A Database on Submarine Landslides of the Mediterranean Sea A. Camerlenghi, R. Urgeles, and L. Fantoni Abstract Submarine landslides are ubiquitous along the continental margins of the Mediterranean basin and occur on tectonically-dominated margins as well as on passive margins and volcanic island flanks. Tectonically quiet zones seem to have the highest density of known events. Most landslides occur as long run-out distance debris flows, but slumps and deep-seated failures are also relatively common. In abyssal plains the distal product of massive failures is recorded as large megaturbidites, while on volcanic islands the dominant failure type is flank-collapse with development of debris avalanches. Submarine landslides, excluding megaturbidites, appear to occur in all water depths between the coastline and about 2000 m. Most landslides occupy areas ranging from a few to about 600 km2 and volumes up to 220 km3. Abyssal plain megaturbidites can attain 60,000 km2 and 1,000 km3. The landslides headwall height are clustered around two modes: 0 to 40 m for relatively small landslides and 160 to 200 m for the largest ones. Most recorded submarine landslides are relatively young in age and several events appear to group near the Pleistocene to Holocene transition. Keywords Submarine landslide • geohazard • Mediterranean • megaturbidite • mass wasting • Pleistocene • Holocene A. Camerlenghi () ICREA, Istitució Catalana de Recerca i Estudis Avançats, Barcelona, Spain; Departament d’Estratigrafia, Paleontologia i Geociències Marines, Facultat de Geologia, Universitat de Barcelona, C/Martí i Franquès, s/n, E-08028 Barcelona, Spain e-mail: acamerlenghi@ub.edu R. Urgeles Departament d’Estratigrafia, Paleontologia i Geociències Marines, Facultat de Geologia, Universitat de Barcelona, C/Martí i Franquès, s/n, E-08028 Barcelona, Spain e-mail: urgeles@ub.edu L. Fantoni Dipartimento di Scienze della Terra, Università di Modena e Reggio Emilia, Via S. Eufemia, 19, 41100 Modena, Italy e-mail: laura.fantoni@unimore.it D.C. Mosher et al. (eds.), Submarine Mass Movements and Their Consequences, Advances in Natural and Technological Hazards Research, Vol 28, © Springer Science + Business Media B.V. 2010 503 504 1 A. Camerlenghi et al. Introduction The Mediterranean basin is a miniature ocean that has been often called a “natural geological laboratory” because of its diversity in tectonic and sedimentary environments (Fig. 1). The basin is limited by different margin types: active margins such as the incipient continental collision in the eastern Mediterranean; transcurrent tectonic margins, such as the Levant margin; young rifted margins in the three back-arc basins (Aegean, Tyrrhenian and Alboran) and in the Sicily Channel; older rifted (passive) margins bounding the Algero Provençal Sea; and passive margins re-activated by tectonic compression (the African margin from Tunisia to Morocco). Although some of the Mediterranean margins are tectonically active (Fig. 2), there are other areas considered as tectonically inactive based on the instrumental record (the Balearic promontory, the Gulf of Valencia, the Sardinia and Corsica margins, and the African Margin from Libya to Egypt). The Mediterranean basin includes major siliciclastic sedimentary wedges fed by the Nile, Rhone, Ebro and Po rivers, as well as sediment starved margins (Balearic, West Corsica and Sardinia, Cyprus, Cyrenaica). The Mediterranean coastline is very densely populated, totalling 160 million inhabitants sharing 46,000 km of coastline. As World’s leading holiday destination, the area receives up to 30% of global tourism and an average of 135 million visitors annually (EEA 2005). When compared to other oceanic basins, the Mediterranean is more vulnerable to marine geohazards due not only to the high density of coastal population, but also to its small dimensions. The latter results in close proximity between tsunami sources (induced by either a submarine landslide or co-seismic seafloor displacement) and impact areas. During the Holocene (<10,000 years), Fig. 1 Tectonic lineaments of the Mediterranean. Modified after Camerlenghi and Pini (2009) A Database on Submarine Landslides of the Mediterranean Sea 0 10W 10E 20E 505 30E 40E 50N 45N 40N 35N 30N Fig. 2 Map of instrumentally recorded seismicity shallower than 50 km in the Mediterranean region. From Vannucci et al. (2004) (permission requested from the publisher). ISC: International Seismological Centre; Mw: Moment Magnitude. Blue bands: Main active deformation areas there is evidence that tsunamis have been common in the Mediterranean basin, and that their consequences have caused severe damage to ancient coastal settlements of the Levant margin, Cyprus and the Hellenic Arc (e.g. Salamon et al. 2007; Papadopoulos and Fokaefs 2005). With the aim to understand the causes of the sediment mass movements identified in recent years in the sedimentary record of the Mediterranean continental margins, we have undertaken a compilation of information from the scientific literature into a GIS based framework. This work provides a first step towards the analysis of geohazard from submarine landslides (e.g. Morgan et al. 2009; Camerlenghi et al. 2007) in the Mediterranean basin. Due to incomplete seafloor mapping, some information is inevitably missing and the database should be considered as in progress. However, the information gathered allows us to draw some preliminary conclusions on the occurrence of submarine landslides in relation to geological setting and sedimentary regime. 2 Methods Information on submarine landslides reported in published research articles was entered in a geographically referenced framework using ArcGIS 9.2. For each landslide the following parameters were entered into the database: boundaries of scar 506 A. Camerlenghi et al. and deposit digitized from scanned or captured figures; name; geographic position; geological setting (e.g. strike slip margin, passive margin); area and volume (defined in the literature and/or calculated); thickness of the sedimentary deposit; height of the headwall; water depth of top and bottom of the headwall; typology; age; recurrence time (if any); estimated trigger mechanism; associated tsunamigenesis; availability of geotechnical information; and finally one or more reference articles. For typology, we selected the following terms according to the terminology in the original manuscripts: Debris Avalanche; debris flow; deep-seated failure (when recognized mainly in deep penetration seismic profiles rather than bathymetric maps); glide; gravitational collapse; mass failure; mass transport; mass wasting; megaturbidite; slide; slump. Such terms often describe similar deposits. For the time being we have not modified the terminology. It is obvious that a unified terminology is needed for correct understanding and comparison of sedimentary deposits originated from submarine sediment mass transport. Slide scars (upper limit of the slide headwall) have been digitized as polylines. Deposits have been digitized as polygons. Where the volume of the deposit is not reported by authors, an approximate volume has been calculated from the minimum thickness in seismic profiles. We are in the process of implementing the database and making it available online. For any query in the meantime, please contact the authors. Figure 3 shows all submarine landslides of the data set superimposed on the bathymetric map of the Mediterranean sea. Summary plots of the main characteristics of the slides are displayed in Fig. 4. With an area less than 400 km2, and a volume less than 100 km3, the majority of the submarine landslides of the Mediterranean basin are relatively small in size, at least compared to the huge submarine landslides of the North Atlantic (e.g. Hühnerbach et al. 2004). Most of the slides are classified by authors as debris flow deposits or slumps, with a considerable number being classified generically as deep seated failure. However, the type of mass transport deposit that covers the largest area of seafloor is that of megaturbidites, covering an area exceeding 130,000 km2 compared to a nearly 40,000 km2 covered by all other deposits together. It must be noted that turbidites other than megaturbidites (see for comparison Cita et al. 1984a) have not been taken into account in this analysis. 3 Results Most of the landslides originate on the mid-upper continental slope, in water depths generally shallower than 1,000 m and generate headwalls mostly less than 40 m high. However, there is also a cluster of the largest landslides with headwalls height ranging from 160 to 200 m (Fig. 4). According to the authors whose published work has been used for this compilation, about one quarter of the landslides are believed to be recurrent events in the geological record. Only 15% of the landslides are believed to have caused a tsunami. Fig. 3 Display of all the submarine landslides of the database superimposed to the shaded relief map of the bathymetry (IOC, IHO and BODC 2003; Medimap Group et al. 2008) A Database on Submarine Landslides of the Mediterranean Sea 507 508 A. Camerlenghi et al. Fig. 4 Statistical distribution of significant parameters of submarine landslides in the Mediterr anean basin 3.1 Landslides Distribution with Respect to Geo-tectonic Environment Submarine landslides occur in very different geological settings of the Mediterranean continental margins. Noticeable is the density of known events on the margins of the Balearic promontory in the Western Mediterranean (e.g. Lastras et al. 2004; 2006), which is one of the instrumentally aseismic regions (Vannucci et al. 2004) and where sedimentation is characterized by low-rate settling of carbonate pelagic particles (Canals and Ballesteros 1997). In contrast, the submarine landslides of the Nile deep sea fan (e.g. Garziglia et al. 2008), also located in a tectonically quiet region, occur in a Plio-Quaternary sedimentary succession exceeding 2,000 m in thickness (Loncke et al. 2002) whose sedimentary architecture is affected by A Database on Submarine Landslides of the Mediterranean Sea 509 Miocene reactivation of the Suez-Red Sea Rift system (Mascle et al. 2000) and by thin-skinned gravity gliding and spreading above the Messinian salt layer (Gaullier et al. 2000; Loncke et al. 2006). In the case of the Ebro Margin (Casas et al. 2003; Lastras et al. 2002) and the Rhone deep sea fan (Droz et al. 2006), both considered as seismically quiet zones based on the instrumental record, recurrent mass wasting throughout the history of sediment accretion is linked to over-steepening and reduction of shear strength induced by differential compaction and associated faulting (e.g. Urgeles et al. 2006). The tectonically active Levant margin experienced recurrent episodes of largescale failure associated with Plio-Quaternary faults (e.g. Almagor and Wiseman 1997), either within a margin-parallel mega-shear zone (e.g. Neev et al. 1982), subduction reactivated by strike-slip faulting (Tapponnier 2004), or as a consequence of basinwards flow of Messinian salt (Frey-Martinez et al. 2005). One intriguing aspect is the lack of evidence for modern submarine slides at the deformation front of the Calabrian and Mediterranean ridges accretionary wedges. The reason must be found in a combination of geo-tectonic factors (Camerlenghi and Pini 2009): (1) low taper angle (as low as 1°) of the accretionary prisms detaching over the ductile Messinian halite as opposed to 8–12° angle of frictional wedges, (2) low hemipelagic sedimentation rate, and (3) the barrier to deeply seated fluid migration imposed by the 3,000 m or thicker Messinian halite layer below the eastern Mediterranean foredeeps (Costa et al. 2004). Conversely, there are large volume mass transport deposits in the Gela basin (offshore Sicily) which is under present-day salt-free deformation within the foredeep of the Maghrebian fold-and-thrust belt. One of the most extensive mass transport deposits is the 600 ka b.p. Gela submarine slide complex, up to 700 m thick, 30 km long and 90 km wide (Di Stefano et al. 1993; Trincardi and Argnani 1990). The NE portion of Gela basin is also affected by multiple slope failures originated during the late-Quaternary (Minisini et al. 2007). Submarine landslides from volcanic flank collapse are presently not fully represented in the database, because the majority of these landslides originate above sealevel. The database will be implemented for inclusions of such landslides. A final remark is about the several late Pleistocene megaturbidites found at shallow depth in the main abyssal plains of the Mediterranean basin: the Herodotus basin Megaturbidite (HBM, at least 20 m thick, lateral extent of 40,000 km2 and a volume of approximately 400 km3) (Rothwell et al. 2000; Reeder et al. 2000); The “Augias Megaturbidite”, or “Homogenite” underlain by two other 10–35 m thick megaturbidites in the Ionian Abyssal Plain (e.g. Rebesco et al. 2000; Hieke 2000); and the 8–10 m thick megaturbidite of the Balearic abyssal plain (e.g. Rothwell et al. 2000; 1998; Cita et al. 1984b). These megaturbidites are thought to reflect major catastrophic collapses of the adjacent continental margins. Apart form the possible link to the Santorini Volcanic caldera collapse put forth for the “Homogenite”, there is no available information on the submarine landslide from which these megaturbidites originated. 510 A. Camerlenghi et al. Fig. 5 Most possible youngest age spectrum of submarine landslides in the Mediterranean basin compared with the mean eustatic sea level from Pillans et al. (1998) 3.2 Age Not all the submarine landslides in the database are supported by accurate dating information. Based on the failure age bracket provided in the literature, we have assigned a youngest possible age to each landslide. The resulting age spectrum (Fig. 5) indicates clearly that the vast majority of the landslides have occurred between 20 and 10 ka b.p., and therefore the coincidence with the last major global climatic change, corresponding to the deglaciation following the last glacial maximum, is striking. 4 Global Implications and Conclusions The database shows unequivocally that submarine landslides are common on Mediterranean continental margins that are seismically inactive. This observation should be used to resolve the present-day paradigm often used in the scientific literature, that earthquakes are the main triggers for large submarine landslides (e.g. Masson et al. 2006; Canals et al. 2004; Locat and Lee 2002). It is known that there are fewer large failures along present-day tectonically active margins (e.g. the Oregon margin, McAdoo and Watts 2004), than along passive continental margins (e.g. ten Brink et al. 2008). Despite larger magnitude earthquakes, the slopes of accretionary complexes and margins undergoing tectonic erosion in many places do not fail because the sediments are over-consolidated. The shear resistance A Database on Submarine Landslides of the Mediterranean Sea 511 is generally higher in these sediments than in the generally under-consolidated sediments of large deep sea fans building up at passive continental margins (Camerlenghi and Pini 2009). The sediment mass movement at active margins occurs primarily in the form of cohesive failure (blocky landslides and slumps) producing high headwalls and short run-out distance on steeper slope with respect to passive margins. Despite being relatively small, these submarine landslides are indeed the ones with the higher tsunamigenic potential (McAdoo and Watts 2004). The correlation of many of the Mediterranean submarine landslides with the last deglaciation appears to support similar observations from the North Atlantic (Lee 2008; ten Brink et al. 2008; Maslin et al. 2004; Owen et al. 2007) and may be viewed as in contrast with the classical view in basin sequence stratigraphy that build-up of deep sea fans by turbidity currents occur mostly during periods of relative sea-level fall (Falling Stage Systems Tract, e.g. Posamentier and Vail 1988). As pointed out recently by Lee (2008) there are some key preconditioning factors that contribute to the decrease of marine sediment strength on continental margins. These are the sediment input, the interstitial fluid pressure, and gas hydrate dissociation. When these preconditioning factors produce weak sediment on a continental slope, then the cyclic loading from earthquakes, even if of low magnitude, can indeed generate slope failure. Intra-plate seismicity on passive margins induced by the isostatic response to glacial load is climatically modulated in phase with sediment input, interstitial fluid pressure, and gas hydrate dissociation. However, because glacially induced isostatic rebound and gas hydrate dissociation likely play no role in generating slope instability of the Mediterranean continental slopes, the observed concentration of submarine landslides during the last deglaciation points to additional climate change control on initiation of slope failure in addition to seismicity. Preconditioning factors that are climatically modulated, such as the fluctuations of the ground water reservoir (Dan et al. 2007) or the deposition of sediments with typical low shear resistance, like contourites (Laberg and Camerlenghi 2008), should also be taken into consideration. As a final remark, we want to stress that taking into account that unknown tsunami sources most probably correspond to aseismic submarine landslides (on-line Mediterranean Tsunami Catalog, 1628B.C.-to present; Institute of Computational Mathematics and Mathematical Geophysics. Novosibirsk, RUSSIA, http://tsun. sscc.ru/tsulab/On_line_Cat.htm) the second most frequent cause of tsunamis in the Mediterranean basin, after earthquakes, are submarine landslides. Surely, not enough experience has been gained on the subject and further studies are necessary, including scientific drilling and in situ monitoring, in order to assess the geohazard potential of submarine landslides in a highly vulnerable area such as the Mediterranean basin. Acknowledgments This study has benefited from a travel grant to L. Fantoni from the University of Modena for a research stay at the University of Barcelona. The analysis is part of the contribution of the University of Barcelona to IODP proposal #517 (MEDSLIDES) presently under evaluation. This a scientific contribution of GRC Geociències Marines, supported by the Generalitat de Catalunya program for excellence research groups (ref. 2005SGR00152). Helpful and constructive critical reviews of the first draft were provided by Brandon Dugan and Michi Strasser. 512 A. Camerlenghi et al. References Almagor G, Wiseman G (1997) Analysis of submarine slumping in the continental slope of the southern coast of Israel. Mar Geotech 2:349–388. Camerlenghi A, Pini GA (2009) Mud volcanoes, olistostromes, and argille scagliose in the Mediterranean Region. Sedimentol 56:319–365. Camerlenghi A, Urgeles R, Ercilla G, Brückman W (2007) Scientific ocean drilling behind the assessment of geo-hazards from submarine slides. Sci Drill 4:45–47. Canals M, Ballesteros E (1997) Production of carbonate particles by phytobenthic communities on the Mallorca-Menorca Shelf, northwestern Mediterranean Sea. Deep-Sea Res II 44:611–629. Canals M, Lastras G Urgeles R et al. (2004) Slope failure dynamics and impacts from seafloor and shallow sub-seafloor geophysical data: an overview, Mar Geol 213:9–72. Casas D, Ercilla G et al. (2003) Recent mass-movement processes on the Ebro continental slope (NW Mediterranean). Mar Petrol Geol 20:445–457. Cita MB, Beghi C, Camerlenghi A et al. (1984a) Turbidites and megaturbidites from Herodotus abyssal plain (eastern Mediterranean) unrelated to seismic events. Mar Geol 55:79–101. Cita MB, Camerlenghi A, Kastens KA et al. (1984b) New findings of Bronze Age Homogenites in the Ionian Sea: geodynamic implications for the Mediterranean. Mar Geol 55:47–62. Costa E, Camerlenghi A, Polonia A et al. (2004) Modeling deformation and salt tectonics in the Eastern Mediterranean Ridge accretionary wedge. Geol Soc Am Bull 116:880–894. Dan G. Sultan N, Savoye B (2007) The 1979 Nice harbour catastrophe revisited: Trigger mechanism inferred from geotechnical measurements and numerical modelling. Mar Geol 245:40–64. Di Stefano E, Infuso S, Scarantino S (1993) Plio-Pleistocene sequence stratigraphy of southwestern offshore Sicily from well logs and seismic sections in a high-resolution calcareous plankton biostratigraphic framework. In: Max MD, Colantoni P (eds) UNESCO Tech Repts Mar Sci 58:105–110. Droz L, dos Reis AT, Rabineau M (2006) Quaternary turbidite systems on the northern margins of the Balearic Basin (Western Mediterranean): a synthesis. Geo-Mar Lett 26:347–359. European Environmental Agency (2005) European environment outlook. EEA Report No 4/2005. Frey Martinez J, Cartwright J, Hallw B (2005) 3D seismic interpretation of slump complexes: examples from the continental margin of Israel. Basin Res 17:83–108. Garziglia S, Migeon S, Ducassou E et al. (2008) Mass-transport deposits on the Rosetta province (NW Nile deep-sea turbidite system, Egyptian margin): characteristics, distribution, and potential causal processes. Mar Geol 250:180–198. Gaullier V, Mart Y, Bellaiche G et al. (2000) Salt tectonics in and around the Nile deep-sea fan: insights from the PRISMED II cruise. Geol Soc Spec Publ 174:111–129. Hieke W (2000) Transparent layers in seismic reflection records from the central Ionian Sea (Mediterranean) – evidence for repeated catastrophic turbidite sedimentation during the Quaternary. Sediment. Geol Vol 135:89–98. Hühnerbach V, Masson DG et al. (2004) Landslides in the North Atlantic and its adjacent seas: an analysis of their morphology, setting and behaviour. Mar Geol 213:343–362. IOC, IHO and BODC (2003) GEBCO digital atlas (Intergovernmental Oceanographic Commission and International Hydrographic Organization) British Oceanographic Data Centre, Liverpool, U.K. Laberg JS, Camerlenghi A (2008) The significance of contourites for submarine slope stability. In: Rebesco M, Camerlenghi A (eds) Contourites, Devel Sediment 60: 537–556. Lastras G, Canals M, Urgeles R et al. (2004) Shallow slides and pockmark swarms in the Eivissa Channel Western Mediterranean Sea. Sedimentol 51:837–850. Lastras G, Canals M, Amblas D et al. (2006) Eivissa slides, western Mediterranean Sea: morphology and processes. Geo-Mar Lett 26:225–233. Lastras G, Canals M, Hughes-Clarke JE et al. (2002) Seafloor imagery from the BIG’95 debris flow, Western Mediterranean. Geol 30:871–874. Lee HJ (2008) Timing of occurrence of large submarine landslides on the Atlantic Ocean margin. Mar Geol. doi:10.1016/j.margeo.2008.09.009. A Database on Submarine Landslides of the Mediterranean Sea 513 Locat J, Lee HJ (2002) Submarine landslides: advances and challenges. Can Geotech J 39:193–212. Loncke L, Gaullier V et al. (2002) Recent depositional pattern of the NDSF from echo-character mapping. Interactions between turbidity currents, mass-wasting processes and tectonics. Am Assoc Petrol Geol Bull 86:1165–1186. Loncke L, Gaullier V et al. (2006) The Nile deep-sea fan: an example of interacting sedimentation, salt tectonics, and inherited subsalt paleotopographic features. Mar Petrol Geol 23:297–315. Mascle J, Benkhelil J, Bellaiche G et al. (2000) Marine geologic evidence for a Levantine-Sinai plate, a new piece of the Mediterranean puzzle. Geol 28:779–782. Maslin M, Owen M et al. (2004) Linking continental-slope failures and climate change: testing the clathrate gun hypothesis. Geol 32:53–59. Masson DG, Harbitz CB, Wynn RB et al. (2006) Submarine landslides: processes, triggers and hazard prediction. Phil Trans R Soc A 364:2009–2039. McAdoo BG, Watts P (2004) Tsunami hazard from submarine landslides on the Oregon continental slope. Mar Geol 203:235–245. Medimap Group, Loubrieu B., Mascle J. et al. (2008) Morpho-bathymetry of the Mediterranean Sea, CIESM edition. http://www.ciesm.org/marine/morphomap.htm Minisini D, Trincardi F, Asioli A et al. (2007) Morphologic variability of exposed mass-transport deposits on the eastern slope of Gela Basin (Sicily Channel), Basin Res 19:217–240. Morgan JK, Silver E, Camerlenghi A et al. (2009) Addressing geohazards through ocean drilling. Sci Drill 7:15–30. Neev D, Hall JK, Saul JM (1982) The Pelusium megashear system across Africa and associated lineament swarms. J Geophys Res 87:1015–1030. Owen M, Day S, Maslin M (2007) Late Pleistocene submarine mass movements: occurrence and causes, Quat Sci Rev 26:958–978. Papadopoulos GA Fokaefs A (2005) Strong tsunamis in the Mediterranean sea: a re-evaluation. ISET J Earthquake Technol Paper 463, 42:159–170. Pillans B, Chappell J, Nash TR (1998) A review of the Milankovitch climatic beat: template for Plio-Pleistocene sea-level changes and sequence stratigraphy. Sediment Geol 122: 5–21. Posamentier HW, Vail PR (1988) Eustatic controls on clastic deposition. II. Sequence and systems tract models. In: Wilgus CK, Hastings BS, Kendall CGSt.C, Posamentier HW, Ross CA, Van Wagoner JC (eds), Sea level changes – an integrated approach, SEPM Spec Pub 42:125–154. Rebesco M, Della Vedova B et al. (2000) Acoustic facies of Holocene megaturbidites in the Eastern Mediterranean. Sediment Geol 135:65–74. Reeder MS, Rothwell RG, Stow DAV (2000) Influence of sea level and basin physiography on emplacement of the late Pleistocene Herodotus Basin Megaturbidite, SE Mediterranean Sea. Mar Petrol Geol 17:199–218. Rothwell RG, Reeder MS, Anastasakis G et al. (2000) Low sea-level stand emplacement of megaturbidites in the western and eastern Mediterranean Sea. Sediment Geol 135:75–88. Rothwell RG, Thomson J, Kähler G (1998) Low sealevel emplacement of a very large Late Pleistocene megaturbidite in the western Mediterranean Sea. Nat 392:377–380. Salamon A, Rockwell T, Ward SN et al. (2007) Tsunami hazard evaluation of the eastern mediterranean: historical analysis and selected modeling. Bull Seismol Soc Am 97:705–724. Tapponnier PE, Daeron M et al. (2004) Passive-active margin inversion along the Levant plateboundary: subduction birth and growth of Mt Lebanon. AGU Fall Meeting 2004 abs #T52B-05. ten Brink US, Lee HJ et al. (2008) Assessment of tsunami hazard to the U.S. East Coast using relationships between submarine landslides and earthquakes. Mar Geol. doi:10.1016/j. margeo.2008.05.011. Trincardi F, Argnani A (1990) Gela submarine slide; a major basin-wide event in the PlioQuaternary foredeep of Sicily. Geo-Mar Lett 10:13–21. Urgeles R, Leynaud D, Lastras G et al. (2006) Back-analysis and failure mechanisms of a large submarine slide on the Ebro slope, NW Mediterranean, Mar Geol 228:185–206. Vannucci G, Pondrelli S, Argnani A et al. (2004) An atlas of Mediterranean seismicity. Ann Geophys Suppl 47:247–306.