2015 Understanding Weather, Climate and Climate Change Activities for informal and formal teachers Background information for educators: Climate change and global warming are topics that come up in conversation and frequently are misunderstood. Children need to understand what these terms mean and that they are not topics that are intended to describe the end of the world, the end of human civilization or the end of nature. These topics mean that the world is changing, and with all change, there are positive things and negative things that can happen. We need communicate with children that what happens to this planet is impacted by everyone’s actions and the changes will ultimately impact every living thing on this planet (positively and negatively). Definitions: Climate: the average course or condition of the weather at a place usually over a period of years as exhibited by temperature, wind velocity, and precipitation (Merriam-Webster, 2013) Climate Change: A change in the state of the climate that can be identified (e.g., by using statistical tests) by changes in the mean and/or the variability of its properties and that persists for an extended period, typically decades or longer. Climate change may be due to natural internal processes or external forces, or to persistent anthropogenic changes in the composition of the atmosphere or in land use. (IPCC, 2011) Global Warming: a gradual increase in the overall temperature of the earth's atmosphere generally attributed to the greenhouse effect caused by increased levels of carbon dioxide, chlorofluorocarbons, and other pollutants. (Cambridge Dictionary, 2013) Weather: the state of the atmosphere with respect to heat or cold, wetness or dryness, calm or storm, clearness or cloudiness (Merriam-Webster, 2013) Weather and climate confuse most people. As per the definitions above climate is based upon long term weather data. Climate is what we expect, weather is what we get. For more information on this and other topics visit the University of Maryland Extension website at www.extension.umd.edu 1 Using Climate: We use climate for a number of important long term planning tasks including agriculture (when to plant crops), travel and leisure (when and where to go on vacation), construction (how and what to build), fashion (how we dress), and nutrition (what we eat). Looking at climate provides a snapshot of what the weather is expected to be during a specific time period in a region. The overall climate of an area can dictates the survival or the failure of living things. Using Weather: Weather is used for short term planning. We can look at forecasts a few days in advance to see what clothing we are going to wear on a given day, or if we are going to be inside or outside for our activities. Where individual weather events may have catastrophic effects (such as tornadoes, hurricanes, flash floods, drought) it is generally not weather that causes the survival or failure for survival of living things in a region. Activity: Knowing when to use Weather and Climate Supplies needed: Note cards (one for each student or group) Set up instructions: Print each of the following scenarios on a note card. Divide the students into groups (this activity can be done without groups if you have a small class). Hand a note card to each student/group and have them decide whether looking up the climate of a location is appropriate or looking at the weather would be appropriate. Have the students discuss. The answer is in parenthesis; however, your students may have a valid reason to look at something different. Scenarios: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. You are planning on going to a new state for college. (Climate) You are going to a football game on Friday of this week. (Weather) You are buying new clothes for a vacation you are taking next year. (Climate) You need to know if you need an umbrella at 12:00pm today. (Weather) You are planting a garden. (Climate) You are going sailing today and need to know about the wind. (Weather) You are planning a hike along the Appalachian Trail which will take 6 months. (Climate) You are building a house. (Climate) For more information on this and other topics visit the University of Maryland Extension website at www.extension.umd.edu 2 9. You are starting an ostrich farm. (Climate) 10. You are jogging and need to know if you should wear shorts or sweatpants. (Weather) Activity: A practice in using climate This activity is one that can be used for all ages. It may be adapted for everyone from preschool to college age. Purpose: To give students an opportunity to use climatic information as opposed to weather. Preschool (non-readers): Supplies: Create a yearlong calendar of a fictional land. (If you are doing a unit on a children’s book this could easily be incorporated) Either cut outs of weather appropriate clothing, or visit a thrift shop and collect various clothing that would be appropriate to the weather that you put on your calendar. Suitcase (or box decorated like a suitcase) Weather calendar or chart for your area Procedure: Put out the clothing on the floor in the middle of a circle. Have the children sit around the pile of clothing (either real clothing or cut outs) Work around the circle and assign each child a month that they are traveling to the fictitious land. Instruct the child to stand up, and collect the clothing they would pack for the weather that they “Should” experience. Keep a weather calendar in the classroom for a month showing what the weather was like (temperature for older children, symbols of the weather conditions for young children). Have the children decide at the end of a month what type of weather they had the most of. Create a calendar like the one below representing the weather that was mostly observed. Show the children that this is your climate calendar-what you expect the weather to be. Even though you may get a rainy day here or there, the most of the weather would be something different. Climate is when you expect the weather that you experience the most, during a time period. For more information on this and other topics visit the University of Maryland Extension website at www.extension.umd.edu 3 Jan Feb Mar Apr May June July Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec PreK climate weather calendar Lower/upper Elementary School: Supplies: Travel guides to locations your children would be interested in traveling to. Outdoor Thermometer Weather calendar Procedure: Prior to this unit have your students chart the weather for each day they are in school. Have them look at the temperature, and the overall conditions at the same time each day. At the end of the month, have them decide what they would tell someone about that month in your location. Is it mostly sunny, rainy, or snowy? Explain that weather is a day to day occurrence, but climate is what the average weather looks like. So what they tell people to expect would be the climate of the region, not necessarily the weather of the region. Demonstrate to your students how to use a travel guide. Show them how to look up the climate of the location and assign them a time of year that you are sending them to that location. Lower elementary: Have your students draw a picture of what they would pack during that time of year at that location based upon the climate. Have them also prepare for mysterious events in the weather that they might encounter based upon their research. Upper Elementary: Have your students write an essay on what they would pack during that time of year at that location based upon the climate. AND/OR Have them write an essay on what time of year they would like to visit that location with reasoning based around climate and what activities they would do and what they would pack. Middle School: For more information on this and other topics visit the University of Maryland Extension website at www.extension.umd.edu 4 Supplies: Travel guides for various countries around the world (or access to the library with those guides) Access to a computer with internet (Weather Underground wunderground.com, NOAA noaa.gov, or weather channel weather.com) World maps that students can copy or write on Graph paper, excel spreadsheet, or science notebook Procedure: This project can be adjusted depending on the time available and learning abilities of your students. Begin this project at the beginning of the month to be optimal. Discuss the difference between climate and weather with your students. Assign your students one or more countries from around the world to research. Have them find the countries on the map, and make a prediction as to what they would expect the weather to be during this time of year (temperature, overall weather conditions, rainfall etc) based upon the location in the world. Once they have made their predictions have them use the travel guides to look up what is the climate for this country during this time of year. Have them create a graph showing the temperature and rainfall expected for an entire month. Using the internet and a respected weather website (NOAA, Weather Underground, Weather Channel etc) have your students take a daily reading on what the weather is in their country(ies) (temperature, overall weather conditions, rainfall). Have them keep track of this in their spreadsheet or in their science notebook. At the end of the month, have them graph the temperature and rainfall on the same chart that they graphed the climatic information. Have them take an average rainfall and an average temperature to see how close the climate prediction was to the actual weather. **note some countries use Celcius to describe their temperature so you may have to demonstrate how to convert Celcius to Fahrenheit or vice versa. Data should be consistent in order to do an accurate comparison. High School: Food production is a big concern when we discuss the world and climate change. For this project you will have students take on a project of researching how to maximize crops for a given climate. This can be a lengthy project. (But most of it can be done from home). Supplies: Access to a computer with internet Map of the United States (large map) Bulletin/cork board/magnet board A dart (with a point if you are using the cork board, magnetic if you are using the magnet board) Zone Map of the United States (can be found in seed or nursery stock catalogs) Seed catalogs For more information on this and other topics visit the University of Maryland Extension website at www.extension.umd.edu 5 Travel guides or access to travel bureaus across the United States Science notebooks or excel or another database program Procedures: Put your United States Map onto the cork board/magnet board Have each of your students throw the dart, and wherever their dart lands that is the town they are tasked with creating a successful garden plan. Assign them an area of land (Acre, 2 Acres, 25 Acres, etc) to farm. First have the students research what the expected climate/growing season is in that area. They can do this by researching tourism bureaus for that state or contacted the Extension Service in that state. (Extension Agents might even suggest plants that would grow in an area as a bit of a cheat, but they are getting a skill in asking). *For an added challenge, have them create a planting plan for the time of year you do this project Provide the students with a budget for the amount of seeds/plants that they can purchase. Each student has to decide how to use their money to grow enough food to take care of their family for that growing period. Have the students create a representation showing how they would set up their garden for maximum production and which plants they would use. (**For an added challenge have them use graph paper and put things to scale, using the space guidelines for the plants) In their science notebooks, have the students write down requirements for each plant that they have chosen (water, sunlight, temperatures, etc) as well as the time to maturity. They should also write the expected average temperature, rainfall, and sunlight amount for the area. Each day have the students look up the weather for their location. Have them create a database with the daily high and low temperatures and the amount of rainfall and the overall weather conditions. If possible have them do this for the time period of the plants maturity. Have each student come to a conclusion based upon the weather information that they have taken if their plants succeeded or failed. Have the students average their daily high temperatures and rainfall amounts to see how it may have differed from the climate they had been told to expect. Activity: What is Climate Change? For Upper Elementary-High School Supplies: For more information on this and other topics visit the University of Maryland Extension website at www.extension.umd.edu 6 At least 2 blank dodecahedron dice for each person or group working on this project Permanent markers in 2 or more different colors Graph paper Colored pencils in 4 colors for each group Set Up: Choose three different sharpie pens to use to identify your dice (It is not recommended to use red and blue because students will associate these colors with heating and cooling.) On one die per group (this die should be labeled with a distinct color sharpie) label 5 sides with 78, 5 sides with 76, one side with 70 and one side with 80 On another one of the dice label as follows (this die should be labeled with a distinct colored sharpie): 5 sides with 77, 1 side with 80, 2 side with 70, 4 sides with 76 On the final die for the group label as follows (this die should be labeled with a distinct colored sharpie): 5 sides 80, 4 sides 78, 1 side 76, 1 side 70, 1 side 77 Give each group one die at a time. Procedures: Discuss what climate is (A long term average of weather conditions). Climate information is generally taken over the course of 10-20 years. Tell your students they are going to be doing a simulation of 1020 years of data collection. Each roll of the dice represents an average temperature for the month of September in one year. (e.g. roll #1 September, 2000 average temp 78 ⁰ F; roll #2 September, 2001 average temp 81 ⁰ F) Have the students roll the die and record what number it lands on. The number represents degrees Fahrenheit. Younger groups will roll the die ten times. Older student will roll the die twenty times. When they are finished with rolling the die and recording their temperatures they should plot them on the graph paper. (Using a designated colored pencil they should create a line graph). Once they graph their results they should then average their results and graph that line (using a different colored pencil) Exchange the original die with a different colored die. Have the students repeat the exercise. When everyone is done, ask if they noticed a big change in temperatures when they were rolling the dice. (Most children would argue no, since they see similar temperatures within a degree or two). For more information on this and other topics visit the University of Maryland Extension website at www.extension.umd.edu 7 Then ask if the average temperature overall was different. (The answer will most likely be “Yes” but not by much). Ask them if they were outside during September would they notice the difference between the first average temperature and the second average temperature? (Most large animals can’t discern between a degree or two difference in climate) Discuss with your students how microbes have very narrow bands of temperature and conditions that they are able to survive and thrive in. If the average temperature changes by just ½ a degree that may mean that something that would typically die off won’t or something else that may typically thrive won’t. Carbon Sources and Sinks: For Upper Elementary through High School Students Supplies needed: Bubble solution, various different bubble wands, optional: Bubble machine Purpose: To demonstrate to students what causes carbon to enter the atmosphere and what collects carbon from the atmosphere. This activity also demonstrates how challenging it can be to keep the carbon cycle in balance. Set up: Start the game with giving each child access to one bubble wand. Provide access to bubble solution and access to additional wands. Procedure: Explain that carbon makes up all living things. It is an extremely important element on the planet Earth and it is required for the survival of the planet. As with most important elements there is a cycle for Carbon where it flows from one living thing to another keeping a perfect balance. Carbon is released into the atmosphere from Carbon Sources, some examples of natural sources are: Animals (respiration, digestion and decomposition), forest fires, volcanoes, and oceans. Carbon is reabsorbed from the atmosphere through Carbon Sinks, some examples of natural carbon sinks are: Plants and trees, the ocean (the ocean is both a source and a sink), and the atmosphere. To demonstrate a successful balance have your class divide into two groups. One group will be the sources, and they will be blowing bubbles, and one group will be the sinks…they will be popping the bubbles. The goal of this exercise is to not have a lot of bubbles floating around in the room. Now to add human caused sources of carbon. Humans can emit extra carbon by utilizing fossil fuels and burning plant matter to provide power and warmth for their life styles. Ask the students if they participate in the following activities: 1. Use coal electricity or natural gas to power the following: TV’s, lights, refrigerators, heaters, air conditioners, gaming systems, radios, computers, cell phones, and any other gadgets or gizmos in their homes. (If they do, they can add an additional bubble wand) For more information on this and other topics visit the University of Maryland Extension website at www.extension.umd.edu 8 2. If they use a private family vehicle to do all of their errands even short distance errands. (If so they can add another bubble wand). 3. If they send their garbage to an incinerator. (If so, they can add another bubble wand). 4. If they cut down trees to use as firewood, without replacing them. (If so they can add a bubble wand) 5. If they purchase items from far away from their home. Foreign cars, toys, clothing, etc. (If so they can add a bubble wand). 6. If they use ATV’s, gas and electric lawn mowers, or other gas or electric tools (If so add another bubble wand) Once the students have their wands together set up the room similar to how you did when observing the cycle. They may utilize any way possible to get all of the wands to produce bubbles, they can wave their arms, they can blow across them, and they can put their wands in front of a fan. Set an amount of time for blowing bubbles and popping bubbles 2-3 minutes should be adequate. The carbon sink students will have to pop the bubbles. Were there any bubbles still left in the room after the popping was over? Was it easier or harder to pop the bubbles with so many bubbles in the air? Now, reduce the number of sinks…when we remove vegetation and trees for construction and other projects it changes the carbon cycle. So choose a few people who were bubble poppers to become bubble blowers. Have the new bubble blowers assess how many wands they will need. Run the exercise again and see what happens. You should see that there is more carbon in the atmosphere with fewer sinks present. Have your students brain storm about what they can do to reduce the amount of carbon in the atmosphere based upon this exercise. A Melting Ice Cap Understanding the Albedo Effect Supplies needed: White paper and dark blue or brown or black construction paper (enough for one sheet per child). Purpose: The Polar Ice Cap has been melting at an alarming rate, which leads people to believe that the temperature change at the poles is extremely large. This is not necessarily the truth. What we are experiencing with the polar ice cap melting is a loss of heat reflective material (ice and snow) and an increased amount of heat absorbing material (open ocean). This creates a negative feedback loop which increases the melting process of the snow and ice. We do not see the rapid nature of the ice melting at the South Pole because the ice cap is on land, and land is not as heat absorbent as the dark open ocean is. Procedure: Give all but one student a white piece of paper. Have them old the white piece of paper above their heads. Give the other student a dark piece of paper. Explain to the class that white reflects the sun’s rays and heat where dark absorbs the sun’s rays. Imagine if the temperature of the For more information on this and other topics visit the University of Maryland Extension website at www.extension.umd.edu 9 North Pole went up a half of a degree F. What do you think would happen? Would the ice melt or stay the same? Would it be fast or would it be slow? The ice would melt, slowly. Have three children put down their white paper and pick up dark paper. Now talk about the open ocean. The ocean is dark, and absorbs heat. Would it slow down the melting of the ice, or would it speed things up? The ice would begin to melt quicker. Have anyone who is next to the dark paper put down their white paper and pick up a dark paper. Now we have even more open ocean. What is going to happen to the ice around it? The ice will melt even faster. Anyone next to a dark paper should put down their white paper and pick up a dark paper. Do this until all the white is gone. Follow up question: Did the ambient (air) temperature change any more than the ½ degree F? Answer: No. However, the ocean absorbed the sun’s rays and it increased the ability to melt the surrounding ice. Resources: NASA.edu. “Radiation Budget Lesson: Exploring Albedo.” Web 7. Aug. 2015. http://scienceedu.larc.nasa.gov/EDDOCS/scierbe.html Cambridge Dictionary. Cambridge, n.d “Global Warming.” Web 3. Sept. 2013. http://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/dictionary/american-english/global-warming IPCC.ch. Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. n.d “Climate Change.” Web 3. Sept. 2013 http://www.ipcc.ch/pdf/special-reports/srex/SREX-Annex_Glossary.pdf Merriam-Webster.com. Merriam-Webster, n.d "Climate." . Web. 3 Sept. 2013. <http://www.merriamwebster.com/dictionary/climate>. Merriam-Webster.com. Merriam-Webster, n.d,. "Weather." Web. 3 Sept. 2013. <http://www.merriamwebster.com/dictionary/weather> The Science Museum. “Climate Changing….A Series of Thought Provoking Events.” Web. 7.Aug. 2015 For more information on this and other topics visit the University of Maryland Extension website at www.extension.umd.edu 1 http://www.sciencemuseum.org.uk/ClimateChanging/ClimateScienceInfoZone/ExploringEarthsclimate/ 1point6/1point6point1.aspx For more information on this and other topics visit the University of Maryland Extension website at www.extension.umd.edu 1 Kim Dixon This publication, (full designation type) (publication number), is a series of publications of the University of Maryland Extension and Program/department name. The information presented has met UME peer review standards, including internal and external technical review. For more information on related publications and programs, visit: program url. Please visit http://extension.umd.edu/ to find out more about Extension programs in Maryland. The University of Maryland Extension programs are open to any person and will not discriminate against anyone because of race, age, sex, color, sexual orientation, physical or mental disability, religion, ancestry, national origin, marital status, genetic information, political affiliation, and gender identity or expression. For more information on this and other topics visit the University of Maryland Extension website at www.extension.umd.edu 1