Page 1 of 9 2010 Internal Assessment Resource - Internal Level 1 Psychology 27256, Demonstrate understanding of the application of theory to fields of psychological practice Credits: 6 Teacher guidelines: The following guidelines are supplied to enable teachers to carry out valid and consistent assessment using this internal assessment resource. Context/setting: In this activity students will demonstrate knowledge of the application of theory to fields of psychological practice. As part of the teaching programme you will work through three fields to demonstrate knowledge of psychological practice. A range of activities needs to be offered in class which will help students understand the varied fields of psychological research and practice. Fields that are most commonly understood by students at this level could include sport, education, media, and human development. You will also give students opportunities to study the human contexts in which psychological practice are applied. Information on psychology as it is practiced in New Zealand is available from the New Zealand Psychological Society, http://www.psychology.org.nz, and The New Zealand Psychologists Board, http://www.psychologistsboard.org.nz/. Conditions: Assessment for this standard will be a portfolio prepared by each student. The portfolio will be based on a New Zealand scenario(s) that has been researched and discussed by the whole class. The portfolio can contain material that includes, but is not limited to: transcripts of interviews, media clippings, extracts and summaries of academic research, marketing material, and case studies. These will be presented in a methodical manner and be supported by linking statements and a written introduction and conclusion. Before assessment begins, teachers should guide students through the process of exploring texts, reading for meaning, and locating relevant information. It is expected that teachers will spend at least one week introducing students to the concepts surrounding fields of psychological practice, the theories underpinning each, and how they are applied in real life situations. Fields refers to human contexts in which psychological practice are applied. These include but are not limited to: sport, forensic, health, education, environment, industrial and organisational, media, clinical and counselling, human development. © New Zealand Qualifications Authority 2011 Page 2 of 9 Theories are organising ideas or concepts that describe, explain or predict behaviour or mental processes. Scenarios will be based on real life and refer to situations that have occurred, or are likely to occur, in every day existence. Examples include but are not limited to: sporting situations where motivation theory can be applied, health situations such as smoking where theories of personal behaviour can be applied, or education situations such as teaching where learning theory can be applied. It is expected that the real life situation will be based on a New Zealand context and should be sensitive to safety, privacy, gender, cultural, and other individual needs. Information on psychology as it is practiced in New Zealand is available from the New Zealand Psychological Society, http://www.psychology.org.nz. Students will be given two weeks of class time to gather relevant information for their portfolio. Work can also be done out of class time. As students are able to undertake research outside of class time, they will be required to complete a declaration of authenticity. References may be oral, visual and/ or written and may be selected from one or several text types. Texts should be appropriate to Level 6 of the New Zealand Curriculum (NZC), or have characteristics that enable students to meet the expected level of understanding. Assessment of this standard also provides opportunities for students to develop aspects of the key competencies of the NZC. Students need to keep a record of all the source material they use. A suggested reference record for source material has been provided. To encourage students into the habit of using citation styles as used by psychologists across the world, teachers can teach them how to cite references using the American Psychological Association (APA) citation style. Guidance on APA citation style can be found through http://www.apastyle.org/ or through the referencing functions provided by various software programmes. Where student work is to be presented for assessment, constructive feedback should not compromise authenticity but can validly include suggestions about areas where further developments are needed. Students should have the opportunity to receive feedback to edit, revise and polish their work before assessment judgements are made. Providing the scenario(s) for the real life situation(s): Assessment for this standard requires students to apply theories from three fields from within psychology to a given scenario(s). The scenario(s) must be broad enough to allow students to explore the three fields chosen. The scenario(s) can be based on academic research. The scenario(s) can relate to individuals or groups. Examples of suitable scenarios could include: A consideration of a local sports club and its members. Sports psychology: Motivation theory can be considered to examine how amateur players are motivated to compete after a busy week’s work. Health psychology: local clubs, due to their position at the heart of communities, can work with health initiatives like anti-drink driving programmes and Push-Play. Organisational psychology can be used to examine how clubs maintain voluntary participation and raise funds. © New Zealand Qualifications Authority 2011 Page 3 of 9 A study of a multinational company with branches in New Zealand. Industrial psychology can be used to consider how staff are recruited, trained and paid. Environmental psychology can be considered to examine where branches are located in relation to socio-economic populations. Marketing psychology can be used to consider how organisations create brands, manage customer expectations, and create pricing strategies. Scenarios need to be supported with a range of resources to enable students to demonstrate understanding of fields of psychological practice. The supporting resources may include: Guest speakers Academic research Field trip Business and marketing textbook examples Advertising e.g. adverts, packaging, company mission statements, use of sponsorship Documentaries and news reports Websites Additional information: Teaching and learning guidelines that inform psychology as it is taught in New Zealand can be found at http://www.tki.org.nz/ncea/. © New Zealand Qualifications Authority 2011 Page 4 of 9 27256, Demonstrate understanding of the application of theory to fields of psychological practice Memories are made of this: The problem with eyewitness testimony Credit: 6 Student Instructions Sheet During your Psychology programme in class, your teacher will work through three fields to demonstrate knowledge of psychological practice. You will do a range of activities in class which will help you understand the concepts surrounding fields of psychological practice, the theories underpinning each, and how they are applied in real life situations. Your assessment task will be a portfolio you will prepare based on a New Zealand scenario(s) that has been researched and discussed by the whole class. You will be given two weeks of class time to gather relevant information for your portfolio. Work can also be done out of class time. As you will be able to undertake research outside of class time, you will be required to complete a declaration of authenticity. Your portfolio can contain material that includes, but is not limited to: transcripts of interviews, media clippings, extracts and summaries of academic research, marketing material, and case studies. You will present these in a methodical manner and support them by linking statements and writing an introduction and conclusion. Your portfolio should: focus on a theory(s) from each of the three fields accurately relate theory(s) to the scenario(s). For merit or excellence your portfolio may also include: accurate descriptions of key links between the respective theory(s) and the scenario(s) your own ideas and references a comprehensive understanding of the theories underlying the fields linking your understanding to other scenarios and/or fields. Before assessment begins, your teacher will guide you through the process of exploring texts, reading for meaning, and locating relevant information. As part of your Psychology programme your teacher will work with you to source reference texts or other materials. Keeping a record of reference or sourced material As you create your portfolio you will need to keep a record of all the source material you will use. Your source material can include books, websites, podcasts, journals, newspapers, magazines, photographs. Draw up a record sheet so that you can record your sources in an ongoing way over the course of work. To get you into the habit of using citation styles as used by psychologists across the world, please cite your references using the American Psychological Association (APA) citation style. Guidance on APA citation style can be found through http://www.apastyle.org/ or through the referencing functions provided by various software programmes. © New Zealand Qualifications Authority 2011 Page 5 of 9 Example of reference record Source description APA Reference Book – Psychology in Aotearoa/New Zealand Weatherall, A., Wilson, M., Harper, D., McDowall, J., (2007) Psychology in Aotearoa/New Zealand. Pearson: Auckland. Example of material relating to eyewitness testimony <Link to web footage relating to testimony in criminal trials> Assessment guide For achieved For merit For excellence The candidate must demonstrate understanding of the application of theory to fields of psychological practice. The candidate must demonstrate detailed understanding of the application of theory to fields of psychological practice. The candidate must demonstrate in-depth understanding of the application of theory to fields of psychological practice. To complete the assessment for this standard there are three checkpoints you need to complete before you can make your final presentation. Portfolio guidelines To complete this assessment your portfolio needs to contain the following: An introduction that demonstrates an understanding of fields of psychological practice. For each field you will need to gather and organise evidence. This evidence will be supported by linking statements. A conclusion that describes key links between the respective theory and the given scenario(s). © New Zealand Qualifications Authority 2011 Page 6 of 9 Sample Exercise: Memories are made of this: The problem with eyewitness testimony. Select a short video clip to show to four or five of your peers. The clip should be one they are not familiar with (it could be a news interview from an overseas news website) and should be suitable for your peers to view! Prepare an answer sheet with up to five questions about the clip e.g. what colour was the speaker’s baseball cap? What accent did the speaker have? Show the video clip to your peers without any preliminary briefing, and, once it is finished, give them your answer sheet to fill out. Once they have completed these, show the clip again and get your peers to correct their own answer sheets. Once you have done this, have a discussion about human memory and the problems associated with it. Discuss the potential implications of differences between what everybody first saw and what they subsequently thought they saw and how this could impact on an event like a criminal trial. Use theories from fields of psychological practice to write up your findings for your portfolio. Forensic or Environmental Psychology might have plenty of material for this particular exercise. © New Zealand Qualifications Authority 2011 Page 7 of 9 Evidence Statements: Demonstrate understanding of the application of theory to fields of psychological practice Field One Achievement Demonstrate understanding: Identify and describe points relevant to eyewitness testimony (EWT) Merit Demonstrate detailed understanding: Describe key links between the respective theory and the EWT scenario Excellence Demonstrate in-depth understanding: Generalise beyond the EWT scenario © New Zealand Qualifications Authority 2011 Memory Page 8 of 9 Identification and description of Descriptions are linked to Links are supported by details of memory stages and points relevant to the EWT cognitive interviewing techniques processes with accurate use of terms, (or application is scenario for a co-operative witness in the made to another scenario) (a) Memory has three sequential EWT scenario (a) A number of factors can affect the stages and processes stores: sensory, short-term and (a) A first attempt at free recall of memory such as attention, stress, cognitive scripts, the long-term store, and (the interviewee’s own stereotypes and alcohol/drugs. involves three processes: uninterrupted account) may give a (b) Appropriate interviewing or using a questionnaire (for encoding, storage and retrieval. broad outline but miss details. large numbers) ASAP reduces trace decay and aids STM to (b) Information may become (b) Interview as soon as possible LTM consolidation. unavailable because it decays before memory decays. (c) Consolidating memories or cognitive schemas can easily or is not processed into LTM. (c) Interviewees are vulnerable to incorporate (misleading) information (Bartlett & Loftus) (c) Memory encoding, storage a range of leading (d) Reduces chances of information being displaced and retrieval are reconstructive questions/comments that can (‘bumped out’) of working (short-term) memory. (not replicative) affect their recall. (e) Information or emotional states (declarative/ explicit or (d) Focused concentration: (d) Focussed retrieval –no implicit memories) encoded or consolidated in the same Distractions deteriorate the distractions, interruptions, focus time frame are more likely to be retrieved together. Cues memory retrieval process. on internal mental images, may activate associated schema (priming cognitive networks). (e) Context and state dependent close eyes, OK to say ‘Don’t (f) Recognition is multiple priming. memory: Recall is enhanced by know’ or ‘Don’t understand’, no (g) Although LTM storage is believed to be unlimited, cuing context (place and event) rush to retrieve information. retrieval is a problem. Using different retrieval and emotional states present (e) Cued recall – interviewee is modes/prompts increases chances of recall. during encoding. asked to think back to the original (h) Activation of implicitly (non-verbally) encoded stimuli that (f) Recognition is a more place, event, associated emotions were associated with the original event powerful form of retrieval than and focus on all senses, (reinstate http://www.police.govt.nz/resources/evaluation/investigativerecall. context/state). interviewing. (g) Recall is increased by (f) Can sketch drawings and use increasing the number and visual aids variety retrieval attempts. (g) Encourage repeated attempts (h) Implicit (unconscious, at recall, can use reverse order emotional, non-verbal and recall, recall from the perspective procedural) memories are partly of another person or reencoded/and stored via the enactment. amygdale. (h) Vulnerable interviewees could be re-traumatised or stressed. © New Zealand Qualifications Authority 2011 Judgement Statements Note Page 9 of 9 Relevant links between the scenario points and theory in the evidence statements above are alphabetically matched across the columns using (a) to (a), (b) to (b) etc. Achieved plus: Merit plus: Identify and describe main (could be a numerical value) Key links between the respective Detailed, accurate linking statements are made for each points relevant to the given theory and the given scenario are field. Application of theory for each field demonstrates scenario being addressed. accurately described for each accurate use of specialist memory terms. Evidence presented for three field. (Professional judgement fields. could be used to specify the number of key links required). Notes: Evidence statements are indicative and not exclusive Two other fields could be environmental or organisational psychology. © New Zealand Qualifications Authority 2011