February 2013 10 YEAR FACILITY MASTER PLAN INDEX 1. Scope and Overview 2. a. Index b. North Clackamas School District Ten Year Facility Master Plan – Outline Summary 3. PSU Enrollment Forecast 2013 4. Capacity Study 2013 5. Ten Year Maintenance Forecast 6. ADA Study 7. Athletic Fields Study 8. Food Services Plan 9. Safety and Security 10. Seismic Study 11. Technology Plan 12. Facility Rating Matrix a. Rating Matrix (over-all, core and safety) b. Scoring Criteria ( all pages) 13. Facility Enhance List-Estimate 14. Facility Growth List – Estimate 15. Ten Year Investment – Estimate and graph of investment vs replacement cost Print Date: 11/15/2012 Print Date: 02/13/13 2 of 58 Page 1 of 52 NORTH CLACKAMAS SCHOOL DISTRICT TEN YEAR FACILITY MASTER PLAN Oregon State Statue (ORS 195.110 School Facility Plan) requires that districts with a student enrollment greater than 2,500 have on file a Ten Year Facility Master Plan for facility development. The North Clackamas School District’s Ten Year Facility Master Plan addressed the following areas: 1. Projected student population by age group 2. Projected educational program needs 3. Projected operational (e.g. administration, transportation, maintenance, safety and security) support needs 4. Projected maintenance needs of existing facilities 5. City and county comprehensive plans, designation, property dedication requirements, system development requirements and projected residential and commercial developments 6. Site upgrades and additions required to meet standards, program needs, operational needs and enrollment projections over the next 10 years a. Includes identifying desirable school sites, suitable and permitted by conditional use 7. Analysis of alternatives to new construction and major renovations and the efficient use of school sites 8. Projected costs and timeline 9. Financial plans to meet school facilities needs 10. Possibly recommending adoption of objective criteria to be used by affected cities or county to determine whether adequate capacity exists to accommodate projected development The process for development of the 10 Year Facility Master Plan includes the following: 1. Formation of a 10 year Facility Master Plan Committee composed of: Superintendent Assistant Superintendent for Finance and Operations Assistant Superintendent for Curriculum and Instruction Executive Director of Elementary Programs Executive Director of Secondary Programs Director of Information and Technology Facility Manager Capital Projects Manager (this position will manage the process) 1 of 58 2. Committee reviewed the following information: a. Legal requirements of the 10 Year Facility Master Plan b. Current facilities and property information c. Facilities Maintenance Plan completed in 2011 d. Food Services Master Plan completed in 2009 e. Student enrollment projections and facility capacity analysis completed in 2013 by Portland State University f. Class size information g. Upcoming program and legal requirements that may impact facility design, modifications, and additions h. City and county comprehensive plans, designation, property dedication requirements, system development requirements and projected residential and commercial developments i. Other related information 3. Utilizing all the information provided, the Committee identified property and facility changes and additions needed to accommodate projected academic program needs, operational needs and student enrollment. 4. District representatives will meet and confer with representatives of City of Milwaukie, City of Happy Valley, City of Damascus and Clackamas County on the 10 Year Facility Master Plan. a. Determine that if inadequate land is available to support the plan, the parties will cooperate in identifying land and take necessary actions to enable land to be utilized for school use. b. Agree in writing to future meeting schedule with other agencies. 5. Present 10 Year Facility Master Plan to School Board and possibly recommend adoption of objective criteria to be used by affected cities or county to determine whether adequate capacity exists to accommodate projected development. 6. Board adopts the 10 Year Facility Master Plan as their “Long Term Facilities Plan” (as required by Senate Bill 1036, a construction excise tax may not be imposed unless the school board adopts by resolution a long-term facilities plan for making capital improvements). 2 of 58 NORTH CLACKAMAS SCHOOL DISTRICT TEN YEAR FACILITY MASTER PLAN SUMMARY The Ten Year Facility Master Plan reviewed needed investment in infrastructure for the North Clackamas School District analyzing nine areas. Major Maintenance Growth - Projected growth in enrollment Facility Enhancement - needed upgrades in facilities to bring them up to current standards in safety, security and core facilities, Food Services. Athletics – High School – update standards ADA - Upgrades to meet current Americans With Disabilities Act (ADA) standards Seismic - Upgrades to eliminate all areas rated at high risk in the event of a major seismic event Technology – plan to establish District Standard for Technology Infrastructure Energy – investments necessary to complete energy upgrades identified as having a 15 year or less pay back Support Facilities – improvements or upgrades needed in support facilities such as transportation, facility maintenance and warehousing. A. Ten Year Maintenance An in-depth assessment of all District facilities for projected major maintenance needs was completed in 2012. This study has identified $42M in maintenance needs over a 10 year period (2012 dollars). This figure inflates to $59M if all projected investment in major maintenance is delayed to 2022. B. Growth The District contracted with Portland State University Population Research Department to conduct population and enrollment forecasts through 2023. This study forecasts modest enrollment increases over the next 10 years. Current enrollment K-12 is 17,013. The PSU study forecasts a total K-12 enrollment of 17,916 in 2023. 1) High Schools Clackamas High School is projected to reach a student population of 2629 in 2023. When Clackamas High reaches an enrollment of 2800 – 3000 students it will trigger the need for a fourth District High School. Current demographic studies indicate this will not occur until 2025 at the earliest. When Rock Creek Middle School was constructed it was designed to be converted to a 1500 1800 student facility when the need arose. The conversion process is projected to take 4 years from the date of the decision to proceed with the conversion to opening of the new high school. This time frame includes passing a bond, design, agency approvals, and construction. Milwaukie and Putman High Schools are not projected to reach design capacity within the study period. 3 of 58 2) Middle Schools Current Growth Projections do not indicate a need for an additional middle school during the study period. Upon conversion of Rock Creek from a middle school to a high school Clackamas High East will be converted back to a middle school. 3) Elementary Schools Current projected increases in enrollment indicate that the District as adequate capacity in the K-5 system. The only school that is projected to have significant capacity issues is Scouters Mountain which is project to be over capacity by 90 students in 2023. It is anticipated that Scouters Mountain will need boundary adjustments or 4 modular classrooms in 2016. Sunnyside and Whitcomb elementary schools are also projected to be at or slightly over capacity by 2023. However, with existing modular buildings at those sites there will be adequate classroom space to accommodate the anticipated enrollment. The District has acquired land for two additional elementary schools in the Damascus area. With the currently projected enrollment pattern a need for an additional elementary school will not occur until at least 2025. C. Facility Enhancement All District sites and buildings were evaluated as to their meeting basic standards. The evaluation included safety, security and core facilities. An investment of $55M would be necessary to bring all facilities up to the Districts current Educational Specification Standard. D. High School Athletics A study of all three District High Schools needs for Athletic Field Infrastructure was completed in 2013. This review updated previous studies from 2000 and 2007 and establishes new District Standards for athletic fields. A complete review of the infrastructure needs at the three high schools indicates a potential investment of $14M. Any investment in District athletics infrastructure should be in coordination with other government agencies such as Park Districts and booster groups. E. AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES (ADA) The District contracted with the firm of BBL Architects and Planners for a complete review of ADA accessibility. The review indicated that the District is substantially in compliance with current standards. However, over the years ADA Standards have changed at both the federal and local levels. The study identified a potential investment of $7M to reach full ADA compliance. Neither State nor Federal laws require full compliance. Investment in ADA upgrades would only be mandated if buildings were remodeled or expanded and then only in proportion to the work done. 4 of 58 F. Seismic The District contracted with the firm of Lewis-VanVleet, Structural Engineers to perform a complete assessment of the seismic risk factors for all facilities. This study identified a six schools at which a portion of the building was at high risk in a major seismic event. These included the oldest building at Milwaukie High, New Urban HS, portions of Concord, Sunnyside and Whitcomb Elementary Schools. The study included recommended actions and cost estimates to mitigate the risk. The oldest section of Clackamas Elementary is also rated at high risk but since this building is no long used for District programs seismic upgrades are not included in this study. G. Technology The District Technology and Information Services Department developed a long range plan for technology Infrastructure. This study establishes standards to guide future investments in technology infrastructure for District Facilities and estimates as to the cost of those investments. H. Energy This District has completed energy audits of all facilities. These audits are required as a condition of SB-1149, the funding source of $5M in energy upgrades that the District completed in the past 7 years. These audits have identified $1.5M of investment in energy upgrades that have a pay back of 15 years or less. The District continues to receive SB-1149 funds earned from previously completed work. These funds could be utilized to pay for the identified upgrades. I. Support Facilities 1) Transportation Center The District Transportation Center is currently located on Johnson Road just south of Hwy 224/212. The facility houses and services 166 buses. Access and egress are limited. Without counting anticipated growth this facility already exceeds its designed capacity. The facility, which was constructed in 1955, is badly in need of upgrading The recommendation is to acquire a new site for this facility with more space to park buses, larger staff parking areas, improved service and administration facilities, and improved ingress and egress. The recommendation is also to relocate the District Facility Operations and Distribution functions to a new Transportation Center when it is built. 2) Facility Operations and Distribution – relocate to new Transportation Center The Facility Operations Facility is located at the intersection of Harmony and Fuller Roads. This facility has served many functions over the years. The original 1920’s Harmony School building is located on the site and is still in use housing District Food Services and Business Operations functions. Those functions will locate to the new District Administration Building in 2015-16. The District Maintenance shops are also located on this site. Originally constructed as a Maintenance Shop and Bus Maintenance Facility in 1960 this facility is becoming inadequate for the needs of the District as it grows. The recommendation is to relocate the maintenance functions to a concurrent site with Transportation and to sell the Harmony Road Site. 5 of 58 The District Distribution Center is located in a leased facility on International Way. The leased facility is adequate for its function as a Distribution Center but is too small to allow for warehousing of surplus furnishings. A larger Distribution Center located in proximity to Facility Operations and Transportation would be more efficient, less expensive than leasing, and afford the District the opportunity to store a limited quantity of surplus furniture. 3) Administration – Move to Freeman Way Building 2015 District Administrative functions are located at 6 sites across the District. This dispersion of staff is inefficient. In 2011 the District purchased a 26,000 sq ft building at 12400 Freeman Way. At the time of purchase this facility was nearly fully occupied by medium to long term lessees. The revenue stream from the leases made it cost effective to delay moving Administrative Staff functions to the new facility until 2015. The District will be moving into the Freeman Way facility in 2015. At that time it is anticipated that the District will sell the current Administration Building located at 4444 SE Lake Road. SUMMARY: No new schools will be needed before the end of the 2023-24 school year. Existing facilities are in need of maintenance and facility upgrades to maintain the integrity of facilities, continue to serve the academic needs of students, improve safety and security, and improve energy efficiency in a time of increasing cost of energy. An investment of $135M would be necessary to meet the identified needs. 6 of 58 13. NCSD Demog Report 12 DRAFT DRAFT NORTHCLACKAMASSCHOOLDISTRICT POPULATIONANDENROLLMENTFORECASTS 201213TO202122 Population Research Center PRC MARCH,2012 Print Date: 10/12 Page 1 of 101 7 of 58 13. NCSD Demog Report 12 DRAFT DRAFT NORTHCLACKAMASSCHOOLDISTRICT POPULATIONANDENROLLMENTFORECASTS 201213TO202122 PreparedBy PopulationResearchCenter PortlandStateUniversity CharlesRynerson,ResearchAssociate JasonJurjevich,AssistantDirector KevinRancik,GISAnalyst VivianSiu,DemographicandGISAnalyst MARCH,2012 Print Date: 10/12 Page 3 of 101 8 of 58 9 of 58 7,168 3,959 5,664 132 0.8% 7,292 3,897 5,771 17,213 253 201516 1,159 1,233 1,210 1,222 1,229 1,239 1,288 1,295 1,314 1,400 1,395 1,444 1,532 5YearChange: 201213to201718 Growth Pct. 213 3% 38 1% 24 0% 199 1% 152 0.9% 7,214 3,897 5,717 115 0.7% 7,153 3,902 5,621 23 0.1% 7,328 3,905 5,704 17,190 253 201617 1,106 1,238 1,255 1,230 1,245 1,254 1,264 1,320 1,321 1,367 1,428 1,422 1,487 2."UN"isungradedspecialeducation,notincludedinK5,68,and912totals. 1.Includesenrollmentatcharterschools. K5 68 912 Total K5 68 912 Annualchange 253 17,081 253 201415 1,139 1,189 1,202 1,206 1,215 1,263 1,263 1,288 1,346 1,368 1,416 1,488 1,445 16,929 253 Total 17,044 2 UN 201314 1,102 1,184 1,189 1,196 1,241 1,241 1,260 1,323 1,319 1,392 1,463 1,407 1,359 201213 1,100 1,178 1,186 1,229 1,228 1,247 1,303 1,305 1,351 1,448 1,393 1,332 1,491 Grade K 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Actual 121 0.7% 7,461 3,929 5,721 17,364 253 201819 1,181 1,218 1,203 1,281 1,300 1,278 1,296 1,311 1,322 1,400 1,401 1,421 1,499 5YearChange: 201718to202223 Growth Pct. 523 7% 132 3% 18 0% 673 4% 53 0.3% 7,381 3,921 5,688 17,243 253 201718 1,140 1,182 1,260 1,276 1,253 1,270 1,279 1,296 1,346 1,374 1,394 1,456 1,464 Forecast 117 0.7% 7,565 3,970 5,693 17,481 253 201920 1,209 1,262 1,240 1,223 1,305 1,326 1,304 1,329 1,337 1,375 1,427 1,428 1,463 155 0.9% 7,727 4,075 5,710 17,765 253 202122 1,265 1,323 1,305 1,297 1,276 1,261 1,347 1,375 1,353 1,399 1,407 1,418 1,486 151 0.8% 7,904 4,053 5,706 17,916 253 202223 1,280 1,347 1,342 1,322 1,316 1,297 1,281 1,375 1,397 1,402 1,421 1,429 1,454 PopulationResearchCenter, PortlandStateUniversity,January2013. 10YearChange: 201213to202223 Growth Pct. 736 10% 94 2% 42 1% 872 5% 129 0.7% 7,633 4,029 5,695 17,610 253 202021 1,242 1,287 1,280 1,257 1,241 1,326 1,347 1,332 1,350 1,385 1,396 1,449 1,465 NorthClackamasSchoolDistrict,MiddleSeriesEnrollmentForecasts,201314to2022231 TableC DRAFT 10 of 58 485 449 384 394 481 406 533 1,014 817 2,353 7,316 465 462 390 382 473 407 538 996 856 2,319 7,288 495 377 321 152 469 973 1,125 3,912 School Dunca nES Ha ppyVa l l eyES MountScottES OregonTra i l ES Scouters Mounta i nES Spri ngMounta i nES Sunnys i deES Ha ppyVa l l eyMS RockCreekMS Cl a cka ma s HS CHSFeederSystem Ardenwa l dES Lewel l i ngES Li nwoodES Mi lwa uki eES Whi tcombES RoweMS Mi lwa uki eHS MHSFeederSystem 483 378 333 147 461 964 1,050 3,816 201314 Historic 201213 460 362 341 148 458 994 1,044 3,807 506 448 383 403 506 403 546 1,040 793 2,443 7,471 201415 457 355 348 145 457 988 1,053 3,803 534 437 384 411 521 400 565 1,047 792 2,476 7,567 201516 460 336 360 152 463 925 1,051 3,747 549 434 397 438 520 412 562 1,070 840 2,491 7,713 455 337 359 155 462 931 1,064 3,763 531 444 407 452 527 419 568 1,057 894 2,524 7,823 tablecontinuedonnextpage 456 347 345 147 462 970 1,034 3,761 543 438 386 417 522 408 557 1,049 834 2,498 7,652 201617 Forecast 201718 201819 461 338 358 159 467 947 1,033 3,763 532 450 413 462 545 433 580 1,065 894 2,543 7,917 201920 465 339 357 162 469 968 1,002 3,762 534 457 422 470 557 444 583 1,066 931 2,559 8,023 202021 467 340 362 164 471 958 988 3,750 536 465 431 482 575 458 588 1,081 921 2,613 8,150 202122 EnrollmentForecastsforIndividualSchools,201314to202223 TableE 475 346 370 168 480 945 977 3,761 547 475 445 501 600 475 600 1,083 916 2,629 8,271 202223 20 31 49 16 11 28 148 151 82 13 55 119 127 68 62 87 60 310 983 4% 8% 15% 11% 2% 3% 13% 4% 18% 3% 14% 31% 27% 17% 12% 9% 7% 13% 13% Change 201213to202223 Number Percent DRAFT 11 of 58 171 179 144 48 15,801 230 459 293 230 1,212 17,013 School Bi l qui s tES ConcordES Oa kGroveES Ri vers i deES Ri vers i deBi l i ngua l Vi ewAcres ES Al derCreekMS RexPutna mHS RPHSFeederSystem El PuenteES SojournerSchool NewUrba nHS OtherProgra ms DistrictrunTotal Ca s ca deHei ghts Cl a ck.WebAca demy Cl a ck.Mi ddl eCol l ege Mi lw.Aca demyofArts ChartersTotal GrandTotal 16,929 228 460 293 259 1,240 162 182 152 79 15,689 201314 411 296 359 146 171 391 992 1,216 3,982 17,081 227 443 293 286 1,249 167 183 160 79 15,832 201415 415 299 350 154 176 399 973 1,199 3,965 HistoricEnrollment:NorthClackamasSchoolDistrict Historic 201213 425 311 370 153 143 382 1,013 1,262 4,059 17,213 226 431 293 284 1,234 171 182 160 79 15,979 201516 414 312 355 157 177 409 971 1,222 4,017 17,190 224 410 293 281 1,208 170 181 160 79 15,982 201617 420 318 355 160 183 411 955 1,177 3,979 17,243 223 404 293 281 1,201 170 180 160 79 16,042 201718 425 318 356 156 184 405 985 1,164 3,993 17,481 220 390 293 281 1,184 170 180 160 79 16,297 201920 448 335 377 162 184 408 967 1,147 4,028 17,610 220 391 293 281 1,185 170 180 160 79 16,425 202021 449 336 383 164 184 404 965 1,166 4,051 17,765 220 398 293 281 1,192 170 180 160 79 16,573 202122 452 338 385 169 184 405 1,017 1,134 4,084 17,916 220 394 293 281 1,188 170 180 160 79 16,728 202223 459 345 394 174 184 411 1,011 1,129 4,107 903 10 65 0 51 24 1 1 16 31 927 Number 34 34 24 21 41 29 2 133 48 5% 4% 14% 0% 22% 2% 1% 1% 11% 65% 6% Percent 8% 11% 6% 14% 29% 8% 0% 11% 1% Change 201213to202223 Forecast:PopulationResearchCenter,PortlandStateUniversity,January2013. 17,364 221 393 293 281 1,188 170 180 160 79 16,176 201819 441 330 370 159 184 408 951 1,158 4,001 Forecast EnrollmentForecastsforIndividualSchools,201314to202223 TableE(continued) DRAFT CAPACITY ANALYSIS Concord Duncan Happy Valley Lewelling Linwood / Sojourner Milwaukie ES / El Puente Mount Scott Oak Grove Oregon Trail Riverside / Riverside 2WI Scouters Mountain Spring Mountain Sunnyside View Acres Whitcomb Current K-5 Enrollment October 2012 K-5 allocation (based on 31:1) Bilquist Total Classrooms Available Classroom Use 2012-13: K-5 Classrooms Music Technology SLC (LEEP@Lew) Resource Room Day Care ELD Modular Classrooms Ardenwald ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS GRAND TOTAL 28 21 20 26 23 24 24 23 22 26 24 19 22 25 27 20.5 28 402.5 22 x 1 2 1 1 1 19 x x x 1 x 1 16 1 1 1 1 x x 21 x 1 2 1 1 x 20 x x x 1 1 1 18 1 1 2 1 x 1 22 stage x x 1 1 x 21 x x x 1 x 1 21 x x 1 x x x 23 x x x 1 1 1 22 x x x 1 x 1 18 1 x x x x x 20 x x x 2 x x 23 x x x 1 x 1 21 1 x x 1 x x 4 17 x 1 1 0.5 1 x 17 1 x 1 1 1 1 6 341 5 5 10 15.5 7 9 10 400 13 x = dedicated space or is not part of the school's current program 302 454 462 377 500 323 368 370 10 14.5 14 12 16 11.5 12 13 382 11.5 296 10.5 473 14.5 396 12 538 16 373 11 459 15.5 6958 222.5 600 24 24 475 19 17 600 24 24 411 16.44 17 480 19.2 19 7809 500 560 575 644 525 588 700 425 476 425 476 644 8525 9548 485 15.5 El Puente: all day K Projected 2022/23 Enrollment Calculated # classrooms K-5 Rooms needed @ 25 students per classroom 475 19 19 Capacity @ 25 Students Capacity @ 28 Students Capacity @ 28 Students W/Modulars 550 616 459 18.36 21 475 532 345 13.8 14 547 21.88 22 400 448 525 588 475 19 19 346 13.84 15 500 560 450 504 560 550 22 24 338 13.52 13 Linwood: 15 Sojourner: 9 Milwaukie: 7 El Puente: 6 550 616 525 588 2WI: K-4, all day K 445 17.8 18 394 15.76 18 501 20.04 19 317 Riverside: 8 2WI: 6 525 588 575 644 550 616 HIGH SCHOOLS General Classrooms Science Classrooms Music/Orchestra Computer Labs Gymnasium/PE teaching stations Media Center Speciality Classrooms Total Teaching Stations (not including self-contained) Capacity @28 (NUHS @22) Capacity @32 (NUHS @25) Capacity with Sabin/Schellenberg (-15%) Current 2012 Enrollment Projected 2022/23 Enrollment 368 14.72 14 450 504 MIDDLE SCHOOLS Clackamas High - West Clackamas High - East Milwaukie High Putnam High New Urban Sub Total Alder Creek Happy Valley Rock Creek Rowe Sub Total GRAND TOTAL 43 8 2 3 4 1 11 26 6 1 3 3 1 3 41 6 2 3 4 1 3 39 7 2 4 3 1 5 8 2 0 2 1 0 1 157 29 7 15 15 4 23 33 4 2 2 2 1 6 21 6 2 1 2 1 6 25 6 2 1 1 1 5 27 5 2 1 2 1 5 106 21 8 5 7 4 22 263 50 15 20 22 8 45 65 40 55 54 14 228 44 37 37 38 156 384 1820 2080 1958 2290 2629 1120 1280 1088 1540 1760 1496 1332 1258 1512 1728 1468.8 1262 1129 308 350 1232 1408 1036 1184 1036 1184 1064 1216 990 1011 996 1083 856 916 950 945 3792 3955 8851 9131 175 160 5059 5176 Milwaukie HS Enrollment includes Milwaukie Acadamy of the Arts 12 of 58 TEN YEAR FACILITY MAINTENANCE PLAN In 2011 the District contracted with the JJHenri Company to do a comprehensive analysis of long term maintenance needs of District facilities. The Ten Year Maintenance Plan included evaluation of the following areas: Parking lots and paved Areas Athletic field artificial turf replacement Track resurfacing Building interiors including; flooring, lockers, door hardware, window and wall coverings, painting, stage curtains and rigging, kitchen equipment, gym floor resurfacing. Building Exterior including; painting, roofing, window replacement. Mechanical systems, boilers, HVAC, ventilation, heating and ventilation control systems. Security and Fire Alarms Electrical systems, emergency generators, intercoms. Elevators Maintenance of a routine nature that would be scheduled to occur on a cycle of 5 years or less is not included in the plan. The plan details the year in which the maintenance activity will become necessary. Estimates are based on 2011 dollar values adjusted annually at a rate of 2.5% for inflation. Example would be that if at a particular school flooring would need to be replaced in 2015 the cost of the work would be estimate at 2011 cost but shown to occur in 2015 at a cost adjusted for 4 years of inflation. The plan included columns showing the total investment in each facility from the 2006 Bond, total estimated maintenance in 2011 dollars and total estimated maintenance in 2022 dollars if no work was completed before that date. 13 of 58 4b. Maintenance Estimate 12-­‐4-­‐13.xlsx School Clackamas HS Sunrise MS Milwaukie HS Putnam HS Schellenberg Sabin Alder Creek MS Happy Valley MS Rock Creek MS Rowe MS Ardenwald ES Bilquist ES Concord ES Happy Valley ES Lewelling ES Linwood ES Milwaukie ES Mt. Scott ES Oak Grove ES Oregon Trail ES Riverside ES Scouters Mountain ES Spring Mt. ES Sunnyside ES Verne Duncan ES View Acres ES Whitcomb ES Campbell ES Clackamas ES Oak Grove Center (NUHS) Land Lab Wichita Transportation Facilities Building Total Amount Invested 2011 Full Estimate 2006 Bond $ 357,134.04 $ 2012 School Total 2013 School Total 2014 School Total 2015 School Total 2016 School Total 2017 School Total 2018 School Total 2019 School Total 2020 School Total 2021 Remaining Estimate Total 2021 School Total Current Total Spent 689,523.56 $ 636,219.08 $ 650,852.12 $ 667,123.42 $ 761,830.17 $ 794,588.87 $ 828,756.19 $ 864,392.71 $ 901,561.60 $ 940,328.74 $ 980,762.88 $ 980,762.88 $ - $ 2,066,204.48 $ 876,694.73 $ 435,630.57 $ 664,763.80 $ 681,382.89 $ 740,071.16 $ 816,600.56 $ 851,714.38 $ 996,085.77 $ 1,038,917.45 $ 1,195,580.98 $ 1,246,990.96 $ 1,246,990.96 $ - $ 11,696,683.95 $ 4,789,508.77 $ 995,970.28 $ 2,220,131.17 $ 2,320,986.19 $ 2,837,313.31 $ 5,413,183.10 $ 5,645,949.97 $ 6,004,169.70 $ 6,262,349.00 $ 6,531,630.01 $ 6,812,490.10 $ 6,812,490.10 $ - $ 14,911,458.57 $ 2,862,666.91 $ 679,213.44 $ 2,295,531.18 $ 2,899,168.37 $ 2,989,042.59 $ 3,298,862.29 $ 3,440,713.37 $ 3,588,664.04 $ 3,742,976.60 $ 3,903,924.59 $ 4,071,793.35 $ 4,071,793.35 $ - $ 1,256,909.25 $ 901,829.77 $ 623,449.80 $ 639,736.40 $ 836,158.96 $ 869,371.99 $ 1,004,271.88 $ 1,047,455.57 $ 1,092,933.36 $ 1,179,154.91 $ 1,229,858.57 $ 1,282,742.49 $ 1,282,742.49 $ - $ 3,770,727.75 $ 2,705,489.32 $ 1,870,349.39 $ 1,919,209.19 $ 2,508,476.87 $ 2,608,115.97 $ 3,012,815.64 $ 3,142,366.72 $ 3,278,800.07 $ 3,537,464.72 $ 3,689,575.70 $ 3,848,227.46 $ 3,848,227.46 $ - $ 1,672,831.12 $ 3,808,659.56 $ 3,168,658.88 $ 3,429,322.45 $ 3,515,055.51 $ 3,764,892.47 $ 3,984,401.54 $ 4,155,730.80 $ 4,774,568.63 $ 4,979,875.08 $ 5,194,009.71 $ 5,417,352.12 $ 5,417,352.12 $ - $ 26,558,850.58 $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ 29,306,243.00 $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ 6,903,414.29 $ $ - $ 16,997,745.00 $ $ - $ 8,331,321.87 $ $ 1,632,335.57 $ $ 19,476,490.42 $ 1,388,777.87 $ 1,270,125.40 $ $ 6,965,116.64 $ 1,154,451.68 $ 1,292,391.68 $ 3,136,432.66 - $ $ 593,902.55 $ 1,487,404.63 $0.00 $ $ 1,898,291.11 - $ $ 2,009,435.56 - $ $ 2,573,073.42 - $ $ 2,652,838.69 - $ $ 3,411,640.22 - $ $ 3,558,340.74 - $ $ 3,734,089.86 - $ $ 3,894,655.72 - $ $ 4,277,269.06 - $ $ 4,461,191.63 - $ $ 4,461,191.63 - 306,837.67 $ 313,894.93 $ 321,742.31 $ 331,716.32 $ 684,397.73 $ 713,826.83 $ 744,521.38 $ 776,535.80 $ 809,926.84 $ 844,753.70 $ 844,753.70 $ - 1,254,089.10 $ 1,282,933.15 $ 1,315,006.47 $ 1,355,771.68 $ 1,619,936.82 $ 1,689,594.11 $ 1,964,623.33 $ 1,944,802.14 $ 2,028,428.63 $ 2,115,651.06 $ 2,115,651.06 $ - $ - - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - 397,694.33 $ 406,841.30 $ 551,679.90 $ 1,075,102.75 $ 1,463,659.21 $ 1,526,596.56 $ 1,592,240.21 $ 1,660,706.54 $ 1,732,116.92 $ 1,806,597.95 $ 1,806,597.95 $ - $ 1,116,604.17 $ 1,142,286.06 $ 1,170,843.22 $ 1,207,139.36 $ 1,330,359.85 $ 1,387,565.32 $ 1,447,230.63 $ 1,509,461.55 $ 1,574,368.39 $ 1,642,066.23 $ 1,642,066.23 $ - $ 623,681.46 $ 594,478.45 $ 608,151.46 $ 623,355.24 $ 689,083.57 $ 718,714.16 $ 749,618.87 $ 781,852.48 $ 815,472.14 $ 850,537.44 $ 887,110.55 $ 887,110.55 $ - 1,371,182.81 $ 617,251.96 $ 410,609.45 $ 422,667.23 $ 437,765.85 $ 451,336.59 $ 626,645.84 $ 653,591.61 $ 681,696.05 $ 774,377.63 $ 841,769.29 $ 877,965.37 $ 877,965.37 $ - $ 740,050.30 $ 1,288,293.04 $ 238,649.30 $ 322,551.19 $ 330,614.97 $ 387,268.35 $ 1,266,473.81 $ 1,320,932.19 $ 1,377,732.27 $ 1,684,460.98 $ 1,756,892.80 $ 1,832,439.19 $ 1,832,439.19 $ - $ 1,021,738.28 $ 502,108.61 $ 479,914.45 $ 519,149.78 $ 532,128.52 $ 548,624.51 $ 578,616.80 $ 603,497.32 $ 629,447.70 $ 656,513.96 $ 684,744.06 $ 714,188.05 $ 714,188.05 $ - $ 1,032,921.53 $ 788,899.39 $ 586,813.89 $ 644,221.86 $ 660,327.41 $ 680,797.56 $ 909,106.97 $ 948,198.57 $ 988,971.11 $ 1,031,496.87 $ 1,075,851.23 $ 1,122,112.84 $ 1,122,112.84 $ - $ 16,209,158.00 $ $ - $ 208,939.48 $ $ 1,184,591.38 $ $ 16,485,924.00 $ $ 1,640,442.38 $ $ 1,221,845.58 $ $ 1,137,184.20 $ $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - 575,052.35 $ 496,745.50 $ 552,081.90 $ 565,883.95 $ 583,426.35 $ 633,865.91 $ 661,122.14 $ 720,890.61 $ 751,888.91 $ 784,220.13 $ 817,941.59 $ 817,941.59 $ - 1,191,280.51 $ 644,570.90 $ 931,820.56 $ 1,025,344.64 $ 1,164,810.42 $ 1,372,800.23 $ 1,431,830.84 $ 1,493,399.57 $ 1,557,615.75 $ 1,624,593.23 $ 1,694,450.74 $ 1,694,450.74 $ - $ - - $ 532,566.93 $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - 136,126.52 $ 228,857.29 $ 234,578.72 $ 241,850.66 $ 545,028.93 $ 640,105.96 $ 667,630.52 $ 696,338.63 $ 726,281.19 $ 757,511.28 $ 757,511.28 $ - $ 1,960,464.37 $ 2,005,555.05 $ 2,055,693.92 $ 2,119,420.44 $ 2,402,828.46 $ 2,506,150.08 $ 2,613,914.53 $ 2,726,312.86 $ 3,040,526.22 $ 3,171,268.85 $ 3,171,268.85 $ - $ 360,134.16 $ 348,089.36 $ 356,581.57 $ 385,331.08 $ 397,276.34 $ 415,009.16 $ 432,854.56 $ 451,467.30 $ 470,880.40 $ 491,128.25 $ 512,246.77 $ 512,246.77 $ - 1,748,708.01 $ 1,085,850.56 $ 315,685.13 $ 341,545.44 $ 530,495.28 $ 649,074.32 $ 847,974.89 $ 884,437.81 $ 1,361,231.67 $ 1,419,764.63 $ 1,480,814.51 $ 1,544,489.54 $ 1,544,489.54 $ - 1,083,812.84 $ 1,841,310.57 $ 791,527.42 $ 1,396,553.01 $ 1,625,996.95 $ 1,722,807.17 $ 2,121,878.02 $ 2,213,118.78 $ 2,308,282.89 $ 2,407,539.05 $ 2,511,063.23 $ 2,619,038.95 $ 2,619,038.95 $ - 2,229,554.80 $ - $ 313,922.50 $ 282,918.22 $ 289,425.33 $ 301,843.44 $ 346,841.86 $ 361,756.06 $ 377,311.57 $ 393,535.97 $ 410,458.01 $ 428,107.71 $ 446,516.34 $ 446,516.34 $ - $ 984,000.00 $ 502,632.77 $ 468,341.48 $ 483,849.48 $ 516,791.33 $ 532,811.86 $ 568,019.75 $ 604,127.32 $ 630,104.80 $ 657,199.30 $ 685,458.87 $ 714,933.60 $ 714,933.60 $ - $ 527,625.00 $ $ - $ 716,522.00 $ 1,999,645.60 $ 1,807,168.87 $ 2,017,579.42 $ 2,092,853.18 $ 2,204,135.94 $ 2,303,342.36 $ 2,402,944.97 $ 2,506,773.05 $ 2,614,564.29 $ 2,726,990.56 $ 2,844,251.15 $ 2,844,251.15 $ - $ 38,728,874.75 $ 22,945,111.13 $ 28,095,527.88 $ 31,279,702.01 $ 33,912,772.41 $ 42,506,779.05 $ 44,418,453.17 $ 47,689,250.21 $ 50,103,344.52 $ 52,815,996.86 $ 55,087,084.74 $ 55,087,084.74 $ - Estimated Remaining Total $76,337,245.87 - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - Amount Estimated Annually $ - $ - $ 22,945,111.13 $ 5,150,416.75 $ 3,184,174.13 $ 4,953,286.05 $ 8,693,776.12 $ 2,015,733.27 $ 3,279,330.95 $ 3,084,925.00 $ 3,327,706.88 $ 2,435,281.79 $ - $ - Projected Amount Per Year $ - $ - $ 22,945,111.13 $ 5,150,416.75 $ 3,184,174.13 $ 4,953,286.05 $ 8,693,776.12 $ 2,015,733.27 $ 3,279,330.95 $ 3,084,925.00 $ 3,327,706.88 $ 2,435,281.79 $ - $ - Annually Spent $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - Total Spent Annually $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - Running Total Spent $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - Print Date: 12/4/13 15 of 58 16 of 58 17 of 58 18 of 58 19 of 58 High School Athletic Fields Study North Clackamas School District Purpose The purpose of this study is to develop a set of standards for outdoor athletic facilities. Every school district faces challenges in providing equal educational opportunities for all students. The physical facilities play an important role in supporting or limiting these opportunities. As school districts grow in size and construct multiple schools, it is important to take stock periodically and make adjustments to ensure that each facility can support a roughly equivalent set of programs. While the district rightfully concentrates most of its resources on its core mission in the classroom, it recognizes the important role that athletics can play in supporting its educational goals. In work associated with the 2006 bond, major improvements were made to athletic facilities at Rex Putnam High School and Milwaukie High School greatly reducing the disparity in athletic facilities among the three district high schools. The district invested $2.1 million in upgrades to athletic facilities at Milwaukie High and $2.7 million at Rex Putnam High. Background As cities grow outward from the historical center, new schools are built to serve new neighborhoods. As time goes by, there can be a large difference in ages among facilities. Problems with older facilities are not limited to physical deterioration alone. Even if facilities are well maintained, if they are not periodically updated, they can drift toward obsolescence. As circumstances that drove their original design change, as standards change, as technology changes, and as society changes, they must be adapted to respond. Milwaukie High School was built in 1925. The grandstands and athletic fields were built in 1938. Putnam High School was built in 1963. Clackamas High School was completed in 2002. In the 64 years between the construction of the fields at Milwaukie and those at Clackamas, there have been dramatic social changes that have put enormous demands on field space. The two most notable changes are the advent of soccer in the United States and girls participation in athletics. The National Federation of State High School Associations (NFSHS) has conducted surveys of member high school sports participation since the 1969-70 school years. In that year, soccer was just beginning to emerge in high school athletics with only 50,000 participants nationwide. More significantly, in that year, not a single high school reported girls participating in soccer, softball, track or tennis. Compare these figures with the most recent in which 358,935 boys participated in soccer. Girls went from no participation thirty-five years ago to 321,555 in soccer, 369,094 in softball, 439,200 in track and field and 173,753 in tennis. These changes have put enormous demands on field space. Both Milwaukie and Putnam were built when field sports consisted of football in the fall and 20 of 58 baseball and track in the spring. Today boys and girls soccer teams, and girls softball teams have been added which require their own field space, and girls participation in track and tennis have nearly doubled the number of participants using the track and tennis facilities. At the same time changes in regulations have been both responding to and driving changes in society. Title IX is a federal regulation passed in 1972 that requires schools that receive federal funding to provide parity between the athletic programs and facilities for boys and girls. Other regulations such as the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and the governing rules of the individual sports themselves have required changes to facilities. Enrollment Trends and Field Space It should also be noted that schools are subject to the demographic trends of the neighborhoods in which they are located. As neighborhoods build out, the level of construction activity decreases, and the population stabilizes. Over the longer term, if the existing housing stock becomes relatively less desirable for families with school age children, many schools in older neighborhoods experience enrollment declines. Enrollment at Milwaukie High School reached a peak of 1,550 in 1957 and then dropped to 746 the following year when the original Clackamas High School building (now Alder Creek Middle School) opened. The population has since rebounded to 1,206 but has not reached its former peak. In contrast with an enrollment of 2,264 at Clackamas High, Clackamas High School is the largest of the three high schools and will continue to grow. While Clackamas has the most acreage devoted to fields, when the acreage per student is considered, the disparity disappears. Process The Oregon Schools Athletic Association (OSAA) establishes a recognized list of sports common throughout the state. For the purposes of this study only OSAA recognized outdoor sports have been included in the study. The current list of sports included: Track and Field (girls and boys teams) Tennis (girls and boys teams) Soccer (girls and boys teams) Football (boys) Baseball (boys) Softball (girls) Cross Country was not included in the study as no specific facility needs were identified. 21 of 58 A committee composed of the below listed district staff evaluated the program needs for each of the three District High Schools. ATHLETIC FIELD STANDARDS/NEEDS COMMITTEE Athletic Directors: Jeff Erdman, Clackamas HS Jesse Eveland, Milwaukie HS Daniel Barendse, Rex Putnam HS Facilities Manager: Melinda Shumaker Assistant Superintendent of Education: Aeylin Summers Consultant: Garry Kryszak The committee used the following criteria to establish the District Standards, evaluate current available facilities, and make recommendations for upgrades or additional facilities DISTRICT STANDARDS – OUTDOOR ATHLETIC FACILITIES A. B. C. D. E. Number of OSAA Sanctioned Teams at each school Number of practice and competition fields needed to support the teams. Support facilities needed; storage, rest rooms, ticket booths, etc. Current field/site conditions Anticipated/known changes or upgrades needed to meet needs. The Athletic Directors at each school established the number of teams in each sport based on historical participation, budget allocation and legal requirements. Charts #1-5 list each school, the number of authorized teams, number of practice/competition of areas, any additional areas needed to meet District Standards, District Standard to provide fields for those teams. Charts #1-5 do not include any evaluation of the condition or suitability of the spaces. Evaluation of Existing Conditions Evaluation of existing facilities was based on the following considerations: 1. Number of teams under current authorized standards in the sports of soccer, football, tennis, baseball and softball 2. Number and condition of areas needed to practice and for competition for existing number of teams and participants. 3. Condition of current fields/courts including size, accessibility, drainage, irrigation. 22 of 58 Milwaukie High School General: The site is generally small and having a large portion of the athletic field infrastructure located two blocks from the main campus is a negative. Main Stadium: Artificial turf was installed in 2008 and the track was re-constructed to an 8 lane facility. The field lighting system was replaced. The stadium field is in excellent condition Football: The main stadium field is in excellent condition. The current practice field at Lake Road is adequate, however, a more efficient use of the area would be to redesign the area creating a multi-use area sharing baseball outfield, soccer and football practice areas. Varsity Baseball Field: Left field is constrained for space and the outfield slopes excessively. Drainage is poor. Infield does not have artificial turf. Varsity Softball Field: The field size is smaller than regulation. Junior Varsity Baseball Field: The field is smaller than regulation and the outfield slopes excessively. Irrigation is not complete. Drainage is poor. Junior Varsity Softball Field: Right field is constrained for space and the field slopes excessively toward the infield. It is not irrigated. Tennis: One of the existing courts is for single play only. Two additional courts would be required to meet a minimum standard of 4 courts. A total of 8 courts would allow for more efficient practice and match play. Soccer: One additional dedicated practice/competition field is needed. A redesign of the Lake Road Complex to include artificial turf areas that would include fields for soccer, baseball outfields, and football practice would be required. Shared Facilities: A field house is needed for softball and baseball. Stadium: The stadium is of adequate size but lacks ADA access to the press box, fire sprinkler system, and needs upgrades. Off Site Facilities: Consideration of the use of tennis courts at Rowe Middle School (located 1/2 mile to the east of Milwaukie HS). Also Alder Creek Middle School has a varsity size baseball field and artificial turf football/soccer field. The Alder Creek facility can be utilized to both competition and practice for football and soccer. Community Participation: Any plan for expansion/upgrade of facilities, especially the installation of artificial turf should include discussion with local sports groups and Park District for combined use and shared costs. 23 of 58 Putnam High School General: The site as currently laid out and the condition of the fields restricts the programming. In order to make the maximum use of existing land, a complete redesign/reconstruction of the existing fields is recommended. Community groups are already working on such an upgrade. Main Stadium: Artificial turf was installed in 2008. The track was re-constructed to an 8 lane configuration. The field lighting system was replaced. The stadium was upgraded, stadium restrooms were remodeled and the press box was remodeled. The stadium does not have ADA access to the press box. Fire sprinkler system is needed. Varsity Baseball Field: The field slopes excessively to the west. Infield does not have artificial turf. The light poles have exceeded their recommended life cycle. Varsity Softball Field: The varsity softball field was replaced in 2008. With the wet spring season in Oregon, drainage is still a problem. Junior Varsity Baseball Field: The junior varsity baseball field has no on-site home. It currently uses a field at Alder Creek Middle School. Junior Varsity Softball Field: Left field is slightly constrained: It requires irrigation, dugouts, and storage. Tennis: One additional court would be required to meet the minimum requirement of 4 courts. The courts are not ADA accessible. A total of 8 courts would allow for more efficient practice and match play. Practice Fields: Three dedicated practice fields (one of which should be competition level for soccer) are needed. Shared Facilities: A field house is needed. Entry Plaza: While not a part of District Standards, an entry plaza to the fields/stadium is desired. Community Participation: Any plan for expansion/upgrade of facilities, especially the installation of artificial turf, should include discussion with local sports groups and Park District for combined use and shared costs. 24 of 58 Clackamas High School General: Being the newest of the three district sites the facilities at Clackamas High are generally up to district standards. However, Clackamas High was designed for a capacity of 1,800 students and has a current enrollment of 2,264 This added enrollment creates challenges for the existing facilities. Soccer: The practice soccer fields do not drain properly. It is recommended that these fields be redesigned and upgraded to a natural turf field of a quality to be used for competition. With 6 teams there is a need for one additional practice field. Baseball: The JV baseball outfield does not drain properly. Softball: The JV softball outfield does not drain properly. Tennis: The are currently 5 tennis courts. A total of 8 courts would be more efficient for match play. Previous Master Planning Work In 2002, Nevue Ngan and Associates (NNA) prepared a master plan for the athletic fields at Milwaukie High School. The NNA master plan considered the high school site, the Lake Road site and the Junior High School site (now the Waldorf School). It recommended the existing configuration of the High School site remain the same, and the recommendations for the Lake Road property are shown in figure-1. Before any major changes in the layout of the fields at Milwaukie High School is started a new layout for the fields should be completed. For visual presentation the 2002 Nevue Ngan plan is included in this report. With a combination of changing of locations of fields and use of artificial turf all needs for practice and competition fields for Milwaukie High athletic programs can be achieved. While Putnam HS would also require the redesign of its field layout, improvements can be achieved provided Alder Creek Middle School facilities continue to support Putnam’s field needs. Recommendations The following improvements are recommended for each school: 25 of 58 Milwaukie High School 1. Varsity Softball: Reposition field in its current location to better fit the space and upgrade facilities. Consider option to relocated field to Lake Road. 2. Varsity Baseball: Relocate field to create a multi-use facility for baseball, soccer and football. Will require artificial turf field. 3. JV baseball to play games at Alder Creek. 4. Add field house for baseball/softball. 5. Consider long-term acquisition of additional field space. 6. Consider direct pedestrian connection from school to Lake Rd. property. 7. Add two new tennis courts in location of current softball field. 8. Light tennis courts for extended use. Putnam High School 1. Upgrade varsity softball field in existing location. Add press box. 2. Re-grade football/soccer practice field and address drainage. 3. Relocate and upgrade existing JV softball field 4. Re-grade existing varsity baseball field and install artificial turf infield. 5. Add field house for baseball/softball 6. Artificial turf at relocated JV Baseball practice field to create shared all-weather turf practice field. 7. Consider JV Baseball playing games at Alder Creek. 8. Consider lighting tennis courts. 9. See Figure 2 for proposed changes to field layout Clackamas High School 1. Varsity Softball add press box. 2. Varsity Baseball – add press box. 3. Re-grade soccer practice field and address drainage. 4. Add storage under stadium. 5. Improve drainage for JV Baseball and JV Softball outfields 6. Add a practice soccer field on the Clackamas High East Campus 7. Consider lighting tennis courts. 26 of 58 Cost Estimate High School Athletic Fields Study North Clackamas School District December 4, 2012 Clackamas High School Add storage under stadium JV Baseball/football practice field – improved drainage JV Softball – improve drainage Soccer – improve drainage of practice soccer field – upgrade to competition field Varsity softball and baseball – construct press box/concessions (not district standard but MHS and PHS do have) * 6. Varsity baseball – field lighting (not District standard) * 7. Roof for Stadium* 8. Tennis – add lighting 85,150 60,000 42.765 136,870 9. For enrollment of 2200 students add one practice soccer field 75,000 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 100,000 N/A 250,000 75,000 * = Not in District Standard Milwaukie High School 1. Varsity Baseball – relocate field 2. JV Baseball – relocate field or move games to Alder Creek Facility 3. Varsity Softball – relocate field to Lake Road (share with practice football) Provide stands, press box. 4. JV Softball – reconstruct filed at Milwaukie Elem 5. Construct indoor hitting facility for softball/baseball 6. Tennis – Build two new courts (brings total to 4 double courts at Milwaukie HS) light courts 7. Stadium – ADA upgrades, renovate aging facility, (replacement may be less expensive option) 8. Stadium Entries – ticket booth, concessions, rest rooms 9. Redesign of Lake Road Facility to provide artificial turf to create multi-use areas for softball, baseball, football practice, soccer practice/JV games. 5,276,221 N/\A See #1 95,165 367,848 182,682 538,738 85,150 N/A Rex Putnam High School 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. Baseball – renovate varsity field – artificial turf infield Varsity Softball – press box, grandstands, concessions JV Baseball – use Alder Creek Soccer/JV Softball/Football – improve lower field for football practice, soccer practice / games, JV Softball Build indoor hitting facility for softball/baseball Renovate stadium – ADA access, restrooms, fire sprinkler system, structural repairs – replacement may be less expensive option. Stadium Entry-Ticket Booth Tennis – light existing courts 300,000 118,765 N/A 2,800,000 367,848 535,738 85,150 75,000 27 of 58 Figure 1 28 of 58 Figure 2 29 of 58 30 of 58 SPORT Stadium Sports Baseball Softball Tennis 1 4 3 2 2 2 # Practice Areas 1 4 2 2 1 2 # Competition Areas District Standars 1 5 1 2 1 2 # Competition Areas 3 1 # Practice Areas 3 1 # Competition Areas Additions Needed Notes JV Field needs drainage improvements Outfield of JV Field needs drainage Current facility meets all District Standards Need 3 additional courts CURRENT FIELD UPGRADES NEEDED 1 5 2 2 2 2 # Practice Areas Currently Exist FIELD NEEDS FOR CURRENT PROGRAM DESCRIBE NEED Roof for bleachers, build concessions, and restrooms Install field lights and pressbox/concession stands Build a pressbox/concession stand Build 3 additional courts ‐ if standard is increased to total of 8 ADDITIONAL/UPGRADED FIELDS/FACILITIES DESCRIBE NEED Permanent storage storage under grandstands renovate JV Outfield renovate JV Outfield Upgrade field along Summers Lane to full sized, competition level field. Change direction, grade, drainage. 4 4 6 3 3 3 Track and Field Tennis Soccer Baseball Football Softball SPORT Stadium Sports Baseball Softball Soccer # TEAMS 1500 ACTIVITY Clackams HS NORTH CLACKAMAS SCHOOL DISTRICT ATHLETIC FIELDS NEEDS ANALYSIS 31 of 58 SPORT Stadium Sports Baseball Softball Tennis Soccer Baseball 1 4 3 2 2 2 # Practice Areas 1 4 2 2 1 2 # Competition Areas District Standars 1 5 1 2 1 2 # Competition Areas 3 1 # Practice Areas 3 1 # Competition Areas Additions Needed JV Field needs drainage improvements Notes Current facility meets all District Standards Need 3 additional courts if standard increased to 8 Need additional practice field for 2500 student school Outfield of JV Field needs drainage CURRENT FIELD UPGRADES NEEDED 1 5 2 2 2 2 # Practice Areas Currently Exist FIELD NEEDS FOR CURRENT PROGRAM DESCRIBE NEED Roof for bleachers, add seating; build concessions, and restrooms Pressbox/concession stands Build a pressbox/concesion stand Build 3 additional courts if standard increased to 8 courts Add a field ‐ south of CHS ‐ East Campus Add field lighting ‐ not District Standard would not be funded by District ADDITIONAL/UPGRADED FIELDS/FACILITIES DESCRIBE NEED Permanent storage facility under bleachers Renovate the JV Outfield‐ same grass area as FB practice JV Field drainage issues Upgrade field along Summers Lane to full sized, competition level field. Change direction, grade, drainage. 4 4 6‐8 3 3 3 Track and Field Tennis Soccer Baseball Football Softball SPORT Stadium Sports Baseball Softball Soccer # TEAMS 2500 ACTIVITY Clackams HS NORTH CLACKAMAS SCHOOL DISTRICT ATHLETIC FIELDS NEEDS ANALYSIS 32 of 58 3‐4 5‐6 3 3 2 Tennis Soccer Baseball Football Softball SPORT Baseball Softball Softball Stadium Stadium entries 3 2 2 2 4 1 # Practice Areas 2 2 1 2 4 1 # Competition Areas District Standars 1 2 1 2 3 1 # Competition Areas 2 5 # Practice Areas 1 5 # Competition Areas Additions Needed CURRENT FIELD UPGRADES NEEDED 1 2 2 2 3 1 # Practice Areas Currently Exist Notes Both fields in need of upgrades Total need is 3 fields, 2 for competition Fields need major renovation Total need is 8 courts, only 2 courts can play doubles. Current District Standard is 4 Courts Current facility meets all District Standards FIELD NEEDS FOR CURRENT PROGRAM DESCRIBE NEED Build indoor hitting facility/shared with softball Build a indoor hitting facility/ shared with baseball Renovate grandstands, build press box Renovate stadium ‐ ADA Access, restrooms, fire sprinklers, structural repairs ‐ replacement may be less expensive option Ticket booth, concessions, restrooms ADDITIONAL/UPGRADED FIELDS/FACILITIES DESCRIBE NEED Renovate varsity baseball field Renovate JV Baseball field Both varsity and JV fields need upgrading Expand and upgrade current facilities Upgrade to a multi‐sport artificial turf complex (artificial turf not District Standard but allows for heavier use of restricted space) 4 Track and Field SPORT Baseball JV Baseball Softball Tennis Lake Road # TEAMS 1500 ACTIVITY Milwaukie HS NORTH CLACKAMAS SCHOOL DISTRICT ATHLETIC FIELDS NEEDS ANALYSIS 33 of 58 General SPORT Baseball Baseball Softball Softball Stadium Stadium entry Football Soccer SPORT Baseball JV Baseball Track and Field Tennis Soccer Baseball Football Softball ACTIVITY Rex Putnam HS 1 4 3 2 2 2 # Practice Areas 1 4 2 2 1 2 # Competition Areas District Standars 1 4 1 1 1 2 # Competition Areas 4 1 1 # Practice Areas 4 1 1 # Competition Areas Additions Needed Notes Meets all current District Standards Need total of 8 courts ‐ Current Standard is 4 Courts lower field is used for JV 2, stadium is shared use due to design problems, varsity field is inadequate need to upgrade practice field to full‐size hitting cage is in the field of play for JV DESCRIBE NEED CURRENT FIELD UPGRADES NEEDED 1 4 2 1 2 2 # Practice Areas Currently Exist FIELD NEEDS FOR CURRENT PROGRAM DESCRIBE NEED Upgrade current hitting facility to indoor facility that can be shared with softball Renovate facility including turf, fences, dugouts, press box/snack shack. Build a indoor hitting facility that can be shared with baseball Renovate grandstands, build press box Renovate stadium ‐ ADA Access, restrooms, fire sprinklers, structural repairs ‐ replacement may be less expensive option Ticket booth, concessions, restrooms Option of renovation of lower fields to include artificial turf that would create multi‐use areas for soccer (games and Practice, JV softball, and football practice should be investigated. ADDITIONAL/UPGRADED FIELDS/FACILITIES Renovate varsity baseball field Use Alder Creek Improve lower field to accommodate safe soccer competition, include seating area/bleachers, inground irrigation (unless artificial turf) Upgrading to adequate football practice facility, in‐ground irrigation (unless artificial truf) 4 3 5‐6 3 3 3 # TEAMS 1500 NORTH CLACKAMAS SCHOOL DISTRICT ATHLETIC FIELDS NEEDS ANALYSIS 34 of 58 4 4 2 Current standard is 4 doubles courts. Request to up standard to 8 Courts Freshman, JV and Varsity Teams for both Boys and Girls. Main competition field shared with Football. Storage Building Storage for track and baseball 8 lane all weather track, pole vault area, 2 long/triple jump areas, discus, javlin, shot put, high jump 6 Tennis 2 1 Track & Field 6 Soccer 2 Freshman, JV and Varsity Teams. Competition field can serve as one practice field. Competition field artificial turf and needs to have lighting. No special facilities needed. JV & Varsity need press box, stadium & dugouts. All weather surfaced field, lighted, Vistors bleachers to seat (500) 3 Football 2 JV and Varsity for a 1500 Student School. Varsity Infield should be artificial turf, seating, press box. Stadium Field 4 Cross Country 2 2 A Stadium that seats (500), press box, ADA accessable, Rest Rooms, Concessions. 2 Softball 2 NOTES Stadium 2 # TEAMS Baseball SPORT NORTH CLACKAMAS SCHOOL DISTRICT ATHLETIC FIELDS ANALYSIS DISTRICT STANDARDS PRACTICE COMPETITION AREAS AREAS NORTH CLACKAMAS SCHOOL DISTRICT FOOD SERVICES 10 YEAR PLAN SITE INVESTMENT NOTES 2013 Costs Food Serivces Office Concord Linwood Oak Grove Sunnyside Oregon Trail Mount Scott Riverside Alder Creek Clackamas East New Urban HS View Acres Milwaukie High TOTAL Equipment only ‐ costs for equipment not part of master plan $45,000 Replace back counter, dinks, dishwasher $145,000 $197,000 Move Serving line, dishwsaer area, in flooring, Move serving line, move ovens/stoove, grease $221,000 interceptor, new flooring, new ceiling $37,000 New dishwasher w/floor sink, freezer, cooler $60,000 New dishwasher, new floor, renovate main line $25,000 Renovate cafeteria $40,000 Replace dishwasher, replace serving counter $305,000 Remodel kitchen $40,000 Replace dishwasher, sneeze guards w/hot lamps $25,000 Replace dishwasher $143,000 Remodel/upgrade to full base kitchen $792,000 Remodel kitchen $1,930,000 does not include Food Services Office 35 of 58 SAFETY AND SECURITY RATING ELEMENTS: Safety and security for each building is determined by evaluating six elements; emergency power, fire detection/suppression, seismic risk, security alarm, security cameras, and student security. Evaluation of each element of safety for individual sites is listed in sections 9 and 12 of the Master Plan Report. EMERGENCY POWER In order to ensure safe egress from and operation of the building in the event of power loss an emergency power source is required for; egress lighting, phones, intercom, fire alarm, and security alarm. Emergency power supply can be via generator or battery pack. FIRE DETECTION/WARNING Fire detection/warning systems are required in all buildings. The level of fire detection (smoke alarms or heat sensors) will vary by building code depending on whether or not the building has a fire sprinkler system. Currently, all District buildings have a fully functional fire detection/warning system that meets current building code. FIRE SUPPRESSION All district facilities should be 100% covered by a fire sprinkler system. Currently, some facilities do not have fire sprinkler systems. Those buildings that lack 100% fire sprinkler coverage are safe and secure due to a higher level of fire detection. However, it is the goal of the district to have all facilities equipped with a fire suppression system. 36 of 58 SEISMIC RATING The District commissioned a comprehensive study of all schools in 2012 to evaluate the level of seismic risk. The results of that study indicate that some facilities have a high risk factor for structural damage in a major seismic event. The 10 Year Plan calls for seismic upgrades in all buildings with a moderate/high to high risk rating. SECURITY ALARM All District Facilities have security systems in place as of January 2012. Systems include remote front door locking control, security alarms, and key card access. SECURITY CAMERAS The district installed security monitoring systems in high schools and middle schools in 2013. Currently, high schools have monitoring of approximately 30% (main entries and some hall ways), middle schools 15% (main entries) and all other facilities at 0% (no cameras in place). STUDENT SECURITY Student Security standards vary by grade level. High Schools and Middle Schools require that exterior doors can be locked down electronically, intercom is available for emergency messaging, phones have emergency power back up, classroom doors can be locked from inside classroom. Elementary Schools require all the afore listed criteria plus physically secure areas in which students can move between spaces. 37 of 58 Safety Rating Emergency Power Fire Detection Fire Supression Seismic Rating Security Alarm Security Cameras Student Security Over‐All Safety 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 50.0 N/A 91.7 100.0 100.0 100.0 90.0 100.0 50.0 90.0 90.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 85.0 90.0 75.0 90.0 100.0 100.0 80.0 50.0 90.0 N/A 90.0 88.3 100.0 100.0 0.0 85.0 100.0 0.0 90.0 64.2 Sabin West (Sabin) 100.0 100.0 0.0 90.0 100.0 0.0 90.0 65.0 Alder Creek MS Happy Valley MS Rock Creek MS Rowe MS Ardenwald ES Bilquist Concord Happy Valley ES Lewelling Linwood Milwaukie ES Mount Scott Oak Grove Oregon Trail Riverside Scouters Mountain Spring Mountain Sunnyside Verne A Duncan View Acres Whitcomb Campbell Clackamas ES Oak Grove Center (NUHS) Land Lab Wichita Center Transportation Facilities Operations 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100 100 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100 100 70.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 0.0 100.0 0.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 0.0 100.0 100.0 0.0 100.0 0.0 0.0 0 0 90.0 100.0 100.0 90.0 100.0 100.0 80.0 100.0 90.0 90.0 90.0 90.0 90.0 100.0 90.0 100.0 100.0 90.0 100.0 100.0 80.0 90 80 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 N/A N/A 30.0 30.0 30.0 30.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 N/A N/A 90.0 N/A N/A 90.0 100.0 90.0 90.0 100.0 85.0 100.0 80.0 90.0 90.0 90.0 100.0 100.0 90.0 90.0 100.0 100.0 90.0 50 90 81.7 88.3 88.3 86.7 85.7 84.3 81.4 85.7 67.9 84.3 67.1 82.9 82.9 84.3 70.0 85.7 84.3 68.6 85.7 71.4 67.1 68.0 74.0 100 100 50 85 100 50 90 82.1 N/A 100 35 50 100 50 0 0 0 N/A 85 N/A 100 100 100 0 0 75 N/A 80 N/A 37.5 66.4 52.0 35 50 0 N/A 100 0 N/A 37.0 Site Clackamas High (West) Clackamas High (East) Milwaukie High Putnam High Sabin East (Schellenberg) 38 of 58 principals chris c. van vleet, p.e. gary j. lewis, p.e. North Clackamas School District Seismic Study Phase One Review and Preliminary Evaluation of all District Sites January 2013 Gary Lewis Feb 5 2013 9:23 PM consulting engineers 18660 s.w. boones ferry road tualatin, oregon 97062 (503) 885-8605 phone (503) 885-1206 fax 39 of 58 SUMMARY The school facilities within the North Clackamas School District range in date of construction from 1916 to as recently as a few years ago, and they range in construction materials from historic unreinforced brick and clay tile to modern reinforced concrete and masonry, steel, and wood. As a result, performance under the loads of a design or lower level earthquake will also vary significantly. Even within some individual properties, the ages and expected seismic performance covers a wide spectrum. For instance, Sunnyside elementary has many phases and types of construction, with buildings from 1944 to 1999, and expected seismic performance risk levels from low to high. Milwaukie High School has similar differences, with construction dates from 1925 to 1999 and risk levels from low to high. Most of the district structures evaluated in this preliminary report (about 75%) were found to be in the low to medium risk categories, while only 25% of the structures are high risk or have high risk elements. Some of the district buildings were previously high or medium seismic risk structures, but have since had full or partial upgrades that have reduced those risk levels. The “School Evaluations” section of this report provides short descriptions of buildings on each property and the evaluated seismic risk level for those buildings. The spreadsheet near the end of this report condenses that information into a chart for a quick overview. Following is a listing of the buildings in each risk category (Low, Low/Medium, Medium, Medium/High, and High). Note that some sites may have buildings in more than one category. DEFINITIONS Low Risk: For purposes of this report, a structure or portion of a structure that meets current Building Codes Medium Risk: For purposes of this report, a structure that is predominantly safe for occupants in the event of a major seismic event but portions of the building need upgrades High Risk: A structure or portion of a structure in need of major repairs or seismic upgrades, and that poses significant life / safety risks to occupants 40 of 58 SEISMIC RISK TABLE LOW RISK Ardenwald Elem Bilquist Elem – Gym Campbell Elem– Gym Clackamas Elem – 2002 Add. Clackamas High – West Happy Valley Elem/MS Lewelling Elem – Gym Linwood Elem - Gym Linwood Elem 2008 Additions Milwaukie HS – Stadium Milwaukie HS – 1993/1999 Additions Mt Scott Elem Oak Grove Elem – 1999/2010 additions Oregon Trail Elem Putnam HS – Aux Gym and Auditorium Rock Creek MS Rowe MS – 2001 Addition Sabin – one story wood buildings Scouters Mountain Elem Spring Mountain Elem Sunnyside Elem – 1999 play structure Verne Duncan Elem View Acres Elem Play Structure Whitcomb Elem – Gym Wichita Center Play Structure LOW / MEDIUM RISK Sunnyside Elem – 1976-1988 Additions MEDIUM RISK Alder Creek MS and Stadium Bilquist Elem Campbell Elem – Classrooms, admin, play structure Clackamas Elem – 1957 Addition Clackamas High East Concord Elem – Play Structure Lewelling Elem Linwood Elem 1967-1988 additions Milwaukie Elem Milwaukie HS – Auditorium Oak Grove Center and NUHS Gym Oak Grove Elem – original 1963 building Putnam HS – original building and stadium Riverside Elem and Play Structure Rowe MS – 1962 and 1967 construction Sunnyside Elem 1992 addition View Acres Elem MEDIUM / HIGH RISK Sabin Original 1967/1968 Buildings Schellenberg Center Wichita Center – Main Building HIGH RISK Clackamas Elem – Original Building and 1953 Addition Concord Elem – partially upgraded Milwaukie HS – Original construction and 1938 / 1949 / 1953 additions New Urban HS Sunnyside Elem – Original 1944 building and 1955 / 1960 / 1962 / 1967 additions Whitcomb Elem 41 of 58 45 NORTH CLACKAMAS SCHOOL DISTRICT PROPERTIES SEISMIC ASSESSMENT 2012 SCHOOL BUILDINGS ADDRESS CONSTR. DATE. STUDY RISK LEVEL ALDER CREEK M.S. 1 + GRANDSTAND 13801 SE Webster Rd., Milwaukie, OR 97267 1952/1957 - Grandstand 1958 Building Medium / Grandstand Medium ARDENWALD ELEM. 1 8950 SE 36th Ave., Milwaukie, OR 97222 2008 Low BILQUIST ELEM. 1 + GYM/PLAY SHED 15708 SE Webster Rd., Milwaukie, OR 97267 1960/1965/2008 - Gym 2000 Building Medium / Gymnasium Low CAMPBELL ELEM. (VACANT) 7 + PLAY SHED 11326 SE 47th Ave., Milwaukie, OR 97222 1956/1958/1979 - Gym 2000 Building.Medium / Play Shed Medium / Gym Low CLACKAMAS ELEM. (LEASED) 2 + PLAY SHED 15301 SE 92nd Ave., Clackamas, OR 97015 1938/1939/1953/1957/2002 Play Shed 1977 1938-1939 High / 1953-1957 Medium / 2002 Low / Play Shed Medium CLACKAMAS H.S. EAST 1 14331 SE 132nd Ave., Clackamas, OR 97015 1990/1992 Medium / Low CLACKAMAS H.S. WEST 1 + GRANDSTAND 14486 SE 122nd Ave., Clackamas, OR 97015 1999 Low CONCORD ELEM. 1 + PLAY SHED 3811 SE Concord Rd., Milwaukie, OR 97267 1935/1948 - Play Shed 1977 Building High / Play Shed Medium HAPPY VALLEY ELEM & M.S 1 13865 SE King Rd., #B, Happy Valley, OR 97086 2008/2009 Low LEWELLING ELEM. 4 + MODULAR 5325 SE Logus Rd., Milwaukie, OR 97222 1962 - Gym 2000 Building Medium / Gymnasium Low LINWOOD ELEM. 2 11909 SE Linwood Ave., Milwaukie, OR 97222 1967/1988/2008 1967 - 1988 Medium / 2008 Low MILWAUKIE ELEM. 1 11250 SE 27th Ave., Milwaukie, OR 97222 1916/1948/Upgrade 2011 Medium MILWAUKIE H.S. 6 + GRANDSTAND 11300 SE 23rd Ave., Milwaukie, OR 97222 1925/1938/1949/1953/1971/1999 Grandstand 1963, Upgrade 1993 1925-1953 High / 1971 Medium / 1993-1999 Low / Grandstands Low MT. SCOTT ELEM. 1 11201 SE Stevens Rd., Happy Valley, OR 97086 1988 Low NEW URBAN H.S./ OAK GROVE CENTER 3 1901 SE Oak Grove Blvd., Milwaukie, OR 97267 New Urban1930 to 1950 Oak Grove Ctr. 1955/1959 - Gym 1957 New Urban HS High / Oak Grove Ctr. Medium / Gymnasium Medium OAK GROVE ELEM. 1 + GYM/PLAY SHED 2150 SE Torbank Ave., Milwaukie, OR 97222 19631999/2010 1963 Medium / 1999-2010 Low OREGON TRAIL ELEM. 1 13895 SE 152nd Dr., Clackamas, OR 97015 1992/1997/2009 Low PUTNAM H.S. 2 + GRANDSTAND 4950 SE Roethe Rd., Milwaukie, OR 97267 1962/ - Grandstand1965 Buildings Medium / Grandstand Medium RIVERSIDE ELEM. 2 + PLAY SHED 16303 SE River Rd., Milwaukie, OR 97267 1955/1958/1969/1992 - Play Shed 1976 Building Medium / Play Shed Medium ROCK CREEK M.S. 1 14897 SE Parklane Dr., Happy Valley, OR 97015 2010 Low ROWE M.S. 2 3606 SE Lake Rd., Milwaukie, OR 97222 1962/1967/1999/2001 1962-1967 Medium / 1999-2001 Gym Low SABIN-SCHELLENBERG CENTER NORTH 2 + 2 WOOD FRAME 14211 SE Johnson Rd., Milwaukie, OR 97267 1967/1968 - Wood frame unknown Medium / Wood Frame Low SABIN-SCHELLENBERG CENTER SOUTH 3 14450 SE Johnson Rd., Milwaukie, OR 97267 1967/1976 Building Medium / Gymnasiums High SCOUTERS MTN. ELEM. 1 10811 SE 172nd Ave., Happy Valley, OR 97086 2009 Low SPRING MTN. ELEM. 1 11645 SE Masa Lane, Happy Valley, OR 97236 1999 Low SUNNYSIDE ELEM. 4 + 2 MODULAR 13402 SE 132nd Ave., Clackamas, OR 97015 1944/1955/1960/1962/1967/1975/ 1978/1987/1988/1992/1999 Play 1944-1955-1960-1962-1967 High / 1976-1978-1987-1988 Low to Medium / 1992 Medium / 1999 Low VERNE DUNCAN ELEM. 1 14898 SE Parklane Dr., Happy Valley, OR 97015 2009 Low VIEW ACRES ELEM. 1 + PLAY SHED 4828 SE View Acres Rd., Milwaukie, OR 97267 1965/1968 - Play Shed 1976 Building Medium / Play Shed Medium WHITCOMB ELEM. 2 + 3 MODULAR 7400 SE Thompson Rd., Milwaukie, OR 97222 1958/1959 - Gym 2001 Building High / Gym Low WICHITA CENTER (ADMIN / HEAD START) 1 6031 SE King Road, Milwaukie, OR 97222 Pre-1940/1940/1946/ - Play Shed 1978 Building High-Medium / Play Shed Low 42 of 58 10 YEAR MASTER PLAN TECHNOLOGY PLAN The District Department of Technology and Information Services has completed an analysis of infrastructure upgrades needed over the 10 year period 2013-2023. The recommended upgrades include: Classroom Data and Power. All classrooms currently have the minimum of two duplex power outlets and three data drops recommended by current District Standards. If the District continues to use the Oak Grove Center to house New Urban HS that facility will require power and data upgrades. Computer Labs Fixed. All schools currently meet the District Standard of one computer lab for elementary and two for middle and high schools. At the middle and high school level some sites have opted for mobile labs instead of computer labs. Wireless Internet Wireless accessibility is currently limited in the District. In order to get full wireless accessibility to support devices in all District facilities an additional 507 wireless access points and associated controllers will be required. Switch Replacement Over the study period 104 switches will need to be replaced or upgraded. MDF/IDF Air Conditioning Computer hub rooms (MDF/IDF) rooms contain switches, controllers, and other computer related equipment. This equipment can be very easily damaged by excess heat. Currently 11 MDF/IDF rooms do not have air conditioning. UPS (Uninterruptible Power Supply) UPS power supply is required to keep portions of computer systems running in the event of power failure. Upgrades in UPS devices will be required during the study period. Phone System Due to both changes in technology and aging of current equipment the District’s current phone system will need to be replaced in 2019-2020. SAN (Storage Area Network) The district’s file storage servers will age out and need to be replaced during this plan. StatX Fire Suppression The specialty fire suppression system protecting the District’s main computer server room has a limited life and will need to be replaced in 2022. Security Cameras In 2013 the District installed security cameras at middle and high schools. A total of 15 cameras were installed at each high school and 5 at each middle school. In order to achieve a minimum level of monitoring, a standard of 30 cameras for high schools, 15 for middle schools and 5 for elementary schools and support facilities has been developed. Due to variances in building design some schools will require more than the minimum standard to achieve adequate levels of monitoring. 43 of 58 Technology Summary Summary Classroom Mobile Wireless Computer Wireless Standard Labs AP labs/Fixed AP needed Data standard Current Totals 507 Costing $327,902.25 205 Switch MDF/IDF Air Server Room Replacement Conditioning Infrastructure 104 $467,298.00 Notes 11 $ Wireless Controller $12,000.00 UPS $30,000.00 $1,000,000.00 Phone System SAN $125,000.00 $20,000.00 StatX Fire Supression Security Cameras HS MS Elem Support 30 15 5 5 44 of 58 FACILITY RATING MATRIX SCORING CRITERIA OVER-ALL MAINTENANCE – Based on projected 10 year maintenance costs on a per square foot basis. New buildings with no major maintenance projected received a perfect score of 100%. Facility receives reduced percentage score based on average projected maintenance cost per square foot over the ten year period as a percentage of total building replacement cost of $200 per square foot. SAFETY – Average score from Facility Rating Matrix Safety. Over-all safety rating for each facility evaluating; emergency power, fire detection and sprinkler system, building security, student safety, and seismic rating. (See details for each category in “Facility Rating Matrix Scoring Criteria – Core Facilities Section”) ADA – Rating of the building based on 2012 ADA Study compiled by Architectural Firm of BBL. Rating is a percentage of estimated cost to achieve total ADA compliance on a per square foot basis for the facility. CORE FACILITIES - Raw average score from Facility Rating Matrix Core Facilities. Over-all rating of each facility evaluating; Building Capacity, Media Center/Computer Lab, Kitchen/Cafeteria, Gymnasium, and Parking/Bus drop. (See details for each category in “Facility Rating Matrix Scoring Criteria – Core Facilities Section”) ENERGY – Average score from Facility Rating Matrix Energy. Value of energy efficiency measures identified but not completed. 45 of 58 Over‐all Facility Rating Site Clackamas High (West) Clackamas High (East) Milwaukie High Putnam High Sabin East (Schellenberg) Sabin West (Sabin) Alder Creek MS Happy Valley MS Rock Creek MS Rowe MS Ardenwald ES Bilquist Concord Happy Valley ES Lewelling Linwood Milwaukie ES Mount Scott Oak Grove Oregon Trail Riverside Scouters Mountain Spring Mountain Sunnyside Verne A Duncan View Acres Whitcomb Campbell Clackamas ES Oak Grove Center (NUHS) Land Lab Wichita Center Transportation Facilities Operations Maint Safety 98.00 94.00 84.00 90.00 91.00 76.00 81.00 100.00 100.00 77.00 100.00 93.00 72.00 100.00 82.00 84.00 87.00 86.00 80.00 94.00 83.00 100.00 93.00 80.00 100.00 88.00 73.00 94.00 83.00 80.00 66.00 77.00 100.00 27.00 92.00 90.00 90.00 88.00 64.00 65.00 82.00 88.00 88.00 87.00 86.00 84.00 81.00 86.00 68.00 84.00 67.00 83.00 83.00 84.00 70.00 86.00 84.00 69.00 86.00 71.00 67.00 68.00 74.00 82.00 38.00 66.00 52.00 37.00 ADA 100 100 99.11 98.74 96.27 97.85 95.85 100 100 98.59 100 100 96.97 100 97.01 98.5 90.84 97.19 98.92 98.34 98.35 100 100 95.53 100 98.64 99.18 80.05 94.23 91.07 N/A 95.49 93.5 80.77 Core Facilities 90.00 98.00 81.00 81.00 100.00 100.00 91.00 98.00 98.00 80.00 95.00 88.00 71.00 95.00 90.00 97.00 86.00 84.00 98.00 99.00 77.00 91.00 96.00 87.00 95.00 85.00 85.00 84.00 71.00 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A Energy 96.33 92.98 93.41 95.63 92.49 95.67 97.47 100.00 100.00 93.93 100.00 90.34 88.18 100.00 89.79 83.13 91.65 96.03 81.14 88.19 91.60 100.00 97.87 83.39 100.00 90.70 89.65 96.62 93.95 75.90 100.00 88.24 100.00 100.00 Over ‐All 95.00 95.00 90.00 91.00 89.00 87.00 89.00 97.00 97.00 87.00 96.00 91.00 82.00 96.00 85.00 89.00 84.00 89.00 88.00 93.00 84.00 95.00 94.00 83.00 96.00 87.00 83.00 85.00 83.00 82.00 68.00 82.00 86.00 61.00 46 of 58 Building Rating Graph 100.00 90.00 80.00 70.00 60.00 50.00 40.00 30.00 20.00 10.00 ‐ 47 of 58 FACILITY SAFETY RATING MATRIX SCORING CRITERIA SAFETY EMERGENCY POWER – Score of 0 -100% based on emergency power source for; egress lighting, phones, intercom, fire alarm, and security alarm. Facilities that have emergency power for all receive score of 100% with deductions for any areas that are not hooked up to emergency power. Emergency power supply can be via generator or battery pack. FIRE DETECTION – Score of 0-100% based on fire detection systems in place to meet current building codes. Facilities that do not have 100% fire suppression (i.e. fire sprinkler system) require higher level of detection than those that do. FIRE SUPPRESSION – Score of 0-100% based percent of building that is fully protected by a fire sprinkler system. SEISMIC RATING – Score of 0-100% based on the seismic evaluation of the facility performed by Structural Engineering Firm of Lewis-VanVleet in 2012. SECURITY ALARM – All District Facilities have security systems in place as of January 2012. Systems include remote door locking control, security alarms, and key card access. SECURITY CAMERAS – Score of 0-100% based on percentage of facility monitored by security cameras. Currently high schools are rated at 30% (main entries and some hall ways), middle schools at 15% (main entries) and all other facilities at 0% (no cameras in place). STUDENT SECURITY – Score based on 0-100%. High Schools and Middle Schools are currently rated at 100% if building can be locked down electronically, intercom is available for emergency messaging, phones have emergency power back up, classroom doors can be locked from inside classroom. Elementary Schools require all the afore listed criteria plus physically secure areas in which students can more between spaces. OVER-ALL SAFETY – Average score of all safety rated areas. 48 of 58 Safety Rating Emergency Power Fire Detection Fire Supression Seismic Rating Security Alarm Security Cameras Student Security Over‐All Safety 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 50.0 N/A 91.7 100.0 100.0 100.0 90.0 100.0 50.0 90.0 90.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 85.0 90.0 75.0 90.0 100.0 100.0 80.0 50.0 90.0 N/A 90.0 88.3 100.0 100.0 0.0 85.0 100.0 0.0 90.0 64.2 Sabin West (Sabin) 100.0 100.0 0.0 90.0 100.0 0.0 90.0 65.0 Alder Creek MS Happy Valley MS Rock Creek MS Rowe MS Ardenwald ES Bilquist Concord Happy Valley ES Lewelling Linwood Milwaukie ES Mount Scott Oak Grove Oregon Trail Riverside Scouters Mountain Spring Mountain Sunnyside Verne A Duncan View Acres Whitcomb Campbell Clackamas ES Oak Grove Center (NUHS) Land Lab Wichita Center Transportation Facilities Operations 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100 100 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100 100 70.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 0.0 100.0 0.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 0.0 100.0 100.0 0.0 100.0 0.0 0.0 0 0 90.0 100.0 100.0 90.0 100.0 100.0 80.0 100.0 90.0 90.0 90.0 90.0 90.0 100.0 90.0 100.0 100.0 90.0 100.0 100.0 80.0 90 80 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 N/A N/A 30.0 30.0 30.0 30.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 N/A N/A 90.0 N/A N/A 90.0 100.0 90.0 90.0 100.0 85.0 100.0 80.0 90.0 90.0 90.0 100.0 100.0 90.0 90.0 100.0 100.0 90.0 50 90 81.7 88.3 88.3 86.7 85.7 84.3 81.4 85.7 67.9 84.3 67.1 82.9 82.9 84.3 70.0 85.7 84.3 68.6 85.7 71.4 67.1 68.0 74.0 100 100 50 85 100 50 90 82.1 N/A 100 35 50 100 50 0 0 0 N/A 85 N/A 100 100 100 0 0 75 N/A 80 N/A 37.5 66.4 52.0 35 50 0 N/A 100 0 N/A 37.0 Site Clackamas High (West) Clackamas High (East) Milwaukie High Putnam High Sabin East (Schellenberg) 49 of 58 FACILITY CORE RATING MATRIX SCORING CRITERIA CORE FACILITIES BUILDING CAPACITY – This criteria is not scored. The capacity number is the existing capacity for the building as designed and shown only to demonstrate how the building relates to current Education Specification of 450-550 for elementary school, 750 for middle school and 1500-1800 for high school. MEDIA CENTER/COMPUTER LAB - Score of 0 -100% based on facility having media center/computer lab that meet District’s currently adopted Educational Specification Standards. KITCHEN/CAFETERIA - Score of 0 -100% based on facility having a kitchen/cafeteria that meet District’s currently adopted Educational Specification Standards. GYMNASIUM/LOCKER ROOMS - Score of 0 -100% based on facility having gymnasium/locker rooms that meet District’s currently adopted Educational Specification Standards. PARKING/BUS DROP/PARENT PICK-UP - Score of 0 -100% based on facility having parking that meets current code, and separated bus drop and parent drop/waiting areas. Deductions: 5 - 25% for inadequate parking, 5-25% for lack of separation of parent drop/bus pick up, 5-25% for inadequate bus stacking space, 5-25% for inadequate parent stacking for pick up. TECHNOLOGY - Score of 0 -100% based on facility meeting Technology Standards identified in the District Technology Plan. 50 of 58 Core Facilities Rating Building Capacity Media Ctr Computer Lab Kitchen Cafeteria Gymnasium Parking Bus Drop Clackamas High (West) 3149 82 100 97 80 90 Clackamas High (East) 0 100 100 100 90 98 Milwaukie High 1431 66 86 94 80 81 Putnam High 1350 35 100 100 90 81 Sabin East (Schellenberg) 100 100 Sabin West (Sabin) 100 100 Site Over ‐All Alder Creek MS 1033 100 73 100 90 91 Happy Valley MS 980 100 91 100 100 98 Rock Creek MS 980 91 100 100 100 98 Rowe MS 1060 54 64 100 100 80 Ardenwald ES 671 82 98 100 100 95 Bilquist 621 68 100 100 85 88 Concord 423 45 83 75 80 71 Happy Valley ES 621 100 82 100 100 95 Lewelling 448 79 100 100 80 90 Linwood 646 100 98 100 90 97 Milwaukie ES 448 58 100 100 85 86 Mount Scott 523 61 77 100 100 84 Oak Grove 696 100 100 100 90 98 Oregon Trail 646 99 100 97 100 99 Riverside 473 57 83 79 90 77 Scouters Mountain 596 81 97 100 85 91 Spring Mountain 671 90 94 99 100 96 Sunnyside 696 60 100 100 90 87 Verne A Duncan 646 91 99 100 90 95 View Acres 523 88 69 83 100 85 Whitcomb 698 50 100 100 90 85 Campbell 423 44 100 100 90 84 Clackamas ES 448 72 75 58 80 71 100 100 Oak Grove Center (NUHS) 51 of 58 NORTH CLACKAMAS SCHOOL DISTRICT TEN YEAR MASTER PLAN CAPITAL FACILITY ENHANCEMENT PROJECTS SITE OR FUNCTION SCOPE OF WORK ESTIMATE NOTES ESTAMATES IN 2023 DOLLARS AT ANNUAL 2.5% INFLATION Clackamas High West Campus Enlarge Weight Room $290,000 Add 1,000 Sq Ft. Athletics - see Section on Athletics Below Clackamas High East Campus Milwaukie HS Classroom hardware upgrades - allow for interior locking classroom doors $35,000 Kitchen remodel $51,203 Remodel/Replace Main Classroom Building Kitchen Remodel $15,084,902 Remodel 100,000 sq ft $1,013,827 Add 700 sf, general remodel Seismic Upgrades MDF air-conditioning $10,000 Athletics - see Section on Athletics Below Putnam HS MDF air-conditioning $10,000 Athletics - see Section on Athletics Below Sabin East (Schellenberg) Fire Sprinkler System Classroom hardware upgrades - allow for interior locking classroom doors Sabin West Fire Sprinkler System General Remodel classroom and administration areas Classroom hardware upgrades - allow for interior locking classroom doors $453,156 $30,600 $268,864 $6,175,128 Remdel approximately 40,000 sq. ft $0 Estimate included in remodel Seismic Upgrades MDF air-conditioning NUHS/Oak Grove Center Alder Creek MS Fire Sprinkler $10,000 $215,000 MDF air-conditioning $10,000 Kitchen Upgrades $31,222 Fire Sprinkler System Remainder of Building Remodel E and F classroom wings Kitchen Remodel Classroom hardware upgrades - allow for interior locking classroom doors $399,944 $4,632,497 Remodel approximately 30,000 sq. ft. $390,426 Move ovens & hood, new freezer, walk-in cooler $39,000 E and F wing in remodel estimate Happy Valley MS Rock Creek MS 52 of 58 SITE OR FUNCTION Rowe Middle School SCOPE OF WORK Added Two Classrooms Expand Cafeteria ESTIMATE NOTES $1,703,793 $425,948 Classroom hardware upgrades - allow for interior locking classroom doors $30,600 Bilquist Secure passage to gymnasium $93,894 Concord Kitchen Remodel $57,604 Ardenwald Seismic Upgrades MDF air-conditioning $10,000 Fire Sprinkler System $492,297 Secure passage from classrooms to main building, gymnasium $384,925 Cobination of hallways and fencing. Does not address modulars Happy Valley ES Lewelling Classroom hardware upgrades - allow for interior locking classroom doors $32,000 MDF air-conditioning $10,000 Linwood Kitchen remodel $273,938 Milwaukie ES Fire Sprinkler System $495,461 New Covered Play Area $148,106 Hallways for classrooms in exterior wings and gymnasium $123,528 Mount Scott Oak Grove Oregon Trail Riverside Classroom hardware upgrades - allow for interior locking classroom doors $28,700 MDF air-conditioning $10,000 Kitchen remodel $32,002 Classroom hardware upgrades - allow for interior locking classroom doors $36,000 Kitchen remodel $282,899 Classroom hardware upgrades - allow for interior locking classroom doors $40,000 Classroom hardware upgrades - allow for interior locking classroom doors $40,000 Kitchen remodel $76,805 Fire Sprinkler System Kitchen remodel Serving line replacement, move dishwasher, new flooring. $412,791 $51,203 Scouters Mountain Change exit from 172nd to 168th $128,008 Spring Mountain Classroom hardware upgrades - allow for interior locking classroom doors $36,000 MDF air-conditioning $10,000 53 of 58 SITE OR FUNCTION Sunnyside SCOPE OF WORK Fire Sprinkler System ESTIMATE NOTES $375,285 Classroom hardware upgrades - allow for interior locking classroom doors $36,000 Kitchen remodel $47,363 Seismic Upgrades Verne A Duncan View Acres Elem Whitcomb Add one Classroom $429,696 Fire Sprinkler System $429,366 Classroom hardware upgrades - allow for interior locking classroom doors $36,000 MDF air-conditioning $10,000 Classroom and hallway Kitchen Upgrades $183,052 Fire Sprinkler System $463,378 Building Securty (secure classrooms off covered play area) $194,957 Does not address modular buildings Classroom hardware upgrades - allow for interior locking classroom doors $36,000 MDF air-conditioning $10,000 Wichita Center Classroom hardware upgrades - allow for interior locking classroom doors $25,000 Admin Bldg - Freeman MDF air-conditioning $10,000 Technology Server Room Infrastructure Land Lab $1,504,099 Phone system, UPS, SAN, StatX Fire Suppression Wireless AP and Controllers $435,103 Switch Replacement $598,181 Security Camera's Phase I Elem (3) Security Camera's Phase II High School (10), Middle School 10), Elem (2), Support (5) $254,002 Three (3) cameras each at 17 elementary sites $976,163 Brings totals to HS (30), MS (15), ELEM (5), Support (5) 54 of 58 SITE OR FUNCTION SCOPE OF WORK Athletic Fields ESTIMATE NOTES ATHLETICS Clackamas High Storage under stadium bleachers $108,999 JV Baseball - renovate outfield $76,805 JV Softball - renovate outfield $54,743 Soccer - renovate soccer filed - improved drainage Soccer - add practice field at CHS East Campus Varsity Softball and Baseball - add press box/concessions/seating $175,205 $96,006 Need for enrollement of 2200 students - 6 soccer teams Not in District Standard but Putnam and Milwaukie HS have these facilities for $128,008 baseball. Varsity Baseball field lighting Roof for stadium Tennis - add lighting Milwaukie High Varsity Softball Field (replace with field at Lake Rd) Not in District Standard - would have to be funded by non District sources. $320,021 Currently only 20% of stadium covered. $75,000 If standard increased to 8 courts $6,754,007 Varsity Baseball Field - relocate - artificial turf - press box outfield shared with soccer/football practice outfield shared with soccer/football JV Softball Field with dugout at Milwaukie Elem $121,819 Field House for softball/baseball $470,877 Renovate Granstands - build press box $689,630 box, and rest rooms. Stadium Entry - ticket booths.. $108,999 Two additional tennis courts (standard total of 4 double courts)-light courts $212,892 Brings MHS total to 4 courts Putnam High Renovate Varsity Baseball Field (JV to use Alder Creek) Soccer- improve lower field to accommodate safe soccer compeititon, seatinng artificial turf Football practice - install artifical turf - combined with soccer Priced out at replacing existing with 1250 seat new grandstand, concessions, press $54,743 $3,584,237 Softball - improved drainage, press box, grandstands $152,029 Field House for softball/baseball $470,877 Stadium - renovate, ADA access to press box, fire supression, Restrooms, $689,630 box, and rest rooms. Stadium Entry - ticket booths, concessions, restrooms. $109,614 Tennis - add lighting Priced out at replacing existing with 1250 seat new grandstand, concessions, press $75,000 $55,200,057 55 of 58 NORTH CLACKAMAS SCHOOL DISTRICT TEN YEAR MASTER PLAN CAPITAL EXPANSION PROJECTS SITE OR FUNCTION SCOPE OF WORK ESTIMATE NOTES ESTIMATES IN 2023 DOLLARS @ 2.5% INFLATION UNLESS OTHERWISE NOTED Transportation New Transportation Center Facility Operations Replace Facility Operations - combine with Transporation $5,000,000 Distribution Center Combine with Transportation $1,300,000 Rock Creek Middle School Convert to Rock Creek HS (add 140,000 sf. ft.) $57,000,000 Projected need in 2025 Vogel Rd Site Construct new Elementary $25,000,000 Projected need in 2024 Eckert Road Site Construct new Elementary $25,000,000 Projected need in 2026 Clackamas High East Revert to Middle School $2,000,000 Add 4 modular classrooms $1,000,000 Scouters Mountain Property Liquidation $20,000,000 Sell existing site Projected need in 2025 Projected need in 2016. May not be needed if boundary changed Campbell Elem Clackamas Elem Wichita Center Facility Operations Administration Building Lake Rd Altamont 56 of 58 TOTAL SITE 10 YEAR INVESTMENT ESTIMATE (1) SITE 10 YEAR MAINT EST $ 1,246,991 Clackamas High (East) $ 980,763 Clackamas High (West) Clackamas High Athletics $ 6,812,490 Milwaukie High Milwaukie High Athletics $ 4,071,793 Putnam High Putnam High Athletics $ 1,282,742 Sabin East (Schellenberg) $ 3,848,227 Sabin West (Sabin) $ 5,417,352 Alder Creek MS $ Happy Valley MS $ Rock Creek MS $ 4,461,192 Rowe MS $ Ardenwald ES $ 844,754 Bilquist $ 2,613,483 Concord $ Happy Valley ES $ 1,806,598 Lewelling $ 2,139,898 Linwood $ 1,384,943 Milwaukie ES $ 1,375,798 Mount Scott $ 2,330,271 Oak Grove $ 714,188 Oregon Trail $ 1,619,945 Riverside $ Scouters Mountain (2) $ 817,942 Spring Mountain $ 2,192,283 Sunnyside $ Verne A Duncan $ 1,255,343 View Acres $ 3,171,269 Whitcomb $ 512,247 Campbell $ 1,544,490 Clackamas ES $ 2,619,039 Oak Grove Center (NUHS) $ 446,516 Land Lab $ 714,934 Wichita Center $ Administration Freeman Way $ Transportation $ 2,844,251 Facilities Operations Distribuition Center Technology Infrastructure Security Cameras Elementary Phase I Security Cameras ‐ Phase II New Elementary School A (2024) New Elementary School B (2025) Rock Creek High School (2025) Convert Clackamas East to Middle School (2025) $ 59,069,742 TOTALS ENERGY $ $ 71,151 98,600 $ 141,930 $ 86,900 $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ 53,158 34,578 36,891 58,309 56,712 56,103 51,156 112,750 43,783 19,363 112,530 66,591 40,386 12,340 91,949 49,990 61,124 13,600 27,046 157,463 39,979 - $ 1,594,382 UPGRADES $ $ 86,203 290,000 $ 1,034,787 GROWTH $ 16,108,729 $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ 8,358,224 10,000 5,136,130 483,756 6,453,992 5,461,867 2,160,341 93,894 67,604 919,222 273,938 805,795 68,002 322,899 116,805 463,994 128,008 46,000 458,883 1,088,114 704,335 256,222 25,000 10,000 - $ $ $ 2,537,383 254,002 976,163 $ 55,200,292 $ 1,000,000 $ $ 20,000,000 5,000,000 $ $ $ $ 25,000,000 25,000,000 57,000,000 2,000,000 $ 135,000,000 TOTAL INVESTMENT $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ 1,404,345 1,369,363 1,034,787 23,063,149 8,358,224 4,168,693 5,136,130 1,819,656 10,336,797 10,916,110 6,679,842 995,360 2,737,190 2,776,976 2,526,586 2,234,521 1,463,163 2,765,700 897,584 2,124,325 128,008 876,282 2,743,115 2,393,447 3,936,728 525,847 1,571,536 3,032,724 446,516 779,913 10,000 2,844,251 2,537,383 254,002 976,163 115,864,416 REPLACEMENT COST $ $ 25,341,500 67,238,750 $ 53,812,500 $ 49,686,000 $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ 17,691,250 19,948,500 36,423,500 29,250,000 32,250,000 24,012,000 16,075,000 14,675,500 11,862,000 17,250,000 12,526,750 16,710,750 13,112,250 12,182,500 14,920,250 14,097,000 12,025,250 16,531,250 14,513,250 13,836,000 15,118,500 13,443,000 14,767,250 10,071,750 11,174,750 16,335,000 1,619,500 8,498,500 6,500,000 20,000,000 4,875,750 $ 678,375,750 TOTAL ESTIMATE W/O GROWTH (1) $ 115,864,416 TOTAL ESTIMATE GROWTH $ 135,000,000 TOTAL ESTMATE WITH GROWTH (1) $ 250,864,416 (1) = Estimates are in 2023 dollars (2) Modular may not be needed if boundary change 57 of 58 TOTAL INVESTMENT / REPLACEMENT COAST $70,000,000 $60,000,000 $50,000,000 $40,000,000 $30,000,000 $20,000,000 $10,000,000 $‐ TOTAL INVESTMENT REPLACEMENT COST 58 of 58