Supplementary table 1: Company Central SOEs1 (China) Regional SOEs1 (China) MAI2 (Israel) BASF AG (Germany) DSM Nutritional Products (Netherlands) Allied Biotech (Taiwan) Parry Nutraceuticals (India) Zhejiang NHU (China) Company Central SoEs1 (China) Regional SoEs1 (China) MAI2 (Israel) Kemin + DSM Nutritional Products (Netherlands) Cognis UK Ltd (now part of BASF AG) (Germany) Omniactive/Kencor (India) Cactus Botantics (China) Parry Nutraceuticals (India) Pioneer Enterprise (India) Beijing Refine Biology Technology (China) β-Carotene European Economic Area Natural Synthetic Market Market share share (%) (%) [0-5]% [0-5]% [0-5]% [0-5]% [5-10]% [0-5]% [0-5]% [20-30]% Worldwide Natural Synthetic Market Market share (%) share (%) [0-5]% [0-5]% [0-5]% [0-5]% [10-20]% [0-5]% [0-5]% [20-30]% [80-90]% [50-60]% [70-80]% [60-70]% [0-5]% [10-20]% [0-5]% [5-10]% [0-5]% [0-5]% [5-10]% [0-5]% [0-5]% [0-5]% [0-5]% [0-5]% Lutein European Economic Area Worldwide Market share (%) Market share (%) [0-5]% [0-5]% [0-5]% [0-5]% [0-5]% [5-10]% [60-70]% [50-60]% [0-5]% [5-10]% [10-20]% [0-5]% [0-5]% [0-5]% [10-20]% [0-5]% [0-5]% [0-5]% [0-5]% [0-5]% Lycopene Company Central SoEs1 (China) Regional SoEs1 (China) MAI2 (Israel) European Economic Area Worldwide Market share (%) Market share (%) [0-5]% [0-5]% [10-20% [0-5]% [0-5]% [10-20]% DSM Nutritional Products (Netherlands) BASF AG (Germany) Cyanotec (United States) Parry Nutraceuticals (India) Chengdu Wagott Pharmacentical (China) Sun Ray India (India) Chenguang (China) Ningbo Shunkang Health Food (China) Viva Herba India (India) Xinjiang Hongfan Biology Technology (China) Zhejiang Xinhecheng Co., Ltd. (China) Zhejiang NHU (China) 1 SOE, State-owned Enterprise 2 [20-30% [50-60]% [5-10]% [5-10]% [10-20% [0-5]% [0-5]% [0-5]% [0-5]% [0-5]% [0-5]% [0-5]% [0-5]% [0-5]% [0-5]% [0-5]% [0-5]% [0-5]% [0-5]% [0-5]% [5-10]% [5-10]% - [0-5]% MAI, Makhteshim Agan Industries Ltd (Israel) Supplementary table 2: Patent number Title Assignee Date of issue Formulation containing βcarotene to increase the longevity of pets Nestec S.A. (Vevey, CH) May 1, 2007 Formulation containing βcarotene for animal feed * April 12, 2005 Use of β-carotene as feed additive The Iams Company (Dayton, OH) October 30, 2001 Formulation containing βcarotene for animal feed The Iams Company (Dayton, OH) October 17, 2000 Roche Vitamins Inc. (Paramus, NJ) September 23, 1997 Hoffmann-La Roche Inc. (Nutley, NJ) February 25, 1997 * July 20, 1993 * June 8, 1993 Brief description Applications of β-carotene in animal feed 7,211,280 6,878,747 6,310,090 6,133,323 Condition of elderly pets Systemic formulations containing β-carotene and derivatives thereof Process and product for enhancing immune response in companion animals using a combination of antioxidants Process for enhancing immune response in animals using .β.-carotene as a dietary supplement 5,670,548 Pigmentation with carotenoids 5,605,699 Pigmentation with carotenoids 5,229,146 5,217,734 Fish feed additive and process for producing the same Pet bird feed additive and process for producing the same Method of pigmenting parts and products of poultry, fish and crustacean containing βcarotene Method of pigmenting parts and products of poultry, fish and crustacean containing βcarotene β-Carotene from Dunliella algae as feed additive β-Carotene from Dunliella algae as feed additive Applications of β-carotene for humans (dietary supplements, cosmetics...) 8,445,037 Volatile distillate by-product of mint oil that promotes absorption and/or bioavailability of compounds of bio-medical and nutritional interest 8,361,512 Nutrient compositions and methods for enhanced effectiveness of the immune system 8,263,147 Infant formulas containing docosahexaenoic acid and lutein 8,197,855 Compositions and methods β-carotene as adjuvant in biomedical compounds Methods and compositions containing β-carotene for increasing CD4.sup.+ cell count in mammals Method of reduce risk of retinopathy of premature infants containing βcarotene Composition containing A. M. Todd Company (Kalamazoo, MI) May 21, 2013 K-PAX Vitamins, Inc. (Mill Valley, CA) January 29, 2013 Abbott Laboratories (Abbott Park, IL) September 11, 2012 Everett June 12, for nutrition supplementation β-carotene to treat subjects undergoing physiologically stressful events Composition containing β-carotene to treat subjects undergoing physiologically stressful events Laboratories, Inc. (West Orange, NJ) Everett Laboratories, Inc. (West Orange, NJ) January 24, 2012 Composition containing β-carotene to be used in nutrient compositions K-PAX Vitamins, Inc. (Mill Valley, CA) May 31, 2011 Ajinomoto Co., Inc. (Tokyo, JP) September 7, 2010 Z Trim Holdings, Inc. (Mundelein, IL) July 27, 2010 Everett Laboratories, Inc. (West Orange, NJ) July 14, 2009 2012 8,101,587 Kits for nutrition supplementation 7,951,847 Nutrient compositions and methods for enhanced effectiveness of the immune system 7,790,209 Total enteral nutritious composition 7,763,301 Emulsified liquid shortening compositions comprising dietary fiber gel, water and lipid 7,560,123 Compositions and methods for nutrition supplementation 7,438,936 Dietary supplement and related method Dietary supplement containing β-carotene 7,273,622 Super absorption Coenzyme Q.sub.10 Dietary supplement containing β-carotene Composition for the prevention and treatment of cachexia Nutritional formula containing select carotenoid combinations Formulation containing βcarotene to prevent and treat cachexia 7,060,263 Super absorption Coenzyme Q.sub.10 Dietary supplement containing β-carotene 7,056,525 Carotenoid formulations, comprising a mixture of .β.carotene, lycopene and lutein Formulation containing βcarotene to be used in human and animal foods, cosmetics and pharmaceuticals BASF Aktiengesellschaft (Ludwigshafen, DE) June 6, 2006 Topic application of a formulation containing βcarotene Micelle Products, Inc. (Lake Forest, CA) May 10, 2005 * February 1, 2005 Pharmaton SA (Bioggio, CH) December 28, 2004 7,223,736 7,090,879 6,890,961 6,849,613 6,835,401 Clear micellized formulations of .β.-carotene and method of treating leukoplakia Multiple antioxidant micronutrients Method of treating diseases caused by over-production of free-radicals Composition containing β-carotene to improves serum albumin and ameliorates bedsores Formulation containing βcarotene to reduce production costs of formulated foods Composition containing β-carotene to treat subjects undergoing physiologically stressful events Formula containing βcarotene Formulation containing βcarotene as antioxidant Formulation containing βcarotene to prevent overproduction of free radicals like aging, arteriosclerosis and Access Business Group International LLC (Ada, MI) Soft Gel Technologies, Inc. (Los Angeles, CA) Abbott Laboratories (Abbott Park, IL) Abbott Laboratories (Abbott Park, IL) Soft Gel Technologies, Inc. (Los Angeles, CA) October 21, 2008 September 25, 2007 May 29, 2007 August 15, 2006 June 13, 2006 cancer 6,814,958 6,764,693 6,759,436 Food compositions, compositions for oral cavity and medicinal compositions for preventing or treating periodontosis and method for preventing or treating periodontosis Free radical quenching composition and a method to increase intracellular and/or extracellular antioxidants Clear micellized formulations of .β.-carotene and method of treating leukoplakia Formulation containing βcarotene to prevent or treat periodontosis Sunstar Inc. (Osaka, JP) November 9, 2004 Formulation containing βcarotene to reduce undesirable side effects of free radicals Amaox, Ltd. (Lawton, MI) July 20, 2004 Topic application of a formulation containing βcarotene Micelle Products, Inc. (Lake Forest, CA) July 6, 2004 Bausch & Lomb Incorporated (Rochester, NY) December 9, 2003 Pharmaton SA (Bioggio, CH) September 30, 2003 Dietary supplement containing β-carotene to strengthen and promote retinal Formulation containing βcarotene to prevent overproduction of free radicals like aging, arteriosclerosis and cancer 6,660,297 Nutritional supplement to treat macular degeneration 6,627,231 Method for improving the cell protection 6,623,734 Super absorption coenzyme Q10 Dietary supplement containing β-carotene Soft Gel Technologies, Inc. (Los Angeles, CA) September 23, 2003 6,617,356 Gel system for oral and topical administration of water insoluble and/or water intolerant drugs and supplements Gel system containing βcarotene to be used as supplement * September 9, 2003 Johnson & Johnson SA (FR) July 8, 2003 6,589,535 Nutritional supplement based on blackcurrant seed oil 6,583,152 Composition for reducing the risk or progression of cardiovascular diseases 6,541,043 Method and synergistic composition for treating attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder 6,511,675 Composition and method for correcting a dietary phytochemical deficiency 6,509,029 Carotenoid formulations, comprising a mixture of .β.carotene, lycopene and lutein 6,428,816 Carotenoid agent for inhibiting the conversion of Composition containing β-carotene for preventing and/or combating the harmful effects of xenobiotics on the skin, in particular on the skin's immune system Composition containing β-carotene to reduce the risk or progression of cardiovascular diseases Composition containing β-carotene for treating attention deficit A composition containing β-carotene for correcting a dietary phytonutrient deficiency Carotenoid formulation to be used in human and animal foods, cosmetics and pharmaceuticals Composition including βcarotene to inhibit a DexGen Pharmaceuticals, Inc. (Manasquan, NJ) DexGen Pharmaceuticals, Inc. (Manasquan, NJ) Access Business Group International, LLC (Ada, MI) BASF Aktiengesellschaft (Ludwigshafen, DE) Cognis Australia Pty., Ltd. June 24, 2003 April 1, 2003 January 28, 2003 January 21, 2003 August 6, 2002 epithelial cells to tumors carcinogen 6,399,114 Nutritional system for nervous system disorders Composition for treating nervous system disorders 6,387,883 Method for the prevention and treatment of cachexia and anorexia 6,326,355 Method for the prevention and treatment of cachexia and anorexia 6,294,520 Material for passage through the blood-brain barrier 6,261,598 Carotenoid formulations, comprising a mixture of βcarotene, lycopene and lutein 6,251,953 β-carotene therapy of individuals having abnormal immunological and serological indices, and individuals having infections and diseases causing changes therein 6,136,859 Pharmaceutical formulation for treating liver disorders Formulation containing βcarotene to prevent or treat cachexia and anorexia Formulation containing βcarotene to prevent or treat cachexia and anorexia Formulation containing βcarotene Formulation containing βcarotene to be used in human and animal foods, cosmetics and pharmaceuticals (Broadmeadows, AU) C & D Foreman, Inc. (Chesterfield, VA) June 4, 2002 Abbott Laboratories (Abbott Park, IL) May 14, 2002 Abbott Laboratories (Abbott Park, IL) December 4, 2001 * September 25, 2001 BASF Aktiengesellschaft (Ludwigshafen, DE) July 17, 2001 Brookner; Andrew (Short HIlls, NJ) June 26, 2001 Pharma Nord ApS (Vojens, DK) October 24, 2000 Laboratoire Oenobiol (Paris, FR) August 29, 2000 Food containing βcarotene as additive * August 15, 2000 6,077,828 Method for the prevention and treatment of cachexia and anorexia Formulation containing βcarotene to prevent or treat cachexia and anorexia Abbott Laboratories (Abbott Park, IL) June 20, 2000 6,007,856 Oil-in-water dispersions of .β.-carotene and other carotenoids stable against oxidation prepared from water-dispersible beadlets having high concentrations of carotenoid β-carotene dispersion to be used as food supplement The Procter & Gamble Company (Cincinnati, OH) December 28, 1999 5,977,073 Nutrient composition for treatment of immune disorders Composition containing β-carotene to treat immune disorders 5,972,985 Histidine containing nutriceutical compositions Nutriceutical composition containing β-carotene 6,110,478 6,103,755 Composition having tanning and photoprotective activity, and its cosmetic applications Foodstuff with prophylactic and/or healing effect and process for its production 5,919,820 Antioxidant medicament 5,883,086 DHEA-containing nutritional β-carotene as therapy of individuals having abnormal immunological and serological indices Pharmaceutical formulation containing βcarotene Composition containing β-carotene with photoprotective activity Pharmaceutical composition containing βcarotene to be used as antioxidant medicament Nutritional supplement Life Sciences' Technologies, Inc. (Birmingham, AL) Cytos Pharmaceuticals, LLC (Durham, NC) November 2, 1999 October 26, 1999 Pharma Nord ApS (Vojens, DK) July 6, 1999 * March 16, supplement 5,871,766 Β-carotene vitamin E therapy for inhibition of major vascular events 5,849,787 Hypercholesterolemia therapeutic agent 5,837,309 5,834,044 5,804,573 5,738,859 5,733,884 5,723,166 Process of making a baby food containing light fleshed vegetables and product thereof Method of making a health food product containing antioxidants Stabilized pharmaceutical composition containing derivative of vitamins D.sub.2 and D.sub.3 Cosmetic composition Enteral formulation designed for optimized wound healing Process of making a baby food containing light fleshed vegetables and product thereof 5,705,526 Hypercholesterolemia therapeutic agent 5,700,782 Enteral nutritional product 5,670,549 5,662,934 5,643,623 5,637,324 5,629,023 5,569,459 5,554,374 Prevention and amelioration of liver toxicity with βcarotene Compositions and methods for lowering cholesterol while maintaining antioxidant levels Health food product and its uses Medical food composition for metabolic detoxification Medical food composition for metabolic detoxification Pharmaceutical compositions for the management of premenstrual syndrome and alleviation of menopausal disorders Skin preparation using nanospheres containing β-carotene to treat stress symptoms Pharmaceutical composition containing βcarotene A hypercholesterolemia therapeutic agent containing β-carotene as an effective ingredient Food composition containing β-carotene for babies β-Carotene as food additive Pharmaceutical composition containing βcarotene Formulation containing βcarotene for cosmetics Formulation containing βcarotene Food composition containing β-carotene for babies A hypercholesterolemia therapeutic agent containing β-carotene as an effective ingredient Formulation containing βcarotene for human supplements Formulation containing βcarotene to prevent liver toxicity Composition containing β-carotene to maintain antioxidant levels Formulation containing βcarotene to enhance in vivo oxidative defense Formulation containing βcarotene as medical food Formulation containing βcarotene as medical food 1999 Brigham and Women's Hospital (Boston, MA) February 16, 1999 Mutsunori Fujiwara (Tokyo, JP) December 15, 1998 Beech-Nut Nutrition Corporation (St. Louis, MO) Mars, Incorporated (McLean, VA) Teva Pharmaceutical Industries Ltd. (Jerusalem, IL) Abbe Cosmetic Group International, Inc. (Farmingdale, NY) Nestec Ltd. (Vevey, CH) Beech-Nut Nutrition Corporation (St. Louis, MO) November 17, 1998 November 10, 1998 September 8, 1998 April 14. 1998 March 31, 1998 March 3, 1998 Fujiwara; Mutsunori (Tokyo, JP) January 6, 1998 Abbott Laboratories (Abbott Park, IL) December 23, 1997 * September 23, 1997 * September 2, 1997 Mars Incorporated (McClean, VA) July 1, 1997 * * June 10, 1997 May 13, 1997 Pharmaceutical composition containing βcarotene Bio-Virus Research Incorporated (San Mateo, CA) October 29, 1996 Drug carrier encapsulating β-carotene for cosmetics Cosmetics Development Company Limited September 10, 1996 (GB) 5,547,927 5,516,535 5,514,656 5,514,382 5,475,006 5,457,135 5,455,280 5,424,331 Enteral nutritional product for patients undergoing radiation therapy and/or chemotherapy Beverage compositions having enhanced .β.-carotene bioavailability Method of providing enteral nutritional support for patients undergoing radiation therapy and/or chemotherapy Daily vitamin and mineral supplement for women Extensively oxidized derivatives of carotenoids, retinoids and related conjugated polyenes useful as non-toxic celldifferentiation inducers, antiproliferative agents, and antitumor agents Treatment of age related macular degeneration with βcarotene Treatment of chronic lymphocytic leukemia with β-carotene Pharmaceutical compositions and dietary soybean food products for the prevention of osteoporosis Formulation containing βcarotene Abbott Laboratories (Abbott Park, IL) August 20, 1996 Formulation containing βcarotene with high bioavailability The Procter & Gamble (Cincinnati, OH) May 14, 1996 Formulation containing βcarotene Abbott Laboratories (Abbott Park, IL) May 7, 1996 Formulation containing βcarotene for food supplement Sultenfuss; Sherry (Largo, FL) May 7, 1996 β-carotene as nutreceutical National Research Council of Canada (Ottawa, CA) December 12, 1995 β-carotene to treat age related macular degeneration * October 10,1995 β-carotene to treat chronic lymphocytic leukemia * October 3, 1995 Pharmaceutical composition of β-carotene Bio-Virus Research Incorporated (San Mateo, CA) June 13, 1995 5,397,786 Rehydration drink Drink to be used in diarrhea processes containing β-carotene * March 14, 1995 5,368,870 Method for making vitamin enriched cereal Fortification process of cereals by β-carotene General Mills, Inc. (Minneapolis, MN) November 29, 1994 5,310,764 Treatment of age related macular degeneration with βcarotene * May 10 1994 5,310,554 High purity β-carotene 5,308,832 Nutritional product for persons having a neurological injury β-carotene to treat age related macular degeneration Composition with high purity of β-carotene to be administrated to humans Nutritional product containing β-carotene as antioxidant 5,294,606 Isotonic energy composition and method to use same Beverage containing βcarotene 5,270,063 Ready-to-eat cereal products enriched with βcarotene Biofortified cereals with β-carotene for humans 5,258,189 Method for making vitamin enriched cereal Fortification process of cereals by β-carotene 5,234,702 Antioxidant system for powdered nutritional Use of β-carotene as antioxidant Natural Carotene Corporation (Tukwila, WA) Abbott Laboratories (Abbott Park, IL) Reliv' International Inc. (Chesterfield, MO) Kellogg Company (Battle Creek, MI) General Mills, Inc. (Minneapolis, MN) Abbott Laboratories May 10, 1994 May 3, 1994 March 15, 1994 December 14, 1993 November 2, 1993 August 10, 1993 products 5,223,285 Nutritional product for pulmonary patients Food supplement containing β-carotene 5,153,012 Process for preparing beverage containing .β.carotene Method to prepare a beverage containing βcarotene 5,124,313 Methods of improved skin care and the treatment of dermatological conditions 5,002,779 4,992,282 Dry stable chocolate beverage containing iron and vitamin C Stable nutritional vitamin and mineral supplemented beverage Methods for treating or preventing dermatological diseases containing βcarotene Method relating to nutritional improvement containing β-carotene Vitamin and mineralfortified beverage containing β-carotene Pharmacological/cosmetic preparation containing βcarotene Composition containing β-carotene as pharmaceutical or cosmetic Capsules for pharmaceuticals containing β-carotene 4,943,433 Pharmacological/cosmetic preparation 4,931,467 Drug composition for treating or preventing acne by oral administration 4,693,892 Gelatin containing .β.carotene 4,689,245 Low-fat dairy coffee whitener Product with β-carotene 4,642,318 Method for decreasing radiation load in PUVA therapy β-Carotene effective polyene compound (Abbott Park, IL) Abbott Laboratories (Abbott Park, IL) Ohtaka; Hisaaki (Nishitama-gun, Tokyo, JP), Sudo; Ryosei (Nishitama-gun, Tokyo, JP) * The Procter & Gamble Company (Cincinnati, OH) The Procter & Gamble Company (Cincinnati, OH) June 29, 1993 October 6, 1992 June 23, 1992 March 26, 1991 February 12, 1991 * July 24, 1990 L'Oreal (Paris, FR) June 5, 1990 Bayer Aktiengesellschaft (Leverkusen, DE) Cornell Research Foundation (Ithaca, NY) September 15,1987 August 25, 1987 * February 10, 1987 Microalgae strain producing β-carotene Universidad de Almeria (Almeria, ES) November 29, 2011 Encapsulated Dunaniella salina * April 10, 1990 Food containing Dunaliella algae * April 10, 1990 Food containing Dunaliella algae * April 3, 1990 Process to produce βcarotene from algae Microbio Resources, Inc. (San Diego, CA) July 14, 1987 Method to obtain βcarotene from algae Commonwealth Scientific and November 19, 1985 β-Carotene produced by algae 8,067,225 4,915,965 4,915,961 4,913,915 4,680,314 4,554,390 Microalga species and its application for animal, human consumption and in obtaining carotenoids Process for production of encapsulated foodstuff containing Dunaliella algae Vacuum-packed food containing Dunaliella algae and process for the production thereof Solid food stuff composition containing Dunaliella algae and process for the production thereof Process for producing a naturally-derived carotene/oil composition by direct extraction from algae Method for harvesting algae 4,439,629 Extraction process for βcarotene Method to obtain βcarotene from algae 4,199,895 Production of glycerol, carotenes and algae meal Process to obtain βcarotene from algae Industrial Research Organization (both of, AU) Βtene Limited (both of, AU) Hoffmann-La Roche Inc. (Nutley, NJ) Yeda Research and Development Co. Ltd. (Rehovot, IL) March 27, 1984 April 29, 1980 β-Carotene produced by bacteria 8,030,022 Microorganism and method for producing carotenoid using it Bacterium from the genus Paracoccus which produce β-carotene 6,825,002 Process for producing carotenoid pigments Method to produce higher levels of β-carotene in E396 strain 5,935,808 Carotenoid-producing bacterial species and process for production of carotenoids using same Paracoccus strain DSM 11574 which produces βcarotene 5,858,761 Bacteria for production of carotenoids Bacteria producing βcarotene 5,607,839 Bacteria belonging to new genus process for production of carotenoids using same Bacterium from a new genus producing βcarotene Tosoh Corporation (Shunan-shi, JP) Nippon Mitsubishi Oil Corporation (Tokyo, JP) Yissum Research and Development Company of the Hebrew University of (Jerusalem, IL) Nippon Oil Company, Ltd. (Tokyo, JP) Nippon Oil Company, Ltd. (Tokyo, JP) October 4, 2011 November 30, 2004 August 10, 1999 January 12, 1999 March 4, 1997 β-Carotene produced by fungi 7,252,965 Method of production of .β.carotene by fermentation in mixed culture using (+) and (-) strains of Blakeslea trispora β-Carotene produced by Blakeslea trispora Antibioticos, S.A.U. (Leon, ES) August 7, 2007 7,015,014 Isolation of carotenoid crystals Crystalline carotenoid composition from Phaffia DSM IP Assets B.V. (Te Heerlen, NL) March 21, 2006 Process for production of carotenoids, xanthophylls and apo-carotenoids utilizing eukaryotic microorganisms Phaffia rhodozyma mutants, process for producing .β.carotene and use of .β.carotene rich biomass Method for produce an effective amount of βcarotene from Thraustochytriales * August 31, 2004 Phaffia rhodozyma mutants with high levels of β-carotene Pernod Ricard (Paris, FR) November 25, 1997 6,783,951 5,691,190 5,643,719 Intersexual heterozygous phycomyces Phycomyces strains which high β-carotene 5,422,247 Blakeslea trispora mated culture capable of increased Production of β-carotene from Blakeslea trispora Gist-brocades, N.V. (Ma Delft, NL) Universal Foods Corporation July 1, 1997 June 6, 1995 5,328,845 4,318,987 β-carotene production Fungal negative microorganism capable of producing high levels of βcarotene .β.-Carotene producing strains of the fungus Phycomyces blakesleenus (Milwaukee, WI) Fungi producing βcarotene Universal Foods Corporation (Milwaukee, WI) July 12, 1994 Process to obtain carotenoids from Phycomyces blakesleeanus * March 9, 1982 β-Carotene produced by plants PP21,005 Kiwi plant named `AU Fitzgerald` Cultivar of Actinidia deliciosa which contains low levels of β-carotene 7,575,766 Tagetes erecta with altered carotenoid compositions and ratios Tagetes erecta with enhanced β-carotene content 7,033,622 Tagetes erecta with altered carotenoid compositions and ratios Tagetes erecta with enhanced β-carotene content 7,018,669 Green soybeans whose color is prevented from discoloring New soybean containing β-carotene 6,784,351 Targetes erecta marigolds with altered carotenoid compositions and ratios Tagetes erecta with enhanced β-carotene content Auburn University (Auburn, AL) Ball Horticultural Company (West Chicago, unknown) Ball Horticultural Company (West Chicago, unknown) Nippon Suisan Kaisha, Ltd. (Tokyo, JP) Ball Horticultural Company (West Chicago, unknown) May 25, 2010 August 18, 2009 April 25, 2006 March 28, 2006 August 31, 2004 Method of extraction of β-carotene 8,486,267 Non-dispersive process for insoluble oil recovery from aqueous slurries Method to recover enhanced β-carotene from algae 7,662,599 Isolation and purification of carotenoids from marigold flowers Isolation and purification of β-carotene from marigold 7,119,238 Process for purification and crystallization of palm oil carotenoids Purification of β-carotene from palm oil 6,909,021 Method of extracting lutein from green plant materials Method of extraction of β-carotene 6,805,800 Method for recovering pigments from algal cultures Method of extraction of β-carotene 6,770,585 Momordica cochinchinensis (Spreng.) .β.-carotene and method Method of extraction of β-carotene 6,737,552 Method for extracting lutein from green plant materials Method of extraction of β-carotene 6,262,284 Process for extraction and purification of lutein, zeaxanthin and rare Method of extraction of different compounds including β-carotene Board of Regents, The University of Texas System (Austin, TX) Katra Phytochem Private Limited (Bangalore, IN) University of Maryland (College Park, MD) Alfalfa America, Inc. (Minneapolis, MN) Β Carotene Investments Limited (Auckland, NZ) Vitalea Science, Inc. (Davis, CA) Alfalfa America, Inc. (Minneapolis, MN) University of Maryland (College Park, July 16, 2013 November 24, 2009 October 10, 2006 June 21, 2005 October 10, 2004 August 3, 2004 May 18, 2004 July 17, 2001 carotenoids from marigold flowers and plants MD) 6,057,484 Method of obtaining a composition containing 9-cis .β.-carotene in high-purity Method of extraction of β-carotene from algae 5,714,658 Process for the extraction of carotenes from natural sources Process of extraction of β-carotene 5,612,485 High cis β-carotene composition Formulation containing βcarotene from natural sources 5,378,369 Solvent extraction β-carotene extraction from alga 4,962,275 Method and apparatus for supercritical fluid extraction solution separation Method to separate βcarotene using supercritical fluid extraction Institute of Applied Biochemistry (Mitake-cho, JP) SKW Trostberg Aktiengesellschaft (Trostberg, DE) Βtene Ltd of Cheltenham (Victoria, AU) Sasol Chemical Industries (Proprietary) Limited (Johannesburg, ZA) United States of America as represented by the Secretary of Commerce (Washington, DC) May 2, 2000 February 3, 1998 March 18, 1997 January 3, 1995 October 9, 1990 β-Carotene produced by chemical synthesis 8,293,946 Dialdehyde compound, preparation method thereof, and synthetic method of carotenoids using the same Novel C dialdehyde compound to synthesize β-carotene 8,288,605 Dialdehyde compound, preparation method thereof, and synthetic method of carotenoids using the same Novel C dialdehyde compound to synthesize β-carotene 8,158,838 Diadehyde compound, preparation method thereof, and synthetic method of carotenoids using the same Novel C dialdehyde compound to synthesize β-carotene 7,928,266 Diadehyde compound, preparation method thereof, and synthetic method of carotenoids using the same Novel C dialdehyde compound to synthesize β-carotene 7,470,822 C10 dialdehyde, synthetic method thereof, and synthetic method of β-carotene using the same Novel C dialdehyde compound to synthesize β-carotene Myongji University Industry and Academia Cooperation (Gyeonggi-do, KR) Myongji University Industry and Academia Cooperation (Gyeonggi-do, KR) Myongji University Industry and Academia Cooperation (Gyeonggi-do, KR) Myongji University Industry and Academia Cooperation (Gyeonggi-do, KR) Myongji University Industry and Academia Cooperation October 23, 2012 October 16, 2012 April 17, 2012 April 19, 2011 December 39, 2008 (Gyeonggi-do, KR) BASF Aktiengesellschaft (Ludwigshafen, DE) Sumitomo Chemical Company, Limited (Osaka, JP) Koo; Sangho (KR) BASF Aktiengesellschaft (Ludwigshafen, DE) BASF Aktiengesellschaft (Ludwigshafen, DE) 7,378,558 Method for producing carotenoids Method to produce βcarotene 6,355,841 Process for producing .β.carotene Process to obtain βcarotene 6,297,416 Process for making .β.carotene Process to obtain βcarotene 5,689,022 Preparation of .β.-carotene products with a high 9 (Z) content Method of production of β-carotene 5,453,447 Preparation of stable injectable .β.-carotene solubilizates Preparation of a βcarotene formula 5,300,658 2,5-bis(1,1-dialkoxy-2propyl)-2,5-dihydrofurans, the preparation thereof and the use thereof for the preparation of carotenoids Chemical synthesis of βcarotene BASF Aktiengesellschaft (Ludwigshafen, DE) April 5, 1994 5,237,102 Sulfone aldehydes useful for producing .β.-carotene Process to produce βcarotene Kuraray Company Ltd. (Kurashiki, JP) August 17, 1993 Process for producing βcarotene Kuraray Company Ltd. (Kurashiki, JP) February 9, 1993 Method to synthetize βcarotene Loyola University of Chicago (Chicago, IL) BASF Aktiengesellschaft (Ludwigshafen, DE) Loyola University of Chicago (Chicago, IL) BASF Aktiengesellschaft (DE) 5,185,468 5,061,819 Process for producing .β.carotene, and intermediate compounds useful for the process Methods of improved skin care and the treatment of dermatological conditions 5,023,095 Color stabilization system for β-carotene in dry food mixes Method to synthetize βcarotene as food coloring agent 4,916,250 Phosphonate reagent compositions Method to produce βcarotene 4,435,427 Stable injectable .β.-carotene micellar solutions and their preparation 4,049,718 Sulphones 4,048,234 Sulphones 4,038,323 Alkenyl aryl sulfones Process for the preparation of β-carotene micellar solutions Process to obtain intermediates for βcarotene synthesis Process to obtain intermediates for βcarotene synthesis Process to obtain intermediates for βcarotene synthesis May 27, 2008 March 12, 2002 October 2, 2001 November 18, 1997 September 26, 1995 October 29, 1991 June 11, 1991 April 10, 1990 March 6, 1984 Rhone-Poulenc, S.A. (Paris, FR) September 20, 1977 Rhone-Poulenc, S.A. (Paris, FR) September 13, 1977 Rhone-Poulenc, S.A. (Paris, FR) July 26, 1977 Patented enzymes or DNA sequences to produce β-carotene by organism transformation 8,138,391 Or gene and its use in manipulating carotenoid Gene related to carotenoid manipulation The United States of America as March 20, 2012 content and composition in plants and other organisms to increase β-carotene levels 8,071,841 Or gene and its use in manipulating carotenoid content and composition in plants and other organisms Gene related to carotenoid manipulation to increase β-carotene levels 7,745,170 Process for producing carotenoid compound Process for producing βcarotene 7,288,387 Genes of strain DC413 encoding enzymes involved in biosynthesis of carotenoid compounds Carotenogenic genes isolated form Panteoa stewartii 7,070,952 Genes encoding carotenoid compounds Carotenogenic genes from Pectobacterium 7,064,196 Genes encoding carotenoid compounds Carotenogenic genes from strain DC260 of the enterobacter family 6,929,928 Genes encoding carotenoid compounds 6,613,543 Fermentative carotenoid production 6,524,811 Methods of increasing or decreasing carotenoids and other isoprenoids using IPP isomerase 6,207,409 Fermentative carotenoid production 6,124,113 Fermentative carotenoid production 6,087,152 Fermentative carotenoid production 5,656,472 β-carotene biosynthesis in genetically engineered hosts 5,589,581 DNA sequences useful for the synthesis of carotenoids Carotenogenic genes from Pantoea agglomerans to produce β-carotene Novel proteins of Flavobacterium sp. R1534 to produce βcarotene DNA sequences to modulate carotenoids Novel proteins of Flavobacterium sp. R1534 to produce βcarotene Novel proteins of Flavobacterium sp. R1534 to produce βcarotene Novel proteins of Flavobacterium sp. R1534 to produce βcarotene DNA segments from Erwinia herbicola to modulate carotenoids DNA sequences which are useful for the represented by the Secretary of Agriculture (Washinton, DC) N/A (Ithaca, NY) Boyce Thompson Institute Inc. (Ithaca, NY) Cornell University The United States of America as represented by the Secretary of Agriculture (Washington, DC) Nippon Oil Corporation (Tokyo, JP) E. I. du Pont de Nemours and Company (Wilmington, DE) E. I. du Pont de Nemours and Company (Wilmington, DE) E. I. du Pont de Nemours and Company (Wilmington, DE) E. I. du Pont de Nemours and Company (Wilmington, DE) December 6, 2011 June 29, 2010 October 30, 2007 July 4, 2006 June 20, 2006 August 16, 2005 Roche Vitamins, Inc. (Parsippany, NJ) September 2, 2003 University of Maryland (College Park, MD) February 25, 2003 Roche Vitamins, Inc. (Parsippany, NJ) March 27, 2001 Roche Vitamins, Inc. (Parsippany, NJ) September 26, 2000 Roche Vitamins, Inc. (Parsippany, NJ) July 11, 2000 Amoco Corporation (Chicago, IL) Kirin Beer Kabushiki Kaisha August 12, 1997 December 31, 1996 5,530,188 β-carotene biosynthesis in genetically engineered hosts 5,429,939 DNA sequences useful for the synthesis of carotenoids * Assignee is not available synthesis of carotenoids such as β-carotene DNA segments encoding the Erwinia enzymes for carotenogenic genes DNA sequences for βcarotene production (Tokyo-To, JP) Amoco Corporation (Chicago, IL) Kirin Beer Kabushiki Kaisha (Tokyo-To, JP) June 25, 1996 July 4, 1995 Supplementary table 3: Patent number Title Brief description Assignee Date of issue Applications of lycopene for humans (cosmetics, dietary supplements...) 8,460,718 Synergistic compositions and methods 8,454,951 Nutritional supplements for women desiring to become pregnant, and pregnant and nursing women 8,377,454 Treating male infertility secondary to sperm oxidative stress 8,354,126 Composition for prostate health 8,263,667 Nutritional supplement for use under physiologically stressful conditions 8,263,156 Food supplement based on biological lycopene and process to obtain biological lycopene 8,263,147 Infant formulas containing docosahexaenoic acid and lutein 8,221,803 Composition for prostate health 8,206,759 Method of reducing blood cholesterol and triglyceride levels using combinations of vasoprotective agent Pharmaceutical compositions for oral administration comprising a therapeutically effective amount of lycopene and one phytosterol to inhibit cell growth LycoRed Ltd. (IL) June 11, 2013 Nutritional formulation containing lycopene Argent Development Group, LLC (Mountain View, CA) June 4, 2013 * February 19, 2013 OncoNatural Solutions, Inc. (Los Angeles, CA) January 15, 2013 Vertical Pharmaceuticals, Inc. (Sayreville, NJ) September 11, 2012 * September 11, 2012 Abbott Laboratories (Abbott Park, IL) September 11, 2012 OncoNatural Solutions, Inc. (Los Angeles, CA) July 17, 2012 Indena S.p. A. (Milan, IT) June 26, 2012 A profertility composition including lycopene for administration to infertile men with sperm oxidative stress Composition containing lycopene to prevent, alleviate, and/or treat symptoms associated with prostate conditions and disease Nutritional supplement May include one or more listed vitamins, minerals and lycopene Innovative food supplement based on biological lycopene Method of reducing the risk or severity of retinopathy of prematurity in preterm infants by administration of a formulation containing lycopene Composition containing lycopene to prevent, alleviate, and/or treat symptoms associated with prostate conditions and disease Combinations of vasoprotective agents (containing lycopene) for the treatment of reducing blood cholesterol and triglyceride levels induced by an excess of plasma 8,202,546 Nutritional supplement for use under physiologically stressful conditions 8,197,854 Nutritional supplement for use under physiologically stressful conditions 7,964,189 Nutritional supplements for women desiring to become pregnant, and pregnant and nursing women 7,939,115 Dietary supplement and related method 7,901,710 Nutritional supplement for use under physiologically stressful conditions 7,662,401 Administration of extracts of nonfruiting nonphotosynthetic filamentous bacteria for increasing the endogenous synthesis of superoxide dismutase 7,438,936 lipids Nutritional supplement May include one or more listed vitamins, minerals and lycopene Nutritional supplement May include one or more listed vitamins, minerals and lycopene Nutritional supplement containing lycopene for the uses set forth above Nutritional supplement to improve plasma concentrations of antioxidant nutrients Nutritional supplement May include one or more listed vitamins, minerals and lycopene Vertical Pharmaceuticals, Inc. (Sayreville, NJ) Vertical Pharmaceuticals, Inc. (Sayreville, NJ) Argent Development Group, LLC (Mountain View, CA) Access Business Group International LLC (Ada, MI) June 19, 2012 June 12, 2012 June 21, 2011 May 10, 2011 Vertical Pharmaceuticals, Inc. (Edison, NJ) March 8, 2011 Cosmetic or pharmaceutical use of an extract of a nonfruiting nonphotosynthetic filamentous bacterium and lycopene L'Oreal (Paris, FR) February 16, 2010 Dietary supplement and related method Nutritional supplement containing lycopene Access Business Group International LLC (Ada, MI) October 21, 2008 7,435,432 Combined marine and plant extract compositions Formulation containing lycopene for the treatment of ageing skin and the delaying of the onset of the signs of ageing in healthy skin Olson; Bengt Krister (Copenhagen O, DK) October 14, 2008 7,416,749 Dietary supplement and related method Nutritional supplement containing lycopene Nutritional formula containing select carotenoid combinations Carotenoid formulations, comprising a mixture of .beta.-carotene, lycopene and lutein Nutritional formulas to improve product stability and color characteristics Carotenoid formulation to be used in human and animal foods, cosmetics and pharmaceuticals Dietary supplement containing lycopene for treating of preventing prostate disease and/or vascular disease A composition containing lycopene for correcting a dietary phytonutrient deficiency Multivitamin and mineral 7,090,879 7,056,525 7,022,350 Dietary supplement 6,989,161 Phytonutrient nutritional supplement 6,953,588 Multi-vitamin and mineral Access Business Group International LLC (Ada, MI) Abbott Laboratories (Abbott Park, IL) BASF Aktiengesellschaft (Ludwigshafen, DE) Proethic Pharmaceuticals, Inc. (Montgomery, AL) Access Business Group International LLC (Ada, MI) Cooper Concepts, August 26, 2008 August 15, 2006 June 6, 2006 April 4, 2006 January 24, 2006 October supplement 6,946,151 6,630,160 6,630,158 Therapeutic compositions Process to modulate disease risk with doses of a nutraceutical Dietary supplement composition and method for improving and maintaining healthy skin 6,623,769 Administration of lycopene for combating skin/mucous membrane damage 6,589,535 Nutritional supplement based on blackcurrant seed oil 6,555,142 Food supplement formulation 6,555,134 Synergistic mixtures of garlic and lycopene for preventing LDL oxidation 6,515,018 Synergistic compositions for lycopene and Vitamin E for the prevention of LDL oxidation 6,511,675 Composition and method for correcting a dietary phytochemical deficiency 6,509,029 Carotenoid formulations, comprising a mixture of .beta.-carotene, lycopene and lutein 6,482,447 Method and composition for the treatment of benign prostate hypertrophy (BPH) and prevention of prostate cancer 6,436,449 Use of a composition 6,399,115 Method and composition for the treatment of benign prostate hypertrophy (BPH) and prevention of prostate cancer supplement tailored to men and post-menopausal women Formulation containing lycopene to ameliorate cholesterolemia, obesity, chronic complications of diabetes Dietary supplement containing lycopene to reduce risk of disease Dietary supplement composition containing lycopene for promoting healthy skin Lycopene for treating, preventively and/or curatively, cutaneous signs of aging Composition containing lycopene for preventing and/or combating the harmful effects of xenobiotics on the skin, in particular on the skin's immune system Formulation containing lycopene Pharmaceutical composition containing lycopene to prevent atherosclerosis Pharmaceutical composition containing lycopene to prevent atherosclerosis A composition containing lycopene for correcting a dietary phytonutrient deficiency Carotenoid formulation to be used in human and animal foods, cosmetics and pharmaceuticals Compositions comprising lycopene for treating various conditions and diseases, including benign prostatic hypertrophy and prostate cancer Manufacture of a medicament for the treatment of a mammal suffering from tinnitus Compositions comprising lycopene for treating various conditions and diseases, including benign prostatic hypertrophy and prostate cancer Inc. (Dallas, TX) 11, 2005 Ayurvedic-Life International, LLC (Neenah, WI) September 20, 2005 Genetic Services Management, Inc. (Omaha, NE) October 7, 2003 Stiefel Laboratories, Inc. (Oak Hill, NY) October 7, 2003 Societe L'Oreal S.A. (Paris, FR) September 23, 2003 July 8, 2 0 0 3 Johnson & Johnson SA (FR) * Lycored Natural Products Industries Ltd. (Beer Sheva, IL) Lycored Natural Products Industries Ltd. (Beer Sheva, IL) Access Business Group International, LLC (Ada, MI) BASF Aktiengesellschaft (Ludwigshafen, DE) April 29, 2003 April 29, 2003 February 4, 2003 January 28, 2003 January 21, 2003 Braswell; Glenn (Miami, FL) November 19, 2002 * August 20, 2002 Braswell; Glenn (Miami, FL) June 4, 2002 6,362,211 Compositions containing natural lycopene and natural tocopherol 6,361,800 Multivitamin and mineral supplement 6,350,776 Method of treating proliferative disease with lycopene and alphatocopherol 6,299,896 Multi-vitamin and mineral supplement 6,262,109 6,261,598 6,235,315 Methods of preventing and/or treating high serum levels of cholesterol and/or lipids Carotenoid formulations, comprising a mixture of .beta.-carotene, lycopene and lutein Stable, pulverulent lycopene formulations, comprising lycopene having a degree of crystallinity of greater than 20% 6,110,478 Composition having tanning and photoprotective activity, and its cosmetic applications 5,849,787 Hypercholesterolemia therapeutic agent 5,834,044 Method of making a health food product containing anti-oxidants 5,827,900 Method and pharmaceutical preparations for reducing the activity of cells 5,705,526 Hypercholesterolemia therapeutic agent 5,643,623 Health food product and its uses A method for preventing or treating high serum levels of cholesterol and lipids in a mammal multi-vitamin and mineral supplement containing lycopene Method of treating, inhibiting, or preventing proliferative disease, particularly cancer, by administering an effective amount of the combination of lycopene and αtocopherol. Multi-vitamin and mineral supplement containing lycopene Formulation containing lycopene to prevent or treat high serum levels of cholesterol or lipids Carotenoid formulation to be used in human and animal foods, cosmetics and pharmaceuticals Carotenoid formulation to be used in human and animal foods, cosmetics and pharmaceuticals Oral or topical composition containing lycopene having tanning and sun-screening activity, and the cosmetic uses thereof, A hypercholesterolemia therapeutic agent containing lycopene as an effective ingredient Lycopene as food additive Composition with a cancer cell growth-inhibiting effective amount of lycopene A hypercholesterolemia therapeutic agent containing lycopene as an effective ingredient Formulation containing lycopene to enhance in vivo oxidative defense Cognis Corporation (Gulph MIlls, PA) March 26, 2002 Cooper Concepts, Inc. (Dallas, TX) March 26, 2002 * February 26, 2002 Cooper Concepts, Inc. (Dallas, TX) October 9, 2001 Henkel Corporation (Gulph Mills, PA) July 17, 2001 BASF Aktiengesellschaft (Ludwigshafen, DE) July 17, 2001 BASF Aktiengesellschaft (Ludwigshafen) May 22, 2001 Laboratoire Oenobiol (Paris, FR) August 29, 2000 Mutsunori Fujiwara (Tokyo, JP) December 15, 1998 Mars, Incorporated (McLean, VA) November 10, 1998 Makhteshim Agan (Beer-Sheva, IL) October 27, 1998 Fujiwara; Mutsunori (Tokyo, JP) January 6, 1998 Mars Incorporated (McClean, VA) July 1, 1997 Aquapharm BioDiscovery Ltd. January 29, 2013 Lycopene produced by bacteria 8,361,743 Biological production of zeaxanthin and carotenoid Strain of Algibacter which is capable of producing biosynthesis control 8,232,083 Method of producing lycopene using recombinant Escherichia coli significant levels of carotenoids, especially zeaxanthin at high purity A method of producing lycopene with high productivity by means of a recombinant bacterial strain (Oban, GB) Amicogen Co., Ltd. (GyungsangnamDo, KR) July 31, 2012 Lycopene produced by fungi 7,799,540 6,696,282 Method of producing lycopene through the fermentation of selected strains of Blackeslea trispora, formulations and uses of the lycopene thus obtained Fermentation with selected strains of B. trispora to achieve lycopene yields higher than those currently described Vitatene, S.A. (Leon, ES) September 21, 2010 Fusarium sporotrichioides strains for production of lycopene Transformed strains of Fusarium sporotrichioides effective for the production of lycopene The United States of America as represented by the Secretary of Agriculture (Washington, DC) January 24, 2004 Lycopene produced by plants 8,524,992 High lycopene content tomato plants and markers for use in breeding for same 7,575,766 Tagetes erecta with altered carotenoid compositions and ratios 7,033,622 Tagetes erecta with altered carotenoid compositions and ratios Solanum pimpinellifolium plants which are exceptionally high in fruit lycopene content Marigold plants with enhanced lycopene content and methods for obtaining such plants Marigold plants with enhanced lycopene content and methods for obtaining such plants The Penn State Research Foundation (University Park, PA) Ball Horticultural Company (West Chicago, unknown) September 3, 2013 August 18, 2009 Ball Horticultural Company (West Chicago, IL) April 25, 2006 Nestec S.A. (Vevey, CH) August 13, 2013 Indena S.p.A. (Milan, IT) July 10, 2012 Methods of extraction of lycopene 8,507,014 Natural lycopene concentrate and method for production thereof 8,216,619 Stable and bioavailable compositions of isomers of carotenoids for skin and hair 7,883,731 Natural coloring products 7,641,931 Industrial tomato process and product obtained thereof Natural lycopene concentrate obtained from a plant structure after alkalinization, solid-liquid separation, acidification and a second solid-liquid separation Method of manufacturing a stable composition enriched in cis-lycopene (z-isomers) A red colorant formed of 500 to 3000 ppm of crystalline lycopene Process to control viscosity and lycopene concentration of tomato Lycored Natural Products (BeerSheva, IL) Lycored Natural Products Industries, Ltd. February 8, 2011 January 5, 2010 7,582,325 7,557,146 6,344,573 Process for the preparation of tomato extracts with high content in lycopene Method of preparing lycopene-enriched formulations that are free of organic solvents, formulations thus obtained, compositions comprising said formulations and use of same Process for extraction and concentration of liposoluble vitamins and provitamins, growth factors and animal and vegetable hormones from residues and byproducts of industrialized animal and vegetable products 5,965,183 Stable lycopene concentrates and process for their preparation 5,897,866 Process for the extraction of lycopene using phospholipid in the extraction medium 5,858,700 Process for the isolation and purification of lycopene crystals products A process for the extraction of lycopene from whole tomatoes (Beer Sheva, IL) Indena S.p.A. (Milan, IT) September 1, 2009 Process to obtain a lycopene-enriched formulation free of organic solvents * July 7,2009 Process for the extraction and concentration of non saponificable substances Resitec Industria Quimica LTDA (Duane de Caxias, BR) February 5, 2002 * October 12, 1999 Indena S.p.A. (Milan, IT) April 27, 1999 Kemin Foods, LC (Des Moines, IA) January 12, 1999 A process for a preparing stable lycopene concentrate in an essentially non-dissolving liquid and uses thereof Preparation of pure lycopene or of lipophilic extracts from tomato Process for isolating and purifying lycopene crystals from a biological lycopene source Lycopene produced by chemical synthesis 1,4,6,10-tetra-double bond pentadec-carbon phosphonate, preparation method thereof, and preparation method of lycopene using the same Preparation method of lycopene via 1,4,6,10tetra-double bond pentadec-carbon phosphonate * September 17, 2013 Process for isomerisation of lycopene in the presence of thiourea The present invention relates to isomerization of Z-lycopene in mixtures of isomers to mixtures enriched with all Elycopene Divi's Laboratories, Ltd. (IN) March 5, 2013 8,293,946 Dialdehyde compound, preparation method thereof, and synthetic method of carotenoids using the same C dialdehyde compound which can be efficiently utilized in the synthesis of carotenoid compounds based on the sulfone chemistry 8,288,605 Dialdehyde compound, preparation method thereof, and synthetic method of carotenoids using the same C dialdehyde compound which can be efficiently utilized in the synthesis of carotenoid compounds based on the sulfone 8,536,361 8,389,790 Myongji University Industry and Academia Cooperation (Gyeonggi-do, KR) Myongji University Industry and Academia Cooperation October 23, 2012 October 16, 2012 chemistry 8,158,838 Dialdehyde compound, preparation method thereof, and synthetic method of carotenoids using the same C dialdehyde compound which can be efficiently utilized in the synthesis of carotenoid compounds based on the sulfone chemistry 7,928,266 Dialdehyde compound, preparation method thereof, and synthetic method of carotenoids using the same C dialdehyde compound which can be efficiently utilized in the synthesis of carotenoid compounds based on the sulfone chemistry 7,378,558 Method for producing carotenoids Process for preparing carotenoids chemically 7,126,036 Thermal isomerization of lycopene Process for the thermal isomerization of a mixture of all-E-lycopene and its Z isomer 6,747,166 Process for preparing carotenoid polyene chain compounds and intermediates for preparing the same Process for preparing carotenoids chemically 6,617,305 Stable aqueous dispersion of nutrients Stable aqueous dispersion of lycopene, isoflavones, lutein and coenzyme Q 6,455,072 Stable aqueous dispersion of nutrients Stable aqueous dispersion of lycopene, isoflavones, lutein and coenzyme Q 6,331,652 Process for producing lycopene and intermediate thereof Process for preparing lycopene chemically 6,204,414 6,040,475 Intermediate compound (5[2-hydroxy-5-(1-hydroxy-1methylethyl)-2-methylcyclopentyl]-3-methyl-p enta-2,4-dienyl) triphenylphos-phosphonium salt, for making metabolites of lycopene Intermediate compounds for making metabolites of lycopene (Gyeonggi-do, KR) Myongji University Industry and Academia Cooperation (Gyeonggi-do, KR) Myongji University Industry and Academia Cooperation (Gyeonggi-do, KR) BASF Aktiengesellschaft (Ludwigshafen, DE) BASF Aktiengesellschaft (Ludwigshafen, DE) Koo; Sangho (Seoul, KR) SK Corporation (Seoul, KR) Ingredient Innovations International (Wooster, OH) Ingredient Innovations International (Wooster, OH) Sumitomo Chemical Company, Limited (Osaka, JP) April 17, 2012 April 19, 2011 May 27, 2008 October 24, 2006 June 8, 2004 September 9, 2003 September 24, 2002 December 18, 2001 Intermediate compound for use in a multi-stage process for making an oxidative metabolite of the carotenoid, lycopene 2,6cyclolycopene-1,5-diol Roche Vitamins Inc. (Parsippany, NJ) March 20, 2001 Useful intermediates for the synthesis of lycopene metabolites Roche Vitamins Inc. (Nutley, NJ) March 21, 2000 6,008,417 Process for making metabolites of lycopene Process for making metabolites of lycopene Roche Vitamins Inc. (Parsippany, NJ) December 28, 1999 5,973,179 C-15 phosphonate reagent compositions for the manufacture of compounds such as lycopene and C-15 phosphonate reagent compositions for the manufacture of lycopene Loyola University of Chicago (Chicago, IL) October 26, 1999 5,208,381 5,166,445 methods of synthesizing the same Method for the manufacture of carotenoids and novel intermediates Method for the manufacture of carotenoids and novel intermediates Process for preparing lycopene chemically Process for preparing lycopene chemically Hoffmann-La Roche Inc. (Nutley, NJ) Hoffmann-La Roche Inc. (Nutley, NJ) May 4, 1993 November 24, 1992 Patented enzymes, DNA sequences or promoters to produce lycopene by organism transformation 7,960,612 Plant quality with various promoters Transcription factor polypeptides to produce transgenic plants having advantageous properties, including increased lycopene Transcription factor polypeptides to produce transgenic plants having advantageous properties, including increased lycopene Mutation in a carotenoidproducing microorganism in which the base sequence of DNA corresponding to 16S ribosomal RNA is substantially homologous to the base sequence described 7,956,242 Plant quality traits 7,745,170 Process for producing carotenoid compound 7,585,659 Carotene synthase gene and uses therefor Gene involved in the carotenoid pathway 7,582,451 Carotene synthase gene and uses therefor Gene involved in the carotenoid pathway 7,288,387 Genes of strain DC413 encoding enzymes involved in biosynthesis of carotenoid compounds A carotenogenic biosynthetic gene cluster isolated from Panteoa stewartii strain DC413 7,205,123 Recombinant materials for carotenoid production Recombinant DNA to produce carotenoids 7,202,067 Carotene synthase gene and uses therefor Gene involved in the carotenoid pathway 7,070,952 Genes encoding carotenoid compounds Carotenogenic genes from Pectobacterium cypripedii 7,064,196 Genes encoding carotenoid compounds Carotenogenic genes from strain DC260 7,063,955 Method for production of Carotenogenic genes Mendel Biotechnology, Inc. (Hayward, CA) Monsanto Technology LLC (St. Louis, MO) June 14, 2011 Mendel Biotechnology, Inc. (Hayward, CA) June 7, 2011 Nippon Oil Corporation (Tokyo, JP) June 29, 2010 Martek Biosciences Corporation (Columbia, MD) Martek Biosciences Corporation (Columbia, MD) E. I. du Pont de Nemours and Company (Wilmington, DE) DSM IP Assets B.V. (Te Heerlen, NL) Martek Biosciences Corporation (Columbia, MD) E. I. du Pont Nemours and Company (Wilmington, DE) E. I. du Pont Nemours and Company (Wilmington, DE) E. I. du Pont September 8, 2009 September 1, 2009 October 30, 2007 April 17, 2007 April 10, 2007 July 4, 2006 June 20, 2006 June 20, asymmetric carotenoids 6,929,928 Genes encoding carotenoid compounds 6,613,543 Fermentative carotenoid production 6,252,141 Tomato gene B polynucleotides coding for lycopene cyclase 6,207,409 Fermentative carotenoid production 6,124,113 Fermentative carotenoid production 6,087,152 Fermentative carotenoid production 5,570,865 Process for modifying the production of carotenoids in plants, and DNA, constructs and cells therefor 5,589,581 DNA sequences useful for the synthesis of carotenoids 5,530,189 Lycopene biosynthesis in genetically engineered hosts 5,304,478 Modification of carotenoid production in tomatoes using pTOM5 * Assignee is not available isolated from Rhodococcus and Deinococcus Carotenogenic biosynthetic gene cluster isolated from Panteoa agglomerans strain DC404 Proteins and DNA sequence of Flavobacterium sp R1534 to produce carotenoids An isolated complementary and genomic DNA segment encoding lycopene cyclase of the B locus of tomato Novel proteins of Flavobacterium sp R1534 to synthesize lycopene Novel proteins of Flavobacterium sp R1534 to synthesize lycopene Novel proteins of Flavobacterium sp R1534 to synthesize lycopene Gene construct pTOM5 involved in the carotenoid pathway DNA sequences which are useful for the synthesis of carotenoids such as lycopene DNA segments encoding the Erwinia enzymes for carotenogenic genes Gene construct pTOM5 involved in the carotenoid pathway Nemours and Company (Wilmington, DE) E. I. du Pont de Nemours and Company (Wilmington, DE) Roche Vitamins, Inc. (Parsippany, NJ) Yissum Research and Development Company of the Hebrew University of Jerusalem (Jerusalem, IL) Roche Vitamins Inc. (Parsippany, NJ) 2006 August 16, 2005 September 2, 2003 June 26, 2001 March 27, 2001 Roche Vitamins Inc. (Nutley, NJ) September 26, 2000 Roche Vitamins Inc. (Parsippany, NJ) July 11, 2000 Zeneca Limited (London, GB2) May 12, 1998 Kirin Beer Kabushiki Kaisha (Tokyo-To, JP) December 31, 1996 Amoco Corporation (Chicago, IL) Imperial Chemical Industries PLC (London, GB2) June 25, 1996 April 19, 1994 Supplementary table 4: Patent number Title Assignee Date of issue Formulation containing lutein to increase carotenoids in eggs Kemin Industries, Inc. (Des Moines, IA) July 20, 2010 Use of lutein as feed additive The Iams Company (Dayton, OH) October 30, 2001 Brief description Applications of lutein in feed 7,758,884 6,310,090 Formulation for increasing the deposition of dietary carotenoids in eggs Process and product for enhancing immune response in companion animals using a combination of antioxidants Applications of lutein for humans (cosmetics, dietary supplements ...) 8,389,504 Prenatal dietary supplement 8,263,667 Nutritional supplement for use under physiologically stressful conditions 8,263,147 Infant formulas containing docosahexaenoic acid and lutein 8,212,063 8,202,546 8,197,854 8,158,164 7,939,115 Xanthophyll composition containing trans, mesozeaxanthin, trans, R, Rzeaxanthin and trans, R, R-lutein useful for nutrition and health care and a process for its preparation Nutritional supplement for use under physiologically stressful conditions Nutritional supplement for use under physiologically stressful conditions Edible composition for treating cutaneous signs of ageing Dietary supplement and related method Prenatal dietary supplement containing lutein Nutritional supplement May include one or more listed vitamins, minerals and lutein Method of reducing the risk or severity of retinopathy of prematurity in preterm infants by administration of a formulation containing lutein Formulation containing lutein for nutrition and health care Nutritional supplement May include one or more listed vitamins, minerals and lutein Nutritional supplement May include one or more listed vitamins, minerals and lutein Formulation containing lutein to treat cutaneous signs of aging Nutritional supplement to improve plasma concentrations of antioxidant nutrients Mead Johnson Nutrition Company (Glenview, IL) March 5, 2013 Vertical Pharmaceuticals, Inc. (Sayreville, NJ) September 11, 2012 Abbott Laboratories (Abbott Park, IL) September 11, 2012 OmniActive Health Technologies Limited (Thane, IN) July 3, 2012 Vertical Pharmaceuticals, Inc. (Sayreville, NJ) June 19, 2012 Vertical Pharmaceuticals, Inc. (Sayreville, NJ) June 12, 2012 Conopco, Inc. (Englewood Cliffs, NJ) April 17, 2012 Access Business Group International LLC (Ada, MI) May 10, 2011 7,901,710 7,887,847 7,842,722 Nutritional supplement for use under physiologically stressful conditions Nutritional supplement for treatment of ocular diseases Composition and methods for inhibiting the progression macular degeneration and promoting healthy vision Nutritional supplement May include one or more listed vitamins, minerals and lutein Composition containing lutein to treat ocular diseases Formulation containing lutein for inhibiting the progression of macular degeneration and promoting health vision Method of reducing the risk or severity of retinopathy of prematurity in preterm infants by administration of a formulation containing lutein 7,829,126 Infant formulas containing docosahexaenoic acid and lutein 7,438,936 Dietary supplement and related method Nutritional supplement containing lutein 7,416,749 Dietary supplement and related method Nutritional supplement containing lutein 7,351,424 7,267,830 7,186,685 7,090,879 7,056,525 Enhanced purity translutein-ester compositions and methods of making same Composition and methods for inhibiting the progression macular degeneration and promoting healthy vision Compositions comprising gelatin-glycine and carotenoids Nutritional formula containing select carotenoid combinations Carotenoid formulations, comprising a mixture of .beta.-carotene, lycopene and lutein 7,045,643 Method for obtaining novel lutein-based formulations 6,989,161 Phytonutrient nutritional supplement 6,946,151 Therapeutic compositions Formulation containing lutein to be used in food supplementation Formulation for inhibiting the progression macular degeneration and promoting health vision Composition containing lutein to be used in cosmetics Nutritional formula including lutein Carotenoid formulation to be used in human and animal foods, cosmetics and pharmaceuticals Formulation containing lutein to be applied as colorant in the pharmaceutical, food and cosmetic industry A composition containing lycopene for correcting a dietary phytonutrient deficiency Formulation containing lycopene to ameliorate cholesterolemia, obesity, chronic complications of Vertical Pharmaceuticals, Inc. (Edison, NJ) March 8, 2011 * February 15, 2011 Alcon, Inc. (Hunenberg, CH) November 30, 2010 Abbott Laboratories (Abbott Park, IL) November 9, 2010 Access Business Group International LLC (Ada, MI) Access Business Group International LLC (Ada, MI) October 21, 2008 August 26, 2008 Bio Lut S.A. de C.V. (San Antonio, TX) April 1, 2008 Alcon, Inc. (Hunenberg, CH) Setembre 11, 2007 Mavi Sud S.R.L. (Aprilia Lt, IT) March 6, 2007 Abbott Laboratories (Abbott Park, IL) August 15, 2006 BASF Aktiengesellschaft (Ludwigshafen, DE) June 6, 2006 Vitatene, S.A. (Leon, ES) May 16, 2006 Access Business Group International LLC (Ada, MI) January 24, 2006 Ayurvedic-Life International, LLC (Neenah, WI) September 20, 2005 diabetes 6,866,877 6,863,914 6,863,904 6,743,953 6,737,535 6,660,293 6,572,897 Carbonated fortified milk-based beverage and method for suppressing bacterial growth in the beverage Stable, aqueous dispersions and stable, water-dispersible dry powders of xanthophylls, and production and use of the same Compositions and methods for prophylactic and therapeutic supplementation of nutrition in subjects Process for the preparation of xanthophyll crystals Trans-lutein enriched xanthophyll ester concentrate and a process for its preparation Compositions and methods for prophylactic and therapeutic supplementation of nutrition in subjects Insulin sensitivity maintenance and blood sugar level maintenance formulation for the prevention and treatment of diabetes 6,511,675 Composition and method for correcting a dietary phytochemical deficiency 6,509,029 Carotenoid formulations, comprising a mixture of .beta.-carotene, lycopene and lutein 6,313,169 Lutein esters having high bioavailability 6,261,598 Carotenoid formulations, comprising a mixture of β-carotens, lycopene and lutein 6,218,436 Pharmaceutically active carotenoids 6,110,478 Composition having tanning and photoprotective activity, and its cosmetic Formulation containing lutein to supply essential nutrients MAC Farms, Inc. (Burlington, MA) March 15, 2005 Formulation containing lutein to be used in the pharmaceutical, food and cosmetic industry BASF Aktiengesellschaft (Ludwigshafen, DE) March 8, 2005 Composition containing lutein for food supplementation Everett Laboratories, Inc. (West Orange, NJ) March 8, 2005 Process for the preparation of xanthophylls crystals to be used in food supplements Kancor Flavours & Extracts Ltd. (Kerala, IN) June 1, 2004 Lutein concentrate to be used for human consumption Kancor Flavours & Extracts Ltd. (Kerala, IN) May 18, 2004 Compositions containing lutein to be used as food supplements Everett Laboratories, Inc. (West Orange, NJ) December 9, 2003 Composition containing lutein to be used in food supplements Vitacost.com, Inc. (Boynton Beach, FL) June 3, 2003 Access Business Group International, LLC (Ada, MI) January 28, 2003 BASF Aktiengesellschaft (Ludwigshafen, DE) January 21, 2003 Composition containing lutein to correct a dietary phytochemical deficiency Carotenoid formulation to be used in human and animal foods, cosmetics and pharmaceuticals Lutein esters to provide protection from harmful effects of free radicals Formulation containing lutein to be used in human and animal foods, cosmetics and pharmaceuticals Pharmaceutical use of lutein to treat advanced macular degeneration Oral or topical composition containing lycopene having tanning and sun- * November 6, 2001 BASF Aktiengesellschaft (Ludwigshafen, DE) July 17, 2001 The Howard Foundation (Cambridge, GB) April 17, 2001 Laboratoire Oenobiol (Paris, FR) August 29, 2000 applications 6,075,058 screening activity, and the cosmetic uses thereof Compositions for increased bioavailability of carotenoids Composition containing lutein for human use Tufts University (Boston, MA) June 13, 2000 Lutein produced by algae 8,357,510 Process for obtaining lutein from algae Process of obtaining lutein in a high yield from green algae 8,067,225 Microalga species and its application for animal, human consumption and in obtaining carotenoids Novel strain of Scenedesmus producing lutein Cognis IP Management GmbH (Duesseldorf, DE) Universidad de Almeria (Almeria, ES) Caja Rural Intermediterranea (Almeria, ES) January 22, 2013 November 29, 2011 Lutein produced by fungi 6,783,951 Process for production of carotenoids, xanthophylls and apo-carotenoids utilizing eukaryotic microorganisms Method for producing an effective amount of lutein in Thraustochytrium * August 31, 2004 Katra Phytochem (India) Private Limited (Bangalore, IN) July 9, 2013 Katra Phytochem India Private Limited (Bangalore District, IN) April 23, 2013 Method of isolation of lutein Unibar Corporation (Houston, TX) August 30, 2011 Use of ozonation to increase lutein extraction from plants Board of Supervisors of Louisiana State University and Agricultural and Mechanical College (Baton Rouge, LA) May 17, 2011 Method of isolation of lutein Allied Biotech Corporation (TW) January 25, 2011 Process of saponifying Marigold flower and obtention of lutein OMNICA GmbH (Hamburg, DE) October 12, 2010 Method for extracting Board of Supervisors March 2, Methods of extraction of lutein 8,481,769 Isolation and purification of cartenoids from marigold flowers 8,425,948 Process for isolation of lutein and zeaxanthin crystals from plant sources 8,088,532 Processes and methods for extraction and purification of lutein from marigold esters 7,943,804 7,875,751 7,812,198 7,671,242 Lutein extraction from ozone-treated plant sources Method for the purification of carotenoids from plant extracts and the products so obtained Process for the manufacture of a composition containing at least one xanthophyll Isolation of aflatoxin-free Process for isolation of carotenoids crystals comprising drying a plant part to obtain a meal and extracting the meal with alcohol Process for isolation of carotenoids crystals comprising drying a plant part to obtain a meal and extracting the meal with alcohol lutein from aflatoxincontaminated plants and plant products 7,622,599 Isolation and purification of carotenoids from marigold 7,297,803 Process for the preparation of lutein ester concentrate 7,253,294 Isolation of lutein from alfalfa 7,214,379 7,179,930 7,150,890 Method for the purification of marigold oleoresin Process for isolating, purifying and formulating a stable, commercial grade Lutein paste from oleoresin Process for the purification of marigold xanthophylls 7,109,361 Isolation of lutein from alfalfa 6,909,021 Method of extracting lutein from green plant materials 6,737,552 Method for extracting lutein from green plant materials 6,689,400 6,380,442 6,329,557 6,262,284 Process of obtaining compositions of stable lutein and lutein derivatives Process for the isolation of mixed carotenoids from plants Purification of xanthophylls from marigold extracts that contain high levels of chlorophylls Process for extraction and purification of lutein, zeaxanthin and rare carotenoids from lutein from aflatoxincontaminated plants Process for isolating and purifying carotenoids from marigold Method for concentrating translutein esters from marigold oleoresin Process for an industrial scale extraction and purification of xanthophylls from plant material of Louisiana State University and Agricultural and Mechanical College (Baton Rouge, LA) 2010 Katra Phytochem Private Limited (Bangalore, IN) November 24, 2009 BioActives, LLC (Belmont, MA) November 20, 2007 Nu-Tein Co., Inc. (St. Paul, MN) August 7, 2007 Method of extraction lutein Riken Vitamin Co., Ltd. (Tokyo, JP) May 8, 2007 Process for obtaining stabilized lutein Indus Biotech Private Limited (Pune, IN) February 20, 2007 * December 19, 2006 AMEC E & C Services Inc (Decatur, GA) September 19, 2006 Alfalfa America, Inc. (Minneapolis, MN) June 21, 2005 * May 18, 2004 Method of extraction of lutein and obtain stable compositions Sabinsa Corporation (Piscataway, NJ) February 10, 2004 Method of extraction of lutein BioActives, LLC (Belmont, MA) April 30, 2002 Industrial scale process for obtaining lutein Prodemex, S.A. de C.V. (Sinaloa, MX) December 11, 2001 Process for extracting saponifying and isolating lutein from plants University of Maryland (College Park, MD) July 17, 2001 Process to extract, saponify and purify lutein from marigold Process for an industrial scale extraction and purification of xanthophylls from plant material Method for extracting lutein from green plant materials using supercritical fluid extraction Method for extracting lutein from green plant materials using supercritical fluid extraction 6,191,293 5,959,138 5,648,564 5,382,714 4,048,203 marigold flowers and plants Trans-xanthophyll ester concentrates of enhanced purity and methods of making same Short chain diesters and process for making the same Process for the formation, isolation and purification of comestible xanthophyll crystals from plants Process for isolation, purification, and recrystallization of lutein from saponified marigold oleoresin and uses thereof Purification of luteinfatty acid esters from plant materials Lutein extracts Inexa, Industria Extractora C.A. (Quito, EC) February 20, 2001 Process to obtain a product with high lutein content Industrial Organica S.A. DE C.V. (Topo Chico, Monterrey, MX) September 28, 1999 Process for forming, isolating and purifying xanthophyll crystals from marigold Kemin Industries, Inc. (Des Moines, IA) July 17, 1997 Process for isolation, purification and recrystallization of lutein from saponified marigold oleoresin The Catholic University of America (Washington, DC) January 17, 1995 Process for the purification of luteinfatty acid esters from marigold flower petals * September 13, 1977 Lutein produced by chemical synthesis 7,858,828 7,220,874 7,112,689 Process for synthesis of (3R,3'R,6'R)-lutein and its stereoisomers Esterification of xanthophylls Method for the production of a luteinfatty acid ester concentrate 6,617,305 Stable aqueous dispersion of nutrients 6,540,654 Carotenoid esters 6,455,072 Stable aqueous dispersion of nutrients 6,420,614 Process for obtaining 3'epilutein Chemical synthesis of lutein University of Maryland, College Park (College Park, MD) DSM IP Assets B.V. (Geleen, NL) December 28, 2010 Esterification of lutein with C-18 fatty acids Method to produce lutein-fatty acid ester concentration from marigold oleoresin Stable aqueous dispersion of lycopene, isoflavones, lutein and coenzyme Q Production of lutein ester Stable aqueous dispersion of lycopene, isoflavones, lutein and coenzyme Q May 22, 2007 Riken Vitamin Co., Ltd. (Tokyo, JP) September 26, 2006 Ingredient Innovations Internaitonal (Wooster, OH) September 9, 2003 * April 1, 2003 Ingredient Innovations International (Wooster, OH) September 24, 2002 Process for obtaining 3'epilutein Industrial Organica, S.A. DE C.V. (Monterrey, MX) July 16, 2002 Patented enzymes, DNA sequences or promoters to produce lutein by organism transformation 5,570,865 5,304,478 Process for modifying the production of carotenoids in plants, and DNA, constructs and cells therefor Modification of Gene construct pTOM5 involved in the carotenoid pathway Zeneca Limited (London, GB2) May 12, 1998 Gene construct pTOM5 Imperial Chemical April 19, carotenoid production in tomatoes using pTOM5 * Assignee is not available involved in the carotenoid pathway Industries PLC (London, GB2) 1994 Supplementary table 5: Patent number Title Assignee Date of issue Esterified zeaxanthin for poultry or aquaculture DSM IP Assets B.V. (Geleen, NL) May 22, 2007 Saponified marigold extract containing zeaxanthin for broiler pigmentation Industrial Organica, S.A. DE C.V. (Monterrey, MX) December 7, 1999 Zeaxanthin esters for broiler pigmentation Industrial Organica, S.A. DE C.V. (Monterrey, MX) September 28, 1999 Brief description Applications of zeaxanthin in feed 7,220,874 5,997,922 5,959,138 Esterification of xanthophylls Broiler skin and egg yolk pigmentation by using saponified marigold extracts with a high content of zeaxanthin Short chain diesters and process for making the same Applications of zeaxanthin for humans (cosmetics, dietary supplements ...) 8,501,163 Protection against sunburn and skin problems with topical and orally-ingested dosages of zeaxanthin 8,481,009 Protection against sunburn and skin problems with orally-ingested highdosage zeaxanthin 8,263,147 Infant formulas containing docosahexaenoic acid and lutein 8,212,063 8,088,363 Xanthophyll composition containing trans, mesozeaxanthin, trans, R, Rzeaxanthin and trans, R, Rlutein useful for nutrition and health care and a process for its preparation Protection against sunburn and skin problems with orally-ingested highdosage zeaxanthin 7,941,211 Preloading with macular pigment to improve photodynamic treatment of retinal vascular disorders 7,887,847 Nutritional supplement for treatment of ocular diseases 7,691,406 Zeaxanthin formulations for human ingestion Formulation containing astaxanthin to protect against sunburns, and can give skin a darker tint that emulates a healthy suntan Formulation containing astaxanthin to protect against sunburns, and can give skin a darker tint that emulates a healthy suntan Method of reduce risk of retinopathy of premature infants containing zeaxanthin Composition containing zeaxanthin to nutrition and healthcare Formulation containing zeaxanthin to protect against sunburn and skin problems Formulation containing zeaxanthin to improve photodynamic treatment of retinal vascular disorders Nutritional supplement containing zeaxanthin to promote visual Health Formulation containing zeaxanthin to treat and ZeaVision LLC (Chesterfield, MO) August 6, 2013 ZeaVision LLC (Chesterfield, MO) July 9, 2013 Abbott Laboratories (Abbott Park, IL) September 11, 2012 OmniActive Health Technologies Limited (Thane, IN) July 3, 2012 ZeaVision LLC (Chesterfield, MO) January 3, 2012 ZeaVision LLC (Chesterfield, MO) May 10, 2011 * February 15, 2011 ZeaVision LLC (Chesterfield, MO) April 6, 2010 7,071,478 6,936,279 6,866,877 6,743,953 6,737,535 6,329,432 Mixed zeaxanthin ester concentrate and uses thereof Microcrystalline zeaxanthin with high bioavailability in oily carrier formulations Carbonated fortified milkbased beverage and method for suppressing bacterial growth in the beverage Process for the preparation of xanthophyll crystals Trans-lutein enriched xanthophyll ester concentrate and a process for its preparation Mesozeaxanthin formulations for treatment of retinal disorders 6,254,898 Nutraceutical composition for protection against solar radiation 6,218,436 Pharmaceutically active carotenoids 6,075,058 Compositions for increased bioavailability of carotenoids 5,827,652 Zeaxanthin formulations for human ingestion prevent eye diseases Formulation containing zeaxanthin for human use Microcrystalline zeaxanthin with higher bioavailability to human use Chrysantis, Inc. (West Chicago, IL) July 25, 2006 ZeaVision LLC (Chesterfield, MO) August 30, 2005 Formulation containing zeaxanthin to provide dietary supplementation MAC Farms, Inc. (Burlington, MA) March 15, 2005 Preparation of xanthophyll crystals to human use Kancor Flavours & Extracts Ltd. (Kerala, IN) June 1, 2004 Preparation of xanthophyll crystals to human use Kancor Flavours and Extracts Limited (Kerala, IN) May 18, 2004 Formulation containing mesozeaxanthin for human use Nutraceutical composition for protection against solar damage Pharmaceutical composition containing zeaxanthin Composition containing zeaxanthin for human use Preparation containing zeaxanthin to treat and prevent macular degeneration The Howard Foundation (Cambridge, GB) December 11, 2001 Protective Factors, Inc. (Boston, MA) July 3, 2001 The Howard Foundation (Cambridge, GB) April 17, 2001 Tufts University (Boston, MA) June 13, 2000 Applied Food Biotechnology, Inc. (O'Fallon, MO) October 27, 1998 Aquapharm BioDiscovery Ltd. (Oban, GB) January 29, 2013 Zeaxanthin produced by bacteria 8,361,743 Biological production of zeaxanthin and carotenoid biosynthesis control Strain of Algibacter which is capable of producing significant levels of carotenoids, especially zeaxanthin at high purity 8,030,022 Microorganism and method for producing carotenoid using it Paracoccuss producing zeaxanthin Tosoh Corporation (Shunan-shi, JP) October 4, 2012 6,825,002 Process for producing carotenoid pigments Method to produce higher levels of zeaxanthin in E-396 strain Nippon Mitsubishi Oil Corporation (Tokyo, JP) November 30, 2004 5,935,808 Carotenoid-producing bacterial species and process for production of carotenoids using same Paracoccus strain DSM 11574 which produces zeaxanthin 5,858,761 Bacteria for production of carotenoids Bacteria producing zeaxanthin Yissum Research and Development Company of the Hebrew University of (Jerusalem, IL) Nippon Oil Company, Ltd. (Tokyo, JP) August 10, 1999 January 12, 1999 5,854,015 5,747,544 5,607,839 5,427,783 5,360,730 5,308,759 Method of making pure 3R-3'R stereoisomer of zeaxanthin for human ingestion Method of using pure 3R3'R stereoisomer of zeaxanthin to treat or prevent retinal degeneration in humans Bacteria belonging to new genus process for production of carotenoids using same Zeaxanthin-containing compositions produced by Flavobacterium multivorum Zeaxanthin producing strains of Neospongiococcum Excentricum Production of zeaxanthin and zeaxanthin-containing compositions Method to produce zeaxanthin in Flavobacterium multivorum Applied Food Biotechnology, Inc. (O'Fallon, MO) December 29, 1998 Method to produce zeaxanthin in Flavobacterium multivorum Applied Food Biotechnology, Inc. (O'Fallon, MO) May 5, 1998 Bacterium from a new genus producing zeaxanthin Nippon Oil Company, Ltd. (Tokyo, JP) March 4, 1997 Flavobacterium multivorum producing zeaxanthin Applied Food Biotechnology, Inc. (O'Fallon, MO) June 27, 1995 Universal Foods Corporation (Milwaukee, WI) November 1, 1994 Method to produce zeaxanthin from Neospongiococcum excentricum Flavobacterium multivorum producing zeaxanthin 3,951,743 Production of zeaxanthin Production of zeaxanthin from Flavobacterium 3,951,742 Production of zeaxanthin Production of zeaxanthin from Flavobacterium Applied Food Biotechnology, Inc. (O'Fallon, MO) Societe d'Assistance Technique pour Produits Nestle S.A. (Lausanne, CH) Societe d'Assistance Technique pour Produits Nestle S.A. (Lausanne, CH) May 3, 1994 April 20, 1976 April 20, 1976 Zeaxanthin produced by plants 7,575,766 6,784,351 Tagetes erecta with altered carotenoid compositions and ratios Targetes erecta marigolds with altered carotenoid compositions and ratios Tagetes erecta with enhanced zeaxanthin content Tagetes erecta with enhanced zeaxanthin content Ball Horticultural Company (West Chicago, unknown) Ball Horticultural Company (West Chicago, unknown) August 18, 2009 August 31, 2004 Method of extraction of zeaxanthin 8,481,769 Isolation and purification of cartenoids from marigold flowers 8,425,948 Process for isolation of lutein and zeaxanthin crystals from plant sources 7,875,751 Method for the purification of carotenoids from plant extracts and the products so obtained Process for isolation of carotenoids crystals comprising drying a plant part to obtain a meal and extracting the meal with alcohol Process for isolation of carotenoids crystals comprising drying a plant part to obtain a meal and extracting the meal with alcohol Method of purification of zeaxanthin Katra Phytochem (India) Private Limited (Bangalore, IN) July 9, 2013 Katra Phytochem India Private Limited (Bangalore District, IN) April 23, 2013 Allied Biotech Corporation (TW) January 25, 2011 7,812,198 Process for the manufacture of a composition containing at least one xanthophyll 7,662,599 Isolation and purification of carotenoids from marigold flowers 7,253,294 Isolation of lutein from alfalfa 7,173,145 Process for extraction and purification of lutein, zeaxanthin and rare carotenoids from marigold flowers and plants 7,109,361 Isolation of lutein from alfalfa 6,863,914 6,329,557 6,262,284 5,648,564 Stable, aqueous dispersions and stable, waterdispersible dry powders of xanthophylls, and production and use of the same Purification of xanthophylls from marigold extracts that contain high levels of chlorophylls Process for extraction and purification of lutein, zeaxanthin and rare carotenoids from marigold flowers and plants Process for the formation, isolation and purification of comestible xanthophyll crystals from plants Extraction method of zeaxanthin from marigold OMNICA GmbH (Hamburg, DE) October 12, 2010 Katra Phytochem Private Limited (Bangalore, IN) November 24, 2009 Nu-Tein Co., Inc. (St. Paul, MN) August 7, 2007 Process for extracting and isolating carotenoid esters from marigold University of Maryland, College Park (College Park, MD) February 6, 2007 Isolation of lutein and zeaxanthin from plant material Nu-Tein Co., Inc. (St. Paul, MN) Process for preparing a table, aqueous dispersion of zeaxanthin BASF Aktiengesellschaft (Ludwigshafen, DE) March 8, 2005 Method for industrially production of zeaxanthin Prodemex, S.A. de C.V. (Sinaloa, MX) December 11, 2001 Process for extracting and isolating carotenoid esters from marigold University of Maryland, College Park (College Park, MD) July 17, 2001 Process for forming, isolating and purifying xanthophyll crystals from marigold Kemin Industries, Inc. (Des Moines, IA) July 15, 1997 Isolation and purification of zeaxanthin from marigold Isolation of lutein and zeaxanthin from plant material September 19, 2006 Zeaxanthin produced by chemical synthesis 8,222,458 8,093,436 7,485,738 Process or synthesis of (3S)- and (3R)-3-hydroxybeta-ionone, and their transformation to zeaxanthin and betacryptoxanthin Process for synthesis of (3R,3'R)-zeaxanthin and (3R,3'S;meso)-zeaxanthin from (3R,3'R,6'R)-lutein via (3R)-3',4'anhydrolutein Method for preparing highcontent food-grade zeaxanthin Chemical synthesis of zeaxanthin University of Maryland, College Park (College Park, MD) July 17, 2012 Method to obtain zeaxanthin University of Maryland, College Park (College Park, MD) January 10, 2012 Preparation of zeaxanthin from chemical isomeration of lutein Zhejiang Medicine Co., Ltd., XinChang Pharmaceutical Factory (XinChang County, Shaoxing, Zhejiang, CN) February 3, 2009 BASF Aktiengesellschaft (Ludwigshafen, DE) BASF Aktiengesellschaft (Ludwigshafen, DE) BASF Aktiengesellschaft (Ludwigshafen, DE) 7,378,558 Method for producing carotenoids Method to produce zeaxanthin chemically 6,747,177 Process for the preparation of meso-zeaxanthin Method to produce meso-zeaxanthin 6,743,954 Process for the preparation of meso-zeaxanthin Method to produce meso-zeaxanthin Lutein to zeaxanthin isomerization process and product Preparation of zeaxanthin, intermediates for this preparation, and the preparation thereof Isomeration process to obtain zeaxanthin from lutein * April 23, 2002 Preparation of zeaxanthin BASF Aktiengesellschaft (Ludwigshafen, DE) August 15, 2000 Process for the preparation of zeaxanthin Investigaciones Quimicas y Farmaceutics, S.A. (Tarragona, ES) December 7, 1999 Prodemex, S.A. DE C.V. (MX) October 26, 1999 Roche Vitamins Inc. (Parsippany, NJ) July 14, 1998 Production of an intermediate to produce zeaxanthin BASF Aktiengesellschaft (Ludwigshafen, DE) July 7, 1998 Process to obtain a product with a high zeaxanthin content Industrial Organica, S.A. de C.V. (Monterrey, MX) June 4, 1996 Method to produce zeaxanthin Hoffmann-La Roche Inc. (Nutley, NJ) July 13, 1993 Method to produce zeaxanthin Hoffmann-La Roche Inc. (Nutley, NJ) August 28, 1990 Method to produce zeaxanthin Hoffmann-La Roche Inc. (Nutley, NJ) April 1, 1986 Method to produce zeaxanthin Hoffmann-La Roche Inc. (Nutley, NJ) September 20, 1983 Method to produce zeaxanthin Hoffmann-La Roche Inc. (Nutley, NJ) BASF Aktiengesellschaft (Ludwigshafen, DE) May 8, 1979 6,376,722 6,103,940 5,998,678 5,973,211 5,780,693 5,777,173 5,523,494 5,227,507 4,952,716 4,579,973 4,405,417 4,153,615 3,954,804 Process for preparing carotenoid pigments Pigmenting efficiency of a natural xanthophyll by isomerization Process for the manufacturing of zeaxanthin from lutein Preparation of pure transand cis-4-Hydroxy-2,2,6trimethylcyclohexan-1-one from isomeric mixtures Process for the isomerization of lutein Ethynylcyclohexene compounds and processes for manufacture thereof Ethynylcyclohexene compounds Process for the manufacture of cyclohexene derivatives Process for the manufacture of cyclohexene derivatives Method of producing coloring agents Production of high molecular weight unsaturated ketones Method of isomerizing lutein to yield zeaxanthin Process for the conversion of lutein into zeaxanthin Method to produce zeaxanthin May 27, 2008 June 8, 2004 June 1, 2004 May 4, 1976 Patented enzymes or DNA sequences to produce zeaxanthin by organism transformation 7,745,170 7,288,387 7,232,679 Process for producing carotenoid compound Genes of strain DC413 encoding enzymes involved in biosynthesis of carotenoid compounds Isoprenoid production Process for producing zeaxanthin Gene cluster from Panteoa stewartii to produce carotenoids Isolated Nippon Oil Corporation (Tokyo, JP) E. I. du Pont de Nemours and Company (Wilmington, DE) DSM IP Assets B.V. June 29, 2010 October 30, 2007 June 19, 7,070,952 Genes encoding carotenoid compounds 7,064,196 Genes encoding carotenoid compounds 7,063,956 Fermentative carotenoid production 7,041,471 Carotene hydroxylase and method for producing xanthophyll derivatives 6,989,257 Isoprenoid production 6,677,134 Fermentative carotenoid production 6,613,543 Fermentative carotenoid production 6,465,228 Levodione reductase 6,291,204 Fermentative carotenoid production 6,207,409 Fermentative carotenoid production 6,124,113 Fermentative carotenoid production 6,087,152 Fermentative carotenoid production 5,684,238 5,589,581 5,429,939 Biosynthesis of zeaxanthin and glycosylated zeaxanthin in genetically engineered hosts DNA sequences useful for the synthesis of carotenoids DNA sequences useful for the synthesis of carotenoids * Assignee is not available polynucleotides to produce zeaxanthin Carotenogenic genes isolated from Pectobacterium crypripedii encoding Carotenogenic genes isolated from strain DC260, a member of the Enterobacteriaceae family Novel proteins from microorganism E-396 to higher zeaxanthin production Enzymes to synthetize zeaxanthin Isolated polynucleotides to produce zeaxanthin Novel proteins of microorganism E-396 to produce zeaxanthin Novel proteins of Flavobacterium sp. R1534 to produce zeaxanthin Enzyme that produce an intermediate for zeaxanthin synthesis Novel proteins of microorganism E-396 to produce zeaxanthin Novel proteins of Flavobacterium sp. R1534 to produce zeaxanthin Novel proteins of Flavobacterium sp. R1534 to produce zeaxanthin Novel proteins of Flavobacterium sp. R1534 to produce zeaxanthin DNA segments from Erwinia herbicola to produce zeaxanthin DNA sequences for zeaxanthin production DNA sequences for zeaxanthin production (Heerlen, NL) 2007 E. I. du Pont Nemours and Company (Wilmington, DE) July 4, 2006 E. I. du Pont Nemours and Company (Wilmington, DE) June 20, 2006 DSM IP Assets B.V. (Heerlen, NL) June 20, 2006 BASF Aktiengesellschaft (Ludwigshafen, DE) May 9, 2006 DSM IP Assets B.V. (Heerlen, NL) January 24, 2006 Roche Vitamins, Inc. (Parsippany, NJ) January 13, 2004 Roche Vitamins, Inc. (Parsippany, NJ) September 2, 2003 Roche Vitamins, Inc. (Parsippany, NJ) October 15, 2002 Roche Vitamins, Inc. (Parsippany, NJ) September 18, 2001 Roche Vitamins, Inc. (Parsippany, NJ) March 27, 2001 Roche Vitamins, Inc. (Parsippany, NJ) September 26, 2000 Roche Vitamins, Inc. (Parsippany, NJ) July 11, 2000 Amoco Corporation (Chicago, IL) November 4, 1997 Kirin Beer Kabushiki Kaisha (Tokyo-To, JP) Kirin Beer Kabushiki Kaisha (Tokyo-To, JP) December 31, 1996 July 4, 1995 Supplementary table 6: Patent number Title Brief description Assignee Date of issue Occurente AS (Auli, NO) September 4, 2012 Nestec S. A. (Vevey, CH) October 11, 2011 Phares Pharmaceutical Research N.V. et al. (Curacao, NL) July 21, 2009 DSM IP Assets B.V. (Te Heerlen, NL) June 10, 2008 SunGene GmbH & Co. KGaA (DE) BASF Aktiengesellschaft (DE) BASF Plant Science GmbH (DE) June 3, 2008 Nippon Mitsubishi Oil Corporation (Tokyo, JP) November 30, 2004 Norsk Hydro ASA (Oslo, NO) October 7, 2003 AstaCarotene AB (Gustavsberg, SE) November 5, 2002 Archer-DanielsMidland Company (Decatur, IL) July 2, 2002 Astacarotene AB (Gustavsberg, SE) June 25, 2002 Astacarotene AB (Gustavsberg, SE) April 25, 2000 Applications of astaxanthin in feed 8,257,763 8,034,373 Process for manufacture of feed for aquaculture species Methods and compositions for reducing oxidative stress in an animal 7,563,935 Crystal forms of astaxanthin 7,383,788 Enhanced feeding and growth rates of aquatic animals fed an astaxanthin product derived from marigold extract 7,381,541 Methods for producing animal feed preparations with astaxanthincontaining plants or parts of plants of the genus Tagetes 6,825,002 Process for producing carotenoid pigments 6,630,188 Stabilization of pigments and polyunsaturated oils 6,475,547 Immunoglobulin-rich milk, production and use thereof 6,413,736 Astaxanthin overproducing strains of Phaffia rhodozyma, methods for their cultivation, and their use in animal feed 6,410,602 Method of increasing the production and improving the quality of semen 6,054,491 Agent for increasing the production of/in breeding and production mammals Feed and a feed product from proteins containing astaxanthin as additive Compositions containing astaxanthin to reduce or prevent oxidative stress in animals Mixtures of specific crystal forms of astaxanthin useful for fish feed Astaxanthin pigment product obtained by semisynthesis from marigold extract to enhance the feeding and growth rates of commercially cultivated aquatic species Use of astaxanthincontaining plants, parts of plants or extracts from Marigold for oral administration to animals Method for changing production ratios of carotenoid compounds in microorganisms for application in animal feed a method for stabilizing vegetable and animal oils as well as pigment and optimize the effect of the pigment in feed for salmons Method of producing immunoglobulin-rich milk by administrating astaxanthin to cows Phaffia rhodozyma strains with high astaxanthin synthesis capacity to be incorporated into animal feeds A methods of increasing production and quality of semen by administrating a preparation containing astaxanthin A method of increasing the production of/in breeding and production 5,744,502 Method for increasing the production of/in breeding and production animals in the poultry industry 4,505,936 Process for the utilization of shellfish waste 5,959,138 Short chain diesters and process for making the same mammals by astaxanthin administration in feed Administration of astaxanthin in animal feed to increase the production in the poultry industry Process for extraction astaxanthin from the chitinous shells and proteinaceous tissues of shellfish to provide astaxanthin enriched dietary food ingredient Astaxanthin synthesis from marigold extracts to be used for the pigmentation of broilers and egg yolks Astacarotene AB (Gustavsberg, SE) April 28, 1998 Louisiana State University (Baton Rouge, LA) March 19, 1985 Industrial Organica S.A. DE C.V. (Topo Chico, Monterrey, MX) September 28, 1999 Applications of astaxanthin for humans (cosmetics, dietary supplements ...) 8,524,980 Composition and method to alleviate joint pain 8,507,757 Composition and method to alleviate joint pain 8,481,072 Composition and method to alleviate joint pain 8,372,812 Phospholipid and protein tablets 8,197,865 Methods and compositions for modulating hair growth or regrowth 8,029,830 Composition and method for promoting internal health and external appearance 7,838,050 Cytokine modulators and related method of use Krill oil and/or marine oil in combination with other active constituents, including astaxanthin in an oral dosage form to alliviate joint paint Krill oil and/or marine oil in combination with other active constituents, including astaxanthin in an oral dosage form to alliviate joint paint Krill oil and/or marine oil in combination with other active constituents, including astaxanthin in an oral dosage form to alliviate joint paint A new method for krill meal production has been developed using a two step cooking process. Compositions and methods for modulating hair growth or regrowth, containing astaxanthin Composition containing astaxanthin to promote DNA repair, reduce body fat levels and increase lean body mass and that decrease wrinkle appearance and/or improvement in skin surface Composition including astaxanthin to modulate cytokines to regulate an inflammatory or U.S. Nutraceuticals, LLC (Eustis, FL) September 3, 2013 U.S. Nutraceuticals, LLC (Eustis, FL) August 13, 2013 U.S. Nutraceuticals, LLC (Eustis, FL) July 9, 2013 Aker Biomarine ASA (Oslo, NO) February 12, 2013 Access Business Group International LLC (Ada, MI) June 12, 2012 Nuvocare Health Services Inc. (Toronto, Ontario, CA) October 4, 2011 Access Business Group International LLC (Ada, MI) November 23, 2010 7,758,903 Cytokine modulators and related methods of use 7,758,902 Cytokine modulators and related methods of use 7,731,992 Method of inhibiting aromatase with specific dietary supplements 7,241,463 Methods for processing crustacean material 7,078,040 Method of inhibiting the expression of inflammatory cytokines and chemokines 7,001,611 Compositions normalizing circadian rhythm 6,923,967 Treatment of dyspepsia 6,863,914 Stable, aqueous dispersions and stable, water-dispersible dry powders of xanthophylls, and production and use of the same 6,773,708 Use of xanthophylls, astaxanthin e.g., for immunomodulatory response Composition including astaxanthin to modulate cytokines to regulate an inflammatory or immunomodulatory response Composition including astaxanthin to modulate cytokines to regulate an inflammatory or immunomodulatory response A method of administering to a subject a dietary supplement composition consisting of astaxanthin, black cohosh, echinacea, and phytosterols. The enzyme aromatase plays a role in the synthesis of estrogen, which has a role in the development of cancers in women Enzymatic treatment of crustaceans with lipolytic enzymes promotes the extraction of astaxanthin and cosmetic and consumable products produced therefrom Medicament containing astaxanthin for the prophylactic and/or therapeutic inhibition of the express of inflammatory cytokines and chemokines for animal or man Composition containing astaxanthin and/or its ester as an active ingredient to normalize circadian rhythm Astaxanthin containing medicament for prophylactic and/or therapeutic treatment of dyspepsia A process for preparing a stable, aqueous dispersion or a stable waterdispersible dry powder of xanthophylls and human foods, pharmaceuticals and/or animal feed containing such dry powders Production of a medicament for Access Business Group International LLC (Ada, MI) July 20, 2010 Access Business Group International LLC (Ada, MI) July 20, 2010 Triarco Industries, Inc. (Wayne, NJ) June 8, 2010 Novozymes A/S (Bagsvaerd, DK) July 10, 2007 Fuji Chemical Industry Co., Ltd. (Toyama-Pref, JP) July 18, 2006 Suntory Limited (Osaka, JP) February 21, 2006 Astacarotene AB (Gustavsberg, SE) August 2, 2005 BASF Aktiengesellschaft (Ludwigshafen, DE) March 8, 2005 AstaReal AB (Gustavsberg, SE) August 10, 2004 treatment of autoimmune diseases, chronic viral and intracellular bacterial infections 6,433,025 Method for retarding and preventing sunburn by UV light 6,344,214 Method for retarding and ameliorating fever blisters and canker sores 6,335,015 Method of the prophylactic treatment of mastitis 6,277,417 Method of inhibiting 5.alpha.-reductase with astaxanthin 6,265,450 Anti-stress composition 6,262,316 Oral preparation for the prophylactic and therapeutic treatment of Helicobacter sp. infection 6,258,855 Method of retarding and ameliorating carpal tunnel syndrome 6,245,818 Medicament for improvement of duration of muscle function or treatment of muscle disorders or diseases 5,527,533 Method of retarding and ameliorating central nervous system and eye damage suppression of excessive Th1 cell mediated immune responses and stimulation of Th2 cell mediated immune responses Administration a source of astaxanthin in a therapeutically effective amount to prevent and retard sunburns Administration of astaxanthin orally or topically to retard and ameliorate fever blisters and canker sores Administration of a prophylactically effective dosage of a human or veterinary medicament containing astaxanthin to prevent mastitis Method to inhibit the activity of 5.alpha.reductase in humans by administration of a composition containing astaxanthin useful to prevent and treat benign prostate hyperplasia and prostate cancer in human males An anti-stress composition having for its active ingredient astaxanthin and/or its ester Oral preparation containing astaxanthin for the prophylactic and/or therapeutic treatment of inflammation in the mucous of mammalian gastrointestinal tract caused by Helicobacter sp Administering a source of astaxanthin in a therapeutically effective amount to prevent, retard and ameliorate carpal tunnel syndrome and tenosynovitis Preparation containing astaxanthin to improve the duration of muscle function and/or treat mammalian muscle disorders or diseases Administration of astaxanthin to prevent, retard or treat eye and central nervous system diseases or injuries Cyanotech Corporation (KailuKona, HI) August 13, 2002 Cyanotech Corporation (Kailua-Kona, HI) February , 2002 Astacarotene AB (Gustavsberg, SE) January 1, 2002 Triarco Industries, Inc. (Wayne, NJ) August 21, 2001 Itano Refrigerated Food Co., Ltd. (Tokushima, JP) July 24, 2001 Astacarotene AB (Gustavsberg, SE) July 17, 2001 Cyanotech Corporation (Kailua-Kona, HI) July 10, 2001 Astacarotene AB (Gustavsberg, SE) June 12, 2001 Board of Trustees of the University of Illinois (Urbana, IL) June 18, 1996 Astaxanthin produced by algae Methods of generating microorganisms producing high yields of carotenoids, in particular astaxanthin Cognis IP Management GmbH (Duesseldorf, DE) March 26, 2013 Purification method of free-astaxanthin from Haematococcus pluvialis Sungkyunkwan University (Gyeonggi-Do, KR) August 31, 2010 Astaxanthin production from Chlorella zoofingiensis The University of Hong Kong (Hong Kong, HK) June 20, 2006 Stable astaxanthincontaining powdery composition from Haematococcus alga Fuji Chemical Industry Co., Ltd. (Toyoma, JP) June 20, 2006 process for cultivating Haematococcus for the large scale production of astaxanthin-enriched Haematococcus cell Ben-Gurion University of the Negev Research and Development Authority (BeerSheva, IL) February 8, 2000 Peptide having a .beta.-C4-oxygenase activity to biotechnologically produce astaxanthin Yissum Research and Development Company of the Hebrew University of (Jerusalem, IL) October 12, 1999 Peptide having a .beta.-C4-oxygenase activity to biotechnologically produce astaxanthin * June 29, 1999 5,882,849 Method of control of Haematococcus spp, growth process A control method of growth stages of Haematococcus spp. and its photoadaptive stages of producing astaxanthin Aquasearch, Inc. (Kailua-Kona, HI) March 16, 1999 5,739,006 Process of feeding juvenile fish with astaxanthin-containing zooplankton Culture of Brachionus pricatilis zooplankton producing astaxanthin Kyowa Hakko Kogyo Co., Ltd. (Tokyo, JP) April 14, 1998 8,404,468 7,785,823 7,063,957 7,064,101 6,022,701 5,965,795 5,916,791 Efficient astaxanthin production strains derived from Haematococcus pluvialis Method for selective separation of freeastaxanthin from green algae Haematococcus pluvialis Methods for production of astaxanthin from the green microalgae Chlorella in darkheterotrophic cultures Stable astaxanthincontaining powdery compositions and process for producing the same Procedure for large-scale production of astaxanthin from Haematococcus Polynucleotide molecule from Haematococcus pluvialis encoding a polypeptide having a beta-C-4-oxygenase activity for biotechnological production of (3S, 3'S) astaxanthin and its specific expression in chromoplasts of higher plants Polynucleotide molecule from Haematococcus pluvialis encoding a polypeptide having a .beta.--C--4--oxygenase activity for biotechnological production of (3S,3S) astaxanthin Astaxanthin produced by bacteria 8,221,997 Microorganism and method for producing carotenoid using the same Paracoccus bacteria capable of producing a large amount of carotenoids, mainly astaxanthin 7,232,666 Optimized bacterial host strains of Methylomonas sp. 16a Optimized Methylomonas strains for the production of astaxanthin 5,935,808 Carotenoid-producing bacterial species and process for production of carotenoids using same Paracoccus species type strain DSM 11574 which produces astaxanthin 5,858,761 Bacteria for production of carotenoids Bacterium belonging to a new genus which can produce astaxanthin in an industrial scale Nippon Oil Company, Ltd. (Tokyo, JP) January 12, 1999 5,607,839 Bacteria belonging to new genus process for production of carotenoids using same Bacterium belonging to a new genus which produces astaxanthin Nippon Oil Company, Ltd. (Tokyo, JP) March 4, 1997 Tosoh Corporation (Shunan-shi, JP) E. I. du Pont de Nemours and Company (Wilmington, DE) Yissum Research and Development Company of the Hebrew University of (Jerusalem, IL) July 17, 2012 June 19, 2007 August 10, 1999 Astaxanthin produced by fungi 7,723,066 7,432,076 Processes for in vivo production of astaxanthin and Phaffia rhodozyma yeast of enhanced astaxanthin content Astaxanthin production using fed-batch fermentation process by Phaffia rhodozyma 7,374,908 Microorganism and production of carotinoid compounds thereby 7,291,749 Method for producing esterified astaxanthin from esterified zeaxanthin 6,783,951 Process for production of carotenoids, xanthophylls and apo-carotenoids utilizing eukaryotic microorganisms 6,291,204 Fermentative carotenoid production 6,015,684 Astaxanthin overproducing strains of Phaffia rhodozyma method for their cultivation and their use Process for enhance production of astaxanthin of Phaffia yeast Fermentation method of astaxanthin using Phaffia rhodozyma Thraustochytrium sp. CHN-3 (FERM P-18556) capable of producing astaxanthin and canthaxanthin Method for producing esterified astaxanthin from zeaxanthin suitable for salmon feed Method for produce an effective amount of xanthophylls from Thraustochytriales Proteins of microorganism E-396 (FERM BP-4283) to improve biosynthetic pathway from farnesyl pyrophosphate and isopentyl pyrophosphate to various carotenoids Phaffia rhodozyma strains with high astaxanthin capacity of synthesis to be incorporated into animal feeds Igene Biotechnology, Inc. (Columbia, MD) May 25, 2010 DSM IP Assets B.V. (TE Heerlen, NL) October 7, 2008 National Institute of Advanced Industrial Science and Technology (Tokyo, JP) May 20, 2008 DSM IP Assets B.V. (Te Heerlen, NL) November 6, 2007 * August 31, 2004 Roche Vitamins Inc. (Parsippany, NJ) Archer-DanielsMidland Company (Decatur, IL) September 18, 2001 January 18, 2000 5,922,560 5,879,927 5,712,110 5,709,856 5,679,567 5,648,261 5,356,809 in animal feeds Astaxanthin overproducing strains of Phaffia rhodozyma, methods for their cultivation, and their use in animal feeds Strains of Phaffia rhodozyma containing high levels of astaxanthin and low levels of 3hydroxy-3', 4'-didehydro.beta., .psi.-caroten-4-one (HDCO) Astaxanthin-producing yeast cells methods for their preparation and their use Astaxanthin-producing yeast cells methods for their preparation and their use Astaxanthin-producing yeast cells, methods for their preparation and their use Strains of Phaffia rhodozyma containing high levels of astaxanthin and low levels of 3hydroxy-3',4'-didehydro.beta., .PSI.-caroten-4-one (HDCO) Processes for in vivo production of astaxanthin and Phaffia rhodozyma yeast of enhanced astaxanthin content 5,599,711 Astaxanthin-producing yeast cells, methods for their preparation and their use 5,466,599 Astaxanthin overproducing strains of Phaffia rhodozyma 5,356,810 5,356,809 5,182,208 Astaxanthin-producing yeast cells, methods for their preparation and their use Processes for in vivo production of astaxanthin and Phaffia rhodozyma yeast of enhanced astaxanthin content Processes for in vivo production of astaxanthin and Phaffia rhodozyma Phaffia rhodozyma strains which produce high amounts of astaxanthin to be incorporated into animal feeds Archer Daniels Midland Company (Decatur, IL) July 13, 1999 Phaffia rhodozyma strains having increased levels of astaxanthin Gist-Brocades, B.V. (Ma Delft, NL) March 9, 1999 Gist-brocades, B.V. (NL) January 27, 1998 Gist-brocades, B.V. (NL) January 20, 1998 Gist-brocades, B.V. (NL) October 21, 1997 Phaffia rhodozyma strains having increased levels of astaxanthin Gist-brocades, N.V. (Ma Delft, NL) July 15, 1997 An economical process for in vivo production of the pigment astaxanthin by Phaffia yeast Igene Biotechnology, Inc. (Columbia, MD) October 18, 1994 Gist-brocades, N.V. (Ma Delft, NL) February 4, 1997 Universal Foods Corporation (Milwaukee, WI) November 14, 1995 Gist-brocades N.V. (NL) October 18, 1994 Igene Biotechnology, Inc. (Columbia, MD) October 18, 1994 Igene Biotechnology, Inc. (Columbia, MD) January 26, 1993 An isolated pure culture of a strain of Phaffia rhodozyma which produces astaxanthin An isolated pure culture of a strain of Phaffia rhodozyma which produces astaxanthin An isolated pure culture of a strain of Phaffia rhodozyma which produces astaxanthin Phaffia rhodozyma strain which produces high amount of astaxanthin to be incorporated into animal feeds Phaffia rhodozyma strains which produces high amount of astaxanthin to be incorporated into animal feeds Phaffia rhodozyma strains which produces high amount of astaxanthin Phaffia rhodozyma strains which produces high amount of astaxanthin to be incorporated into animal feeds Process for in vivo production of astaxanthin in Phaffia yeast of enhanced astaxanthin content Astaxanthin produced by plants 7,595,171 Ketocarotenoids from Adonis palaestina 5,453,565 Astaxanthin from flowers of the genus Adonis 5,959,138 Short chain diesters and process for making the same Method for the production of Adonis palaestina plants with increased astaxanthin content Novel strain of Adonis aestivalis containing astaxanthin Astaxanthin synthesis from marigold extracts to be used for the pigmentation of broilers and egg yolks Sinotrade Technology Limited (Hong Kong, CN) September 29, 2009 Unilever Patent Holdings B.V. (Vlaardingen, DK) September 26, 1995 Industrial Organica S.A. DE C.V. (Topo Chico, Monterrey, MX) September 28, 1999 Method of extraction of astaxanthin 8,383,178 Stabilisation of pigments and polyunsaturated oils and oil concentrates A method for stabilizing vegetable, marine and single cell oils/oil concentrates as well as pigments like astaxanthin and canthaxanthin with regard to oxidation Pronova Biopharma Norge AS (Baerum, NO) February 26, 2013 Astaxanthin produced by chemical synthesis 8,492,579 Method for producing astaxanthin dimethyldisuccinate 7,247,752 Methods for the synthesis of astaxanthin 6,376,717 Preparation of astaxanthin 6,372,946 Preparation of 4,4'diketo-.beta.-carotene derivatives 5,654,488 Preparation of astaxanthin 5,455,362 5,210,186 Preparation of astaxanthin novel intermediates therefor and the preparation thereof Method for recovery and separation of chitin, proteins and astaxanthin Improved method for producing all-E astaxanthin dimethyldisuccinate A method used for synthesizing intermediates for use in the synthesis of carotenoids and carotenoid analogs, and/or carotenoid derivatives A method for preparing astaxanthin from zeaxanthin Chemical synthesis of astaxanthin using hypobromous acid preparation of astaxanthin by Wittig reaction avoiding the use of halohydrocarbons as solvents BASF SE (DE) July 23, 2013 Cardax Pharmaceuticals, Inc. (Aiea, HI) July 24, 2007 Prodemex, S.A. de C.V. (Sinaloa, MX) April 23, 2002 Prodemex, S.A. DE C.V. (Los Mochis, MX) April 16, 2002 BASF Aktiengesellschaft (Ludwigshafen, DE) August 5, 1997 Synthesis of intermediates to produce astaxanthin BASF Aktiengesellschaft (Ludwigshafen, DE) October 3, 1995 Method for recover astaxanthin from crustacean tissues * May 11, 1993 5,097,063 4,585,885 4,245,109 and esters thereof Hydroxycarbonyl derivatives and process for making the same Cyclohexenone derivatives and process for making same Process for producing astaxanthin Chemical preparation of astaxanthin NeuroSearch A/S (Glostrup, DK) March 17, 1992 Chemical preparation of astaxanthin Hoffmann-La Roche Inc. (Nutley, NJ) April 29, 1986 Chemical preparation of astaxanthin Hoffmann-La Roche Inc. (Nutley, NJ) January 13, 1981 Patented enzymes or DNA sequences to produce astaxanthin by organism transformation Two sequences of a nucleic acid isolated from a cDNA library of the flowering plant Adonis aestivalis is disclosed Beta.-ionone ring-4ketolase gene and/or .beta.-ionone ring-3hydroxylase gene derived from Brevundimonas sp. strain SD-212 to transform a microorganism or plant and increase astaxanthin production 8,373,023 Biochemical route to astaxanthin 7,999,151 Method of producing astaxanthin or metabolic product thereof by using carotenoid ketolase and carotenoid hydroxylase genes 7,422,873 Mutant carotenoid ketolase CrtW carotenoid ketolase with improved activity 7,393,671 Mutant carotenoid ketolases Sphingomonas melonis DC18 CrtW 7,351,564 SQS gene 7,288,395 ACC gene Gene useful in a process to increase the microbial production of carotenoids Gene useful in a process to increase the microbial production of carotenoids University of Maryland (College Park, MD) February 12, 2013 Kirin Holdings Kabushiki Kaisha (Tokyo, JP) August 16, 2011 E.I. du Pont de Nemours and Company (Wilmington, DE) E.I. du Pont de Nemours and Company (Wimington, DE) September 9, 2008 July 1, 2008 DSM IP Assets B.V. (Heerlen, NL) April 1, 2008 DSM IP Assets B.V. (TE Heerlen, NL) October 30, 2007 Carotenoid ketolases Novel CrtW carotenoid ketolase E. I. du Pont de Nemours and Company (Wilmington, DE) August 7, 2007 7,253,297 Astaxanthin esters Formulation containing an astaxanthin derivative with higher heat stability for use in a feed for aquatic animals DSM IP Assetts B.V. (TE Heerlen, NL) August 7, 2007 7,074,604 Bioproduction of astaxanthin using mutant carotenoid ketolase and carotenoid hydroxylase genes CrtO ketolase and a CrtZ hydroxylase with increased astaxanthin synthesis activity E. I. du Pont de Nemours and Company (Wilmington, DE) July 11, 2006 Astaxanthin synthase Polypeptides having astaxanthin synthase activity, DNA fragments coding for astaxanthin synthase and recombinant organisms DSM IP Assets B.V. (Heerlen, NL) July 11, 2006 7,252,985 7,074,587 7,063,956 Fermentative carotenoid production 7,041,854 Process for the preparation of an xanthophyll 7,041,471 6,903,245 Carotene hydroxylase and method for producing xanthophyll derivatives Polynucleotide molecule from Haematococcus pluvialis encoding a polypeptide having a .sym.-C-4-oxigenase activity for biotechnological production of (3S,3'S) astaxanthin and its specific expression in chromoplasts of higher plants proteins of microorganism E-396 (FERM BP-4283) to improve biosynthetic pathway from farnesyl pyrophosphate and isopentyl pyrophosphate to various carotenoids Synthesis of astaxanthin by oxidation of lutein or zeaxanthin in the presence of hydrogen peroxide and an iodine-containing compound Proteins which convert canthaxanthin into astaxanthin Peptide having .beta.-C-4oxygenase activity to biotechnologically produce astaxanthin Proteins of microorganism E-396 (FERM BP-4283) to improve biosynthetic pathway from farnesyl pyrophosphate and isopentyl pyrophosphate to various carotenoids Genetic materials for the preparation of astaxanthin from Phaffia rhodozyma 6,677,134 Fermentative carotenoid production 6,365,386 Astaxanthin synthase 6,218,599 Polynucleotide molecule from Haematococcus pluvialis encoding a polypeptide having a .beta.-C-4-oxygenase activity for biotechnological production of (3S, 3'S) astaxanthin and its specific expression in chromoplasts of higher plants Peptide having a .beta.-C4-oxygenase activity to biotechnologically produce astaxanthin 6,150,130 DNA strands useful for the synthesis of xanthophylls and the process for producing the xanthophylls DNA strands useful for the synthesis of xanthophylls and the process for producing the xanthophylls 5,972,690 DNA strands useful for the synthesis of xanthophylls and the process for producing the DNA strands useful for the synthesis of xanthophylls and the process for producing the DSM IP Assets B.V. (Heerlen, NL) June 20, 2006 Adisseo France S.A.S. (Antony, FR) May 9, 2006 BASF Aktiengesellschaft (Ludwigshafen, DE) May 9, 2006 Yissum Research Development Company of The Hebrew University of Jerusalem (Jerusalem, IL) June 7, 2005 Roche Vitamins, Inc. (Parsippany, NJ) January 13, 2004 Roche Vitamins Inc. (Parsippany, NJ) April 2, 2002 Yissum Research and Development Company of the Hebrew University of Jerusalem (Jerusalem, IL) April 17, 2001 Kirin Beer Kabushiki Kaisha (Tokyo-to, JP) Marine Biotechnology Institute Co., Ltd. (Tokyo-to, JP) Kirin Beer Kabushiki Kaisha (Tokyo-to, JP) Marine November 21, 2000 October 26, 1999 5,972,642 5,910,433 5,811,273 xanthophylls xanthophylls Astaxanthin-producing yeast cells, methods for their preparation and their use Keto group-introducing enzyme, DNA coding therefor and method for producing ketocarotenoids Pure culture of a strain of Phaffia rhodozyma which produces large amounts of astaxanthin DSM N.V. (NL) October 26, 1999 DNA sequences that encode genes for synthesizing astaxanthin Kirin Beer Kabushiki Kaisha (Tokyo, JP) June 8, 1999 DNA strands useful for the synthesis of xanthophylls and the process for producing the xanthophylls DNA strands useful for the synthesis of xanthophylls and the process for producing the xanthophylls Kirin Beer Kabushiki Kaisha (Tokyo-To, JP) Marine Biotechnology Institute Co., Ltd, (Tokyo-To, JP) September 22, 1998 * Assignee is not available Biotechnology Institute Co., Ltd (Tokyo-to, JP) Supplementary table 7: Crop Method 1 Portion required to achieve mostly used commercial dosage Carotenoid level Percentage (%) mostly used commercial dosage provided by 100g Reference 51 % Paine et al. 2005 158% Shewmaker et al. 1999 β-Carotene2 Rice (Oryza sativa) GE 31 μg/g DW βcarotene Canola (Brassica napus) GE 949 μg/g FW βcarotene Tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum) GE 205 μg/g FW βcarotene 29.2 g 341% D’Ambrosio et al. 2004 Plant Sci. CB 13.6 μg/g DW β-carotene 441g 22.6% Harjes et al. 2008 GE 59.32 μg/g DW β-carotene 101 g 98.8% Naqvi et al. 2009 M 79.85 μg/g FW β-carotene 75 g 125% Jaswir et al. 2011 153 g 65% Jayaraj et al. 2008 69.44/g DW βcarotene 86.4 g 115% GE 112μg/g DW βcarotene 53.6g 186% M 44.89 μg/g FW β-carotene 133.6g 75% Jaswir et al. 2011 Maize (Zea Mays) GE Spinach (Spinacia oleracea) 6.3 g 39 μg/g FW βcarotene Carrot (Daucus carota) Soybean (Glycine max) 193 g CB (Assuming water content 87%) Kim et al. 2012 Lycopene3 Tomato CB 169μg/g FW lycopene 118 g 84 % Frusciante et al. 2007 GE 313.2 μg/g FW lycopene 63.9 g 156% Fraser et al. 2002 M 43.75 μg/g FW lycopene 137 g 73% Jaswir et al. 2011 Watermelon (Citrullus lanatus) M 47.5 μg/g FW lycopene 126 g 79% Jaswir et al. 2011 Lutein4 Canola GE 76.22 μg/g FW lutein 78.7g 127% Yu et al. 2008 CB 25.24 μg/g DW lutein (assuming water content 75%) 237g 42% Fanning et al. 2010 GE 23.41 μg/g DW lutein 256g 39% Naqvi et al. 2011 M 62.65 μg/g FW lutein 95.7 g 104% Jaswir et al. 2011 Maize Spinach Zeaxanthin5 CB 47.7 μg/g DW zeaxanthin (assuming water content of 75%) 83.8g 119% Fanning et al. 2010 GE 56.49 μg/g DW zeaxanthin 70.8g 141% Naqvi et al. 2011 GE 15.2 μg/g FW zeaxanthin 263g 38% Gerjets and Sandmann 2006 Maize Potato (Solanum tuberosum) Astaxanthin6 1 Carrot GE 91.6 μg/g FW astaxanthin 21.8g 458% Jayaraj et al. 2009 Potato GE 13.9 μg/g DW astaxanthin 143g 69.5% Morris et al. 2006 Maize GE 4.26 μg/g DW astaxanthin 469g 21% Zhu et al. 2008 Tomato GE 16,104.7 μg/g DW astaxanthin 0.12g 80523% Huang et al. 2013 Method; conventional breeding (CB), genetic engineering (GE) or on the market (M). Commercial dosage of β-carotene is 6-15mg/day. Calculations are made considering 6mg/day. 3 Commercial dosage of lycopene is 10-40mg/day. Calculations are made considering 20mg/day. 4 Commercial dosage of lutein is 5-20mg/day. Calculations are made considering 6mg/day. 5 Commercial dosage of zeaxanthin is 1-10mg/day. Calculations are made considering 4mg/day. 6 Commercial dosage of astaxanthin is 2-4mg/day. Calculations are made considering 2mg/day. 2 References D’ambrosio C, Giorio G, Mariano I et al. (2004) Virtually complete conversion of lycopene into beta-carotene in fruits of tomato plants. Plant Science 166, 207-214. Fanning KD, Martin I, Wong L et al. (2010) Screening sweetcorn for enhanced zeaxanthin concentration. J Sci Food Agric 90, 91-96. Fraser PD, Romer S, Shipton CA et al. (2002) Evaluation of transgenic tomato plants expressing an additional phytoene synthase in a fruit-specific manner. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 99, 1092-1097. Frusciante L, Carli P, Ercolano MR et al. (2007) Antioxidant nutritional quality of tomato. Mol Nutr Food Res 51, 609-617. Gerjets T & Sandmann G (2006) Ketocarotenoid formation in transgenic potato. J Exp Botany 57, 3639–3645. Harjes CE, Rocheford TR, Bai L et al. (2008) Natural genetic variation in lycopene epsilon cyclase tapped for corn biofortification. Science 319, 330–333. Jaswir I, Noviendri D, Hasrini RF et al. (2011) Carotenoids: sources, medicinal properties and their application in food and nutraceutical industry. J Med Plants Res 5, 7119-7131. Jayaraj J, Devlin R & Punja Z (2008) Metabolic engineering of novel ketocarotenoid production in carrot plants. Transgenic Res 17, 489-501. Kim MJ, Kim JK, Kim HJ et al. (2012) Genetic modification of the soybean to enhance the β-carotene content through seed-specific expression. PlosOne 7, e48287. Morris WL, Ducreux LJM, Fraser PD et al. (2006) Engineering ketocarotenoid biosynthesis in porato tubers. Met eng 8, 253-263. Naqvi S, Zhu C, Farré G et al. (2009) Transgenic multivitamin corn through biofortification of endosperm with three vitamins representing three distinct metabolic pathways. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 106: 7762-7767. Naqvi S, Zhu C, Farré G et al. (2011) Synergistic metabolism in hybrid corn indicates bottlenecks in the carotenoid pathway and leads to the accumulation of extraordinary levels of the nutritionally important carotenoid zeaxanthin. Plant Biotechnol J 9, 384– 393. Paine JA, Shipton CA, Chaggar S et al. (2005) Improving the nutritional value of Golden Rice through increased pro-vitamin A content. Nat Biotechnol 23, 482-487. Shewmaker CK, Sheehy JA, Daley M et al. (1999) Seed-specific overexpression of phytoene synthase: increase in carotenoids and other metabolic effects. Plant J 20, 401412. Yu D, Lydiate DJ, Young LW et al. (2008) Enhancing the carotenoid content of Brassica napus seeds by downregulating lycopene epsilon cyclase. Transgenic Res 17, 573-585.