DRAFT Hampton Roads Electronic Tolling / E-ZPass Study March 17, 2008 Objectives and Methodology 2 Study Objectives • An electronic tolling/E-ZPass information campaign is being planned for the Hampton Roads’ area • This campaign is designed to: – Accelerate the sales of electronic tolling / E-ZPass subscriptions – Increase the frequency of use of electronic tolling / E-ZPass among existing subscribers – Help lay the groundwork for potential congestion priced tolling 3 Study Objectives • This research is designed to: – Provide information and related insights to help support VDOT’s upcoming electronic tolling / E-ZPass public education and information campaign in Hampton Roads – Establish performance benchmark measures (such as awareness, perceptions, attitudes, and intent to purchase) from which to assess the impact of VDOT’s electronic tolling / E-ZPass marketing campaign – Provide information and insights on the extent to which residents of Hampton Roads understand and know about “electronic tolling” 4 Study Methodology • A telephone survey was designed and conducted in order to meet the objectives of this research. • The sample for this research consists of three key audiences: Current E-ZPass Users Adult drivers in Hampton Roads, ages 21-59, who have and use E-ZPass on tolled facilities in Hampton Roads Prospective E-ZPass Users Adult drivers in Hampton Roads, ages 21-59, who use any of the tolled facilities in Hampton Roads at least one day a week and could use E-ZPass, but do not Residents Adult residents of Hampton Roads, ages 2159, who do not use any of the tolled facilities in the Hampton Roads’ area 5 Study Methodology • A sample size quota of 200 was targeted for each audience. • Sample sizes of 200 have a margin of error of +/- 6.9 percentage points at the 95% level of confidence. • 606 interviews were completed, distributed as follows: 6 E-ZPass Users 200 E-ZPass Prospects 201 Residents 205 Study Methodology • The survey topics guide and survey instrument were developed with input from project team members. • The survey was programmed in CATI and tested prior to launch. The survey questionnaire included elaborate skip patterns to accommodate the three key audiences being studied. • The interview averaged 18 minutes. • Residents who work for VDOT, DRPT, Transcore, and the media were excluded. 7 Detailed Findings 8 Outline of Report I. E-ZPass Awareness and Familiarity II. E-ZPass Usage III. Propsective Users IV. E-ZPass Perceptions V. Communications VI. Electronic Tolling: The Future VII. HOV Lanes Use and HOT Lanes Perceptions 9 Awareness of E-ZPass Is High – Even among Those Who Do Not Use E-ZPass E-ZPass User 100% E-ZPass Prospect 79% 82% Resident 0% 10 20% 40% 60% Q9. Are you aware of the service called E-ZPass, sometimes referred to as SmartTag? 80% 100% Top-2-box score refers to the total proportion answering “4” or “5” on a 5-point scale. Not Just E-ZPass Users Are Familiar with It; About Twothirds of Prospects and Residents Who Are Aware of E-ZPass Also Say They Are Familiar with E-ZPass 5 - Very familiar 8% 4 3% 3 2 1 - Not at all familiar 89% 45% 43% 0% 97% E-ZPass Users Top-2-Box 25% 19% 70% 15% 20% E-ZPass Prospects Top-2-Box 11% 8% 1% 5% 62% Residents Top-2-Box 10% E-ZPass User E-ZPass User n = 200 E-ZPass Prospect n = 158 Resident n = 175 E-ZPass Prospect 0% 20% 40% 60% Resident Q10. Overall, how familiar are you with E-ZPass, sometimes referred to as SmartTag? ASKED ONLY OF THOSE AWARE 11 80% 100% Generally, motorists seem to have learned about E-ZPass through a variety of sources – or may have forgotten exactly where they first learned about E-ZPass. Q12. How did you first learn about E-ZPass? ASKED ONLY OF THOSE AWARE Of Advertising Media, “Sign” Is Mentioned Most Frequently as the Source of First Learning about E-ZPass – But, Most Often, Motorists First Learn about E-ZPass by Word of Mouth E-ZPass Users E-ZPass Prospects Residents Word of mouth 19% 36% 26% Sign 16% 14% 15% Newspaper ad 9% 6% 6% Toll booth flier 7% 3% 7% Other ad 3% 8% 5% Billboard 4% 4% 5% TV ad 3% 4% 5% Driving by/toll booth 4% 2% 3% News report 3% 3% 2% Employer 2% 2% 2% Radio ad 2% 1% 2% Regular mail 3% - 1% Gas station ad 1% - 1% Retailer display 1% - 1% Magazine/online article 1% 1% - Other 10% 11% 10% 12 18% of Residents Who Are Aware of E-ZPass Have an E-ZPass Even Though They Do Not Travel the Tolled Facilities in Hampton Roads Yes, 18% By definition, 100% of Users and 0% of Prospects have an account. E-ZPass User n = 200 E-ZPass Prospect n = 158 Resident n = 175 No, 82% 13 Q11. Do you currently have an E-ZPass account? ASKED ONLY OF THOSE AWARE This equates to approximately 15% of Residents who do not currently travel tolled facilities in Hampton Roads and indicates that residents already have some understanding and appreciation of E-ZPass Outline of Report I. E-ZPass Awareness and Familiarity II. E-ZPass Usage III. Propsective Users IV. E-ZPass Perceptions V. Communications VI. Electronic Tolling: The Future VII. HOV Lanes Use and HOT Lanes Perceptions 14 The Majority of E-ZPass Users Have Had Their Pass for More Than a Year 64% More than 5 years 30% 1 to 5 years 3% About a year Only 5% have had their pass a year or less. Several months 2% Don't know 2% 0% 20% 40% 60% Q13. How long have you had your E-ZPass? ASKED ONLY OF E-ZPASS USERS 15 80% 100% Almost Two-thirds Use Their Pass At Least Several Times A Week – Nearly a Third Use It Every Day 31% Every day 65% Several times a week 34% About once a week 12% Several times a month/not weekly 15% Less than once a month 9% 0% 20% 40% 60% Q14. How often do you use E-ZPass? ASKED ONLY OF E-ZPASS USERS 16 80% 100% “It Is Cheaper” Is the Most Frequently Mentioned Reason for Using an E-ZPass Some respondents gave more than one answer. Thus, proportions total to more than 100%. It is cheaper 44% Convenience 29% Don’t have to stop at toll 21% Saves time / faster 14% Use it for work 9% Don’t have to carry cash 7% Other E-ZPass Prospect n = 200 Q15. What is the most important reason that you use E-ZPass? ASKED ONLY OF E-ZPASS USERS 17 10% Saving Time Is The Most Important Reason to Have an E-ZPass – But, Not Having to Carry Cash Is Also an Important Reason to Have an E-ZPass Saves time 11% Don't have to carry 10% cash Reduces stress 65% 52% 11% 0% 70% 51% 13% Keep accurate records 84% 74% 19% Don't have to roll down window 90% 79% 29% 20% 40% 40% 4 60% Q16a-e. I would like to know how important each of these statements is as a reason that you use E-ZPass. ASKED ONLY OF E-ZPASS USERS 18 5 - Very important 80% 100% The Majority of Users Are Satisfied with E-ZPass 74% 5 - Very satisfied 92% 18% 4 E-ZPass Users Top-2-Box 6% 3 2 1% 1 - Not at all satisfied 2% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% Q17. Overall, how satisfied are you with E-ZPass? ASKED ONLY OF E-ZPASS USERS 19 100% Most Users Would Recommend E-ZPass 81% 5 - Very likely 93% 12% 4 E-ZPass Users Top-2-Box 4% 3 2 1% 1 - Not at all likely 2% 0% 20% 40% 60% Q18. How likely would you be to recommend E-ZPass to your friends or family members who drive on a roadway or bridge or through a tunnel 20 that has a toll? ASKED ONLY OF E-ZPASS USERS 80% 100% Outline of Report I. E-ZPass Awareness and Familiarity II. E-ZPass Usage III. Propsective Users IV. E-ZPass Perceptions V. Communications VI. Electronic Tolling: The Future VII. HOV Lanes Use and HOT Lanes Perceptions 21 Of the Prospects, Less Than 1 in 10 Had an E-ZPass Account in the Past Had an E-ZPass, no 8% longer do 91% Never had an E-Zpass 1% Other 0% E-ZPass Prospect n = 158 20% 40% 60% Q19. Which of the following phrases best describes you? ASKED ONLY OF THOSE AWARE 22 80% 100% The Reason Cited by Prospects Most Often for Not Having an E-ZPass: Don’t Feel They Drive Far on Tolled Facilities Lack of use does not seem to reflect negative perceptions of E-ZPass. E-ZPass Prospect n = 153 23 Don’t drive that far 57% Don’t need it/have use for it 14% Haven’t gotten around to it 5% Not convenient 5% Not familiar 5% Does not save any/enough time 3% Don’t like paying in advance/giving out credit card 3% Too expensive/can’t afford it 3% Other family member has one/I get one at work 2% Cannot expense it without receipt 1% Don’t trust it 1% Don’t like it 1% Other 7% Don’t know 3% Q20. Why do you not use E-ZPass? ASKED ONLY OF THOSE AWARE 10% of Prospects Are Likely To Obtain An E-ZPass In the Next Year; But, Likelihood Diminishes As the Time Period Decreases 7% 6% 4% 5 - Very likely 3% 3% 2% 4 3 6% 4% 4% 2 6% 6% 3% 10% 9% 6% 12 month Top-2-Box 6 month Top-2-Box 3 month Top-2-Box Next 12 months Next 6 months Next 3 months 78% 81% 86% 1 - Not very likely Don't know 1% 1% 0% E-ZPass Prospect n = 158 20% 40% 60% Q21, 23, 24. How likely is it that you will obtain an E-ZPass within the next [12, 6, 3] months? ASKED ONLY OF THOSE AWARE 24 80% 100% Prospects Familiar with E-ZPass Are More Likely to Say they Will Obtain a Pass in the Next Year Familiarity does not have an effect on likelihood of purchase in the next 3 or 6 months. 5 - Very likely 4 3 E-ZPass Prospects who gave a 4 or 5 to familiarity with E-ZPass n = 110 E-ZPass Prospects who gave a 1, 2, or 3 to familiarity with E-ZPass n = 48 9% 2% 4% 0% 0% 4% 2 Familiar with E-Zpass (4 - 5) 8% Not familiar with E-ZPass (1 - 3) 10% 75% 1 - Not very likely 0% 20% 40% 60% Q21. How likely is it that you will obtain an E-ZPass within the next 12 months? ASKED ONLY OF THOSE AWARE 25 80% 88% 100% Prospects Familiar with E-ZPass Are More Likely to Say they Will Obtain a Pass in the Next Year 60% Score "5" ("very likely") Score "4" 40% Familiarity “lifts” likelihood of obtaining an E-ZPass 20% 0% 13% 2% 9% 2% 4% Not familiar with E-Zpass (scores 1-3) Familiar with E-Zpass (score 4-5) Q21. How likely is it that you will obtain an E-ZPass within the next 12 months? ASKED ONLY OF THOSE AWARE 26 Prospects Not Planning to Obtain an E-ZPass Most Often Believe They Have No Need for One Reasons for not likely to obtain an E-ZPass tend not to be “negative” views of E-ZPass. Have no need for it 40% Wouldn’t use it enough 12% Don’t travel much 8% Not familiar with E-ZPass 5% Obtaining E-ZPass is not convenient 1% Prefer to pay cash 1% Use company E-ZPass if I need one 1% Safety/trust issues 1% Other Don’t know E-ZPass Prospect n = 158 27 Q22. Why is that (you will not obtain an E-ZPass)? ASKED ONLY OF THOSE WHO SAID THEY WOULD NOT BE LIKELY TO OBTAIN E-ZPASS IN NEXT 12 MONTHS 12% 1% “Online” Is the Single Most Popular Channel to Obtain an E-ZPass Among Prospects E-ZPass Prospect n = 113 28 Online 27% At the Coleman Bridge 12% DMV 6% VDOT 4% Specific facilities (other than Coleman Bridge) 4% Grocery store/store (nonspecific) 2% Farm Fresh 2% Post Office 2% Wal-Mart 1% Gas station 1% Mail 1% City Hall 1% Other 14% Not getting one 12% Don’t know 15% Q22. If you were to get an E-ZPass, where would you prefer to get one? ASKED ONLY OF THOSE WHO SAID THEY WOULD BE LIKELY TO OBTAIN E-ZPASS IN NEXT 12 MONTHS Outline of Report I. E-ZPass Awareness and Familiarity II. E-ZPass Usage III. Propsective Users IV. E-ZPass Perceptions V. Communications VI. Electronic Tolling: The Future VII. HOV Lanes Use and HOT Lanes Perceptions 29 Prospects Are Less Likely than Users to Believe that the EZPass Lanes Move More Quickly or That the Facilities are 24/7; But, Most Prospects Believe the E-ZPass Lanes Move More Quickly and that E-ZPass Is In Effect 24/7 E-ZPass lanes move more quickly 86% 8% 8% 78% E-ZPass facilities are 24/7 3% 6% 3% 8% 11% 0% E-ZPass User n = 200 E-ZPass Prospect n = 158 E-ZPass User - 4 E-ZPass Prospect - 4 97% 82% E-ZPass can only be used at certain times 6% 4% 9% 86% 94% 8% E-ZPass can only be used by frequent users 4% 10% 94% Prospects do not have these incorrect perceptions of E-ZPass. 14% 13% 20% 90% 40% 60% 100% E-ZPass User - 5 Agree strongly E-ZPass Prospect - 5 Agree strongly Q26a-h. I would like to know the extent to which you agree or disagree with each statement. ASKED ONLY OF THOSE AWARE 30 80% Prospects and Users Have Different Views on the Costs Associated with E-ZPass; E-ZPass Users Are More Likely to Think It Is Cheaper with E-ZPass 73% 67% E-ZPass cost not prohibitive 6% 5% 60% 55% Average Incomes E-ZPass User – 15% Toll cost is same for booth and E-ZPass 2%13% $74K 24% 3% 21% E-ZPass Prospect - $67K 13% Resident – 82% 78% E-ZPass is cheaper than booth 4% 37% 50% $70K E-ZPass is more expensive than booth 9% 12% 0% E-ZPass User n = 200 E-ZPass Prospect n = 158 E-ZPass User - 4 E-ZPass Prospect - 4 10% 13% 20% 40% 60% 100% E-ZPass User - 5 Agree strongly E-ZPass Prospect - 5 Agree strongly Q26a-h. I would like to know the extent to which you agree or disagree with each statement. ASKED ONLY OF THOSE AWARE 31 80% Outline of Report I. E-ZPass Awareness and Familiarity II. E-ZPass Usage III. Propsective Users IV. E-ZPass Perceptions V. Communications VI. Electronic Tolling: The Future VII. HOV Lanes Use and HOT Lanes Perceptions 32 E-ZPass Users Are Slightly But Not Significantly More Likely to Have Heard or Read about E-ZPass in the Past Year Residents who are aware of E-ZPass communication/ promotion are more likely than Residents who are not to have an E-ZPass. E-ZPass User 36% E-ZPass Prospect 25% 30% Resident 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% Q32. Have you heard or seen any communication or promotion about E-ZPass in the past year? 33 100% Prospects Aware of E-ZPass Communication Are More Likely to Say They Will Obtain a Pass in the Next Six Months 60% Score "5" ("very likely") This relationship does not hold for likelihood of obtaining in next year or next 3 months. Score "4" Communication awareness “lifts” likelihood of obtaining an E-ZPass 40% 20% 16% 6% 8% 4% 8% Not aware of E-ZPass communication Aware of E-ZPass communication 0% Q21. How likely is it that you will obtain an E-ZPass within the next 6 months? ASKED ONLY OF THOSE AWARE 34 E-ZPass Communication Is Most Frequently Associated with Television, Radio, Billboard and Newspaper Q33. Where did you hear or see this communication? ASKED ONLY OF THOSE WHO INDICATED THEY SAW OR HEARD SOMETHING E-ZPass User n = 72 E-ZPass Prospect n = 51 Resident n = 61 E-ZPass Users E-ZPass Prospects Residents TV ad 31% 25% 48% Radio ad 22% 16% 20% Billboard 14% 22% 10% Newspaper ad 19% 10% 15% Highway sign 6% 6% 10% Word of mouth 1% 10% 7% Regular mail 7% 2% 3% Toll booth flier 7% 4% - Gas station ad - 6% - News report - 4% 2% Brochure - 2% 3% Web/internet 1% 2% 2% Statement/comm. from E-ZPass 4% - - Magazine ad 1% - - Other responses 7% 8% 3% Don’t know 8% 6% 5% 35 Advertising Awareness/Recall Is Measured in 3 Ways 1. Unaided recall: without interviewer prompting 2. Aided recall: with interviewer prompting 3. Total recall: the sum of unaided and aided 36 Unaided Ad Recall Is about 5% or Lower for All Messages It's easier with E-ZPass E-ZPass is faster People save time with Stop stopping, get going Save miles, time, gas Stress free/no hassle Coins slow you down 5% 4% 4% 2% 5% 3% 2% 3% 2% 3% 2% 1% E-ZPass User E-ZPass Propsect 3% 2% 1% 3% 2% 1% Resident 1% 2% 1% 11% 5% 8% 12% 9%10% Other Don't know 0% 20% Unaided awareness tends to be lowest for “coins slow you down.” 40% Q34. What specifically did you hear? (UNAIDED) 37 60% 80% 100% Aided Ad Recall Is Strongest for “E-ZPass Is Faster” and “People Save Time with E-ZPass” – Especially among Current E-ZPass Users 25% 22% 19% It's easier with E-ZPass E-ZPass is faster 32% 27% 28% People save time with E-Zpass 32% 28% 26% E-ZPass User E-ZPass Propsect 15% 14% 20% Stop stopping, get going Save miles, time, gas Resident 17% 15% Stress free/no hassle 24% 26% 22% 20% Coins slow you down 18% 16% 18% 0% 20% 40% 60% Q35a-g. Do you recall hearing or seeing an ad that said . . . (AIDED) 38 80% 100% Total Recall Is Highest for “E-ZPass Is Faster” and “People Save Time with E-ZPass” – Across All Three Groups It's easier with E-ZPass 30% 26% 23% 34% 32% 31% E-ZPass is faster 34% 31% 28% People save time with E-Zpass Stop stopping, get going 18% 16% 21% 20% 26% 16% 29% 24% 21% Save miles, time, gas Q34. What specifically did you hear? (UNAIDED) Stress free/no hassle Coins slow you down Q35a-g. Do you recall hearing or seeing an ad that said . . . (UNAIDED) 19% 18% 19% 0% 39 20% 40% 60% E-ZPass User - unaided E-ZPass User - aided E-ZPass Prospect - unaided E-ZPass Prospect - aided Resident - unaided Resident - aided 80% 100% Television, Radio, and Daily Newspaper Are the Most Typical Sources of Transportation and Traffic Information 26% Television Radio 34% 32% 27% 28% 36% And, they reach all three groups about equally. 22% 17% 17% Daily newspaper 5% 7% 9% Internet 4% 2% 3% Weekly newspaper E-ZPass User E-ZPass Prospect 2% 3% 3% Word of mouth Resident 7% 9% 7% Other, don't know, no answer 0% 20% 40% 60% Q53. Where do you typically get information about transportation and traffic issues? 40 80% 100% Motorists Prefer to Receive Information about Tolling and E-ZPass from Television, Radio, and the Daily Newspaper – Regardless of Their Status as E-ZPass Users 21% Television 30% 27% 23% 18% 21% Radio 17% 17% 19% Daily newspaper 7% Internet Regular mail 5% 5% 11% 13% E-ZPass User 13% E-ZPass Prospect Resident 6% 4% 4% Weekly newspaper 7% 2% 4% Email 3% 2% 3% Word of mouth 6% 10% 3% Other, don't know, no answer 0% 20% 40% 60% Q54. Which of these channels of communication do you most prefer to receive information about tolling and E-ZPass? 41 80% 100% Outline of Report I. E-ZPass Awareness and Familiarity II. E-ZPass Usage III. Propsective Users IV. E-ZPass Perceptions V. Communications VI. Electronic Tolling: The Future VII. HOV Lanes Use and HOT Lanes Perceptions 42 All Three Groups Are Most Likely to Say They Would Make No Changes To Their Commute if New Tolls Were Instituted; This Is Especially True for E-ZPass Users Make no changes Change route 9% 10% 11% 31% 22% 33% 33% Change job/work site 3% 6% 9% 3% 9% 12% 5% 5% 10% Change residence 3% 5% 5% E-ZPass User n = 140 E-ZPass Prospect n = 154 Resident n = 152 0% 4% 6% 6% 74% 63% 50% 49% 11% 13% 18% 63% 67% Both Prospects and 43% Residents are more likely 44% than current E-ZPass Users to say they would change their route if new tolls were instituted. E-ZPass User - 4 E-ZPass User - 5 Very likely E-ZPass Prospect - 4 E-ZPass Prospect - 5 Very likely Resident - 4 Resident - 5 Very likely 20% 40% 60% Q27a-h. How likely would you be to adopt each of the following in response to that new toll? ASKED ONLY OF THOSE WHO WORK 3+ DAYS 43 OUTSIDE OF THE HOME 80% 100% Some Commuters Would Switch Modes in Response to Possible New Toll; They Say They Would Most Likely Try Carpooling, Vanpooling and Teleworking Commute in carpool African-American Prospects and Users with incomes under $50K are more likely than their counterparts to respond by commuting by bus. 10% 8% 18% 26% 11% 15% 7% 11% 18% Commute in vanpool 6% 8% 14% 5% 16% 21% 5% 9% 14% While differences across the groups are fairly small, Prospects tend to express the greatest likelihood of changing modes. Residents are less likely than E-ZPass Users or prospects to say they would telework. Telework 1-2 days or more 4% 14% 18% 4% 16% 20% 5% 6% 11% Commute by bus 3%4% 7% 3% 8% 11% 4%5% 9% E-ZPass User - 4 E-ZPass User n = 140 E-ZPass Prospect n = 154 Resident n = 152 E-ZPass Prospect - 4 Resident - 4 0% E-ZPass User - 5 Very likely 20% 40% E-ZPass Prospect - 5 Very likely 60% Resident - 5 Very likely Q27a-h. How likely would you be to adopt each of the following in response to that new toll? ASKED ONLY OF THOSE WHO WORK 3+ DAYS 44 OUTSIDE OF THE HOME 80% 100% More Are Aware of Advanced Electronic Tolling Than Congestion Pricing Prospects who are familiar with E-ZPass are more likely than Prospects who are not to be aware of advanced electronic tolling. 20% Aware of congestion pricing 19% Users and Residents who are aware of advanced electronic tolling are more likely to also be aware of congestion pricing, and vice versa. 16% E-ZPass User E-ZPass Prospect 53% Aware of advanced electronic tolling Resident 47% 51% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% Q28. Prior to this survey, had you ever heard or read anything about a concept called “variable priced tolling,” sometimes called “congestion pricing”? Q30. Prior to this survey, had you heard or read anything about this advanced 45 type of electronic tolling? 100% Of Those Aware of Congestion Pricing, Prospects Are Most Likely to Say They Are Familiar with It Base sizes small. Interpret with caution. 5 - Very familiar 23% 26% 18% 4 21% 26% 21% 3 16% E-ZPass Prospect 52% 36% E-ZPass Prospects Top-2-Box 30% 39% Residents Top-2-Box 10% 16% 12% 1 - Not at all familiar E-ZPass User n = 39 E-ZPass Prospect n = 38 Resident n = 33 E-ZPass Users Top-2-Box 10% 16% 18% 2 E-ZPass User 44% 0% 20% 40% 60% Resident Q29. How familiar would you say you are with variable priced tolling or congestion pricing? ASKED ONLY OF THOSE AWARE 46 80% 100% Of Those Aware of Advanced Electronic Tolling, Most Are Familiar with It 5 - Very familiar 12% 4 67% E-ZPass Prospects Top-2-Box 66% 6% 10% 8% 1 - Not at all familiar E-ZPass Prospect E-ZPass Users Top-2-Box 3% 5% 7% 2 E-ZPass User n = 105 E-ZPass Prospect n = 94 Resident n = 104 76% 22% 26% 15% 18% 18% 3 E-ZPass User 64% 45% 40% 0% 20% Residents Top-2-Box 40% 60% Resident Q31. How familiar would you say you are with this type of electronic tolling? ASKED ONLY OF THOSE AWARE 47 80% 100% Outline of Report I. E-ZPass Awareness and Familiarity II. E-ZPass Usage III. Propsective Users IV. E-ZPass Perceptions V. Communications VI. Electronic Tolling: The Future VII. HOV Lanes Use and HOT Lanes Perceptions 48 The Three Groups Are Equally Likely to Be Aware of the HOV Lanes on I-64; Prospects Are More Likely than Other Audiences to Be Aware of the HOV Lanes on I-264 97% 96% HOV lanes on I-64 96% 73% 89% HOV lanes on I-264 72% E-ZPass User E-ZPass Prospect 0% 20% 40% 60% Resident 49 Q36. Prior to this survey, were you aware of the HOV lanes on I-64? Q41. Prior to this survey, were you aware of the HOV lanes on I-264? 80% 100% Prospects Are More Likely to Be Familiar with the I-64 HOV Lanes 53% 5 - Very familiar Prospects who are aware of E-ZPass are more likely than Prospects who are not to be familiar with the I-64 HOV lanes. 58% 78% E-ZPass Prospects Top-2-Box 10% 4% 6% 2 E-ZPass Prospect E-ZPass Users Top-2-Box 14% 9% 13% 3 75% 9% 8% 6% 1 - Not at all familiar E-ZPass User n = 194 E-ZPass Prospect n = 192 Resident n = 196 67% 14% 10% 17% 4 E-ZPass User 68% 0% Residents Top-2-Box 20% 40% 60% Resident Q37. How familiar are you with the HOV lanes on I-64? ASKED ONLY OF THOSE AWARE 50 80% 100% Prospects Are also More Likely to Use the HOV Lanes on I-64 Users, Prospects, and Residents who use the I-64 HOV lanes at least once a week are more likely than Users, Prospects, and Residents who do not to also use the I-264 HOV lanes at least once a week and vice versa. E-ZPass User n = 194 E-ZPass Prospect n = 192 Resident n = 196 8% More than 3 times a week 9% 19% 4% 8% 2% 3 times a week 29% 32% 28% 1 to 2 times a week E-ZPass Prospect Resident 41% Never Don't know E-ZPass User 57% 61% 1% 1% 1% 0% 20% 40% 60% Q38. In a typical week, how often, if ever, do you use the HOV lanes on I-64? ASKED ONLY OF THOSE AWARE 51 80% 100% Opinion Leaders are community and civic leaders who have the power & potential to influence others. Some support for HOT lanes already exists among Opinion Leaders. For example, 43% of E-ZPass Prospects who are Opinion Leaders support HOT Lanes on I-64. Without Prior Information about HOT Lanes, Roughly a Third Are Supportive of HOT Lanes on I-64; Residents Are Most Supportive 19% 23% 23% 5 - Very supportive 8% 12% 14% 4 E-ZPass Prospects Top-2-Box 37% 42% 41% 37% 1 - Not at all suppportive E-ZPass Prospect 35% 6% 6% 7% 2 Residents Top-2-Box 2% 2% 2% Don't know E-ZPass User n = 194 E-ZPass Prospect n = 192 Resident n = 196 E-ZPass Users Top-2-Box 24% 17% 16% 3 E-ZPass User 27% 0% 20% 40% 60% Resident Q39. Based on this description, how supportive would you be of converting the HOV lanes on I-64 to HOT lanes, that is High Occupancy 52 Toll lanes? ASKED ONLY OF THOSE AWARE 80% 100% Supporters of HOT Lanes on I-64 Do Not Seem to Have Clearly Defined Reasons for Supporting HOT Lanes, Although a Few Mention that the Lanes Would Ease Congestion and Encourage People to Carpool Reasons for supporting HOT lanes on I-64 E-ZPass User n = 194 E-ZPass Prospect n = 192 Resident n = 196 E-ZPass Users E-ZPass Prospects Residents Supportive of HOT lanes 16% 23% 22% Would help ease congestion 5% 6% 6% Encourage people to carpool 1% 3% 1% Q45. Why do you say that (support or not support HOT lanes on I-64)? 53 Most Often, Non-supporters of HOT Lanes on I-64 Say That They Don’t Want to Pay for It, They’ve Already Paid Taxes, or It’s a Waste of Money Reasons for not supporting HOT lanes on I-64 E-ZPass User n = 194 E-ZPass Prospect n = 192 Resident n = 196 E-ZPass Users E-ZPass Prospects Residents Don’t want to pay for it/don’t want any more tolls 12% 13% 9% Not supportive of HOT lanes 20% 11% 11% Already paid taxes, shouldn’t have to pay tolls 8% 10% 9% It doesn’t support single drivers 4% 6% 7% Would make traffic worse 4% 4% 4% Fine the way it is 5% 3% 4% It’s waste of money 2% 2% 3% Q45. Why do you say that (support or not support HOT lanes on I-64)? 54 Those with Neutral Views of HOT Lanes on I-64 Believe the Lanes Would Have No Impact on Them or that They Need More Information to Come to a Decision Reasons for neutral view of HOT lanes on I-64 E-ZPass User n = 194 E-ZPass Prospect n = 192 Resident n = 196 E-ZPass Users E-ZPass Prospects Residents Does not impact me 13% 10% 11% Need more information 3% 4% 7% Q40. Why do you say that (support or not support HOT lanes on I-64)? 55 Prospects Are Also Slightly More Familiar with the I-264 HOV Lanes 45% 5 - Very familiar 49% 3 E-ZPass Prospect E-ZPass Prospects Top-2-Box 18% 8% 9% 60% 13% Residents Top-2-Box 17% 12% 13% 1 - Not at all familiar E-ZPass User n = 146 E-ZPass Prospect n = 179 Resident n = 148 67% 17% 8% 2 E-ZPass User E-ZPass Users Top-2-Box 13% 12% 11% 4 58% 55% 0% 20% 40% 60% Resident Q42. How familiar are you with the HOV lanes on I-264? ASKED ONLY OF THOSE AWARE 56 80% 100% Prospects Are Also More Likely to Use the I-264 HOV Lanes 6% More than 3 times a week 5% 15% 3% 6% 3% 3 times a week E-ZPass User 19% 1 to 2 times a week 21% E-ZPass User n = 146 E-ZPass Prospect n = 179 Resident n = 148 Resident 71% 45% Never Don't know E-ZPass Prospect 31% 70% 1% 3% 1% 0% 20% 40% 60% Q43. In a typical week, how often, if ever, do you use the HOV lanes on I-264? ASKED ONLY OF THOSE AWARE 57 80% 100% Similar to Support for the I-64 HOT Lanes, About a Third Support I-264 HOT Lanes Those in all three groups who are supportive of the HOT lanes on I-64 are more likely than those who are not to be supportive of HOT lanes on I-264. 34% E-ZPass Prospects Top-2-Box 5% 4% 8% 2 37% 45% 45% 39% 1 - Not at all suppportive E-ZPass Prospect E-ZPass Users Top-2-Box 21% 16% 16% 3 E-ZPass User 28% 8% 13% 15% 4 Don't know E-ZPass User n = 146 E-ZPass Prospect n = 179 Resident n = 148 20% 21% 22% 5 - Very supportive Residents Top-2-Box 1% 1% 1% 0% 20% 40% 60% Resident Q44. Based on this description, how supportive would you be of converting the HOV lanes on I-264 to HOT lanes, that is High Occupancy 58 Toll lanes? ASKED ONLY OF THOSE AWARE 80% 100% Most Often, Supporters of HOT Lanes on I-264 Mention an Improvement in Traffic Congestion and Encouraging Carpooling – But, for the Most Part, Supporters Do Not Have Clearly Defined Reasons for Supporting the HOT Lanes Reasons for supporting HOT lanes on I-264 E-ZPass User n = 146 E-ZPass Prospect n = 179 Resident n = 148 E-ZPass Users E-ZPass Prospects Residents Supportive of HOT lanes 16% 20% 23% Would help ease congestion 6% 7% 4% Encourage people to carpool 3% 2% 1% Q45. Why do you say that (support or not support HOT lanes on I-264)? 59 Most Often Criticism of HOT Lanes on I-264 Relate to Money: Not Wanting to Pay for It, Already Paid Taxes, It’s a Waste of Money Reasons for not supporting HOT lanes on I-264 E-ZPass User n = 146 E-ZPass Prospect n = 179 Resident n = 148 E-ZPass Users E-ZPass Prospects Residents Don’t want to pay for it/don’t want any more tolls 14% 18% 13% Not supportive of HOT lanes 11% 6% 7% Already paid taxes, shouldn’t have to pay tolls 6% 7% 5% It doesn’t support single drivers 2% 4% 5% Would make traffic worse 10% 7% 5% Fine the way it is 3% 2% 3% It’s waste of money 1% 2% 1% Q45. Why do you say that (support or not support HOT lanes on I-264)? 60 Those Who Adopt a Neutral View Regarding HOT Lanes on I-264 Do Not Envision Potential HOT Lanes on this Corridor Impacting Them or They Say That They Need More Information Reasons for neutral view of HOT lanes on I-264 E-ZPass User n = 146 E-ZPass Prospect n = 179 Resident n = 148 E-ZPass Users E-ZPass Prospects Residents Does not impact me 13% 9% 14% Need more information 3% 6% 3% Q45. Why do you say that (support or not support HOT lanes on I-64)? 61 Support for HOT Lanes on I-64 Is Fairly Consistent across Gender, Race and Level of Education Gender Race Education Male Female White Other Less than college grad Support HOT lanes on I-64 36% 31% 36% 25% 29% 36% Do not support HOT lanes on I-64 62% 68% 63% 73% 69% 62% Q39. Based on this description, how supportive would you be of converting the HOV lanes on I-64 to HOT lanes, that is High Occupancy 62 Toll lanes? ASKED ONLY OF THOSE AWARE College grad Support for HOT Lanes on I-64 Is Fairly Consistent among Those Working and Not Working and Voters and Non-Voters; Support Increases with Income Employment Registered Voter Income Employed Not employed Under $35K $35$79K $80$99K $100K or higher Yes No Support HOT lanes on I-64 34% 27% 27% 31% 35% 42% 33% 28% Do not support HOT lanes on I-64 64% 70% 72% 68% 61% 57% 65% 72% Q39. Based on this description, how supportive would you be of converting the HOV lanes on I-64 to HOT lanes, that is High Occupancy 63 Toll lanes? ASKED ONLY OF THOSE AWARE Similar to I-64, Support for HOT Lanes on I-264 Is Fairly Consistent across Gender, Race and Level of Education Gender Race Education Male Female White Other Less than college grad Support HOT lanes on I-264 34% 32% 35% 26% 29% 37% Do not support HOT lanes on I-264 64% 67% 64% 72% 70% 62% Q39. Based on this description, how supportive would you be of converting the HOV lanes on I-264 to HOT lanes, that is High Occupancy 64 Toll lanes? ASKED ONLY OF THOSE AWARE College grad Support for HOT Lanes on I-264 Lanes Is Slightly Higher among those Employed and those with Higher Incomes ($80,000 and Higher) Employment Registered Voter Income Employed Not employed Under $35K $35$79K $80$99K $100K or higher Yes No Support HOT lanes on I-264 36% 23% 28% 29% 41% 39% 33% 34% Do not support HOT lanes on I-264 64% 76% 72% 70% 56% 61% 66% 66% Q39. Based on this description, how supportive would you be of converting the HOV lanes on I-264 to HOT lanes, that is High Occupancy 65 Toll lanes? ASKED ONLY OF THOSE AWARE Conclusions and Implications 66 Conclusion & Implication: E-ZPass Conclusion: Levels of awareness and familiarity with E-ZPass are high among motorists in Hampton Roads, even among those who do not currently use E-ZPass in Hampton Roads. More than three-fourths of E-ZPass Prospects and Residents are aware of E-ZPass; and, about two-thirds of Prospects and Residents who are aware of E-ZPass also say they are familiar with it. Implication: Significantly growing awareness of E-ZPass among Prospects may not increase their adoption of E-ZPass. Converting Prospects to Users by overcoming their concerns or persuading them of the benefits, ease of usage, and affordability may be more effective than growing awareness. 67 Conclusion & Implication: E-ZPass Conclusion: Current Users are especially satisfied with E-ZPass. More than 9 out of 10 current Users say they are satisfied with E-ZPass; and, more than 9 out of 10 would recommend it to family and friends. Implication: Satisfied users may be good “marketers” for E-ZPass. In fact, they may already be “marketing” EZpass through “word of mouth.” Explore the use of “testimonials” or “usage scenarios” with satisfied users to market E-ZPass. In the development of key messages explore the effectiveness of benefits Users most value: saving time and not having to carry cash. But, don’t forget the lower income levels of Prospects and the potential appeal of “cost” messages. 68 Conclusion & Implication: E-ZPass Conclusion: “Familiarity” increases the likelihood of usage of E-ZPass. E-ZPass prospects are more likely to say they will obtain an E-ZPass in the next year if they are already familiar with it. Implication: Use marketing and communications as a way to increase familiarity of E-ZPass, not just grow awareness. Use marketing to educate and inform motorists about E-ZPass, not just attract their attention. 69 Conclusion & Implication: E-ZPass Conclusion: Both current Users (80%) and Prospects (50%) tend to think the cost is cheaper with E-ZPass than paying at the booth. But, Prospects are much less likely to hold this view. In fact, half of Prospects do not think it is cheaper with E-ZPass. Thus, because they do not have strong reasons to use E-ZPass, have lower incomes than Users, and may not save any money with E-ZPass, they have not obtained an E-ZPass. Implication: For some Prospects, cost may be a factor in not obtaining an E-ZPass. While they may believe E-ZPass could save them time and is convenient, it also costs money. Explore the development of messages and promotions that educate Prospects about the cost of E-ZPass and any cost savings. Consider the implementation of promotions that offer a cost savings with E-ZPass, e.g., every fifth trip with E-ZPass is free. 70 Conclusion & Implication: E-ZPass Conclusion: Marketing messages about time and ease tend to post the strongest levels of recall: “It’s easier with E-ZPass,” “E-ZPass is faster,” “People save time with E-ZPass.” This holds true for both current Users and Prospects. Implication: Messages recalled and an important reason for using E-ZPass (saving time) are consistent. Continue to communicate “saving time” as a benefit of E-ZPass, but don’t overlook other message components or promotions that may be persuasive, i.e., cost. 71 Conclusion & Implication: New Tolls Conclusion: While many commuters say that they would make no changes in their commute in the event of new tolls, about one-fifth would try commuting in a carpool or vanpool or they would telework. Implication: Other research has indicated that ridesharing awareness and usage is low and underdeveloped in the Hampton Roads’ area. Instituting new tolls in the Hampton Roads’ area may have an impact on mode choices and provide an opportunity to educate commuters about their commute options. Take advantage of the opportunity to grow the use of ridesharing in Hampton Roads that would be provided by instituting new tolls. 72 Conclusion & Implication: Advanced Electronic Tolling and Congestion Pricing Conclusion: Motorists in Hampton Roads are more likely to be aware of and familiar with advanced electronic tolling than congestion pricing. Implication: Introduction of congestion pricing in Hampton Roads will be more challenging than introduction of advanced electronic support. Advanced electronic tolling would start in a more favorable position simply because a greater level of awareness and familiarity already exist. 73 Conclusion & Implication: HOT Lanes Conclusion: Support for possible HOT lanes on I-64 and I-264 is surprisingly high. Without prior information about HOT Lanes on these routes, about a third of respondents said that they supported making the HOV lanes on these routes into HOT lanes. Some Opinion Leaders are even more supportive. More than 4 out of 10, or 43%, of Prospects who are also Opinion Leaders support HOT lanes on I-64. Implication: Explore the possibility of implementing HOT lanes on I-64/I-264. HOT lanes could be a way of implementing new tolls in a way that is “acceptable” to residents and introduces them to advanced electronic tolling and congestion pricing. Put in place a strong marketing/communications plan to build on the support that already exists. Explore the potential of utilizing Opinion Leader support by transforming Opinion Leaders into Apostles for HOT lanes. 74 One Final Observation 75 Nearly Half of Respondents Agreed to Participate in Future Transportation Research E-ZPass User 47% E-ZPass Prospect 48% This level of interest is slightly higher than is typical in other areas in Virginia, suggesting a fairly high level of interest in this and other transportation topics in Hampton Roads. 40% Resident 0% 20% 40% 60% Q57. Would you be interested in participating in future research, such as focus groups, telephone interviews, or internet surveys, related to 76 transportation issues in your area? 80% 100% Summary of Key Findings 77 Summary of Key Findings • Awareness of E-ZPass is fairly high among motorists in Hampton Roads. It will be difficult to grow awareness higher, and increased awareness will not generate much new usage. • New usage will come about by persuading Prospects of the benefits and ease of usage and overcoming their concerns about cost. • Current users are quite satisfied with E-ZPass. Explore utilizing this satisfaction to market E-ZPass to Prospects through testimonials or usage scenarios. • “Familiarity” increases the likelihood of usage of E-ZPass. Use marketing and communications as a way to educate motorists about E-ZPass and increase familiarity – not just to grow awareness. 78 Summary of Key Findings • Concerns about cost seem to be preventing some Prospects from obtaining an E-ZPass. Confront issues of cost directly by developing messages and promotions about cost and cost savings. • Don’t forget benefits that matter to current Users, e.g., saving time and easy payment of tolls. Use marketing messages to reinforce recognition of these benefits among satisfied customers – and, potentially, convert Prospects to Users. • Introduction of new tolls in Hampton Roads would prompt some commuters to try alternate modes, e.g., carpooling. If new tolls are introduced in Hampton Roads, take advantage of this opportunity to grow ridesharing through a strong marketing and communications program. 79 Summary of Key Findings • Awareness of advanced electronic tolling is much higher than awareness of congestion pricing. In fact, only about 20% have heard or read anything about congestion pricing. Strong communications will be necessary to introduce congestion pricing in Hampton Roads. • Support for possible HOT lanes on I-64 and I-264 is surprisingly high. Implementation of HOT lanes on I-64 and I-264 may be an important way to introduce new tolls and congestion pricing in Hampton Roads. Explore the possibility of implementing HOT lanes on I-64/ I-264. 80 Appendix 81 Demographic Profile of E-ZPass Users, Prospects, and Residents 82 E-ZPass Users Skew Slightly Older and Prospects Slightly Younger E-ZPass User mean – 9% Ages 29 and younger 9% 45 18% 42 19% 23% 21% Ages 30 to 39 Resident mean – 30% 30% Ages 40 to 49 44 38% 28% 32% Ages 50 plus 0% 20% Q2. In what year were you born? 83 E-ZPass Prospect mean - 40% E-ZPass User 43% E-ZPass Prospect Resident 60% 80% 100% E-ZPass Users, Prospects and Residents Are Equally Likely to Be Male; A Similar Pattern Holds True for Females 43% 45% Male 43% E-ZPass User E-ZPass Prospect 58% Resident 55% Female 57% 0% 20% Q56. Gender (interviewer recorded) 84 40% 60% 80% 100% Prospects Are More Likely than Users to Be African-American White, non-Hispanic 64% 9% African-American, Black American Indian, Alaska Native 16% Asian Hispanic, Latino 1% 2% 2% E-ZPass User E-ZPass Prospect Resident 4% 4% 3% Other Don't know, no answer 24% 4% 1% 2% 1% 2% 2% 2% 1% 0% 0% 20% 40% 60% Q47. Which one of the following best describes your racial background? 85 82% 75% 80% 100% Users and Prospects Have Slightly Lower Levels of Education than Other Residents Some high school or less 3% 2% 1% Some college or technical school 44% 35% 35% E-ZPass Prospects College degree 30% 24% 36% 59% Residents College degree 19% 20% 23% Post-grad studies or degree E-ZPass Prospect E-ZPass Users College degree 26% College graduate E-ZPass User 49% 15% 17% 14% High school graduate 0% 20% 40% 60% Resident Q46. Which of the following categories includes the last year or grade of school you have completed? 86 80% 100% While All Three Groups Tend to Be Employed, A Greater Proportion of E-ZPass Users Is Retired 62% Employed full time 10% 10% 9% Employed part time 7% 5% 6% Not currently employed 2% 2% Retired E-ZPass User 10% E-ZPass Prospect Resident 5% 3% 5% Stay at home parent 6% 7% 5% Other Don't know, no answer 1% 2% 0% 0% 20% 40% Q50. What is your employment status? Are you: 87 70% 73% 60% 80% 100% E-ZPass Users, Prospects and Residents Are Equally Likely to Work Three or More Days Outside the Home 92% 90% 90% Three or more One or two E-ZPass Prospect Resident 3% 6% 4% None E-ZPass User n = 152 E-ZPass Prospect n = 171 Resident n = 168 E-ZPass User 5% 4% 5% 0% 20% 40% 60% Q6b. How many days a week do you work outside your home? ASKED OF THOSE WHO CURRENTLY WORK FULL OR PART TIME 88 80% 100% No Distinct Occupational Differences Are Apparent Across the Three Groups 16% 14% Professional Executive Administratrive Service Building Military Retail Real Estate Agriculture 18% 12% 16% 9% 13% 13% 7% 9% 5% 7% 8% 3% 5% 6% 4% 3% 6% 5% 1% 2% 1% 1% 1% 1% E-ZPass User E-ZPass Prospect Resident 33% 29% 29% Other, don't know, no answer E-ZPass User n = 147 E-ZPass Prospect n = 164 Resident n = 167 25% 0% 20% 40% 60% Q51. Which of the following best describes your work or occupation? ASKED OF THOSE EMPLOYED 89 80% 100% E-ZPass Users Have Slightly Higher Incomes 5% Under $25,000 E-ZPass User mean – $74K 10% 9% 11% 15% 10% $25,000 to $34,999 E-ZPass Prospect mean - $67K 13% 16% 15% $35,000 to $49,999 Resident mean – 30% 23% 26% $50,000 to $74,999 $70K 21% 15% 22% $75,000 to $99,999 7% 8% 6% $100,000 to $124,999 E-ZPass User 15% 11% 11% $125,000 and higher 0% 20% E-ZPass Prospect Resident 40% 60% Q5. Which of the following best represents your total annual household income? 90 80% 100% Not Surprisingly, The Majority Commute Alone – And, All Three Groups Are Equally Likely to Use This Commute Mode 90% 85% 89% Drive alone 6% 4% 5% Carpool Vanpool 1% 1% 1% Bus 0% 1% 1% E-ZPass User n = 147 E-ZPass Prospect n = 164 Resident n = 167 E-ZPass Prospect Resident 2% 7% 2% Other Do not commute E-ZPass User 1% 2% 1% 0% 20% 40% 60% Q52. Which of the following transportation modes do you use most often when commuting to work? ASKED OF THOSE EMPLOYED 91 80% 100% Thank You! For additional information on this report, please contact Dr. Karen Smith Southeastern Institute of Research 804-358-8981 92