Original 765kV Public Open Day
Title
First Name
Last Name
Company/Organization
Date
Issue
Issue
Ms
Margie
Adriaanse
We Care (Communty Services)
2000/02/22
7
2. Cultural Sites
There is no knowledge of any cultural sites in the area of the Hydra Sub-station.
Ms
Margie
Adriaanse
We Care (Communty Services)
2000/02/22
1
10. Regional economic benefit
This project will benefit the region’s growth.
Ms
Margie
Adriaanse
We Care (Communty Services)
2000/02/22
1
11. Local economic benefit
It is understood that there will be limited benefit to the local economy.
Ms
Margie
Adriaanse
We Care (Communty Services)
2000/02/22
4
5. Venue
The Public Open Day should be held at a more central point to allow for more
participation
Ms
Margie
Adriaanse
We Care (Communty Services)
2000/02/22
1
9. National economic benefit
This project will benefit the country’s national growth.
Ms
Margie
Adriaanse
We Care (Communty Services)
2000/02/22
2
Strict security with adequate fencing and signage must be in place at the sub-station.
Ms
Margie
Adriaanse
We Care (Communty Services)
2000/02/22
1
Will there be sub-contracting opportunities for locals and will these be advertised in the
local media? Eskom should investigate potential opportunities for locals that would
include bush clearing, fence erecting, administration, security etc.
Ms
Margie
Adriaanse
We Care (Communty Services)
2000/02/22
3
2. Regional Alternatives
There is an awareness that other regional alternatives to upgrading De Aar do exist,
however, it is understood that this project would benefit De Aar, even if only indirectly.
There is support for this project.
Ms
Margie
Adriaanse
We Care (Communty Services)
2000/02/22
2
4. Electromagnetic Fields
People living along the new route and next to the sub-station must be informed about the
Electromagnetic Fields.
Ms
Margie
Adriaanse
We Care (Communty Services)
2000/02/22
2
3. Loss of Residence
Do not anticipate any loss of residence. Will the Hydra Guesthouse be affected?
S Dunsmore, PBA: This must be investigated.
Ms
Margie
Adriaanse
We Care (Communty Services)
2000/02/22
6
1. General
Eskom is fortunate that the Hydra plant is not situated in a sensitive environment, ie. No
wetlands, etc. This area has already been damaged by roads, gravel, tar and railwa
K van der Merwe, Eskom: Every regional Eskom office has an
Environmental Unit. These individuals ensure that activities,
whether these are maintenance or the erection of transmission
lines, are carried out in terms of Environmental Legislation.
612926878
Page 1 of 27
Action
K van der Merwe, Eskom: Yes, all sub-stations have emergency
plans. Also, sub-stations adhere to NOSA safety regulations. Local
emergency services are in communication with the sub-station and
action will be taken
Mr K van der Merwe, Eskom: Perhaps only small contracting
opportunities in relation to other projects. Also, there are a limited
number of companies which are able to erect power lines.
Original 765kV Public Open Day
Mnr
W
de Vlang
2000/02/28
3
2. The new 400 kV route to Salene - Doornboom
There are farms that have broilers along this route.
Ds
WJ
Dreyer
Steinthal Landgoed
2000/02/21
2
10. Electromagnetic Fields
Are animals and vegetation affected by EMFs?
Ds
WJ
Dreyer
Steinthal Landgoed
2000/02/21
8
Construction activities should be avoided between March and September when the
Steinthal Farm and School has its busiest activities.
Ds
WJ
Dreyer
Steinthal Landgoed
2000/02/21
2
Ds
WJ
Dreyer
Steinthal Landgoed
2000/02/21
3
Ds
WJ
Dreyer
Steinthal Landgoed
2000/02/21
6
9. Alien Vegetation
The possibility of importing alien vegetation such as Hakia, Port Jackson, with building
material should be avoided. This should be addressed in the Environmental
management plan
Ds
WJ
Dreyer
Steinthal Landgoed
2000/02/21
2
Property could be leased out to Eskom for construction camps as there is water available
at these sites. Negotiations should take place timeously.
Ds
WJ
Dreyer
Steinthal Landgoed
2000/02/21
7
2. Historical Sites
While constructing a line 13 years ago in the Agterwitzenberg area, Eskom damaged an
historical cannon station. This has never been repaired.
Ds
WJ
Dreyer
Steinthal Landgoed
2000/02/21
2
Ds
WJ
Dreyer
Steinthal Landgoed
2000/02/21
1
612926878
Page 2 of 27
S Dunsmore: Research is on-going in this field, but is currently
inconclusive.
Potential developments to promote agri-tourism could be negatively impacted on by the
transmission lines due to the visual impacts.
If the southern route is used, it could follow an existing 400 kV Line, this would run
across arable land of the Steinthal school. Would it be possible to move the proposed
line approximately 200 meters to maximise the available arable land?
Construction camps could lead to potential social problems at the Steinthal school.
Discussions should take place timeously with the Board.
Foreign capital investment in the area is important to future growth and the sustainability
of existing infrastructure, more transmission lines could be detrimental to this.
S Dunsmore – this would be negotiated with Eskom.
Original 765kV Public Open Day
Mnr
K
Du Plessis
Modderasrivier
2000/02/21
6
1. Erosion
Erosion on Eskom access roads is a problem. Preventative action should include the
construction of berms. The farmer, and/or private contractors could maintain access
roads. Eskom should compensate the landowner if he appoints the contractor or hires
the necessary equipment.
Alternatively, Eskom should pay the farmers to build and maintain the access roads.
Mnr
K
Du Plessis
Modderasrivier
2000/02/21
8
1. Agricultural activities during construction
Gates should be closed at all times by Eskom officials to avoid the integrating of rams
and ewes.
Mnr
Braam
du Preez
SAFCOL
2000/02/28
2
2. Aesthetics
What will the Salene Switching station look like in appearance?
S Dunsmore – It will be mainly a steel structure. I think that we
should elaborate on this slightly
Site 1a – if the switching station is situated here, there will be a higher visual impact.
Me
Calla
Du Toit
Ouplaas
2000/02/21
8
Discussions pertaining to construction activities should be done well in advance.
Me
Calla
Du Toit
Ouplaas
2000/02/21
2
Certain of the proposed routes could affect labourer cottages, this can only be finally
determined once the route becomes fixed.
K van der Merwe – Eskom. This matter will be dealt with in parallel
with the landowner negotiations.
Me
Calla
Du Toit
Ouplaas
2000/02/21
3
Alternative Routes – Karoo Poort through to Malmesbury
The proposed route should preferably avoid the valley.
North of the pink route is highly populated and should preferably avoided.
There is less development or proposed development north of the pink line.
J Tooley – Yes, but there are problems in terms of mountain
crossings, forestry and ecologically senstive areas.
Me
Calla
Du Toit
Ouplaas
2000/02/21
7
Notice must be taken of a restored, historical stable when planning the route.
Notice must be taken of a 150 year old Akkerbos (oak tree orchard or orchards???) that
is situated approximately 100 m of existing line.
4. Nature Reserve
The area over the Agterwitsenberg mountains is currently being registered as a nature
reserve. More specifically, the historical buildings, cannon site, stone walls.
Me
Calla
Du Toit
Ouplaas
2000/02/21
3
Suggestion is to cross the existing line before going over the Witsenberg Mountain.
612926878
Page 3 of 27
Original 765kV Public Open Day
Me
Calla
Du Toit
Ouplaas
2000/02/21
8
3. Construction Activities
Construction activities should preferably take place in the winter months, from May to
August.
5. Access roads
Eskom should, as far as possible make use of existing access roads.
4. Height servitudes
The maximum height allowed for vegetation under the transmission lines could affect
some of the orchards and windbreaker avenues.
Me
Calla
Du Toit
Ouplaas
2000/02/21
8
The ladders used by the pickers are fairly tall, how much clearance space is required in
terms of the transmission lines?
Me
Calla
Du Toit
Ouplaas
2000/02/21
2
9. Theft
Theft of equipment and fruit is a common problem that needs to be addressed. The
former is however easier to control
Me
Calla
Du Toit
Ouplaas
2000/02/21
2
8. Loss of Residence/work areas
The transmission lines could affect working areas/ sheds.
Me
Calla
Du Toit
Ouplaas
2000/02/21
4
4. Decommissioning
What action will be taken in future when the 765 kV line is not longer sufficient?
S Dunsmore: - Explained the project, the alternatives that need to
be examined and Eskom’s policy of future strategic planning.
Me
Calla
Du Toit
Ouplaas
2000/02/21
5
1. Construction dates
When will construction commence?
S Dunsmore – about 2010.
Me
Calla
Du Toit
Ouplaas
2000/02/21
2
4. Construction camps
Discussions pertaining to construction camps should be done well in advance.
Me
Calla
Du Toit
Ouplaas
2000/02/21
3
Is Kudu Gas not a cheaper option to transmission lines?
Mnr
FJ
du Toit
Witzenberg Propert
2000/02/21
2
9. Theft
Theft of equipment and fruit is a common problem that needs to be addressed. The
former is however easier to control
Mnr
FJ
du Toit
Witzenberg Propert
2000/02/21
2
Certain of the proposed routes could affect labourer cottages, this can only be finally
determined once the route becomes fixed.
Mnr
FJ
du Toit
Witzenberg Propert
2000/02/21
2
8. Loss of Residence/work areas
The transmission lines could affect working areas/ sheds.
Mnr
FJ
du Toit
Witzenberg Propert
2000/02/21
8
Discussions pertaining to construction activities should be done well in advance.
612926878
Page 4 of 27
S Dunsmore , K van der Merwe – the minimum requirement is
20m. This doesn’t seem right.
K van der Merwe – Eskom. This matter will be dealt with in parallel
with the landowner negotiations.
Original 765kV Public Open Day
Mnr
FJ
du Toit
Witzenberg Propert
2000/02/21
5
1. Construction dates
When will construction commence?
Mnr
FJ
du Toit
Witzenberg Propert
2000/02/21
8
3. Construction Activities
Construction activities should preferably take place in the winter months, from May to
August.
5. Access roads
Eskom should, as far as possible make use of existing access roads.
4. Height servitudes
The maximum height allowed for vegetation under the transmission lines could affect
some of the orchards and windbreaker avenues.
Mnr
FJ
du Toit
Witzenberg Propert
2000/02/21
8
The ladders used by the pickers are fairly tall, how much clearance space is required in
terms of the transmission lines?
Mnr
FJ
du Toit
Witzenberg Propert
2000/02/21
3
Is Kudu Gas not a cheaper option to transmission lines?
Mnr
FJ
du Toit
Witzenberg Propert
2000/02/21
4
4. Decommissioning
What action will be taken in future when the 765 kV line is not longer sufficient?
S Dunsmore: - Explained the project, the alternatives that need to
be examined and Eskom’s policy of future strategic planning.
Mnr
FJ
du Toit
Witzenberg Propert
2000/02/21
3
Alternative Routes – Karoo Poort through to Malmesbury
The proposed route should preferably avoid the valley.
North of the pink route is highly populated and should preferably avoided.
There is less development or proposed development north of the pink line.
J Tooley – Yes, but there are problems in terms of mountain
crossings, forestry and ecologically senstive areas.
Mnr
Jan
Eksteen
2000/02/21
2
8. Loss of Residence/work areas
The transmission lines could affect working areas/ sheds.
Mnr
Jan
Eksteen
2000/02/21
8
The ladders used by the pickers are fairly tall, how much clearance space is required in
terms of the transmission lines?
S Dunsmore , K van der Merwe – the minimum requirement is
20m. This doesn’t seem right.
Mnr
Jan
Eksteen
2000/02/21
3
Alternative Routes – Karoo Poort through to Malmesbury
The proposed route should preferably avoid the valley.
North of the pink route is highly populated and should preferably avoided.
There is less development or proposed development north of the pink line.
J Tooley – Yes, but there are problems in terms of mountain
crossings, forestry and ecologically senstive areas.
Mnr
Jan
Eksteen
2000/02/21
2
4. Construction camps
Discussions pertaining to construction camps should be done well in advance.
Mnr
Jan
Eksteen
2000/02/21
2
9. Theft
Theft of equipment and fruit is a common problem that needs to be addressed. The
former is however easier to control
612926878
Page 5 of 27
S Dunsmore – about 2010.
S Dunsmore , K van der Merwe – the minimum requirement is
20m. This doesn’t seem right.
Original 765kV Public Open Day
Mnr
Jan
Eksteen
2000/02/21
3
Is Kudu Gas not a cheaper option to transmission lines?
Mnr
Jan
Eksteen
2000/02/21
8
3. Construction Activities
Construction activities should preferably take place in the winter months, from May to
August.
Mnr
Jan
Eksteen
2000/02/21
2
Mnr
Jan
Eksteen
2000/02/21
5
Mnr
Jan
Eksteen
2000/02/21
4
Certain of the proposed routes could affect labourer cottages, this can only be finally
determined once the route becomes fixed.
4. Height servitudes
The maximum height allowed for vegetation under the transmission lines could affect
some
of the orchards
1. Construction
dates and windbreaker avenues.
When will construction commence?
5. Access roads
Eskom
should, as far as possible make use of existing access roads.
4. Decommissioning
Mr
M
Faas
SA Municipal Workers Union
2000/02/21
4
3. EIA Process
This process highlights crucial aspects of the proposed development and promotes the
Discussions
to construction activities should be done well in advance.
idea
of good pertaining
governance.
Mr
M
Faas
SA Municipal Workers Union
2000/02/21
3
1 Strategic Approach
How will this project impact on the transformation of the energy sector that delivers to the
domestic and commercial sector?
5. Other sources of power generation
Why is nuclear power generation not used as it is said to be a cheaper option?
Is an integrated approach followed to address any shortcomings on the current
transmission system?
How does Eskom’s approach compare to International models of restructuring itself as
an Energy company?
Mr
M
Faas
SA Municipal Workers Union
2000/02/21
4
1.2 Consultation
What action will be taken in future when the 765 kV line is not longer sufficient?
Consulting with stakeholders and communities allows for a better understanding of
issues.
Mr
M
Faas
SA Municipal Workers Union
2000/02/23
7
1. Cultural heritage sites
It does not appear that any cultural heritage sites will be affected by construction
activities.
Mnr
F
Gerber
SAFCOL
2000/02/21
8
The 765 kV line should avoid Wolseley. If this line runs from north to south, it will result
in a reduction of profit margins in the forestry industry. The current 400 kV lines result in
a loss of 96ha due to the servitudes.
Mnr
F
Gerber
SAFCOL
2000/02/28
6
Eskom is responsible for de-bushing and spraying the areas under the servitude lines.
612926878
Page 6 of 27
K van der Merwe – Eskom. This matter will be dealt with in parallel
with the landowner negotiations.
S Dunsmore – about 2010.
S Dunsmore: - Explained the project, the alternatives that need to
be examined and Eskom’s policy of future strategic planning.
Original 765kV Public Open Day
Mnr
F
Gerber
SAFCOL
2000/02/28
2
2. Aesthetics
What will the Salene Switching station look like in appearance?
S Dunsmore – It will be mainly a steel structure. I think that we
should elaborate on this slightly
Site 1a – if the switching station is situated here, there will be a higher visual impact.
Mnr
F
Gerber
SAFCOL
2000/02/28
1
2. Job losses
The loss of forestry plantations due to the Salene switching station will result in 1 person
per hectare losing their jobs. It is important that a decision on the Salene is made soon
as SAFCOL intends to plant new plantations.
Mr
John
Goibaiyer
Monwabisi Secondary
2000/02/22
6
There should be minimal dust impact during construction due to the sub-station being
situated some distance from the town.
Mr
John
Goibaiyer
Monwabisi Secondary
2000/02/22
7
1. Archaeological
Historically the town of De Aar was situated close to the Hydra Sub-station. There could
be ruins in this area.
Mr
John
Goibaiyer
Monwabisi Secondary
2000/02/22
1
8. Economic benefits during construction
Will there be a positive impact on the local economy during the construction period?
Mr
John
Goibaiyer
Monwabisi Secondary
2000/02/22
6
There is currently a project underway to rehabilitate the raptors to the area.
Eskom must please ensure that the birds are protected.
Are environmental specialist studies being conducted?
K van der Merwe, Eskom: Yes, specialists study the flight paths
and use this mechanism which appears to be effective. An
example used is the transmission lines in the Natal Midlands.
Are the red and white balls that are placed on the transmission lines effective?
Mr
John
Goibaiyer
Monwabisi Secondary
2000/02/22
4
3 Advertising
The advert was seen in the Echo and Mr Yanta visited the school to distribute
information about the Project.
Mr
John
Goibaiyer
Monwabisi Secondary
2000/02/22
1
7. Disruption of Services during construction
Will there be disruption to services during construction?
K van der Merwe, Eskom. No, the services will not be disrupted.
Mr
John
Goibaiyer
Monwabisi Secondary
2000/02/22
4
1. Public Consultation
Historically, not everybody could participate Has the Public Participation Process tried to
include everybody?
Where will Eskom draw the line with Public comment?
J Tooley, ACER: Expanded on the Public Participation
Programme. Although it is not possible to identify everyone, the
intention is to identify key stakeholders and to create an
opportunity for participation throughout the Environmental Impact
Assessment. Feedback will be given to the Interested And
Affected Parties registered on the database. Also, the deadlines
for comments were explained.
612926878
Page 7 of 27
Original 765kV Public Open Day
Ms
Sheila
Josi
Municipality Library
2000/02/22
4
1. Public Consultation
Historically, not everybody could participate Has the Public Participation Process tried to
include everybody?
Where will Eskom draw the line with Public comment?
Ms
Sheila
Josi
Municipality Library
2000/02/22
1
4. Local Distribution
Will the upgrade of Hydra address the distribution problems at De Aar?
Ms
Sheila
Josi
Municipality Library
2000/02/22
2
5. Increased power supply
If the power supply to the sub-station is being increased, is there a danger that this will
increase in residential homes and lead to fires and/or other dangers?
K van der Merwe, Eskom: No, the electricity is stepped down with
transformers all the way into residential homes.
Ms
Sheila
Josi
Municipality Library
2000/02/22
1
1. Disruption of Services during construction
Will there be disruption to services during construction?
K van der Merwe, Eskom. No, the services will not be disrupted.
Ms
Sheila
Josi
Municipality Library
2000/02/22
2
1. Safety and Security
Are emergency plans in place at the sub-station?
Is Eskom NOSA accredited?
If there is a fire or explosion at the sub-station, will this endanger the neighbours?
K van der Merwe, Eskom: Yes, all sub-stations have emergency
plans. Also, sub-stations adhere to NOSA safety regulations. Local
emergency services are in communication with the sub-station and
action will be taken
Mnr
Pippin
Joubert
Boontjiesdam
2000/02/21
3
The Tulbagh route should be well motivated.
Mnr
Pippin
Joubert
Boontjiesdam
2000/02/28
5
1. Transmission lines
Will the current lines be removed?
What is the life span of transmission lines?
Mnr
Pippin
Joubert
Boontjiesdam
2000/02/28
2
1. Loss of residence – labour tenants
The existing 400 kV lines north of the proposed lines run very close to labour tenant’s
homes. This should be further investigated in terms of the effect of the new lines.
2. Electromagnetic fields
The existing lines interfere with the television and radio reception. Reception is not
possible without satellite.
Mnr
Pippin
Joubert
Boontjiesdam
2000/02/28
4
The Public Open Day posters were seen at the Sentra shop.
612926878
Page 8 of 27
J Tooley, ACER: Expanded on the Public Participation
Programme. Although it is not possible to identify everyone, the
intention is to identify key stakeholders and to create an
opportunity for participation throughout the Environmental Impact
Assessment. Feedback will be given to the Interested And
process is necessary in terms of the new democracy. A broad range of stakeholders has Affected Parties registered on the database. Also, the deadlines
participated and this is important, as all opinions must be considered.
for comments were explained.
Original 765kV Public Open Day
Mr
Jonathan
Kakora
Klein Boere
2000/02/21
1
4. Future agricultural developments
The Department of Water Affairs and Forestry and the Small Scale Farmers are
exploring a potential irrigation scheme. With the upgrade of Luckhoff Sub-station provide
the additional electricity for this project?
K Bowler responded that she didn’t think that this would happen
and that this development would have to be negotiated with the
Luckhoff Municipality. To be confirmed by Eskom.
Mr
Jonathan
Kakora
Klein Boere
2000/02/21
1
2. Job Creation
K Bowler noted the issue and would raise this with Eskom.
How many job opportunities will the CSP create?
Although it is understood that specially trained people will need to construct the capacitor
station, local labour should be used for de-bushing, digging of trenches and fence
erecting.
Mr
Jonathan
Kakora
Klein Boere
2000/02/21
1
1. Job Creation
Although it is understood that much of the work can only be carried out by specially
trained teams, Eskom contractors should make a special effort to use locals to do work
that requires minimal skills, e.g. digging of foundations. Not doing this could potentially
lead to conflict with locals.
Mr
FCF
Kirk
2000/02/21
3
8. 765 kV Design & Safety
Do the 765 kV lines present a problem from the point of view in that they attract
lightning?
Mr
FCF
Kirk
2000/02/21
3
Does Koeberg not have sufficient spare capacity to provide the required electricity?
Mr
FCF
Kirk
2000/02/21
2
Is the intention to run the 765 KV lines along the escarpment?
Mr
FCF
Kirk
2000/02/21
4
How will the decommissioning of lines be addressed?
Mnr
Franci
Krone
2000/02/21
6
Racing Pigeons are known to also fly into transmission lines if these are in their flight
paths.
Waveren Landgoed
6. Geometric Tortoises
The status of these tortoises is currently being investigated
Mnr
Franci
612926878
Krone
Page 9 of 27
Waveren Landgoed
2000/02/21
2
Aesthetics of an area must be balance with development needs. The visual impact of
transmission lines dissipates over time as people become used to them.
K Bowler noted the issue.
J Geeringh , Eskom – No there are conductors which alleviate this
problem.
J Geeringh, Eskom- The intention is to leave the escarpment as
often as possible.
Original 765kV Public Open Day
Mnr
Franci
Krone
Waveren Landgoed
2000/02/21
8
2. Agricultural activities during operation
Vineyards are planted in areas of 100 m x 100 m with 2,5 m gaps in between. The newer
vineyards are planned to allow for mechanisation while in the older vineyards, a
combination of manpower and machines are used.
Farming implements can comfortably clear the height restrictions of the transmission
lines. However, the footprint of the pylons would present problems.
Mr
Renaldo
Le Grange
VIBE
2000/02/22
1
6. Provincial effects
How will the project affect services in the Eastern Cape. There are many problems in
the Eastern Cape and when will Eskom address these?
Mr
Renaldo
Le Grange
VIBE
2000/02/22
1
Will there be sub-contracting opportunities for locals and will these be advertised in the
local media? Eskom should investigate potential opportunities for locals that would
include bush clearing, fence erecting, administration, security etc.
Mr
Renaldo
Le Grange
VIBE
2000/02/22
1
4. Local Distribution
Will the upgrade of Hydra address the distribution problems at De Aar?
Mr
Renaldo
Le Grange
VIBE
2000/02/22
1
5. Tariffs
Will the tariffs increase as a result of the project?
Mr
Simon
Lobi
2000/02/21
1
1. Tariffs
K Bowler said that the project would not lead to an increase in the
Will the cost of electricity increase once the capacitor station is operative? Currently R 10 tariffs. However, it should be expected that normal tariff increases
coupons are used and these last approximately seven days.
could be expected.
Mr
Simon
Lobi
2000/02/21
4
2. Public Participation
How can Interested and Affected Parties further participate in this project?
K Bowler responded: by reading the material, identifying issues,
discussing the project with the project team, informing friends and
commenting on the draft Scoping Report.
Mr
Simon
Lobi
2000/02/21
1
6. Interruption of services
K Bowler responded that this would be minimal, if at all. Eskom to
confirm.
Will services be interrupted during the construction of the capacitor station?
Mr
Simon
612926878
Lobi
Page 10 of 27
2000/02/21
1
Mr K van der Merwe, Eskom: Perhaps only small contracting
opportunities in relation to other projects. Also, there are a limited
number of companies which are able to erect power lines.
S Dunsmore, PBA: No, not as far as it is understood.
3. Training
K Bowler note the issue. Eskom to respond.
Can local people not be trained for certain jobs rather than employ only specially trained
individuals?
Original 765kV Public Open Day
Mr
Simon
Lobi
2000/02/21
1
2. Job Creation
K Bowler noted the issue and would raise this with Eskom.
How many job opportunities will the CSP create?
Although it is understood that specially trained people will need to construct the capacitor
station, local labour should be used for de-bushing, digging of trenches and fence
erecting.
Mr
Simon
Lobi
2000/02/21
4
1. Public Consultation
K Bowler noted the issue.
The Background Information Document and posters were distributed in the town and the
Public Open Days were advertised.
Future documentation should include more information on Eskom.
Mr
Simon
Lobi
2000/02/21
2
2. Safety and Security
What emergencies can occur at the capacitor station?
Eskom to respond.
Is any safety procedure in place should an emergency occur at the capacitor station?
Who should be contacted in this regard?
Mnr
J
Lombard
Roodezand
2000/02/21
1
Foreign capital investment in the area is important to future growth and the sustainability
of existing infrastructure, more transmission lines could be detrimental to this.
Mnr
J
Lombard
Roodezand
2000/02/21
1
Eskom should co-operate with tourism officials to ensure better planning.
Agri-tourism is becoming an important feature in the Tulbagh area.
Mr
P
Loubser
Loubser Landgoed
2000/02/21
4
Impressed with the Public Open Days and compliments Eskom on taking these issues to
the Public.
Mr
P
Loubser
Loubser Landgoed
2000/02/21
3
Tulbagh route –
This route should preferably run south of Tulbagh.
The northern route has intensive fruit and vines as well as building and should be
avoided.
Menno Klapwijk explained that the southern route was the
preferred alternative.
Ms
Lucille
Ludick
Youth Development Forum
2000/02/22
1
1. Job Creation
Will the Hydra project create work for locals?
Mr K van der Merwe, Eskom: Perhaps only small contracting
opportunities in relation to other projects. Also, there are a limited
number of companies which are able to erect power lines.
Ms
Lucille
Ludick
Youth Development Forum
2000/02/22
2
5. Increased power supply
If the power supply to the sub-station is being increased, is there a danger that this will
increase in residential homes and lead to fires and/or other dangers?
K van der Merwe, Eskom: No, the electricity is stepped down with
transformers all the way into residential homes.
612926878
Page 11 of 27
Original 765kV Public Open Day
Ms
Lucille
Ludick
Youth Development Forum
2000/02/22
1
4. Local Distribution
Will the upgrade of Hydra address the distribution problems at De Aar?
Ms
Lucille
Ludick
Youth Development Forum
2000/02/22
1
7. Disruption of Services during construction
Will there be disruption to services during construction?
K van der Merwe, Eskom. No, the services will not be disrupted.
Ms
Lucille
Ludick
Youth Development Forum
2000/02/22
2
1. Safety and Security
Are emergency plans in place at the sub-station?
Is Eskom NOSA accredited?
If there is a fire or explosion at the sub-station, will this endanger the neighbours?
K van der Merwe, Eskom: Yes, all sub-stations have emergency
plans. Also, sub-stations adhere to NOSA safety regulations. Local
emergency services are in communication with the sub-station and
action will be taken
Ms
Lucille
Ludick
Youth Development Forum
2000/02/22
4
1. Public Consultation
Historically, not everybody could participate Has the Public Participation Process tried to
include everybody?
Where will Eskom draw the line with Public comment?
Mnr
HS
Marais
2000/02/21
6
1. Erosion
Erosion on Eskom access roads is a problem. Preventative action should include the
construction of berms. The farmer, and/or private contractors could maintain access
roads. Eskom should compensate the landowner if he appoints the contractor or hires
the necessary equipment.
Alternatively, Eskom should pay the farmers to build and maintain the access roads.
Mnr
HS
Marais
2000/02/21
8
1. Agricultural activities during construction
Gates should be closed at all times by Eskom officials to avoid the integrating of rams
and ewes.
Mnr
HS
Marais
2000/02/21
2
7. Servitudes
How will the servitudes and compensation of these be dealt with?
Mnr
DB
Marais
Boer
2000/02/21
8
1. Agricultural activities during construction
Gates should be closed at all times by Eskom officials to avoid the integrating of rams
and ewes.
Mnr
DB
Marais
Boer
2000/02/21
6
1. Erosion
Erosion on Eskom access roads is a problem. Preventative action should include the
construction of berms. The farmer, and/or private contractors could maintain access
roads. Eskom should compensate the landowner if he appoints the contractor or hires
the necessary equipment.
Alternatively, Eskom should pay the farmers to build and maintain the access roads.
612926878
Page 12 of 27
J Tooley, ACER: Expanded on the Public Participation
Programme. Although it is not possible to identify everyone, the
intention is to identify key stakeholders and to create an
opportunity for participation throughout the Environmental Impact
Assessment. Feedback will be given to the Interested And
process is necessary in terms of the new democracy. A broad range of stakeholders has Affected Parties registered on the database. Also, the deadlines
participated and this is important, as all opinions must be considered.
for comments were explained.
K van der Merwe – Eskom. These negotiations will be done by
Eskom
Original 765kV Public Open Day
Ms
Liziwe
McDaid
Earthlife Africa
2000/02/21
2
2. PCB Disposal
How and where are used PCBs disposed of?
Disposal of PCBs is done strictly in compliance with the
requirements of the Basil convention, an international agreement
controlling the trans-boundary movement of hazardous waste. This
entails carefully packaging, storing and eventually transporting the
PCBs to avoid leakage. The packaged PCBs are sent either to
Denmark or the United Kingdom where the PCBs are destroyed in
special incinerators.
Ms
Liziwe
McDaid
Earthlife Africa
2000/02/28
6
2. Renosterveld
There are areas carrying Renosterveld that need to be preserved.
D Jefferies, the main problem with the Renosterveld is the
potential impact that the footprint of the Pylon can have on the
vegetation. Also, an additional problem that may arise is that
Eskom will be creating new access routes into these areas with
their servitudes and access roads.
Ms
Liziwe
McDaid
Earthlife Africa
2000/02/29
2
1. Community Well being
Are any communities situated close to the Droerivier Sub-station?
S Dunsmore – No, this sub-station is situated far out of Beaufort
West.
Mr
David
Mentoro
2000/02/22
1
7. Disruption of Services during construction
Will there be disruption to services during construction?
K van der Merwe, Eskom. No, the services will not be disrupted.
Mr
David
Mentoro
2000/02/22
1
Will the upgrade of Hydra Sub-station affect the small lines?
K van der Merwe, Eskom: it will improve the supply as more
electricity will be supplied to Hydra.
Mr
David
Mentoro
2000/02/22
1
1. Job Creation
Will the Hydra project create work for locals?
Mr K van der Merwe, Eskom: Perhaps only small contracting
opportunities in relation to other projects. Also, there are a limited
number of companies which are able to erect power lines.
Mr
David
Morris
McGregor Museum
2000/12/19
9
Comment on : Hydra, Victoria and Komsberg - draft scoping report.
I note that ESKOM has secured the services of Johathan Kaplan as an arcaeologist to
investigate impacts of the proposed development.
I note that in the case of Hydra, inspection of tower footprints is recommended before
design is finalised: and that in the other two instances contractor awareness is advised. I
am satisfied that this would result in adequate management of potential impacts on
archaeological and other material culture resources.
Ms
Frangelina
Ngqabaza
Zingisani P School
2000/02/22
6
4. Dust
How much dust will be generated during construction activities? What measures will be
taken to protect the workers and residents?
Ms
Frangelina
Ngqabaza
Zingisani P School
2000/02/22
1
7. Disruption of Services during construction
Will there be disruption to services during construction?
612926878
Page 13 of 27
K van der Merwe, Eskom. No, the services will not be disrupted.
Original 765kV Public Open Day
Ms
Frangelina
Ngqabaza
Zingisani P School
2000/02/22
6
3. Hazardous Chemicals
Will dangerous chemicals be used (eg. Herbicides and pesticides) which pollute the are
and could affect humans? This should be guarded against.
Landowners are the ones to be most likely affected.
Mnr
Johannes
Noduku
Private
2000/02/21
4
1. Public Consultation
1.1 Media
The project advertisement was seen in the Gariep Newspaper.
Mnr
Johannes
Noduku
Private
2000/02/21
1
What job opportunities the 765 kV lines can create?
Mr
Sivuyile
Ntamehlo
Youth Development Forum
2000/02/22
2
2. Health & Hygiene
As Hydra is situated far from any communities, it is not likely that it will affect them in any
way.
Mr
Sivuyile
Ntamehlo
Youth Development Forum
2000/02/22
1
1. Job Creation
Will the Hydra project create work for locals?
Ms
Mreliez
Oosthuizen
Dept of Env. Affairs, Culture & Sport
2000/02/21
3
7. Design alternatives
Can 765 kV lines be designed to carry cell phone towers?
Ms
Mreliez
Oosthuizen
Dept of Env. Affairs, Culture & Sport
2000/02/21
1
How will tourism plans affect the positioning of the lines?
M Klapwijk – A Report is currently being compiled and will soon be
available. It is has been advised that existing corridors should not
be followed as these are already cluttered.
Ms
Mreliez
Oosthuizen
Dept of Env. Affairs, Culture & Sport
2000/02/21
4
Is the National and Provincial Departments of Environmental Affairs involved in the EIA
process?
S Dunsmore – Both National and provincial departments have
been involved since the start of the project and are being kept
informed of progress.
Ms
Mreliez
Oosthuizen
Dept of Env. Affairs, Culture & Sport
2000/02/21
3
If Kudu Gas does not get off the ground, how much sooner will the 765 kV line need to
go ahead?
Will the Kudu Gas project have any affect on the project and the route?
S Dunsmore – the servitude will go ahead and it is anticipated that
construction on the lines will go ahead within the next 8 years even
if Kudu does go ahead. The site-specific projects are expected to
commence within the next two to three years.
S Dunsmore, no, the servitude still needs to be established and
negotiated with the landowners. The EIA for this will still need to
be done.
1. EIA Process
Is the National and Provincial Departments of Environmental Affairs involved in the EIA
process?
S Dunsmore – Both National and provincial departments have
been involved since the start of the project and are being kept
informed of progress.
Ms
Mreliez
612926878
Oosthuizen
Page 14 of 27
Dept of Env. Affairs, Culture & Sport
2000/02/28
4
S Dunsmore, PBA: It is unlikely that many job opportunities will be
created.
Mr K van der Merwe, Eskom: Perhaps only small contracting
opportunities in relation to other projects. Also, there are a limited
number of companies which are able to erect power lines.
Original 765kV Public Open Day
Ms
Mreliez
Oosthuizen
Dept of Env. Affairs, Culture & Sport
2000/02/28
1
How will tourism plans affect the positioning of the lines?
M Klapwijk – A Report is currently being compiled and will soon be
available. It is has been advised that existing corridors should not
be followed as these are already cluttered.
Ms
Mreliez
Oosthuizen
Dept of Env. Affairs, Culture & Sport
2000/02/28
1
1. Tourism
M Klapwijk – A Report is currently being compiled and will soon be
available. It is has been advised that existing corridors should not
be followed as these are already cluttered.
How will tourism plans affect the positioning of the lines?
Me
Lettie
Pieterse
We Care Community Services
2000/02/22
1
9. National economic benefit
This project will benefit the country’s national growth.
Me
Lettie
Pieterse
We Care Community Services
2000/02/22
1
10. Regional economic benefit
This project will benefit the region’s growth.
Me
Lettie
Pieterse
We Care Community Services
2000/02/22
2
3. Loss of Residence
Do not anticipate any loss of residence. Will the Hydra Guesthouse be affected?
Me
Lettie
Pieterse
We Care Community Services
2000/02/22
1
11. Local economic benefit
It is understood that there will be limited benefit to the local economy.
Me
Lettie
Pieterse
We Care Community Services
2000/02/22
3
2. Regional Alternatives
There is an awareness that other regional alternatives to upgrading De Aar do exist,
however, it is understood that this project would benefit De Aar, even if only indirectly.
There is support for this project.
Me
Lettie
Pieterse
We Care Community Services
2000/02/22
7
2. Cultural Sites
There is no knowledge of any cultural sites in the area of the Hydra Sub-station.
Me
Lettie
Pieterse
We Care Community Services
2000/02/22
2
Strict security with adequate fencing and signage must be in place at the sub-station.
Me
Lettie
Pieterse
We Care Community Services
2000/02/22
2
4. Electromagnetic Fields
People living along the new route and next to the sub-station must be informed about the
Electromagnetic Fields.
612926878
Page 15 of 27
S Dunsmore, PBA: This must be investigated.
K van der Merwe, Eskom: Yes, all sub-stations have emergency
plans. Also, sub-stations adhere to NOSA safety regulations. Local
emergency services are in communication with the sub-station and
action will be taken
Original 765kV Public Open Day
Mnr
Johan
Prins
Witzenberg Prop
2000/02/21
3
Is Kudu Gas not a cheaper option to transmission lines?
Mnr
Johan
Prins
Witzenberg Prop
2000/02/21
3
Alternative Routes – Karoo Poort through to Malmesbury
The proposed route should preferably avoid the valley.
North of the pink route is highly populated and should preferably avoided.
There is less development or proposed development north of the pink line.
Mnr
Johan
Prins
Witzenberg Prop
2000/02/21
2
4. Construction camps
Discussions pertaining to construction camps should be done well in advance.
Mnr
Johan
Prins
Witzenberg Prop
2000/02/21
5
1. Construction dates
When will construction commence?
S Dunsmore – about 2010.
Mnr
Johan
Prins
Witzenberg Prop
2000/02/21
4
4. Decommissioning
What action will be taken in future when the 765 kV line is not longer sufficient?
S Dunsmore: - Explained the project, the alternatives that need to
be examined and Eskom’s policy of future strategic planning.
Mnr
Johan
Prins
Witzenberg Prop
2000/02/21
2
Certain of the proposed routes could affect labourer cottages, this can only be finally
determined once the route becomes fixed.
K van der Merwe – Eskom. This matter will be dealt with in parallel
with the landowner negotiations.
Mnr
Johan
Prins
Witzenberg Prop
2000/02/21
8
3. Construction Activities
Construction activities should preferably take place in the winter months, from May to
August.
J Tooley – Yes, but there are problems in terms of mountain
crossings, forestry and ecologically senstive areas.
5. Access roads
Eskom should, as far as possible make use of existing access roads.
4. Height servitudes
The maximum height allowed for vegetation under the transmission lines could affect
some of the orchards and windbreaker avenues.
Mnr
Johan
Prins
Witzenberg Prop
2000/02/21
2
8. Loss of Residence/work areas
The transmission lines could affect working areas/ sheds.
Mnr
Johan
Prins
Witzenberg Prop
2000/02/21
2
9. Theft
Theft of equipment and fruit is a common problem that needs to be addressed. The
former is however easier to control
Mnr
Johan
Prins
Witzenberg Prop
2000/02/21
8
Discussions pertaining to construction activities should be done well in advance.
Mnr
Johan
612926878
Prins
Page 16 of 27
Witzenberg Prop
2000/02/21
8
The ladders used by the pickers are fairly tall, how much clearance space is required in
terms of the transmission lines?
S Dunsmore , K van der Merwe – the minimum requirement is
20m. This doesn’t seem right.
Original 765kV Public Open Day
Mr
Wandile
Ranelo
Mnr
Fanie
Mnr
Mnr
Youth Development Forum
2000/02/22
2
2. Health & Hygiene
As Hydra is situated far from any communities, it is not likely that it will affect them in any
way.
Redelinghuys
2000/02/21
3
There are already too many power lines running through the area, there is no room for
any more.
Fanie
Redelinghuys
2000/02/21
3
5. Other sources of power generation
Why is nuclear power generation not used as it is said to be a cheaper option?
Fanie
Redelinghuys
2000/02/28
3
2. Alternative Routes
As there are already numerous 400 kV lines traversing private property bordering the
proposed sites 1b and 2 for the Salene Switching Station. It is strongly suggested that
alternative routes be sought.
3. Economic viability – Salene Switching Station
Proposed site 2 for the Salene Switching Station falls on an area that would threaten the
economic viability of agricultural activities.
Ms
Daphne
Redman
ANC Youth League
2000/02/21
1
Unemployment is a problem in the area.
Me
Patricia
Reitz
Boontjiesrivier
2000/02/21
8
Eskom has used private roads as access roads. These have been damaged and the
repair costs have been carried by individual landowners.
7. Construction Activities
Eskom should timeously announce their intention to begin construction. This has not
been done in the past.
Me
Patricia
612926878
Reitz
Page 17 of 27
Boontjiesrivier
2000/02/21
2
Dissatisfaction with the Pylon structures carrying the transmission lines, these are
considered to be unsightly.
S Dunsmore, PBA: It is unlikely that many job opportunities will be
created.
Original 765kV Public Open Day
Me
Patricia
Reitz
Boontjiesrivier
2000/02/21
6
1. Erosion
Erosion on Eskom access roads is a problem. Preventative action should include the
construction of berms. The farmer, and/or private contractors could maintain access
roads. Eskom should compensate the landowner if he appoints the contractor or hires
the necessary equipment.
Alternatively, Eskom should pay the farmers to build and maintain the access roads.
5. Renosterveld
There are conservancy area carrying Renosterveld that need to be preserved.
Specifically through the Elandskloof Nature Reserve through to Samchem. This is the
last pice of Renosterveld in the Western Cape Area.
7. Servitude clearance – Fynbos
Eskom should inform landowners of their intention to clear servitudes, especially where
fynbos is involved.
Me
Patricia
Reitz
Boontjiesrivier
2000/02/21
2
Me
Patricia
Reitz
Boontjiesrivier
2000/02/28
6
1. Erosion
There is a problem of erosion on the access roads, which needs to be investigated and
managed by Eskom.
Me
Patricia
Reitz
Boontjiesrivier
2000/02/28
6
3. Conservancy Areas
There are conservancy area carrying Renosterveld that need to be preserved.
Me
Patricia
Reitz
Boontjiesrivier
2000/02/28
6
2. Servitude clearance – Fynbos
Eskom should inform landowners of their intention to clear servitudes, especially where
fynbos is involved.
Me
Patricia
Reitz
Boontjiesrivier
2000/02/28
6
Dissatisfaction with the Pylon structures carrying the transmission lines, these are
considered to be unsightly
Mnr
Jannie
Smuts
2000/02/28
3
1. Strategic
In terms of this project and generating power for transmission of electricity, is there
sufficient coal in Mpumalanga?
Mr
Eugene
Speirs
2000/02/28
2
Dissatisfaction with the Pylon structures carrying the transmission lines, these are
unsightly.
612926878
Page 18 of 27
KBE
There have been no problems experienced to date with construction camps.
M Klapwijk – A report currently being compiled will soon be
available. It is preferable not to use existing corridors as these are
already cluttered.
Original 765kV Public Open Day
Mr
Eugene
Speirs
KBE
2000/02/28
6
Dissatisfaction with the Pylon structures carrying the transmission lines, these are
considered to be unsightly
Mr
Hannes
Stadler
Cape Nature Conservation
2000/02/28
3
2. The new 400 kV route to Salene - Doornboom
There are farms that have broilers along this route.
Mnr
Nicolaas
Stoman
Loubser L/Goed
2000/02/21
8
The new styles proposed for the pylons would be a problem in the vineyards. The selfsupporting structures are preferred.
Mnr
Nicolaas
Stoman
Loubser L/Goed
2000/02/21
3
Mnr
SJ
Thompson
Luckhoff Munisipaliteit
2000/02/21
1
Tulbagh route –
This route should preferably run south of Tulbagh.
The northern route has intensive fruit and vines as well as building and should be
avoided.
1. Tourism
M Klapwijk – A report currently being compiled will soon be
available. It is preferable not to use existing corridors as these are
already cluttered.
Menno Klapwijk explained that the southern route was the
preferred alternative.
J Tooley noted issue.
The proposed expansion will increase the Capacitor stations visibility from the R48.
Although Luckhoff does not have much to offer in terms of tourism, it may have potential
as part of a regional package; Jacobsdal winery, diamond mine at Koffiefontein and van
der Kloof Dam. Although this is not a big issue, it should be noted.
Ms
Pat
Titmus
Blaauwberg Municipality
2000/02/21
2
Port Jackson should be removed as this presents a fire hazard.
Ms
Pat
Titmus
Blaauwberg Municipality
2000/02/21
8
6. Economic viability
Future developments on private property should be taken into account when planning
the routes as the economic viability of these could be negatively impacted on.
Ms
Pat
Titmus
Blaauwberg Municipality
2000/02/21
4
5. Aesthetics
Is there a specialist that deals with the visual impacts of the proposed projects?
Ms
Pat
Titmus
Blaauwberg Municipality
2000/02/21
7
1. Historical Sites
While constructing a line 13 years ago in the Agterwitzenberg area, Eskom damaged an
historical cannon station. This has never been repaired.
Notice must be taken of a restored, historical stable when planning the route.
Notice must be taken of a 150 year old Akkerbos (oak tree orchard or orchards???) that
is situated approximately 100 m of existing line.
Historical gum tree avenues on the old route to Malmesbury and Darling should be
noted.
612926878
Page 19 of 27
J Tooley – Yes, there are three specialists that will deal with
Social, ecology and visual issues. Other specialists will be used
as required.
Original 765kV Public Open Day
Ms
Pat
Titmus
Blaauwberg Municipality
2000/02/21
3
6. Alternative Routes
Are alternative routes being examined through the Ceres Area?
J Tooley – Yes, but there are problems in terms of mountain
crossings, forestry and ecologically senstive areas.
Ms
Pat
Titmus
Blaauwberg Municipality
2000/02/21
5
3. The Omega Site
Will stakeholders raise the issue of the Omega site during the project?
J Tooley & S Dunsmore – A report is available and some public
consultation has been done. However, it will be necessary to
determined if the EIA needs to be reviewed.
Ms
Pat
Titmus
Blaauwberg Municipality
2000/02/21
6
Botanical core area on Farm Schoongezicht (on map 3318DAPhil).
Ms
Pat
Titmus
Blaauwberg Municipality
2000/02/21
4
Will all the landowners be consulted?
Mr
Roland
Toehand
Private
2000/02/21
1
2. Job Creation
K Bowler noted the issue and would raise this with Eskom.
How many job opportunities will the CSP create?
Although it is understood that specially trained people will need to construct the capacitor
station, local labour should be used for de-bushing, digging of trenches and fence
erecting.2. Job Creation
S Dunsmore – Although not all the landowners will be personally
consulted during the EIA process, Eskom will be negotiating
personally with the Landowners.
How many job opportunities will the CSP create?
Although it is understood that specially trained people will need to construct the capacitor
station, local labour should be used for de-bushing, digging of trenches and fence
erecting.
Mr
Roland
Toehand
Private
2000/02/21
1
3. Training
K Bowler note the issue. Eskom to respond.
Can local people not be trained for certain jobs rather than employ only specially trained
individuals?
Mr
Roland
Toehand
Private
2000/02/21
1
5. Tariffs
K Bowler said that the project would not lead to an increase in the
Will the cost of electricity increase once the capacitor station is operative? Currently R 10 tariffs. However, it should be expected that normal tariff increases
coupons are used and these last approximately seven days.
could be expected.
Mr
Roland
Toehand
Private
2000/02/21
1
6. Interruption of services
Will services be interrupted during the construction of the capacitor station?
612926878
Page 20 of 27
K Bowler responded that this would be minimal, if at all. Eskom to
confirm.
Original 765kV Public Open Day
Mr
Roland
Toehand
Private
2000/02/21
4
1. Public Consultation
K Bowler noted the issue.
The Background Information Document and posters were distributed in the town and the
Public Open Days were advertised.
Future documentation should include more information on Eskom.
Mr
Roland
Toehand
Private
2000/02/21
4
2. Public Participation
How can Interested and Affected Parties further participate in this project?
K Bowler responded: by reading the material, identifying issues,
discussing the project with the project team, informing friends and
commenting on the draft Scoping Report.
Mr
Roland
Toehand
Private
2000/02/21
2
2. Safety and Security
Eskom to respond.
What emergencies can occur at the capacitor station?
Is any safety procedure in place should an emergency occur at the capacitor station?
Who should be contacted in this regard?
Mr
R
van Staden
E.H.O
2000/02/22
1
2. Servitude compensation
Does Eskom pay for the servitudes on a monthly basis? It has been rumoured that this
could be R 25 000 per month.
K van der Merwe, Eskom: It is Eskom’s policy to pay for the used
of servitudes according to market related prices. Registered
valuators are appointed to determine these values which will
depend on land use and area. The landowner receives a single
payment.
Should the landowner not be satisfied with the evaluation, he/she
may appoint an evaluator at own cost.
Although, landowners may not erect or build infrastructure under
the lines, farming activities may continue.
Understanding that landowners do not like servitudes, Eskom will,
as far as possible run parallel to boundaries or where no
developments are planned.
Should no agreement be reached with the landowner on
servitudes, the matter will be referred to court.
Mr
R
van Staden
E.H.O
2000/02/22
1
Will there be sub-contracting opportunities for locals and will these be advertised in the
local media? Eskom should investigate potential opportunities for locals that would
include bush clearing, fence erecting, administration, security etc.
Mr K van der Merwe, Eskom: Perhaps only small contracting
opportunities in relation to other projects. Also, there are a limited
number of companies which are able to erect power lines.
Mr
R
van Staden
E.H.O
2000/02/22
1
3. Project Timing
When will construction at Hydra start?
612926878
Page 21 of 27
K van der Merwe, Eskom. Once the project has been approved, it
is anticipated that construction will commence in 2001.
Original 765kV Public Open Day
Mr
R
van Staden
E.H.O
2000/02/22
6
2. Birds
Black Eagles are suffering large losses due to transmission lines. What can be done
about this?
K van der Merwe, Eskom: Yes, specialists study the flight paths
and use this mechanism which appears to be effective. An
example used is the transmission lines in the Natal Midlands.
Mr
R
van Staden
E.H.O
2000/02/22
2
1. Safety and Security
Are emergency plans in place at the sub-station?
Is Eskom NOSA accredited?
If there is a fire or explosion at the sub-station, will this endanger the neighbours?
K van der Merwe, Eskom: Yes, all sub-stations have emergency
plans. Also, sub-stations adhere to NOSA safety regulations. Local
emergency services are in communication with the sub-station and
action will be taken
Mr
R
van Staden
E.H.O
2000/02/22
4
1. Public Consultation
Historically, not everybody could participate Has the Public Participation Process tried to
include everybody?
Where will Eskom draw the line with Public comment?
J Tooley, ACER: Expanded on the Public Participation
Programme. Although it is not possible to identify everyone, the
intention is to identify key stakeholders and to create an
opportunity for participation throughout the Environmental Impact
Assessment. Feedback will be given to the Interested And
Affected Parties registered on the database. Also, the deadlines
for comments were explained.
Mr
R
van Staden
E.H.O
2000/02/22
6
3. Hazardous Chemicals
Will dangerous chemicals be used (eg. Herbicides and pesticides) which pollute the are
and could affect humans? This should be guarded against.
Landowners are the ones to be most likely affected.
Mr
R
van Staden
E.H.O
2000/02/22
6
1. General
Eskom is fortunate that the Hydra plant is not situated in a sensitive environment, ie. No
wetlands, etc. This area has already been damaged by roads, gravel, tar and railway
lines.
Does Eskom have an environmental unit?
Mr
R
van Staden
E.H.O
2000/02/22
4
1. Public Consultation
Historically, not everybody could participate Has the Public Participation Process tried to
include everybody?
Where will Eskom draw the line with Public comment?
process is necessary in terms of the new democracy. A broad range of stakeholders has
participated and this is important, as all opinions must be considered.
2. Eskom consultation
What opinions do Eskom employees have about the project?
What expectations do Eskom employees have about the Hydra sub-station?
Have the Eskom employees been interviewed?
612926878
Page 22 of 27
K van der Merwe, Eskom: Every regional Eskom office has an
Environmental Unit. These individuals ensure that activities,
whether these are maintenance or the erection of transmission
lines, are carried out in terms of Environmental Legislation.
Original 765kV Public Open Day
Mr
R
van Staden
E.H.O
2000/02/22
6
4. Dust
How much dust will be generated during construction activities? What measures will be
taken to protect the workers and residents?
Mnr
Deen
van Zyl
Dutoit Groep
2000/02/21
7
3. Position of pylons
The position of the pylons must be discussed timeously with landowners to avoid
sensitive sites, soils, etc.
Mr
P
Viljoen
CNC
2000/02/21
8
5. Access roads
Eskom should, as far as possible make use of existing access roads.
Access Roads can be beneficial as fire breaks.
Mr
P
Viljoen
CNC
2000/02/21
2
Mr
P
Viljoen
CNC
2000/02/21
2
What will be the visual impacts from Tulbagh?
Menno Klapwijk- The new structures are not as dense as the old
structures. When there is a high ground view, with the mountain
serving as a backdrop, the structures blend into the visual
diversity. When the structures break the skyline, the pylons and
lines become dominant and these can then become intrusive.
Fires - Thulbagh area
Height of the vegetation could lead to greater fire hazards.
Cape Nature Conservation no longer implement fire breaks under the lines, especially
where fynbos is involved.
Access Roads can serve as effective fire breaks.
Fires – Fynbos management
Fynbos does not need to be burnt artificially, this should be left to burn naturally. 50 % of
Fires are manmade and 50% caused by lightning.
Fires – Access routes
A 4 X 4 trail can serve as a useful access roads for fire fighting purposes. This should
however be examined from an environmental point of view.
Mr
P
Viljoen
CNC
2000/02/21
3
Mr
P
Viljoen
CNC
2000/02/21
3
Tulbagh route –
This route should preferably run south of Tulbagh.
The northern route has intensive fruit and vines as well as building and should be
avoided.
Slagtersnek vs Oudnekpas
Is there an alternative to this route?
612926878
Page 23 of 27
Menno Klapwijk explained that the southern route was the
preferred alternative.
Menno Klapwijk: The best possible option to reduce the impact on
these passes will be sought.
Original 765kV Public Open Day
Mr
P
Viljoen
CNC
2000/02/21
4
The media release in the Witzenburg Herald was read.
Mr
P
Viljoen
CNC
2000/02/21
2
2. Safety
Operating rules are essential in terms of fires. What are Eskoms policies in this regard,
more specifically, switching off the power during fires to allow fire fighters under the
transmission lines.
Mr
P
Viljoen
CNC
2000/02/21
6
Thulbagh area –
Cognisance must be taken of the Voelvlei Conservancy.
There is also a Provincial reserve near the Voelvry Dam.
Rosendal and Schurveberg areas
5. Renosterveld
There are conservancy area carrying Renosterveld that need to be preserved.
Specifically through the Elandskloof Nature Reserve through to Samchem. This is the
last pice of Renosterveld in the Western Cape Area.
Servitudes – Green Corridors
Servitudes are only advantageous as green corridors in towns or forestry areas, not on
agricultural land.
8. Sensitive vegetation
Spatella Taligensis
Marsh Areas
Orchids
Mr
P
Viljoen
CNC
2000/02/28
6
4. Geometric Tortoises
The status of these tortoises is currently being investigated.
Mr
P
Viljoen
CNC
2000/02/28
1
1. SAFCOL Plantations
What is the long-term viability of these plantations and how will the Salene switching
station affect them?
Mr
S
Visser
Blauuwberg Municipality
2000/02/21
3
The future of the Pebble Bed Modular Reactors needs to be taken into account in future
power generation developments.
Mr
S
Visser
Blauuwberg Municipality
2000/02/21
5
4. Project Time Frames
What are the implementation time frames of the projects and when will the transmission
lines be erected?
J Geeringh – the time frames for the erection of the actual
structures are not clear, but it is important the servitudes are
secured as soon as possible to avoid any future development
within the servitudes.
Mr
Archie
Wearne
Worcester Municipality
2000/02/21
2
10. Electromagnetic Fields
Are animals and vegetation affected by EMFs?
S Dunsmore: Research is on-going in this field, but is currently
inconclusive.
612926878
Page 24 of 27
Original 765kV Public Open Day
Mr
Archie
Wearne
Worcester Municipality
2000/02/21
5
5. Eskom Service & Reliability of Supply
There is considerable downtime in the Worcester Area. Eskom is not always available to
take calls on the toll number provided for this.
Mr
Archie
Wearne
Worcester Municipality
2000/02/21
8
5. Access roads
Eskom should, as far as possible make use of existing access roads.
Mr
Archie
Wearne
Worcester Municipality
2000/02/21
3
Will the Kudu Gas project have any affect on the project and the route?
Mr
Archie
Wearne
Worcester Municipality
2000/02/21
1
2. National economy
The project is in the interest of the national economy and has to happen.
Mr
Archie
Wearne
Worcester Municipality
2000/02/21
2
The possibility of using invisible line structures should be examined.
Mr
Archie
Wearne
Worcester Municipality
2000/02/28
2
1. PCBs
Will PCBs be used in the upgrade of Bacchus?
S Dunsmore – Only new, non-PCBs will be used in the upgrade.
Mr
Archie
Wearne
Worcester Municipality
2000/02/28
6
1. Geotechnical Information
Are any problems foreseen at the proposed Salene sites and are specific studies
available?
S Dunsmore ; there is seismic activity and specialist geotechncial
studies have been conducted to determine the fault lines..
Mr
Archie
Wearne
Worcester Municipality
2000/02/28
1
1. Local Distribution
S Dunsmore explained that there should be a decrease in the
Problems are currently experienced with the existing 400 kV system. Downtime is often downtime.
experienced as a result of storms and fires.
Currently the system is running to almost full capacity, what will be the effect of the new
developments for Worcester?
There is the perception that Eskom can no longer provide sustainable (firm) supply as
this is becoming too expensive
Mr
Archie
612926878
Wearne
Page 25 of 27
Worcester Municipality
2000/02/28
4
1. Bacchus Sub-station
Why was Bacchus originally situated at its current locality?
S Dunsmore – the servitude will go ahead and it is anticipated that
construction on the lines will go ahead within the next 8 years even
if Kudu does go ahead. The site-specific projects are expected to
commence within the next two to three years.
S Dunsmore, no, the servitude still needs to be established and
negotiated with the landowners. The EIA for this will still need to
be done.
Original 765kV Public Open Day
Mr
Archie
Wearne
Worcester Municipality
2000/02/28
3
1. Local - Cost Implications
What are the comparative costs of developing Bacchus vs Salene?
Mr
Archie
Wearne
Worcester Municipality
2000/06/07
1
Local
Distribution:
2. Routes
Problems
What alternative routes are being proposed for the 400 kV lines if Salene does not go
ahead?
Mnr
Gys
Wege
DuToit Eindomme
2000/02/21
8
Discussions pertaining to construction activities should be done well in advance.
Mnr
Gys
Wege
DuToit Eindomme
2000/02/21
8
The ladders used by the pickers are fairly tall, how much clearance space is required in
terms of the transmission lines?
Mnr
Gys
Wege
DuToit Eindomme
2000/02/21
8
3. Construction Activities
Construction activities should preferably take place in the winter months, from May to
August.
S Dunsmore , K van der Merwe – the minimum requirement is
20m. This doesn’t seem right.
5. Access roads
Eskom should, as far as possible make use of existing access roads.
4. Height servitudes
The maximum height allowed for vegetation under the transmission lines could affect
some of the orchards and windbreaker avenues.
Mnr
Gys
Wege
DuToit Eindomme
2000/02/21
2
9. Theft
Theft of equipment and fruit is a common problem that needs to be addressed. The
former is however easier to control
Mnr
Gys
Wege
DuToit Eindomme
2000/02/21
2
8. Loss of Residence/work areas
The transmission lines could affect working areas/ sheds.
Mnr
Gys
Wege
DuToit Eindomme
2000/02/21
3
Alternative Routes – Karoo Poort through to Malmesbury
The proposed route should preferably avoid the valley.
North of the pink route is highly populated and should preferably avoided.
There is less development or proposed development north of the pink line.
612926878
Page 26 of 27
J Tooley – Yes, but there are problems in terms of mountain
crossings, forestry and ecologically senstive areas.
Original 765kV Public Open Day
Mnr
Gys
Wege
DuToit Eindomme
2000/02/21
5
Mnr
Gys
Wege
DuToit Eindomme
2000/02/21
3
1. Construction dates
When will construction commence?
S Dunsmore – about 2010.
Is Kudu Gas not a cheaper option to transmission lines?
Mnr
Gys
Wege
DuToit Eindomme
2000/02/21
4
4. Decommissioning
What action will be taken in future when the 765 kV line is not longer sufficient?
Mnr
Gys
Wege
DuToit Eindomme
2000/02/21
2
4. Construction camps
Discussions pertaining to construction camps should be done well in advance.
Mnr
Gys
Wege
DuToit Eindomme
2000/02/21
2
Certain of the proposed routes could affect labourer cottages, this can only be finally
determined once the route becomes fixed.
Mnr
Roelf
Zeeman
2000/02/28
2
1. Construction Activities
K Bowler – It is anticipated that construction will commence in
When will construction begin on the Salene switching station should it go ahead and how 2003 and will take approximately two years to complete.
long will it last?
Mnr
Roelf
Zeeman
2000/02/28
4
1. Public Participation Programme
The advertisement and press release was read in Die Burger Newspaper.
612926878
Page 27 of 27
S Dunsmore: - Explained the project, the alternatives that need to
be examined and Eskom’s policy of future strategic planning.