District-Determined Measure Example Locomotor Skills in Kindergarten Physical Education Content Area and Grade Range: Physical Education, Kindergarten DDM Summary: Locomotor skills are the foundations of movements needed to perform a variety of physical activities. They are the building blocks of coordination. This assessment measures students acquisition of these foundational skills of running, galloping, skipping, and hopping. Development Team: David Folli, Ludlow Public Schools; Mary Johansmeyer & Jamie Bishop, Mohawk Trail Regional School District; Rebecca Minton, Northampton Public Schools; Gwynne Morrissey, Collaborative for Educational Services; Linda Davis­Delano, Springfield College Last updated: June 16, 2015 Table of Contents Introduction .............................................................................................................. 2 Administration Protocol .......................................................................................... 2 Instrument ................................................................................................................ 2 Scoring Guide .......................................................................................................... 9 Measuring Growth and Setting Parameters........................................................... 9 Piloting .................................................................................................................... 10 Kindergarten Locomotor Skills Rubric ................................................................ 11 Collaborative for Educational Services – DDM – Kindergarten Physical Education 1 Introduction We used a DDM from Ludlow Public Schools as a starting point for this collaborative, cross-district elementary level DDM. We ultimately found that the commonly used assessments published in PE Metrics: Assessing National Standards 1-6 in Elementary School (SHAPE America-Society of Health and Physical Educators, 2013) assessed the same skills as our initial assessment, and we liked the format of the published rubrics better. Kindergarten was chosen because locomotor skills are introduced at this level and are the essential foundations of whole body movement required to perform a variety of physical activities, including those involved in team and individual recreation. They are the building blocks of coordination. This DDM was created by four current and former P.E. elementary teachers, a member of the Collaborative for Educational Services with experience in developing assessments, and the director of education preparation and licensure of Physical Education from Springfield College. Table of Test Specifications This measure is aligned with: ● NASPE (National Association for Sport and Physical Education): ○ Standard 1: The physically literate individual demonstrates competency in a variety of motor skills and movement patterns. ● MA State Standards: ○ 2.1 Apply movement concepts, including direction, balance, level (high, low), pathway (straight, curve, zigzag), range (expansive, narrow), and force absorption (rigid, with bent knees) to extend versatility and improve physical performance. ○ 2.2 Use a variety of manipulative (throwing, catching, striking), locomotor (walking, running, skipping, hopping, galloping, sliding, jumping, leaping), and non-locomotor (twisting, balancing, extending) skills as individuals and in teams. Collaborative for Educational Services – DDM – Kindergarten Physical Education 2 Cognitive Complexity Content (Standard) Low Moderate High Difficulty Easy Moderate Hard % 25 Running 1 Galloping 1 Skipping 1 1 25 Hopping 1 1 25 % of Total Items 25 50 25 1 25 1 25 25 50 Administration Protocol This test will be given three times a year (September, January, and May) for all four locomotor skills. Results of the first and third administrations are used to calculate student growth, while the second administration gives teachers the opportunity to check in on student progress—an instructional best practice. The scripts for describing the tasks and expectations to students are in the Instrument section. Expectations of prior experience: It is expected that the average kindergarten child will have already experienced locomotor skills in their everyday play prior to entering kindergarten. Young children may acquire running, galloping, skipping, and hopping skills through informal activities. The goal of this assessment and associated instruction is to ensure that all students leave Kindergarten with good whole body movement habits. Instruction in locomotor skills: Each locomotor skill will be taught during the first few months of the school year. Each skill will be broken down into steps, practiced, and infused into activities and games throughout the school year. Preparation for all four skill assessments: ● Allow only safe footwear, i.e., no sandals, boots, bare feet, etc. ● Assessments can be done inside or outside. ● If outside, use a smooth, hard surface that is free of obstructions. ● Setting up a video camera is optional, but highly recommended; make sure that it is close enough to be in view and close enough to see the Collaborative for Educational Services – DDM – Kindergarten Physical Education 3 ● ● ● ● students’ entire bodies to assess the form and consistency of each locomotor skill. Video use may be especially valuable for large classes, where it is challenging to see individual performances happening simultaneously. All four skills may be assessed in the course of one 30-minute class period, but teachers should use their professional judgment—it may be valuable to assess one or more of these skills during the warm-up or as the main activity. Cones mark the starting points for three or four lines of students (“squads”). Cones also mark each line’s end point. Each set of start and end cones should be 40 to 60 feet apart. (See diagram below; depends on the length of your gym.) Starting cones should be five feet apart; ending cones should also be five feet apart. Ensure that there are 10 feet of unobstructed space in front of the starting cones, and an additional 15 feet of unobstructed space beyond the ending cones. Create three or four three-foot squares, five feet apart at each starting point with floor tape, chalk, etc. to be used for hopping assessment. Accommodations for students with special needs and English Language Learners The rubric and task directions make expectations clear for all students. Modeling included in beginning and mid-year administrations makes expectations clear to Collaborative for Educational Services – DDM – Kindergarten Physical Education 4 English Language Learners alongside their peers. Students with physical disabilities will be accommodated in accordance with their IEPs, which may include making lanes wider or distances or time shorter. Deviations from protocol ● Based on absence: Should children be absent on assessment days, they may be assessed at the next most convenient time. If a child enters the school after the start of the year and before Thanksgiving, that child’s locomotor skills may be assessed upon entry and included in the measure’s student population for the year. For children entering the school after Thanksgiving, they may be assessed alongside their peers in the remaining test administration windows (i.e., January and May), but will not be included in the measure’s student population for the year. ● Based on individual school context: Teachers should use their professional judgment in deviating from this protocol. Reasons for deviation might include the size of the gym, class size, length of class time, and how often classes meet, e.g., classes that meet twice a week may have quite different experiences and opportunities from classes that meet only once a week. We recognize that some classes meet for only half the year, others for the whole year, and teachers may need to adjust the timeline of this DDM’s administration depending on the length of time they spend with classes in a year. Additionally, being mindful of time for assessment versus time for learning or participation, teachers could consider increasing the number of students performing each skill simultaneously, especially if video is available. ● For students who come to kindergarten with well-developed locomotor skills: For numerous reasons, some students arrive in kindergarten with welldeveloped locomotor skills. Teachers may want to consider the following extensions for these students: ○ Perform each skill in a circle, approximately the size of the gym, not in place. ○ Without stopping, perform each skill in different combinations, e.g., skipping to hopping, skipping to galloping to running. Collaborative for Educational Services – DDM – Kindergarten Physical Education 5 Guidelines for the administration of each skill Administration of RUNNING ● Students will run the length of the lane you created with cones. ● Make sure students do not stop running until after they pass the ending cone. ● Clearly indicate that the running lane is from their starting cone to their ending cone. ● After all students first in line (Group 1) arrive at the ending cones, Group 2 begins. ● Group 2 lines up behind Group 1 as they finish, and once all have arrived, Group 3 begins, etc. ● Once every student has run across, begin the process again with Group 1 running from the end cone to the start cone. ● Repeat as needed to accurately assess each student’s performance. Administration of GALLOPING ● Students will gallop the length of the lane you created. ● Clearly indicate the galloping lane (from their starting cone to their ending cone) and the stopping zones (the fifteen feet beyond the ending cone). ● Do not designate right foot or left foot; use the terms “one foot” and “the other foot”. ● Students first in line (Group 1) wait at their cones until everyone in Group 1 has arrived, then all start their return at the same time. ● Students should turn around and gallop back with their other foot leading. ● Once finished, students will go to the back of their line. ● Repeat as needed to accurately assess each student’s performance. Administration of SKIPPING ● Clearly indicate the skipping lanes (from their starting cone to their ending cone). ● Assessment process is the same as for running, assessing three or four students at a time. ● Once finished, students go to the back of their line. ● Repeat as needed to accurately assess each student’s performance. Administration of HOPPING ● Clearly indicate each student’s personal space for hopping. ● A stopwatch or a clock will be needed for timing. Use your own stop and go signals, allowing students to hop for 10 seconds on each foot. ● Once finished, students go to the back of their line. ● Repeat as needed to accurately assess each student’s performance. Collaborative for Educational Services – DDM – Kindergarten Physical Education 6 Instrument Any of the following instructions may be repeated to the whole class as often as necessary during each skill’s assessment. Instructions for students: Running and galloping RUNNING pre-test and mid year test: ● Today, we are going to work on running. ● This is what running looks like. (Demonstrate the skill to the class.) ● Pump your arms forward and backwards, moving them opposite of your legs. Your toes point forward and your foot lands heel to toe. ● On my signal, run fast staying in the running lane. ● Do not stop running until after you cross the finish line. ● Run as fast as you can, showing me your best running form. RUNNING post-test: ● Today, I am going to watch you run. ● Stand behind the starting line. ● On my signal, run fast all the way through the course. ● Stay in the running lane by running in a straight line. ● Do not stop running until after you cross the finish line. ● Run as fast as you can, showing me your best running form by swinging your arms forward and backward, having your toes pointed forward and landing on the heel of your foot first. GALLOPING pre-test and mid year test: ● Today, we’re going to work on galloping. ● Watch me first. I’m going to put one foot in front of the other. Notice how my back foot chases my front foot while I am moving forward. (Gallop four or five paces) ● Stand behind the starting line. ● On my signal, gallop to the end of the lane, with one foot leading. ● Stop, then turn around and gallop back, with the other foot leading. ● Stay in your lane. ● This is not a race. ● Show me your best galloping form by using the same foot in front, facing forward, bringing your feet together without crossing them and without stopping your movement. GALLOPING post-test: ● Today, I’m going to look at your galloping. ● Stand behind the starting line. ● On my signal, gallop to the end of the lane, with one foot leading. ● Stop, then turn around and gallop back, with the other foot leading. ● Stay in your lane. ● This is not a race. ● Show me your best galloping form by using the same foot in front, facing forward, bringing your feet together without crossing them and without stopping your movement. Collaborative for Educational Services – DDM – Kindergarten Physical Education 7 Instructions for students: Skipping and hopping SKIPPING pre-test and mid year test: ● Today we are going to work on skipping. ● Watch me first. I take a step and a hop on one foot and then a step and a hop on the other foot. Keep repeating this pattern. (Skip four or five paces) ● On my signal, start skipping from the starting line to the finish line, while staying in your lane. ● This is not a race. ● Show me your best skipping! SKIPPING post-test: ● Today, I’m going to look at you skipping. ● Stand behind the starting line. ● Skip from the starting line to the finish line, while staying in your lane. ● This is not a race. ● Show me your best skipping; step­hop on one foot, then step-hop on the other without stopping in between. ● On my signal, skip to the finish line. HOPPING pre-test and mid year test: ● Today, we are going to work on hopping. ● Watch me first. I am going to stand on one foot, push off the ground with that foot and land back on the ground with the same foot. Look how I am landing in the same spot from where I took off each time. I can hop up and down for 10 seconds without stopping. (Hop up and down four or five times) ● Stand in the middle of your own square. ● On my signal, start hopping on one foot in your square until I give the stop signal. ● Then, I will ask you to switch to your other foot. ● I am looking to see if you take off and land on the same foot without stopping or moving outside your square for 10 seconds. HOPPING post-test: ● Today, I am going to watch you hop. ● Stand in the middle of your own square. ● On my signal, start hopping on one foot in your square until I give the stop signal. ● Then, I will ask you to switch to your other foot. ● I am looking to see if you take off and land on the same foot without stopping or moving outside your square for 10 seconds. Collaborative for Educational Services – DDM – Kindergarten Physical Education 8 Scoring Guide The scoring rubric thoroughly describes each discrete skill. A level 3 performance describes a proficient performance in detail. Levels below and above that refer to elements of a proficient performance. At each administration of each skill, look both at students’ form and their ability to consistently execute the skill, as best described in the rubric cells. Note each student’s level of performance in both columns, Form and Consistency. At the end of each of the three administration windows (September, January, and May), add students’ points from the Form and Consistency columns for each skill. The minimum possible score for each skill is 2 points; the maximum is 8. Helpful reference videos showing proficient performance of each skill can be found in the “5­8 Years Old” list of Active For Life lesson plans (http://activeforlife.com/lesson-plans-and-resources/#!prettyPhoto). Measuring Growth and Setting Parameters Elementary P.E. teachers applied a repeated measures approach to the assessment as a way of gathering mid­year information on student’s progress. They also chose a pre­test/post­test approach to measuring growth, comparing skills at the end of the year to those at the beginning of the year. Students tend to arrive in Kindergarten with a 2 or 3 in Form and a 2 or 3 in Consistency, i.e., a total score in each skill of 4 to 6 points. Teachers wanted to reflect that growth might not be uniform across skills, and came to consensus about using growth in some skills as an indicator. Parameters Total Point Gain (Form + Consistency) in X number of skills 4 or more points in 1 skill OR High 3 points in each of 2 or more skills 2 points in each of 2 or more skills OR Moderate 3 points in 1 skill AND 2 points in 1 or more skills Low 0 or 1 points in 3 or more skills We recommend excluding students from the class growth determination who arrive in kindergarten already scoring 4s in three or more skills in Form and/or Consistency. This should be a very small number of students, if any. Collaborative for Educational Services – DDM – Kindergarten Physical Education 9 Piloting Elementary teachers in the development group and some volunteers from nearby districts piloted the DDM between March 10 and May 31, 2015 (a total of six teachers). We sent a descriptive cover letter via email, along with a copy of the draft assessment tool, scoring rubric, and growth parameters to participating teachers. We asked that teachers pilot the tool before the end of March. On April 3, we sent out a Google Form survey requesting preliminary feedback (we received three responses), and suggesting that a second administration occur around the middle to end of May. We requested follow-up feedback from that second administration on June 8, also via a Google Form, to which we received just two responses. We requested that participating teachers share pilot student data with us, but we received data only from one of the development group teachers. Please see the file titled “CES Elementary PE DDM Pilot Forms and Data” for the survey tools, summary of responses, and pilot data sample. In particular, we were pleased with one teacher’s response: “The students seemed like they would have done the routine all class. Funny.” Based on feedback from two surveys and from conversation with the whole development group, we have made the following revisions: ● Highlight the value of videotaping student performances for accurate scoring. ● Put instructions, script, and skill descriptions into bullet format for easy reading. ● Streamline the instructions onto one piece of paper. ● Devise suggestions for extending these skills’ challenges for students who arrive in Kindergarten already highly proficient. ● Revise proposed length of lanes for performing skills, based on feedback that numerous elementary gyms are not 60 feet long. ● Explicitly recognize the need for professional judgment in determining the length of lanes, the number of students who can perform the skill simultaneously, and duration of the DDM’s administration (e.g., Sept to June, Sept to Jan) dependent on each school’s context and class schedule. ● Revise scoring and growth parameters to more accurately reflect student performance of each skill. Suggest the exclusion of students from growth scoring who begin the year already highly proficient. ● Revise the score-tracking sheet in line with new parameters to make growth scoring simpler. Collaborative for Educational Services – DDM – Kindergarten Physical Education 10 Kindergarten Locomotor Skills Rubric RUNNING Similar to the walk, except that the tempo and body lean differ. There is a time at which both feet are off the ground simultaneously. Arms should move forward and backward in opposition to the legs without crossing the midline. Form 1 Runs with 2 or fewer essential elements present. Runs with 3 of 4 essential elements present. 2 3 4 Consistency GALLOPING A form of locomotion which is a combination of an open step by the leading foot and a closed step by the trailing foot. The same foot leads throughout. The rhythm is uneven. Form Stops running action Gallops with 2 or fewer OR essential elements falls down. present. Runs… Gallops with only 3 of 4 without stopping or essential elements falling down, present. BUT stumbles, runs in erratic pathway or has inconsistent stride. Runs with the essential Runs… elements of a mature in straight pathway pattern: without stumbling, arm/leg opposition stopping, or falling toes point forward down. arms swing forward/backward and do not cross midline of body feet land at the ball or midfoot. Displays all the Runs… essential elements of a smoothly mature pattern, with in straight pathway fluid motion. without breaks in stride. Consistency Two or more breaks in action AND/OR does not return to the start with the other foot leading. Gallops… with no more than 1 break in action for entire task, turns and gallops back to the start, with other foot leading. Gallops… with no break in action for 40-60 feet turns and gallops back to the start, with the other foot leading. Gallops with the essential elements of a mature pattern for entire task: same foot leading forward orientation moment of nonsupport back foot does not move in front of lead foot. Displays all the Gallops… essential elements of a smoothly mature pattern, with with continuous fluid motion for entire action task. with each foot leading. Collaborative for Educational Services – DDM – Kindergarten Physical Education 11 HOPPING Springing action from one foot and landing on the same foot. The knee stays bent and the ankle joint is primarily what accomplishes the push into the air. Form Performs hopping action incorrectly for both feet 1 3 4 Loses balance OR cannot sustain hopping motion on both left and right feet for 10 seconds. Hops… continuously for 10 seconds with no loss of balance BUT does not stay in selfspace. Hops… Hops… taking off from one within self-space foot continuously for 10 AND seconds landing on the same with no loss of foot. balance or Performs action on extraneous arm other foot. motion. Performs action on other foot. Hops… Hops… taking off from one within self-space foot continuously for 10 AND seconds landing on the same with fluid motion AND foot with smooth, consistency on each balanced action. foot. Performs action correctly on other foot. Performs hopping action correctly for one but not the other foot 2 Consistency SKIPPING A combination of a step and a hop, first on one foot then the other. The pattern has the alternation and opposition of the walk plus the same-sided one-foot step. It's an uneven rhythm. Form Lacks the essential elements of skipping. Skips with 1 of 2 essential elements present. Consistency Skips… for less than 40-60 feet OR with 2 or more breaks in movement OR loses balance. Skips… for 40-60 feet with no more than 1 break in movement or loss of balance. Skips with the Skips… essential elements of a for 40-60 feet with no breaks in mature pattern: step-hop action movement or loss of on alternating feet balance. with a moment of non-support. Displays all the Skips… essential elements of a with smooth mature pattern, with movement fluid motion. for 40-60 feet. Collaborative for Educational Services – DDM – Kindergarten Physical Education 12 RUNNING FORM Student Sept GALLOPING CONSISTENCY FORM HOPPING CONSISTENCY FORM SKIPPING CONSISTENCY FORM CONSISTENCY TOTAL SKILL GROWTH June Growth Sept June Growth Sept June Growth Sept June Growth Sept June Growth Sept June Growth Sept June Growth Sept June Growth RUNNING GALLOPING HOPPING SKIPPING Growth Categor Notes (e.g., ac A 1 2 1 1 2 1 2 3 1 2 4 2 3 3 0 3 4 1 1 2 1 1 2 1 2 3 1 2 Mod B 2 3 1 1 3 2 3 3 0 3 4 1 3 3 0 3 3 0 2 3 1 2 2 0 3 1 0 1 Low C 1 2 1 0 2 2 1 3 2 0 3 3 2 4 2 2 3 1 1 2 1 1 1 0 3 5 3 1 High D 3 4 1 3 4 1 4 4 0 4 4 0 2 3 1 2 2 0 3 4 1 3 3 0 2 0 1 1 Low Learning disabili E 0 1 1 0 1 1 3 4 1 3 3 0 0 1 1 0 1 1 0 1 1 0 1 1 2 1 2 2 Mod Student often di GROWTH KEY Total point gain (Form + Consistency) in X number of skills High 4 or more points gained in 1 skill OR 3 points gained in each of 2 or more skills Moderate 2 points gained in each of 2 or more skills OR 3 points gained in 1 skill AND 2 points gained in 1 or more skills Low 0 or 1 point gained in 3 or more skills Collaborative for Educational Services – DDM – Kindergarten Physical Education 13