. demonstrate global and multicultural competence 6. demonstrate understanding of contemporary social and ethical issues 7. participate in democratic society as informed and civically engaged citizens For the CLS major, the following ULOs will be assessed in the CL 4200 Laboratory Management Course: communicate effectively evaluate arguments and evidence critically This course has a required writing intensive component which culminates in writing a scientific paper. There is a required management project which the students must design, form a scientific hypothesis, run parallel studies, apply appropriate statistics, and draw conclusions. Both of the university learning outcomes can be evaluated in this course.